3BbpWeH~SI cnennpaaaraaauaonea KOHTpOll no ~3nbllHeH~e

3BbpWeH~SI cnennpaaaraaauaonea KOHTpOll no ~3nbllHeH~e

npWl0>KEHVlE No 1
AOKJ1AA
aa peaynrarare OT ~3BbpWeH~SI cnennpaaaraaauaonea KOHTpOll no ~3nbllHeH~e
aa aHra>K~MeHT~Teaa 2008 r. 110 CKIIIO"leH~ np~BaT~3a,-,~oHH~ noroaopa
YBA>KAEM~ ODU.I~HCK~ CbBETH~LI~,
B ~3nbIlHeH~e Ha Peureuae No 343/24.11.2009 r. Ha 06C - Ka3aHIlbK, C KoeTO M~ e Bb3IlO>KeHO
opraaasapaae Ha cIleAnp~BaT~3al.\~oHeH KOHTpOIl aa 2008 r. no CKnI04eH~ no pena Ha 3nnAOn /OTM./
np~BaTVl3al.\~oHH~ AOroBOP~ , CMOs:l 3anoBeA No 1161/07.12.2009 r., ~3M . CbC 3anoBeA No 24/15.01 ,2010 r.,
6e Ha3Ha4eHa KOM~C~s:I aa Vl3BbpwBaHe Ha KOHTPOIlH~ nposepsa no l.\~T~paHVlTe B peuiesaero AOroBOp~.
KOM~C~s:lTa e ~3Bbpw~Ila KOHTPOflH~ nposepsn no CIleAH~Te np~BaT~3al.\~oHH~ AOroBOP~ :
,QorOBOP~ no 4n. 35 snnnon
,QOroBOp No 30/30.11 ,1999 r. aa npoAa>K6a aa 6oayKoBo KaepeHe, rp. KaaaHIlbK
,QOroBOp No 32/29.01 .2003 r. aa npoAa>K6a aa KH~>KapH~l.\a, nn. "Cesrononac" No 11 , rp. KaaaHIlbK
,QOroBOp No 33/14.02.2003 r. aa npoAa>K6a Ha Maraa~H aa p~6a, nn, "Cearononac" No 11, rp. KaaaHIlbK
,QOroBOp No 34/28.05.2005 r. aa npoAa>K6a Ha Maraa~H "np~Hl.\eCa ,QcrnHa", yn. " P .AoIl ~ H a" 1, rp. KaaaHIlbK
,QorOBOP~ no 4n. 25 snnnon
,QOroBOp No 35/12.02.98 r. aa nosynso-nponaxoa Ha AHIlOBe OT "Xns:l6 ~ XJle6H~ ~aAem1s:1" EOO,Q, rp. KaaaHIlbK
,QOroBOp No 39/25.11 .1998 r. aa nOKynKo-npoAa>K6a Ha AHIlOBe OT "KaaaHIlbK" EM. rp. KaaaHIlbK
,QOroBOp No 42/01.09.1999 r. aa nOKynKo-npoAa>K6a Ha AHIlOBe OT " CTO K~ aa 6~Ta " EOO,Q, rp. KaaaHIlbK
Ha KOMVlC~s:lTa OT rpoaeae-are 3aCeAaH~s:I aa nposepxa no Vl3nbIlHeHVle
aHra>KVlMeHT~Te sa 2008 r. no np~BaTVl3aLl~oHHVlTe norosopa, MoraT Aa ce 0606l.l.\s:lT BCIleAHOTO:
KOHCTaTal.\Vl~Te
,QorOBOP~
no 4n. 35 snnnon
1. AoroBop No 30/30.11.1999 r. sa npoAa}l(6a Ha o6eKT: D03yKOBO KaepeHe, rp. Ka3aHnbK.
B npOAbIl>KeH~e Ha 5
roA~HVl OT OKOH4aTeIlHOTO My ~3nIlal.l.\aHe. 06eKTbT e OKOH4aTeIlHO uannarea Ha 21.09.2004 r.
B~AHO OT YAocToBepeH~e No 1846/10.12.2009 r. Ha CIlY>K6a no BnV1CBaHV1s:1Ta rp. Ka3aHIlbK, KbM
MOMeHTa Ha ~3AaBaHeTO MY, Hs:lMa HaIlO>KeH~ Te>KeCT~ ~ Vl3BbpweHVl npOAa>K6V1 no oraouieaae Ha 06eKTa.
Csrnacao 4Il. 12, T. 1 OT noroaopa, KynyBa4bT Hs:lMa npaso Aa npoaaaa
~MOTa
2. AoroBop No 32/29.01.2003 r. sa npoAa}l(6a Ha o6eKT: KHH}I(apHHl.la, nn. "Cearononac''
No 11, rp. Ka3aHnbK
CbrnaCHO 4Il. 12, T. 1 OT noroaopa, KynyBa4bT Hs:lMa npaso na nponasa ~MOTa B npOAbIl>KeH~e Ha
ner roA~HVl OT asnnauiaaero MY. 06eKTbT e ~3nIlaTeH ~3l.\s:lIlO Ha 01.03.2008 r.
B~AHO OT YAocToBepeHV1e No 1848/10.12.2009 r. Ha CIly>K6a no BnV1CBaHVls:lTa rp. Ka3aHIlbK, KbM
MOMeHTa Ha ~3AaBaHeTO MY, Hs:lMa HaIlO>KeHVl Te>KeCT~ ~ Vl3BbpweHV1 npOAa>K6Vl no oraouie-ae Ha 06eKTa.
3. AoroBop No 33/14.02.2003 r. sa npo,Qa}l(6a Ha Mara3HH sa pH6a, nn. "Cearononac" No 11,
rp. Ka3aHnbK.
Csrnacao 4Il. 12, T. 1 OT noroaopa, KynyBa4bT Hs:lMa npaso na npoaaaa V1MOTa B npOAbIl>KeHV1e Ha
ner roAVlHVl OT asnnauauero My. 06eKTbT e Vl3nIlaTeH npencpo-so Ha 27.02.2004 r.
B~AHO OT YAocTOBepeHVle No 1849/10.12.2009 r. Ha CIlY>K6a no BnV1CBaHVls:lTa rp. Ka3aHHbK, KbM
MOMeHTa Ha Vl3AaBaHeTO MY, Hs:lMa HaIlO>KeHV1 Te>KeCTV1 V1 V13BbpweHV1 npOAa>K6V1 no OTHoweHV1e Ha 06eKTa.
4. AoroBop No 34/28.05.2005 r. sa npo,Qa}l(6a Ha Mara3HH "npHHl.leCa AaSlHa",yn. "P.,QonHHa"
No 1, rp, Ka3aHnbK.
CbrnaCHO 4Il. 12, T. 1 or noroaopa, KynyBa4bT Hs:lMa npaao Aa nponaaa V1MOTa B npOAbIl>KeHVle Ha
ner roAVlHVl OT ~3nIlal.l.\aHeTO My. 06eKTbT e uannareu npencpo-so Ha 11.01.2006 r.
BVlAHO OT YAocToBepeHVle No 1848/10.12.2009 r. Ha CIlY>K6a no Bn~CBaHVls:lTa rp. Ka3aHIlbK,
CKnlO4eH e norosop No 3/05.01.2006 r. sa HaeM Ha 06eKTa sa CpOK OT 10 r. V1 noroaopua VlnOTeKa B nonsa
Ha "All epa 6aHK" A,Q rp. COepVls:l. Te3Vl 06CTOs:lTeIlCTBa He ca HOBVl; se-e ca KOHCTaTVlpaHV1 OT KOMV1CV1s:1Ta sa
cIleAnpVlBaTVl3al.\VlOHeH KOHTpOIl aT npeAXOAHaTa rOA~Ha. Tb~ KaTO 06eKTbT e OKOH4aTeIlHO Vl3nIlaTeH,
CKnlO4eHaTa V1nOTeKa He npencraanasa HapyweHV1e Ha 4Il. 12, T. 2 OT norosopa.
3aKnfOl.feH~e, KOM~C~HTa e npaena sa ~3nbnHeH~ aHra)IC~MeHT~Te sa 2008 r. Ha
KYnYBa~~Te no np~BaT~3a4~oHH~ noroaopa, CKntO~eH~ no pena Ha xn, 35 3nn,QOn 10TM.!:
8
,QoroBop No 30/30.11.1999 r. 3a npOAaJK6a Ha 603yKOBO Ka¢eHe. rp. Kasaarrsx
,QoroBop No 32/29.01.2003 r. sa npoAaJK6a Ha KH~>KapH~4a, nn. "Cearononac" No 11, rp. Ka3aHnbK
,QOroBOp No 33/14.02.2003 r. aa npOAaJK6a Ha Mara3~H aa p~6a, nn, "Cearononac" No 11, rp. Ka3aHnbK
,QOroBOp No 34/28.05.2005 r. 3a npoAaJK6a aa Mara3~H Tlpaaueca ,QCl5lHa", yn. "P.Aon~Ha " 1, rp. Ka3aHnbK
AorOBOP~
no 4fl. 25 snnnon
,QoroBop No 35/12.02.1998 r.
aa nOKynKo-npo,Qa)IC6a Ha ,QHnOBe OT "XnH6 ~ xne6H~ ~3,Qen~H" EOO,Q, rp. Ka3aHnbK
06eKTbT Ha np~Ban"'3al..\~oHHaTa caerxa e OKOHyaTenHO sannareu Ha 13.01.2005 r. , nopaA~ KoeTO
aHra>K~MeHT~Te Ha KynyBaYa OTHOCHO pa60TH~ MeCTa Ltl AP. ca epaKTLtlyeCKLtl npLtlKnlOyLtlnLtl KbM MOMeHTa Ha
nposepsara 06eKT Ha KOHTpon ca noernre OT KynyBaYa aHra)l(LtlMeHTLtl sa aanasaaue npenvera Ha AeVlHocT
Ha APY)l(ecTBoTo Ltl aCOpTLtlMeHTa Ha OCHOBHLtlTe BLtlAOBe xns:l6 sa CpOK OT 10 roALtlHLtl, KaKTO Ltl aaopana sa
npexaspnaue cofcraeuocrra Ha 3aKyneHLtlTe AP~eCTBeHLtl As:InoBe sa CpOK OT 10 ron. KynyBal.lbT e
npencrasan OTyeT no Ltl3nbflHeHLtle Ha aHra)l(LtlMeHTLtlTe Ltl npLtlnO>KeHLtls:l - KOnLtls:l OT cneaaare AOKyMeHTLtl:
• Cnpaasa sa npOLtl3BOACTBOTO Ltl npOAa)l(6LtlTe Ha npOMLtlWneHLtl npoAyKTLtl sa 2008 r.
• YAocToBepeHLtle No 20091201142558/01.12.2009 r. OT AreHl..\Ltls:l no BnLtlCBaHLtls:lTa KbM Mn, aa
snacauare Brsproacora perncrsp 06CTOs:lTenCTBa no napruaara Ha "Xns:l6 Ltl xne6HLtl Ltl3AenLtls:l"00A .
• 3aBepeHLtl Ltl3BaAKLtl OT KHLtlra Ha AP~eCTBeHLtlTe As:lnOBe.
• 3aBepeHo sonae OT aacrpaxoaarenaa nonnua OT 13.05.2009 r. Ha 3nAA "AfILtlaHl..\ 5bnrapLtls:l".
• 3aBepeHLtl KOnLtls:l OT CyeTOBOAeH 6anaHc Ltl OTyeT sa npLtlxOALtl Ltl pa3XOALtl KbM 31 .12.2008 r.
• KonLtle OT npOToKon OT 04.11.2008 r. sa Ltl3BbpUJeHa npoeepxa OT Boeuao OKpb)l(Ltle rp. Crapa 3aropa
Ha M06LtlnLtl3al..\LtlOHHaTa roTOBHOCT Ha "Xns:l6 Ltl xne6HLtl Ltl3AenLtls:l" 00,£1.
OT npencraaeuaa OTyeT KOMLtlCLtls:lTa e sanpaeana Cne,lJ,HLtlTe Ltl3BOALtl:
1. 3ana3eH e npe,lJ,MeTa Ha AeVlHocT Ha AP~ecTBoTo - npOLtl3BOACTBO Ha xns:l6, xne6HLtl Ltl
cnaAKapCKLtl Ltl3,lJ,enLtls:l, KaKTO Ltl aCOpTLtlMeHTa Ha OCHOBHLtlTe BLtlAOBe xns:l6 - "A06pY,lJ,)l(a" Ltl .Crapa 3aropa".
2. Hs:lMa npOMeHLtl B cofcraesocrra Ha 3aKyneHLtlTe As:InOBe, BLtlAHO OT npencraaeaoro
y,lJ,ocTOBepeHLtle OT AreHl..\Ltls:l no BnLtlCBaHLtls:lTa KbM Mn Ltl Ltl3BaAKLtlTe OT KHLtlra Ha AP~eCTBeHLtlTe As:InoBe.
Apy>KecTBoTo e CKanLtlTan 50 072 na., pasopenene« Me}K,lJ,y CbAP~HLtll..\LtlTe , KaKTO cneaaa:
• "XJls:l6 97" 00,£1, rp. Ka3aHnbK - 1 As:ln Bpaaaep Ha 35 732.40 na.
• 06lL\LtlHa Ka3aHnbK - 1As:In Bpasaep na 9 125.20 na
• EKLtln OT 192 nLtll..\a no -m. 5, an. 2 31111,£1011-1 As:In Bpasaep Ha 5 214.40 na
3. Apy>KecTBoTo e 3acTpaxoBaHo OT 06LtlyaVlHLtlTe pLtlCKOBe, BLtlAHO OT npeAcTaBeHaTa
aacrpaxoaarenaa nonaua
4. ApY)l(ecTBoTo nO,lJ,Abp)l(a npaeroro LtlMYlL\ecTBo B Ltl3npaBHOCT. V13BbpweH e OCHOBeH peaour na
,[IMA sa 400000 ns. sa npLtlBe}K,lJ,aHeTO LtlM BCbOTBeTCTBLtle CbC 3aKOHa sa xpasare Ltl ,lJ,p.HopMaTLtlBHLtl aKTOBe.
5. ApY)l(ecTBoTo Ltl31lbnHs:lBa BoeHHoBpeMeHHLtlTe CLtl aHra)l(LtlMeHTLtl, no OTHOWeHLtle Ha TpaHCnOpTHLtlTe
CpeACTBa, Hs:lMa AOroBOp sa aHra)l(LtlMeHT nO,lJ,Abp)l(aHe Ha BoeHHoBpeMeHHLtl sanaca sa 2008 r.
V13BbH 3aAaYLtlTe Ha KOMLtlCLtls:lTa no PeWeHLtle No 343/24.11 .2009 r. Ha 06C sa KOHTpon aa
aHra)l(LtlMeHTLtlTe sa 2008 r., KOMLtlCLtls:lTa e 06Cb,lJ,Ltlna Ltl APyrLtl np06neMLtl, xacaeum yyaCTLtleTO Ha 06lL\LtlHaTa B
"Xns:l6 Ltl xne6HLtl Ltl3,lJ,enLtls:l" 00,£1: YBenLtlyaBaHe KanLtlTana Ha AP~ecTBoTO, nLtlnCaTa Ha ALtlBLtlAeHTLtl 3a
06lL\LtlHa Ka3aHnbK Ltl AP.
B Ta3Ltl Bpb3Ka Ltl corneA Ltl3s:1CHs:lBaHe OTpa3s:1BaHeTO Ha cyMaTa no T. 4 B6anaHca Ha APY)l(eCTBOTo,
e npoBeAeHo BTOPO 3aCeAaHLtle Ha KOMLtlCLtls:lTa, Ha KoeTO e nOKaHeH ynpaBLtlTens:l Ha "Xns:l6 - 97" 00,£1 - r-)I(a
HLtlKOnLtlHa AOHyeBa ,lJ,a npeACTaBLtl BCLtlYKLtl AOKyMeHTLtl, cBbp3aHLtl C npOMs:lHa Ha KanLtlTana OT MOMeHTa Ha
CKnIOYBaHe Ha npLtlBaTLtl3al..\LtlOHHLtls:l AOroBOp AO MOMeHTa, KaKTO Ltl LtlHepopMal\Ltls:l 3a npOLtl3xO,lJ, Ha napLtlYHLtlTe
cpeAcTBa 3a Ta3Ltl npOMs:lHa. Ha npoBeAeHoTo BTOpO 3aCeAaHLtle, cneA pa3roBop C r-)I(a AOHyeBa Ltl
3an03HaBaHe C AOnbnHLtlTenHO npeACTaBeHLtlTe AOKYMeHTLtl, KOMLtlCLtls:lTa e Ltl3pa3Ltlna CbrnaCLtle C
KOHcTaTal..\LtlLtlTe Ha KOMLtlCLtls:lTa no CilK OT npe,n,xoAHLtl roA~HLtl , a LtlMeHHO: npe3 1998 r. e Ltl3BbpWeH anopT B
"Xns:l6 Ltl xne6HLtl Ltl3,lJ,enLtls:l" 00,£1, B pe3ymaT Ha LtlHBeCTLtll..\LtlLtl - peKoHcTpyKl..\Ltls:l Ha crpa,lJ,Ltl, BKnlOyeHLtl B
KanLtlTana Ha CblL\OTO APY)l(ecTBo. CneA peKoHcTpyKl..\Ltls:lTa, CTOVlHocna Ha 06eKTLtlTe e anOpTLtlpaHa B"Xns:l6 Ltl
xne6Hl1 113,QenI1H" 00,L:l, CKOeTO e YBenl14eH xanarana Ha ,Qpy>KeCTBOTO, HO -ipea aapacreaae CTO~HOCna ua
.QHna Ha "XnH6 - 97" 00,[\. nOpa,Q11 113Tl14aHe CpOKa sa 06>KanBaHe Ha peuieaasra Ha 06Ll.\OTO cb6paHl1e, He
e Bb3MO>KHO 113MeHeHl1e Ha B3eTOTO peWeHl1e.
BbB Bpb3Ka C nOCTbnl1no nl1TaHe OT KOMI1CI1HTa OTHOCHO HeOTpa3HBaHe Ha OT4eTeH peMOHT 3a
400000 na. B C4eTOBO,QHI1H fianaac Ha ,QpY>KecTBoTo, r-xa ,[\oH4eBa e npencrasana 113Bne4eHl1H OT
CMeTKI1Te sa ,[\MA, OTKb,QeTO e BI1,QHO, 4e croaaocrra Ha crpanare e 3aBl1WeHa C 113nnaTeHl1Te CYMI1 sa
Kanl1TanoBI1 pa3XO,QI1, KOI1TO npeBI1WaBaT LjI1Tl1paHI1Te 400 000 na.
BbB Bpb3Ka C nocrsnano rurraae OTHOCHO pasrpeneneuaero Ha ne-enoara 11 nancara Ha
,QI1BI1,QeHTI1 sa 06Ll.\I1Ha Kasaarn,«, r-xa ,[\oH4eBa 06HcHHBa riancara Ha ,QI1BI1,QeHTI1 C Heo6xo,QI1MOCna OT
HeOTnO>KHI1 peMOHTI1 B np0113Bo,QcTBeHI1Te uexose, 6e3 KOI1TO e HeBb3MO>KHO OLjenHBaHeTO Ha ,Qpy>KeCTBOTo
11 seroaara KOHKypeHTocnoco6HoCT Ha nasapa. Ha Bbnpoca OTHOCHO eee-rryan-ara Bb3MO>KHOCT sa
npo,Qa>K6a Ha MI1HOpl1TapHI1H ,QHn Ha 06Ll.\I1HaTa B "XnH6 11 xne6Hl1 113,QenI1H" 00,[\, r-xa ,[\OH4eBa He ce
asraxapa C«areropasao MHeHl1e, CMOTI1Ba, 4e l1,QeHTa e HOBa 11 cnensa na ce 06MI1Cfll1.
YneHOBeTe Ha KOMI1CI1HTa C4l1TaT, 4e 611 Morno na ce nOMI1Cnl1 sa eaenryanao npe,Qnpl1eMaHe na
,Qe~CTBIo1H no npouenypara sa npo,Qa>K6a Ha MI1HOpl1TapHI1H .QHn Ha 06Ll.\I1HaTa B "XnH6 11 xne6Hl1 113,QenI1H"
OOn Bpaauep Ha 17,31 %, cnen T04Ha npeueusa Ha eBeHTyanHI1Te pl1CKOBe 11 I1KOHOMl14eCKaTa 113ro,Qa aa
06Ll.\I1Ha Ka3aHnbK. KOMI1CI1HTa He O¢OPMH nocnenaoro KaTO peuieuae, Tb~ KaTO TOBa e 113BbH 3a,Qa4aTa ~,
csrnacuo Peuiesae No 343/24 .11.2009 r. na 06e - Ka3aHnbK.
B 3aKmo~eH~e, KOMVlCVlSlTa e npaena aa Vl3nbI1HeHVI aHra>KVlMeHTVlTe aa 2008 r. Ha KYnYBa~a
no npVlBaTVl3a4V1oHeH norcaop No 35/12.02.1998 r. sa nOKynKo-npOAa>K6a aa ASlIlOBe OT
"XnSl6 VI XIle6HVI Vl3AeI1V1S1" EOOA, rp. Ka3aHI1bK.
AorOBOp No 39/25.11.1998 r.
aa nOKYnKo-npOAa>K6a aa aK4V1V1 OT "Ka3aHI1bK" EM, rp. Ka3aHI1bK
06eKTbT Ha npl1BaTl13aLjl10HHaTa enema e OKOH4aTenHO aannares Ha 17.05.2005 r.
06eKT Ha KOHTpon npa nposepsara, ca nOeTI1Te OT KynyBa4a aHra>KI1MeHTI1 OTHOCHO aanassaue
cbLl.\ecTBYBaLl.\I1H npeaaer Ha ,Qe~HocT Ha ,Qpy>KeCTBOTo 11 3a6paHa sa npexaspnsae cofcrseaocrra na
3aKyneHl1Te aKLjl111 sa CpOK OT 10 ro,QI1HI1 cnen npl1,Qo6l1BaHeTO 11M. KynyBa4bT e npencrasan I1H¢OpMaLjI1H
OTHOCHO 113nbnHeHl1e Ha aHra>KI1MeHTI1Te 11 npl1no>KeHI1H KbM HeH - KOIlI1H OT cne,QHI1Te ,QoKyMeHTI1:
1, Y,QocToBepeHl1e No 20091208111119/08.12.2009 r. OT AreHLjI1H no Bnl1CBaHI1HTa KbM Mn , sa
Bnl1CaHI1Te BTbprOBCKI1H perucrsp 06cToHTencTBa no napruaara Ha "Ka3aHnbK" A,Q.
2, 3aBepeHa 113Ba,QKa OT aKLjl10HepHaTa KHl1ra.
3. OT4eT sa saerure f1I1Lja, cpencrsara aa pa60THa sannara 11 ,Qpyrl1 pasxona sa 2008 r., BKOHTO e
perucrpapaa cpenes Cnl1Cb4eH 6po~ sa 2008 r. - 99 naua.
4. 3acTpaxoBaTenHl1 nonl1LjI1.
5, 3aBepeHl1 KOnl1H OT OT4eT sa npl1xo,Q1111 pa3xo,Q1111 C4eTOBO,QeH 6anaHc KbM 31.12.2008 r.
OT npencraaeuara I1H¢OpMaLjI1H KOMI1CI1HTa e aanpasana cne,QHI1Te 113BO,QI1: npe,QMeTbT Ha
Ae~HocT Ha npyxecrsoro, KaKTO 11 cotcraeuocrra Ha 3aKyneHl1Te aKLjl111 He ca npOMeHeHI1. ,[lpy>t<eCTBOTO e C
«anuran 250 000 na Paanpenenenaero Ha aKLjl1l1Te e cne,QHOTO:
IIKa3aHnbK - K" A,Q, rp. Ka3aHnbK - 237 500 aKLjI1I1;
06Ll.\I1Ha Ka3aHnbK - 12 435 aKLjl111
EKl1n OT nl1Lja no 4n. 5, an, 2 3nn,[\On - 65 aKLjI1I1.
npe,QcTaBeHI1Te ,QoKyMeHTI1 no T. T. 3, 4 11 5 I1MaT I1H¢OpMaTI1BeH xaparrep, Tb~ KaTO 06eKTbT Ha
npl1BaTl13aLjl10HHaTa C,QenKa e OKOH4aTenHO aannarea 11 aHra>KI1MeHTI1Te Ha KynyBa4a OTHOCHO 6po~
pa60THl1 MeCTa, 3acTpaXOBKl1l1 np. ca ¢aKTI14eCKI1 npl1KnlO4l1nl1 KbM MOMeHTa.
V1 TyK KOMI1CI1HTa, 113BbH 3aAa4l1Te CI1 no PeWeHl1e No 343/24.11.2009 r. Ha 06e sa KOHTpon Ha
aHra>KI1MeHTI1Te sa 2008 r., e Ae6aTl1pana HaManHBaHeTO Ha -acrra Ha aKLjl1l1Te Ha 06Ll.\I1HaTa B xanarana
Ha ,QpY>KeCTBoTo. B Ta311 epsaxa KOMI1CI1HTa e peuiuna na nOKaHI1 Ha cnenaauioro sacenasae
113nbnHlo1TenHl1H ,Ql1peKTOp Ha ,QpY>KeCTBOTO sa ,Qa npe,QCTaBI1 ,QOKyMeHTI1, CBbp3aHl1 CnpOMHHa Ha «arurrana
OT CKnlO4BaHe Ha npl1BaTl13aLjl10HHl1H ,QOroBOp ,QO MOMeHTa, KaKTO 11 I1H¢OpMaLjI1H sa np0I13XO,Q Ha
napl14Hlo1Te cpencrsa aa Ta311 npOMHHa. B 06HBeHl1H 4ac Ha sacenauaero Ha KOMI1CI1HTa He ce HBHBaT
npe,QCTaBI1Tenl1 Ha ,Qpy>KeCTBOTO. OT ,QonbnHI1TenHO npe,QCTaBeHI1Te OT ,Qpy>KeCTBOTO 11 Hanl14Hl1Te B
06Ll.\I1Ha Ka3aHnbK no nOBoA Ha KOHTpon OT npe,QXO,QHI1 ro,QI1HI1 ,QOKyMeHTI1, KOMI1CI1HTa Ha CBoeTO BTOpO
"~(,Cln~:lI.HACl Cl ImI-l(,T~TlAn~n;:l llP. r. nnmOKOnHO OeWeHl1e Ha CbBeTa Ha nl10eKT00l1Te Ha ..Ka3aHnbK" AD OT
11.08.1999 r., csrnacao ycraaa Ha ,Qpy>KecTsoTo 1-1 4n. 196 or TbproSCK1-151 3aKOH, e S3eTO peuieaae sa
ysen1-14eH1-1e Ha «arurrana aT 50 000 na Ha 250 000 na 4pe3 1-13,QasaHe Ha HOS1-1 200 000 n01-1MeHH1-1 aK41-11-1 C
npaso Ha rnac 1-1 CHOM1-1HanHa CTO~HOCT 1 na. SC5IKa. , KoeTO e ny6n1-1KysaHo SAB 6p. 79/1999 r. C PeWeH1-1e
No 3130 aT 12.10.1999 r. Craposaropcsa OKpb>KeH Cb,Q snacsa S TbprOSCK1-151 peracrsp ysen1-14eH1-1eTO Ha
kanarana, sa KoeTO e ny6n1-1KysaHo o651SneH1-1e S6p. 13/2000 r. aa ~IB.
VI TyK -mesoaere Ha KOM1-1C1-151Ta 1-13pa351SaT MHeH1-1e, -e 61-1 Morna ,Qa ce nOM1-1Cn1-1 sa eae-rryanuo
npennpaeaaue Ha ,Qe~CTS1-151 no npouenypara sa npo,Qa>K6a Ha M1-1HOp1-1TapH1-151 naser aKl\1-11-1 Ha 06LL\1-1HaTa S
"Ka3aHnbK" AA, - KO~TO e S pasvep Ha 4,974 % cnen T04Ha npeueasa Ha eae-rryan-are p1-1CKOSe 1-1
1-1KOHOM1-14eCKaTa 1-13ro,Qa sa 06ll.l1-1Ha Ka3aHnbK, KaKTO 1-1 cuuoro OTHOCHO M1-1HOp1-1TapH1-151 ,Q5In Ha 06LL\1-1HaTa
S "VlHcPpa CeSTOnOn1-1C" OOA, KO~TO e S pasaep Ha 20 %. KOM1-1C1-151Ta He OcPOPM5I nocnensoro KaTO
peUJeH1-1e, Tb~ KaTO rosa e 1-13S"bH 3a,Qa4aTa ~, csrnacso PeWeH1-1e No 343/24.11 .2009 r. Ha 06C - Ka3aHnbK.
B 3aK.ntO"leH~e, KOMHCHSlT3 e npaena 33 H3nbIlHeHH 3Hr3>KHMeHTHTe 33 2008 r. H3 KYnyB31.f3
no npHB3TH33l.\HOHeH noroscp No 39/25.11.1998 r. 33 lloKynKo-npOA3>K63 H3 3Kl.\HH OT "K333HIlbK"
EM, rp. K333HIlbK.
AOroBOp No
42/01.09.1999 r.
33 nOKynKo-npOA3>K63 H3 AS1IlOBe OT "CTOKH 33 6HT3" EOOA, rp. K333HIlbK
06eKTbTe 1-13nnaTeH 1-13451nO Ha 10.03.2006 r. Ilorosopsr He npe,QS1-1>t<p,a aHra>K1-1MeHT1-1, nOAJle>Kall.l1-1
Ha KOHTpon cnea OKOH4aTenHOTO 1-13Ilnall.laHe Ha o6eKTa Ha np1-1SaT1-13a41-10HHaTa cnerxa, ST.4. 1-1 sa 2008 r.
KOM1-1C1-151Ta e KOHCTaT1-1pana, -e no OTHOWeH1-1e Ha np1-1SaT1-13a41-10HHaTa cnerxa MoraT na ce 1-13nD>KaT
xpOHOnOr1-14eCK1-1 cne,QH1-1Te cPaKT1-1: C
BbS spssxa C KOHCTaT1-1paH1-1 or Ha3Ha4eHaTa npes 2007 r. KOM1-1C1-151 no CllK HapyweH1-151 no
1-13nbnHeH1-1e Ha norosopeua aHra>K1-1MeHT1-1 - aesannareua HeycTO~K1-1 sa He3aeT1-1 pa60TH1-1 MeCTa, C
PeWeH1-1e No 95/29.07.2004 r. 06C- Ka3aHnbK 3a,Qbn>KaSa 1-1 ynbnHoM0ll.lasa KMeTa Ha 06ll.l1-1Ha Ka3aHnbK
,Qa npe,Qnp1-1eMe ,Qe~CTS1-151 no paaaarsae Ha Aorosop No 42 ot 01 .09.1999 r. aa nOKYnKO-npo,QffiK6a Ha
,Q5InDse aT "CTOK1-1 sa 61-1Ta" OOA, rp. Ka3aHnbK. B 1-13nbnHeH1-1e Ha peWeH1-1eTO, e 1-13roTseHo yse,QOM1-1TenHO
n1-1CMO Haw No 68-1011-1/26.06.2007 r. ,QO "CTa61-1n" OOA, rp. Ka3aHnbK sa pasaanaae Ha noroaopa, Ha
OCHOSaH1-1e -m. 16 aT Cbll.l1-151. IlP1-1 1-13SbpWeHa nposepaa Ha ,QOKyMeHT1-1Te, e ycranoseno. 4e cpososere sa
rspce-e Ha HeYCTO~Ka ca 1-13TeKn1-1, C omen paanopentiare Ha 4n. 111 33A /CpOKbT sa noracssaue Ha
S3eMaHe Ha HeycTO~K1-1 e 3-ro,Q1-1WeH/ 1-1 Tb~ KaTa Cbll.l1-1Te ca sa nepaoa no 2004 r., csuioro e noraceuo KbM
2007 r., «oraro e pasaanea ,QOroSOpbT.
Cnen pasaananero Ha ,Qorosopa, cnensa ,Qa ce CS1-1Ka o6ll.lo cb6paH1-1e 1-1 csrnacuo APY>KeCTSeH1-151
norosop "CTa61-1n" OOA, KaTO Cb,QPY>KH1-1K S "CTOK1-1 sa 61-1Ta" OOA ,Qa npexsspna Ha 06ll.l1-1Ha Ka3aHnbK
np1-1SaT1-131-1paH1-1Te A5InDSe, a 06ll.l1-1Ha Ka3aHHbK na SbpHe nnareuara cyMa or 38000 ns. IlP1-1 nanca Ha
csrnacae "CTa61-1n" OOA ,Q06posonHo ,Qa npexsspnn 3aKyneH1-1Te nsnoee, ocrasa Sb3MO>KHOCna 06ll.l1-1HaTa
,Qa npe,Q5IS1-1 cb,Qe6eH 1-1CK sa YCTaHOS5IsaHe cotcrseuocrra SbPXY ,Q5InOSeTe, HO CroToSHOCT na 1-13SbPW1-1
aannauaue Ha cyMaTa 38 000 na lloco4eH1-1Te ,Qe~CTS1-151 cnensa ,Qa ce 1-13SbpWaT cnen peWeH1-151 Ha 06C S
Ka4eCTSOTO My Ha opras no np1-1BaT1-13a41-151 1-1 cne,Qnp1-1SaT1-13a41-10HeH KOHTpon, KaKTO 1-1 nbnHOM0ll.\1-151 Ha
KMeTa sa 1-13BbpWSaHe Ha KOHKpeTH1-1Te Ae~CTB1-151.
KOM1-1C1-1HTa e c-ena sa 4eneCb06pa3HO na ce nOKaH1-1 yrpaaarens Ha ,Qpy>KeCTSOTO - K. Kapryaos Ha
cnensauioro aacena-ae ,Qa ,QaAe 06HCHeH1-151 sa np1-1eT1-1Te peWeH1-151 Ha 06ll.\OTO cb6paH1-1e Ha Cb,QPY>KH1-141-1Te
OT 19.01.2008 r.: sa npaeuane Ha CbAPy>KH1-1K ,,51-1n,QKoM" EOOA 1-1 sa npexaspnsne Ha 400 ,Q5Ina OT xanarana
Ha ,Qpy>KeCTBOTO S noma Ha ,,51-1n,QKoM" EOOA; sa npOM5IHa Ha anpeca Ha ynpaaneune Ha ,Qpy>KeCTSOTO aT
rp. Ka3aHnbK S rp. Bpaua, npOMeH1-1 S,Qpy>KeCTSeH1-151 norosop, K01-1TO peWeH1-151 ca OTMeHeH1-1 CpeWeH1-151 no
TbproSCKO neno No 929/2008 r. no onaca Ha AnenaT1-1SeH Cb,Q, rp. IlnDs,Q1-1s; sa nocnenaauto rpexaspnaae
Ha ,Q5Inose Sxona Ha S~C5Ill.l1-151 cb,Qe6eH npousc OT ,,51-1n,QKoM" EOOA na .Jlanasap" OOA·
B 0651SeH1-151 AeH 1-1 -ac, Ha 3ace,QaH1-1eTO Ha KOM1-1C1-151Ta npe,QCTaS1-1Ten1-1 Ha ,Qpy>KeCTSOTO He ca ce
51S1-1n 1-1 , KOM1-1C1-151Ta e KOHCTaT1-1pana, 4e ,QO ,QeH5I Ha 3ace,QaH1-1eTO He e aspaara 06paTHaTa pa3n1-1CKa,
ynocroaepseauia HaAJle>KHO spb4saHe Ha nosaaara 3a np1-1CbCTS1-1e Ha 3ace,QaH1-1eTO.
B 3aKnI04eH1-1e, no OTHOWeH1-1e Ha He06xo,Q1-1MOCna OT 1l0cne,Qsall.\1-1 ,Qe~CTS1-151 cne,Q pa3San5lHeTO Ha
Aorosop No 42 OT 01.09.1999 r. 3a nOKynKo-npo,Qa>K6a Ha ,Q5Inose OT "CTOK1-1 3a 61-1Ta" OOA Cn1-1CMO Haw
No 68-1011-1/26.06.2007 r. ,QO "CTa61-1n" OOA, rp. Ka3aHnbK, 1-1 Sb3MO>KH1-1Te p1-1CKOSe, KOM1-1C1-151Ta 1-13nara
cneAHOTO CTaHOS1-1ll.le:
He06xo,Ql-1MO e ,Qa ce aanpasn npeueaxa Ha l-1HTepeCa Ha 06Ll.\l-1HaTa OT BpbLl.\aHe Ha CYMaTa OT
38 000 na. 06paTHo Ha "CTa61J1n" 00):1 sa nony.aaaae Ha 400 ,QHna OT xarnrrana Ha ,Qpy>KecTBoTO, l-1
axryanaa KbM MOMeHTa na npennpneaaae Ha ,Qe~CTBl-1H crpaexa B AreHl..\l-1H no Bnl-1CBaHl-1HTa ,Qanl-1
He,QB1J1>Kl-1Ml-1Te l-1MOTl-1, c06cTBeHocT Ha "CTOKl-1 sa 6l-1Ta" 00):1 nporrsnxa BaT na 6b,QaT C06CTBeHOCT Ha TOBa
,Qpy>KeCTBO 1J1nVl ca V13BbpWeH1J1 paanopennrenan c,QenK1J1 C THX. 3a na C1J1 BbpHe 06Ll.\1J1HaTa ,QHnoBeTe,
Bb3MO>KHOCTVlTe ca ,QBe: "CTa6V1n" 00):1 na npexsspna B noma Ha 06Ll.\1J1HaTa npVl,Q06V1T1J1Te spea
npVlBaTl-13al..\1J1H ,QHnOBe C HOTapVlanHO 3aBepeH ,QorOBOp; V1nVl aKO He CTOp1J1 TOBa ,Q06pOBonHO cne,QBa
06Ll.\V1HaTa ,Qa npe,QHBl-1 l-1CK sa yCTaHoBHBaHe Ha npaBOTO na c06CTBeHOCT BbPXY AHnOBeTe, HO
npensaparenao ,Qa e sspaana cyMaTa OT 38 000 na. Cnensa ,Qa ce 1J1MaT npe,QBVI,Q cnenaare Bb3MO>KHVI
pVlCKOBe. B cnY4a~ , 4e V1MYLl.\eCTBOTO e npexnspneuo na TpeTO naue, a 0611\1J1HaTa e npasena cyMaTa OT
38 000 na., npencraanaaauia croaaocrra Ha ,QHnOBeTe, npl-1,Q06V1TVI OT CTa61J1n 00):1, Ll.\e ce HanO>K1J1
3aBe>K,QaHe Ha V1CKOBe sa 06paTHo epuuaue Ha nnareaara OT 06Ll.\V1HaTa cyMa 1J1n1J1 sa paseanase Ha
noroaopa, C KO~TO e npexaspnesa C06CTBeHOCna OT "CTOKVI sa 6l-1Ta" OOA Ha TpeTOTO n1J1l..\e. np1J1 rasaaa
cVlTyal..\l-1H 6V1 Morno na ce OKa>Ke, 4e B MOMeHTa, B KO~TO 06Ll.\l-1Ha Ka3aHnbK npl-1Be>K,Qa Ha "CTa6V1n" OOA
cyMaTa OT 38 000 na. "CTOKVI sa 61J1Ta" se-e He nparexaaa c06CTBeHOCT, BbPXY KOHTO ,Qa ce nOl-1CKa
aanarare Ha 06e3ne41J1TenHa MHpKa BbPXY 1J1MYLl.\eCTBO Cuen otieane-aaaae Ha nnaresara 06paTHO CYMa.
BbB apsaxa C1J13nO>KeH1J1Te cb06pa>KeHl-1H, KOM1J1Cl-1HTa C41J1Ta sa uenecioopasao 06C, KaTO opraa no
np1J1BaTVl3al..\V1H na aanpasa pa3YMHa npeueasa Ha 6anaHca Ha 1J1HTepeCVlTe Ha 06Ll.\V1HaTa 1J1 npl-1eMe peWeH1J1H
sa nO-HaTaTbWHl-1 ,Qe~CTB1J1H, KaTO ce cb06pa31J11J1 C¢aKTa, 4e B 61O,Q>KeT 2010 r. HHMa npe,QBVI,QeHVI cpencrsa
sa nnauiaae sa Bb3CTaHOBHBaHe Ha 100 % ,QHn Ha 06111l-1HaTa B"CTOK1J1 sa 61J1Ta" OOA, rp. Ka3aHnbK.
~~
ff~ 1
CTEltlAH ,QAM~HOB
KMem H8 06~UH8 K838
Csrnacyaana:
\
~~ ,
,;,
~ / ~~
eHeB ~y)I(1
MpVlaHa T
H-K omoen nHO
f'.;{/
f
./. - /
feoprVl YPYMOB'
~
an. CLJemOBOOumen
,
TaTHHa CTaHeBa
oupeKmop OUpeK4uR
•.
y~
I~
'
EBreHl-1H -lepaeaa
38MecmHUK-KMem C~T ~
v13rOTBVln:
'F
CTe¢Ka V1n1J1eBa CAfJ
an escn. "npUB., KOH4 UH8eMU OC"