Das Produktesicherheitsgesetz: Eine Büchse der Pandora Eugéne

Das Produktesicherheitsgesetz: Eine Büchse der Pandora Eugéne

Recht etzung
3/2010
Eugénie Holliger-Hagmann*
!
Das Produktesicherheitsgesetz:
Eine Büchse der Pandora
186
Das Produktesicherheitsgesetz (PrSG) trat am 1. Juli 2010
in Kraft und wirft mehr Fragen auf, als es löst
Ausgerechnet das Produktesicherheitsgesetz (PrSG)
schafft Unsicherheiten über seine Auslegung. Sein Verhältnis zu sektoriellen Produktsicherheitserlassen ist
prekär definiert. Die Akteure im öffentlichrechtlichen
PrSG sind nicht deckungsgleich mit jenen in seinem
privatrechtlichen Zwilling, dem Produktehaftpflichtgesetz (PrHG). Der Unterschied zwischen primär und
subsidiär Verantwortlichen ist nicht konsequent durchgeführt. Noch vieles mehr harrt der Auslegung durch
Verwaltung und Gerichte.
C’est précisément la loi sur la sécurité des produits (LSPro) qui engendre des incertitudes quant à son interprétation. Son lien avec les lois sectorielles sur la sécurité
des produits est défini de manière précaire. Les acteurs
de la LSPro de droit public ne se recoupent pas avec ceux
de son pendant de droit privé, la loi sur la responsabilité
du fait des produits (LRFP). La différence entre responsables à titre primaire et subsidiaire n’est pas appliquée
de manière conséquente. Sans compter que l’interprétation de cette loi réservera à l’administration et aux tribunaux encore d’autres surprises.
Inhalt
,>5# =5.5>*,# :=5.# +>5# 5.,*5# +5.# 1%<F.5>;<5&# !&*5.H.5*%B
*>(&,<:.+5&M#+>5#+%,#05,5*1#D(.#><&5&#%2R=%2*"#G5.#!&B
D5.'5<.=.>&65.# )2,,# =52.*5>F5&M# 45F;<5# 3.*>'5F# +5,#
,5'*(.>5FF5&# Z.F%,,5,M# D(&# +5)# ,5>&# -.(+2'*# 5.R%,,*#
4>.+M# P(..%&6# D(.# +5)# -./0# <%=5&# '[&&*5&"# N5=5&#
+5)#-./0#=5,*5<5&#)>&+5,*5&,#88I#,5'*(.>5FF5#\2&+5,B
65,5*15#2&+#P5.(.+&2&65&M#45F;<5#+>5#-.(+2'*,>;<5.B
<5>*#(+5.#654>,,5#3,H5'*5#+%D(&#.565F&"#/>5#65F*5&#R:.#
?]# D5.,;<>5+5&5# -.(+2'*5# 2&+# -.(+2'*'%*56(.>5&# >)#
@((+B#2&+#N(&R((+B\5.5>;<"#Z,#6>=*#+5,<%F=#'%2)#5>&#
-.(+2'*M# +%,# &>;<*# 2&*5.# )>&+5,*5&,# 5>&5# />;<5.<5>*,B
D(.,;<.>R*#RKFF*M#+>5#>&#5>&5)#/H51>%F5.F%,,#D5.%&'5.*#>,*"#
S&+# &2&# 6>F*# ,5>*# +5)# 8"# U2F># ?V8V# R:.# %FF5# -.(+2'*5#
6.2&+,K*1F>;<#%2;<#&(;<#+%,#-./0"#Z,#F[,*5#+%,#D5.%F*5B
*5#/^Z0?#8JK#18?#15*#F59:*.:*53#1*.#J*.%<59:#%,1#8%?I
?*.J*.%<59:#J*,%3-3*,#A8?9:5,*,K#$;;8.83*K#$,B8+*,K#
$5.'15265# 2&+# /;<2*1%2,.:,*2&65&M# %=5.# %2;<# D(&#
Z.1526&>,,5&# R:.# 9%2,<%F*M# 9(==_# 2&+# /H(.*# .565F*5"#
05)K,,# +5.# \(*,;<%R*# 12)# -./0I# D5.F%&6*# +5.# /;<2*1#
+5.#/>;<5.<5>*#2&+#+5.#05,2&+<5>*#+5.#T5&,;<5&M#+%,,#
+%,#-./0#R:.#,K)*F>;<5#-.(+2'*5#6>F*M#R:.#+>5#&>;<*#=5B
.5>*,# >&# +5.# ,5'*(.>5FF5&# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1B
65=2&6# +>5# D5.F%&6*5&# />;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#
#=5,*5<5&"# $>5# +%,# /^Z0# >,*# %2;<# +%,# -./0# 5>&# [RR5&*B
F>;<.5;<*F>;<5.#Z.F%,,"#
!"# $%&&#'())*#+%,#-./0#12.#3&45&+2&67
#
8"#9:.+5#,;<(&#=5>)#/*%.*
#
?"#@3ABC>,*5#D()#/5;(
!!"# -5.,(&%5#+.%)%*>,
#
8"#$5&>6#:=5.15265&+5#E(FF5&D5.*5>F2&6
#
?"#G5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#5&*H2HH*#,>;<#%F,#-.(*52,
#
I"#J)&>H.K,5&1#+5,#95.,*5FF5.,
#
L"#9%2H*.(FF5&M#N5=5&.(FF5&#2&+#,(6%.#E(FF5&45;<,5F
#
O"#E(FF5&,*.5>*#+5.#P(FF126,B#2&+#Q(&*.(FF(.6%&5
!!!"# $%&#'()*+*,#-%.#/.01%231*4,5350,
!P"# G>5#-.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*
#
8"#/>;<5.<5>*,H%.%)5*5.
#
?"#/>;<5.<5>*,&%;<45>,
6"# 789:(8.23;<59:3*,
#
8"#/H51>%F,5.D>;5#R:.#Q(&,2)5&*5&H.(+2'*5#
#
="#>.+8,5?8350,?;<59:3*,
#
I"#N525#E(FF5#R:.#+5&#9K&+F5.
#
@"#A*B1*;<59:3*,
P!"# $%,#+%,#-./0#+5&#S&*5.&5<)5&#%2;<#&(;<#=5,;<5.*
#
8"#T%,,&%<)5&#+5,#P(FF126,(.6%&,
#
?"#/*.%R=5,*>))2&65&
#
I"#U%<.5,45;<,5F#?V88W?V8?
P!!"#365&+%#X#(+5.#4%,#12#*2&#>,*
I. Wann kommt das PrSG zur
Anwendung?
1. Hürde schon beim Start
$5&&# 95.,*5FF5.# 2&+# %&+5.5# P5.)%.'*5.# 4>,,5&# 4(FB
F5&M# (=# ><.5# -.(+2'*5# 2&*5.# +%,# -./08# R%FF5&M# ,*(FH5.&#
Y# E3#G."#>2."#$>.*,;<%R*,.5+%'*(.>&#2&+#E5R5.5&*>&#R:.#-.(+2'*B
?59:*.:*53# %,1# /.01%23:8&3;<59:3C# D*.&8??3*# E/.FG# H# /.01%23#I
.>,>'5&# >)# 0.>RR# X# .5;<*F>;<5# @%FF,*.>;'5# D5.)5>+5&`M# /;<2F*<5,,#
P5.F%6M#a:.>;<#?V8V"
8#
\2&+5,65,5*1# :=5.# +>5# -.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*# D()# 8?"# U2&># ?VV]#
b-./0cM#/E#]IV"88"
?#
\2&+5,65,5*1#:=5.#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*#D(&#*5;<&>,;<5&#Z>&.>;<*2&B
65&#2&+#05.K*5&#D()#8]"#TK.1#8]de#b/^Z0cM#/E#f8]"8"
I#
\(*,;<%R*#12)#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1#b]f"VOOc#D()#?O"#U2&>#
?VVf#b\\F#?VVf#dLVdM#/"#?Ic"
3/2010
@:.#+>5#6>6%&*>,;<5#a%<F#+5.#Z.1526&>,,5M#+>5#,>;<#%2R#
1*(#A8.23#J*4,1*,#%,1#%,3*.#18?#/.FG#&8BB*,K#+*J*,#
&2.#,;<(&#/(.*>)5&*5#+5.#=5>+5&#0.(,,D5.*5>F5.#T>6.(,#
2&+# k((H# 5>&5&# 9>&45>,M# +>5# %=5.# &(;<# FK&6,*# &>;<*#
%FF5#-.(+2'*'%*56(.>5&#2)R%,,5&"#!&#5>&5)#6.(,,5&#C%B
1*,#15*?*.#$,J5*3*.#J*4,1*,#?59:#X*)*5B?#J5?#-%#@Y#YYY#
D5.,;<>5+5&5#-.(+2'*5"#G%12#'())5&#%FF5#Z.1526&>,B
,5M# +>5# >&# /H51>%F65,;<KR*5&# R:.# !&&5&5>&.>;<*2&6M#
9%2,<%F*M#/H(.*#2&+#@.5>15>*M#T(+5M#Q(,)5*>'M#ZF5'*.(B
%HH%.%*5M#32*()(=>F#5*;"#%&65=(*5&#45.+5&"#G%,#/5;(L#
<%*#5>&5#C>,*5#)>*#+5&#=5,*5<5&+5&#-.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*,B
65,5*15&# 2&+# BD5.(.+&2&65&# 5.,*5FF*# ,(4>5# 5>&5# &%;<#
-.(+2'*5&# 65(.+&5*5# C>,*5# +5.# R:.# +>5# T%.'*:=5.4%B
;<2&6# 12,*K&+>65&# !&,*%&15&"O# \5>+5# C>,*5&# 5.<5=5&#
'5>&5&#3&,H.2;<#%2R#P(FF,*K&+>6'5>*"#
3.*"# 8# 3=,"# I# -./0# 654K<.*# +5&# ,5'*(.>5FF5&# =2&+5,B
.5;<*F>;<5&# \5,*>))2&65&# &2.# +%&&# +5&# P(..%&6M#
)*,,# (53# 5:,*,# E18??*BJ*# Z5*B# D*.&0B+3# )5.1["# !,# 1*.#
\(*,;<%R*#/5>*5#?OWe#5.RK<.*#)%&M#+%,,#+%,#-./0#+%&&#
$,)*,1%,+#4,1*3K#)*,,#5,#*5,*(#?*230.5*BB*,#\.B8??#
12#5>&5)#0565&,*%&+M#+5&#+%,#-./0#.565F*M#&>;<*,#&(.B
)>5.*# >,*M# =5>,H>5F,45>,5M# 45&&# +5.# ,5'*(.>5FF5# Z.F%,,#
'5>&5# P(.'5<.5&# 12.# 05R%<.5&5.'5&&2&6# (+5.# '5>&5#
A*B1*;<59:3*,# ,89:# 1*(# !,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,# *,3:VB3#
01*.#)*,,#*.#2*5,*#1*(#?;*-54?9:*,#G*&V:.1%,+?;0B
*5&1>%F#+5,#-.(+2'*,#5&*,H.5;<5&+5#Q5&&15>;<&2&65&#
(+5.# $%.&<>&45>,5# D5.F%&6*"# @%FF,# +5.# ,5'*(.>5FF5# Z.B
F%,,# 14%.# 5>&5# \5,*>))2&6# 5&*<KF*M# +>5# D(.65,5<5&5#
C[,2&6#i5+(;<#D(&#i5&5.#>)#-./0#%=45>;<*M#<%*#+5.#,5'B
30.5*BB*# \.B8??# 60..8,+K# ?0&*.,# *.# 18J*5# E18??*BJ*# Z5*B#
D5.R(F6*#4>5#+>5#>)#-./0#D(.65,5<5&5#C[,2&6#)>*#+5&#
<(<5&#/*%&+%.+,#+5.#Z0BE>;<*F>&>5`"#G>5,5#E%-/e#42.B
+5#+2.;<#+%,#-./0#>&<%F*F>;<#45>*65<5&+#>&#+%,#,;<45>B
15.>,;<5#E5;<*#:=5.&())5&"#!)#9>&=F>;'#%2R#+5&#<(B
<5&# />;<5.<5>*,,*%&+%.+# +5.# E%-/# ,%6*# +>5# \(*,;<%R*#
%2R# /5>*5# ?8M# 45&&# 5>&# 95.,*5FF5.# 9%R*2&6,.>,>'5&# >)#
32,F%&+#D5.)5>+5&#4(FF5M#):,,5#5.#+%R:.#,(.65&M#+%,,#
,5>&5# -.(+2'*5# i5+5&R%FF,#+5)# >)#-./0# D(.65,5<5&5&#
/>;<5.<5>*,&>D5%2#5&*,H.5;<5&"#Z,#=5,*5<5#'5>&#0.2&+M#
+5)#95.,*5FF5.#5>&5#D5.4%F*2&6,.5;<*F>;<5#/>;<5.<5>*,B
1*4,5350,#D0.-%+*J*,K#15*#:5,3*.#X*,*.#5(#/.01%23:8&3B
;<59:3.*9:3#:5,3*.:*.:5,23"
/(R5.&# ,>;<# +5.# ,5'*(.>5FF5# Z.F%,,# %&# +5&# D()# :=5.65B
(.+&5*5&# 05,5*1# D(.6565=5&5&# E%<)5&# <KF*M# =5.2<*#
+>5#3=45>;<2&6#D()#-./0#14%.#%2R#5>&5.#<>&.5>;<5&B
+5&#65,5*1F>;<5&#0.2&+F%65"#G>5#\(*,;<%R*#=5*(&*#%=5.M#
+%,,#+%,#-./0#R:.#+%,#/;<2*1&>D5%2M#+>5#T%,,&%<)5&#
+5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#2&+#i5&5#+5.#P(FF126,(.6%&5#+5&#
T%,,,*%=#,5*1*M#+5.#6.2&+,K*1F>;<#%2;<#R:.#+>5#,5'*(.>5FB
F5&#Z.F%,,5#)%,,65=5&+#>,*"#G%,#=5+52*5*#&>;<*,#%&+5B
.5,M# %F,# +%,,# +%,# -./0# >))5.# +%&&# P(..%&6# 65&>5,,*M#
45&&#+>5#12#=52.*5>F5&+5#\5,*>))2&6#>)#,5'*(.>5FF5&#
Z.F%,,#<>&,>;<*F>;<#+5.#+.5>#65&%&&*5&#\5.5>;<5#X#'(&B
'.5*5# />;<5.<5>*,D(.6%=5&M# T%,,&%<)5&# +5.# !&D5.B
'5<.=.>&65.#2&+#,(F;<5#+5.#P(FF126,(.6%&5#X#+%,#<(<5#
/;<2*1&>D5%2# +5,# -./0# &>;<*# 5..5>;<*"# G>5# \(*,;<%R*#
10;;*B3#8%&#F*53*#=L#,89:M#E/.01%23*#(N??*,#*5,#:0:*?#
/;<2*1&>D5%2# R:.# +>5# 05,2&+<5>*# 2&+# />;<5.<5>*# D(&#
-5.,(&5&# 654K<.F5>,*5&`"# $5>F# 5>&>65# +5.# ,5'*(.>5FF5&#
Z.F%,,5#,;<(&#:=5.#5>&#<%F=5,#U%<.<2&+5.*#%2R#+5)#\2B
;'5F# <%=5&M# 45>,5&# +>5# />;<5.<5>*,D(.,*5FF2&65&M# %2R#
+5&5&#,>5#=5.2<5&M#5>&5#,H:.=%.5#-%*>&%#%2R"#
O8?# /.FG# )%.1*# 1%.9:# 15*# P0.(%B5*.%,+# E18??*BJ*#
a>5F#D5.R(F6*`#>&#3.*"#8#3=,"#I#)>*#5>&5.#32,F562&6,<_B
H(*<5'#=5F%,*5*M#+>5#D5.)5>+=%.#6545,5&#4K.5"#/(#,%6*#
+%,#+52*,;<5#0-/0d#>&#j#8#3=,"#IM#+%,,#+>5#P(.,;<.>R*5&M#
+>5#+5.#054K<.F5>,*2&6#D(&#/>;<5.<5>*#2&+#05,2&+<5>*#
=5>)#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#(+5.#32,,*5FF5&#D(&#-.(+2'*5&#
15*,*,K# ,%.# 18,,# ,59:3# +*B3*,K# E?0)*53# 5,# 8,1*.*,#
E5;<*,D(.,;<.>R*5&#5&*,H.5;<5&+5#(+5.#45>*5.65<5&+5#
3&R(.+5.2&65&# %&# +>5# 054K<.F5>,*2&6# +5.# />;<5.<5>*#
2&+#05,2&+<5>*#D(.65,5<5&#,>&+`"#G%,,5F=5#6>F*#R:.#+>5#
EQ*?0,1*.*,#/<59:3*,#J*5(#!,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,#D0,#6*.B
=.%2;<5.H.(+2'*5&`# ,(4>5# <>&,>;<*F>;<# +5.# kZBQ5&&B
15>;<&2&6# 2&+# R:.# +>5# l=5.4%;<2&6# +5,# !&D5.'5<.B
=.>&65&,# D(&# -.(+2'*5&# +2.;<# +>5# \5<[.+5&"# G>5,5#
'5>&5# a45>R5F# 12F%,,5&+5# @(.)2F>5.2&6# <K**5# %2;<#
+5)#-./0#62*65*%&"
2. FAQ-Liste vom Seco
$565&# +5.# %=,5<=%.5&M# D()# -./0# 2&+# +5.# -./Pf# 65B
?9:8&&*,*,#$%?B*+%,+?;.0JB*(*#?38&4*.3*#18?#F*90#18?#
05,5*1#2&+#+>5#P5.(.+&2&6#=5.5>*,#%2R#><.#!&'.%R**.5B
*5&#<>&#)>*#5>&5.#@3ABC>,*5]#12)#-./0#2&+#12.#-./P#
8%?"# O*.# R838B0+# (53# 1*,# EP.*S%*,3BT# $?2*1# U%*?B
*>(&,`#42.+5#=5.5>*,#&%;<#45&>65&#$(;<5&#+2.;<#5>&5#
&52# %2R65*%2;<*5# @.%65# 5.6K&1*"# U5# ':.15.# +>5# %)#
I8"# G515)=5.# ?V88# 5.F[,;<5&+5# l=5.6%&6,R.>,*# 4>.+M#
1*?30#:V%4+*.#)*.1*,#P.8+*,#1*.#W*.?3*BB*.#%,1#!,D*.B
'5<.=.>&65.#D(&#-.(+2'*5&#%2R*%2;<5&"#G5,<%F=#>,*#>)B
)5.# +>5# &525,*5# P5.,>(&# +>5,5.# @3A# 12# '(&,2F*>5.5&"#
32;<# +>5# ,5'*(.>5FF5&# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*15# 2&+#
P5.(.+&2&65&# 45.+5&# F%2R5&+# %&# +>5# Z0BC56>R5.>5B
.2&6#%&65H%,,*"#Z,#>,*#<52*5#>))5.#45&>65.#P5.F%,,#%2R#
+>5#D(.<%&+5&5&#65+.2;'*5&#P5.,>(&5&M#2&+#)%&#<KF*#
,>;<#=5,,5.#%&<%&+#+5,#!&*5.&5*,#m#i(2."#
05,5*1# :=5.# *5;<&>,;<5# 3.=5>*,)>**5F# 2&+# P5.=.%2;<5.H.(B
+2'*5#D()#e"#U%&2%.#?VVL#b05.K*5B#2&+#-.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1#X#
0-/0c#\2&+5,65,5*1=F%**#U%<.6%&6#?VVL#^5>F#!#N."#8M#%2,6565=5&#12#
\(&&#%)#]"#U%&2%.#?VVLM#/5>*5#?"
f#
P5.(.+&2&6# :=5.# +>5# -.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*# D()# 8]"# T%># ?V8V#
b-./PcM#/E#]IV"88"
]#
<**HhWW444"H.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*"%+)>&";<"
d#
/*%%*,,5'.5*%.>%*#R:.#$>.*,;<%R*#>)#Z>+65&[,,>,;<5&#P(F',4>.*B
,;<%R*,+5H%.*5)5&*#bZPGc"
O#
<**HhWW444"H.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*"%+)>&";<"
e#
E>;<*F>&>5# ?VV8W]OWZ0# +5,# Z2.(HK>,;<5&# -%.F%)5&*,# 2&+# +5,#
E%*5,# D()# I"# G515)=5.# ?VV8# :=5.# +>5# %FF65)5>&5# -.(+2'*,>;<5.B
:*53C#$QB"#]#^^_@#D0(#^`"^"=YY="
L#
!
!,1*(# *?# F9:%3-;<59:3*,# &N.# 15*# F59:*.:*53# %,1# G*B
,2&+<5>*#D(&#-5.,(&5&#%2R,*5FF*#2&+#+>5,5#*5>F45>,5#5nB
823K#3*5B)*5?*#,%.#?9:)8((5+#1*4,5*.3K#?9:8&&3#*?#20,B
'.5*5#/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#%&#-.(+2'*5#2&+#,(6%.#
/;<2*1&(.)5&"# G%+2.;<# ,*.5;'*# 5,# ,5>&5# ^5&*%'5F# 4>5#
*5,*#R.82*#8%9:#,89:#1*,#G*4B1*,#1*?#;.5D83*,#W8&3B
;<59:3.*9:3?# 8%?K# )0# *?# 8B?# $.?*,8B# &N.# 15*# +*&8:.*,I
=51(65&5# 3.62)5&*>5.2&6# >)# /;<%+5&5.,%*1H.(15,,#
+>5&*"
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
187
3/2010
!
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
188
G5.#(<&5#05+%&'5&%'.(=%*>'#&%;<D(FF1>5<=%.5&#%2*<5&B
*>,;<5&# 32,F562&6# D(&# 3.*"# 8# 3=,"# I# >&# +5.# \(*,;<%R*#
D5.H%,,*#@3A#3"#8#5>&5&#GK)HR5."#G%&%;<#5.6K=5&#,>;<#
32,&%<)5&#D()#-.>&1>HM#+%,,#+%,#-./0#6.2&+,K*1F>;<#
R:.#%FF5#-.(+2'*5#6>F*M#%2,#+5)#-./0#,5F=,*#2&+#%2,#+5.#
P(..%&6.565F2&6# D(&# 3.*"# 8# 3=,"# IM# 4%,# %=5.# %2R# 5>&5#
^%2*(F(6>5#<>&%2,FK2R*"#05)K,,#@3A#65&>5,,*#5>&#/5'B
30.*.B8??# 60..8,+K# )*,,# *.# Ee3*9:,"f# F59:*.:*53?;<59:B
*5&`# >&# \5126# %2R# =5,*>))*5# E>,>'5&# (+5.# E>,>'(B
'%*56(.>5&# 5&*<KF*M# 2&+# 14%.# ,5F=,*# +%&&M# 45&&# +5.#
/5'*(.5.F%,,# 5>&# *>5R5.5,# />;<5.<5>*,&>D5%2# R5,*F56*# %F,#
+%,#-./0"#G>5,5#32,F562&6#4>+5.,H.>;<*#+5)#D(&#+5.#
\(*,;<%R*# =5*(&*5&# P(..%&6# +5,# <(<5&# />;<5.<5>*,B
&>D5%2,# +5,# -./0"# 32;<# '%&&# +5.# >&# @3A# 3"# 8# %2R65B
,*5FF*5&#\5<%2H*2&6M#5>&#,5'*(.>5FF5.#Z.F%,,#)>*#\5,*>)B
(%,+*,#NJ*.#15*#789:(8.23;<59:3*,#J*3.*&&*,1#R0,I#
#,2)5&*5&H.(+2'*5# 65<5# +5)# -./0# D(.M# &>;<*# (<&5#
\5,?9:.V,2%,+#J*5+*;<59:3*3#)*.1*,"#\?#5?3#5((*.:5,#
+5&'=%.M#+%,,#+>5#>&#5>&5)#+5.#*5>F45>,5#.5;<*#=5*%6*5&#
?*230.5*BB*,# \.B8??*# D*.8,2*.3*,# 789:(8.23;<59:3*,#
+%,#D()#-./0#%&65H5>F*5M#+2.;<#5>&5#)(+5.&5#32RR%,B
,2&6# D(&# Q(&,2)5&*5&,;<2*1# 65H.K6*5# />;<5.<5>*,B
&>D5%2#&>;<*#5..5>;<5&M#,(#+%,,#+5)#-./0#+5.#P(..%&6#
12'())5&# ):,,*5"# @%FF,# ,>;<# %=5.# +>5# ,5'*(.>5FF5&#
789:(8.23;<59:3*,#J*.*53?#8%&#1*(#F59:*.:*53?,5D*8%#
1*?#/.FG#J*4,1*,K#5?3#15*#O5?2%??50,#%(#E/.FG# 01*.#
,5'*(.>5FF5.#Z.F%,,`#(<&5<>&#&2.#5>&#/*.5>*#2)#+5,#Q%>B
,5.,#\%.*"#
Z,#>,*#=52&.2<>65&+M#+%,,#+%,#@3ABG('2)5&*#)>*#+5&#
%2;<# %&# %&+5.5&# /*5FF5&# &>;<*# >))5.# :=5.15265&+5&#
3&*4(.*5&#+5,#/5;(#%2R#+5.#5.,*5&#/5>*5#5>&5&#G>,;F%>B
(*.#*,3:VB3"#O8,89:#D*.?3*:*,#?59:#15*#P$U#8B?#E.*5,*#
J.>5&*>5.2&6,<>FR5#+5.#P5.4%F*2&6`"#T%,,65=5&+#,5>5&#
E*5,-5+#15*#*5,?9:BV+5+*,#G*?*3-*?I#%,1#6*.0.1,%,+?B
*5n*5# ,(4>5# +>5# 654(<&*5&# T%*5.>%F>5&# b1"\"# \(*,;<%R*#
2&+#Z.FK2*5.2&65&#12)#-./0W-./Pc`"#3&+5.5.,5>*,#.5B
F%*>D>5.*# +%,# +>5# \5+52*2&6# +5.# @3A# 6%&1# 5.<5=F>;<M#
2&+# 5,# 4>.+# +5)# \(*,;<%R*,*5n*# 12)# P5.<KF*&>,# 14>B
,;<5&# -./0# 2&+# ,5'*(.>5FF5&# Z.F%,,5&# +(;<# &(;<# +>5#
65=:<.5&+5#E5D5.5&1#5.4>5,5&"
II. Personae dramatis
1. Wenig überzeugende
Rollenverteilung
G%,#-./0#FK,,*#,>;<#%F,#/;<%2,H>5F#>&#145>#3'*5&#>&*5.B
H.5*>5.5&"#G5.#5.,*5#3'*#=5R%,,*#,>;<#)>*#+5&#3&R(.+5B
.2&65&M#+>5#6.2&+,K*1F>;<#%FF5#-.(+2'*5#>&#i5&5)#T(B
)5&*# %2R45>,5&# ):,,5&M# +%# ,>5# >&# P5.'5<.# 65=.%;<*#
)*.1*,"#O*.#-)*53*#$23#:8,1*B3#D0,#1*,#/<59:3*,#1*.#
$23*%.*# 5,# 1*.# 789:(8.23;:8?*"# $B?# d*S%5?53*,# ?5,1#
+%&&# &2.# &(;<# +>5#"#$!%&'$('$)*#+%,('# >)# /H>5F"# G%,#
-5.,(&5&D5.15>;<&>,#,%6*M#45F;<5#-5.,(&5&#>&#+5&#D5.B
,;<>5+5&5&# />*2%*>(&5&# R:.# 45F;<5# 32R6%=5&# D5.%&*B
4(.*F>;<#,>&+"#G>5#3'*52.5M#+>5#D(&#+5.#95.,*5FF2&6#+5,#
-.(+2'*,# :=5.# !)H(.*M# 3&=>5*5&# 2&+# 12.# P5.R:62&6B
,*5FF5&M# D(&# +5,,5&# P5.45&+2&6W3&45&+2&6# +2.;<#
G>5&,*F5>,*5.#=>,#2&+#)>*#+5)#P5.'%2R5&M#P5.,;<5&'5&M#
P5.F5><5&M#P5.)>5*5&#(+5.#P5.F5%,5&#%2R#+5&#-F%&#*.5B
*5&M# <%=5&# *5>F45>,5# *.%65&+5# E(FF5&M# 45.+5&# )>*# N5B
=5&.(FF5&# %=65,H5>,*# (+5.# D5.,;<4>&+5&# ,HK*5.# ,(6%.#
D(&#+5.#\:<&5"
2. Der Inverkehrbringer entpuppt sich
als Proteus
G>5#)5>,*5&#32R*.>**5#2&+#3'*>(&5&#*5>F*#+%,#-./0#&>;<*#
&K<5.# 2),;<.>5=5&5&# -5.,(&5&# 12M# ,(&+5.&# 65&5.5FF#
+5)#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65."#3&#D5.,;<>5+5&5&#/*5FF5&#,5*1*#
*?#5:,#8B?#:8,1*B,1*#01*.#D*.;<59:3*3*#/*.?0,#D0.8%?K#
1%.9:# P0.(%B5*.%,+*,# )5*# E/.01%23*# 1N.&*,# 5,# 6*.B
2*:.#+*J.89:3#)*.1*,a[#01*.#Eb*.#*5,#/.01%23#5,#6*.B
2*:.#J.5,+3Ka["#Q*5#<N9:35+*.#Q*3.89:3%,+#2c,,3*#(8,#
6F%2=5&M# +%,# -./0# 5.R%,,5# &2.# 95.,*5FF5.M# !)H(.*52.5M#
9K&+F5.#2&+#G>5&,*F5>,*5."#G(;<#*%2;<5&#%2R#+5.#-5.,(B
&5&F>,*5# 3'*52.5# %2RM# +>5# D5.)2*F>;<# &(;<# 6%.# &>;<*#
4>,,5&M#+%,,#%2;<#><&5&#5>&5#E(FF5#1265+%;<*#>,*"#G5.#
=.5>*#65RK;<5.*5#\56.>RR#+5,#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&,#<%*#12.#
@(F65M# +%,,# D>5F# )5<.# S&*5.&5<)5&# D()# -./0# 5.R%,,*#
45.+5&#%F,#D()#-.90M#+%,#R%,*#%2,,;<F>5,,F>;<#&2.#R:.#
+5&#95.,*5FF5.#2&+#+>5#><)#6F5>;<#65,*5FF*5&#-5.,(&5&#
6>F*"#
S&*5.# +5&# \56.>RR# +5,# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65&,# R%FF5&# 6%&1#
D5.,;<>5+5&%.*>65# ^K*>6'5>*5&"# 32,# 3.*"# ?# 3=,"# I# FK,,*#
,>;<#%=F5>*5&M#+%,,#%FF5#-5.,(&5&M#+>5#i5)%&+5)#5>&#-.(B
+2'*# 5&*65F*F>;<# (+5.# 2&5&*65F*F>;<# :=5.F%,,5&M# !&D5.B
'5<.=.>&65.# ,>&+"# Z.,*5.# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# >,*# &%*2.B
65)K,,# +5.# 95.,*5FF5."# G%&&# R(F65&# !)H(.*52.5M#
0.(,,>,*5&M# G5*%>FF>,*5&# 2&+# ,(&,*>65# P5.'K2R5."# 32;<#
)*.#E20?3*,B0?*[#b*.J*+*?9:*,2*#(89:3#01*.#/.01%2B
3*#-%#/dIZ)*92*,#E+.835?[#8J+5J3K#J.5,+3#15*?*#5,#6*.B
2*:.K#)*5B#*.#18J*5#+*)*.JB59:#01*.#J*.%<59:#:8,1*B3"#
G%)>*#5.R:FF*#5.#+>5#>&#3.*"#8#3=,"#?#65&%&&*5#P(.%2,,5*B
12&6# R:.# +>5# 3&45&+2&6# +5,# -./0M# +%,# &2.# +%,# .5>&#
H.>D%*5#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#=5>,5>*5#FK,,*"#!&D5.'5<.=.>&B
65.#>,*#%2;<M#45.#5>&5#/%;<5#D5.)>5*5*#(+5.#6.%*>,#D5.B
F5><*M#=5>,H>5F,45>,5#+%,#@5.>5&<(*5FM#+%,#,5>&5&#0K,*5&#
P5F(,# %&=>5*5*M# (+5.# +%,# 95>)45.'5.65,;<KR*M# +%,# 5>B
,*(# R8%4,3*.*??*,3*,# NJ*.?# b09:*,*,1*# *5,*,# d8B
,5&)K<5.#(+5.#5>&5#\(<.)%,;<>&5#12)#32,H.(=>5.5&#
)>*6>=*"#/5F=,*#C5%,>&665=5.#45.+5&#D()#-./0#5.R%,,*M#
,(R5.&#,>;<#5>&#'(&'.5*5,#05,;<KR*#%2R#5>&#-.(+2'*#=5B
1>5<*M# +%,# +5.# C5%,>&665=5.# ,5F=,*# =5,;<%RR*# (+5.# >)B
H(.*>5.*#<%*M#,5F=,*#<5.65,*5FF*M#2)65=%2*#(+5.#'()HF5*B
*>5.*# <%*# (+5.# <5.,*5FF5&# F>5,,"# G(;<# =5># +5&# )5>,*5&#
C5%,>&665,;<KR*5&# <%*# +5.# '(&'.5*5# P5.*.%6# %2,B
,;<F>5,,F>;<# +>5# @>&%&1>5.2&6# +5.# 3=6%=5# 5>&5,# -.(B
+2'*,#+2.;<#5>&5&#G.>**5&#%&#+5&#C5%,>&6&5<)5.#12)#
0565&,*%&+M# 2&+# +%&&# >,*# +5.# C5%,>&665=5.# H.(+2'*B
,>;<5.<5>*,.5;<*F>;<#%2,#+5)#/;<&5>+5."#
3.*"#?#3=,"#I#,*5FF*#+5)#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#%2,+.:;'F>;<#
D>5.# 45>*5.5# /%;<D5.<%F*5# 6F5>;<h# G5&# 6545.=F>;<5&#
01*.# J*.%<59:*,# \5+*,+*J.8%9:K# 18?# Q*.*53:8B3*,# -%.#
\5&:*12&6# +2.;<# G.>**5M# +%,# 3&=>5*5&# ,(4>5# +>5# P5.B
45&+2&6#(+5.#3&45&+2&6#>)#E%<)5&#+5,#Z.=.>&65&,#
5>&5.#G>5&,*F5>,*2&6"#T>*#+5)#G>5&,*F5>,*5.#=.>&6*#+%,#
05,5*1# 5>&5# -5.,(&# >&,# /H>5FM# D(&# +5.# >)# a2,%))5&B
3/2010
G*)*.JB59:*.# 01*.# J*.%<59:*.# \5+*,+*J.8%9:# 20((3#
5,#/.01%2350,?J*3.5*J*,#:V%4+#D0."#\?#)*.1*,#A8?9:5B
&5&M# 3HH%.%*5M# $5.'1526# (+5.# />;<5.<5>*,D(..>;<*2&B
65&#'(&,*.2>5.*W65=%2*W65=%,*5F*M#+>5#+%&&#>&#+5.#@%=B
.>'M#>&#+5.#\2+5#(+5.#%2R#+5)#$5.'HF%*1#D()#5>65&5&#
-5.,(&%F#D5.45&+5*#45.+5&"#G>5#\5*.>5=,'%&*>&5#5>&5,#
C5=5&,)>**5F<5.,*5FF5.,# =5.5>*5*# +>5# 5>65&5&# -.(+2'*5#
&N.#15*#6*.;<*+%,+#1*.#A538.J*53*.#-%K#%,1#15*#d*5,5B
+%,+?(533*B&8J.52#)5.1#D0,#5:.*.#/%3-*S%5;*#(53#1*,#
5>65&5&#-.(+2'*5&#%2R#9(;<6F%&1#65=.%;<*"#!&+5)#+%,#
05,5*1#%2;<#+%,#\5.5>*<%F*5&#D(&#-.(+2'*5&#12)#05B
=.%2;<#+2.;<#G.>**5#,(4>5#+%,#3&=>5*5&#>&#32,,*5FF2&B
+*,# 01*.# 1%.9:# 60.&N:.*,# 8B?# !,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,# 1*4B
&>5.*M#5.R%,,*#5,#=5.5>*,#5>&5#P(.,*2R5#+5.#-.(+2'*%=6%=5"#
9(*5F,#<%F*5&#R:.#><.5#0K,*5#\((*5M#P5F(,#(+5.#/H(.*%2,B
.:,*2&65&# =5.5>*M# 2&+# E5,*%2.%&*,M# Z>&'%2R,15&*.5&#
(+5.# Q>&+5.6K.*5&# ,*5FF5&# /H>5F65.K*5# 12.# P5.R:62&6"#
3FF5# +>5,5# -.(+2'*5# ):,,5&# +5&# />;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5B
.2&65&#5&*,H.5;<5&"#G%,,5F=5#6>F*#R:.#05.K*5#2&+#T%B
,;<>&5&#>)#/(F%.>2)#(+5.#>)#@>*&5,,,*2+>(#(+5.#R:.#+>5#
D()# k(>RR52.# 2&+# +5.# Q(,)5*>'5.>&# %F,# G>5&,*F5>,*5.#
D*.)*,1*3*,#/<*+*;.01%23*#%,1#G*.V3*"#$%9:#18?#$,B
H.5>,5&# 5>&5,# -.(+2'*,# +2.;<# $5.=2&6# 4>.+# D(&# +5.#
Q03?9:8&3#8%&#F*53*#=L#8B?#$,J5*3*,#1*4,5*.3K#8BB*.15,+?#
&2.M#45&&#>&#!&,5.%*5&M#-.(,H5'*5&M#Q%*%F(65&#5*;"#5>&#
\5,*5FF;(2H(&#5&*<%F*5&#>,*#(+5.#45&&#=5>#5>&5)#5F5'B
*.(&>,;<5&# 3&65=(*# %2;<# 5>&5# \5,*5FF2&6# %2R6565=5&#
45.+5&#'%&&"#
3. Omnipräsenz des Herstellers
^.K65.# +5.# 9%2H*.(FF5# >,*# +5.# 95.,*5FF5."# Z.# =F5>=*# =>,#
2&+# )>*# +5&# l=5.6%&6,=5,*>))2&65&# %)# Z&+5# +5,#
05,5*15,# H5.)%&5&*# >)# /H>5F"# G(;<# >,*# +5.# D5.4%FB
*2&6,.5;<*F>;<5# 95.,*5FF5.=56.>RR# +5,# -./0# &>;<*#
#1*92%,+?+B*59:# (53# ?*5,*(# :8&3;<59:3.*9:3B59:*,#
#-5&+%&*# >)# -.908V"# G5)# U2.>,*5&# >,*# 14%.# +>5# <%R*B
;<59:3.*9:3B59:*# GB*59:?3*BB%,+# 1*?# W*.?3*BB*.?# *5,*?#
0.2&+,*(RR,#(+5.#^5>FH.(+2'*,#)>*#+5)#95.,*5FF5.#+5,#
\,1;.01%23?#1%.9:#18?#/.WG#+*BV%4+K#*J*,?0#15*#60.B
,;<.>R*M#+%,,#%2;<#i5)%&+M#+5.#,5>&5&#N%)5&M#,5>&#$%B
.5&15>;<5&# (+5.# 5>&# %&+5.5,# Z.'5&&2&6,15>;<5&# %2R#
+5)# -.(+2'*# %&=.>&6*M# ,>;<# +5&# 3&,;<5>&# 5>&5,# 95.B
,*5FF5.,#6>=*#bA2%,><5.,*5FF5.c"#Z,#5.,;<5>&*#)5<.#%F,#F(B
6>,;<M#+%,,#>)#-.90#%2;<#+5)#!)H(.*52.#+>5#95.,*5FB
F5.5>65&,;<%R*#1265*5>F*#4>.+M#,(#+%,,#+5.#05,;<K+>6*5#
&>;<*# 65142&65&# >,*M# +5&# *%*,K;<F>;<5&# 95.,*5FF5.# %)#
Z&+5#+5.#$5F*#12#=5F%&65&"#G>5#@('2,,>5.2&6#%2R#+5&#
95.,*5FF5.#>,*#%F,(#5>&#k<%.%'*5.>,*>'2)#+5,#-.90"#G%B
+2.;<#65.K*#+>5#P5.%&*4(.*2&6#+5,#9K&+F5.,#D[FF>6#>&#
+5&# 9>&*5.6.2&+"# G>5,5.# '())*# >)# -.90# &2.# >&# +5&#
,5F*5&5&#@KFF5&#12.#Q%,,5M#+%#5.#(+5.#5>&#,(&,*>65.#C>5B
R5.%&*#+5,#-.(+2'*,#&>;<*#>&#+5.#C%65#(+5.#4>FF5&,#>,*M#
+5)# 05,;<K+>6*5&# +5&# >)# !&F%&+# +()>1>F>5.*5&# 95.B
Q%,1*?+*?*3-# NJ*.# 15*# /.01%23*:8&3;<59:3# D0(# ^L"# h%,5# ^iij#
e/.01%23*:8&3;<59:3+*?*3-K#/.WGfK#Fd#==^"^^="i@@"
8V#
,*5FF5.#(+5.#+>5#-5.,(&#12#&5&&5&M#+>5#><)#+%,#-.(+2'*#
65F>5R5.*#<%*"#!&#+>5,5&#@KFF5&#&>))*#5.#95.,*5FF5.5>65&B
,;<%R*#%&"#G5.#05,;<K+>6*5#<%*#5,#%F,(#R:.#+>5#9%R*2&6#
%2,#-.90#>))5.#)>*#5>&5)#95.,*5FF5.#12#*2&M#,5>#5,#)>*#
*5,*(#*9:3*,#01*.#*5,*(#4235D*,"#
G%,# E(FF5&D5.15>;<&>,# +5,# -./0# 45>,*# )5<.# 2&+# D5.B
,;<>5+5&%.*>65.5# 3'*52.5# %2R# %F,# i5&5,# +5,# -.90"# !)#
S&*5.,;<>5+#12)#-.90#D5.1>;<*5*#5,#+%.%2RM#+5&#95.B
?3*BB*.#-%#1*4,5*.*,"#\?#?*3-3#?*5,*#\g5?3*,-#%,1#P%,2B
*>(&# %F,# D5.%&*4(.*F>;<5.M# D()# 05,5*1# 5.R%,,*5.# -.(B
+215&*# 2&+# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# +5,# -.(+2'*,# %F,#
?*BJ?3D*.?3V,1B59:#D0.8%?"#!,#$.3"#=#$J?"#@#1*4,5*.3#*?#
+>5# -5.,(&5&M# +>5# 5=5&R%FF,# %F,# 95.,*5FF5.# 65F*5&"# G5.#
A2%,><5.,*5FF5.# 4>.+# >+5&*>,;<# 2),;<.>5=5&# 4>5# >)#
-.90"#G(;<#,*%**#+5,#!)H(.*52.,#4>.+#+5)#95.,*5FF5.#
+>5#-5.,(&#6F5>;<65,*5FF*M#+>5#%F,#P5.*.5*5.>&#+5,#&>;<*#>&#
+5.#/;<45>1#+()>1>F>5.*5&#95.,*5FF5.,#-%.(*/((M#4%,#%2;<#
>))5.#2&*5.#5>&5)#,(F;<5&#32R*.5*5&#12#D5.,*5<5&#>,*"#
G%,,#+>5#-./P#+%D(&#%=45>;<*M#)%;<*#5,#R:.#+>5#6565=5B
&5&R%FF,# %F,# 95.,*5FF5.>&# >&,# E5;<*# 65&())5&5# G5B#
R%;*(BP5.*.5*5.>&# (+5.# -,52+(D5.*.5*5.>&# &>;<*# 5>&R%B
;<5.M#%2;<#&>;<*#R:.#+%,#P(FF126,(.6%&M#+%,#,>;<#+%.2)#
':))5.&# )2,,M# 45.# R:.# +>5# Q(&R(.)>*K*,5.'FK.2&6#
D5.%&*4(.*F>;<#>,*"#
G>5#-./P#5.4K<&*#+5&#P5.*.5*5.#145>)%F"#!&#3.*"#f#3=,"#
I# ,H.>;<*# ,>5# D(&# +5.# !&,*%FF%*>(&# 2&+# !&,*%&+,*5FF2&6#
*5,*?#/.01%23?K#15*#E8%??9:B5*??B59:#D0(#P89:;*.?0,8B#
+5,#95.,*5FF5.,#(+5.#,5>&5,#>&#+5.#/;<45>1#$/'+'*0'1-!!'2
$'$#P5.*.5*5.,`#5.R(F6*"#!&#3.*"#]#3=,"#?#,%6*#,>5M#+>5#Q(&B
R(.)>*K*,5.'FK.2&6# 45.+5# D()# 95.,*5FF5.# (+5.# D(&#
#,5>&5)#>&#+5.#/;<45>1#$/'+'*0'1-!!'$'$#P5.*.5*5.#%2,65B
,*5FF*"# G>5# -./P# R%,,*# (RR5&,>;<*F>;<# &2.# +5&# G5B>2.5B#
P5.*.5*5.# >&,# E5;<*M# 4(6565&# +%,# -./0# %2;<# +5&#
#G5BR%;*(BP5.*.5*5.M#&K)F>;<#+>5#-5.,(&M#+>5#F5+>6F>;<#%F,#
P5.*.5*5.# %2R*.>**M# >&# +>5# 95.,*5FF5.D5.%&*4(.*2&6#
&>))*"#G(;<#:=5.#+5&#S)456M#+%,,#+%,#-./0#+5.#-5.B
,(&M#+>5#,>;<#%F,#P5.*.5*5.#65.>5.*M#95.,*5FF5.5>65&,;<%R*#
12*5>F*M# '%&&# +2.;<# -./P# 3.*"# ]# 3=,"# ?# %2;<# +5.# G5B#
R%;*(BP5.*.5*5.#12)#32,,*5FF5&#+5.#Q(&R(.)>*K*,5.'FKB
.%,+# D*.;<59:3*3_J*.*9:35+3# ?*5,K# ?0&*.,# *5,# G*?*3-#
(+5.#5>&5#P5.(.+&2&6#5>&5#,(F;<5#D5.F%&65&"
32;<# 45.# 5>&# -.(+2'*# 4>5+5.%2R=5.5>*5*# (+5.# +2.;<#
,5>&5# ^K*>6'5>*# +>5# />;<5.<5>*,5>65&,;<%R*5&# +5,# -.(B
1%23?#8,1*.)*535+#J**5,<%??3K#5?3#+*(V??#$.3"#=#$J?"#@#
-./0#5>&#95.,*5FF5."#S&*5.#$>5+5.%2R=5.5>*2&6#>,*#&>;<*#
&2.# +%,# E51_'F>5.5&# D(&# T%*5.>%F# (+5.# %2,65+>5&*5&#
Z.1526&>,,5&# 2&+# %&+5.5&# 3=RKFF5&# 12# D5.,*5<5&"#
32;<#+>5#05&5.%F.5D>,>(&#RKFF*#+%.2&*5.#2&+#+>5#E5D>,>B
(&#,>;<5.<5>*,.5F5D%&*5.#^5>F5#5>&5,#-.(+2'*,M#+5&&#,>5#
>,*# 5>&# $>5+5.%2R=5.5>*5&# 5>&5.# D(.<5.# &>;<*# )5<.# 65B
R%<.F(,#D5.45&+=%.5&#/%;<5#12#5>&5)#65=.%2;<,*:;<*>B
65&M# ,>;<5.5&# -.(+2'*"# />;<5.<5>*,.5F5D%&*# ,>&+# %2;<#
+%,#S)B#2&+#N52D5.H%;'5&M#=5>#+5)#-.(+2'*5#>&#\5B
<KF*&>,,5# 2)65R:FF*# (+5.# )>*# P5.H%;'2&65&# 2)<:FF*#
45.+5&M# +>5# 2&*5.# S),*K&+5&# +5&# E>,>'5&# +5,# -.(B
+2'*,# &>;<*# %&65)5,,5&# ,>&+# (+5.# '5>&5# +5&# E>,>'5&#
+5,# -.(+2'*,# 5&*,H.5;<5&+5# />;<5.<5>*,<>&45>,5# 2&+#
05R%<.5&4%.&2&65&#%2R45>,5&"#$5.#32*()(=>F5#*2&*M#
2&+#,5>#5,#%2;<#&2.#%2R#5F5'*.>,;<5)#$56#+2.;<#k<>HB
^2&>&6M#=5>#+5)#5.#,>;<#&>;<*#5>&)%F#+>5#9K&+5#,;<)2*B
!
<%&6# )>*# +5.# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*# &(;<# '%2)# +>5# E5+5#
4%."#
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
189
3/2010
!
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
190
1>6#)%;<*#2&+#,(#5>&5#C5>,*2&6,,*5>65.2&6#D(&#=>,#12#
LV#o# =54>.'*M# >,*# 95.,*5FF5."# G%,# E5,2F*%*# <%*# 4%<.B
,;<5>&F>;<# 5>&5# 45,5&*F>;<5# />;<5.<5>*,5>&=2,,5# +5,#
&>;<*# R:.# +5.%.*>6# /2H5.F5>,*2&65&# 65=%2*5&# T(*(.B
R%<.15265,#12.#@(F65"#95.,*5FF5.#>,*#%2;<#+5.#32*()5B
;<%&>'5.M# +5.# %F,# /H51>%F>,*# /*(,,+K)HR5.# D(&# JF+*>B
)5.&#.5H%.>5.*#2&+#4>5+5.#R2&'*>(&,*:;<*>6#)%;<*"#
$(# D()# 95.,*5FF5.# +>5# E5+5# >,*M# ,>&+# %2;<# >))5.# +5.#
A2%,><5.,*5FF5.M#+>5#-5.,(&M#+>5#,>;<#%F,#P5.*.5*5.>&#+5,#
95.,*5FF5.,#65.>5.*M#2&+#+>5#-5.,(&M#45F;<5#,>;<5.<5>*,B
.5F5D%&*5# ^K*>6'5>*5&# %)# -.(+2'*# %2,:=*M# >&=56.>RR5&"#
S&+# 4(# 5>&# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# %2R*.>**M# >)HF>1>5.*# +5.#
\56.>RR# %2*()%*>,;<# %2;<# +>5# D5.,;<>5+5&5&# %F,# 95.B
,*5FF5.#%6>5.5&+5&#-5.,(&5&"
4. Hauptrollen, Nebenrollen und sogar
Rollenwechsel
G5)#95.,*5FF5.#4>.+#D(&#3.*"#I#3=,"#e#-./0#+>5#9%2H*B
D5.%&*4(.*2&6#1265*5>F*M#4K<.5&+#!)H(.*52.5M#9K&+B
F5.#2&+#Z.=.>&65.#D(&#G>5&,*F5>,*2&65&#&2.#+%&&#%2RB
*.5*5&#,(FF5&M#45&&#+5.#95.,*5FF5.#-%2,5#<%*"#3.*"#I#3=,"#
k#?8+3#-)8.K#15*#/<59:3*,#J*5(#!,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,K#1*(#
5.,*5&# 3'*# +5,# G.%)%,M# ):,,*5&# D()# 95.,*5FF5.M# +5)#
!)H(.*52.M#+5)#9K&+F5.#2&+#+5)#G>5&,*F5>,*5.#5.R:FF*#
45.+5&M# R:6*# +%&&# %=5.# =5># +5&# +.5># C5*1*65&%&&*5&#
1*,#Z%?83-#E!%3!/+/4*56=5>"#G(;<#*%2;<*#+5.#12)#,2=,>B
+>K.5&# P5.%&*4(.*2&6,*.K65.# +56.%+>5.*5# !)H(.*52.#
5(# -)*53*,# $23K# 8B?0# J*5# 1*,# 789:(8.23;<59:3*,K#
HF[*1F>;<#>&#5>&5.#9%2H*.(FF5#%2R"#N5=5&#+5)#95.,*5FF5.#
>,*# 5.# +>5# 5>&1>65# -5.,(&M# +5.# 3.*"# f# 3=,"# ?# 2&+# I# +>5#
D(FF5# P5.%&*4(.*2&6# R:.# +>5# (.6%&>,%*(.>,;<5&# T%,,B
&%<)5&# %2R5.F56*h# %c# 12.# Z.'5&&2&6# D(&# -.(+2'*65B
R%<.5&M#=c#12#+5.5&#3=45&+2&6M#;c#12.#E:;'D5.R(F6=%.B
'5>*# +5.# -.(+2'*5M# +c# 12.# ,(.6RKF*>65&# -.:R2&6# D(&#
,>;<5.<5>*,=51(65&5&#E5'F%)%*>(&5&#2&+#5c#12.#/*>;<B
H.(=5&5.<5=2&6"
G>5#@2&'*>(&#+5,#9K&+F5.,M#+5)#65)K,,#3.*"#I#3=,"#e#
5>&5# N5=5&.(FF5# %F,# F5+>6F>;<# ,2=,>+>K.# P5.%&*4(.*F>B
;<5.#12'())M#4>.+#>&#3.*"#f#3=,"#L#5=5&R%FF,#%2R6545.B
*5*"#!&#+5.#N%;<)%.'*H<%,5#)2,,#5.#12.#Z>&<%F*2&6#+5.#
/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&# =5>*.%65&# 2&+# %&# +5.# l=5.B
4%;<2&6#+5.#>&#P5.'5<.#65=.%;<*5&#-.(+2'*5#)>*4>.B
'5&"#Z,#45.+5&#D()#9K&+F5.#,(6%.#T%,,&%<)5&#D5.B
F%&6*M# +>5# ><)# 5>&5# 4>.',%)5# a2,%))5&%.=5>*# )>*#
+5)# 95.,*5FF5.# (+5.# !)H(.*52.# ,(4>5# )>*# +5)# P(FFB
126,(.6%&#5.)[6F>;<5&"#S&*5.#+>5,5&#S),*K&+5&#'%&&#
5.# ,>;<# %F,(# &>;<*# )5<.# %2R# +>5# ><)# &(;<# =5>)# !&D5.B
'5<.=.>&65&# +5,# -.(+2'*,# 5.4>5,5&5# 0&%+5# +5.# &2.#
,2=,>+>K.5&#E(FF5#=5.2R5&"#a2.#3=R5+5.2&6#+5,#0545.B
=5,# <%**5# N%*>(&%F.%*# E>)588# =5%&*.%6*M# +5)# 05,5*1#
5>&5# P5.%&*4(.*2&6,'%,'%+5# =5>12R:65&"# G%.%2,# .5B
,2F*>5.*5#+5.#R.%64:.+>65#3=,%*1#e#D(&#3.*"#I"#Z.,*5&,#
42.+5#+%=5>#:=5.,5<5&M#+%,,#+5)#9K&+F5.#>)#145>*5&#
$23K# 8B?0# J*5# 1*,# 789:(8.23;<59:3*,K# 1%.9:# $.3"# L
/>*12&6# D()# ?I"W?L"# TK.1# ?VV]# +5.# $3QBN# bQ())>,,>(&# R:.#
$>.*,;<%R*#2&+#3=6%=5&#+5,#N%*>(&%F.%*,c"
88#
3=,"# L# 5>&5# +2.;<# +>D5.,5# 32R6%=5&# 5.,;<45.*5# E(FF5#
1265*5>F*# >,*M# +>5# i5&5.# +5.# 95.,*5FF5.,# 2&+# !)H(.*52.,#
&%<512# 6F5>;<'())*"# S&+# 145>*5&,# :=5.,%<# )%&# =5>#
+>5,5)#3=R5+5.2&6,D5.,2;<M#+%,,#+2.;<#+>5#,5F5'*>D5#
a2*5>F2&6# D(&# N5=5&.(FF5&# %&# &2.# +.5># %2,+.:;'F>;<#
65&%&&*5#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#+>5#:=.>65&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&B
65.#6%.#&>;<*#5&*F%,*5*#45.+5&M#,(&+5.&#&%;<#4>5#D(.#>&#
1*.# +B*59:*,# ;.5(V.*,# /<59:3# ?5,1# )5*# 1*.# W*.?3*BB*."#
G5.# a45;'# +5.# l=2&6# 4%.# %=5.# &>;<*M# +>5# P5.F5><5.M#
P5.)>5*5.# 2&+# C5%,>&665=5.M# +>5# '())5.1>5FF5&#
EF9:*,2*.[K# \5+*,+*J.8%9:*.# D0,# /.01%23*,K# Q*.*53B
<%F*5.#D(&#-.(+2'*5&#R:.#G.>**5#2&+#+>5#3&=>5*5.#>&#+5.#
H.>)K.5&#P5.%&*4(.*2&6#12#=5F%,,5&"#$565&#+5.#R%<.B
BV??5+*.)*5?*# ,%.# ?*B*235D*,# O*4,5350,# 1*.# ?%J?515V.#
P5.%&*4(.*F>;<5&# >&# 3.*"# I# 3=,"# e# X# +5.# +5)# -./0# %F,#
/;<&5FF,;<2,,#D5.%=.5>;<*#42.+5#X#'[&&5&#%FF5#:=.>65&#
!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# D()# P(FF126,(.6%&# 65&%2# 4>5# 5>&#
95.,*5FF5.# H.>)K.# =5F%&6*# 45.+5&"# />5# ,;<2F+5&# +5)#
P(FF126,(.6%&# +>5# 6F5>;<5&# 32,':&R*5# 2&+# ,(&,*>65#
T>*4>.'2&6M#45&&#@.%65&#(+5.#6%.#\5+5&'5&#<>&,>;<*B
F>;<#+5.#/>;<5.<5>*#5>&5,#-.(+2'*,#%2R*%2;<5&M#4>5#5>&#
95.,*5FF5."# G(;<# 65&%2# +%D(&# <%**5# ,>5# +%,# -%.F%)5&*#
5>65&*F>;<#5&*F%,*5&#4(FF5&"#
G>5# @3A# +5,# /5;(# H5.H5*2>5.5&# +%,# T>,,D5.,*K&+&>,M#
5,1*(#?5*#5,#O"#k#15*#789:(8.23;<59:3*,#1*.#WV,1B*.#
8B?# JB0??# E%,3*.+*0.1,*3*# ',3*.?3N3-%,+?;<59:3[# J*B
15>;<&5&"# G>5# ,2=,>+>K.5# P5.%&*4(.*2&6# D(&# 3.*"# I#
3=,"#e#6>F*#%=5.#%2,,;<F>5,,F>;<#&2.#R:.#+5&#?"#3=,;<&>**#
+5,# 05,5*15,M# +5.# +>5# P(.%2,,5*12&65&# R:.# +%,# !&D5.B
'5<.=.>&65&#5>&5,#-.(+2'*,#.565F*M#i5+(;<#&>;<*#R:.#+>5#
5,# $J?9:,533# j# +*.*+*B3*,# /<59:3*,# ,89:# 1*(# !,D*.B
'5<.=.>&65&"#
G5.#G>5&,*F5>,*5.#>,*#+5.#5>&1>65#+5.#D(&#3.*"#I#3=,"# e#
)>*#5>&5.#3,;<5&H2**5F.(FF5#\5+%;<*5&M#+5.#+>5,5#E(FF5#
%2;<#>)#45>*5.5&#P5.F%2R#+5,#G.%)%,#&>;<*#)5<.#F(,B
4>.+"#Z.#D5.,;<4>&+5*#,(6%.#D(FF,*K&+>6#>&#+5.#P5.,5&B
'2&6M# 12)>&+5,*# +5)# N%)5&# &%;<"# G(;<# )2,,# 5.#
:=5.%FF#)>*,H>5F5&M#4(#D()#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#+>5#E5+5#
>,*M#,(#F%&65#=>,#+5.#P(.<%&6#RKFF*"#
!,#$.3"#^^#38%9:*,#E8BB&VBB5+*#)*53*.*#J*3.0&&*,*#/*.?0B
&5&`#%F,#T>*,H>5F5.#%2R"#/>5#):,,5&#+5)#P(FF126,(.6%&#
%FF5#5.R(.+5.F>;<5&#32,':&R*5#5.*5>F5&#,(4>5#+>5#5.R(.B
+5.F>;<5&#N%;<45>,5#2&+#S&*5.F%65&#<5.%2,65=5&"
5. Rollenstreit der Vollzugs- und
Kontrollorgane
!)#P5.F%2R#+5.#-.(+2'*5n>,*5&1#D()#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#
=>,# 12.# Z&*,(.62&6# ,*5<*# +%,# P(FF126,(.6%&# >))5.#
4>5+5.#%2R#+5.#\:<&5"#Z,#)2,,#D(&#+5)#T()5&*#%&M#+%#
+%,# Z.1526&>,# >&# +5&# P5.'5<.# 65=.%;<*# 4>.+M# +5,,5&#
l=5.5>&,*>))2&6# )>*# +5&# />;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#
+5,#-./0#'(&*.(FF>5.5&#2&+#655>6&5*5#T%,,&%<)5&#5.B
6.5>R5&M# R%FF,# +%,# Z.1526&>,# +>5,5&# 3&R(.+5.2&65&#
,59:3# +*,N+3"# O5*# Q*-*59:,%,+# E60BB-%+?0.+8,[# 4+%B
.>5.*# %2;<# >&# +5.# -./PM# i5+(;<# R%,*# %2,,;<F>5,,F>;<# >)#
="# $J?9:,533# (53# 1*,# E$BB+*(*5,*,# 60.?9:.5&3*,# NJ*.#
+5&#P(FF126`"#!&#+5&#3=,;<&>**5&#L#2&+#O#*%2;<*#<>&65B
+*,#;Bc3-B59:#18?#ER0,3.0BB0.+8,[#8B?#d*B523#1*?#&.N:*B
3/2010
III. Auf Umwegen zur
Produktdefinition
O*.#Q*+.5&&#E/.01%23[#?3*:3#&N.#*5,*#*,0.(#+.0??*#Z8:B#
D(&#Z.1526&>,,5&#%FF5.#3.*#2&+#6>F*#R:.#+%,#&2.#45&>65#
T>FF>)5*5.# 'F5>&5# '(,)5*>,;<5# ->5.;>&6# 65&%2,(# 62*#
4>5# R:.# +5&# 6>6%&*>,;<5&M# d?# ^(&&5&# ,;<45.5&# Q.%&M#
+5,,5&#32R=%2#=>,#12#ef#T5*5.#9[<5#2&+#5>&5#<(.>1(&B
*%F5#32,F%+2&6#D(&#eV#T5*5.&#5..5>;<*"#0F5>;<#145>#+>5B
,5.#Q.K&5#)%;<*5&#+2.;<#,H5'*%'2FK.5#S&RKFF5#/;<F%6B
15>F5&"8L#
$5.# ,>;<# QF%.<5>*# +%.:=5.# D5.,;<%RR5&# 4>FFM# 4>5# +%,#
/.FG# 1*,# Q*+.5&&# E/.01%23[# D*.?3*:3K# (%??# -)5?9:*,#
+5&#3.*"#8#3=,"#L#2&+#?#3=,"#8#=>,#I#<>&B#2&+#<5.H5&B
1*B,K#8B?0#-)5?9:*,#1*(#Z)*928.352*B#%,1#1*,#O*4,5B
350,*,#1*.#Q*+.5&&*#E/.01%23[#%,1#E!,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,["#
O5*# O*4,5350,# 1*?# /.01%23?# 5,# $.3"# =# $J?"# =# /.FG# 8B?#
P5.(.+&2&6#:=5.#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*#D(&#*5;<&>,;<5&#Z>&.>;<*2&65&#
2&+#05.K*5&#D()#8?"#U2&>#8]]O#b/^ZPcM#/E#f8]"88"
8I#
Z.FK2*5.2&65&#D()#?f"#3H.>F#?V8V#12.#P5.(.+&2&6#:=5.#+>5#-.(B
+2'*,>;<5.<5>*#b-./Pc"
8L#
7*%*#ZN.9:*.#Z*53%,+#e7ZZf#=m"#$%+%?3#=Y^Y#EF%D8#%,3*.?%9:3#
Q.%&2&RKFF5`"
ED*.)*,1%,+?J*.*53*#J*)*+B59:*#F89:*[#)*59:3#%,,cB
*>65.45>,5#D(&#i5&5.#>)#-.90#%=M#+%,#i5+5#=5456F>;<5#
F89:*#-%(#/.01%23#?3*(;*B3#%,1#?8+3K#18??#%,3*.#E/.0B
+2'*`#,(4(<F#5>&#Z&+H.(+2'*#%F,#%2;<#5>&#0.2&+,*(RR#
(+5.#5>&#^5>FH.(+2'*#12#D5.,*5<5&#>,*"#\5>#+5.#3&45&B
+2&6# +5,# -./0# 4>.+# 5,# <>&6565&# &[*>6M# +%,# D5.45&B
+2&6,=5.5>*5# -.(+2'*# D()# =F(,,5&# 0.2&+,*(RR# %=12B
6.5&15&"#T%&#'[&&*5#=5>,H>5F,45>,5#a5)5&*#R:.#5>&5&#
=F(,,5&#0.2&+,*(RR#<%F*5&"#G(;<#>&#/K;'5#D5.H%;'*M#>,*#
5.# 5>&# D5.45&+2&6,=5.5>*5,# -.(+2'*M# +%,# ,(6%.# 12)#
ER0,?%(*,3*,;.01%23[# 8D8,95*.3K# )*,,# *?# 5,# Q8%B
)K.'*5&#%&#9(==_)%2.5.#D5.'%2R*#4>.+"#G5&#-.(+2'*B
1*4,5350,*,#5(#/.FG#%,1#5(#/.WG#5?3#8,1*.*.?*53?#1*.#
S),*%&+# 65)5>&,%)M# +%,,# 5>&5# /%;<5# T(=>F>5# =F5>=*M#
%2;<#45&&#,>5#^5>F#5>&5.#%&+5.5&#=5456F>;<5&#(+5.#2&B
=5456F>;<5&#/%;<5#=>F+5*"#G>5#\(*,;<%R*#5.'FK.*#+%,#3+B
X*235D# ED*.)*,1%,+?J*.*53[# 8%&# F*53*# =k# 18(53K# 18??#
/.01%23*# 8%?+*?9:B0??*,# )*.1*,# ?0BB*,K# 15*# E*.?3# 5(#
Z&*,*5<5&#2&+#+5,<%F=#%2;<#&>;<*#+%12#=5,*>))*#,>&+M#
D(&# i5)%&+5)# %F,# =5&2*1=%.5,M# D5.45&+2&6,RK<>65,#
-.(+2'*#=5<%&+5F*#12#45.+5&`"#
G%,#-.90#&>))*#>&#3.*"#I#3=,"#8#F>*"#=#+>5#ZF5'*.>1>*K*#
%2,+.:;'F>;<# >&# +5&# Q%*%F(6# +5.# H(*5&1>5FF# <%R*2&6,B
%2,F[,5&+5&# -.(+2'*5# %2R"# G%,# -./0# ,;<45>6*# ,>;<#
+%12#&>;<*#=F(,,#%2,"#G>5#ZF5'*.>1>*K*#R%&+#%=,>;<*F>;<M#
45&&#%2;<#(<&5#,*>;<<%F*>65#\56.:&+2&6M#'5>&5#32RB
&%<)5# >&# +5&# -.(+2'*'%*%F(6"# G5.# /(R*4%.5# R:.# +%,#
-./0# +>5# -.(+2'*5>65&,;<%R*# %=12,H.5;<5&M# +:.R*5#
,;<45.#R%FF5&M#6>F*#,>5#+(;<#&%;<#<52*>65.#3&,;<%22&6#
:8&3;<59:3.*9:3B59:#8B?#/.01%23"8O#G%,#9T08e#1*4,5*.3#
+5&&#%2;<#>&#3.*"#L#3=,"#8#F>*"#=#+>5#/(R*4%.5#%2,+.:;'B
F>;<#%F,#T5+>1>&H.(+2'*"#C(6>,;<5.45>,5#)2,,#)%&#><.#
8%9:#&N.#18?#/.FG#/.01%23S%8B53V3#-%?9:.*5J*,"#
Z>&#-.(+2'*#6>F*#65)K,,#3.*"#?#3=,"#?#-./0#%2;<#+%&&#
%F,# D5.45&+2&6,=5.5>*M# 45&&# ,5>&5# Z>&15F*5>F5# +5)#
Z)HRK&65.# 12)# Z>&B# (+5.# a2,%))5&=%2# :=5.65=5&#
45.+5&M#%F,(#45&&#5.#E56%F=.5**5.M#/5>*5&4K&+5#5>&5,#
':&R*>65&# \:;<5.65,*5FF,# ,(4>5# /;<.%2=5&# 2&+# @5,*B
,*5FF5.#R:.#+>5#E56%F5#%2,65<K&+>6*#=5'())*M#%2R#+%,,#
5.# ,>;<# 12<%2,5# )>*# +5)# a2,%))5&=%2# %=HF%65"# G%,#
6>F*#%=5.#&2.M#45&&#,>;<#%FF5#^5>F5#>&#+5.#6F5>;<5&#P5.H%B
92%,+#J*4,1*,"#$,1*.,&8BB?#*.:VB3#*.#*5,&89:#(*:.*.*#
5>&15F&5# -.(+2'*5M# +>5# ><.5.,5>*,# D5.45&+2&6,=5.5>*#
,>&+"#!<.5#P5.45&+2&6#5.R(F6*#=5>)#a2,%))5&=%25&#
+5,# T[=5F,*:;',M# Q>&+5.R%<..%+,M# /*%2=,%265.,# 5*;"#
32;<#=5>#+5&#QF5>&*5>F5&#>,*#'5>&#a45>R5F#%&#><.5.#P5.B
45&+=%.'5>*# )[6F>;<"# G>5# /5>*5&4K&+5# +5,# \:;<5.65B
,*5FF,# 2&+# +>5# E56%F=.5**5.# ,>&+# ><.5.,5>*,# D5.45&B
+2&6,=5.5>*M# 45>F# ,>5# ,>;<# (<&5# 45>*5.5# P5.%.=5>*2&6#
12)#a2,%))5&=%2#5>6&5&"#
G%,# -./0# 6>F*# &>;<*# &2.# R:.# &525# -.(+2'*5"# G%,# FK,,*#
,>;<#%2,#3.*"#?#3=,"#I#%=F5>*5&M#+5.#+%,#!&D5.'5<.=.>&B
+*,#8B?#lJ*.B8??*,#*5,*?#/.01%23?#1*4,5*.3K#E%,8J:V,B
6>6#+%D(&M#(=#+>5,5,#&52M#65=.%2;<*M#4>5+5.%2R=5.5>*5*#
(+5.#45,5&*F>;<#D5.K&+5.*#>,*`"#G%.2)#R%FF5&#%2;<#3&B
8?#
!"#$%&' ()*+,!-# 0-/0# 05.K*5B# 2&+# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1M#
T:&;<5&#?VVdM#ff#R"
8e#
\2&+5,65,5*1# :=5.# 3.1&5>)>**5F# 2&+# T5+>1>&H.(+2'*5# D()#
8O"#G515)=5.#?VVV#b95>F)>**5F65,5*1M#9T0cM#/E#f8?"?8"
8O#
!
.5&#/^Z0#2&+#+5.#/^ZP8?#%2R"#G%,#/5;(#=56.:&+5*#+%,#
%2R#/5>*5#L#,5>&5.#Z.FK2*5.2&65&#12.#-./P8I#2&+#>&#@"#?#
?*5,*.#P$U#18(53K#18??#%,3*.#1*(#E60BB-%+?0.+8,[#15*B
i5&>65#\5<[.+5#>)#45>*5.5&#/>&&5#12#D5.,*5<5&#,5>M#45FB
;<5#)>*#+5)#P(FF126#+5,#05,5*15,#>)#5&*,H.5;<5&+5&#
Q*.*59:#J*8%&3.8+3#5?3"#E60BB-%+?0.+8,[#?*5#1*.#>J*.J*B
+.5&&K#)0+*+*,#1*.#Q*+.5&&#ER0,3.0BB0.+8,[#8B?#EQ*:c.B
+5# >)# 5&65.5&# />&&`# 12# D5.,*5<5&# ,5>M# +>5# )>**5F,#
T%.'*:=5.4%;<2&6# +5&# P(FF126# +2.;<R:<.*"# 05&%2#
+>5,5# 32R6%=5# +5.# T%.'*:=5.4%;<2&6# *5>F*# %=5.# +%,#
-./0# >&# +5&# 3.*"# ]# =>,# 8L# +5)# P(FF126,(.6%&# 12# 2&+#
F>,*5*# +(.*# ,5>&5# \5R26&>,,5# %2RM# 4%,# &>;<*# 65.%+5# 12.#
J*+.5&<59:*,#RB8.:*53#J*53.V+3"#Z%1*(#(%??#?59:#8%?+*B
.*9:,*3# 18?# 5,# 1*,# $%+*,# 1*?# F*90# 8B?# EQ*:c.1*# 5(#
45>*5.5&#/>&&5`#12#D5.,*5<5&+5#P(FF126,(.6%&#65)K,,#
3.*"# 8V# 3=,"# ?# -./P# +>5# *5;<&>,;<5&# S&*5.F%65&M# Q(&B
R(.)>*K*,5.'FK.2&65&#5*;"#D()#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#D(.F5B
65&# F%,,5&"# G%,# >,*# 145>R5F,(<&5# 5>&5# D(FF1>5<5&+5#
l=5.4%;<2&6,*K*>6'5>*# D(.# J.*"# G(;<# ,(45>*# 5,# ,>;<#
2)#+>5#T%.'*:=5.4%;<2&6#=5>#T%,;<>&5&M#32R1:65&M#
0%,65.K*5&M# G.2;'65.K*5&# 2&+# H5.,[&F>;<5&# /;<2*1B
D(..>;<*2&65&# <%&+5F*# ,(4>5# =5># -.(+2'*5&M# +>5# &>;<*#
2&*5.#5>&5#%&+5.5#=2&+5,.5;<*F>;<5#E565F2&6#R%FF5&M#5.B
R(F6*# +>5# T%.'*:=5.4%;<2&6# 65)K,,# 3.*"# 8]# R# -./P#
+2.;<#5>&#Q(&*.(FF(.6%&#2&+#&>;<*#+2.;<#5>&#P(FF126,B
(.6%&"#/()>*#D5.45&+5*#3.*"#?8#-./P#+>5#=5>+5&#\56.>RB
R5#(<&5#E:;',>;<*#%2R#+>5#!&*5.H.5*%*>(&#+2.;<#+%,#/5;(#
>)# 6565&*5>F>65&# />&&5M# %F,(# :=5.,# Q.521"# 05)K,,#
3=,"#?#):,,5&#&K)F>;<#+>5#P(FF126,(.6%&5#+5,#3.=5>*,B
65,5*15,# +5)# /5;(# 2&+# +5)# Q(&*.(FF(.6%&# i5&5# -.(B
+2'*5#)5F+5&M#=5>#+5&5&#5>&#T%&65F#5.'%&&*#(+5.#D5.B
)2*5*# 4>.+"# $:.+5&# +>5# Z.FK2*5.2&65&# +5,# /5;(#
,*>))5&M# +%&&# <K**5# )%&# +>5# =5>+5&# \515>;<&2&65&#
D5.*%2,;<5&#(+5.#+>5#E(FF5&#%&+5.,#D5.*5>F5&#):,,5&"
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
191
3/2010
!
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
192
35S%53V3*,#%,1#.*;8.83%.J*1N.&35+*#\.-*%+,5??*#+.%,1B
,K*1F>;<# 2&*5.# +%,# -./0"# G(;<# ,>&+# ,>5# &>;<*# =5># +5&#
Q*+.5&&?J*?35((%,+*,#5,#$.3"#=#-%#4,1*,K#?0,1*.,#J8.#
i5+5.#C(6>'#>&#3.*"#8#3=,"#L"#G>5,5.#&>))*#,>5#2&*5.#=5B
,*>))*5&# P(.%2,,5*12&65&# D()# 05F*2&6,=5.5>;<# +5,#
G*?*3-*?#8%?K#,V(B59:#18,,K#)*,,#/.01%23*#E8B?#$,35B
S%53V3*,[# NJ*.B8??*,# )*.1*,# J*-5*:%,+?)*5?*# )*,,#
+5.# Z)HRK&65.# .5H%.%*2.=5+:.R*>65.# -.(+2'*5# :=5.#
15*?*,# '(?38,1# E8%?.*59:*,1[# 5,&0.(5*.3# )5.1"# O*.#
R8%&# 5,# *5,*(# $,35S%53V3*,+*?9:V&3# :83# -)*5&*BB0?# *.B
2*,,J8.#*5,*#$,35S%53V3#-%(#G*+*,?38,1"#!,#*5,*.#8,B
+5.5&# />*2%*>(&# ):,,*5# +5.# Z.45.=5.# +%.:=5.# >&R(.B
(5*.3# )*.1*,K# 18??# *.# *5,*# $,35S%53V3# *.)5.J3"# >:,*#
*,3?;.*9:*,1*# !,&0.(8350,# )5.1# 15*# $,35S%53V3# -%(#
,0.(8B*,# /.01%23C# 0:,*# $,+8J*,# -%.# d*;8.83%.J*B
+:.R*>6'5>*#)2*>5.*#+%,#=%2RKFF>65#/5;(&+<%&+BZ.1526B
&>,#12.#J;;%,>(&"#G%)>*#R%FF5&#=5>+5#>&#+5&#05F*2&6,B
=5.5>;<#+5,#-./0"#
IV. Die Produktsicherheit
1. Sicherheitsparameter
-.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*#<%*#1%<F.5>;<5#@%;5**5&#2&+#>,*#+5,B
<%F=#5>&5#@F5>,,%2R6%=5"#T%&#)2,,#+>5#5&*,H.5;<5&+5&#
-%.%)5*5.# 2&+# +>5# \545>,>&,*.2)5&*5# %2,# +5&# 3.*>B
'5F&# I# =>,# d# ,(4>5# %2,# +5&# R:.# +%,# -.(+2'*# 65F*5&+5&#
,5'*(.>5FF5&# Z.F%,,5&# 2&+# +5&# =515>;<&5*5&# *5;<B
&>,;<5&#N(.)5&#5&*&5<)5&"#
G%,#5.,*5M#>&#3.*"#I#3=,"#8#D5.%&'5.*5#05=(*#=5,%6*M#+%,,#
5>&#-.(+2'*#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*#2&+#05,2&+<5>*#+5.#P5.45&B
+5.# 2&+# G.>**5.# =5># &(.)%F5.# (+5.# D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5#
D(.<5.,5<=%.5.# P5.45&+2&6# &>;<*# (+5.# &2.# 65.>&6R:B
6>6#65RK<.+5&#+%.R"#G%,#05,5*1#654K<.*#,5>&5&#/;<2*1#
&>;<*#=F(,,#+5)#P5.45&+5.M#,(&+5.&#i5+5.)%&&M#%2;<#
1*(# E5,,09*,3# JT?38,1*.[K# 8B?0# *5,*.# /*.?0,K# 15*# (53#
+5)#-.(+2'*M#+%,#,>5#D5.F5*1*#(+5.#*[*5*M#6%.#&>;<*,#12#
3%,# :833*"# O5*# E,0.(8B*# 01*.# D*.,N,&35+*.)*5?*# D0.B
<5.,5<=%.5#P5.45&+2&6`#>,*#5>&#%2,#+5)#-.90#,*%)B
)5&+5,M#D5.*.%2*5,#ZF5)5&*"#G5,,5&#3.*"#L#3=,"#8#F>*"#=#
&5&&*# +5&# 05=.%2;<M# )>*# +5)# D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5# 65B
.5;<&5*#45.+5&#'%&&"#G>5#5>&1>65#G>RR5.5&1#12)#-.90#
B5*+3# 5,# 1*.# *.B8%J3*,# E+*.5,+&N+5+*,# G*&V:.1%,+["#
!<.5#a2)2*=%.'5>*#2&+#+%)>*#C56%F>*K*#+:.R*5#,>;<#%=5.#
>)#E%<)5&#+5,,5&#=54565&M#4%,#+%,#-.90#2&*5.#5>&5.#
&%;<# +5&# S),*K&+5&# =5.5;<*>6*5&# />;<5.<5>*,5.4%.B
*2&6#D5.,*5<*"#G>5,5#=5>&<%F*5*#'5>&5#<2&+5.*H.(15&*>B
65#/>;<5.<5>*#>&#+5)#/>&&5M#+%,,#+5)#P5.45&+5.#&>;<*#
5>&)%F#+>5#'F5>&,*5&#/;<:.R2&65&M#/;<&>**5#(+5.#=F%2B
5&#@F5;'5&#1265)2*5*#4:.+5&"#
G%,# -./0# '(&'.5*>,>5.*# +>5# />;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#
5>&5.,5>*,#+2.;<#P5.45>,5#%2R#%&+5.5#Z.F%,,5#2&+#%&+5B
.5.,5>*,#+2.;<#+5*%>FF>5.*5#P(.6%=5&M#+>5#+5.#!&D5.'5<.B
=.>&65.#12#5.R:FF5&#<%*"#Z>&#-.(+2'*#)2,,#+5&#6.2&+F5B
65&+5&# />;<5.<5>*,B# 2&+# 05,2&+<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#
5&*,H.5;<5&"#G>5,5#45.+5&#D()#\2&+5,.%*#+2.;<#,5'B
*(.>5FF5# P5.(.+&2&65&# R5,*65F56*M# +>5# +5.# !&D5.'5<.B
=.>&65.#'(&,2F*>5.5&#)2,,"#$5&&#,5>&#-.(+2'*#)>*#+5&#
>&#3.*"#e#5.4K<&*5&M#D()#12,*K&+>65&#\2&+5,%)*#2&+#
+5)# /5;(# =515>;<&5*5&# *5;<&>,;<5&# N(.)5&# :=5.5>&B
?35((3K#;.0435*.3#*.#D0,#1*.#6*.(%3%,+K#*?#?*5#?59:*."#
G>5#P5.)2*2&6#'%&&#%FF5.+>&6,#2)65,*(,,5&#45.+5&"#
$5&&#+%,#-.(+2'*#+5&#*5;<&>,;<5&#N(.)5&#&>;<*#5&*B
,H.>;<*M#)2,,#+5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#&%;<45>,5&M#+%,,#5,#
+>5#6.2&+F565&+5&#/>;<5.<5>*,B#2&+#05,2&+<5>*,%&R(.B
+5.2&65&# %2R# %&+5.5# $5>,5# 5.R:FF*"# @5<F5&# ,(F;<5# 3&B
R(.+5.2&65&M# +%&&# )2,,# +%,# -.(+2'*# +5)# /*%&+# +5,#
$>,,5&,#2&+#+5.#^5;<&>'#5&*,H.5;<5&"#G5.#2R5.F(,5#\5B
+.5&&#Eb5??*,[#+*:3#)*53*.K#8B?#15*#?0,?3#+*J.V%9:B59:*,#
P5.45>,5#%2R#+5&#/*%&+#+5.#$>,,5&,;<%R*"#S&*5.#F5*1*5B
.5)#4>.+#5.<K.*5*5,#2&+M#45>F#H2=F>1>5.*M#%2;<#%=.2R=%B
.5,# $>,,5&# D5.,*%&+5&M# 4(6565&# =F(,,5,# $>,,5&# >.B
65&+4(# >&# >.65&+45F;<5&# Q[HR5&M# ,;<F>)),*5&R%FF,#
%F,#9%F=4>,,5&M#<5.2)65>,*5.&#'%&&M#(<&5#+%,,#5,#+5)#
!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# 126K&6F>;<# ,5>&# )2,,"# G5.# \56.>RR#
+:.R*5#%2;<#+5)#P(FF126,(.6%&#Q(HR15.=.5;<5&#=5.5>B
*5&"#
G5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.M#+5.#+5&#>&#3.*"#O#D(.6565=5&5&M#
.5>;<F>;<# '()HF>1>5.*5&# \545>,H%.;(2.,# 5.R(F6.5>;<#
<>&*5.#,>;<#65=.%;<*#<%*M#+%.R#,>;<#&>;<*#+5.#!FF2,>(&#<>&B
65=5&M#,5>&#-.(+2'*#,5>#&2&#D(FF,*K&+>6#-./0B'(&R(.)"#
G>5#P(.6%=5&#>&#3.*"#O#=51>5<5&#,>;<#&2.#%2R#+>5#/>;<5.B
<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&M# +>5# >&# +5&# ,5'*(.>5FF5&# Z.F%,,5&#
2&+# *5;<&>,;<5&# N(.)5&# &>5+5.65F56*# ,>&+M# 2&+# %2R#
i5&5# %&+5.5&M# +>5# )%&# &[*>65&R%FF,# =5>)# /*%&+# D(&#
$>,,5&#2&+#^5;<&>'#%2R,H:.5&#)2,,"#!&#3.*"#I#4%.*5&#
%2R# +5&# 95.,*5FF5.# 2&+# +>5# :=.>65&# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#
&(;<# 45>*5.5M# ,5<.# +5*%>FF>5.*5# P(.6%=5&"# G%,# -.(+2'*#
)2,,# ,>;<5.# ,5>&# >)# 9>&=F>;'# %2R# ,5>&5# %&6565=5&5#
(+5.# D(.%2,,>;<*F>;<5# 05=.%2;<,+%25.M# %2R# ,5>&5# D(.B
<5.,5<=%.5#Z>&4>.'2&6#%2R#%&+5.5#-.(+2'*5M#%2R#,5>&5#
P5.45&+2&6# +2.;<# ,*K.'5.# 65RK<.+5*5# -5.,(&5&# 4>5#
Q>&+5.M# \5<>&+5.*5# (+5.# /5&>(.5&M# 2&+# ,;<F>5,,F>;<#
)2,,#5,#%2;<#>&#+5&#9K&+5&#D(&#Q(&,2)5&*5&#,>;<5.#
,5>&M#,(R5.&#5,#2&*5.#D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5#D(.<5.,5<=%.5&#
\5+>&62&65&#D(&#Q(&,2)5&*5&#=5&:*1*#45.+5&#'%&&"#
G5.#95.,*5FF5.M#+5.#%FF5,#+%,#=5+%;<*#2&+#,5>&#-.(+2'*#
5&*,H.5;<5&+#'(&,*.2>5.*#2&+#D5.H%;'*#<%*M#+5.#><)#5>B
&5&# '>&+5.,>;<5.5&# P5.,;<F2,,# 2&+# 62*# F5,=%.5# $%.B
&2&65&# >&# 6.(,,5.# /;<.>R*# )>*6>=*M# '%&&# +>5# 9K&+5#
&(;<#&>;<*#>&#+5&#/;<(,,#F565&"
O*(# ?;*-54?9:*,# G*&V:.1%,+?;03*,-58B# *5,*?# /.0B
+2'*,# )2,,# %2;<# +>5# G%.=>5*2&6# 5&*,H.5;<5&M# R:.# +>5#
+%,#05,5*1#5>&#62*5,#G2*15&+#/*>;<4(.*5#F>5R5.*"#3.*"#I#
3=,"#L#&5&&*#&5=5&#+5.#P5.H%;'2&6#2&+#32R)%;<2&6#
+5,#-.(+2'*,#%FF5#:=.>65&#32,,*%**2&6,)5.')%F5#4>5#
=5>,H>5F,45>,5#3&F5>*2&65&M#$%.&B#2&+#/>;<5.<5>*,<>&B
)*5?*#%,1#*.)V:,3#?0+8.#E8BB*#?0,?35+*,#;.01%23J*-0B
65&5&# 3&6%=5&# (+5.# !&R(.)%*>(&5&`"# G%.2&*5.# ,>&+#
$5.=2&6# 2&+# -E# 12# D5.,*5<5&M# +>5# 12# F5>;<*,>&&>65)#
05=.%2;<#5>&5,#-.(+2'*,#%&>)>5.5&#2&+#5,#65RK<.F>;<#
)%;<5&#'[&&5&"#
9>5.# *%2;<*# +>5# @.%65# %2RM# (=# 5,# 65&:6*M# +%,,# 5>&# -.(B
+2'*#+5&#,5'*(.>5FF5&#Z.F%,,5&M#+5&#=515>;<&5*5&#*5;<B
&>,;<5&#N(.)5&#2&+#+5)#/*%&+#+5,#$>,,5&,#2&+#+5.#
^5;<&>'# 5&*,H.>;<*# (+5.# (=# +>5# >&# -./0# 3.*"# I# 3=,"# I#
%,1# @# 8%&+*?3*BB3*,# ?;*-54?9:*,# F59:*.:*53?D0.?9:.5&B
*5&#R:.#%FF5#-.(+2'*5#65F*5&"#Z,#>,*#):,,>6M#+>5,5#@.%65#
%&<%&+#+5.#32,F562&6#D(&#3.*"#8#3=,"#I#)>*#\F>;'#%2R#
3/2010
G5.# <(<5# /*5FF5&45.*M# +5&# +%,# -./0# +5.# !&R(.)%*>(&#
=5>)>,,*M# )%&>R5,*>5.*# ,>;<# 2&*5.# %&+5.5)# +%.>&M# +%,,#
3.*"#f#3=,"#?#-./P#R:.#+>5#$%.&B#2&+#/>;<5.<5>*,<>&45>B
,5# >&# +5&# \5*.>5=,BM# \5+>5&2&6,B# 2&+# $%.*2&6,%&F5>B
*2&65&# %FF5# +.5># ,;<45>15.>,;<5&# 3)*,,H.%;<5&# D(.B
,;<.5>=*"# G(;<# 4>.+# +%,# R:.# -.(+2'*5M# +>5# &%;<# +5)#
k%,,>,B+5BG>i(&B-.>&1>H#>)H(.*>5.*#45.+5&M#D()#^908f#
%,3*.B8%&*,"# !(# Z5*B20,<523# -)5?9:*,# F59:*.:*53# %,1#
R.5>5)# 9%&+5F# 5&*,;<>5+# ,>;<# +%,# -%.F%)5&*M# 45F;<5,#
,>;<#6F5>;<15>*>6#)>*#+5.#^90BE5D>,>(&#2&+#+5)#-./0#
=5R%,,*5M# R:.# F5*1*5.5&# 2&+# 5.F%2=*5# >&# ^90# 3.*"# 8e'6
3=,"# ?M# +>5# $%.&B# 2&+# />;<5.<5>*,<>&45>,5# ,(4>5# +>5#
R:.#+>5#-5.,(&5&,>;<5.<5>*#.5F5D%&*5&#3&F5>*2&65&#%2,B
,;<F>5,,F>;<#>&#+5.#3)*,,H.%;<5#+5,#J.*5,#%=12R%,,5&M#
%&# +5)# +%,# -.(+2'*# >&# P5.'5<.# 65=.%;<*# 4>.+"# G>5,5#
Z>&,;<.K&'2&6# +5.# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*# >&# 2&,5.5)#
)5<.,H.%;<>65&# C%&+# 5.<>5F*# E:;'5&+5;'2&6# +2.;<#
15*#Z)*921*4,5350,#1*?#/.FG#5,#$.3"#^K#1*.#,*J*,#1*.#
054K<.F5>,*2&6# +5.# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*# %2;<# &(;<# +>5#
Z.F5>;<*5.2&6# +5,# 6.5&1:=5.,;<.5>*5&+5&# $%.5&D5.B
'5<.,#H(,*2F>5.*"
G%,#-.(+2'*#)2,,#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#=5>#i5B
+5)#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#5.R:FF5&M#%F,(#D(&#+5.#32,F>5R5B
.2&6# +2.;<# +5&# 95.,*5FF5.# (+5.# !)H(.*52.# :=5.# %FF5#
P5.*.>5=,,*2R5&# =>,# 2&+# )>*# i5&5)# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.M#
+5.# 5,# +5)# P5.45&+5.# %2,<K&+>6*"# 3&+5.,# FK,,*# ,>;<#
3.*"#I#3=,"#8#6%.#&>;<*#>&*5.H.5*>5.5&M#4(&%;<#-.(+2'*5#
&2.# >&# P5.'5<.# 65=.%;<*# 45.+5&# +:.R5&M# 45&&# ,>5# +>5#
/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&# 5.R:FF5&"# G%,# 6>F*# %2;<# R:.#
J;;%,>(&5&M#45>F#-./0#3.*"#?#3=,"#I#%2;<#+>5#l=5.F%,B
,2&6#D(&#65=.%2;<*5&#-.(+2'*5&#%F,#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#
1*4,5*.3"#O*?:8BJ#28,,#15*#$,?59:3#1*?#F*90#5,#$"#@#?*5B
QG*.#'.3*5B#D0(#=i"#h%,5#=Y^YK#@$n=``_=Y^YC#QG\#^jj#!!!#L^"
\2&+5,65,5*1# :=5.# +>5# *5;<&>,;<5&# 9%&+5F,<5))&>,,5# D()#
e"#J'*(=5.#8]]O#b^90cM#/E#]Le"O8"
&5.#@3AM#4(&%;<#+5.#$5>*5.D5.'%2R#5>&5,#J;;%,>(&H.(B
+2'*,# >&# +5.# /;<45>1# '5>&# 5.&52*5,# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65&#
>,*M#&>;<*#12*.5RR5&"#P5.)2*F>;<#<%*#,>;<#+%,#/5;(#%&#+5.#
T%,;<P8]# (.>5&*>5.*M# 45F;<5# +>5# 5.,*)%F>65# \5.5>*,*5FB
F2&6#+5.#T%,;<>&5#2&*5.#\5126&%<)5#%2R#Z0BE5;<*#%F,#
!,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,#1*4,5*.3"#
2. Sicherheitsnachweis
$5.#5>&#-.(+2'*#>&#+5&#P5.'5<.#=.>&6*M#)2,,#&>;<*#&2.#
+%R:.#,(.65&M#+%,,#5,#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#5.B
R:FF*"#Z.#)2,,#+%,#%2;<#=545>,5&#'[&&5&"#$>5#+%,#12#
5.R(F65&# <%*M# 65<*# %2,# 3.*"# ]# 2&+# 8V# -./P# <5.D(."# @:.#
+5&# N%;<45>,M# +%,,# +%,# -.(+2'*# +>5# 3&R(.+5.2&65&#
65)K,,#3.*"#I#=>,#O#-./0#5.R:FF*M#)2,,#5.#%FF5#5.R(.+5.F>B
;<5&# *5;<&>,;<5&# S&*5.F%65&# =5>=.>&65&# '[&&5&"# @:.#
i5&5#-.(+2'*5M#R:.#+>5#+5.#\2&+5,.%*#6.2&+F565&+5#/>B
;<5.<5>*,B# 2&+# 05,2&+<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&# %2R65,*5FF*#
<%*M#=5&[*>6*#5.#,(6%.#5>&5#Q(&R(.)>*K*,5.'FK.2&6M#+>5#
D()#95.,*5FF5.#(+5.#+5,,5&#>&#+5.#/;<45>1#&>5+5.65F%,B
,5&5&#P5.*.5*5.#%2,65,*5FF*#4>.+"#/;<4>5.>65.#>,*#5,#R:.#
1*,# !,D*.2*:.J.5,+*.# 8,1*.*.# /.01%23*# :*.8%?-%4,B
+5&M#R:.#45F;<5#+%D(&#5.#+>5#D(&#3.*"#8V#-./P#D5.F%&6B
*5&# *5;<&>,;<5&# S&*5.F%65&# =5>=.>&65&# '[&&5&# )2,,"#
G>5# Z.FK2*5.2&65&# +5,# /5;(# 12.# -./P# ,;<45>65&# ,>;<#
+%.:=5.# %2,# 2&+# +>5# 32,'2&R*# >&# k"# e# +5.# @3A# <>FR*#
+5)# E%*,2;<5&+5&# %2;<# &>;<*# 45>*5."# G%,# /5;(# D5.B
45>,*#R:.#+>5#R:.#5>&#=5,*>))*5,#-.(+2'*#5.R(.+5.F>;<5&#
',3*.B8+*,# J*5# &*:B*,1*(# F*230..*9:3# 8%&# 15*# ENJB5B
9:*,# G*;<0+*,:*53*,# J*5# D*.+B*59:J8.*,# /.01%23*,["#
@:.#-.(+2'*5M#+>5#&%;<#+5)#/*%&+#+5,#$>,,5&,#2&+#+5.#
^5;<&>'# <5.65,*5FF*# 42.+5&M# D5.F%&6*# 5,# )>&+5,*5&,#
5>&5# E>,>'(%&%F_,5# ,(4>5# 5>&5# \5*.>5=,BM# \5+>5&2&6,B#
2&+# $%.*2&6,%&F5>*2&6M# ,(R5.&# +%,# -.(+2'*# &>;<*#
,5F=,*5.'FK.5&+#>,*"#
G>5# G('2)5&*5# )2,,# 5.# 4K<.5&+# +5.# %&6565=5&5&#
(+5.# D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5# D(.<5.,5<=%.5&# 05=.%2;<,B
+%25.# +5,# -.(+2'*,M# i5+(;<# 4K<.5&+# )>&+5,*5&,# 8V#
U%<.5&# =5>=.>&65&# '[&&5&"# Z,# >,*# H.(=F5)%*>,;<M# +%,,#
+>5,5#@.>,*#R:.#i5+5&#>&#+5.#P5.*5>F5.'5**5#&>;<*#5*4%#)>*#
+5)# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65&# ,5>&5,# F5*1*5&# Zn5)HF%.,# =5B
6>&&*M#,(&+5.&#)>*#+5.#95.,*5FF2&6#+5,#F5*1*5&#Zn5)HB
F%.,# 5>&5.# /5.>5"# G5&# !)H(.*52.5&M# 9K&+F5.&M# G>5&,*B
F5>,*5.&#2&+#%&+5.5&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.&#>,*#i5&5,#G%*2)#
'%2)#=5'%&&*"#P(&#+5.#>))5.#4>5+5.#H.(H%6>5.*5&#%+B
)>&>,*.%*>D5&#Z&*F%,*2&6#+5.#S&*5.&5<)5&#X#>&,=5,(&B
+5.5#+5.#QTS#X#D()#-%H>5.'.%)#>,*#<>5.#&>;<*,#R5,*12B
,*5FF5&"
V. Nachmarktpflichten
1. Spezialservice für
Konsumentenprodukte
$5.# 5>&# Q(&,2)5&*5&H.(+2'*# >&# +5&# P5.'5<.# =.>&6*M#
+%.R# 5,# i%<.5F%&6M# ,;<F>)),*5&R%FF,# ,(6%.# 4K<.5&+#
8d#
8f#
P5.(.+&2&6# :=5.# +>5# />;<5.<5>*# D(&# T%,;<>&5&# D()# ?"# 3H.>F#
?VVf#bT%,;<>&5&D5.(.+&2&6M#T%,;<PcM#/E#f8]"8L"
8]#
!
+%,#D()#,5'*(.>5FF5&#Z.F%,,#(+5.#+5.#*5;<&>,;<5&#N(.)#
D5.R(F6*5# a>5F# 5&*,;<5>+5&# 12# 4(FF5&"# Z.,*5&,# +:.R*5&#
+>5#+5*%>FF>5.*5&#3&R(.+5.2&65&#D(&#3.*"#I#3=,"#I#2&+#
L#>&#+5&#45&>6,*5&#+5.#5.4K<&*5&#E565F45.'5#%2;<#&2.#
%&,%*145>,5# 5&*<%F*5&# ,5>&M# ,(# +%,,# ,>;<# 5>&5# C:;'5&B
R:FF2&6#+2.;<#+%,#-./0#%2R+.K&6*"#a45>*5&,#5&*,H.>;<*#
5>&#-.(+2'*M#+%,#+5&#>&#3.*"#I#3=,"#I#2&+#L#65&%&&*5&#
3&R(.+5.2&65&# &>;<*# 65&:6*M# %2;<# &>;<*# +5)# <(<5&M#
D()#-./0#%&65H5>F*5&#/>;<5.<5>*,&>D5%2"#G.>**5&,#>,*#5,#
):,,>6M#%2R#+>5#/2;<5#&%;<#3.62)5&*5&#12#65<5&M#+>5#
+5&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#D(&#+5&#P(.6%=5&#+5,#-./0#5&*B
=>&+5&#'[&&*5&"#G%,#-./0#4>+5.,H>565F*#145>R5FF(,#+5&#
<52*>65&# /*%&+%.+# +5.# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*"# $5&&# 5>&#
&>;<*#-./0B'(&R(.)5,#Z.1526&>,#5>&5#-5.,(&#,;<K+>6*M#
*.>**#R:.#+5&#/;<%+5&5.,%*1#+%,#-.90#%2R#+5&#-F%&"#Z,#
,*5FF*# %2R# +>5# =5.5;<*>6*5&# />;<5.<5>*,5.4%.*2&65&# +5.#
3FF65)5>&<5>*# %="# S&+# 65&%2# +>5,5# 45.+5&# D(&# -./0#
3.*"#I#3=,"#I#2&+#L#=5+>5&*h#Z>6&2&6#+5,#-.(+2'*,#R:.#
+5&# P5.45&+5.'.5>,# 2&+# <>&.5>;<5&+5M# +>5# 05R%<.5&#
5>&+K))5&+5#G%.=>5*2&6"#l=5.+>5,#=51>5<5&#,>;<#65B
)K,,# \2&+5,65.>;<*8d# +>5# />;<5.<5>*,5.4%.*2&65&# +5.#
3FF65)5>&<5>*# F56>*>)5.45>,5# %2;<# +%.%2RM# +%,,# +5.#
95.,*5FF5.# +>5# 5>&,;<FK6>65&# *5;<&>,;<5&# P(.,;<.>R*5&#
2&+#N(.)5&#=5R(F6*5"#
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
193
3/2010
!
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
194
U%<.15<&*5&#&>;<*#)5<.#%2,#+5&#3265&#F%,,5&"#95.,*5FB
F5.#2&+#!)H(.*52.5#):,,5&#+%,#-.(+2'*#2&*5.#*%*'.KRB
*>65.# T>*4>.'2&6# +5,# 9%&+5F,# X# +5.# <>5.# 2&*5.# 32,B
,;<F2,,#%FF5.#:=.>65&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#65&%&&*#>,*#X#)>*#
32R)5.',%)'5>*# %2R# ,5>&5)# 45>*5.5&# C5=5&,456# =5B
6F5>*5&"# />5# ):,,5&# 5,# +%.%2R<>&# '(&*.(FF>5.5&M# (=# 5,#
3&15>;<5&# D(&# 05R%<.5&# R:.# +>5# />;<5.<5>*# (+5.# 05B
,2&+<5>*#+5.#P5.45&+5.#12#5.'5&&5&#6>=*"#a2#+>5,5)#
Z)*92#8%&*.B*+3#5:,*,#18?#G*?*3-#*5,#/<59:3*,:*&3K#18?#
R:.#+>5#)5>,*5&#\.%&;<5&#D[FF>6#&52#>,*"#$5&&#>.65&+B
5>&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#R5,*,*5FF*M#+%,,#+5)#-.(+2'*#)[6B
F>;<5.45>,5#5>&5#,(F;<5#05R%<.#>&&54(<&*M#)2,,#5.#+%,#
E%,D*.-N+B59:[# 1*(# 60BB-%+?0.+8,# (533*5B*,"# O5*# Q*B
0J89:3%,+?I# %,1# A*B1*;<59:3*,# +*B3*,# -)8.# 8%?B
,;<F>5,,F>;<# R:.# Q(&,2)5&*5&H.(+2'*5M# +(;<# '[&&5&#
+>5# Z.1526&>,,5# +5.# )5>,*5&# -.(+215&*5&# 2&+# P5.B
(8.23*.#%,3*.#15*?*,#Q*+.5&&#&8BB*,"#789:#1*.#O*4,5350,#
>&#3.*"#I#3=,"#I#F>*"#;#2&+#3.*"#f#3=,"#8#<%&+5F*#5,#,>;<#2)#
-.(+2'*5M#+>5#R:.#Q(&,2)5&*5&#=5,*>))*#,>&+#(+5.#+>5#
2&*5.#D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5#D(.<5.,5<=%.5&#\5+>&62&65&#
%2;<# D(&# Q(&,2)5&*5&# =5&2*1*# 45.+5&# '[&&5&"# G>5#
$%<.,;<5>&F>;<'5>*# >,*# <52*5# 6.(,,M# +%,,# 5>&# %2,# +5.#
/>;<*#+5,#95.,*5FF5.,M#!)H(.*52.,#(+5.#0.(,,>,*5&#%2,B
,;<F>5,,F>;<# D(&# C52*5&M# +>5# :=5.# +>5# /%;<'2&+5# 2&+#
+%,# 05,;<>;'# D(&# @%;<F52*5&# D5.R:65&M# D5.45&+5*5,#
-.(+2'*#:=5.#95>)45.'5.FK+5&M#\%2B#2&+#9(==_15&*B
.5&# ,(4>5# :=5.# +5&# P5.,%&+<%&+5F# >&# +>5# 9K&+5# D(&#
70.(8BD*.J.8%9:*.,# +*B8,+3"# A8,# ?;.59:3# D0,# E/.0B
+2'*)>6.%*>(&`# %2,# +5)# R:.# @%;<F52*5# =5,*>))*5&#
P5.*.>5=,,5'*(.#>&#+5&#Q(&,2)5&*5&=5.5>;<M#4(+2.;<#
,>;<#5>&#-.(+2'*#>&#+5.#9%&+#D(&#C%>5&#%F,#65RK<.F>;<#
5&*H2HH5&#'%&&"#
O5*#Q*0J89:3%,+?I#%,1#A*B1*;<59:3*,K#15*#,8:3B0?#8,#
+%,# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65&# %&,;<F>5,,5&M# ,>&+# +5,<%F=# R:.#
+5&#6.[,,*5&#^5>F#+5.#-.(+2'*5M#+>5#<52*5#%2R#+5&#T%.'*#
'())5&M# 12# =5R(F65&"# G5,<%F=# )2,,# H.%'*>,;<# i5+5.#
95.,*5FF5.# 2&+# P5.)%.'*5.# ,HK*5,*5&,# =>,# Z&+5# +5.#
l=5.6%&6,R.>,*#+5,#-./0M#%F,(#%=#8"#U%&2%.#?V8?M#+2.;<#
5>&#4>.',%)5,#E>,>'()%&%65)5&*#65.:,*5*#,5>&"
2. Organisationspflichten
G>5#95.,*5FF5.M#!)H(.*52.5#2&+#+>5#D()#05,5*1#%F,#T>*B
)5.2*,1*# D*.;<59:3*3*,# WV,1B*.# (N??*,# ?59:# +*(V??#
3.*"#f#3=,"#?#=>,#L#,(#(.6%&>,>5.5&M#+%,,#,>5#4K<.5&+#+5.#
%&6565=5&5&# (+5.# D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5# D(.<5.,5<=%.5&#
05=.%2;<,+%25.# 5>&5,# -.(+2'*,# +>5# 05R%<.5&# 5.'5&B
&5&M#+>5#D(&#><)#=5>#&(.)%F5.#(+5.#D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5#
D(.<5.,5<=%.5.# P5.45&+2&6# %2,65<5&# '[&&5&"# G>5#
05=.%2;<,+%25.# D(&# -.(+2'*5&# D%.>>5.*# 5&(.)"# G%,#
65<*# D(&# +5.# &2.# 5>&)%F# =.%2;<=%.5&# Z>&4561%<&B
=:.,*5# :=5.# 05,;<>..# 2&+# %&+5.5# .5F%*>D# '2.1F5=>65#
9%2,<%F*%.*>'5F#=>,#12#T[=5F&M#$5.'1526M#C5>*5.&#(+5.#
0%.*5&65.K*5M#+>5#(<&5#$5>*5.5,#5>&5#05&5.%*>(&#:=5.B
F5=5&"# 32;<# -.(+2'*5M# +>5# >&# !))(=>F>5&# 5>&65=%2*#
45.+5&M# <%=5&# 5>&5# C5=5&,+%25.# D(&# )5<.5.5&# U%<.B
15<&*5&"#@:.#ZF5'*.('%=5F#.5;<&5*#)%&#=5>,H>5F,45>,5#
)>*#5>&5)#<%F=5&#U%<.<2&+5.*#/>;<5.<5>*"#$5.#,>;<#D(&#
1*.# %,3*.# '(?3V,1*,# E*)5+*,[# Q*0J89:3%,+?;<59:3#
=5R.5>5&# 4>FFM# D5.,>5<*# F%&6F5=>65# -.(+2'*5# )>*# 5>&5)#
Z&+65=.%2;<,+%*2)"#G%,#'%&&#+5)#!)%65#+5,#!&D5.B
'5<.=.>&65.,# %F,# 95.,*5FF5.WP5.*.5>=5.# ,(F>+5.# Z.1526B
&>,,5# %=*.K6F>;<# ,5>&M# 5,# ,5># +5&&M# 5,# 4:.+5&# D(&# +5&#
D*.?9:5*1*,*,# Q.8,9:*,# ;.01%23?;*-54?9:*# P.5?3*,#
D5.5>&=%.*M# 4%,# i5+(;<# +>5# $5**=545.=,'())>,,>(&#
%2R# +5&# -F%&# .2R5&# '[&&*5"# @>&%&1>5FF5# l=5.F562&65&#
2&+# +%,# ['(F(6>,;<5# \542,,*,5>&# 5>&5,# ^5>F,# +5.# P5.B
=.%2;<5.# '[&&*5&# +5)# +%+2.;<# 5.1526*5&# $5645.RB
14%&6#5>&5&#E>565F#,;<>5=5&"#!)#P(.5&*42.R#4%.5&#+>5#
789:(8.23;<59:3*,# 8%&# 15*# ,09:# -%(%3J8.*# O8%*.#
D(&# 15<&# U%<.5&# ,5>*# +5)# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65&# +5,# -.(B
+2'*,#=56.5&1*"#T>*#+5.#/*.5>;<2&6#+>5,5.#@.>,*#42.+5#
+5&#S&*5.&5<)5&#5>&#Q2;'2;',5>#2&*5.65i2=5F*"
95.,*5FF5.# 2&+# !)H(.*52.5# ):,,5&# ,(+%&&# T%,,&%<B
)5&#*.5RR5&M#2)#5.'%&&*5#05R%<.5&#%=45&+5&#12#'[&B
&5&"#G%,#-./0#,;<.5>=*#><&5&#&>;<*#5*4%#+>5#E:;'&%<B
)5#+5,#65RK<.F>;<5&#-.(+2'*,#%2,#+5&#P5.*.>5=,'%&KF5&M#
+>5#$%.&2&6#+5.#P5.45&+5.#(+5.#6%.#+5&#E:;'.2R#D(.M#
)*5B# 15*# /<59:3# *5,*?# ',3*.,*:(*,?# -%# 1*.8.35+*,#
T%,,&%<)5&# 6.2&+,K*1F>;<# D()# a>D>F.5;<*# 5.R%,,*#
4>.+"#3FF5.+>&6,#45.+5&#,>5#+5)#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#D(&#
+5.# C0P?V# %2R5.F56*"# G>5# C0P# F5>,*5*# ,>;<# +%)>*# 5>&5&#
l=5.6.>RR# >&# +%,# a>D>F.5;<*M# '5&&*# %&+5.5.,5>*,# '5>&5#
/.01%23J*0J89:3%,+?;<59:3"# >J+B*59:# $.3"# L# $J?"# =#
F>*"#=#-./0#5>&+52*>6#R(.)2F>5.*#>,*M#,*5<*#>&#@3A#G"#LM#+>5#
05R%<.5&%=45&+2&6# ,5># 0565&,*%&+# +5.# N%;<)%.'*B
;<59:3*,#1*?#/.FG"#
GB*59:)0:B# 18.&# *5,# !,D*.2*:.J.5,+*.# 8%?# :8&3;<59:3B
.5;<*F>;<5&#Z.4K62&65&#&>;<*#2&*K*>6#=F5>=5&M#45&&#5.#
Q5&&*&>,# D(&# 5>&5.# 05R%<.# 5.<KF*"# 32R6.2&+# +5,# %2,#
3.*"#L8#JE#%=65F5>*5*5&#05R%<.5&,%*15,#)2,,#+5.i5&>65M#
+5.# 5>&5&# 65RK<.F>;<5&# a2,*%&+# ,;<%RR*M# %&65)5,,5&5#
2&+# 12)2*=%.5# T%,,&%<)5&# 5.6.5>R5&M# +%)>*# '5>&#
/;<%+5&#(+5.#6%.#45>*5.5#/;<K+5&#5&*,*5<5&"#3&+5.&B
R%FF,#<%R*5*#5.#R:.#+5&#+2.;<#,;<2F+<%R*5#S&*5.F%,,2&6#
D5.2.,%;<*5&# /;<%+5&"# Z&*,H.5;<5&+5# /;<%+5&D5.<:B
*2&6,)%,,&%<)5&#+5,#P5.,>;<5.2&6,&5<)5.,#,>&+#>)#
PP0?8# D(.65,;<.>5=5&M# 2&+# +>5# 3FF65)5>&5&# 9%R*B
;<59:3I6*.?59:*.%,+?J*15,+%,+*,# *,3:8B3*,# F9:81*,B
(5,1*.%,+?;<59:3*,"# \?# (89:3# ?59:# 8%9:# D5*B# J*??*.K#
45&&# )%&# 12.# T5F+2&6# 5>&5.# -.(+2'*65R%<.# =5>)#
P(FF126,(.6%&#&>;<*#)>*#F55.5&#9K&+5&#%&*.>**"#Z>&#S&B
*5.&5<)5&M# +%,# :=5.# =5.5>*,# 5.6.>RR5&5# T%,,&%<)5&#
12.# P5.<:*2&6WP5.)>&+5.2&6# D(&# /;<K+5&# =5.>;<*5&#
'%&&M#15>6*#6F%2=4:.+>6M#+%,,#5,#+>5#-.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*#
5.&,*#&>))*"#G%,#'%&&#>&#5>&5)#/*.%RD5.R%<.5&#4>;<*>6#
,5>&"
a2#+5&#(.6%&>,%*(.>,;<5&#P(.'5<.5&M#+>5#+%,#-./0#D(.B
,;<.5>=*M# 65<[.*# 5,# %2;<M# +>5# E:;'D5.R(F6=%.'5>*# +5.#
-.(+2'*5# 2H,*.5%)# 2&+# +(4&,*.5%)# =>,# 12)# F5*1*5&#
3&=>5*5.# >&# +5.# P5.*.>5=,'5**5# ,>;<5.12,*5FF5&"# T%&#
)2,,#%=5.#&>;<*#&%;<45>,5&#'[&&5&M#=5>#45F;<5)#P5.B
45&+5.#+%,#-.(+2'*#65F%&+5*#>,*"#a%<F.5>;<5#S&*5.&5<B
)5&# D5.R:65&# 5&*45+5.# :=5.# 5>&5# Q2&+5&'%.*5>M# %&B
<%&+# +5.5.# ,>5# $%.&2&65&# (+5.# E:;'.2R5# 651>5F*#
C5=5&,)>**5FB#2&+#05=.%2;<,6565&,*K&+5D5.(.+&2&6#D()#?I"
N(D5)=5.#?VVO#bC0PcM#/E#f8d"V?"
?8#
\2&+5,65,5*1#:=5.#+5&#P5.,>;<5.2&6,D5.*.%6#D()#?"#3H.>F#?VVf#
bP5.,>;<5.2&6,D5.*.%6,65,5*1M#PP0cM#/E#??8"??]"8"
?V#
3/2010
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
G%,#05,5*1#4>FF#D5.<>&+5.&M#+%,,#E5'F%)%*>(&5&#2&*5.#
+5&#^>,;<#654>,;<*M#=5>#32,,5&,*5FF5&#+>F5**%&*>,;<#5.B
F5+>6*#45.+5&#(+5.#%2R#+5)#$56#12.#05,;<KR*,F5>*2&6#
D5.,>;'5.&"#3.*"#f#3=,"#L#%2R5.F56*#+5)#95.,*5FF5.M#+5)#
!(;0.3*%.#%,1#-%&0B+*#?*5,*.#A53)5.2%,+?;<59:3#8%9:#
+5)#9K&+F5.M#E5'F%)%*>(&5&M#+>5#,>;<#%2R#+>5#-.(+2'*B
,>;<5.<5>*#=51>5<5&M#)>*#+5.#65=(*5&5&#/(.6R%F*#12#H.:B
R5&#2&+#&[*>65&R%FF,#,(6%.#/*>;<H.(=5&#12#)%;<5&"#G%B
=5>#5.RK<.*#+5.#P5.)%.'*5.#%2;<M#45F;<5&#/*.%H%15&#+>5#
-.(+2'*5# >&# +5&# C%65.&# 2&+# CK+5&M# =5>)# ^.%&,H(.*#
2&+# >)# 9%2,<%F*# %2,65,5*1*# ,>&+"# Z.# 5.'5&&*# ,(# %2;<#
+>5# /;<4%;<,*5FF5&# D(&# Q(&,*.2'*>(&WE515H*2.M# P5.B
H%;'2&6# 2&+# +5.# :=.>65&# G%.=>5*2&6,5F5)5&*5# 2&+#
'%&&#+>5#&[*>65&#3&H%,,2&65&#D(.&5<)5&"#
!,#1*,#F*90IP$U#?3*:3#5,#O"#=K#15*#789:(8.23;<59:3*,#
4:.+5&# =5># 32R6%=5# +5.# 05,;<KR*,*K*>6'5>*# 5.F[,;<5&"#
G%,#,*>))*#>&,(R5.&#&>;<*M#%F,#=5>#+5.#l=5.&%<)5#5>&5,#
G*?9:V&3?#(53#$235D*,#%,1#/8??5D*,#8%9:#15*#/<59:3*,#
<>&,>;<*F>;<# +5.# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*# %2R# +5&# Z.45.=5.#
:=5.65<5&"# G5,<%F=# )2,,# )%&# =5># +5.# G25# G>F>65&;5#
>)# E%<)5&# 5>&5.# S&*5.&5<)5&,:=5.&%<)5# %2;<# +5.#
P5.%&*4(.*2&6#%2,#+5)#-./0#=5,(&+5.5,#3265&)5.'#
?9:*,2*,"#7%.#)*,,#18?#',3*.,*:(*,#1%.9:#]5S%518B
*>(&# (+5.# Q(&'2.,# 2&*5.65<*M# 5.F[,;<5&# %2;<# ,5>&5#
/<59:3*,#8%?#1*(#/.FG"
3. Neue Rolle für den Händler
G5.#9K&+F5.#4>.+#D(&#3.*"#f#3=,"#L#>&#+>5#-.(+2'*=5(=B
89:3%,+?;<59:3# 1*.# W*.?3*BB*.?# %,1# 1*?# !(;0.3*%.?#
5>&=51(65&"#Z,#4>.+#D(&#><)#D5.F%&6*M#+%,,#5.#12.#Z>&B
<%F*2&6#+5.#/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#=5>*.K6*#2&+#%&#
+5.# l=5.4%;<2&6# +5.# />;<5.<5>*# +5.# >&# P5.'5<.# 65B
=.%;<*5&#-.(+2'*5#)>*4>.'*"#Z,#4>.+#><)#,(6%.#D(.65B
,;<.>5=5&M#+>5#R:.#5>&5#4>.',%)5#a2,%))5&%.=5>*#)>*#
+5)# 95.,*5FF5.M# +5)# !)H(.*52.# 2&+# +5)# P(FF126,(.B
6%&#5.R(.+5.F>;<5&#T%,,&%<)5&#12#5.6.5>R5&"#G%,#FK2R*#
8%&# 15*# lJ*.JN.1%,+# 1*.# +B*59:*,# /<59:3*,# :5,8%?K#
45F;<5# +5)# 95.,*5FF5.# 2&+# +5)# !)H(.*52.# (=F>565&M#
&2.# *[&*# 5,# <%.)F(,5."# T%*5.>5FF# 4>.+# +%+2.;<# +>5# >&#
$.3"#j#$J?"#k#B53"#J#8B?#E?%J?515V.[#*5,+*?3%&3*#WV,1B*.B
D5.%&*4(.*2&6#%2R#+>5#/*2R5#+5.#H.>)K.5&#P5.%&*4(.*B
F>;<'5>*# %&65<(=5&"# G%,# >,*# %2;<# '(..5'*M# +5&&# +>5#
-)*5?3%4+*# 6*.8,3)0.3%,+# +*(V??# $.3"# j# $J?"# k# +5B3#
8%?1.N92B59:# ,%.# &N.# 15*# /<59:3*,# ,89:# 1*(# ="# $JB
?9:,533# E60.8%??*3-%,+*,# &N.# 18?# !,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,["#
G%,# 4>.+# D()# /5;(# =5>,5>*5# 654>,;<*"# J=6F5>;<# 5,# >&#
@3A#G"#e#+5&#9K&+F5.#)>*#5FR#'(&'.5*5&#2&+#*5>F45>,5#
%2R45&+>65&# 32R6%=5&# 5>&+5;'*M# ,;<.5>=*# 5,M# 5.# <%=5#
6565&:=5.# +5&# 95.,*5FF5.&# 2&+# !)H(.*52.5&# &2.# 5>&5#
%,3*.+*0.1,*3*#',3*.?3N3-%,+?;<59:3"#
4. Meldepflichten
Q*5# 1*,# A*B1*;<59:3*,# 8,# 18?# 60BB-%+?0.+8,# %,3*.B
,;<5>+5*# 3.*"# f# 3=,"# O# &>;<*# )5<.# 14>,;<5&# +5&# D5.B
,;<>5+5&5&# -5.,(&5&"# Z,# %2R5.F56*# +>5# P5.%&*4(.*2&6#
i5+5)#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#2&+#5.R%,,*#+%)>*#%2;<#P5.F5>B
<5.M#P5.)>5*5.M#G>5&,*F5>,*5.M#C5%,>&665=5.#5*;"#G>5#/5B
;(B@3A#,H.5;<5&#%=5.#>&#G"#d#&2.#D(&#T5F+2&65&#+5.#
95.,*5FF5.#%&#+>5#12,*K&+>65&#\5<[.+5&#2&+#5.45;'5&#
+%)>*#RKF,;<F>;<5.45>,5#+5&#Z>&+.2;'M#+>5#:=.>65&#!&B
D*.2*:.J.5,+*.#?*5*,#D0,#1*.#D*.8,2*.3*,#A*B1*;<59:3#
&>;<*#5.R%,,*"#
Z,# >,*# H.(=F5)%*>,;<M# +%,,# +5.# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# ,5F=,*#
+%&&# 2&D5.1:6F>;<# %&# +%,# P(FF126,(.6%&# 65F%&65&#
)2,,M#45&&#&(;<#6%.#&>;<*#R5,*,*5<*M#+%,,#+%,#-.(+2'*#
4>.'F>;<#65RK<.F>;<#>,*#2&+#5.#F5+>6F>;<#0.2&+#12.#3&B
,8:(*# *5,*?# F59:*.:*53?1*4-53?# :83"# O5*# A*B1*;<59:3#
=5,*5<*#,5F=,*#+%&&M#45&&#+%,#-.(+2'*#&(;<#R5<F5.R.5>#
4%.M# %F,# 5,# >&# P5.'5<.# 65F%&6*5# 2&+# 5.,*# &%;<*.K6F>;<#
+2.;<#+>5#^K*>6'5>*#D(&#G.>**H5.,(&5&#65RK<.F>;<#42.B
+5M# =5>,H>5F,45>,5# 45>F# =5>)# P5.*.>5=# 5>&# 05R%<.5&B
,_)=(F# 5&*R5.&*# (+5.# :=5.'F5=*# 4>.+# (+5.# 45&&# +5.#
P5.45&+5.# *.(*1# '(..5'*5.# 2&+# F5>;<*# D5.,*K&+F>;<5.#
!&,#*.2'*>(&#5>&5&#'.%,,5&#\5+>5&2&6,R5<F5.#)%;<*"#!&#
1*.#/.01%23:8&3;<59:3#28,,#?59:#1*.#W*.?3*BB*.#5,#1*.B
%.*>65&# @KFF5&# %2R6.2&+# D(&# 3.*"# O# 3=,"# 8# F>*"# =# -.90#
=51>5<2&6,45>,5# +2.;<# \5.2R2&6# %2R# /5F=,*D5.,;<2FB
+5&# 5&*F%,*5&"??# !)# P5.4%F*2&6,.5;<*# 65<*# 5,# +%.2)M#
+%,# E>,>'(# ':&R*>65.# /;<K+5&# ,(R(.*# %=12'F5))5&M#
4(6565&# +%,# /;<%+5&5.,%*1.5;<*# 5.,*# >)# N%;<<>&5>&#
12)#a265#'())*"#G%&&#>,*#65&:65&+#a5>*M#2)#l=5.F5B
62&65&# %&12,*5FF5&M# (=# )%&# +>5# P5.%&*4(.*2&6# %2R#
5>&5# %&+5.5# -5.,(&# %=4KF15&# '[&&*5"# G%,# -./0# 65B
)V:.3# 1*(# (*B1*;<59:35+*,# !,D*.2*:.J.5,+*.# ,03+*B
+.2&65&#'5>&5#a5>*M#2)#12#:=5.F565&M#4>5#6.(,,#:=5.B
<%2H*# +>5# 05R%<.# >,*M# %2R# 45F;<5)# -.(+2'*R5<F5.# ,>5#
=5.2<*#(+5.#45.#F5*1*5&#Z&+5,#+>5#P5.%&*4(.*2&6#+%B
R:.#*.K6*"
??#
\05.#S.*5>F#D()#L"#J'*(=5.#?V8VM#L3pI8]W?V8V"
!
$5&&# 5>&# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# R5,*,*5FF*# (+5.# 0.2&+# 12.#
3&&%<)5# <%*M# +%,,# D(&# ,5>&5)# -.(+2'*# 5>&5# 05R%<.#
R:.#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*#(+5.#05,2&+<5>*#+5.#P5.45&+5.#%2,B
65<*M#)2,,#5.#+5)#P(FF126,(.6%&#%2R6.2&+#D(&#3.*"#f#
$J?"#`#E%,D*.-N+B59:[#$,+8J*,#(89:*,#J*3.*&&*,1#15*#
/.01%2351*,354-5*.%,+K# 15*# D0(# /.01%23# (c+B59:*.B
45>,5#%2,65<5&+5#05R%<.M#+>5#E:;'D5.R(F6=%.'5>*#2&+#
+>5# 65*.(RR5&5&# T%,,&%<)5&# 12.# 05R%<.5&%=45&B
1%,+"#G*(V??#F*90IP$U#O"#L#J*1*%3*3#E%,D*.-N+B59:[#
5>&5#@.>,*#D(&#5>&#=>,#145>#^%65&M#i5#&%;<#32,4>.'2&6#
+5,# T%&65F,# %2R# +>5# />;<5.<5>*# 2&+# 05,2&+<5>*# D(&#
-5.,(&5&"#
Recht etzung
+2.;<R:<.5&#'[&&5&"#G>5#5F5'*.(&>,;<5&#Q2&+5&5.R%,B
,2&6,,_,*5)5#4>5#=5>,H>5F,45>,5#TBk2)2F2,#(+5.#/2B
H5.;%.+#D(&#k((H#5.)[6F>;<5&#>)#N(*R%FF#+5&#Q(&*%'*#
)>*#+5&#Z.45.=5.&#D(&#65RK<.F>;<5&#-.(+2'*5&"#/>5#5.B
R%,,5&#%=5.#&2.#i5&5#Z>&'K2R5M#=5>#+5&5&#5>&5#Q2&+5&B
'%.*5#D(.654>5,5&#42.+5M#2&+#5&*<%F*5&#%2;<#&>;<*#+>5#
3+.5,,5&#D(&#G.>**5&M#R:.#45F;<5#i5)%&+#5>&#-.(+2'*#
=5,(.6*#<%*"#
195
3/2010
!
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
196
VI. Was das PrSG den Unternehmen
auch noch beschert
1. Massnahmen des Vollzugsorgans
Z>&# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# )2,,# i5+5.15>*# +%)>*# .5;<&5&M#
+%,,#+%,#P(FF126,(.6%&#D(&#+5)#T()5&*#%&M#+%#5.#,5>B
&5#-.(+2'*5#%&=>5*5*M#+>5,5#'(&*.(FF>5.*M#T2,*5.#5.<5=*#
2&+#/>;<5.<5>*,&%;<45>,5#D5.F%&6*"#$>5#+>5,5#Q(&*.(FB
F5&# D(.65<5&M# ,;<>F+5.*# +>5# -./P# >&# 3.*"# ??# )>&2*>[,M#
)0J*5# ?5*# 8BB*.15,+?# 1*,# o*.(5,%?# ER0,3.0BB0.+8,[#
D5.45&+5*"#G(;<#+>5#65&%&&*5&#3'*>D>*K*5&#,>&+#145>B
R5FF(,#i5&5M#+>5#+%,#-./0#>&#3.*"#8V#+5)#P(FF126,(.6%&#
%2R*.K6*"#G>5,5,#H.:R*#125.,*M#(=#+>5#6565=5&5&R%FF,#5.B
R(.+5.F>;<5# Q(&R(.)>*K*,5.'FK.2&6# 65,5*15,'(&R(.)#
>,*#2&+#(=#+>5#*5;<&>,;<5&#S&*5.F%65&#D(FF,*K&+>6#,>&+"#
N[*>65&R%FF,# )%;<*# 5,# =5>)# -.(+2'*# 5>&5# />;<*B# 2&+#
@2&'*>(&,'(&*.(FF5# =51>5<2&6,45>,5# 5>&5# N%;<'(&B
*.(FF5"#\5>#a45>R5F&#<>&,>;<*F>;<#+5.#l=5.5>&,*>))2&6#
+5,#-.(+2'*,#)>*#+5&#5>&65.5>;<*5&#S&*5.F%65&#(+5.#%&#
+5.# />;<5.<5>*# +5,# -.(+2'*,# '%&&# +%,# P(FF126,(.6%&#
5>&5# *5;<&>,;<5# l=5.H.:R2&6# %&(.+&5&M# 5=5&R%FF,#
45&&# *.(*1# '(..5'*5.# S&*5.F%65&# a45>R5F# %&# +5.# -.(B
+2'*,>;<5.<5>*# %2R*%2;<5&"# @%FF,# +5.# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#
+>5# S&*5.F%65&# &>;<*# R.>,*65)K,,# =5>=.>&6*# (+5.# +%,#
-.(+2'*# +5&# />;<5.<5>*,D(.,;<.>R*5&# &>;<*# 5&*,H.>;<*M#
'%&&#5,#+>5#>&#3.*"#8V#3=,"#I#-./0#=5,;<.>5=5&5&#T%,,B
&%<)5&#5.6.5>R5&M#+(;<#&2.M#45&&#5,#+5)#!&D5.'5<.B
=.>&65.#D(.<5.#05F565&<5>*#12.#/*5FF2&6&%<)5#6%="#G>5#
Z.FK2*5.2&65&#+5,#/5;(#12.#-./P#,%65&M#5,#F>565#>)#Z.B
)5,,5&# +5,# Q(&*.(FF(.6%&,M# %2;<# 5>&5# )>F+5.5# T%,,B
&%<)5#12#5.6.5>R5&"#
05)K,,# 3.*"# 8V# -./0# 654K.*>6*# +5.# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#
5>&#P5.=(*M#+%,#-.(+2'*#45>*5.<>&#>&#P5.'5<.#12#=.>&B
65&#,(4>5#+>5#3&(.+&2&6#5>&5.#05R%<.5&4%.&2&6M#+5.#
E:;'&%<)5# (+5.# +5,# E:;'.2R,"# G%,# P(FF126,(.6%&#
'%&&# +>5,5# T%,,&%<)5&# &[*>65&R%FF,# ,5F=,*# D(.&5<B
)5&M# +5&# ZnH(.*# 5>&5,# D5.=(*5&5&# -.(+2'*,# 2&*5.,%B
65&M#-.(+2'*5M#D(&#+5&5&#5>&5#2&)>**5F=%.5#5.&,*5#05B
R%<.# %2,65<*M# 5>&1>5<5&M# D5.&>;<*5&# (+5.# 2&=.%2;<=%.#
)%;<5&"# G5)# T%,,&%<)5&'%*%F(6# D(&# -./0# 3.*"# 8V#
$J?"# j# 5?3# *5,# E!,?J*?0,1*.*[# D0.8,+*?3*BB3K# ?0# 18??#
&(;<# %&+5.5# T%,,&%<)5&# +5&'=%.# ,>&+"# @%FF,# T%,,B
&%<)5&#+5,#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.,#&>;<*#(+5.#&>;<*#.5;<*B
15>*>6# 5.R(F65&M# 4%.&*# +%,# P(FF126,(.6%&# +>5# \5D[F'5B
.2&6#D(.#65RK<.F>;<5&#-.(+2'*5&"#
2. Strafbestimmungen
$5.# 5>&# -.(+2'*# >&# P5.'5<.# =.>&6*M# +%,# 45+5.# +5&#
6.2&+F565&+5&# />;<5.<5>*,B# 2&+# 05,2&+<5>*,%&R(.+5B
.2&65&#2&+#=5>#+5.5&#@5<F5&#%2;<#&>;<*#+5)#/*%&+#D(&#
$>,,5&# 2&+# ^5;<&>'# 5&*,H.>;<*M# )%;<*# ,>;<# 65)K,,#
3.*"# 8e# -./0# 4565&# 5>&5,# P5.65<5&,# ,*.%R=%."# G>5,5#
P(.,;<.>R*# =51>5<*# ,>;<# %2,,;<F>5,,F>;<# %2R# +>5# />;<5.B
<5>*,%&R(.+5.2&65&#&%;<#3.*"#I#3=,"#8#2&+#?"#9>&6565&#
=F5>=*#+5.#P5.,*(,,#6565&#3=,"#I#D[FF>6#2&65%<&+5*M#2&+#
+>5#N>;<*5.R:FF2&6#+5.#>&#3=,"#L#+5*%>FF>5.*#%2R65F>,*5*5&#
O8.J5*3%,+?;<59:3*,#)5.1#D0,#$.3"#^m#,%.#8B?#lJ*.3.*B
*2&6# 5.R%,,*"# \5>+5,# 5&*=5<.*# +5.# C(6>'"# G>5# >&# 3.*"# I#
3=,"#I#65&%&&*5&#3&R(.+5.2&65&#,>&+#R:.#+>5#-.(+2'*B
,>;<5.<5>*#2&D5.1>;<*=%.M#&K)F>;<#+>5#\5.:;',>;<*>62&6#
D(&#05=.%2;<,+%25.M#Z>&4>.'2&6#%2R#%&+5.5#-.(+2'*5M#
P5.45&+2&6# +2.;<# Q(&,2)5&*5&# (+5.# -5.,(&5&M# +>5#
5>&5.#6.[,,5.5&#05R%<.#%2,65,5*1*#,>&+"#\5>#+5.#G%.=>5B
*2&6#<%&+5F*#5,#,>;<#2)#+>5#32,,*%**2&6#+5,#-.(+2'*,#
(53#!,&0.(8350,*,K#15*#?*5,*(#?;*-54?9:*,#G*&8:.*,B
H(*5&1>%F# E5;<&2&6# *.%65&"# G>5# C>,*5# 65<*# D(&# +5.#
Q5&&15>;<&2&6#2&+#32R)%;<2&6#:=5.#+>5#$%.&B#2&+#
/>;<5.<5>*,<>&45>,5# =>,# 12# +5&# 32,,%65&# >&# $5.=2&6#
2&+# -E"# Z>&5# 2&*5.F%,,5&5# (+5.# 2&65&:65&+5# 05R%<B
.5&+5'F%.%*>(&# '%&&# +%,# -.(+2'*# ,5>&5.# 6.2&+,K*1F>B
;<5&#/>;<5.<5>*#(+5.#,5>&5.#/>;<5.<5>*#&%;<#+5)#/*%&+#
D(&# $>,,5&# 2&+# ^5;<&>'# =5.%2=5&# 2&+# >,*# +5,<%F=#
6F5>;<#6.%D>5.5&+#4>5#+5.#P5.65<5&,*%*=5,*%&+"#
G5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#)2,,#P(.,>;<*#4%F*5&#F%,,5&#<>&B
,>;<*F>;<# +5.# Q(..5'*<5>*# 2&+# Z;<*<5>*# D(&# Q(&R(.)>B
*K*,=5,;<5>&>62&65&M#Q(&R(.)>*K*,15>;<5&#5*;"M#+>5#+%,#
-.(+2'*#=56F5>*5&"#P(.#%FF5)#=5>#!)H(.*H.(+2'*5&#'[&B
&5&# ,>;<# >)# -%H>5.'.%)# Q2;'2;',5>5.# D5.=5.65&"# @:.#
@KF,;<2&6M#@%F,;<=52.'2&+2&6M#+5&#05=.%2;<#2&5;<B
*5.# (+5.# 2&4%<.5.# \5,;<5>&>62&65&# 5*;"# D5.45>,*# +%,#
-./0#%2R#+>5#.5>;<+(*>5.*5#C>,*5#D(&#/*.%R*%*=5,*K&+5&#
>&#^90#3.*"#?I#=>,#?f"#
/*.%R=%.# >,*# %2;<# +>5# P5.F5*12&6# +5.# >&# 3.*"# f# 3=,"# O#
/.FG#D*.8,2*.3*,#A*B1*;<59:3#8,#18?#60BB-%+?0.+8,"#
b*.#15*#5,#$.3"#^^#+*.*+*B3*#A53)5.2%,+?;<59:3#D*.)*5B
65.*M# )%;<*# ,>;<# 5=5&R%FF,# ,*.%R=%."# G%,# 6>F*# =5>,H>5F,B
45>,5#R:.#-5.,(&%FM#+%,#Q(&R(.)>*K*,=5,;<5>&>62&65&#
D(.F565&#(+5.#=5>)#$56.K2)5&#65RK<.F>;<5.#-.(+2'*5#
%2,#+5&#05,*5FF5&#9%&+#%&F565&#):,,*5#5=5&,(#4>5#R:.#
+>5# +2.;<# 5>&# 65RK<.F>;<5,# -.(+2'*# 05,;<K+>6*5&M# +>5#
12.#32,'2&R*#%&#+%,#P(FF126,(.6%&#%2R65R(.+5.*#45.B
+5&"
S&.5;<*)K,,>6# +2.;<# 5>&5# /*.%R*%*# &%;<# +5&# 3.*>'5F&#
8e#2&+#8d#5.F%&6*5#P5.)[65&,D(.*5>F5#'[&&5&#5>&651(B
65&#45.+5&"
3. Jahreswechsel 2011/2012
/HK*5,*5&,#%)#I8"#G515)=5.#?V88#)2,,#+%,#%FF5.F5*1*5#
-.(+2'*M# +%,# +5)# -./0# &(;<# &>;<*# 5&*,H.>;<*M# =5>)#
P5.45&+5.#F%&+5&#(+5.#&%;<65.:,*5*#,5>&#=51>5<2&6,B
45>,5#,(#5&*,(.6*#45.+5&M#+%,,#5,#&>5)%&+5)#65RK<.B
F>;<#4>.+"#G%,#6>F*#%2;<#R:.#+>5#/H(.*B#2&+#/H>5F65.K*5M#
+>5#>&#9(*5F,M#Z>&'%2R,15&*.5&M#@>*&5,,,*2+>(,#2&+#%2R#
/H>5FHFK*15&#'(,*5&F(,#(+5.#6565&#T>5*H.5>,#12.#P5.R:B
62&6#,*5<5&M#5=5&,(#R:.#+>5#D(&#G>5&,*F5>,*5.&#D5.45&B
+5*5&#(+5.#12.#P5.R:62&6#65,*5FF*5&#-.(+2'*5M#R:.#+>5#
>)#C5%,>&6#%=6565=5&5&#T(*(.R%<.15265M#Q:<F,;<.K&B
'5#2&+#@5.&,5<65.K*5M#R:.#$5.=65,;<5&'5#5*;"#
32;<#&%;<#+5)#I8"#G515)=5.#?V88#+:.R5&#+>5#95.,*5FB
F5.M#!)H(.*52.5#2&+#9K&+F5.#+>5#&(;<#2&*5.#+5)#%F*5&#
E56>)5#%=65,5*1*5&#-.(+2'*5#&>;<*#%2,#+5&#3265&#F%,B
,5&"# G5&&# 4>5# 5>&# /;<%**5&# R(F6*# +>5# \5(=%;<*2&6,B
;<59:3#1*(#/.01%23#8%&#?*5,*(#)*53*.*,#b*+K#%,1#,%.#
15*#8,+*+*J*,*#G*J.8%9:?&.5?3#01*.#18?#ED*.,N,&35+*.B
3/2010
\>,# I8"# G515)=5.# ?V88# ):,,5&# 95.,*5FF5.M# !)H(.*52.5#
2&+#9K&+F5.#+>5#12.#S),5*12&6#D(&#3.*"#f#&(*45&+>B
65&# P(.%2,,5*12&65&# ,;<%RR5&M# %F,(# ><.# E>,')%&%65B
)5&*# %2R# P(.+5.)%&&# =.>&65&# 2&+# 5>&# E:;'.2R'(&B
15H*#%2,%.=5>*5&M#+>5#-.(+2'*5#12.#E:;'D5.R(F6=%.'5>*#
'5&&15>;<&5&#2&+#+%,#E5'F%)%*>(&,45,5&#,(#(.6%&>B
,>5.5&M#+%,,#,>5#05R%<.5&#5>&5,#-.(+2'*,#,(R(.*#5.'5&B
&5&"#3FF5#\5*5>F>6*5&#):,,5&#=>,#12#+>5,5)#a5>*H2&'*#
%2;<# +>5# 6565&,5>*>65# a2,%))5&%.=5>*# =5># +5.# l=5.B
4%;<2&6# +5.# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*# 2&+# +5.# T5F+2&6# %&#
+%,#P(FF126,(.6%&#.565F&"
G>5# l=5.6%&6,D(.,;<.>R*5&# >&# 3.*"# ?8# =51>5<5&# ,>;<#
&>;<*#&2.#%2R#+>5#3=6%=5#+5.#&(;<#&>;<*#65,5*15,'(&B
R(.)5&#-.(+2'*5#2&+#%2R#+>5#:=5.%2,#'()HF5n5#\5(=B
89:3%,+?;<59:3#1*.#W*.?3*BB*.K#!(;0.3*%.*#%,1#WV,1B
B*."#$.3"#=^#$J?"#=#?;.59:3#+*,*.*BB#D0,#1*.#E'(?*3-%,+#
D(&# 3.*"# f`"# G%,# <%*# =5.5>*,# 12.# @.%65# 65R:<.*M# (=# +>5#
A*B1*;<59:3#8,#18?#60BB-%+?0.+8,#8%9:#*.?3#8J#^"#h8,%B
%.#?V8?#6>F*M#,(R5.&#+>5#(.6%&>,%*(.>,;<5&#P(.%2,,5*12&B
65&#+%R:.#&>;<*#R.:<5.#5n>,*>5.5&M#=5>,H>5F,45>,5#45&&#
>&# 5>&5)# S&*5.&5<)5&# +>5# 12.# T5F+2&6# '()H5*5&*5#
-5.,(&#&(;<#&>;<*#=5,*>))*#42.+5"#G%,#/5;(#<%*#+5,B
<%F=#%)#I"#3262,*#?V8V#,5>&5#@3A#)>*#5>&5.#&525&#a>RB
&*.# O"# i# *.+V,-3"# O8,89:# +5B3# 15*# A*B1*;<59:3# J*.*53?#
,5>*#+5)#8"#U2F>#?V8V#2&+#>,*#%2;<#%2R#-.(+2'*5#%&45&+B
=%.M# +>5# D(.# +>5,5)# G%*2)# >&# P5.'5<.# 65=.%;<*# 42.B
1*,"# \5,# W*.?3*BB*.K# 1*.# D0,# *5,*(# F59:*.:*53?1*4-53#
,5>&5,#-.(+2'*,#=5>,H>5F,45>,5#+2.;<#5>&5&#S&R%FF#(+5.#
5>&5# E5'F%)%*>(&# 5.RK<.*M# >,*# ,;<(&# D(.# +5)# 8"# U%&2%.#
=Y^=#(*B1*;<59:35+"#
VII. Agenda – oder was zu tun ist
3F,#H.%FF#65R:FF*5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%#<KF*#+%,#-./0#2&B
%&65&5<)5# l=5..%,;<2&65&# =5.5>*"# /5>&5# /H>5F.565F&#
R(F65&#&>;<*#>))5.#+5.#C(6>'M#2&+#5,#=>.6*#@%FF,*.>;'5M#
>&#+5&5&#)%&#,>;<#D5.<5++5.&#'%&&"#Z,#,5*1*#%=5.#%2;<#
&525#A2%F>*K*,,*%&+%.+,M#>&+5)#5,#+%,#\542,,*,5>&#R:.#
F59:*.:*53?8,&0.1*.%,+*,#%,1#I1*4-53*#?0)0:B#8%&#F*5B
*5&#+5.#3&=>5*5.#%F,#%2;<#+5.#P5.45&+5.#,;<K.R*"#^.(*1#
,5>&5.#S&65.5>)*<5>*5&#'%&&#5,#%F,#3&F5>*2&6#+>5&5&M#
2)#32,5>&%&+5.,5*12&65&#)>*#+5)#P(FF126,(.6%&#12#
D5.)5>+5&# 2&+# 9%R*2&6,.>,>'5&# 12# )>&>)>5.5&"# G>5#
U2.>,*5&# ,(FF*5&# +5&# S&*5.&5<)5&# >&# ><.5)# T%&+%&B
*5&'.5>,# &>;<*# 5.,*# H.(15,,2%FM# ,(&+5.&# ,;<(&# =5># +5.#
Z.R:FF2&6# +5.# &525&# 32R6%=5&# D(.=5265&+# 12.# /5>*5#
,*5<5&"#
Z,# F(<&*# ,>;<# &>;<*M# =5;')5,,5.>,;<5# ^:R*5F5>5&# %&12B
?3.*,+*,K#%(#:*.8%?-%4,1*,K#0J#15*#F59:*.:*53?8,&0.B
+5.2&65&# %&# 5>&# '(&'.5*5,# Z.1526&>,# %2,,;<F>5,,F>;<#
>&# 5>&5)# ,5'*(.>5FF5&# -.(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*,5.F%,,# D5.%&B
'5.*# ,>&+# 2&+# (=# +%,# -./0# *5>F45>,5# (+5.# 6%&1# %&12B
45&+5&#>,*"#$5&&#5*4%,#,;<>5R65<*M#4>.+#+>5#/>;<5.<5>*#
&>;<*# &2.# %&<%&+# +5,# -./0M# ,(&+5.&# %2;<# &%;<# +5&#
F;5*B.*+*B,# 1*?# W8&3;<59:3.*9:3?K# 8B?0# +*(V??# /.WG#
2&+# 3.*"# L8WOO# JEM# =52.*5>F*"# T%,,,*%=# >,*# +%&&# +>5#
# .(+2'*,>;<5.<5>*M# 45F;<5# +5.# 05,;<K+>6*5# =5.5;<*>6B
*5.45>,5#5.4%.*5&#'(&&*5"#3FFRKFF>65M#>&#,5'*(.>5FF5&#Z.B
F%,,5&#&(;<#D(.'())5&+5#65.>&65.5#/>;<5.<5>*,%&R(.B
+5.2&65&#*.5*5&#>&#+5&#9>&*5.6.2&+"
G>5#95.,*5FF5.#2&+#+>5#:=.>65&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#):,B
,5&#,>;<#D5.,;<>5+5&5#/%;<D5.<%F*5#%2,)%F5&M#&K)F>;<#
15*# ED*.,N,&35+*.)*5?*# D0.:*.?*:J8.*[# 6*.)*,1%,+#
+5,#-.(+2'*,#X#%FF5&R%FF,#12,%))5&#)>*#%&+5.5&#-.(B
+2'*5&# X# ,5>&5# 05=.%2;<,+%25.# (+5.# ,5>&5# T2*%*>(&#
-%(#ER0,?%(*,3*,;.01%23["#b*,,#18?#/.01%23#,59:3#
%FF5&# +>5,5&# D(.,*5FF=%.5&# /%;<D5.<%F*5&# 5&*,H.>;<*M#
'%&&#+%,#P(FF126,(.6%&#T%,,&%<)5&#5.6.5>R5&M#,5F=,*#
45&&#5,#&(;<#'5>&5&#/;<%+5&#D5.2.,%;<*#<%*"#!&#5>&5)#
1%.9:#*5,*#F9:V15+%,+#8%?+*Bc?3*,#W8&3;<59:3D*.&8:B
.5&#,*5<*#>&#+5.#E565F#&2.#5>&#5>&1>65.#/%;<D5.<%F*#12.#
G>,'2,,>(&M# =5>,H>5F,45>,5# (=# +5.# 95.,*5FF5.# )>*# +5)#
'(&'.5*5&# 05=.%2;<M# +5.# 12)# /;<%+5&# 65R:<.*# <%**5M#
.5;<&5&#)2,,*5#(+5.#(=#5.#<K**5#5.'5&&5&#'[&&5&M#+%,,#
,5>&# -.(+2'*# +5.5>&,*# >&# Q(&,2)5&*5&<K&+5# 65.K*#
(+5.#12,%))5&#)>*#5>&5)#%&+5.5&#-.(+2'*#D5.45&+5*#
4>.+#2&+#+%=5>#S&<5>F#%&.>;<*5*"#G(;<#2)#+%,#-.(+2'*#
&N.#18?#!,D*.2*:.J.5,+*,#43#-%#(89:*,K#(%??#?59:#1*.#
!,D*.2*:.J.5,+*.# ?V(3B59:*# D0(# /.FG# 8B?# ED*.,N,&35B
65.45>,5# D(.<5.,5<=%.`# 5*>'5**>5.*5&# /%;<D5.<%F*5# D(.#
3265&#R:<.5&#2&+#5&*,H.5;<5&+#=5.:;',>;<*>65&"#G%B
)>*#'[&&*5&#5*F>;<5#-.(+215&*5&#2&+#P5.)%.'*5.#:=5.B
R(.+5.*#,5>&"
\5># Z.1526&>,,5&M# +>5# &2.# R:.# +>5# P5.45&+2&6# +2.;<#
@%;<F52*5# =5,*>))*# ,>&+M# '%&&# )%&# ,>;<# &>;<*# +%.%2R#
D5.F%,,5&M#+%,,#,>5#%2,,;<F>5,,F>;<#D(&#/H51>%F>,*5&#2&+#
E(2*>&>5.,#D5.45&+5*#45.+5&"#$5&&#+>5,5#-.(+2'*)>B
+.8350,# ED*.,N,&35+*.)*5?*# D0.:*.?*:J8.[# 5?3K# )*.1*,#
-.(+215&*5&# 2&+# P5.)%.'*5.# D(&# +5&# ):<,%)5&#
789:(8.23;<59:3*,#*.&8??3"#O8?#BV??3#?59:#,59:3#1%.9:#
5>&5# =F(,,5# Q5&&15>;<&2&6# D5.)5>+5&M# 4(&%;<# +%,#
-.(+2'*#%2,,;<F>5,,F>;<#R:.#+5&#05=.%2;<#+2.;<#@%;<B
F52*5# =5,*>))*# >,*"# Z,# =.%2;<*# +%R:.# +>5# 3=,>;<5.2&6#
)>*#5>&5.#+2.;<,5*1=%.5&#P5.5>&=%.2&6#>&&5.<%F=#+5.#
P5.*.>5=,'5**5"#
!)H(.*52.5M# 9K&+F5.# 2&+# G>5&,*F5>,*5.# +:.R5&# ,>;<#
,59:3#1%.9:#5:.*#E?%J?515V.*#6*.8,3)0.3%,+[#*5,B%BB*,#
B8??*,"# !:.# /<59:3*,:*&3# )5.1# ,09:# D0,# 8,1*.*,# 60.B
?9:.5&3*,#15235*.3#8B?#,%.#D0(#E$J&*1*.%,+?8.352*B[#5(#
="#$J?9:,533#(53#1*,#E60.8%??*3-%,+*,#&N.#18?#!,D*.B
2*:.J.5,+*,["#Q*5#1*,#E/<59:3*,#,89:#1*(#!,D*.2*:.B
=.>&65&`# >)# I"# 3=,;<&>**# <%*# +>5# /2=,>+>%.>*K*,.565F#
%2,65,H>5F*"#
bV:.*,1#15*#5(#/.WG#D*.8,2*.3*#F9:81*,*.?83-;<59:3#
6.2&+,K*1F>;<#&2.#+>5#95.,*5FF5.#5.R%,,*M#R:<.5&#,;<2F+B
<%R*5# P5.,*[,,5# 6565&# +>5# D5.4%F*2&6,.5;<*F>;<5&# />B
9:*.:*53?;<59:3*,# J*5# 6*.B*3-%,+# 01*.# oc3%,+# *5,*?#
T5&,;<5&#12#/;<%+5&5.,%*1%&,H.:;<5&#6565&#%FF5#!&B
D*.2*:.J.5,+*."# $,+*?59:3?# 1*.# 8%?&N:.B59:*,# /<59:B
*5&'%*%F(65#>)#-./0#+:.R*5#,>;<#+5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#
)>*# 5>&5)# Zn'2FH%*>(&,=545>,# ,;<45.*2&"# /5>*# 8"# U2F>#
=Y^Y# :83# *.# 15*# /<59:3K# ?59:# NJ*.# 15*# F59:*.:*53# ?*5,*.#
-.(+2'*5#12#D5.654>,,5.&"#
$>.+# +>5# 05=.%2;<,+%25.# 5>&5,# -.(+2'*,# &>;<*# +2.;<#
5>&# Z&+65=.%2;<,+%*2)# =56.5&1*# X# 4>5# +%,# R:.# 3.1B
!
45>,5# D(.<5.,5<=%.5`# C5=5&,5&+5# +5,# -.(+2'*,# FK,,*#
8%9:#15*#/<59:3#-%#?*5,*.#Q*0J89:3%,+#*.Bc?9:*,"#
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
197
3/2010
!
Recht etzung
Z26g&>5#9(FF>65.B9%6)%&&h#G%,#-.(+2'*5,>;<5.<5>*,65,5*1h#Z>&5#\:;<,5#+5.#-%&+(.%
198
&5>)>**5FM# C5=5&,)>**5F# 2&+# Q(,)5*>'%# <52*5# +2.;<B
456,#+5.#@%FF#>,*#X#+%&&#)2,,#+%,#-.(+2'*#,(#F%&65#=5B
(=%;<*5*#2&+#):,,5&#%2R*%2;<5&+5#05R%<.5&#,(#F%&65#
65)5F+5*#45.+5&M#4>5#+%,#-.(+2'*#D5.&:&R*>65.45>,5#
D(.<5.,5<=%.# >&# 05=.%2;<# =F5>=*"# /;<%+5&5.,%*1%&B
,H.:;<5# %2R6.2&+# D5.,K2)*5.# -.(+2'*=5(=%;<*2&6#
2&+#+%+2.;<#&>;<*#D5.<>&+5.*5.#/;<K+>62&65&#'[&&5&#
2&*5.#S),*K&+5&#&(;<#4K<.5&+#U%<.15<&*5&#+.(<5&"#
@:.#+>5#D(&#3.*"#f#3=,"#L#D5.F%&6*5&#T%,,&%<)5&#12.#
4>.',%)5&# a2,%))5&%.=5>*#14>,;<5&#95.,*5FF5.M#!)B
H(.*52.# 2&+# 9K&+F5.# ):,,5&# +>5# C>5R5.B# 2&+# 3=&%<B
)5D5.*.K65# 14>,;<5&# +>5,5&# +.5># 3'*52.5&# m# i(2.# 65B
=.%;<*# 45.+5&"# G%,# P(.65<5&# =5>)# 32R*%2;<5&# 5>&5.#
/.01%23+*&8:.#5?3#-%#.*+*B,K#18(53#2*5,#A*B1*;<59:35B
65.#6.2&+F(,#D(.H.5,;<*"#32;<#45&&#+>5#D()#[RR5&*F>B
9:*,#d*9:3#D*.B8,+3*#E%,D*.-N+B59:*[#A*B1%,+#8,#18?#
P(FF126,(.6%&#&>;<*#+2.;<#D5.*.%6F>;<5#3=.5+5&#5>&65B
,;<.K&'*#45.+5&#'%&&M#5)HR5<F5&#,>;<#>&*5.&5#/H>5F.5B
65F&# 2"%"# %2;<# :=5.# E56.5,,# 2&+# Q(,*5&D5.*5>F2&6# =5>#
T%,,&%<)5&#5*;"#
\?# *(;4*:B3# ?59:# *5,*# \.+V,-%,+# 1*.# Q*3.5*J?:8&3B
;<59:3D*.?59:*.%,+# 1%.9:# *5,*# dN92.%&1*92%,+"# b*B
+*,# 1*.# ,*%*,K# 8235D*,# /.01%23J*0J89:3%,+?;<59:3#
65.K*#5>&#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65.#D5.)2*F>;<#5<5.#%F,#=>,<5.#>&#
+>5#C%65M#%2R6.2&+#+5,#05R%<.5&,%*15,#5>&5&#E:;'.2R#
>&# Z.4K62&6# 12# 1>5<5&"# /(+%&&# 5.*5>F*# 3.*"# 8V# 3=,"# I#
+5)#P(FF126,(.6%&#+>5#Q()H5*5&1M#5>&5&#E:;'.2R#%&B
12(.+&5&# (+5.# ,5F=,*# 12# D(FF1>5<5&"# G>5# Q(,*5&# +%R:.#
1%<F*#+5.#!&D5.'5<.=.>&65."#@:.#i5&5#-.(+2'*5M#+>5#2&B
*5.# +>5# C0P# R%FF5&M# %2R5.F56*# C0P# 3.*"# OL# 3=,"# 8# F>*"# ;#
+5)# !&D5.'5<.=.>&65.# ,(6%.# 5>&5# D5.4%F*2&6,.5;<*B
B59:*#dN92.%&;<59:3"#
U2.>,*5&M#45F;<5#+%,#05,5*1#%2R#C:;'5&#2&+#$>+5.,H.:B
;<5# +2.;<'K))5&M# '())5&# )[6F>;<5.45>,5# 5>&5)#
F9:B%;<09:#8%&#15*#F;%.K#18?#5:.*(#A8,18,3*,#0&&*,B
,*5<*M#R%FF,#5.#,>;<#12#S&.5;<*#+2.;<#P(FF126)%,,&%<B
)5&#=5+.K&6*#R:<F*"#Z,#>,*#%=5.#,>&&D(FF5.M#5>&5)#S&*5.B
&5<)5&# =5># +5.# '(..5'*5&# -.(+2'*+%.=>5*2&6M# +5.#
3=R%,,2&6# D(&# ,;<%+5&D5.<:*5&+5&# 05=.%2;<,B# 2&+#
%&+5.5&# !&,*.2'*>(&5&# ,(4>5# =5>)# 32R=%2# +5,# -.(B
+2'*=5(=%;<*2&6,,_,*5),# 2&+# +5.# 9%&+<%=2&6# +5.#
A*B1*;<59:3*,#;.0;:TB8235?9:#8,#15*#W8,1#-%#+*:*,"#
O5*#',3*.,*:(*,#?5,1#NJ*.#5:.*#F59:*.:*53?;<59:3*,#?0#
12#>&,*.2>5.5&M#+%,,#><&5&#'5>&5#FK,*>65&#(+5.#'(,*,H>5B
F>65&# P(FF126,)%,,&%<)5&# (+5.# 6%.# 5>&# /;<%+5&5.B
,%*1D5.R%<.5&#+.(<*"