THE COLUMBIA JOURNAL OF EUROPEAN LAW

THE COLUMBIA JOURNAL
OF EUROPEAN LAW
Volume 12
2005/2006
EXECUTIVE EDITORIAL BOARD
GEORGE A. BERMANN
Walter Gellhorn Professor of Law
Jean Monnet Professor of European Union Law
Chair of the Executive Editorial Board
VINCENT M. DELUCA
Coordinator
European Legal Studies Center
Editorial Supervisor
CHRISTOPHER D. BELELIEU
Editor-in-Chief
MATTHEW BATTERS
Executive Editor
EDITORIAL BOARD
ROBERT REED CAREY
Submissions Editor
DOLORES F. DIBELLA
NICHOLAS RYAN-LANG
JENNIFER SWICK
Managing Editors
EMMANUELLE HENRY
ALEXANDER MITTENDORF
JAIME PARKS
SEAN BLAIR ARTHUR SULLIVAN
Articles Editors
CHRISTOS RAVANIDES (Columbia)
TIM CORTHAUT (Leuven, Belgium)
Case Law Editors
NICOLE RUBINSTEIN
Production Editor
DIONYSIA-THEODORA AVGERINOPOULOU
Legislative Developments Editor
EMILY DUPILL
Book Reviews Editor
SUSAN P. LONG
Student Notes Editor
EDITORIAL STAFF
JACOB ADLERSTEIN
FREYA BAETENS
SHARON R. BILAR
MICHAEL CASTLEFORTE
DANIEL CHEN
ANDREA DE LA FUENTE
CARLOS EGEA
TONY FERNANDEZ
MATTHEW GERBER
CHRISTINA CATHEY SCHÜTZ
JUAN GONZALEZ
JESSICA SOLINSKY
ETSUKO HARA
ANDREEA STEFANESCU
CHARLOTTE HOUGHTELING
CHRISTOPHER STRONG
HEE-JEAN KIM
ANDREW SULLIVAN
AMIT KHANNA
ANDREW THOMISON
SERGIO LEAL
AMANDA TORRES SANCHEZ
TAYLOR WASHBURN
PRODUCED IN COOPERATION WITH
THE INSTITUTE FOR EUROPEAN LAW
KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN, BELGIUM
EUROPEAN LEGAL STUDIES CENTER
COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW