RESPGE - Procuradoria Geral do Estado de São Paulo
Transcrição
RESPGE - Procuradoria Geral do Estado de São Paulo
REViSta da Escola Superior da Procuradoria Geral do Estado de São Paulo Journal of São Paulo State’s Attorney Generalship School Volume 3 – Número 1 Jan / Dez 2012 ISSN 2179-8532 GERALDO ALCKMIN GOVERNADOR DO ESTADO PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO ELIVAL DA SILVA RAMOS Procurador-Geral do Estado MARIÂNGELA SARRUBBO FRAGATA Chefe do Centro de Estudos ESPGE ESCOLA SUPERIOR DA PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO DE SÃO PAULO REVISTA DA ESCOLA SUPERIOR DA PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO DE SÃO PAULO JOURNAL OF SÃO PAULO STATE’S ATTORNEY GENERALSHIP SCHOOL WtOtKBOFJSPEF[FNCSP *44/ ESPGE ESCOLA SUPERIOR DA PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO DE SÃO PAULO ª "3FWJTUBEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP 3&41(&41 ÏVNBQVCMJDBÎÍPBOVBMEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP &TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP²QFSNJUJEBBSFQSPEVÎÍPEFUSFDIPTEPTBSUJHPTEFTEFRVF NFODJPOBEBBGPOUFPSJHJOBMEFQVCMJDBÎÍP 5JSBHFNFYFNQMBSFT Editora Científica / Scientific Editor 1BUSÓDJB6MTPO1J[BSSP8FSOFS Conselho Editorial / Editorial Board "MWBSP#FSFJKP6OJWFSTJEBE"VUPOPNBEF.BESJE.BESJE&TQBOIB $BSMPT"SJ7JFJSB4VOEGFME'VOEBÎÍP(FUÞMJP7BSHBT4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM $BSMPT#MBODPEF.PSBJT6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPB-JTCPB1PSUVHBM $FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF.FMMP1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP 4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM $POTVFMP:BUTVEB.PSPNJ[BUP:PTIJEB1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP 1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM %BOJFM"OUÙOJPEF.PSBFT4BSNFOUP6OJWFSTJEBEFEP&TUBEPEP3JPEF+BOFJSP 3JPEF+BOFJSP3+#SBTJM %JOPSÈ"EFMBJEF.VTFUUJ(SPUUJ1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP 4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM &EVBSEP"VHVTUP"MWFT7FSB$SV[1JOUP6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPB-JTCPB1PSUVHBM )VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPS6OJWFSTJEBEF'FEFSBMEF.JOBT(FSBJT#FMP )PSJ[POUF.(#SBTJM (JTFMEB)JSPTIJEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM +PSHF.JSBOEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPB-JTCPB1PSUVHBM +PTÏ3FJOBMEPEF-JNB-PQFT6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM +VBO;PSOP[B1ÏSFT6OJWFSTJEBE$BSMPT***EF.BESJE.BESJE&TQBOIB -FP1FQF6OJWFSTJUËEJ3PNB5SF3PNB*UÈMJB -VJ["MCFSUP%BWJE"SBÞKP1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP 4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM .BOPFM(POÎBMWFT'FSSFJSB'JMIP6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM .BSHBSJUBEF)FHFEVT6OJWFSTJEBEEF.POUFWJEFP.POUFWJEÏV6SVHVBJ .BSHFSFUF(SFTTF6OJWFSTJUZPG8BTIJOHUPO4FBUUMF&6" .BSJB(BSDJB1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM .BSJB)FMFOB%JOJ[1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM /JOB#FBUSJ[4UPDDP3BOJFSJ6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM 1BVMP"GGPOTP-FNF.BDIBEP6OJWFSTJEBEF.FUPEJTUBEF1JSBDJDBCB1JSBDJDBCB 41#SBTJM 4VFMJ%BMMBSJ6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM 7BTDP1FSFJSBEB4JMWBo6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPB-JTCPB1PSUVHBM Corpo Editorial/ Publishers "SMJOEP1IJMJQQJ+VOJPS6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM &EVBSEP$BSMPT#JBODB#JUUBS6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM ²SJLB#FDIBSB1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM 'FSOBOEP%JBT.FOF[FTEF"MNFJEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41 #SBTJM (VJMIFSNF"TTJTEF"MNFJEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM *MUPO(BSDJBEB$PTUB6OJWFSTJEBEF&TUBEVBMEP/PSUFEP1BSBOÈ+BDBSF[JOIP13 #SBTJM +PTÏEF.FMP"MFYBOESJOP6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPB-JTCPB1PSUVHBM +PTÏ-FWJ.FMMPEP"NBSBM+ÞOJPS6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM +PTÏ.BVSJDJP$POUJ6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM -VDJBOBEF5PMFEP5FNFS$BTUFMP#SBODP1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF 4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM .ÈSDJP1VHMJFTJ1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM .BSJB1BVMB%BMMBSJ#VDDJ6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP41#SBTJM 1JFUSPEF+FTÞT-PSB"MBSDØO1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP 1BVMP41#SBTJM 7JEBM4FSSBOP/VOFT+ÞOJPS1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP 1BVMP41#SBTJM Pareceristas / Reviewers A RESPGE-SP DPOUBDPNVNHSVQPQFSNBOFOUFEFQBSFDFSJTUBTGPSNBEPQFMPT JOUFHSBOUFTEP$POTFMIPFEP$PSQP&EJUPSJBJTEBQVCMJDBÎÍPCFNDPNPQPS QSPGFTTPSFTFQFTRVJTBEPSFTEB&41(&"MÏNEJTTPBRESPGE-SP QPEFDPOWJEBS FTQFDJBMJTUBTad hocQBSBBOÈMJTFEPTNBOVTDSJUPT Secretaria Executiva $BSMPT3PCFSUP5SJOEBEF#PSHPOPWJ 3PTBOB4BOUPSP)FOSJRVFT &NBJMFTQHFTFDSFUBSJB!TQHPWCS Revisão de Texto 4ÈSWJP/PHVFJSB)PMBOEB Projeto Gráfico 'ÈUJNB$POTBMFT Editoração 'FSOBOEB#VDDFMMJ CTP, Impressão e Acabamento *NQSFOTB0mDJBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP Correspondência 1FEJEPTEFQFSNVUBEFWFNTFSFOEFSFÎBEPTË&41(& Exchange orders should be addressed to ESPGE. Normas editoriais disponíveis em: XXXQHFTQHPWCSFTDPMBTVQFSJPSSFWJTUBT Endereço / Address 3VB1BNQMPOBBOEBS #FMB7JTUBo4ÍP1BVMP41o#SBTJM $&1 5FM &NBJMFTQHFTFDSFUBSJB!TQHPWCS &OEFSFÎPFMFUSÙOJDPwww.pge.sp.gov.br/escolasuperior/respge 3FWJTUBEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP+PVSOBMPG4ÍP 1BVMP4UBUFT"UUPSOFZ(FOFSBMTIJQ4DIPPM&TDPMBTVQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEP EF4ÍP1BVMPoWO 4ÍP1BVMP"1SPDVSBEPSJB&TDPMBTVQFSJPS "OVBM 5FYUPTCJMÓOHàF 3FTVNPTFNQPSUVHVÐTFJOHMÐT *44/ W W W %JSFJUP1FSJØEJDPT*4ÍP1BVMP&TUBEP 1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBM&TDPMB4VQFSJPS**+PVSOBM PG4ÍP1BVMP4UBUFT"UUPSOFZ(FOFSBMTIJQ4DIPPM $%% $%6 ESCOLA SUPERIOR DA PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO DE SÃO PAULO EQUIPE Diretoria Patrícia Ulson Pizarro Werner, Procuradora do Estado, Diretora da ESPGE Marily Diniz do Amaral Chaves, Procuradora do Estado, Vice-Diretora da ESPGE Conselho Curador Ana Lúcia Correa Freire Pires de Oliveira Dias; Cintia Orefice; Liliane Kiomi Ito Ishikawa; Marcelo Gomes Sodré; Mariana Rosada Pantano; Mariângela Sarrubbo Fragata (Chefe do Centro de Estudos, membro nato); Mirna Cianci; Nina Beatriz Stocco Ranieri; Patricia Ulson Pizarro Werner (Diretora da ESPGE, membro nato); Ruth Helena Pimentel de Oliveira EQUIPE DE COORDENADORES E MONITORES Direito do Estado Coordenadores Dora Maria de Oliveira Ramos; Carlos José Teixeira de Toledo; Eugênia Cristina Cleto Marolla Monitores Cristiana Corrêa Conde Faldini; Enio Moraes da Silva; Liliane Kiomi Ito Ishikawa; Luciana Rita Laurenza Saldanha Gasparini; Maria Clara Osuna Diaz Falavigna; René Zamlutti Júnior. Filosofia e TGD Coordenadores João Carlos Pietropaolo; Haroldo Pereira; Romualdo Baptista dos Santos Monitores Alessandra Ferreira de Araujo Ribeiro; Ana Lucia Corrêa Freire Pires Oliveira Dias; Christiane Mina Falsarella; Julia Cara Giovannetti Metodologia Clarice Von Oertzen de Araújo; Márcia Walquiria Batista dos Santos Didática Gabriel Veiga Catellani Direito Processual Civil Mirna Cianci; Rita de Cássia Conte Quartieri; Fábio Victor da Fonte Monnerat Monitores Levi de Mello; Lúcia Cerqueira Alves Barbosa; Maria Luciana de Oliveira Facchina Podval; Thais Teizen Direitos Humanos Coordenação Ana Paula Zomer; José Luiz Souza de Moraes; Margarete Gonçalves Pedroso Monitores Alexandre Aboud; Ana Cláudia Vergamini Luna; Anna Cândida Alves Pinto Serrano; Anna Luiza Quintella Fernandes; Ivanira Pancheri; Levi de Mello; Luciana Augusta Sanches; Messias José Lourenço; Paulo David Cordioli; Rene Zamlutti Junior; Rosely Sucena Pastore; Vera Pimentel Fonseca; Virgílio Bernardes Carbonieri Direito Tributário e Financeiro Coordenação Estevão Horvath; Mara Regina Castilho Reinauer Ong; Monica de Almeida Magalhães Serrano Monitores Bruno Maciel dos Santos; Claudia Bocardi Allegretti; Fabrizio de Lima Pieroni; Fabrizio Lungarzo O’Connor; Lucia de Faria Freitas; Rafael de Oliveira Rodrigues; Silvia Vaz Domingus; Valéria Martinez da Gama Direito Ambiental Coordenação Marcelo Gomes Sodré; Cintia Oréfice; Daniel Smolentzov Monitores Adriana Ruiz Vicentin; Ana Carolina Daldegan Serraglia; Fábio André Uema Oliveira; Jean Jacques Erenberg; Marcos Narche Louzada; Mariana Rosada Pantano; Tatiana Capochin Paes Leme; Vivian Alves Carmichael Funcionários da ESPGE Arabi Santos Mesquita; Carlos Roberto Trindade Borgonovi; Daniel Martins Silva; Deise Aparecida Santiago; Izabel Cristina L de Freitas; Leda Regina Machado Lima; Maritza Cristine Lins de Araujo Rocha e Cabral Sacadura; Monica Achcar de Azambuja; Paulo Severo dos Santos; Rosana Santoro Henriques; Sergio Antonio Petry; Thiago Blumer Estagiárias Caroline Tiemi; Mariana da Costa Battani; Melissa Ibrahim SUMÁRIO Editorial Direito Comparado La composition du Conseil constitutionnel, un exotisme bien français....... 15 'BCSJDF)PVSRVFCJF Tradução: A composição do Conselho Constitucional: um exotismo bem francês ...... 25 'FSOBOEB%JBT.FOF[FTEF"MNFJEB La financiación del Sistema Nacional de Salud Español ............................. 35 +VBO;PSOP[B1ÏSF[ Direito Constitucional – nacional Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro ............................ 65 .BOPFM(POÎBMWFT'FSSFJSB'JMIP Reclamação Constitucional: a preservação da competência e garantia da autoridade das decisões do STF brasileiro ............................................. 81 .BSDJB"NJOP Direito Administrativo A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas ................................. 107 &SJEBOF#BQUJTUB'VSMBO Direito Ambiental Algumas considerações sobre o Direito Ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo ............................................................................ +PTÏ'FSOBOEP$FEF×PEF#BSSPT -JEJBOJ.BDIBEP4PBSFTEPT4BOUPT 135 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional do meio ambiente a ser considerado no licenciamento ambiental........................................................................... 165 4ÓMWJB)FMFOB/PHVFJSB/BTDJNFOUP 5IBÓT5FJ[FO Direito Processual Civil Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil.......................................................................... 191 $SJTUJBOF"RVJOP(PO[BHB Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais: reflexões sobre o procedimento até a expedição de ordem de pagamento .......................................................... 227 3FHJOB.BSJB3PESJHVFTEB4JMWB+BDPWB[ Mandado de Segurança e Silêncio Administrativo ................................... 265 .BSJOBEF-JNB-PQFT Direito Tributário A compensação Tributária e o regime constitucional de precatórios instituídos pela Emenda Constitucional nº 62/2009.................................... 291 $MBVEJB#PDBSEJ"MMFHSFUUJ Transação Tributária no Brasil: Possibilidades e limites .......................... -VDJMJB"QBSFDJEBEPT4BOUPT 321 EDITORIAL "3FWJTUBEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP 3&41(& DIFHBBTFVUFSDFJSPWPMVNFDPNPGÙMFHPEBKVWFOUVEFRVFBDBSBDUFSJ[B" MFJUVSBEB3FWJTUBEFTWFMBOPFOUBOUPTVBPVUSBGBDFWPMUBEBQBSBBDSJUFSJPTBFMFJÎÍP EPTUFYUPTRVFBDPNQÜFNQBSBPDVJEBEPSJHPSPTPDPNTFVDPOUFÞEPBEFOPUBSB TFHVSBOÎB EPT NBJT FYQFSJNFOUBEPT 0T BSUJHPT KVSÓEJDPT RVF WFJDVMB EF VNB QBSUF FYQSFTTBNBJORVJFUBÎÍPQSØQSJBEPTFTQÓSJUPTKPWFOTFEFPVUSBBQSVEFOUFTBCFEPSJB EFEPVUSJOBEPSFTDPOTBHSBEPT&TTBEJWFSTJEBEFEFJEFJBTÏKVTUBNFOUFPRVFDPOGFSF Ë3FWJTUBBRVBMJEBEFEFQVCMJDBÎÍPBDBEÐNJDBTFEFEFEFCBUFTFEFDPOWJWÐODJBSFT QFJUPTBEFQFOTBNFOUPTFQPTJÎÜFTBJOEBRVBOEPOÍPDPOWFSHFOUFT$PNPSFTVMUBEP PMFJUPSFYQBOEFTFVDPOIFDJNFOUPCFCFOBTGPOUFTPSJHJOÈSJBTTFKBEBEPVUSJOBOBDJP OBMTFKBEBFTUSBOHFJSBQPSRVFBNCBTQSFTFOUFTOB3FWJTUBTFFYQÜFNBPTFVEFTGSVUF "DPORVJTUBEPHSBVEFFYDFMÐODJBEB3FWJTUBSFQSFTFOUBEBQFMBDFSUJmDBÎÍP QFMPTJTUFNBQualisWFNBPFODPOUSPEPTJOUFOUPTQFSTFHVJEPTQFMB&TDPMB4VQFSJPS EB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP&41(& FNUPEPPTFVQFSDVSTP%FT EFTVBJOTUBMBÎÍPFNNBSÎPEFB&41(&UFNTFQBVUBEPQFMBCVTDBEBFYDFMÐO DJBFNQSPDFTTPDPOUÓOVPTVBDSJBÎÍPKÈGPSBJOTQJSBEBQPSFTTFJEFBM0IJTUØSJDPEB &TDPMBCFNPEFNPOTUSBEPRVFTÍPFYFNQMPTBJOBVHVSBÎÍPEBTJOTUBMBÎÜFTQSØQSJBT FQFSGFJUBNFOUFQSPKFUBEBTQBSBTFVGVODJPOBNFOUPPJODSFNFOUPEBPGFSUBEFDVSTPT FNÈSFBTEJWFSTBTBEJQMPNBÎÍPEFWBSJBEBTUVSNBTUVEPJTTPEJSJHJEPËTVBSB[ÍPEF TFSRVFÏBGPSNBÎÍPEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTPRVFWFNTFOEPTBUJTGFJUPDPNPBVNFOUPEP OÞNFSPEFBMVOPTBDBEBQFSÓPEPMFUJWP "FEJÎÍPEB3FWJTUBEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF 4ÍP1BVMPÏVNBDPOUFDJNFOUPFYJUPTP"MÏNEPWBMPSFNTJEBTQVCMJDBÎÜFTUFN BJOEBPNÏSJUPEFEJGVOEJSPOPNFEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&T UBEPFNNFJPËDPNVOJEBEFKVSÓEJDBUBOUPOBDJPOBMRVBOUPJOUFSOBDJPOBM"3FWJTUB QSPKFUBBJOEBQPSTFSVNWFÓDVMPEFQSJWJMFHJBEBDJSDVMBÎÍPPTOPNFTEPTBMVOPTEB &TDPMBQPSNFJPEBEJWVMHBÎÍPEFUSBCBMIPTTFMFDJPOBEPTQBSBDPNQPSPTFVBDFSWP DPNPRVFDPOUSJCVJQBSBBEJTTFNJOBÎÍPEFOPWBTJEFJBTFQBSBBBmSNBÎÍPEFOPWBT QFSTPOBMJEBEFTOPNVOEPKVSÓEJDP "%SB1BUSJDJB6MTPO1J[BSSP8FSOFS1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPBUVBM%JSFUPSB EB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1(&DPNTVBSFDPOIFDJEBDPNQFUÐODJBTVBEFEJDBÎÍPÓNQBS FJOWFKÈWFMQFSUJOÈDJBÏBHSBOEFBSUÓmDFEB3FWJTUBFQPSNFSFDJNFOUPTVBFEJUPSB DJFOUÓmDB/BUBSFGBEFDPODSFUJ[BSFTTBPCSBDPOUPVDPNBDPMBCPSBÎÍPEJSFUBEB%SB .BSJMZ%JOJ[EP"NBSBM$IBWFT7JDF%JSFUPSBEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSFEP%S$BSMPT+PTÏ 5FJYFJSBEF5PMFEP$IFGFEP$FOUSPEF&TUVEPTEB1(&F1SFTJEFOUFEP$POTFMIP $VSBEPSEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSËÏQPDBEBQVCMJDBÎÍPEPQSJNFJSPWPMVNFEB3FWJTUB BPTRVBJTUBNCÏNEFWFTFSDPOTJHOBEPFMFWBEPSFDPOIFDJNFOUP 0 USBCBMIP GSVUJmDPV F IPKF B 3FWJTUB EB &TDPMB 4VQFSJPS EB 1SPDVSBEPSJB (FSBMEP&TUBEPBQSFTFOUBTFVUFSDFJSPWPMVNF&TUFBQPSUBTPCBDIBODFMBEB%SB .BSJÉOHFMB4BSSVCCP'SBHBUB1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEP$IFGFEP$FOUSPEF&TUVEPTEB 1(&BPRVBMTFWJODVMBB&TDPMBQSPmTTJPOBMEFSFDPOIFDJEPWBMPSQFSTPOBMJEBEF EJOÉNJDBFBMUBDPNQFUÐODJBOBHFTUÍPQÞCMJDBRVBMJEBEFTGVOEBNFOUBJTOPUSBCBMIP EFFMBCPSBÎÍPEB3FWJTUB&TUBFEJÎÍPTVSHFUBNCÏNTPCPTBVTQÓDJPTEP%S&MJWBM EB4JMWB3BNPT1SPDVSBEPS(FSBMEP&TUBEPDSJBEPSEB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1(&DVKP JODFOUJWPFDPOmBOÎBHBSBOUJSBNPTVDFTTPEFTUBQVCMJDBÎÍP 0UFSDFJSPWPMVNFEB3FWJTUBEB&41(&USBUBEFUFNBTEF%JSFJUP$POTUJUV DJPOBM %JSFJUP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP %JSFJUP "NCJFOUBM %JSFJUP 1SPDFTTVBM $JWJM %JSFJUP 5SJCVUÈSJP FN BCPSEBHFOT EJWFSTJmDBEBT UPEPT UFNBT SFMFWBOUFT UPEPT BCPSEBEPT DPNSJHPSDJFOUÓmDP &TUÍP QSFTFOUFT BVUPSFT DPODFJUVBEPT OP DFOÈSJP KVSÓEJDP DPNP 'BCSJDF )PVSRVFCJF+VBO;PSOP[B1ÏSF[.BOVFM(POÎBMWFT'FSSFJSB'JMIP&SJEBOF#BQUJTUB 'VSMBO+PTÏ'FSOBOEP$FEF×PEF#BSSPT-JEJBOJ.BDIBEP4PBSFTEPT4BOUPT$SJT UJBOF"RVJOP(PO[BHB3FHJOB.BSJB3PESJHVFT4JMWB+BDPWB[.BSJOB-JNBF-VDJMJB "QBSFDJEBEPT4BOUPTFQSBUBTEBDBTBOÍPNFOPTDPODFJUVBEBTDPNP.ÈSDJB"NJOP 4JMWJB)FMFOB/PHVFJSB/BTDJNFOUP5IBJT5FJ[FOF$MBVEJB#PDBSEJ"MMFHSFUUJ "QSFTFOUBSFTUFWPMVNFÏUBSFGBQSB[FSPTBÏSFWJTJUBSOPTTB&TDPMBFFODPO USÈMBBJOEBNFMIPSDPNPNFMIPSTFSÈBDBEBEJBTPCBEJSFÎÍPEFQSPmTTJPOBJTEF EJDBEPTGSFRàFOUBEBQPSDPMFHBTFNQFOIBEPTFNTFVBQSJNPSBNFOUPJOUFMFDUVBMF QFTTPBMTPCPTBVTQÓDJPTEFVNB*OTUJUVJÎÍPEPQPSUFEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUB EPFDPNPKÈUJWFPQPSUVOJEBEFEFEFTUBDBSNBJTEFVNBWF[BQSPTTFHVJSTFNQSF OBCVTDBEBFYDFMÐODJBOÍPDPNPVNPCKFUJWPNBTDPNPVNIÈCJUP Dora Maria Vendramini Barreto 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPBQPTFOUBEB 'PJ%JSFUPSBEB&41(&FN MENSAGEM AOS ALUNOS FORMANDOS DAS TURMAS 2010-2011 $BSPTDPMFHBTBNJHPTFGBNJMJBSFTQSFTFOUFT ²DPNJNFOTBBMFHSJBRVFSFEJHJFTTBTQPVDBTMJOIBTQBSBTBVEBSUPEPTPT GPSNBOEPTBRVJQSFTFOUFT 5JWFPQSB[FSEFTFSDPPSEFOBEPSBEPDVSTPEF%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPUSBCB MIPEFTBmBOUFRVFFOWPMWFPQSPKFUPFMBCPSBÎÍPEPQSPHSBNBBDBEÐNJDPDPOUB UPTFBDPNQBOIBNFOUPDPOTUBOUFEVSBOUFBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEPDVSTP 5SBCBMIBOEPOBEJSFUPSJBEB&TDPMBTPVUFTUFNVOIBEPFTGPSÎPFNQSF FOEJEP QFMBT FRVJQFT EF DPPSEFOBEPSFT NPOJUPSFT F FTQFDJBMJTUBT SFTQPOTÈWFJT QPSDBEBVNEPTDVSTPTPGFSFDJEPTQFMB&TDPMBFTGPSÎPFTUFRVFFYJHFFNQFOIP EFEJDBÎÍPBUVBMJ[BÎÍPDPOTUBOUFCFNDPNPSFMBÎÜFTBDBEÐNJDBTQSFFYJTUFOUFTBT RVBJTQFSNJUFNPBDFTTPBPTHSBOEFTOPNFTDPOUFNQPSÉOFPTEP%JSFJUPEFNPEP RVF PT QSPGFTTPSFT UJUVMBEPT RVF NJOJTUSBN BVMB OB &41(& OB HSBOEF NBJPSJB TÍP EPVUSJOBEPSFT SFDPOIFDJEPT DPNP BT NBJPSFT BVUPSJEBEFT OPT UFNBT TPCSF PT RVBJT TÍP DPOWJEBEPT B QBMFTUSBSFN0T TFNJOÈSJPT F QSPWBT TÍP QSFQBSBEPT QPSVNHSVQPEFQSPDVSBEPSFTFQSPGFTTPSFTUJUVMBEPTFWFSTBNTPCSFRVFTUÜFT QPMÐNJDBTBUVBJT "FYQFSJÐODJBBDBEÐNJDBQSPQJDJBEBQFMBBUJWJEBEFÏFYUSFNBNFOUFFO SJRVFDFEPSBQPSWÈSJPTGBUPSFTFOUSFPTRVBJTEFTUBDPBFYDFMÐODJBEPDPSQPEP DFOUFFEJTDFOUFEB&41(&RVFTPNBEBËDSJUFSJPTBTFMFÎÍPEPTUFNBTEFHSBOEF SFMFWÉODJBBUVBMRVFDPNQÜFPDPOUFÞEPQSPHSBNÈUJDPFBCJCMJPHSBmBCÈTJDBF DPNQMFNFOUBSJOEJDBEBQBSBPNØEVMPQFSNJUFNVNEFCBUFBNQMPWJTJUBOEPBT EJWFSTBTDPSSFOUFTEPVUSJOÈSJBTFFOUFOEJNFOUPTKVSJTQSVEFODJBJTTPCSFUFNBTEF NBJPSSFMFWÉODJBQBSBP&TUBEP0BQSPGVOEBNFOUPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPQPTTJCJMJUBP EFMJOFBNFOUPNBJTQSFDJTPEBBUVBÎÍPEP&TUBEPRVFNFMIPSBUFOEFBPJOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDP/FTTFTFOUJEPB&41(&BPEFTFNQFOIBSBUJWJEBEFEFDVOIPFEVDBDJPOBM QSPNPWFOEPPBQFSGFJÎPBNFOUPQSPmTTJPOBMEPQÞCMJDPBMWPDPOmHVSBTFDPNP WFSEBEFJSPJOTUSVNFOUPEFUSBOTGPSNBÎÍPFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTPDJBM 0USBCBMIPSFBMJ[BEPBPMPOHPEPQFSÓPEPEFFYJTUÐODJBEB&41(&QFMB %JSFUPSJBF4FDSFUBSJBKVOUBNFOUFDPNP$POTFMIP$VSBEPSFP$FOUSPEF&TUV EPTQFSNJUFBDPODSFUJ[BÎÍPFFYFDVÎÍPEFVNTPOIPRVFTFUPSOPVSFBMJEBEFHB SBOUJOEPRVFUPEPTPTQSPDVSBEPSFTQPTTBNQBSUJDJQBSEBTBUJWJEBEFTBDBEÐNJDBT BJOEBRVFQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEBTBVMBTBCFSUBTQBSBUPEBBDBSSFJSB 0TDVSTPTSFBMJ[BEPTFNQBSDFSJBDPNPVUSBTJOTUJUVJÎÜFTOBDJPOBJTFJO UFSOBDJPOBJT JOTFSFN B &41(& FN VN DFOÈSJP NBJT BNQMP DPOFDUBOEPB DPN EJWFSTBT SFBMJEBEFT P RVF QSPEV[ NBJPSFT SFnFYÜFT F DPOTFRVFOUFNFOUF VN SFQFSUØSJP NBJPS QBSB B DPOTUSVÎÍP EF OPWPT DPOIFDJNFOUPT F FOGSFOUBNFOUP EF RVFTUÜFTEFDPSSFOUFTEPQSØQSJPHSBVEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTPDJFEBEFUBJTDPNPBT RVFTUÜFTSFGFSFOUFTBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMRVFTUÜFTEFPSEFNQSFWJEFODJÈ SJBFOUSFUBOUBTPVUSBT "&41(&DPNQSPNFUJEBDPNBQSPQPTUBEFTFSEJGVTPSBEPDPOIFDJNFOUP QSPEV[JEPOBTTBMBTEFBVMBJODFOUJWBBJOTFSÎÍPEPTFYBMVOPTOPUSBCBMIPEPDFOUF UBOUPDPNPNPOJUPSFTDPNPQFTRVJTBEPSFTFTUJNVMBOEPBQSPQBHBÎÍPEPDPOIFDJ NFOUPQBSBUPEBBDBSSFJSB "HSBOEFQBSUJDJQBÎÍPEPTJOUFHSBOUFTEBDBSSFJSBEF1SPDVSBEPSEP&TUBEP OPTDVSTPTEF1ØT(SBEVBÎÍPlato sensuQSPNPWJEPTQFMB&TDPMBQSPKFUBB1(&DPNP VNBDBSSFJSBEFFYDFMÐODJBDVKPTJOUFHSBOUFTTÍPWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFWPDBDJPOBEPTFJT RVF OÍP PCTUBOUF TFKBN EFUFOUPSFT EF HSBOEF FYQFSJÐODJB EFDPSSFOUF EPT BOPT EF BUVBÎÍPOB1(&FNFTNPEPNJOBOEPVNDPOIFDJNFOUPJNQPTTÓWFMEFTFBERVJSJS QPSRVBMRVFSPVUSPDBNJOIPEFBQSFOEJ[BEPEFTFKBNDPOUJOVBSTFBQSJNPSBOEP /ÍPIÈDPNPTFFTRVFDFSRVFPUFNQPTVCUSBÓEPEPDPOWÓWJPEPTGBNJMJBSFT FBNJHPTGPJJOWFTUJEPOBDPOTUSVÎÍPEPDPOIFDJNFOUPUPSOBOEPPTNFMIPSFTQSPmT TJPOBJTFNFMIPSFTQFTTPBTCFOFmDJBOEPBDPNVOJEBEFDPNPVNUPEP 0TIJTUØSJDPTFTDPMBSFTPTUSBCBMIPTEFmOBMEFDVSTPQSPEV[JEPTFPUSBCB MIPSFBMJ[BEPQPSDBEBVNEPTBUVBJTFFYGPSNBOEPTEB&41(&TÍPVNUFTUFNVOIP WJWPRVFEJTQFOTBNBJPSFTSFMBUPTEPPCKFUJWPBMNFKBEPFDPORVJTUBEPQPSUPEPTPT RVFQBSUJDJQBSBNFPVQBSUJDJQBNEFTTFCFMPUSBCBMIP 0CSJHBEBQFMBDPPQFSBÎÍPFQBSBCÏOTBUPEPT Marily Diniz do Amaral Chaves 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEP7JDF%JSFUPSBEB&41(& .FTUSFF%PVUPSBFN%JSFJUP LA COMPOSITION DU CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL, UN EXOTISME BIEN FRANÇAIS The composition of the Constitucional Council, a very French exoticism Fabrice Hourquebie1 RÉSUMÉ 1SÏTFOUBUJPO-FQSPDÒTFOJMMÏHJUJNJUÏGBJUËMBDPNQPTJUJPOEV$POTFJM1PVS MBOPNJOBUJPO$POUSFMFTNFNCSFTEFESPJU-BMÏHJUJNJUÏEVQSPDÒTGBJUËMB DPNQPTJUJPOEV$POTFJM1MVTEFKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPO.PJOTEFQPMJUJTBUJPO 4VQQSJNFSMFTNFNCSFTEFESPJU3FNQMBDFSMFTNFNCSFTEFESPJU 3FTTFSSFSMFDPOUSÙMFTVSMBOPNJOBUJPO RESUMO 0BSUJHPUSB[VNBSFnFYÍPTPCSFBOFDFTTJEBEFEFSFGPSNBEBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$PO TFMIP $POTUJUVDJPOBM GSBODÐT &YQÜF PT QSPCMFNBT DFOUSBJT OB QSJNFJSB QBSUF EP USBCBMIP BP BOBMJTBS BT QFSTQFDUJWBT EP NPEP EF OPNFBÎÍP EF TFVT NFNCSPT BP RVFTUJPOBS B QPMJUJ[BÎÍP EB JOTUJUVJÎÍP B OÍP FYJHÐODJB EB RVBMJmDBÎÍP KVSÓEJDB EF TFVTNFNCSPTBEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFEBTOPNFBÎÜFTFBRVFTUÍPEBQFSNBOÐODJBEPT BOUJHPT1SFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDBOP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPNFNCSPTOBUPTF WJUBMÓDJPT/BTFHVOEBQBSUFGB[QSPQPTUBTQBSBBQFSGFJÎPBSBMFHJUJNJEBEFEPQSPDFTTP EFSFQSFTFOUBUJWJEBEFDPNPTVQSJNJSFPVTVCTUJUVJSNFNCSPTOBUPTFUPSOBSNFOPT SJHPSPTPPDPOUSPMFTPCSFBOPNFBÎÍP ABSTRACT 5IF QBQFS QSFTFOUT B SFnFDUJPO PO UIF OFFE GPS SFGPSN PG UIF DPNQPTJUJPO PG UIF 'SFODI$POTUJUVUJPOBM$PVODJM&YQPTFTUIFDFOUSBMQSPCMFNTJOUIFmSTUQBSUPGUIF XPSLXIFOBOBMZ[JOHUIFQSPTQFDUTPGUIFNPEFPGBQQPJOUNFOUPGJUTNFNCFSTCZ RVFTUJPOJOH UIF QPMJUJDJ[BUJPO PG UIF JOTUJUVUJPO OPU PG UIF MFHBM SFRVJSFNFOU PG JUT NFNCFSTBOEUIFEJTDSFUJPOPGUIFBQQPJOUNFOUTBOEUIFRVFTUJPOPGUIFQFSNBOFO DFPGUIFGPSNFS1SFTJEFOUTPGUIF3FQVCMJDPG$POTUJUVUJPOBM$PVODJMBTQFSNBOFOU NFNCFSTBOEMJGFMPOH*OUIFTFDPOEQBSUNBLFTQSPQPTBMTUPJNQSPWFUIFMFHJUJNBDZ PGUIFQSPDFTTPGSFQSFTFOUBUJPOBTEFMFUFBOEPSSFQMBDFQFSNBOFOUNFNCFSTBOE NBLFMFTTTUSJDUDPOUSPMPWFSUIFBQQPJOUNFOU Palavras-chaves$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMo'SBOÎBo$PNQPTJÎÍPoBMUFSBÎÍP Keywords$POTUJUVUJPOBM$PVODJM'SBODF$PNQPTJUJPODIBOHF 1SPGFTTFVSEFESPJUQVCMJD. 6OJWFSTJUÏ.POUFTRVJFV#PSEFBVY*7. %JSFDUFVSEFM*OTUJUVUQPVSMF%ÏWF MPQQFNFOUEFM&OTFJHOFNFOU4VQÏSJFVS'SBODPQIPOF*%&46' . %JSFDUFVSBEKPJOUEV$FOUSFE&UVEFT FUEF3FDIFSDIFTTVSMFT$POTUJUVUJPOTMFT-JCFSUÏTFUM&UBU$&3$$-& %JSFDUFVS EVNBTUFSjù$POUFOUJFVYQVCMJDTùx&YQFSUKVTUJDFBVQSÒTEFM0SHBOJTBUJPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMF EFMB'SBODPQIPOJF 16 Fabrice Hourquebie 1. PRÉSENTATION -FTUSPQJRVFTOFUSBWFSTFOUQBTFODPSF1BSJTQPVSUBOURVFMRVFTGSVJUTJOTUJUVUJP OOFMTUSPQJDBVYTÏQBOPVJTTFOUEFNBOJÒSFBMBOHVJFFUËMPNCSFFODPSFEFUPVUFUFNQÐUF DPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFTùUFMFTUMFDBTEFMBDPNQPTJUJPOEV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMGSBOÎBJT -BEPDUSJOFEPVUFSÏHVMJÒSFNFOUEFMBMÏHJUJNJUÏEFMBDPNQPTJUJPOEV$PO TFJM .BJT UPVU OFTU QFVUÐUSF QBT CPO Ë KFUFS EBOT MB NBOJÒSF EF DPNQPTFS DFUUF JOTUJUVUJPOMBMÏHJUJNJUÏOÏUBOUQBTRVVOFRVFTUJPOEFNPEFEFEÏTJHOBUJPONBJT CJFOBVTTJVOFRVFTUJPOEFRVBMJUÏEFOTFNCMFEFMJOTUJUVUJPOEFGmDBDJUÏFUQBSUBOU EBDDFQUBUJPOEFTEÏDJTJPOTEFDFUUFKVSJEJDUJPO. -F$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMFTUDPNQPTÏEFOFVGNFNCSFTOPNNÏTQPVSOFVG BOTOPOSFOPVWFMBCMFTQBSMFTUSPJTQMVTIBVUFTBVUPSJUÏTQPMJUJRVFTEFM&UBUMF1SÏ TJEFOUEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFMF1SÏTJEFOUEV4ÏOBUFUMF1SÏTJEFOUEFM"TTFNCMÏFOBUJP OBMFBSUEFMBDPOTUJUVUJPOEVPDUPCSF -FTNFNCSFTEV$POTFJMTPOU SFOPVWFMÏTQBSUJFSTUPVTMFTUSPJTBOTDGJOGSB .BJTTJÒHFOUÏHBMFNFOUBV$POTFJM DPOTUJUVUJPOOFMDPNNF NFNCSFT EF ESPJU FU EPOD Ë WJF MFT BODJFOT 1SÏTJEFOUT EF MB3ÏQVCMJRVF*MOPVTTFNCMFRVFÎBOFTUQBTUBOUMBQSPDÏEVSFEFOPNJOBUJPOEFT NFNCSFTQBSMFTBVUPSJUÏTQPMJUJRVFTRVJNFUUFFODBVTFMBMÏHJUJNJUÏEV$POTFJMRVF MBQSÏTFODFEFTBODJFOTDIFGTE&UBUNFNCSFTEFESPJU&OFGGFUMBWPJFQSPDÏEVSBMFEF MBOPNJOBUJPOQBSMFTBVUPSJUÏTQPMJUJRVFTFTUËQFVQSÒTBENJTTJCMFTJPOBDDFQUFMJEÏF RVFMF$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMDPNNFUPVUFKVSJEJDUJPODPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFUSBODIFVO ESPJUVODPOnJUFOUSFEFTOPSNFTQBSOBUVSFQPMJUJRVFTMBMPJFUMBDPOTUJUVUJPO &O SFWBODIFMBQSÏTFODFEFTNFNCSFTEFESPJUNBQQBSBÔUJOmOJNFOUQMVTDPOEBNOB CMFMFTBODJFOTDIFGTE&UBUOBZBOUSJFOËGBJSFEBOTVOFJOTUJUVUJPORVJWFVUQSÏTFOUFS MFWJTBHFEVOFBVUIFOUJRVFKVSJEJDUJPO 6OFSÏGPSNFEFMBDPNQPTJUJPOEV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMFTUFMMFFOWJTBHF BCMF &MMFOPVTTFNCMFWJWFNFOUTPVIBJUBCMF*MFOWBEFMBMÏHJUJNJUÏEFMJOTUJUVUJPO FUQBSUBOUEFTBDSÏEJCJMJUÏUBOUBVYZFVYEFTBDUFVSTJOTUJUVUJPOOFMTEVDPOUFOUJFVY DPOTUJUVUJPOOFMRVFEVQFVQMFGSBOÎBJT 2. LE PROCÈS EN ILLÉGITIMITÉ FAIT À LA COMPOSITION DU CONSEIL 4FMPO +BDRVFT ,SZOFO «La faiblesse du dispositif français ne résiderait pas tant dans la sélection politique des membres du Conseil que dans les garanties de compétences de ces membres»3 %F NBOJÒSF TDIÏNBUJRVF FU DPNNF PO MJOEJRVBJU FO 3 4VSDFUUFRVFTUJPOW')PVSRVFCJFSur l’émergence du contre-pouvoir juridictionnel sous la Vème République#SVZMBOU +,SZOFOL’Etat de justice, France, XIII-XXème siècles. L’empire des juges5PNF/3'(BMMJNBSE Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 La composition du Conseil constitutionnel, un exotisme bien français 17 JOUSPEVDUJPO JM TFNCMF RVF MJMMÏHJUJNJUÏ TPJU NPJOT VOF BGGBJSF EF QSPDÏEVSF EF OPNJOBUJPO(A)RVFEFQSÏTFODFEFTNFNCSFTEFESPJU(B). 2.1 Pour la nomination /PVTBWPOTUPVKPVSTTPVUFOVEBOTOPTBSUJDMFTPVPVWSBHFTMBQSPDÏEVSFEF OPNJOBUJPOËMBGSBOÎBJTFùOPORVFOPVTMBUSPVWJPOTMBNFJMMFVSFEFUPVUFùFMMFFTU FOUPVTDBTNPJOTQJSFRVFEBVUSFTù1PVSBVUBOUMBQSPDÏEVSFEFOPNJOBUJPOEFMBSU FODPVSUUSPJTDSJUJRVFTQSJODJQBMFTBJTÏNFOUEJTDVUBCMFT 1SFNJÒSFNFOU FMMF WÏIJDVMF MB QPMJUJTBUJPO EF MJOTUJUVUJPO /PNNÏFT EJT DSÏUJPOOBJSFNFOUFOUIÏPSJFKVTRVËSÏDFNNFOUMBSÏWJTJPODPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFEV KVJMMFUFODBESFMBQSPDÏEVSFEFOPNJOBUJPOQBSVOFBVEJUJPOEFDIBDVOEFTDBO EJEBUTQSPQPTÏTQBSMFTIBVUFTBVUPSJUÏTQBSMFTDPNNJTTJPOTEFTMPJTEV4ÏOBUFUEF M"TTFNCMÏFOBUJPOBMF QBSMFTIBVUFTBVUPSJUÏTQPMJUJRVFTMFTQFSTPOOBMJUÏTDIPJTJFT TFSÏDMBNFSBJFOUQMVTPVNPJOTPVWFSUFNFOUEFMBTFOTJCJMJUÏQPMJUJRVFEFMBVUPSJUÏ RVJ MFT B OPNNÏFT NÐNF TJ MFT EFVY EFSOJFST SFOPVWFMMFNFOUT USJFOOBVY EF GÏ WSJFSFUGÏWSJFSEPJWFOUDPOEVJSFËOVBODFSDFUUFPCTFSWBUJPO -FDIPJY EBNJTQPMJUJRVFTTFSBJUEPODVOFDPOTUBOUFEBOTMFTOPNJOBUJPOTEFQVJTMBDSÏBUJPO EFMJOTUJUVUJPO« L’esprit de faveur, d’amitié et de complaisance plus difficile à tuer que les malformations constitutionnelles à redresser pouvait régulièrement guider le choix des autorités de nominations », ÏDSJWBJU$IBSMFT&JTFONBOO4. &UJMFTUWSBJRVFMFDPNQBHOPOOB HFQPMJUJRVFBQVTFNBOJGFTUFSUBOUËESPJUFBWFDEFTBVUPSJUÏTEFOPNJOBUJPODPNNF MFHÏOÏSBMEF(BVMMF1IJMJQQF4FHVJOPV+BDRVFT$IJSBDùRVBVDFOUSFBWFD7BMÏSZ (JTDBSEE&TUBJOH3FOÏ.POPSZPV$ISJTUJBO1PODFMFUùPVËHBVDIFBWFD'SBOÎPJT .JUUFSSBOE-BVSFOU'BCJVT)FOSJ&NNBOVFMMJPV3BZNPOE'PSOJ$FTDIPJYQPMJ UJRVFT TBDDPNQBHOBOU CJFO TPVWFOU EBSSJÒSFT QFOTÏFT TUSBUÏHJRVFTù BJOTJ +BDRVFT $IJSBDOPNNBOUFOËMBmOEFTPONBOEBU+FBO-PVJT%FCSÏDFSUBJOEBWPJS VOBMMJÏPCKFDUJGQPVSTPQQPTFSË/JDPMBT4BSLP[ZGVUVS1SÏTJEFOUEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVF. %POUBDUF.BJTVOFBVUSFQSPDÏEVSFEFEÏTJHOBUJPOTFSBJUFMMFQMVTËNÐNF EFNJOJNJTFSMFSJTRVFEFQPMJUJTBUJPOù /PVTOFMFQFOTPOTQBT 'BJSFOPNNFSMFT NFNCSFTQBSMFQBSMFNFOUù $FTUFOQBSUJFMFDBTFO"VUSJDIFPáMF$POTFJMOBUJPOBMFU MF$POTFJMGÏEÏSBMEÏTJHOFOUUSPJTKVHFT<BSU>6OFEFTTPMVUJPOTMFTQJSFTùFMMFQSJ WFEFMBEJWFSTJUÏEBOTMFTBVUPSJUÏTEFOPNJOBUJPOFUPVWSFMBWPJFBVYNBSDIBOEBHFT QPMJUJRVFTFUBVYQBDUFTUBDJUFT -ÏMFDUJPOù &OHÏOÏSBMËMJOJUJBUJWFEFTBTTFNCMÏFT FO"MMFNBHOFoBSUIVJUNFNCSFTTPOUÏMVTQBSMF#VOEFTUBHFUIVJUQBSMF#VO EFTSBUùFO&TQBHOFIVJUKVHFTTVSEPV[FTPOUÏMVTQBSMFTDIBNCSFTBSU FMMFFTU $I&JTFONBOOLe MondeNBST 7')PVSRVFCJF-FTOPNJOBUJPOTBV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFML.P.A.O¡QQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 18 Fabrice Hourquebie MBRVJOUFTTFODFEFMBQPMJUJTBUJPOZBUJMBDUFQMVTQPMJUJRVFRVVOFÏMFDUJPOù RVJ PCMJHFËEFTBMMJBODFTPCKFDUJWFTFUEFTUBDUJRVFTQBSUJTBOFTQPVSQBSWFOJSBVYTVGGSB HFTSFRVJTQBSMFTDPOEJUJPOTEFNBKPSJUÏSFOGPSDÏF %FVYJÒNFNFOU MB DPOTUJUVUJPO GSBOÎBJTF OF QSÏWPZBOU BVDVOF DMBVTF EF DPNQÏUFODF MFT QFSTPOOBMJUÏT OPNNÏFT TPOU UBYÏFT EJODPNQÏUFODF KVSJEJRVF 4JM FTUWSBJRVFMF$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMFTUVOFEFTUSÒTSBSFT$PVSTRVJOJNQPTFOU BVDVOFRVBMJmDBUJPOKVSJEJRVFJMOFOSFTTPSUQBTNPJOTRVFMFTQFSTPOOBMJUÏTOPN NÏFTTPOUEBOTMBUSÒTHSBOEFNBKPSJUÏEFTDBTUPVUFTFYQÏSJNFOUÏFT$PNQÏUFODF DPOTBDSÏFQBSVOEJQMÙNFFUFYQÏSJFODFBDRVJTFQBSMBQSBUJRVFTPOUCJFOEJGGÏSFOUFT &UPOOFQFVURVPCTFSWFSRVFMBQMVQBSUEFTQFSTPOOBMJUÏTEÏTJHOÏFTEFQVJT TPOUEFTKVSJTUFTEFGPSNBUJPOTPVTPOUUJUVMBJSFTEFEJQMÙNFTRVJPVWSFOUMBWPJFEF DBSSJÒSFTKVSJEJRVFTù&OWJSPOEFTTPJYBOUFOFVGNFNCSFTOPNNÏTKVTRVËDF KPVSKVTUJmFOUEVOEJQMÙNFQFSNFUUBOUMBDDÒTBVYNBHJTUSBUVSFTPO[FQSPGFTTFVSTEF ESPJUPOUTJÏHÏoNÐNFTJDFMBSFTUFUSÒTJOGÏSJFVSBVDIJGGSFEFTBVUSFT$PVSTFVSP QÏFOOFTUSPJT7JDFQSÏTJEFOUTEV$POTFJME&UBUVOBODJFO1SÏTJEFOUEFMB$PVSEF KVTUJDFEFM6OJPOFVSPQÏFOOFVOBODJFO1SFNJFSQSÏTJEFOUEFMB$PVSEFDBTTBUJPO FUDy'BVUJMBMPSTmHFSVOFFYJHFODFEFDBQBDJUÏKVSJEJRVFEBOTVOFDMBVTFDPOTUJUV UJPOOFMMFEFDPNQÏUFODFù /PVTOFMFQFOTPOTQBT$BS1)DPNNFOPVTMJOEJRVJPOT MBRVBTJUPUBMJUÏEFTNFNCSFTEÏUJFOUEÏKËVOEJQMÙNFEFESPJUPVEVOFHSBOEFÏDPMF QBTUPVUËGBJUÏUSBOHÒSFËMBGPSNBUJPOKVSJEJRVFùJMOFTUEÒTMPSTQBTDFSUBJORVF HSBWFSDFUUFFYJHFODFEBOTMFNBSCSFDIBOHFRVFMRVFDIPTFù2)$PNNFOUEÏUFSNJOFS jùMBEJHOJUÏKVSJEJRVFTVGmTBOUFùxQPVSSFQSFOESFMFYQSFTTJPOEF%EF#ÏDIJMMPOù &YJHFSVOEPDUPSBUFYDMVSBJUCJFOTPVWFOUMFTNBHJTUSBUTEFTEJGGÏSFOUTDPSQTùFUFYJHFS VONBTUFSEFESPJUFYDMVSBJUTPVWFOUMFTÏMÒWFTEFHSBOEFTÏDPMFTùFU3)-BCTFODFEF DMBVTFDPNQÏUFODFBWFDOJWFBVKVSJEJRVFSFRVJTQFSNFUEFKPVFSMBDBSUFEFMBEJWFS TJmDBUJPOEFTQBSDPVSTFUEFTFYQÏSJFODFTUFMMFNFOUOÏDFTTBJSFEBOTVODPOUFYUFEF DPOTUJUVUJPOOBMJTBUJPOUFOUBDVMBJSFEFTEJWFSTFTCSBODIFTEVESPJU 7OPUBNNFOU-'BWPSFVFU8.BTUPS-FT$PVSTDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFT$POOBJTTBODFEVESPJU%BMMP[ QQFUT *CJEQùWBVTTJMBOBMZTFTUBUJTUJRVFEF%PNJOJRVF3PVTTFBVJO%SPJUEVDPOUFOUJFVYDPOTUJUV UJPOOFM.POUDISFTUJFOÒNFÏE $FTUËOPUSFTFOTVOFGBJCMFTTFDSVDJBMFùMBTBHFTTFEFTBVUPSJUÏTEFOPNJOBUJPODPOEVJUSBSFNFOUË DIPJTJSEFTQSPGFTTFVSTEFESPJU0O[FQSPGFTTFVSTEFESPJUPOUÏUÏOPNNÏTKVTRVËBVKPVSEIVJ"WFD VOFjQPJOUFxFOUSFMFTFQUFNCSFFUMFNBSTQVJTRVFUSPJTEFOUSFFVYPOUTJÏHÏFOTFN CMFBV$POTFJM.BSDFM8BMJOF3FOÏ$BTTJOFU'SBOÎPJT-VDIBJSF FUJOEÏOJBCMFNFOUQFTÏTVSMFTEÏCBUT TVSMBOBUVSFKVSJEJDUJPOOFMMFEV$POTFJMQBSFYFNQMF FUTVSMFTFOTEFTEÏMJCÏSÏTTVSMFDPOUSÙMFEF DPOTUJUVUJPOOBMJUÏ EFT MPJT SÏGÏSFOEBJSFT OPUBNNFOU W ' )PVSRVFCJF MF QPVWPJS KVSJEJDUJPOOFM FO 'SBODF-(%+ùFUBVTTJOPUSFDPNNFOUBJSFEBOT#.BUIJFV+1.BDIFMPO'.ÏMJO4PVDSBNB OJFO%3PVTTFBVFU91IJMJQQFEJS Les grandes délibérations du Conseil constitutionnel %BMMP[QQFUT %EF#ÏDIJMMPOBSUDJUQùjù-BQUJUVEFËNFOFSVOFEJTDVTTJPOKVSJEJRVFEFIBVUOJWFBVOF TBVSBJUTFSÏTVNFSËMBEÏUFOUJPOEVOUJUSFBDBEÏNJRVFùx RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 La composition du Conseil constitutionnel, un exotisme bien français 19 &OEÏDPVMFGPSUMPHJRVFNFOUMBUSPJTJÒNFDSJUJRVFùDFMMFEVDBSBDUÒSFEJTDSÏ UJPOOBJSF EF MB OPNJOBUJPO -FODBESFNFOU TVCTUBOUJFM QBS VOF DMBVTF DPNQÏUFODF OBZBOU QBT ÏUÏ SFUFOV MF DPOTUJUVBOU EF B QSÏGÏSÏ VO FODBESFNFOU GPSNFM EF UZQFQSPDÏEVSBMQVJTRVFEÏTPSNBJTBSU MFTOPNJOBUJPOTTPOUTPVNJTFTËMBWJTEFT DPNNJTTJPOTEFTMPJTEFTEFVYBTTFNCMÏFTQPVSMFDIPJYEV1SÏTJEFOUEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVF FUEFMVOFPVMBVUSFEFTDPNNJTTJPOTTFMPORVFMFDIPJYFTUDFMVJEV1SÏTJEFOUEV4ÏOBU PVEFM"TTFNCMÏFOBUJPOBMF&MMFTSFOEFOUVOBWJTQVCMJDFUEJTQPTFOUEVOESPJUEFWFUP UIÏPSJRVFQVJTRVJMOFQFVUÐUSFQSPDÏEÏËMBOPNJOBUJPOTJMBDBOEJEBUVSFSFDVFJMMFUSPJT DJORVJÒNFTEFTVGGSBHFTOÏHBUJGTPVQMVT&OSÏBMJUÏDFEJTQPTJUJGOFTUHVÒSFDPOUSBJH OBOUEBOTMBNFTVSFPáSÏVOJSUSPJTDJORVJÒNFTEFWPUFTOÏHBUJGTFMPOMFTQSFTDSJQUJPOT DPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFT PCMJHFSBJUËEFTBMMJBODFTFOUSFMBNBKPSJUÏFUMPQQPTJUJPOBMMJBODFT RVFMFGBJUNBKPSJUBJSFSFOEIBVUFNFOUJNQSPCBCMF%PáDFTBVEJUJPOTTBOTTVSQSJTFFO oFOMBCTFODFEFMPJPSHBOJRVFmYBOUMFTDPOEJUJPOTQSPDÏEVSBMFToNBJTRVFMRVF QFVQJRVBOUFTQBSGPJT"JOTJËMFOESPJUEF.JDIFM$IBSBTTFËMBEFNBOEFEF.BOVFM 7BMMTù« À titre personnel, oserez-vous censurer un projet de loi soutenu par l’autorité qui vous a nommé ? » PVEF3FOÏ%PTJÒSF« Que pensez-vous du fait que les anciens Présidents de la République siègent de droit au sein du Conseil constitutionnel » FUEFSÏQPOTFTVOQFV JOBUUFOEVFTEFMJOUÏSFTTÏ(« La dignité humaine a forcément valeur constitutionnelle puisque tout notre droit est protecteur de la personne humaine » y 'SBOÎPJT-VDIBJSFSBQQFMBJURVFMBMDIJNJFQBSGBJUFQPVSMBDPNQPTJUJPOEVOF KVSJEJDUJPODPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFEFWBJUTÏUBCMJSBVUPVSEFUSPJTDSJUÒSFTùVOFNBKPSJUÏEF KVSJTUFTEFTQFSTPOOBMJUÏTJODPOUFTUBCMFTFUVODFSUBJONÏMBOHFEFHÏOÏSBUJPO3FTUFË TBWPJSËMBRVFMMFEFDFTDBUÏHPSJFTBQQBSUJFOOFOUMFTNFNCSFTEFESPJUy 2.2 Contre les membres de droit 2VFGBJSFEFTBODJFOTQSÏTJEFOUTEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFù 4PZPOT DMBJSTù MB CBHVFUUF NBHJRVF EV DPOTUJUVBOU EFWSBJU VOF GPJT QPVS UPVUFGBJSFEJTQBSBÔUSFMFTBODJFOTQSÏTJEFOUTEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFEV$POTFJMDPOTUJUV UJPOOFM*MTOPOUSJFOËGBJSFEBOTDFUUFJOTUJUVUJPO2VFMPOTFOUFOEFCJFOùNFNCSFT EFESPJUTJHOJmFNFNCSFTËWJF -FTQSPQPTJUJPOTGBJUFTFODFTFOTEFWBOUMF$PNJUÏ#BMMBEVSFODIBSHFEF GBJSFEFTQSPQPTJUJPOTEFSÏWJTJPOTEFMBDPOTUJUVUJPOOPOUQBTÏUÏTVJWJFTMPSTEF MBSÏWJTJPODPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFEVKVJMMFUMFTTÏOBUFVSTZÏUBJFOUGBWPSBCMFTù M"TTFNCMÏFOBUJPOBMFBSFKFUÏMBQSPQPTJUJPOFOTFDPOEFMFDUVSF ùFUMJOEJHFODFEF MBSHVNFOU BWBODÏ QBS MF 1SÏTJEFOU EF MB 3ÏQVCMJRVF EBOT TPO EJTDPVST QSPOPO DÏMFFSNBSTBV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMOFQFVUÏWJEFNNFOUQBTTVGmSFË DPOWBJODSFUPVUKVSJTUFVOUBOUTPJUQFVÏDMBJSÏTVSDFUUFRVFTUJPOù« […] Le Conseil constitutionnel ne saurait être une juridiction comme une autre. C’est la raison pour laquelle j’ai souhaité qu’il ne soit pas composé que de techniciens du droit et que les anciens RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 20 Fabrice Hourquebie présidents de la République y conservent leur qualité de membres de droit, parce que l’expérience d’un ancien chef de l’État, qui a fait fonctionner les institutions, peut apporter beaucoup à la qualité des décisions du Conseil, à leur équilibre, à leur réalisme ». 0OTBJUMBSBJTPOÏNJOFNNFOUDPOKPODUVSFMMFRVJBQSÏTJEÏËDFUUFBOPNBMJF DPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFËTBWPJSTPOBEPQUJPOFOHBHFEFSFDPOOBJTTBODFEFMBDUJPONFOÏFQBS 3FOÏ$PUZFU7JODFOU"VSJPMBVNPNFOUEFMBDDFTTJPOEVHÏOÏSBMEF(BVMMFBVQPVWPJS 1PVSÐUSFUPVUËGBJUIPOOÐUFPOQPVSSBJUQFVUÐUSFUSPVWFSEBOTMBSUJDMFEFMBDPOTUJ UVUJPOVOFKVTUJmDBUJPOËDFUUFEJTQPTJUJPO-BDPODFQUJPOHBVMMJFOOFEFMBSCJUSBHFEF WBJUGBJSFEV1SÏTJEFOUMFHBSEJFOEVSFTQFDUEFMBDPOTUJUVUJPO-FEÏCPVDIÏOBUVSFM QFVUBMPSTÐUSFVOTJÒHFBVTFJOEFMJOTUJUVUJPORVJFTUMFHBSEJFOKVSJEJDUJPOOFMEVUFYUF GPOEBNFOUBMËTBWPJSMF$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFM%FTVSDSPÔUBMPSTNÐNFRVFMFTNFN CSFTOPNNÏTOFTPOUQBTTPVNJTËVOFPCMJHBUJPODPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFEFDPNQÏUFODFKVSJ EJRVFJMQPVSSBJUQBSBÔUSFQBSBEPYBMEFWPVMPJSTFQSJWFSEFMÏNJOFOUFFYQÏSJFODFEFMB QMVTBVUPSJUÏQPMJUJRVFEFM&UBU.BJTMËFODPSFDFUUFFYQMJDBUJPOFTUUSPQJOTVGmTBOUFBV SFHBSEEFTDPOTÏRVFODFTRVJEÏDPVMFOUEFMBQSÏTFODFEFTNFNCSFTEFESPJU$BSBWFD MFSBDDPVSDJTTFNFOUEFMBEVSÏFEVNBOEBUQSÏTJEFOUJFMËDJORBOTMBMJNJUBUJPOËEFVY NBOEBUTDPOTÏDVUJGTMÏMFDUJPOEF1SÏTJEFOUTEFQMVTFOQMVTKFVOFTFUMBMMPOHFNFOUEF MFTQÏSBODFEFWJFËNPZFOUFSNFMFTBODJFOT1SÏTJEFOUTEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFQPVSSBJFOU CJFOUÙUDPOTUJUVFSMBNBKPSJUÏEFTNFNCSFTEV$POTFJM $FQSPDÒTFOJMMÏHJUJNJUÏEFMBDPNQPTJUJPOEV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMBQQB SBÔUEPODËDFSUBJOTÏHBSETUPVUËGBJUMÏHJUJNF 3. LA LÉGITIMITÉ DU PROCÈS FAIT À LA COMPOSITION DU CONSEIL « Le CC peut-il demeurer longtemps un acteur moyen du jeu politique si la composition et les modes de recrutement ne changent pas » ?12 -FQSPDÒTFOJMMÏHJUJNJUÏTJMDPO mOFVOQFVBVjùNBSSPOOJFSEFMBDPOWFSTBUJPOKVSJEJRVFùxOFOBQQBSBÔUQBTNPJOT QFSUJOFOUEBOTMBNFTVSFPáJMNFUFORVFTUJPOMBKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPOEFMJOTUJUVUJPO (A)ù KVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPO RVJ PCMJHF Ë RVFMRVFT SÏGPSNFT EF MB DPNQPTJUJPO QPVS MJNJUFSFODPSFEBWBOUBHFMBQPMJUJTBUJPO(B). IUUQXXXDPOTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMGSDPOTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMGSBODBJTOPVWFBVYDBIJFSTEVDPOTFJM DBIJFSOEJTDPVSTQSPOPODFMFFSNBSTQBSNOJDPMBTTBSLP[ZQSFTJEFOUEFMBSFQVCMJ RVFIUNM "SUJDMFùjù-F1SÏTJEFOUEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFWFJMMFBVSFTQFDUEFMB$POTUJUVUJPO*MBTTVSFQBSTPOBSCJ USBHFMFGPODUJPOOFNFOUSÏHVMJFSEFTQPVWPJSTQVCMJDTBJOTJRVFMBDPOUJOVJUÏEFM²UBU*MFTUMFHBSBOU EFMJOEÏQFOEBODFOBUJPOBMFEFMJOUÏHSJUÏEVUFSSJUPJSFFUEVSFTQFDUEFTUSBJUÏT +,SZOFOop. citQ %EF#ÏDIJMMPOart. citQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 La composition du Conseil constitutionnel, un exotisme bien français 21 3.1 Plus de juridictionnalisation .JDIFM'SPNPOUEJTBJUEV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMRVJMÏUBJUVOjùNPEÒMFBUZ QJRVFùxDFRVJWFVUUPVUEJSFTVSTBOBUVSFKVSJEJDUJPOOFMMFRVJTJFMMFTBQQSÏDJFCJFO FOUFOEVËMBVOFEFMBQSPDÏEVSFBQQMJDBCMFTÏWBMVFBVTTJFOBNPOUËMBMVNJÒSFEV SFDSVUFNFOUFUEFMBDPNQÏUFODFEFTKVHFTRVJGPSNFOUMB$PVS "JOTJ EF MB QBSUJDVMBSJUÏ EF MB DPNQPTJUJPO SÏTVMUF« une récurrente question sur la nature ambivalente de cet organe lequel participe hautement du pouvoir juridictionnel mais qui, du fait de la désignation discrétionnaire de ses membres par trois autorités politiques, voit constamment peser sur lui le soupçon de politisation »14$FTUFOUSBNF EFGPOEMBMBODJOBOUFRVFTUJPOEFMBKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPORVJFTUFOEÏCBU$PNNFOU BENFUUSFRVFMF$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMEFWJFOOFVONFNCSFËQBSUFOUJÒSFEVDMVC EFT$PVSTDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFTFVSPQÏFOOFTTJTBDPNQPTJUJPOOFQFSNFUQBTEFSFnÏUFS MFTHBSBOUJFTRVVOKVTUJDJBCMFFTUFOESPJUEBUUFOESFMPSTEVOQSPDÒTGßUJMDPOTUJUV UJPOOFM)ÏTJUBUJPORVFUSBEVJTBJU.BVSJDF%VWFSHFSQPVSRVJ« Le terme de juridiction politique exprime le caractère ambigu de l’institution. (…). Elle intervient dans des matières politiques et plus encore dans des buts politiques ; ses membres doivent avoir l’indépendance des magistrats mais leur recrutement est politique ». &ODPSFVOFGPJTDFOFTUQBTTFMPOOPVTMFTNFNCSFTOPNNÏTRVJGPOUQMBOFS VOEPVUFTVSMBKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPODBSMFTHBSBOUJFTEJOEÏQFOEBODFDPOTVCTUBOUJFMMFTË MBDUJWJUÏKVSJEJDUJPOOFMMFTPOUMË-BEVSÏFEFTGPODUJPOTOFVGBOT MFVSOPOSFOPVWFMMF NFOUFUMJOBNPWJCJMJUÏRVJFOEÏDPVMFRVJTPOUMFTNBSRVFVSTPCKFDUJGTEFDFUUFJOEÏQFO EBODFEVKVHFDPOTUJUVUJPOOFM"RVPJTBKPVUFTVSVOQMBOQMVTTVCKFDUJGMFGBNFVYEF WPJSEJOHSBUJUVEFRVJUSPVWFËTFYFSDFSËDPNQUFSEVNPNFOUPáMBQFSTPOOBMJUÏOPNNÏF OBQMVTSJFOËBUUFOESFEFMBVUPSJUÏEFOPNJOBUJPO« La fonction saisit l’homme quand c’est un honnête homme », ÏDSJWBJUFODPSF(FPSHFT7FEFM$FTUBJOTJFUHSÉDFBVSFOPVWFMMF NFOUQBSUJFSTUPVTMFTUSPJTBOTRVJÏWJUFMFTSVQUVSFTEFKVSJTQSVEFODFDPOTÏDVUJWFTBVY DIBOHFNFOUTEFNBKPSJUÏTQPMJUJRVFTRVFMF$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMFTUEBWBOUBHFQFSÎV DPNNFVOFKVSJEJDUJPOSÏHVMBUSJDFEFTBMUFSOBODFTQPMJUJRVFTRVFDPNNFVOFJOTUJUVUJPO QBSUJTBOF-FTDFOTVSFTSÏDFOUFTFOUÏNPJHOFOUFODPSF. $FTUCJFOFOUFOEVTVSMFTNFNCSFTEFESPJURVFQÒTFUPVUMFQPJETEFMBQP MJUJTBUJPOFUEPODQBSUBOUEVEÏGBVUEFKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPO4JMBKVSJEJDUJPODPOTUJ UVUJPOOFMMFFTUOÏDFTTBJSFNFOUQPMJUJRVFBVWVEFMBTQÏDJmDJUÏEVDPOUFOUJFVYRVFMMF BËDPOOBÔUSFJMOFTUQBTQPVSBVUBOUBDDFQUBCMFRVVOFDBVTFTPJUUSBODIÏFQBSVOF JOTUJUVUJPO RVJ Ë MB GPJT TF WFVU ÐUSF KVSJEJDUJPO FU RVJ DPNQSFOE FO TPO TFJO MFT QFSTPOOBMJUÏT MFT QMVT QPMJUJRVFT RVJ TPJFOU MFT 1SÏTJEFOUT EF MB 3ÏQVCMJRVF $FUUF +,SZOFOop. citQ "RVPJTBKPVUFVOSÏHJNFEJOÏMJHJCJMJUÏTEJODPNQBUJCJMJUÏTEJOUFSEJDUJPOTFUVOFPCMJHBUJPOEFSÏTFSWF Le Conseil constitutionnel a quarante ans$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMFU-(%+Q ')PVSRVFCJFLe pouvoir juridictionnel en FranceQSÏD RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 22 Fabrice Hourquebie DPNQPTJUJPOOFTUQBTBDDFQUBCMFEBOTMFDBESFEVDPOUSÙMFBCTUSBJUEFMBDPOTUJUVUJPO OBMJUÏùFMMFMFTUFODPSFNPJOTBGPSUJPSJEBOTMFDBESFEVDPOUSÙMFFYFSDÏWJBMBOPV WFMMFQSPDÏEVSFEFRVFTUJPOQSJPSJUBJSFEFDPOTUJUVUJPOOBMJUÏBSU &UMBSHVNFOU TFMPOMFRVFMMFT1SÏTJEFOUEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFOFQSFOOFOUQBTQBSUBVYBVEJFODFTEF RVFTUJPO QSJPSJUBJSF EF DPOTUJUVUJPOOBMJUÏ BV NPUJG EF MB USPQ HSBOEF UFDIOJDJUÏ OF TVGmUQBTËÐUSFMFTPVQÎPOEVEÏGBVUEFKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPONÐNFTJDFUBSHVNFOU QMBJEFa contrarioQPVSMBCTFODFEFDPNQÏUFODFTVGmTBOUFEFTBODJFOT1SÏTJEFOUT EBOTEFTDPOUFOUJFVYKVSJEJRVFTUFDIOJRVFTFUQBSUBOUQPVSMFVSFYDMVTJPOEV$PO TFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFM-F$POTFJMOFTUQBTVODMVCQSFTUJHJFVYQPVSMFTSFUSBJUÏTEFMB QPMJUJRVFù%FTVSDSPÔUFURVFMRVFTPJUMFDPOUFOUJFVYVOFQSÏTFODFBMÏBUPJSFMBJTTÏF ËMBQQSÏDJBUJPOEVNFNCSFEFESPJUQFVUÐUSFJOUFSQSÏUÏFEVOFQBSUDPNNFVOF TUSBUÏHJFQPMJUJRVFWJTBOUËTPVUFOJSPVËTPQQPTFSBVQPVWPJSFOQMBDFùFUEBVUSF QBSUQFVUBWPJSQPVSFGGFUEFDIBOHFSMFTÏRVJMJCSFTFOUFSNFEFQBSUBHFTEFWPJYBV NPNFOUEVOWPUFDFRVJFTUÏNJOFNNFOUDPOUFTUBCMFUBOUQPVSMBVUPSJUÏEFTEÏDJ TJPOTRVFQPVSMBMÏHJUJNJUÏEFMJOTUJUVUJPOFOUBOURVFKVSJEJDUJPO %FTSÏGPSNFTEBOTMBDPNQPTJUJPOTJNQPTFOUBTTVSÏNFOUQPVSÏMPJHOFSFO DPSFEBWBOUBHFMFTQFDUSFEFMBQPMJUJTBUJPO 3.2 Moins de politisation #FSOBSE$IFOPUBODJFO7JDFQSÏTJEFOUEV$POTFJME&UBUBGmSNBJUù« Je n’ai jamais pensé une seconde que le Conseil fût un organe juridictionnel ; c’est un corps politique par son recrutement et par les fonctions qu’il remplit ». 2VF GBVESBJUJM BMPST QPVS DPOUSFEJSF DFUUF PQJOJPOù 5SPJT QJTUFT TPNNF UPVUFTTJNQMFTFUBTTF[ÏWJEFOUFTQFVWFOUÐUSFFYQMPSÏFT 3.2.1 Supprimer les membres de droit 1PVSBVUBOUEPJUPOTFEÏQBSUJSEFMFYQÏSJFODFEFTBODJFOT1SÏTJEFOUTù /PO CJFOFOUFOEVùMFVSQBSPMFFUMFVSFYQÏSJFODFFTUOÏDFTTBJSFEBOTVODPOUFYUFMJCÏSBM UPVSNFOUÏ 0S MFT GBJSF TJÏHFS BV $POTFJM JNQMJRVF EF MFT BTTVKFUUJS Ë MPCMJHBUJPO EF SÏTFSWFEFTNFNCSFTDFRVJFTUBVmOBMQSÏKVEJDJBCMF1PVSRVPJOFQBTBMPSTFOWJTBHF EFMFTOPNNFSTÏOBUFVSTËWJFBVCFTPJOTBOTWPJYEÏMJCÏSBUJWF ù $FRVJTFSBJUËMBGPJT DPOGPSNFËMBOPUJPOEBSCJUSBHFDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMDPOTBDSÏËMBSUEFMBDPOTUJUVUJPOË %BOTVOFEÏDJTJPOÏMFDUPSBMFEVOPWFNCSFMF$POTFJMBÏUÏBNFOÏËTFQSPOPODFSTVSMFVSDPOEJUJPO FUBFTUJNÏRVF« sous la seule réserve de la dispense de serment, ils sont soumis aux mêmes obligations que les autres membres », %ÏDJTJPOO¡"/OPWFNCSF1VZEF%ÙNFÒNFDJSD3FDQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 La composition du Conseil constitutionnel, un exotisme bien français 23 MFYJHFODFEFKVSJEJDUJPOOBMJTBUJPOEV$POTFJMFUËMBSÏWÏSFODFRVFMPOEPJUËVOBODJFO DIFGE&UBU-FYFNQMFJUBMJFOQPVSSBJUJOTQJSFSMFDPOTUJUVBOUGSBOÎBJT. 3.2.2 Remplacer les membres de droit $FMBQFSNFUUSBJUVOBMJHOFNFOUTVSMFTFGGFDUJGTRVJDPNQPTFOUMFT$PVSTDPOTUJ UVUJPOOFMMFTFO&VSPQFFURVJTPOUQMVTQSPDIFTEFEPV[FPVRVJO[FRVFEFOFVG"JOTJ USPJTNFNCSFTTVQQMÏNFOUBJSFTQPVSSBJFOUÐUSFOPNNÏTFOSFNQMBDFNFOUEFTNFNCSFT EFESPJURVJBVKPVSEIVJEBOTVOFIZQPUIÒTFUIÏPSJRVFIBVUFQPVSSBJFOUQSÏDJTÏNFOU ÐUSFUSPJT+BDRVFT$IJSBD7BMÏSZ(JTDBSEE&TUBJOHFU/JDPMBT4BSLP[Z %FVYQPTTJCJMJUÏT QPVSMBEÏTJHOBUJPOEFDFTNFNCSFT1).BJOUFOJSVOFOPNJOBUJPOQBSMFTUSPJTIBVUFT BVUPSJUÏTQPMJUJRVFTEFTPSUFRVFMMFTEFWSBJFOUEÏTPSNBJTOPNNFSRVBUSFNFNCSFTUPVT MFTUSPJTBOTDFRVJJNQMJRVFSBJUVOSFOPVWFMMFNFOUQBSRVBSUUPVTMFTUSPJTBOTNBJT RVJTPVMÒWFSBJUMFQSPCMÒNFEFTBWPJSRVFMMFBVUPSJUÏBVSBJUMBDPNQÏUFODFQPVSOPNNFS EFVYNFNCSFT4PJUDFUUFDPNQÏUFODFÏDIPJUBV1SÏTJEFOUEFMB3ÏQVCMJRVFBVOPNEF MBMPHJRVFEFMB7ÒNF3ÏQVCMJRVFFUBMPSTMBDSJUJRVFEFQPMJUJTBUJPOFYDFTTJWFSJTRVFSF WFOJS4PJUVOFRVBUSJÒNFBVUPSJUÏEFOPNJOBUJPOJOUFSWJFOUFUÎBOFQFVUÐUSFMF1SFNJFS .JOJTUSFFOSBJTPOEFMJOTUBCJMJUÏDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMMFRVJMFDBSBDUÏSJTF $FUUFTPMVUJPOQPTF QFVUÐUSFEBWBOUBHFEFQSPCMÒNFRVFMMFOFOSÏTPVU$FTUQPVSRVPJPOQFVUFOWJTBHFS2) RVFMFTUSPJTNFNCSFTTVQQMÏNFOUBJSFTTPJFOUOPNNÏTQBSMFTIBVUFTKVSJEJDUJPOT$PVS EFDBTTBUJPO$POTFJME&UBUFU$PVSEFTDPNQUFT BWFDEFVYBWBOUBHFTEFQPJETùEPOOFS BV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMUPVKPVSTMBTTVSBODFEFEJTQPTFSEBOTTFTSBOHTEFKVHFTFY QÏSJNFOUÏTDFRVJFTUJOEÏOJBCMFNFOUVOHBJOEFQVJTMFOUSÏFFOWJHVFVSEFMBRVFTUJPO QSJPSJUBJSFEFDPOTUJUVUJPOOBMJUÏùEPOOFSBV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMEFTKVHFTEÏDPOOFDUÏT EFTOPNJOBUJPOTEJUFTjùQPMJUJRVFTùx20 3.2.3 Resserrer le contrôle sur la nomination *MGBVUGBJSFFOTPSUFRVFMFTBVEJUJPOTEÏTPSNBJTQSÏWVFTËMBSUJDMFEFMB DPOTUJUVUJPO QVJTTFOU WÏSJUBCMFNFOU ÏDMBJSFS MFT NFNCSFT EFT DPNNJTTJPOT EFT MPJT TVSMFTNPUJWBUJPOTFUMFTDPOWJDUJPOTEFTQFSTPOOBMJUÏTQSFTTFOUJFT0OMBEJUMFOPV WFBVTZTUÒNFOFDPOUSBJOUHVÒSFWÏSJUBCMFNFOUMBVUPSJUÏEFOPNJOBUJPO 4BOT BMMFS KVTRVË MB USBOTQPTJUJPO EFT SFEPVUBCMFT QSPDÏEVSFT EBVEJUJPOT EF DPOmSNBUJPOEV4ÏOBUBNÏSJDBJOMFThearings BVDPVSTEFTRVFMMFTMBDBSSJÒSFDFRVJFTU 4VSDFUUFRVFTUJPOWBVTTJ%EF#ÏDIJMMPO"QQFMBVDBMNFTVSMBDPNQPTJUJPOEV$POTFJM3%"GFW Q 1SPQPTJUJPOEF%EF#ÏDIJMMPOart. citQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 24 Fabrice Hourquebie OÏDFTTBJSF FUMBWJFQSJWÏFDFRVJFTUEJTDVUBCMF EFTKVHFTQSFTTFOUJTËMB$PVSTVQSÐNF FTUQBTTÏFBVDSJCMFJMDPOWJFOESBJUQFVUÐUSFEBCBJTTFSMBDPOEJUJPOEFNBKPSJUÏSFOGPSDÏF EFWPUFTOÏHBUJGTBVEFMËEFMBRVFMMFMBOPNJOBUJPOFTUJNQPTTJCMFùPVSFOWFSTFSSBEJDB MFNFOU MF TZTUÒNF FO FTUJNBOU RVVOF OPNJOBUJPO OF QFVU JOUFSWFOJS RVBWFD MBDDPSE EFTUSPJTDJORVJÒNFTEFTTVGGSBHFTFYQSJNÏT0CUFOJSMBDPOmBODFFOSÏVOJTTBOUVOFUFMMF DPOEJUJPOEFNBKPSJUÏFTUJODPOUFTUBCMFNFOUQMVTSFEPVUBCMFRVFEFQBSWFOJSËGBJSFMPCKFU EVOWPUFEFEÏmBODFEBOTMFTNÐNFTDPOEJUJPOTEFNBKPSJUÏ%BOTMBQSFNJÒSFIZQPUIÒ TFTJMBOPNJOBUJPOOJOUFSWJFOUQBTMÏDIFDFTUJNQVUBCMFBVNBORVFEFDPOWJDUJPOEFMB QFSTPOOBMJUÏQSÏTFOUÏFùEBOTMBTFDPOEFIZQPUIÒTFMÏDIFDEFMBOPNJOBUJPOFTUEBWBOUBHF JNQVUBCMFBVNBORVFEFTFOTQPMJUJRVFEFMBVUPSJUÏEFOPNJOBUJPO 3FTUFËTBWPJSDFRVJFTUMFQMVTHSBWFy %BOTUPVTMFTDBTMFYPUJTNFGSBOÎBJTBFODPSFRVFMRVFTCFBVYKPVSTEFWBOU MVJTBVGTJMBDUVFMMFDPNNJTTJPOEFSÏOPWBUJPOFUEFNPEFSOJTBUJPOEFMBWJFQPMJUJRVF WPVMVF QBS MF 1SÏTJEFOU )PMMBOEF FU QSÏTJEÏF QBS MBODJFO 1SFNJFS .JOJTUSF -JPOFM +PTQJOTFTBJTJTTBJUEFMBRVFTUJPOFUGPSNVMBJUMBQSPQPTJUJPORVFUPVTMFTQSPGFTTFVST EFESPJUDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMBUUFOEFOUy RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 15 a 24 A COMPOSIÇÃO DO CONSELHO CONSTITUCIONAL: UM EXOTISMO BEM FRANCÊS (tradução Fernanda Dias Menezes de Almeida) Fabrice Hourquebie1 Fernanda Dias Menezes de Almeida2 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP0QSPDFTTPTPCSFBJMFHJUJNJEBEFGFJUBOBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$POTFMIP 1FMBOPNFBÎÍP$POUSBPTNFNCSPTOBUPT"MFHJUJNJEBEFEPQSPDFTTP GFJUPQBSBBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$POTFMIP.BJTKVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍP.FOPT QPMJUJ[BÎÍP4VQSJNJSPTNFNCSPTOBUPT4VCTUJUVJSPTNFNCSPTOBUPT 5PSOBSNBJTSJHPSPTPPDPOUSPMFTPCSFBOPNFBÎÍP 1. INTRODUÇÃO 0TUSØQJDPTBJOEBOÍPBUSBWFTTBN1BSJTFOUSFUBOUPBMHVOTGSVUPTJOTUJUVDJP OBJTUSPQJDBJTTFFTQBMIBNEFNBOFJSBFOGSBRVFDJEBFËTPNCSBEFRVBMRVFSUFNQFT UBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTUFÏPDBTPEBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMGSBODÐT "EPVUSJOBEVWJEBSFHVMBSNFOUFEBMFHJUJNJEBEFEBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$POTF MIP.BTUBMWF[OÍPTFKBCPNKPHBSUVEPOBNBOFJSBEFDPNQPSFTUBJOTUJUVJÎÍPBMF HJUJNJEBEFOÍPTFOEPBQFOBTVNBRVFTUÍPTPCSFPNPEPEFEFTJHOBÎÍPNBTUBNCÏN VNBRVFTUÍPEFRVBMJEBEFEPDPOKVOUPEBJOTUJUVJÎÍPEFFmDÈDJBFFNDPOTFRVÐODJB EFBDFJUBÎÍPEBTEFDJTÜFTEFTTBKVSJTEJÎÍP3 0$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMÏDPNQPTUPEFOPWFNFNCSPTOPNFBEPTQBSB OPWFBOPTOÍPSFOPWÈWFJTQFMBTUSÐTNBJTBMUBTBVUPSJEBEFTQPMÓUJDBTEP&TUBEPP 1SFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDBP1SFTJEFOUFEP4FOBEPFP1SFTJEFOUFEB"TTFNCMFJB/B DJPOBMBSUEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFEFPVUVCSPEF 0TNFNCSPTEP$POTFMIP TÍPSFOPWBEPTQPSUFSÎPTBDBEBUSÐTBOPTDGJOGSB .BTUÐNBTTFOUPJHVBMNFOUF OP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPNFNCSPTOBUPTFQPSUBOUPWJUBMÓDJPTPTBOUJHPT 1SFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDB1BSFDFOPTRVFOÍPÏUBOUPPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFOPNFBÎÍP EPTNFNCSPTQFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTQPMÓUJDBTRVFUPSOBRVFTUJPOÈWFMBMFHJUJNJEBEFEP $POTFMIPNBTTJNBQSFTFOÎBEPTBOUJHPTDIFGFTEFFTUBEPNFNCSPTOBUPT$PN 3 PSPGFTTPSEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDP6OJWFSTJEBEF.POUFTRVJFV o #PSEFBVY *7 %JSFUPS EP *OTUJUVUP QBSB P %FTFOWPMWJNFOUPEP&OTJOP4VQFSJPS'SBODPGPOF*%&46' %JSFUPSBEKVOUPEP$FOUSPEF&TUVEPTF EF1FTRVJTBTTPCSFBT$POTUJUVJÎÜFTBT-JCFSEBEFTFP&TUBEP$&3$-& %JSFUPSEP.FTUSBEPi$PO UFODJPTPT1ÞCMJDPTw&YQFSU+VTUJDFKVOUPË0SHBOJ[BÎÍP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEB'SBODPGPOJB .FTUSFF%PVUPSBFN%JSFJUP1SPGFTTPSB%PVUPSBEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP 4PCSFFTUBRVFTUÍPW')PVSRVFCJFSur l’émergence du contre-pouvoir juridictionnel sous la Vème République, Bruylant, 2004. 26 Fabrice Hourquebie e Fernanda Dias Menezes de Almeida FGFJUPBWJBQSPDFEJNFOUBMEBOPNFBÎÍPQFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTQPMÓUJDBTÏBUÏBENJTTÓ WFMTFBDFJUBSNPTBJEFJBEFRVFP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPUPEBKVSJTEJÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBMSFTPMWFEFEJSFJUPVNDPOnJUPFOUSFOPSNBTQPSOBUVSF[BQPMÓUJDBT B MFJ F B $POTUJUVJÎÍP "P DPOUSÈSJP B QSFTFOÎB EPT NFNCSPT OBUPT QBSFDFOPT JOmOJUBNFOUFNBJTDPOEFOÈWFMOÍPUFOEPPTBOUJHPTDIFGFTEFFTUBEPOBEBBGB[FS FNVNBJOTUJUVJÎÍPRVFRVFSBQSFTFOUBSPSPTUPEFVNBBVUÐOUJDBKVSJTEJÎÍP 6NBSFGPSNBEBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMÏEFTFDPOTJEFSBS &MB OPT QBSFDF WJWBNFOUF EFTFKÈWFM 5SBUBTF EB MFHJUJNJEBEF EB JOTUJUVJÎÍP F QPS UBOUPEFTVBDSFEJCJMJEBEFUBOUPBPTPMIPTEPTBUPSFTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTEPDPOUFODJPTP DPOTUJUVDJPOBMRVBOUPEPQPWPGSBODÐT 2. O PROCESSO SOBRE A ILEGITIMIDADE FEITA NA COMPOSIÇÃO DO CONSELHO 4FHVOEP+BDRVFT,SZOFOia fraqueza do dispositivo francês não residiria tanto na seleção política dos membros do Conselho, e sim nas garantias de competências desses membrosw%FNBOFJSBFTRVFNÈUJDBFDPNPGPJJOEJDBEPOBJOUSPEVÎÍPQBSFDFRVF BJMFHJUJNJEBEFTFKBNFOPTVNBTTVOUPEFQSPDFEJNFOUPEFOPNFBÎÍP(A) EPRVFEB QSFTFOÎBEFNFNCSPTOBUPT(B). 2.1 Pela nomeação 5FNPTTFNQSFBQPJBEPOPTBSUJHPTPVPCSBTPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFOPNFBÎÍP ËGSBODFTBOÍPRVFBDPOTJEFSFNPTBNFMIPSEFUPEBTFMBÏFNUPEPDBTPNFOPT QJPSRVFPVUSBT&OUSFUBOUPPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFOPNFBÎÍPEPBSUJODPSSFFNUSÐT DSÓUJDBTQSJODJQBJTGBDJMNFOUFEJTDVUÓWFJT 1SJNFJSBNFOUFFMBWFJDVMBBQPMJUJ[BÎÍPEBJOTUJUVJÎÍP/PNFBEPTEJTDSJDJP OBSJBNFOUFFNUFPSJBBUÏSFDFOUFNFOUFBSFWJTÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFEFKVMIPEF JOTFSFOPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFOPNFBÎÍPVNBJORVJSJÎÍPFNBVEJÐODJBEFDBEBVN EPTDBOEJEBUPTQSPQPTUPTQFMBTBMUBTBVUPSJEBEFTGFJUBQFMBT$PNJTTÜFTEF+VTUJÎBEP 4FOBEPFEB"TTFNCMFJB/BDJPOBM QFMBTBMUBTBVUPSJEBEFTQPMÓUJDBTBTQFSTPOBMJEB EFTFTDPMIJEBTEFQFOEFSJBNNBJTPVNFOPTBCFSUBNFOUFEBTFOTJCJMJEBEFQPMÓUJDB EBBVUPSJEBEFRVFBTOPNFPVNFTNPTFBTEVBTÞMUJNBTSFOPWBÎÜFTUSJFOBJTEFGFWF SFJSPEFFGFWFSFJSPEFEFWBNDPOEV[JSBNBUJ[BSFTUBPCTFSWBÎÍP "FT DPMIBEFBNJHPTQPMÓUJDPTTFSJBFOUÍPVNBDPOTUBOUFOBTOPNFBÎÜFTEFQPJTEBDSJBÎÍP EBJOTUJUVJÎÍPiO espírito de favor, de amizade e de complacência, mais difícil de matar que as malformações constitucionais a consertar, poderia regularmente guiar a escolha pelas +,SZOFOL’État de justice, France, XIII-XXème siècles. L’empire des juges, Tomo 2, NRF Gallimard, 2012, p.329. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 A composição do conselho constitucional: um exotismo bem francês 27 autoridades de nomeaçãowFTDSFWJB$IBSMFT&JTFONBOO&ÏWFSEBEFRVFPDPNQB OIFJSJTNPQPMÓUJDPQÙEFTFNBOJGFTUBSËEJSFJUBDPNBVUPSJEBEFTEFOPNFBÎÍPDPNPP (FOFSBM%F(BVMMF1IJMJQQF4FHVJOPV+BDRVFT$IJSBDOPDFOUSPDPN7BMÏSZ(JTDBSE E&TUBJOH3FOÏ.POPSZPV$ISJTUJBO1PODFMFUPVËFTRVFSEBDPN'SBOÎPJT.JUUFS SBOE -BVSFOU 'BCJVT PV 3BZNPOE 'PSOJ &TTBT FTDPMIBT QPMÓUJDBT BDPNQBOIBNTF CFN GSFRVFOUFNFOUF EF TFHVOEBT JOUFOÎÜFT FTUSBUÏHJDBT BTTJN +BDRVFT $IJSBD OP NFBOEPFNOPmNEFTFVNBOEBUP+FBO-PVJT%FCSÏDFSUPEFUFSVNBMJBEP PCKFUJWPQBSBTFPQPSB/JDPMBT4BSLP[ZGVUVSP1SFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDB. 5PNFTFDJÐODJB.BTVNPVUSPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFEFTJHOBÎÍPTFSJBNFTNPDBQB[ EFNJOJNJ[BSPSJTDPEFQPMJUJ[BÎÍP /ÍPQFOTBNPTBTTJN 'B[FSOPNFBSPTNFNCSPT QFMP1BSMBNFOUP ²FNQBSUFPDBTPEB«VTUSJBPOEFP$POTFMIP/BDJPOBMFP$POTFMIP 'FEFSBMEFTJHOBNUSÐTKVÓ[FTBSU 6NBEBTQJPSFTTPMVÎÜFTFMBJNQFEFBEJWFSTJ EBEFOBTBVUPSJEBEFTEFOPNFBÎÍPFBCSFPDBNJOIPQBSBOFHPDJBÎÜFTQPMÓUJDBTFQBDUPT UÈDJUPT "FMFJÎÍP &NHFSBMQFMBJOJDJBUJWBEBTBTTFNCMFJBTOB"MFNBOIBoBSUoPJUP NFNCSPTTÍPFMFJUPTQFMP#VOEFTUBHFPJUPQFMP#VOEFTSBUOB&TQBOIBPJUPKVÓ[FTFOUSF EP[FTÍPFMFJUPTQFMBTDÉNBSBToBSU FMBÏBRVJOUFTTÐODJBEBQPMJUJ[BÎÍPFYJTUFBUP NBJTQPMÓUJDPRVFVNBFMFJÎÍP RVFPCSJHBBBMJBOÎBTPCKFUJWBTFUÈUJDBTQBSUJEÈSJBTQBSB BMDBOÎBSPTTVGSÈHJPTSFRVFSJEPTQFMBTDPOEJÎÜFTEFNBJPSJBRVBMJmDBEB. &NTFHVOEPMVHBSB$POTUJUVJÎÍPGSBODFTBOÍPQSFWFOEPOFOIVNBDMÈVTVMB EFDPNQFUÐODJBBTQFSTPOBMJEBEFTOPNFBEBTTÍPUBYBEBTEFJODPNQFUÐODJBKVSÓEJDB 4F Ï WFSEBEF RVF P $POTFMIP $POTUJUVDJPOBM Ï VNB EBT SBSÓTTJNBT DPSUFT RVF OÍP JNQÜFN OFOIVNB RVBMJmDBÎÍP KVSÓEJDB OÍP TF FYUSBJ EJTTP RVF BT QFSTPOBMJEBEFT OPNFBEBTOÍPTFKBNOBHSBOEFNBJPSJBEPTDBTPTUPEBTFYQFSJFOUFT$PNQFUÐODJB DPOTBHSBEBQPSVNEJQMPNBFFYQFSJÐODJBBERVJSJEBQFMBQSÈUJDBTÍPCFNEJGFSFOUFT &PRVFTFQPEFPCTFSWBSÏRVFBNBJPSQBSUFEBTQFSTPOBMJEBEFTEFTJHOBEBTEFQPJT EFTÍPKVSJTUBTEFGPSNBÎÍPPVTÍPUJUVMBSFTEFEJQMPNBTRVFBCSFNDBNJOIP EF DBSSFJSBT KVSÓEJDBT $FSDB EF EPT TFTTFOUB F OPWF NFNCSPT OPNFBEPT BUÏ IPKFBQSFTFOUBNVNEJQMPNBQFSNJUJOEPPBDFTTPËTNBHJTUSBUVSBTPO[FQSPGFTTPSFT EF%JSFJUPUJWFSBNBTTFOUPoNFTNPTFJTUPmRVFCFNBRVÏNEPOÞNFSPEBTPVUSBT $I&JTFONBOOLe Monde, 5 de março 1959. 7')PVSRVFCJF-FTOPNJOBUJPOTBV$POTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFML.P.A., nº 108, 2001, PP. 9-16. 7QSJODJQBMNFOUF-'BWPSFVF8.BTUPSLes Cours constitutionnelles, Connaissance du droit, Dalloz, PP.34 e segs. *CJEQWUBNCÏNBBOÈMJTFFTUBUÓTUJDBEF%PNJOJRVF3PVTTFBVJODroit du contentieux constitutionnel, Montchrestien, 9ème Ed., 2010. ²FNOPTTPTFOUJSVNBGSBRVF[BDSVDJBMBTBCFEPSJBEBTBVUPSJEBEFTEFOPNFBÎÍPDPOEV[SBSBNFOUFB FTDPMIFSQSPGFTTPSFTEF%JSFJUP0O[FQSPGFTTPSFTEF%JSFJUPOPNFBEPTBUÏIPKF$PNVNiQJDPwFOUSFEF TFUFNCSPEFFEFNBSÎPEFQPJTUSÐTFOUSFFMFTUJWFSBNBTTFOUPKVOUPTOP$POTFMIP.BSDFM 8BMJOF3FOÏ$BTTJOF'SBOÎPJU-VDIBJSF FJOFHBWFMNFOUFQFTBSBNTPCSFPTEFCBUFTTPCSFBOBUVSF[BKVSJT EJDJPOBMEP$POTFMIPQPSFYFNQMP FTPCSFPTFOUJEPEBTEFMJCFSBÎÜFTTPCSFPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJ EBEFEBTMFJTSFGFSFOEÈSJBTOPUBEBNFOUF 7')PVSRVFCJFLe pouvoir juridictionnel en France, LGDJ, 2010; e também nosso comentário em B.Mathieu, J.P. Machelon, F.Mélin-Soucramanien, D.Rousseau e X. Philippe (dir), Les grandes délibérations du Conseil constitutionnel, 1958-1983, Dalloz, 2009, PP.133 e segs. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 28 Fabrice Hourquebie e Fernanda Dias Menezes de Almeida $PSUFTFVSPQFJBToUSÐT7JDF1SFTJEFOUFTEP$POTFMIPEF&TUBEPVNBOUJHP1SFTJ EFOUFEB$PSUFEF+VTUJÎBEB6OJÍP&VSPQFJBVNBOUJHP1SJNFJSP1SFTJEFOUFEB$PSUF EF $BTTBÎÍP FUD ² QSFDJTP FOUÍP GJYBS VNB FYJHÐODJB EB DBQBDJEBEF KVSÓEJDB FN VNBDMÈVTVMBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFDPNQFUÐODJB /ÍPQFOTBNPTBTTJN1PSRVF1)DPNP JOEJDBNPTBRVBTFUPUBMJEBEFEPTNFNCSPTKÈEFUÏNVNEJQMPNBEF%JSFJUPPVEF VNBHSBOEFFTDPMBOÍPUPUBMNFOUFFTUSBOIBËGPSNBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBOÍPÏBMJÈTDFSUF[B RVFHSBWBSFTUBFYJHÐODJBOPNÈSNPSFNVEFRVBMRVFSDPJTB2)DPNPEFUFSNJOBSiB EJHOJEBEFKVSÓEJDBTVmDJFOUFwQBSBUPNBSBFYQSFTTÍPEF%EF#ÏDIJMMPO &YJHJSVN EPVUPSBEPFYDMVJSJBNVJUPGSFRVFOUFNFOUFPTNBHJTUSBEPTEFEJGFSFOUFT5SJCVOBJTF FYJHJSVNNFTUSBEPEF%JSFJUPFYDMVJSJBGSFRVFOUFNFOUFPTBMVOPTEFHSBOEFTFTDPMBT F3) BBVTÐODJBEFDMÈVTVMBEFDPNQFUÐODJBDPNOÓWFMKVSÓEJDPSFRVJTJUBEPQFSNJUF KPHBSBDBSUBEB%JWFSTJmDBÎÍPEPTQFSDVSTPTFEBTFYQFSJÐODJBTUÍPOFDFTTÈSJBFNVN DPOUFYUPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPUFOUBDVMBSEPTEJWFSTPTSBNPTEP%JSFJUP %JTUPEFDPSSFNVJUPMPHJDBNFOUFBUFSDFJSBDSÓUJDBBRVFMBEPDBSÈUFSEJTDSJ DJPOÈSJPEBOPNFBÎÍP0FORVBESBNFOUPTVCTUBODJBMQPSVNBDMÈVTVMBEFDPNQF UÐODJB OÍPUFOEPTJEPNBOUJEPPDPOTUJUVJOUFEFQSFGFSJVVNFORVBESBNFOUP GPSNBMEFUJQPQSPDFEJNFOUBMQPJTEFTEFFOUÍPBSU BTOPNFBÎÜFTTÍPTVCNF UJEBTBPQBSFDFSEBT$PNJTTÜFTEF+VTUJÎBEBTEVBTBTTFNCMFJBTRVBOEPBFTDPMIBÏ EP1SFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDBFEFVNBPVEFPVUSBEBTDPNJTTÜFTDPOGPSNFBFTDPMIB TFKB BRVFMB EP 1SFTJEFOUF EP 4FOBEP PV EB "TTFNCMFJB /BDJPOBM &MBT FNJUFN VN QBSFDFSQÞCMJDPFEJTQÜFNEFVNEJSFJUPEFWFUPUFØSJDPKÈRVFOÍPTFQPEFQSPDFEFS ËOPNFBÎÍPTFBDBOEJEBUVSBSFDPMIFSUSÐTRVJOUPTEFTVGSÈHJPTOFHBUJWPTPVNBJT &N SFBMJEBEF FTUF EJTQPTJUJWP OÍP Ï NVJUP FNCBSBÎPTP OB NFEJEB FN RVF SFVOJS USÐTRVJOUPTEFWPUPTOFHBUJWPTDPOGPSNFBTQSFTDSJÎÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT PCSJHBSJBB BMJBOÎBTFOUSFBNBJPSJBFBPQPTJÎÍPBMJBOÎBTRVFPGBUPNBKPSJUÈSJPUPSOBBMUBNFOUF JNQSPWÈWFJT%BÓFTTBTJORVJSJÎÜFTTFNTVSQSFTBFNoOBBVTÐODJBEFMFJPSHÉ OJDBmYBOEPBTDPOEJÎÜFTQSPDFEJNFOUBJToNBTVNQPVDPQJDBOUFTËTWF[FT"TTJN GPJOBWF[EF.JDIFM$IBSBTTFËJOEBHBÎÍPEF.BOVFM7BMMTiA título pessoal o senhor ousaria censurar um projeto de lei sustentado pela autoridade que o nomeou wPVEF3FOÏ %PTJÒSFiO que o senhor pensa do fato de os antigos Presidentes da República terem assento nato no seio do Conselho Constitucionalw FEFSFTQPTUBTVNQPVDPJOFTQFSBEBTEPJO UFSFTTBEPiA dignidade humana tem forçosamente valor constitucional pois todo o nosso Direito é protetor da pessoa humanaw 'SBOÎPJT-VDIBJSFMFNCSBWBRVFBBMRVJNJBQFSGFJUBQBSBBDPNQPTJÎÍPEF VNB KVSJTEJÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EFWJB TF FTUBCFMFDFS BP SFEPS EF USÐT DSJUÏSJPT VNB NBJPSJBEFKVSJTUBTEFQFSTPOBMJEBEFTJODPOUFTUÈWFJTFVNBDFSUBNJTUVSBEFHFSBÎÜFT 3FTUBTBCFSBRVBMEFTTBTDBUFHPSJBTQFSUFODFNPTNFNCSPTEP%JSFJUP %EF#ÏDIJMMPOBSUDJUQi"BUJUVEFQBSBDPOEV[JSVNBEJTDVTTÍPKVSÓEJDBEFBMUPOÓWFMOÍPTF SFTVNJSJBËEFUFOÎÍPEFVNUÓUVMPBDBEÐNJDPw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 A composição do conselho constitucional: um exotismo bem francês 29 2.2 Contra os membros natos 0RVFGB[FSEPTBOUJHPTQSFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDB 4FKBNPTDMBSPTBWBSJOIBNÈHJDBEPDPOTUJUVJOUFEFWFSJBEFVNBWF[QPSUP EBTGB[FSEFTBQBSFDFSPTBOUJHPTQSFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDBEP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJP OBM&MFTOÍPUÐNOBEBBGB[FSOFTTBJOTUJUVJÎÍP2VFOPTFOUFOEBNPTCFNNFNCSPT OBUPTTJHOJmDBNFNCSPTWJUBMÓDJPT "TQSPQPTUBTGFJUBTOFTTFTFOUJEPEJBOUFEP$PNJUÐ#BMMBEVSFODBSSFHBEPEFGB[FS QSPQPTUBTEFSFWJTÜFTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPOÍPGPSBNTFHVJEBTRVBOEPEBSFWJTÍPDPOTUJUVDJP OBMEFEFKVMIPEFPTTFOBEPSFTFSBNGBWPSÈWFJTB"TTFNCMFJB/BDJPOBMSFKFJUPV BQSPQPTUBFNTFHVOEBWPUBÎÍP FBJOEJHÐODJBEPBSHVNFOUPBWBOÎBEPQFMP1SFTJEFOUF EB3FQÞCMJDBOPEJTDVSTPQSPGFSJEPFNEFNBSÎPEFOP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBM OÍPQPEFFWJEFOUFNFOUFCBTUBSQBSBDPOWFODFSRVBMRVFSKVSJTUBFTDMBSFDJEPVNQPVDP RVFTFKBTPCSFFTUBRVFTUÍPi[...] O Conselho Constitucional não deveria ser uma jurisdição como outra. É a razão pela qual eu desejei que ele não seja composto apenas por técnicos do Direito e que os antigos Presidentes da República ali conservem sua qualidade de membros natos, porque a experiência de um antigo Chefe de Estado que fez funcionar as instituições, pode acrescentar muito à qualidade das decisões do Conselho, a seu equilíbrio, a seu realismow. 4BCFTF B SB[ÍP FNJOFOUFNFOUF DPOKVOUVSBM RVF QSFTJEJV FTUB BOPNBMJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBMRVBMTFKBTVBBEPÎÍPFNQFOIPSEFSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBBÎÍPDPOEV[J EBQPS3FOÏ$PUZF7JODFOU"VSJPMOPNPNFOUPEBBTDFOTÍPEP(FOFSBM%F(BVMMFBP QPEFS1BSBTFSCBTUBOUFIPOFTUPQPEFSTFJBUBMWF[FODPOUSBSOPBSUEB$POTUJUVJ ÎÍPVNBKVTUJmDBÎÍPQBSBFTUBEJTQPTJÎÍP"DPODFQÎÍPHBVMJTUBEBBSCJUSBHFNEFWJB GB[FS EP QSFTJEFOUF P HVBSEJÍP EP SFTQFJUP Ë $POTUJUVJÎÍP " TBÓEB OBUVSBM QPEF FOUÍPTFSVNBTTFOUPOPTFJPEBJOTUJUVJÎÍPRVFÏBHVBSEJÍKVSJTEJDJPOBMEPUFYUPGVO EBNFOUBMBTBCFSP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBM"MÏNEJTTPNFTNPRVFPTNFNCSPT OPNFBEPT OÍP TFKBN TVCNFUJEPT B VNB PCSJHBÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EF DPNQFUÐODJB KVSÓEJDBQPEFSJBQBSFDFSQBSBEPYBMRVFSFSTFQSJWBSEBFNJOFOUFFYQFSJÐODJBEBNBJT BMUBBVUPSJEBEFQPMÓUJDBEP&TUBEP.BTBÓBJOEBFTUBFYQMJDBÎÍPÏNVJUPJOTVmDJFOUFË WJTUBEBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTRVFEFDPSSFNEBQSFTFOÎBEPTNFNCSPTOBUPT1PSRVFDPN PFODVSUBNFOUPEBEVSBÎÍPEPNBOEBUPQSFTJEFODJBMQBSBDJODPBOPTBMJNJUBÎÍPB EPJTNBOEBUPTDPOTFDVUJWPTBFMFJÎÍPEFQSFTJEFOUFTDBEBWF[NBJTKPWFOTFPBMPO HBNFOUPEBFTQFSBOÎBEFWJEBBNÏEJPQSB[PPTBOUJHPTQSFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDB QPEFSJBNMPHPDPOTUJUVJSBNBJPSJBEPTNFNCSPTEP$POTFMIP IUUQXXXDPOTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMGSDPOTFJMDPOTUJUVUJPOOFMGSBOÎBJTOPVWFBVYDBIJFSTEVDPOTFJM DIJFSOEJTDPVSTQSPOPODFMFFSNBSTQBSNOJDPMBTTBSLP[ZQSFTJEFOUEFMBSFQVCMJ RVFIUNM "SUJHPi01SFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDB[FMBQFMPSFTQFJUPË$POTUJUVJÎÍP&MFBTTFHVSBQPSTVBBSCJ USBHFNPGVODJPOBNFOUPSFHVMBSEPTQPEFSFTQÞCMJDPTCFNDPNPBDPOUJOVJEBEFEP&TUBEP&MFÏP mBEPSEBJOEFQFOEÐODJBOBDJPOBMEBJOUFHSJEBEFEPUFSSJUØSJPFEPSFTQFJUPBPTUSBUBEPTw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 30 Fabrice Hourquebie e Fernanda Dias Menezes de Almeida &TUFQSPDFTTPEFJMFHJUJNJEBEFEBDPNQPTJÎÍPEP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBM BQBSFDFBTTJNTPCBMHVNBTØUJDBTJOUFJSBNFOUFMFHÓUJNP 3. A LEGITIMIDADE DO PROCESSO FEITO PARA A COMPOSIÇÃO DO CONSELHO iO CC pode permanecer por muito tempo um ator médio do jogo político se a composição e os modos de recrutamento não mudarem?w0QSPDFTTPEFJMFHJUJNJEBEFTFFMFTF DPOmOBVNQPVDPËiQSÈUJDBEBDPOWFSTBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBwOÍPQBSFDFNFOPTQFSUJOFOUFË NFEJEBRVFDPMPDBFNRVFTUÍPBKVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPEBJOTUJUVJÎÍP(A)KVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍP RVFPCSJHBBBMHVNBTSFGPSNBTEBDPNQPTJÎÍPQBSBMJNJUBSBJOEBNBJTBQPMJUJ[BÎÍP(B). 3.1 Mais jurisdicionalização .JDIFM'SPNPOUEJ[JBEP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMRVFFMFFSBVNiNPEFMP BUÓQJDPwPRVFRVFSEJ[FSUVEPTPCSFTVBOBUVSF[BKVSJTEJDJPOBMRVFTFBQSFDJBEB CFNFOUFOEJEPQFMBNFEJEBEPQSPDFEJNFOUPBQMJDÈWFMTFBWBMJBUBNCÏNBMÏNEJT TPËMV[EPSFDSVUBNFOUPFEBDPNQFUÐODJBEPTKVÓ[FTRVFGPSNBNB$PSUF "TTJNEBQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFEBDPNQPTJÎÍPSFTVMUBiuma questão recorrente sobre a natureza ambivalente deste órgão que participa elevadamente do poder jurisdicional, mas pelo fato da designação discricionária de seus membros por três autoridades políticas, vê constantemente pesar sobre ele a suspeita de politizaçãow²OPQBOPEFGVOEPB MBODJOBOUFRVFTUÍPEBKVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPRVFFTUÈFNEFCBUF$PNPBENJUJSRVFP $POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMTFUPSOFVNNFNCSPQPSJOUFJSPEPDMVCFEBT$PSUFT$POT UJUVDJPOBJTFVSPQFJBTTFTVBDPNQPTJÎÍPOÍPQFSNJUFSFnFUJSBTHBSBOUJBTRVFBQBSUF UFNEJSFJUPEFFTQFSBSEFVNQSPDFTTPTFKBFMFDPOTUJUVDJPOBM)FTJUBÎÍPRVF.BVSJDF %VWFSHFSBTTJNUSBEV[JBiO termo jurisdição política exprime o caráter ambíguo da instituição. (...). Ela intervém em matérias políticas e mais ainda nos fins políticos; seus membros devem ter a independência dos magistrados, mas seu recrutamento é políticow "JOEBVNBWF[OÍPTÍPTFHVOEPQFOTBNPTPTNFNCSPTOPNFBEPTRVFGB [FNQMBJOBSVNBEÞWJEBTPCSFBKVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPQPJTBTHBSBOUJBTEFJOEFQFOEÐODJB DPOTVCTUBODJBJTËBUJWJEBEFKVSJTEJDJPOBMFTUÍPMÈ"EVSBÎÍPEBTGVOÎÜFTOPWFBOPT TVBOÍPSFOPWBÎÍPFBJOBNPWJCJMJEBEFRVFEJTTPEFDPSSFÏRVFTÍPPTNBSDPTPCKFUJWPT EFTUBJOEFQFOEÐODJBEPKVJ[DPOTUJUVDJPOBM"JTUPTFBDSFTDFOUBFNVNQMBOPNBJT +,SZOFOop.cit.Q %EF#ÏDIJMMPOart.cit.Q +,SZOFOop. cit.Q "RVFTFBDSFTDFOUBVNSFHJNFEFJOFMFHJCJMJEBEFTEFJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFTEFJOUFSEJÎÜFTFVNBPCSJ HBÎÍPEFSFTFSWB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 A composição do conselho constitucional: um exotismo bem francês 31 TVCKFUJWPPGBNPTPEFWFSEFJOHSBUJEÍPBTFSFYFSDJEPBDPOUBSEPNPNFOUPFNRVF BQFSTPOBMJEBEFOPNFBEBOÍPUFNNBJTOBEBBFTQFSBSEBBVUPSJEBEFEFOPNFBÎÍP iA função se apodera do homem quando o homem é honestowFTDSFWJB(FPSHFT7FEFM² BTTJNFHSBÎBTËSFOPWBÎÍPQPSUFSÎPTBDBEBUSÐTBOPTRVFFWJUBBTSVQUVSBTEFKVSJTQSV EÐODJBFNDPOTFRVÐODJBEBTUSPDBTEFNBJPSJBTQPMÓUJDBTRVFP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJP OBMÏNBJTQFSDFCJEPDPNPVNBKVSJTEJÎÍPSFHVMBEPSBEBTBMUFSOÉODJBTQPMÓUJDBTEPRVF DPNPVNBJOTUJUVJÎÍPQBSUJEÈSJB"TDFOTVSBTSFDFOUFTBJOEBTÍPEJTTPUFTUFNVOIBT. ²CFNFOUFOEJEPTPCSFPTNFNCSPTOBUPTRVFSFDBJUPEPPQFTPEBQPMJUJ[BÎÍP FQPSUBOUPEPEFGFJUPEFKVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍP4FBKVSJTEJÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMÏOFDFTTBSJB NFOUFQPMÓUJDBUFOEPFNWJTUBBFTQFDJmDJEBEFEPDPOUFODJPTPRVFFMBEFWFDPOIFDFSOÍP ÏFOUSFUBOUPBDFJUÈWFMRVFVNBDBVTBTFKBTVCNFUJEBBVNBJOTUJUVJÎÍPRVFBPNFTNPUFN QPTFRVFSVNBKVSJTEJÎÍPFRVFDPNQSFFOEFFNTFVTFJPBTQFSTPOBMJEBEFTNBJTQPMÓUJDBT RVFTFKBNPTQSFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDB&TUBDPNQPTJÎÍPOÍPÏBDFJUÈWFMOPRVBESPEP DPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFMBÏNFOPTBDFJUÈWFMBJOEBa fortiori,OPRVBESP EPDPOUSPMFFYFSDJEPDPOGPSNFPOPWPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFRVFTUÍPQSJPSJUÈSJBEFDPOTUJUV DJPOBMJEBEFBSU &PBSHVNFOUPTFHVOEPPRVBMPTQSFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDBOÍP UPNBNQBSUFOBTBVEJÐODJBTEFRVFTUÍPQSJPSJUÈSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFNSB[ÍPEB TVBFOPSNFUFDOJDJEBEFOÍPCBTUBQBSBDSJBSBTVTQFJUBEPEFGFJUPEFKVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍP NFTNPRVFFTUFBSHVNFOUPEFQPOIBa contrario,QFMBBVTÐODJBEFDPNQFUÐODJBTVmDJFOUF EPTBOUJHPTQSFTJEFOUFTOPTDPOUFODJPTPTKVSÓEJDPTUÏDOJDPTFQPSUBOUPQPSTVBFYDMVTÍP EP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBM0$POTFMIPOÍPÏVNDMVCFQSFTUJHJPTPQBSBPTBQPTFOUBEPT EBQPMÓUJDB"MÏNEJTTPFRVBMRVFSRVFTFKBPDPOUFODJPTPVNBQSFTFOÎBBMFBUØSJBEFJYB EBËBQSFDJBÎÍPEPNFNCSPOBUPQPEFTFSJOUFSQSFUBEBEFVNMBEPDPNPVNBFTUSBUÏHJB QPMÓUJDBWJTBOEPBTVTUFOUBSPVBTFPQPSBPQPEFSJOTUBMBEPFEFPVUSPMBEPQPEFUFS DPNPFGFJUPNVEBSPTFRVJMÓCSJPTFNUFSNPEFSFQBSUJÎÍPEFWP[FTOPNPNFOUPEFVN WPUPPRVFÏFNJOFOUFNFOUFDPOUFTUÈWFMUBOUPQFMBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTRVBOUPQFMB MFHJUJNJEBEFEBJOTUJUVJÎÍPDPNPKVSJTEJÎÍP 3FGPSNBTOBDPNQPTJÎÍPTFJNQÜFNTFHVSBNFOUFQBSBBGBTUBSBJOEBNBJTP FTQFDUSPEBQPMJUJ[BÎÍP 3.2 Menos politização #FSOBSE $IFOPU BOUJHP 7JDF1SFTJEFOUF EP $POTFMIP EF &TUBEP BmSNBWB iEu jamais pensei por um segundo que o Conselho fosse um órgão jurisdicional; é um corpo político por seu recrutamento e pelas funções que preenchew Le Conseil constitutionnel a quarante ans, Conseil constitutionnel et LGDJ, 1999, p.66. ')PVSRVFCJFLe pouvoir juridictionnel em France, préc. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 32 Fabrice Hourquebie e Fernanda Dias Menezes de Almeida 0RVFTFSJBQSFDJTPFOUÍPQBSBDPOUSBEJ[FSFTUBPQJOJÍP 5SÐTQJTUBTFNSFTV NPTJNQMFTFNVJUPFWJEFOUFTQPEFNTFSFYQMPSBEBT 3.2.1 Suprimir os membros natos 1BSB UBOUP EFWFNPT BCEJDBS EB FYQFSJÐODJB EPT BOUJHPT QSFTJEFOUFT /ÍP CFNFOUFOEJEPTVBQBMBWSBFTVBFYQFSJÐODJBTÍPOFDFTTÈSJBTFNVNDPOUFYUPMJCFSBM BUPSNFOUBEP0SBGB[ÐMPTTFOUBSTFOP$POTFMIPJNQMJDBTVCNFUÐMPTËPCSJHBÎÍP EFSFTFSWBEPTNFNCSPTPRVFÏBmOBMQSFKVEJDJBM1PSRVFOÍPDPOTJEFSBSFOUÍP BIJQØUFTFEFOPNFÈMPTTFOBEPSFTWJUBMÓDJPTTFGPSQSFDJTPTFNWP[EFMJCFSBUJWB 0RVFFTUBSJBBPNFTNPUFNQPEFBDPSEPDPNOPÎÍPEFBSCJUSBHFNDPOTUJUVDJPOBM DPOTBHSBEB OP BSU EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP DPN B FYJHÐODJB EF KVSJTEJDJPOBMJ[BÎÍP EP $POTFMIPFDPNBSFWFSÐODJBRVFTFEFWFBVNBOUJHPDIFGFEF&TUBEP0FYFNQMP JUBMJBOPQPEFSJBJOTQJSBSPDPOTUJUVJOUFGSBODÐT. 3.2.2 Substituir os membros natos *TUPQFSNJUJSJBVNBMJOIBNFOUPDPNPTNFNCSPTFGFUJWPTRVFDPNQÜFNBT $PSUFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJTOB&VSPQBFRVFTÍPNBJTQSØYJNPTEFEP[FPVRVJO[FEPRVF EF OPWF "TTJN USÐT NFNCSPT TVQMFNFOUBSFT QPEFSJBN TFS OPNFBEPT OP MVHBS EPT NFNCSPTOBUPTRVFIPKFOVNBIJQØUFTFUFØSJDBFMFWBEBQPEFSJBNQSFDJTBNFOUFTFS USÐT+$IJSBD7(JTDBSEE&TUBJOHF/4BSLP[Z %VBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTQBSBBEFTJHOB ÎÍPEFTTFTNFNCSPT1).BOUFSVNBOPNFBÎÍPQFMBTUSÐTBMUBTBVUPSJEBEFTQPMÓUJDBT EFNPEPRVFFMBTEFWFSJBNEPSBWBOUFOPNFBSRVBUSPNFNCSPTBDBEBUSÐTBOPTPRVF JNQMJDBSJBVNBSFOPWBÎÍPQPSRVBSUPTBDBEBUSÐTBOPTNBTMFWBOUBSJBPQSPCMFNBEF TBCFSRVFBVUPSJEBEFUFSJBDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBOPNFBSEPJTNFNCSPT4FKBFTTBDPNQF UÐODJBBUSJCVÓEBBPQSFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDBFNOPNFEBMØHJDBEB2VJOUB3FQÞCMJDBF FOUÍPBDSÓUJDBEBQPMJUJ[BÎÍPFYDFTTJWBDPSSFPSJTDPEFWPMUBS4FKBVNBRVBSUBBVUPSJ EBEFEFOPNFBÎÍPBJOUFSWJSFOÍPQPEFTFSPQSJNFJSPNJOJTUSPFNSB[ÍPEBJOTUBCJ MJEBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMRVFPDBSBDUFSJ[B &TUBTPMVÎÍPDPMPDBUBMWF[NBJTQSPCMFNBTEP RVFPTSFTPMWF²QPSJTTPRVFTFQPEFFODBSBS2) RVFPTUSÐTNFNCSPTTVQMFNFOUBSFT TFKBNOPNFBEPTQFMBTBMUBTKVSJTEJÎÜFT$PSUFEF$BTTBÎÍP$POTFMIPEF&TUBEPF$PSUF EF $POUBT DPN EVBT WBOUBHFOT EF QFTP EBS BP $POTFMIP $POTUJUVDJPOBM TFNQSF B TFHVSBOÎBEFEJTQPSFNTVBTmMFJSBTEFKVÓ[FTFYQFSJFOUFTPRVFJOFHBWFMNFOUFÏVN &NVNBEFDJTÍPFMFJUPSBMEFEFOPWFNCSPEFP$POTFMIPGPJMFWBEPBTFQSPOVODJBSTPCSFBDPOEJÎÍP EFMFTFFTUJNPVRVFisob a única reserva de dispensa de juramento, eles são submetidos às mesmas obrigações dos outros membros”, Decisão nº 84-983, NA, 7 de novembro de 1984, Puy-de-Dôme, 2ème circ, Rec., p.117. 4PCSFFTUBRVFTUÍPWUBNCÏN%EF#ÏDIJMMPOart. cit., p.116. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 A composição do conselho constitucional: um exotismo bem francês 33 HBOIPEFQPJTEBFOUSBEBFNWJHPSEBRVFTUÍPQSJPSJUÈSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBSBP $POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMKVÓ[FTEFTDPOFDUBEPTEFOPNFBÎÜFTEJUBTiQPMÓUJDBTw. 3.2.3 Tornar mais rigoroso o controle sobre a nomeação ² QSFDJTP FTGPSÎBSTF QBSB RVF BT BVEJÐODJBT BHPSB QSFWJTUBT OP BSU EB $POTUJUVJÎÍPQPTTBNWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFFTDMBSFDFSPTNFNCSPTEBT$PNJTTÜFTEF+VT UJÎBTPCSFBTNPUJWBÎÜFTFBTDPOWJDÎÜFTEBTQFSTPOBMJEBEFTJOEJDBEBT+ÈEJTTFNPT POPWPTJTUFNBRVBTFOÍPDPOTUSBOHFWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFBBVUPSJEBEFEFOPNFBÎÍP 4FNDIFHBSBUÏBUSBOTQPTJÎÍPEPTUFNÓWFJTQSPDFEJNFOUPTEFBVEJÐODJBTEF DPOmSNBÎÍPEP4FOBEPBNFSJDBOPBThearings OPDVSTPEBTRVBJTBDBSSFJSBPRVFÏ OFDFTTÈSJP FBWJEBQSJWBEBPRVFÏEJTDVUÓWFM EPTKVÓ[FTJOEJDBEPTQBSBB$PSUF4V QSFNBQBTTBNQFMPDSJWPDPOWJSJBUBMWF[EJNJOVJSBDPOEJÎÍPEFNBJPSJBRVBMJmDBEB EFWPUPTOFHBUJWPTBMÏNEBRVBMBOPNFBÎÍPÏJNQPTTÓWFMPVSFOPWBSSBEJDBMNFOUFP TJTUFNBQSFWFOEPRVFVNBOPNFBÎÍPOÍPQPEFPDPSSFSTFOÍPDPNBDPODPSEÉODJBEF USÐTRVJOUPTEPTTVGSÈHJPTNBOJGFTUBEPT0CUFSBDPOmBOÎBSFVOJOEPUBMDPOEJÎÍPEF NBJPSJBÏJODPOUFTUBWFMNFOUFNBJTUFNÓWFMEPRVFDIFHBSBTFSPCKFUPEFVNWPUPEF EFTDPOmBOÎBOBTNFTNBTDPOEJÎÜFTEFNBJPSJB/BQSJNFJSBIJQØUFTFTFBOPNFBÎÍP OÍPBDPOUFDFPGSBDBTTPÏJNQVUÈWFMËGBMUBEFDPOWJDÎÍPEBQFSTPOBMJEBEFBQSFTFO UBEBOBTFHVOEBIJQØUFTFPGSBDBTTPEBOPNFBÎÍPÏNBJTJNQVUÈWFMËGBMUBEFTFOTP QPMÓUJDPEBBVUPSJEBEFEFOPNFBÎÍP3FTUBTBCFSPRVFÏNBJTHSBWF &NRVBMRVFSEPTDBTPTPFYPUJTNPGSBODÐTUFNBJOEBCFMPTEJBTEJBOUFEFTJ TBMWPTFBBUVBMDPNJTTÍPEFSFOPWBÎÍPFEFNPEFSOJ[BÎÍPEBWJEBQPMÓUJDBEFTFKBEB QFMP1SFTJEFOUF)PMMBOEFFQSFTJEJEBQFMPBOUJHP1SJNFJSP.JOJTUSP-JPOFM+PTQJOMF WBTTFFNDPOUBBRVFTUÍPFGPSNVMBTTFBQSPQPTUBRVFUPEPTPTQSPGFTTPSFTEF%JSFJUP $POTUJUVDJPOBMFTQFSBN 1SPQPTJÎÍPEF%EF#ÏDIJMMPOart. cit., p.116. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 25 a 33 LA FINANCIACIÓN DEL SISTEMA NACIONAL DE SALUD ESPAÑOL The financing of the Spanish National Health System Juan Zornoza Pérez1 RESUMEN *OUSPEVDDJØO-PTEJTUJOUPTNPEFMPTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPT -BmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTBOJEBEFOFMNBSDPEFMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT "VUØOPNBT -B JODJEFODJB FO MB mOBODJBDJØO EF MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB EF MB -FZ EFEFNBZPEFDPIFTJØOZDBMJEBEEFM4JTUFNBOBDJPOBMEF4BMVE6OB WBMPSBDJØOmOBMBNPEPEFDPODMVTJPOFT RESUMO 0 FTUVEP BOBMJTB WÈSJPT NPEFMPT EF mOBODJBNFOUP EP TJTUFNB EF TFSWJÎP EF TBÞEF FTQBOIPMDPNÐOGBTFOBUSBOTGFSÐODJBEFDPNQFUÐODJBTEFHFTUÍPQBSBBTDPNVOJEBEFT BVUÙOPNBT"QSPGVOEBRVFTUÜFTTPCSFBTNPEVMBÎÜFTRVFPTJTUFNBFYJHFQBSBBUFOEFSËT QFDVMJBSJEBEFTEBÈSFBEBTBÞEFDPNPBHBSBOUJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBBVUPOPNJBSFHJPOBM JOUFHSBÎÍPFVOJmDBÎÍPEBHFTUÍPEPTTFSWJÎPTEFTBÞEFBVNFOUPEPDVTUPNFMIPSJB EBRVBMJEBEFFYJHJEBOBQSFTUBÎÍPEPTTFSWJÎPTWJODVMBÎÍPEPBVNFOUPEFSFDFJUBBP DSFTDJNFOUPEFSFDVSTPTUSJCVUÈSJPTOPUFSSJUØSJPEFDBEBDPNVOJEBEFFQPSmNDSJUJDB BUFOEÐODJBBDPOTUSVJSSFHSBTFTUBCFMFDJEBTQFMPQSJODÓQJPEBBGFUBÎÍPQBSBHBSBOUJSP TJTUFNBEFJHVBMEBEFFDPFTÍPEPTJTUFNBTBOJUÈSJPPRVBMDPMJEFDPNPQSJODÓQJPEB BVUPOPNJB mOBODFJSB F B KVSJTQSVEÐODJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBM $PODMVJ QFMB OFDFTTJEBEF EF FTUBCFMFDFSVNOPWPNPEFMPRVFWJBCJMJ[FBDPPSEFOBÎÍPQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP(FSBMEP &TUBEPEFNPEPRVFFWJUFBQSFWBMÐODJBEFJOUFSFTTFTMPDBJTmOBODFJSPTFNQSFKVÓ[PEB JHVBMEBEFFEBHBSBOUJBEPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTEPTDJEBEÍPT ABSTRACT 5IFTUVEZXJMMBOBMZ[FBSBOHFPGGSBNFTFYBNJOFTWBSJPVTNPEFMTPGmOBODJOHTZTUFN IFBMUIJO4QBOJTIXJUIFNQIBTJTPOUIFUSBOTGFSPGNBOBHFNFOUTLJMMTUPUIF"VUPOPNPVT $PNNVOJUJFT%FFQFSRVFTUJPOTBCPVUUIFNPEVMBUJPOTUIBUUIFTZTUFNSFRVJSFTUPNFFU UIF QFDVMJBSJUJFT PG IFBMUI TVDI BT UIF DPOTUJUVUJPOBM HVBSBOUFF PG SFHJPOBM BVUPOPNZ JOUFHSBUJPOBOEVOJmDBUJPOPGUIFNBOBHFNFOUPGIFBMUITFSWJDFTJODSFBTFEDPTUJNQSPWJOH UIFRVBMJUZSFRVJSFEJOUIFQSPWJTJPOPGTFSWJDFTMJOLJOHJODSFBTJOHSFWFOVFHSPXUIPGUBY SFWFOVFTJOFBDIPGUIFDPNNVOJUJFTBOEVMUJNBUFMZDSJUJDJ[FTUIFUFOEFODZUPCVJMESVMFT FTUBCMJTIFECZUIFQSJODJQMFPGBMMPDBUJPOTZTUFNUPFOTVSFFRVBMJUZBOEDPIFTJPOPGUIF IFBMUITZTUFNXIJDIDPMMJEFTXJUIUIFQSJODJQMFPGBVUPOPNZmOBODJBMBOEDPOTUJUVUJPOBM KVSJTQSVEFODF *U DPODMVEFT XJUI UIF OFFE UP FTUBCMJTI B OFX NPEFM UIBU BMMPXT GPS DPPSEJOBUJPOCZUIF(FOFSBM"ENJOJTUSBUJPOPGUIF4UBUFUPQSFWFOUUIFQSFWBMFODFPGMPDBM mOBODJBMJOUFSFTUTUPUIFEFUSJNFOUFRVBMJUZBOEHVBSBOUFFUIFGVOEBNFOUBM Palavras-chaves4JTUFNBT'JOBODJBNFOUP4BÞEF1ÞCMJDB$PNVOJEBEFT"VUÙOPNBT &TQBOIB Keywords4ZTUFNT'JOBODJOH1VCMJD)FBMUI"VUPOPNPVT$PNNVOJUJFT4QBJO 1. INTRODUCCIÓN2 6OBEFMBTOPUBTNÈTEFTUBDBEBTEFMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT "VUØOPNBT$$""FOMPTVDFTJWP TVSHJEPEFMPT"DVFSEPTEFM$POTFKPEF1PMÓUJDB'JTDBM 6OJWFSTJEBE$BSMPT***EF.BESJE &TUFUSBCBKPTFFONBSDBFOMBMÓOFBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOmOBODJBEBQPSFM.JOJTUFSJPEF$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHÓB 3FG#+6 TPCSFMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTZMPT&OUFT-PDBMFT 36 Juan Zornoza Pérez Z'JOBODJFSBEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBT$1''FOMPTVDFTJWP EFEFKVMJPEF MVFHPSFWJTBEPTBEFOPWJFNCSFEF FTTVDBSÈDUFSJOUFHSBEPS&OFGFDUPFM OVFWPNPEFMPTFIBQSPQVFTUPJOUFHSBSZVOJmDBSMPTUSFTDBVDFTFNQMFBEPTDPOBOUFSJP SJEBEQBSBEPUBSBMBT$$""EFMPTSFDVSTPTOFDFTBSJPTQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFTVTDPNQF UFODJBTTVQFSBOEPMBEJTQBSJEBEEFDSJUFSJPTRVFTFFNQMFBCBOQBSBMBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFMB mOBODJBDJØOTFHÞOTFEFTUJOBSBBMBTDPNQFUFODJBTDPNVOFTBMBHFTUJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPT EFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBPQPSmOBMBHFTUJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTPDJBMFT $PNPDBCÓBQSFWFSMBDPOTFDVDJØOEFFTFQSPQØTJUPIBDPOEJDJPOBEPTFSJB NFOUFMBQSPQJBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMNPEFMPQBSBFNQF[BSFOMPRVFTFSFmFSFBMWPMV NFOZUJQPEFSFDVSTPTRVFIBOEFBUSJCVJSTFBMBT$$""EBEBMBJNQPSUBODJBDVBOUJ UBUJWBEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPoRVFTJOFNCBSHPTFNBOUJFOFDPOTUBOUFFOSFMBDJØOBM1*#3 oEFOUSPEFMPTQSFTVQVFTUPTBVUPOØNJDPT:OPTØMPFOFTFBTQFDUPTJOPUBNCJÏOFO PUSPTEFBMDBODFNÈTDVBMJUBUJWPDPNPMPTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMBFMFDDJØOEFMPTDSJUFSJPT QBSBMBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFUBMFTSFDVSTPTFORVFIBCÓBEFTVQFSBSTFMBIFUFSPHFOFJEBE EFMPTRVFTFWFOÓBOFNQMFBOEPQBSBMBBTJHOBDJØOBFTUPTFOUFTUFSSJUPSJBMFTEFMPT EJTUJOUPTGPOEPTIBTUBFOUPODFTFYJTUFOUFTTFHÞODVÈMGVFSBTVmOBMJEBETJOJODVSSJS FOVOBFYDFTJWBVOJGPSNJEBEEBEBMBDPOWFOJFODJBEFBUFOEFSBDSJUFSJPTFTQFDÓmDPT SFTQFDUPEFBMHVOPTEFMPTTFSWJDJPTBmOBODJBS 2VJ[ÈTQPSFMMPUBNCJÏOTFIBQSPEVDJEPVOFGFDUPSFnFKPQVFTBMSFDPO EVDJSTF MB mOBODJBDJØO EF MB TBOJEBE BM NPEFMP HFOFSBM EF mOBODJBDJØO IB TJEP OFDFTBSJP JOUSPEVDJS FO FTUF BMHVOBT NPEVMBDJPOFT QBSB BUFOEFS B MBT QFDVMJBSFT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPT"TÓQPSFKFNQMPQBSBHBSBOUJ[BSVOBDJFSUB DPOUJOVJEBEFOTVGVODJPOBNJFOUPUSBTTVUSBOTGFSFODJBBMBT$$""EBEPRVFFO FTUB NBUFSJB FTUÈ FO KVFHP MB FGFDUJWJEBE EF EFSFDIPT DPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT DPNP TPO MPT EF MPT BSUT Z EF MB $POTUJUVDJØO TF IB QSPDFEJEP B JOUSPEVDJS BMHVOBT NFEJEBTRVFOPTØMPQVFEFOSFTVMUBSQSPCMFNÈUJDBTEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMSFTQFUP BMBBVUPOPNÓBBMJNQPOFSBMBT$$""MBPCMJHBDJØOEFEFTUJOBSBMBHFTUJØOEFMB BTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBVOEFUFSNJOBEPWPMVNFOEFTVTSFDVSTPTTJOPRVFSFTVMUBOFO DJFSUPNPEPDPOUSBEJDUPSJBTDPOFMQSPQØTJUPEFBNQMJBSiMBTQPUFTUBEFTEFEFDJTJØO EFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTFONBUFSJBmTDBMUBOUPFOMPRVFSFTQFDUBBMBGPSNB EFPCUFODJØOEFTVTSFDVSTPTDPNPBMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFQSFTUBDJØOEFTVTTFSWJDJPTw RVFJOTQJSBFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$$""TFHÞOMB&YQPTJDJØOEF .PUJWPTEFMB-FZEFEFEJDJFNCSF 3 "VORVFQVFEBSFTVMUBSQBSBEØKJDPQPSRVFFOFMNJTNPMVHBSTFFODVFOUSBOEBUPTEFBOÈMJTJTFDPOØNJ DPSFGFSJEPTBMB×PMBTÞMUJNBTFTUBEÓTUJDBTEFHBTUPTBOJUBSJPBDDFTJCMFTFOMBQÈHJOBFO*OUFSOFU EFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BOJEBEZ$POTVNPIUUQXXXNTDFT%JTFOPJOGPSNBDJPO1SPGFTJPOBMQSPGFTJPOBM@ TJTUFNBT@JOGPSNBDJPOIUN TFSFmFSFOBMFKFSDJDJPEF&OFTFFKFSDJDJPFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPDPOUJOV BCBFTUBCJMJ[BEPFOFMEFM1*#MPRVFTVQPOFVOBSFEVDDJØOEFMEFTEF ZEFOUSPEF ÏMFMHBTUPQÞCMJDPTVQPOÓBVOEFM1*#DPOJEÏOUJDBSFEVDDJØOEFVOBEÏDJNBSFTQFDUPB WJEMPTEBUPTEF$"#"4&4)*5"+.QÈHTZTT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 37 $POWJFOFQPSFMMPEFUFOFSTFFOFMFYBNFOEFFTFOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBO DJBDJØOEFDBSÈDUFSJOUFHSBEPSiFOUBOUPRVFBCBSDBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFUPEPTMPTTFS WJDJPTTVTDFQUJCMFTEFUSBTQBTPBMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTwDPNPEJDFMBDJUBEB &YQPTJDJØOEF.PUJWPTQBSBBOBMJ[BSMPBIPSBEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBmOBODJBDJØO EFMPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTOPTJOBOUFTIBDFSVOBCSFWFSFGFSFODJBBMBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT EFMPTEJTUJOUPTNPEFMPTmOBODJFSPTRVFTFIBOFNQMFBEPBMPMBSHPEFMQSPDFTPEF EFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJØOEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPFODVBOUPQVFEBSFTVMUBSÞUJMQBSBDPNQSFOEFS MBTSFQFSDVTJPOFTRVFQVFEFQSPEVDJSTVUSBUBNJFOUPFOMB-FZ 2. LOS DISTINTOS MODELOS DE FINANCIACIÓN DE LOS SERVICIOS SANITARIOS &OMBEFTDSJQDJØOEFMPTEJTUJOUPTNPEFMPTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPT TBOJUBSJPTBOUFSJPSFTBMIPZWJHFOUFFTIBCJUVBMIBDFSSFGFSFODJBBUSFTQFSÓPEPTEJGF SFODJBEPTRVFTPOMPTRVFEJTUJOHVFFM"DVFSEPEFM$1''EFEFOPWJFNCSFEF QBSBTF×BMBSTVTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTFTFODJBMFT &Mprimero de dichos períodosTFBCSJSÓBDPOFMJOJDJPNJTNPEFMQSPDFTP EFTDFOUSBMJ[BEPSEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTBQBSUJSEFMUSBTQBTPBMB(FOFSBMJEBE EF $BUBMV×B EF MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB EF MB 4FHVSJEBE 4PDJBM RVF WFOÓB QSFTUBOEP FM*/4"-6%GPSNBMJ[BEP FO FM 3FBM %FDSFUP EF EF KVMJP SFnFKP EFM BDVFSEPEFMB$PNJTJØO.JYUBEFUSBOTGFSFODJBTBEPQUBEPFO*OJDJBMNFOUFMB mOBODJBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTUSBTQBTBEPTBEJDIB$PNVOJEBETFBSUJDVMBSÓBBUSBWÏTEF MBUSBOTGFSFODJBEFMPTDSÏEJUPTQSFTVQVFTUBSJPTBFMMPTBTPDJBEPTIBTUBRVFDPONP UJWPEFMBMJRVJEBDJØOEFMFKFSDJDJPEFTFBDPSEØBDVEJSDPNPDSJUFSJPUSBOTJUPSJP EF BTJHOBDJØO EF SFDVSTPT BM DPTUF FGFDUJWP EF MPT TFSWJDJPT USBOTGFSJEPT 5".":0 -03&/;0QÈHT 1FTF B RVF FM DSJUFSJP EFM iDPTUF FGFDUJWP EFM TFSWJDJP FO FM UFSSJUPSJP EF MB $PNVOJEBEFOFMNPNFOUPEFMBUSBOTGFSFODJBwIBCÓBTJEPDPOTBHSBEPDPNPDSJUFSJP HFOFSBMQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTFSWJDJPTUSBOTGFSJEPTFOMB%JTQPTJDJØO5SBOTJUP SJBQSJNFSBEFMB-FZ0SHÈOJDBEFEFTFQUJFNCSFEF'JOBODJBDJØOEF MBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBT-0'$"FOMPTVDFTJWP FYJTUFVOHFOFSBMBDVFSEPFO DPOTJEFSBSRVFMBQSJODJQBMDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBEFFTUFQFSÓPEPFTMBHSBOIFUFSPHFOFJEBE EFDSJUFSJPTFNQMFBEPTBMFGFDUP&OFTUFTFOUJEPTJQSFTDJOEJNPTEFMBTUSBOTGFSFODJBT FGFDUVBEBTBGBWPSEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFTEFM1BÓT7BTDPZ/BWBSSBRVFBMmOBODJBSTF NFEJBOUFMPTSFHÓNFOFTEF$PODJFSUPZ$POWFOJPFDPOØNJDPDBSFDFOEFJOUFSÏTB OVFTUSPTFGFDUPTPCTFSWBSFNPTRVFDBEB$$""OFHPDJØFMDSJUFSJPEFBTJHOBDJØOEF -PRVFEJPMVHBSBMDÈMDVMPEFTVmOBODJBDJØONFEJBOUFFMFNQMFPEFMÓOEJDFEFJNQVUBDJØOBVUJMJ[BS FODBEBFKFSDJDJPEFBDVFSEPDPOMB-FZQBSBFMDÈMDVMPEFM$VQPBTBUJTGBDFSQPSDBEB$PNV OJEBE"VUØOPNBBM&TUBEPFOUÏSNJOPTRVFMMFWBOBBmSNBSRVFTFUSBUBEFVONPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØO FTQFDÓmDP5".":0-03&/;0QÈH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 38 Juan Zornoza Pérez SFDVSTPTQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTBOJEBEEFBDVFSEPDPOTVTQFDVMJBSJEBEFTMPRVF FO BVTFODJB EF VO NBSDP FTUBCMF EF SFGFSFODJB OFDFTBSJBNFOUF IBCÓB EF DPOEVDJS B SFTVMUBEPTEJTQFSTPTQSPEVDJFOEPEJGFSFODJBTBQSFDJBCMFTFOMPTSFDVSTPTBTJHOBEPTB MBTEJTUJOUBT$$""(".";0"-#*--04(0/;"-&;QÈH RVFUFNQSBOB NFOUFEJFSPOMVHBSBMBEFOVODJBEFBHSBWJPTDPNQBSBUJWPTZEFQSFUFOEJEBTTJUVBDJPOFT EFQSJWJMFHJP$"#"4²4)*5"+.QÈH "TÓQPSSFGFSJSOPTBMPTUSBTQBTPTSFBMJ[BEPTFOFTUBQSJNFSBFUBQBFM3FBM %FDSFUPEFEFOPWJFNCSFQPSFMRVFTFUSBTmSJFSPOMPTTFSWJDJPTEFM */4"-6%BMB$PNVOJEBEEF"OEBMVDÓBSFnFKBCBVOEPCMFDSJUFSJPEFmOBODJBDJØO USBOTJUPSJPQBSBMPTEJTUJOUPTUJQPTEFHBTUPTQVFTNJFOUSBTMPTHBTUPTDPSSJFOUFTTF mOBODJBSÓBOTFHÞOFMDPTUFFGFDUJWPMBTJOWFSTJPOFTZTFSWJDJPTOVFWPTTFWBMPSBSÓBO EF BDVFSEP DPO MB QPCMBDJØO EF EFSFDIP EFUFSNJOBEB TFHÞO FM DFOTP EFM */& EF FTUBCMFDJÏOEPTFVOQFSÓPEPEFBKVTUFRVFoVOBWF[TFEJTQVTJFSBEFEBUPTTP CSFQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBoIBCÓBEFDPOEVDJSBMBJNQMBOUBDJØOEFFTUFÞMUJNPDSJUFSJP 1PSTVQBSUFFM3FBM%FDSFUPEFEFOPWJFNCSFEFUSBOTGFSFODJBEF TFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTBMB$PNVOJEBE7BMFODJBOBBDVEJSÓBBMDSJUFSJPEFMBQPCMBDJØO QSPUFHJEBBÞOBENJUJFOEPUSBOTJUPSJBNFOUFFMFNQMFPEFMDSJUFSJPEFMDPTUFFGFDUJWP EFMPTTFSWJDJPTFOUBOUPOPTFEJTQVTJFSBEFEBUPTTBUJTGBDUPSJPTRVFQFSNJUJFSBOEF UFSNJOBSBRVFMMB%FGPSNBTJNJMBSPQFSBSÓBFM3FBM%FDSFUPEFUSBTQBTP EFTFSWJDJPTBMB$PNVOJEBEEF(BMJDJBRVFTFDPNQSPNFUFBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMPT TFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTQPSTVDPTUFFGFDUJWPBÞODPOFMDPNQSPNJTPEFBMDBO[BSBUSBWÏT EFBQSPYJNBDJPOFTTVDFTJWBTFOVOQMB[PEFEJF[B×PTVOBmOBODJBDJØODPOGPSNF BMDSJUFSJPEFQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBEFUFSNJOBEBNJOPSBOEPMBQPCMBDJØOEFEFSFDIP FOMBDJGSBEFMPTDPMFDUJWPTQSPUFHJEPTQPSFOUJEBEFTNVUVBMJTUBT.6'"$&*4'"4 .6(&+6FUD ZFMNJTNPFTRVFNBmOBODJFSPQVFEFFODPOUSBSTFFOFM3FBM%FDSFUP EFEFNBS[PRVFGPSNBMJ[ØFMUSBTQBTPEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB 4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMBMB$PNVOJEBEEF$BOBSJBT +VOUPBFMMPDPOTUJUVZFVOMVHBSDPNÞOMBBmSNBDJØOEFRVFFMNPEFMPFN QMFBEPQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTFOFTUBQSJNFSBFUBQBEBEBT TVTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTOPQPEÓBHBSBOUJ[BSMBTVmDJFODJBmOBODJFSBEFMBT$$""RVF QBEFDÓBOEFTGBTFTQSFTVQVFTUBSJPTZUFOTJPOFTmOBODJFSBTRVFFOMBMÓOFBEFUFO EFODJBEFM*/4"-6%OPUSBOTGFSJEPEBCBOMVHBSBNPEJmDBDJPOFTQSFTVQVFTUBSJBT SFJUFSBEBTFOTVDFTJWPTFKFSDJDJPTTÓOUPNBEFVOBJOTVmDJFODJBmOBODJFSBDSØOJDB TØMP DPSSFHJEB NFEJBOUF QMBOFT EF TBOFBNJFOUP mOBODJFSP B USBWÏT EF MPT RVF MB "ENJOJTUSBDJØODFOUSBMBTVNÓBMBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFSJWBEBTEFMBTDPOTUBOUFTEFT WJBDJPOFT QSFTVQVFTUBSJBT (".";0(":6#04"º6%0 QÈH Z 36*; )6&35"(3"/"%04QÈH &O UPEP DBTP TFSÓB FO FTUB QSJNFSB FUBQB DVBOEP TF QSPEVDJSÓB MB OÓUJEB TFQBSBDJØOFOUSFMBmOBODJBDJØOHFOFSBMEFMBT$$""ZMBDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMBTDPN QFUFODJBT TBOJUBSJBT RVF IB PQFSBEP IBTUB MB BQSPCBDJØO EFM WJHFOUF NPEFMP EF m OBODJBDJØOEBEPRVFMB-FZEFEFBCSJM(FOFSBMEF4BOJEBE-(4FO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 39 BEFMBOUF BMFTUBCMFDFSMBTCBTFTQBSBMBSFPSEFOBDJØOEFMTJTUFNBTBOJUBSJPQÞCMJDP WJOP B TFOUBS DPNP DSJUFSJP QBSB MB mOBODJBDJØO EF MBT DPNQFUFODJBT TBOJUBSJBT EF MBT$$""oFOTVBSUoFMEFMBQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBRVFOPFTUBCBQSFWJTUPFOMB -0'$"OJQBSBFMQFSÓPEPUSBOTJUPSJPOJQBSBMBEFUFSNJOBDJØOEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJØO FOMPTJOHSFTPTEFM&TUBEP1*&FOBEFMBOUF FOMPTTVDFTJWPTNPEFMPTRVFIBCSÓBO EFTVDFEFSTF&TDJFSUPRVFFMBSUF EFMB-0'$"BFGFDUPTEFMBOFHPDJBDJØO EFMB1*&DPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMBT$$""QFSNJUFBDVEJSBDVBMFTRVJFSBDSJUFSJPTRVF iTFFTUJNFOQSPDFEFOUFTwQFSPOJTJRVJFSBBTÓQBSFDFQPTJCMFTBMWBSMBBEFDVBDJØOBM CMPRVFEFMBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEoEFMRVFGPSNBQBSUFMB-0'$"DPNPFYQSFTBNFOUF IBEJDIPMB45$oEFMB-(4RVFFOMPSFMBUJWPBMPTBTQFDUPTmOBODJFSPT SFBMJ[BVOEFTBSSPMMPJOEFQFOEJFOUFBMNBSHFOEFMTJTUFNBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFmOBODJB DJØOBVUPOØNJDBRVFTØMPQVFEFKVTUJmDBSTFQPSSB[POFTQSBHNÈUJDBTQFSPOPEFTEF MBQFSTQFDUJWBUÏDOJDPKVSÓEJDB &TBSFHVMBDJØOQBSUJDVMBSEFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBDVZBTSB[POFTTFIBO RVFSJEPFODPOUSBSiUBOUPFOMBQFSWJWFODJBFTUSVDUVSBMEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMDPNP OFYPEFMPTUSBTQBTPTDPNPFOVOBJOUFSQSFUBDJØOFTQFDÓmDBEFMPTBSUÓDVMPTDPOT UJUVDJPOBMFTEFBUSJCVDJØOEFDPNQFUFODJBTw5".":0-03&/;0QÈH PCFEFDFGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFBSB[POFTQSBHNÈUJDBTSFMBDJPOBEBTUBOUPDPOFMFNQMFP EFMBTDPUJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTDPNPGVFOUFEFmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBDPNPDPOMBFYJT UFODJBEFVOHSBOOÞNFSPEF$$""RVFOPUFOÓBOBTVNJEBTMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJ UBSJBT$"#"4²4)*5"QÈH 1PSFMMPBÞOSFDPOPDJFOEPRVFUBMFTDJSDVOT UBODJBTQMBOUFBCBOTVTQSPQJBTFYJHFODJBTFOUÏSNJOPTKVSÓEJDPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTOP QVFEFEFKBSEFTF×BMBSTFMBBOPNBMÓBRVFIBTVQVFTUPRVFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJB TFEFTBSSPMMBSBQPSGVFSBEFMTJTUFNBHFOFSBMEFmOBODJBDJØOPNFKPSEJDIPDPNP VOTJTUFNBQBSBMFMP3"."--0."44"/&5QÈHT RVFTFTJSWFEF MPTNJTNPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTRVFFMTJTUFNBHFOFSBMBVORVFTFBQBSBBQMJDBSEJTUJOUPT DSJUFSJPTFOMBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOFOUSFMBT$$""UPEPFMMPTJOBNQBSP OPSNBUJWPTVmDJFOUF&OFGFDUPMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTUSBOT GFSJEBTBMBT$$""TFQSPEVDJSÓBFOFTUFQSJNFSQFSÓPEPEFGPSNBQBSBMFMBBMBEFM SFTUPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTUSBOTGFSJEBTTPCSFMBCBTFEFOFHPDJBDJPOFTQPMÓUJDBTDVZPT SFTVMUBEPTTFKVTUJmDBSÓBOMVFHPEFGPSNBNÈTPNFOPTGPS[BEBFOMBBQMJDBDJØOEF MPTDSJUFSJPTMFHBMPSFHMBNFOUBSJBNFOUFFTUBCMFDJEPTRVFTPOPCKFUPEFOFHPDJBDJØO UBOUPFOFMTFOPEFM$1''RVFBTVNJSÈUBNCJÏOFOFTUBNBUFSJBVOQSPUBHPOJTNPRVF TFDPNQBEFDFNBMDPOTVDPOmHVSBDJØOMFHBMDPNPØSHBOPDPOTVMUJWPZEFMJCFSBDJØO 3"."--0."44"/&5;03/0;"1²3&;QÈHT DPNPFOMBT$PNJTJP OFT.JYUBTFORVFTFQBDUBSÓBOMPTDPTUFTFGFDUJWPTRVFMBT$$""QFSDJCJSÓBOUSBTMB BTVODJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFRVFTFUSBUB &MUSÈOTJUPBMTFHVOEPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$$""RVFTFBQSPCB SÓB NFEJBOUF FM BDVFSEP EFM $1'' EF EF FOFSP EF OP EFUFSNJOØ OJOHVOB WBSJBDJØOFODVBOUPBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBBQFTBSEFMBDSFBDJØO EFVOHSVQPEFUSBCBKPFTQFDÓmDPQBSBFMFYBNFOEFMTJTUFNBEFQSFTVQVFTUBDJØOZ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 40 Juan Zornoza Pérez MJRVJEBDJØOEFMHBTUPFOFTUBNBUFSJB1PSFMMPTØMPFOVONPNFOUPQPTUFSJPSDPNP DPOTFDVFODJBEFMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''EFEFTFQUJFNCSFEFTFQSPEVDJSÓB VOBSFGPSNBEFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBNFEJBOUFMBBQSPCBDJØOEFVOOVFWPNPEFMP QBSBFMperíodo 1994-1997RVFQFTFBUPEPOPTVQPOESÓBMBJOUSPEVDDJØOEFOP WFEBEFTEFFYDFTJWBUSBTDFOEFODJB&OFGFDUPBEFNÈTEFJODSFNFOUBSOPUBCMFNFOUF oBMQBSUJSEFMHBTUPFGFDUJWPEFM*/4"-6%FOoMBEPUBDJØOJOJDJBMQBSBFMHBTUP TBOJUBSJP DPO FM QSPQØTJUPEFQBMJBSMBJOTVmDJFODJB mOBODJFSB DSØOJDB RVF TF WFOÓB QBEFDJFOEPMPTBDVFSEPTTFMJNJUBSÓBOBJOUFOUBSVOBDJFSUBIPNPHFOFJ[BDJØOEFMPT DSJUFSJPTEFSFQBSUPBMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFMBWBSJBDJØOFOFM1*#OPNJOBMDPNPÓOEJDF EFFWPMVDJØOEFMPTSFDVSTPTEFTUJOBEPTBMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBZBMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EFBMHVOBTSFHMBTUFOEFOUFTBMBHBSBOUÓBEFVOBNBZPSEJTDJQMJOBmTDBM(".";0 (":6#04"º6%0QÈHTZ5".":0-03&/;0QÈHTZTT 4FJOUFOUØEFFTFNPEPDPSSFHJSMPTEFGFDUPTNÈTWJTJCMFTPDBTJPOBEPTQPS FM BOUFSJPS NPEFMP QBSB FNQF[BS EFUFSNJOBOEP FTDFOBSJPT mOBODJFSPT FTUBCMFT Z TBOFBOEPMBEFVEBFYJTUFOUFFOFMTJTUFNB*/4"-6%QBSBIBDFSQPTJCMFVOBNFKPSB FOUÏSNJOPTEFTVmDJFODJBEFVOBTVmDJFODJBRVFEFCÓBIBDFSQPTJCMFMBBEPQDJØOEF NFEJEBTEFEJTDJQMJOBmTDBMUFOEFOUFTBMDPOUSPMEFVOBTQBSUJEBTEFHBTUPTJFNQSF DSFDJFOUFT"UBMFGFDUPQBSBSPNQFSMBEFOPNJOBEBiDVMUVSBEFMDSÏEJUPBNQMJBCMFw (*.²/&; .0/5&30 QÈH DVZPT FGFDUPT FO FM JODSFNFOUP EFM HBTUP TBOJUBSJPFSBOFWJEFOUFTMPTDSÏEJUPTQSFTVQVFTUBSJPTEFTUJOBEPTBFTUBTBUFODJPOFT QBTBSPOBUFOFSDBSÈDUFSMJNJUBUJWPDPOMBDPOTFDVFODJBEFRVFMBTQPTJCMFTJOTVm DJFODJBTQSFTVQVFTUBSJBTSFRVFSJSÓBOQBSBTVDPCFSUVSBMBUSBNJUBDJØOEFMPTDPSSFT QPOEJFOUFTTVQMFNFOUPTEFDSÏEJUPPDSÏEJUPTFYUSBPSEJOBSJPTMPRVFJNQMJDBCBBEF NÈTUSBTQBTBSBMBT$$""VODJFSUPHSBEPEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBETPCSFMBTEFTWJBDJPOFT QSFTVQVFTUBSJBTRVFQVEJFSBOQSPEVDJSTF4JBFMMPVOJNPTFMJOUFOUPEFTVQFSBSMB IFUFSPHFOFJEBEFODVBOUPBMPTDSJUFSJPTEFUFSNJOBOUFTEFMBmOBODJBDJØOIBDJFOEP QPTJCMFMBJNQMBOUBDJØOEFMEFQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBTBODJPOBEPQPSMB-(4NFEJBO UFVOQSPDFTPEFBEBQUBDJØOQSPHSFTJWPZFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFMBUBTBEFWBSJBDJØO EFM1*#OPNJOBMDPNPÓOEJDFEFFWPMVDJØOTFDPNQSPCBSÈRVFFMBDVFSEPEFM$1'' EFEFTFQUJFNCSFEFUVWPTJOEVEBMBWJSUVBMJEBEEFSFTPMWFSBMHVOPTEF MPTQSPCMFNBTHFOFSBEPTFOVOEFTPSEFOBEPQSPDFTPEFUSBTQBTPTBVORVFOPQVEP BMVNCSBSVONPEFMPFTUBCMFEFmOBODJBDJØOBMOPBCPSEBSMPTQSPCMFNBTEFSJWBEPT EFMPTnVKPTJOUFSUFSSJUPSJBMFTEFQBDJFOUFToZBRVFFM&TUBEPDPOUJOVØBTVNJFOEPFM DPTUFEFMBBTJTUFODJBBEFTQMB[BEPToOJTFSDBQB[EFFTUBCMFDFSDSJUFSJPTRVFSFnF KBSBOMBTEJGFSFODJBTFOUÏSNJOPTEFOFDFTJEBESFMBUJWBFYJTUFOUFTFOUSFMBTEJTUJOUBT $$""5".":0-03&/;0QÈH &OQBSBMFMPBMPTUSBCBKPTRVFIBCÓBOEFDPOEVDJSBMBFMBCPSBDJØOEFMOVFWP NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOHFOFSBMEFMBT$$""SFDPHJEPFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''EF EFTFQUJFNCSFEFFM$POHSFTPEFMPT%JQVUBEPTBDPSEØMBDSFBDJØOEFVOB 4VCDPNJTJØOQBSBFMFTUVEJPEFMBTSFGPSNBTOFDFTBSJBTQBSBMBNPEFSOJ[BDJØOEFMTJT UFNBTBOJUBSJPRVFSJOEJØVO*OGPSNFmOBMFORVFQSFTDJOEJFOEPEFPUSPTBTQFDUPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 41 TFJOTUBCBBM$1''QBSBRVFFOEVSBOUFMBWJHFODJBEFMNPEFMPRVFIBCÓBEFBQSPCBSTF QBSB FM período 1998-2001 BCPSEBTF MB JODPSQPSBDJØO EF MB mOBODJBDJØO TBOJUBSJB B MB mOBODJBDJØO HFOFSBM EF MBT $$"" TPCSF MB CBTF EF DSJUFSJPT EF JODPSQPSBDJØO QSPHSFTJWBZDPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmTDBM2VJ[ÈTEFTEFFTBQFSTQFDUJWBDPNPNFEJEBT EFTUJOBEBTBQSFQBSBSMBBOVODJBEBDPOWFSHFODJBFOUSFBNCPTNPEFMPTEFmOBODJB DJØOEBEPRVFTVFYQJSBDJØOIBCÓBEFQSPEVDJSTFFOFMNJTNPFKFSDJDJPEFMPT BDVFSEPTEFM$1''EFEFOPWJFNCSFEFJOUSPEVKFSPOBMHVOBTSFGPSNBTFO MBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTBOJEBERVFNFSFDFMBQFOBDPNFOUBSCSFWFNFOUFFODVBOUP QVFEFODPOUSJCVJSBMBNFKPSDPNQSFOTJØOEFMBTJUVBDJØOIPZFYJTUFOUF "TÓFOHBSBOUÓBEFMBTVmDJFODJBFTUÈUJDBEFMNPEFMPTFEFUFSNJOBVOWPMV NFOJOJDJBMEFSFDVSTPTBQBSUJSEFMHBTUPQSFTVQVFTUBEPQBSBFMFKFSDJDJPEFBM RVFTFBHSFHBOEJTUJOUBTQBSUJEBTBEJDJPOBMFTQBSBDPOTUJUVJSVOBNBTBEFmOBODJBDJØO RVFTFEJTUSJCVJSÈFOUSFTGPOEPTDVZBTPMBFYJTUFODJBDPOTUJUVZFZBVOBOPWFEBESFMF WBOUF&MQSJNFSPEFFMMPTFMEFOPNJOBEP'POEPHFOFSBMBMRVFTFBTJHOBFMQPS EFMPTSFDVSTPTHMPCBMFTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFTBMQSJNFSFKFSDJDJPTFEFTUJOBBMBDP CFSUVSBEFMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTHFOFSBMFTZTFEJTUSJCVZFFOUSFMBT$$""EFBDVFSEPDPOFM DSJUFSJPEFQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBDBMDVMBEBBQBSUJSEFMQBESØOEFZBDUVBMJ[BOEP MPTEBUPTEFMBTQFSTPOBTBDPHJEBTBFOUJEBEFTEFNVUVBMJTNPBENJOJTUSBUJWP+VOUPB FMTFTJUÞBOEPTGPOEPTBEJDJPOBMFTEFDBSÈDUFSmOBMJTUBQBSBBUFODJPOFTFTQFDÓmDBT DVZBEJTUSJCVDJØOPCFEFDFSÈBDSJUFSJPTEJTUJOUPTEFMEFQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBÞOJDP TBODJPOBEPFOMB-(4"TÓPDVSSFDPOFM'POEPEFNPEVMBDJØOmOBODJFSBEFTUJOBEP BDPNQFOTBSMBTQPUFODJBMFTQÏSEJEBTEFmOBODJBDJØORVFQVEJFSBOTVGSJSMBT$$"" DVZBQPCMBDJØOIVCJFSBEJTNJOVJEPSFTQFDUPBMDFOTPEFEBEPRVFMBQPCMBDJØO QSPUFHJEBIBCÓBFWPMVDJPOBEPEFGPSNBEJTUJOUBFODBEBUFSSJUPSJPZDVZPGVODJPOB NJFOUPSFTVMUBTPSQSFOEFOUFQVFTDPNPIBPCTFSWBEP(*.²/&;.0/5&30 QÈH BTJHOBNÈTGPOEPTBMBT$$""RVFNFOPTIBODSFDJEPMPRVFTØMPQVFEF FOUFOEFSTFoDPNPBmSNBFMDJUBEPBVUPSoTJTFDPOTJEFSBRVFMBMØHJDBiPDVMUBwEFFTUF GPOEPOPFTPUSBRVFMBEFPGSFDFSBMBT$$""VOBHBSBOUÓBEFNÓOJNPTQBSBMFMBBMB RVFPQFSBFOFMÈNCJUPEFMBmOBODJBDJØOHFOFSBMEFNPEPRVFOJOHVOB$PNVOJEBE SFDJCBQPSFMOVFWPNPEFMPVOWPMVNFOEFSFDVSTPTJOGFSJPSBMRVFMFQSPQPSDJPOBCB FMBOUFSJPS1PSTVQBSUFFMRVFTFDPOPDFDPNP'POEPEFBTJTUFODJBIPTQJUBMBSJBTF WJODVMBBMBDPCFSUVSBEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTmOBODJFSBTPSJHJOBEBTQPSMBEPDFODJBZBTJT UFODJBIPTQJUBMBSJBBOPSFTJEFOUFTDJSDVOTUBODJBTRVFJOEVEBCMFNFOUFDPOEJDJPOBO FMOJWFMEFHBTUPTBOJUBSJPQFSPRVFQFSNJUFODPNPFOFMGPOEPBOUFSJPSJOUSPEV DJS DSJUFSJPT EF EJTUSJCVDJØO OP FYQMÓDJUPT EF DVZB BQMJDBDJØO SFTVMUBO iEJGFSFODJBT /P PCTUBOUF (".";0"-#*--04(0/;«-&; QÈH NFODJPOBO DPNP DSJUFSJPT QBSB TV EJTUSJCVDJØOUFSSJUPSJBMFMiTBMEPEFQBDJFOUFTBUFOEJEPTQPSDBEB$"EJGFSFODJBFOUSFQBDJFOUFTiJN QPSUBEPTwZQBDJFOUFTiFYQPSUBEPTw OÞNFSPEFNÏEJDPTJOUFSOPTSFTJEFOUFT.*3 FUDw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 42 Juan Zornoza Pérez QBSBEØKJDBTFOMBSFMBDJØOFOUSFQÏSEJEBTSFMBUJWBTEFQPCMBDJØOZSFDVSTPTBTJHOBEPTw 5".":0-03&/;0QÈH : FTUF EBUP EFCF EFTUBDBSTF DPNP NFSFDF QVFT QPOF EF NBOJmFTUP RVF UBNCJÏOFOFMÈNCJUPEFMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPTFIBPQFSBEPBMNBSHFO EFMEFSFDIPQSFTDJOEJFOEPEFMPTDSJUFSJPTMFHBMNFOUFFTUBCMFDJEPTQBSBMBEJTUSJCV DJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØODPOFMmOEFBMDBO[BSMPTSFTVMUBEPTDPOTJEFSBEPTSB[POB CMFTPEFTFBCMFTRVFMVFHPTFKVTUJmDBONFEJBOUFUÏDOJDBTEFBKVTUFOFDFTBSJBNFOUF EJTDVUJCMFTRVFOPQVFEFOKVTUJmDBSTFOJQPSSB[POFTEFTVmDJFODJBOJEFFRVJEBE FJNQMJDBORVFiTFBCBOEPOByVODSJUFSJPUSBOTQBSFOUFEFSFQBSUPZMBmOBODJB DJØOTBOJUBSJBRVFEBNÈTWVMOFSBCMFBQPTJCMFTQSFTJPOFTQPMÓUJDBTRVFQVFEBOFKFS DFSMBTEJTUJOUBT$$""w(".";0(":6#04"º6%0QÈHT &OFGFDUP FYJTUFVOBBNQMJBDPJODJEFODJBFODVBOUPBMBFTDBTBDMBSJEBEEFMPTDSJUFSJPTEFEJT USJCVDJØOFNQMFBEPTSFTQFDUPBMPTEPT'POEPTFTQFDJBMFTQPSMPRVFOPFTFYUSB×P RVFTVEFTUJOPIBZBTJEPiFYDFTJWBNFOUFEFQFOEJFOUFEFMBOFHPDJBDJØOQPMÓUJDBw (".";0"-#*--04(0/;«-&;QÈHZ5".":0-03&/;0 QÈHT DPOMBJOFWJUBCMFDPOTFDVFODJBEFRVFFMNPEFMPFOTVDPOKVOUPTF UPSOBJOFTUBCMFBMRVFEBSBMBSCJUSJPZBMBMJCSFEJTQPTJDJØOEFMBTGVFS[BTQPMÓUJDBT FOBVTFODJBEFDSJUFSJPTMFHBMNFOUFQSFFTUBCMFDJEPTRVFQVEJFSBODPOEJDJPOBSKVSÓ EJDBNFOUFMPTSFTVMUBEPTBBMDBO[BS 1PSmOQBSBQPOFSUÏSNJOPBFTUFBQSFUBEPSFDPSSJEPIJTUØSJDPDPOWJFOFTF ×BMBSRVFUBNCJÏOQBSBFMQFSÓPEPFODVNQMJNJFOUPEFMQSJODJQJPEFTVm DJFODJBEJOÈNJDBTFQSFWJØMBFWPMVDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBEFMBT$$""TFHÞO FMÓOEJDFEFJODSFNFOUPEFM1*#OPNJOBMÓOEJDFRVFTFIBNPTUSBEPJOTVmDJFOUFQBSB HBSBOUJ[BSVOBBEFDVBEBDPCFSUVSBEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFHBTUPFOFTUBNBUFSJBQVFTMB SFBMJEBEIBNPTUSBEPDPNPFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPQÞCMJDPIBDSFDJEPFOVOQPSDFOUBKFNB ZPSRVFFM1*#OPNJOBM(".";0"-#*--04(0/;«-&;QÈH %FBIÓMB JOTJTUFODJBFOMBPCUFODJØOEFBIPSSPTFOFTUBNBUFSJBRVFTFIBORVFSJEPJOEVDJSFOMPT QSPQJPTNPEFMPTEFmOBODJBDJØODPNPPDVSSJØFOFMDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMQFSÓPEPRVF OPTPDVQBBMQSFWFSTFRVFMPTBIPSSPTBMDBO[BEPTDPNPDPOTFDVFODJBEFMBBEBQUBDJØO EFMDPOTVNPGBSNBDÏVUJDPBMBTOFDFTJEBEFTSFBMFTEFMBQPCMBDJØOZQPSFMDPOUSPMEFM HBTUPQPSJODBQBDJEBEMBCPSBMUSBOTJUPSJBSFWJSUJFSBOFOFMNJTNPTJTUFNBTBOJUBSJPFO MVHBSEFEFTUJOBSTFBMBSFEVDDJØOEFMEÏmDJUQÞCMJDPDPNPPDVSSÓBDPOBOUFSJPSJEBE "-#*--0(".";0(0/;«-&;4"º6%0QÈH /PFTGÈDJMFTUBCMFDFSMPTFMFNFOUPTDPNVOFTBMPTNPEFMPTEFmOBODJBDJØORVF IBORVFEBEPEFTDSJUPTRVFDJFSUBNFOUFIBOIFDIPQPTJCMFRVFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJB EJTDVSSJFSBQPSTVTQSPQJBTWÓBTBMNBSHFOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOHFOFSBMEFMBTSFTUBOUFT DPNQFUFODJBTZTFSWJDJPTEFMBT$$""BVORVFPQFSBOEPEFNBOFSBQBSBMFMBFOBN CPTÈNCJUPT1SFDJTBNFOUFQPSFMMPTJRVJTJÏSBNPTTF×BMBSTVSBTHPNÈTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDP ÏTUFTFSÓBMBJOFYJTUFODJBEFVONBSDPOPSNBUJWPRVFIBZBTFSWJEPEFSFGFSFODJBQBSB FMDÈMDVMPEFMBmOBODJBDJØOBSFDJCJSQPSMBT$$""QVFTTJJOJDJBMNFOUFTFBDVEJØBMB mOBODJBDJØOEFMDPTUFFGFDUJWPEFMPTTFSWJDJPTUSBOTGFSJEPTOPGVFTFHÞOMB%JTQPTJDJØO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 43 5SBOTJUPSJBQSJNFSBEFMB-0'$"ZEFTEFMVFHPQPDPUJFOFRVFWFSMBQPCMBDJØOQSPUF HJEBBRVFBDVEJØMB-(4DPOMPTDSJUFSJPTEFMBSUEFBRVFMMB-FZ0SHÈOJDB %FBIÓRVFDPNPTFIBTF×BMBEPQPSMBHFOFSBMJEBEEFMPTBVUPSFTMBEFUFS NJOBDJØOEFMBTDBOUJEBEFTBQFSDJCJSQPSDBEB$PNVOJEBEIBZBTJEPFMSFTVMUBEPEF DPNQMFKBTOFHPDJBDJPOFTEFTBSSPMMBEBTPSBFOFM$1''PSBFOMBT$PNJTJPOFT.JYUBT EFUSBOTGFSFODJBTSFTVMUBEPRVFMVFHPTFIBRVFSJEPSFWFTUJSNFEJBOUFFMSFDVSTPB DSJUFSJPTQSFUFOEJEBNFOUFPCKFUJWPTQVFTMPTSFTQPOTBCMFTQPMÓUJDPTTPONVZBmDJP OBEPTBTVQMJSDPOVOBTVQVFTUBPCKFUJWBDJØOUÏDOJDBTVGBMUBEFDBQBDJEBEQBSBFM DPNQSPNJTPQPMÓUJDP-»1&;$"4"4/07"4(QÈH :DPOWJFOFEFTUBDBS MPQPSRVFFTUBFTVOBEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTDBVTBTEFJOFTUBCJMJEBEEFMBmOBODJBDJØOBV UPOØNJDBHFOFSBMZEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFVOBJOFTUBCJMJEBERVFFTBOUFUPEP JOFTUBCJMJEBEOPSNBUJWBZQPSUBOUPOPEFQFOEFEFMBNBZPSPNFOPSEVSBDJØOEFM NPEFMPEFRVFTFUSBUFTJOPEFMBFYJTUFODJBEFSFHMBTWJODVMBOUFTQBSBFMQSPQJPMFHJT MBEPSoJOUFHSBEBTQPSUBOUPFOFMCMPRVFEFMBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEoRVFDPODSFUFOMPT DSJUFSJPTQBSBFMSFQBSUPEFMPTSFDVSTPTmOBODJFSPTEJTQPOJCMFTBTFHVSBOEPMBQSFWJ TJCJMJEBEZQMBOJmDBDJØOmOBODJFSBTEFMPT&OUFTUFSSJUPSJBMFT1PSRVFDPNPBEWJSUJFSB FM5SJCVOBM$POTUJUVDJPOBM'FEFSBMBMFNÈOFOTV4FOUFODJBEFEFOPWJFNCSFEF #7FSG(& MBT OPSNBT EF MB $POTUJUVDJØO mOBODJFSB FYDMVZFO RVF MBmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTFOUFTUFSSJUPSJBMFTQVFEBBSUJDVMBSTFBQBSUJSEFBDVFSEPTTPCSF DJGSBTDPODSFUBTMVFHPSFWFTUJEPTTPCSFMBCBTFEFQSFUFOEJEPTDSJUFSJPTUÏDOJDPTZ BOUFTBMDPOUSBSJPSFDMBNBOFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFDSJUFSJPTMFHBMFTQSFDJTPTEPUBEPT EFVOBWJHFODJBUFNQPSBMSB[POBCMFRVFEFTBSSPMMFOEFNBOFSBBEFDVBEBMPTQSJO DJQJPTZOPSNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFNBOFSBRVFiMPTDSJUFSJPTBDFSDBEFMSFQBSUPEF MPTJOHSFTPTUSJCVUBSJPTZMPTNFDBOJTNPTEFTPMJEBSJEBETFFODVFOUSFODPOmHVSBEPT BOUFTEFRVFTFBODPOPDJEPTTVTFGFDUPTQPTUFSJPSFTw. 3. LA FINANCIACIÓN DE LA SANIDAD EN EL MARCO DE LA FINANCIACIÓN DE LAS COMUNIDADES AUTÓNOMAS. $PNPTFIBCÓBBWBO[BEPQPSMBHFOFSBMJEBEEFMPTBVUPSFTVOBWF[QSPEV DJEBMBTFQBSBDJØOEFMBTGVFOUFTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMTJTUFNBEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBM EFNPEPRVFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBQBTBSBBDVCSJSTFDPODBSHPBMPTSFDVSTPTQSFTV QVFTUBSJPTPSEJOBSJPTEFTWJODVMÈOEPTFEFMBTDPUJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTMBQFSWJWFODJBEF VONPEFMPQSPQJPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFFTUBDPODSFUBDPNQFUFODJBBVUPOØNJDBQFSEFSÓB CVFOBQBSUFEFTVTFOUJEPMPRVFBVHVSBCBTVJODPSQPSBDJØOBMNPEFMPEFmOBODJB DJØOHFOFSBMSFTVMUBOUFEFMB-0'$"NÈYJNFVOBWF[RVFMBUPUBMJEBEEFMBT$$"" 4PCSFEJDIBKVSJTQSVEFODJBDPONBZPSFTSFGFSFODJBTWJE035*;$"--&&QÈHTZTT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 44 Juan Zornoza Pérez IBCÓBOBTVNJEPDPNQFUFODJBTFONBUFSJBEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBZTØMPRVFEBCBQFO EJFOUFMBDPODSFDJØOEFMQSPDFTPEFUSBTQBTPT. 1VFTCJFOBVORVFEJDIPTUSBTQBTPTGVFSPOFGFDUJWBNFOUFBDPSEBEPTFOQB SBMFMPBMBEJTDVTJØOEFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$$""SFTVMUBOUFEF MPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''EFEFKVMJPEFQBSDJBMNFOUFNPEJmDBEPTBEF OPWJFNCSFEFMNJTNPB×PEFTEFVOQSJNFSNPNFOUPTFQSFUFOEJØRVFEJDIPNP EFMPJOUFHSBSBMPTIBTUBFOUPODFTFYJTUFOUFTQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBT DPNVOFTEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTZEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTFONBUFSJBEFTFSWJ DJPTTPDJBMFT/PPCTUBOUFQPSMPRVFBIPSBJOUFSFTBFTBJOUFHSBDJØOOPBGFDUBBMB UPUBMJEBEEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBTJOPTØMPBMPTRVF FSBOEFMBUJUVMBSJEBEEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMEFNBOFSBRVFFOMPT1SFTVQVFTUPT(F OFSBMFTEFM&TUBEPDPOUJOVBSÈOFYJTUJFOEPQBSUJEBTEFHBTUPTBOJUBSJPHFTUJPOBEBTQPS JOTUJUVDJPOFTBKFOBTBMTJTUFNBEFTFHVSJEBE4PDJBMDPNPMBTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFTBMBT FOUJEBEFTEFNVUVBMJTNPBENJOJTUSBUJWPNVUVBTQBUSPOBMFTBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBFO JOTUJUVDJPOFTQFOJUFODJBSJBTFUDMPRVFTVQPOFVOBEJTQFSTJØOEFSFDVSTPTRVFQVFEF QFSKVEJDBSMBFmDJFODJBEFM4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE36*;)6&35"(3"/"%0 ."35¶/&;QÈH 4FBDPNPGVFSFMBJOUFHSBDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBFOFMNPEFMPHF OFSBMEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$$""IBCÓBEFJODJEJSOFDFTBSJBNFOUFFOMBBSUJDVMBDJØO EFFTFNPEFMPHFOFSBMOFDFTJUBEPEFOVFWPTZNBZPSFTSFDVSTPTEBEBMBJNQPSUBO DJBEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPQÞCMJDPZUBNCJÏOEFOVFWPTDSJUFSJPTQBSBMBEJTUSJCVDJØOEF GPOEPTFOUSFMBT$$""EBEBMBQFDVMJBSJEBEEFMPTOVFWPTTFSWJDJPTUSBOTGFSJEPTZTV JONFEJBUBDPOFYJØODPOMBTBUJTGBDDJØOEFOFDFTJEBEFTGVOEBNFOUBMFTDVZBBUFODJØO EFCFQSPEVDJSTFFODPOEJDJPOFTCÈTJDBTEFJHVBMEBEFOUPEPFMUFSSJUPSJPFTQB×PM &ODVBOUPBMPQSJNFSPQSFTDJOEJFOEPJODMVTPEFMQSPQØTJUPEFJODSFNFOUBS MBDPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmTDBMEFMBT$$""RVFFOTÓNJTNPIVCJFSBKVTUJmDBEPMBBTJH OBDJØOEFOVFWPTSFDVSTPTUSJCVUBSJPTBTVmOBODJBDJØOMPDJFSUPFTRVFMPTBDVFSEPT EFM$1''FTUBCMFDFOVOBJONFEJBUBDPOFYJØOFOUSFTVBTJHOBDJØOZMBBTVODJØOEF MBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTIBTUBFMQVOUPEFRVFFOUSFTVTMÓOFBTCÈTJDBTTFJOEJDB RVFiQBSBQPEFSBTVNJSMBDFTJØOEFM*7"ZMPT*NQVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFTEFGBCSJDBDJØO BTÓ DPNP MB DFTJØO EFM *NQVFTUP TPCSF MB &MFDUSJDJEBE Z EFM *NQVFTUP &TQFDJBM TP CSF%FUFSNJOBEPT.FEJPTEF5SBOTQPSUFZEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSF7FOUBT.JOPSJTUBTEF $PJODJEFOUFTFOFTFTFOUJEP$"#"4²4+.QÈH(".";0"-#*--04(0/;«-&; QÈH.0/5&30(3"/"%04ZPUSPTQÈH(".";0(":6#04"º6%0QÈH Z-»1&;$"4"4/07"4QÈH -PTUSBTQBTPTTFGPSNBMJ[BSPOFGFDUJWBNFOUFFOMPT3FBMFT%FDSFUPTBUPEPTFMMPTEF EFEJDJFNCSFDPOWBMPSBDJPOFTEFMPTUSBTQBTPTRVFPGSFDFFM.*/*45&3*0%&4"/*%"%:$0/ 46.0QÈHDVBESP 4FHÞOMPTEBUPTEFM.*/*45&3*0%&4"/*%"%:$0/46.0QÈHDVBESPFMHBTUPQÞCMJ DPTBOJUBSJPHFTUJPOBEPQPSMB"ENJOJTUSBDJØO(FOFSBMEFM&TUBEPBTDFOEJØFOUSBTMBmOBMJ[BDJØO EFMPTUSBTQBTPTBMQPSEFMHBTUPUPUBM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 45 %FUFSNJOBEPT)JESPDBSCVSPTTFSÈDPOEJDJØOOFDFTBSJBUFOFSUSBTQBTBEPTMPTTFSWJDJPT EFHFTUJØOEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMw3FTVMUBQVFTFWJEFOUFRVF MPTOVFWPTSFDVSTPTRVFTFQPOFOBEJTQPTJDJØOEFMBT$$""MPTPOQBSBMBmOBODJB DJØOEFTVTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTZEFTFSWJDJPTTPDJBMFTÈSFBTRVFQBSFDFODPOTJ EFSBSTFFTQFDJBMNFOUFTFOTJCMFTEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBJHVBMEBEQPSMPRVFGSFOUF BMBTFYJHFODJBTEFMBBVUPOPNÓBmOBODJFSBRVFIVCJFSBOSFDMBNBEPMBJOUFHSBDJØOEF MPTSFDVSTPTEFTUJOBEPTBMBTBOJEBEFOFMCMPRVFEFMBmOBODJBDJØOJODPOEJDJPOBEB $"#"4²4)*5"QÈH DPOFMmOEFRVFMBT$$""QVEJFSBOFTUBCMFDFSTVT QSPQJBTQPMÓUJDBTFOMBNBUFSJBMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''IBOPQUBEPQPSFTUBCMFDFSVO FMFWBEPHSBEPEFDPOEJDJPOBMJEBEBGFDUBOEPBMBHFTUJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBVO JNQPSUBOUFWPMVNFOEFSFDVSTPTEFMBT$$""DPNPGPSNBoTFHÞOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM $1''oEFIBDFSQPTJCMFMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEFMBHFTUJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBNBOUF OJFOEPBMUJFNQPMBTDPOEJDJPOFTOFDFTBSJBTQBSBFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBDPNQFUFODJBFYDMV TJWBEFM&TUBEPTPCSFFMSÏHJNFOFDPOØNJDPEFMBTFHVSJEBETPDJBMBSU$& &ODVBOUPBMPTFHVOEPMBBQSPYJNBDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOHFOFSBMBVODSJ UFSJPQPCMBDJPOBMGBDJMJUBCBTJOEVEBFMFNQMFPEFDSJUFSJPTVOJUBSJPTQBSBMBEJTUSJCV DJØOEFVOBmOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBJOUFHSBM-»1&;$"4"4/07"4QÈH 4JOFNCBSHPMBBQBSFOUFVOJEBEEFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOOPIBJNQFEJEP MBDPOTBHSBDJØOEFDSJUFSJPTEJGFSFODJBEPTQBSBMBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFMPTEJTUJOUPTGPOEPT FORVFTFEJWJEFMBmOBODJBDJØOBQFSDJCJSQPSMBT$$""MPRVFEJmDVMUBFMMPHSPEF MBEFTFBCMFUSBOTQBSFODJBZEFOVFWPIBDFQFOTBSRVFTFIBPQFSBEPDPOMBUSBEJDJP OBMNFUPEPMPHÓBEFBDVFSEPTQSFWJPToTPCSFMPTSFTVMUBEPTmOBODJFSPToRVFFOVO NPNFOUPQPTUFSJPSTFSFWJTUFOEFDSJUFSJPTQSFUFOEJEBNFOUFUÏDOJDPTRVFQPSFMMP EFCFOTFSOFDFTBSJBNFOUFNÞMUJQMFTZIFUFSPHÏOFPT 3.1. 4PCSF UPEP FMMP WPMWFSFNPT FO VO NPNFOUP QPTUFSJPS QVFT BOUFT EF FNJUJSVOKVJDJPTPCSFFMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØODPOWJFOFEFTDSJCJSTVFTUSVDUVSBZ GVODJPOBNJFOUPBQBSUJSOPTØMPEFMPTBDVFSEPTDJUBEPTEFM$1''TJOPEFMPTJOTUSV NFOUPTOPSNBUJWPTBUSBWÏTEFMPTDVBMFTTFIBJNQMBOUBEPFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBO DJBDJØO1PSRVFMBQSJNFSBOPWFEBEFOMBJNQMBOUBDJØOEFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBO DJBDJØOTFSFmFSFBMBUÏDOJDBMFHJTMBUJWBFNQMFBEBZBRVFGSFOUFBMDPOGVTPKVFHPEF SFMBDJPOFTZSFNJTJPOFTFOUSFMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''ZMBTMFZFTRVFEFUFSNJOBCBOTVT FGFDUPTFOUÏSNJOPTQSFTVQVFTUBSJPTRVFIFNPTDSJUJDBEPFOPUSPMVHBS3"."--0 ."44"/&5;03/0;"1²3&;QÈHTTTZFOUÏSNJOPTNÈTQSFDJTPT QÈHTTT TFIBPQUBEPFOFTUBPDBTJØOQPSJODPSQPSBSFMDPOUFOJEPEFMPTDJUB EPTBDVFSEPTBMB-FZEFEFEJDJFNCSFRVFSFHVMBMBTNFEJEBTmTDBMFTZ BENJOJTUSBUJWBTEFMOVFWPTJTUFNBEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTEF %BEPRVFDPNPEJKPMB45$EFEFNBZPVOBEFMBTGBDFUBTNFOPTDPOUSPWFSUJEBTEFMB BVUPOPNÓBmOBODJFSBEFMBT$$""FTQSFDJTBNFOUFiMBDBQBDJEBEEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFTQBSBEFmOJSTVT HBTUPTFOMPTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFTQSFTVQVFTUPTw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 46 Juan Zornoza Pérez SÏHJNFODPNÞOZEFMBT$JVEBEFTDPO&TUBUVUPEF"VUPOPNÓB-'$"FOMPTVDFTJWP TFHÞOBDMBSBTV&YQPTJDJØOEF.PUJWPTiEBEBTVWPDBDJØOEFQFSNBOFODJBw &OUPEPDBTPMBJOUSPEVDDJØOEFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOJOUFHSBEPIB SFRVFSJEPUBNCJÏOVOBSFGPSNBEFMB-0'$"RVFIBMMFWBEPBFGFDUPMB-FZ0SHÈOJDB EFEFEJDJFNCSFVOBSFGPSNBRVFFOBQBSJFODJBTØMPIBUFOJEPFODVFOUBMB JOUFHSBDJØOFOFMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTBFGFDUPTEFDPOTJEF SBSMPTDPNPTFSWJDJPTQÞCMJDPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTDVZPOJWFMNÓOJNPEFCFTFSHBSBOUJ[BEP QPSFM&TUBEPBUSBWÏTEFMBTBTJHOBDJPOFTEFOJWFMBDJØOBRVFTFSFmFSFFMUFYUPNPEJm DBEPEFMBSUEFMB-0'$"/PPCTUBOUFDPNPMVFHPWFSFNPTUBNCJÏOFYJTUFOPUSBT NFEJEBTEJSFDUBNFOUFDPOFDUBEBTDPOMBJODPSQPSBDJØOBMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMB BTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBBVORVFOPTFBEFGPSNBFYQMÓDJUB1PSRVFUBOUPFMJODSFNFOUPEFMB mOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBNFEJBOUFMBDFTJØOEFOVFWPTUSJCVUPTDPNPMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEF VO'POEPEFTVmDJFODJBBUSBWÏTEFMDVBMTFSFBMJ[BSÈMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEFMBT$$""FOMPT JOHSFTPTEFM&TUBEPRVFTPOMPTFMFNFOUPTDFOUSBMFTEFMOVFWPNPEFMPFTUÈOSFMBDJPOB EPTDPOMBJOUFHSBDJØOFOFMNJTNPEFMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTBOJEBEBVORVFMBDPOFYJØO DPOÏTUBSFTVMUBFOPDBTJPOFTNÈTWJTJCMFDPNPWFSFNPTRVFPDVSSFFOSFMBDJØOBMOVFWP *NQVFTUPTPCSFMBT7FOUBT.JOPSJTUBTEFEFUFSNJOBEPT)JESPDBSCVSPT*7.) DVZBDF TJØOTØMPQVFEFBTVNJSTFoDPNPEJDFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''oTJTFUJFOFOUSBTQBTBEPT MPTTFSWJDJPTEFHFTUJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBM -BJODPSQPSBDJØOEJSFDUBEFMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''BMBMFZRVFIBSFRVFSJEP VOBQSFWJBSFGPSNBEFMB-0'$"TVQPOFVOBDJFSUBNFKPSBFODVBOUPBMBUÏDOJDB MFHJTMBUJWB USBEJDJPOBMNFOUF FNQMFBEB FO NBUFSJB EF mOBODJBDJØO BVUPOØNJDB 4JO FNCBSHPOPTFIBODPOTFHVJEPEFFTFNPEPMPTPCKFUJWPTEFFTUBCJMJEBEQSFUFOEJ EPTQVFTMPTDSJUFSJPTQBSBFMSFQBSUPEFMBmOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBTJHVFOQSFWJTUPT FOVOBMFZPSEJOBSJBoMB-'$"oRVFQBSBOBEBWJODVMBBMMFHJTMBEPSQPTUFSJPSRVF FODPOTFDVFODJBFOMBTQPTUFSJPSFTMFZFTEFQSFTVQVFTUPTQPESÓBNPEJmDBSMPTPJH OPSBSMPToFOVOBTVFSUFEFEFSPHBDJØOUÈDJUBoTJORVFEFTEFFMQVOUPEFWJTUBEFMB UFPSÓBEFMBTGVFOUFTTFIVCJFSBJODVSSJEPFOOJOHÞOUJQPEFWJDJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM1PS FMMP IVCJFSB SFTVMUBEP QSFGFSJCMF RVF EJDIPT DSJUFSJPT RVFEBSBO FTUBCMFDJEPT FO MB -0'$"EFNPEPRVFEJDIBOPSNBoJOUFHSBEBFOFMCMPRVFEFMBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEo DPODSFUBSBZDPNQMFUBSBNFEJBOUFDSJUFSJPTHFOFSBMFTZQSBDUJDBCMFTWJODVMBOUFTQBSB FMMFHJTMBEPSMPTDPODFQUPTKVSÓEJDPTJOEFUFSNJOBEPTRVFTPCSFMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT $$""ZMBTPMJEBSJEBEFOUSFMBTNJTNBTFTUBCMFDFMB$POTUJUVDJØOQPSRVFEFFTF NPEP IVCJFSB RVFEBEP MFHBMNFOUF HBSBOUJ[BEB MB OFDFTBSJB FTUBCJMJEBE EFM OVFWP NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØORVFDPNPFTPCWJPOPEFQFOEFEFTVNBZPSPNFOPSEVSB DJØOUFNQPSBMTJOPEFTVDPOmHVSBDJØOOPSNBUJWB 3.2. &T FO UPEP DBTP MB -'$" MB EJTQPTJDJØO RVF oBM FMFWBS B SBOHP MFHBM MPT BDVFSEPT EFM $1''o FTUBCMFDF Z SFHVMB MPT FMFNFOUPT RVF JOUFHSBO FM OVFWP NPEFMP EF "FMMPBQVOUBOMPTBSHVNFOUPTEF035*;$"--&QÈHTTTZ"+"'&3/«/%&;QÈHTTT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 47 mOBODJBDJØOVONPEFMPRVFFOMPRVFBIPSBOPTJOUFSFTBEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBm OBODJBDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBQSFTFOUBBMHVOBTTJOHVMBSJEBEFTRVFDPOWJFOFEFTUBDBS "TÓFOQSJNFSMVHBSQFTFBRVFFMNPEFMPQSFUFOEFJOUFHSBSMBmOBODJBDJØO DPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMBUPUBMJEBEEFDPNQFUFODJBTZTFSWJDJPTUSBOTGFSJEPTBMBT$$""TF EJTUJOHVFFOUSFEJWFSTPTCMPRVFTDPNQFUFODJBMFTBFGFDUPTEFEJDIBmOBODJBDJØODPO FMPCKFUJWPEFFTUBCMFDFSEFNBOFSBTFQBSBEBMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFHBTUPRVFHFOFSBTV HFTUJØO&TBTnecesidades de financiaciónDVZBQFSDFQDJØOHBSBOUJ[BBMBT$$""MB TVmDJFODJBFTUÈUJDBFRVJWBMFOBMHBTUPFGFDUVBEPFOFMFKFSDJDJPEFRVFTFUPNB DPNP SFGFSFODJB P CBTF B FGFDUPT EF DÈMDVMP BSU -'$" EF VO DBMDVMP RVF TF FGFDUÞBEFNBOFSBEJGFSFODJBEBTFHÞOCMPRVFTDPNQFUFODJBMFTQBSBTFQBSBSMBTDPN QFUFODJBTDPNVOFTMBHFTUJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE 4PDJBMZMBEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTPDJBMFTBSU-'$" $FOUSÈOEPOPTFOMPRVFBIPSBJOUFSFTBBMDPJODJEJSMBBQSPCBDJØOEFMOVFWP NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØODPOFMUSBTQBTPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTTPOEPTMPT CMPRVFTRVFJOUFHSBOMBNBTBEFmOBODJBDJØODPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBUBMFTDPNQFUFODJBT QVFTQPSVOMBEPIBEFUPNBSTFFODPOTJEFSBDJØOMBmOBODJBDJØOSFTVMUBOUFEFMB MJRVJEBDJØOEFmOJUJWBEFMB×PCBTFEFQBSBMBT$$""DPODPNQFUFODJBTBTVNJ EBTNJFOUSBTRVFQPSPUSPEFCFDPNQVUBSTFiFMJNQPSUFEFMBmOBODJBDJØOSFTVMUBO UFwQBSBMBTSFTUBOUFT$$""JOUFHSBEBTFOFMCMPRVFi*/4"-6%HFTUJØOEJSFDUBwBSU -'$" "TÓEFUFSNJOBEBMBNBTBIPNPHÏOFBEFmOBODJBDJØODPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMBT DPNQFUFODJBT TBOJUBSJBT QPS SFGFSFODJB B VO FKFSDJDJP DVZB FMFDDJØO OP QBSFDF RVF QVFEBDPOTJEFSBSTFDBTVBMTVEJTUSJCVDJØOFOUSFMBTEJTUJOUBT$$""TFSFBMJ[BBUSBWÏT EFVO'POEPHFOFSBMZWBSJPT'POEPTFTQFDÓmDPTDVZBMØHJDBFTEJWFSTBZFOMB[BDPO MBEFMPTGPOEPTZBFYJTUFOUFTFOFMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJB SFTVMUBOUFEFMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''EFEFOPWJFNCSFEF 1PSMPRVFTFSFmFSFBMEFOPNJOBEPFondo generalJOUFSFTBEFTUBDBSRVFTV SFHVMBDJØOJODPSQPSBMBUSBEJDJPOBMHBSBOUÓBEFNÓOJNPTUFOEFOUFBGBDJMJUBSMBBDFQ UBDJØOEFMOVFWPNPEFMPQPSQBSUFEF$PNVOJEBEFTRVFQVEJFSBOWFSSFEVDJEBTV mOBODJBDJØOBMBTFHVSBSMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''RVFiMBmOBODJBDJØOBTJHOBEBBDBEB $PNVOJEBE"VUØOPNBQPSFM'POEP(FOFSBMyTFBBMNFOPTJHVBMBMBRVFDBEBVOB EFFMMBTUJFOFBTJHOBEByw6OBHBSBOUÓBRVFTFDPODSFUBFOMB%JTQPTJDJØO5SBOTJUP SJBTFHVOEBEFMB-'$"FODVZBWJSUVEi& M&TUBEPHBSBOUJ[BBMBT$PNVOJEBEFT "VUØOPNBTRVFUFOHBOBTVNJEBMBHFTUJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEF MB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMRVFMBmOBODJBDJØOEFEJDIPTTFSWJDJPTFOFMB×PTFSÈDPNP NÓOJNPMBPCUFOJEBFOFMÞMUJNPB×PEFMTJTUFNBWJHFOUFwZRVFBERVJFSFQBSUJDVMBS JNQPSUBODJB QPSRVF GSFOUF BM FNQMFP FYDMVTJWP EFM DSJUFSJP EF MB QPCMBDJØO QSPUF HJEBRVFDPOTBHSØMB-(4FMOVFWPNPEFMPFTUBCMFDFUSFTDSJUFSJPTEJTUJOUPTQBSBMB EJTUSJCVDJØOEFM'POEPHFOFSBMDVZPKVFHPQPESÓBBMUFSBSMBQPTJDJØOSFMBUJWBEFMBT EJTUJOUBT$$"":FTRVFMBQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBDBMDVMBEBQPSSFGFSFODJBBMWBMPSEF MBNJTNBQBSBTFHÞOMBTFTUBEÓTUJDBTFMBCPSBEBTQPSFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BOJEBE Z$POTVNPQPOEFSBFYDMVTJWBNFOUFVOQPSDPSSFTQPOEJFOEPVOQPS RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 48 Juan Zornoza Pérez BMDSJUFSJPEFQPCMBDJØONBZPSEFTFTFOUBZDJODPB×PTNJFOUSBTRVFFMQPS SFTUBOUFTFEJTUSJCVJSÈTFHÞOMBWBSJBCMFEFJOTVMBSJEBEBSU#B-'$" MPRVF IBQSPEVDJEPiMBSFPSEFOBDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOper cápitaFOUSF$$""MBTBOUJHVBT DPOMBTOVFWBTHFTUPSBTTJORVFTFBEJWJOFOJOHÞOQBUSØOSFEJTUSJCVUJWPDMBSPw-» 1&;$"4"4/07"4QÈH &T DJFSUP RVF MPT OVFWPT DSJUFSJPT TF FODVFOUSBO SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO GBDUPSFT HFOFSBMNFOUFDPOTJEFSBEPTDPNPEFUFSNJOBOUFTEFMBGBDUVSBTBOJUBSJB(".";0 (":6#04"º6%0QBHT QFSPOPMPFTNFOPTRVFMBGBMUBEFFTUV EJPTQSFWJPTTPCSFMPTFGFDUPTSFTVMUBOUFTEFMBBQMJDBDJØOEFEJDIPTDSJUFSJPTQFSNJUF NBOUFOFSRVFiMBVUJMJ[BDJØOZMBQPOEFSBDJØOEFFTUBTWBSJBCMFTEFSFQBSUPOPQVFEFO KVTUJmDBSTFDPODSJUFSJPTUÏDOJDPTBDFQUBCMFTOJDPNPDPOTFDVFODJBEFVOQSPDFTPEF BQSPYJNBDJØOBMPTDPNQPOFOUFTEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPFOGVODJØOEFMBFEBETJOPTJN QMFNFOUFQPSSB[POFTEFSFTVMUBEPw36*;)6&35"(3"/"%0."35¶/&; QÈH EFVOSFTVMUBEPRVFQSFUFOEÓBHBSBOUJ[BSMBBDFQUBDJØOVOÈOJNFEFMOVFWP NPEFMPZRVFQPSFMMPOPTØMPTVQVTPVOJNQPSUBOUFDPTUFBEJDJPOBMTJOPRVFSF TVMUBEJGÓDJMEFKVTUJmDBSQVFTMPTSFTVMUBEPTFOUÏSNJOPTEFmOBODJBDJØOper cápita PC UFOJEBQPSMBTEJTUJOUBT$$""OPTFBUJFOFOBOJOHÞOQBUSØOEFEJTUSJCVDJØODMBSP. 1FTFBRVFFTBGPSNBEFPQFSBSSFTVMUBJOKVTUJmDBCMFZQSPEVDFFGFDUPTQFSWFSTPTTPCSF FMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOMPDJFSUPFTRVFQVFEFDPNQSFOEFSTFTJTFUJFOFFODVFOUB RVFMBJOUFHSBDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBFOFMNPEFMPHFOFSBMEFmOBODJBDJØOTF IBQSPEVDJEPFOQBSBMFMPBMQSPDFTPEFUSBTQBTPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTBWB SJBT$PNVOJEBEFT1PSRVFFOMPTUSBEJDJPOBMFTQSPDFTPTEFUSBTQBTPEFDPNQFUFODJBT MBOFHPDJBDJØOFOUSFFM&TUBEPZDBEB$PNVOJEBETFDFOUSBCBFOMBEFUFSNJOBDJØO EFMDPTUFFGFDUJWPEFMPTTFSWJDJPTUSBOTGFSJEPTRVFQPTUFSJPSNFOUFTFJOUFHSBCBFOFM NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØONJFOUSBTRVFFOFMDBTPEFMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEFMPTTFSWJDJPT EFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBBMJODPSQPSBSTFEJSFDUBNFOUFTVmOBODJBDJØOBMOVFWPNPEFMP FOFMNPNFOUPEFDBMDVMBSMBTOFDFTJEBEFTIPNPHÏOFBTEFmOBODJBDJØOMBEJTDVTJØO 4FHÞOMBQPCMBDJØONBZPSEFTFTFOUBZDJODPEFM1BESØOFMBCPSBEPQPSFM*/&QBSBDBEB$PNVOJEBE BEFFOFSPEF $VZBBTJHOBDJØOTFFGFDUÞBQSPQPSDJPOBMNFOUFBMBEJTUBODJBFOLJMØNFUSPTQPOEFSBEBQPSUSBNPT FOUSFMBTDPTUBTEFMBQFOÓOTVMBZMBTDBQJUBMFTJOTVMBSFTTFHÞOMBJOGPSNBDJØOEFM$FOUSP/BDJPOBMEF *OGPSNBDJØO(FPHSÈmDBEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF'PNFOUP -»1&;$"4"4/07"4QÈHMPDJGSBFOUPSOPBMPTEPTNJMNJMMPOFTEFFVSPT -PTEBUPTEFM.*/*45&3*0%&4"/*%"%:$0/46.0QÈHTZTTDVBESPTPCSFQSF TVQVFTUPJOJDJBMQPSQFSTPOBQSPUFHJEBZB×PFOBSSPKBOVOBNFEJBEFèQFSPFYJTUFVOB JNQPSUBOUFEJTQFSTJØOQVFTFMQSFTVQVFTUPper cápitaPTDJMBFOUSFMPTèEF-B3JPKBMPTEF MB$PNVOJEBE/BWBSSBPMPTèEF$BOUBCSJBZMPTèEFMBT*TMBT#BMFBSFTPMPTèEFMB $PNVOJEBE7BMFODJBOBTJORVFTFBODMBSBTMBTSB[POFTRVFQVFEFOFYQMJDBSMBCSFDIBFYJTUFOUFFOUSF EJDIBT$$""QFTFBRVFTJFTFWJEFOUFDPNPFYQSFTBNFOUFTFEJDFQÈH RVFMBTRVFQSFTVQVFT UBONBZPSHBTUPTPOQSFDJTBNFOUFMBTEFNFOPSQPCMBDJØO-BJOGPSNBDJØOSFMBUJWBBMFKFSDJDJPEF BDDFTJCMFFOMBQÈHJOBEF*OUFSOFUEFM.JOJTUFSJPBVNFOUBOMBEJTUBODJBFYJTUFOUFFOUSFMB$PNVOJEBE DPONBZPSQSFTVQVFTUPper cápitaRVFTFSÓB-B3JPKBDPOèZMBEFNFOPSQSFTVQVFTUPRVF TFSÓBMB$PNVOJEBEEFMBT*TMBT#BMFBSFTDPOèRVFFYQFSJNFOUBVOEFTDFOTPEFMQPS SFTQFDUPBMB×PBOUFSJPS RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 49 TPCSFFMDPTUFFGFDUJWPDBSFDÓBEFSFMFWBODJBZTFUFSNJOBCBDPOWJSUJFOEPFOVOBEJTDV TJØOTPCSFFMSFTVMUBEPmOBODJFSPEFMNPEFMPQSJNFSPFOMPSFMBUJWPBMBmOBODJBDJØO EFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBZFOTVDBTPWBMPSBEPFOTVDPOKVOUP +VOUPBMDJUBEP'POEPHFOFSBMFMBSU# D EFMB-'$"FTUBCMFDFEPTFondos específicosRVFBUJFOEFOQPSVOMBEPBmOBODJBSMPTQSPHSBNBTZNFEJEBTEJSJHJEBTBM DPOUSPMEFMHBTUPSFMBUJWPBMBJODBQBDJEBEUFNQPSBMBTÓDPNPBMBNFKPSBEFMBHFTUJØO EFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBQBSBFTUBDPOUJOHFODJBZQPSPUSPBMBHBSBOUÓBEF MBJHVBMEBEFOMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBQÞCMJDPT FOUPEPFMUFSSJUPSJPFTQB×PMZMBBUFODJØOBDJVEBEBOPTEFTQMB[BEPTEFMB6OJØO&VSP QFBPEFQBÓTFTDPOMPTRVFFYJTUBDPOWFOJPEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBSFDÓQSPDB &MQSJNFSPEFFMMPTFondo “Programa de ahorro en incapacidad temporal” TFFODVFOUSBWJODVMBEPoDPNPTVOPNCSFJOEJDBoBMEFTBSSPMMPEFBDUVBDJPOFTUFOEFOUFT BMDPOUSPMEFMGSBVEFFYJTUFOUFSFTQFDUPBMBTTJUVBDJPOFTEFJODBQBDJEBEUFNQPSBMQPSMP RVFFNQBSFOUBEJSFDUBNFOUFDPOMBTNFEJEBTQSFWJTUBTFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''EF EFOPWJFNCSFEFRVFZBDPOUFNQMBCBONFEJEBTEFBIPSSPSFMBDJPOBEBTDPOFTUF UJQPEFBDUVBDJPOFTRVFSFWFSUJSÓBOFOMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBTFHÞOTFFTUBCMFDFBIPSB FOFMBSU# D EFMB-'$"RVFFYQSFTBNFOUFQSFWÏRVFFMJNQPSUFEFFTUF'POEPoDVZB EPUBDJØODPJODJEÓBJOJDJBMNFOUFDPOMBEFFTUFQSPHSBNBFOFKFSDJDJPTQSFDFEFOUFToiFTUÈ JOUFHSBEPFOMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFmOBODJBDJØOQBSBDBEB$PNVOJEBE"VUØOPNBw 1PS TV QBSUF FM EFOPNJOBEP Fondo de cohesión sanitaria TF EJTF×B FO FM DJUBEPQSFDFQUPEFMB-'$"DPOMBBNCJDJPTBmOBMJEBEEFiHBSBOUJ[BSMBJHVBMEBEEF BDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBFOUPEPFMUFSSJUPSJPFTQB×PMZMBBUFODJØO BDJVEBEBOPTEFTQMB[BEPTQSPDFEFOUFTEFQBÓTFTEFMB6OJØO&VSPQFBPEFQBÓTFTDPO MPTRVF&TQB×BUFOHBTVTDSJUPTDPOWFOJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBSFDÓQSPDBw4FUSBUBEF VO'POEPMMBNBEPBBTVNJSMBTGVODJPOFTEFMBOUJHVPGPOEPEFiEFTQMB[BEPTwDPOUFN QMBEPFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''EFEFOPWJFNCSFEFQFSPDVZBJNQPSUBODJB TFIBRVFSJEPSFBM[BSFOMB-FZEFEFNBZPEFDPIFTJØOZDBMJEBEEFM 4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVEBMBUSJCVJSMFoOJNÈTOJNFOPToMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTQP MÓUJDBTRVFBTFHVSFOMBDPIFTJØOTBOJUBSJBZMBDPSSFDDJØOEFEFTJHVBMEBEFTmOBMJEBEFT IBSUPBNCJDJPTBTQBSBVOBEPUBDJØOWBSJBCMFZRVFIBFWPMVDJPOBEPBMBCBKB36*; )6&35"(3"/"%0."35¶/&;QÈH TJORVFTVTDSJUFSJPTEFEJTUSJCVDJØO TFFODVFOUSFOMFHBMNFOUFQSFEFUFSNJOBEPTZBRVFMB-'$"MPTEJmFSFoDPNPMPTEFM PUSP'POEPFTQFDÓmDPNFODJPOBEPoBVOBGVUVSBiSFHVMBDJØOFTQFDÓmDBwRVFNVDIP OPTUFNFNPTTBMWPFOMPSFMBUJWPBMBHFTUJØOEFEFTQMB[BEPTRVFIBTJEPZBPCKFUPEF SFHVMBDJØODPOUJOVBSÈDPOTUJUVZFOEPMBWÈMWVMBEFBKVTUFPÞMUJNPSFNFEJPQBSBBUFO -PTEBUPTEFM.*/*45&3*0%&4"/*%"%:$0/46.0QÈHTPOFTDMBSFDFEPSFTQVFTEF VOBEPUBDJØOJOJDJBMEFNJMMPOFTEFFVSPTFOFMQSFTVQVFTUPEFTFEJTUSJCVZFSPOTØMP NJMMPOFTZTJHVJFOEPFTBTFOEBEFTDFOEFOUFFOTFQSFTVQVFTUBSPOTØMPNJMMPOFTEFFVSPT 1PSFM3FBM%FDSFUPEFEFEJDJFNCSFQPSFMRVFTFSFHVMBMBHFTUJØOEFM'POEPEFDP IFTJØOTBOJUBSJBRVFTFMJNJUBBEJTUSJCVJSMBDPNQFOTBDJØOEFM'POEPQPSBTJTUFODJBBEFTQMB[BEPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 50 Juan Zornoza Pérez EFSBMBTEFNBOEBTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFTRVFTJOUJÏOEPTFQFSKVEJDBEBT QPSFMOVFWPNPEFMPEJTQPOHBOEFTVmDJFOUFDBQBDJEBEEFQSFTJØOQPMÓUJDB &OUPEPDBTPDPOWJFOFSFTBMUBSRVFMBHFTUJØOEFBNCPT'POEPTFTQFDÓmDPT DPOUJOÞBDFOUSBMJ[BEBFOFMQSJNFSPEFFMMPTFOMB5FTPSFSÓB(FOFSBMEFMB4FHVSJEBE 4PDJBMRVFBMUFOFSFODPNFOEBEBMBQVSBiHFTUJØOmOBODJFSBwMJNJUBSÈTVTGVODJPOFT BMMJCSBNJFOUPEFMPTDSÏEJUPTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFTBMPTQSPHSBNBTJODMVJEPTFOFMNJTNP ZFOFMTFHVOEPEFFMMPTFOFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BOJEBEZ$POTVNPRVFBTVNFGVODJP OFTRVFWBONVDIPNÈTBMMÈEFMBTJNQMFHFTUJØOmOBODJFSBBMUSBUBSTFEFVO'POEP DVZBTmOBMJEBEFTSFRVJFSFOMBJOUFSWFODJØOEFM&TUBEPDPNPHBSBOUFEFMBJHVBMEBECÈ TJDBEFMPTDJVEBEBOPTFOFMBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPTBOJUBSJPTEBEBTVDPOFYJØOoDVBOEP NFOPToDPOMPTEFSFDIPTEFEVDJCMFTEFMPTBSUTZEFMB$POTUJUVDJØO:OPQVFEF EFKBSEFTF×BMBSTFBFTUFSFTQFDUPMPBOØNBMPRVFSFTVMUBFTFQSPUBHPOJTNPHFTUPSEFM &TUBEPVOBWF[mOBMJ[BEPFMQSPDFTPEFUSBOTGFSFODJBTQVFTFODPNFOEBEBBMBT$$"" MBHFTUJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBBM&TUBEPMFJODVNCFFOFTUFÈNCJUPGVOEBNFO UBMNFOUF VOB GVODJØO FTUSBUÏHJDB RVF QVFEF EFTFNQF×BS NFEJBOUF FM SFDVSTP B MBT DPNQFUFODJBTMFHJTMBUJWBTZEFDPPSEJOBDJØORVFMB$POTUJUVDJØOMFBUSJCVZF7"26&3 $"#"--&3¶"QÈH QFSPOPBTVNJFOEPEJSFDUBNFOUFVOBHFTUJØORVFOPMF DPSSFTQPOEFOJTJRVJFSBCBKPMBDPCFSUVSBEFMUÓUVMPiHFTUJØOFDPOØNJDBEFMB4FHVSJEBE 4PDJBMwRVFQBSFDFTFHVJSTFFNQMFBOEPBFTUPTFGFDUPTQPSTVNBZPSJOUFOTJEBESFMBUJWB RVFMPTRVFFM&TUBEPPTUFOUBEJSFDUBNFOUFTPCSFMBNBUFSJBTBOJEBE "TÓTFDPNQSVFCBFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''RVFFTHSJNFOEJDIPUÓUVMPQBSB KVTUJmDBSFMEFOPNJOBEPiQSJODJQJPEFBGFDUBDJØOwDPOGPSNFBMDVÈMMBT$$""RVFEB SÈOPCMJHBEBTBiEFTUJOBSBMBHFTUJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBM VOEFUFSNJOBEPWPMVNFOEFTVTSFDVSTPTwMPRVFBTVWF[PCMJHBBRVFiFTBmOBO DJBDJØOBQBSF[DBEJGFSFODJBEBZDPOEJDJPOBEBBMBmOBMJEBEQFSTFHVJEBwQBSBRVFMBT $$""EFTUJOFOFOUPEPDBTPBMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMBTFHVSJEBETPDJBMVONÓOJNP FRVJWBMFOUFBMSFTVMUBEPEFBQMJDBSFMÓOEJDF*5&OBDJPOBM*5&OFOBEFMBOUF BMBT OFDFTJEBEFTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTEFUFSNJOBEBTQBSBFMB×P CBTFEF&JNQVFTUBUBMPCMJHBDJØORVFTFGPSNBMJ[BFOFMBSUEFMB-'$" QBSBGBDJMJUBSTVDVNQMJNJFOUPJODMVTPFOFMDBTPEFRVFMBFWPMVDJØOEFMPTSFDVSTPT EFMBT$$""OPGVFSBTBUJTGBDUPSJBHFOFSBOEPUFOTJPOFTmOBODJFSBTMPTBDVFSEPTEFM $1''HBSBOUJ[BOBMBT$$""EVSBOUFMPTUSFTQSJNFSPTB×PTEFWJHFODJBEFMNPEFMP RVFMPTJOHSFTPTBGFDUBEPTBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFFTUBTDPNQFUFODJBTFYQFSJNFOUBSÈOVO SFTJEFOUFTFO&TQB×BPBDBSHPEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTEFPUSP&TUBEP ¶OEJDF*5&OEFmOJEPFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''DPNPJOEJDBEPSOBDJPOBMEFMPTJOHSFTPTUSJCVUBSJPT EFM&TUBEPZDPOUPEBQSFDJTJØOFOFMBSUEFMB-'$"DPNPiMBSFDBVEBDJØOFTUBUBMFYDMVJEB MBTVTDFQUJCMFEFDFTJØOBMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTQPS*31'*7"ZMPT*NQVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFTEF GBCSJDBDJØOTPCSFMB$FSWF[BTPCSFFM7JOPZ#FCJEBTGFSNFOUBEBTTPCSF1SPEVDUPT*OUFSNFEJPTTPCSF "MDPIPMZ#FCJEBT%FSJWBEBTTPCSF)JESPDBSCVSPTZTPCSF-BCPSFTEFM5BCBDPw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 51 DSFDJNJFOUPBMNFOPTJHVBMBMBiFWPMVDJØOEFM1*/OPNJOBMBQSFDJPTEFNFSDBEPw HBSBOUJ[BOEPBTÓMBTVmDJFODJBEJOÈNJDBEFMNPEFMP 3.3.%FUFSNJOBEBTMBTOFDFTJEBEFTmOBODJFSBTEFMBT$$""QBSBMBBUFODJØOB TVTEJTUJOUPTCMPRVFTDPNQFUFODJBMFTUBOUPMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''DPNPFMBSUEFMB -'$"FTUBCMFDFORVFiTFmOBODJBSÈODPOUPEPTMPTSFDVSTPTEFMTJTUFNBFOTVWBMPSFTEFM B×PwRVFTFSFMBDJPOBOTJOBTJHOBDJØOFTQFDÓmDBBEJDIPTCMPRVFTDPNQFUFODJBMFT "EFNÈTEFMPTUSJCVUPTDFEJEPTUSBEJDJPOBMFTZEFMBUBSJGBBVUPOØNJDBEFM *31'MBTOVFWBTZNBZPSFTOFDFTJEBEFTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFUFSNJOBEBTQPSMBHFOFSBMJ [BDJØOEFMUSBTQBTPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTIBOEBEPMVHBSBRVFTFQSPEV[DBO OPWFEBEFTSFMFWBOUFTFODVBOUPBMPTrecursos financierosFNQMFBEPTFOFMOVFWP NPEFMP&OFTUFTFOUJEPBMBDFTJØOUPUBMEFMBSFDBVEBDJØOEFMPTUSJCVUPTDFEJEPT USBEJDJPOBMFT *NQVFTUP TPCSF FM 1BUSJNPOJP *NQVFTUP EF 5SBOTNJTJPOFT 1BUSJNP OJBMFTZ"DUPT+VSÓEJDPT%PDVNFOUBEPT*NQVFTUPTPCSF4VDFTJPOFTZ%POBDJPOFTZ 5SJCVUPTTPCSFFMKVFHP TFIBVOJEPMBEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSF%FUFSNJOBEPT.FEJPTEF 5SBOTQPSUFZMBEFMOVFWP*NQVFTUPTPCSF7FOUBT.JOPSJTUBTEF%FUFSNJOBEPT)JESP DBSCVSPTVOBmHVSBOPWFEPTBDVZBDPNQBUJCJMJEBEDPOMB%JSFDUJWB$&&EF *NQVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFTTØMPFTQPTJCMFFOMBNFEJEBFORVFTFMFBTJHOFOmOBMJEBEFTFT QFDÓmDBTEFNPEPRVFOPUFOHBPCKFUJWPTQSJODJQBMNFOUFQSFTVQVFTUBSJPTZTFBFYJ HJCMFÞOJDBNFOUFFOMBQVFTUBBMDPOTVNP%FMNJTNPNPEPBMBDFTJØOQBSDJBM QPS EFM*31'QMBTNBEBFOMBSFHVMBDJØOEFTVUBSJGBBVUPOØNJDBTFIBWFOJEPB BHSFHBSMBDFTJØOUBNCJÏOQBSDJBMEFMBSFDBVEBDJØOMÓRVJEBFOFMUFSSJUPSJPEFDBEB $PNVOJEBEQPSFM*7"QPS ZQPSMPTUSBEJDJPOBMFT*NQVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFTEF 'BCSJDBDJØOQPSEFMBSFDBVEBDJØOMÓRVJEBQPSMPT*NQVFTUPTTPCSFMB$FSWF [BTPCSFFM7JOPZ#FCJEBT'FSNFOUBEBTTPCSF1SPEVDUPT*OUFSNFEJPTTPCSF"MDPIPM Z#FCJEBT%FSJWBEBTTPCSF)JESPDBSCVSPTZTPCSF-BCPSFTEFM5BCBDP BEFNÈTEFMB EFMQPSEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSFMB&MFDUSJDJEBE:QPSmODVCSJFOEPMBGVODJØO SFTJEVBMEFDPCFSUVSBEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFHBTUPOPBUFOEJEBTNFEJBOUFMPTSFDVSTPT USJCVUBSJPTRVFIBORVFEBEPFOVNFSBEPTTFTJUÞBFMEFOPNJOBEP'POEPEFTVm DJFODJBRVFOPFTNÈTRVFFMJOTUSVNFOUPBUSBWÏTEFMDVBMMBT$$""Z$JVEBEFTDPO &TUBUVUPEF"VUPOPNÓBQBSUJDJQBSÈOFOMPTJOHSFTPTEFM&TUBEP "VORVFQPSSB[POFTPCWJBTFODVBOUPOPTBQBSUBSÓBEFMBMÓOFBBSHVNFOUBM RVFWFOJNPTEFTBSSPMMBOEPOPFTFTUFFMNPNFOUPEFBOBMJ[BSEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWB FTUSJDUBNFOUFmOBODJFSBMBPQPSUVOJEBEEFMFNQMFPEFFTUPTSFDVSTPTZMBTSFHMBTB 1SFDJTBNFOUFQPSFMMPFMBSUVOPEFMB-FZEFEFEJDJFNCSFEFNFEJEBT'JTDBMFT "ENJOJTUSBUJWBTZEFM0SEFO4PDJBMRVFFTUBCMFDJØFM*NQVFTUPTF×BMBRVFTVTSFOEJNJFOUPTiRVFEBSÈO BGFDUBEPTFOTVUPUBMJEBEBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFHBTUPTEFOBUVSBMF[BTBOJUBSJBPSJFOUBEPTQPSDSJUFSJPT PCKFUJWPTmKBEPTFOFMÈNCJUPOBDJPOBMwBVORVFMBQBSUFEFSFDVSTPTEFSJWBEBEFMUJQPEFHSBWBNFO BVUPOØNJDPQPESÈFNQMFBSTFQBSBmOBODJBSBDUVBDJPOFTNFEJPBNCJFOUBMFT $BQBDJEBE mTDBM FO MPT UÏSNJOPT EFM BSU EF MB -0'$" FO SFEBDDJØO EBEB QPS MB -FZ PSHÈOJDB EFEFEJDJFNCSF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 52 Juan Zornoza Pérez RVFTFTVKFUBTVVUJMJ[BDJØOEFCFEFKBSTFDPOTUBODJBEFRVFMBBNQMJBDJØOEFMBDFTJØO EFUSJCVUPTNÈTBMMÈEFMBJNQPTJDJØOTPCSFMBSFOUBZFMQBUSJNPOJPEFMBTQFSTPOBT GÓTJDBTFTVOIFDIPQPTJUJWPRVFDPOUSJCVZFBTVQFSBSMBTEFmDJFODJBTRVFEFTEFFTUB QFSTQFDUJWB PGSFDÓB FM BOUFSJPS NPEFMP EF mOBODJBDJØO BM DFEFS GVOEBNFOUBMNFOUF mHVSBTBQPZBEBTFOFMHSBWBNFOEFDBQBDJEBEFTmTDBMFTEJSFDUBTDVZBEJTUSJCVDJØO UFSSJUPSJBM FT EFTJHVBM ;03/0;" 1²3&; QÈH /P PCTUBOUF FMMP OP TVQPOFRVFTVBSUJDVMBDJØORVFEFFYFOUBEFDSÓUJDBTQVFTFMIFDIPEFRVFMBDFTJØO EFMPTJNQVFTUPTTPCSFFMDPOTVNPOPJODMVZBQPSSB[POFTGÈDJMFTEFFOUFOEFSMB BUSJCVDJØOEFDPNQFUFODJBTOPSNBUJWBTBMBT$$""EFUFSNJOBVODJFSUPTFTHPEFM NPEFMPEBEPRVFÏTUBTOPQPESÈOJODJEJSFOMBDBSHBUSJCVUBSJBTPQPSUBEBQPSTVT DJVEBEBOPTBUSBWÏTEFEJDIBJNQPTJDJØOTBMWPFONBUFSJBEFIJESPDBSCVSPTZEF PUSP MBEP IBDF EVEBS EF RVF MB DPOTJEFSBDJØO EFM *7" Z MPT *NQVFTUPT &TQFDJBMFT DPNPUSJCVUPTDFEJEPTSFTVMUFBEFDVBEBEBEBTVTJNJMJUVEDPOMBTQBSUJDJQBDJPOFTFO MBSFDBVEBDJØOUFSSJUPSJBMJ[BEBEFEFUFSNJOBEPTJNQVFTUPT &OUPEPDBTPEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMPTSFDVSTPTmOBODJFSPTBFNQMFBSFO MBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTBOJEBEFMOVFWPNPEFMPPGSFDFBMHVOBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFTRVF DPOWJFOFSFTBMUBS1PSRVFBMWJODVMBSTFEFGPSNBFYQMÓDJUBDPOMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB MB DFTJØO EFM *7" EF MPT *NQVFTUPT &TQFDJBMFT EF GBCSJDBDJØO EFM*NQVFTUPTPCSF%FUFSNJOBEPT.FEJPTEF5SBOTQPSUFEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSFMB&MFD USJDJEBEZEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSF7FOUBT.JOPSJTUBTEF%FUFSNJOBEPT)JESPDBSCVSPTTF DPOEJDJPOBFOMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''OPTØMPBRVFMBT$$""IBZBOBDFQUBEPFMOVF WPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMRVFUBMFTSFDVSTPTGPSNBOQBSUFTJOPUBNCJÏOBRVF iUFOHBOBTVNJEBMBDPNQFUFODJBFONBUFSJBEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE 4PDJBMw&TFDPOEJDJPOBNJFOUPDVZBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBESFTVMUBEJTDVUJCMFFOVOTJTUF NBEFPSHBOJ[BDJØOUFSSJUPSJBMDPNPFMFTQB×PMCBTBEPFOFMQSJODJQJPEJTQPTJUJWPIB FODPOUSBEPUSBEVDDJØOOPSNBUJWBFOMB%JTQPTJDJØO'JOBMTFHVOEBEFMB-'$"EF BDVFSEPDPOMBDVBMiFMOVFWPTJTUFNBEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOP NBTEFSÏHJNFODPNÞOyBTÓDPNPFMOVFWPSÏHJNFOHFOFSBMEFDFTJØOEFUSJCVUPT EFM &TUBEP B MBT $PNVOJEBEFT "VUØOPNBT MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF ÏTUBT FO MB "HFODJB &TUBUBMEF"ENJOJTUSBDJØO5SJCVUBSJBZMBTBTJHOBDJPOFTEFOJWFMBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPT QÞCMJDPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTTØMPTFSÈOEFBQMJDBDJØOBMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTRVF IBZBOSFDJCJEPMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEFMPTTFSWJDJPTRVFTFmOBODJBSÈONFEJBOUFFMOVFWP TJTUFNBZFO$PNJTJØO.JYUBBDFQUFOFTUFÞMUJNPw 5BMQSFWJTJØOOPDBSFDFEFMØHJDBQVFTFTQPTJCMFRVFMPTSFDVSTPTRVFFMOVFWP NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOQSPQPSDJPOBSFTVMUBSBOFYDFTJWPTQBSBVOB$PNVOJEBERVFOP IVCJFSBBTVNJEPMBTDPNQFUFODJBTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBBMNBSHFOEFRVFFOFMDBTP 3FMBDJPOBEBTDPOTVDBSÈDUFSEFJNQVFTUPTBSNPOJ[BEPTBOJWFMFVSPQFPDPNVOJUBSJPBFMMBTNFSFGFSÓ QPSSFGFSFODJBBMPT*NQVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFTFO;03/0;"1²3&;QÈHTZTTSFDJFOUFNFOUF 36*;"-.&/%3"-QÈHTTT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 53 EFM*NQVFTUPTPCSF7FOUBT.JOPSJTUBTEF%FUFSNJOBEPT)JESPDBSCVSPTSFTVMUBCBPCMJHBEB QBSBTBMWBSTVDPNQBUJCJMJEBEDPOMB%JSFDUJWBEF*NQVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFT4JOFNCBSHPOP TFBMDBO[BBWFSMBVUJMJEBEEFTVDPOTBHSBDJØOHFOFSBMZFYQSFTBFOMB-'$"QVFTTJMB mOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBNÈTBMMÈEFMBTQSFWJTJPOFTMFHBMFTRVFMBFONBSDBOTFEFmOF FOTVTFMFNFOUPTFTFODJBMFTBUSBWÏTEFMPTBDVFSEPTEFMBT$PNJTJPOFT.JYUBTDVZBJOUFS WFODJØOFTJOTVQSJNJCMF3"."--0."44"/&5;03/0;"1²3&;QÈHT Z QBSBDPODSFUBSFMBMDBODFZDPOEJDJPOFTEFMBDFTJØOEFUSJCVUPTMBSFQSFTFO UBDJØOFTUBUBMQPESÓBIBCFSSFDIB[BEPMBDFTJØOEFMPTOVFWPTUSJCVUPTBMBT$$""RVFOP IVCJFSBOBTVNJEPMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBT:MPRVFFTQFPSBEFNÈTEFJOÞUJMMBOPS NBEFRVFTFUSBUBFTTFHVSBNFOUFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMQVFTBMDPOEJDJPOBSMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFT EFBDUVBDJØOEFMBT$PNJTJPOFT.JYUBTJODVSSFFOVOBJOGSBDDJØOEFMQSJODJQJPEJTQPTJUJWP GVOEBNFOUBMFOMBBSUJDVMBDJØOEFMNPEFMPEFPSHBOJ[BDJØOUFSSJUPSJBMEFM&TUBEPUBNCJÏO EFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBmOBODJFSBQVFTDPNPEJKPMB45$EFEFBHPTUPMPTBDVFS EPTEFMBT$PNJTJPOFT.JYUBTUJFOFOTVPSJHFOÞMUJNPFOFMBSUEFMB$POTUJUVDJØO ZQPSFMMPiOPDBCFBENJUJSRVFVOBMFZFTUBUBMQVFEBJODJEJSFOFMÈNCJUPDPNQFUFODJBM EFMBT$PNJTJPOFT.JYUBTFJNQPOFSTFBTVTBDVFSEPTw'+ 4JMBBTVODJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTTFRVJFSFDPOWFSUJSFOSFRVJTJUP sine qua non QBSB MB BUSJCVDJØO B MBT $$"" EF MPT OVFWPT USJCVUPT DFEJEPT FM FN QMFPEFFTUPTTFFODVFOUSBUBNCJÏODPOEJDJPOBEPFOUÏSNJOPTRVFOPQVFEFOQBTBS TJODPNFOUBSJP&OFGFDUPDPNPIFNPTEJDIPMPTBDVFSEPTEFM$1''DPOTBHSBOVO iQSJODJQJPEFBGFDUBDJØOwDPOGPSNFBMDVBMMBT$$""EFCFOEFTUJOBSFOUPEPDBTPBMB BTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMBTFHVSJEBETPDJBMFYDMVJEBMBQBSUFDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBM'POEP 1SPHSBNBEF"IPSSPFO*ODBQBDJEBE5FNQPSBMVONÓOJNPFRVJWBMFOUFBMSFTVMUBEP EFBQMJDBSFMÓOEJDF*5&OBMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJ UBSJBTEFUFSNJOBEBTQBSBFMB×PCBTFEFBSU-'$" :QPSTJFMMPOPGVFSB TVmDJFOUFFMQSJODJQJPEFBGFDUBDJØOEFMPTOVFWPTUSJCVUPTDFEJEPTBMBmOBODJBDJØO EFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBTFSFGVFS[BFOMPTFKFSDJDJPTEFZFOWJSUVEEFMBT %JTQPTJDJPOFT5SBOTJUPSJBTTFYUBZTÏQUJNBEFMB-'$"RVFFTUBCMFDFORVFFMSFOEJ NJFOUPDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMBDFTJØOEFMQPSEFM*7"EFMQPSEFMPT*N QVFTUPT&TQFDJBMFTEFGBCSJDBDJØOEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSFMB&MFDUSJDJEBEEFM*NQVFTUP TPCSF%FUFSNJOBEPT.FEJPTEF5SBOTQPSUFZEFM*NQVFTUPTPCSF7FOUBT.JOPSJTUBTEF %FUFSNJOBEPT)JESPDBSCVSPTTFDPOTJEFSBSÈDPNPJNQPSUFRVFQSPQPSDJPOBFMOVF WPNPEFMPQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBNÓOJNPRVFMBT "TÓSFTVMUBEFMB45$EFEFPDUVCSFDVBOEPBMFOKVJDJBSMBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEEFMB-FZ EF$FTJØOEF5SJCVUPTBMB(FOFSBMJEBEEF$BUBMV×BBmSNØRVFiTJOPPUSBTSB[POFTDVBOEPNFOPTFM NJTNPQSJODJQJPEFMFBMUBEDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPORVFFOHBS[BFMBQBSUBEPEFMB%JTQPTJDJØOBEJDJPOBM TFYUBEFM&TUBUVUPyPCMJHBCBBM(PCJFSOPBFMBCPSBSFMDPSSFTQPOEJFOUF1SPZFDUPEF-FZyTPCSFMB CBTFEFVO"DVFSEPBEPQUBEPQPSMB$PNJTJØO.JYUBQBSJUBSJBw'+ *OUSPEVDJEBÏTUBQPSMB-FZEFEFEJDJFNCSFQBSBFYUFOEFSMBBGFDUBDJØOBMFKFSDJDJPEF QVFTUPRVFMB%JTQPTJDJØO5SBOTJUPSJBTFYUBEFMB-'$"MBSFGFSÓBTØMPBMFKFSDJDJPEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 54 Juan Zornoza Pérez $$""EFCFOEFTUJOBSBTVmOBODJBDJØOBEFNÈTEFMBQBSUFEFM'POEPEF4VmDJFODJB RVFDPSSFTQPOEBBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFEJDIPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPT "ÞODPNQSFOEJFOEPRVFUBMFTEJTQPTJDJPOFToTJOEVEBCJFOJOUFODJPOBEBTo IBORVFSJEPHBSBOUJ[BSMBDPOUJOVJEBEFOMPTOJWFMFTEFQSFTUBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPT TBOJUBSJPTUSBOTGFSJEPTPDPNPUBNCJÏOTFIBEJDIPJNQFEJSRVFMBNBZPSBVUPOPNÓB QSFTVQVFTUBSJBEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFTiEFSJWFFOVOBEJGFSFODJBFOMBQSFTUBDJØOEFMPT TFSWJDJPTCÈTJDPTwMPDJFSUPFTRVFMBJOFYJTUFODJBEFNFEJEBTBEFDVBEBTZFmDBDFT QBSBIBDFSGSFOUFBVOFWFOUVBMJODVNQMJNJFOUPEFTVTPCMJHBDJPOFTQPSMBT$$"" MMFWBBQFOTBSRVFMBBGFDUBDJØOFTUBCMFDJEBFOMB-'$"iUJFOFVOWBMPSNÈTTJNCØMJDP RVFSFBMZOPTFHBSBOUJ[BDPOFMMBFOMBQSÈDUJDBFMOJWFMEFHBTUPTBOJUBSJPOFDFTB SJPw36*;)6&35"(3"/"%0."35¶/&;QÈH :EFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWB KVSÓEJDPmOBODJFSBOPQBSFDFNFOPTDJFSUPRVFMBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTEFRVFTFUSBUBGSV UPEFVOBFWJEFOUFEFTDPOmBO[BFOMBHFTUJØOBVUPOØNJDBEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPQVFEFO SFTVMUBSDPOUSBSJBTBMBBVUPOPNÓBmOBODJFSBEFMBT$$""RVFTFQSPZFDUBEFGPSNB FTQFDJBMNFOUFJOUFOTBFOMBPSEFOBDJØOEFMHBTUPRVFSFBMJ[BOBMNBSHFOEFRVFSF TVMUBOJOBEFDVBEBTQBSBMBJNQMBOUBDJØOEFVOBBVUÏOUJDBDPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmTDBM &ODVBOUPBMPQSJNFSPCBTUBSÈBIPSBDPOSFDPSEBSDPOQBMBCSBTEFMB45$ EF EF GFCSFSP RVF iMB BVUPOPNÓB QSFTVQVFTUBSJB EF MBT $PNVOJEBEFT "VUØOPNBTFTUPFTTVDBQBDJEBEQBSBEJTQPOFSMJCSFNFOUFEFTVTSFDVSTPTmOBO DJFSPTBTJHOÈOEPMFTBMPTmOFTNFEJBOUFQSPHSBNBTEFHBTUPFMBCPSBEPTTFHÞOTVT QSPQJBTQSJPSJEBEFTyBERVJFSFVOQBQFMDBQJUBMFOMBSFBMJ[BDJØOFGFDUJWBEFMB BVUPOPNÓB mOBODJFSB EF MBT $PNVOJEBEFT "VUØOPNBT SFDPOPDJEB QPS MB $POTUJ UVDJØOwZRVFiMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTHP[BSÈOEFBVUPOPNÓBmOBODJFSBEF HBTUP FOMBNFEJEBFORVFQVFEBOFMFHJSZSFBMJ[BSTVTQSPQJPTPCKFUJWPTQPMÓUJDPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPTTPDJBMFTPFDPOØNJDPTDPOJOEFQFOEFODJBEFDVÈMFTIBZBOTJEPMBT GVFOUFT EF MPT JOHSFTPT RVF OVUSFO TVT QSFTVQVFTUPTw '+ 1PSRVF TJFOEP FMMP BTÓJODMVTPSFDPOPDJFOEPRVFMBBVUPOPNÓBmOBODJFSBIBEFFKFSDFSTFDPOBSSFHMP B MPT QSJODJQJPT EF DPPSEJOBDJØO Z EF TPMJEBSJEBE OP QBSFDF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUF KVTUJmDBEP FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF VOB NFEJEB RVF TF FODBNJOB EF GPSNB EJSFDUB B DPOEJDJPOBS FM EFTUJOP EF VOB QBSUF TVTUBODJBM EF MPT JOHSFTPT BVUPOØNJDPT QBSB EFUFSNJOBEBTBUFODJPOFTPmOBMJEBEFTQPSNVZJNQPSUBOUFRVFFTUBTTFBOEFTEFMB QFSTQFDUJWBEFMMFHJTMBEPSFTUBUBMFJODMVTPEFTEFMBQSPQJBQFSTQFDUJWBDPOTUJUVDJP OBMQPSBGFDUBSBMBSFBMJ[BDJØOEFEFSFDIPTGVOEBNFOUBMFT &ODVBOUPBMPTFHVOEPTJBMDPOEJDJPOBSFMFNQMFPEFTVTSFDVSTPTTFQSJWB BMBT$$""EFVOBQBSUFEFTVNBSHFOQBSBEJTF×BSQPMÓUJDBTTBOJUBSJBTQSPQJBTSFTVM UBSÈNVDIPNÈTEJGÓDJMSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BSMBTFOMBPCUFODJØOEFMPTJOHSFTPTOFDFTBSJPT QBSBTVmOBODJBDJØO&OFGFDUPQPSEFDJSMPDMBSBNFOUFFMFKFSDJDJPBEFDVBEPEFMB QSPQJBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmTDBMFTFMQSFDJPRVFMBT$$""EFCFOQBHBSQBSBFTUBSFO &NQMFBOEPMPTUÏSNJOPTEF.*/*45&3*0%&4"/*%"%:$0/46.0QÈH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 55 DPOEJDJPOFTEFmOBODJBSQPMÓUJDBTQSPQJBTFOMPTÈNCJUPTEFTVDPNQFUFODJBZQSFDJ TBNFOUFQPSFMMPSFEVDJSFMNBSHFOEFBVUPOPNÓBFOFMEJTF×PEFUBMFTQPMÓUJDBTQPS FKFNQMPFTUBCMFDJFOEPOJWFMFTNÓOJNPTEFHBTUPTBOJUBSJPEFTJODFOUJWBMBBEPQDJØO EFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTmTDBMFTRVFTJFNQSFQPESÈOFOEPTBSTFBMMFHJTMBEPSFTUBUBMRVF IBEFDJEJEPMPTOJWFMFTEFHBTUPNÓOJNPFORVFEFCFJODVSSJSTFZBMRVFFODPOTF DVFODJBTFEFNBOEBSÈRVFTFPDVQFEFTVmOBODJBDJØO 1PS mO VO ÞMUJNP DPNFOUBSJP QBSFDF JNQSFTDJOEJCMF FO SFMBDJØO B MPT SFDVSTPTBGFDUBEPTBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBQBSBTF×BMBSRVFTV FWPMVDJØO FT PCKFUP EF VOB HBSBOUÓB USBOTJUPSJB QVFT EVSBOUF MPT USFT QSJNFSPT B×PTEFWJHFODJBEFMOVFWPNPEFMPiFM&TUBEPHBSBOUJ[BBMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØ OPNBTRVFUFOHBOBTVNJEBMBHFTUJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB 4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMRVFFMÓOEJDFEFFWPMVDJØOEFMBmOBODJBDJØOBTJHOBEBBMPTNJT NPTUFOESÈVOÓOEJDFEFFWPMVDJØOEFM1*#OPNJOBMBQSFDJPTEFNFSDBEPw%JT QPTJDJØO5SBOTJUPSJBTFHVOEB-'$" $PNPFTPCWJPTFSFDPOPDFEFFTFNPEP MB FYJTUFODJB EF VO CMPRVF EF SFDVSTPT BGFDUBEPT P BTJHOBEPT B MB mOBODJBDJØO TBOJUBSJBDVZPDSFDJNJFOUPSFBMTFQSPEVDJSÈTFHÞOFMÓOEJDFEFJOHSFTPTUSJCVUB SJPTEFM&TUBEPFODBEB$PNVOJEBE*5&S QFSPRVFTFRVJFSFRVFFWPMVDJPOFO EVSBOUFFTFQFSÓPEPUSBOTJUPSJPBMSJUNPEFM1*#OPNJOBM:EJDIBEJTQPTJDJØOOP UJFOF FYDFTJWP TFOUJEP TJ TF QJFOTB RVF FO TV WJSUVE MPT JOHSFTPT EF MBT $$"" QBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBDSFDFSÈOBMSJUNPEFM1*#OPNJOBMNJFOUSBTRVFFM HBTUPBTJHOBEPBEJDIBDPNQFUFODJBPCMJHBUPSJBNFOUFQPSWJSUVEEFMBSUEF MB-'$"DSFDFSÈBOVBMNFOUFBMSJUNPEFM*5&O1PSRVFMPNÈTSB[POBCMFIVCJFSB TJEPRVFFMDSFDJNJFOUPEFMPTJOHSFTPTTFQSPEVKFSBQPSSFGFSFODJBBMNJTNPÓOEJDF RVFEFCFNBSDBSFMDSFDJNJFOUPEFMHBTUPFORVFOFDFTBSJBNFOUFEFCFOJODVSSJSMBT $$""ZBRVFFMFNQMFPEFÓOEJDFTEJTQBSFTOFDFTBSJBNFOUFHFOFSBSÈTVQFSÈWJUTP EÏmDJUTFOMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTTFHÞORVFFM1*#OPNJOBM FWPMVDJPOFQPSFODJNBPOPEFM*5&OMPDVBMOPUJFOFTFOUJEP36*;)6&35" (3"/"%0."35¶/&;QÈHTZTT %FUPEBTGPSNBTDPNPMBHBSBOUÓBEFDSFDJNJFOUPEFMPTSFDVSTPTBGFDUPTB MBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBTØMPPQFSBFOMPTUSFTQSJNFSPTFKFSDJDJPTEF WJHFODJBEFMOVFWPNPEFMPNJFOUSBTRVFFMHBTUPFOEJDIBDPNQFUFODJBUJFOFRVF DSFDFSBOVBMNFOUFFOFMJNQPSUFRVFSFTVMUFEFMBBQMJDBDJØOEFMÓOEJDF*5&OQPSJN QFSBUJWPEFMBSUEFMB-'$"OPQBSFDFRVFFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOIBZB SFTVFMUPMPTQSPCMFNBTPDBTJPOBEPTQPSFMDSFDJNJFOUPFTUSVDUVSBMEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJP 36*;)6&35"(3"/"%0."35¶/&;QÈH 4JOFNCBSHPFTQPTJCMFRVF FMNBOEBUPEFMDJUBEPBSURVFDPOTUJUVZFFMHFSNFOEFVOBGVUVSBJOTVmDJFODJB FOMBmOBODJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBOPMMFHVFBQMBOUFBSQSPCMFNBTQVFTVOBWF[EFTBQBSFDJ EBMBHBSBOUÓBEFDSFDJNJFOUPEFMPTSFDVSTPTEFMBT$$""FTUBTQPESÈOoZEFCFSÈOo IBDFSGSFOUFBMNBZPSHBTUPTBOJUBSJPCJFOEFUSBZFOEPSFDVSTPTEFPUSBTBUFODJPOFT CJFONFEJBOUFFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBDPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmTDBMIBDJFOEPVTPEFTVQPEFS OPSNBUJWPQBSBJODSFNFOUBSMBSFDBVEBDJØOQSPDFEFOUFEFMPTUSJCVUPTDFEJEPTCJFO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 56 Juan Zornoza Pérez NFEJBOUFMBDSFBDJØOEFUSJCVUPTQSPQJPTWJODVMBEPTBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTBOJEBE QVFTMBDPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmTDBMFTFMQSFDJPEFMBBTQJSBDJØOBMBTVmDJFODJB-»1&; $"4"4/07"4QÈH 3.4.1BSBmOBMJ[BSDPOFMTVDJOUPSFQBTPEFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØO RVFWFOJNPTSFBMJ[BOEPEFCFEFTUBDBSTFDPNPNFSFDFMBSFHVMBDJØOEFRVFIBOTJEP PCKFUPlas asignaciones de nivelación del art. 15 de la LOFCAQSFWJTUBTQBSBMB HBSBOUÓBFOUPEPFMUFSSJUPSJPFTQB×PMEFVOOJWFMNÓOJNPEFQSFTUBDJØOEFMPTTFS WJDJPT QÞCMJDPT GVOEBNFOUBMFT EF MB DPNQFUFODJB EFM &TUBEP -B DPOmHVSBDJØO EF FTUBTBTJHOBDJPOFTFOMB-0'$"QMBOUFBCBOPUBCMFTEJmDVMUBEFTQBSBTVEFTBSSPMMP FOUSF FMMBT MB QSPQJB EFmOJDJØO EF MP RVF GVFSBO TFSWJDJPT QÞCMJDPT GVOEBNFOUBMFT PMBEFUFSNJOBDJØOEFDVÈMTFBFMOJWFMNÓOJNPEFQSFTUBDJPOFTRVFFM&TUBEPIBEF HBSBOUJ[BSQPSMPRVFIBOTJEPNBZPSJUBSJBNFOUFDPOTJEFSBEBTDPNPVOSFDVSTPFY DFQDJPOBMVONFDBOJTNPad hocFTUBCMFDJEPQBSBFMTVQVFTUPEFRVFBDBVTBEFVO EFmDJFOUFGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOWJHFOUFOJTJRVJFSBVUJMJ[BOEP MPTSFDVSTPTmOBODJFSPTPSEJOBSJPToFTUPFTUSJCVUPTDFEJEPTZ'POEPEFTVmDJFODJBo TFQVFEBBMDBO[BSVOOJWFMNÓOJNPFOMBQSFTUBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTGVOEBNFOUBMFT 1VFTCJFOFOMBMÓOFBQSPQVFTUBQPSMPTFYQFSUPTFOMBNBUFSJBMBSFGPSNBEFMBSU EFMB-0'$"MMFWBEBBDBCPQPSMB-FZ0SHÈOJDBIBPQUBEPQPSEFmOJSDPNP TFSWJDJPTQÞCMJDPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTMBFEVDBDJØOZMBTBOJEBEBDMBSBOEPBMUJFNQPRVF TFDPOTJEFSBSÈRVFOPTFBMDBO[BBDVCSJSFMOJWFMNÓOJNPEFQSFTUBDJØOiDVBOEPTV DPCFSUVSBTFEFTWÓFFOMBDVBOUÓBRVFEJTQPOHBMBMFZEFMOJWFMNFEJPEFMPTNJTNPT FOFMUFSSJUPSJPOBDJPOBMw &TUBGPSNBEFEFmOJSFMOJWFMNÓOJNPEFQSFTUBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTQPSSFGF SFODJBBMOJWFMNFEJPFOFMUFSSJUPSJPOBDJPOBMIBCÓBNFSFDJEPZBDSÓUJDBTKVTUJmDBEBT QVFTJNQMJDBRVFMBTEFDJTJPOFTBEPQUBEBTQPSDBEB$PNVOJEBESFTQFDUPEFMOJWFMEF QSFTUBDJØOEFTFSWJDJPTFOTVUFSSJUPSJPSFQFSDVUFTPCSFMBTEFNÈTZTPCSFFM&TUBEPBM RVFJODVNCFMBHBSBOUÓBEFOJWFMBDJØOEFRVFTFUSBUB(3610%&&456%*0 1«( 4FHVSBNFOUFQPSFMMPFMBSUEFMB-'$"BMQSPDFEFSBTVEFTBSSPMMP IBBMUFSBEPSBEJDBMNFOUFFMTJHOJmDBEPEFUBMEFmOJDJØOBMFOUFOEFSRVFFMOJWFMEF QSFTUBDJØOEFMTFSWJDJPTFWFBGFDUBEPQPSFMDSFDJNJFOUPFYDFTJWPEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFT EFHBTUPSFTQFDUPBMBNFEJBOBDJPOBMNFEJEPFOUÏSNJOPTBCTPMVUBNFOUFPCKFUJWPT &OFGFDUPFMDJUBEPQSFDFQUPEJTQPOFRVFFMOJWFMNÓOJNPEFQSFTUBDJØOEFMPTTFS WJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTTFFOUFOEFSÈBGFDUBEPiDVBOEPFMJODSFNFOUPEFMBQPCMBDJØOQSP UFHJEBEFCJEBNFOUFQPOEFSBEBFOGVODJØOEFMBFEBEFOMB$PNVOJEBE"VUØOPNB FOUSF VO B×P Z FM TJHVJFOUF FYQSFTBEP FO UÏSNJOPT QPSDFOUVBMFT TFB TVQFSJPS FO NÈTEFQVOUPTBMJODSFNFOUPQPSDFOUVBMRVFFYQFSJNFOUFFOFTFQFSÓPEPMBNFEJB OBDJPOBMwMPRVFFTUBOUPDPNPSFDPOPDFSRVFVODSFDJNJFOUPEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEF 0DPNPEJDFFMNJTNPBSUEFMB-'$"FONÈTEFQVOUPDVBOEPMBTVQFSmDJFEFMB$PNVOJEBE EFRVFTFUSBUFTFBTVQFSJPSBLJMØNFUSPTDVBESBEPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 57 HBTUPEFSJWBEPEFMBVNFOUPFYDFTJWPEFMBQPCMBDJØOQSPUFHJEBZEFTVFEBEHFOFSB FOTÓNJTNPVOBEFTWJBDJØOEFMOJWFMNFEJPEFQSFTUBDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTCBTUBOUF QBSB QPOFS FO NBSDIB FM QSPDFEJNJFOUP QSFWJP B MB BQMJDBDJØO EF MBT BTJHOBDJPOFT EFOJWFMBDJØO1PSRVFQBSBRVFMBTBTJHOBDJPOFTEFOJWFMBDJØOTFDPODFEBOOPCBTUB DPORVFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFHBTUPIBZBODSFDJEPQPSFODJNBEFMBNFEJBOBDJPOBMFO MPTUÏSNJOPTRVFIBORVFEBEPEFTDSJUPTTJOPRVFFTOFDFTBSJPBEFNÈTRVFEJDIBT OFDFTJEBEFT OP QVFEBO TFS DVCJFSUBT QPS MPT SFDVSTPT mOBODJFSPT PSEJOBSJPT EF MB $PNVOJEBEEFRVFTFUSBUFMPRVFEFCFSÈTFSPCKFUPEFBOÈMJTJTZWBMPSBDJØOQPSMB "ENJOJTUSBDJØO(FOFSBMEFM&TUBEPZMB$PNVOJEBE"VUØOPNBQBSBEFUFSNJOBSMBT DBVTBTZQPTJCMFTTPMVDJPOFTEFMBTJUVBDJØOQMBOUFBEBVOBWF[FYBNJOBEBFOTVDPO KVOUPMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMB$PNVOJEBEBSU-'$" . 4. LA INCIDENCIA EN LA FINANCIACIÓN DE LA ASISTENCIA SANITARIA DE LA LEY 16/2003, DE 28 DE MAYO, DE COHESIÓN Y CALIDAD DEL SISTEMA NACIONAL DE SALUD. 4PCSFFMNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBRVFIBRVFEBEP EFTDSJUPIBWFOJEPBJODJEJSMB-FZEFEFNBZP-$$4/4FOBEFMBOUF DVZB %JTQPTJDJØO 'JOBM QSJNFSBB JOWPDB FYQSFTBNFOUF MB DPNQFUFODJB FYDMVTJ WBEFM&TUBEPFONBUFSJBEFi)BDJFOEBHFOFSBMwBSU$& QBSBMFHJUJNBS DPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFFMDPOUFOJEPEFTVTBSUTZFMÞMUJNPQÈSSBGPEFMBSU 4FBDVBMTFBFMDPOUFOJEPEFEJDIPUÓUVMPDPNQFUFODJBMRVFMBKVSJTQSVEFODJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBMIBFNQMFBEPBFGFDUPTCJFOEJWFSTPTFTHFOFSBMNFOUFBDFQUBEPRVF DVBOEPNFOPTBNQBSBMBBEPQDJØOEFNFEJEBTEFDPPSEJOBDJØOFOUSFMB)BDJFOEB FTUBUBMZMPTEJTUJOUPTOJWFMFTEF)BDJFOEBTUFSSJUPSJBMFT445$Z RVFFTFMTFOUJEPFORVFQBSFDFJOWPDBSMPMB-$$4/4RVFTJOFNCBSHPMPVUJMJ[BFO VOTFOUJEPBMHPJNQSPQJP 1PSRVFFOFGFDUPTJTFSFQBTBOMBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTEFMDJUBEPUFYUPMFHBMEJD UBEBT BM BNQBSP EFM UÓUVMP DPNQFUFODJBM i)BDJFOEB HFOFSBMw QBSFDF RVF FO UPEBT FMMBTMBUFVOBDJFSUBWPMVOUBEEFDPPSEJOBDJØOQFSPOPTJFNQSFFTDMBSPTJTFUSBUBEF MBBEPQDJØOEFNFEJEBTEFDPPSEJOBDJØOmOBODJFSBRVFRVFEBSÓBOBNQBSBEBTQPS EJDIPUÓUVMPDPNQFUFODJBMPDPNPFOPDBTJPOFTQBSFDFEFMBBEPQDJØOEFNFEJEBT EFDBSÈDUFSmOBODJFSPRVFTJOFNCBSHPOPQPESÓBOMFHJUJNBSTFFTHSJNJFOEPFMUÓUVMP i)BDJFOEB HFOFSBMw QVFT OP QSFUFOEFO DPPSEJOBS FM FKFSDJDJP EF MBT DPNQFUFODJBT 5FOJFOEPFODVFOUBRVFDPNPEJDFMB%JTQPTJDJØO"EJDJPOBMQSJNFSBEFMB-'$"FTUFQSPDFEJNJFOUP EFBDUVBDJØOTØMPTFSÈBQMJDBCMFQBSBMBTEFTWJBDJPOFTRVFTFQSPEV[DBOFOFMNBSDPEFMOVFWPNPEFMP EFmOBODJBDJØOZQPSFMMPBQBSUJSEFMEFFOFSPEF $PNPQVFEFWFSTFFOFMSFDJFOUFBOÈMJTJTEF36*;"-.&/%"3-QÈHTZTTEPOEFFYQSF TBNFOUFTFBQVOUBoDPOSB[ØOoRVFQPSTVFYDFTJWBJOEFUFSNJOBDJØOFTUFUÓUVMPDPNQFUFODJBMTFIB VUJMJ[BEPFOPDBTJPOFTBNPEPEFiDPNPEÓOwQBSBKVTUJmDBSUPEPUJQPEFDPNQFUFODJBTFTUBUBMFT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 58 Juan Zornoza Pérez EFMBTEJTUJOUBT)BDJFOEBTQÞCMJDBTTJOPEFUSBTMBEBSBFTFÈNCJUPFMSFTVMUBEPEFMB DPPSEJOBDJØO EF MBT QPMÓUJDBT TBOJUBSJBT EF MBT $$"" DVBOEP OP EF TVQFSQPOFS MB DPPSEJOBDJØOmOBODJFSBBMBTNFEJEBTEFDPPSEJOBDJØOEFFTBDPODSFUBQPMÓUJDBQÞCMJ DBRVFIBQSFWJTUPMB-$$4/4 4.1.&OFTUFTFOUJEPFMBSUEFMB-$$4/4QBSFDFBmSNBSBMHPPCWJP DVBOEPJOEJDBRVFMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFmOBODJBSMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTDPSSFT QPOEFBMBT$$""iEFDPOGPSNJEBEDPOMPTBDVFSEPTEFUSBOTGFSFODJBTZFMBDUVBM TJTUFNBEFmOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBwDVZBTVmDJFODJBTFQSPDMBNBFOUÏSNJOPTQV SBNFOUFSFUØSJDPTFOTVBQBSUBEP4JOFNCBSHPFMDJUBEPQSFDFQUPWBBMHPNÈTBMMÈ QVFTMPRVFQSFUFOEFFTDPODSFUBSFMBMDBODFEFEJDIBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmOBODJFSBEF MBT$$""QBSBRVFBMDBODFBiMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTRVFFTUBCMFDFFTUBMFZwZBTVTiTJTUF NBTEFHBSBOUÓBTw&OEFmOJUJWBNÈTBMMÈEFMBTSFJUFSBDJPOFTFORVFEJDIPQSFDFQUP JODVSSFTVGVODJØODPOTJTUFFODPODSFUBSMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmOBODJFSBEFMBT$$"" RVF MB -'$" SFGFSÓB HFOÏSJDBNFOUF B MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB EF MB 4FHVSJEBE 4PDJBM FTUBCMFDJFOEPRVFBMDBO[BBMDBUÈMPHPEFQSFTUBDJPOFTEFM4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE BSU-$$4/4 ZBMPTTJTUFNBTRVFHBSBOUJ[BOFMBDDFTPEFUPEPTMPTVTVBSJPTBMBT QSFTUBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTBSU-$$4/4 DPOJOEFQFOEFODJBEFMMVHBSEFMUFSSJUPSJP OBDJPOBMFORVFTFFODVFOUSFOBSU-$$4/4 ZFOVOUJFNQPNÈYJNPBSU -$$4/4 EJTQPOJFOEPEFJOGPSNBDJØOTVmDJFOUFTPCSFTVTEFSFDIPTZEFCFSFTBSU -$$4/4 EF TFHVSJEBE FO DVBOUP B MBT UÏDOJDBT UFDOPMPHÓBT Z QSPDFEJNJFOUPT FNQMFBEPTBSU-$$4/4 ZFOEFmOJUJWBEFHBSBOUÓBTFODVBOUPBMBDBMJEBEEF EJDIBTQSFTUBDJPOFTBSU-$$4/4 %FFTUFNPEPFMSFTVMUBEPEFMBDPPSEJOBDJØOEFMBTQPMÓUJDBTTBOJUBSJBTFY QSFTBEPFOFMBDVFSEPEFM$POTFKP*OUFSUFSSJUPSJBMEFM4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVERVF EFmOFFMDBUÈMPHPEFQSFTUBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTBSU-$$4/4 RVFTFJODPSQPSBSÈOB MBDBSUFSBEFTFSWJDJPTBQSPCBEBQPS3FBM%FDSFUPBSU-$$4/4 SFQFSDVUFEJSFD UBNFOUFFOFMÈNCJUPmOBODJFSPQPSDVBOUPDPOMPTSFDVSTPTRVFMFTBTJHOBFMOVFWP NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOMBT$$""RVFEBOPCMJHBEBTBmOBODJBSVODPOKVOUPEFQSFT UBDJPOFTZTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPTEFmOJEPTFOVONPNFOUPQPTUFSJPS:FMMPOPDBSFDFEF TJHOJmDBEPTPCSFUPEPFOUÏSNJOPTEFTVmDJFODJBmOBODJFSBQVFTDPOWJFOFSFDPSEBS RVFQBSBFMDBMDVMPEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBT MB-'$"IBVUJMJ[BEPEBUPTEFMB×PCBTFEFFORVFOJMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBT OJMBTUÏDOJDBTUFDOPMPHÓBTZQSPDFEJNJFOUPTRVFMBTIBDFOQPTJCMFTFSBOMBTNJTNBT RVFMBTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFTBMNPNFOUPFORVFTFEJDUBMB-$$4/44FHVSBNFOUFQPS FMMPFMBSUEFMB-$$4/4TFSFmFSFBMBHBSBOUÓBEFMBTVmDJFODJBQBSBMBmOBODJB DJØOEFMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTRVFTVQPOFOMPTSFDVSTPTBTJHOBEPTBMBT$$""QPS &OFTUFTFOUJEP7*%"'&3/«/%&;QÈHTPTUJFOFRVFMB-$$4/4BHSBWBMPTQSPCMFNBTEF mOBODJBDJØOiFODVBOUPSFEJNFOTJPOBFMDPOUFOJEPZBMDBODFEFMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTMPRVFEFKB PCTPMFUPFMTJTUFNBmKBEPDPOBOUFSJPSJEBEBMBNJTNBw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 59 MB-'$"iEFBDVFSEPDPOFMQSJODJQJPEFMFBMUBEDPOTUJUVDJPOBMwFOMPTUÏSNJOPTEFM BSUF EFMB-0'$"1PSRVFEJDIPQSJODJQJPSFDMBNBTFHÞOMBEJDDJØOEFMDJUBEP QSFDFQUPRVFFOFMTFOPEFM$1''TFWBMPSFBOVBMNFOUFiFMJNQBDUPQPTJUJWPPOFHB UJWPRVFQVFEBOTVQPOFSMBTBDUVBDJPOFTEFM&TUBEPMFHJTMBEPSFONBUFSJBUSJCVUBSJB PMBBEPQDJØOEFNFEJEBTEFJOUFSÏTHFOFSBMRVFFWFOUVBMNFOUFQVFEBOIBDFSSFDBFS TPCSFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEFHBTUPOPQSFWJTUBTBMBGFDIBEF BQSPCBDJØOEFMTJTUFNBEFmOBODJBDJØOWJHFOUFw%FBIÓRVFFOÞMUJNPFYUSFNPMB DPPSEJOBDJØOEFMBTQPMÓUJDBTTBOJUBSJBTTFWFBNFEJBUJ[BEBQPSVOBSFTUSJDDJØOmOBO DJFSBQVFTMBT$$""EJGÓDJMNFOUFBDPSEBSÈOFOFM$POFKP*OUFSUFSSJUPSJBMNFEJEBTEF QPMÓUJDBTBOJUBSJBDVZBmOBODJBDJØOOPFTUÏHBSBOUJ[BEBPRVFOPWBZBOBEBSMVHBSB VOBWBMPSBDJØOEFM$1''RVFEFUFSNJOFVOJODSFNFOUPEFmOBODJBDJØODPSSFMBUJWP: FTRVFTJQVFEFDPOTJEFSBSTFMØHJDPoZSB[POBCMFoRVFFM&TUBEPFOFKFSDJDJPEFTVT DPNQFUFODJBTFOMBNBUFSJBFJODMVTPIBDJFOEPFNQMFPEFTVTQPUFTUBEFTEFDPPS EJOBDJØOQVFEBBQSPCBSMBJODPSQPSBDJØOEFVOBQSFTUBDJØOBMBDBSUFSBEFTFSWJDJPT 7"26&3$"#"--&3¶"QÈH UBNCJÏOMPFTRVFFOFTFDBTPFOBVTFODJB EFSFDVSTPTTVmDJFOUFTQBSBTVmOBODJBDJØOPTJTFQSFmFSFDVBOEPMPTSFDVSTPTRVF TFMFIBOBTJHOBEPQPSFMNPEFMPWJHFOUFOPSFTVMUFOTVmDJFOUFTBMFGFDUPIBZBEF QSPDFEFSBJODPSQPSBSMPTQSFWJPBDVFSEPEFM$1''MØHJDBNFOUFNFEJBOUFFMJODSF NFOUPEFMBEPUBDJØODPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBM'POEPEFTVmDJFODJB &TNÈTFTBSFTUSJDDJØOmOBODJFSBEBMVHBSBVOBTVQFSQPTJDJØOEFMPTNF DBOJTNPTEFDPPSEJOBDJØOTBOJUBSJBZmOBODJFSBDVBOEPTFUSBUBEFMBJODPSQPSBDJØO EFOVFWBTQSFTUBDJPOFTBMDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFDBUÈMPHPEFM4JTUFNBOBDJPOBMEF4BMVE QPSRVFFOFTFDBTPEFCFFMBCPSBSTFVOBNFNPSJBFDPOØNJDBRVFDPOUFOHBMBWBMPSB DJØOEFMJNQBDUPQPTJUJWPPOFHBUJWPRVFQVFEBTVQPOFSQBSBTVFMFWBDJØOBM$1'' RVFEFCFSÈBOBMJ[BSTJHFOFSBQBSBMBT$$""PCMJHBDJPOFTEFHBTUPOPQSFWJTUBTFOFM NPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOWJHFOUFBSU-$$4/4 %FFTFNPEPBMUJFNQPRVFTF QSPEVDFMBEJTDVTJØOFOFM$POTFKP*OUFSUFSSJUPSJBMDPODBSÈDUFSQSFWJPBMBJODPSQP SBDJØOBMDBUÈMPHPEFQSFTUBDJPOFTUFOESÈMVHBSVOBWBMPSBDJØOQBSBMFMBEFMPTFGFDUPT mOBODJFSPTEFSJWBEPTEFMBNJTNBFTUBWF[FOFM$1''TJORVFQVFEBJHOPSBSTFRVF BNCPTQSPDFTPTGPSNBMNFOUFJOEFQFOEJFOUFTWBOBDPOEJDJPOBSTFNVUVBNFOUFZB RVFEJGÓDJMNFOUFTFBDFQUBSÈQPSMBT$$""MBJODPSQPSBDJØOEFOVFWBTQSFTUBDJPOFT DVZBmOBODJBDJØOOPTFFODVFOUSFHBSBOUJ[BEB. 4.2.+VOUPBFMMPSFTVMUBVOUBOUPTPSQSFOEFOUFRVFMB-$$4/4BQFOBTTF SFmFSBBM'POEPEFDPIFTJØOTBMWPDPNPNFDBOJTNPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMVTPUVUF MBEPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTUÏDOJDBTUFDOPMPHÓBTPQSPDFEJNJFOUPTBOUFTEFEFDJEJSTPCSF MB DPOWFOJFODJB P OFDFTJEBE EF TV JODMVTJØO FO MB DBSUFSB EF TFSWJDJPT EFM 4JTUFNB "TÓQBSFDFEFNPTUSBSMPMBFYQFSJFODJBSFDJFOUFDPNPSFTVMUBEFMBOPUJDJBQVCMJDBEBFOFMEJBSJP"#$ EFMKVFWFTEFEJDJFNCSFEFQÈHTFHÞOMBDVBMPDIP$$""SFDIB[BSPOMPTQMBOFTEFTBMVEEF 4BOJEBEQPSGBMUBEFmOBODJBDJØOZFOMBRVFTFBUSJCVZFBMB.JOJTUSBEF4BOJEBEVOBTNBOJGFTUBDJPOFT TPCSFMBJOUFSWFODJØOEFM$1''QBSBRVFEFOPFYJTUJSmOBODJBDJØOiEFDJEBTJPGSFDFNÈTBQPSUBDJPOFTw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 60 Juan Zornoza Pérez /BDJPOBMEF4BMVEBSU ZQBSBBUFOEFSBMHBTUPHFOFSBEPQPSMBBUFODJØOEF QBDJFOUFTFODFOUSPTRVFEJTQPOHBOEFTFSWJDJPTEFSFGFSFODJBBDSFEJUBEPTBSU in fine &OFGFDUPTBMWPFSSPSQPSOVFTUSBQBSUFOPFYJTUFOPUSBTNFODJPOFTBMDJUBEP 'POEP FO MB -$$4/4 TBMWP MB FGFDUVBEB FO TV %JTQPTJDJØO "EJDJPOBM RVJOUB RVF DBSFDFEFDPOUFOJEPOPSNBUJWPQSFDJTPZBRVFTFMJNJUBBQSPDMBNBSoFOUÏSNJOPT VOUBOUPBNQVMPTPToMBmOBMJEBERVFTFMFBUSJCVZFDPNPNFEJPQBSBiHBSBOUJ[BSMB JHVBMEBEEFBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPTEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBQÞCMJDBFOUPEPFMUFSSJUPSJP FTQB×PMZMBBUFODJØOBDJVEBEBOPTEFTQMB[BEPTwZTVDBSÈDUFSEFJOTUSVNFOUPBUSB WÏTEFMDVBMFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BOJEBEZ$POTVNPiSFBMJ[BSÈQPMÓUJDBTRVFBTFHVSFOMB DPIFTJØOTBOJUBSJBZMBDPSSFDDJØOEFEFTJHVBMEBEFTw 1VFTCJFOEFBDVFSEPDPOMBSFHVMBDJØOEFM'POEPEFDPIFTJØOUBOUPFOFM BSUEFMB-FZDPNPFOFM3FBM%FDSFUPQVFEFDPOTJEFSBSTF DPIFSFOUF mOBODJBS DPO DBSHP BM NJTNP MB BTJTUFODJB FO TFSWJDJPT EF SFGFSFODJB FO DVBOUPSFTVMUBOFDFTBSJBQBSBMBHBSBOUÓBEFMBJHVBMEBEEFBDDFTPZBEFNÈTDPOGSF DVFODJBTFSFGFSJSÈBQBDJFOUFTEFTQMB[BEPT1PSDPOUSBOPDSFFNPTRVFFTUF'POEP TFBVOJOTUSVNFOUPBEFDVBEPQBSBMBmOBODJBDJØOEFMEFOPNJOBEPiVTPUVUFMBEPwSF MBDJPOBEPDPOMBFYQFSJNFOUBDJØOEFOVFWBTUÏDOJDBTUFDOPMPHÓBTZQSPDFEJNJFOUPT DPOBSSFHMPBVOEJTF×PEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZRVFOJQBSFDFUFOFSSFMBDJØOBMHVOBDPO MBJHVBMEBEFOMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFBDDFTPOJUBNQPDPDPOMBBTJTUFODJBBEFTQMB[BEPT BMBRVFTFBHSFHBBIPSBVOBOVFWBGVODJØOFOWJSUVEEFMBSUEFMB-$$4/4 6OBOVFWBGVODJØONVDIPNÈTDPODSFUBRVFMBEFSFBMJ[BSFTBTQPMÓUJDBTEFDPIFTJØO FJHVBMEBERVFQPNQPTBNFOUFMFBUSJCVZFMB%JTQPTJDJØO"EJDJPOBMRVJOUBEFMDJUBEP UFYUPMFHBMZRVFEJDIPTFBEFQBTPOPQBSFDFGÈDJMmOBODJBSDPOMBTFTDBTBTEPUB DJPOFTRVFIBTUBMBGFDIBTFMFIBOBTJHOBEPTPCSFUPEPTJBEFNÈTDPNPSFTVMUBDPO DMBSJEBEEFM3FBM%FDSFUPRVFSFHVMBTVHFTUJØOTVPCKFUJWPGVOEBNFOUBMFTBUFOEFS BMBDPNQFOTBDJØOEFMPTHBTUPTJODVSSJEPTQPSMBT$$"RVFSFBMJ[BOMBBTJTUFODJBB EFTQMB[BEPTSFTJEFOUFTFO&TQB×BPDPODBSHPBJOTUJUVDJPOFTEFPUSPTFTUBEPT 4.3.&OUPEPDBTPMPRVFEFCFRVFEBSDMBSPFTRVFFMEFOPNJOBEP'POEPEF DPIFTJØOOPFTVOJOTUSVNFOUPQBSBMBDPPSEJOBDJØOEFMBTQPMÓUJDBTTBOJUBSJBTEFMBT $$""EFNPEPRVFFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFTVTGVODJPOFTEFHBSBOUÓBEFMBDPIFTJØOZ DPSSFDDJØOEFEFTJHVBMEBEFTMB"ENJOJTUSBDJØO(FOFSBMEFM&TUBEPEFCFSÈVUJMJ[BSMBT UÏDOJDBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMZMFHBMNFOUFQSFWJTUBT36*;)6&35"(3"/"%0."35¶ /&;QÈH TJORVFMFTFBEBEPBDVEJSBFTUFJOTUSVNFOUPmOBODJFSPQBSBB TVUSBWÏTJOUFSGFSJSFOFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTEFMBT$$"" :FTRVFDPNPZBIFNPTBEWFSUJEPMB-$$4/4DPOGVOEFFOPDBTJPOFTMB DPPSEJOBDJØOmOBODJFSBZMBEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTEFMBT$$""FNQMFBO EPMBVOBBMTFSWJDJPEFMBPUSBPEJTQPOJFOEPNFDBOJTNPTRVFPQFSBOFOQBSBMFMP DPNPNVFTUSBFMBSUO Z× EFEJDIPUFYUPMFHBMRVFBUSJCVZFBM$POTFKP*O UFSUFSSJUPSJBMDPNQFUFODJBTDPODVSSFOUFTDPOMBTEFM$1''PRVFEFCFFKFSDFSTFHÞO EJDFFMÞMUJNPQSFDFQUPDJUBEPiTJOQFSKVJDJPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTEFM$POTFKPEF 1PMÓUJDB'JTDBMZ'JOBODJFSBEFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT"VUØOPNBTw"MHPQBSFDJEPPDVSSF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 61 FOSFMBDJØOBPUSPØSHBOPTDPNPMPTEF"MUB*OTQFDDJØOBMPTRVFFMBSUD ZE EFMB-$$4/4BUSJCVZFDPNQFUFODJBTDPODVSSFOUFTDPOMBTEFMB*OUFSWFODJØO (FOFSBMEFMB"ENJOJTUSBDJØOEFM&TUBEPTFHVSBNFOUFDPNPTJHOPEFMBFTQFDJBM QSPYJNJEBE RVF FYJTUF FOUSF MPT BTQFDUPT mOBODJFSPT Z MPT BTQFDUPT TVCTUBOUJWPT FOFMÈNCJUPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBT6OBQSPYJNJEBERVFQBSFDFSFRVFSJS VOFTQFDJBMDPOUBDUPFOUSFMPTSFTQPOTBCMFTEFBNCBTDMBTFTEFBDUVBDJPOFTMPRVF FYQMJDBRVFMB%JTQPTJDJØO'JOBMTFHVOEBEFMB-$$4/4DPNQSPNFUBBM(PCJFSOP B EJDUBS MBT EJTQPTJDJPOFT OFDFTBSJBT QBSB MB DSFBDJØO EF VO ØSHBOP DPMFHJBEP F JOUFSNJOJTUFSJBMRVFDPODBSÈDUFSQSFDFQUJWPEFCFSÈJOGPSNBSMPTBTVOUPTRVFUFO HBOUSBTDFOEFODJBQSFTVQVFTUBSJBQBSBFMFRVJMJCSJPmOBODJFSPEFM4JTUFNBOBDJPOBM EF 4BMVE P JNQMJDBDJPOFT FDPOØNJDBT TJHOJmDBUJWBT BVORVF TFB TPMP QBSB RVF FM JOGPSNFTFQPOHBFODPOPDJNJFOUPEFM$POTFKP*OUFSUFSSJUPSJBMZEFPUSPMBEPFM .JOJTUFSJPEF)BDJFOEBMPUSBTMBEFBM$1''EFNPEPRVFFTUFØSHBOPFTUÏFODPOEJ DJPOFTEFQSPQPOFSiFOTVDBTPMBTNFEJEBTOFDFTBSJBTQBSBHBSBOUJ[BSFMFRVJMJCSJP mOBODJFSPEFM4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVEw 5. UNA VALORACIÓN FINAL: A MODO DE CONCLUSIONES "EJGFSFODJBEFMPPDVSSJEPSFTQFDUPBMBTSFTUBOUFTDPNQFUFODJBTBVUPOØNJ DBTFORVFTVUSBTQBTPOPHFOFSBCBPUSPQSPCMFNBmOBODJFSPRVFMBEFUFSNJOBDJØO EFM DPTUF FGFDUJWP RVF TF JOUFHSBCB MVFHP FO MB mOBODJBDJØO HFOFSBM SFTVMUBOUF EFM NPEFMPWJHFOUFFODBEBNPNFOUPMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEFDPNQFUFODJBTEFHFTUJØOEFMB BTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMIBUFOJEPJNQPSUBOUFTDPOTFDVFODJBTFOMB DPOmHVSBDJØOEFMNJTNPNPEFMPEFmOBODJBDJØOEFMBT$$"""MPMBSHPEFVOEJMB UBEPQFSÓPEPUFNQPSBMQPSRVFFMUSBTQBTPEFMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTGVFBDPN QB×BEPEFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFVONPEFMPQSPQJPZFTQFDÓmDPQBSBTVmOBODJBDJØO EJTUJOUPZTFQBSBEPEFMRVFDPODBSÈDUFSHFOFSBMQSPQPSDJPOBCBMPTSFDVSTPTQBSB MBmOBODJBDJØOEFMBTSFTUBOUFTDPNQFUFODJBTBVUPOØNJDBT:FOUJFNQPTSFDJFOUFT DVBOEPMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBEFMB4FHVSJEBE4PDJBMTFUSBOTmSJØBMBUPUBMJEBEEFMBT $$""QPSRVFGVFQSFDJTPNPEJmDBSQSPGVOEBNFOUFFMQSPQJPNPEFMPEFmOBODJB DJØOQBSBJOUFHSBSFOÏMMBDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFBMBTDPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTUBOUPFO UÏSNJOPTDVBOUJUBUJWPTDPNPDVBMJUBUJWPT %FTEFMBQSJNFSBQFSTQFDUJWBFMDBSÈDUFSJOUFHSBEPSEFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFm OBODJBDJØOIBPCMJHBEPBJODSFNFOUBSOPUBCMFNFOUFFMWPMVNFOEFMPTSFDVSTPTRVFMP JOUFHSBOEFCJEPBMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJP:TPCSFUPEPEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWB DVBMJUBUJWBFMOVFWPNPEFMPHFOFSBMEFmOBODJBDJØOBMDPNQSFOEFSUBNCJÏOMBmOBO DJBDJØOTBOJUBSJBIBEFCJEPJODPSQPSBSUPEBVOBTFSJFEFFMFNFOUPTOPWFEPTPTRVFFO BMHÞODBTPSFTVMUBOIBSUPEJTDVUJCMFT &OFTUFTFOUJEPFMQSPQJPQSPDFTPEFJNQMBOUBDJØOEFMOVFWPNPEFMPIBTJEP EJTDVUJEP BM WJODVMBSTF MB BQMJDBDJØO EFM NJTNP B MB BDFQUBDJØO EFM USBTQBTP EF MBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 62 Juan Zornoza Pérez DPNQFUFODJBTTBOJUBSJBTMPRVFOPTØMPFSBJOOFDFTBSJPEBEMBMØHJDBEFMGVODJPOBNJFOUP EFM&TUBEPEFMBTBVUPOPNÓBTTJOPRVFTFHVSBNFOUFFTUBNCJÏODPOUSBSJPBMB$POTUJUV DJØOQPSSFTVMUBSJODPNQBUJCMFDPOMBTFYJHFODJBTEFMQSJODJQJPEJTQPTJUJWPZMBMØHJDBEF MBJOUFSWFODJØOFOMBmOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBEFMBT$PNJTJPOFT.JYUBT +VOUPBFMMPFOTFHVOEPMVHBSFMOVFWPNPEFMPJODPSQPSBFMFNFOUPTNVZ QPTJUJWPTEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMPTSFDVSTPTRVFQPOFBEJTQPTJDJØOEFMBT$$"" QPSFKFNQMPFODVBOUPBMBJODPSQPSBDJØOBMBMJTUBEFUSJCVUPTDFEJEPTEFMPTHSBO EFTJNQVFTUPTTPCSFFMDPOTVNP4JOFNCBSHPOPFTTFHVSPRVFBMDBODFBHBSBOUJ [BSMBTVmDJFODJBmOBODJFSBFOFMÈNCJUPTBOJUBSJPQPSVOMBEPBMIBCFSDBMDVMBEP MBT OFDFTJEBEFT EF HBTUP TPCSF MPT EBUPT EFM B×P BDUVBMJ[BEPT DPOGPSNF B ÓOEJDFTRVFOPSFnFKBOFMDSFDJNJFOUPSFBMEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPQPSPUSPFODVBO UP FM DÈMDVMP EF UBMFT OFDFTJEBEFT EF HBTUP OP IB UPNBEP FO DVFOUB FM DBUÈMPHP EFQSFTUBDJPOFTIPZJODPSQPSBEBTBMBDBSUFSBEFTFSWJDJPTRVFQSFWÏMB-$$4/4 RVFUBNQPDPFTUBCMFDFNFDBOJTNPTJEØOFPTQBSBBTFHVSBSMBJODPSQPSBDJØOEFMBT OVFWBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFmOBODJBDJØOZQPSmOQPSRVFTFFTUBCMFDFVOJODSFNFOUP BOVBMEFMHBTUPTBOJUBSJPEFBDVFSEPDPOVOÓOEJDFEFDSFDJNJFOUPOBDJPOBMRVFOP FTTFHVSPDPJODJEBDPOFMEFDSFDJNJFOUPEFMPTSFDVSTPTUSJCVUBSJPTFOFMUFSSJUPSJP EFDBEB$PNVOJEBE &OUFSDFSMVHBSVOBDJFSUBEFTDPOmBO[BIBDJBMBHFTUJØOBVUPOØNJDBEFMPTSF DVSTPTTBOJUBSJPTVOJEBBVOEJTDVUJCMFFNQMFPEFMBmOBODJBDJØODPNPJOTUSVNFOUP EFHBSBOUÓBEFMBJHVBMEBEZDPIFTJØOEFMTJTUFNBTBOJUBSJPIBMMFWBEPBMMFHJTMBEPSB FTUBCMFDFSVOQSJODJQJPEFBGFDUBDJØORVFTJCJFOFTEFMJNJUBEPBMDBODFBMOPFYJTUJS NFDBOJTNPT RVF HBSBOUJDFO TV DVNQMJNJFOUP SFTVMUB EJGÓDJMNFOUF DPNQBUJCMF DPO FM FOUFOEJNJFOUPEFMBBVUPOPNÓBmOBODJFSBEFMBT$$""FOMBKVSJTQSVEFODJBDPOTUJUV DJPOBMRVFMB45$EFEFGFCSFSPDJGSBQSFDJTBNFOUFFOiTVDBQBDJEBEQBSB EJTQPOFSMJCSFNFOUFEFTVTSFDVSTPTmOBODJFSPTBTJHOÈOEPMFTBMPTmOFTNFEJBOUF QSPHSBNBTEFHBTUPFMBCPSBEPTTFHÞOTVTQSPQJBTQSJPSJEBEFTw'+ &MMPEFKBOEP BM NBSHFO MPT QFSOJDJPTPT FGFDUPT RVF FTUF UJQP EF EJTQPTJDJPOFT QSPEVDFO FO UÏS NJOPTEFDPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEmOBODJFSBEBEPRVFVOFOUFUFSSJUPSJBMDVZPHBTUPFT QSFEFUFSNJOBEPQPSMBMFHJTMBDJØOFTUBUBMTFTFOUJSÈTJFNQSFMFHJUJNBEPQBSBSFDMBNBS BM&TUBEPNBZPSFTSFDVSTPTFOMVHBSEFSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BSTFEFTVPCUFODJØONFEJBOUF FMFKFSDJDJPEFMQPEFSUSJCVUBSJPRVFTFMFDPOmFSFBMFGFDUP %FBIÓRVFOPTFBTFODJMMPQSFEFDJSMPTSFTVMUBEPTRVFDBCFFTQFSBSEFVONP EFMPDVZBSBEJDBMOPWFEBEJOWJUBBNBOUFOFSVOBDJFSUBQSVEFODJBFOTVWBMPSBDJØOB MBFTQFSBEFRVFMPTEBUPTEJTQPOJCMFTQFSNJUBOFWBMVBSTJIBTJEPDBQB[EFHBSBOUJ[BS MBTVmDJFODJBmOBODJFSBBMBT$$"QBSBMBHFTUJØOEFVOPTTFSWJDJPTQBSUJDVMBSNFO UFTFOTJCMFTFODVBOUPBGFDUBOBEFSFDIPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMPTDJVEBEBOPT6OPT TFSWJDJPTSFTQFDUPEFDVZBQSFTUBDJØOOPQVFEFEFTFOUFOEFSTFMB"ENJOJTUSBDJØO(F OFSBMEFM&TUBEPBMBRVFJODVNCFOUBSFBTEFDPPSEJOBDJØOTVTUBOUJWBZmOBODJFSB RVFBVORVFQVFEBQBSFDFSSFEVOEBOUFDPOWFOESÓBFKFSDFSEFNBOFSBDPPSEJOBEB DPOFMmOEFFWJUBSRVFMPTJOUFSFTFTQSFTFOUFTFOVOBEFEJDIBTÈSFBTQVFEBOMMFWBS RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 La financiación del sistema nacional de salud 63 BEFTDPOPDFSMPTJNQMJDBEPTFOMBPUSBQPSRVFTJFOEPQSBHNÈUJDPTFMMPUFSNJOBSÓB USBEVDJÏOEPTFEFGPSNBDBTJJOFWJUBCMFFOMBQSFWBMFODJBEFMPTJOUFSFTFTmOBODJFSPT TPCSFMPTEFMBBEFDVBEBQSPWJTJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPT BIBLIOGRAFÍA "+"'&3/«/%&;&1SJODJQJPTOPSNBTZQSPDFEJNJFOUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFMBmOBO DJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDBFO(0/;«-&;1«3".0+.FE #BTFTQBSBVOTJTUFNBFTUBCMFEF mOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDB.BESJE "-#*--04 '&3/«/%&; .- (".";0 $)*--»/ +$(0/;«-&; '&3/«/%&; +.4"º6%0("3$¶"4Presupuestación pública y fnanciación sanitaria. Análisis presupuestario del modelo de financiación de la asistencia sanitaria para el período 1998-20013F WJTUB7BMFODJBOBEF&DPOPNÓBZ)BDJFOEBO* $"#"4²4)*5"+.La financiación sanitaria autonómica.#BTFTQBSBVOBQSPQVFTUBFO 1BQFMFTEF&DPOPNÓB&TQB×PMBO $"#"4²4)*5"+.La financiación de la sanidad en España,FO""77*OGPSNF4&41"4 .BESJE $"#"4²4)*5"+.."35¶/."35¶/++La financiación de la sanidad en España&M .ÏEJDP"OVBSJP (".";0 $)*--»/ +$"-#*--04 '&3/«/%&; .-(0/;«-&; '&3/«/%&; +.Financiación territorial de la sanidad en españa. Estudio de su evolución en las últimas décadas 3FWJTUBEF"ENJOJTUSBDJØO4BOJUBSJBWPM*7O (".";0$)*--»/+$(":6#01²3&;14"º6%0("3$¶"4Estudio de la financiación autonómica del gasto sanitario3FWJTUB7BMFODJBOBEF&DPOPNÓBZ)BDJFOEBO* (*.²/&;.0/5&30"La financiación autonómica de la sanidad$VBEFSOPTEF*OGPS NBDJØO&DPOØNJDB (3610%&&456%*0$0/45*56*%0"13016&45"%&-$0/4&+0%&10-¶5*$" '*4$"- : '*/"/$*&3" Informe sobre el actual sistema de financiación autonómica y sus problemas.BESJE -01&;$"4"4/07"4(La financiación autonómica de la sanidad,FO""77-BPSHBOJ[B DJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTQÞCMJDPTTBOJUBSJPT.BESJE -01&;$"4"4/07"4(La financiación autonómica y la financiación de la sanidad: algunas claves$FOUSFEFSFDFSDBFOFDPOPNJBJTBMVU6OJWFSTJUBU1PNQFV'BCSB#BSDFMPOB -01&;$"4"/07"4(Reflexiones acerca de la nueva financiación autonómica de la sanidad, mimeo#BSDFMPOB .*/*45&3*0 %& 4"/*%"% : $0/46.0 Recursos económicos del Sistema Nacional de Salud. Datos y Cifras.BESJE .0/5&30(3"/"%043."35¶/."35¶/+++*.&/&;"(6*-&3"+%4«/ $)&;$".1*--0+*.²/&;36#*0%-»1&;%&-".0.1Financiación autonómica de la sanidad: escenarios dinámicos básicosNJNFP(SBOBEB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 64 Juan Zornoza Pérez 035*;$"--&&Procesos negociadores e inestabilidad del sistema de financiación autonómica: una perspectiva de derecho comparadoFO*NQVFTUPTOEJDJFNCSFEF 3"."--0."44"/&5+Z;03/0;"1²3&;+&MConsejo de Política Fiscal y Financiera y las Comisiones Mixtas en la financiación de las Comunidades Autónomas $VBEFSOPT EF %FSFDIP1ÞCMJDPO 3"."--0."44"/&5+Elementos jurídicos de la financiación autonómicaFO(0/;« -&;1«3".0+.FE #BTFTQBSBVOTJTUFNBFTUBCMFEFmOBODJBDJØOBVUPOØNJDB.B ESJE 36*;"-.&/%3"-7Impuestos cedidos y corresponsabilidad fiscal7BMFODJB 36*;)6&35"$"3#0/&--+Z(3"/"%04."35¶/&;0La sanidad en el uevo modelo de financiación autonómica%PDVNFOUPEFUSBCBKP'VOEBDJØO"MUFSOBUJWBT .BESJE 5".":0-03&/;01"Descentralización y financiación de la asistencia sanitaria pública en España.BESJE 5033&4$0#0'Análisis de la financiación de la asistencia sanitaria de la Seguridad Social */4"-6% FO""77&MGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFM&TUBEP"VUPOØNJDP.BESJE 653*--"%&-")0;"La suficiencia financiera en el nuevo sistema autonómico de financiación: un ejercicio de simulación dinámica7*&ODVFOUSPEF&DPOPNÓB"QMJDBEB(SBOBEB 7"26&3$"#"--&3¶".La función de coordinación interterritorial del sistema de las Administraciones. Su organización en relaciones de coordinación y cooperación; trabajo presentado a las II Jornadas sobre la organización de los servicios públicos sanitarios,6OJWFSTJEBE$BSMPT***EF .BESJENJNFPRVFTFQVCMJDBFOFTUFNJTNPWPMVNFO 7*%"'&3/«/%&;+Las prestaciones del SNS: carteras de servicios y prestaciones farmacéuticasUSBCBKPQSFTFOUBEPBMBT**+PSOBEBTTPCSFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTQÞCMJ DPTTBOJUBSJPT6OJWFSTJEBE$BSMPT***EF.BESJENJNFPRVFTFQVCMJDBFOFTUF NJTNPWPMVNFO ;03/0;"1²3&;+Corresponsabilidad fiscal y financiación de las Comunidades Autónomas: el modelo para el quinquenio 1997-2001FO+*.&/&;#-"/$0"FE &M&TUBEP EF MBT "VUPOPNÓBT -PT TFDUPSFT QSPEVDUJWPT Z MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO UFSSJUPSJBM EFM FTUBEP .BESJE ;03/0;"1²3&;+Los Impuestos Especiales en el marco del Sistema tributario español: impuestos estatales o impuestos cedidos a las Comunidades Autónomas,FO""77-PT*NQVFTUPT &TQFDJBMFTIPZFO&TQB×BZFOMBVOJØO&VSPQFB7**+PSOBEBTEF&TUVEJPT"EVBOFSPT .BESJE RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 35 a 64 ALTERAÇÃO E MUDANÇA DA CONSTITUIÇÃO. O CASO BRASILEIRO.1 Amendments and Mutation of Constitution. The Brazilian case. Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho2 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP"NVEBOÎBOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP04VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMFBTQSJODJ QBJTNVEBOÎBTJOGPSNBJTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEF*NQMJDBÎÜFTFRVFTUJPOBNFOUPT RESUMO 0PCKFUJWPEPQSFTFOUFFTUVEPÏDPNQSFFOEFSPJNQBDUPOB%FNPDSBDJBCSBTJMFJSB QSPNPWJEPQFMBTBMUFSBÎÜFTGPSNBJTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPPDPSSJEBTEFTEFBOBMJTBO EPTFBMFHJUJNJEBEFEBEFNPDSBDJBFODPOUSBTFBTTFHVSBEBBUSBWÏTEPQBQFMEFTFN QFOIBEPQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMOBWBMPSBÎÍPEBTFNFOEBTEVSBOUFBSFWJTÍP KVEJDJBMBTTFHVSBOEPTVBFmDJÐODJBOPQSPDFTTPEFDPOUSPMFEBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF ABSTRACT 5IFPCKFDUJWFPGUIJTTUVEZJTVOEFSTUBOEUIFJNQBDUPO#SB[JMJBOT%FNPDSBDZQSPNP UFECZDPOTUJUVUJPOBNFOENFOUTTJODFBOBMZTJOHJGUIFEFNPDSBUJDMFHJUJNBDZ JTFOTVSFECZUIFSPMFVOEFSUBLFOCZUIF4VQSFNF$PVSUEVSJOHUIFKVEJDJBMSFWJFX WBMVBUJOHBNFOENFOUTBOEBTTVSJOHJUTFGmDBDZJOUIFDPOTUJUVUJPOBMDPOUSPMQSPDFTT Palavras-chaves$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMo&NFOEBTo&GFUJWJEBEFo7BMPSo.VUBÎÍP $POTUJUVDJPOBMo$POUSPMFEF$POTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFo%FNPDSBDJB Keywords$POTUJUVUJPOo"NFOENFOUTo&GGFDUJWFOFTTo7BMVF.VUBUJPO $POTUJUVUJPOBMDPOUSPMPGDPOTUJUVUJPOBMJUZo%FNPDSBDZ INTRODUÇÃO ²GBUPOPUØSJPRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPCSBTJMFJSBoEFTEFBTVBQSPNVMHBÎÍP FNEFPVUVCSPEFoBUÏIPKFoTFUFNCSPEFoGPJNPEJmDBEBQPS &NFOEBTEFSFWJTÍPNBJTPSEJOÈSJBT 0CWJBNFOUFQPSUBOUPUFWFFMBPTFVUFPS BMUFSBEPFNOVNFSPTPTQPOUPTJNQPSUBOUFT01PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPQPSFYFNQMPTPGSFV NFTNPVNBSFGPSNBQPSNFJPEFVNBFNFOEBFYBUBNFOUFDPOIFDJEBQPS3FGPSNB EP+VEJDJÈSJP&NFOEBO ²FTUBBUFSDFJSBWFSTÍPEFTUFUSBCBMIPFNSB[ÍPEBDPSSFÎÍPEFFOHBOPTFPBDSÏTDJNPEFOPWPTBT QFDUPT$FSUBNFOUFBJOEBWJSÍPPVUSBTQFMBTNFTNBTSB[ÜFT1FÎPFTDVTBTQPSQVCMJDBSVNUSBCBMIP JNQFSGFJUPNBTPGBÎPQBSBBUFOEFSBJOUFSFTTBEPTRVFUFOEPNFPVWJEPTPCSFPBTTVOUPRVFSFNUFS OBTNÍPTVNUFYUPNBJTQSFDJTP 1SPGFTTPS&NÏSJUPEB'BDVMEBEFEF%JSFJUPEB6411SPGFTTPS5JUVMBSBQPTFOUBEP EF%JSFJUP$POTUJUV DJPOBMEB'BDVMEBEFEF%JSFJUPEB641%PVUPShonoris causaEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPB%PVUPSQFMB 6OJWFSTJEBEF EF 1BSJT &Y1SPGFTTPS WJTJUBOUF EB 'BDVMEBEF EF %JSFJUP EF Aix-en-Provence 'SBOÎB .FNCSPEB"DBEFNJB#SBTJMFJSBEF-FUSBT+VSÓEJDBT1SFTJEFOUFEP*OTUJUVUPi1JNFOUB#VFOPwo"TTP DJBÎÍP#SBTJMFJSBEPT$POTUJUVDJPOBMJTUBT 66 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho &MBTFNEÞWJEBQPSJTTPNVEPV$POUVEPOÍPUFSÈFMBNVEBEPTFNRVFP GPTTFQPSBMUFSBÎÍPGPSNBMEFTFVUFYUP $PNFGFJUPEFIÈNVJUPPTKVSJTUBTKÈTFBQFSDFCFSBNRVFBT$POTUJUVJÎÜFT NVEBNNFTNPTFNBMUFSBÎÍPEPUFYUP"BMUFSBÎÍPGPSNBMQSPEV[NVEBOÎBTRVF QPEFNTFSEJUBTNVEBOÎBTGPSNBJTFOUSFUBOUPBFYQFSJÐODJBBQPOUBQBSBPGBUPEF RVFBT$POTUJUVJÎÜFTUBNCÏNNVEBNoFRVBOUPoJOGPSNBMNFOUFRVFSEJ[FSTFN BMUFSBÎÍPEBTVBMFUSB4JNQPSRVFBNVEBOÎBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPoNVEBOÎBEFTFOUJEP oOÍPQSPWÏNBQFOBTEFBMUFSBÎÜFTEFTVBSFEBÎÍP 0QSFTFOUFFTUVEPWJTBBFYBNJOBSTFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFNVEPVJO GPSNBMNFOUFFNBTQFDUPTTJHOJmDBUJWPTFRVBOUP"RVFTUÍPOÍPÏEFTQJDJFOEBQPJT OP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMKÈTFDIFHPVBTVTUFOUBSRVFFMBOÍPTPNFOUFNVEPV NBTTPGSFVNVUBÎÍP "SFTQPTUBBFTTBRVFTUÍPFOWPMWFQFSRVJSJÎÜFTEFQFMPNFOPTEVBTPSEFOT oJTUPOÍPTFEFJYBOEPPFTUSJUPDBNQPKVSÓEJDPQPJTTFTFEFTDFTTFBPEBQPMÓUJDBEB TPDJPMPHJBEBIJTUØSJBNVJUBTPVUSBTTFJNQPSJBN "QSJNFJSBEFMBTÏBBOÈMJTFEPGFOÙNFOPEBNVEBOÎBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFOGB UJ[BOEPBRVFTUÍPEBTNVEBOÎBTOÍPGPSNBJTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP"ÞMUJNBPFYBNFEF BMHVNBTJNQMJDBÎÜFTEPVUSJOÈSJBTFQSBUJDBNFOUFJNQPSUBOUFT&OUSFFMBTTFJOTJOVB PVUSBRVBMTFKBBEBTNVEBOÎBTPQFSBEBTJOGPSNBMNFOUFOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPCSBTJMFJSB OP QFSÓPEP QFMP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM PV DPN B iTBOÎÍPw EFTUF DVKPQBQFMQSJNPSEJBMOFTTBPDPSSÐODJBBEJBOUFTFBOBMJTB 1. A MUDANÇA NA CONSTITUIÇÃO4 $PNPÏFMFNFOUBSBT$POTUJUVJÎÜFTFTDSJUBTEPDVNFOUBJT TPNFOUFQP EFNTFSBMUFSBEBTQPSFNFOEBTBEPUBEBTQPSVNQSPDFEJNFOUPGPSNBMRVFBQSØQSJB $POTUJUVJÎÍPFTUBCFMFDF&TUÈOJTUPBDIBNBEBSJHJEF[EB$POTUJUVJÎÍPRVFÏHFOFSB MJ[BEBOBT$POTUJUVJÎÜFTFTDSJUBTTFOEPFYDFQDJPOBMRVFBENJUBFTUBTBMUFSBÎÜFTQPS GPSÎBEFMFJTBEPUBEBTQFMPQSPDFEJNFOUPPSEJOÈSJPEFMFHJGFSBÎÍP0CWJBNFOUFFTTBT BMUFSBÎÜFTGPSNBJTMFWBNRVBOEPFGFUJWBT BNVEBOÎBTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPNVEBOÎBT RVFFNEFDPSSÐODJBEFTVBGPOUFTÍPDIBNBEBTEFNVEBOÎBTGPSNBJT 3 %B EJTUJOÎÍP BQPOUBEB UPSOBTF DMBSP RVF OFTUF USBCBMIP BMUFSBÎÍP F NVEBOÎB OÍP TÍP TJOÙOJNPT "MUFSBÎÍPÏNPEJmDBÎÍPOPUFYUPNVEBOÎBÏNPEJmDBÎÍPOPTFOUJEPTJHOJmDBÎÍPPVBMDBODF1BSB QFSDFCÐMPOÍPÏQSFDJTPSFDPSSFSËTTVUJMF[BTEBTFNJØUJDB &YQPOIPOFTUFUFYUPJEFJBTRVFIBVSJFNNVJUBTPCSBTFOUSFBTRVBJTEFTUBDPBTEF,FOOFUI$ 8IFBSF, Modern Constitutions, "7%JDFZoLaw of the ConstitutionBTEPTDPMBCPSBEPSFTEBPCSBDPMFUJWBLes règles et principes non écrits en droit publicDPPSEFOBEBQPS1JFSSF"WSJMF.JDIFM7FSQFBVYUBNCÏN1JFSSF"WSJMoLes conventions de la ConstitutionFFOUSFPTCSBTJMFJSPT"OOB$ÉOEJEBEB$VOIB'FSSB[Processos informais de mudança da ConstituiçãoFOUSFNVJUPTPVUSPT"FTUFTBVUPSFTÏRVFEFWFNTFSDSFEJUBEPTPTNÏSJUPTEB DPOUSJCVJÎÍPOÍPQSFUFOEFOEPFTUFUSBCBMIPTFOÍPEJWVMHÈMBBQMJDBOEPBËFYQFSJÐODJBCSBTJMFJSB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 67 &OUSFUBOUPoDPNPKÈTFBTTJOBMPVOBJOUSPEVÎÍPoKVSJTUBTNBJTTVUJTEFIÈ NVJUPTFBQFSDFCFSBNEFRVFBT$POTUJUVJÎÜFTNVEBNFGFUJWBNFOUFOPTFVDPOUFÞ EPOPSNBUJWPTFNRVFJTTPTFKBEFUFSNJOBEPQPSBMUFSBÎÜFTGPSNBJT0VTFKBTPGSFN NVEBOÎBTJOGPSNBJT0UFYUPOÍPÏBMUFSBEPNBTPTFVTFOUJEPNVEB "NVEBOÎBJOGPSNBMEFSJWBEFEJWFSTPTNPUJWPTBMHVOTEFMFTFOVNFSBEPT BTFHVJSOÍPFNDBSÈUFSUBYBUJWPFTJNFYFNQMJmDBUJWP 6NQSJNFJSPBDPOTJEFSBSÏBnova compreensão dos valoresRVFBJOTQJSBN %JTUPÏFYFNQMPOBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBCSBTJMFJSBBFYUFOTÍPEBEBËiEJHOJEBEF EBQFTTPBIVNBOBwJOTDSJUBDPNPQSJODÓQJPGVOEBNFOUBMEB3FQÞCMJDBOP"SU ***4ÍPJODPOUÈWFJTBTEFDJTÜFTRVFGVOEBEBTFNJOUFSQSFUBÎÜFTOÍPSBSPTVCKFUJWJT UBTSFDPOIFDFNEJSFJUPTDPNCBTFOFMBBJOEBPTWFOEPDPNPEJSFJUPTBCTPMVUPTF JMJNJUBEPT²PDBTPEPEJSFJUPËTBÞEF 0VUSPÏBreação em face de problemas insuspeitadosQFMPDPOTUJUVJOUF "RVJTFQÜFoTFNQSFDPNPFYFNQMPCSBTJMFJSPoPDBTPEBTSFOÞODJBTBNBOEBUPQBSB FWJUBSTBOÎÜFT*TUPRVFTFUPSOPVGSFRVFOUFOPQMBOPQBSMBNFOUBSFDMPEJVEFNPEP FTUSPOEPTPRVBOEPOPimpeachmentEP1SFT$PMMPSFTUFSFOVODJPVQBSBFWJUBSBJN QPTJÎÍPEBQFOBBDFTTØSJBEFTVTQFOTÍPEPTEJSFJUPTQPMÓUJDPT5BMQFOBMIFGPJBTTJN NFTNPBQMJDBEBDPOUSBSJBOEPPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPUSBEJDJPOBMEFRVFOÍPQPEFOEPTFS JNQPTUBBQFOBQSJODJQBMoOPDBTPBQFSEBEPNBOEBUPoOÍPQPEFSJBTFSBQMJDBEBB QFOBBDFTTØSJBoBTVTQFOTÍP$FSUBNFOUFBQFSDFQÎÍPEBGSBVEFEJUPVFTUBTPMVÎÍP 6NUFSDFJSPQPEFTFSWJTUPOBaceitação de práticasRVFHFSBNDPOWFOÎÜFT OBMJÎÍPEF%JDFZ PVBUÏWFSEBEFJSPTDPTUVNFT"TTJNPDPSSFVOP#SBTJMBOUFTEB &NFOEB O DPN B SFFEJÎÍP EF NFEJEBT QSPWJTØSJBT OÍP BQSPWBEBT OFN SFKFJUBEBTOPQSB[PDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFUSJOUBEJBT&TUBTQSÈUJDBTQPEFNBEFNBJTTFS FODBSBEBTDPNPBJEFOUJmDBÎÍPEFOPSNBTOÍPFTDSJUBTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPVNBPVUSB IJQØUFTFEFNVEBOÎBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP 2VBSUBIJQØUFTFÏFYBUBNFOUFBSFGFSJEBdescoberta de normas não escritas, mas implícitasOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP*TUPUSBOTQBSFDFEPFOUFOEJNFOUPIPKFBEPUB EP EF RVF B SFOÞODJB EF NBOEBUP QBSMBNFOUBS BOUFT EF JOTUBVSBEP QSPDFEJNFOUP QVOJUJWPOÍPHFSBJOFHJCJMJEBEF0VPSFWFSTPEFRVFQPEFPQBSMBNFOUBSQFSEFSP NBOEBUPQPSEFJYBSPQBSUJEPQFMPRVBMTFFMFHFV &OmNOÍPTFQPEFJHOPSBSRVFP&TUBEPDPOUFNQPSÉOFPTPGSFVNBHSBOEF JOnVÐODJBEFJOTUJUVJÎÜFTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTFQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEFTUBTEPEJSFJUPJOUFSOBDJP OBMFTQFDJBMNFOUFFNNBUÏSJBEFEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTPRVFTFSFnFUFOÍPTPNFOUF FN BMUFSBÎÜFT RVF USB[FN NVEBOÎBT GPSNBJT DPOUVEP UBNCÏN FN FOUFOEJNFOUPT OPWPTRVFTFBTTJNJMBNBNVEBOÎBTJOGPSNBJT /BTVBPCSBDMÈTTJDB– Introduction to the study of the Law of the constitutionoFMFBQPOUBBFYJTUÐODJB EBTiDPOWFOÎÜFTEBDPOTUJUVJÎÍPw 3FnFYPEJTUPFTUÈOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPCSBTJMFJSBOPEJTQPTUPOPBSUfBDSFTDFOUBEPQFMB&NFOEB$POT UJUVDJPOBMOFOPOPWPFOUFOEJNFOUPQPSQBSUFEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMBDFSDBEBSFMBÎÍP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 68 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho ²DFSUPRVFOBNBJPSQBSUFEBTWF[FTFTTBTNVEBOÎBTBQBSFDFNOBKVSJT QSVEÐODJBFTÍPKVTUJmDBEBTDPNPJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEPUFYUP)ÈTFNEÞWJEBVNBi[POB DJO[FOUBwBTFQBSBSBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPFBDSJBÎÍPoIÈUPEBVNBFTDPMBRVFJOTJTUFFN RVFUPEBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPFOWPMWFVNBDSJBÎÍP&OUSFUBOUPBNFVWFSIÈDSJBÎÍPUPEB WF[ RVF B QSFUFOEJEB JOUFSQSFUBÎÍP FYUSBWBTB P FOUFOEJNFOUP EP UFYUP BQPOUBOEP OPSNBTUÍPEJTUBOUFTEBSFEBÎÍPFTDSJUBRVFTFSJBIJQPDSJTJBQSFUFOEFSTFSFNEFEV [JEBTEPUFYUPFTDSJUP"TTJNQPSFYFNQMPRVBOEPTFFTUFOEFBPDPOUSPMFDPODSFUP EFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFPRVFÏBENJUJEPQBSBPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPFWJDFWFSTBDPNP WÈSJBTWF[FTPGB[P4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM0VRVBOEPÏBSSPHBEPVNQPEFSRVF OÍPFTUÈOBFTGFSBEFDPNQFUÐODJBEFTUF 1PSPVUSPMBEPMFNCSFTFRVFOPT&TUBEPT6OJEPTEB"NÏSJDBGPSUFFJNQPS UBOUFDPSSFOUFFOUFOEFRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFEFWFTFSJOUFSQSFUBEBDPNPTFOUJEP CÈTJDPRVFEFnVJEBWPOUBEFEPTfounding fathers. 5BMQPTJDJPOBNFOUPTFSBEJDBMJ[BEPQFUSJmDBB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFTVQFSWBMPSJ[B BWPOUBEFEPMFHJTMBEPSoBvoluntas legislatorisoRVFOÍPTFDPOGVOEFOFDFTTBSJBNFO UFDPNBvoluntas legisDPNPEFIÈNVJUPTFBENJUFFOUSFOØT&TUBÞMUJNBBENJUF SFTQFJUBEPTDFSUPTQBSÉNFUSPTDPNPBmOBMJEBEFEBOPSNBBTVBBUVBMJ[BÎÍPBOPWPT UFNQPT&TUBJOEVCJUBWFMNFOUFBCSFPDBNQPQBSBiJOUFSQSFUBÎÜFTDSJBUJWBTwoVTP EF FYQSFTTÍP DPOTBHSBEB QFMP 1SPG &MJWBM EB 4JMWB 3BNPT o RVF TFNQSF TF EFWFN EJTUJOHVJSEBTDSJBÎÜFTUSBWFTUJEBTEFJOUFSQSFUBÎÜFT %FWFTFPCTFSWBSPVUSPTTJNRVFBJEFOUJmDBÎÍPEFOPSNBTOÍPFTDSJUBT iBVNFOUBwPViBMBSHBwB$POTUJUVJÎÍP0NFMIPSFYFNQMPEJTUPWFNEPEJSFJUPDPOT UJUVDJPOBMGSBODÐT $PNPTFTBCFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFOÍPDPOUÏNOFNEFDMBSBÎÍPEFEJ SFJUPT OFN EJTQPTJÎÜFT TPCSF B PSEFN FDPOÙNJDB F TPDJBM "QFOBT TFV 1SFÉNCVMP SFNFUFBP1SFÉNCVMPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFRVFDPOmSNBBBEFTÍPBPTQSJODÓQJPT EB%FDMBSBÎÍPEPT%JSFJUPTEP)PNFNFEP$JEBEÍPEFCFNDPNPBPTRVF FNNBUÏSJBFDPOÙNJDPTPDJBMOFMFTÍPFOVODJBEPT5BJTQSJODÓQJPTWJFSBNBTFSBQMJ DBEPTQFMP$POTFMIP$POTUJUVDJPOBMOPFYFSDÓDJPEPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF FBTTJNTFEFTFOWPMWFVOBEPVUSJOBBUFTFEPiBloc de constitutionnalitéw&NUFSNPT TJNQMJmDBEPTBDPODFQÎÍPEFRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPGSBODFTBOÍPTFMJNJUBBPUFYUPQSP NVMHBEPFNNBTJODMVJFOUSFTFVTQSJODÓQJPTFSFHSBTPRVFEFDPSSFEPTSFGSJ EPT1SFÉNCVMPT"TTJNTFOEPDPNPEFnVJEBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBEPSFGFSJEP$POTFMIP BmTDBMJ[BÎÍPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFUPNBDPNPQBSÉNFUSPFNNBUÏSJBEFEJSFJUPT GVOEBNFOUBJTB%FDMBSBÎÍPEFRVFQPSUBOUPÏOPSNBWJHFOUF FOUSFPEJSFJUPJOUFSOBDJPOBMBEWJOEPEFUSBUBEPTFPEJSFJUPJOUFSOPoNFTNPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM&TUÈBRVJVN QPOUPOÍPBCPSEBEPOFTUBWFSTÍPEFTUFUSBCBMIPRVFGPSÎPTBNFOUFPTFSÈFVNBPVUSBGPSFTUBCFMFDJEB 7TPCSFPBTTVOUPQPSFYFNQMP$BTT4VOTUFJOA Constituição parcialpassim. 5BMOPÎÍPEFRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPÏNBJTRVFPUFYUPBTTJNEFOPNJOBEPGPJJODPSQPSBEBQFMPQFOTBNFOUP KVSÓEJDPFTQBOIPM7-PVJT'BWPSFVF'SBODJTDP3VCJP-MPSFOUFEl bloque de constitucionalidad. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 69 1PS JTUP OB DPOIFDJEB MJÎÍP EF 8IFBSF “Constitutions are not made, they growwi"T$POTUJUVJÎÜFTOÍPTÍPGFJUBTFMBTDSFTDFNw &TTBNVEBOÎBJOGPSNBMUFNDPNPBUPSEFTUBDBEPDPOUVEPOÍPÞOJDPP +VEJDJÈSJPQSJODJQBMNFOUFB$PSUFDPOTUJUVDJPOBM&OUSFUBOUPOFNTFNQSFÏFMFPBV UPSEBNVEBOÎBNBTTJNQMFTNFOUFRVFNDIBODFMBFTTBTNVEBOÎBTSFDPOIFDFOEP MIFTWBMPSEFOPSNBTKVSÓEJDBTFGFUJWBTFFmDB[FT/P#SBTJMUPEBWJBPTFVQBQFMEF BHFOUFTFWFNBDFOUVBOEPDPOGPSNFTFBOBMJTBSÈNBJTBEJBOUF 5PEPTPT1PEFSFTDPNFGFJUPNVEBNB$POTUJUVJÎÍPRVBOEPEFTFOWPMWFN QSÈUJDBT EF SFMBDJPOBNFOUP FTQFDJBMNFOUF P &YFDVUJWP F P -FHJTMBUJWP "TTJN OPT &TUBEPT6OJEPTP1SFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDBOÍPSFDFCFEPUFYUPEFBJOJDJBUJWB MFHJTMBUJWBNBTOFNQPSJTTPEFJYBFMFEFTFSBVUPSEFOVNFSPTÓTTJNPTQSPKFUPTGPS NBMJ[BEPTTFNBTVBBTTJOBUVSB 0VUSPTTJNP-FHJTMBUJWPFTQFDJBMNFOUFBGFJÎPBPQSPDFTTPMFHJTMBUJWP²PRVF OP#SBTJMGB[FMFUPSOBOEPMFUSBNPSUBPiKVÓ[PQSÏWJPTPCSFPBUFOEJNFOUPEPT QSFT TVQPTUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTwEBTNFEJEBTQSPWJTØSJBT"SUfEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPDPNB SFEBÎÍPEB&NFOEBO *HVBMNFOUFBQMJDBOEPOPSNBTSFHFOUFTEBFMBCPSB ÎÍPEBMFJBPQSPDFTTPEFBEPÎÍPEF&NFOEBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT1PSFYFNQMPiFTRVFDFO EPwBTEVBTWPUBÎÜFTTPCSFUPEPPUFYUPDPOGPSNFQSFWÐB$POTUJUVJÎÍPQBSBBT&NFO EBT"SUf QBSBGB[ÐMPBQFOBTRVBOUPBPRVFGPJBMUFSBEPOB$BTBiSFWJTPSBwP RVFTFBENJUFFNSFMBÎÍPBPTQSPKFUPTEFMFJ"SUQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDP *HVBMNFOUFP-FHJTMBUJWPNVEBB$POTUJUVJÎÍPRVBOEPBEPUBMFJTJOUFSQSF UBUJWBT PV SFHVMBNFOUBEPSBT RVF EÍP OPWP BMDBODF B OPSNBT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJT #PN FYFNQMPEJTUPÏB-FJORVFBPSFHVMBNFOUBSBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJ UVDJPOBMJEBEFFEFDMBSBUØSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFJOPWPVFNWÈSJPTQPOUPT"MÏN EJTUPBENJUJVDMBSBNFOUFDPOUSBVNBMPOHBUSBEJÎÍPDPSSPCPSBEBQFMBQSØQSJBKV SJTQSVEÐODJBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMRVFOFNTFNQSFPBUPJODPOTUJUVDJPOBM ÏOVMPFÓSSJUPEFWFOEPUFSPTTFVTFGFJUPTEFTDPOTUJUVÓEPTex tunc%FGBUPP"SU EFTTB-FJQFSNJUJVBSFTUSJÎÍPEPTFGFJUPTEBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFUBOUPOPUFNQP RVBOUPOBTVCTUÉODJBoBDIBNBEBiNPEVMBÎÍPwEPTFGFJUPT "NVEBOÎBJOGPSNBMQPEFJSUÍPMPOHFRVFDPOmHVSBTFHVOEPBQPOUBBEPV USJOBVNBNVUBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM0VTFKBPOPWPTFOUJEPFTUÈUÍPMPOHFEPPSJHJOBM DPOTJEFSBEPFNCMPDPRVFQPEFTFSUJEPDPNPFYQSJNJOEPVNBOPWB$POTUJUVJÎÍP *OEJDBTFDPNPFYFNQMPEFTUFGFOÙNFOPPDIBNBEP&TUBUVUP"MCFSUJOPEF &TUFGPJQSPNVMHBEPDPNP$POTUJUVJÎÍPEPSFJOPEB4BSEFOIB$PNBVOJm DBÎÍP JUBMJBOB UPSOPVTF B $POTUJUVJÎÍP EB *UÈMJB F WJHPSPV GPSNBMNFOUF BUÏ EF $PNPTFWÐFTUFKVSJTUBKÈBOUFDJQPVVNBEBTJEFJBTNBHOBTEBNPEFSOBUFPSJBEBBVUPQPJFTFKVSÓEJDB *TUPEFVMVHBSIÈQPVDPEFNBSÎPEF BVNBSVNPSPTBEFDMBSBÎÍPEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF QFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM"%*SFM.JOJTUSP-VJ['VY 0UFNBGPJBCPSEBEPFNQSPGVOEJEBEFOP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMQFMPT.JOJTUSPT(JMNBS.FOEFT F&SPT(SBVDPNPTFFYBNJOBSÈNBJTBEJBOUF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 70 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho EF[FNCSPEFRVBOEPDFEFVMVHBSËWJHFOUF$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDBEB*UÈMJB /FTTFMPOHPTÏDVMPUBM$BSUBQSFTJEJVVNBNPOBSRVJBMJNJUBEBEFQPJTVNBEFNP DSBDJBSFQSFTFOUBUJWBEFSFHJNFQBSMBNFOUBSJTUBNBJTUBSEFVN&TUBEPGBTDJTUBFGPJ JOWPDBEBFYQSFTTBNFOUFFNRVBOEPEBEFTUJUVJÎÍPEF.VTTPMJOJ&OUSFUBOUP EFWFTFUFSFNNFOUFQPSVNMBEPRVFTFUSBUBWBFNCPSBFTDSJUBEFVNB$POTUJUVJ ÎÍPnFYÓWFMQPSUBOUPBMUFSÈWFMFBMUFSBEBQFMBMFJPSEJOÈSJB 4PCTVBÏHJEFBMJÈTWJFSBNËMV[OPSNBTOÍPFTDSJUBTRVF#JTDBSFUUJEJ3VGmB EFOPNJOPVinorme di correttezza costituzionalewRVFTFSWJSBNQBSBNVJUBTBEBQUB ÎÜFTBVNBSFBMJEBEFQPMÓUJDBoFTUBTJNoJODPOUFTUBWFMNFOUFNVUBOUF 2. O SUPREMO TRIBUNAL FEDERAL E AS PRINCIPAIS MUDANÇAS INFORMAIS NA CONSTITUIÇÃO DE 1988 /B WJHÐODJB EB -FJ .BHOB EF TPCSFUVEP OPT ÞMUJNPT EF[ BOPT P 4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMWFNUPNBOEPEFDJTÜFTRVFNVJUPTFBGBTUBNEBMFUSBEB $POTUJUVJÎÍPTFKBOPÉNCJUPEPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPTFKBOPÉNCJUPEPDPOUSPMFDPODSF UPRVFSOBTBÎÜFTEFDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFTUSJUBNFOUFGBMBOEPRVFSOBT BÎÜFTRVFUBNCÏNPJOTUSVNFOUBMJ[BNDPNPPNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍP"TTJNQPEFTF EJ[FSRVFFMFUFNmudadoB$BSUBGVOEBNFOUBM5FNJEPNVJUPBMÏNEFOFHBSWBMJEB EFBMFJTFBUPTJODPOTUJUVDJPOBJTWFNPVTBOEPDPOTUSVJSVNBPSEFNDPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVFSFnFUFPTFVFOUFOEJNFOUPBDFSDBEPTWBMPSFTFQSJODÓQJPTEB-FJTVQSFNB/JTUP FWJEFOUFNFOUFBTTVNFVNQBQFMQPMÓUJDPOPTFOUJEPOPCSFEPUFSNP QPSRVFDPO USJCVJQBSBBHPWFSOBOÎBEP&TUBEPCSBTJMFJSP ²PRVFTFWBJNPTUSBSJOEJDBOEPFBOBMJTBOEPTVNBSJTTJNBNFOUF BMHVNBT EFUBJTEFDJTÜFT "TQSJNFJSBTEFDJTÜFTRVFNFSFDFSJBNFYBNFTFSJBNBToKÈBMVEJEBTo FNRVFP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMEFDMBSPVQPTTÓWFMBSFFEJÎÍPEFNFEJEBTQSPWJTØ SJBTOÍPUSBOTGPSNBEBTFNMFJQFMP$POHSFTTP/BDJPOBMTFNRVFFTUFFYQSFTTBNFOUF BTUJWFTTFSFKFJUBEP&MBTDPNFGFJUPGPSBNEBTQSJNFJSBTBNVEBSB$POTUJUVJÎÍP" RVFTUÍPQPSÏNQFSEFVJNQPSUÉODJBDPNBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEB&NFOEBORVF BSFEFmOJVFSFHVMPV&OUSFUBOUPDBCFMFNCSBSRVFBSFEBÎÍPQSJNJUJWBEP"SUEB $POTUJUVJÎÍPOÍPQSFWJBBSFFEJÎÍPFEBWBBFOUFOEFSDMBSBNFOUF BJNQPTTJCJMJEBEF %FGBUPPQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDPEP"SUEJTQVOIBTFNPCTDVSJEBEF 1BPMP#JTDBSFUUJEJ3VGmBLe norme della correttezza costituzionale /BWFSEBEFQPEFTFEJ[FSRVFP+VEJDJÈSJPCSBTJMFJSPDPNPVNUPEPWFNBTTVNJOEPVNQBQFMBUJWPOB HPWFSOBOÎBOÍPIFTJUBOEPQPSFYFNQMPFNQSPNPWFSBDPODSFUJ[BÎÍPEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTPVBFGFUJWB ÎÍPEFEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJT"BOÈMJTFEFTUFGFOÙNFOPFTDBQBËUFNÈUJDBEFTUFUSBCBMIPNBTUSBUPEFMF FNWÈSJPTFTUVEPTDPNPiO papel político do Judiciário na ordem constitucionalwQVCMJDBEPOBRevista dos AdvogadosEB""41OÞNFSPEFEJDBEPBPTBOPTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPBOP997***TFUFNCSPEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 71 iAs medidas provisórias perderão eficácia, desde a edição, se não forem convertidas em lei no prazo de trinta dias, a partir de sua publicaçãoEFWFOEPP $POHSFTTP/BDJPOBMEJTDJQMJOBSBTSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDBTEFMBTEFDPSSFOUFTwTVCMJOIFJ "NVEBOÎBGFJUBQFMP4VQSFNPGPJBBEKVOÎÍPEFVNBFYDFÎÍPoPSFDPOIFDJ NFOUPEFVNBOPSNBOÍPFTDSJUBRVFEJSJBoiFYDFUPTFOÍPUJWFSIBWJEPEFMJCFSBÎÍP TPCSFFMBTwDPORVBOUPBOÍPDPOWFSTÍPKÈQVEFTTFJOEJDBSBOFHBUJWB 0SBPJNQBDUPEFTTBFYDFÎÍPGPJHSBWF$PNFGFJUPUSBOTGPSNPVP&YFDVUJWP FNMFHJTMBEPSEFGBUPQPJTMIFQFSNJUJVFEJUBSOPSNBTRVFTFNBQSPWBÎÍPEP-FHJTMB UJWPTFQFSQFUVBWBNQFMBTSFFEJÎÜFToËTWF[FTQPSEF[FOBTEFWF[FT*TUPTFPCUJOIB FNWJTUBEBPCTUSVÎÍPEBCBODBEBHPWFSOJTUBFEPBDÞNVMPEFNFEJEBTBWPUBSQFMP $POHSFTTP"MÏNEJTUPDSJPVVNGBUPSEFJOTFHVSBOÎBKVSÓEJDBWJTUPRVFBTOPSNBT FEJUBEBTFSBNiQSPWJTØSJBTwoFNUFTFoKÈRVFQPEFSJBNOÍPTFSDPOWFSUJEBTFNMFJ QFSEFOEPFmDÈDJBex tuncoOFNTFGBMBOEPRVFOBTSFFEJÎÜFTOÍPSBSPP&YFDVUJWP BMUFSBWBBMHVNBTEBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEPBUPSFOPWBEP 0VUSBEFDJTÍPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMUPNBEBFTUBTFNRVBMRVFS GVOEBNFOUP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM NBT KVTUJmDBEB QFMB OFDFTTJEBEF F QFMB VSHÐODJB GPJ P DBTPEBmYBÎÍPEPOÞNFSPEFWFSFBEPSFT " $POTUJUVJÎÍP EF BUSJCVJ BPT .VOJDÓQJPT P QPEFS EF BVUP PSHBOJ[BÎÍPSFTQFJUBEPTPTQSJODÓQJPTFOPSNBTRVFFMBQSØQSJBFEJUBBSFTQFJUPEF MFTCFNDPNPPTRVFOBTVBFTGFSBEFDPNQFUÐODJBGPSFNQPTUPTQFMPT&TUBEPTFN RVFTFJOUFHSBN"SU 0SBB$POTUJUVJÎÍPOBSFEBÎÍPRVFQFSEVSPVBUÏB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBM OEJTQVOIBOPJODJTP*7RVF 0OÞNFSPEFWFSFBEPSFT<TFSJB>QSPQPSDJPOBMËQPQVMBÎÍPEP.VOJDÓQJP PCTFSWBEPTPTTFHVJOUFTMJNJUFT <> *7 OÞNFSP EF WFSFBEPSFT QSPQPSDJPOBM Ë QPQVMBÎÍP EP .VOJDÓQJP PCTFSWBEPTPTTFHVJOUFTMJNJUFTB NÓOJNPEFOPWFFNÈYJNPEFWJOUF FVNOPT.VOJDÓQJPTEFBUÏVNNJMIÍPEFIBCJUBOUFTC NÓOJNPEF USJOUBFUSÐTFNÈYJNPEFRVBSFOUBFVNOPT.VOJDÓQJPTEFNBJTEFVN NJMIÍPFNFOPTEFDJODPNJMIÜFTEFIBCJUBOUFTD NÓOJNPEFRVBSFOUB FEPJTFNÈYJNPEFDJORVFOUBFDJODPOPTNVOJDÓQJPTEFNBJTEFDJODP NJMIÜFTEFIBCJUBOUFT /FNTFGBMFEPEFTJOUFSFTTFEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMQFMBBGFSJÎÍPEBDPOEJÎÍPEFVSHÐODJBQPTUB QFMPBSUcaputFYJHJEBDPNPDPOEJÎÍPQBSBBFEJÎÍPEBNFEJEBQSPWJTØSJB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 72 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho $POTJEFSBOEP P TFV QPEFS EF BVUPPSHBOJ[BÎÍP F P GBUP EF RVF B OPSNB DPOTUJUVDJPOBMGFEFSBMTFSFGFSJBBiMJNJUFTwNVJUPTNVOJDÓQJPTmYBSBNOPNÈYJNP QFSNJUJEPQBSBDBEBOÓWFMQPQVMBDJPOBMPOÞNFSPEFWFSFBEPSFTBJOUFHSBSTVB$É NBSBMFHJTMBUJWB/ÍPMFWBSBNFNDPOUBFNSJHPSNBUFNÈUJDPBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEF NFODJPOBEBOBEJTQPTJÎÍP 5BM mYBÎÍP GPJ PCKFUP EF RVFTUJPOBNFOUP KVEJDJBM OP DPOUSPMF DPODSFUP F DIFHPVQPSNFJPEFSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPËBQSFDJBÎÍPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'F EFSBM&TUFOVNleading caseKVMHPVFNJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTTBmYBÎÍPFOUFO EFOEPTFSJNQFSBUJWBBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEFEFSJHPSNBUFNÈUJDPFOUSFBQPQVMBÎÍPF POÞNFSPEFWFSFBEPSFTFNDBEBVNEPTOÓWFJTFTUBCFMFDJEPTQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP &OUSFUBOUPOFTTFNFTNPBOPJSJBPDPSSFSBSFOPWBÎÍPEPTNBOEBUPTFOÍP IBWFSJBUFNQPQBSBRVFPTNVOJDÓQJPTDPSSJHJTTFNBBOPNBMJB*TUPMFWPVP4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMBGB[FSDPNRVFP5SJCVOBM4VQFSJPS&MFJUPSBMmYBTTFQBSBBTFMFJÎÜFT POÞNFSPEFWFSFBEPSFTEFDBEBNVOJDÓQJPPRVFFTUFGF[QPSNFJPEFVNBSFTPMV ÎÍPCBJYBEBDPNBQPJPFNOPSNBEP$ØEJHP&MFJUPSBMRVFMIFQFSNJUJBSFHVMBNFO UBSPQSPDFTTPFMFJUPSBM/FTTBSFTPMVÎÍPPDSJUÏSJPGPJPEBFTUSJUBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEF DBMDVMBEBNBUFNBUJDBNFOUFFNDBEBDBTP 4FNEJTDVUJSBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEBEBBPQSFDFJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMoRVFTFNFO DJPOBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEFQFSNJUFVNBmYBÎÍPFOUSFiMJNJUFTwNÈYJNPFNÓOJNPo OÍPÏFYDFTTJWPBQPOUBSRVFOFTTBEFDJTÍPGPJIBCJMJUBEPP5SJCVOBM4VQFSJPS&MFJUPSBM BTVCTUJUVJSPQPEFSNVOJDJQBMoOPDBNQPEFBVUPOPNJBEFTUFOBmYBÎÍPEPOÞNFSP EFWFSFBEPSFT/ÍPTFDPOIFDFRVBMBOPSNBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTDSJUBRVFPKVTUJmRVF FNCPSBSB[ÜFTEFOFDFTTJEBEFFVSHÐODJBEFTTFNDPCFSUVSBËTPMVÎÍP *ODPOUFTUBWFMNFOUFQPSÏNP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMDPODFEFVBTJQSØ QSJP VNB DPNQFUÐODJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBM iFYUSBPSEJOÈSJBw FN DBTP EF VSHÐODJB 0V TFKBBEFTFTVCTUJUVJSBVNFOUFQPMÓUJDPBVUÙOPNPPVPRVFWFNBEBSQSBUJDB NFOUF OP NFTNP B EF EFTJHOBS VN ØSHÍP RVF P TVCTUJUVB OP FYFSDÓDJP EF VNB DPNQFUÐODJB QSJWBUJWB FYQSFTTBNFOUF DPOGFSJEB QFMB $POTUJUVJÎÍP B PVUSP ØSHÍP & UBMDPNQFUÐODJBÏBEFBVUPPSHBOJ[BÎÍPEFVNEPTFOUFTDPOTUJUVUJWPTEB3FQVCMJDB CSBTJMFJSBoP.VOJDÓQJP *TUPQSPWPDPVOBPQJOJÍPQÞCMJDBJODJUBEBQFMPTNFJPTEFDPNVOJDBÎÍPEFNBTTBVNBGPSUFPOEBEF JOEJHOBÎÍPQFMPBCVTPFQFMPBDSÏTDJNPEFEFTQFTBRVFBDBSSFUBWB /BSFBMJEBEFGPSBNNVJUPTPTDBTPTFPTSFDVSTPTFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPTRVFDPODFSOJBNBPNFTNPUFNB 3&41SFMBUPS.JO.BVSÓDJP$PSSÐBSFGFSFOUFBPNVOJDÓQJPEF.JSB&TUSFMBKVMHBEPFN EFNBSÎPEF "QPOUFTFRVFNPEVMPVPFGFJUPEBEFDJTÍPQBSBRVFTPNFOUFPQFSBTTFBPSFOPWBSFNTFBT$ÉNBSBT DPNPUÏSNJOPEPNBOEBUPEPTWFSFBEPSFTFNFYFSDÓDJP 3FTPMVÎÍPO 4FP&YFDVUJWPPUJWFTTFGFJUPDFSUBNFOUFP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMUFSJBEFDSFUBEPBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF -FNCSFTFPBSUcaputEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 73 .BJT/VNBUFNÈUJDBQPMÓUJDBEFMJDBEBoBEBWJODVMBÎÍPEPFMFJUPBP QBSUJEP QPS RVF TF FMFHFSB o P 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM EFV BQPJP BP 5SJCVOBM 4VQFSJPS&MFJUPSBMJOTUJUVJOEPPVSFJOTUJUVJOEPTFPQMBOPÏIJTUØSJDP BDIBNBEB mEFMJEBEFQBSUJEÈSJB $PNFGFJUPFNP5SJCVOBM4VQFSJPS&MFJUPSBMSFTQPOEFVBEVBTDPO TVMUBTJOEBHBOEPTPCSFBFYJTUÐODJBEFWÓODVMPFOUSFPFMFJUPFPQBSUJEPQFMPRVBM FMFUFSJBTJEPFMFJUPEFUBMNPEPRVFEFJYBOEPBRVFMFFTUBBHSFNJBÎÍPQFSEFSJBP NBOEBUP"QSJNFJSBDPODFSOJBBPTFMFJUPTFNFMFJÎÍPQSPQPSDJPOBMoTJTUFNBBEPUBEP QBSBB$ÉNBSBEPT%FQVUBEPT"TTFNCMFJBT-FHJTMBUJWBTEPT&TUBEPTPVEP%JTUSJUP 'FEFSBM $ÉNBSBT.VOJDJQBJT'PJFMBSFTQPOEJEBBmSNBUJWBNFOUFFOUFOEFOEPP 5SJCVOBMRVFPBCBOEPOPEPQBSUJEPTFNNPUJWPMFHÓUJNPJNQPSUBSJBFNUBMQFSEB" TFHVOEBBPTFMFJUPTFNFMFJÎÍPNBKPSJUÈSJBoTJTUFNBQSFWJTUPQBSBP4FOBEP'FEFSBM FBDIFmBEPT&YFDVUJWPTGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMFEJTUSJUBM FNVOJDJQBM"SFTQPTUBGPJ EBEBOPNFTNPTFOUJEP "QSJNFJSBGPJDPOUFTUBEBOP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMQPSNFJPEFWÈSJPT NBOEBEPTEFTFHVSBOÎBRVFUPEBWJBEFSBNBQPJPËPSJFOUBÎÍPEP5SJCVOBM4VQF SJPS&MFJUPSBM0SBDPNPTFNUBJTEFDJTÜFTEP4VQSFNPBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEP5SJCVOBM FMFJUPSBMOÍPTVCTJTUJSJBBP4VQSFNPTFIÈEFJNQVUBSBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFQFMBJOTUBV SBÎÍPEBmEFMJEBEFQBSUJEÈSJBTPCB$POTUJUVJÎÍPWJHFOUF %FTEPCSBNFOUPEJTUPGPJP5SJCVOBM4VQFSJPS&MFJUPSBMFEJUBSVNBSFTPMVÎÍP RVFSFHVMBUBMQFSEBFPQSPDFEJNFOUPRVFBEFUFSNJOBSÈ0RVFQPEFTFSWJTUPDPNP FYFSDÓDJPEPQPEFSEFMFHJTMBSUBNCÏNTPCBUVUFMBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM 1BSBBWBMJBSPBMDBODFEFTUFFOUFOEJNFOUPÏQSFDJTPMFWBSFNDPOUBBMHVOT QPOUPT0QSJNFJSPRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPOÍPFOVODJBPBCBOEPOPEPQBSUJEPDPNP DBVTBEFQFSEBEPNBOEBUP&RVBOUPBPTQBSMBNFOUBSFTGFEFSBJTFMBUSBUBEBQFSEB EPNBOEBUPEFNPEPNJOVEFOUFOP"SU0VUSPoRVFBMJNFOUBPDSJUÏSJPJOUFS QSFUBUJWPIJTUØSJDPoÏRVFTPCPSFHJNFNJMJUBSTFQSFWJVBQFSEBEPNBOEBUPQPS iJOmEFMJEBEFQBSUJEÈSJBwoFYDMVTJWBNFOUFQBSBPTNFNCSPTEP-FHJTMBUJWPOVODB QBSB PT DIFGFT EP &YFDVUJWP o F JTUP GPSB JOUFOTBNFOUF DSJUJDBEP OB FMBCPSBÎÍP EB $POTUJUVJÎÍPFNWJHPS*OEJTDVUJWFMNFOUFBJOUFOÎÍPEPMFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVDJPOBMGPJ BEFQSPTDSFWFSFTTBDBVTBEFQFSEBEFNBOEBUP0UFSDFJSPQPOUPFTUÈOPUFYUPEP "SUfEB-FJ.BHOBPÞOJDPRVFTFSFGFSFBiEJTDJQMJOBFmEFMJEBEFQBSUJEÈSJBw &TUFEJTQPTJUJWPUPEBWJBFYQSFTTBBiBVUPOPNJBwEPTQBSUJEPTiQBSBEFmOJSTVBFTUSV $POTVMUBSFM.JO"TGPS3PDIB $POTVMUBSFM.JO$BSMPT#SJUUPJOUFHSBOUFEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM .BOEBEPTEFTFHVSBOÎB.43FM.JO&SPT(SBV.43FM.JO$FMTPEF.FMMP.4 .JO$ÈSNFO-ÞDJB 3FTPMVÎÍPEFEFPVUVCSPEF3FQVCMJDBEBOP%06EF $POTUJUVJÎÍPEFDPNBSFEBÎÍPEB&NFOEBO"SUfRVFTVCTJTUJVBUÏB&NFOEB O RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 74 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho UVSBJOUFSOBPSHBOJ[BÎÍPFGVODJPOBNFOUPwFUDiEFWFOEPTFVTFTUBUVUPTFTUBCFMFDFS OPSNBT EF EJTDJQMJOB F mEFMJEBEF QBSUJEÈSJBw "TTJN FOUFOEJBTF RVF EJTDJQMJOB F mEFMJEBEFQBSUJEÈSJBTTFSJBNRVFTUÜFTinterna corporis. "TSFTQPTUBTËT$POTVMUBTCFNDPNPPTWPUPTOBTEFDJTÜFTEP4VQSFNP5SJ CVOBM'FEFSBMTÍPFSVEJUBTFFMPRVFOUFTFNNBUÏSJBEFEPVUSJOBQPMÓUJDBFYQSJNJOEP DPOWJDUBNFOUFBJEFJBEFRVFBEFNPDSBDJBTFGB[QFMPTQBSUJEPTFRVFQPSUBOUPQBSB GPSUBMFDFSBRVFMBTFEFWFGPSUBMFDÐMPT+ÈBBSHVNFOUBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBUFNNFOPTEFTFO WPMWJNFOUPDPOUFOUBOEPTFFNFTHSJNJSQPOUPTDPNPPNPOPQØMJPQBSUJEÈSJPEBT DBOEJEBUVSBTFTUBCFMFDJEPQFMB$BSUB.BHOBPVBÓOEPMFEPTJTUFNBEFSFQSFTFOUBÎÍP QSPQPSDJPOBMEPTRVBJT OÍP EFSJWB EF NPEP JOFYPSÈWFM B QFSEB EP NBOEBUP EPT JOmÏJTBPQBSUJEPQPSRVFTFFMFHFSBN 5SBUBTF DPNP TF WÐ EF EFDJTÜFT RVF BMUFSBN B FTUSVUVSB EB EFNPDSBDJB SFQSFTFOUBUJWB BEPUBEB QFMB $POTUJUVJÎÍP UPNBEBT DPN CBTF TPCSFUVEP FN BSHV NFOUBÎÍPEPVUSJOÈSJB 0VUSBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEBBTTVOÎÍPQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMEPQBQFM EFMFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVJOUFPDPSSFVBQSPQØTJUPEPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFSFMBDJPOBNFOUPT IPNPTTFYVBJTDPNPiVOJÜFTFTUÈWFJTw&NDBVTBFTUBWBBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEP"SU fEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPRVFSFDPOIFDFDPNPFOUJEBEFGBNJMJBSiBVOJÍPFTUÈWFMFOUSFP IPNFNFBNVMIFSwPRVFUBNCÏNGB[P$ØEJHP$JWJMOP"SU 4FNEÞWJEBBMHVNBOVNBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPIJTUØSJDBTFQPEFEFNPOTUSBSRVFB JOUFOÎÍPEPDPOTUJUVJOUFBPJOTDSFWFSOPUFYUPBNFOÎÍPBVOJÍPFTUÈWFMFOUSFhomem e mulherFSBFYBUBNFOUFBEFJNQFEJSRVFVOJÜFTFOUSFIPNPTTFYVBJTBMDBOÎBTTFNP status EFiFOUJEBEFGBNJMJBSw²PRVFSFTVMUBDMBSÓTTJNPEPT"OBJTEB$POTUJUVJOUFPV TFKBBSFGFSÐODJBBIPNFNFNVMIFSGPJJOTDSJUBDPNPPCKFUJWPEFDMBSBEPEFWFEBSP SFDPOIFDJNFOUPDPNPFOUJEBEFGBNJMJBSEBTVOJÜFTIPNPTTFYVBJT. %FDJEJVUPEBWJBP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMRVFPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOÍP FYDMVÓBPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFPVUSBVOJÍPFTUÈWFMBEFIPNPTTFYVBJTDPNPFOUJEBEF GBNJMJBS5BMQPTJÎÍPUFNUVEPQBSBTFSFOUFOEJEBDPNPVNBNVEBOÎBOB$POTUJUVJ ÎÍPBPNFOPTDPNTJHOJmDBEPBRVFFMBTFEBWBFN 0VUSBNVEBOÎBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMPQFSBEBQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM FTUÈFNIBWFSFMFTFJOWFTUJEPEBDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBDPMNBUBSBPNJTTÍPMFHJTMBUJWB "QSFPDVQBÎÍPDPNFTUBNBOJGFTUBTFOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDVKP"SU fQSFWÐVNBBÎÍPEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQPSPNJTTÍPBTFSKVMHBEBQPSFTTB$PS UF&OUSFUBOUPFTTFUFYUPFTQFDJmDBRVFWFSJmDBEBBPNJTTÍP“de medida para tornar efetiva norma constitucional, será dada ciência ao Poder competente para a adoção das providências necessárias”#FNDMBSPmDBBÓRVFRVFNDPMNBUBSJBBMBDVOBTFSJBP1PEFS %FDJTÍP OB "ÎÍP %JSFUB EF *ODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF O 3+ FN DPOKVOUP DPN B "%1' EP NFTNP OÞNFSPTFOEPSFMBUPSP.JO"ZSFT#SJUUPFQPSWPUBÎÍPVOÉOJNF /FTUFTFOUJEPW*WFT(BOESBEB4JMWB.BSUJOTiA Constituição ‘conforme’ o STFwFNFolha de S. Paulo 4ÍP1BVMPEFNBJPEFQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 75 DPNQFUFOUFoPCWJBNFOUFOBIJQØUFTFEFPNJTTÍPMFHJTMBUJWBP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWPOÍP P+VEJDJÈSJP"FYQFSJÐODJBNPTUSPVRVFFTTBBÎÍPFSBJOØDVB /PVUSBEJTQPTJÎÍPUPEBWJBB$POTUJUVJÎÍPUBNCÏNEJTQÙTTPCSFBPNJTTÍP² PRVFFTUÈOP"SU-99*OPRVBMTFQSFWÐVNNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍPiTFNQSFRVF BGBMUBEFOPSNBSFHVMBNFOUBEPSBUPSOFJOWJÈWFMPFYFSDÓDJPEPTEJSFJUPTFMJCFSEBEFT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFEBTQSFSSPHBUJWBTJOFSFOUFTËOBDJPOBMJEBEFËTPCFSBOJBFËDJEBEBOJBw $POTJEFSBOEP FTUB OPSNB BVUP FYFDVUÈWFM P 4VQSFNP EFTEF P JOÓDJP EB WJHÐODJBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFYQFEJVUBJTNBOEBEPT&OUSFUBOUPËGBMUBEFSFHVMBNFO UBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPOPTQSJNFJSPTUFNQPTTFSFTUSJOHJVËDPNVOJDBÎÍPEBPNJTTÍPBP 1PEFSDPNQFUFOUF"PTQPVDPTQPSÏNWFJPBEJTQFOTBSQBSBPFYFSDÓDJPEFEJSFJUPT JOEJWJEVBJTBOPSNBSFHVMBNFOUBEPSBFYJHJEBQFMPUFYUP .BJT SFDFOUFNFOUF QPSÏN BTTVNJV EF NPEP PTUFOTJWP B DPNQFUÐODJB EF TVQSJSBPNJTTÍPEPMFHJTMBEPSmYBOEPFMFQSØQSJPPEJSFJUPBQMJDÈWFMËNBUÏSJBEJT DVUJEB0DBTPFNRVFJTTPTFUPSOPVnBHSBOUFÏPEBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPEF HSFWFEPTFSWJEPSQÞCMJDP "$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFDPODFEFVBPTFSWJEPSQÞCMJDPPEJSFJUPEFHSFWF"SU 7** EFUFSNJOBOEPUPEBWJBRVFTFSJBiFYFSDJEPOPTUFSNPTFOPTMJNJUFTEFmOJEPT FNMFJFTQFDJBMw&OUSFUBOUPFTUFEJTQPTJUJWPOÍPGPSBSFHVMBEPFNoOÍPPGPJBUÏ IPKFoQFMPMFHJTMBEPS%JTUPSFTVMUBSBNQSPCMFNBTUBOUPQBSBPTRVFQSFUFOEFSBNVTBS EFTTFEJSFJUPoPRVFEFTDBNCPVQBSBHSFWFTiTFMWBHFOTwoDPNPQBSBB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDBRVFOÍPUJOIBPSJFOUBÎÍPRVBOUPBFMFoFTFVTFWFOUVBJTBCVTPT 0SBFOUJEBEFTEFTFSWJEPSFTQÞCMJDPTRVFDPOTJEFSBWBNDFSDFBEPPEJSFJ UPEFHSFWFQPSGBMUBEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPJNQFUSBSBNNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍPFNGBDF EP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM&TUFBPKVMHÈMPEFUFSNJOPVGPTTFBQMJDBEBËHSFWF EFTFSWJEPSFTQÞCMJDPTPRVFFTUÈQSFWJTUPOBMFHJTMBÎÍPTPCSFBHSFWFOPTFUPSQSJ WBEP BDSFTDFOUBOEP BMHVOT QBSÉNFUSPT DPODFSOFOUFT Ë FTQFDJmDJEBEF EPT TFSWJÎPT QÞCMJDPT'ÐMPBEFNBJTEFUFSNJOBOEPUBMBQMJDBÎÍPOÍPBQFOBTSFMBUJWBNFOUFBPT JNQFUSBOUFTNBTBUPEBBDBUFHPSJB"TTJNBTTVNJVPQBQFMEFMFHJTMBEPSJODMVTJWF GB[FOEPtabula rasaEBFYJHÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFRVFVNBMFJiFTQFDJBMwEJTQVTFTTF TPCSFBHSFWFOPTFUPSQÞCMJDP &TUBQPTUVSBEFMFHJTMBEPSQPSÏNKÈGPJBMÏNQPJTWFJPBEJTQFOTBSBUÏ BPNJTTÍPEPMFHJTMBEPS$PNFGFJUPNFSFDFSFHJTUSPBFEJÎÍPQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBMFNDPOUSPMFDPODSFUPEFOPSNBTEFEJSFDJPOBNFOUPHFSBM'PJPRVFTFWFSJ mDBQPSFYFNQMPEBEFDJTÍPUPNBEBOPUPSNFOUPTPDBTPEBUFSSBJOEÓHFOB3BQPTB 4FSSBEP4PM $G.*1"SFM.JO&SPT(SBV.*&43FM.JO.BVSÓDJP$PSSFB.*%'3FM.JO (JMNBS.FOEFT+VMHBEPTFNEFPVUVCSPEF 1FUJÎÍP33SFM.JO$BSMPT#SJUUPKVMHBEBFNEFNBSÎPEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 76 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho "EFMJNJUBÎÍPEFTUBÈSFBGPJDPOUFTUBEBQFSBOUFFTTB$PSUFRVFBSFKFJUPVB QSFUFOTÍPNBOUFOEPPRVFGPSBFTUBCFMFDJEPBENJOJTUSBUJWBNFOUF$POUVEPBEFDJ TÍPUFWFPDVJEBEPEFFYQMJDJUBSdezenove pontosRVFEFWFSJBNQBVUBSOÍPBRVFMB EFNBSDBÎÍPRVFKÈFTUBWBGFJUBNBTRVBJTRVFSEFNBSDBÎÜFTPVUSBT 4FNEÞWJEBFEJUPVDPNJTUPiMFJwOPTFOUJEPNBUFSJBMFGPSNBMEPUFSNP mYBOEPOPSNBTHFSBJTBQMJDÈWFJTBUPEPTPTDBTPTEBFTQÏDJF/FOIVNBOFDFTTJEBEF KVSÓEJDBPDPODMBNBWBBGB[ÐMPOFNVSHÐODJBIBWJBRVFKVTUJmDBTTFTVCTUJUVJSTFB $PSUFKVEJDJÈSJBBP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWP $PNQMFUFTFPRVBESPDPNBTOPSNBTFEJUBEBTDPNPTÞNVMBTWJODVMBOUFT&T UBTTFHVOEPQSFWÐPUFYUPEP"SU"EB$POTUJUVJÎÍPTFEFTUJOBNBFYQSJNJSEFNPEP DPOTPMJEBEPBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMTPCSFNBUÏSJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 5ÐNBEFNBJTFGFJUPWJODVMBOUF"TTJNTÍPWFSEBEFJSBTMFJTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTJODMVTJWFQPSRVF WÍPTFSWJSQBSBBBGFSJÎÍPEPTBUPTEPTEFNBJT1PEFSFTEB3FQÞCMJDB0SBP4VQSFNPUFN EFMBTVTBEPQBSBFTUBCFMFDFSOPSNBTDJSDVOTUBODJBEBTDVKPGVOEBNFOUPÏOJUJEBNFOUFBQSF DJBÎÍPEFDPOWFOJÐODJBoKVÓ[PQPMÓUJDP%JTUPTÍPFYFNQMPTDMBSPTB4ÞNVMBOoTPCSF PFNQSFHPEFBMHFNBToFB4ÞNVMBOoTPCSFPOFQPUJTNP 7BMFSFGFSJSTFËQPTJÎÍPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMOPUPDBOUFËNP EVMBÎÍP EPT FGFJUPT EP SFDPOIFDJNFOUP EF JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF &TUB NPEVMBÎÍP DPOGPSNFKÈTFJOEJDPVOÍPFTUÈFNRVBMRVFSEBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPCSB TJMFJSB&MBBTTJNKÈÏQPSTJTØVNBDPNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEFTUBGFJUBQPSMFJPSEJOÈSJB NBT QBDJmDBNFOUF BDFJUB DPNP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM QFMP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM. A TVBBQMJDBÎÍPQPSPVUSPMBEPDPOmHVSBoSJHPSPTBNFOUFGBMBOEPoVNBNVEBOÎBEB $POTUJUVJÎÍPOBNFEJEBFNRVFBGBTUBBJOEBRVFQPOUVBMNFOUFVNBOPSNBEB-FJ .BHOBQBSBGB[FSTVCTJTUJSVNBUPBFMBDPOUSÈSJP"TTJOBMFTFQPSÏNRVFB-FJO RVFBQSFWÐOÍPPGB[TFOÍPSFMBUJWBNFOUFBEFDJTÜFTOPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUP &OUSFUBOUPP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMWFNPQFSBOEPBNPEVMBÎÍPUBNCÏN OPDPOUSPMFDPODSFUP$JUFNTFBMHVOTDBTPTTJHOJmDBUJWPT6NÏPEBEFDMBSBÎÍPEF JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOBTRVFTUÜFToKÈNFODJPOBEBToSFMBUJWBTBPOÞNFSPEF7FSFB EPSFT/FMBTQFMPWPUPEP.JO(JMNBS.FOEFTRVFJOWPDBPQSJODÓQJPEBTFHVSBOÎB KVSÓEJDBFBTHSBWFTJNQMJDBÎÜFTQBSBPTJTUFNBMFHJTMBUJWPNVOJDJQBMTFSFTUSJOHJVP TFVBMDBODFOPUFNQPEBOEPMIFTFGFJUPTFYDMVTJWBNFOUFpro futuro. 0VUSP Ï P EB mEFMJEBEF QBSUJEÈSJB o UBNCÏN KÈ FYBNJOBEP o FN RVF OPT NBOEBEPT EF TFHVSBOÎB RVF OP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM DPPOFTUBSBN P FOUFO EJNFOUPEP5SJCVOBM4VQFSJPS&MFJUPSBMGPJmYBEPDPNPUFSNPBEBUBEBSFTQPTUBË $POTVMUBO "OUFTEB-FJOFNFTNPTPCB$POTUJUVJÎÍPBOUFSJPSIPVWFDBTPTEFNPEVMBÎÍPDPNP SFMBUB+PTÏ-FWJ.FMMPEP"NBSBM+ÞOJPSOPUSBCBMIPiDa admissibilidade da restrição temporal dos efeitos das decisões de inconstitucionalidade em controlo concretowMJEPFN&ODPOUSP-VTPCSBTJMFJSPEF%JSFJUP $POTUJUVDJPOBMOB'BDVMEBEFEF%JSFJUPEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF-JTCPBFNBCSJMEF4JSWPNFEFTUF USBCBMIPFNUPEPFTUFJUFNEPQSFTFOUFFTUVEP"FMFQPJTPNÏSJUPEBQFTRVJTB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 77 .BJTVNWFJPOPKVMHBNFOUPEFVNIBCFBTDPSQVTOPRVBMGPJSFDPOIFDJEBB JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBOPSNBRVFFYDMVÓBBQSPHSFTTÍPOPDVNQSJNFOUPEFQFOBJN QPTUBDPNCBTFOBDIBNBEBLei dos Crimes HediondosQPSWJPMBSBHBSBOUJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM EBJOEJWJEVBMJ[BÎÍPEBQFOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP"SU-97* /FTUFKVMHBNFOUPGPJFYQMJDJUB EPRVFUBMEFDMBSBÎÍPOÍPUFSJBDPOTFRVÐODJBTKVSÓEJDBTSFMBUJWBNFOUFBQFOBTKÈFYUJOUBT OBTVBEBUBOFNFYDMVJSJBBBQSFDJBÎÍPQFMPNBHJTUSBEPDPNQFUFOUFEPTSFRVJTJUPTRVF QSFTJEFNBQSPHSFTTÍPOPDVNQSJNFOUPEBTQFOBT 'PJFTUFÞMUJNPDBTPRVFTVTDJUPVPEFCBUFBDFSDBEFVNBNVUBÎÍPOB $POTUJUVJÎÍPEF *TUP TF EFV QPSRVF OP "DSF FTUJNVMBEPT QFMB NFODJPOBEB EFDJTÍP QSFTJ EJÈSJPTRVFDVNQSJBNQFOBQPSDSJNFIFEJPOEPSFDMBNBSBNEPKVÓ[PDPNQFUFOUFB QSPHSFTTÍP&TUFBSFDVTPVBMFHBOEPRVFEFDJTÜFTOPDPOUSPMFDPODSFUPUÐNFGFJUPT FYDMVTJWBNFOUF inter partes TFOEP FYQSFTTB B $POTUJUVJÎÍP EF RVF B TVTQFOTÍP EB FYFDVÎÍP EF OPSNB EFDMBSBEB JODPOTUJUVDJPOBM QFMP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM OP DPOUSPMFDPODSFUPEFQFOEFEFBUPEBDPNQFUÐODJBQSJWBUJWBEP4FOBEP'FEFSBM$POT UJUVJÎÍPBSU9 RVFJOFYJTUJBOPDBTP %JSJHJSBNFMFTVNB3FDMBNBÎÍPBP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM33/PFOTFKPEF TFVKVMHBNFOUPPSFMBUPS.JO(JMNBS.FOEFTTVTUFOUPVBQSPDFEÐODJBEPQFEJEP BMFHBOEPRVFËSFHSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFWFSJBTFSEBEPOPWPFOUFOEJNFOUPQPSGPSÎB EF VNB NVUBÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM 0V TFKB UFSJB IBWJEP iVNB BVUÐOUJDB SFGPSNB EB $POTUJUVJÎÍPTFNFYQSFTTBNPEJmDBÎÍPEPUFYUPw'PJFMFTFHVJEPOFTUBQPTJÎÍPQFMP .JO&SPT(SBVUBNCÏNBMFHBOEPUBMNVUBÎÍP%FTUBSFTVMUBSJBRVFBOPSNBDPOT UJUVDJPOBMEFWFSJBTFSMJEBi$PNQFUFQSJWBUJWBNFOUFBP4FOBEP'FEFSBMEBSQVCMJDJ EBEFËTVTQFOTÍPEBFYFDVÎÍPPQFSBEBQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMw&OUSFUBOUP OÍPDIFHPVP5SJCVOBMBUPNBSEFDJTÍPFNSB[ÍPEFQFEJEPEFWJTUB %FQPJTBRVFTUÍPGPJTVQFSBEBQFMBFEJÎÍPEB4ÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFORVF DPOTPMJEPVPFOUFOEJNFOUPEFRVFTFBQMJDBBPDVNQSJNFOUPEBQFOBFNDBTPEF DSJNFIFEJPOEPBQSPHSFTTJWJEBEF 3. IMPLICAÇÕES E QUESTIONAMENTOS " BOÈMJTF TVNBSJBNFOUF GFJUB OBT QÈHJOBT BOUFSJPSFT EFNPOTUSB VNB QPOEFSÈWFMNVEBOÎBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPCSBTJMFJSBTFDPNQBSBEBBPRVFTJHOJmDBWBBP TFSQSPNVMHBEB$FSUBNFOUFFTTBNVEBOÎB–OBPQJOJÍPEPBVUPS– OÍPDIFHB BVNBNVUBÎÍPNBTBUJOHJVQPOUPTJNQPSUBOUFT"TTJNBSFBEPÎÍPEBmEFMJEBEF 33 )BCFBT$PSQVTO413FMBUPSP.JOJTUSP.BSDP"VSÏMJPKVMHBEPFNEFGFWFSFJSPEF 3FDMBNBÎÍPO $MBSPFTUÈRVFQBSBBHFOFSBMJEBEFEPTRVFFOUÍPBDPNFOUBSBNFOÍPGPSBNQPVDPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 78 Manoel Gonçalves Ferreira Filho QBSUJEÈSJBBBTTVOÎÍPEBDPMNBUBÎÍPEBTPNJTTÜFTMFHJTMBUJWBTBMFHJGFSBÎÍPQPSTÞ NVMBTBFYUFOTÍPEPFOUFOEJNFOUPTPCSFBVOJÍPFTUÈWFMTÍPCPOTFYFNQMPTEJTUP 5PEPTFTUFTQPOUPTTÍPPCSBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMQFSUPEPTRVBJT BTNVEBOÎBTPSJHJOBEBTEP-FHJTMBUJWPFEP&YFDVUJWPTÍPiJOPDFOUFTw3FnFUFTFBÓ PQBQFMQPMÓUJDPRVFFTUB$PSUFWFNDPOTDJFOUFNFOUFBTTVNJOEPDPNPBMJÈTUPEP P+VEJDJÈSJPIPKFNBOJGFTUBNFOUFiBUJWJTUBw"EJTDVTTÍPTPCSFFTTFQBQFMQPMÓUJDPF TVBTJNQMJDBÎÜFTFDPOTFRVÐODJBTPVSJTDPTOÍPÏUPEBWJBPPCKFUPEFTUFUSBCBMIP. /PUPDBOUFFOUSFUBOUPBPDPOTUJUVJOUFIÈPCTFSWBÎÜFTSFMFWBOUFTNFSF DFEPSBTEFBUFOÎÍPFNFEJUBÎÍP "EPVUSJOBDPSSFOUFEFSJWBEBEF4JFZÒTFOTJOBRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPÏPCSBEF VNQPEFSFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPoPQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUFoRVFFNBOBEJSFUBNFOUFEPQPWPo PTPCFSBOPoFTPNFOUFQPEFTFSNPEJmDBEBEFBDPSEPDPNB$POTUJUVJÎÍP0VTFKB QPSVNQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUF EFSJWBEPEFTUBEFBDPSEPDPNOPSNBTQSPDFEJNFOUBJT EFmOJEBTOB$BSUBFMJNJUBEBTBPRVFFTUBDPOTFOUFTFKBNVEBEP%FDPSSFMPHJDBNFO UFEJTUPRVFUPEBNVEBOÎBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPUFSJBEFBEWJSEFBMUFSBÎÍPGPSNBMEFTUB +BNBJTQPSPCSBEPTQPEFSFTDPOTUJUVÓEPTo-FHJTMBUJWP&YFDVUJWPF+VEJDJÈSJP5VEP JTUPTPCQFOBEFTFSJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMBNVEBOÎBFQPSUBOUPOVMBFÓSSJUB ²DFSUPRVFUBMEPVUSJOBTVQPSUBRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPTFKBDPNQMFUBEBPVEFT EPCSBEBQFMBMFJNBTBTNVEBOÎBTEJTUPEFDPSSFOUFTKBNBJTBMDBOÎBNPstatusDPOT UJUVDJPOBMFEFTUBSUFOÍPUÐNTVQSFNBDJBTPCSFBTOPSNBTPSEJOÈSJBTOÍPQPEFN TFSWJSQBSBRVFFTUBTTFKBNGVMNJOBEBTQPSJODPOTUJUVDJPOBJT 0SB FTTB EPVUSJOB Ï BP NFOPT SFMBUJWJ[BEB QFMB PDPSSÐODJB EF NVEBOÎBT JOGPSNBJT &NQSJNFJSPMVHBSFTTBTNVEBOÎBTUPSOBNDMBSPRVFOPSNBTEFWBMPS DPOTUJUVDJPOBMOPQMBOPEBFGFUJWJEBEFNVJUBTWF[FTQSPWÐNEFQPEFSFTDPOTUJUVÓ EPTBPTRVBJTPQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUFOÍPPVUPSHPVDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBUBOUP)ÈQPJT OPSNBT SFDPOIFDJEBT DPNP DPOTUJUVDJPOBJT RVF OÍP TF WJODVMBN EJSFUBNFOUF BP QPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUFOFNTFKVTUJmDBNQPSVNBEFSJWBÎÍPQPSFMFBENJUJEB²DMBSB QPSUBOUPBSFMBUJWJ[BÎÍPEBEPVUSJOBEPQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUFRVFOP#SBTJMÏEJWJOJ [BEBQPSNVJUPT &N TFHVOEP MVHBS BT NVEBOÎBT EFTUBDBN VNB GBDFUB EP DPOUSPMF EF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF RVF OÍP GPJ QSFWJTUB QFMPT TFVT BSUJDVMBEPSFT PSJHJOBJT OFN Ï NVJUBTWF[FTEFWJEBNFOUFFOGBUJ[BEBQFMPTKVSJTUBT0VTFKBPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJP OBMJEBEFDPODFCJEPQBSBHVBSEBSB$POTUJUVJÎÍPQPEFNVEBSFNVEBB$POTUJUVJÎÍP )ÈNBJTEFVNTÏDVMPKÈTFEJTTFRVFiB$POTUJUVJÎÍPÏBRVJMPRVFB4VQSF NB$PSUFEJ[RVFFMBÏw/PDPOUFYUPFTUBPCTFSWBÎÍPOÍPTJHOJmDBWBNBJTEPRVF +ÈPm[OPVUSPTUSBCBMIPT1PSFYFNQMPOPKÈSFGFSJEPBSUJHPiO papel político do Judiciário na ordem constitucionalwQVCMJDBEPOBRevista dos AdvogadosEB""41OÞNFSPEFEJDBEPBPTBOPTEB$POT UJUVJÎÍPBOP997***TFUFNCSPEF 5FSJBTJEP0MJWFS8FOEFMM)PMNFTKVJ[EB4VQSFNB$PSUFEPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 Alteração e mudança da Constituição. O caso brasileiro 79 EJ[FSRVFPTFOUJEPFPBMDBODFEBTOPSNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTGPSNBJTTFSJBEFmOJEPQFMB JOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEB$PSUF)PKFOP#SBTJMUFSJBEFTFSFOUFOEJEPVNQPVDPEJGFSFOUF NFOUFi"$POTUJUVJÎÍPÏBRVJMPRVFB$PSUFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMestabeleceDPNPUBMwOÍP PTFOUJEPEBTOPSNBTGPSNBJTRVFFTUÍPFOVODJBEBTOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM /ÍP Ï FYBHFSP TBMJFOUBS RVF OB BUVBMJEBEF NPSNFOUF CSBTJMFJSB B $PSUF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMBTTVNJVVNQBQFMEFTVQFSQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUF&MBNVEBB$POTUJUVJ ÎÍPDPNPFOUFOEFRVFFMBEFWBFTUBTFS1PEFJEFOUJmDBSOPSNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTOÍP FTDSJUBTFBQMJDÈMBTTFNDPOUFTUBÎÍPQPTTÓWFM1PEFBDFJUBSPVSFKFJUBSFNFOEBTDPOTUJ UVDJPOBJTTFOBTVBDPNQSFFOTÍPEFTPCFEFDFSFNËTQSFTDSJÎÜFTGPSNBJTFNBUFSJBJT BBÓFTUÍPBTDMÈVTVMBTQÏUSFBTBTFSWJÎPEJTUP1PEFBDFJUBSPVSFKFJUBSBTQSÈUJDBTEP -FHJTMBUJWPPVEP&YFDVUJWPRVFFGFUJWBNFOUFQSFDJTBNEFTVBiTBOÎÍPwQBSBWJOHBS /JTUPTFSFQFUFPFYFNQMPDSJBEPQFMBBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFRVF QÜFP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMDPNPVNBUFSDFJSBDBTBMFHJTMBUJWBQPJTSFDMBNBP TFVDPODVSTPQBSBFTUBCFMFDFSBMFHJUJNJEBEFEBOPSNBMFHBMFEBSBPTFVDPNBOEPB JNQFSBUJWJEBEFEBGPSÎBWJODVMBOUF &OmNFTTFQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUFBOÙNBMPEJTQFOTBBMFHJUJNJEBEFEFNP DSÈUJDB$PNFGFJUPNVEBOÎBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTOÍPEFDPSSFOUFTEFBMUFSBÎÜFTGPSNBJT EB$POTUJUVJÎÍPOÍPQPEFNOFNJOEJSFUBNFOUFJOWPDBSBTPCFSBOJBQPQVMBS0QPWP OÍPÏBTTJNPBVUPSNFTNPJOEJSFUPEBNVEBOÎBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM&MFQPEFTFSWJTUP DPNPBVUPSJOEJSFUPEPRVFFTUBCFMFDFNQFMPQSPDFEJNFOUPFTQFDÓmDPFEFOUSPEPT MJNJUFTFTQFDJmDBEPTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPPTTFVTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTOÍPPRVFÏPCSBEPTKV Ó[FT²PRVFTFUFNEFEFEV[JSEPQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDPEPBSUEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPCSBTJMFJ SBFYQSJNJOEPBTPCFSBOJBEFNPDSÈUJDB“Todo o poder emana do povo, que o exerce por meio de representantes eleitos ou diretamente, nos termos desta Constituição”TVCMJOIFJ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 65 a 80 RECLAMAÇÃO CONSTITUCIONAL: A PRESERVAÇÃO DA COMPETÊNCIA E GARANTIA DA AUTORIDADE DAS DECISÕES DO SUPREMO TRIBUNAL FEDERAL BRASILEIRO CONSTITUTIONAL COMPLAINT: to preserve the jurisdiction and ensure the authority of the Brazilian Supreme Court decisions Marcia Amino1 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP $BCJNFOUP EB SFDMBNBÎÍP OP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM 1SFTFSWBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJB(BSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTEP45'0 DBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPPVPCKFUJWPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF "SFDMBNBÎÍPFBFmDÈDJBWJODVMBOUFOBTDBVUFMBSFTFNBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF "%*/ F FN BÎÍP EFDMBSBUØSJB EF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF "%$ 3FDMBNBÎÍP F BÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQPSPNJTTÍP3FDMBNBÎÍPFPDVNQSJNFOUP EP EFDJEJEP FN "ÎÍP EF %FTDVNQSJNFOUP EF 1SFDFJUP 'VOEBNFOUBM "%1' 3FDMBNBÎÍPDPOUSBBUPRVFEFTSFTQFJUPVFOVODJBEPEBTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFEP4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM F B -FJ O 0VUSBT IJQØUFTFT EF DBCJNFOUP EF SFDMBNBÎÍP"SFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTEP4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMFPTQSPDFTTPTTVCKFUJWPT$PODMVTÜFT#JCMJPHSBmB RESUMO 0PCKFUPEPQSFTFOUFUSBCBMIPFPFTUVEPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQSFWJTUBOB $POTUJUVJÎÍP CSBTJMFJSB EF QBSB B QSFTFSWBÎÍP EB DPNQFUÐODJB F HBSBOUJB EB BVUPSJEBEF EBT EFDJTÜFT EP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM &N RVF QFTF P BVNFOUP PCTFSWBEP OB TVB JOUFSQPTJÎÍP ËT IJQØUFTFT EF DBCJNFOUP EB 3FDMBNBÎÍP $POTUJUVDJPOBMBJOEBFTUÍPFNDPOTUSVÎÍP ABSTRACT 5IJT BSUJDMF JOUFOET UP BOBMZ[F UIF $POTUJUVUJPOBM $PNQMBJOU QSPWJEFE JO UIF $POTUJUVUJPO PG UP QSFTFSWF UIF DPNQFUFODF KVSJTEJDUJPO PG UIF 'FEFSBM 4VQSFNF$PVSUBOEFOTVSFUIFBVUIPSJUZPGJUTEFDJTJPOTPWFSBMMPUIFSDPVSUT%FTQJUF UIF PCTFSWFE JODSFBTF JO JUT VTF UIF BQQSPQSJBUFOFTT IZQPUIFTJT PG $POTUJUVUJPOBM $PNQMBJOUJTTUJMMVOEFSDPOTUSVDUJPO Palavras-Chaves3FDMBNBÎÍP$POTUJUVDJPOBM4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM$BCJNFOUP Keywords$POTUJUVUJPOBM$PNQMBJOU4VQSFNF$PVSU1FSUJOFODF 1. INTRODUÇÃO 0QSFTFOUFFTUVEPUFNDPNPPCKFUPBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQSFWJTUBOPT BSUJHPTJODJTP*BMÓOFBiMwDD"fEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFB 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP&TQFDJBMJTUBFN%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPQFMB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDV SBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP 82 Marcia Amino BÎÍPGPJDSJBEBQBSBHBSBOUJSBQSFTFSWBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBFHBSBOUJSBBVUPSJEBEFEBT EFDJTÜFTEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM45' . "SFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMÏGSVUPEBDPOTUSVÎÍPEPQSØQSJP4VQSFNP5SJ CVOBM'FEFSBMCSBTJMFJSP3DPNCBTFOBUFPSJBEPTQPEFSFTJNQMÓDJUPTPSJHJOÈSJBOPEJ SFJUPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPTFHVOEPBRVBMEFTEFRVFVNmNÏSFDPOIFDJEPFOFDFTTÈSJP PTNFJPTTÍPQFSNJUJEPTUPEBTBTWF[FTRVFGPSBUSJCVÓEBVNBDPNQFUÐODJBHFSBMQBSB GB[FSBMHVNBDPJTBOFMBFTUÍPDPNQSFFOEJEPTUPEPTPTQBSUJDVMBSFTQPEFSFTOFDFTTÈ SJPTQBSBSFBMJ[ÈMB"TTJNKVTUJmDBEBOPTQSJNØSEJPTBBENJTTJCJMJEBEFEBNFEJEB QPSBVTÐODJBEFQSFWJTÍPOPSNBUJWBBSFTQFJUPQPTUFSJPSNFOUFWFJPFMBBTFSJOTUJUVÓ EBOP3FHJNFOUP*OUFSOPEP45'FNFFNOB$BSUB.BJPS $PNPDSJBÎÍPKVSJTQSVEFODJBMPJOTUJUVUPUFNTFVÉNCJUPEFVUJMJ[BÎÍPWBSJB EPEFBDPSEPDPNBQPTJÎÍPEBDPNQPTJÎÍPEB4VQSFNB$PSUFTPCSFPDPOUSPMFEF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF"USBOTGPSNBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPEPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEB EFDPNBJOUSPEVÎÍPEBQSFWJTÍPEFNBJTNFDBOJTNPTQBSBPFYFSDÓDJPEPDPOUSPMFin abstrato FBBUSJCVJÎÍPEFFGFJUPTerga omnesFWJODVMBOUFTBVNFOUPVBTIJQØUFTFTEF DBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOP45' "MÏN EPT EJTQPTJUJWPT PSJHJOBJT EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM EF TPCSF BT IJQØUFTFTEFDBCJNFOUPEBBÎÍPEVSBOUFVNBEÏDBEBBMFHJTMBÎÍPJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVFBSFHVMBNFOUBDPOTJTUJVOBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEB-FJOEFEFNBJPEF EFDBSÈUFSQSPDFEJNFOUBMNVJUPTJNJMBSBMJÈTËBÎÍPEPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB" JOPWBÎÍPWFJPDPNBQVCMJDBÎÍPEFEVBTOPWBTMFJTB-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSP EFBRVBMFNTFVBSUJHPBPSFHVMBSPQSPDFTTPFKVMHBNFOUPEFBÎÍPEFEFT DVNQSJNFOUPEFQSFDFJUPGVOEBNFOUBMQSFWJVBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOBIJQØUFTF EFEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEBEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBQFMP45'OBGPSNBEFTFV3FHJNFOUP*OUFS OPFB-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFWFJPBFYQMJDJUBSBTIJQØUFTFTEF DBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNGVOEBNFOUPFNJOPCTFSWÉODJBEFTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUF OP45'CFNDPNPBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTEFTFVKVMHBNFOUPBSUJHP %JBOUF EB WBSJFEBEF EF TJUVBÎÜFT QBTTÓWFJT EF DPOmHVSBS B VTVSQBÎÍP EF DPNQFUÐODJB EP 45' PV P EFTDVNQSJNFOUP EF TVBT EFDJTÜFT mDPV B DSJUÏSJP EB KVSJTQSVEÐODJBEFTFOWPMWFSBTIJQØUFTFTEFDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPCFNDPNP B MFHJUJNJEBEF QBSB QSPQPTJUVSB RVF EJGFSF DBTP TF USBUF EF DPOUSPMF PCKFUJWP PV TVCKFUJWP1PSFTTFNPUJWPPQSFTFOUFUSBCBMIPBOBMJTBBTEFDJTÜFTRVFDPMBCPSBSBN 3 &NCPSBPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJOTUJUVBDPNQFUJSUBNCÏNBP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB45+ QSPDFTTBS FKVMHBSPSJHJOBSJBNFOUFFTTBNFTNBBÎÍPEBEPTPTMJNJUFTEPUSBCBMIPTPNFOUFEJTDPSSFSFNPTTPCSFB FWPMVÎÍPFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBTIJQØUFTFTEFDBCJNFOUPEBBÎÍPRVBOEPEFDPNQFUÐODJBEP45' /P TFOUJEP EF RVF OÍP FODPOUSB P JOTUJUVUP QBSBMFMP OP EJSFJUP DPNQBSBEP P FTUVEP EFUBMIBEP EF %"/5"4.BSDFMP/BWBSSP3JCFJSPReclamação constitucional no direito brasileiro. 1PSUP"MFHSF4FSHJP "OUPOJP'BCSJT&EJUPSQBF(0&4(JTFMF4BOUPT'FSOBOEFT3FDMBNBÎÍP$POTUJUVDJP OBM*O%*%*&3+3'SFEJF0SH Ações constitucionais. FEJÎÍP4BMWBEPS+VT1PEJVNQ $POGPSNF1"$)&$0+PTÏEB4JMWB%B3FDMBNBÎÍP *O@O mandado de segurança e outras ações constitucionais típicas. FEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 83 QBSBFTTFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFKVMHBEPTJOEJDBUJWPTEFOPWPTQBSBEJHNBTOBVUJMJ[B ÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOP45' "BOÈMJTFEBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPEFNPOTUSBBDSFTDFOUFRVBOUJEBEFEFSFDMBNBÎÜFT QSPDFTTBEBTOB$PSUFBUBMQPOUPRVFKÈTFGBMBRVFBEJNFOTÍPEBDSJTFOVNÏSJDB USBEJDJPOBMNFOUFBUSJCVÓEBBPHSBOEFWPMVNFEFSFDVSTPTFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPTFNUSÉNJUF OP45'TFSÈTVCTUJUVÓEBQFMBFTDBMBEBEBTSFDMBNBÎÜFTEPOEFBJNQPSUÉODJBEPUFNB 2. CABIMENTO DA RECLAMAÇÃO NO SUPREMO TRIBUNAL FEDERAL "QPTJÎÍPQSFEPNJOBOUFOBEPVUSJOBÏRVFBSFDMBNBÎÍPÏVNBBÎÍP"P QSFWFSBSFDMBNBÎÍPOPSPMEFQSPDFTTPTEFDPNQFUÐODJBPSJHJOÈSJBEP45'PDPOT UJUVJOUFFSJHJVBFNBÎÍPEFOBUVSF[BDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBPMBEPEPhabeas corpusNBO EBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBhabeas dataNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍPHBSBOUJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMRVF TFSWFBPBQSJNPSBNFOUPEBKVSJTEJÎÍPNFDBOJTNPQBSBRVFB$PSUFFYFSÎBBGVOÎÍP EFHVBSEJÍEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM " -FJ O QPS TVB GFJUB SFHVMPV P QSPDFEJNFOUP EB SFDMBNBÎÍP OPUÓUVMPEPTProcessos de competência originária, KVOUBNFOUFBPVUSBTBÎÜFTDPNPB SFTDJTØSJBPhabeas corpus FPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBEJTUJOHVJOEPBEPTSFDVSTPT USBUBEPTFNPVUSPUÓUVMP 3FGPSÎBBOBUVSF[BEFBÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPBQSFWJTÍPEPMFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUV DJPOBMoOBIJQØUFTFEFprocedênciaEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQFMBOÍPPCTFSWÉODJBEBTÞNVMB WJODVMBOUFQPSBVUPSJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWBoEFPDPSSFSBcassação de decisão judicial PV anulação do ato administrativoFGFJUPTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDPTEFVNBBÎÍP &NBOPRVFNBSDBPJOÓDJPEBDPOUBHFNEJWVMHBEBQFMP45'GPSBNEJTUSJCVÓEBTSFDMBNBÎÜFT/PT BOPTTFHVJOUFTPOÞNFSPEVQMJDPVDIFHBOEPBFN&NQFMBQSJNFJSBWF[DIFHPVTFËDBTB EBTEVBTDFOUFOBTSFDMBNBÎÜFTEJTUSJCVÓEBT/PQSJNFJSPEFDÐOJPTFHVJOUFBRVBOUJEBEFQBTTPVBDBTB EPTNJMIBSFTOPBOPEFRVBOEPGPSBNQSPUPDPMBEBTSFDMBNBÎÜFTFBUJOHJVPSFDPSEFFN DPNSFDMBNBÎÜFTBVUVBEBT/PÞMUJNPBOPEBDPOUBHFNGPSBNBVUVBEBTSFDMBNBÎÜFT FORVBOUPPTEBEPTEFBUVBMJ[BEPTBUÏEFKVMIPSFHJTUSBNBVUVBÎÜFT0TEBEPTGPSBNFYUSB ÓEPTEPTÓUJPEP45'FNEFBHPTUPEFOPDBNQPFTUBUÓTUJDBFQFTRVJTBQPSDMBTTFT 1"$)&$0Q%"/5"4Q$6/)"-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEB"'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB FN+VÓ[PFEJÎÍPSFWJTUBFBUVBMJ[BEB4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDBQFOUSFPVUSPT$POmSBTFFN (3*/07&3"EB1FMMFHSJOJ(0.&4'*-)0"OUPOJP.BHBMIÍFT'&3/"/%&4"OUPOJP4DBSBODFRecursos no processo penal: teoria geral dos recursos, recursos em espécie, ações de impugnação: revisão criminal, habeas corpus, mandado de segurança contra ato jurisdicional penal: reclamação aos tribunais.FEJÎÍPBUVBMJ [BEBDPNBSFGPSNBEP+VEJDJÈSJP&$O 4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTPFOUFEJNFOUP RVFGVOEBNFOUBPWPUPWFODFEPSEBSFMBUPSB.JO&MMFO(SBDJFOB"%*5SJCVOBM1MFOP%+ QBSBRVFNBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOmHVSBFYFSDÓDJPEPEJSFJUPEFQFUJÎÍP .BTBRVBMJmDBÎÍPDPNPSFDVSTPJODJEFOUFQSPDFTTVBMPVBÎÍPOVODBGPJDPOTFOTVBMOFNOBEPVUSJOB OFN OB KVSJTQSVEÐODJB $POmSBTF P JOWFOUÈSJP QSPDFEJEP QFMP .JO $FMTP EF .FMMP SFMBUPS EB 3DM KVMHBEP%+JMVTUSBUJWPEBBVTÐODJBEFDPOTFOTPRVBOUPËEFmOJÎÍPEB OBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBEBSFDMBNBÎÍP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 84 Marcia Amino "SFDMBNBÎÍPÏVNBEFNBOEBUÓQJDBEFGVOEBNFOUBÎÍPWJODVMBEB4JHOJmDBEJ [FSRVFTPNFOUFQPEFTFSVUJMJ[BEBOBTIJQØUFTFTEFUFSNJOBEBTQFMPMFHJTMBEPSB QBSB QSFTFSWBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBFC QBSBHBSBOUJSBBVUPSJEBEFEBEFDJTÍPEP45'BRVJDPN QSFFOEJEPPDBCJNFOUPDPOUSBPBUPRVFEFTSFTQFJUPVFOVODJBEPEFTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUF OPTUFSNPTmYBEPTQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEFEFEF[FNCSPEF 4FVQSPDFEJNFOUPÏCBTUBOUFTJNQMFTQSFWJTUPOB-FJOBSUJHPT BEFWFSÈTFSEJSJHJEBBP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMEFWJEBNFOUFJOTUSVÓEBDPNQSP WBEPDVNFOUBMFTFSBVUVBEBFEJTUSJCVÓEBBPSFMBUPSEBDBVTBQSJODJQBMTFNQSFRVF QPTTÓWFM0SFMBUPSSFRVJTJUBSÈJOGPSNBÎÜFTQBSBBBVUPSJEBEFBRVFNGPSJNQVUBEBB QSÈUJDBEPBUPJNQVHOBEPOPQSB[PEFEF[EJBTFPSEFOBSÈTFOFDFTTÈSJPQBSBFWJUBS EBOPJSSFQBSÈWFMBTVTQFOTÍPEPQSPDFTTPPVEPBUPJNQVHOBEP 2VBMRVFS JOUFSFTTBEP QPEFSÈ JNQVHOBS P QFEJEP EP SFDMBNBOUF BUVBOEP OBDPOEJÎÍPEFBTTJTUFOUFBSUJHPTBEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM %FDPSSJEP P QSB[P QBSB QSFTUBÎÍP EBT JOGPSNBÎÜFT P QSPDFTTP Ï FODBNJOIBEP BP .JOJTUÏSJP 1ÞCMJDPRVFUFSÈWJTUBQPSDJODPEJBTOPTDBTPTFNRVFOÍPUFOIBQSPQPTUPBSFDMB NBÎÍP"PKVMHBSQSPDFEFOUFBSFDMBNBÎÍPP5SJCVOBMDBTTBSÈBEFDJTÍPFYPSCJUBOUF EFTFVKVMHBEPPVEFUFSNJOBSÈNFEJEBBEFRVBEBËQSFTFSWBÎÍPEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJB MBWSBOEPTFPBDØSEÍPQPTUFSJPSNFOUF /ÍPDBCFSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBQSPNPWFSBFYFDVÎÍPEBEFDJTÍP0EFTDVNQSJ NFOUP QFMB QBSUF EFWF TFS PCKFUP EF DPNVOJDBÎÍP BP KVÓ[P PSEJOÈSJP QPS QFUJÎÍP F OÍP EF SFDMBNBÎÍP &N SFHSB P QSØQSJP 5SJCVOBM UFS DPNQFUÐODJB QBSB FYFDVUBS TFVTBDØSEÍPTRVBOEPQSPGFSJEPTFNDBVTBEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJBPSJHJOÈSJBFPKVJ[EF QSJNFJSBJOTUÉODJBRVBOEPQSPGFSJEPTFNHSBVEFSFDVSTP"TTJNTFPTBVUPTFTUÍP FNGBTFEFFYFDVÎÍPUPEPTPTSFRVFSJNFOUPTIÍPEFTFSEJSJHJEPTBPKVÓ[PPSEJOÈSJP RVFDVNQSFPBDØSEÍP&MFÏRVFNUFNEFFYFDVUBSPVEFTGB[FSFNDVNQSJNFOUPEP KVMHBEPQPTUFSJPSPRVFFYFDVUPV "EJWJTÍPJOUFSOBEP5SJCVOBMOÍPFOTFKBBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOUSB EFDJTÍP EPT ØSHÍPT GSBDJPOÈSJPT /B IJQØUFTF EF EFDJTÍP NPOPDSÈUJDB DBCF TPNFO UFBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFSFDVSTPTRVFTUÜFTEFPSEFNPVPVUSBTNFEJEBTQPSFYFNQMPB BÎÍPSFTDJTØSJBTFUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPBEFDJTÍP 045'FOUFOEFOÍPDBCFS “reclamação contra atos decisórios dos ministros ou das Turmas que integram esta Corte Suprema, dado que tais decisões são juridicamente imputadas à autoria do próprio Tribunal em sua inteireza”BTTJNDPNP“a reclamação não pode constituir via adequada a cassar decisão do próprio tribunal. Também não é a reclamação instrumento que possa corresponder a pedido de reconsideração de decisum da Corte”. 4"/504"MFYBOESF.PSFJSB5BWBSFTEPT%B3FDMBNBÎÍP*ORevista dos Tribunais. 7PMVNFOÞNFSP QKBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ 3DMSFM.JO$BSMPT#SJUUPKVMHBEP%+FOUSFPVUSBT 3DMSFM/ÏSJEB4JMWBKVMHBEP%+ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 85 *OJDJBEPPKVMHBNFOUPQFMPDPMFHJBEPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOÍPTFBENJUFPQFEJEP EFEFTJTUÐODJB5BMFOUFOEJNFOUPÏDPOTFRVÐODJBEPQSJODÓQJPEBVOJDJEBEFPKVM HBNFOUPQFMPDPMFHJBEPÏVOP /ÍPTVCTJTUFBSFDMBNBÎÍPTFKVMHBEPTFNFYBNFEPNÏSJUPPQSPDFTTPOP RVBMTFQSBUJDPVBUPDPOUSBPRVBMGPJBKVJ[BEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTUBTFDPO TJEFSBQSFKVEJDBEBTFNTVCTJTUÐODJBEFJOUFSFTTFFNSFDVSTPOFMBJOUFSQPTUP. /FNB$POTUJUVJÎÍPOFNB-FJOFTUBCFMFDFNQSB[PQBSBBQSPQP TJUVSBEBSFDMBNBÎÍP)ÈDPOUVEPFOUFOEJNFOUPTVNVMBEPOP45'OPTFOUJEPEFRVF OÍPDBCFSFDMBNBÎÍPRVBOEPKÈIPVWFSUSBOTJUBEPFNKVMHBEPPBUPKVEJDJBMJNQVHOBEP “Não cabe reclamação quando já houver transitado em julgado o ato judicial que se alega tenha desrespeitado decisão do Supremo Tribunal Federal”4ÞNVMBO "TTJN“não cabe a reclamação como meio de desfazer, reformar, cassar, modificar decisão transitada em julgado, pois, nesse caso, estaria fazendo as vezes (sic) de uma ação rescisória”. "EFTQFJUPEFFTTFFOUFOEJNFOUPFTUBSTVNVMBEPIÈBVUPSFTDSJUJDPTBPFT UBCFMFDJNFOUPEFQSB[PQBSBQSPQPTJUVSBEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNGVOEBNFOUPOBmOBMJ EBEFEPJOTUJUVUPFOBQSØQSJBOBUVSF[BBCTPMVUBEBOVMJEBEFEBEFDJTÍP 1PSÏN TFBKVJ[BEBBUFNQPBSFDMBNBÎÍPPTVQFSWFOJFOUFUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBEFDJTÍP JNQVHOBEBOÍPBUPSOBJODBCÓWFMOÍPJODJEJOEPOFTUFDBTPP&OVODJBEPOEB 4ÞNVMBEP45' /B-FJORVFEJTDJQMJOBBTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFPDBCJNFOUPEB SFDMBNBÎÍPDPOUSBBUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPmDPVDPOEJDJPOBEPBPQSÏWJPFTHPUBNFOUP EBWJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBBSUJHPf "QSFWJTÍPEFTTFTDSJUÏSJPTQSB[PQBSBBQSPQPTJUVSBEBSFDMBNBÎÍPBOF DFTTJEBEFEFOÍPPDPSSFSPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBEFDJTÍPJNQVHOBEBFPFTHPUB NFOUP EB WJB BENJOJTUSBUJWB SFMBDJPOBNTF DPN B BVUPOPNJB EB SFDMBNBÎÍP DPN SFMBÎÍPBPTEFNBJTNFJPTEFJNQVHOBÎÍPFDPNBOBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBEPJOTUJUVUP "EPUBEBBQSFNJTTBEFTFUSBUBSEFBÎÍPBSJHPSOÍPIBWFSJBRVFTFGBMBSFNQSB[P QBSBTVBQSPQPTJUVSBUBNQPVDPOPDPOEJDJPOBNFOUPËQSÏWJBQSPQPTJUVSBEPSF DVSTPPVEPFTHPUBNFOUPEBWJBBENJOJTUSBUJWB/PFOUBOUPBQSFPDVQBÎÍPFNOÍP USBOTGPSNBSBSFDMBNBÎÍPFN“um instrumento que permita que casos corriqueiros cheguem diretamente ao STF”FNGVOÎÍPEBFYJTUÐODJBEFEFDJTÜFTWJODVMBOUFT“quando seria mais lógica, menos onerosa e igualmente eficaz a utilização dos mecanismos 3DM20F3DM203FM.JO3JDBSEP-FXBOEPXTLJKVMHBEP%+F 0QSPQØTJUPEBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPÏUBNCÏNBGBTUBSBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFNBOJQVMBÎÍPEFSFTVMUBEPTTFBQBS UFQPSFYFNQMPEFTJTUJSBQØTQFSDFCFSEFUFSNJOBEBUFOEÐODJBOPTWPUPTKÈFYBSBEPT 3DM"H33FM.JO$F[BS1FMVTPKVMHBEP%+FEFOUSFPVUSPT $6/)"Q .FTNPBFYJTUÐODJBEFNFJPTBVUÙOPNPTEFJNQVHOBÎÍPOÍPJNQFEJSJBBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSB 4"/504QQPSFYFNQMP 3DM&%3FM.JO$F[BS1FMVTPKVMHBEP%+F RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 86 Marcia Amino processuais à disposição dos interessados nas instâncias ordinárias da justiça”, KVTUJmDB PFOUFOEJNFOUP /FTTFTFOUJEPÏRVFTFGBMBOPDBSÈUFSTVCTJEJÈSJPPVTVQMFUJWPEBSFDMBNBÎÍP 'FJUBTFTTBTPCTFSWBÎÜFTQSFMJNJOBSFTBTFHVJSEFTFOWPMWFSFNPTBTIJQØUFTFT EFDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQSFWJTUBTOB$'QBSBQSFTFSWBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBF HBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEFKVMHBEPT 2.1 Preservação da competência "$POTUJUVJÎÍPFTUBCFMFDFOPBSUJHPBDPNQFUÐODJBEP45'RVFTFEFTEP CSBFNUSÐTHSVQPTDPNQFUÐODJBPSJHJOÈSJBJODJTP* QBSBKVMHBSSFDVSTPTPSEJOÈSJPT JODJTP** FQBSBKVMHBSSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPJODJTP*** "MÏNEBDPNQFUÐODJBBUSJ CVÓEBEJSFUBNFOUFQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍPP45'ÏSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMPKVMHBNFOUPEFSFDVS TPTQSFWJTUPTOBMFHJTMBÎÍPJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPPBHSBWPEFJOTUSVNFOUPDPOUSB EFDJTÍP RVF JOBENJUF SFDVSTP FYUSBPSEJOÈSJP F FTQFDJBM FNCBSHPT EF EJWFSHÐODJB FNCBSHPTEFEFDMBSBÎÍPBHSBWPSFHJNFOUBMTVTQFOTÍPEFTFHVSBOÎBFOUSFPVUSPT "SFDMBNBÎÍPÏDBCÓWFMQBSBQSFTFSWBSUBOUPBDPNQFUÐODJBQSFWJTUBOB$POT UJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMDPNPBQSFWJTUBOBMFHJTMBÎÍPPSEJOÈSJBBNCBTEFOBUVSF[BBCTPMVUB /ÍPTFSWFDPNPNFJPEFFMJNJOBSDPOnJUPEFDPNQFUÐODJBFOUSFUSJCVOBJTPVKVÓ[PT EFQSJNFJSBJOTUÉODJBOFNEFSFTHVBSEBSBDPNQFUÐODJBEFTUFTFTUBCFMFDJEBQFMBQSF WFOÎÍPPVCVSMBEBQPSJOEFWJEBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPQPSEFQFOEÐODJB4FSWFQBSBQSFTFSWBS BDPNQFUÐODJBEPQSØQSJP45'FOÍPEPØSHÍPJOGFSJPS "DPNQFUÐODJBPSJHJOÈSJBEP45'OÍPDPNQPSUBBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFSFTUFO EJEBBTJUVBÎÜFTRVFFYUSBWBTFNPTMJNJUFTmYBEPTQFMPSPMFYBVTUJWPJOTDSJUPOP"SU *EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP 2VBOEPBNBUÏSJBPCKFUPEBEFDJTÍPSFDMBNBEBUFNOBUVSF[BJOGSBDPOTUJUV DJPOBMOÍPIÈVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM /ÍP IÈ EÞWJEB EF RVF P BUP KVEJDJBM QPEF TFS PCKFUP EF SFDMBNBÎÍP QBSB QSFTFSWBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBQFMBOBUVSBMJOTFSÎÍPEP4VQSFNPOPÈQJDFEBFTUSVUVSB KVEJDJÈSJB2VBOUPBPBUPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPIÈIJQØUFTFEFVTVSQBÎÍPRVFQPEFPDPS SFS EB BUVBÎÍP mTDBMJ[BEPSB EP $POTFMIP /BDJPOBM EF +VTUJÎB F $POTFMIP /BDJPOBM EP .JOJTUÏSJP 1ÞCMJDP BP FYFSDFS DPOUSPMF EF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF DPODMVJOEP RVF -&0/&-3JDBSEPEF#BSSPTReclamação Constitucional. 4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ /PNFTNPTFOUJEP%"/5"4Q "BEWFSUÐODJBDPOTUBEF$6/)"Q 3DM "H3 3FM .JO 3JDBSEP -FXBOEPXTLJ KVMHBEP %+F /P NFTNP TFOUJEP3DM"H33FM.JO$ÈSNFO-ÞDJBKVMHBEP%+F 3DM"H33FM.JO1SFTJEFOUF$F[BS1FMVTPKVMHBEP%+F RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 87 EFUFSNJOBEBMFJDPOUSBSJBB$POTUJUVJÎÍPBQSFUFYUPEFBOÈMJTFEFBUJWJEBEFBENJOJT USBUJWBEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFEP.JOJTUÏSJP1ÞCMJDP 0VUSB IJQØUFTF EF SFDMBNBÎÍP QPS VTVSQBÎÍP EF DPNQFUÐODJB FOWPMWF EF NBOEBT FOUSF &TUBEPT.FNCSPT PV FOUSF FTUFT F B 6OJÍP F SFTQFDUJWPT ØSHÍPT EB BENJOJTUSBÎÍPEJSFUBPVJOEJSFUBFBDBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPEFDPOnJUPGFEFSBUJWP&NDB TPT FOWPMWFOEP UBM UFNB GPJ SFDPOIFDJEB B VTVSQBÎÍP EF DPNQFUÐODJB EP 45' QPS FYFNQMPRVBOEPJ VN&TUBEP.FNCSPQSPQÙTBÎÍPDJWJMQÞCMJDBFNGBDFEFØSHÍP BNCJFOUBMEB6OJÍPDVKPBDPMIJNFOUPUSBSJBSFQFSDVTTÍPEJSFUBFNQSPKFUPEFHSBOEF WVMUPEFJOUFSFTTFGFEFSBMJJ VN&TUBEPNPWFVBÎÍPDPOUSBØSHÍPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍP JOEJSFUBEFPVUSP&TUBEPJJJ FNQSPDFTTPTEFEFNBSDBÎÍPEFUFSSBTJOEÓHFOBTVNB BÎÍPDJWJMQÞCMJDBGPSBQSPQPTUBDPNPPCKFUJWPEFEJTDVUJSBWBMJEBEFEFQPSUBSJBEP .JOJTUÏSJPEB+VTUJÎB. /BTEFNBOEBTRVFUÐNQPSPCKFUPPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF OPT&TUBEPTFOUFOEFTFRVFOÍPIÈVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBRVBOEPUFOIBNDPNPQB SÉNFUSPEFDPOUSPMFOPSNBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP&TUBEVBMRVFSFQSPEV[B$BSUB'FEFSBM1PS PVUSPMBEPPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOPT&TUBEPTUFOEPDPNPQBSÉNFUSP OPSNBDPOTUBOUFEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMDBSBDUFSJ[BVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJB "VUJMJ[BÎÍPEFBÎÍPQPQVMBSPVBÎÍPDJWJMQÞCMJDBDPNPPCKFUJWPEFPCUFSEF DMBSBÎÍPEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFMFJPVDPNPTVDFEÉOFPEFBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJBEFJO DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQPSPNJTTÍPUBNCÏNDBSBDUFSJ[BVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBEJGFSFO UFNFOUFEBIJQØUFTFFNRVFOBRVFMBTBRVFTUÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMÏWFJDVMBEBDPNPRVFTUÍP QSFKVEJDJBMEPQFEJEPQSJODJQBMFPFYBNFÏSFBMJ[BEPEFGPSNBEJGVTBPVJODJEFOUBM )ÈVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBPSJHJOÈSJBEP45'DPSSJHÓWFMQPSNFJPEFSF DMBNBÎÍPRVBOEPTÍPJOUFSFTTBEPTOBDBVTBUPEPTPVBNBJPSQBSUFEPTNFNCSPTEP USJCVOBMEFPSJHFNBSUJHP*EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM "QSPQPTJUVSBEFBÎÍPSFTDJTØSJBQFSBOUFP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBRVBOEPP45' FNCPSBOÍPUFOIBDPOIFDJEPBQSFDJPVBNBUÏSJBFNTFEFEFSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJP DBSBDUFSJ[BVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJB 0FYFNQMPGPJFYUSBÓEPEF-&0/&-Q $PNQFUFBP45'QSPDFTTBSFKVMHBSPSJHJOBSJBNFOUFBTDBVTBTFPTDPOnJUPTFOUSFB6OJÍPFPT&TUBEPTB 6OJÍPFP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMPVFOUSFVOTFPVUSPTJODMVTJWFBTSFTQFDUJWBTFOUJEBEFTEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPJOEJSFUB DPOGPSNFBSUJHP*GEB$' OFTTBTIJQØUFTFTBmYBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBEP45'iÏEFTUJOBEBBNBOUFS PFRVJMÓCSJPJOEJTQFOTÈWFMBPQBDUPGFEFSBUJWPFPQSØQSJP&TUBEPEFNPDSÈUJDPEF%JSFJUPFWJUBOEPTFDPO TFRVFOUFNFOUFPSJTDPEFDSJTFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMwDPOGPSNFFOTJOB-&0/&-Q 3DM3FM4FQÞMWFEB1FSUFODF%+3DM3FM0DUBWJP(BMMPUUJ%+F 3DM3FM$BSMPT#SJUUP%+SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF 4PCSFBFWPMVÎÍPEPFOUFOEJNFOUPEP45'OPUFNBDPOmSBTF.&/%&4Q 3DM3FM.JO4ZEOFZ4BODIFT%+ $POGPSNF-&0/&-QF.&/%&4PQDJUQ 3DMSFM.JO4FQÞMWFEB1FSUFODF%+ 3DMSFM.JO*MNBS(BMWÍPKVMHBEP%+ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 88 Marcia Amino "VTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBQPEFPDPSSFSBOUFTPVEFQPJTEBJOTUBVSBÎÍP EFVNQSPDFTTPFNFTNPBOUFTEFIBWFSEFDJTÍPQPSDPNJTTÍPPVPNJTTÍP /ÍPIÈVTVSQBÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBEP4VQSFNPRVBOEPBPSJHFNBQMJDBQSFT DSJÎÍPQPJTFTUB“age na ação, enquanto a limitação dos efeitos da declaração de inconstitucionalidade age no próprio direito”. " VTVSQBÎÍP EB DPNQFUÐODJB OÍP FYJHF OFDFTTBSJBNFOUF B QSÈUJDB EF BUP 1PEFPDPSSFSQPSFYFNQMPRVBOEPPUSJCVOBMEFPSJHFNOÍPBQSFDJBPSFDVSTPFTQF DJBMPVFYUSBPSEJOÈSJP/ÍPTFOFHBTVBDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBBQSFDJBSBBENJTTJCJMJEBEF EFUBJTSFDVSTPTOPTUFSNPTEPBSUJHPFEP$PEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMNBTB VTVSQBÎÍPFTUBSJBQSFTFOUFOBNFEJEBFNRVFBPNJTTÍPEFTTBJOTUÉODJBJNQFEJSJBP FYFSDÓDJPEBDPNQFUÐODJBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM 2VBOUPËBQSFDJBÎÍPEFBHSBWPEFEFTQBDIPEFOFHBUØSJPIÈFOUFOEJNFOUP TVNVMBEPWFSCFUF OPTFOUJEPEFRVFi/ÍPQPEFPNBHJTUSBEPEFJYBSEFFODB NJOIBSBP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMPBHSBWPEFJOTUSVNFOUPJOUFSQPTUPEBEFDJTÍP RVF OÍP BENJUF SFDVSTP FYUSBPSEJOÈSJP BJOEB RVF SFGFSFOUF Ë DBVTB JOTUBVSBEB OP ÉNCJUPEPTKVJ[BEPTFTQFDJBJTw 1PSPVUSPMBEPTFB1SFTJEÐODJBEP5SJCVOBMEFPSJHFNBQØTBENJUJSPSFDVS TPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPPVFTQFDJBMBQSFDJBDBVUFMBSFMIFDPOGFSFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPVTVSQB DPNQFUÐODJBEBTDPSUFTTVQFSJPSFT/FTTFTFOUJEPBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEPWFSCFUFEB 4ÞNVMBEP45'“Cabe ao Presidente do Tribunal de origem decidir o pedido de medida cautelar em recurso extraordinário ainda pendente do seu juízo de admissibilidade”. &TTFTEPJTWFSCFUFTEBTÞNVMBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMDJUBEPTEFWFN TFSJOUFSQSFUBEPTDPNUFNQFSBNFOUPOPDBTPEFSFDVSTPTFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPTJOUFSQPTUPT OPSFHJNFEBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMBSUJHPfPEB$' QPJTSFDFOUFNFOUFP 45'EFDJEJVRVFOÍPUFNDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBBQSFDJBSDBVUFMBSRVFCVTDBDPODFTTÍPEF FGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPTPCSFTUBEPOBPSJHFNFNWJSUVEFEPSFDP OIFDJNFOUPEBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMEBRVFTUÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOFMFEFDJEJEB. )PVWFTJHOJmDBUJWBNVEBOÎBOPSFHJNFEPTSFDVSTPTFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPTDPNB JOTUJUVJÎÍPEBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOTFHVOEPP RVBMPSFDPSSFOUFEFWFSÈEFNPOTUSBSB“repercussão geral das questões constitucionais discutidas no caso, nos termos da lei, a fim de que o Tribunal examine a admissão do recurso, somente podendo recusá-lo pela manifestação de dois terços de seus membros”. -&0/&-QFYFNQMJmDBDPNQSPDFTTPTEFOBUVSF[BDSJNJOBMFNRVFIÈQSFSSPHBUJWBEFGPSP FBUSBNJUBÎÍPEFJORVÏSJUPTQPMJDJBJTEFWFPDPSSFSOP45' 3DM"H33FM.JO3JDBSEP-FXBOEPXTLJKVMHBEP%+F /PÉNCJUPEPTKVJ[BEPTFTQFDJBJTDBCÓWFMBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOUSBBUPEPT+VJ[BEPT&TQFDJBJTRVFOFHBTF HVJNFOUPBSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPRVBOUPËNBUÏSJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFCBUJEBQFMPTØSHÍPTSFDVSTBJT3DM 3FM.JO$FMTPEF.FMMP%+3DM3FM.JO$FMTPEF.FMMP%+ "$.$203FM.JO&MMFO(SBDJFKVMHBEP%+ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 89 "-FJOBPBDSFTDFOUBSBP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMPTBSUJHPT "F#DPOGFSJVBP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMNFDBOJTNPQBSBEBSFGFJUPHF SBMBEFDJTÜFTRVFPSEJOBSJBNFOUFUFSJBNFmDÈDJBNFSBNFOUFinter partes&TTFFGFJUP erga omnesQFSNJUJSJBBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSUFSDFJSPTRVFOÍPUFOIBNTJEP QBSUFOPDBTPQBSBEJHNBQBSBPDBTPEFOÍPDVNQSJNFOUPEFEFDJTÍPFNSFDVSTP FYUSBPSEJOÈSJPDPNSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBM %FGBUPPfEP"SU#EP$1$EJTQÜFRVFP45'QPEFSÈOPTUFSNPT EFTFV3FHJNFOUP*OUFSOPDBTTBSPVSFGPSNBSMJNJOBSNFOUFPBDØSEÍPDPOUSÈSJPË PSJFOUBÎÍPmSNBEBOPQSFDFEFOUFEFSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBM /ÍPPCTUBOUFFTTBQSFWJTÍPMFHBMQPSPDBTJÍPEPKVMHBNFOUPEF2VFTUÍPEF0S EFNOP"*SFM.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTP5SJCVOBMFOUFOEFVJOBENJTTÓWFM BHSBWPEFJOTUSVNFOUPPVreclamação EBEFDJTÍPRVFBQMJDBFOUFOEJNFOUPEP45'BPT QSPDFTTPTNÞMUJQMPT/BNFTNBTFTTÍPB$PSUFKVMHPVB3FDMBNBÎÍPSFMBUPSBB .JOJTUSB&MMFO(SBDJF33BTTFOUBOEPJEÐOUJDPQPTJDJPOBNFOUP7FKBTFRVFDPNFTTFQB SBEJHNÈUJDPKVMHBEPP45'GVOEBEPFNSFDFJPEPBVNFOUPEBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPEFSFDMBNB ÎÜFTJOUFSQSFUPVPTJTUFNBEBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMEFNPEPBSFDPOIFDFSTVBDPNQFUÐODJB TPNFOUFOPTDBTPTFNRVFKVMHBEBBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMP5SJCVOBMEFPSJHFNSFDVTBSTF BTFSFUSBUBSEFQPTJDJPOBNFOUPDPOUSÈSJPBPFOUFOEFSRVFOÍPUFOEPIBWJEPKVÓ[PEF BENJTTJCJMJEBEFOÍPÏDBCÓWFMBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFBHSBWPEFJOTUSVNFOUPOPTUFSNPTEP BSUEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMNPUJWPQFMPRVFBGBTUPVBPGFOTBË4ÞNVMB 0FOUFOEJNFOUPDPOUVEPÏPCKFUPEFOPWBSFnFYÍPOB3FDMBNBÎÍP SFMBUBEBQFMP.JOJTUSP3JDBSEP-FXBOEPXTLJFNRVFBQØTPWPUPWJTUBEB.JOJTUSB &MMFO(SBDJFBDPNQBOIBOEPPWPUPEPSFMBUPSOPRVFOFHPVQSPWJNFOUPBPBHSBWP SFHJNFOUBMQFEJVWJTUBP.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTOBTFTTÍPEFKVMHBNFOUPTEPEJB "QSFPDVQBÎÍPNBOJGFTUBEBEVSBOUFPTEFCBUFTQFMP.JOJTUSP.BSDP"VSÏ MJPGPJEFRVFBTPMVÎÍPEBEBQFMP45'FTUBSJBBUSBOTGPSNBSPTUSJCVOBJTEPQBÓTFNÞMUJ NBJOTUÉODJB“não admitindo que sua decisão pudesse ser contestada”0.JOJTUSP1SFTJEFO UF$F[BS1FMVTPDPODPSEPVDPNBUFTFEFRVF“quando o tribunal de origem se equivocar deve caber recurso ao STF, pois, do contrário, se deixaria a outro tribunal a última palavra”. 0.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTPCTFSWPVBDPNQMFYJEBEFEPBTTVOUPRVFP5SJCVOBMBJOEB FTUÈDPOTUSVJOEPPTJTUFNBEFBQMJDBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPEBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMF“pretende refletir sobre a matéria para propor uma síntese e solução de compromisso sobre a questão.” 33 20"*3FMù.JO(JMNBS.FOEFTKVMHBEP%+F 3DM3FMù.JO&MMFO(SBDJF%+FFOUFOEJNFOUPSFQFUJEPOB3DMEBNFTNB SFMBUPSB%+F"MFJUVSBEPWPUPDPOEVUPSÏCBTUBOUFFTDMBSFDFEPSBRVBOUPBPTNPUJWPTRVF MFWBSBNBFTTFFOUFOEJNFOUPRVFUFNTJEPBQMJDBEPFNNJMIBSFTEFGFJUPTFBTTVBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTOP TJTUFNBSFDVSTBMFTQFDJBMNFOUFRVBOUPBQBTTBSBDBCFSBHSBWPJOUFSOPOP5SJCVOBMEFPSJHFNDPOUSBP BUPRVFBQMJDBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMFSSPOFBNFOUF $POGPSNF OPUÓDJB WFJDVMBEB OP QPSUBM EP 45' MPDBMJ[ÈWFM FN XXXTUGKVTCSQPSUBMDNTWFS/PUJDJB %FUBMIFBTQ JE$POUFVEPVJOUBGFJSB EF BHPTUP EF NJOJTUSPT WPMUBN B EFCBUFS WJB QSPDFTTVBMQBSBDPOUFTUBS3FQFSDVTTÍP(FSBM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 90 Marcia Amino $PNPTFFYQÙTBTIJQØUFTFTEFDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSVTVSQBÎÍPEF DPNQFUÐODJBTÍPUÍPEJWFSTBTRVBOUPÏPSPMEFGFJUPTDVKPKVMHBNFOUPÏBUSJCVÓEPBP 4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMGB[FOEPSFTTBMUBSBJNQPSUÉODJBEPJOTUJUVUPOBHBSBOUJBEP EJSFJUPGVOEBNFOUBMBPKVMHBNFOUPQFMB$PSUF.BJPS 2.2 Garantia da autoridade das decisões do STF /BT ÞMUJNBT EVBT %ÏDBEBT BT USBOTGPSNBÎÜFT PDPSSJEBT TPCSF P DPOUSPMF EFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFGPSBNBDPNQBOIBEBTQFMPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍP DPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEFHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTQSPGFSJEBTTFKBFNTFEFEF DPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPTFKBEPDPOUSPMFEJGVTP 2.2.1. O cabimento da reclamação no controle abstrato ou objetivo de constitucionalidade &NCPSBIPKFTFKBBTTFOUFPDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJ EBEFEFKVMHBEPFNTFEFEFDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPOFNTFNQSFGPJBTTJNPFOUFOEJNFOUP EP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM"$PSUFDPOTJEFSBWBJOBENJTTÓWFMQPSFYFNQMPBSF DMBNBÎÍPTFPSFDMBNBOUFOÍPUJWFTTFTJEPQBSUFOPQSPDFTTPFNRVFGPJQSPGFSJEBB EFDJTÍPDVKBBVUPSJEBEFUJWFTTFTJEPEFTSFTQFJUBEB "EFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBFNTFEFEFSFQSFTFOUBÎÍPEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOBWJHÐO DJBEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPBOUFSJPSHP[BOEPEPTFGFJUPTerga omnesBUJOHJBBRVFMFTRVFOFNTF RVFSmHVSBWBNOBSFMBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMNBTOÍPTFBENJUJBBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBQSFTFSWBÎÍP EFTVBBVUPSJEBEFDPNGVOEBNFOUPFNRVFBOBUVSF[BPCKFUJWBEPQSPDFTTPEFDPOUSPMF EFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFTFNQBSUFTOPTFOUJEPQSØQSJPEPUFSNPJNQFEJBBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEP JOTUJUVUPQPSUFSDFJSPT"MJNJUBEBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPFTQFMIBWBPQSØQSJPTJTUFNBEF DPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFDBMDBEPFOUÍPOPDPOUSPMFJODJEFOUBM $PNBFOUSBEBFNWJHPSEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFFPBQFSGFJÎPBNFOUPEPTJOT USVNFOUPTEFDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPFNCPSBJOJDJBMNFO UFNBOUJEPGPJTPGSFOEPUFNQFSBNFOUPT"QBSUJSEBDPOTUBUBÎÍPEFRVFBTEFDJTÜFT QSPGFSJEBTFNTFEFEFDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOFNTFNQSFFSBN 0TKVMHBEPTQBSBEJHNÈUJDPTEBOÍPBDFJUBÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBDVNQSJSEFDJTÜFTDPNDBSÈUFSOPSNB UJWPEFTEFFTUÍPDJUBEPTFN%"/5"4.BSDFMP/BWBSSP3JCFJSP*O.&%*/"+PTÏ.JHVFM(BSDJB $36;-VBOB1FESPTBEF'JHVFJSFEP$&326&*3"-VJT0UBWJP4FRVFJSBEF(0.&4+6/*03-VJ[ .BOPFMDPPSE Os poderes do juiz e o controle das decisões judiciais – Estudos em homenagem à Professora Teresa Arruda Alvim Wambier4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ 3FMBUBOEPB3DMP.JO.PSFJSB"MWFTBTTFOUPVBPSJFOUBÎÍPFNWJHPSOBEÏDBEBEF$POmSB TFBFNFOUBFN%"/5"4Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 91 PCFEFDJEBTQFMBT$PSUFTPSEJOÈSJBTP4VQSFNPQBTTPVBBENJUJSBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBHB SBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEFEFDJTÍPFNTFEFEFBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFTEF RVFBKVJ[BEBQPSMFHJUJNBEPQBSBBQSPQPTJUVSBEBQSØQSJBBÎÍPEJSFUBFRVFUJWFTTFP NFTNPPCKFUPOPKVMHBNFOUPEB3FDMBNBÎÍPSFMBUPS.JOJTUSP$FMTPEF.FMMP 0SFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBMFHJUJNJEBEFEFUFSDFJSPTQBSBQSPQPSSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSEFT DVNQSJNFOUPEFEFDJTÍPFNTFEFEFDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPQSFOVODJBBJNQPSUÉODJBBUVBM EBNFEJEBQBSBEPUBSPTJTUFNBEFDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFNBJPSFmDÈDJB *NQPSUBOUFFWPMVÎÍPGPJQPTTJCJMJUBEBQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEF EFNBSÎPEFRVFBPJOTUJUVJSBBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFBM UFSBOEPPBSUJHP*BMÓOFBiBwEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP QSFWJVRVFBTEFDJTÜFTEFmOJUJWBT EFNÏSJUPOFMBQSPGFSJEBTiQSPEV[JSÍPFmDÈDJBDPOUSBUPEPTFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFSFMB UJWBNFOUFBPTEFNBJTØSHÍPTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFBP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPwQBSÈHSBGPP EPBSUJHP "PKVMHBSBRVFTUÍPEFPSEFNOB"%$OBRVBMTFEFDMBSPVBDPOT UJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEB&NFOEBPSFMBUPS.JOJTUSP.PSFJSB"MWFTQSFOVODJPVPVTP EBSFDMBNBÎÍPFNWJSUVEFEBGPSÎBWJODVMBOUFEBTEFDJTÜFTEPSBWBOUFQSPGFSJEBTFN TFEFEF"%$FYUSBJOEPEPFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFRVFMIFÏQSØQSJPRVF TFPTEFNBJTØSHÍPTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPOPTDBTPTDPODSFUPTTPCTFV KVMHBNFOUP OÍP SFTQFJUBSFN B EFDJTÍP QSPMBUBEB OFTTB BÎÍP B QBSUF QSFKVEJDBEB QPEFSÈ WBMFSTF EP JOTUJUVUP EB SFDMBNBÎÍP QBSB P 45' B mNEFRVFFTUFHBSBOUBBBVUPSJEBEFEFTTBEFDJTÍP $BTPBDPOUSPWÏSTJBTPCSFPDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUP EFOPSNBTSFTUPVTVQFSBEBRVBOUPËBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFDPN SFMBÎÍPËBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFP45'NBOUFWFOVNQSJNFJSPNPNFO UPPFOUFOEJNFOUPOPTFOUJEPEPOÍPDBCJNFOUPDPOWFSUFOEPSFDMBNBÎÍPFNBÎÍP EJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQBSBQSFTFSWBSEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBFNBÎÍPBOUFSJPS &NTFHVJEBWFJPSFWFSUFSBPSJFOUBÎÍPQBSBBENJUJSBSFDMBNBÎÍP“quando o mesmo órgão de que emanara a norma declarada inconstitucional persiste na prática de atos concretos que pressuporiam a validade”. 3DM.$203FM.JO$FMTPEF.FMMPKVMHBEPFN%+0NFTNPSFMBUPS IBWJBNBOJGFTUBEPFOUFOEJNFOUPQFMPOÍPDBCJNFOUPBOUFSJPSNFOUFOB3DM%+ "%$203FM.JO.PSFJSB"MWFTK%+/FTTFTFOUJEP.&/%&4 3DM3FM.JO/ÏSJEB4JMWFJSBKVMHBEPFN%++ÈWJHFOUFB&$OB "%*.$3+SFM.JO*MNBS(BMWÍPKVMHBEPFN%+P1MFOPWPMUBBSFQFUJS BPSJFOUBÎÍPUBNCÏNFYBSBEBOB"%*.$3+SFMBUPS.JO.PSFJSB"MWFTKVMHBEPFN %+.&/%&4QBOPUBDPOUVEPBFYJTUÐODJBEPFOUFOEJNFOUPNJOPSJUÈSJPDB QJUBOFBEPQPS4FQÞMWFEB1FSUFODFOB3DMTVTUFOUBOEPiRVBOEPDBCÓWFMFNUFTFBBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJB EFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFBNFTNBGPSÎBWJODVMBOUFIBWFSÈEFTFSBUSJCVÓEBËEFDJTÍPEFmOJUJWBEBBÎÍP EJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFw 3DM1&SFM.JO4FQÞMWFEB1FSUFODF%+ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 92 Marcia Amino "PKVMHBSDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBEJTQPTJÎÍPDPOTUBOUFEPQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDPEPBSUJHP EB-FJOoRVFFTUFOEFVËEFDJTÍPEFEFDMBSBÎÍPEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF JODMVTJWFBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPDPOGPSNFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFBEFDMBSBÎÍPQBSDJBMEFJODPOTUJUV DJPOBMJEBEFTFNSFEVÎÍPEFUFYUPFmDÈDJBDPOUSBUPEPTFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFFNSFMBÎÍP BPTØSHÍPTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMFNVOJDJQBM oP45'BTTFOUPVBMFHJUJNJEBEFQBSBQSPQPTJUVSBEFSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBHBSBOUJBEFBVUP SJEBEFEFEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBFNTFEFEFBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFBUPEPTPT RVFDPNQSPWFNQSFKVÓ[PEFDPSSFOUFEPOÍPDVNQSJNFOUPEBEFDJTÍP. 0DPOTUJUVJOUFSFGPSNBEPSEFFTUBCFMFDFVRVFBTEFDJTÜFTEFmOJUJWBTEF NÏSJUPOBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBTEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFOBTBÎÜFTEFDMBSBUØSJBTEFDPOTUJ UVDJPOBMJEBEFQSPEV[JSÍPFmDÈDJBDPOUSBUPEPTFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFSFMBUJWBNFOUFBPT EFNBJTØSHÍPTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBEJSFUBFJOEJSFUBOBT FTGFSBTGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMFNVOJDJQBMBMUFSBOEPPBSUJHPQBSÈHSBGPEB$POT UJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM EF F BTTFOUPV FN EFmOJUJWP P DBCJNFOUP EB SFDMBNBÎÍP OP DPOUSPMFQFMBWJBEBBÎÍPEJSFUB &TTFFOUFOEJNFOUPÏBQMJDÈWFMUBNCÏNËTEFDJTÜFTFNBSHVJÎÍPEFDVNQSJ NFOUPEFQSFDFJUPGVOEBNFOUBM 2.2.2 A reclamação e a eficácia vinculante nas cautelares em ação direta de inconstitucionalidade (ADIN) e em ação declaratória de constitucionalidade (ADC) 0DBCJNFOUPEFSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBQSFTFSWBSBBVUPSJEBEFEFDBVUFMBSDPODF EJEBFNBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFGPJUBNCÏNVNBDPOTUSVÎÍPKVSJT QSVEFODJBM"PSJFOUBÎÍPGPJmSNBEBQPSPDBTJÍPEPKVMHBNFOUPEB"ÎÍP%FDMBSBUØSJB EF $POTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF %' FN RVF P 45' KVMHPV DPOTUJUVDJPOBM P "SU ' EB -FJOEFEFTFUFNCSPEFRVFWFEBBDPODFTTÍPEFUVUFMBBOUFDJQBEB DPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOBTIJQØUFTFTFNRVFOPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBFOBBÎÍP DBVUFMBSOÍPQPTTBTFSDPODFEJEBBMJNJOBS/FTTFKVMHBNFOUPP1MFOPQPSNBJPSJB EFGFSJVFNQBSUFPQFEJEPEFNFEJEBDBVUFMBSQBSBTVTQFOEFSex nunce com efeito vinculante BUÏ FOUÍP QSFWJTUP TPNFOUF QBSB P KVMHBNFOUP EF NÏSJUP OPT UFSNPT EPBSUJHPfEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMOBSFEBÎÍPEBSFGPSNBEF BUÏP KVMHBNFOUPmOBMEBBÎÍPBDPODFTTÍPEFUVUFMBBOUFDJQBEBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB RVFUFOIBQPSQSFTTVQPTUPBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFPVJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEPBSUJHP EB-FJOTVTUBOEPJHVBMNFOUFex nuncPTFGFJUPTGVUVSPTEBTEFDJTÜFTKÈ QSPGFSJEBTOFTTFTFOUJEP 3DM"H33FM.JO.BVSÓDJP$PSSFBKVMHBEPFN%+ $POGPSNF.&/%&4QFUTFR-&0/&-Q "%$.$3FMù.JO4ZEOFZ4BODIFTKVMHBEP%+ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 93 0 WPUP EP SFMBUPS .JOJTUSP 4ZEOFZ 4BODIFT DPOTJHOB FYQSFTTB NFOÎÍP BP DBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOBIJQØUFTFEFOÍPDVNQSJNFOUPEPEFDJEJEP $BCF BEWFSUJS QPS OFDFTTÈSJP RVF P FWFOUVBM EFTDVNQSJNFOUP QPS KVÓ[FTPV5SJCVOBJTEBEFDJTÍPQMFOÈSJBEP45'FTQFDJBMNFOUFRVBOEP QSPGFSJEBDPNFGFJUPWJODVMBOUF$'"SUQBSÈHSBGP KVTUJmDBSÈ B VUJMJ[BÎÍP EF JOTUSVNFOUP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EB SFDMBNBÎÍP NFTNP USBUBOEPTF EF KVMHBNFOUP SFGFSFOUF B QFEJEP EF NFEJEB DBVUFMBS FN TFEFEFBÎÍPEFDMBSBUØSJBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF²RVFP1MFOÈSJPEP 45'BPEFGFSJSPQFEJEPEFNFEJEBDBVUFMBSOB"%$%'FYQSFTTBNFOUF BUSJCVJVËTVBEFDJTÍPFmDÈDJBWJODVMBOUFFTVCPSEJOBOUFDPNUPEBTBT DPOTFRVÐODJBTKVSÓEJDBTEBÓEFDPSSFOUFTJODMVTJWFBRVFMBTEFOBUVSF[B QSPDFTTVBMDPODFSOFOUFTBPFNQSFHPEPJOTUJUVUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍP /ÍPTFQPEFJHOPSBSOFTUFQPOUPRVFVNBEBTGVOÎÜFTQSPDFTTVBJTEB SFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTJTUFQSFDJTBNFOUFFNHBSBOUJSBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFT QSPGFSJEBTQFMP45'DPOTPBOUFUFNTJEPFOGBUJ[BEPQFMBKVSJTQSVEÐODJB EFTUB $PSUF 3DM 1* SFM .JO $FMTP EF .FMMP &TTF JOTUSVNFOUP GPSNBM EF UVUFMB iRVF OBTDFV EF VNB DPOTUSVÎÍP QSFUPSJBOBw 35+ CVTDBFNFTTÐODJBGB[FSQSFWBMFDFSOPQMBOPEBIJFSBSRVJB KVEJDJÈSJBPFGFJUPSFTQFJUPBPTQSPOVODJBNFOUPTKVSJTEJDJPOBJTFNBOBEPT EFTUB 4VQSFNB $PSUF SFTHVBSEBOEP EFTTF NPEP B JOUFHSJEBEF F B FmDÈDJB TVCPSEJOBOUF EPT DPNBOEPT RVF EFMF FNFSHFN 35+ SFM .JO $FMTP EF .FMMP 7ÐTF QPSUBOUP RVF P JOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDPoNFTNPSFDPOIFDJEBBQSFKVEJDJBMJEBEFEFTUFQFEJEPoOÍPmDBSÈ DPNQSPNFUJEPOFNTFFYQPSÈBRVBMRVFSTJUVBÎÍPEFSJTDPQSFDJTBNFOUF FNWJSUVEFEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJNFEJBUBVUJMJ[BÎÍPQFMBFOUJEBEFFTUBUBM RVBOEPGPSPDBTPEPJOTUSVNFOUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBSFDMBNBÎÍP %P FGFJUP WJODVMBOUF EFDPSSF B QPTTJCJMJEBEF EF QSPQPTJUVSB EF SFDMBNBÎÍP DPOGPSNF"%$20SFMBUPS.JOJTUSP.PSFJSB"MWFT "-FJOPEFBPQFS NJUJSBJNQPTJÎÍPEFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFBMÏNEBTIJQØUFTFTFYQSFTTBNFOUFQSFWJTUBTOB $POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMDPOTBHSPVBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEP4VQSFNPOB"%$OPTFOUJEPEF 0QBSBEJHNÈUJDPKVMHBNFOUPJOJDJPVOPFOUFOEFSEF%"/5"4Q NBJPSGSFRVÐODJBOB VUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNPWJBEFFGFUJWBÎÍPEPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF 4PCSFBDBVUFMBSFNTFEFEFDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFTFVTFGFJUPTQBSBmOTEFQSPQP TJUVSBEFSFDMBNBÎÍPWJEF.&/%&4Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 94 Marcia Amino RVFPQPEFSEFBDBVUFMBSFTUÈDPOUJEPOPQPEFSEFKVMHBSFBGBTUPVPØCJDFRVFNFTNP OP45'TFPQVOIBBPFOUFOEJNFOUPBEPUBEPQPSPDBTJÍPEFTTFKVMHBNFOUP "NFTNBratio decidendiRVFGVOEPVPKVMHBNFOUPEB3FDMBNBÎÍPOPTFO UJEPEFRVFIÈ“similitude substancial de objetos nas ações declaratória de constitucionalidade e direta de inconstitucionalidade”GVOEBPFOUFOEJNFOUPOPTFOUJEPEFRVFUBNCÏNBTDBVUF MBSFTOBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBTEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFHP[BNEFFGFJUPTWJODVMBOUFT "TTJNPEFTDVNQSJNFOUPQPSRVBJTRVFSKVÓ[FTPVUSJCVOBJTEFEFDJTÜFTDPO DFTTJWBTEFNFEJEBTDBVUFMBSFToPVUPSHBEBTDPNFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFQFMP1MFOÈSJPEP 45'FNTFEFEFmTDBMJ[BÎÍPBCTUSBUBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFoBVUPSJ[BPFNQSFHPEB SFDMBNBÎÍPUBNCÏNWPDBDJPOBEBFNTVBFTQFDÓmDBGVOÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMBSFTHVBSEBSF BGB[FSQSFWBMFDFSOPRVFDPODFSOFË4VQSFNB$PSUFBJOUFHSJEBEFBBVUPSJEBEFFB FmDÈDJBTVCPSEJOBOUFEPTDPNBOEPTRVFFNFSHFNEFTFVTBUPTEFDJTØSJPTDoutrina. Precedentes. (...) A procedência da reclamação, quando promovida com o objetivo de fazer prevalecer o imperium inerente aos julgados proferidos pelo STF, importará em desconstituição do ato que houver desrespeitado a autoridade da decisão emanada da Suprema Corte. 3FQVUBTF PGFOTJWP Ë BVUPSJEBEF EF TFOUFOÎB EF NÏSJUP QSPGFSJEB FN BÎÍP EJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFDPNFGFJUPex tuncPBDØSEÍPRVFKVMHBOEPJNQSP DFEFOUFBÎÍPSFTDJTØSJBBEPUPVFOUFOEJNFOUPDPOUSÈSJPBJOEBRVFOBWJHÐODJBFOPT UFSNPTEFMJNJOBSDPODFEJEBOBNFTNBBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF 1PS PVUSP MBEP “(...) somente as decisões concessivas das liminares em ADIs e ADCs é que se dotam de efeito vinculante. Não as denegatórias. Ante a natureza subjetiva do processo, as decisões proferidas em reclamação não têm eficácia erga omnes”. "PCSJHBUPSJFEBEFEFPCTFSWÉODJBEBEFDJTÍPEFMJNJOBSFNDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUP SFBMJ[BEPQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMJNQÜFTFDPNBQVCMJDBÎÍPEBBUBEBTFTTÍP EFKVMHBNFOUPOP%JÈSJPEB+VTUJÎB0BKVJ[BNFOUPEFSFDMBNBÎÍPJOEFQFOEFUBOUPEB QVCMJDBÎÍPEPBDØSEÍPDVKBBVUPSJEBEFTFRVFSHBSBOUJSDPNPEFTVBKVOUBEB 2.2.3 Reclamação e ação direta de inconstitucionalidade por omissão "PNJTTÍPRVBOUPBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFQSFDFJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMUBOUPQPEFUFS PSJHFNOPTØSHÍPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTDPNPOPTMFHJTMBUJWPT2VBOUPBP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWP /FTTFTFOUJEP%"/5"4Q 1PSFYFNQMPPWPUPEP.JO.BSDP"VSÏMJPQBSBJOEFGFSJSNPOPDSBUJDBNFOUFMJNJOBSOB.FEJEB$BVUFMBS OB3DMKVMHBEPFN%+"SFDMBNBÎÍPGPJKVMHBEBQSPDFEFOUFQFMPDPMFHJBEP DPOUSBPWPUPEPSFMBUPS3FMQBSBPBDØSEÍP.JO&MMFO(SBDJFKVMHBEPFN%+ 3DM3FM.JO$FMTPEF.FMMPKVMHBEPFN%+F 3DM"H33FM.JO$F[BS1FMVTPKVMHBEP%+EF 3DM"H33FM.JOù"ZSFT#SJUUPKVMHBEP%+F/PNFTNPTFOUJEP3DM "H33DM"H3F3DM"H33FM.JO.BSDP"VSÏMJPKVMHBEP%+FEF 3DM"H3F3DM"H33FMQPBD.JO+PBRVJN#BSCPTB%+EFOUSFPVUSBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 95 B EFDJTÍP RVF EFDMBSB B JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF QPS PNJTTÍP EF NFEJEB QBSB UPSOBS FGFUJWBOPSNBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBSÈiDJÐODJBBP1PEFSDPNQFUFOUFQBSBBBEPÎÍPEBT QSPWJEÐODJBTOFDFTTÈSJBTFFNTFUSBUBOEPEFØSHÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWPQBSBGB[ÐMPFN USJOUBEJBTwBSUJHPfEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM OÍPFOTFKBBQSPQPTJUVSBEFSF DMBNBÎÍPDPOGPSNFPEFDJEJEPOB3FDMBNBÎÍPSFMBUPS.JOJTUSP*MNBS(BMWÍP %BEBBOBUVSF[BNBOEBNFOUBMEBEFDJTÍPTVBFYFDVÎÍPEFWFTFSGFJUBQFMB 1SFTJEÐODJBEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMTVCNFUJEBBP1MFOÈSJPBEFDJTÍPBTFSQSP GFSJEBOBFYFDVÎÍPPVPVUSPJODJEFOUFBEFDJTÍPFNBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJP OBMJEBEF QPS PNJTTÍP OÍP EÈ FOTFKP Ë QSPQPTJUVSB EF SFDMBNBÎÍP iQPJT GBMUBSJB BP SFDMBNBOUF JOUFSFTTF EF BHJS FN PCUFS PVUSB EFDJTÍP EB NFTNB OBUVSF[B F DPN PT NFTNPTFGFJUPTEBEFDJTÍPBTFSBTTFHVSBEBw 2.2.4 Reclamação e o cumprimento do decidido em Ação de descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental (ADPF) ²DBCÓWFMBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBBTTFHVSBSBBVUPSJEBEFEBEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBFN TFEFEF"%1'ex viEPEJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPEB-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSPEF RVFEJTQÜFTPCSFPQSPDFTTPFKVMHBNFOUPEFTTBBÎÍP“Caberá reclamação contra o descumprimento da decisão proferida pelo Supremo Tribunal Federal, na forma do seu Regimento Interno”CFNDPNPDPNSFMBÎÍPËEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBFNTFEFEFDBVUFMBS QPSGPSÎBEPEJTQPTUPOPfPEPBSUJHPPEBNFTNBMFJ 2VFTUÍPRVFTFDPMPDBDPNSFMBÎÍPË"%1'oRVFQFSNJUFJODMVTJWFPDPOUSPMF EFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFEJSFJUPNVOJDJQBMoÏTFIBWFSJBWJODVMBÎÍPEPMFHJTMBEPSBP EFDJEJEPQFMP45'FNWJSUVEFEPEJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPfEB-FJRVFOÍP EJTDSJNJOBRVFPFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFmDBBETUSJUPBP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP "OÍPBQMJDBÎÍPEPFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFBPMFHJTMBEPSFNWJSUVEFEPDPOTFRVFOUF FOHFTTBNFOUPEBPSEFNKVSÓEJDBPCKFUJWBUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUFEFNBOEBSJBSFTQPTUBOF HBUJWBBFTTBRVFTUÍP-FJDPNPNFTNPUFPSEBRVFMBEFDMBSBEBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMFOUÍP TØQPEFSJBTFSBUBDBEBQPSBÎÍPBVUÙOPNB 0.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTTVTUFOUBBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNB ÎÍPQBSBEFDMBSBÎÍPJODJEFOUBMEBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBOPSNBRVFSFQFUFBRVFMB EFDMBSBEBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBM. ²QPTTÓWFMQPSÏNRVFFTTBDPOUSPWÏSTJBUFOIBQFSmMIPKFBDFOUVBEBNFOUF BDBEÐNJDP"JOEBRVFOÍPTFFNQSFTUFFmDÈDJBUSBOTDFOEFOUFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFEPT NPUJWPTEFUFSNJOBOUFT ËEFDJTÍPPUSJCVOBMFNTFEFEFSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOUSBBQMJDBÎÍP 3DM"H33FM.JO*MNBS(BMWÍPKVMHBEP%+ "SUJHPFEP3*45' $POGPSNF4"/504Q .&/%&4Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 96 Marcia Amino EFMFJJEÐOUJDBËRVFMBEFDMBSBEBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMQPEFSÈEFDMBSBSJODJEFOUBMNFOUFB JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBMFJBJOEBOÍPBUJOHJEBQFMPKVÓ[PEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF 0QSFDFEFOUFEFUBMFOUFOEJNFOUPÏPEFDJEJEPOB3FDMBNBÎÍPORVBO EPB$PSUFEFDMBSPVBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFEJTQPTJUJWPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEP&TUBEP EP4FSHJQFDPNGVOEBNFOUPFNQSFDFEFOUFFOWPMWFOEPPVUSP&TUBEPEB'FEFSBÎÍP 0.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTTVTUFOUBRVFNFTNPRVFTFFOUFOEBJODBCÓ WFM B SFDMBNBÎÍP TFSJB WJÈWFM B EFDMBSBÎÍP JODJEFOUBM EF JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF &TTB EFDMBSBÎÍP FN TFEF EF SFDMBNBÎÍP BGBTUBSJB B OFDFTTJEBEF EF QSPQPTJUVSB EFPVUSBBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFDPOmHVSBWFSEBEFJSBNVUBÎÍPOB mOBMJEBEFEPJOTUJUVUP %FGBUPOÍPGBSJBNVJUPTFOUJEPTFPUSJCVOBMUFSHJWFSTBTTFOÍPDPOIFDFOEP EFSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSRVFTUÜFTNFSBNFOUFGPSNBJTFFYJHJTTFEPJOUFSFTTBEPBQSPQPTJ UVSBEBBSHVJÎÍPEFEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEFQSFDFJUPGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBBUFTUBSBJODPOT UJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFMFJNVOJDJQBMPVFTUBEVBMEFUFPSJEÐOUJDPËPVUSBRVFKÈUFWFB MFHJUJNJEBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMSFDPOIFDJEBQFMBQSØQSJB$PSUF /FTTBQFSTQFDUJWBQBSFDFCBTUBOUFMØHJDBBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFRVFFNTFEFEF SFDMBNBÎÍPPUSJCVOBMBOBMJTFBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFMFJTDVKPUFPSÏJEÐOUJDPPV NFTNPTFNFMIBOUFBPEFPVUSBTMFJTRVFKÈGPSBNPCKFUPEPDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPEF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQFSBOUFP45' "SFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMoTVBQSØQSJBFWPMVÎÍPPEFNPOTUSBoOÍPNBJT TFEFTUJOBBQFOBTBBTTFHVSBSBDPNQFUÐODJBFBBVUPSJEBEFEFEFDJTÜFTFTQFDÓmDBT NBTUBNCÏNTFDPOTUJUVJDPNPBÎÍPWPMUBEBËQSPUFÎÍPEBPSEFNDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 2.2.5. Reclamação contra ato que desrespeitou enunciado da súmula vinculante do Supremo Tribunal Federal e a Lei nº 11.417/2006 "HSBOEFJOPWBÎÍPOPUFNBFNFTUVEPQSPNPWJEBOPTÞMUJNPTBOPTQPSNV EBOÎBMFHJTMBUJWBGPJBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVUJMJ[BSSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBPCTFSWÉODJBEFTÞNV MBWJODVMBOUF"OPWJEBEFWFJPJOUSPEV[JEBQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMBP JOTFSJSPBSUJHP"FffOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM "SJHPSPDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBPCTFSWÉODJBEFEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMDPN FGFJUPWJODVMBOUFKÈFSBBTTFOUFEFDPSSFOEPEBEJTQPTJÎÍPHFSBMDPOTUBOUFEPBSUJHP *lEB$'"FYQSFTTBQSFWJTÍPEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFSQSPQPTUBDPOUSBBUP EBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPDPOmHVSBBWFSEBEFJSBJOPWBÎÍPBMÏNEFDPNPBDJNBTFFYQÙT SFGPSÎBSBOBUVSF[BEFBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPBmSNBOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJOTUBVSBÎÍPTFN QSPDFTTPQSÏWJPFNGBDFEFBVUPSJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWBFEFGPSNBBVUÙOPNB 3DM3FM.JO4ZEOFZ4BODIFTKVMHBEP%+ .&/%&4Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 97 7FKBTFRVFB-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFSFHVMBNFOUPVPBSUJHP "EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMFEJTDJQMJOPVOPBSUJHPP PDBCJNFOUPEFSFDMBNBÎÍP BUSJCVJOEPMIFPTFGFJUPTQSØQSJPTEFBÎÍPKVEJDJBMKVMHBNFOUPEFQSPDFEÐODJBBOVMB ÎÍPEFBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDBTTBÎÍPEFEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMQPEFOEPTFSQSPQPTUBDPOUSB EFDJTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWB "SU Pù %B EFDJTÍP KVEJDJBM PV EP BUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP RVF DPOUSBSJBS FOVODJBEP EF TÞNVMB WJODVMBOUF OFHBSMIF WJHÐODJB PV BQMJDÈMP JOEFWJEBNFOUF DBCFSÈ SFDMBNBÎÍP BP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM TFN QSFKVÓ[PEPTSFDVSTPTPVPVUSPTNFJPTBENJTTÓWFJTEFJNQVHOBÎÍP f Pù $POUSB PNJTTÍP PV BUP EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB P VTP EB SFDMBNBÎÍPTØTFSÈBENJUJEPBQØTFTHPUBNFOUPEBTWJBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBT fPù"PKVMHBSQSPDFEFOUFBSFDMBNBÎÍPP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMBOVMBSÈ PBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPPVDBTTBSÈBEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMJNQVHOBEBEFUFSNJOBOEP RVFPVUSBTFKBQSPGFSJEBDPNPVTFNBQMJDBÎÍPEBTÞNVMBDPOGPSNFPDBTP 6NBWF[BQSPWBEBQPSNBJPSJBEFEPJTUFSÎPTEPTNFNCSPTEP45'FEFWJ EBNFOUFQVCMJDBEBOBJNQSFOTBPmDJBMBTÞNVMBBRVFTFSFGFSFPBSUJHP"EB $POTUJUVJÎÍPQBTTBBUFSOPTUFSNPTEFTUFEJTQPTJUJWPFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFFNSFMBÎÍP BPTEFNBJTNFNCSPTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBEJSFUBFJOEJSFUB OBTFTGFSBTGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMFNVOJDJQBM "PQSFWFSPFTHPUBNFOUPEBTWJBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTQBSBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNB ÎÍPOPDBTPEFBUPPVPNJTTÍPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBPfPEPBSUJHPPEB-FJO BUFOEFËQSFPDVQBÎÍPDPNBHSBOEFRVBOUJEBEFEFGFJUPTFNRVFÏQBSUF P1PEFS1ÞCMJDPFBUFOUBQBSBBOFDFTTJEBEFEFFTHPUBNFOUPEBTWJBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBT QBSBQSPQPTJUVSBEBSFDMBNBÎÍP $PNFOUBOEPPOPWPQFSNJTTJWPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM(JMNBS.FOEFTressalta “situar-se na seara da Administração Pública o grande desafio na implantação da súmula vinculante em toda a sua amplitude”,QBSBBmSNBSBOFDFTTJEBEFEFFTHPUBNFOUPEBWJB BENJOJTUSBUJWBQBSBQSPQPTJUVSBEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNBDSJTFOVNÏSJDBEP45' BBEPÎÍPEBTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFQBSBB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBWBJFYJHJSB QSPNVMHBÎÍPEFOPSNBTEFPSHBOJ[BÎÍPFQSPDFEJNFOUPRVFQFSNJUBN BTTFHVSBSBPCTFSWÉODJBQPSQBSUFEFTUBEPTEJUBNFTDPOUJEPTOBTÞNVMB TFNRVFTFWFSJmRVFVNBOPWBFBEJDJPOBMTPCSFDBSHBEFQSPDFTTPTo BHPSBEFSFDMBNBÎÜFToQBSBP45' %BÓQSPWBWFMNFOUFBOFDFTTJEBEFEFRVFBMFJQSFWFKBQSPDFEJNFOUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP BEFRVBEP EF NPEP B QFSNJUJS UBOUP RVBOUP QPTTÓWFM RVF BT RVFTUÜFT FWFOUVBMNFOUF TVTDJUBEBT QPTTBN TFS SFTPMWJEBT OB TFBSBEBQSØQSJBBENJOJTUSBÎÍP1BSFDFBCVTJWPOFTTFDPOUFYUPRVFTF BENJUB B SFDMBNBÎÍP TFN RVF TF FOWJEFN FTGPSÎPT QBSB B TPMVÎÍP EB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 98 Marcia Amino DPOUSPWÏSTJBOPÉNCJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP"RVJSFTJEFVNEPTQPOUPTNBJT EFMJDBEPT F NBJT SFMFWBOUFT EP OPWP TJTUFNB JOBVHVSBEP QFMB &$ O ²RVFOÍPTFQPEFTVCTUJUVJSBDSJTFOVNÏSJDBPDBTJPOBEBQFMP SFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPQFMBNVMUJQMJDBÎÍPEFSFDMBNBÎÜFTGPSNVMBEBT EJSFUBNFOUFDPOUSBBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPQFSBOUFP45' "TEFDJTÜFTEP4VQSFNPWÐNCBMJ[BOEPBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBB IJQØUFTFEFEFTSFTQFJUPËTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFFTUBCFMFDFOEPQPSFYFNQMPRVF“inexiste ofensa à autoridade de Súmula Vinculante quando o ato de que se reclama é anterior à decisão emanada da Corte Suprema”SFTUSJOHJOEPTVBVUJMJ[BÎÍPBPOÍPBBENJUJS “quando, ao se alegar descumprimento da Súmula Vinculante 3, o ato reclamado não é proveniente do TCU”,60 “contra demora na cognição de recurso que invoque ofensa à súmula vinculante”PVQPSOÍPUFSDBSÈUFSQSFWFOUJWPEF“impedir que sejam proferidas decisões judiciais ou administrativas”. /BEPVUSJOBBTQPTJÎÜFTWBSJBN .BSDFMP/BWBSSP3JCFJSP%BOUBTFOUFOEFRVFDPNPBSFDMBNBÎÍPSFQSFTFO UBPFYFSDÓDJPEPEJSFJUPEFBÎÍPOÍPSFTUSJOHJEPQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍPOÍPQPEFSJBP MFHJTMBEPSDPOEJDJPOBSTFVFYFSDÓDJPJODJEJOEPFNJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFBPGB[ÐMP "SHVNFOUBRVFNFTNPRVFTFUSBUBTTFEFEJSFJUPEFQFUJÎÍPOÍPTFKVTUJmDBSJBQFSNJ UJSË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEFTDVNQSJSEFDJTÍPEP4VQSFNPFORVBOUPEVSBSFNPTSFDVSTPTF JOTUÉODJBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBT +È-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEB$VOIBFOUFOEFRVFBSFTUSJÎÍPÏem princípio razoável, QBSB FWJUBS RVF P 5SJCVOBM TF USBOTGPSNF FN ØSHÍP EF QSJNFJSB JOTUÉODJB QBSBUFNBTRVFEFWFNTFSSFTPMWJEPTOPÉNCJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPPVOBTJOTUÉODJBT PSEJOÈSJBTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP-FNCSBPBVUPSRVFBSFDMBNBÎÍPEFWFTFSBKVJ[BEB TFNQSFKVÓ[PEPTEFNBJTNFJPTEFJNQVHOBÎÍPDPNPPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB QPS FYFNQMP P RVF NBOUÏN ÓOUFHSP P QSJODÓQJP EB JOBGBTUBCJMJEBEF EP DPOUSPMF KVSJTEJDJPOBM"OPUBDPOUVEPRVFBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFNUFTF EPEJTQPTJUJWPOÍP JNQFEFRVFFWFOUVBMNFOUFTVBBQMJDBÎÍPOPDBTPDPODSFUPFOTFKFTJUVBÎÍPJODPOT UJUVDJPOBM$BCFSJBBPSFDMBNBOUF“expor o motivo pelo qual não se foi possível esperar a decisão administrativa, demonstrando a utilidade e a necessidade da imediata intervenção do STF para corrigir o ato administrativo que contrariou o enunciado da súmula .&/%&4Q 3DM"H33FM.JO&SPT(SBVKVMHBEP%+F EFFOUSFPVUSBTù0BSUJHP DBQVUEB-FJOQSFWÐRVFPFOVODJBEPEBTÞNVMBUFSÈFGFJUPTBQBSUJSEFTVBQVCMJDBÎÍPOBJN QSFOTBPmDJBM²QPSJTTPRVFEFDJEJEPOB3DMOP"H33FM.JOù"ZSFT#SJUUP%+FRVFOÍP DBCFSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQBSBRVFTUJPOBSWJPMBÎÍPBTÞNVMBEP45'EFTUJUVÓEBEFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUF 3DMO"H3WPUPEB3FM.JO$ÈSNFO-ÞDJBKVMHBEP%+F 3DMO"H33FM.JO$F[BS1FMVTPKVMHBEP%+F 3DMO3FM.JO$BSNFO-VDJBKVMHBEP%+F %"/5"4Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 99 vinculante”,QBSBRVFTFQPTTBBGBTUBSPDPOEJDJPOBNFOUPDPNBBQMJDBÎÍPEPQSJO DÓQJPEBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEF4JHOJmDBEJ[FSRVF OÍPTFQPEFBmSNBSRVFTFNQSFIBWFSÈJOUFSFTTFEFBHJSOBSFDMBNBÎÍP BKVJ[BEBTFNPFTHPUBNFOUPEBJOTUÉODJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBTPCQFOBEFTF JODPSSFSOPNFTNPFSSPEFTFEFmOJSa priori PJOUFSFTTFEFBHJSNFSDÐ EPEJSFJUPGVOEBNFOUBMEFBDFTTPËKVTUJÎB5BMDPOEJÎÍPEBBÎÍPQPEF OÍPFTUBSQSFTFOUFFNDFSUBTQPTUVMBÎÜFTGFJUBTTFNQSÏWJBQSPWPDBÎÍP FYUSBKVEJDJBMEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB 3JDBSEPEF#BSSPT-FPOFMTVTUFOUBQPTJÎÍPJEÐOUJDB %VBTQSFPDVQBÎÜFTQFSNFJBNPEFCBUFRVBOUPËDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEPFT HPUBNFOUPEBFTGFSBBENJOJTUSBUJWBQBSBBENJTTÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPEFVNMBEPBCB OBMJ[BÎÍPEFTFVVTPRVFTPCSFDBSSFHBSJBP4VQSFNPFQSPWPDBSJBDSJTFTFNFMIBOUFË RVFPDPSSFVDPNPSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPQBSBPRVBMGPSBNJOTUJUVÓEPTPTJTUFNBEF SFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMFKVMHBNFOUPEFDBTPTSFQFUJUJWPTFEFPVUSPMBEPBOFDFTTJEBEFEF OÍPFTWB[JBSJNQPSUBOUFNFDBOJTNPEFSFTHVBSEPEBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTEP45' "$PSUFEFWFSÈOPTKVMHBNFOUPTTPCSFPUFNBFRVJMJCSBSBBVUPOPNJBEBSFDMBNBÎÍP F TVB TVCTJEJBSJFEBEF BOUF PT PVUSPT NFJPT EF JNQVHOBÎÍP EBT EFDJTÜFT KVEJDJBJT %FDJTÜFTNPOPDSÈUJDBTBQPOUBNOPTFOUJEPEFTFSBEFRVBEPPDPOEJDJPOBNFOUPEB -FJO 5BNCÏNB-FJRVFSFHVMBPQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPOPÉNCJUPEB"ENJOJT USBÎÍP'FEFSBMGPJSFGPSNBEBQFMB-FJOQBSBQSFWFSBOFDFTTÈSJBNPUJWBÎÍP EBTEFDJTÜFTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTRVFBQMJRVFNPVEFJYFNEFBQMJDBSTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUF EFNPEPRVFQFSNJUBPDPOUSPMFKVEJDJBMFBJOEBRVFBTBVUPSJEBEFTBENJOJTUSBUJWBT EFWBNBEFRVBSTVBTGVUVSBTEFDJTÜFTËEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBOBSFDMBNBÎÍPTPCQFOBEF SFTQPOTBCJMJ[BÎÍPQFTTPBMOBTFTGFSBTDÓWFMBENJOJTUSBUJWBFQFOBM $6/)"Q -&0/&-Q 7JEF3DMO3FM.JO&MMFO(SBDJFEFDJTÍPNPOPDSÈUJDB%+F3DM3FM O.JO&SPT(SBVKVMHBEP%+3DMO.$3FM.JO&MMFO(SBDJF %+FBSFMBUPSBBOPUPVFOUSFPVUSPTNPUJWPTJODMVTJWFEFNÏSJUPQBSBJOEFGFSJSBMJNJOBS RVBOUPBPEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEB4ÞNVMB7JODVMBOUFQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB1BVMJTUBRVFiBSFDMB NBOUFOÍPEFNPOTUSPVRVFIPVWFPEFWJEPFTHPUBNFOUPEBTWJBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTPRVFQPTTJCJMJUBSJB PDBCJNFOUPEBQSFTFOUFSFDMBNBÎÍPw1FOEFEFKVMHBNFOUPBHSBWPSFHJNFOUBMDPOUSBBEFDJTÍPBTFS SFMBUBEPQFMB.JO3PTB8FCFS/PNFTNPTFOUJEPFDPN JEÐOUJDP BOEBNFOUP QSPDFTTVBM B 3DM O .$3FM.JO&MMFO(SBDJFKVMHBEP%+F /FTTFTFOUJEPB-FJOPBMUFSPVB-FJEFEFKBOFJSPEFRVFSFHVMBPQSPDFTTP BENJOJTUSBUJWPOPÉNCJUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB'FEFSBMQBSBBDSFTDFOUBSEJTQPTJUJWPTRVFQSFWFFNB OFDFTTJEBEFEFFYQMJDJUBÎÍPQPSQBSUFEBBVUPSJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWBEBTSB[ÜFTEBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFPVOÍP EBTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFFPTFGFJUPTEBEFDJTÍPEFQSPDFEÐODJBEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNSFMBÎÍPBGVUVSBTEFDJTÜFT EB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEFNPEPRVFDPÓCBBSFJUFSBÎÍPEFEFDJTÜFTDPOUSÈSJBTBPFOUFOEJNFOUPTVNVMBEP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 100 Marcia Amino 4FKBDPNPGPSPBEWFOUPEP"SU"FTFVfPDPOTPMJEBUFOEÐODJBBQPO UBEBQPS.BSDFMP/BWBSSP3JCFJSP%BOUBTKÈFNBEPVTPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNP NFDBOJTNPQBSBDPOGFSJSNBJPSFmDÈDJBPVFGFUJWJEBEFËTEFDJTÜFTOPSNBUJWBTEP45' &OUSFPTNBJTQSPNJTTPSFTDBNJOIPTRVFPGVUVSPBQPOUBËSFDMBNBÎÍP FTUÈ P EF UPSOÈMB JOTUSVNFOUP EP DPOUSPMF BCTUSBUP EF OPSNBT QSJODJQBMNFOUFJNQPOEPBFmDÈDJBEBTEFDJTÜFTUPNBEBTFNUFTF 4FQPSVNMBEPBOPUBTFBOFDFTTJEBEFEFRVFOBFMBCPSBÎÍPEBTÞNVMBTF FOWJEFNFTGPSÎPTQBSBRVFOÍPHFSFNQSPCMFNBTJOUFSQSFUBUJWPTQPSPVUSPMBEPTVB JOUFSQSFUBÎÍPJODPSSFUBUBNCÏNFOTFKBBQSPQPTJUVSBEFSFDMBNBÎÍP %FWFTFUPNBSPNBJPSDVJEBEPOPUPDBOUFËJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEBTÞNVMB4JN QPSRVFBBVUPSJEBEFRVFUJWFSEFBQMJDÈMBEFWFBEPUBSBNFTNBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPFOUFO EJEBQFMP45'TPCQFOBEFTFOEPEJTUPSDJEBFTTBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPBDBCBSTFOEPWJPMBEB BTÞNVMBFDPNJTUPmDBSFNBCFSUBTBTQPSUBTQBSBPBKVJ[BNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍP %BÓQPSRVF+PTÏ.JHVFM(BSDJB.FEJOB5FSFTB"SSVEB"MWJN8BNCJFSF-VJ[ 3PESJHVFT 8BNCJFS FN USBCBMIP FTQFDÓmDP TPCSF P UFNB CFN QPOEFSBSBN RVF B TÞNVMBQBTTBOEPBUFSFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFEFWFQBTTBSBTFSFMBCPSBEBDPNNVJUPNBJT DSJUÏSJPFEFGPSNBRVFOÍPHFSFOBNFEJEBEPQPTTÓWFMQSPCMFNBTJOUFSQSFUBUJWPT NBJTDPNQMFYPTEPRVFHFSBEPTQFMBQSØQSJBMFJ 0KVMHBNFOUPEFQSPDFEÐODJBEBSFDMBNBÎÍPFNIJQØUFTFEFEFTSFTQFJUPË TÞNVMB WJODVMBOUF EBSÈ FOTFKP Ë BOVMBÎÍP EP BUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP PV Ë DBTTBÎÍP EB EFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMRVFBGSPOUBSBNBTÞNVMBOPTUFSNPTEPEJTQPTUPOPQBSÈHSBGP EPBSUJHP"EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM5BNCÏNTFQSFWJVRVFBQØTBBOVMBÎÍPEP BUPPVBDBTTBÎÍPEBEFDJTÍPB4VQSFNB$PSUFideterminará que outra seja proferida com ou sem aplicação da súmula, conforme o caso”."OPUB.PSBUPRVFPMFHJTMBEPSBP UFSVUJMJ[BEPBQBMBWSBPVUSBQBSFDFUFSTFFTRVFDJEPEPBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFOEPEF TFBQMJDBSQPSBOBMPHJBUBNCÏNQBSBFTUFBNFTNBDPOTFRVÐODJB"JNQPSUÉODJBEP QBQFMBUSJCVÓEPBP45'WFSEBEFJSPiDPNBOEBOUFwEBTÞNVMBDPNDPNQFUÐODJBQBSB EFDJEJSRVBOEPBQSFDJBSVNBSFDMBNBÎÍPTFVNBEFUFSNJOBEBTÞNVMBUFNPVOÍP BQMJDBÎÍPOVNEBEPDBTPDPODSFUP " QSJODÓQJP B SFDMBNBÎÍP OÍP EFWF TFSWJS DPNP NFJP QBSB DBODFMBNFOUP PVSFWJTÍPEFFOVODJBEPTEBTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFEBEBBFYJTUÐODJBEFQSPDFEJNFOUP %"/5"4Q .03"50Q ("3$*".&%*/"+PTÏ.JHVFM8".#*&3-VJ[3PESJHVFT8".#*&35FSFTB"SSVEB"MWJN3F QFSDVTTÍPHFSBMFTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUF3FMFWBOUFTOPWJEBEFTUSB[JEBTQFMB&$OP*O3FGPSNB EP+VEJDJÈSJPQSJNFJSPTFOTBJPTDSÓUJDPTTPCSFB&$OP4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT Q .03"50Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 101 BVUÙOPNPQBSBUBMPCKFUJWPBTFSJOTUBVSBEPOP4VQSFNPEFPGÓDJPPVNFEJBOUFQSP WPDBÎÍPEFVNEPTMFHJUJNBEPT /BDPOTUSVÎÍPEPSFHJNFEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQBSBPCTFSWBÎÍPEFTÞNVMBWJODV MBOUFBMHVNBTRVFTUÜFTOPWBTUÐNTVSHJEPFEFWFNTFSPCKFUPEFEFDJTÍPQFMP1MFOÈ SJPEB$PSUFQPSFYFNQMPBBQMJDBÎÍPEFTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFBFYFDVÎÜFTEFEFDJTÜFT USBOTJUBEBTFNKVMHBEPSFGFSFOUFTBQSFTUBÎÜFTEFUSBUPTVDFTTJWP 2.2.6 Outras hipóteses de cabimento de reclamação $PNPÏQSØQSJPEFVNJOTUJUVUPRVFUFNPSJHFNOBDPOTUSVÎÍPKVSJTQSVEFO DJBMFTVCTFRVFOUFQPTJUJWBÎÍPBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPWBSJBDPOGPSNFBBNQMJUVEF RVFBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEP45'FNQSFTUBBPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFDPOGPSNF DPNQPTJÎÍPWBSJBOUF )ÈDPSSFOUFOP45'RVFTVTUFOUBRVFBFmDÈDJBUSBOTDFOEFOUFQFSNJUFBSFDMBNB ÎÍPQPSWJPMBÎÍPEPTGVOEBNFOUPTPVNPUJWPTWJODVMBOUFTEBEFDJTÍP&NCPSBQSFEPNJOF PFOUFOEJNFOUPDPOUSÈSJPOB3FDMBNBÎÍP%'QPSFYFNQMPTFFTUBUVJVRVFCBTUBP BUPEFTBmBSBFYFHFTFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPOTBHSBEBQFMP45'FNDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPoBJOEB RVFBPGFOTBTFEÐQPSWJBPCMÓRVBoQBSBFOTFKBSBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFSFDMBNBÎÍP &YJTUFEJTDVTTÍPRVBOUPËQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFP5SJCVOBMBOBMJTBSFNTFEFEFSF DMBNBÎÍPBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFMFJEFUFPSJEÐOUJDPPVTFNFMIBOUFBPEBMFJRVFKÈGPJ PCKFUPEBmTDBMJ[BÎÍPBCTUSBUBEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQFSBOUFBDPSUF"EJTDVTTÍPQFS NFPVPEFCBUFOB3FDMBNBÎÍPOFNRVFP.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTDBQJUBOFPV BDPSSFOUFOPTFOUJEPEFRVFBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOÍPNBJTTFEFTUJOBBQFOBTB BTTFHVSBSBDPNQFUÐODJBFBBVUPSJEBEFEFEFDJTÜFTFTQFDJmDBTFCFNEFMJNJUBEBTEP 4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMNBTDPOTUJUVJBÎÍPWPMUBEBËQSPUFÎÍPEBPSEFNDPOTUJUVDJP OBMDPNPVNUPEP/PWPUPRVFBDBCPVOÍPQSFWBMFDFOEPTVTUFOUPVP.JOJTUSPRVFTF USBUBWBEPQPEFSÓOTJUPËQSØQSJBDPNQFUÐODJBEP5SJCVOBMEFmTDBMJ[BSJODJEFOUBMNFOUF BDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBTMFJTFEPTBUPTOPSNBUJWPTQBSBEFDMBSBSJODJEFOUBMNFOUFB JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBTMFJTFEPTBUPTOPSNBUJWPTPCKFUPEBRVFMBSFDMBNBÎÍP $POGPSNFQSFWJTUPOB-FJO "RVFTUÍPGPJPCKFUPEFSFNFTTBBPDPMFHJBEPOB3DMOQFMB3FMBUPSB.JO&MMFO(SBDJFNBTOÍPGPJ EFDJEJEBFNWJSUVEFEBEFTJTUÐODJBEPQSPDFTTPIPNPMPHBEBQFMB3FMBUPSB3PTB8FCFS%+F .&/%&4Q 7JEFB3DMO"H33FM.JO+PBRVJN#BSCPTBKVMHBEP%+F EF&BJOEB 3DMO.$"H33FM.JO.BSDP"VSÏMJPKVMHBNFOUPFN%+F 3DMO3FMù.JO.BVSÓDJP$PSSÐB5SJCVOBM1MFOPKVMHBEP%+/FTTF TFOUJEPB3DMO3FMù.JO(JMNBS.FOEFTKVMHBEPFN%+ 3DMO3FMù.JO"ZSFT#SJUUPKVMHBEP%KF0FOUFOEJNFOUPSFTUPV WFODJEPQPSNBJPSJBNBTBMFJUVSBEPTEFCBUFTJOEJDBQPTTÓWFMVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM DPNPNFDBOJTNPEFQSPUFÎÍPEBPSEFNDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBEBBBNQMBMFHJUJNBÎÍPFPSJUPTJNQMFTF DÏMFSFRVFQFSNJUFPQSPOVODJBNFOUPEFmOJUJWPEP45'EFNPEPRVFJOJCBBQSPQPTJUVSBEFJOÞNFSBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 102 Marcia Amino /B3FDMBNBÎÍPOQSPQPTUBQBSBSFDPOIFDFSBDPNQFUÐODJBEB+VTUJÎB DPNVNQBSBKVMHBSHSFWFEPTQPMJDJBJTDJWJTOP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPDPNGVOEBNFOUP OBBVUPSJEBEFEPEFDJEJEPOB"ÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOoRVF BGBTUPVPFOUFOEJNFOUPTFHVOEPPRVBMB+VTUJÎBEP5SBCBMIPTFSJBDPNQFUFOUFQBSB EJSJNJS DPOUSPWÏSTJBT SFMBUJWBT Ë SFMBÎÍP EF USBCBMIP FOUSF P 1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP F TFVT TFSWJEPSFToQFSNFPVPTEFCBUFTRVFMFWBSBNËQSPDFEÐODJBEPQFEJEPBEJTDVTTÍP RVBOUPËDPOWFOJÐODJBEFTFEFCBUFSTPCSFBQSØQSJBWJBCJMJEBEFEPEJSFJUPEFHSFWF 6NBmOBMJEBEFRVFBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQPEFUFSBHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEF EBTEFDJTÜFTFNNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍP/FTTFTFOUJEPPSFMBUPS.JOJTUSP&SPT(SBV JOJDJPVPWPUPOPDPMFHJBEPJOEJDBOEPRVF“o exame do objeto desta reclamação permitirá a esta Corte esclarecer e demarcar adequadamente o sentido mais correto e a amplitude do decidido no MI 712” BTTJJNBTTFHVSPVPEJSFJUPEFHSFWFBPTTFSWJEPSFTQÞCMJDPT /B3FDMBNBÎÍPOBEFDJTÍPNPOPDSÈUJDBEB1SFTJEÐODJBEP4VQSFNP BEPUBDPNPQBSBEJHNBOÍPPKVMHBEPBQPOUBEPQFMBQBSUFSFDMBNBOUFNBTPVUSPBmS NBOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEF“consideração de uma causa de pedir aberta nas reclamações”F SFGPSÎBOEPPKÈNFODJPOBEPFOUFOEJNFOUPOPTFOUJEPEFRVFBSFDMBNBÎÍPUFNPQBQFM EFBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMWPMUBEBËQSPUFÎÍPEBPSEFNDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPVNUPEP 2.2.7 A reclamação para garantia da autoridade das decisões do Supremo Tribunal Federal e os processos subjetivos &NTFEFEFDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFYFSDJEPOPTQSPDFTTPTTVCKFUJ WPTQBSBRVFFTUFKBDPOmHVSBEBBOÍPPCTFSWÉODJBEPKVMHBEPBFOTFKBSPVTPEBSF DMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUFP45'FOUFOEFOFDFTTÈSJBBDPODPSSÐODJB EFEJWFSTPTSFRVJTJUPTB RVFPBUPVTVSQBEPSDPMJEBGSPOUBMNFOUFDPNPDPNBOEP FNFSHFOUFEBEFDJTÍPEFTDVNQSJEBC RVFBWJPMBÎÍPmRVFDBSBDUFSJ[BEBQPSQBSUF EFRVFNFTUÈWJODVMBEPQFMBBVUPSJEBEFEPKVMHBEPPVTFKBQPSRVFNGPJQBSUFOP QSPDFTTP EF PSJHFN D OÍP Ï QPTTÓWFM VUJMJ[BS B SFDMBNBÎÍP DPNP TVCTUJUVUP PV BÎÜFTJODMVTJWFRVBOUPBP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFPDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEFMFJNVOJDJQBM3FT TBMUBNPTBSHVNFOUPTQPOEFSBEPTEBDPSSFOUFBEWFSTBGVOEBEBOBQSFPDVQBÎÍPRVBOUPBPBVNFOUP EPOÞNFSPEFSFDMBNBÎÜFTRVFPFOUFOEJNFOUPQPEFSJBHFSBSDPNTVQSFTTÍPEPFYBNFEBNBUÏSJB QFMBTJOTUÉODJBTPSEJOÈSJBTFOBWJBCJMJEBEFEBEJTDVTTÍPEBRVFTUÍPEFGVOEPQPSWJBEFSFDVSTPFYUSB PSEJOÈSJPDPNPTFGFJUPTEBSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBM 3DMO3FM.JO&SPT(SBVKVMHBEP%+F 3DMO.$3FM.JO1SFTJEFOUF(JMNBS.FOEFTKVMHBEP%+FTVCNF UJEPBBHSBWPSFHJNFOUBMBJOEBOÍPKVMHBEP 3DMO"H33FM.JO.BSDP"VSÏMJPKVMHBEP%+F$POTUBOEPEPBUP BUBDBEPGVOEBNFOUPOÍPWFSTBEPOPBDØSEÍPEP4VQSFNPEFTDBCFBTTFOUBSBBEFRVBÎÍPEPQFEJEP "TTJNTFPQSFDFEFOUFUJEPQPSWJPMBEPGPJUPNBEPFNKVMHBNFOUPEFBMDBODFTVCKFUJWPDPNPTFEÈOP DPOUSPMFEJGVTPFJODJEFOUBMEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFTPNFOUFTÍPMFHJUJNBEBTBPNBOFKPEBSFDMBNBÎÍP BTQBSUFTRVFDPNQVTFSBNBSFMBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMEPBSFTUP3DMO"H33FM.JO+PBRVJN#BS CPTBKVMHBEP%+FEFOUSFPVUSBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 103 TVDFEÉOFPEFSFDVSTPQBSBPCUFSBSFGPSNBEBEFDJTÍPFE OÍPTFQPEFVUJMJ[BSB SFDMBNBÎÍPTFBEFDJTÍPJNQVHOBEBKÈUSBOTJUPVFNKVMHBEP. 0 GFOÙNFOP EB PCKFUJWJ[BÎÍP PV BCTUSBUJWJ[BÎÍP EP DPOUSPMF EJGVTP DPN B BQSPYJNBÎÍPEPTNPEFMPTEFDPOUSPMFEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFDPOUVEPUSB[NVEBO ÎBTDPNSFMBÎÍPBFTTFTSFRVJTJUPTQSØQSJPTEPDPOUSPMFEJGVTP $BSBDUFSÓTUJDBEBPCKFUJWJ[BÎÍPOBTQBMBWSBTEF%"/5"4ÏB $PODFTTÍP NFTNP OP ÉNCJUP EF UBM DPOUSPMF EJGVTP EF QSFTUBÎÍP KVSJTEJDJPOBM RVF TF EFTUJOB OÍP BQFOBT B QSPUFHFS DPODSFUBNFOUF P EJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEBQBSUFoPCKFUJWPUSBEJDJPOBMEBmTDBMJ[BÎÍPEJGVTBEF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFoNBTUBNCÏNBBNQBSBSBCTUSBUBNFOUFPEJSFJUP PCKFUJWPRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPBUPEPTFQPSUBOUPJNQMJDBSFWFTUJSBTEFDJTÜFT SFTQFDUJWBTEFFGFJUPTerga omnesPVBUÏWJODVMBOUFTRVFTFNQSFGPSBN UÓQJDPTBQFOBTEPDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEP 4F B EFDJTÍP QSPGFSJEB FN TFEF EF DPOUSPMF EJGVTP QBTTB B UFS FGFJUPT erga omnes PVWJODVMBOUFTQBTTBBTFSDBCÓWFMSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSUFSDFJSPRVFOÍPUFOIBTJEP QBSUFOPQSPDFTTP /FTTFTFOUJEPOB3FDMBNBÎÍPOQPSFYFNQMPBMFHBTFPEFTDVNQSJ NFOUPEPEFDJEJEPOP)$OSFM.JOJTUSP.BSDP"VSÏMJPFNRVFP45'EF DMBSPVBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEPBSUJHPEFMFJRVFWFEBWBBQSPHSFTTÍPEFSFHJNFFN DBTPTEFDSJNFTIFEJPOEPT"EJTDVTTÍPBTFSUSBWBEBOFTTFTBVUPTSFMBDJPOBTFOVN QSJNFJSPNPNFOUPTFBENJUJEBBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPNBFmDÈDJBerga omnesEBEFDJTÍP OP)$OPRVFQPSTJTØÏDPOUSPWFSUJEPNBTUBNCÏNDPNBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍP RVBOUPËFYQFEJÎÍPQFMP4FOBEP'FEFSBMEFSFTPMVÎÍPOPTUFSNPTEPBSUJHP9EB $POTUJUVJÎÍPQPTUPRVFPKVÓ[PEFCBTFFOUFOEFVRVFBEFDJTÍPEP45'EFQFOEFSJB EPJNQMFNFOUPEBUBMSFTPMVÎÍP "SFDMBNBDÍPNBOFKBEBOFTTFTUFSNPTUFSÈDPOUPSOPTNBJTBNQMPTEPRVFBRVF MFTPSJHJOBMNFOUFQSFWJTUPTQFMPMFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVJOUFDPOGPSNF'SFEJF%JEJFS+ÞOJPS 5VEP JTTP OPT MFWB B BENJUJS B BNQMJBÎÍP EP cabimento da reclamação constitucional QBSB BCSBOHFS PT DBTPT EF EFTPCFEJÐODJB B EFDJTÜFT -&0/&-Q %"/5"4Q /PNFTNPTFOUJEP%"/5"4Q $POmSBTFPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPDPOUSÈSJPOBEFDJTÍPNPOPDSÈUJDBEP.JO$BSMPT#SJUUPOB3$-O .5%+FOUFOEFOEPJODBCÓWFMBSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSBVTÐODJBEFFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFFFGFJUPTFSHB PNOFTEBEFDJTÍPOP)$SFGFSJEP 4PCSF B SFDMBNBÎÍP F TVTQFOTÍP EB FYFDVÎÍP EF MFJ QFMP 4FOBEP 'FEFSBM DPOmSBNTF BT SB[ÜFT EP FOUFOEJNFOUPEP.JOJTUSP(JMNBS.FOEFTTVTUFOUBOEPBSFMFJUVSBEPEJTQPTUPOPBSUJHP9EB$' QBSBBmSNBSBQSPDFEÐODJBEB3DMOFN.&/%&4Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 104 Marcia Amino UPNBEBT QFMP 1MFOP EP 45' FN DPOUSPMF EJGVTP EF DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EB FYJTUÐODJB EF FOVODJBEP TVNVMBS EF FmDÈDJB WJODVMBOUF²DFSUPQPSÏNRVFOÍPIÈQSFWJTÍPFYQSFTTBOFTUFTFOUJEPGBMB TFEFSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSEFTSFTQFJUPËiTÞNVMBwWJODVMBOUFFËEFDJTÍPFNBÎÍP EFDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF .BTBOPWBGFJÎÍPRVFWFN BTTVNJOEPPcontrole difuso EFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFRVBOEPGFJUPQFMP45' QFSNJUFRVFTFGBÎBFTTBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPFYUFOTJWBBUÏNFTNPDPNPGPSNBEF FWJUBSEFDJTÜFTDPOUSBEJUØSJBTFBDFMFSBSPKVMHBNFOUPEBTEFNBOEBT $PNP TF WÐ OÍP TÍP FTUBORVFT BT IJQØUFTFT EF DBCJNFOUP EB SFDMBNBÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM5SBUBTFEFJOTUJUVUPFNQFSNBOFOUFFWPMVÎÍP 3. CONCLUSÕES "SFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMÏSFTVMUBEPEFDPOTUSVÎÍPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBMCBTFBEBOBUFPSJBEPTQPEFSFTJNQMÓDJUPT0FTUVEPEFTVBFWPMVÎÍPQPEFTFS EJWJEJEPFNEJGFSFOUFTGBTFTEBBVTÐODJBEFQSFWJTÍPOPSNBUJWBQBTTBOEPQFMBQSFWJTÍP OPSFHJNFOUPJOUFSOPEP45'TFNGPSÎBEFMFJQPTUFSJPSNFOUFDPNGPSÎBEFMFJFDPOT UJUVDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPFN"BUVBMGBTFÏEFFYQBOTÍPEBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUP 1SFWJTUBOPUFYUPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFPSJHJOBMNFOUFQBSBQSF TFSWBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBFHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTEP45+FEP45'BSFDMB NBÎÍPUFWFTFVQSPDFEJNFOUPSFHVMBEPOB-FJO ²BÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFTUJ OBEBËQSFTFSWBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBFHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTEP45+F45' 0DBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOP45'ÏPCKFUPEFEJOÉNJDBDPOTUSVÎÍPKV SJTQSVEFODJBM/ÍPQPEFOEPTFSVUJMJ[BEBDPNPTVDFEÉOFPEFSFDVSTPPVBÎÍPSFTDJ TØSJBBUVBMNFOUFFOUFOEFTFRVFOÍPDBCFSFDMBNBÎÍPRVBOEPKÈIPVWFSUSÉOTJUPFN KVMHBEPEBEFDJTÍPJNQVHOBEB0DBSÈUFSTVQMFUJWPPVTVCTJEJÈSJPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPÏ BmSNBEPQFMBTEFDJTÜFTEP45'"DPNQFUÐODJBBTFSQSFTFSWBEBQFMBWJBEBSFDMBNB ÎÍPDPNQSFFOEFUBOUPBPSJHJOÈSJBDPNPBSFDVSTBM ²QBDÓmDBBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPQPSUFSDFJSPTRVFOÍP UFOIBNTJEPQBSUFOPQSPDFTTPQBSBHBSBOUJSBBVUPSJEBEFEFEFDJTÜFTQSPGFSJEBTFN DPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQFMP45'UBNCÏNFNTFEFEFDBVUFMBS $PNPFYFNQMPEBPCKFUJWBÎÍPPVBCTUSBUJWJ[BÎÍPEPDPOUSPMFEJGVTPP4VQSFNPDPOmSNPVBFmDÈDJB erga omnes EPBDØSEÍPEP1MFOÈSJPQSPGFSJEPOP3&mYBÎÍPEFOÞNFSPEFWFSFBEPSFTQPS MFJNVOJDJQBM BPKVMHBSJNQSPDFEFOUFTBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBTEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOFO SFM.JO$FMTPEF.FMMPKVMHBEP%KF&BJOEBP"*3FM.JO&MMFO (SBDJFKVMHBEP%+OPRVBMTFFOUFOEFVRVFPKVMHBNFOUPEFSFDVSTPFYUSB PSEJOÈSJPFNBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVJDJPOBMJEBEFEFDPNQFUÐODJBPSJHJOÈSJBEF5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB &TUBEVBMUFNFGFJUPTFSHBPNOFTBQMJDBOEPPBSUJHPEP3*45' RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 Reclamação constitucional 105 )ÈFOUFOEJNFOUPNJOPSJUÈSJPRVFQFSNJUFBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPOÍP NBJTTPNFOUFDPNPSFNÏEJPQBSBHBSBOUJBEBBVUPSJEBEFEFVNBEFDJTÍPFTQFDÓmDBPV QSFTFSWBÎÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBEP5SJCVOBMNBTUBNCÏNQPSWJPMBÎÍPEPTGVOEBNFOUPT PVNPUJWPTWJODVMBOUFTEBEFDJTÍPEP45'QBSBDPOUSPMFJODJEFOUBMEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJ EBEFEFOPSNBTFNFMIBOUFËRVFMBKÈPCKFUPEFEFDJTÍPEB$PSUFFQBSBDPODSFUJ[BSEF DJTÍPQSPGFSJEBFNNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍPDPNDBSÈUFSPCKFUJWP1BSBFTTBDPSSFOUFTFSJB QPTTÓWFMBJOEBBBEPÎÍPEFDBVTBEFQFEJSiBCFSUBwDPNPOPDPOUSPMFBCTUSBUPEFDPOT UJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFNRVFP45'OÍPmDBWJODVMBEPBPTGVOEBNFOUPTEBQFUJÎÍPJOJDJBM "DPOTUSVÎÍPKVSJTQSVEFODJBMEFTTBTOPWBTIJQØUFTFTEFDBCJNFOUPQPEFBUSJ CVJSVNOPWPQBQFMËSFDMBNBÎÍPoPEFBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMWPMUBEBËQSPUFÎÍPEBPSEFN DPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPNPVNUPEPFOÍPEFVNBEFDJTÍPFTQFDÓmDB0BVNFOUPOPOÞNF SPEFSFDMBNBÎÜFTRVFFTTFFOUFOEJNFOUPQPEFHFSBSCFNDPNPBQSFPDVQBÎÍPEFOÍP USBOTGPSNBSBSFDMBNBÎÍPFNWJBEFBDFTTPEJSFUPBP45'TVQSJNJOEPBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEBT JOTUÉODJBTPSEJOÈSJBTQFSNFJBPTEFCBUFTRVFTFEFTFOWPMWFNOP45'TPCSFPBMBSHBNFOUP EBTGVOÎÜFTEPJOTUJUVUP/FTTFDPOUFYUPHBOIBSFMFWPPDBSÈUFSTVCTJEJÈSJPEBSFDMBNBÎÍP EFNPEPBOÍPQFSNJUJSRVFDBTPTDPSSJRVFJSPTDIFHVFNEJSFUBNFOUFBP45' 0OÍPDBCJNFOUPEBSFDMBNBÎÍPDPOUSBEFDJTÍPEBJOTUÉODJBJOGFSJPSRVF BQMJDB FOUFOEJNFOUP EP 45' OPT SFDVSTPT NÞMUJQMPT FOWPMWFOEP UFNBT DPN SFQFS DVTTÍP HFSBM GPJ BmSNBEP QFMP 1MFOÈSJP EB $PSUF /P DPOUSPMF EJGVTP FN WJSUVEF EPTJTUFNBEFKVMHBNFOUPEFSFDVSTPTSFQFUJUJWPTFNRVFBTEFDJTÜFTQSPGFSJEBTOPT SFDVSTPTFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPTDPNSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMUÐNFGFJUPTerga omnes IÈOFDFTTJEBEF EFSFWJTÍPEFTTFFOUFOEJNFOUPTPCQFOBEFUPSOBSPTUSJCVOBJTEFTFHVOEPHSBVOPT ÞMUJNPTJOUÏSQSFUFTEBEFDJTÍPEP45' "FYJTUÐODJBEFNFDBOJTNPQSPDFTTVBMFTQFDÓmDPoDPNPÏBSFDMBNBÎÍPo QBSBQSFTFSWBSBDPNQFUÐODJBFQBSBJNQPSPDVNQSJNFOUPEFEFDJTÍPEP45'SFWFMBB EJmDVMEBEFEP5SJCVOBMEFGB[FSWBMFSTVBTEFDJTÜFTJODMVTJWFQFSBOUFPTEFNBJTØSHÍPT EP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP1BSBEPYBMNFOUFDPOUVEPBSFDMBNBÎÍPUFNTFNPTUSBEPJNQPSUBOUF JOTUSVNFOUPEFGPSUBMFDJNFOUPEPQBQFMEFTTFUSJCVOBMOBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP TFKBQFMBBNQMBMFHJUJNBÎÍPTFKBQFMBDFMFSJEBEFFEFmOJUJWJEBEFEFTVBTEFDJTÜFT BIBLIOGRAFIA $6/)"-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEBA Fazenda Pública em Juízo.FEJÎÍPSFWJTUBFBUVB MJ[BEB4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDB %"/5"4.BSDFMP/BWBSSP3JCFJSPReclamação constitucional no direito brasileiro. 1PS UP"MFHSF4FSHJP"OUPOJP'BCSJT&EJUPS %"/5"4 .BSDFMP /BWBSSP 3JCFJSP /PWJEBEFT FN SFDMBNBÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM TFV VTP QBSB JNQPS P DVNQSJNFOUP EF TÞNVMB WJODVMBOUF *O .&%*/" +PTÏ .JHVFM (BSDJB$36;-VBOB1FESPTBEF'JHVFJSFEP$&326&*3"-VJT0UBWJP4FRVFJSBEF (0.&4 +6/*03 -VJ[ .BOPFM DPPSE Os poderes do juiz e o controle das decisões RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 106 Marcia Amino judiciais – Estudos em homenagem à Professora Teresa Arruda Alvim Wambier4ÍP1BVMP 3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ %*%*&3+3'SFEJF5SBOTGPSNBÎÜFTEPSFDVSTPFYUSBPSEJOÈSJP*O"336%""-7*. 8".#*&35FSFTB/&3:+6/*03/FMTPO$PPSE Aspectos polêmicos e atuais dos recursos cíveis e assuntos afins7PMVNF4ÍP1BVMP35Q ("3$*".&%*/"+PTÏ.JHVFM8".#*&3-VJ[3PESJHVFT8".#*&35FSFTB"SSV EB"MWJN3FQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMFTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUF3FMFWBOUFTOPWJEBEFTUSB[JEBTQFMB &$ O *O@@@@@@@@@@@@@$PPSE Reforma do Judiciário: primeiros ensaios críticos sobre a EC n. 45/20044ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ (0&4(JTFMF4BOUPT'FSOBOEFT3FDMBNBÎÍP$POTUJUVDJPOBM*O%*%*&3+3'SFEJF 0SH Ações constitucionais. FEJÎÍP4BMWBEPS+VT1PEJVNQ (3*/07&3"EB1FMMFHSJOJ(0.&4'*-)0"OUPOJP.BHBMIÍFT'&3/"/%&4"O UPOJP4DBSBODFRecursos no processo penal: teoria geral dos recursos, recursos em espécie, ações de impugnação: revisão criminal, habeas corpus, mandado de segurança contra ato jurisdicional penal: reclamação aos tribunais. FEJÎÍP BUVBMJ[BEB DPN B SFGPSNB EP +VEJDJÈSJP&$O 4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT -&0/&-3JDBSEPEF#BSSPTReclamação Constitucional. 4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCV OBJT .&/%&4(JMNBS'FSSFJSB$0&-)0*OPDÐODJP.ÈSUJSFT$PFMIP#3"/$01BVMP (VTUBWPCurso de Direito ConstitucionalBFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB .&/%&4(JMNBS'FSSFJSB"SFDMBNBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOP45'*O.&*3&--&4)FMZ -PQFT 8"-% "SOPMEP .&/%&4 (JMNBS 'FSSFJSB Mandado de segurança e ações constitucionais. FEJÎÍPBUVBMJ[BEBEFBDPSEPDPNB-FJ ODPNBDP MBCPSBÎÍPEF3PESJHP(BSDJBEB'POTFDB4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ .03"50-FPOBSEP-Reclamação e a sua finalidade para impor o respeito à súmula vinculante. *O 8".#*&35FSFTB"SSVEB"MWJN$PPSE Reforma do Judiciário: primeiros ensaios críticos sobre a EC n. 45/20044ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ 1"$)&$0+PTÏEB4JMWB%B3FDMBNBÎÍP *O@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@O mandado de segurança e outras ações constitucionais típicas. FEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUB EPT5SJCVOBJTQ 4"/504"MFYBOESF.PSFJSB5BWBSFTEPT%B3FDMBNBÎÍP*ORevista dos Tribunais. 7PMVNFOÞNFSPQKBOFJSPGFWFSFJSP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 81 a 106 A ARBITRAGEM NOS CONFLITOS ENTRE POLÍTICAS PÚBLICAS The Arbitration in Conflicts between Public Policy Eridane Baptista Furlan1 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP 1PMÓUJDBT 1ÞCMJDBT 'VOÎÜFT FTUBUBJT JOEFQFOEFOUFT F IBSNÙOJDBT "UJWJTNP+VEJDJBMF+VEJDJBMJ[BÎÍPEB1PMÓUJDB1SFTTVQPTUPTEPFYFSDÓDJPQPMÓUJDPQFMP 1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP1SFTUBÎÍP+VSJTEJDJPOBMBEFRVBEB"BSCJUSBHFN"BSCJUSBHFN OP 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJP -FHJTMBÎÜFT DPN QSFWJTÍP EF BSCJUSBHFN " MFHJTMBÎÍP FTQFDÓmDB OB BSCJUSBHFN *OUFSFTTFT JOEJTQPOÓWFJT " BSCJUSBHFN QPS ØSHÍPT F FOUJEBEFT FTUBUBJT "HÐODJB SFHVMBEPSB $ÉNBSB EF DPODJMJBÎÍP F BSCJUSBHFN OB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 'FEFSBM $$"' " BSCJUSBHFN OP TFUPS QÞCMJDP QPSUVHVÐT $PODMVTÍP#JCMJPHSBmB RESUMO 0QSFTFOUFBSUJHPJOWFTUJHBSÈPQPUFODJBMEFVTPEBBSCJUSBHFNEJTDJQMJOBEBQFMB-FJ 'FEFSBMO¡EFEFTFUFNCSPEFOBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTFTUBCFMFDJEPT FOUSFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTBQBSUJSEFTVBBQMJDBÎÍPQPSBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBTTFUPSJBJTFEB FYQFSJÐODJBEB$ÉNBSBEF$PODJMJBÎÍPF"SCJUSBHFNEB"EWPDBDJB(FSBMEB6OJÍPDPN WJTUBTËNFMIPSFGFUJWJEBEFEFEJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBTGVOEBNFOUBJTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BEPT Ë PCUFOÎÍP EP ØUJNP EFTFNQFOIP EBT GVOÎÜFT FTUBUBJT Ë EFTPCTUSVÎÍP EP 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJPFËNJUJHBÎÍPEBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTTPDJBJT ABSTRACT 5IJTQBQFSJOWFTUJHBUFTUIFQPUFOUJBMVTFPGBSCJUSBUJPOSFHVMBUFECZ'FEFSBM-BXO¡ PG4FQUFNCFSJOSFTPMWJOHDPOnJDUTCFUXFFOFTUBCMJTIFEQVCMJDQPMJDZ GSPN JUT JNQMFNFOUBUJPO CZ SFHVMBUPSZ BHFODJFT BOE FYQFSJFODF PG UIF Câmara de Conciliação e Arbitragem da Advocacia Geral da UniãoXJUIBWJFXUPCFUUFSFGGFDUJWFOFTT PG GVOEBNFOUBM SJHIUT BOE HVBSBOUFFT PCUBJOJOH PQUJNBM QFSGPSNBODF PG TUBUF GVODUJPOTVOCMPDLUIF+VEJDJBSZBOENJUJHBUJPOPGTPDJBMJOFRVBMJUJFT Palavras-chavesQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBTFBSCJUSBHFN Keywords: QVCMJDQPMJDZSFHVMBUPSZBHFODJFTBOEBSCJUSBUJPO INTRODUÇÃO 0NPEFMPQPMÓUJDPFDPOÙNJDPBEPUBEPOBTÞMUJNBTEÏDBEBTNBOUFWFVNBSF QBSUJÎÍPEFTJHVBMEFSFOEBTDBVTBOEPEJmDVMEBEFTQBSBPBMDBODFEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP IVNBOPQPUFODJBM &TQFDJBMJ[BÎÍPFN%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM$JWJM&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP 1BVMP&41(&41&TQFDJBMJ[BÎÍPFN%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBM'BDVMEBEFEF4BÞEF1ÞCMJDBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP 1BVMPo'41641F'BDVMEBEFEF%JSFJUPEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP641.BTUFS#VTJOFTT"ENJOJT USBUJPOo*OGSBFTUSVUVSB'VOEBÎÍP(FUÞMJP7BSHBTo'(741 i0*%)EP#SBTJMQBSBÏ/PFOUBOUPRVBOEPÏEFTDPOUBEBBEFTJHVBMEBEFEPWBMPSP*%) 108 Eridane Baptista Furlan /FTTFDPOUFYUPPMFHJTMBEPSEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDB'FEFSBUJWBEP#SB TJM EF $' DPOTBHSPV P &TUBEP %FNPDSÈUJDP EF %JSFJUP TPC B QSFNJTTB EPT %JSFJUPT)VNBOPTBNQMJPVHBSBOUJBTDSJPVEJSFJUPTTPDJBJTFSFDPOIFDFVBFYJTUÐODJB EFJOUFSFTTFTDPMFUJWPTMBUPTFOTV 3 .BTBTPDJFEBEFCSBTJMFJSBBJOEBFTUÈMPOHFEFTFBQSFTFOUBSUPUBMNFOUFMJWSF KVTUBFTPMJEÈSJB&NHSBOEFQBSUFBEFTJHVBMEBEFTPDJBMFYQMJDBTFQFMBBVTÐODJBPV JOTVmDJÐODJBEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTFmDB[FTFFmDJFOUFTRVFFGFUJWFNPTEJSFJUPTFHB SBOUJBTGVOEBNFOUBJTTPDJBJTFDPMFUJWPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFQPTJUJWBEPT 5SBOTDPSSJEPTNBJTEFWJOUFBOPTEBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEB$BSUB.BHOBBTPDJF EBEF BHVBSEB B GPSNVMBÎÍP F B FYFDVÎÍP EF OPWBT QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT CFN DPNP B SFWJTÍPFBDPNQBUJCJMJ[BÎÍPEBTQPMÓUJDBTWJHFOUFTRVFEJTDJQMJOFNIBSNPOJDBNFOUF PTEJTUJOUPTFNÞMUJQMPTJOUFSFTTFTDPNÐOGBTFBPTNFOPTGBWPSFDJEPT 1. POLÍTICAS PÚBLICAS .BSJB1BVMB%BMMBSJ#VDDJFOTJOBOPTRVFPDPODFJUPEFQPMÓUJDBQÞCMJDBOÍP TFBQSFTFOUBVOÓTTPOPFOUSFPTEPVUSJOBEPSFTQÈUSJPTFTVBDPODFQÎÍPVTVBMBQPJBTF FRVJWPDBEBNFOUFOBJEFJBEFQMBOPHPWFSOBNFOUBMBJOEBRVFFMBTFNQSFUFOIBPSJ HFNOBMFJNFTNPRVBOEPEFJOJDJBUJWBEP&YFDVUJWPOPFYFSDÓDJPEFGVOÎÍPBUÓQJDB 0TGVOEBNFOUPTOPSNBUJWPTEBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTTÍPEJWFSTPT%JTQPTJÎÜFT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJT JOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT FNBOBEBT EPT EJGFSFOUFT OÓWFJT QPMÓUJDPBENJ OJTUSBUJWPT5BNCÏNQSPWÐNEFNFEJEBTQSPWJTØSJBTDPNGPSÎBEFMFJFEJUBEBTQFMP 1SFTJEFOUFEB3FQÞCMJDBFNDBTPTEFSFMFWÉODJBFVSHÐODJBNBTTFNQSFTVCNFUJEBT EFJNFEJBUPBPDSJWPEP$POHSFTTP/BDJPOBMEFDSFUPTQPSUBSJBTFBUÏJOTUSVNFOUPT KVSÓEJDPTTVCPSEJOBEPTBPSFHJNFEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPDPNPPDPOUSBUPEFDPODFTTÍP PCKFUJWBOEPBQSFTUBÎÍPEFTFSWJÎPTQÞCMJDPT 3 DBJQBSBVNBQFSEBEFEFWJEPËEFTJHVBMEBEFOBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPEPTÓOEJDFTEFEJNFOTÍP0 *%)"%RVFWFNDPNQMFNFOUBSBMFJUVSBGFJUBQFMP*%)NPTUSBRVFPDJEBEÍPCSBTJMFJSPNÏEJPUFSJB RVBTFEFSJTDPEFOÍPDPOTFHVJSBMDBOÎBSPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPIVNBOPQPUFODJBMRVFPQBÓTUFN QBSBMIFPGFSFDFSFNGVOÎÍPEPTPCTUÈDVMPTRVFBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTQPEFNMIFJNQPS/FTUBÈSFBP#SBTJM TFJOTFSFFNVNDPOUFYUPTFNFMIBOUFBPEB"NÏSJDB-BUJOBPOEFBEFTJHVBMEBEFoFNFTQFDJBMEF SFOEBoGB[QBSUFEFVNQBTTJWPIJTUØSJDPRVFBJOEBSFQSFTFOUBVNHSBOEFPCTUÈDVMPQBSBPEFTFOWPM WJNFOUP IVNBOPw IUUQQSFTTSPPNJQDVOEQPSHCSBTJMBWBODBOPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPIVNBOP FTPCFVNBQPTJDBPOPSBOLJOHEPJEI MBOHQUCS BDFTTBEP FN F IUUQXXX POVIBCJUBUPSHFM&TUBEPEF-BT$JVEBEFTEF"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCFBDFTTBEPFN IUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCSDDJWJM@DPOTUJUVJDBPDPOTUJUVJ$"BPIUN BDFTTBEP FN oQSFÉNCVMP #"6."/;JHNVOU-FHJTMBEPSFTF*OUÏSQSFUFTTPCSFNPEFSOJEBEFQØTNPEFSOJEBEFFJOUF MFDUVBJT;JHNVOU#BVNBOUSBEVÎÍP3FOBUP"HVJBSo3JPEF+BOFJSP;BIBS #6$$*.BSJB1BVMB%BMMBSJ"TQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTFPEJSFJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP3FWJTUBUSJNFTUSBMEFEJ SFJUPQÞCMJDP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.BMIFJSPTQ $POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFBSU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 109 "TQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTDPNPSFHSBSFTVMUBNEFDPNQMFYPTQSPDFTTPTQPMÓUJDP KVSÓEJDPBENJOJTUSBUJWPT &TTFT QSPDFTTPT EFWFN DPOEV[JS Ë FGFUJWBÎÍP EB WPOUBEF TPDJBMDPOIFDJEBDPNQSFFOEJEBDPOUFYUVBMNFOUFBQBSUJSEBSFVOJÍPEFUPEPTPTTB CFSFTEBEPTJOGPSNBÎÜFTFFYQSFTTÜFTTPDJBJTQMVSBJTQPJTDPOGPSNF.PSJOiO todo está na parte, que está no todowFTFNBDPOTJEFSBÎÍPEFTTBQSFNJTTBOÍPOPTQBSFDF WJÈWFMTPMVDJPOBSPVNJUJHBSBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTTPDJBJT &SPT(SBVEJTDPSSFOEPTPCSFPBVNFOUPEBRVBOUJEBEFFEPQPEFSEBDBQBDJ EBEFOPSNBUJWBEFDPOKVOUVSBSFTTBMUBRVFBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTQPEFNBEWJSEFBUPT FYQFEJEPTQPSBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBTTFUPSJBJTRVFBUVBNTPCPGVOEBNFOUPEBEFMF HBÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWBUSBOTGFSJOEPTFPFYFSDÓDJPEFQPEFSFTOPSNBUJWPTBP&YFDVUJWP "FTTFSFTQFJUP"MFYBOESF.B[[BBMFSUBOPTTPCSFBFYJTUÐODJBEFJODPOTUJUVDJP OBMJEBEFTOBTMFJTEFDSJBÎÍPEBTBHÐODJBTGFEFSBJTFSFHJTUSBBTVKFJÎÍPEFTTBTFOUJEBEFT BPTQSJODÓQJPTFOPSNBTEPSFHJNFKVSÓEJDPBENJOJTUSBUJWP"BHÐODJBOPEFTFOWPMWJ NFOUPEFTVBTBUSJCVJÎÜFTOPSNBUJWBTTVCPSEJOBTFBUPEPTPTMJNJUFTUFSSJUPSJBJTUFN QPSBJTQFTTPBJTFNBUFSJBJTBBPTDPOUSPMFTEP&YFDVUJWP-FHJTMBUJWPF+VEJDJÈSJP 2. FUNÇÕES ESTATAIS INDEPENDENTES E HARMÔNICAS 0FTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTBEFRVBEBTDPNQSFFOEFBFGFUJWBÎÍP EPQSJODÓQJPEBFmDJÐODJBJOUSPEV[JEPQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO¡EFEF KVOIPEFRVFBMUFSPVP"SUEB$' &OUSFUBOUPPFYFSDÓDJPEPQPEFSFTUBUBMBMÏNEFJOEFQFOEFOUFQSFDJTBUBNCÏN TFSIBSNÙOJDPQBSBSFnFUJSBDPNQMFUVEFEPFTQÓSJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPOTVCTUBODJBEPOP FMFNFOUPJOEFQFOEÐODJBFTUFDPNQSFFOEJEPFBQMJDBEPDPODPNJUBOUFNFOUFDPNPFMF NFOUPIBSNPOJBRVFFNTJNFTNPUSBEV[TFOPDPODFJUPEFPSEFNEBQFSGFJUBJOUFHSBÎÍP "TFHSFHBÎÍPEPFYFSDÓDJPEFDBEBGVOÎÍPFTUBUBMTFNIBSNPOJ[ÈMBTFOUSF TJJNQMJDBJOEFTFKÈWFMEJTUBODJBNFOUPEBTSFBMJEBEFTDPOTVCTUBODJBEBTOBTEJWFSTBT QPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTFHPWFSOBNFOUBJTFNDVSTPPVFNFMBCPSBÎÍP "JOEBTVQSJNFPTTBCFSFTUÏDOJDPTFFNQÓSJDPTEFTDPOTJEFSBBTEJGFSFOUFT SFBMJEBEFTTPDJBJTSBDJPOBMJEBEFTFBÎÜFTWJPMBOEPQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFTQF DJBMNFOUFPQSJODÓQJPEBSB[PBCJMJEBEFFEBFmDJÐODJB &TTBSBDJPOBMJEBEFUBNCÏNÏJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMËBEFRVBEBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJ DJPOBMDPOTJEFSBOEPTFRVFBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTTPDJBJTPSJHJOBNTFFNHSBOEFQBSUF EBBVTÐODJBPVJOTVmDJÐODJBEFEJWFSTBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTNVJUBTWF[FTFYFDVUBEBT .03*/ &EHBS o *OUSPEVÎÍP BP 1FOTBNFOUP $PNQMFYP&EHBS .PSJO 5SBEVÎÍP EF &MJBOF -JTCPB o 1PSUP"MFHSF4VMJOB&EJÎÍPoQ (3"6&SPT3PCFSUP1MBOFKBNFOUP&DPOÙNJDPF3FHSB+VSÓEJDB4ÍP1BVMPFEEPBVUPSQ .";;""MFYBOESFo"HÐODJBT3FHVMBEPSBT.BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT-UEB*4#/Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 110 Eridane Baptista Furlan EF GPSNB EFTBSUJDVMBEB F EFTJOUFHSBEB FMFWBOEP PT ÓOEJDFT EF KVEJDJBMJ[BÎÍP EPT NBJTWBSJBEPTDPOnJUPTJODMVTJWFFOUSFBTQSØQSJBTQPMÓUJDBTTFVTQMBOFKBNFOUPT QSPHSBNBTFBÎÜFT /POPTTPTFOUJSFTTBÏVNBEBTKVTUJmDBUJWBTQBSBBDSJBÎÍPEFBHÐODJBTSFHV MBEPSBTOBDPOEJÎÍPEFFOUJEBEFTFYFDVUJWBTJOEFQFOEFOUFTEPUBEBTEFBUSJCVJÎÜFT EFDJTØSJBTFOPSNBUJWBTQBSBFEJUBSOPSNBTEFEJNFOTÜFTUÏDOJDBFDPOÙNJDPmOBO DFJSB F TPDJBM FTUB ÞMUJNB FYFSDJEB JODMVTJWF OP DBNQP EP EFUBMIBNFOUP EF UJQPT JOGSBDJPOBJTQBSBTVQFSBSTJUVBÎÜFTEFCBJYBEFOTJEBEFOPSNBUJWB 3. ATIVISMO JUDICIAL E JUDICIALIZAÇÃO DA POLÍTICA 0BTTFOUBNFOUPEP&TUBEPQSPWJEÐODJBOBRVBMJEBEFEFBHFOUFSFHVMBNFO UBEPSRVFQSPUFHFFEFGFOEFBQPQVMBÎÍPFPBHFOUFEJTDJQMJOBEPSEBQPMÓUJDBFFDPOP NJBUFWFDPNPDPOTFRVÐODJBPBVNFOUPEPTDPOnJUPTTPDJBJTRVFJOFYPSBWFMNFOUF EFTFNCPDBNOP+VEJDJÈSJPFEFWFNTFSEFDJEJEBT 5BMTFEÈFNSB[ÍPEPQSJODÓQJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBJOBGBTUBCJMJEBEFEPBDFTTPË +VTUJÎBFEBPSEFNEFJNFEJBUBBQMJDBÎÍPEFHBSBOUJBTFEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTOPRVF UBOHFBPTEJSFJUPTQSFTUBDJPOBJTOPTUFSNPTEP"SU¡9997Ff¡$' "EJDJPOBMNFOUFB$BSUB.BHOBBJOEBSFDFQDJPOPVBMFJEBBÎÍPDJWJMQÞCMJDB FEBBÎÍPQPQVMBSJOUSPEV[JVPNBOEBEPEFJOKVOÎÍPFPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB DPMFUJWPSBUJmDPVBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM45' KVMHBSBÎÜFT EJSFUBTEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF"%*/ FJOTUJUVJVBSHVJÎÜFTEFEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEF QSFDFJUPGVOEBNFOUBM"%1' )PVWFBBNQMJBÎÍPEFTUFSPMDPNPBEWFOUPEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO BRVBMJOTUJUVJVBTÞNVMBWJODVMBOUFDPNPmNEFJNQSJNJSWBMJEBEFQBSB B JOUFSQSFUBÎÍP F FmDÈDJB BPT EJTQPTJUJWPT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJT UJEPT DPNP DPOUSPWFSTPT FOUSF ØSHÍPT KVEJDJÈSJPT F "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB JNQFEJOEP P FTUBCFMFDJNFOUP EF JOTFHVSBOÎBTKVSÓEJDBTFPBVNFOUPEBMJUJHJPTJEBEFTPCSFVNBNFTNBNBUÏSJB 0DPOUFYUPEBTPDJFEBEFBUVBMFYJHFRVFP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFNBMHVNBTTJ UVBÎÜFTBUVFBMÏNEPDPOUSPMFEBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTWJTBOEP BJNQFEJSFBDPOUFSBTWJPMBÎÜFTË-FJ.BJPSOPRVFUBOHFËFGFUJWBÎÍPJNFEJBUBEF EJSFJUPTQSFTUBDJPOBJT /FTTBMJOIBBKVSJTEJÎÍPQBTTBBBCSBOHFSUBNCÏNBBWBMJBÎÍPEPTBUPTEF HPWFSOPPVRVFTUÜFTQPMÓUJDBTËMV[EBTOPWBTmOBMJEBEFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFBUSJ CVÓEBT BP &TUBEP FN SB[ÍP EB QPTJUJWBÎÍP EF QSJODÓQJPT F EP SFDPOIFDJNFOUP EPT EJSFJUPTEFTFHVOEBFUFSDFJSBHFSBÎÍP. #0##*0/PSCFSUP"&SBEPT%JSFJUPTUSBEVÎÍP$BSMPT/FMTPO$PVUJOIPo3JPEF+BOFJSP$BNQVT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 111 "FGFUJWJEBEFEBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMFYJHFNVJUBTWF[FTEPKVMHBEPSBDSJB ÎÍPEFDBNJOIPTFTPMVÎÜFTQBSBBMFJRVFBQSFTFOUFMBDVOBTJOEFUFSNJOBÎÜFTHFOFSB MJ[BÎÜFTBCTUSBÎÜFTFDPODFJUPTWBHPT4VQFSBSUBJTDJSDVOTUÉODJBTDPOWFSHFQBSBPFYFS DÓDJPEPFMFNFOUPAWPOUBEFEJTDSJDJPOÈSJBFEFOPUBVNWJÏTQPMÓUJDPBENJOJTUSBUJWP /PFOUBOUPTVCTJTUFNBDJSSBEBTEJTDVTTÜFTTPCSFFTTBOPWBGPSNBEFBUVBÎÍPEP 1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPGVOEBNFOUBEBTEFVNMBEPOBFYJTUÐODJBEFWJPMBÎÍPBPQSJODÓQJPEB TFQBSBÎÍPEPTQPEFSFTDVMNJOBOEPOPEFOPNJOBEPBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBMFEFPVUSPOPQSØ QSJPNPEFMPEFDPOUSPMFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMWJHFOUFQFSNJUJOEPBKVEJDJBMJ[BÎÍPEBQPMÓUJDB 1BSB&MJWBMEB4JMWB3BNPTPBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBMDPOTJTUFOBFYBDFSCBÎÍPEP DPOUFÞEPEFUFYUPTOPSNBUJWPTNFEJBOUFPFYFSDÓDJPEFBUJWJEBEFMFHJTMBUJWBQFMP+V EJDJÈSJP TJUVBÎÍP EJWFSTB EB JOUFQSFUBÎÍP DSJBUJWB FN RVF P KVMHBEPS BUVB DPOTJEF SBOEPQBSÉNFUSPTOPSNBUJWPT$JUBDPNPFYFNQMPBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEBmEFMJEBEF QBSUJEÈSJBEFNBSDBÎÍPEFUFSSBTJOEÓHFOBTEJSFJUPEFHSFWFEPTFSWJEPSFOFQPUJTNP QFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMBTTFWFSBOEP /ÍPTFQPEFOBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEFUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDIFHBSBVNQPOUP FNRVFTFSFFTDSFWBPTFVDPOUFÞEP0UFYUPÏVNMJNJUBEPSPCKFUJWP FMFFYJTUF &YJTUFVNFRVJMÓCSJPFOUSFBOPSNBFJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPRVFÏ SPNQJEPQFMPBUJWJTNP %FGBUPBJOÏSDJBEP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWPTVTDJUBFTTFBUJWJTNPKVEJDJBMDPOTPBOUF BQPOUBEPQPS-VÓT3PCFSUP#BSSPTPFNQBMFTUSBQSPGFSJEBEVSBOUFPTFNJOÈSJP%JSFJUPF %FTFOWPMWJNFOUPFOUSFP#SBTJMF&6"SFBMJ[BEPOP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBnVNJOFOTFQFMB 'VOEBÎÍP(FUÞMJP7BSHBTTBMJFOUPVPTCFOFGÓDJPTFSJTDPTEBKVEJDJBMJ[BÎÍPEBQPMÓUJDB /ÍPÏQPSBDBTPRVFPBUJWJTNPTFFYQBOEJV ²QSFDJTPVNBSFGPSNB QPMÓUJDB VSHFOUF QPJT OÍP IÈ EFNPDSBDJB TFN VN 1PEFS -FHJTMBUJWP BUVBOUF "UÏBRVJPBUJWJTNPUFNTFSWJEPCFN.BTÏQSFDJTPUFSB DPNQSFFOTÍPEPGFOÙNFOP "KVEJDJBMJ[BÎÍPÏVNGBUPFOÍPVNB WPOUBEFQPMÓUJDBEP+VEJDJÈSJPÏDJSDVOTUÉODJBEPNPEFMPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVFOØTUFNPT 0KVJ[EFOUSPEPDPOUFYUPEFKVEJDJBMJ[BÎÍPOVODB BHFRVFOÍPTFKBFNOPNFEFVNBWPOUBEFQPMÓUJDBQSFFYJTUFOUFRVF OÍPÏBEFMFÏBRVFFTUÈOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPPVOBMFJ. 0QBMFTUSBOUFFYFNQMJmDBPGFOÙNFOPDPNBSFGPSNBEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPF EB1SFWJEÐODJBPTMJNJUFTOBBUVBÎÍPEB$PNJTTÍP1BSMBNFOUBSEF*ORVÏSJUP$1* P 3".04&MJWBMEB4JMWB"UJWJTNP+VEJDJBM1BSÉNFUSPT%PHNÈUJDPT4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB 3".04&MJWBMEB4JMWBIUUQDPNCSBHPFOUSFWJTUBBDFTTBEPFN IUUQXXXDPOKVSDPNCSNBJKVEJDJBMJ[BDBPGBUPBUJWJTNPBUJUVEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJTUBBDFTTB EPFNEFKVMIPEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 112 Eridane Baptista Furlan QPEFSJOWFTUJHBUØSJPEP.JOJTUÏSJP1ÞCMJDPBWBMJBEPTKVEJDJBMNFOUFNBTBMFSUBRVBOUP ËTQPTTJCMJEBEFTEFFYDFTTP 1BSB$BOFMB+ÞOJPSPBUFOEJNFOUPËmOBMJEBEFQÞCMJDBKVTUJmDBFTTBGPSNBEF JOUFSWFOÎÍPQFMP+VEJDJÈSJP $PNP UPEB BUJWJEBEF QPMÓUJDB QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT FYFSDJEB QFMP -FHJTMBUJWPFQFMP&YFDVUJWPEFWFDPNQBUJCJMJ[BSTFDPNB$POTUJUVJÎÍP DBCF BP 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJP BOBMJTBS FN RVBMRVFS TJUVBÎÍP F EFTEF RVF QSPWPDBEP P RVF TF DPOWFODJPOPV DIBNBS EF ABUPT EF HPWFSOP PV ARVFTUÜFT QPMÓUJDBT TPC P QSJTNB EP BUFOEJNFOUP BPT mOT EP &TUBEP "SUEB$' "TTJNTPCBØUJDBEPFYFSDÓDJPJOEFQFOEFOUFFIBSNÙOJDPSFMBUJWBNFOUFËT EFNBJTGVOÎÜFTFTUBUBJTBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMFTUBSJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFWJODV MBEBBPFYFSDÓDJPQPMÓUJDPOPTDBTPTEFPNJTTÍPHPWFSOBNFOUBMPVMFHJTMBUJWBEFWFOEP EFUFSNJOBSBDPNQMFNFOUBÎÍPPVJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTQFOEFOUFT &TTFUBNCÏNÏPFOUFOEJNFOUPEP.JOJTUSP$FMTPEF.FMMPFNWPUPQBSDJBM NFOUFSFQSPEV[JEP ² DFSUP RVF OÍP TF JODMVJ PSEJOBSJBNFOUF OP ÉNCJUP EBT GVOÎÜFT JOTUJUVDJPOBJTEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFOBTEFTUB4VQSFNB$PSUFFNFTQFDJBM o B BUSJCVJÎÍP EF GPSNVMBS F JNQMFNFOUBS QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT +PTÏ $BSMPT 7JFJSBEF"OESBEF0TEJSFJUPT'VOEBNFOUBJTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPQPSUVHVFTBEF QJUFNO"MNFEJOB$PJNCSB QPJTOFTTFEPNÓOJP PFODBSHPSFTJEFQSJNBSJBNFOUFOPT1PEFSFT-FHJTMBUJWPF&YFDVUJWP5BM JODVNCÐODJBOPFOUBOUPFNCPSBFNCBTFTFYDFQDJPOBJTQPEFSÈBUSJCVJS TF BP 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJP TF F RVBOEP PT ØSHÍPT FTUBUBJT DPNQFUFOUFT QPS EFTDVNQSJSFNPTFODBSHPTQPMÓUJDPKVSÓEJDPTRVFTPCSFFMFTJODJEFNWJFSFN BDPNQSPNFUFSDPNUBMDPNQPSUBNFOUPBFmDÈDJBFBJOUFHSJEBEFEFEJSFJUPT JOEJWJEVBJTFPVDPMFUJWPTJNQSFHOBEPTEFFTUBUVSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBJOEBRVF EFSJWBEPTEFDMÈVTVMBTSFWFTUJEBTEFDPOUFÞEPQSPHSBNÈUJDP$BCFBTTJOBMBS QSFTFOUFFTTFDPOUFYUPoDPOTPBOUFKÈQSPDMBNPVFTUB4VQSFNB$PSUFoRVFP DBSÈUFSQSPHSBNÈUJDPEBTSFHSBTJOTDSJUBTOPUFYUPEB$BSUB1PMÓUJDBOÍPQPEF DPOWFSUFSTFFNQSPNFTTBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJODPOTFRVFOUFTPCQFOBEFPQPEFS QÞCMJDPGSBVEBOEPKVTUBTFYQFDUBUJWBTOFMFEFQPTJUBEBTQFMBDPMFUJWJEBEF TVCTUJUVJSEFNBOFJSBJMFHÓUJNBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFVJNQPTUFSHÈWFMEFWFS $"/&-"+6/*030TXBMEPo"FGFUJWBÎÍPEPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTBUSBWÏTEPQSPDFTTPDPMFUJWPVN OPWPNPEFMPEFKVSJTEJÎÍPUSBCBMIPEFRVBMJmDBÎÍPEFEPVUPSBEPBQSFTFOUBEPË641TPCPSJFOUBÎÍP EF,B[VP8BUBOBCF JOÏEJUP11 RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 113 QPSVNHFTUPJSSFTQPOTÈWFMEFJOmEFMJEBEFHPWFSOBNFOUBMBPRVFEFUFSNJOB BQSØQSJBMFJEP&TUBEP /PFOUBOUPOPOPTTPTFOUJSBBUVBÎÍPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPTFNQSFUFSÈBMFJ DPNPGVOEBNFOUPDBSBDUFSJ[BOEPBDJUBEBinterpretação criativa EFDPSSFOUFEB KVEJ DJBMJ[BÎÍPEBQPMÓUJDBQFSNJUJEBFNOPTTP%JSFJUPBPRVFDPNQBSUJMIBNPTPUFPSEP WPUPQSPGFSJEPFNTFEFEFSFDVSTPFTQFDJBMQFMP.JOJTUSP-VJ['VY BBQMJDBÎÍPEBMFJRVBMRVFSRVFTFKBPSBNPEBDJÐODJBPOEFTFEFWB PQFSBSBDPODSFÎÍPKVSÓEJDBEFWFQFSQBTTBSQPSFTTFUFDJEPOPSNBUJWP RVFTVTDJUBBSFnFYÍPBYJPMØHJDBEPSFTVMUBEPKVEJDJBM 4. PRESSUPOSTOS DO EXERCÍCIO POLÍTICO PELO JUDICIÁRIO "MÏNEPGVOEBNFOUPOPSNBUJWPDPODSFUJ[BEPEFGPSNBJOEFQFOEFOUFFIBSNÙOJDB SFMBUJWBNFOUFËTEFNBJTGVOÎÜFTFTUBUBJTIÈRVFTFQPOEFSBSUBNCÏNTPCSFPVUSBTDPOEJÎÜFT JOEJTQFOTÈWFJTËQFSUJOÐODJBEBJOUFSWFOÎÍPQPMÓUJDBOPÉNCJUPEBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBM %FBDPSEPDPN3JDBSEP-PCP5PSSFT"A dignidade humana e as condições materiais de existência não podem retroceder aquém de um mínimo, do qual nem os prisioneiros, os doentes mentais e os indigentes podem ser privados." 1BSB"OB1BVMBEF#BSDFMMPTPNÓOJNPFYJTUFODJBMÏQBSUFEPQSJODÓQJPEB EJHOJEBEFIVNBOBDPNHBSBOUJBEFFmDÈDJBKVSÓEJDBBTFSFYJHJEBKVEJDJBMNFOUF /PFOUBOUPBBWBMJBÎÍPEPNÓOJNPFYJTUFODJBMDPNPmUPEFDPSSJHJSPVJN QMFNFOUBSVNBQPMÓUJDBQÞCMJDBBOUFBQSFTFOÎBEFPVUSBQPMÓUJDBQÞCMJDBJHVBMNFOUF SFMFWBOUFBUSFMBTFBPDPUFKPDPNPQSJODÓQJPEBSB[PBCJMJEBEFNFOTVSBEPQFMPQSJO DÓQJPEBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEFDPOTPBOUFMJÎÍPEF&VSJDP'FSSBSFTJ RVBOEP TF EJTDVUF BUJWJEBEF EJTDSJDJPOÈSJB EJTDVUFNTF PQÎÜFT RVF EFWFN TFS UPNBEBT QFMP BHFOUF QÞCMJDP EF GPSNB FRVJMJCSBEB F IBSNPOJPTB FWJEFOUFNFOUF P KVJ[ OÍP BQFOBT QPEF DPNP EFWF WFSJmDBSTFBFTDPMIBGFJUBQFMP"ENJOJTUSBEPS1ÞCMJDPSFTQFJUPVPTEJUBNFT MFHBJT0RVFOÍPQPEFPDPSSFSÏBBMUFSBÎÍPEBFTDPMIBGFJUBQFMPBHFOUF QÞCMJDPRVBOEPFMBOÍPTFBmHVSFJOBQSPQSJBEB/PNPNFOUPFNRVFP 35+ 3&TQ3/3FM.JO-VJ['VY1SJNFJSB5VSNBKVMHBEPFN%+F 5033&43JDBSEP-PCP0NÓOJNPFYJTUFODJBMFPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJT3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUPEB1SPDV SBEPSJB(FSBM3JPEF+BOFJSPOKVMTFUQ #"3$&--04"OB1BVMBEF"FmDÈDJBKVSÓEJDBEPTQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTPQSJODÓQJPEBEJHOJEBEF IVNBOB3JPEFKBOFJSP3FOPWBSQF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 114 Eridane Baptista Furlan PSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPQFSNJUFBPBHFOUFQÞCMJDPBUVBSDPNEFUFSNJOBEP DBNQP EF JOEFQFOEÐODJB QFSNJUFTF EJTDSJDJPOBSJBNFOUF B SFWJTÍP KVEJDJBMBQFOBTOPTDBTPTFNRVFBFTDPMIBGFJUBTFKBEFTBSSB[PBEB "EJTQPOJCJMJEBEFmOBODFJSBQÞCMJDBUBNCÏNOÍPQPEFTFSEFTQSF[BEBOBJN QMFNFOUBÎÍPEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTTPDJBJTQFMP+VEJDJÈSJPDPOTPBOUFTFFYUSBJEBEFDJTÍP QSPGFSJEBOP"HSBWP3FHJNFOUBMOP3FDVSTP&YUSBPSEJOÈSJPO¡41EB5VS NBEP45'DPNSFMBUPSJBEP.JOJTUSP$FMTPEF.FMMPFQVCMJDBÎÍPOP%+6FN &NCPSB SFTJEB QSJNBSJBNFOUF OPT 1PEFSFT -FHJTMBUJWP F &YFDVUJWP B QSFSSPHBUJWB EF GPSNVMBS F FYFDVUBS QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT SFWFMBTF QPTTÓWFM OP FOUBOUP BP 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJP EFUFSNJOBS BJOEB RVF FN CBTFT FYDFQDJPOBJT FTQFDJBMNFOUF OBT IJQØUFTFT EF QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT EFmOJEBT QFMB QSØQSJB $POTUJUVJÎÍP TFKBN FTUBT JNQMFNFOUBEBT QFMPT ØSHÍPT FTUBUBJT JOBEJNQMFOUFT DVKB PNJTTÍP o QPS JNQPSUBS FN EFTDVNQSJNFOUP EPT FODBSHPT QPMÓUJDPTKVSÓEJDPT RVF TPCSF FMFT JODJEFN FN DBSÈUFS NBOEBUØSJP o NPTUSBTF BQUB B DPNQSPNFUFS B FmDÈDJBFBJOUFHSJEBEFEFEJSFJUPTTPDJBJTFDVMUVSBJTJNQSFHOBEPTEF FTUBUVSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM"RVFTUÍPQFSUJOFOUFËSFTFSWBEPQPTTÓWFM "EB1FMMFHSJOJ(SJOPWFSEFMJOFJBSFMFWBOUFTQSFTTVQPTUPTFMJNJUFTQBSBBJO UFSWFOÎÍP KVSJTEJDJPOBM OP DPOUSPMF EF QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT DJOHJOEPPT BP NÓOJNP FYJTUFODJBMRVFSFEVOEBFNQSFTUBÎÜFTFTUBUBJTQPTJUJWBTQBSBBTTFHVSBSBEJHOJEBEF IVNBOBBSB[PBCJMJEBEFEBQSFUFOTÍPJOEJWJEVBMTPDJBMEFEV[JEBFNGBDFEP1PEFS 1ÞCMJDPoBFYJTUÐODJBEFEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFmOBODFJSBFTUBUBMDPNQSPWBEBQPJTTFJO WFSUFPÙOVTQSPCBUØSJPFNEFTGBWPSEP&TUBEP. 5. PRESTAÇÃO JURISDICIONAL ADEQUADA "BNQMJBÎÍPEPTEJSFJUPTFDPOTFRVFOUFNFOUFEBTUFNÈUJDBTDPOnJUVPTBTBHSF HBEBËDVMUVSBEPTSFDVSTPTFMJUJHJPTJEBEFFWJEFODJBSBNBOFDFTTJEBEFEFVNSFBQB SFMIBNFOUPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPDSJBOEPNFJPTEFTVQPSUBSPBVNFOUPFYQSFTTJWPEB EFNBOEBQFMBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMFFGFUJWBSBTVBSFBMJ[BÎÍPFNUFNQPSB[PÈWFM '&33"3&4*&VSJDP.PEFMPTQSPDFTTVBJTDPMFUJWPTDPNQBSBÎÍPFOUSFBÎÍPQPQVMBSBÎÍPDJWJMQÞCMJDB FNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPMFUJWP*4#/ &EJUPSB'03*o IUUQSFEJSTUGKVTCSQBHJOBEPSQVCQBHJOBEPSKTQ EPD51"$EPD*%BDFTTBEPFNBHPTUP (3*/07&3"EB1FMMFHSJOJ0DPOUSPMFEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTQFMP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP3FWJTUBEF1SPDFT TP4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTWQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 115 .BTPØUJNPEFTFNQFOIPEP+VEJDJÈSJPOÍPEFQFOEFTPNFOUFEPFYFSDÓDJP JOEFQFOEFOUFFIBSNÙOJDPEPQSJODÓQJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBTFQBSBÎÍPEPTQPEFSFT %FQFOEFUBNCÏNEPTFVSFBQBSFMIBNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPEPBVNFOUPEBT BUJWJEBEFTMFHJTMBUJWBTEBSFWJTÍPEPTJTUFNBKVSÓEJDPQBSBRVFFTUFGPNFOUFEJTDVT TÜFTTPDJBJTFQMVSBJTEFTFOWPMWJEBTOVNBNCJFOUFEFDPOUSBEJUØSJPFRVFDPNQPSUF P BMBSHBNFOUP EP MFRVF UFNÈUJDP EF DPOnJUPT JOEJWJEVBJT F DPMFUJWPT BCSBOHFOEP JODMVTJWFBRVFMFTFTUBCFMFDJEPTFOUSFBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTFNDVSTP "MÏNEJTTPBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMEFWFQSPDVSBSSFnFUJSPBOTFJPEBTP DJFEBEFFNHFSBMFPSFTVMUBEPFYUSBÓEPEFTVBTNBOJGFTUBÎÜFTBDFSDBEFVNBEBEB NBUÏSJB DPNP TF PCTFSWPV OB BVEJÐODJB QÞCMJDB SFBMJ[BEB QFMP 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM TPCSF B $POTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF EF 1PMÓUJDBT EF "ÎÍP "mSNBUJWB EF "DFTTP BP &OTJOP4VQFSJPSFNTFEFEF"ÎÍPEF%FTDVNQSJNFOUPEF1SFDFJUP'VOEBNFOUBM F3FDVSTP&YUSBPSEJOÈSJP34 "GBMUBEFJOWFTUJNFOUPTTVmDJFOUFTEFSFDVSTPTNBUFSJBJTUFDOPMØHJDPTFIV NBOPTBMÏNEFMFJTFQSB[PTBEFRVBEPTBMJBEPTËOFDFTTJEBEFEFNVEBOÎBTQBSBEJH NÈUJDBTOBBUVBÎÍPEPTPQFSBEPSFTEP%JSFJUPUPSOBBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMNPSPTB "FTTFSFTQFJUP(BKBSEPOJBTTFWFSBRVFPUFNQPJEFBMQBSBBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEB QSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMSFTVMUBEBTPNBEPTQSB[PTQSPDFTTVBJTEJTQPTUPTOP$ØEJHP EF1SPDFTTP$JWJMQBSBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFUPEPTPTBUPTQSPDFEJNFOUBJTFEPUFNQP EFUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP. /FTTFDFOÈSJPUPSOBTFBUSBUJWPCVTDBSNFJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFSFTPMVÎÍPEF DPOnJUPTJODMVTJWFOPÉNCJUPEPTFUPSQÞCMJDP&OUSFBTBMUFSOBUJWBTQPTJUJWBEBT OPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPQÈUSJPJOUFSFTTBOPTBWBMJBSPQPUFODJBMVTPEBBSCJUSBHFN QFMPTFUPSQÞCMJDP 6. A ARBITRAGEM 0JOTUJUVUPEBBSCJUSBHFNFSBDPOIFDJEPKÈOB"OUJHVJEBEFFDIFHPVBPT OPTTPTEJBTDPNPVNNFJPEFSFTPMVÎÍPFYUSBKVEJDJBMEFDPOnJUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMNFOUF SFDPOIFDJEBNFEJBOUFBBEFTÍPBPTUSBUBEPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTRVFSFHVMBNBNBUÏSJBEF EJWFSTPTQBÓTFTJODMVTJWFP#SBTJM " $' EF OP "SU ¡ f ¡ DPOTBHSPV RVF ios direitos e garantias expressos nesta Constituição não excluem outros decorrentes do regime e dos princípios IUUQXXXTUGKVTCSQPSUBMDNTWFS5FYUPBTQ TFSWJDPQSPDFTTP"VEJFODJB1VCMJDB"DBP"GJSNBUJWB BDFTTPFNKVMIP ("+"3%0/*''5ÏDOJDBTEFBDFMFSBÎÍPEPQSPDFTTP4ÍP1BVMP-FNPT$SV[ 4;-"3084,:-FPO'SFEKB6NBOPWBWJTÍPEBBSCJUSBHFN/#3"#/5+VT/BWJHBOEJ 5FSFTJOBBOPOKVM%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSFWJTUBUFYUP"DFTTP FNKVMIP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 116 Eridane Baptista Furlan por ela adotados, ou dos tratados internacionais em que a República Federativa do Brasil seja partew "TTJNP#SBTJMQBSUJDJQBEP1SPUPDPMPEF(FOFCSBSFMBUJWPËTDMÈVTVMBTEF BSCJUSBHFN P 1SPUPDPMP EF -BT -F×BT EF DPPQFSBÎÍP F BTTJTUÐODJB KVSJTEJDJPOBM FN NBUÏSJBDJWJMDPNFSDJBMUSBCBMIJTUBFBENJOJTUSBUJWBP1SPUPDPMPEF#SBTÓMJBTPCSFTP MVÎÜFTEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTF1SPUPDPMPEF0VSP1SFUPBEJDJPOBMBP5SBUBEPEF"TTVOÎÍP TPCSF&TUSVUVSB*OTUJUVDJPOBMEP.FSDPTVMP1SPUPDPMPEF0MJWPTQBSB4PMVÎÜFTEF $POUSPWÏSTJBTEP.FSDPTVMF"DPSEPTPCSFB"SCJUSBHFN$PNFSDJBM*OUFSOBDJPOBMEP .FSDPTVM$POWFOÎÍPEF#VFOPT"JSFTTPCSFBSCJUSBHFNDPNFSDJBMEP.FSDPTVMF-FJ .PEFMP6ODJUSBMTPCSFBSCJUSBHFNDPNFSDJBMJOUFSOBDJPOBM &NSBUJmDPVBBEFTÍPË$POWFOÎÍPEF/PWB:PSLRVFSFHVMBPSFDP OIFDJNFOUPFFYFDVÎÍPEFTFOUFOÎBTBSCJUSBJTFTUSBOHFJSBTEB$POWFOÎÍPEP1BOBNÈ TPCSFBSCJUSBHFNDPNFSDJBMEB$POWFOÎÍPEF.POUFWJEÏVTPCSFBFmDÈDJBFYUSBUFSSJ UPSJBMEBTTFOUFOÎBTMBVEPTBSCJUSBJTFTUSBOHFJSPT "$'BJOEBOP"SUDPOGFSFDPNQFUÐODJBMFHJTMBUJWBË6OJÍP&TUBEPT FBP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMQBSBBDSJBÎÍPEFKVJ[BEPTFTQFDJBJT&TUFTTÍPQSPWJEPTQPSKVÓ [FTUPHBEPTFMFJHPTWJTBOEPËDPODJMJBÎÍPKVMHBNFOUPFFYFDVÎÍPEFDBVTBTDÓWFJTEF NFOPSDPNQMFYJEBEFFËTJOGSBÎÜFTQFOBJTEFNFOPSQPUFODJBMPGFOTJWP5SBUBTFEF QSPDFTTPPSBMTVNBSÓTTJNPFNRVFTFGBDVMUBBUSBOTBÎÍPFPKVMHBNFOUPEFSFDVSTPT QPSUVSNBTEFKVÓ[FTEFQSJNFJSPHSBV *HVBMNFOUFOPQBSÈHSBGPQSJNFJSPEP"SUBENJUFBFMFJÎÍPEFÈSCJUSPT QBSBTPMVDJPOBSOFHPDJBÎÍPUSBCBMIJTUBDPMFUJWBRVFSFTVMUFGSVTUSBEBCFNDPNPOPT MJUÓHJPTDPNPSJHFNFNDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBTEB+VTUJÎBEP5SBCBMIP 6.1. A Arbitragem no Poder Judiciário /P1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPTÍPSFDPSSFOUFTBTEFNBOEBTWJTBOEPBPFYBNFEFMFHB MJEBEFFJODJEÐODJBEBBSCJUSBHFN /FTTBUPBEBTPCSFTTBJPFNCMFNÈUJDP$BTP-BHF " 6OJÍP FEJUPV %FDSFUPMFJ O¡ EF EF TFUFNCSP EF JODPS QPSBOEPBPQBUSJNÙOJPOBDJPOBMCFOTFEJSFJUPTEBT0SHBOJ[BÎÜFT-BHF&NEF TFUFNCSPEFP%FDSFUPMFJO¡EFUFSNJOPVBMJRVJEBÎÍPEBTFNQSFTBTRVF JOUFHSBWBNBTPSHBOJ[BÎÜFTFBJODPSQPSBÎÍPSFTUSJUBBPTCFOTEFOBWFHBÎÍPFTUBMFJSPT $G$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFIUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCSDDJWJMDPOTUJUVJDBPDPOTUJUVJ$"BPIUN 045'DPOTJEFSPVWÈMJEBBBSCJUSBHFNTPMVDJPOBEPSBEFQFOEÐODJBEFWBMPSEFDPSSFOUFEFEFTBQSPQSJB ÎÍPEFCFOTDPNBT0SHBOJ[BÎÜFT-BHFGPSNBEBQPSFNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTFB6OJÍPQBSBBUVBSOPTFUPS EFOBWFHBÎÍPFTUBMFJSPTFQPSUPT45'"HSBWPEF*OTUSVNFOUPO¡(#3FM.JO#JMBD1JOUPEF 35+ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 117 F QPSUPT DPN B SFTUJUVJÎÍP EP SFTUBOUF NFEJBOUF BSCJUSBHFN DPNP JOTUÉODJB ÞOJDB DPOTPBOUFEJTQPTUPOP%FDSFUPO¡EFEFKVMIPEF 5BMNFEJEBSFTVMUPVOVNMBVEPVOÉOJNFCBMJ[BOEPBBCFSUVSBEFDSÏEJUPFT QFDJBMQBSBBEJNQMFNFOUPDPNQPTUFSJPSQMFJUPBP4FOBEPWJTBOEPËTVQMFNFOUBÎÍP RVFQPSTVBWF[SFTVMUPVEFGFSJEP5PEBWJBP1SPDVSBEPS(FSBMEB'B[FOEB/BDJPOBM JNQVUPVQPSJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMBTVCNJTTÍPEBNBUÏSJBJOEFOJ[BUØSJBBPKVÓ[PBSCJUSBM 1PTUFSJPSNFOUF OP "HSBWP EF *OTUSVNFOUP O¡ o (VBOBCBSB EF SF MBUPSJBEP.JOJTUSP#JMBD1JOUPKVMHBEPFNEFPVUVCSPEFFYBNJOPVTFB BCSBOHÐODJBEBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFFTUBUBMQPSEBOPTFBWBMPSBÎÍPEFBUJWPTEFFNQSF TBTOBDJPOBMJ[BEBTmSNBOEPTFBBSCJUSBHFNDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPMFHÓUJNPEFmYBÎÍPEF KVTUPWBMPSJOEFOJ[BUØSJPFNGBWPSEPFTQØMJPEF)FOSJRVFFEF3FOBVE-BHFFNGBDF EB6OJÍP&NPVUSBPQPSUVOJEBEFP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM45' KVMHPVJODJ EFOUFEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFPSJVOEPEFQFEJEPIPNPMPHBUØSJPQBSBVNBTFOUFOÎB FTQBOIPMBEFDJEJOEPTFQFMBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBMFJEFBSCJUSBHFNFNQSPDFTTP EFTFOUFOÎBFTUSBOHFJSBDPOUFTUBEBo4&$O¡RVFTFUPSOPVVNleading case. /FTTFFQJTØEJPP45'KVMHPVJOFYJTUFOUFRVBMRVFSWJPMBÎÍPFNGBDFEPQSJO DÓQJPEBJOBGBTUBCJMJEBEFEPBDFTTPEPDJEBEÍPBP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPDPOGPSNFQPEF FYUSBJSTFEBUSBOTDSJÎÍPEFUSFDIPEPWPUPGBWPSÈWFMQSPGFSJEPQFMP.JOJTUSP$BSMPT 7FMMPTP“O inciso XXXV representa um direito à ação não um dever.” "JOEB BOBMJTBOEP PVUSB TJUVBÎÍP P 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM o 5SJCVOBM 1MFOPoFNTFEFEFTFOUFOÎBFTUSBOHFJSBDPOUFTUBEB4&$O¡PSJVOEBEP3FJ OP 6OJEP EB (SÍ #SFUBOIB F EB *SMBOEB EP /PSUF "DØSEÍP EF %+ EF &NFOUÈSJPO¡BTTJNKVMHPV " DPOWFOÎÍP EF BSCJUSBHFN Ï B GPOUF PSEJOÈSJB EP EJSFJUP QSPDFTTVBM BSCJUSBMFTQÏDJFEFTUJOBEBËTPMVÎÍPQSJWBEBEPTDPOnJUPTEFJOUFSFTTFT F RVF UFN QPS GVOEBNFOUP NBJPS BVUPOPNJB EB WPOUBEF EBT QBSUFT &TUBT FTQPOUBOFBNFOUF PQUBN FN TVCNFUFS PT MJUÓHJPT FYJTUFOUFT PV RVF WFOIBN B TVSHJS OBT SFMBÎÜFT OFHPDJBJT Ë EFDJTÍP EF VN ÈSCJUSP EJTQPOEPEBKVSJTEJÎÍPFTUBUBMDPNVN /FTTB NFTNB MJOIB TFHVF B KVSJTQSVEÐODJB EP 4VQFSJPS 5SJCVOBM EF +VTUJÎB 45+ RVFWFNIPNPMPHBOEPEFDJTÜFTFTUSBOHFJSBTFJNQFEJOEPSFDVSTPTJNQFSUJOFOUFT 35+ IUUQXXXDPOKVSDPNCSEF[TUG@EFDMBSB@MFJ@BSCJUSBHFN@DPOTUJUVDJPOBM "DFTTBEP FN EFKVMIPEF IUUQXXXTUGKVTCSQPSUBMQSPDFTTPWFS1SPDFTTP"OEBNFOUPBTQ JODJEFOUF "DFTTBEP FN EFKVMIPEF IUUQXXXTUGKVTCSQPSUBMQSPDFTTPWFS1SPDFTTP"OEBNFOUPBTQ JODJEFOUF "DFTTBEP FN EFKVMIPEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 118 Eridane Baptista Furlan DPOUSBBTEFDJTÜFTBSCJUSBJTCFNDPNPSFBmSNBOEPBBQMJDBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPOBTPMVÎÍP EFMJUÓHJPTFNNBUÏSJBBENJOJTUSBUJWB $PNP FYFNQMP DJUBNPT P QSPWJNFOUP QBSDJBM QSPGFSJEP QFMB 5VSNB OP3FDVSTP&TQFDJBMO¡34RVFBQSFDJPVDPOUSBUPEFDPNQSBFWFOEBEF FOFSHJBFMÏUSJDBFOUSFTPDJFEBEFEFFDPOPNJBNJTUBFTUBEVBMFFNQSFTBQSJWBEBFP 3FDVSTP&TQFDJBMO¡34RVFDPODMVJVQFMBFmDÈDJBEBDMÈVTVMBDPNQSP NJTTØSJBQBDUVBEB "JOEBPBSFTUPEB4FÎÍPQSPGFSJEPOP"HSBWP3FHJNFOUBMOP.BOEBEP EF4FHVSBOÎBO¡%'FNRVFP45+BDPMIFVPJOTUJUVUPEBBSCJUSBHFNWJTBOEP ËDPOUSBUBÎÍPEFBSSFOEBNFOUPEFJOTUBMBÎÜFTQPSUVÈSJBT "TTJN QBSFDFOPT QPTTÓWFM JOGFSJS VN QPTJDJPOBNFOUP GBWPSÈWFM EP 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJPSFMBUJWBNFOUFËBEPÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPEBBSCJUSBHFNOPTFUPSQÞCMJDPQBSB BMHVNBTTJUVBÎÜFT 6.2. Legislações com Previsão de Arbitragem 0JOTUJUVUPFTUÈQSFTFOUFEFGPSNBFTQBSTBFNEJWFSTBTMFHJTMBÎÜFT /PEJSFJUPTPDJFUÈSJPBBENJTTÍPEFÈSCJUSPTDPNPNFJPEFEJSJNJSBTEÞWJEBT FSBQSFWJTUBOP$ØEJHP$PNFSDJBMEF"SUJUFNDPNPSFRVJTJUPFTTFO DJBMEPJOTUSVNFOUPEFDPOTUJUVJÎÍPEBTPDJBMFYUJOUPQFMB-FJO¡FTVCTUJUVÓEP QPSVNKVÓ[PBSCJUSBMGBDVMUBUJWPJOUSPEV[JEPQFMB-FJO¡ 0 $ØEJHP $JWJM OP $BQÓUVMP 99 o %P $PNQSPNJTTP BENJUF B TPMVÎÍP FY USBKVEJDJBMEFMJUÓHJPTFOUSFQFTTPBTRVFQPTTBNDPOUSBUBSFBJOTUJUVJÎÍPEFDMÈVTVMB DPNQSPNJTTØSJBQBSBFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEFKVÓ[PBSCJUSBMDPOTPBOUFSFHSBTBMFHJTMBÎÍP EFSFHÐODJBFTQFDÓmDB1FMP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM"SUPQSPDFTTPFYUJOHVF TFTFNSFTPMVÎÍPEFNÏSJUPQFMBDPOWFOÎÍPEFBSCJUSBHFN /B-FJ'FEFSBMO¡RVFSFHFBTMJDJUBÎÜFTFDPOUSBUBÎÜFTQÞCMJDBT P BSU BQMJDBEP TVQMFUJWBNFOUF BPT DPOUSBUPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT F PT QSJODÓQJPT EB UFPSJBHFSBMEPTDPOUSBUPTFBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEFEJSFJUPQSJWBEPBVUPSJ[BSJBNFNUFTFB VUJMJ[BÎÍPEBBSCJUSBHFN "-FJO¡RVFEJTDJQMJOBBEFTDFOUSBMJ[BÎÍPEPUSBOTQPSUFGFSSPWJÈSJP DPMFUJWPEFQBTTBHFJSPTVSCBOPFTVCVSCBOPEFUPEPTPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTOPBSU¡ BVUPSJ[BBDFMFCSBÎÍPEFBDPSEPTFOUSFB3FEF'FSSPWJÈSJB'FEFSBM4PDJFEBEF"OÙOJNB o3''4" FB$PNQBOIJB#SBTJMFJSBEF5SFOT6SCBOPT$#56 3&TQ34F34F"H3FH.4O%'SFTQFDUJWBNFOUFQSPGFSJEPTFN FBDFTTBEPTFNBHPTUP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 119 /P"SU97EB-FJ'FEFSBMO¡RVFSFHVMBNFOUBBTDPODFTTÜFTF QFSNJTTÜFTEFTFSWJÎPTQÞCMJDPTIÈFYJHÐODJBEFDMÈVTVMBFTTFODJBMEFmOJOEPPGPSPF PNPEPBNJHÈWFMEFTPMVÎÍPEBTEJWFSHÐODJBTDPOUSBUVBJT /BT UFMFDPNVOJDBÎÜFT P "SU EB -FJ 'FEFSBM O¡ RVF DSJPV B "HÐODJB/BDJPOBMEF5FMFDPNVOJDBÎÜFT"/"5&- FEJTDJQMJOPVPDPOUSBUPEFDPO DFTTÍPEPTFUPSEFUFSNJOBBJOEJDBÎÍPEPNPEPBNJHÈWFMQBSBBTPMVÎÍPFYUSBKVEJDJBM EFDPOUSPWÏSTJBT *HVBMNFOUFB-FJ'FEFSBMO¡EFDSJBÎÍPEB"HÐODJB/BDJPOBMEP1F USØMFP"/1 FB-FJ'FEFSBMORVFDSJPVB"HÐODJB/BDJPOBMEF5SBOT QPSUFT5FSSFTUSFT"/55 B"HÐODJB/BDJPOBMEF5SBOTQPSUFT"RVBWJÈSJPT"/5"2 FP%FQBSUBNFOUP/BDJPOBMEF*OGSBFTUSVUVSBEF5SBOTQPSUFT%/*5 FPTDPOUSBUPT JOUFSOBDJPOBJTSFHJEPTQFMB-FJOF%FDSFUPMFJOEFUFSNJOPVB JODMVTÍPEPJOTUJUVUPOBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTDPOUSBUVBJTEPTFUPSJODMVJOEPB DPODJMJBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNJOUFSOBDJPOBM "QØTBTBMUFSBÎÜFTQSPEV[JEBTQFMB-FJO¡OB-FJEF4PDJFEBEF QPS"ÎÜFTO¡TVBBQMJDBÎÍPHBOIPVNBJTTPMJEF[OBSFTPMVÎÍPEFRVFTUÜFT FOUSFBDJPOJTUBTFFNQSFTBTRVFUFOIBNDPNPQSFTTVQPTUPBDPPQFSBÎÍPFOUSFQBSUFT QSPQPSDJPOBOEPMIFTBNFMIPSTPMVÎÍPFDFMFSJEBEF &NB-FJ'FEFSBMORVFJOUSPEV[JVP.FSDBEP"UBDBEJTUBEF &OFSHJB&MÏUSJDBBEPUPVBBSCJUSBHFNDPNPGPSNBEFTPMVÎÍPEPTDPOnJUPT%BNFTNB GPSNBPDPOUSBUPEFBEFTÍPOBTQFSNJTTÜFTFBVUPSJ[BÎÜFTEFTFSWJÎPTEFUSBOTQPSUF SPEPWJÈSJPJOUFSFTUBEVBMFJOUFSOBDJPOBMEFQBTTBHFJSPTDPOGPSNF%FDSFUPO¡ ² EF TF DJUBS P %FDSFUP O RVF QSPNVMHB B DPOWFOÎÍP TPCSF P SFDPOIFDJNFOUP F B FYFDVÎÍP EBT TFOUFOÎBT BSCJUSBJT FTUSBOHFJSBT P %FDSFUP O¡ RVF QSPNVMHB P BDPSEP TPCSF BSCJUSBHFN DPNFSDJBM JOUFSOBDJPOBM EP .FSDPTVMP%FDSFUPO¡RVFBVUPSJ[BP&YFDVUJWPBEBSHBSBOUJBEP5FTPVSP /BDJPOBMBPQFSBÎÜFTEFDSÏEJUPTPCUJEPTOPFYUFSJPSFOP"SUBVUPSJ[BBBDFJUBÎÍP EFDMÈVTVMBTFDPOEJÎÜFTVTVBJTOBTPQFSBÎÜFTDPNPSHBOJTNPTmOBODJBEPSFTJOUFS OBDJPOBJTJODMVTJWFBBTTVOÎÍPEFDPNQSPNJTTPHFSBMFBOUFDJQBEPQBSBEJSJNJSQPS BSCJUSBNFOUPBTRVFTUÜFTDPOUSBUVBJT "-FJO¡RVFDSJPVB$ÉNBSBEF$PNFSDJBMJ[BÎÍPEF&OFSHJB &MÏUSJDB$$&& QBSBDPNFSDJBMJ[BÎÍPEFFOFSHJBFMÏUSJDBQSFWÐRVFBSFTPMVÎÍPEBT EJWFSHÐODJBTPDPSSFSÈQPSBSCJUSBHFN 1PS TVB WF[ B -FJ 'FEFSBM O¡ EF SFMBUJWB BP #BODP /BDJPOBM EP%FTFOWPMWJNFOUP#/%&4BMUFSPVP"SU¡QBSÈHSBGPÞOJDPEBRVFQBTTPVBUFSB TFHVJOUFSFEBÎÍPi"TPQFSBÎÜFTSFGFSJEBTOFTUFBSUQPEFSÍPGPSNBMJ[BSTFOPFYUFSJPS RVBOEPOFDFTTÈSJPQBSBPRVFmDBBFNQSFTBQÞCMJDB#BODP/BDJPOBMEP%FTFOWPMWJ NFOUP&DPOÙNJDPF4PDJBMo#/%&4BVUPSJ[BEBBDPOTUJUVJSTVCTJEJÈSJBTOPFYUFSJPSF BBDFJUBSBTDMÈVTVMBTVTVBJTFNDPOUSBUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTFOUSFFMBTBEFBSCJUSBNFOUPw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 120 Eridane Baptista Furlan 6.3. A Legislação Específica da Arbitragem .BTBBSCJUSBHFNQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUBGPJEJTDJQMJOBEBQFMB-FJ'FEFSBMO¡ EFEFTFUFNCSPEFDPOTUJUVJOEPTFFNVNJOTUSVNFOUPKVSÓEJDPEFTUJOBEPË SFTPMVÎÍPFYUSBKVEJDJBMEFDPOnJUPTRVFWFSTFNTPCSFEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTEJTQPOÓWFJT 0T NPUJWPT EFUFSNJOBOUFT EF TVB FYJTUÐODJB FOUSF PVUSPT EFDPSSFN EPT QSJODÓQJPTEBDFMFSJEBEFJOGPSNBMJEBEFFDPOPNJDJEBEFQSPDFTTVBJTBJOEBEBOFDFT TJEBEFEFWJBCJMJ[BSBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMFNVNUFNQPSB[PÈWFMEFNPEPRVFTF FGFUJWFNPTEJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBTFEFTDPOHFTUJPOFNBEFNBOEBEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP "BSCJUSBHFNÏFOUFOEJEBDPNPVNOFHØDJPKVSÓEJDPEFOPNJOBEPQPSDPO WFOÎÍPEFBSCJUSBHFNWJBCJMJ[BEBFNDPOUSBUPOBGPSNBEFDMÈVTVMBDPNQSPNJTTØSJB PVQPSNFJPEFDPNQSPNJTTPBSCJUSBMFNRVFBTQBSUFTBDPSEBNEJTQFOTBSP+VEJDJÈ SJPQBSBEJSJNJSEFUFSNJOBEBEFNBOEBFNDVSTP4FSÈJOTUJUVDJPOBMRVBOEPBTQBSUFT FMFHFSFNVNBJOTUJUVJÎÍPQBSBHFSJSPQSPDFEJNFOUPDPNSFHSBTKÈFYJTUFOUFTBDFJUBT QFMBTQBSUFTOBFTUSVUVSBÎÍPEBDPOWFOÎÍPBSCJUSBM "BVUPOPNJBEBWPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTBCPBGÏFBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTÍPQSF WBMFOUFT BT QBSUFT EFmOFN PT QSPDFEJNFOUPT EJTDJQMJOBSFT EP QSPDFTTP FTUJQVMBN PQSB[PmOBMQBSBBTVBDPOEVÎÍPFJOEJDBNPTÈSCJUSPTRVFBWBMJBSÍPFEFDJEJSÍPP DPOnJUPJOTUBVSBEP 0T QSJODÓQJPT OPSUFBEPSFT EP JOTUJUVUP DPOTVCTUBODJBN B BVUPOPNJB EB WPOUBEF C MJWSF FMFJÎÍP EB MFJ BQMJDÈWFM PCTFSWBEPT PT CPOT DPTUVNFT F B PSEFN QÞCMJDBD DPNQFUÐODJBE KVSJTEJÎÍPQPSFRVJEBEFFQSJODÓQJPTHFSBJTEPEJSFJUPF EFWJEPQSPDFTTPMFHBMDPNHBSBOUJBEFDPOUSBEJUØSJPBNQMBEFGFTBG JNQBSDJBMJEBEF FJOEFQFOEÐODJBKVSÓEJDBEPTÈSCJUSPTH MJWSFDPOWFODJNFOUPNPUJWBEPQFMPTÈSCJUSPT FI BQMJDBÎÍPEFPVUSPTQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT ²QPTTÓWFMWJTMVNCSBSBKVSJTEJDJPOBMJEBEFEBBSCJUSBHFNBOUFBQSFTFOÎBEF JEFOUJEBEF EF PCSJHBÎÜFT SFRVJTJUPT F FGFJUPT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDPT ËT TFOUFOÎBT KVEJDJBJT QSFTFOUFTUBNCÏNOPMBVEPPVNFMIPSOBTFOUFOÎBBSCJUSBMDPOGPSNFOPTSFWFMBN PT"SUTFUPEPTEB-FJGFEFSBMO¡"TTJNBTFOUFOÎBBSCJUSBMRVBO UPBPTFGFJUPTJHVBMNFOUFDPOTUJUVJTFFNUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPKVEJDJBMEBNFTNBGPSNB RVFBEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBQFMPKVÓ[PFTUBUBMEJTQFOTBOEPIPNPMPHBÎÍPQFMP+VEJDJÈSJP RVBOEPQSPGFSJEBFNÉNCJUPOBDJPOBM "DMÈVTVMBBSCJUSBMUFNFGFJUPWJODVMBOUFQBSBBTQBSUFTFBDPJTBKVMHBEBNB UFSJBMEBTFOUFOÎBBSCJUSBMDPOTUJUVJSÈUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPKVEJDJBM"DMÈVTVMBDPNQSPNJT TØSJBBQSFTFOUBTFBVUÙOPNBSFMBUJWBNFOUFBPDPOUSBUPEFNPEPRVFDBTPFTUFTFKB BOVMBEPBRVFMBOÍPTFSÈBGFUBEB "OBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBEBDMÈVTVMBDPNQSPNJTTØSJBÏBEFVNOFHØDJPKVSÓEJDP BQUPQPSTJTØQBSBJOTUJUVJSBBSCJUSBHFN1PEFTFSWB[JBPVQBUPMØHJDBRVBOEPPTSF RVJTJUPTGPSFNJOTVmDJFOUFTQBSBJOJDJBSBBSCJUSBHFNEFNBOEBOEPPTVQSJNFOUPQPS NFJPEFFMBCPSBÎÍPDPOKVOUBEFVNDPNQSPNJTTPBSCJUSBMPVJOUFSWFOÎÍPEP1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJPQBSBRVFTFJOTUJUVBBBSCJUSBHFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 121 5BNCÏNQPEFTFSFTDBMPOBEBPRVFPCSJHBBDPNQPTJÎÍPBNJHÈWFMEFSFHSB QPSJOUFSNÏEJPEBOFHPDJBÎÍPPVNFEJBÎÍPFTFNQSFQSFWJBNFOUFBPJOÓDJPEBBSCJ USBHFNTPCQFOBEFOVMJEBEFEPSFTQFDUJWPQSPDFEJNFOUP "DMÈVTVMBDPNQSPNJTTØSJBUBNCÏNQPEFTFSiDIFJBwRVBOEPQPTTVJSUPEPT PT SFRVJTJUPT JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EB DFMFCSBÎÍP EF DPNQSPNJTTP BSCJUSBM PV TFKB MPDBMMFHJTMBÎÍPBQMJDÈWFMJEJPNBOÞNFSPEFÈSCJUSPTUJQPEFBSCJUSBHFNBEIPDPV JOTUJUVDJPOBM /BNPEBMJEBEFad hocPVBWVMTBBTQBSUFTEFWFNmYBSBTSFHSBTEPQSPDFEJ NFOUPFEBBSCJUSBHFNFBTOPSNBTFTDPMIFOEPEFNÞUVPBDPSEPPTQSPmTTJPOBJTRVF QBSUJDJQBSÍP²QPTTÓWFMBEPUBSSFHSBTOPWBTQSFFYJTUFOUFTPVNJTUBT%JGFSFOUFNFOUF PDPNQSPNJTTPBSCJUSBMBQMJDBTFOPDBTPEFDMÈVTVMBDPNQSPNJTTØSJBWB[JBTFOEP mSNBEPFNKVÓ[PQPSBDPSEPPVJNQPTJÎÍPEFTFOUFOÎBKVEJDJBM 0T QSJODJQBJT BSHVNFOUPT GBWPSÈWFJT Ë BSCJUSBHFN DPOWFSHFN QBSB VNB NBJPS MJCFSEBEF EBT QBSUFT DFMFSJEBEF QSPDFEJNFOUBM nFYJCJMJEBEF JOGPSNBMJEBEF FTQFDJBMJ[BÎÍPEPTÈSCJUSPTBQSPGVOEBNFOUPOBTNBUÏSJBTFNSB[ÍPEBNFOPSRVBO UJEBEFEFQSPDFTTPTJNQPTUPTBPÈSCJUSPPTJHJMPVNBNFMIPSSFMBÎÍPDVTUPCFOFGÓDJP FPKVMHBNFOUPQPSFRVJEBEF "FTTFSFTQFJUP$BSNPOBOPTFOTJOBRVFA(...) A expressão julgamento por equidade expressa a ideia de equidade substitutiva, ou seja, autorização para deixar de lado as normas de direito posto e julgar segundo o que parecer mais justo no caso concreto 3FGPSÎBFTTF FOUFOEJNFOUP P "SU ¡EB -FJ EF *OUSPEVÎÍP ËT /PSNBT EP %JSFJUP#SBTJMFJSPFNWJHPSNFEJBOUFB-FJOBPQSFWFSRVFBBQMJDBÎÍP EBMFJQFMPKVJ[EFWFBUFOEFSBPTmOTTPDJBJTBRVFFMBTFEJSJHFFËTFYJHÐODJBTEPCFN DPNVNQSPQJDJBOEPDPOEJÎÜFTUFØSJDBTEFBQMJDBÎÍPEBOPSNBEFBDPSEPDPNPNP NFOUPFPDPOUFYUPTPDJBMFNRVFQSPEV[JSÈTFVTFGFJUPT "FRVJEBEFBQMJDBTFTPNFOUFFNDBTPTBVUPSJ[BEPTQPSMFJDPOTPBOUFEJTQÜF P$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM"SU0KVJ[TØEFDJEJSÈQPSFRVJEBEFOPTDBTPTQSF WJTUPTFNMFJDPNPTFEÈDPNBMFJEFBSCJUSBHFN /FTTBFTUFJSBB-FJEF*OUSPEVÎÍPBP$ØEJHP$JWJMBSSPMBIJFSBSRVJDBNFOUF BTEFNBJTGPOUFTGPSNBJTEP%JSFJUPRVFEFWFNCBMJ[BSPKVMHBEPSTFKBFMFUPHBEPPV FMFJUPQFMBTQBSUFTAArt. 4° – Quando a lei for omissa, o juiz decidirá de acordo com a analogia, os costumes e os princípios gerais do direito33. "EJDJPOBMNFOUFP$ØEJHP$JWJMEFEJTQÜFOP"SUAQue os negócios jurídicos devem ser interpretados conforme a boa-fé e os usos do lugar de sua celebração &NUPEBTFTTBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTOPUBTFBBEFSÐODJBDPNPQSJODÓQJPEBIJFSBS RVJB OPSNBUJWB JOTQJSBEP FN ,FMTFO F SFDFQDJPOBEP DPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUF "TTJN 33 $"3.0/"$BSMPT"MCFSUP"SCJUSBHFNFQSPDFTTPVNDPNFOUÈSJPË-FJFE4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT IUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCS$DJWJM@%FDSFUP-FJ%FMIUNBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP IUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCSDDJWJM@MFJTMIUNBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 122 Eridane Baptista Furlan DPOTBHSBTF RVF B QSØQSJB OPSNB BVUPSJ[BSÈ P KVMHBEPS P VTP EF PVUSBT GPOUFT EP %JSFJUP /PRVFDPODFSOFËTEFTWBOUBHFOTFSJTDPTOBBEPÎÍPEBBSCJUSBHFNDPOTJ EFSBNPTSFMFWBOUFBQFOBTVN5SBUBTFEBBVTÐODJBEFQPEFSEFQPMÓDJBRVFJNQÜF BPÈSCJUSPSFDPSSFSBPKVJ[UPHBEPQBSBEBSDVNQSJNFOUPËNFEJEBMJNJOBSEFGFSJEB FNTFEFEFBSCJUSBHFNPVQBSBBFYFDVÎÍPEBEFDJTÍPBSCJUSBMTVTDJUBOEPEFNPSBOB PCUFOÎÍPEPCFOFGÓDJPDPODFEJEP "T EFNBJT IJQØUFTFT EF EFTWBOUBHFOT B FYFNQMP EP USÈmDP EF JOnVÐO DJBTEBFNJTTÍPEFMBVEPTBSCJUSBJTTFNPTSFRVJTJUPTMFHBJTOFDFTTÈSJPTËWBMJEB EFFEBBUVBÎÍPJOTBUJTGBUØSJBEPTÈSCJUSPTUBNCÏNQPEFNPDPSSFSOBQSFTUBÎÍP KVSJTEJDJPOBM " POFSPTJEBEF EB BSCJUSBHFN JOTUJUVDJPOBM OB DPOUSBUBÎÍP EF QSPmTTJPOBJT FTQFDJBMJ[BEPTQBSBBTTFHVSBSVNBEFDJTÍPDPOmÈWFMQPEFSJBTFSVNBEFTWBOUBHFN FNUFTFUPEBWJBFTTBTJUVBÎÍPÏQPTTÓWFMUBNCÏNOP+VEJDJÈSJP/BQSFTUBÎÍPKVEJDJBM FTTFTQSPmTTJPOBJTBUVBNDPNPBTTJTUFOUFTEPQFSJUPOPNFBEPQFMPKVJ[ &OUSFUBOUP P KVJ[ QPEFSÈ PV OÍP TFS UFDOJDBNFOUF FTQFDJBMJ[BEP TPCSF B NBUÏSJBFOWPMWJEBUFOEPBQSFSSPHBUJWBEFEFDJEJMBTFNSFTUBSBETUSJUPËDPODMVTÍP EPTMBVEPTQFSJDJBJTFEPTBTTJTUFOUFTDPOUSBUBEPTQFMBTQBSUFT*TTPOÍPEFJYBEFTFS VNSJTDPFÙOVTBP QBTTP RVF OB BSCJUSBHFN UBM TJUVBÎÍPQPEF TFS FWJUBEB DPN B DPOUSBUBÎÍPEFÈSCJUSPFTQFDJBMJ[BEP "JODJEÐODJBEB-FJEF"SCJUSBHFNEFNBOEBBQSFTFOÎBEFEJSFJUPEJTQPOÓWFM BDSFTDFOEPTFBJOEBPDPODFJUPEFQBUSJNPOJBMJEBEFUJQJmDBEPQFMBQFSDFQÎÍPWB MPSBUJWBEFDVOIPFDPOÙNJDPmOBODFJSPBPEJSFJUPQMFJUFBEPFYDMVÓEPTQPSUBOUPPT EJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBTJOEJWJEVBJTFDPMFUJWPTDPOTJEFSBEPTGVOEBNFOUBJT "TDPOEJÎÜFTQBSBBIBCJMJUBÎÍPOBBSCJUSBHFNDPOTJTUFNOBUJQJmDBÎÍPEF MJUÓHJPRVFPCKFUJWFEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTEJTQPOÓWFJTPVTFKBQBTTÓWFJTEFUSBO TBÎÍP QFMP TFV UJUVMBS B FYFNQMP EPT JOTUJUVUPT KVSÓEJDPT EB SFOÞODJB DFTTÍP F USBOTGFSÐODJB 7. INTERESSES INDISPONÍVEIS &YJTUFN TJUVBÎÜFT FN RVF NBUÏSJB EF PSEFN QÞCMJDB TF GB[ QSFTFOUF TFN QSFKVÓ[PEPVTPEBBSCJUSBHFNQPJTGPDBMJ[BNEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTEJTQPOÓWFJTDPNP OPDBTPEBmYBÎÍPEPNPOUBOUFSFMBUJWPBPTBMJNFOUPTPVSFMBUJWPTBPQBUSJNÙOJPEBT QFTTPBTFNSFHJNFEFVOJÍPFTUÈWFMBJOEBOBSFDVQFSBÎÍPFYUSBKVEJDJBMEFFNQSFTBT OPTDPOUSBUPTGPSNBMJ[BEPTDPNQFTTPBTEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPTPDJFEBEFTEFFDPOPNJB NJTUBFOWPMWFOEPRVFTUÜFTFDPOÙNJDBTQBTTÓWFJTEFUSBOTBÎÍPFEJTQPOÓWFJT0TEJSFJ UPTRVFOÍPQPTTBNTFSWBMPSBEPTOÍPTÍPBSCJUSÈWFJTFSFQSFTFOUBNFYDFÎÍPËSFHSB EBEJTQPOJCJMJEBEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 123 /FTTFTFOUJEPTÍPDPOTJEFSBEPTJOEJTQPOÓWFJTUPEPTPTEJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBT GVOEBNFOUBJTQPTUPRVFSFGFSFOUFTËTDPOEJÎÜFTCÈTJDBTEBFYJTUÐODJBIVNBOBEJHOB &TUFTRVBOEPQPTJUJWBEPTSFnFUFNPDPOKVOUPEBTQSFSSPHBUJWBTFJOTUJUVJÎÜFTRVF WJBCJMJ[BNBMJCFSEBEFFJHVBMEBEFRVFGVOEBNFOUBNBTPDJFEBEFQPMÓUJDB &ODPOUSBNTFFYFNQMJmDBEPTOP"SU¡EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEF OÍPFYDMVJOEPPVUSPTEFDPSSFOUFTEPSFHJNFFQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFBEPUB EPTBMÏNEFPVUSPTQSFWJTUPTOPTUSBUBEPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTFNRVFIBKBBQBSUJDJQBÎÍP EB3FQÞCMJDB'FEFSBUJWBEP#SBTJM %F BDPSEP DPN 5BMBNJOJ TFSÈ BSCJUSÈWFM UVEP BRVJMP RVF GPS TVTDFUÓWFM EF SFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFGBMUBEFSB[ÍPQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB $FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF.FMMPGPDBMJ[BOEPBEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEFJOUFSFTTFT OBØSCJUBEBBUVBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBBTTJNMFDJPOB 6NBWF[RVFBBUJWJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWBÏTVCPSEJOBEBËMFJFmSNBEP RVF B BENJOJTUSBÎÍP BTTJN DPNP BT QFTTPBT BENJOJTUSBUJWBT OÍP UÐN EJTQPOJCJMJEBEF TPCSF PT JOUFSFTTFT QÞCMJDPT NBT BQFOBT P EFWFS EF DVSÈMPT OPT UFSNPT EBT mOBMJEBEFT QSFEFUFSNJOBEBT MFHBMNFOUF DPNQSFFOEFTFRVFFTUFKBNTVCNFUJEPTBPTTFHVJOUFTQSJODÓQJPTB EB MFHBMJEBEFDPNTVBTJNQMJDBÎÜFTPVEFDPSSÐODJBTBTBCFSQSJODÓQJPT EBmOBMJEBEFEBSB[PBCJMJEBEFEBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEFEBNPUJWBÎÍPF EBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFEP&TUBEP "P DPOUSÈSJP 'ÈCJP 1FESP "MFN FOUFOEF RVF OÍP TF DPOGVOEFN B JOEJT QPOJCJMJEBEF EP JOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDP DPN B EJTQPOJCJMJEBEF EF EJSFJUPT QBUSJNPOJBJT BCSJOEPTFNBSHFNËBQMJDBÎÍPEBBSCJUSBHFNOBTPMVÎÍPTPCSFJOUFSFTTFTEFOBUVSF[B FDPOÙNJDBEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB *HVBMNFOUF $BSNPOB DPODMVJ RVF iA arbitragem, portanto, coloca-se como opção válida para a solução de litígios, não se podendo confundir disponibilidade ou indisponibilidade de direitos patrimoniais com disponibilidade ou indisponibilidade do interesse públicow /FTTB FTUFJSB QSPTTFHVF "MFYBOESF 'SFJUBT $ÉNBSB EFGFOEFOEP P VTP EP JOTUJUVUP OPT DPOnJUPT EF JOUFSFTTFT TPCSF BUPT OFHPDJBJT QSBUJDBEPT QFMP &T UBEP FN QPTJÎÍP EF JHVBMEBEF DPN P QBSUJDVMBS UPEBWJB FYDMVJOEP B IJQØUFTF QBSB 5"-".*/*&EVBSEP"SCJUSBHFNF1BSDFSJB1ÞCMJDP1SJWBEB111 *O@@$PPSE 1BSDFSJBT1ÞCMJDP 1SJWBEBT6NFOGPRVFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBS4ÍP1BVMP35Q #"/%&*3"%&.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPFE&EJUPSB.BMIFJSPT 4ÍP1BVMP1 "-&.'BCJP1FESP$PM1SÈUJDBEP%JSFJUPW&E4BSBJWB $"3.0/"$BSMPT"MCFSUP"SCJUSBHFNFQSPDFTTP6N$PNFOUÈSJPË-FJOFESFW BUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP"UMBTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 124 Eridane Baptista Furlan DPOUSBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTQPTUPRVFDBSBDUFSJ[BEPTQFMBQSFTFOÎBEFEJSFJUPTQÞCMJDPT JOEJTQPOÓWFJT 1PSTVBWF[-VJ['FSOBOEP.PVSBNFTNPDPOTUBUBOEPRVFPTJOUFSFTTFT EB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBTÍPJOEJTQPOÓWFJTQPSPCKFUJWBSFNPBUFOEJNFOUPJNF EJBUPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPBENJUFBFYJTUÐODJBEFJOUFSFTTFTEJTQPOÓWFJTQBTTÓWFJTEF SFOÞODJBRVBOEPSFMBUJWPTBEJSFJUPTDPOUSBUVBJTQSJWBEPTNBTDPODMVJQFMBJOBQMJ DBCJMJEBEFEPJOTUJUVUP $POUSBSJBNFOUF&EVBSEP5BMBNJOJMFDJPOBRVF $BCF B BSCJUSBHFN TFNQSF RVF B NBUÏSJB FOWPMWJEB QPTTB TFS SFTPMWJEBQFMBTQSØQSJBTQBSUFTJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFJOHSFTTPFN +VÓ[P 4F P DPOnJUP FOUSF P QBSUJDVMBS F B "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB Ï FNJOFOUFNFOUFQBUSJNPOJBMWBTFHVJS FTFFMFWFSTBTPCSFNBUÏSJB RVFQPEFSJBTFSTPMVDJPOBEBEJSFUBNFOUFFOUSFBTQBSUFTTFNRVFTF m[FTTF OFDFTTÈSJB B JOUFSWFOÎÍP KVSJTEJDJPOBM FOUÍP B BSCJUSBHFN Ï DBCÓWFM 0JOUFSFTTFUFNDBSÈUFSQBUSJNPOJBMOÍPBQFOBTRVBOEP TFVPCKFUPEJSFUBNFOUFTFSFWFTUFEFBQUJEÍPEFPJOBEJNQMFNFOUPTFS SFQBSBEPDPNQFOTBEPPVOFVUSBMJ[BEPQPSNFEJEBTDPNDPOUFÞEP FDPOÙNJDP /FTTBFTUFJSB.BSÎBM+VTUFO'JMIPDPNQMFNFOUB " EJTQPOJCJMJEBEF QBSB JNQPS B BSCJUSBHFN Ï B NFTNB QBSB DSJBS EJSFJUPTFPCSJHBÎÜFTQPSWJBDPOTFOTVBM 4FPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPÏ JOEJTQPOÓWFMBPQPOUPEFFYDMVJSBBSCJUSBHFNFOUÍPTFSJBJOEJTQPOÓWFM JHVBMNFOUFQBSBPFGFJUPEFQSPEV[JSDPOUSBUBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWB $BJP5ÈDJUPBSHVNFOUBRVF "TTJNDPNPÏMÓDJUPOPTUFSNPTEPDPOUSBUPBFYFDVÎÍPFTQPOUÉOFB EBPCSJHBÎÍPBOFHPDJBÎÍPoFQPSWJBEFDPOTFRVÐODJBBDPOWFOÎÍP EF BSCJUSBHFN TFSÈ NFJP BEFRVBEP B UPSOBS FGFUJWP P DVNQSJNFOUP PCSJHBDJPOBM RVBOEP DPNQBUÓWFM DPN B EJTQPOJCJMJEBEF EF CFOT $¬."3""MFYBOESF'SFJUBT"SCJUSBHFNo-FJOFEJÎÍPSFWJTUBBNQMJBEBFBUVBMJ[BEB -VNFO+VSJT .063"-VJ['FSOBOEPIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSFWJTUBBVUPSMVJ[GFSOBOEPEFNPVSBSBNPTBDFTTBEP FNKVMIP "SCJUSBHFNF1BSDFSJBQÞCMJDP1SJWBEB111 *OParcerias Público-Privadas: 6N&OGPRVF.VMUJEJTDJQMJ OBSDPPSE&EVBSEP5BMBNJOJF.POJDB4QF[JB+VTUFO 4ÍP1BVMP35QF +645&/'*-)0.BSÎBM$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP&E4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 125 &N TVNB OFN UPEPT PT DPOUSBUPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT FOWPMWFN OFDFTTBSJBNFOUFEJSFJUPTJOEJTQPOÓWFJTEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍP &OUSFUBOUP P FOUFOEJNFOUP EP 5SJCVOBM EF $POUBT EB 6OJÍP Ï DPOUSÈSJP DPNPSFnFUJEPOPBDØSEÍP5$EB$ÉNBSBo%06oEFSFMB UPSJBEP.JOJTUSP8BMUPO"MFODBS3PESJHVFTF"DØSEÍPo%06 o 1MFOÈSJP F SFMBUPSJB EP .JOJTUSP "VHVTUP /BSEFT BTTFOUBSBN RVF B BVTÐODJB EF BVUPSJ[BÎÍP MFHJTMBUJWB JNQFEF B VUJMJ[BÎÍP EB BSCJUSBHFN FN MJUÓHJPT FOWPMWFOEP B "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP "FTTFSFTQFJUP-FPO'SFKEB4[LMBSPXTLZEFGFOEFBJODMVTÍPEFOPSNBË -FJ'FEFSBMO¡EFEFKVOIPEFBENJUJOEPBBSCJUSBHFNOPÉNCJUP EBTMJDJUBÎÜFTFDPOUSBUPTDFMFCSBEPTQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBDPNQFTTPBTGÓTJDBT FKVSÓEJDBTJODMVTJWFEPNJDJMJBEBTOPFTUSBOHFJSPEFTEFRVFNFEJBOUFBQSFTFOÎB EF SFQSFTFOUBOUF EP 1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP MJDJUBOUF PV DPOUSBUBOUF BMÏN EF QSFWJTÍP OP FEJUBMFDPOUSBUP 0SFMBUPS.JOJTUSP-VJ['VYFNWPUPFYBSBEPOP.BOEBEPEF4FHVSBOÎBO¡ KVMHBEPQFMP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBFOGSFOUBFSFDIBÎBBTUFTFTDPOUSÈ SJBTBPVTPEBBSCJUSBHFNDPNPTBSHVNFOUPTDBMDBEPTOBPQÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQBSBB TPDJFEBEFEFFDPOPNJBNJTUBFOBBUVBMEPVUSJOBBENJOJTUSBUJWJTUBRVFUSB[BEJTUJO ÎÍPFOUSFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQSJNÈSJPFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTFDVOEÈSJP "TTFWFSBP.JOJTUSPSFMBUPSRVFBBEPÎÍPEPDPNQSPNJTTPBSCJUSBMJOTFSFTF OBPQÎÍPEFHFSÐODJBEPTJOUFSFTTFTFQPEFSFTJOUFSOPTEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPDPNPJOUF SFTTFQÞCMJDPTFDVOEÈSJPQSPKFUBOEPQBSBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQSJNÈSJPRVFTFSJBOP DBTPBBEPÎÍPEBGPSNBNFOPTEJTQFOEJPTBQBSBTPMVDJPOBSPDPOnJUP "BSCJUSBHFNÏBDFJUBOBTTPDJFEBEFTEFFDPOPNJBNJTUBFNQSFTBTQÞCMJDBT PSHBOJ[BÎÜFTTPDJBJTGVOEBÎÜFTQSJWBEBTPSHBOJ[BÎÜFTEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMDPOTJEFSB EBTEFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQBSBBTRVBJTTFKBNEFTUJOBEPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJDPTFBBUVBÎÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWBFQSJWBEBTÍPGSPOUFJSBTFOUSFTJJNQPOEPNBJPSDFMFSJEBEFBVUPOP NJBFJOEFQFOEÐODJBOBTEFDJTÜFT 0JOTUJUVUPNVJUBTWF[FTQPEFSÈQSPQPSDJPOBSVNNFMIPSEFTFNQFOIPEBT GVOÎÜFTOBDPOTFDVÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTFTQFDJBMNFOUFRVBOEPFTUFTWFSTBSFN TPCSFRVFTUÜFTEFBMUBDPNQMFYJEBEFUÏDOJDBTFKBFDPOÙNJDPmOBODFJSPDPOUÈCJMEF FOHFOIBSJBPVEFRVBMRVFSÈSFBRVFFYUSBQPMFBDJÐODJBEPEJSFJUP 5«$*50$BJP0+VÓ[P"SCJUSBMFN%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP*O(BSDF[+PTÏ.BSJB3PTTBOJ."35*/4 1FESP#BUJTUB3FnFYÜFTTPCSFB"SCJUSBHFN4ÍP1BVMP-5SQ 5SJCVOBMEF$POUBTEB6OJÍPBD5$EB$ÉNBSBo%06oSFM.JO8BMUPO "MFODBS3PESJHVFTF"Do%06o1MFOÈSJPoSFM.JO"VHVTUP/BSEFT 4;,-"3084,:-FPO'SFEKBIUUQXXXGBDUVNDPNCSBSUJHPTIUNBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP IUUQXXXKVTCSBTJMDPNCSKVSJTQSVEFODJBBHSBWPSFHJNFOUBMOPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBODB BHSHOPNTEGTUKJOUFJSPUFPSKVMHBEPQFMP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBSFM .JO-VJ['VY RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 126 Eridane Baptista Furlan "JOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQSJNÈSJPOÍPTFDPOGVOEFDPNB EJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEFEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTJODMVTJWFRVBOEPSFQSFTFOUBNPJOUFSFTTF FDPOÙNJDPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBPRVFUPSOBSJBWJÈWFMFNUFTFBBQMJDBÎÍPEB BSCJUSBHFNQBSBEJSJNJSBMHVNBTIJQØUFTFTEFDPOnJUPTQÞCMJDPT 1BSB/JMUPO$ÏTBS"OUVOFTEB$PTUB EFWF FYJTUJS SFMBÎÍP IBSNPOJPTB F DPPQFSBUJWB FOUSF B BUJWJEBEF KVSJTEJDJPOBM FTUBUBM F BSCJUSBM TPC QFOB EF GB[FS DPN RVF P KVSJTEJDJPOBEP QFSDB VN NFJP BMUFSOBUJWP EF SFTPMVÎÍP EF DPOnJUPT CBTUBOUFTBMVUBSFEFNPDSÈUJDPRVFQSJNBQFMBQBSUJDJQBÎÍPEPQPWP OBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEBKVTUJÎB 1PSPVUSPMBEPUFNTFRVFBDPOmEFODJBMJEBEFFMFNFOUPDBSBDUFSJ[BEPSEBBSCJ USBHFNÏKVSJEJDBNFOUFJODPNQBUÓWFMOPTQSPDFTTPTEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBSFHJEPTQFMP QSJODÓQJPEBQVCMJDJEBEFNFTNPRVBOEPTFUSBUFEFEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTEJTQPOÓWFJT /FTTFTFOUJEPQBSFDFOPTRVFEJBOUFEBDPOmEFODJBMJEBEFDPNQVMTØSJBEFT DBCFSJBBBSCJUSBHFNQPJTP&TUBEPRVBOEPBUVBOBNFTNBDPOEJÎÍPEPQBSUJDVMBSOÍP EFWFSÈJOWPDBSBTQSFSSPHBUJWBTJOFSFOUFTËEFGFTBJODPOEJDJPOBMEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP 8. A ARBITRAGEM POR ÓRGÃOS E ENTIDADES ESTATAIS 1PS PVUSP MBEP JOUFSFTTBOPT BWFSJHVBS B OBUVSF[B EB BSCJUSBHFN BQMJDBEB QPSØSHÍPTFFOUJEBEFTFTUBUBJTFTQFDJBMNFOUFQFMBTBHÐODJBTBUVBOUFTTPCSFTFUPSFT SFHVMBEPTFQFMB$ÉNBSBEF$PODJMJBÎÍPF"SCJUSBHFNEB"EWPDBDJB(FSBMEB6OJÍP 8.1. Agência Reguladora $VNQSFEJ[FSRVFPQPEFSOPSNBUJWPEBBHÐODJBSFHVMBEPSBMJNJUBTFËTEJT QPTJÎÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFMFHBJTBPRVFDJUBNPT.BSÎBM+VTUFO'JMIPi VNBBHÐO DJBOÍPQPEFGB[FSBMHPBMÏNPVEJWFSTPEPRVFTFSJBSFDPOIFDJEPBP1PEFS&YFDVUJWP FNNBUÏSJBEFQSPEVÎÍPOPSNBUJWBw /PUPDBOUFËBUVBÎÍPEBBHÐODJBSFHVMBEPSBOBGVOÎÍPBSCJUSBM-VJ[3JDBSEP5SJO EBEF#BDDFMMBSFOUFOEFOEPRVFBGVOÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMOÍPÏNBJTVNNPOPQØMJPEP+V EJDJÈSJPBmSNBRVFA OBEBJNQFEFRVFVNBBHÐODJBSFHVMBEPSBWFOIBBGVODJPOBS $045"/JMUPO$ÏTBS"OUVOFTEB1PEFSFTEP«SCJUSPEFBDPSEPDPNB-FJO4ÍP1BVMP 3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ +645&/'*-)0.BSÎBM0EJSFJUPEBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBTJOEFQFOEFOUFT%JBMÏUJDB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 127 DPNPUSJCVOBMBSCJUSBMFYFSDJUBOEPQMFOBNFOUFTVBGVOÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMIBWFOEPBPSF WÏTFOPSNFWBOUBHFNWJTUPRVFEFUFOUPSBEFDPOIFDJNFOUPUÏDOJDPFTQFDÓmDPEPTFUPS .BTOÍPÏCFNBTTJNDPNPCFNJMVTUSB+PTÏ-VÓT&TRVÓWFM P GBDUP EF B MFJ SFDPOIFDFS DPNQFUÐODJB B VNB FOUJEBEF BENJOJTUSBUJWBQBSBEFDJEJSOVNQSJNFJSPNPNFOUPVNMJUÓHJPFOUSF QBSUJDVMBSFT PV BUÏ FOUSF PVUSBT FOUJEBEFT BENJOJTUSBUJWBT OÍP QPEF TJHOJmDBS JNFEJBUBNFOUF B DPOWFSTÍP EFTTB FOUJEBEF BENJOJTUSBUJWB OVNB FOUJEBEF KVSJTEJDJPOBM VNB WF[ RVF QPS NBJT SFMFWBOUFT RVF QPTTBNTFSBTEFDJTÜFTPVBDUPTSFTVMUBOUFTEBBUJWJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWB BSCJUSBMAOÍPTÍPFMFTRVFJOEJWJEVBMJ[BNBTGVOÎÜFTEP&TUBEPPVRVF BGFDUBNPOÞDMFPFTQFDÓmDPEPTØSHÍPTBRVFTÍPDPNFUJEPT "MÏNEJTTPBTBHÐODJBTOÍPTFTVCNFUFNBPQSJODÓQJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBJOÏSDJB EBKVSJTEJÎÍPFBBSCJUSBHFNEFNBOEBBWPMVOUBSJFEBEFEBTQBSUFTDVKBNBOJGFTUBÎÍP EFWPOUBEFRVFOÍPQPEFTFSTVCTUJUVÓEBQFMBMFJ "EFDJTÍPEBBHÐODJBSFHVMBEPSBTVKFJUBTFBPSFDVSTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPEFTFO WPMWJEPTPCPTQSJODÓQJPTFQSFDFJUPTEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPFËSFWJTÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBM"JO EBDBTPFTTBFOUJEBEFFODPOUSFTFOBDPOEJÎÍPEFUFSDFJSPOÍPFTUBSÈPCSJHBEBBQBS UJDJQBSEFQSPDFTTPBSCJUSBMPVNFTNPTFTVCNFUFSBPTFGFJUPTEFVNBEFDJTÍPBSCJUSBM &TUVEPEFTFOWPMWJEPQPS"OESÏ$BSEPTP(VTLPXEFTUJOBEPËPCSBDPMFUJWB TPCSFBSCJUSBHFNOP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPQSPQÜFBTTFHVJOUFTDPOEJÎÜFTQBSBPVTPEBBSCJ USBHFNFNDPOnJUPTTPCSFOPSNBTSFHVMBUØSJBT B PDPOnJUPEFSJWFEBBQMJDBÎÍPDPODSFUBEBOPSNBSFHVMBUØSJBHFSBM FEJUBEBQFMBBHÐODJBPVFOWPMWBBFEJÎÍPEFOPSNBSFHVMBUØSJBEFFGFJUPT DPODSFUPT F JNFEJBUPT C P DPOnJUP BQSFTFOUF PCKFUP TVTDFUÓWFM EF TVCNJTTÍP Ë BSCJUSBHFN F D FYJTUB QSFWJTÍP EF TPMVÎÍP EF DPOnJUPT QFMBWJBBSCJUSBM KBNBJTBFNJTTÍPEFOPSNBSFHVMBUØSJBFTQFDÓmDB QFMPÈSCJUSPPVQFMPUSJCVOBMBSCJUSBM .BTQBSB"MFYBOESF'SFJUBT$ÉNBSB OPTDPOnJUPTFOWPMWFOEPTVBBUJWJEBEFUÓQJDBPVTFKBBmTDBMJ[BÎÍP EF EFUFSNJOBEB BUJWJEBEF RVF DPSSFTQPOEB B BMHVN TFSWJÎP QÞCMJDP #"$$&--"3-VJ[3JDBSEP5SJOEBEF'VOÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMEBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3FWJTUBEF1SPDFT TPOKVOTFUQ &426¶7&-+PTÏ-VÓT0TDPOUSBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFBBSCJUSBHFN$PJNCSB"MNFEJOB $"3%040"OESÏ(VTLPX*4#/"SCJUSBHFNFQPEFSQÞCMJDPDPPSEFOBÎÍP$F TBS"(VJNBSÍFT1FSFJSB&EVBSEP5BMBNJOJo4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 128 Eridane Baptista Furlan PV B BMHVNB ÈSFB FDPOÙNJDB FN RVF BUVBÎÍP EFQFOEB EF DPODFTTÍP PVQFSNJTTÍP B BSCJUSBHFN OÍP QPEFSÈ TFS FNQSFHBEB DPNP NÏUPEP EFDPNQPTJÎÍPKÈFOWPMWJEPTJOUFSFTTFTJOEJTQPOÓWFJT BTBHÐODJBT SFHVMBEPSBTOÍPQPEFNBUVBSDPNPDPSUFTBSCJUSBJT "EJDJPOBMNFOUF.BVSP3PCFSUP(PNFTEF.BUUPTBTTFWFSB UPEBTBTDMÈVTVMBTRVFJNQMJRVFNSFNJTTÍPUSBOTBÎÍPPVSFOÞODJB EFEJSFJUPTEFDPOUFÞEPQÞCMJDPDPNPBTSFMBUJWBTBPFYFSDÓDJPEPQPEFS EFQPMÓDJBEPQPEFSJNQPTJUJWPEBTCBTFTEBTUBSJGBTEBEJTQPTJÎÍPEP EPNÓOJPQÞCMJDPEFDPOUSPMBSBQSFTUBÎÍPEPTTFSWJÎPTDPODFEJEPTOÍP TÍPBENJUJEPTOPKVÓ[PBSCJUSBMQPSTFSFNFORVBESBEPTDPNPEJSFJUPT JOEJTQPOÓWFJTFDPNPUBMJOTVTDFUÓWFMEBTPMVÎÍPFYUSBKVEJDJBM /FTTFTFOUJEPNJTUFSTFGB[DJUBSPNBHJTUÏSJPEF-VJ[B3BOHFMEF.PSBFT " BUSJCVJÎÍP RVF OPSNBMNFOUF DPOTUB EB EJTDJQMJOB EBT BHÐODJBT SFHVMBEPSBT OP ÉNCJUP EPT TFSWJÎPT QÞCMJDPT EF DPNQPS DPOnJUPT FOUSF PT BHFOUFT TVCPSEJOBEPT Ë TVB DPNQFUÐODJB OÍP DPOmHVSB BVUÐOUJDB BSCJUSBHFN &TTB BUVBÎÍP EFTFOWPMWFTF OP SJTDP EF VN QSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPRVFOÍPQPEFTFSDPOGVOEJEPDPNPQSPDFTTP EFBSCJUSBHFN &OUFOEJNFOUPBOÈMPHPBQSFTFOUBB1SPGB.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMB%J1JFUSPBP BOBMJTBSB-FJ(FSBMEF5FMFDPNVOJDBÎÜFTo-FJO¡ BGVOÎÍPEFÈSCJUSPGPJDPOGFSJEBË"HÐODJBDFSUBNFOUFJOTQJSBEB QFMPEJSFJUPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPFNRVFBTBHÐODJBTEFTFNQFOIBNGVOÎÜFT RVBTFKVEJDJBJTTPCSFBTEFDJTÜFTQSPGFSJEBTQFMBTBHÐODJBT/PDBTPEB -FJ(FSBMEF5FMFDPNVOJDBÎÜFTFUBNCÏNEB3FTPMVÎÍPOPQSØQSJP WPDÈCVMP BSCJUSBHFN Ï NBM FNQSFHBEP QPSRVF HFSB DPOGVTÍP DPN P JOTUJUVUPEFmOJEPQFMB-FJEF"SCJUSBHFNPÈSCJUSPOÍPÏFTDPMIJEPQFMBT QBSUFTFNDPOnJUPBBSCJUSBHFNOÍPTFCBTFJBOBJEFJBEBDPOmBOÎBOP ÈSCJUSPFOÍPÏMJWSFNFOUFDPOWFODJPOBEBQFMBTQBSUFTFNDPOnJUPFMB ÏJNQPTUBQFMBMFJ&NDPOTFRVÐODJBOÍPQPEFBEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBQFMB $¬."3""MFYBOESFEF'SFJUBT"SCJUSBHFNOPTDPOnJUPTFOWPMWFOEPBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3FWJTUBEF %JSFJUPEB"TTPDJBÎÍPEPT1SPDVSBEPSFTEP/PWP&TUBEPEP3JPEF+BOFJSPO $POUSBUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPFB-FJEF"SCJUSBHFN3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPo3%"OQ .03"&4-VJ[3BOHFMEF"SCJUSBHFNFBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3FWJTUBEF"SCJUSBHFNF.FEJBÎÍPO NBJPBHP353Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 129 "HÐODJB UFS DBSÈUFS EFmOJUJWP &MB TFNQSF TFSÈ QBTTÓWFM EF BQSFDJBÎÍP KVEJDJBMQPSFYJHÐODJBEP"SU¡JODJTP9997EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP *HVBMNFOUF1BVMP#SBODIFSBEPUBUBMQPTJÎÍPBPFYBNJOBSPTDPOnJUPTFOUSF QSFTUBEPSFTEFTFSWJÎPTEFUFMFDPNVOJDBÎÜFTFVTVÈSJPT USBUBTF EF IJQØUFTF FN RVF P QSØQSJP 1PEFS &YFDVUJWP BHF OP TFOUJEPEFNFEJBSFEJTQPSTPCSFPTDPOnJUPTWJTBOEPËTVBTPMVÎÍP /FTTFTFOUJEPRVBMRVFSQSPDFEJNFOUPJOJDJBEPFEJSFDJPOBEPË"HÐODJB USBUBSTFÈEFWFSEBEFJSPQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPFOÍPEFBSCJUSBHFN OPTNPMEFTEB-FJO 1PSUBOUPFNRVFQFTFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBBHÐODJBSFHVMBEPSBWBMFSTFEFBM HVOTQSFTTVQPTUPTHFSBJTEB-FJGFEFSBMO¡OBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTFOUSF BHFOUFTEFVNEBEPTFUPSWFSJmDBTFBQFOBTPFYFSDÓDJPEFVNBGVOÎÍPUÓQJDBFJOF SFOUFËQSØQSJBBUVBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBOÍPTFDPOGVOEJOEPDPNPJOTUJUVUPEBBSCJ USBHFNQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUP 8.2. Câmara de Conciliação e Arbitragem da Administração Federal (CCAF) *HVBMNFOUF PDPSSF DPN B $ÉNBSB EF $PODJMJBÎÍP F "SCJUSBHFN EB "ENJ OJTUSBÎÍP'FEFSBM$$"'EB"EWPDBDJB(FSBMEB6OJÍPDSJBEBNFEJBOUFP"UP3FHJ NFOUBMO¡EFEFTFUFNCSPEF4FVFTDPQPWJTBËTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBT QPTUBTFOUSFPTØSHÍPTFBTFOUJEBEFTQÞCMJDBTGFEFSBJT"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP'FEFSBMF"E NJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBEPT&TUBEPTPVEP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMQPSNFJPEBDPODJMJBÎÍPPV EBBSCJUSBHFNTPCPGVOEBNFOUPEBDPPQFSBÎÍPFEPEJÈMPHPFDPNBPCTFSWÉODJB EPTQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTGFEFSBJTFEP%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP " BUVBÎÍP EB $$"' QPEF TFS DPNQSFFOEJEB NFEJBOUF DBSUJMIB QPTUBEB OP TÓUJPEB"(6F&NFOUÈSJPEF$PODJMJBÎÍPF"SCJUSBHFNEFFEJTQPOÓWFM OPTJUFEB"(6NBOUJEPEB8&# %PSFGFSJEPFNFOUÈSJPTPCSFTTBJVPDPOnJUPBNCJFOUBMFTUBCFMFDJEPFOUSFB 6OJÍPFB6TJOBEF9JOHØEB$PNQBOIJB)JESP&MÏUSJDBEP4ÍP'SBODJTDP$)&4' "BÎÍPDJWJMQÞCMJDBBNCJFOUBMQSPQPTUBQFMP.JOJTUÏSJP1ÞCMJDPGPJFYUJOUBTFNKVM HBNFOUPEFNÏSJUPQPSGBMUBEFJOUFSFTTFEFBHJSNBOJGFTUBEBDPNBWBMJEBÎÍPUÏDOJDB 1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBEJ1BSDFSJBTOB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB&E"UMBTQ #3"/$)&31BVMP4PMVÎÜFTEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBFBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3FWJTUB#SBTJMFJSBEF"SCJUSB HFNOKBONBSQ IUUQXXXBHVHPWCSTJTUFNBTTJUF1BHJOBT*OUFSOBT1VCMJDBDBP&NFOUBSJP$PODJMJBDBPBTQY BDFTTBEP FNKVMIP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 130 Eridane Baptista Furlan EP*OTUJUVUP#SBTJMFJSPEP.FJP"NCJFOUFF3FDVSTPT/BUVSBJT*#"." FNSFMBÎÍP BPTSFTVMUBEPTFFTUVEPTUÏDOJDPTPCUJEPTFYUSBKVEJDJBMNFOUFQFMBSFGFSJEBFNQSFTB 5BJTFTUVEPTQSPWBWBNBBVTÐODJBEFOFYPDBVTBMFOUSFPFWFOUPBNCJFOUBM JNQVUBEPFBTBUJWJEBEFTEBVTJOBFP*#"."OBDPOEJÎÍPEFFOUJEBEFBNCJFOUBMEB 6OJÍPBPFYFSDFSQMFOBNFOUFBTTVBTGVOÎÜFTUÏDOJDBTDPOUSJCVJVQBSBBTPMVÎÍPEB EFNBOEBKVEJDJBMBNCJFOUBM 4VBBUVBÎÍPBJOEBRVFEFFGFJUPTSFnFYPTEFOPUBVNBGVODJPOBMJEBEFBSCJ USBMTPCSFBBÎÍP&TTBGVODJPOBMJEBEFEFOBUVSF[BFYFDVUJWBJOEV[JVËTPMVÎÍPEBEF NBOEBDPODJMJBOEPUFDOJDBNFOUFBEJWFSHÐODJBFTUBCFMFDJEBFOUSFB6OJÍPFB$)&4' DPNQBOIJBJOUFHSBOUFEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBGFEFSBM*OEJSFUB 0FNFOUÈSJPEB$"''USB[PVUSBTIJQØUFTFTBHPSBOBFTGFSBBENJOJTUSBUJWB GFEFSBMBPFYFNQMPEPTQSPDFTTPT WFSTBOEPTPCSFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBTFTUBCFMFDJEBTFOUSFØSHÍPTFFOUJEBEFTEB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP'FEFSBMFODBNJOIBEPTQBSB"EWPHBEB(FSBMEB6OJÍPRVFEFUFSNJOB BTPMVÎÍPBSCJUSBMQFSBOUFB$ÉNBSBEF$PODJMJBÎÍPF"SCJUSBHFNEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 'FEFSBM$$"' .BTEBNFTNBGPSNBRVFPDPSSFDPNBBSCJUSBHFNEFTFOWPMWJEBOPÉNCJUP EBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBTBBUVBÎÍPEB$$"'ÏEFOBUVSF[BNFSBNFOUFBENJOJTUSBUJWB QBSBBRVBMB"(6ÏDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFMFHBMNFOUFWPDBDJPOBEB"DPODJMJBÎÍPFBBSCJ USBHFNPQFSBEBTOB$$"'OÍPTFSFGFSFNQSPQSJBNFOUFËBSCJUSBHFNEB-FJ'FEFSBM O¡DPORVBOUPQPTTBNTFBQPJBSOPTSFRVJTJUPTFDSJUÏSJPTEFMB 0NPEFMPGB[QBSUFEBBUVBMQPMÓUJDBQÞCMJDBGFEFSBMBEPUBEBFNGBDFEBDVMUVSB EBMJUJHJPTJEBEFOPÉNCJUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP0PCKFUJWPQSJODJQBMÏBQSJNPSBSOBFTGFSB GFEFSBMBFYFDVÎÍPEBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTFBJOUFSMPDVÎÍPDPNPTEFNBJTFOUFTGFEFSBEPT FWJUBOEPBQSPMJGFSBÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTFOUSFØSHÍPTFFOUJEBEFTEBQSØQSJB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP NJOJNJ[BOEPTVBKVEJDJBMJ[BÎÍPFSFUJSBOEPEP+VEJDJÈSJPBTEFNBOEBTFNBOEBNFOUP /PÉNCJUPFTUBEVBMDPOTJEFSBOEPTFBTBUSJCVJÎÜFTEFBTTFTTPSJBFDPOTVMUP SJBJOFSFOUFTËT1SPDVSBEPSJBT(FSBJTFTTFNPEFMPQPEFSJBTFSSFQMJDBEP 8.3. A Arbitragem no Setor Público Português +ÈOBFYQFSJÐODJBJOUFSOBDJPOBMFODPOUSBNPTBWBOÎPTTJHOJmDBUJWPTOBVUJMJ[B ÎÍPEBBSCJUSBHFN²PDBTPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB1PSUVHVFTBRVFDPNBQVCMJDB ÎÍPEP&TUBUVUPEPT5SJCVOBJT"ENJOJTUSBUJWPTF'JTDBJTNFEJBOUFP%FDSFUP-FJO¡ EFEFBCSJMEFFEFQPJTEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTPOPT5SJCVOBJT"ENJOJTUSBUJWPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 131 o-FJO¡EFEFGFWFSFJSPEFBMUFSBEPQFMB-FJO¡"EFEFGFWFSFJSPEF DPOTBHSPVTFVNBBSCJUSBHFNEFOBUVSF[BQPUFTUBUJWBQBSBB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP %FBDPSEPDPNP"SUEFTTFSFGFSJEPcódexGBDVMUBTFVOJMBUFSBMNFOUFBP BENJOJTUSBEPFYJHJSEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBRVFDFMFCSFDPNQSPNJTTPBSCJUSBM" BSCJUSBHFNOÍPSFTVMUBEBBVUPOPNJBEBWPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTNBTEFVNBGBDVMEBEF MFHBMBTFSFYFSDJEBQFMPBENJOJTUSBEPFJNQPTUBBP&TUBEPBQMJDBOEPTFRVBOUPË DPOTUJUVJÎÍPFGVODJPOBNFOUPEPUSJCVOBMBSCJUSBMPTQSFTTVQPTUPTEBBSCJUSBHFNWP MVOUÈSJBFBENJUJOEPTFSFDVSTPTQBSBP5SJCVOBM$FOUSBM"ENJOJTUSBUJWPBSUEB -FJEF"SCJUSBHFN7PMVOUÈSJB /PDPOUFYUPKVSÓEJDPMFHBMMVTJUBOPTÍPBSCJUSÈWFJTPTMJUÓHJPTTPCSFRVFTUÜFT SFMBUJWBTBDPOUSBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTJODMVTJWFBRVFMFTEFDPSSFOUFTEPTBUPTBENJOJT USBUJWPTEFFYFDVÎÍPSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFDJWJMFYUSBDPOUSBUVBMFFGFUJWBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPEF SFHSFTTPFBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTQBTTÓWFJTEFSFWPHBÎÍPTPCPVUSPTGVOEBNFOUPTRVF OÍPSFTWBMFNTPCSFBTVBWBMJEBEFFPDPOUSPMFJODJEFOUBMEFOPSNBTSFHVMBNFOUBSFT QBSBWJBCJMJ[BSPDPOIFDJNFOUPEFPVUSBTNBUÏSJBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBT &YDFQDJPOBNTFPNÏSJUPEPTBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTPTBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPT QSFQBSBUØSJPTEBDFMFCSBÎÍPEFDPOUSBUPTPDPOUFODJPTPHFSBMEPTBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJ WPTFBTOPSNBTSFHVMBNFOUBSFTBWBMJBEBTDPNPRVFTUÜFTQSJODJQBJT 9. CONCLUSÃO %F UPEP FYQPTUP PCTFSWBTF RVF P JOTUJUVP EB BSCJUSBHFN VUJMJ[BEB QFMP &TUBEP OB GPSNVMBÎÍP PV OB FYFDVÎÍP EF QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT BJOEB OB SFTPMVÎÍP EFDPOnJUPTFOUSFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTQPMÓUJDBTHPWFSOBNFOUBJTTFUPSJBJTPVJOUFSTF UPSJBJTNFEJBOUFPTTFVTØSHÍPTPVFOUJEBEFTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTEJSFUBTPVJOEJSFUBT OÍPTFDPOGVOEFDPNBBSCJUSBHFNEJTDJQMJOBEBQFMB-FJ'FEFSBMO¡BJOEB RVFTFVUJMJ[FNBMHVOTEFTFVTFMFNFOUPTQPJTTFUSBUBEFBUJWJEBEFFTUBUBMQSJNÈSJB "SFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTOBGPSNBEFTVBMFHJTMBÎÍPFTQFDÓmDBPVFTQBSTBBBS CJUSBHFNQBSFDFOPTBVUPSJ[BEBBQFOBTOPTDBTPTFNRVFP&TUBEPmHVSFOBQPTJÎÍPEF QBSUJDVMBSPVTFKBRVBOEPOÍPIPVWFSEJTDVTTÍPFOWPMWFOEPEJSFJUPTJOEJTQPOÓWFJT /PFOUBOUPBBSCJUSBHFNEJTDJQMJOBEBQFMB-'DPNPBBUJWJEBEF BSCJUSBMFYFSDJEBQFMP&TUBEPOPÉNCJUPEFTVBTJODJEÐODJBTBQSFTFOUBNTFFmDB[FT F FmDJFOUFT BP BQSJNPSBNFOUP EBT QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT EP EFTFNQFOIP EBT GVOÎÜFT FTUBUBJTSFEV[JOEPBEFNBOEBEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPJOEV[JOEPËPUJNJ[BÎÍPEPFYFS DÓDJPEBGVOÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMOBFGFUJWBÎÍPEFEJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBTJOEJWJEVBJTFTPDJBJT GVOEBNFOUBJTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFQPTJUJWBEPT #"330$"4 .BOVFM 1FSFJSB .BOVBM EF BSCJUSBHFN *4#/ &E "MNFEJOB 4" $PJNCSBQB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 132 Eridane Baptista Furlan BIBLIOGRAFIA "-&.'BCJP1FESP$PM1SÈUJDBEP%JSFJUPW&E4BSBJWB #"/%&*3"%&.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPFE&EJUPSB .BMIFJSPT4ÍP1BVMP1 #"$$&--"3-VJ[3JDBSEP5SJOEBEF'VOÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMEBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3F WJTUBEF1SPDFTTPOKVOTFUQ #"3$&--04"OB1BVMBEF"FmDÈDJBKVSÓEJDBEPTQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTPQSJODÓQJP EBEJHOJEBEFIVNBOB3JPEFKBOFJSP3FOPWBSQF #"330$"4.BOVFM1FSFJSB.BOVBMEFBSCJUSBHFN*4#/&E"M NFEJOB4"$PJNCSBQB #"6."/;JHNVOU-FHJTMBEPSFTF*OUÏSQSFUFTTPCSFNPEFSOJEBEFQØTNPEFSOJEBEFF JOUFMFDUVBJT;JHNVOU#BVNBOUSBEVÎÍP3FOBUP"HVJBSo3JPEF+BOFJSP;BIBS #3"/$)&31BVMP4PMVÎÜFTEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBFBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3FWJTUB#SBTJMFJSB EF"SCJUSBHFNOKBONBSQ #6$$*.BSJB1BVMB%BMMBSJ"TQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTFPEJSFJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP3FWJTUBUSJ NFTUSBMEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.BMIFJSPTQ$¬."3" "MFYBOESF'SFJUBT"SCJUSBHFN-FJOFEJÎÍPSFWJTUBBNQMJBEBFBUVBMJ[B EB-VNFO+VSJT $¬."3""MFYBOESFEF'SFJUBT"SCJUSBHFNOPTDPOnJUPTFOWPMWFOEPBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3F WJTUBEF%JSFJUPEB"TTPDJBÎÍPEPT1SPDVSBEPSFTEP/PWP&TUBEPEP3JPEF+BOFJSPO $"/&-"+6/*030TXBMEP"FGFUJWBÎÍPEPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTBUSBWÏTEPQSPDFTTP DPMFUJWPVNOPWPNPEFMPEFKVSJTEJÎÍPUSBCBMIPEFRVBMJmDBÎÍPEFEPVUPSBEPBQSFTFO UBEPË641TPCBPSJFOUBÎÍPEF,B[VP8BUBOBCF JOÏEJUP11 $"3%040"OESÏ(VTLPX*4#/"SCJUSBHFNFQPEFSQÞCMJDPDPPSEFOB ÎÍP$FTBS"(VJNBSÍFT1FSFJSB&EVBSEP5BMBNJOJo4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ $"3.0/"$BSMPT"MCFSUP"SCJUSBHFNFQSPDFTTPVNDPNFOUÈSJPË-FJFE 4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT $0/45*56*±°0'&%&3"-%&BSU $045"/JMUPO$ÏTBS"OUVOFTEB1PEFSFTEP«SCJUSPEFBDPSEPDPNBMFJO 4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ &426¶7&-+PTÏ-VÓT0TDPOUSBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFBBSCJUSBHFN$PJNCSB"MNFEJOB '&33"3&4*&VSJDP.PEFMPTQSPDFTTVBJTDPMFUJWPTDPNQBSBÎÍPFOUSFBÎÍPQPQVMBSBÎÍP DJWJMQÞCMJDBFNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPMFUJWPUFTFEFEPVUPSBNFOUPEFGFOEJEBOB'BDVMEB EFEF%JSFJUPEB641PSJFOUBEPSB"EB1FMMFHSJOJ(SJOPWFS OPQSFMPQ ("+"3%0/*''5ÏDOJDBTEFBDFMFSBÎÍPEPQSPDFTTP4ÍP1BVMP-FNPT$SV[ (3"6&SPT3PCFSUP1MBOFKBNFOUP&DPOÙNJDPF3FHSB+VSÓEJDB4ÍP1BVMPFEEPBVUPS Q (3*/07&3"EB1FMMFHSJOJ0DPOUSPMFEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTQFMP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP3FWJT UBEF1SPDFTTP4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTWQ +645&/ '*-)0 .BSÎBM $VSTP EF %JSFJUP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP &E 4ÍP 1BVMP 4BSBJWB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 A arbitragem nos conflitos entre políticas públicas 133 Q +645&/'*-)0.BSÎBM0EJSFJUPEBTBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBTJOEFQFOEFOUFT%JBMÏUJDB .";;""MFYBOESFo"HÐODJBT3FHVMBEPSBT.BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT-UEB*4#/ Q .03*/&EHBSo*OUSPEVÎÍPBP1FOTBNFOUP$PNQMFYP&EHBS.PSJO5SBEVÎÍPEF&MJBOF -JTCPBo1PSUP"MFHSF4VMJOB&EJÎÍPoQ .063" -VJ[ 'FSOBOEP IUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSFWJTUBBVUPSMVJ[GFSOBOEPEFNPVSB SBNPTBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP .03"&4-VJ[3BOHFMEF"SCJUSBHFNFBHÐODJBTSFHVMBEPSBT3FWJTUBEF"SCJUSBHFNF .FEJBÎÍPONBJPBHP353Q 1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBEJ1BSDFSJBTOB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB&E"UMBTQ 5«$*50$BJP0+VÓ[P"SCJUSBMFN%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP*O(BSDF[+PTÏ.BSJB3PTTBOJ ."35*/41FESP#BUJTUB3FnFYÜFTTPCSFB"SCJUSBHFN4ÍP1BVMP-5SQ 5"-".*/*&EVBSEP"SCJUSBHFNF1BSDFSJB1ÞCMJDP1SJWBEB111 *O@@$PPSE 1BSDFSJBT 1ÞCMJDP1SJWBEBT6NFOGPRVFNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBS4ÍP1BVMP35Q 5033&43JDBSEP-PCP0NÓOJNPFYJTUFODJBMFPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJT3FWJTUBEF%J SFJUPEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBM3JPEF+BOFJSPOKVMTFUQ 4;-"3084,:-FPO'SFEKB6NBOPWBWJTÍPEBBSCJUSBHFN/#3"#/5+VT /BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPOKVM%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSF WJTUBUFYUP"DFTTPFNKVMIP4;,-"3084,:-FPO'SFEKBIUUQXXX GBDUVNDPNCSBSUJHPTIUNBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP "SCJUSBHFNF1BSDFSJB1ÞCMJDP1SJWBEB111 *O1BSDFSJBT1ÞCMJDP1SJWBEBT6N&OGPRVF .VMUJEJTDJQMJOBSDPPSE&EVBSEP5BMBNJOJF.POJDB4QF[JB+VTUFO 4ÍP1BVMP35 QF $POUSBUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPFB-FJEF"SCJUSBHFN3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPo3%" OQ IUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCSDDJWJM@DPOTUJUVJDBPDPOTUJUVJ$"BPIUNBDFTTBEPFN oQSFÉNCVMP IUUQQSFTTSPPNJQDVOEQPSHCSBTJMBWBODBOPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPIVNBOPFTPCF VNBQPTJDBPOPSBOLJOHEPJEI MBOHQUCSBDFTTBEPFN IUUQXXXDPOKVSDPNCSNBJKVEJDJBMJ[BDBPGBUPBUJWJTNPBUJUVEFDPOTUJUVDJP OBMJTUBBDFTTBEPFNEFKVMIPEF 3&TQ 3/ 3FM .JO -VJ[ 'VY 1SJNFJSB 5VSNB KVMHBEP FN %+F IUUQSFEJSTUGKVTCSQBHJOBEPSQVCQBHJOBEPSKTQ EPD51"$EPD*% BDFTTBEP FNBHPTUP IUUQXXXTUGKVTCSQPSUBMDNTWFS5FYUPBTQ TFSWJDPQSPDFTTP"VEJFODJB1VCMJDB"DBP"m SNBUJWBBDFTTPFNKVMIP IUUQXXXDPOKVSDPNCSEF[TUG@EFDMBSB@MFJ@BSCJUSBHFN@DPOTUJUVDJPOBM"DFT TBEPFNEFKVMIPEF IUUQXXXTUGKVTCSQPSUBMQSPDFTTPWFS1SPDFTTP"OEBNFOUPBTQ JODJEFOUF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 107 a 134 "DFTTBEPFNEFKVMIPEF IUUQSFEJSTUGKVTCSQBHJOBEPSQVCQBHJOBEPSKTQ EPD51"$EPD*% 45' 4&$O¡PSJVOEBEP3FJOP6OJEPEB(SÍ#SFUBOIBFEB*SMBOEBEP/PSUF"DØSEÍP EF%+EF&NFOUÈSJPO¡BDFTTBEPFN 3&TQ34F34F"H3FH.4O%'SFTQFDUJWBNFOUFQSPGFSJEPTFN F45+BDFTTBEPTFNBHPTUP IUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCS$DJWJM@%FDSFUP-FJ%FMIUN BDFTTBEP FN KV MIP IUUQXXXQMBOBMUPHPWCSDDJWJM@MFJTMIUNBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP IUUQXXXBHVHPWCSTJTUFNBTTJUF1BHJOBT*OUFSOBT1VCMJDBDBP&NFOUBSJP$PODJMJBDBP BTQYBDFTTBEPFNKVMIP ALGUMAS CONSIDERAÇÕES SOBRE O DIREITO AMBIENTAL E O IMPACTO DAS EXPLORAÇÕES DE PETRÓLEO Some considerations about environmental law and the impact of petroleum haldings José Fernando Cedeño de Barros1 Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos2 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP*NQBDUPBNCJFOUBMEBT&YQMPSBÎÜFT1FUSPMÓGFSBT0T1SJODÓQJPTEB 5VUFMB"NCJFOUBM6NQBOPSBNBEBQPMVJÎÍPEFDPSSFOUFEPQFUSØMFP$PODMVTÍP "MHVNBTTVHFTUÜFTQBSBP#SBTJMFP.&3$046-#JCMJPHSBmB RESUMO $POWFOÎÜFT*OUFSOBDJPOBJTJNQBDUPTBPNFJPBNCJFOUFEFDPSSFOUFTEBBÎÍPIVNBOB EJSFJUPFUVUFMBTQSFWFOUJWBTËDPOTFDVÎÍPEBQSFWFOÎÍPEPNBSFEBT[POBTDPTUFJSBT TVCTUÉODJBTQPMVJEPSBTDPOUSJCVJÎÍPEPQFUSØMFPQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFTVBQBS DFMBDPNPBHFOUFQPMVJEPS SUMMARY *OUFSOBUJPOBM $POWFOUJPOT JNQBDUT PO UIF FOWJSPONFOU EVF UP IVNBO BDUJPO QSFWFOUJWF MBX BOE HVBSEJBOTIJQT UP BDIJFWF UIF QSFWFOUJPO PG TFB BOE DPBTUBM [POFTQPMMVUJOHTVCTUBODFTPJMDPOUSJCVUJPOUPUIFEFWFMPQNFOUBOEJUTTIBSFBTB QPMMVUBOU Palavras chaves$POWFOÎÜFT*OUFSOBDJPOBJT.FJPBNCJFOUF1SFWFOÎÍP1PMVJÎÍP 1FUSØMFP Keywords*OUFSOBUJPOBM$POWFOUJPOT&OWJSPONFOU1SFWFOUJPO1PMVJÎÍP0JM 1. INTRODUÇÃO "TPDJFEBEFNPEFSOBFTUÈJOUFJSBNFOUFWJODVMBEBBPTFMFNFOUPTGPSOFDFEPSFT EFFOFSHJBDPNEFTUBRVFQBSBPQFUSØMFPDPOTVNJEPFNMBSHBFTDBMBNVOEJBMNFOUF OÍPTPNFOUFQBSBGPSOFDFSDPNCVTUÓWFJTNBTQBSBQSPWFSBTNBUÏSJBTQSJNBTOFDFT TÈSJBTBVNBDSFTDFOUFEFNBOEBEFQSPEVUPTQMÈTUJDPTFTJOUÏUJDPTEFUPEPTPTUJQPT "MBSHBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEPQFUSØMFPUFNVNQSFÎPBQSPEVÎÍPHMPCBMUFNVNFGFJUP QPMVFOUFTJHOJmDBUJWPQSJODJQBMNFOUFOPTPDFBOPTFMJUPSBJT "FYQMPSBÎÍPEPQFUSØMFPJNCSJDBOPFTUVEPEBQSPUFÎÍPEBT[POBTDPTUFJSBT FNBSJOIBT 4FHVOEPPWorld Resources InstituteBT[POBTDPTUFJSBTTÍPDPOTJEFSBEBTDPNP ÈSFBTPOEFBJOnVÐODJBEBUFSSBFEPNBSTFFODPOUSBNFJOUFSBHFN .#"FN(FTUÍPEF1FUSØMFP(ÈTQFMB'VOEBÎÍP&TDPMBEF$PNÏSDJP«MWBSFT1FOUFBEP'&$"1 .FTUSFFN%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM5SJCVUÈSJPQFMB'BDVMEBEFEF%JSFJUPEB641&YCPMTJTUBEB$"1&4%' QFMB'BDVMUÏEF%SPJUFUEFTTDJFODFTÏDPOPNJRVFTEFM}6OJWFSTJUÏ.POUQFMMJFS*'SBOÎB "EWPHBEPEF FNQSFTBTQFMB6OJWFSTJEBEF.BDLFO[JF #BDIBSFMFN%JSFJUPQFMB6OJWFSTJEBEF1SFTCJUFSJBOB.BDLFO[JF 136 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos 0TQSJODJQBJTFDPTTJTUFNBTDPTUFJSPTEPNVOEPFTUÍPQPUFODJBMNFOUFBNFB ÎBEPTQFMPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPOÍPTVTUFOUÈWFMNÈYJNFQPSRVFFNCPSBBT[POBTDPT UFJSBTPDVQFNBQFOBTEBTVQFSGÓDJFEBUFSSBNBJTEFEBQPQVMBÎÍPNVOEJBM TFFODPOUSBOFTTBTSFHJÜFTDG6/$&% "FYQMPSBÎÍPEPQFUSØMFPTFEÈNPEFSOBNFOUFTPCSFUVEPOBTSFGFSJEBTSF HJÜFTDPTUFJSBTFMJUPSÉOFBTBNFBÎBOEPPNFJPBNCJFOUFJOnVJOEPEJSFUBNFOUFOB RVFTUÍPEBUVUFMBJOUFHSBMEPBNCJFOUF "EJDPUPNJBFOUSFBQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDP OÙNJDPQPEFBUJOHJSMJNJUFTFYUSFNPTDPOGPSNFCFNBTTJOBMB(JBNQJFSP%J1MJOJP3. 0 HPWFSOP DBOBEFOTF UFNTF NPTUSBEP NVJUP QSFPDVQBEP DPN P QSPCMFNB BNCJFOUBMMJHBEPËFYQMPSBÎÍPEFQFUSØMFP/FTTFTFOUJEPQVCMJDPVPInformation Bulletin – Offshore Oil Spill Cleanup – A discussion of the methods by which oil can be cleaned up at sea (#PMFUJN*OGPSNBUJWPo-JNQF[BEPT%FSSBNBNFOUPTEF»MFPBPMBSHPo"OÈMJTF EPTNÏUPEPTBUSBWÏTEPTRVBJTQPEFTFSGFJUBBMJNQF[BEPØMFPEPNBS BTTJOBMBOEP 0ØMFPDIFHBBPBNCJFOUFNBSJOIPBQBSUJSEFEJWFSTBTSPUBTFQPSVNB HSBOEF WBSJFEBEF EF NPUJWPT "T NBJPSFT GPOUFT EF ØMFP EFSSBNBEP BP MBSHP TÍP PT BDJEFOUFT FOWPMWFOEP QFUSPMFJSPT F PT FTDBQFT SFQFOUJOPTEFØMFPFHÈTEFWJEPËFYQMPSBÎÍPEFTUFTFEBTJOTUBMBÎÜFT EFQSPEVÎÍP7BMFSFTTBMUBSFOUSFUBOUPRVFPØMFPEFTUBTEVBTGPOUFT DPOTUJUVJBQFOBTBQSPYJNBEBNFOUFEBRVBOUJEBEFUPUBMEFØMFP RVFÏEFTQFKBEPOPPDFBOP %JWFSTBTUFPSJBTGPSBNEFTFOWPMWJEBTOPTFOUJEPEBQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBN CJFOUFQBSFDFOEPOPTBNBJTDPSSFUBBRVFQSFDPOJ[BBDPOTUSVÎÍPEPVUSJOÈSJBFMF HJTMBUJWBEFVNEJSFJUPEPBNCJFOUFËQSPUFÎÍPKVSÓEJDBRVFGPJDVSJPTBNFOUFFEJm DBEBQFMBBUVBÎÍPKVSJTQSVEFODJBMBQBSUJSEFFMFNFOUPTEF%JSFJUP$JWJMFEBQSÈYJT EPFTUVEPEFDBTPDPNBBEPÎÍPEBequityDPNPFMFNFOUPEFUFSNJOBEPSEBBUVBÎÍP QPTJUJWBEP%JSFJUPSFTVMUBOEPFNVNUSBCBMIPKVEJDJBMPSJHJOBMEFKVOÎÍPEP%JSFJUP EFDVOIPSPNBOÓTUJDPFEBcommon LawBSFWFMBSBHMPCBMJ[BÎÍPDSFTDFOUFEBTFTGFSBT EFBUVBÎÍPEBIVNBOJEBEF 1BSFDFOPTRVFBNFMIPSTPMVÎÍPSFTJEFOBFYQSFTTÍPUÍPCFNDPOTUSVÓEBQPS #SVOEUMBOE %FTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMÏBTBUJTGBÎÍPEBTOFDFTTJEBEFTEPQSFTFOUF TFNDPNQSPNFUFSBDBQBDJEBEFEBTHFSBÎÜFTGVUVSBTQBSBTBUJTGB[FSFN BTTVBTQSØQSJBTOFDFTTJEBEFTJO0VS$PNNPO'VUVSF $PNFGFJUP 3 Principi di Diritto Ambientale(JVGGSÒ&EJUPSF.JMÍPoTFHVJOUFT. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 137 " FYQMPSBÎÍP F P EFTFOWPMWJNFOUP EPT DBNQPT EF FYQMPSBÎÍP EP QFUSØMFP EFWFNFTUBSBUSFMBEPTËTFHVSBOÎBPQFSBDJPOBMFBPJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBM %FMJNJUBNPTOPTTPFTUVEPOPQSFTFOUFBSUJHPBVNQFSGVODUØSJPFYBNFEB RVFTUÍPUÏDOJDBEBFYQMPSBÎÍPQFUSPMÓGFSBEFTFOWPMWFOEPNBJTQSPGVOEBNFOUFVNB BOÈMJTFBSFTQFJUPEPTQSPCMFNBTMPDBJTBUJOFOUFTBPNFJPBNCJFOUF "TJOEÞTUSJBTEPQFUSØMFPFEPHÈTFTUÍPGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFMJHBEBTBPNFJPBN CJFOUFFNWJSUVEFEPTBDJEFOUFTNVJUPDPNVOTJOGFMJ[NFOUFRVFPDPSSFNOFTTFDBNQP +PSHF4BMHBEP(PNFTF'FSOBOEP#BSBUB"MWFT BHSVQBNPTBDJEFOUFTDPN QFUSØMFPFNUSÐTDBUFHPSJBTQSJODJQBJT tPTEFSSBNFTEFQFUSØMFPUBOUPFNUFSSBRVBOUPOPNBS tBTFNJTTÜFTHBTPTBTQBSBBBUNPTGFSB tBTBMUFSBÎÜFTOBTVQFSGÓDJFUFSSFTUSFEFTEFBTnPSFTUBTUSPQJDBJTBUÏPTEFTFS UPTQBTTBOEPQFMBT[POBTIBCJUBEBT 0TFTUVEPTEPJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBMUPNBNVNBEJNFOTÍPCBTUBOUFJNQPSUBOUF QBSBRVFTFQPTTBDPOUSJCVJSEFDJTJWBNFOUFOPTFOUJEPEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFM %JWFSTPTSBNPTEP%JSFJUPFVNBEJWFSTJEBEFCBTUBOUFJNQPSUBOUFEFMFHJTMBÎÜFT EFQBÓTFTEJWFSTPTTFSFWFMBNOPRVFUBOHFBPQFUSØMFPVNBWF[RVFBTFNQSFTBTFY QMPSBEPSBTEPTIJESPDBSCPOFUPTOPSNBMNFOUFOÍPTÍPOBDJPOBJTOPTUFSSJUØSJPTPOEFTF EFEJDBNËFYQMPSBÎÍPQFUSPMÓGFSB 4PGSFNPTQPSUBOUPQBSBBMÏNEPTEBOPTBNCJFOUBJTPJNQBDUPEBHMPCBMJ [BÎÍPFEBUSBOTOBDJPOBMJEBEF /FTUFTFOUJEPQPTJDJPOBNTF%J1MJOJPF'JSNJBOJ /FMM}BNCJUP EFMMB SJDFSDB EFJ GBUUPSJ JODJEFOUJ TVMMB DPOGPSNB[JPOF WJWFOUFEFMEJSJUUPBNCJFOUBMFWJÒVOBMUSPBTQFUUPEBDPOTJEFSBSFOFM RVBESPBUUVBMFEFJHSBOEJQSPDFTTJEJUSBTGPSNB[JPOFFNPOEJBMJ[[B[JPOF EFMM}FDPOPNJB MF MFHJTMB[JPOJ BNCJFOUBMJ QPTTPOP EJWFOJSF PTUBDPMJ QPUFOUJBMMBDSFB[JPOFEJBSFFEJMJCFSPTDBNCJPBMMBJOUFHSB[JPOFEFJ NFSDBUJBMMBSFBMJ[[B[JPOFQJFOBEFJQSJODJQJEJMJCFSUËEJDPODPSSFO[B 4JDPOTJEFSJOPBEFTFNQJPEVFJNQSFTFPNPHFOOFEBMQVOUPEJWJTUB EJ QSPEPUUP F TUSVUUVSB QSPEVUUJWB VOB MPDBMJ[[BUB JO *UBMJB M}BMUSB JO 'SBODJB TF JM EJSJUUP BNCJFOUBMF JUBMJBOP QPOF NFOP WJODPMJ B RVFM UJQP EJ JNQSFTB SJTQFUUP BM EJSJUUP GSBODFTF M}JNQSFTB JUBMJBOB BWSË NJOPSJDPTUJFEVORVFHPESËEJVOWBOUBHHJPDPNQBSBUPJOUFSNJOJEJ DPNQFUJUJWJUËQPUSËWFOEFSFJO'SBODJBBQSF[[JJOGFSJPSJSJTQFUUPBMMË JNQSFTB GSBODFTF EFSJWBOUF OPO EBMMB EJWFSTB DBQBDJUË FE FGmDJFO[B O Universo da Indústria Petrolífera – Da Pesquisa à 3FmOBÎÍP-JTCPB'VOEBÎÍP$BMPVTUF(VMCFOLJBO Q Principi di Diritto AmbientaleDJUQQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 138 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos EFJ EVF JNQSFOEJUPSJ NB EBMM}BTJNNFUSJB EFJ EVF EJSJUUJ BNCJFOUBMJ $PODPSSFO[B F NFSDBUP VOJDP TBSFCCFSP JO RVFTUP DBTP HSBWFNFOUF DPNQSPNFTTJ F QFSUBOUP MB $PNVOJUË FVSPQFB JOUFSWFSSË EFUUBOEP SFHPMF EJ BSNPOJ[[B[JPOF EFMMF MFHJTMB[JPOJ JO NBUÏSJB BNCJFOUBMF "MUSPFTFNQJPMBMJCFSUËEFMNFSDBUPFEFMMBDPODPSSFO[BQSFTVQQPOF M}JOFTJTUFO[BEJMJNJUB[JPOJFWJODPMJBMM}JNQPSUB[JPOFJOVOP4UBUPEJVOB NFSDFQSPWFOJFOUFEBVOBMUSP4UBUPRVFTUJWJODPMJQPTTPOPFTTFSFEJ PSEJOFUSJCVUBSJPNBQPTTPOPDPOTJTUFSFBODIFJONJTVSFRVBOUJUBUJWF FTFNQJPJDPOUJOHFOUBNFOUJ PQQVSFJOSFHPMFHJVSJEJDIFPUFDOJDIF iFRVJWBMFOUJBSFTUSJ[JPOJRVBOUJUBUJWFwJMEJSJUUPEFMM}BNCJFOUFQVÛEB RVFTUPQVOUPEJWJTUBFTTFSFVUJMJ[[BUPEBVOP4UBUPQFSEFUUBSFSFHPMF JOFSFOUJBEFTFNQJPDFSUFRVBMJUËEJQSPEPUUJPEFJMPSPJNCBMMBHHJUBMJ DIF TVM QSØQSJP UFSSJUPSJP QPTTBOP EJ GBUUP FTTFSF DPNNFSDJBMJ[[BUJ TPMUBOUPNFSDJQSPEPUUFEBMMFJNQSFTFOB[JPOBMJ"ODIFDPOUSPRVFTUP FWFOJFO[F MF JTUJUV[JPOJ DPNVOJUBSJF IBOOP TWJMVQQBUP TUSVNFOUJ BEFRVBUJ EJ SJTQPTUB PMUSF BMMF EJSFUUJWF EJ VOJGPSNJ[[B[JPOF EFJ EJSJUUJ BNCJFOUBMJ DPNF MF QSPDFEVSF EJ FTBNF F EJ DPOUSPMMP EFMMF MFHJTMB[JPOJ OB[JPOBMJ F J QSJODJQJ EJ iNVUVP SPDPOPTDJNFOUPw F EJ iFRVJWBMFO[B EFMMF MFHJTMB[JPOJw JO CBTF BJ RVBMJ VOP 4UBUP OPO QVÛ JNQFEJSFMBDPNNFSDJBMJ[[B[JPOFOFMQSØQSJPUFSJUPSJPEJQSPEPUUJMBDVJ DPNQBUJCJMJUËBNCJFOUBMFÒDFSUJmDBUBJOVOBMUSP4UBUP %J 1MJOJP F 'JSNJBOJ BJOEB EFTUBDBN BT QSFTTÜFT RVF P DBQJUBMJTNP FYFSDF TPCSFBMFHJTMBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMOPÉNCJUPJOUFSOBDJPOBMOPTFOUJEPEFQSPUFHFSPTJT UFNBDPNFSDJBMNVMUJMBUFSBMBWPDBOEPVNBIJQPUÏUJDBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFPCTFSWÉODJB EPQSJODÓQJPEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMNFSDÐEFVNBMFHJTMBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMFT UBOEBSEJ[BEBFVOJGPSNFRVFTPCSFQVKBSJBVNBMFHJTMBÎÍPOBDJPOBMNBJTSBDJPOBMRVF QPEFSJBJNQFEJSPDBSÈUFSBCFSUPFRVJUBUJWPFOÍPEJTDSJNJOBUØSJPEBTUSPDBTDPNFS DJBJTOPUBEBNFOUFEPQFUSØMFPFEFTFVTEFSJWBEPT. $BCFGSJTBSRVFÏEPJOUFSFTTFEBTQSØQSJBTDPNQBOIJBTQFUSPMÓGFSBTDPOUSJ CVJSQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP TVTUFOUÈWFM QFSNJUJOEP B JOUFSBÎÍP FOUSF VN QSPKFUP EFFYQMPSBÎÍPEFQFUSØMFPFBQSPUFÎÍPEPBNCJFOUFRVFPSPEFJBUBOUPBTTJNRVFBT FYQMPSBÎÜFTQFUSPMÓGFSBTEFWFNFTUBSTVCNFUJEBTQSFWJBNFOUFBPTFTUVEPTEFJNQBDUP BNCJFOUBMenvironnmental impact assessment – EIA)5BJTFTUVEPTOÍPmDBNWJODVMB EPTBQFOBTËTFNQSFTBTJOUFSFTTBEBTNBTTÍPTVCNFUJEPTBPTHPWFSOPTFBPQÞCMJDP FNHFSBMEJSFJUPEFJOGPSNBÎÍP PCDJUQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 139 2. IMPACTO AMBIENTAL DAS EXPLORAÇÕES PETROLÍFERAS " FYQMPSBÎÍP EP QFUSØMFP EFQFOEF QSFWJBNFOUF EF FTUVEPT BNCJFOUBJT HMPCBMJ[BEPT $SJUÏSJPTNVJUPFTQFDÓmDPTTÍPBCPSEBEPTDPNPQPSFYFNQMPBSFDVQFSBÎÍP EP$0BTDPOEJÎÜFTHFPHSÈmDBTUPQPHSBmBNBSFTBCFSUPTPVGFDIBEPTQSPYJNJ EBEFTEFDJEBEFTFUD JNQBDUPTEFDPSSFOUFTEBTBUJWJEBEFTRVFFOWPMWFNSFmOBSJBT UFSNJOBJTQJQFMJOFTFPVUSPTRVFQPEFNQÙSFNSJTDPBTFHVSBOÎBEBTQPQVMBÎÜFTF EPQSØQSJPNFJPBNCJFOUF 0FTUVEPEFWFSÈJEFOUJmDBSBPNFOPTPJUPJUFOT JEFOUJmDBSPTJNQBDUPTFSJTDPTOPTFSIVNBOPOPBNCJFOUFOBTQSPQSJF EBEFTOBSFQVUBÎÍPFOPTBTQFDUPTFDPOÙNJDPT SFEV[JSPTJNQBDUPTBOÓWFJTNÓOJNPTEFBDFJUBÎÍPPVFMJNJOÈMPTTFQPTTÓWFM EBSDVNQSJNFOUPBPTSFHVMBNFOUPTEBTBHÐODJBTHPWFSOBNFOUBJTEFDBEBQBÓT PCFEFDFSBPTTJTUFNBTEFHFTUÍPEF)4&HSE management system NFMIPSBSBTQSÈUJDBTPQFSBDJPOBJT DPNVOJDBSFFTUBCFMFDFSNFUBTJOEJDBEPSBTEFperformance (KPI – key performance indicators ); BKVTUBSPPSÎBNFOUPPQFSBDJPOBM EJWVMHBSBJNQPSUÉODJBEBTRVFTUÜFTBNCJFOUBJT 0 FTUVEP EP DJDMP FDPOÙNJDP UPSOBTF GVOEBNFOUBM OB NFEJEB FN RVF P TFVOBTDJNFOUPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFFYQMPSBÎÍPBCBSDBNEPJTFMFNFOUPTQSJODJQBJTEF JOUFSFTTFQBSBPOPTTPFTUVEPBBOÈMJTFEBTSJRVF[BTOBUVSBJTFPFTUVEPEPIPNFN "TQSJNFJSBTQPSRVFEFMBTÏRVFEFDPSSFNFNFTTÐODJBBFYJTUÐODJBEBUFSSBFPTF HVOEPQPSRVFQSJODJQBMNFOUFOBÏQPDBDPOUFNQPSÉOFBÏFMFPHSBOEFSFTQPOTÈWFM QPSBMUFSBÎÜFTJOFTQFSBEBTEFVNHSBOEFBMDBODF&NTFHVJEBBQSFTFOUBNTFPDBQJ UBMPVTFKBPNFJPQSÈUJDPEFDSJBSPGBUPSEFQSPEVÎÍPFEPQSPHSFTTPFBGVOÎÍPEB FNQSFTBRVFDPPSEFOBBBÎÍPEFPVUSPTGBUPSFTBTTFHVSBOEPPNÈYJNPEFFmDÈDJB %BDPNQFUÐODJBFEPUSBCBMIPEPFNQSFTÈSJPEFQFOEFNHFSBMNFOUFPÐYJUP EBJOJDJBUJWBUPNBEBFPEPQSPHSFTTPFDPOÙNJDP OFDFTTBSJBNFOUFTVCNFUJEPTËT RVFTUÜFTEBUVUFMBBNCJFOUBM 6NBWJTÍPJOEJWJEVBMJTUBUPSOBSJBJNQPTTÓWFMPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFM #FN QPS JTTP PT GVOEBNFOUPT MFHJTMBUJWPT EB QSPUFÎÍP BNCJFOUBM OBTDFSBN FTTFO DJBMNFOUFEBBUVBÎÍPDPNVOJUÈSJBOPNFBEBNFOUFEB$PNVOJEBEF&VSPQFJBNBJT BGFUBEB NVOEJBMNFOUF QFMPT GFOÙNFOPT EF QPMVJÎÍP EBEB B JOUFOTB DPODFOUSBÎÍP EF QFTTPBT EF DBQJUBJT F EPT SFTVMUBEPT QPS WF[FT DBUBTUSØmDPT EB FYQMPSBÎÍP EBT +PSHF4BMHBEP(PNFTet alDJUQ #BVEIVJOPrincípios de economia contemporânea, volume I – A 1SPEVÎÍP%JGVTÍP&VSPQFJBEP-JWSPo %*'&-1PSUVHBMQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 140 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos SJRVF[BT EB UFSSB DPN EFTUBRVF QBSB P QFUSØMFP F NBJT FTQFDJmDBNFOUF OP RVF TF SFGFSFBPTEBOPTDBVTBEPTBPTNBSFTPDFBOPTFMJUPSBJT 0TMPOHPTFNJOVDJPTPTFTUVEPTMFWBEPTBFGFJUPOFTTBRVFTUÍPDPOEV[JSBN BPFOUFOEJNFOUPVOÉOJNFEFRVFBQSFWFOÎÍPBQSFDBVÎÍPFBDPSSFÎÍPEPTEBOPTOB GPOUFTFSJBNQSJNPSEJBJTTFOEPSBQJEBNFOUFFMFWBEPTËDBUFHPSJBEFQSJODÓQJPTTPC PTRVBJTFTUBSJBNTVCNFUJEPTUPEPTPTEFNBJT 3. OS PRINCÍPIOS DA TUTELA AMBIENTAL 1PEFNPTTJUVBSDPNPNBSDPEBQPMÓUJDBMFHJTMBUJWBBNCJFOUBMJOUFSOBDJPOBMPBOP EFRVBOEPB$PNVOJEBEF&VSPQFJBmSNPVPTFVQSJNFJSP1SPHSBNBEF"ÎÍP"N CJFOUBMFTUBCFMFDFOEPPQSJODÓQJPEBQSFWFOÎÍPPVEBBÎÍPQSFWFOUJWBIPKFSBUJmDBEPTOP BSUJHPEP5SBUBEPEB$PNVOJEBEF&VSPQFJBEBÓEFSJWBOEPBJNQSFTDJOEJCJMJEBEFEPTFT UVEPTQSÏWJPTEFJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBMEFRVBMRVFSBUJWJEBEFFDPOÙNJDBEFDFSUBJNQPSUÉODJB 7FSJmDPVTFBOFDFTTJEBEFEFVNDPOUSBQPOUPBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPDPOTJT UFOUFOBTQPMÓUJDBTEFJOHFSÐODJBFYUSFNBNFOUFDSJUJDBEBTOBEÏDBEBEFEBDFO UÞSJBQBTTBEBRVBOEPPNVOEPPDJEFOUBMTFFODPOUSBWBOPBVHFEPDBQJUBMJTNP "$POGFSÐODJBEFTFEJBEBFN&TUPDPMNPKÈIBWJBQSFDPOJ[BEPBOFDFTTJEBEF EFBIVNBOJEBEFGSFBSPTFVBGÍEFTFOWPMWJNFOUJTUBVNBWF[RVFTFFWJEFODJBWBPEFTHBTUF EPQMBOFUB5FSSBFNWJSUVEFEBFYQMPSBÎÍPNBDJÎBTPCSFUVEPEFIJESPDBSCPOFUPT "QSJNFJSBDPODMVTÍPGPJBEFRVFWJWFNPTUPEPTFNVNNFTNPQMBOFUBTP NPTJOUFSEFQFOEFOUFTFBDPODFQÎÍPEPIPNFNDPNPDFOUSPEPVOJWFSTPEFWFDFEFS MVHBSBVNDPODFJUPNBJTHMPCBMEFRVFBOBUVSF[BUFNTVBTQSØQSJBTFJOFYPSÈWFJT MFJTEFTDPOIFDFOEPGSPOUFJSBTFSFTQPOEFOEPDPNWJPMÐODJBËTBHSFTTÜFTIVNBOBT 7FSJmDPVTFEFJNFEJBUPVNBEJDPUPNJBFOUSFPTDIBNBEPTQBÓTFTEP4VMFPT QBÓTFTEP/PSUFPTQSJNFJSPTBJOEBFNFTUÈHJPTNBJTBUSBTBEPTEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPF PTÞMUJNPTCBTUBOUFBWBOÎBEPTOPRVFUBOHFËÈSFBFDPOÙNJDBDVMUVSBMQPMÓUJDBFJOUF MFDUVBM0TQSJNFJSPTFNCPSBiJOGFSJPSFTwEFVNQPOUPEFWJTUBmOBODFJSPFFDPOÙNJDP TFNPTUSBWBNNVJUPNBJTSFBMJTUBTDPNBTDPOEJÎÜFTEBOBUVSF[BFORVBOUPPTQBÓTFT SJDPTJOEJGFSFOUFTBPTQSPCMFNBTUSB[JEPTQFMBQPMVJÎÍPCVTDBWBNFYQMPSBSBTTPDJFEB EFTSJDBTFNSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFQPCSFTEPQPOUPEFWJTUBFDPOÙNJDPDVMUVSBMFQPMÓUJDP "TFNJTTÜFTUØYJDBTTFSFWFMBSBNNBJTEFTUSVUJWBTOPRVFTFSFGFSFËFYQMPSB ÎÍPEFQFUSØMFPOBTFYUFOTÜFTNBSÓUJNBT "$POGFSÐODJBEP3JPEFDPOTBHSPVPQBQFMEFQSPUBHPOJTUBBPTQPWPT EFOPNJOBEPTBVUØDUPOFTPVTFKBBRVFMFTQPWPTDVKBSFMBÎÍPDPNBTUFSSBTTFEJTUJO HVJVEBTEFNBJTDJWJMJ[BÎÜFTTFOEPDPOTJEFSBEPTiFNIBSNPOJBDPNBOBUVSF[Bw. -ZEJB WBO EF 'MJFSU PSHBOJ[BEPSB Indigneous Peoples and International Organisations /PUUJOHIBN 4QPLFTNBO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 141 0TEPDVNFOUPTMFHJTMBUJWPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTDBCFSFQJTBSUÐNUJEPVNQBQFM NVJUPJNQPSUBOUFOPEPNÓOJPEBQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUF 7BNPTEFTUBDBSBMHVNBTEBTQSJODJQBJTDPOWFOÎÜFTTPCSFPNFJPBNCJFOUF RVFEFTWFOEBSBNOPWPTSVNPTQBSBBQSPUFÎÍPEBOBUVSF[B A) A Convenção de Basileia $PNPÏTBCJEPPTEFKFUPTOÍPUÐNGSPOUFJSBT/BNFEJEBFNRVFBEFUF SJPSBÎÍPEPFDPTTJTUFNBNVOEJBMTFBHSBWBPNFJPBNCJFOUFWFNTFUPSOBOEPVN FMFNFOUPQSJPSJUÈSJPOBQPMÓUJDBJOUFSOBDJPOBM 0TNPWJNFOUPTUSBOTGSPOUFJSJÎPTEFEFKFUPTQFSJHPTPTFEFTVBFMJNJOBÎÍPGP SBNEFWJEBNFOUFFOGSFOUBEPTQFMBMFHJTMBÎÍPJOUFSOBDJPOBMDVMNJOBOEPDPNB$POWFO ÎÍPEF#BTJMFJBRVFFNQSPJCJVUPUBMNFOUFBFYQPSUBÎÍPEFEFKFUPTQFSJHPTPTQBSB PTQBÓTFTEB0$%&0SHBOJ[BÎÍPEF$PPQFSBÎÍPFEF%FTFOWPMWJNFOUP&DPOÙNJDP 0QBQFMEB0$%&GPJEFDJTJWPQBSBmSNBSPDPOUSPMFEPTNPWJNFOUPTUSBOT GSPOUFJSJÎPTEFEFKFUPTQFSJHPTPTFEFTVBFMJNJOBÎÍPDPOTUJUVJOEPBQSPWBNBJTDPO WJODFOUFEBFmDÈDJBEFVNiCMPDPQMBOFUÈSJPwFEFTVBDBQBDJEBEFQPUFODJBMEFGB[FS TBJSEBJOÏSDJBPEJSFJUPJOUFSOBDJPOBMEPNFJPBNCJFOUF. NFNCSPTEPi(SVQPEPTwDPOTFHVJSBNDPOTUSBOHFSPTHPWFSOPTEB "VTUSÈMJBEB«VTUSJBEPT&TUBEPT6OJEPTEP+BQÍPEP$BOBEÈEFEP[FNFNCSPTEB 6OJÍP&VSPQFJBBTTJNDPNPB$PNJTTÍPEF#SVYFMBTBBEPUBSFTUBQSPJCJÎÍP&WJEFO UFNFOUFBDPOUSBHPTUPVNBWF[RVFPTSFGFSJEPTQBÓTFTDPOTJEFSBNBTNFEJEBTEF QSPUFÎÍPEFTGBWPSÈWFJTBPTJOUFSFTTFTEFTVBTJOEÞTUSJBTFEFTFVWÓODVMPBPQSJODÓQJP EPMJWSFDÉNCJPVNBWF[RVFPTEFKFUPTQFSJHPTPTFSBNDPOTJEFSBEPTVNQSPEVUP B) A Convenção de Helsinki "$POWFOÎÍP4PCSFB1SPUFÎÍPEP"NCJFOUF.BSJOIPOB3FHJÍPEP.BS#ÈM UJDPNBJTDPOIFDJEBDPNPB$POWFOÎÍPEF)FMTJOLJFQFMPUSBCBMIPEB$PNJTTÍPEF )FMTJOLJ)&-$0. GPJQMBOFKBEBQBSBQSPUFHFSBSFHJÍPEPNBS#ÈMUJDPEBQPMVJÎÍP &TTFEPDVNFOUPGPJBTTJOBEPFNQPS%JOBNBSDB'JOMÉOEJB"MFNBOIB 0SJFOUBM1PMÙOJB4VÏDJBF63446OJÍPEBT3FQÞCMJDBT4PDJBMJTUBT4PWJÏUJDBT FO USBOEPFNWJHPSFN +JN1VDLFUU%ÏDIFUTTBOTGSPOUJÒSFTMFTFOKFVYEFMB$POWFOUJPOEF#ÉMFin Ecologie contre nature – Développement e politiques d´ingérence16'1BSJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 142 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos 05SBUBEPJODMVJVUPEPFRVBMRVFSUJQPEFQPMVJÎÍPRVFBEFOUSFOPNBS#ÈMUJDP OÍPPCTUBOUFBPSJHFNEBOEPTFNBJPSFOGPRVFËQPMVJÎÍPEFGPOUFTDPNCBTFUFSSFTUSF EFTDBSHBEFEFUSJUPTQPMVJÎÍPEPTOBWJPTFPDPNCBUFDPOKVOUPEFEFSSBNBNFOUPT "$POWFOÎÍPEF)FMTJOLJQSFPDVQPVTFFNHBSBOUJSVNBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPJOUF HSBEBUFOEFOUFËQSPUFÎÍPEP#ÈMUJDPSFDPOIFDFOEPRVFPTFTGPSÎPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPT QBSBPDPOUSPMFEBQPMVJÎÍPOÍPQSFDJTBNQBTTBSOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFQFMBHFTUÍPJOUFHSB EBEPTSFDVSTPTNBSJOIPTFDPTUFJSPT "$POWFOÎÍPQSFPDVQPVTFFNEJTDVUJSBTEFTDBSHBTEFQPMVJÎÍPFNOÓWFJT JOBDFJUÈWFJTQSPWFOJFOUFTEFEJWFSTBTGPOUFTEFCBTFUFSSFTUSFUBJTDPNPB NFUBJT QFTBEPTC NBUFSJBJTDPOTVNJEPSFTEFPYJHÐOJPD %%51$#1$5FE EFSSB NBNFOUPEFØMFP"QFTDBSJBFNFYDFTTPGPJVNQSPCMFNBFOGSFOUBEPFNTFQBSBEP QPSPVUSBDPOWFOÎÍPB$POWFOÎÍPEF(EBOTL 0.BS#ÈMUJDPNFSFDFFTQFDJBMBUFOÎÍPFNSB[ÍPEBTQFDVMJBSJEBEFTFFOUSBWFT OBUVSBJTJOFSFOUFTBFTUBSFHJÍPRVFEJmDVMUBNBJOEBNBJTNFEJEBTRVFWJTFNBDPSSJHJS PTFGFJUPTEFQPMVFOUFTEJWFSTPT5BJTQFDVMJBSJEBEFTTÍP ÓOEJDFTTBMPCSFTFFTUSBUJmDB ÎÍPRVBTFQFSNBOFOUFUSPDBEFÈHVBTNVJUBMFOUBFOUSFPNBS#ÈMUJDPFP.BSEP/PSUF MFWBOEPBPBDÞNVMPEFTFEJNFOUPTFËBMUFSBÎÍPEBCJPUBFNSB[ÍPEPTQPMVFOUFTEFT DBSSFHBEPT CBDJBTGSJBTFTUBHOBEBTEP#ÈMUJDPBUVBNDPNPBSNBEJMIBTËTNBUÏSJBT PSHÉOJDBT/BTDBNBEBTBRVÈUJDBTNBJTQSPGVOEBTRVFOÍPSFDFCFNÈHVBEBTVQFSGÓDJF EFWJEPËFTUSBUJmDBÎÍPBEFDPNQPTJÎÍPEPNBUFSJBMPSHÉOJDPQPEFMFWBSBDPOEJÎÜFT BOPYFNBTUPSOBOEPFTTBTDBNBEBTQSBUJDBNFOUFTFNWJEBF FDPTTJTUFNBNBSJOIP EP#ÈMUJDPÏQPCSFFNSB[ÍPEBTDPOEJÎÜFTEFUFNQFSBUVSBFTBMJOJEBEFEBSFHJÍP &TUVEPTQSÏWJPTQSFDFEFSBNBFEJÎÍPEB$POWFOÎÍPEF)FMTJOLJJEFOUJmDBO EPQSPCMFNBTBNCJFOUBJTFTQFDÓmDPTEPNBS#ÈMUJDPBTBCFS tBDBQUVSBEFBSFORVFTQFJYFNBSJOIP EP#ÈMUJDPFNSFEFTFNVNBEBT ÈSFBTEFNBJPSEFTPWBUFNDBÓEPESBTUJDBNFOUFFNSB[ÍPEBTFEJNFOUBÎÍP FEBFVUSPmDBÎÍP tBEFmDJÐODJBEFPYJHÐOJPOBTÈSFBTNBJTQSPGVOEBTPSJHJOBEBQFMBTEFTDBSHBT EF OVUSJFOUFT QSPWFOJFOUFT EF GPOUFT UFSSFTUSFT TJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUF BGFUB PT DBSEVNFTEFCBDBMIBVTFFNNFOPSHSBVBGFUBPTBSFORVFTFBTFTQBEJMIBT %%5EJDMPSPEJGFOJMDMPSPFUBOP1$#CJGFOJMBTQPMJDMPSBEBT1$5QPMJDMPSPUSJGFOJMPT #JPUBÏPDPOKVOUPEFTFSFTWJWPTnPSBFGBVOBRVFIBCJUBNPVIBCJUBWBNVNEFUFSNJOBEPBNCJFOUF HFPMØHJDPDPNPQPSFYFNQMPCJPUBNBSJOIBFCJPUBUFSSFTUSFPVNBJTFTQFDJmDBNFOUFCJPUBMBHVOBS CJPUBFTUVBSJOBCJPUBCFOUÙOJDB"TWBSJBÎÜFTDMJNBUPMØHJDBTFBNCJFOUBJTFNHFSBMDPNPTBMJOJ[BÎÍP EFVNBMBHVOBRVBOUJEBEFEFTFEJNFOUPTFNTVTQFOTÍPBMUFSBNBCJPUBQFMBBEBQUBÎÍPNVUBÎÍPF FYUJOÎÍPEFFTQÏDJFTFOUSBEBEFOPWBTFTQÏDJFTFHÐOFSPT"TTJNPTFTUVEPTQBMFPOUPMØHJDPTOBTVDFT TÍPEFDBNBEBTCJPFTUSBUJHSBmB BKVEBNBEFTWFOEBSOÍPTØPTBNCJFOUFTNBTUBNCÏNBTWBSJBÎÜFT BNCJFOUBJT EP QBTTBEP QBMFPBNCJFOUF SFHJTUSBEPT OFTTBT SPDIBT QSJODJQBMNFOUF QPS DPNQBSBÎÍP DPNFTUVEPTBUVBJTEBTCJPUBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEFDBEBBNCJFOUF "OPYFNBTTFNPYJHÐOJPTFNWJEB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 143 tBQFTDB FNBMHVNBTEBTCBÓBT DPTUFJSBT EB4VÏDJB GPJQSPJCJEBEFWJEPËT BMUBTDPODFOUSBÎÜFTEFNFSDÞSJPFODPOUSBEBTOPTQFJYFT tB FVUSPmDBÎÍP F BT TVCTUÉODJBT PSHÉOJDBT DMPSBEBT TÍP QSPCMFNÈUJDBT OP QSØQSJP #ÈMUJDP EFTDBSHBT EF NFUBM QFTBEP DVKB EFOTJEBEF Ï TVQFSJPS B DJODP TÍP P NBJPS QSPCMFNB BP MPOHP EP 3JP %BMBWFO F BT TVCTUÉODJBT PSHÉOJDBTDMPSBEBTPSJHJOBEBTQFMBTJOEÞTUSJBTnPSFTUBJTTÍPPTQSJODJQBJT QSPCMFNBTEP(PMGPEF#ØUOJBF tBFVUSPmDBÎÍPDBVTBEBQFMBQFTDBFNDBUJWFJSPFTUÈBVNFOUBOEPSBQJEB NFOUFNFEJBOUFPBVNFOUPOBQSPEVÎÍP &NVNBOPWB$POWFOÎÍPEF)FMTJOLJFVN1SPHSBNBEF"ÎÍP"N CJFOUBM$POKVOUBF*ODMVTBEPNBS#ÈMUJDPGPSBNBEPUBEPTBVNFOUBOEPPGPDPRVBO UPËDPCFSUVSBEBTÈHVBTJOUFSOBTEBTCBDJBTIJESÈVMJDBTEPNBS#ÈMUJDPFRVFJODPSQP SBNOPWBTDPOTJEFSBÎÜFTSFMBDJPOBEBTËDPOTFSWBÎÍPEBOBUVSF[BEBCJPEJWFSTJEBEF FBPTBTTVOUPTSFMBUJWPTBPJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBMCFNDPNPËQSFDPOJ[BÎÍPEBFEJÎÍP EFOPWPTQSJODÓQJPTEPQBÓTQPMVJEPSEBNFMIPSUFDOPMPHJBEJTQPOÓWFMEBTNFMIPSFT QSÈUJDBTBNCJFOUBJTFEPQSJODÓQJPEBQSFWFOÎÍP "$POWFOÎÍPEF)FMTJOLJFNDPOUSBTUFDPNBTEFNBJTDPOWFOÎÜFTBDFTTPV BQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMEPNBS#ÈMUJDPEFVNBNBOFJSBBNQMBFBCSBOHFOUFEFTUBDBOEP PJNQBDUPIVNBOPCFNDPNPPEFUPEBTBTGPOUFTEFQPMVJÎÍPRVFBGFUBNPBNCJFO UFNBSJOIP1PSDPOTFRVÐODJBQPEFTFEJ[FSRVFFTUB$POWFOÎÍPUFNBEPUBEPVN QPTJDJPOBNFOUPEFDPOUSPMFJOUFHSBMEBQPMVJÎÍP " $POWFOÎÍP UPEBWJB OÍP TF BQMJDB ËT ÈHVBT JOUFSOBT EPT QBÓTFT TJHOBUÈ SJPTGB[FOEPDPNRVFTFUFOEBBFYDMVJSPTQSPCMFNBTSFMBDJPOBEPTË[POBDPTUFJSB MJNJUBOEPTFËQSPUFÎÍPEPNBSBCFSUP 0USBCBMIPEB)&-$0. rTFNFNCBSHPQFSNJUFBGFSJSRVFPTFGFJUPTEB QPMVJÎÍPVMUSBQBTTBNBTGSPOUFJSBTEPTQBÓTFTFRVFPTQSPCMFNBTEFBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEF SFDVSTPTEFWFNTFSTPMVDJPOBEPTQPSNFJPEBDPPQFSBÎÍPJOUFSOBDJPOBM C) A Convenção de Barcelona "$POWFOÎÍPEF#BSDFMPOBQBSBB1SPUFÎÍPDPOUSBB1PMVJÎÍPOPNBS.F EJUFSSÉOFPGPJmSNBEBFNFOUSFPTQBÓTFTRVFDJSDVOEBNFTUBSFHJÍPTFOEP 'FOÙNFOPRVFPDPSSFOPBNCJFOUFBRVÈUJDPFNSB[ÍPEBFMFWBEBRVBOUJEBEFEFOVUSJFOUFToQSJO DJQBMNFOUFOJUSBUPTFGPTGBUPTÏSFTVMUBOUFEBQPMVJÎÍPEBTÈHVBTQPSFKFÎÍPEFBEVCPTGFSUJMJ[BOUFT EFUFSHFOUFTFFTHPUPEPNÏTUJDPTFNUSBUBNFOUPQSÏWJPRVFQSPWPDBNPBVNFOUPEFNJOFSBJTFDPOTF RVFOUFNFOUFBQSPMJGFSBÎÍPEFBMHBTNJDSPTDØQJDBTRVFTFMPDBMJ[BNOBTVQFSGÓDJF 1BÓTFT JOUFHSBOUFT BUVBMNFOUF EB )&-$0. %JOBNBSDB &TUÙOJB $PNVOJEBEF &VSPQFJB 'JOMÉOEJB "MFNBOIB-FUÙOJB-JUVÉOJB1PMÙOJB3ÞTTJB4VÏDJBoIUUQXXXIFMDPNmIFMDPNFO@(#BCPVUVT EBUBI 1BÓTFTCBOIBEPTQFMP.BS.FEJUFSSÉOFP&VSPQBEFPFTUFQBSBMFTUF &TQBOIB(JCSBMUBSEP3FJOP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 144 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos NPEJmDBEBFNKVOIPEFQBSBBNQMJBSPTFVDPOUFÞEPJODMVJOEPBQMBOJmDBÎÍP FBHFTUÍPJOUFHSBEBEB[POBDPTUFJSB 0PCKFUJWPQSJODJQBMEBSFGFSJEB$POWFOÎÍPQPEFTFUSBEV[JSOBJOUFOÎÍPEF ireduzir a poluição no mar Mediterrâneo e proteger e melhorar o ambiente marinho da região, contribuindo assim para o seu desenvolvimento sustentávelw "EFNBJT B NFODJPOBEB DPOWFOÎÍP QSFUFOEF B BWBMJBS F DPOUSPMBS B DPO UBNJOBÎÍPC HBSBOUJSBHFTUÍPFBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEFEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTNBSJOIPT FDPTUFJSPTD JOUFHSBSPNFJPBNCJFOUFOPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTPDJBMFFDPOÙNJDPE QSPUFHFSPNFJPNBSJOIPFBT[POBTDPTUFJSBTNFEJBOUFBÎÜFTRVFQSFUFOEBNQSFWFOJS FSFEV[JSBDPOUBNJOBÎÍPF QSPUFHFSPQBUSJNÙOJPOBUVSBMFDVMUVSBMG SFGPSÎBSB TPMJEBSJFEBEFFOUSFPTQBÓTFTSJCFJSJOIPTEPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFPH DPOUSJCVJSQBSBB NFMIPSBEBRVBMJEBEFEFWJEB "$POWFOÎÍPJODFOUJWBPTQBÓTFTTJHOBUÈSJPTËBÎÍPEFNFEJEBTEFDPPQFSB ÎÍPOPTDBNQPTDJFOUÓmDPFUFDOPMØHJDPQBSBJNQFEJSFNRVFOPWBTDPOUBNJOBÎÜFT PDPSSBNCFNDPNPQSFUFOEFFTUBCFMFDFSNFEJEBTJOUFHSBEBTEFSFEVÎÍPEPTJNQBD UPTDPSSFUBNFOUFJEFOUJmDBEPT 1BSBBMÏNEB$POWFOÎÍPEF#BSDFMPOBPTQBÓTFTTJHOBUÈSJPTmSNBSBNQSPUP DPMPTEJWFSTPTWJTBOEPBUSBUBSEFUFNBTFTQFDÓmDPT B 1SPUPDPMPQBSBB1SFWFOÎÍPEB1PMVJÎÍPEPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFPEFDPSSFOUF EFSFTÓEVPTEFOBWJPTFBFSPOBWFToFTUFQSPUPDPMPWJTBQSPJCJSBDJSDVMBÎÍPEFOBWJPT FBFSPOBWFTRVFEFTQFKBNEFUFSNJOBEBTTVCTUÉODJBTOPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFPNFSDÞSJP DÈENJPQFUSØMFPCSVUPDPNQPTUPTPSHBOPUØYJDPTFPSHÉOJDPTIBMPHFOBEPTFUD1SF WFFNBJOEBBBVUPSJ[BÎÍPDPODFEJEBQPSBVUPSJEBEFTHPWFSOBNFOUBJTQBSBBDJSDVMB ÎÍPDPNSFTUSJÎÍPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTTVCTUÉODJBTEFTEFRVFDVNQSJEBTBTFYJHÐODJBT &YFNQMJmDBOEP[JODPDSPNPOÓRVFMBMHVOTQFTUJDJEBTFUD"MHVNBTFYDFÎÜFTTÍP BENJUJEBTFNTFUSBUBOEPEBDJSDVMBÎÍPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTTVCTUÉODJBTQSPJCJEBTQFMP 1SPUPDPMPTVKFJUBTBFTUVEPEFDBTPDPODSFUP C 1SPUPDPMPEFDPPQFSBÎÍPQBSBDPNCBUFSTJUVBÎÜFTEFFNFSHÐODJBQFSBOUF B DPOUBNJOBÎÍP EP NBS .FEJUFSSÉOFP DBVTBEB QPS IJESPDBSCPOFUPT F PVUSBT TVCT UÉODJBTQSFKVEJDJBJTFTUF1SPUPDPMPPCSJHBDBEBQBSUFDPOGSPOUBEBDPNVNBTJUVBÎÍP DSÓUJDBBFGFUVBSBTBWBMJBÎÜFTOFDFTTÈSJBTFPQPSUVOBTTPCSFBOBUVSF[BFBFYUFOTÍP EPTJOJTUSPBUPNBSUPEBTBTNFEJEBTRVFQFSNJUBNSFEV[JSPVFMJNJOBSPTFGFJUPT EFSJWBEPTEBDPOUBNJOBÎÍPFBJOGPSNBSPTEFNBJTQBÓTFTTJHOBUÈSJPTTPCSFBFWPMVÎÍP FBTNFEJEBTUPNBEBT "BOÈMJTFEB$POWFOÎÍPEF#BSDFMPOBQFSNJUFQFSDFCFSVNBQSFPDVQBÎÍPEF FmDÈDJBOPDPNCBUFËQPMVJÎÍPQPSQBSUFEFTFVTJOUFHSBOUFTRVFUÐNTFQSFPDVQBEP 6OJEP 'SBOÎB.ÙOBDP*UÈMJB.BMUB&TMPWÐOJB$SPÈDJB#ØTOJBF)FS[FHPWJOB.POUFOFHSP"MCÉOJB (SÏDJB$IJQSFF5VSRVJB«TJBEFOPSUFQBSBTVM 5VSRVJB4ÓSJB-ÓCBOP*TSBFMF1BMFTUJOB«GSJDBEF MFTUFQBSBPFTUF &HJUP-ÓCJB5VOÓTJB"SHÏMJBF.BSSPDPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 145 FNVUJMJ[BSSFDVSTPTUFDOPMØHJDPTFDJFOUÓmDPTQBSBUFSFNBFYBUBOPÎÍPEBFYUFOTÍP EPTEBOPTDBVTBEPTBPMPOHPEPTUFNQPTQFMBBÎÍPIVNBOBFQFMBQSØQSJBFWPMVÎÍP OBUVSBMEPFDPTTJTUFNBFOGBUJ[BOEPBOFDFTTJEBEFEPEJÈMPHPFEBDPNVOJDBÎÍPQBDÓ mDBFOUSFPTQBÓTFTBDPMBCPSBSQBSBBFMJNJOBÎÍPEBQPMVJÎÍPOPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFP D 1SPUPDPMP TPCSF B HFTUÍP JOUFHSBEB EBT [POBT DPTUFJSBT EP NBS .FEJUFS SÉOFPBJOUFOÎÍPEPTTJHOBUÈSJPTGPJFTUBCFMFDFSVNNBSDPJOJDJBMQBSBBHFTUÍPJO UFHSBEBEBT[POBTDPTUFJSBTEP.FEJUFSSÉOFPEFMJNJUBOEPBQSJNFJSBGFSSBNFOUBEF %JSFJUP*OUFSOBDJPOBMDSJBEBQBSBUSBUBSEFTUFUFNBEFGPSNBFYDMVTJWBDPNPPCKFUJWP EFQSPNPWFSPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMNFEJBOUFVNQMBOFKBNFOUPSBDJPOBMEBT BUJWJEBEFTQSPNPWFSBQSFTFSWBÎÍPEBT[POBTDPTUFJSBTFYQMPSBSEFGPSNBSTVTUFO UÈWFMPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTJOFSFOUFTËT[POBTDPTUFJSBTQSFTFSWBSPTFDPTTJTUFNBTFBT QBJTBHFOTMJUPSÉOFBTFQSPQPSNFEJEBTRVFUFOEBNBSFEV[JSBTDBUÈTUSPGFTBNCJFOUBJT FBTNVEBOÎBTDMJNÈUJDBTFTUBCFMFDFOEPDPNPTTFVTQSPUPDPMPTNBSDPFTTFODJBMQBSB BDPNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEPTUSBUBEPTFDPOWFOÎÜFTRVFPTBOUFDFEFSBN"MÏNEJTTPBN QMJPVBÈSFBEFFTUVEPFPFOGPRVFEFQSPUFÎÍPPGFSFDFOEPBTQFDUPHMPCBMJ[BEPBPT QSPCMFNBTBNCJFOUBJT D) A Convenção RAMOGE "$POWFOÎÍP3BNPHFQSJNBOEPQPSTFSEFJOJDJBUJWBEF4"4P1SÓODJQF3BJ OJFS***EF.ÙOBDPSFTQPOTÈWFMFNQPSDPODMBNBSPTQBÓTFTNFEJUFSSÉOJDPTBTF SFVOJSFNQBSBFTUVEBSPTQSPCMFNBTEFDPSSFOUFTEBQPMVJÎÍPFEFTVBTDBVTBTDPOTJTUF OPÞOJDPBDPSEPEFÓOEPMFJOUFSOBDJPOBMBUSBUBSEBTÈHVBTJOUFSJPSFTUFSSJUPSJBJTFQPS UPT IBSNPOJ[BOEPBTMFHJTMBÎÜFTBNCJFOUBJTEB'SBOÎBEB*UÈMJBFEF.ÙOBDPDPNP PCKFUJWPEFQSFTFSWBSPNBSFBTSFHJÜFTDPTUFJSBTEBTBÎÜFTIVNBOBTQPMVJEPSBT 0EPDVNFOUPFMBCPSBEPQBSBBDPOTFDVÎÍPEPBDPSEP3".0(&DPOUFNQMB RVBUSPUFNBTFTQFDÓmDPTB QMBOJmDBÎÍPFBHFTUÍPEPTFTQBÎPTC BQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJP BNCJFOUFD BTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOÙNJDBTFPTFVVTPFE BQPMVJÎÍP "$POWFOÎÍP3".0(&ÏPSJHJOBMOÍPTØQPSRVFDVJEBEFVNBDPSEPJOUFS OBDJPOBMRVFDPOUFNQMBBTÈHVBTJOUFSOBTNBTQPSRVFBHSFHBËTOPSNBTEF%JSFJUP *OUFSOBDJPOBMSFHSBTEFVSCBOJTNPRVFPCFEFDFNBVNBWPOUBEFDPNVNEPTUSÐT &TUBEPTEFPSHBOJ[BSBPDVQBÎÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPOBDJPOBMSFTQFDUJWPQPSEJGFSFOUFTBUP SFTFDPOÙNJDPTQÞCMJDPTFQSJWBEPTOPSFTQFJUPEPJOUFSFTTFHFSBM 0TUSÐT&TUBEPTBEPUBSBNNFEJEBTKVSÓEJDBTFTQFDÓmDBTBEBQUBEBTËQSPUFÎÍP EPTFTQBÎPTNBSÓUJNPTRVFBUJOHFNFTTBTUSÐTOBÎÜFTDVNQSJOEPDJUBSBMFJiMJUPSBMw $&%&º0%&#"3304+PTÏ'FSOBOEP%JSFJUPEP.BSFEP.FJP"NCJFOUF-&9&EJUPSB4ÍP1BVMP Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 146 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos EB'SBOÎBP$ØEJHPEPNBSEP1SJODJQBEPEF.ÙOBDPFP%FDSFUP-FHJTMBUJWPO EFEFNBJPEFEB*UÈMJB "TÈSFBTQSPUFHJEBTOB[POB3".0(&TÍPBTTFHVJOUFT B /B'SBOÎB tVNQBSRVFOBDJPOBMB*MIBEF1PSU$SPTJODMVJOEPB*MIBEF1PSRVFSPMMFT tnPSFTUBTEPNJOJBJTOB*MIB4BJOUF.BSRVFSJUIFFOB*MIB4BJOU)POPSBUOBT nPSFTUBTEFM|&TUÏSFMEFMB(BSEJPMFFEFT$BMBORVFT tQSPQSJFEBEFT EP $POTFSWBUPSJF EV -JUUPSBM B $PTUB "[VM MF $PSCVTJFS M|&TUÏSFMP$BQ-BSEJFSB$PMMF/PJSFMB'POUBTTFF tOVNFSPTPTTÓUJPTJOTDSJUPTBCBOEBDPTUFJSBFOUSF5IÏPMVMFToTVSNFS/JDFF $BQE|"OUJCFTFOUSFPVUSPTPVDMBTTJmDBEPT1PSRVFSPMMFT*MIBTEF-ÏSJOT&[F TVS.FS$BQ.BSUJOM|&TUÏSFMMFTDBMBORVFTEF.BSTFJMMFFMF$BQ$BOBJMMF C /B*UÈMJB tUSÐTQBSRVFTOBUVSBJTSFHJPOBJT*MIBEF(BMMJOBSB$JORVF5FSSFF1PSUP'JOP tVNBSFTFSWBOBUVSBMB*MIBEF#FSHFHHJ D /P1SJODJQBEPEF.ÙOBDP tEVBTSFTFSWBTNBSJOIBTBSFTFSWBEP-BSWBUUPFBSFTFSWBEPTDPSBJTWFSNFMIPT 01SJODJQBEPEF.ÙOBDPUPNPVBJOJDJBUJWBQBSBBDSJBÎÍPOB[POBEFOPNJ OBEB3".0(&EFVNTBOUVÈSJPEFNBNÓGFSPTNBSJOIPT0SJHJOBSJBNFOUFQSFWJTUP QBSBBQSPUFÎÍPEBTCBMFJBTFHPMmOIPTP4BOUVÈSJPUFSNJOPVQPSGPSOFDFSQSPUFÎÍP BVNBEJWFSTJEBEFEFPVUSBTFTQÏDJFTRVFFTUÍPBTTPDJBEBTËTCBMFJBTFBPTHPMmOIPT DPNQBSUJMIBOEPPNFTNPFDPTTJTUFNBDPNPQPSFYFNQMPPUVCBSÍPGSBEFCetorhinus maximus FNVJUBTFTQÏDJFTEFHSBOEFTQFJYFTQFMÈHJDPT 0TBOUVÈSJPNBSJOIPGPJDSJBEPQPSUSÐTSB[ÜFTQSJODJQBJTB BEFTDPCFSUB EFQPQVMBÎÜFTTJHOJmDBUJWBTEFCBMFJBTFJOÞNFSBTPVUSBTFTQÏDJFTEFDFUÈDFPTOP NBSEB-JHÞSJBC PBVNFOUPEPOÞNFSPEFFODBMIFTEFNBNÓGFSPTNBSJOIPTBDJ EFOUBMNFOUFQSFTPTQPSSFEFTEFQFTDBRVFTFFODPOUSBWBNBEFSJWBFD PRVBESP KVSÓEJDPOÍPGPSOFDJBTVCTÓEJPTBEFRVBEPTQBSBBQSPUFÎÍPEBGBVOBNBSJOIBOPT NBSFTEP.FEJUFSSÉOFP 7JTBOEPBVNBQSPUFÎÍPFmDB[EPTNBNÓGFSPTNBSJOIPTGPJEFTTBSUFDSJBEB BÈSFBEFQSPUFÎÍPNBSJOIBOPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFPUFOEPTJEPSBUJmDBEPPBDPSEPQFMP 1SJODJQBEPEF.ÙOBDP 'SBOÎB F*UÈMJB DG(JVTFQQF/PUBSCBS UPMPEJ4DJBSBF%BWJE)ZSFOCBDIThe Pelagos Sanctuary Mammals "EFDJTÍPEFTFFMFHFSVNBQPSÎÍPEFVNEFUFSNJOBOEPUFSSJUØSJPJNVOFË QPMVJÎÍPFEFTUJOBSDPNFYDMVTJWJEBEFBSFHJÍPBVNHSVQPEFBOJNBJTFBPVUSPT TFSFTWJWPTFNQFSJHPEFFYUJOÎÍPFTUÈJOTFSJEBOP%JSFJUP*OUFSOBDJPOBMDMÈTTJDPEP QSPCMFNBEBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTOPTFOUJEPEFBTTVNJSVNSFMFWPFTQFDÓ mDPEPQPOUPEFWJTUBOPSNBUJWPPVDPNPNFMIPSTFFYQSFTTB.BSDP(FTUSJ FTDMVWJTBNFOUFJOSJGFSJNFOUPBMMFJQPUFTJEJSJTPSTFDPNVOJUSBEVFP QJá4UBUJmVNJJOUFSOB[JPOBMJMBHIJEJGSPOUJFSBTQFDJFBOJNBMJNJHSBOUJ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 147 FUD PEJTGSVUUBNFOUPEFMMFSJTPSTFEFHMJTQB[JBMEJMËEFMMBHJVSJTEJ[JPOF OB[JPOBMFFEJOQBSUJDPMBSFEFMM}BMUPNBSFDG-BHFTUJPOFEFMMFSJTPSTF OBUVSBMJE}JOUFSFTTFHFOFSBMFQFSMB$PNVOJUËJOFSOB[JPOBMF /PRVFTFSFGFSFBPNBSKÈIÈNVJUPUFNQPP%JSFJUP*OUFSOBDJPOBMSFDFQDJP OPVPQSJODÓQJPEFQBUSJNÙOJPDPNVNEB)VNBOJEBEFPRVFDPOEJDJPOBBVUJMJ[BÎÍP EPTIJESPDBSCPOFUPTOFTTBTSFHJÜFTBTVCTVNJSTFËTOPSNBTJOUFSOBTFJOUFSOBDJPOBJT RVFDPOEJDJPOBNBFYQMPSBÎÍPFVTVGSVUPEFVNBSJRVF[BBFTUBUVUPTQSPUFUPSFTEB OBUVSF[BRVFTFTPCSFQÜFNËMFHJTMBÎÍPJOUFSOBDPNEFTUBRVFQBSBB$POWFOÎÍPEF $0/7&/±°0%&.0/5&(0#": UFOEPB'SBOÎBB*UÈMJBF.ÙOBDPBEFSJ EPJOUFHSBMNFOUFËEJTDJQMJOBEBTOPSNBTSFMBUJWBTBPTGVOEPTNBSJOIPTFTUBCFMFDFO EPFNDPOTFRVÐODJBVNTJTUFNBEFHFTUÍPFEFWJHJMÉODJBOBT[POBTBMDBOÎBEBTQFMB $POWFOÎÍP3".0(& E) Os princípios do poluidor-pagador, da prevenção na fonte e da precaução 0EJSFJUPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFBJOEBOÍPFODPOUSPVVNBTJTUFNBUJ[BÎÍPEFmOJUJWB FNOPTTPTJTUFNBKVSÓEJDPEFQFOEFOUFBJOEBEFVNBTFEJNFOUBÎÍPNBJTQSPGVOEB 0TFTUVEPTBNCJFOUBJTUJWFSBNJOÓDJPTPCSFUVEPOB&VSPQBNFSDÐEPTEF TBTUSFTFDPMØHJDPTRVFBUJOHJSBNEFVNBGPSNBNBJTFWJEFOUFPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFPF FNSB[ÍPEBBUFOÎÍPRVFBNÓEJBUFNUJEPQBSBDPNBRVFMBSFHJÍPQPJTTFUSBUBEF VNBEBTSFHJÜFTEFNBJPSDPODFOUSBÎÍPUVSÓTUJDBFEFSJRVF[BTIJTUØSJDBTFBSRVFPMØ HJDBTEPQMBOFUBNFSFDFOEPEFTUBRVFPTTFHVJOUFTEPDVNFOUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJT "%FDMBSBÎÍPEF&TUPDPMNPTPCSFPNFJPBNCJFOUFIVNBOPEFEFKVOIP EFB$BSUBNVOEJBMEBOBUVSF[BBEPUBEBFNEFPVUVCSPEFQFMB"T TFNCMFJB(FSBMEB0/6CFNDPNPBEFDMBSBÎÍPEP3JPEF+BOFJSPEFKVOIPEF TPCSFPNFJPBNCJFOUFFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEPQSPHSBNBEFOPNJOBEP"HFOEB 2VBOUPËBTTFNCMÏJB3JPQBSFDFOPTTPCBOPTTBØUJDBRVFBTNBUÏSJBTUSBUBEBT OÍPUJOIBNVNWÓODVMPFTUSFJUPDPNBQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBM$PNPFYFNQMPQPEFNPT NFODJPOBS RVF GPSBN PCKFUP EF EFMJCFSBÎÍP UFNBT TPCSF B RVFTUÍP EP DPOUSPMF EF OBUBMJEBEFEJSFJUPBPBCPSUPFSFVOJÜFTEFNVMUJEÜFTEFKPWFOTDPNDVOIPSFMJHJPTP .FTNPVNFYBNFQFSGVODUØSJPEPTUFNBTQFSNJUFBVGFSJSGBDJMNFOUFRVFFNOBEB FTTFTUFNBTTFSFMBDJPOBNDPNBRVFTUÍPBNCJFOUBM/PNBJTEBTWF[FTNPTUSBSBN TFBOØEJOBTBTDPMPDBÎÜFTEPTQBÓTFTFNFSHFOUFTCFNDPNPTVBTÞMUJNBTDPODMVTÜFT ((JBQQJDIFMMJFEJUPSF5PSJOPQ DGNBJTFYUFOTBNFOUF3".0(&"DPSEPSFMBUJWPËQSPUFÎÍPEBTÈHVBTEPMJUPSBMNFEJUFSSÉOJDPBTTJ OBEPFN.ÙOBDPBEFNBJPEFin +PTÏ'FSOBOEP$FEF×PEF#BSSPTDireito do Mar e do Meio AmbienteDJUQQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 148 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos QPVDPSFQFSDVUJSBNKVOUPBPTNFJPTKVSÓEJDPT²DFEPBJOEBQBSBVNBNBOJGFTUBÎÍP TPCSFVNFWFOUPUÍPSFDFOUF 1PSPVUSPMBEPÏJNQPSUBOUFGSJTBSRVFPTQSJODÓQJPTUFOEFOUFTËQSPUFÎÍP EPNFJPBNCJFOUFUJWFSBNVNBWFSUFOUFFDPOÙNJDBVNBWF[RVFBQPMVJÎÍPTFEÈ QSJNPSEJBMNFOUFQFMPTIJESPDBSCPOFUPTPRVFÏKVTUJmDBEPQFMPDIBNBEPEFTFOWPM WJNFOUPFQSPHSFTTPEBT/BÎÜFT $PNCBTFOPTEFTBTUSFTFDPMØHJDPTDJFOUJTUBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTOBTÈSFBTEBCJP MPHJBEBPDFBOPHSBmBFKVSJTUBTDPODMVÓSBNRVFPNFMIPSNFJPEFTFQSPUFHFSEPT EFTBTUSFTFDPMØHJDPTÏBTVBQSFWFOÎÍP %BÓBDPOTBHSBÎÍPEPQSJODÓQJPEB13&7&/±°0UFOEPDPNPDPSPMÈSJPPmOBO DJBNFOUPQFMP&TUBEPQBSBFWJUBSTFEBOPTFDPMØHJDPTOBGPOUF 0EFOPNJOBEPQSJODÓQJPEB13&$"6±°0GPJFMBCPSBEPOPÉNCJUPEPEJSFJ UPBMFNÍPFSFDFQDJPOBEPFNUFSNPTHFSBJTQFMB%FDMBSBÎÍPEP3JPDPODMBNBOEPPT &TUBEPTBBQMJDBSFNBNQMBNFOUFPQSJODÓQJPEFTFQSFDBWFSEPTJODJEFOUFTOPDJWPTË OBUVSF[BBmNEFQSPUFHFSPBNCJFOUFDPOGPSNFBTVBDBQBDJEBEF /BMJÎÍPFTDPSSFJUBEF.BSDP(FTUSJ $PNF EFmOJUP OFMMB %JDIJBSB[JPOF EP 3JP JM DSJUÏSJP TVHHFSJTDF DIF OFM DBTP EJ NJOBDDJB EJ EBOOJ BNCJFOUBMJ TFSJ P JSSFWFSTJCJMJ OPO TJ EFCCB DPOTJEFSBSF JM EJGFUUP EJ VOB QJFOB DFSUF[[B TDJFOUJmDB RVBMF NPUJWP QFS SJOWJBSF M}BEP[JPOF EJ NJTVSF FDPOPNJDBNFOUF FGmDJFOUJ DPTUFGGFDUJWF QFS QSFWFOJSF JM EFHSBEP BNCJFOUBMF WFEJ JM QSJODJQJP EFMMB%JDIJBSB[JPOFEJ3JPTVBNCJFOUFFTWJMVQQP *OBMUSJUFSNJOJ JM QSJODJQJP EFMM}B[JPOF QSFDBV[JPOBMF DPTUJUVJTDF VOP TWJMVQQP EFM DSJUFSJP EJ QSFWFO[JPOF JO RVBOUP SJDIJFEF EJ BHJSB P B TFDPOEB EFJ DBTJ EJ OPOB HJSF BODIF JO NBODBO[B EJ QSPWB TDJFOUJmDB TVHMJ FGGFUJ EJVO}BUUJWJUËEFUFSNJOBUBFEJOQSFTFO[BEJVOBTFNQMJDFNJOBDDJBEJ EBOOPBNCJFOUBMFTFSJPPEJSSFWFSTJCJMJF0DPSSFOPOEJNFOPSJDPSEBSF DIF QFSNBOHPOP SJMFWBOUJ EVCCJ TBJ TVM DPODSFUP TJHOJmDBUP DIF TVMMB QPSUBUB HJVSJEJDB EFM QSJODJQJP 4PUUP JM QSJNP QSPmMP FTTP QPHHJB JOWFSTPTVEJVOJOTJFNFEJFMFNFOUJQFSPHOVOPEFJRVBMJTVTTJUFVO NBSHJOFEJWBMVUB[JPOFTPHHFUJWBNPMUPBNQJPJMDIFQVÛUSBEVSTJJO TJHOJmDBUJWFEJGmDPMUÈEJBQQMJDB[JPOF%}BMUSBQBSUFOFMMBUFPSJBFOFMMB QSBTTJ TJ Ò WFOVUB BGmBODBOEP BMMB EFmOJ[JPOF DMBTTJDB EFM QSJODJQJP BDDPMUB EBMMB %JDIJBSB[JPOF EJ 3JP VOB DPODF[JPOF SBEJDBMF *O WJSUá EJ UBMF JOUFSQSFUB[JPOF JO QSFTFO[B EJ SBHJPOFWPMJ NPUJWJ EJ QFSJDPMP TQFUUFSFCCF B DPMVJ JM RVBMF JOUFOEF QPSSF JO FTTFSF VOB EFUFSNJOBUB BUUJWJUËM}POFSFEJQSPWBSOFMBDPNQBUJCJMJUËDPOMFFTJHFO[FBNCJFOUBMJ (&453*.BSDP-B(FTUJPOF Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 149 "HFTUÍPEPTSFDVSTPTWJWPTÏGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBBQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFO UF&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBTPQMBOFKBNFOUPQBSBBDPSSFUBFYQMPSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUV SBJTÏPCSJHBUØSJPQBSBRVFTFQPTTBQSFWFOJSDPOUSBEBOPTBNCJFOUBJTFNFTNPDPOUSB BNFSBBNFBÎBEFEBOPRVFQPEFSJBWJSBTFSJSSFWFSTÓWFM ²FWJEFOUFRVFBNFSBJNQPTJÎÍPEFNVMUBQFDVOJÈSJBPVBUÏNFTNPBQSJTÍP EPTSFTQPOTÈWFJTQFMPTEBOPTBNCJFOUBJTOÍPQFSNJUJSÈRVFTFSFDPNQPOIBBTJUVBÎÍP BOUFSJPSËDBUÈTUSPGFFDPMØHJDB 0 QSJODÓQJP EB QSFDBVÎÍP OÍP TF DPNQBHJOB DPN PT FTUSFJUPT MJNJUFT EBT MFHJTMBÎÜFTJOUFSOBTUFOEPDPNPFYFNQMPBRVFTUÍPEBTCBOEFJSBTEFDPOWFOJÐODJB DPOTJTUFOUFTFNDPODFTTÜFTEFBVUPSJ[BÎÍPEFVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFCBOEFJSBTEFQBÓTFTTP CFSBOPTQBSBRVFOBWJPTNFSDBOUJTTJOHSFNBTÈHVBTJOUFSOBDJPOBJT/FNTFNQSFPT OBWJPTTFFODPOUSBNFNDPOEJÎÜFTQBSBPUSBOTQPSUFTFHVSPEFTVCTUÉODJBTQFSJHP TBTFOFNTFNQSFPTQBÓTFTRVFDPODFEFNBTBVUPSJ[BÎÜFTTFQSFPDVQBNFNUPSOBS FGFUJWB VNB mTDBMJ[BÎÍP BEFRVBEB prévia EPT OBWJPT F PVUSPT NFJPT EF USBOTQPSUF OÈVUJDPTHFSBOEPEFTBTUSFTQPSWF[FTJSSFNFEJÈWFJTQPEFOEPTFSDJUBEPPDBTPSF DFOUFEP²3*$"EF[FNCSPEF RVFTFQBSUJVFNEPJTOPOPSUFEB'SBOÎBDPN EFSSBNBNFOUP EF IJESPDBSCPOFUP QPS VNB HSBOEF FYUFOTÍP EP 0DFBOP "UMÉOUJDP BUJOHJOEPBTDPTUBTEB*OHMBUFSSBFDBVTBOEPBNPSUFEFJOÞNFSBTFTQÏDJFTEFBOJNBJT RVFBMJWJWJBN 0QSJODÓQJPEBQSFDBVÎÍPQPSWF[FTQPEFTFSBEPUBEPEBGPSNBNBJTSBEJ DBMDPOTJTUFOUFOB130*#*±°0QVSBFTJNQMFTEFEFUFSNJOBEBTBUJWJEBEFTFNEFUFS NJOBEPTMPDBJT 0 BMDBODF KVSÓEJDP EP QSJODÓQJP FN FYBNF BQSFTFOUB DPOUSPWÏSTJBT BMHVOT EPVUSJOBEPSFTFOUFOEFNRVFPQSFDFJUPFTUÈDBCBMNFOUFQSFTFOUFOP%JSFJUP*OUFSOB DJPOBMHFSBMFUFSJBBQMJDBÎÍPJNFEJBUBPVUSPTFOUFOEFNRVFEFWFSJBIBWFSBPNFOPT VNBDPNQSPWBÎÍPDJFOUÓmDBEBQSPCBCJMJEBEFEFSJTDPBOUFTEFTFQSPJCJSEFUFSNJOBEB BUJWJEBEFTPCSFUVEPUFOEPFNWJTUBPTEBOPTFDPOÙNJDPTRVFBTSFTUSJÎÜFTQPEFSJBN DBVTBSBPTQBÓTFTFNFSHFOUFT (FTUSJUSB[ËDPMBÎÍPBPQJOJÍPEB$PSUF*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF+VTUJÎBOPDBTP EBDomanda di esame della situazioneQPOEPFNSFMFWPBEJmDVMEBEFEFQSPWBEPT FGFJUPT BNCJFOUBJT EF EFUFSNJOBEB BUJWJEBEF DPNP PCTFSWPV P +VJ[ 8FFSBNOUSZ OPTFOUJEPEFRVFPEJSFJUPOÍPQPEFPQFSBSBQSPUFÎÍPEPBNCJFOUFunless a legal principle is evolved to meet evidentiary difficulty, and environmental has responded with what has come to be described as the precautionary principle a principle which is gaining increasing support as part of the international law of the environment. 0#SBTJMÏVNFYFNQMPDMÈTTJDPEBTDPOUSPWÏSTJBTRVFTVSHFNBSFTQFJUPEP EFTGSVUBNFOUPEBTSJRVF[BTQFUSPMÓGFSBTFODPOUSBEBTOB;&&;POB&DPOÙNJDB&YDMV TJWB FOBTÈHVBTUFSSJUPSJBJTTPCSFUVEPEFQPJTEBEFTDPCFSUBEBTKB[JEBTEFQFUSØMFP PCDJUQOPUB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 150 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos OBDIBNBEBDBNBEBEFQSÏTBMO Pré-sal é uma camada de rocha formada por sal que delimita um conjunto de reservatórios petrolíferos mais antigos que os depósitos encontrados sobre a camada pós-sal neoapitiniano e que na costa brasileira se estende desde o Alto Vitória e Santos, nas Bacias de Campos, até o Alto de Florianópolis, respectivamente. Este sal foi depositado durante a abertura do Oceano Atlântico, após a quebra do Gondwana (Jurássico Superior-Cretáceo) durante a fase de mar raso e de clima semiárido/árido do Neoapitiniano (1 a 7 Ma). A descoberta de indícios de petróleo no pré-sal foi anunciada pela Petrobras em 2006. Em 2008, a Petrobras extraiu pela primeira vez petróleo do pré-sal 0T JOUFSFTTFT FN DPOnJUP OP DBTP BDJNB TÍP FYUSFNBNFOUF EJWFSTPT "T RVFTUÜFT BJOEB FTUÍP FN WJB EF FYBNF F DFSUBNFOUF PT DBTPT DPODSFUPT MFWBEPT ËT $PSUFT*OUFSOBDJPOBJTFNFTNPJOUFSOBTQFSNJUJSÍPVNNFMIPSBQFSGFJÎPBNFOUPEB EPVUSJOBEPQSJODÓQJPEBQSFDBVÎÍP 0FRVJMÓCSJPQPMÓUJDPTFSFWFMBJOEJTQFOTÈWFMBOUFBQMVSBMJEBEFEFJOUFSFTTFT FOWPMWJEPTIPKFIBWFOEPVNBEJNJOVJÎÍPEBEJDPUPNJBFOUSFPTQBÓTFTEFTFOWPMWJ EPTEJUPTJOEVTUSJBMJ[BEPTFPTQBÓTFTFNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPRVFJNCSJDBOBRVFTUÍP EBTVCNJTTÍPEPTQBÓTFTNBJTQPCSFTRVFTVQPTUBNFOUFBHSFEJSJBNNFOPTPNFJP BNCJFOUF FN SFMBÎÍP BPT QBÓTFT SJDPT UBNCÏN TVQPTUBNFOUF HFSBEPSFT EF EBOPT BNCJFOUBJTEFVNBGPSNBNBJTDPOUVOEFOUF "DPNQPTJÎÍPEBTDPSUFTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTEF+VTUJÎBQBSFDFTFSPDBNJOIPNBJT BDFSUBEPQBSBPEFTFKBEPFRVJMÓCSJPVUJMJ[BOEPPNFDBOJTNPEFSFQBSUJSPTDPNQP OFOUFTEPT$POTFMIPTEF"VUPSJEBEFEPTGVOEPTNBSJOIPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJT (FTUSJQSFDPOJ[BBGPSNBÎÍPEFRVBUSPEJTUJOUBTi$ÉNBSBTwQBSBFYQSJNJSB FYJHÐODJBEFEFMJOFBSVNFRVJMÓCSJPQPMÓUJDPFOUSFPTJOUFSFTTFTEPT&TUBEPTJOEVTUSJB MJ[BEPTFEPTRVFBJOEBFTUÍPFNWJBEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVCMJOIBOEPRVFB"HFOEB KÈEFTUBDBWBBJOBEFRVBEB QBSUJDJQBÎÍP EPT &TUBEPT FNFSHFOUFT FN NVJUPT EPT USBUBEPTFYJTUFOUFTFNNBUÏSJBBNCJFOUBMmYBOEPBOFDFTTJEBEFEBFYJHÐODJBOPTFO UJEPEFTFBTTFHVSBSVNbalanced governance OPTSFGFSJEPTUSBUBEPTFBQPTTJCJMJEBEF QFSNBOFOUFEFVNBSFWJTÍPEPTEPDVNFOUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBJTBNCJFOUBJTQPSUPEPTPT QBÓTFTJOUFSFTTBEPT &N TFHVJEB EJWFSTPT EPDVNFOUPT OBDJPOBJT F JOUFSOBDJPOBJT USBUBSBN EB GVOÎÍPDVSBUJWBIPVWFPEFTBTUSFFVSHFSFQBSBSPTEBOPT %FmOJVTF UBNCÏN RVF B NFMIPS NBOFJSB EF TF QSFDBWFS DPOUSB PT EBOPT BNCJFOUBJT Ï B EF JEFOUJmDBS F SFTQPOTBCJMJ[BS BUÏ NFTNP BOUFT EP GBUP EBOPTP P QPUFODJBM DBVTBEPS EB QPMVJÎÍP FMFHFOEPTF Ë DBUFHPSJB EF QSJODÓQJP B FTDPMIB EP 10-6*%031"("%03 RVF SFEVOEPV OP 5SBUBEP EF ,:050 F EF TFV EFTEPCSB NFOUPP1SPUPDPMPEF,:050RVFOÍPEFJYBEFTVTDJUBSDPOUSPWÏSTJBT PCDJUQQF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 151 &TTF NPWJNFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM DPN WJTUBT B SBUJmDBS P 1SPUPDPMP EF ,ZPUP TVSHJVEFRVFTUÜFTRVFJOUFSFTTBWBNUBOUPBTOBÎÜFTEFTFOWPMWJEBTRVBOUPPTQBÓTFT EFOPNJOBEPTFNFSHFOUFT O QMBOPEFGVOEPEFTTFBDPSEPTFEFVFNEFDPSSÐODJBEPDIBNBEPiFGFJUP FTUVGBwJTUPÏPQSPCMFNBEPBRVFDJNFOUPHMPCBMRVFDPOTJTUFOPBVNFOUPEBUFN QFSBUVSBNÏEJBEBTVQFSGÓDJFUFSSFTUSFEF$B$FPBVNFOUPEPOÓWFMNÏEJP EPNBSEFBDFOUÓNFUSPTDPNQSPKFÎÍPBUÏFEBQSFTTÍPEPTPSHBOJTNPT JOUFSOBDJPOBJTQBSBRVFPTQBÓTFTEFTFOWPMWJEPTUPNBTTFNBMJEFSBOÎBOPDPNCBUF DPOUSBPBRVFDJNFOUPHMPCBMFPTQBÓTFTQPMVJEPSFTEFWFSJBNSFEV[JSDPOTJEFSBWFM NFOUFTVBTFNJTTÜFTEFHBTFTOBBUNPTGFSB 01SPUPDPMPEF,ZPUPDPOTJEFSBPTHBTFTDBVTBEPSFTEPFGFJUPFTUVGBPEJ ØYJEPEFDBSCPOPNFUBOPØYJEPOJUSPTPIFYBnVPSFUPEFFOYPGSFFBTGBNÓMJBTEPT QFSnVPSDBSCPOPTFIJESPnVPSDBSCPOPT "TFNJTTÜFTDPOTJEFSBEBTQFMPEPDVNFOUPFNRVFTUÍPTÍPBQFOBTBRVFMBT HFSBEBTQPSBUJWJEBEFTIVNBOBTOPTFUPSFOFSHÏUJDPQSPEVÎÍPFVTPEFFOFSHJB FN QSPDFTTPTJOEVTUSJBJTHBTFTHFSBEPTDPNPDPQSPEVUPTEPQSPDFTTPEFGBCSJDBÎÍPEF DJNFOUPJOEÞTUSJBRVÓNJDB OPVTPEFTPMWFOUFTOPTFUPSBHSPQFDVÈSJPGFSNFOUBÎÍP FOFSHÏUJDBEFHBEPSVNJOBOUFQSPEVÎÍPEFBSSP[JSSJHBEPTPMPTBHSÓDPMBTRVFJNBEBT EFDFSSBEPTRVFJNBEFSFTÓEVPTBHSÓDPMBT FUSBUBNFOUPEFSFTÓEVPTMJYPFFTHPUP $BCFSFTTBMUBSRVFP1SPUPDPMPMJNJUPVTFBWJODVMBSPTQBÓTFTDPOTJEFSBEPT BUÏFOUÍPEFTFOWPMWJEPTFYDMVJOEPPTQBÓTFTFNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍPEF EJNJOVJSBTFNJTTÜFTEFHBTFTQPMVFOUFTJEFBMJ[BOEPVNBBMUFSOBUJWBDPOTJTUFOUFOB VUJMJ[BÎÍPEPNFSDBEPQBSBBVYJMJBSOPQSPDFTTPEFSFEVÎÍPEBTFNJTTÜFTEPTHBTFT EPFGFJUPFTUVGBWJBCJMJ[BOEPBQSPQPTUBEFTFDSJBSVNWBMPSUSBOTBDJPOBMQBSBFTTBT SFEVÎÜFTWJTBOEPBTTJNËSFEVÎÍPEFQPMVFOUFT. 0PCKFUJWPFWJEFOUFGPJPEFOÍPDPNQSPNFUFSBQSPEVUJWJEBEFFDPOÙNJDB EPTQBÓTFTEFTFOWPMWJEPTCFNDPNPBOHBSJBSFMPHJPTEBDPNVOJEBEFJOUFSOBDJPOBM DPNPiVNQBÓTRVFFTUÈBUFOUPËTBÞEFEPNVOEPw &TTFNPWJNFOUPQSPQPSDJPOPVPDIBNBEPi.FSDBEPEF$BSCPOPw 0FYBNFNFTNPQFSGVODUØSJPEP5SBUBEPEF,ZPUPFEFTFV1SPUPDPMPQFSNJ UFWFSJmDBSRVFPTQBÓTFTFNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPOÍPFTUBWBNPCSJHBEPTBSFEV[JSBTFNJT TÜFTEFHBTFTEFDPSSFOUFTEBTBUJWJEBEFTMFWBEBTBFGFJUPQFMPTHSBOEFTQBÓTFTJOEVTUSJBJT )PVWFUPEBWJBBBEFTÍPËTEJSFUSJ[FTEP5SBUBEPQSFUFOEFOEPQPVQBSBBUNPTGFSBEF FNJTTÜFTEFHBTFTQPSNFJPEFUSBOTBÎÜFTWJTBOEPBVNBiRVPUBEFSFEVÎÍPwNFSDÐ EFBDPSEPTRVFQSJWJMFHJBSJBNBTSFEVÎÜFTPDPSSJEBTOPTQBÓTFTEJUPTFNFSHFOUFTFN USPDBEFDPOUSBQSFTUBÎÍPQFDVOJÈSJBPVEFmOBODJBNFOUPTFNJOWFTUJNFOUPTOBDJPOBJT 1SPUPDPMP EF 2VJUP F MFHJTMBÎÍP DPSSFMBUB o $PMFÎÍP "NCJFOUBM o WPMVNF *** #SBTÓMJB 4FOBEP 'FEFSBM1 4*45&3(BCSJFM.FSDBEPEF$BSCPOPFP1SPUPDPMPEF2VJPUPo"TQFDUPTOFHPDJBJTFUSJCVUBÎÍP&E &MTFWJFSQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 152 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos &TUVEPT SFBMJ[BEPT QFMB DPNVOJEBEF DJFOUÓmDB DPOUFNQPSÉOFB MFWBSBN Ë DPODMVTÍPEFRVFBQSPEVÎÍPEFFOFSHJBBDBSSFUBPFGFJUPFTUVGBFBGPOUFEFNBJPS JODJEÐODJBÏBRVFMBPSJHJOBEBEPQFUSØMFPFEFTFVTEFSJWBEPT. %FTUBSUFBTJOEÞTUSJBTQFUSPMÓGFSBTQBTTBSBNBUFSRVFTFQSFPDVQBSOÍPTØ DPNBRVFTUÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBNBTUJWFSBNRVFmDBSBUFOUBTRVBOUPBPJNQBDUPBN CJFOUBMEFDPSSFOUFEBPQFSBÎÍPJOEVTUSJBM/FTUFQBTTPBQSFWFOÎÍPUPSOPVTFPNF MIPSDBNJOIPQBSBBGBTUBSBTJOFWJUÈWFJTSFQFSDVTTÜFTFDPOÙNJDPmOBODFJSBTOBTFN QSFTBTDPOEFOBEBTQPSQPMVJÎÍP "BQMJDBÎÍPQSÈUJDBEPQSJODÓQJPEBQSFDBVÎÍPQSPQJDJPVPBQFSGFJÎPBNFOUP EBBEPÎÍPEFNFEJEBTEFQVOJÎÍPEPTBHFOUFTDBVTBEPSFTEPTEBOPTFGFUJWBNFOUF WFSJmDBEPTQFSNJUJOEPRVFTFFGFUVFBSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BÎÍPQFOBMEPTFOUFTDPMFUJWPT BÓDPNQSFFOEJEBTBTQFTTPBTKVSÓEJDBTFNQSFTBT RVFBUÏCFNQPVDPUFNQPBUSÈT mDBWBNJNVOFTËTDPOTFRVÐODJBTEFBUPTMFTJWPTQSBUJDBEPTDPOUSBPNFJPBNCJFOUF MJNJUBEBTBTQFOBTËTQFTTPBTGÓTJDBT &NCMFNÈUJDBTFNPTUSBBSFTQFJUPBEFDJTÍPEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB QSPMBUBEBOPBDØSEÍPFYBSBEPOP3FDVSTP&TQFDJBMO TFOEP 3FMBUPSP.JOJTUSP(JMTPO%JQQ 0BDØSEÍPFNSFGFSÐODJBTVCMJOIBBQMFOBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BS BQFTTPBKVSÓEJDBQPSDSJNFBNCJFOUBMBODPSBEPOPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEF SBMFNTFVQBSÈHSBGPRVFUFNBTFHVJOUFEJDÎÍPin verbis 1BSÈHSBGP o "T DPOEVUBT F BUJWJEBEFT DPOTJEFSBEBT MFTJWBT BP NFJP BNCJFOUF TVKFJUBSÍP PT JOGSBUPSFT QFTTPBT GÓTJDBT PV KVSÓEJDBT B TBOÎÜFTQFOBJTFBENJOJTUSBUJWBTJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBPCSJHBÎÍPEF SFQBSBSPTEBOPTDBVTBEPT $POGPSNFP.JOJTUSP(JMTPO%JQQBSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BÎÍPQFOBMEBQFTTPBKVSÓEJDB QFMBQSÈUJDBEFEFMJUPTBNCJFOUBJTTVSHFDPNPGPSNBOÍPBQFOBTEFQVOJÎÍPEBTDPOEVUBT MFTJWBTBPNFJPBNCJFOUFNBTDPNPGPSNBNFTNPEFprevenção EBQSÈUJDBEFTFNFMIBO UFTEFMJUPTGVOÎÍPEFSFTUPFTTFODJBMEBQPMÓUJDBBNCJFOUBMRVFDMBNBQFMBQSFTFSWBÎÍP 0DBSÈUFSQSFWFOUJWPEBQFOBMJ[BÎÍPQSFWBMFDFTPCSFPQVOJUJWPOBNFEJEB FNRVFNVJUPTEBOPTTÍPJSSFWFSTÓWFJTBUFOUBOEPNFTNPDPOUSBBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEF WJEBOPOPTTPQMBOFUB %JTDFSOJSPWFSEBEFJSPSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBQSÈUJDBEFMJUVPTBDPOUSBPNFJPBN CJFOUFÏUBSFGBNVJUPEJGÓDJM $PNFGFJUPDPOGPSNFEPVUSJOB&MÈEJP-FDFZUSB[JEPËDPMBÎÍPQFMP.JOJTUSP%JQQ "-7&4'FSOBOEP#BSBUBF(0.&4+PSHF4BMHBEP06OJWFSTPEB*OEÞTUSJBEF1FUSØMFPoEBQFTRVJTB ËSFmOBÎÍP&EJUPSB'VOEBÎÍP$BMPVTUF(VCFOLJBOQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 153 4BCJEBNFOUF PT NBJT HSBWFT BUFOUBEPT BP NFJP BNCJFOUF TÍP DBVTBEPT QFMBT FNQSFTBT QFMPT FOUFT DPMFUJWPT &N SB[ÍP EF TFSFN DPNFUJEPTOPÉNCJUPEBTQFTTPBTKVSÓEJDBTTVSHFFYUSFNBEJmDVMEBEF OBBQVSBÎÍPEPPVEPT TVKFJUPTBUJWPTEFUBJTEFMJUPT"DPNQMFYJEBEF EPT JOUFSFTTFT FN KPHP OB FTUSVUVSB EBT FNQSFTBT QPEF MFWBS Ë JSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFPSHBOJ[BEBEPTJOEJWÓEVPT " JNQPSUÉODJB DSFTDFOUF EB JOEÞTUSJB QFUSPMÓGFSB OP QBOPSBNB FOFSHÏUJDP NVOEJBM DPOEV[JV B VN FTUVEP EP QSPCMFNB BNCJFOUBM EF GPSNB TJTUFNÈUJDB EF NPEPRVFUSBOTGPSNBFTUBJOEÞTUSJBFNVNDPOUSJCVJOUFFGFUJWPQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJ NFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMEPNVOEPFNRVFWJWFNPTQFSNJUJOEPRVFTFUPSOBTTFSFBMJEBEF PQFOTBNFOUPEFRVFBTHFSBÎÜFTQSFTFOUFTEFWFSÍPEFTGSVUBSPTCFOTEBOBUVSF[B TFNQSFEFNPEPRVFOÍPDPNQSPNFUBBTOFDFTTJEBEFTEBTHFSBÎÜFTGVUVSBT. .VJUBT WF[FT B PDVQBÎÍP EP TPMP QPS QBSUF EBT JOEÞTUSJBT QFUSPRVÓNJDBT PDPSSFFNÈSFBTTFOTÓWFJTDPNQSPNFUFOEPOÍPTØPNFJPBNCJFOUFDPNBTFNJTTÜFT EFHBTFTFFnVFOUFTNBTUBNCÏNBDPOTFSWBÎÍPEFFDPTTJTUFNBTDPTUFJSPT 0EFSSBNBNFOUPEFMÓRVJEPTWB[BNFOUPTEFHBTFTJOEVTUSJBJTFNSB[ÍPEF BDJEFOUFTOBWBJTPVJOFmDÈDJBOPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFFYUSBÎÍPEPQFUSØMFPDPNQSPNF UFNTPCSFNBOFJSBPFDPTTJTUFNBNBSJOIP 0#SBTJMUFNEFNPOTUSBEPRVFPQSPCMFNBQPEFTFUPSOBSSFDPSSFOUF. %FUFOUPSEFJNQPSUBOUFTSFTFSWBTEFQFUSØMFPP#SBTJMUFNOP$BOBMEF4ÍP 4FCBTUJÍPPNBJPSUFSNJOBMQFUSPMÓGFSPEPQBÓTPBOUJHP5FSNJOBM"MNJSBOUF#BSSPTP 5&#"3 EFOPNJOBEPBUVBMNFOUF%VUPF5FSNJOBJT$FOUSP4VM%5$4 0 UFSNJOBM FTUÈ FN BUJWJEBEF EFTEF SFDFCFOEP FTUPRVF F EJTUSJCVJ ÎÍPEFBQSPYJNBEBNFOUFEPØMFPVUJMJ[BEPOP#SBTJM05$4UFNJNQPSUBOUF BUJWJEBEF DPNP JNQPSUBEPS F FOUSFQPTUP EF QFUSØMFP F EFSJWBEPT SFDFCFOEP NBJT EF TFJTDFOUPT OBWJPT QPS BOP NPWJNFOUBOEP NJMIÜFT EF N EF QFUSØMFP DPN DBQBDJEBEFEFBSNB[FOBNFOUPEFNJMIÍPEFNEFQFUSØMFPFNJMIÜFTEF NEFEFSJWBEPT. /VNFSPTPTBDJEFOUFTGPSBNDPOTUBUBEPTOBSFHJÍPEF4ÍP4FCBTUJÍPOBNBJPS QBSUFUFOEPTJEPJEFOUJmDBEPTDPNPSFTQPOTÈWFJTPTOBWJPTQFUSPMFJSPTEFSSBNBOEP NBJTEFTFJTNJMNEFØMFPOPDBOBMFTUVÈSJP (SP)#SVOEUMBOE0VS$PNNPO'VUVSF#SVOEUMBOE$PNJTTJPO0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT &NoDFOUPFTFTTFOUBCBSSJTEFQFUSØMFPWB[BSBNEFVNBDPMVOBEFQSPEVÎÍPEPOBWJPQMBUB GPSNBEFQSPEVÎÍPFBSNB[FOBNFOUPRVFSFBMJ[BWBUFTUFTEFFYUSBÎÍPOPQPÎP$BSJPDBFNo DFSDBEFEPJTNJMMJUSPTEFQFUSØMFPWB[BSBNEFVNOBWJPEFTBUJWBEPQFSUFODFOUFBVNBFNQSFTBQSJWBEB OP3JPEF+BOFJSPFNIPVWFWB[BNFOUPEFØMFPDSVRVFQPMVJVPSJP(VBFDÈFQSBJBFN4ÍP 4FCBTUJÍPoMJUPSBMOPSUFEF4ÍP1BVMPFNoDFSDBEFMJUSPTEFØMFPWB[BSBNEBMJOIBEF QSPEVÎÍPEB1FUSPCSBTFN3JBDIVFMPBLNEF"SBDBKVo$&%&º0%&QQ $FUFTCFin Oceanografia de um ecossistema subtropical – Plataforma de São Sebastião, SP"OB.BSJB4FUVCBM1JSFT7BOJOPSHBOJ[BEPSB &EVTQ4ÍP1BVMPQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 154 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos "USFMBEPBJTUPDPOTUBUBNPTRVFB#BJYBEB4BOUJTUBBQSFTFOUBPTNBJTHSBWFT DPOnJUPTEFVTPEPTPMPTFEJBOEPBUJWJEBEFTJOEVTUSJBJTQPSUVÈSJBTFVSCBOBTBMUB NFOUFQPMVFOUFTRVFDBVTBNTÏSJPTJNQBDUPTFNTFVWVMOFSÈWFMFQSPEVUJWPFDPT TJTUFNBFTUVBSJOPQSFKVEJDBOEPTFOTJWFMNFOUFPFTUPRVFQFTRVFJSPOBSFHJÍPCFN DPNPEBOPËTBUJWJEBEFTUVSÓTUJDBT 4FHVOEPFTUVEPTSFBMJ[BEPTPTHBTFTMJCFSBEPTQFMBTJOEÞTUSJBTTFEJBEBTFN $VCBUÍPUÐNDBVTBEPTÏSJPTSJTDPTEFEFTMJ[BNFOUPEBTFODPTUBTTFSSBOBTQSØYJNBT "TBVUPSJEBEFTDPNQFUFOUFTEFGPSNBEJSFUBPVJOEJSFUBEFWFNTFFTGPSÎBS QBSBFTUBCFMFDFSNFUBTFNFEJEBTBTFSFNFYFDVUBEBTFNDBSÈUFSFNFSHFODJBMDPN PPCKFUJWPEFSFEV[JSFDPOUSPMBSBDJEFOUFTOBFTUFJSBEPTFTGPSÎPTSFBMJ[BEPTQFMPT QBÓTFTEPNBS.FEJUFSSÉOFP. 4. UM PANORAMA DA POLUIÇÃO DECORRENTE DO PETRÓLEO "TFHVSBOÎBFPJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBMDPOTUJUVFNEPJTEPTBTQFDUPTNBJTJNQPS UBOUFTEFRVBMRVFSPQFSBÎÍPJOEVTUSJBMJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEPTFVSBNPEFBUVBÎÍP /PFOUBOUPPFTUVEPEBIJTUØSJBEPQFUSØMFPCFNDPNPBTEJmDVMEBEFTJOFSFO UFTBPTQSPKFUPTEFFYQMPSBÎÍPFQSPEVÎÍPDPOTUSVÎÍPEFQPÎPTQMBUBGPSNBTFPVUSBT JOTUBMBÎÜFT QFSNJUFWFSJmDBSRVFFTTBJOEÞTUSJBTFNPTUSBNVJUPNBJTJNQMJDBEBDPNPT QSPCMFNBTBUJOFOUFTËFTGFSBBNCJFOUBMHMPCBMFNSFMBÎÍPBPVUSBTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOÙNJDBT %FGBUP 3FDFOUFNFOUFBTDPNQBOIJBTDPNFÎBSBNBBWBMJBSBNFMIPSGPSNBEFEFmOJS TFVT QSPDFEJNFOUPT EF TFHVSBOÎB RVF OPSNBMNFOUF TÍP FYUSFNBNFOUF QSFTDSJUJWPT "QPOUBTFBHPSBNBJTQBSBBTQFDUPTHFSBJTEFJYBOEPBPTUÏDOJDPTBUBSFGBEFEFmOJSF JNQMFNFOUBSBTNFMIPSFTGPSNBTEFBUJOHJSFTTFTPCKFUJWPTEFOUSPEFDFSUPTQBSÉNFUSPT $POUVEPFTUBNFMIPSBOPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTEFTFHVSBOÎBOÍPBMDBOÎBUPEBT BTFNQSFTBTQFUSPMÓGFSBT $PNPFOTJOBN+PSHF4BMHBEP(PNFTF'FSOBOEP#BSBUB"MWFTBTDPNQB OIJBTEFWFN QPTTVJS iVN TJTUFNB EF HFTUÍP EF TFHVSBOÎBw DPODMVJOEP OP TFOUJEP EFRVFipolíticas e procedimentos sem um seguimento permanente da sua aplicação, estão destinados ao fracassowTPCQFOBEFBPBGBTUBSTFEBHFTUÍPEBDPNQBOIJBPDBTJPOBS SFTVMUBEPTHSBWPTPTËDPMFUJWJEBEF 0TFSSPTEFHFTUÍPEFOUSPEPTFHNFOUPQFUSPMÓGFSPHFSBNJNQBDUPTTFOTÓWFJT EPQPOUPEFWJTUBBNCJFOUBMQPEFOEPTFSTVCEJWJEJEPTFNUSÐTDBUFHPSJBTQSJODJQBJT "'0/40$ÓOUJB.BSJBUso e ocupação do solo na zona costeira do Estado de São Paulo – uma análise ambiental4ÍP1BVMP"OOBCMVNF'"1&41Q $G6NBDPSEP3FHJPOBM0SJHJOBMin Direito do Mar e do Meio AmbientePCDJUQQ "-7&4'FSOBOEP#BSBUBF(0.&4+PSHF4BMHBEP06OJWFSTPEB*OEÞTUSJBEF1FUSØMFPoEBQFTRVJTB ËSFmOBÎÍP&EJUPSB'VOEBÎÍP$BMPVTUF(VCFOLJBOQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 155 tEFSSBNFTEFQFUSØMFPUBOUPFNUFSSBRVBOUPOPNBS tFNJTTÜFTHBTPTBTOBBUNPTGFSBF tBMUFSBÎÜFTOBTVQFSGÓDJFUFSSFTUSFEFTEFBTnPSFTUBTUSPQJDBJTBUÏPTEFTFS UPTQBTTBOEPQFMBT[POBTIBCJUBEBT 0EFSSBNBNFOUPEFQFUSØMFPÏVNUJQPEFQPMVJÎÍPBNCJFOUBMEJGÓDJMEFTFS DPOUJEPFNSB[ÍPEBTFTQFDJmDJEBEFTEPQFUSØMFPRVFDPOTJTUFFNVNDPNCVTUÓWFM GØTTJM EF PSJHFN BOJNBM F WFHFUBM GPSNBEP HFPMPHJDBNFOUF IÈ NJMIÜFT EF BOPT ² VNBTVCTUÉODJBMÓRVJEBPMFPTBEFDPMPSBÎÍPFTDVSBFODPOUSBEBFNNVJUPTMVHBSFTOP NVOEPRVFQPEFTFSFYUSBÓEBOPDPOUJOFOUFFNUFSSBmSNFPVOPBTTPBMIPPDFÉOJDP DPNVNBOBUVSF[BQFDVMJBS " FYUSBÎÍP EP QFUSØMFP OP PDFBOP Ï GFJUB BUSBWÏT EF NBRVJOÈSJPT FTUBCFMF DJEPT FN QMBUBGPSNBT mYBT PV NØWFJT RVF CPNCFJBN P QFUSØMFP QBSB P OBWJP PV PMFPEVUPTQPEFOEPPDPSSFSPWB[BNFOUPEFQFUSØMFPFNOBWJPTQFUSPMFJSPTOBTQMB UBGPSNBTEFFYUSBÎÍPFOPTPMFPEVUPTEFEJTUSJCVJÎÍPDBVTBOEPEBOPTFOPSNFTBP NFJP BNCJFOUF FN SB[ÍP EF GBMIBT FTUSVUVSBJT EPT FRVJQBNFOUPT GBMIBT IVNBOBT OBFYFDVÎÍPFUBNCÏNQFMBQSFTTÍPFYFSDJEBOPGVOEPEPPDFBOPRVFQPEFDBVTBS mTTVSBTPVGBMIBTOPBTTPBMIPFTDBQBOEPHÈTPVØMFPBDBSSFUBOEPDBUÈTUSPGFTDVKB PSJHFNQPEFTFSFODPOUSBEBOBNÈHFTUÍP %FTBTUSFTBNCJFOUBJTEFTTFUJQPBDBSSFUBNPMBOÎBNFOUPOPNBSEFRVBOUJ EBEFTFOPSNFTEFØMFPGPSNBOEPNBODIBTRVFTÍPFTQBMIBEBTQFMBTDPSSFOUFTNBSÓ UJNBTFQFMBTDPSSFOUFTEFBS "QPMVJÎÍPDBVTBEBQFMPQFUSØMFPÏNVJUPUØYJDBQBSBPTBOJNBJTNBSJOIPTF QBSBBTBWFTNJHSBUØSJBTBMÏNEFQSFKVEJDBSJOEJSFUBNFOUFBQPQVMBÎÍPRVFWJWFOP MJUPSBMEBTÈSFBTBUJOHJEBT "JNQPSUÉODJBDSFTDFOUFEBJOEÞTUSJBQFUSPMÓGFSBOPQBOPSBNBFOFSHÏUJDPNVOEJBM FTVBTJOnVÐODJBTEJSFUBTOBFDPOPNJBEFRVBMRVFSQBÓTRVFQPTTVBVNBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBEF DBQUBÎÍPEFQFUSØMFPJOEV[BVNBFTQFDJBMBUFOÎÍPBFTUFTFUPSQPSQBSUFEP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP &OUSFOØTGPJJOTUJUVÓEBBBVUBSRVJBGFEFSBMEFOPNJOBEB"HÐODJB/BDJPOBM EP 1FUSØMFP (ÈT /BUVSBM F #JPDPNCVTUÓWFT "/1 DPN B GVOÎÍP EF SFHVMBNFO UBSPTFUPSDPNWJODVMBÎÍPBP.JOJTUÏSJPEF.JOBTF&OFSHJBBSUJHPEB-FJO¡ DPNPVNBGPSNBEFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBQPEFSHFSFODJBSBTBUJ WJEBEFTEBTDPNQBOIJBTQFUSPMÓGFSBT "MÏNEJTTPFNGPJTBODJPOBEPPUFYUPEFMFJRVFBQSPWPVBDSJBÎÍPEB FNQSFTB1FUSØMFP#SBTJMFJSP4"1&530#3"4 TPDJFEBEFBOÙOJNBEFDBQJUBMBCFSUPDVKP NBJPSBDJPOJTUBÏPHPWFSOPCSBTJMFJSPBUVBOEPOPTTFUPSFTEFFYQMPSBÎÍPFQSPEVÎÍP SFmOPDPNFSDJBMJ[BÎÍPFUSBOTQPSUFEFØMFPFHÈTOBUVSBMQFUSPRVÓNJDBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPEF EFSJWBEPTFOFSHJBFMÏUSJDBCJPDPNCVTUÓWFJTFPVUSBTGPOUFTSFOPWÈWFJTEFFOFSHJB. IUUQXXXQFUSPCSBTDPNCSQURVFNTPNPTQFSmMGPOUFPCUJEBFNBTI RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 156 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos &NRVFQFTFB1FUSPCSBTUFSDPNPNBJPSBDJPOJTUBPHPWFSOPCSBTJMFJSPFTUBOÍP ÏQSFTUBEPSBEFTFSWJÎPQÞCMJDPOÍPQPEFOEPTFSDPODFCJEBDPNPEFMFHBEBEB6OJÍP "6OJÍPFYQMPSBBBUJWJEBEFFDPOÙNJDBFNTFOUJEPFTUSJUPTVKFJUBOEPTFË EJTDJQMJOBKVSÓEJDBEBTFNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTBUVBOEPTPCPSFHJNFEFDPNQFUJÎÍPDPN BTEFNBJTFNQSFTBTRVFRVFJSBNQBSUJDJQBSEPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTMJDJUBUØSJPTOPTUFS NPTEPfEPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM33. %FTUB GPSNB P SFDPSSFOUF OÞNFSP EF BDJEFOUFT PDBTJPOBEPT BP MPOHP EPT BOPTQFMB1FUSPCSBTFBJODJQJFOUFSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BÎÍPQPSQBSUFEP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPTV HFSFDFSUBMFOJDÐODJBOPRVFUBOHFËmTDBMJ[BÎÍPFTUBUBMBQPOUPEFFTUBCFMFDFSVNB DPOGVTÍPFYJTUFOUFOPUPDBOUFËTSFMBÎÜFTFNQSFTBSJBJTFB6OJÍP /FTTFQBTTPP.JOJTUSP&SPT(SBVEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM45' OP WPUPQSPMBUBEPOB"%*"ÎÍP%JSFUBEF*ODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF OQFSNJUJVRVF TFQPOUVBTTFNBTSFMBÎÜFTFYJTUFOUFTFOUSFB1FUSPCSBTFB6OJÍP'FEFSBMDPNPTFHVF 0 BSHVNFOUP TFHVOEP P RVBM QPEFSJB DPNFSDJBMJ[BS P QFUSØMFP EB 6OJÍPQPSRVFBTVBQSPQSJFEBEFEFMB1FUSPCSBT ÏEFUJEBQFMB6OJÍP OÍP TF TVTUFOUB 1PJT Ï DFSUP RVF NFTNP QBSB DPOUSBUBS VOJDBNFOUF B DPNFSDJBMJ[BÎÍP EF QFUSØMFP B 6OJÍP UFSÈ EF MJDJUÈMB %F RVBMRVFS NPEPB1FUSPCSBTUSBOTGPSNBEBFNTJNQMFTBHFOUFDPNFSDJBMEB6OJÍP GPSOFDFSJBBPQBTTPRVFSFTVMUBSJBNBSDBOUFFNBSDBEBNFOUFTBDSJmDBEB BFYQMPSBÎÍPEPQFUSØMFPFEPHÈTOBUVSBMFOUSFOØT "1FUSPCSBTBUVBMNFOUFFTUÈQSFTFOUFFNWJOUFFPJUP QBÓTFTDPNVN WPMVNFEFJOWFTUJNFOUPTOPNPOUBOUFEFTFUFOUBFUSÐT3 CJ MIÜFT EF SFBJT PCUFOEP VNB SFDFJUB MÓRVJEB EF EV[FOUPT F RVBSFOUB F RVBUSP 3 CJMIÜFT EF SFBJT BQVSBOEP VN MVDSP MÓRVJEP EF USJOUB F USÐT CJMIÜFT EF SFBJT 3 QSPEV[JOEP EJBSJBNFOUF EPJT NJMIÜFT F TFJTDFOUPTFWJOUFFVNNJMCBSSJTEFQFUSØMFP FOUSFFMFTRVBUSPDFOUPTF DJORVFOUBFEPJTNJM EFCBSSJTEFHÈTOBUVSBMCFNDPNPQPTTVJOEPVNB 33 Art. 177. CF: Constituem monopólio da União: I – a pesquisa e a lavra das jazidas de petróleo e gás natural e outros hidrocarbonetos fluidos; II – a refinação do petróleo nacional ou estrangeiro; III – a importação e exportação dos produtos e derivados básicos resultantes das atividades previstas nos incisos anteriores; IV – o transporte marítimo do petróleo bruto de origem nacional ou de derivados básicos de petróleo produzidos no País, bem assim o transporte, por meio de conduto, de petróleo bruto, seus derivados e gás natural de qualquer origem; V – a pesquisa, a lavra, o enriquecimento, o reprocessamento, a industrialização e o comércio de minérios e minerais nucleares e seus derivados, com exceção dos radioisótopos, cuja produção, comercialização e utilização poderão ser autorizadas sob regime de permissão, conforme as alíneas b e c do inciso XXIII do caput do Art. 21 desta Constituição Federal. § 1º A União poderá contratar com empresas estatais ou privadas a realização das atividades previstas nos incisos I a IV deste artigo, observadas as condições estabelecidas em lei. (...) "ÎÍP%JSFUBEF*ODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFO¡%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM3FMBUPSQBSBPBDØSEÍP.JOJTUSP&SPT (SBVKVMHBNFOUP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 157 SFTFSWBEFEF[FTTFJTCJMIÜFTFRVBUSPDFOUPTNJMIÜFT EFCBSSJTFEF ØMFPFHÈTFRVJWBMFOUFT "1FUSPCSBTÏBSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBJOTUBMBÎÍPEFOVNFSPTBTQMBUBGPSNBTmYBT FnVUVBOUFTBMÏNEFQPTTVJSVNBGSPUBEFEV[FOUPTFRVBSFOUBFEPJTOBWJPTFBO HBSJBSUSJOUBNJMFTFTTFOUBFTFUFRVJMÙNFUSPTLN EFEVUPTEFQFUSØMFPF TFVTEFSJWBEPTBMÏNEFUFSPDPOUSPMFEFTFUFVTJOBTEFCJPDPNCVTUÓWFJTEF[FTTFJT UFSNFMÏUSJDBTFRVBUSPVTJOBTEFFOFSHJBFØMJDB35 $PNFTUFTFYQSFTTJWPTEBEPTUPSOBTFFWJEFOUFBJNQPSUÉODJBRVFPTFTUVEPT TPCSFJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBMEFDPSSFOUFTEPSJTDPJOFSFOUFËBUJWJEBEFQFUSPMÓGFSBQPEFN QSPQJDJBSFNVNDPOUFYUPEFQPMÓUJDBBNCJFOUBMOPQMBOPHMPCBM 0 FTUVEP EF JNQBDUP BNCJFOUBM EFWFSÈ QFSNJUJS B EPDVNFOUBÎÍP EPT QP UFODJBJT FGFJUPT GÓTJDPT CJPMØHJDPT TPDJBJT F EF TBÞEF RVF BT BUJWJEBEFT QFUSPMÓGFSBT QPEFSÍPEFTFOWPMWFSOBSFHJÍPCFNDPNPBJOGPSNBÎÍPOFDFTTÈSJBQBSBRVFPTFTQF DJBMJTUBTFHFTUPSFTQPTTBNUPNBSEFDJTÜFTTPCSFBWJBCJMJEBEFEPQSPKFUP "1FUSPCSBTDBVTBDPOTUBOUFTQSFPDVQBÎÜFTFNSB[ÍPEPTWB[BNFOUPTEFØMFP RVFGPSBNDPOTUBUBEPTDPNPEFTVBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF %FGBUPBOUFTEPBGVOEBNFOUPEBQMBUBGPSNB1FNNBSÎPEFFEP BDJEFOUFDPNBQMBUBGPSNB1FNBCSJMB1FUSPCSBTTPNBWBEF[PJUPEFTBTUSFTDBVTBEPT EFTEFNBSÎPEFQPSWB[BNFOUPEFØMFPFHBTPMJOBPVFNJTTÍPEFWBQPSFTEFTPEB DÈVTUJDBOPWFEFMFTTPNFOUFFOUSFF&NBQFOBTRVBUSPEFMFTKBOFJSPNBS ÎPKVOIPFKVMIPEF GPSBNMBOÎBEPTNBJTEFDJODPNJMIÜFTEFMJUSPTEFQFUSØMFP OBSFHJÍPDPTUFJSBEB#BÓBEF(VBOBCBSB3+ FN"SBVDÈSJB13 FFN5SBNBOEBÓ34 0DVTUPEFTTFTWB[BNFOUPTQBSBPFDPTTJTUFNBNBSJOIPQPEFSFQSFTFOUBSP DPNQSPNFUJNFOUPBMPOHPQSB[PEBEJWFSTJEBEFCJPMØHJDBFHFOÏUJDBDPNQPTUBQPS PSHBOJTNPTFQMBOUBTRVFGPSNBNBCBTFEBDBEFJBBMJNFOUBSFTÍPSFTQPOTÈWFJTQFMB EJTQFSTÍPJOUSBFJOUFSPDFÉOJDBEBTFTQÏDJFTBMJFYJTUFOUFT "BMUFSBÎÍPTJHOJmDBUJWBEPBNCJFOUFPDFÉOJDPQPEFSÈBHSBWBSBEJNJOVJÎÍP EPTQSJODJQBJTFTUPRVFTQFTRVFJSPTDPOTJEFSBEPTTPCSJTDPVNBWF[RVFTFUFOUBQPS DFOUP EFMFTTÍPTVQFSFYQMPSBEPTPVFTUÍPFNTFVMJNJUFCJPMØHJDPEFSFQSP EVÎÍP$BCFNFODJPOBSNBJTRVFPVUSPTJOBMWJTÓWFMEBEFHSBEBÎÍPEPTBNCJFOUFT PDFÉOJDPTÏBEFTDPMPSBÎÍPEPTSFDJGFTEFDPSBM &NCSFWFBBUJWJEBEFQFUSPMÓGFSBBQSFTFOUBNVJUPTSJTDPTFPNBJPSEFTBmP QBSBBTFNQSFTBTMJHBEBTBPTFUPSDPOTJTUFOBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFUPSOBSSFTQPOTÈWFM BNCJFOUBMNFOUFOPTFOUJEPEFQPEFSDPMBCPSBSQBSBNJOJNJ[BSPTEBOPTEBFYQMPSB ÎÍPEPTIJESPDBSCPOFUPTTPCSFBTSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTQBSBPTQSPQSJFUÈSJPTEBTDBSHBT EFIJESPDBSCPOFUPTEPTCBODPTEPNFSDBEPEFTFHVSPTEPQPOUPEFWJTUBEP%JSFJ UP*OUFSOBDJPOBMSFKFJUBOEPPTBDPSEPTQSJWBEPTFBMFJOPSUFBNFSJDBOB01"o0JM 1PMMVUJPO"DU WFKBPQSJNPSPTPUSBCBMIPEF.BEBNF$IBP8VLa Pollution du Fait IUUQXXXQFUSPCSBTDPNCSQURVFNTPNPTQFSmMGPOUFPCUJEBFNËTI RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 158 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos du Transfert Maritime des Hydrocarbures – Responsabilité et Indemnisation des Dommages*/%&.&3.ÙOBDP 1&%0/&1BSJT passim /FTUFQBTTPP1SJODÓQJPEB%FDMBSBÎÍPEP3JPTPCSFP.FJP"NCJFOUFFP %FTFOWPMWJNFOUPGPJMBQJEBS .FEJEBT EF QSFDBVÎÍP EFWFN TFS MBSHBNFOUF BQMJDBEBT QFMPT &TUBEPT TFHVOEP TVBT DBQBDJEBEFT &N DBTP EF SJTDP EF EBOPT HSBWFT PV JSSFWFSTÓWFJT B BVTÐODJB EF DFSUF[B DJFOUÓmDB BCTPMVUB OÍP EFWF TFSWJS EFQSFUFYUPQBSBSFNFUFSQBSBNBJTUBSEFBBEPÎÍPEBTNFEJEBTFGFUJWBT WJTBOEPQSFWFOJSBEFHSBEBÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUF &N DPNQMFNFOUP EFUFSNJOB P 1SJODÓQJP EB NFTNB EFDMBSBÎÍP JOUFSOBDJPOBM "T BVUPSJEBEFT OBDJPOBJT EFWFN TF FTGPSÎBS QBSB QSPNPWFS B JOUFSOBMJ[BÎÍPEPTDVTUPTEFQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFFBVUJMJ[BÎÍP EFJOTUSVNFOUPTFDPOÙNJDPTFNWJSUVEFEPQSJODÓQJPTFHVOEPPRVBM ÏPQPMVJEPSRVFEFWFFNQSJODÓQJPBTTVNJSPDVTUPEBQPMVJÎÍPOB QSFPDVQBÎÍP QFMP JOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDP F TFN TVCNFUFSTF BP DPNÏSDJP JOUFSOBDJPOBMFBPJOWFTUJNFOUP ²FWJEFOUFRVFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPFPBVNFOUPFYQSFTTJWPEBT BUJWJEBEFTQFUSPMÓGFSBTUÐNMFWBEPNVJUPNBJTBPEFTHBTUFFDPMØHJDPEPRVFBPEFTFO WPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFM 4PNFOUFPHFSFODJBNFOUPDPTUFJSPBNQBSBEPQFMPTFTUVEPTDJFOUÓmDPTFQFMB MFHJTMBÎÍPEFDVOIPJOUFSOBDJPOBM$POWFOÎÜFTF5SBUBEPT QPEFSÈQFSNJUJSRVFBJO EB QFSEVSF B FYQMPSBÎÍP P USBOTQPSUF F P DPOTVNP EF IJESPDBSCPOFUPT EF NPEP RVFOPGVUVSPB5FSSBBJOEBFTUFKBÓOUFHSBFBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTEFFYQBOTÍPEPTFS IVNBOPDPOUJOVFNJOUBDUBT 5. CONCLUSÃO: ALGUMAS SUGESTÕES PARA O BRASIL E O MERCOSUL "[POBDPTUFJSBCSBTJMFJSBBCSBOHFVNBGBJYBTVQFSJPSBRVJMÙNFUSPTEF FYUFOTÍPDPNQSFFOEFOEPVNDPOKVOUPEFFDPTTJTUFNBTDPOUÓHVPTTPCSFVNBÈSFBEF BQSPYJNBEBNFOUFNJMRVJMÙNFUSPTRVBESBEPT"DPTUBCSBTJMFJSBBCBSDBVNBQBSUF UFSSFTUSFDPOUBOEPDPNNVOJDÓQJPTFVNBÈSFBNBSJOIBRVFDPSSFTQPOEFBPNBS UFSSJUPSJBMCSBTJMFJSPDPNMBSHVSBEFNJMIBTOÈVUJDBTBQBSUJMIBSEBMJOIBEFDPTUB "[POBDPTUFJSBDPODFOUSBNJMIÜFTEFQFTTPBTJNQMJDBOEPHSBOEFEFO TJEBEFQPQVMBDJPOBMFNUPSOPEFIBCJUBOUFTQPSRVJMÙNFUSPRVBESBEPDJODPWF [FTTVQFSJPSËNFEJBOBDJPOBMRVFÏEFIBCJUBOUFTQPSRVJMÙNFUSPRVBESBEP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 159 "GPSNBÎÍPUFSSJUPSJBMCSBTJMFJSBUFWFJOÓDJPOPQFSÓPEPDPMPOJBMQPSPDBTJÍPEF TVBEFTDPCFSUBFNQSJODJQJBOEPQFMPMJUPSBMFUFOEPTFDPODFOUSBEPOBTDJEBEFT NBJTJNQPSUBOUFTFNUPSOPEBTÈSFBTMJUPSÉOFBTDPNFYDFÎÍPEF4ÍP1BVMPRVFUPNPV PVUSPDBNJOIPNBJTQBSBPFTUFFNEJSFÎÍPEPQMBOBMUPBmNEFFWJUBSPTBUBRVFTEPT UBNPJPTDGBSFTQFJUPEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFEBDPMPOJ[BÎÍPEF4ÍP1BVMP.BSJBEB $PODFJÎÍP.BSUJOT3JCFJSPin A Vida Urbana Paulistana vista pela Administração Municipal 1562-1822.BOPMF&EJUPSB.JOIB&EJUPSB 4ÍP1BVMPpassim /PUPDBOUFBPMJUPSBMJOJDJBMNFOUFBPDVQBÎÍPPDPSSJEBGPJEFOBUVSF[BNJ MJUBSQBSBFYQVMTBSPTDPSTÈSJPTJOHMFTFTFGSBODFTFT1PTUFSJPSNFOUFDPNPBVYÓMJP EPTKFTVÓUBTPTDPMPOPTQPSUVHVFTFTGPSBNTFmYBOEPOPJOUFSJPSEPQBÓTQBSUJOEP TFNQSFEBDPTUB "TGPSNBÎÜFTVSCBOÓTUJDBTRVFEFTUBSUFTFBQSFTFOUBSBNBJOEBIPKFJOnVFN OPBTQFDUPQPMÓUJDPFFDPOÙNJDPEP#SBTJMQPEFOEPTFNFODJPOBSDPOKVOUPTFYQSFT TJWPTBTBCFSOBSFHJÍPEF0MJOEB3FDJGFOP3FDÙODBWP#BJBOPOBSFHJÍPEPMJUPSBM nVNJOFOTFFOPMJUPSBMQBVMJTUB "JOEVTUSJBMJ[BÎÍPQPSTVBWF[UFWFJOÓDJPTPNFOUFOPTBOPTEPTÏDVMP 99JNQMJDBOEPVNBHSBOEFFYQBOTÍPFBnVYPEFSJRVF[BTNBTUBNCÏNVNBBUJWJ EBEFEFTFOGSFBEBDMBSBNFOUFEFTUSVJEPSBEBTTFOTÓWFJTÈSFBTMJUPSÉOFBTNBSDBEBTQFMB FYDFTTJWBDPODFOUSBÎÍPEBQPQVMBÎÍPFQPSVNBVSCBOJ[BÎÍPDBØUJDBUFOEPFNWJTUBP TVSHJNFOUPEFÈSFBTEFDBSÐODJBGBWFMBT CFNFWJEFOUFTDPNPÏPDBTPEB7JMB4PDØ FN$VCBUÍP41 FEPTNPSSPTBPMPOHPEBPSMBNBSÓUJNBEBDJEBEFEP3JPEF+BOFJSP &NRVFQFTFPRVBESPWFSEBEFJSBNFOUFCSVUBMEBDPOEJÎÍPEFWJEBEBTQP QVMBÎÜFTFYJTUFOUFTBPMPOHPEBGBJYBMJUPSÉOFBQSJODJQBMNFOUFEBTHSBOEFTNFUSØQP MFTBMFHJTMBÎÍPCSBTJMFJSBQSPDVSPVEFmOJSPTFTQBÎPTDPTUFJSPTFMJUPSÉOFPTEBOEP ÐOGBTFBPDPOUSPMFFYFSDJEPOBTÈSFBTFNDPNFOUPTPCSFUVEPQFMB6OJÍP'FEFSBM "SFHJÍPDPTUFJSBCSBTJMFJSBÏNBSDBEBQPSHSBOEFTDPOUSBTUFTDPODFOUSBOEP ÈSFBTEFVSCBOJ[BÎÍPJOUFOTBBUJWJEBEFTQPSUVÈSJBTFJOEVTUSJBJTFFYQMPSBÎÍPUVSÓTUJDB FNHSBOEFFTDBMBQSJODJQBMNFOUFOPTDFOUSPTSFHJPOBJTMJUPSÉOFPTÈSFBTFTUVBSJOBTF CBÓBTPOEFTFEFVPJOÓDJPEBDPMPOJ[BÎÍPEPQBÓT %FBDPSEPDPNVNFTUVEP'POUF*#(&#"4&4&."30." MFWBEPBFGFJUPQFMB'BDVMEBEFEF"SRVJUFUVSBF6SCBOJTNPEB641DPOTUBUPVTFRVF EF/PSUFB4VMBDPTUBCSBTJMFJSBTPGSFEFHSBEBÎÍPCJPMØHJDBBUNPTGÏSJDBFEBGPMØHJDB FQBJTBHÓTUJDBEFDPSSFOUFTEPTTFHVJOUFTGBUPSFT* FTQFDVMBÎÍPJNPCJMJÈSJB** QP MVJÎÍPJOEVTUSJBM*** FYQMPSBÎÍPBHSPQFDVÈSJBEFÓOEPMFEFTUSVUJWBQBSBPNFJPBN CJFOUF*7 PTQPSUPTDPNPTTFVTDPOTFDUÈSJPTEFTUSVUJWPTQBSBPNBSFQBSBBMJOIB EBDPTUB7 BQFTDBQSFEBUØSJB7* BNJOFSBÎÍPDPNSFTVMUBEPTQFSWFSTPTOÍPTØ QBSBBOBUVSF[BNBTQBSBBTQPQVMBÎÜFTBCPSÓHJOFTPDPSSFOEPFNUPEPPQBÓT7** PEFTNBUBNFOUPF7*** BFYQBOTÍPVSCBOBEFTFOGSFBEB "ÈSFBEFEPNÓOJPEB.BUB"UMÉOUJDBÏVNEPTTFHNFOUPTRVFTFDPOTJEFSB FNFTUBEPDSÓUJDPEFEFHSBEBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMOP#SBTJM"MJOIBDPTUFJSBEB+VSFJB1JDJO HVBCB#FSUJPHB$BOBOFJBF*HVBQFOP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPFBSFHJÍPEF1BSBOBHVÈ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 160 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos OP1BSBOÈFBSFHJÍPNFUSPQPMJUBOBEP3JPEF+BOFJSPTVQPSUBNEPJTEPTUSÐTNBJT JNQPSUBOUFTDFOUSPTJOEVTUSJBJTEPQBÓTPDPNQMFYPQPSUVÈSJPQFUSPRVÓNJDPFTJEF SÞSHJDPEF4BOUPT$VCBUÍPFPDPNQMFYPJOEVTUSJBMQPSUVÈSJPEP3JPEF+BOFJSP 0MJUPSBMCSBTJMFJSPUFNTJEPBHSFEJEPQPSBDJEFOUFTDPNQFUSØMFPFEFSJWBEPT DPOTUBOUFNFOUF NBT EF NPEP QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF HSBWF B QBSUJS EF NBSÎP EF RVBOEP VN DBSHVFJSP GSFUBEP QFMB 1FUSPCSBT EFSSBNPV NJM UPOFMBEBT EF ØMFP OB #BÓBEB(VBOBCBSBDGIUUQXXXBNCJFOUFCSBTJMDPNCS &NGPJDSJBEPP*#"."*OTUJUVUPEF.FJP"NCJFOUFFEPT3FDVSTPT /BUVSBJT 3FOPWÈWFJT NFSDÐ EB -FJ O EF EF GFWFSFJSP EF DPN P PCKFUJWPEFVOJmDBSBQPMÓUJDBBNCJFOUBMCSBTJMFJSBFDPSSJHJSBTEJTUPSÎÜFTFYJTUFOUFT TPCSFUVEPOBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEBTVOJEBEFTEFDPOTFSWBÎÍP 4PCSFWFJPP%FDSFUPOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFRVFQSPNVMHBB $POWFOÎÍP*OUFSOBDJPOBMTPCSF1SFQBSP3FTQPTUBF$PPQFSBÎÍPEFDBTPEF1PMVJÎÍP -POESFT RVFQÜFFNEFTUBRVFBOFDFTTJEBEFEFTFQSFTFSWBSPNFJP BNCJFOUF IVNBOP FN HFSBM F P NFJP BNCJFOUF NBSJOIP FN QBSUJDVMBS CFN DPNP SFDPOIFDFOEPBTÏSJBBNFBÎBEFQPMVJÎÍPQPSØMFPFOWPMWFOEPQMBUBGPSNBTPDFÉOJDBT QPSUPTNBSÓUJNPTFJOTUBMBÎÜFTEFPQFSBÎÍPDPNQFUSØMFPCFNDPNPQSFDPOJ[BOEP BOFDFTTJEBEFEFVNBBÎÍPSÈQJEBFFGFUJWBQBSBNJOJNJ[BSPTEBOPTEFDPSSFOUFTEBT BUJWJEBEFTQSJODJQBMNFOUFQFUSPMÓGFSBTOPNFJPNBSJOIP 3FGFSJEB$POWFOÎÍPEF-POESFTEFJOEJDBBOFDFTTJEBEFEFTFQSFWFOJS FEFQSFDBWFSBDJEFOUFTDPNØMFPOPNBSQFMBmTDBMJ[BÎÍPEPTOBWJPTFEFNBJTFOHF OIPTUSFJOBNFOUPEPQFTTPBMBGFUBEPËmTDBMJ[BÎÍPFBEJTQPOJCJMJ[BÎÍPEFSFDVSTPT QPSQBSUFEPTQBÓTFTDPOUSBUBOUFTQBSBMFWBSBCPOTSFTVMUBEPTPTPCKFUJWPTEFNJOJNJ [BÎÍPEPTSJTDPTEFDPSSFOUFTEPTBDJEFOUFTDPNØMFPOPNBS &NEFKVMIPEFQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEB-FJOGPJJOTUJUVÓEPP 4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMEF6OJEBEFTEF$POTFSWBÎÍPEB/BUVSF[BFTUBCFMFDFOEPDSJUÏSJPT FOPSNBTQBSBBDSJBÎÍPJNQMBOUBÎÍPFBHFTUÍPEBTVOJEBEFTEFDPOTFSWBÎÍPRVF TFEJWJEFNFNEPJTHSVQPTB VOJEBEFTEFQSPUFÎÍPJOUFHSBMFC VOJEBEFTEFVTP TVTUFOUÈWFM"QSJNFJSBUFNQPSPCKFUJWPCÈTJDPQSFTFSWBSBOBUVSF[BTFOEPBENJUJEP BQFOBTPVTPJOEJSFUPEFTFVTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTcom exceção dos casos previstos nesta lei"ÞMUJNBUFNQPSPCKFUJWPCÈTJDPDPNQBUJCJMJ[BSBDPOTFSWBÎÍPEBOBUVSF[BDPNP VTPTVTUFOUÈWFMEFQBSDFMBEFTFVTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJT 0#SBTJMÏTJHOBUÈSJPFNFNCSPEP.&3$046-EJTQPOEPPTRVBUSPQBÓTFT PSJHJOÈSJPT"SHFOUJOB6SVHVBJ#SBTJMF1BSBHVBJ EFQSFWJTÍPMFHJTMBUJWBDPOTUJUVDJP OBMOPRVFTFSFGFSFBPNFJPBNCJFOUFGBDJMJUBOEPBUBSFGBEFBEBQUBÎÍPEBTMFHJTMB ÎÜFTJOUFSOBTQBSBBUFOEFSBVNQSPQØTJUPDPNVOJUÈSJPEFEFGFTBBNCJFOUBMDG"SUJ HPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPBSHFOUJOBSFGPSNBEPEFBSUJHPTFEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP EP1BSBHVBJEFBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDB0SJFOUBMEP6SVHVBJ EF DPN BT SFGPSNBT EF B SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF BNCJFOUBM OP 6SVHVBJ GPJ JNQMFNFOUBEBQFMB-FJORVFQSFWÐBDPPQFSBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMSFHJPOBMF JOUFSOBDJPOBMFBQBSUJDJQBÎÍPOBTPMVÎÍPEPTQSPCMFNBTBNCJFOUBJTHMPCBJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 161 0TEPDVNFOUPTSFGFSFOUFTBP.&3$046-EFJYBNFOUSFWFSVNBHSBOEFQSF PDVQBÎÍPDPNPTQFSJHPTFDPMØHJDPTEFDPSSFOUFTEBMJWSFDJSDVMBÎÍPEFNFSDBEPSJBT DPNP QPS FYFNQMP P 1SPHSBNB EF -JCFSBÎÍP $PNFSDJBM EP 5SBUBEP EF "TTVOÎÍP "OFYP* OÍPIBWFOEPUPEBWJBBUÏPQSFTFOUFNPNFOUPOFOIVNBDPSEPFTQFDÓmDP EFDPPQFSBÎÍPQBSBPDPNCBUFDPOKVOUPFNUFSNPTEFDPPQFSBÎÍPFEFJOUFHSBÎÍP SFMBUJWBNFOUFËQPMVJÎÍPBDJEFOUBMEPTTFVTNBSFTFPDFBOPT "QSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFGPJEFWJEBNFOUFPCKFUPEBTQSFPDVQBÎÜFTEPT EJQMPNBUBTTJHOBUÈSJPTEP5SBUBEPEF"TTVOÎÍPFTUBCFMFDFOEPBOFDFTTJEBEFEFTF SFTPMWFSPQSPCMFNBEBQPMVJÎÍPBUSBWÏTEFVNFYBNFHMPCBMDPOTPBOUFPi1SPHSBNB EF"ÎÍPEP.&3$046-wRVFIBWJBTJEPFTUBCFMFDJEPQBSBPJOÓDJPEPOPWPNJMÐOJP DPOTPBOUFPJUFNEFTFVUFYUP 3.1. El Medio Ambiente. El objetivo será formular y proponer estrategias y directrices que garanticen la protección del medio ambiente de los Estados Partes en un contexto de libre comercio y consolidación de la Unión Aduanera, considerando las directrices básicas de política ambiental aprobadas por la Res. N. 10/94 y los principios del desarrollo sostenido emanados de la Conferencia de Naciones Unidas para el Medio Ambiente y Desarrollo llevada a cabo en Rio de Janeiro en 1992. /FTUB QFSTQFDUJWB GPJ DFMFCSBEP P i"DPSEP TPCSF $PPQFSBÎÍP FN .BUÏSJB "NCJFOUBMwmSNBEPQFMPTRVBUSPQBÓTFTNFNCSPTEP.&3$046-FNEFEF[FN CSPEFQPOEPFNSFMFWPBTRVFTUÜFTBNCJFOUBJTOBTÈSFBTGSPOUFJSJÎBTFFTUBCF MFDFOEPBOFDFTTJEBEFEBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFVNFTGPSÎPDPOKVOUP "FYFDVÎÍPEPSFGFSJEPBDPSEPUFNQPSØSHÍPFYFDVUJWPB$PNJTTÍPEF$PPQFSB ÎÍPFN.BUÏSJB"NCJFOUBMRVFBFYFNQMPEB$PNJTTÍP3".0(&ÏBSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMB IBSNPOJ[BÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWBBNCJFOUBMOPT&TUBEPT1BSUFTEFWFOEPFMBCPSBSQSPHSBNBTEF NPOJUPSBNFOUPBUNPTGÏSJDPEFSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFNHFSBMFEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTPDJPF DPOÙNJDPCFNDPNPSFGFSFOUFËEFmOJÎÍPEPTDSJUÏSJPTSFMBUJWPTBPJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBM &NDPNQMFNFOUBÎÍPGPJmSNBEPP"DPSEP.BSDPTPCSFP.FJP"NCJFOUF EP.&3$046-FN"TTVOÎÍPOP1BSBHVBJFNEFKVOIPEFSFDPOIFDFOEP BOFDFTTJEBEFEFDPOUBSDPNVNNBSDPKVSÓEJDPQBSBSFHVMBNFOUBSBTBÎÜFTEFQSP UFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFFBDPOTFSWBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTEP.&3$046-DPN CBTFOP5SBUBEPEF"TTVOÎÍPOP1SPUPDPMPEF0VSP1SFUPOB3FTPMVÎÍPOEP (SVQP.FSDBEP$PNVNFOB3FTPMVÎÍPOEP4(5O.FJP"NCJFOUF 0DBQÓUVMP***EPNFODJPOBEPBDPSEPQSFWÐBDPPQFSBÎÍPEPT&TUBEPT1BSUFT QBSB B QSPUFÎÍP EPT SFDVSTPT OBUVSBJT NFEJBOUF B BEPÎÍP EF QPMÓUJDBT DPNVOT F B USPDBEFJOGPSNBÎÍPTPCSFBTQPTJÎÜFTSFHJPOBJTFNGPSPTBNCJFOUBJTJOUFSOBDJPOBJT "IBSNPOJ[BÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWBQFSNJUJSÈVNHSBOEFBWBOÎPOPBQFSGFJÎPBNFOUP EBTJOTUJUVJÎÜFTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTFTUBCFMFDJEBTQBSBPDPNCBUFËQPMVJÎÍPTPCSFUVEP BDJEFOUBMQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPBMÓOFBiDwEP"DPSEP.BSDP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 162 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos 0UVSJTNPOP.&3$046-QPSPVUSPMBEPBCSFHSBOEFTQFSTQFDUJWBTQBSB PEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPEPTQBÓTFTTJHOBUÈSJPTEP5SBUBEPEF"TTVOÎÍPEF SFTUP FYQFSJÐODJB CFN DPODSFUJ[BEB OB &VSPQB TPCSFUVEP OB ÈSFB JOUFHSBOUF EB $POWFOÎÍP3".0(& 0UVSJTNPBNCJFOUBMTFNEÞWJEBQFSNJUFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPEP MJUPSBMFNHFSBMNBSDBEPQPSVNBQPQVMBÎÍPDBSFOUFTFNEBOJmDBSBFDPMPHJB4PNFOUF QPEFSÈUFSTVDFTTPDPNBBEPÎÍPEFVNBQPMÓUJDBEFJOUFHSBÎÍPDPNPTQBÓTFTWJ[JOIPT "MFHJTMBÎÍPJOUFSOBEFDBEBVNEPTQBÓTFTOPUØQJDPBNCJFOUBMEFWFSÈTFS SFWJTUBNÈYJNFUFOEPFNDPOUBRVFBMHVOTQBÓTFTTFTVCNFUFNBPTJTUFNBGFEFSBUJWP DPNPP#SBTJMFB"SHFOUJOBFPVUSPTBPTJTUFNBVOJUÈSJPDPNPP1BSBHVBJFP6SVHVBJ "RVFTUÍPEPMJYPOBTQSBJBTEPEFSSBNBNFOUPEFØMFPFTFVTEFSJWBEPTF QSPEVUPTRVÓNJDPTOBGBJYBDPTUFJSBFBQPMVJÎÍPEBTOBTDFOUFTQPEFSÍPUFSTPMVÎÜFT NBJTTBUJTGBUØSJBTFNVNBBCPSEBHFNJOUFSOBDJPOBM 0FYFSDÓDJPEPTQPEFSFTEPT&TUBEPTDPTUFJSPTFNNBUÏSJBEFQSFWFOÎÍPEBQP MVJÎÍPNBSJOIBTFSÈHSBOEFNFOUFBQFSGFJÎPBEPNFSDÐEBBEPÎÍPEFVNBQPMÓUJDBEFDPP QFSBÎÍPFEFJOUFHSBÎÍPTPCSFPTUFNBTEBJOUFHSBÎÍPFDPPQFSBÎÍPWFKBNOPTTPTBSUJHPT Teoria Geral da Integração &DPOÙNJDB3FWJTUB5SJCVUÈSJBFEF'JOBOÎBT1ÞCMJDBT OPW EF[FSoberania: Contribuição para a construção de uma Teoria Geral do Direito da Integração Econômica3FWJTUB5SJCVUÈSJBFEF'JOBOÎBT1ÞCMJDBT TFUPVU FDPNSFMBÎÍPËTNFEJEBTGVODJPOBJTEFJOUFSWFOÎÍPEP&TUBEPTPCSFPTOBWJPTFBT FNQSFTBTQFUSPMÓGFSBTRVFFYQMPSBNIJESPDBSCPOFUPTOBQMBUBGPSNBDPOUJOFOUBM 0OPWPSFHJNFKVSÓEJDPEPNBSDPODMBNBPTQBÓTFTTJHOBUÈSJPTEPUFYUPEF .0/5&(0#": BBEPUBSFNUPEBTBTNFEJEBTOFDFTTÈSJBTËQSPUFÎÍPEFUÍP JOEJTQFOTÈWFMSFDVSTPOBUVSBMRVFOÍPÏJOFTHPUÈWFMPNBSRVFQPEFTFSFYUSFNB NFOUFQSFKVEJDBEPQFMBFYUSBÎÍPTFNDPOUSPMFEPQFUSØMFP $PNFGFJUPB$POWFOÎÍPEBT/BÎÜFT6OJEBTTPCSFP%JSFJUPEP.BS$/6 %. USBUBEPNVMUJMBUFSBMRVFFTUBCFMFDFPTQSJODÓQJPTHFSBJTEBFYQMPSBÎÍPEPTSF DVSTPTOBUVSBJTEPNBSGPJSBUJmDBEBQFMP#SBTJMFNEF[FNCSPEFRVFUBNCÏN DVJEPVQPSNFJPEB-FJOEFEFKBOFJSPBBEPUBSPDPODFJUPEF[POBFDP OÙNJDBFYDMVTJWBQBSBBTNJMIBTNBSÓUJNBTBEKBDFOUFT De lege ferenda DBCF GSJTBS RVF BT NFEJEBT USJCVUÈSJBT QPEFN DPOTJTUJS FN VNBCPBNBOFJSBEFTFQSPUFHFSDPNFmDÈDJBPNFJPBNCJFOUF.VJUPNBJTEPRVF NFSBNFOUF BSSFDBEBUØSJB B GVOÎÍP mTDBMJTUB EPT JNQPTUPT F UBYBT QFSNJUJSÈ NBJPS FmDÈDJB EB mTDBMJ[BÎÍP QPS QBSUF EBT BVUPSJEBEFT TPCSFUVEP NVOJDJQBJT TPCSF BT BUJWJEBEFTEFFYQMPSBÎÍPEPQFUSØMFP 0QSFDFJUPiRVFNDPOUBNJOBQBHBwTFJOTFSFNVJUPCFNOPTJTUFNBEBBEPÎÍP EPTUSJCVUPTEJUPTFDPMØHJDPTDPNPNFJPQBSBSFTUSJOHJSFQVOJSBTTJUVBÎÜFTEFSJTDPPV EFQPMVJÎÍPWFSJmDBEBDPNPCFNTBMJFOUB3BNØO'BMDØOZ5FMMBRVFBQSFTFOUBBTJUVB ÎÍPEBQSPJCJÎÍPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTBUJWJEBEFTHSBWFNFOUFDPOUBNJOBOUFTFYQSFTTBNFO UFQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFTQBOIPMBQBSÈHSBGP FBEFmOJÎÍPOPSNBUJWB EPTMJNJUFTBPVUSPTEJSFJUPTJODMVJOEPBJNQPTJÎÍPmTDBMTPCSFBFNQSFTBRVFFYQMPSF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 Algumas considerações sobre o direito ambiental e o impacto das explorações de petróleo 163 BUJWJEBEFQPMVFOUFDG-"4.&%*%"453*#65"3*"4.&*0".#*&/5"-&4:-"+6 3*4136%&/$*" $0/45*56$*0/"- in %FSFDIP %FM .ÏEJP "NCJFOUF Z "ENJOJT USBDJØO-PDBMPSHBOJ[BEPS+PTÏ&TUFWF1BSEP %JQVUBDJØEF#BSDFMPOB$JWJUBT %FGBUPBUSJCVUBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMDPOTUJUVJVNBFYJHÐODJBMØHJDBEPQSJODÓQJP iQPMVJEPSQBHBEPSwPViRVFNDPOUBNJOBQBHBwSFHSBRVFOBTDFVOPÉNCJUPEBTDJ ÐODJBTFDPOÙNJDBTFGPJBTTVNJEBQPTUFSJPSNFOUFQFMB0$%&FQFMBT$PNVOJEBEFT &VSPQFJBTFNFFNSFTQFDUJWBNFOUF " &TQBOIB EFUFSNJOPV P GBUP JNQPOÓWFM QBSB BT *MIBT #BMFBSFT FMFHFOEP FMFNFOUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTTJUVBEPTOPUFSSJUØSJPBUSÈTDJUBEPFDVKBTBUJWJEBEFTJODJEBN TPCSFPNFJPBNCJFOUFDPNPJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEPQSJODÓQJPEFRVFBBVUPSJEBEFMPDBM EJTQÜFEPTNFJPTQBSBprevenir PTBUFOUBEPTDPOUSBBOBUVSF[BJODMVJOEPBÓBUSJCVUB ÎÍPDGNBJTFYUFOTBNFOUF1FESP.BOVFM)FSSFSB.PMJOBin LOS TRIBUTOS COM '*/&4 ".#*&/5"-&4 *.16&4504 "650/0.*$04 40#3& */45"-"$*0/&4 $0/5".*/"/5&4Derecho Del Médio Ambiente y Administración LocalPCDJU &N CSFWF RVBMRVFS NFEJEB UFOEFOUF Ë QSPUFÎÍP BNCJFOUBM F BP DPOUSPMF EBFYQMPSBÎÍPEPTFMFNFOUPTOBUVSBJTFOFSHÏUJDPTEFQFOEFEPOFDFTTÈSJPFRVJMÓCSJP QBSBFWJUBSPQPOUPEFSVQUVSB 0#SBTJMJNQMFNFOUPVPQSJODÓQJPEBQSFDBVÎÍPQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEFNFEJEBT BENJOJTUSBUJWBTFOUSFBTRVBJTQPEFNPTEFTUBDBSB3FTPMVÎÍPO1MBOPEF &NFSHÐODJB*OEJWJEVBMo1&* P1MBOPEF«SFB%FDSFUPO mYBOEPB BCSBOHÐODJBEPTQMBOPTDPNPTFHVF tBCSBOHÐODJBOBDJPOBM tDPODFOUSBÎÍPEFJOTUBMBÎÜFTFFNQSFFOEJNFOUPTF tGPDPJOEJWJEVBMOPTQPOUPTPSHBOJ[BEPT "MFHJTMBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMFNWJHPSEFUFSNJOBBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFBVEJUPSJBTRVFEF WFNTFSSFBMJ[BEBTQFMB"HÐODJB/BUVSBMEP1FUSØMFP(ÈT/BUVSBMF#JPDPNCVTUÓWFJT "/1 RVFEFWFNTFSSJHPSPTBT 4FHVOEP P SFQSFTFOUBOUF EB "/1 4ÓMWJP +BCMPOTLJ FOUSF F GPSBN GFJUBTDFOUPFUSJOUB BVEJUPSJBTSFMBUPTEFOÍPDPOGPSNJEBEFFBQMJDBEBTNVMUBT EFRVBSFOUBNJMIÜFTEFSFBJTFDBUPS[FNFEJEBTDBVUFMBSFTDPNJOUFSEJÎÍPEFQSPEVÎÍP "TDPNQBOIJBTQFUSPMÓGFSBTFTUÍPTFNPWFOEPOPTFOUJEPEFVNBVNFOUPDSFT DFOUFEFOPWBTPQPSUVOJEBEFTEFOFHØDJPTFNFSDBEPTWJTBOEPKVOUBNFOUFDPNPT QBÓTFTEFUFOUPSFTEFFOFSHJBNBOUFSBDBQBDJEBEFIVNBOBEFSFTPMWFSBTEJmDVMEBEFT BGBTUBOEP BT DSJTFT EF EFQFOEÐODJB F QSPDVSBOEP FTUBCFMFDFS P FRVJMÓCSJP FOFSHÏUJDP HMPCBMFYUSFNBNFOUFEFMJDBEPEFNPEPRVFFTUBCFMFÎBVNBQPMÓUJDBRVFHBSBOUBBTF HVSBOÎBDPNSFMBÎÍPËTFYQMPSBÎÜFTOVDMFBSFTQFSNJUBJOWFTUJNFOUPTFMFWBEPTFNOP WBTUFDOPMPHJBTFDPODSFUJ[FBNBOVUFOÎÍPTFNEFQFOEÐODJBEPTDPNCVTUÓWFJTGØTTFJT 'POUF"HÐODJB$ÉNBSBEF/PUÓDJBT$ÉNBSBEPT%FQVUBEPT1VCMJDBEPOP+PSOBMEB$É NBSB"OPOFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 164 José Fernando Cedeño de Barros & Lidiani Machado Soares dos Santos 6. BIBLIOGRAFIA "'0/40$ÓOUJB.BSJB6TPFPDVQBÎÍPEPTPMPOB[POBDPTUFJSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPo 6NB"OÈMJTF"NCJFOUBM'"1&41"OOB#MVNF "-7&4'FSOBOEP#BSBUBF(0.&4+PSHF4BMHBEP06OJWFSTPEB*OEÞTUSJBEF1FUSØMFPoEB QFTRVJTBËSFmOBÎÍP&EJUPSB'VOEBÎÍP$BMPVTUF(VCFOLJBO #"6%)6*/Princípios de economia contemporânea, volume I – A 1SPEVÎÍP%JGVTÍP&VSPQFJB EP-JWSP%*'&-1PSUVHBM #&&3("#&-+PTFUUFRecueil des Traités relatifs à La Mediterranée1ÏEPOF1BSJT #0*440/%&$)";063/&4%&4("/²3JDIBSEF30."/0$FTBSFProtéction Intrernationale de l´Environnement, ²EJUJPOT1ÏEPOF1BSJT $"/±"%053*/%"%&""%JSFJUPT)VNBOPTF.FJP"NCJFOUF1BSBMFMPEPT4JTUFNBTEF 1SPUFÎÍP*OUFSOBDJPOBM1PSUP"MFHSF4ÏSHJP'BCSJT $&%&º0%&#"3304+PTÏ'FSOBOEP%JSFJUPEP.BSFEP.FJP"NCJFOUF-&9&EJUPSB4ÍP 1BVMP $&%&º0%&#"3304+PTÏ'FSOBOEP5FPSJB(FSBMEB*OUFHSBÎÍP&DPOÙNJDBin 3FWJTUB5SJ CVUÈSJBFEF'JOBOÎBT1ÞCMJDBT353FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT /PW%F[ $&%&º0%&#"3304+PTÏ'FSOBOEP4PCFSBOJB$POUSJCVJÎÍPQBSBBDPOTUSVÎÍPEFVNB 5FPSJB(FSBMEP%JSFJUPEB*OUFHSBÎÍP&DPOÙNJDBin 3FWJTUB5SJCVUÈSJBFEF'JOBOÎBT1ÞCMJDBT 353FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT TFUPVU %*165"$*»/%&#"3$&-0/"Derecho Del Médio Ambiente y Administración Local (coordinado por José Esteve Prado)%JQVUBDJØEF#BSDFMPOB$JWJUBT '-*&35-ZEJBWBOEFIndigneous Peoples and International Organisations/PUUJOHIBN4QPLFT NBO (&453*.BSDPLa gestione delle risorse naturali d´interesse generale per la Comunità Internazionale((JBQQJDIFMMJFEJUPSFo5PSJOP ."35*/43*#&*30.BSJBEB$PODFJÎÍP"7JEB6SCBOB1BVMJTUBOB7JTUBQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP .VOJDJQBM.JOIB&EJUPSB.BOPMF 4ÍP1BVMP 4"%&-&&3/JDPMBTEFLes principes du pollueur-payeur, de prévention et de précaution – Essai sur la gênese et la portée juridique de quelques príncipes du droit de l´environnement#SVZMBOU"6' 4&/"%0'&%&3"-1SPUPDPMPEF2VJPUPFMFHJTMBÎÍPDPSSFMBUBo$PMFÎÍP"NCJFOUBMoWPMVNF ***#SBTÓMJB 4*45&3(BCSJFM.FSDBEPEF$BSCPOPFP1SPUPDPMPEF2VJPUPo"TQFDUPTOFHPDJBJTFUSJCV UBÎÍP&E&MTFWJFS %J1MJOJP(JBNQJFSPF'JNJBOJ1BTRVBMFPrincipi di Diritto Ambientale(JVGGSÒ&EJUPSF.JMÍP 16$,&55+JN%ÏDIFUTTBOTGSPOUJÒSFTMFTFOKFVYEFMB$POWFOUJPOEF#ÉMFin Ecologie contre nature – Développement et politiques d´ingérence16'1BSJT 1SPUPDPMPEF2VJPUPFMFHJTMBÎÍPDPSSFMBUBo$PMFÎÍP"NCJFOUBMoWPMVNF***#SBTÓMJB 4FOBEP'FEFSBM 8V$IBPLa Pollution du Fait du Transfert Maritime des Hydrocarbures – Responsabilité et Indemnisation des Dommages*/%&.&3.ÙOBDP 1&%0/&1BSJT IUUQXXXQFUSPCSBTDPNCSQURVFNTPNPTQFSmMGPOUFPCUJEBFNËTI RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 135 a 164 ZONEAMENTO ECOLÓGICO-ECONÔMICO COMO INSTRUMENTO ESSENCIAL DA POLÍTICA NACIONAL DO MEIO AMBIENTE A SER CONSIDERADO NO LICENCIAMENTO AMBIENTAL Ecological-Economic Zoning as a essential tool to the National Environmental Policy to be considered in environment license Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento1 Thaís Teizen2 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP -JDFODJBNFOUP DPNP JOTUSVNFOUP EB 1PMÓUJDB /BDJPOBM EP .FJP "NCJFOUF$PODFJUP$PNQFUÐODJB;POFBNFOUP&DPMØHJDP&DPOÙNJDPo ;&&DPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUF$PODFJUP $PNQFUÐODJB%FDSFUP'FEFSBMO¡-FJ'FEFSBMO¡o;&&EB ;POB$PTUFJSB%FDSFUP'FEFSBMO¡-FJ&TUBEVBMO¡ o1MBOP&TUBEVBMEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSPo1&($411PMÓUJDB"HSÓDPMBo-FJ O¡FP;&&;POFBNFOUP"HSPBNCJFOUBMEPTFUPSTVDSPBMDPPMFJSPOP &TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP-FJO¡o;&&FBBMUFSBÎÍPEPQFSDFOUVBMEF 3FTFSWB-FHBM;POFBNFOUP*OEVTUSJBM;POFBNFOUP"NCJFOUBMOP&TUBUVUPEB $JEBEF$PODMVTÍP#JCMJPHSBmB RESUMO "1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUFCSBTJMFJSPQSFWÐJNQPSUBOUFJOTUSVNFOUPQBSB BQSJNPSBS BT QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT EFOPNJOBEP ;POFBNFOUP &DPMØHJDP&DPOÙNJDP ;&& 0 FTUVEP BCPSEB B MFHJTMBÎÍP WJHFOUF DPN ÐOGBTF OPT UFNBT [POB DPTUFJSB QPMÓUJDBBHSÓDPMB[POFBNFOUPJOEVTUSJBMF&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEF"PmOBMEFNPOTUSBTF TVBJNQPSUÉODJBQBSBSFBMJ[BSPDPSSFUPPSEFOBNFOUPEPUFSSJUØSJPCSBTJMFJSPBUSBWÏTEB JOUFHSBÎÍPFmDJFOUFEBPSEFNFDPOÙNJDBTPDJBMFBNCJFOUBM SUMMARY 5IF#SB[JMJBO/BUJPOBM&OWJSPONFOUBM1PMJDZQSFEJDUTBOJNQPSUBOUUPPMUPJNQSPWF QVCMJDQPMJDJFTDBMMFE&DPMPHJDBM&DPOPNJD;POJOH;&& 5IJTTUVEZBEESFTTFTUIF DVSSFOU MFHJTMBUJPO XJUI FNQIBTJT PO PGG TIPSF [POFT BHSJDVMUVSBM BOE JOEVTUSJBM QPMJDZBOEUIF$JUZ4UBUVUF$PEF$PODMVEFUPEFNPOTUSBUFUIFJNQPSUBODFUPNBLF UIF DPSSFDU [POJOH PG UIF #SB[JMJBO UFSSJUPSZ GPS BO FGmDJFOU FDPOPNJDBM TPDJBM BOE FOWJSPONFOUBMJOUFHSBUJPO Palavras-chaves.FJPBNCJFOUF–JOTUSVNFOUPT–[POFBNFOUP–JOUFHSBÎÍP– FDPOPNJB Keywords&OWJSPONFOUUPPMT[POJOHJOUFHSBUJPOFDPOPNZ 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPDIFGFEBDPOTVMUPSJBKVSÓEJDBEB4FDSFUBSJBEP.FJP"NCJFOUFEP &TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP.FTUSBOEBFN%JSFJUPT%JGVTPTF$PMFUJWPTQFMB16$41 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPFNFYFSDÓDJPOBDPOTVMUPSJBKVSÓEJDBEB4FDSFUBSJBEP.FJP"N CJFOUFEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP&TQFDJBMJ[BÎÍPFN1SPDFTTP$JWJMQFMB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB (FSBMEP&TUBEPFQFMB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDBEF4BOUPT&TQFDJBMJ[BÎÍPFN%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPQFMB641 .FTUSBOEBFN%JSFJUPT%JGVTPTF$PMFUJWPTQFMB16$41 166 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen 1. INTRODUÇÃO 0QSFTFOUFBSUJHPUFNDPNPmOBMJEBEFBOBMJTBSP;POFBNFOUP&DPMØHJDP&DP OÙNJDP;&& DPNPVNEPTJOTUSVNFOUPTFTTFODJBJTQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEB1PMÓUJDB /BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUF1/." BRVBMQSFWÐWÈSJPTJOTUSVNFOUPTQBSBTVBFYFDV ÎÍPFOUSFPTRVBJTTFEFTUBDBNPi[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMwFPiMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMw QSFWJTUPTSFTQFDUJWBNFOUFOPTJODJTPT**F*7EP"SUEB-FJ'FEFSBMOEF EFBHPTUPEF &NCPSB OP ÉNCJUP GFEFSBM P MJDFODJBNFOUP BNCJFOUBM TØ UFOIB TF UPSOBEP PCSJHBUØSJP B QBSUJS EFTTB SFGFSJEB MFJ OP &TUBEP EF 4ÍP 1BVMP B -FJ &TUBEVBM O BPEJTDJQMJOBSPVTPEPTPMPQBSBBQSPUFÎÍPEPTNBOBODJBJTDVSTPTFSFTFS WBUØSJPTEFÈHVBFEFNBJTSFDVSTPTIÓESJDPTEFJOUFSFTTFEB3FHJÍP.FUSPQPMJUBOBEB (SBOEF4ÍP1BVMPKÈGB[JBSFGFSÐODJBËDFTTBÎÍPDPNQVMTØSJBEBBUJWJEBEFPVEFNPMJ ÎÍPEBPCSBDPNDBTTBÎÍPEBMJDFOÎBRVBOEPTVBSFBMJ[BÎÍPTFEÐFNEFTBDPSEPDPN PQSPKFUPBQSPWBEPPVTFNMJDFODJBNFOUP 0CTFSWBTFEFTEFFOUÍPVNBDSFTDFOUFQSFPDVQBÎÍPDPNPTUFNBTEPMJ DFODJBNFOUPFEP[POFBNFOUPRVFQBTTBSBNBTFSPCKFUPEFFTUVEPTEPVUSJOÈSJPTF KVSJTQSVEFODJBJTBMÏNEFDPOUFNQMBEPTQPSEJWFSTPTEJQMPNBTMFHBJT"JOUFSBÎÍP FOUSF PT JOTUJUVUPT GPJ CFN PCTFSWBEB QPS "55"/"4*0 +6/*03 & "55"/"4*0 3%" 0 [POFBNFOUP FDPMØHJDPFDPOÙNJDP TF BQSFTFOUB NVJUP FmDJFOUF OBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEPEJBHOØTUJDPBNCJFOUBMRVFÏSFRVJTJUPFTTFODJBMEP FTUVEP EF JNQBDUP BNCJFOUBM 3FTPMVÎÍP $POBNB $PNP P FNQSFFOEFEPSÏPSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBFMBCPSBÎÍPEPFTUVEPEFJNQBDUP BNCJFOUBM BDBCB UFOEP RVF QSPEV[JS JOGPSNBÎÜFT TPCSF PT NFJPT GÓTJDP CJPMØHJDP F TØDJPFDPOÙNJDP EB ÈSFB EF JOnVÐODJB EP QSPKFUP OÍPSFMBDJPOBEBTBPTFVFNQSFFOEJNFOUPBTRVBJTKÈQPEFSJBNFTUBS EJTQPOJCJMJ[BEBT QFMP QPEFS QÞCMJDP OVN [POFBNFOUP FDPMØHJDP FDPOÙNJDP /PUFTF DPOUVEP RVF P FNQSFFOEFEPS OÍP FTUÈ EFTPCSJHBEPEFQSPEV[JSBTJOGPSNBÎÜFTTPCSFPTFVFNQSFFOEJNFOUP RVF BT QSPEV[JSÈ DPN NBJPS BHJMJEBEF RVBOEP KÈ DPOUBS DPN P [POFBNFOUPFDPMØHJDPFDPOÙNJDP )ÈRVFTFEFTUBDBSUBNCÏNRVFP[POFBNFOUPFDPMØHJDPFDPOÙNJDP BP EFUFSNJOBS BT WPDBÎÜFT F TVTDFUJCJMJEBEFT OBUVSBJT EPT GBUPSFT BNCJFOUBJTFNGVOÎÍPEBDBQBDJEBEFEFTVQPSUFEPNFJPFQFSNJUJSVN DPOIFDJNFOUPHMPCBMEBÈSFBEFFTUVEPEFGPSNBTJTUFNÈUJDBQPTTJCJMJUB UPNBEBTEFEFDJTÍPNBJTBEFRVBEBTOPRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPËWJBCJMJEBEF BNCJFOUBMEPFNQSFFOEJNFOUPQSPNPWFOEPVNNBJPSEJOBNJTNPBP FTUVEPEFJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBM4PV[B RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 167 2. LICENCIAMENTO COMO INSTRUMENTO DA POLÍTICA NACIONAL DO MEIO AMBIENTE 2.1. Conceito "3FTPMVÎÍP$0/"."OKÈEFmOJBMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMDPNPP QSPDFEJNFOUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP QFMP RVBM P ØSHÍP BNCJFOUBM DPNQFUFOUF MJDFODJBBMPDBMJ[BÎÍPJOTUBMBÎÍPBNQMJBÎÍPFBPQFSBÎÍPEFFNQSFFOEJNFOUPT F BUJWJEBEFT VUJMJ[BEPSBT EF SFDVSTPT BNCJFOUBJT DPOTJEFSBEBT FGFUJWB PV QPUFODJBMNFOUF QPMVJEPSBT PV EBRVFMBT RVF TPC RVBMRVFS GPSNB QPTTBNDBVTBSEFHSBEBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMDPOTJEFSBOEPBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTMFHBJTF SFHVMBNFOUBSFTFBTOPSNBTUÏDOJDBTBQMJDÈWFJTBPDBTP3 "TTJNDPNPmYBWBBOPÎÍPEF-JDFOÎB"NCJFOUBMDPNP iBUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP QFMP RVBM P ØSHÍP BNCJFOUBM DPNQFUFOUF FTUBCFMFDF BTDPOEJÎÜFTSFTUSJÎÜFTFNFEJEBTEFDPOUSPMFBNCJFOUBMRVFEFWFSÍPTFS PCFEFDJEBT QFMP FNQSFFOEFEPS QFTTPB GÓTJDB PV KVSÓEJDB QBSB MPDBMJ[BS JOTUBMBSBNQMJBSFPQFSBSFNQSFFOEJNFOUPTPVBUJWJEBEFTVUJMJ[BEPSBTEPT SFDVSTPTBNCJFOUBJTDPOTJEFSBEBTFGFUJWBPVQPUFODJBMNFOUFQPMVJEPSBTPV BRVFMBTRVFTPCRVBMRVFSGPSNBQPTTBNDBVTBSEFHSBEBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMw )PKF P MJDFODJBNFOUP BNCJFOUBM FODPOUSBTF EFmOJEP OP BSU * EB -FJ $PNQMFNFOUBSOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFOPTTFHVJOUFTUFSNPT MJDFODJBNFOUP BNCJFOUBM P QSPDFEJNFOUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP EFTUJOBEP B MJDFODJBS BUJWJEBEFT PV FNQSFFOEJNFOUPT VUJMJ[BEPSFT EF SFDVSTPT BNCJFOUBJT FGFUJWB PV QPUFODJBMNFOUF QPMVJEPSFT PV DBQB[FT TPC RVBMRVFSGPSNBEFDBVTBSEFHSBEBÎÍPBNCJFOUBM "MJDFOÎBFNWFSEBEFÏPBUPmOBMEPQSPDFEJNFOUPPVQSPDFTTPRVFBBO UFDFEFDVKBPVUPSHBEFNPOTUSBPQSFFODIJNFOUPEPTSFRVJTJUPTMFHBJTPVDPOEJÎÜFT JNQPTUBTQBSBPFYFSDÓDJPEFEFUFSNJOBEBBUJWJEBEFPVQBSBEFUFSNJOBEPFNQSFFO EJNFOUPDBSBDUFSJ[BOEPTFDPNPPSFTVMUBEPEFVNBTFRVÐODJBEFBUPTEFTUJOBEPT ËPCUFOÎÍPEFVNBEFDMBSBÎÍPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPGBDVMUBOEPËRVFMFRVFQSFFODIBPT SFRVJTJUPTMFHBJTDPOEJÎÜFTSFTUSJÎÜFTFNFEJEBTEFDPOUSPMFBNCJFOUBM PFYFSDÓDJP EFEFUFSNJOBEBBUJWJEBEFPVPFNQSFFOEJNFOUP 3 "SUJHP*EB3FT$0/"." "SUJHP**EB3FT$0/"." RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 168 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen /P%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPDPTUVNBTFDPOTJEFSBSBMJDFOÎBDPNPBUPWJODV MBEPPRVFBEJGFSFODJBEBBVUPSJ[BÎÍPTFOEPBRVFMBDPODFJUVBEBDPNP“ato administrativo unilateral e vinculado pelo qual a Administração faculta àquele que preencha os requisitos legais o exercício de uma atividade.” "MJDFOÎBBNCJFOUBMOPFOUBOUPUSB[DFSUBOVBOÎBBPDPODFJUPFYQPTUPFJT RVFUFNDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTQSØQSJBT)ÈBVUPSFTRVFBUSJCVFNDFSUPHSBVEFEJTDSJDJP OBSJFEBEFBPBUPFNSB[ÍPEFBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPFTUBCFMFDFSBTDPOEJÎÜFTSFTUSJÎÜFT FNFEJEBTEFDPOUSPMFBNCJFOUBMRVFEFWFSÍPTFSPCFEFDJEBTQFMPFNQSFFOEFEPS QBSB B PCUFOÎÍP EB MJDFOÎB 5PEBWJB OÍP OPT QBSFDF RVF P DPOEJDJPOBNFOUP EB MJDFOÎBUSBOTGPSNBPTFVDBSÈUFSBPQPOUPEFDPOTJEFSÈMBBUPEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPFTQF DJBMNFOUFRVBOEPUBJTDPOEJDJPOBOUFTTÍPEFWJEBNFOUFNPUJWBEBTFBNPUJWBÎÍP BDBCBQPSTFSWJODVMBUØSJB "TJUVBÎÍPRVFBUPSOBsui generisÏPGBUPEFWBSJBSDPNPUFNQPFTVBPVUPSHB TVKFJUBSTFËSFHSB“rebus sic stantibus”. "BMUFSBÎÍPEBTJUVBÎÍPDPNPOBIJQØUFTFEF TVBDPODFTTÍPRVBOEPPFTUÈHJPEBUÏDOJDBPVEPDPOIFDJNFOUPIVNBOPOÍPQFSNJUJB QSFWFSDPOTFRVÐODJBTQSFKVEJDJBJTRVFEFQPJTTÍPEFUFDUBEBTQPEFEBSFOTFKPËTVB DBTTBÎÍP 0RVFJNQPSUBEFJYBSDMBSPÏRVFBMJDFOÎBBNCJFOUBMOÍPQPTTVJVNDB SÈUFSEFEFmOJUJWJEBEFQPEFOEPTFSmYBEPVNQSB[PmOBMQBSBRVFTFFYQJSFPV NFTNPTFSTVQSJNJEBEJBOUFEBWFSJmDBÎÍPEFRVFEFTSFTQFJUBPEJSFJUPBPNFJP BNCJFOUFFRVJMJCSBEP &ORVBOUP JOTUSVNFOUPT EB 1PMÓUJDB /BDJPOBM EP .FJP "NCJFOUF UBOUP P MJ DFODJBNFOUPRVBOUPP[POFBNFOUPFDPMØHJDPFDPOÙNJDPTÍPQBTTÓWFJTEFSFWJTÍPDPN WJTUBTBEBSFGFUJWJEBEFBPEFUFSNJOBEPQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM/FTTFTFOUJEPQPEF IBWFSTVQSFTTÍPEBMJDFOÎBUBOUPFNSB[ÍPEBDPOTUBUBÎÍPEFRVFGPJDPODFEJEBTFN RVFGPTTFNSFTQFJUBEPTPTQSFTTVQPTUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTMFHBJTQBSBTVBFYQFEJÎÍPJO WBMJEBÎÍP RVBOUPFNGVOÎÍPEFTVBDPODFTTÍPRVBOEPPFTUÈHJPEBUÏDOJDBPVEPDP OIFDJNFOUPIVNBOPOÍPQFSNJUJBQSFWFSDPOTFRVÐODJBTQSFKVEJDJBJTRVFEFQPJTTÍP EFUFDUBEBTDBTTBÎÍP 4FIPVWFSQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJNQMBOUBÎÍPEFNFEJEBTQBSBBEBQ UBÎÍPOPWBTDPOEJDJPOBOUFTQPEFSÍPTFSJNQPTUBTBPFNQSFFOEFEPS"MJDFOÎBUBNCÏN QPEFSÈQFSEFSBWBMJEBEFBPBUJOHJSTFVUFSNPmOBMPVEFQFOEFSEFSFOPWBÎÍP *NQPSUBBJOEBBDSFTDFOUBSRVFB3FTPMVÎÍP$0/"."OFTUBCFMFDF RVFP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPOPFYFSDÓDJPEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJBEFDPOUSPMFFYQFEJSÈMJDFOÎBT BNCJFOUBJT JTPMBEB PV TVDFTTJWBNFOUF EF BDPSEP DPN B OBUVSF[B DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT F GBTFEPFNQSFFOEJNFOUPPVBUJWJEBEFQSFWFOEPVNSPMEFUSÐTUJQPTEFOPNJOBEBT MJDFOÎBQSÏWJB-1 MJDFOÎBEFJOTUBMBÎÍP-* FMJDFOÎBEFPQFSBÎÍP-0 . %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBDireito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT"/0 Q *-JDFOÎB1SÏWJB-1 oDPODFEJEBOBGBTFQSFMJNJOBSEPQMBOFKBNFOUPEPFNQSFFOEJNFOUPPVBUJWJ EBEF BQSPWBOEP TVB MPDBMJ[BÎÍP F DPODFQÎÍP BUFTUBOEP B WJBCJMJEBEF BNCJFOUBM F FTUBCFMFDFOEP PT SFRVJTJUPTCÈTJDPTFDPOEJDJPOBOUFTBTFSFNBUFOEJEPTOBTQSØYJNBTGBTFTEFTVBJNQMFNFOUBÎÍP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 169 2.2. Competência 0BSUJHPJODJTP7*EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEJ[RVFÏDPNQFUÐODJBDP NVNEB6OJÍPEPT&TUBEPTEP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFEPT.VOJDÓQJPTQSPUFHFSPNFJP BNCJFOUFFDPNCBUFSBQPMVJÎÍPFNRVBMRVFSEFTVBTGPSNBT/BQBSUJMIBDPOTUJUV DJPOBMEFDPNQFUÐODJBTPBSUJHPFTUBCFMFDFBEFOPNJOBEBDPNQFUÐODJBBENJOJT USBUJWBDPNVNFPBSUJHPBDPNQFUÐODJBMFHJTMBUJWBDPODPSSFOUFEB6OJÍP&TUBEPT F%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM +PTÏ"GPOTPEB4JMWBBPDPNFOUBSBRVFTUÍPFOTJOBOPTPTFHVJOUF BSFQBSUJÎÍPEFDPNQFUÐODJBTFGVOEBNFOUBOBUÏDOJDBEBFOVNFSBÎÍPEPT QPEFSFTEB6OJÍPQSFWJTUPTOPTBSUTFDPNQPEFSFTSFNBOFTDFOUFT QBSBPT&TUBEPTBSUf FQPEFSFTEFmOJEPTJOEJDBUJWBNFOUFQBSB PT.VOJDÓQJPTBSUF NBTDPNCJOBDPNFTTBSFTFSWBEFDBNQPT FTQFDÓmDPTÈSFBTDPNVOTFNRVFTFQSFWÐFNBUVBÎÜFTQBSBMFMBTEB6OJÍP &TUBEPT %JTUSJUP 'FEFSBM F .VOJDÓQJPT BSU F TFUPSFT DPODPSSFOUFT FOUSFB6OJÍPF&TUBEPTFNRVFBDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBFTUBCFMFDFSQPMÓUJDBT HFSBJTFOPSNBTHFSBJTDBCFË6OJÍPFORVBOUPTFEFGFSFBPT&TUBEPTFBUÏ BPT.VOJDÓQJPTBDPNQFUÐODJBTVQMFNFOUBSBSUF .BT BOUFT NFTNP EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP EF P 4JTUFNB /BDJPOBM EP .FJP "NCJFOUF4*4/"." DSJBEPQFMB-FJOFSFHVMBNFOUBEPQFMP%FDSFUPO GPJFTUSVUVSBEPQBSBDPNCJOBSBBUVBÎÍPEPTUSÐTOÓWFJTGFEFSBJT6OJÍP &TUBEPTF.VOJDÓQJPT OBQSPUFÎÍPFNFMIPSJBEBRVBMJEBEFBNCJFOUBM$POUVEPTVBT EJTQPTJÎÜFTOÍPGPSBNTVmDJFOUFTQBSBJNQFEJSRVFBDPNQFUÐODJBNBUFSJBMDPNVN BUSJCVÓEB QFMP "SU EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM TF USBOTGPSNBTTF FN VNB GPOUF EF MJUÓHJPT QSJODJQBMNFOUF OP UPDBOUF Ë DPNQFUÐODJB QBSB P MJDFODJBNFOUP BNCJFOUBM FmTDBMJ[BÎÍP"SUEB-FJO "TTJNCVTDBOEPBQSJNPSBSP4JTUFNBP $0/"."FEJUPVB3FTPMVÎÍPOEFmOJOEPBDPNQFUÐODJBEFBDPSEPDPN VNDSJUÏSJPNJTUPRVFDPNCJOBWBBFYUFOTÍPEPJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBMBMPDBMJ[BÎÍPPV PUJQPEFBUJWJEBEFMJDFODJBEB$POUVEPSFHSBTDPNPBEPf"SUEB3FTPMVÎÍP O¡SFWFMBSBNTFNVJUPQSPCMFNÈUJDBTOBQSÈUJDB II -JDFOÎBEF*OTUBMBÎÍP-* oBVUPSJ[BBJOTUBMBÎÍPEPFNQSFFOEJNFOUPPVBUJWJEBEFEFBDPSEPDPN BT FTQFDJmDBÎÜFT DPOTUBOUFT EPT QMBOPT QSPHSBNBT F QSPKFUPT BQSPWBEPT JODMVJOEP BT NFEJEBT EF DPOUSPMFBNCJFOUBMFEFNBJTDPOEJDJPOBOUFTEBRVBMDPOTUJUVFNNPUJWPEFUFSNJOBOUF III -JDFOÎBEF0QFSBÎÍP-0 oBVUPSJ[BBPQFSBÎÍPEBBUJWJEBEFPVFNQSFFOEJNFOUPBQØTBWFSJmDBÎÍP EPFGFUJWPDVNQSJNFOUPEPRVFDPOTUBEBTMJDFOÎBTBOUFSJPSFTDPNBTNFEJEBTEFDPOUSPMFBNCJFOUBM FDPOEJDJPOBOUFTEFUFSNJOBEBTQBSBBPQFSBÎÍP 4JMWB+PTÏ"GPOTPEBDireito Ambiental Constitucional4ÍP1BVMP&E.BMIFJSPTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 170 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen 0TEFTBmPTTVSHJSBNOBGPSNBEFSFJUFSBEPTDPOnJUPTEFDPNQFUÐODJBOPS NBUJWBmTDBMJ[BUØSJBFTBODJPOBUØSJBPTRVBJTGSFRVFOUFNFOUFFSBNKVEJDJBMJ[BEPTOB CVTDBEPQSFFODIJNFOUPEBTMBDVOBTPVFMJNJOBÎÍPEBTBOUJOPNJBTEBGBSUBMFHJTMBÎÍP FEJUBEBOPTUSÐTOÓWFJTGFEFSBUJWPT " -FJ $PNQMFNFOUBS O UFOUPV SFTPMWFS FTTFT JNQBTTFT HFSBEPT EFTEFBDSJBÎÍPEP4*4/"."mYBOEPBUVBMNFOUFBTSFHSBTEFDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBP MJDFODJBNFOUP /PFOUBOUPEBEPPPCKFUJWPFEJNFOTÍPEFTUFUSBCBMIPOPNPNFOUPJNQPSUB GSJTBSRVFDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUFPMJDFODJBNFOUP ÏSFHVMBEPQFMPBSUJHPEB-FJO¡DVKBSFEBÎÍPBQØTBBMUFSBÎÍPUSB[JEB QFMB-FJ$PNQMFNFOUBSOQBTTPVBTFSBTFHVJOUF "SU " DPOTUSVÎÍP JOTUBMBÎÍP BNQMJBÎÍP F GVODJPOBNFOUP EF FTUBCFMFDJNFOUPTFBUJWJEBEFTVUJMJ[BEPSFTEFSFDVSTPTBNCJFOUBJTFGFUJWB PVQPUFODJBMNFOUFQPMVJEPSFTPVDBQB[FTTPCRVBMRVFSGPSNBEFDBVTBS EFHSBEBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMEFQFOEFSÍPEFQSÏWJPMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBM f P 0T QFEJEPT EF MJDFODJBNFOUP TVB SFOPWBÎÍP F B SFTQFDUJWB DPODFTTÍPTFSÍPQVCMJDBEPTOPKPSOBMPmDJBMCFNDPNPFNQFSJØEJDP SFHJPOBM PV MPDBM EF HSBOEF DJSDVMBÎÍP PV FN NFJP FMFUSÙOJDP EF DPNVOJDBÎÍPNBOUJEPQFMPØSHÍPBNCJFOUBMDPNQFUFOUF 3. ZEE COMO INSTRUMENTO DA POLÍTICA NACIONAL DO MEIO AMBIENTE 3.1. Conceito *OTUJUVUPPSJHJOÈSJPEPTEJSFJUPTJOHMÐTFOPSUFBNFSJDBOPi[POJOHw P[POF BNFOUPTVSHJVOBTTPDJFEBEFTJOEVTUSJBMJ[BEBTFVSCBOJ[BEBTTFHVOEPBQPOUBEPQPS 1&3&*3"&8*/$,-&33%" &NTFOUJEPBNQMPTFHVOEPFTTBDPODFQÎÍPUSBEJDJPOBM[POFBSÏSFQBSUJSP TPMPFEFTJHOBSPTTFVTVTPTOPFYFSDÓDJPEPQPEFSEFQPMÓDJBBENJOJTUSBUJWB 0DPNFOUÈSJPEF4JEOFZ(VFSSBBPBOBMJTBSBRVFTUÍPEBDPNQFUÐODJBBNCJFOUBMËMV[EBMFJDPNQMFNFO UBSOQPSPDBTJÍPEPBEWFOUPEFTTFEJQMPNBOPSNBUJWPi PDPOnJUPEFDPNQFUÐODJBFOUSF PTEJGFSFOUFTØSHÍPTBNCJFOUBJT'FEFSBM&TUBEVBMF.VOJDJQBM UFNTJEPBQPOUBEPDPNPVNEPTNBJPSFT FNQFDJMIPTQBSBPBOEBNFOUPEPMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBM%FGFOEFNPTËÏQPDBRVFTFSJBKVTUPDPODMVJS RVFP#SBTJMQSFDJTBWBUFSDPNVSHÐODJBVNBEFmOJÎÍPEP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWPoFOÍPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP DSJUJDBEPQPSBQBSFOUFNFOUFBUVBSBUJWBNFOUFFVTVSQBSGVOÎÍPEP-FHJTMBUJWPoRVBOUPËTDPNQFUÐODJBT EPT FOUFT GFEFSBEPT FN NBUÏSJB BNCJFOUBM w 4JEOFZ (VFSSB $PNQFUÐODJB BNCJFOUBM Ë MV[ EB -FJ $PNQMFNFOUBSOIUUQNEGTFDSFMDPNCSENEPDVNFOUTTJEOFZQEG DPOGFSJEPFNEBUB '*03*--0$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 171 "55"/"4*0+6/*03&"55"/"4*03%" EFTDSFWFNP[POFBNFO UP DPNP JOTUSVNFOUP EF QMBOFKBNFOUP VSCBOP GPSUFNFOUF NBSDBEP QPS FMFNFOUP GVODJPOBMJTUB F FYDMVEFOUF QPSRVF FTUBCFMFDF B EJWJTÍP EBT DJEBEFT FN [POBT TF HVOEPDBUFHPSJBTEFBUJWJEBEFTFVTPT&TTFTEPVUSJOBEPSFTPCTFSWBNRVFPNPEFMP PSJHJOÈSJPEF[POFBNFOUPNVOJDJQBMFGVODJPOBMJTUBÏDSJUJDBEP QPS BQSFTFOUBS BP MPOHP EP UFNQP VN DBSÈUFS EF EJTDJQMJOBNFOUP EB QSPQSJFEBEFTPCPQPOUPEFWJTUBFNJOFOUFNFOUFFDPOÙNJDPWPMUBEP NBJTQBSBPTJOUFSFTTFTEPNFSDBEPJNPCJMJÈSJPTFNTFQSFPDVQBSDPN PTQSPCMFNBTTPDJBJTFBNCJFOUBJTEBDJEBEF $PNP FGFJUPT JOEFTFKÈWFJT EP NPEFMP EF [POFBNFOUP FTUSJUBNFOUF FDPOÙ NJDPTPTTVQSBDJUBEPTBVUPSFT3%" EFTUBDBNBFTQFDVMBÎÍPJNPCJMJÈSJBFB FYDMVTÍPIBCJUBDJPOBMRVFDBOBMJ[BNBEFNBOEBQPSNPSBEJBQBSBÈSFBTEFSFMFWBOUF JNQPSUÉODJBBNCJFOUBMQFYNBOHVF[BJTGVOEPTEFWBMFNBSHFOTEFSJPTFODPTUBT ÓOHSFNFTFUD HFSBOEPEFHSBEBÎÍPBNCJFOUBM 0;&&TVSHFDPNPVNBSFTQPTUBËQSPCMFNÈUJDBBDJNBEFTDSJUBTFOEPEF TFOWPMWJEPBQBSUJSEFVNBOPWBDPODFQÎÍPCBTFBEBOBEJNFOTÍPTPDJPBNCJFOUBMF PSJFOUBEBQPSQSJODÓQJPTQSØQSJPTRVFTFEJTUJOHVFNEP[POFBNFOUPDMÈTTJDP/FTTF TFOUJEPTFHVOEPOPTBMFSUB.BSDFMP/PHVFJSB$BNBSHPT QFMP [POFBNFOUP BNCJFOUBM TÍP JOTUJUVÓEPT EJGFSFOUFT UJQPT EF [POBT OBT RVBJT P 1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP FTUBCFMFDF SFHJNFT FTQFDJBJT EF VTP HP[P F GSVJÎÍP EB QSPQSJFEBEF OB CVTDB EB NFMIPSJB F SFDVQFSBÎÍP EB RVBMJEBEFBNCJFOUBMFEPCFNFTUBSEBQPQVMBÎÍP4VBTOPSNBTRVF EFWFSÍPPCSJHBUPSJBNFOUFSFTQFJUBSPEJTQPTUPFNMFHJTMBÎÍPBNCJFOUBM WJODVMBN UPEBT BT BUJWJEBEFT FYFSDJEBT OB SFHJÍP EF TVB JODJEÐODJB P RVF JNQMJDB OB JOBENJTTJCJMJEBEF EF BMJ TFSFN FYFSDJEBT BUJWJEBEFT DPOUSÈSJBTBFMBT &N OPTTP PSEFOBNFOUP KVSÓEJDP B QBSUJS EB -FJ O BSU JOD ** P ;&& Ï DMBTTJmDBEP DPNP VN EPT JOTUSVNFOUPT EB 1PMÓUJDB /BDJPOBM EF .FJP "NCJFOUF1/." /PQMBOPGFEFSBMB-FJOEFEFNBJPEFRVFJOTUJUVJVP1MBOP /BDJPOBMEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSP1/($ GPJQJPOFJSBOBBEPÎÍPEPOPWPNPEFMP BJOEBRVFSFTUSJUPBP[POFBNFOUPDPTUFJSP/PTUFSNPTEPBSUP1/($EFWFSÈQSF WFSP[POFBNFOUPEFVTPTFBUJWJEBEFTOB[POBDPTUFJSBFEBSQSJPSJEBEFËDPOTFSWBÎÍP FQSPUFÎÍPEPTCFOTBNCJFOUBJTEFTDSJUPTOPTJODJTPT*B***EBRVFMFEJTQPTJUJWPMFHBM /BFWPMVÎÍPIJTUØSJDBEP;&&EFTUBDBTFUBNCÏNB-FJOEFEF KBOFJSPEFRVFOP$BQÓUVMP7*EFEJDBEPËQSPUFÎÍPBPNFJPBNCJFOUFFDPO TFSWBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTJNQÙTBP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEP[POFBNFOUP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 172 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen BHSPFDPMØHJDP"SUJOD*** DPNBmOBMJEBEFEF“estabelecer critérios para o disciplinamento e o ordenamento da ocupação espacial pelas diversas atividades produtivas, bem como para a instalação de novas hidrelétricas.” /PFOUBOUPP"SUJOD**EB-FJOTPNFOUFWFJPBTFSSFHVMB NFOUBEPFNDPNBFEJÎÍPEP%FDSFUP'FEFSBMOEFEFKVMIPRVF BQPOUBPTFHVJOUF 0;&&JOTUSVNFOUPEFPSHBOJ[BÎÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPBTFSPCSJHBUPSJBNFOUF TFHVJEP OB JNQMBOUBÎÍP EF QMBOPT PCSBT F BUJWJEBEFT QÞCMJDBT F QSJWBEBT FTUBCFMFDF NFEJEBT F QBESÜFT EF QSPUFÎÍP BNCJFOUBM EFTUJOBEPTBBTTFHVSBSBRVBMJEBEFBNCJFOUBMEPTSFDVSTPTIÓESJDPTFEP TPMPFBDPOTFSWBÎÍPEBCJPEJWFSTJEBEFHBSBOUJOEPPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP TVTUFOUÈWFMFBNFMIPSJBEBTDPOEJÎÜFTEFWJEBEBQPQVMBÎÍP %JBOUFEFTTFTFMFNFOUPTFDPODJMJBOEPPTBSUJHPTFEP%F DSFUPOQPEFNPTDPODFJUVBSP;&&OPTTFHVJOUFTUFSNPTJOTUSVNFOUP PCSJHBUØSJPEFQMBOFKBNFOUPUFSSJUPSJBMQBSBBJNQMBOUBÎÍPEFQMBOPTPCSBTFBUJWJ EBEFTQÞCMJDBTFQSJWBEBTDPNPPCKFUJWPEFEJBHOØTUJDPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTEB TØDJPFDPOPNJBFEPNBSDPKVSÓEJDPJOTUJUVDJPOBMFEJWJTÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPOBDJPOBMFN [POBTOBTFTDBMBTOBDJPOBMNBDSPSSFHJPOBJTFTUBEVBJTSFHJPOBJTFMPDBJTEFBDPSEP DPNBTOFDFTTJEBEFTEFQSPUFÎÍPDPOTFSWBÎÍPFSFDVQFSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTF EPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMTFHVOEPPTQSJODÓQJPTEBGVOÎÍPTPDJPBNCJFOUBMEB QSPQSJFEBEFEBQSFWFOÎÍPEBQSFDBVÎÍPEPQPMVJEPSQBHBEPSEPVTVÈSJPQBHBEPS EBQBSUJDJQBÎÍPJOGPSNBEBEPBDFTTPFRVJUBUJWPFEBJOUFHSBÎÍP 0[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMFNTFOUJEPFTUSJUPJOTUSVNFOUPEFQMBOFKBNFOUPNV OJDJQBMQSFWJTUPOP"SUJODJTP***iDwEB-FJ'FEFSBMOEFEFKVMIPEF ÏP;&&FNFTDBMBMPDBM1PSUBOUPFYJTUFVNBOÓUJEBSFMBÎÍPEFDPNQMFNFOUBSJEBEFFOUSF PTJOTUSVNFOUPTQSFWJTUPTOBT-FJTOFOFYJHJOEPTFEPBQMJ DBEPSBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPTJTUFNÈUJDBPVEJBMØHJDB EBTSFGFSJEBTMFHJTMBÎÜFT"SFMBÎÍPFOUSF P;&&FP&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEFTFSÈBOBMJTBEBDPNNBJPSQSPGVOEJEBEFOPJUFN*9infra. 3.2. Competência " DPNQFUÐODJB FN NBUÏSJB EF [POFBNFOUP Ï FODPOUSBEB CBTJDBNFOUF OPT "SUTFEB-FJ$PNQMFNFOUBSO¡RVFBUSJCVFNSFTQFDUJWBNFOUFË 6OJÍPFMBCPSBSP[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMEFÉNCJUP/BDJPOBMF3FHJPOBMBPT&TUBEPT 0 %FDSFUP GFEFSBM GPJ BMUFSBEP QPTUFSJPSNFOUF QFMPT %FDSFUPT O ¡ F O¡ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 173 FMBCPSBSP[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMFTUBEVBMFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNPT[POFBNFOUPT OBDJPOBMFSFHJPOBMFBPTNVOJDÓQJPTFMBCPSBSP1MBOP%JSFUPSPCTFSWBOEPPT[POF BNFOUPTBNCJFOUBJT5BJTBSUJHPTFTUÍPFNDPOTPOÉODJBDPNPFTUBCFMFDJEPQFMP"SU JODJTP*9EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMRVFQSFWÐDPNQFUJSË6OJÍPFMBCPSBSFFYF DVUBSQMBOPTOBDJPOBJTFSFHJPOBJTEFPSEFOBÎÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPFEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP FDPOÙNJDPFTPDJBM "UÏPBEWFOUPEB-$OBNBUÏSJBSFMBUJWBBP[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBM FSBUSBUBEBKVOUPBP%FDSFUPO RVFSFHVMBNFOUBPBSU**EB1/." )PKFDPNSFMBÎÍPËDPNQFUÐODJBBNBUÏSJBÏUSBUBEBQFMBSFGFSJEBMFJDPNQMFNFOUBS 4. O DECRETO FEDERAL Nº 4.297/2002 4FHVOEPP%FDSFUPOP;&&UFNQPSPCKFUJWPHFSBMPSHBOJ [BSde forma vinculadaBTEFDJTÜFTEPTBHFOUFTQÞCMJDPTFQSJWBEPTRVBOUPBPT QMBOPT QSPHSBNBT QSPKFUPT F BUJWJEBEFT RVF VUJMJ[FN SFDVSTPT OBUVSBJT EJSFUB PVJOEJSFUBNFOUFBTTFHVSBOEPBQMFOBNBOVUFOÎÍPEPDBQJUBMFEPTTFSWJÎPTBN CJFOUBJTEPTFDPTTJTUFNBT "EJTUSJCVJÎÍPFTQBDJBMEBTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOÙNJDBTEFWFSÈMFWBSFNDPOUBB JNQPSUÉODJBFDPMØHJDBBTMJNJUBÎÜFTFBTGSBHJMJEBEFTEPTFDPTTJTUFNBTFFTUBCFMFDFSÈ WFEBÎÜFTSFTUSJÎÜFTFBMUFSOBUJWBTEFFYQMPSBÎÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPEFUFSNJOBOEPRVBOEP GPSPDBTPBSFMPDBMJ[BÎÍPEFBUJWJEBEFTJODPNQBUÓWFJTDPNTVBTEJSFUSJ[FTHFSBJT 0;&&EFWFHVBSEBSDPNQBUJCJMJEBEFNFUPEPMØHJDBDPNPTQSJODÓQJPTFDSJ UÏSJPTBQSPWBEPTQFMB$PNJTTÍP$PPSEFOBEPSBEP;POFBNFOUP&DPMØHJDP&DPOÙNJDP EP5FSSJUØSJP/BDJPOBMJOTUJUVÓEBQFMP%FDSFUP%4/ 0;&&EJWJEJSÈPUFSSJUØSJPFN[POBTEFBDPSEPDPNBOFDFTTJEBEFEFQSP UFÎÍPDPOTFSWBÎÍPFSFDVQFSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVT UFOUÈWFM/BEFmOJÎÍPEBT[POBTEFWFSÍPTFSPCTFSWBEPTPEJBHOØTUJDPEPTSFDVSTPT OBUVSBJTEBTØDJPFDPOPNJBFEPNBSDPKVSÓEJDPJOTUJUVDJPOBMRVFEFWFSÈDPOUFS OPNÓOJNP DPOTPBOUFEFUFSNJOBPBSUJHPEP%FDSFUP%4/:J VOJ EBEFT EPT TJTUFNBT BNCJFOUBJT EFmOJEBT B QBSUJS EB JOUFHSBÎÍP FOUSF PT DPNQP OFOUFTEBOBUVSF[BJJ QPUFODJBMJEBEFOBUVSBMEFmOJEBQFMPTTFSWJÎPTBNCJFOUBJT EPT FDPTTJTUFNBT F QFMPT SFDVSTPT OBUVSBJT EJTQPOÓWFJT JODMVJOEP FOUSF PVUSPT BQUJEÍPBHSÓDPMBQPUFODJBMNBEFJSFJSPFQPUFODJBMEFQSPEVUPTnPSFTUBJTOÍPNB EFJSFJSPTRVFJODMVJPQPUFODJBMQBSBBFYQMPSBÎÍPEFQSPEVUPTEFSJWBEPTOBCJPEJ WFSTJEBEFJJJ GSBHJMJEBEFOBUVSBMQPUFODJBMEFmOJEBQPSJOEJDBEPSFTEFQFSEBEB $PNBMUFSBÎÜFTJOUSPEV[JEBTQFMPT%FDSFUPTOFO $VKPBSUJHPEJTQÜFPTFHVJOUF"SUo$PNQFUFBP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP'FEFSBMFMBCPSBSFFYFDVUBSP;&& OBDJPOBMFSFHJPOBJTRVBOEPUJWFSQPSPCKFUPCJPNBTCSBTJMFJSPTPVUFSSJUØSJPTBCSBOHJEPTQPSQMBOPTF QSPKFUPTQSJPSJUÈSJPTFTUBCFMFDJEPTQFMP(PWFSOP'FEFSBMù3FEBÎÍPEBEBQFMP%FDSFUPOEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 174 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen CJPEJWFSTJEBEF WVMOFSBCJMJEBEF OBUVSBM Ë QFSEB EP TPMP RVBOUJEBEF F RVBMJEBEF EPTSFDVSTPTIÓESJDPTTVQFSmDJBJTFTVCUFSSÉOFPTJW JOEJDBÎÍPEPTDPSSFEPSFTFDP MØHJDPTW UFOEÐODJBTEFPDVQBÎÍPFBSUJDVMBÎÍPSFHJPOBMEFmOJEBTFNGVOÎÍPEF VTPEBUFSSBEPTnVYPTFDPOÙNJDPTFQPQVMBDJPOBJTEBMPDBMJ[BÎÍPEBTJOGSBFTUSV UVSBTFDJSDVMBÎÍPEBJOGPSNBÎÍPWJ BTDPOEJÎÜFTEFWJEBEBQPQVMBÎÍPEFmOJEBT QPSJOEJDBEPSFTEFDPOEJÎÜFTEFWJEBEBTJUVBÎÍPEBTBÞEFFEVDBÎÍPNFSDBEPEF USBCBMIPFTBOFBNFOUPCÈTJDPFWJJ BTJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFTMFHBJTEFmOJEBTQFMB TJUVBÎÍPEFÈSFBTMFHBMNFOUFQSPUFHJEBTFPUJQPEFPDVQBÎÍPRVFFMBTWÐNTPGSFO EP WJJJ BT ÈSFBT JOTUJUVDJPOBJT EFmOJEBT QFMP NBQFBNFOUP EF UFSSBT JOEÓHFOBT VOJEBEFTEFDPOTFSWBÎÍPFÈSFBTEFGSPOUFJSBT "EFmOJÎÍPEBT[POBTEFWFSÈPCTFSWBSBJOEBBTJOGPSNBÎÜFTDPOTUBOUFTEP 4JTUFNBEF*OGPSNBÎÜFT(FPHSÈmDBTPTDFOÈSJPTUFOEFODJBJTFBMUFSOBUJWPTFBT%J SFUSJ[FT(FSBJTF&TQFDÓmDBTQSFWJTUBTOPBSUJHPEP%FDSFUP'FEFSBMOEF EFKVMIPEFRVFEFWFSÍPDPOUFSOPNÓOJNPJ BTBUJWJEBEFTBEFRVBEBTB DBEB[POBEFBDPSEPDPNBTVBGSBHJMJEBEFFDPMØHJDBDBQBDJEBEFEFTVQPSUFBNCJFO UBMFQPUFODJBMJEBEFTJJ BTOFDFTTJEBEFTEFQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMFDPOTFSWBÎÍPEBT ÈHVBTEPTPMPEPTVCTPMPEBGBVOBFnPSBFEFNBJTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTSFOPWÈWFJTF OÍPSFOPWÈWFJTJJJ BEFmOJÎÍPEBTÈSFBTQBSBVOJEBEFTEFDPOTFSWBÎÍPEFQSPUFÎÍP JOUFHSBMFEFVTPTVTUFOUÈWFMJW PTDSJUÏSJPTQBSBPSJFOUBSBTBUJWJEBEFTNBEFJSFJSBF OÍPNBEFJSFJSBBHSÓDPMBQFDVÈSJBQFTRVFJSBFEFQJTDJDVMUVSBEFVSCBOJ[BÎÍPFEF JOEVTUSJBMJ[BÎÍPEFNJOFSBÎÍPFEFPVUSBTPQÎÜFTEFVTPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTW BT NFEJEBTEFTUJOBEBTBQSPNPWFSEFGPSNBPSEFOBEBFJOUFHSBEBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP FDPMØHJDPFFDPOPNJDBNFOUFTVTUFOUÈWFMEPTFUPSSVSBMDPNPPCKFUJWPEFNFMIPSBSB DPOWJWÐODJBFOUSFBQPQVMBÎÍPFPTSFDVSTPTBNCJFOUBJTJODMVTJWFDPNBQSFWJTÍPEF EJSFUSJ[FTQBSBJNQMBOUBÎÍPEFJOGSBFTUSVUVSBEFGPNFOUPËTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOÙNJDBT WJ BTNFEJEBTEFDPOUSPMFFEFBKVTUBNFOUPEFQMBOPTEF[POFBNFOUPEFBUJWJEBEFT FDPOÙNJDBTFTPDJBJTSFTVMUBOUFTEBJOJDJBUJWBEPTNVOJDÓQJPTWJTBOEPBDPNQBUJCJ MJ[BS OP JOUFSFTTF EB QSPUFÎÍP BNCJFOUBM VTPT DPOnJUBOUFT FN FTQBÎPT NVOJDJQBJT DPOUÓHVPTFBJOUFHSBSJOJDJBUJWBTSFHJPOBJTBNQMBTFOÍPSFTUSJUBTËTDJEBEFTFWJJ PT QMBOPTQSPHSBNBTFQSPKFUPTEPTHPWFSOPTGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMFNVOJDJQBMCFNDPNP BTSFTQFDUJWBTGPOUFTEFSFDVSTPTDPNWJTUBTBWJBCJMJ[BSBTBUJWJEBEFTBQPOUBEBTDPNP BEFRVBEBTBDBEB[POB /PTUFSNPTEP"SUBBMUFSBÎÍPEPTQSPEVUPTEP;&&CFNDPNPBTNV EBOÎBTOPTMJNJUFTEBT[POBTFJOEJDBÎÍPEFOPWBTEJSFUSJ[FTHFSBJTFFTQFDÓmDBTQP EFSÍPTFSSFBMJ[BEBTBQØTEFDPSSJEPPQSB[PNÓOJNPEFEF[ BOPTEFDPODMVTÍP EP;&&PVEFTVBNPEJmDBÎÍP5BMQSB[POÍPÏFYJHÓWFMOBIJQØUFTFEFBNQMJBÎÍPEP SJHPSEBQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMEB[POBBTFSBMUFSBEBPVEFBMUFSBÎÜFTEFDPSSFOUFTEF BQSJNPSBNFOUPUÏDOJDPDJFOUÓmDP " BMUFSBÎÍP TPNFOUF QPEFSÈ TF FGFUJWBS BQØT DPOTVMUB QÞCMJDB F BQSPWBÎÍP QFMB$PNJTTÍP&TUBEVBMFQFMB$PNJTTÍP$PPSEFOBEPSBNFEJBOUFQSPDFTTPMFHJTMBUJ WPEFJOJDJBUJWBEP1PEFS&YFDVUJWP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 175 ;&&DPODMVÓEPÏBRVFMFRVFEJTQVTFSEF[POBTEFmOJEBTFDBSBDUFSJ[BEBTF DPOUJWFSBT%JSFUSJ[FT(FSBJTF&TQFDÓmDBTBQSPWBEBTQFMB$PNJTTÍPFTUBEVBMEP;&& FQFMB$PNJTTÍP$PPSEFOBEPSBEP;&& "BMUFSBÎÍPEP;&&OÍPQPEFSÈSFEV[JSPQFSDFOUVBMEBSFTFSWBMFHBMEFmOJEP FNMFJOFNBTÈSFBTQSPUFHJEBTDPNVOJEBEFTEFDPOTFSWBÎÍPPVOÍP 0TDSJUÏSJPTQBESÜFTFPCSJHBÎÜFTFTUBCFMFDJEPTOP;&&RVBOEPFYJTUJSFN TFNQSFKVÓ[PEPTQSFWJTUPTOBMFHJTMBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMEFWFSÍPTFSPCTFSWBEPTQFMBTJOT UJUVJÎÜFTQÞCMJDBTPVQSJWBEBTJ OPQMBOFKBNFOUPFOBJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEFQPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBTJJ OPMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMJJJ OBDPODFTTÍPEFDSÏEJUPPmDJBMPVCF OFGÓDJPTUSJCVUÈSJPTFJW OBBTTJTUÐODJBUÏDOJDBEFRVBMRVFSOBUVSF[B $POGPSNFTFWFSJmDBÏFTTFODJBMBDPOKVHBÎÍPEPTJOTUJUVUPTEP;&&FEP MJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMFNSB[ÍPEFTFVDBSÈUFSWJODVMBOUF 5. LEI FEDERAL Nº 7.661/88: ZEE DA ZONA COSTEIRA /PÉNCJUPEP;&&DVNQSFVNQBQFMEFFYUSFNPEFTUBRVFQBSBB;POB$PT UFJSBPVTFKBPFTQBÎPHFPHSÈmDPEFJOUFSBÎÍPEPBSEPNBSFEBUFSSBRVFJODMVJPT SFDVSTPTSFOPWÈWFJTPVOÍPBCSBOHFOEPUBOUPVNBGBJYBNBSÓUJNBRVBOUPUFSSFTUSF QSPUFHJEBDPNPQBUSJNÙOJPOBDJPOBMQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFSFHSBEBEFGPSNBFTQFDÓmDB QFMB-FJOEFEFNBJPEFRVFJOTUJUVJP1MBOP/BDJPOBMEF(FSFODJB NFOUP$PTUFJSP1/($ DPNPQBSUFJOUFHSBOUFEB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMQBSBPT3FDVSTPT EP.BS1/3. FEB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUF1/." 5SBUBTFEFVNBÈSFBDPNFOPSNFSFMFWÉODJBBNCJFOUBMFRVFTPGSFVNBQSFT TÍPDPOTUBOUFFNGBDFEFTVBDSFTDFOUFPDVQBÎÍPOPNBJTEBTWF[FTEFGPSNBEFTPS EFOBEBFFNÈSFBTEFSJTDP²EJT.JMBSÏJOEJDB /P MJUPSBM FTUBCFMFDFSBNTF PT QSJNFJSPT OÞDMFPT F DPMPOJ[BÎÍP EF NPEPRVFGPJBÓRVFTFJOJDJBSBNPTDPOnJUPTEBTBUJWJEBEFTBOUSØQJDBT DPNPNFJPBNCJFOUFPTRVBJTOPEFDPSSFSEFTÏDVMPTTFUSBEV[JSBN FNEJGFSFOUFTUJQPTEFPDVQBÎÍPEFTPSEFOBEBEPFTQBÎPFFNBUJWJEBEFT QSPEVUJWBTEBOPTBTËRVBMJEBEFBNCJFOUBM1PMVJÎÍPFPVUSBTGPSNBTEF EFHSBEBÎÍPBQSFTFOUBNÓOEJDFTBMBSNBOUFT %FTTBGPSNBBQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMBQSFTFOUBTFDPNPVNGBUPSFTTFODJBMEF HFTUÍPEB;$FTUBCFMFDFOEPPBSUEBMFJRVFP1/($EFWFSÈQSFWFSP[POFBNFOUP EFVTPTFBUJWJEBEFTOB;$FEBSQSJPSJEBEFËDPOTFSWBÎÍPFQSPUFÎÍPFOUSFPVUSPT %JSFJUPEPBNCJFOUFBHFTUÍPBNCJFOUBMFNGPDPEPVUSJOBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBHMPTTÈSJP4ÍP1BVMP35 Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 176 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen EPTTFHVJOUFTCFOTJ SFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTSFOPWÈWFJTFOÍPSFOPWÈWFJTSFDJGFTQBSDFJT FCBODPTFBMHBTJMIBTDPTUFJSBTFPDFÉOJDBTTJTUFNBTnVWJBJTFTUVBSJOPTFMBHVOBSFT CBÓBTFFOTFBEBTQSBJBTQSPNPOUØSJPTDPTUÜFTFHSVUBTNBSJOIBTSFTUJOHBTFEVOBT nPSFTUBTMJUPSÉOFBTNBOHVF[BJTFQSBEBSJBTTVCNFSTBTJJ TÓUJPTFDPMØHJDPTEFSFMF WÉODJBDVMUVSBMFEFNBJTVOJEBEFTEFQSFTFSWBÎÍPQFSNBOFOUFFJJJ NPOVNFOUPT RVFJOUFHSFNPQBUSJNÙOJPOBUVSBMIJTUØSJDPQBMFPOUPMØHJDPFTQFMFPMØHJDPBSRVFP MØHJDPÏUOJDPDVMUVSBMFQBJTBHÓTUJDP "BQMJDBÎÍPEP1/($BPRVBMDPNQFUFEFmOJSBTGBJYBTNBSÓUJNBTFUFSSFT USFTRVFJOUFHSBNB;$FOWPMWFBQBSUJDJQBÎÍPEB6OJÍPEPT&TUBEPTEPTUFSSJUØSJPT FEPTNVOJDÓQJPTQPSNFJPEPTØSHÍPTFFOUJEBEFTJOUFHSBOUFTEP4*4/"."²GBDVM UBEBBPT&TUBEPTFNVOJDÓQJPTBJOTUJUVJÎÍPNFEJBOUFMFJEPTSFTQFDUJWPT1MBOPT&T UBEVBJTPV.VOJDJQBJTEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSPPCTFSWBEPTBTOPSNBTFEJSFUSJ[FT EP1/($FPEJTQPTUPOB-FJO "-FJEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSPSFDPOIFDFËTQSBJBTBOBUVSF[BEFCFNQÞ CMJDPEFVTPDPNVNEPQPWPËTRVBJTÏBTTFHVSBEPPMJWSFFGSBODPBDFTTPFYUFOTÓWFM BPNBS“em qualquer direção e sentido, ressalvados os trechos considerados de interesse de segurança nacional ou incluídos em áreas protegidas por legislação específica”TFOEPWFEB EBBVSCBOJ[BÎÍPPVRVBMRVFSPVUSBGPSNBEFVUJMJ[BÎÍPEB;$RVFWFOIBBJNQFEJS PVNFTNPEJmDVMUBSSFGFSJEPBDFTTP 0BSUfEB-FJODPOUFNQMBVNJNQPSUBOUFEJTQPTJUJWPEF QSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMBPEFUFSNJOBSRVFPT1MBOPTEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSP/BDJP OBM&TUBEVBMF.VOJDJQBMQPEFSÍPFTUBCFMFDFSOPSNBTFEJSFUSJ[FTTPCSFPVTPEPTPMP EPTVCTPMPFEBTÈHVBTCFNDPNPMJNJUBÎÜFTËVUJMJ[BÎÍPEPTJNØWFJTQSFWBMFDFOEP FOUSFUBOUPTFNQSFBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTNBJTSFTUSJUJWBTWPMUBEBTËQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMBTFS PCTFSWBEBTUBOUPQFMPQPEFSQÞCMJDPRVBOUPQFMPTQBSUJDVMBSFTEFGPSNBWJODVMBOUF 5.1. Decreto Federal nº 5.300/2004 " -FJ O GPJ SFHVMBNFOUBEB TPNFOUF EF[FTTFJT BOPT BQØT B TVB FEJÎÍPQFMP%FDSFUP'FEFSBMOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFRVFWFNFTUBCF MFDFSBTOPSNBTHFSBJTQBSBBHFTUÍPBNCJFOUBMEB;POB$PTUFJSB;$ FBQSFTFOUBS BTCBTFTQBSBBGPSNVMBÎÍPEBTQPMÓUJDBTQMBOPTFQSPHSBNBTGFEFSBJTFTUBEVBJTF NVOJDJQBJTQBSBBÈSFBFNRVFTUÍP "P.JOJTUÏSJPEP.FJP"NCJFOUFDBCFBFMBCPSBÎÍPFSFTQFDUJWBBUVBMJ[BÎÍP EBMJTUBHFNEPTNVOJDÓQJPTBCSBOHJEPTQFMBGBJYBUFSSFTUSFEB;$EP#SBTJMËRVBMEF WFSÈTFSEBEBQVCMJDJEBEFBOVBMNFEJBOUFTVBEJWVMHBÎÍPOP%JÈSJP0mDJBMEB6OJÍP $PNQFUFBJOEBBP.JOJTUÏSJPEP.FJP"NCJFOUFTFNQSFKVÓ[PEBDPNQFUÐODJBEF PVUSPT ØSHÍPT BDPNQBOIBS F BWBMJBS QFSNBOFOUFNFOUF B FYFDVÎÍP EP 1/($ DVJ EBOEPQBSBRVFPTQMBOPTFTUBEVBJTFNVOJDJQBJTFTUFKBNDPNFMFDPNQBUÓWFJTFFN IBSNPOJBDPNBTEFNBJTOPSNBTGFEFSBJTBQMJDÈWFJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 177 $PNPPCKFUJWPEFWJBCJMJ[BSBDPSSFUBHFTUÍPEB;$NFEJBOUFVNBPDVQBÎÍP QMBOFKBEB F PSEFOBEB P %FDSFUP O QSFWÐ B BQMJDBÎÍP EF OPWF JOTUSV NFOUPTBTTJNEFmOJEPTJ 1MBOP/BDJPOBMEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSP1/($ JJ 1MBOPEF"ÎÍP'FEFSBMOB;POB$PTUFJSB1"';$ JJJ 1MBOP&TUBEVBMEF(FSFODJB NFOUP$PTUFJSP1&($ JW 1MBOP.VOJDJQBMEF(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSP1.($ W 4JTUFNBEF*OGPSNBÎÜFTEP(FSFODJBNFOUP$PTUFJSP4*(&3$0 WJ 4JTUFNBEF .POJUPSBNFOUP"NCJFOUBMEB;POB$PTUFJSB4.";$ WJJ 3FMBUØSJPEB2VBMJEBEF "NCJFOUBM EB ;POB $PTUFJSB 32";$ F WJJJ ;POFBNFOUP &DPMØHJDP&DPOÙNJDP $PTUFJSP;&&$ JY NBDSPEJBHOØTUJDPEB;$ 7ÐTFQPSUBOUPRVFP;POFBNFOUP&DPMØHJDP&DPOÙNJDP$PTUFJSP;&&$ DPOTUJUVJJOTUSVNFOUPOÍPBQFOBTEB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUFDPNPUBN CÏNEFHFTUÍPEB;$DBCFOEPMIFFTUBCFMFDFSBTEJSFUSJ[FTRVFQFSNJUBNBEFmOJÎÍP EPTVTPTOFMBQFSNJUJEPTQSPJCJEPTPVFTUJNVMBEPTMFWBOEPTFFNDPOUBTFNQSFB JOUFHSBÎÍPEBTGBJYBTUFSSFTUSFFNBSÓUJNBVNBWF[PCTFSWBEBTBTPSJFOUBÎÜFTDPOUJ EBTOP"OFYP*EPSFGFSJEPEFDSFUP$POTPBOUFFTUBCFMFDFP"SU*EP%FDSFUPO 0;&&$EFWFSÈTFSFMBCPSBEPPCSJHBUPSJBNFOUFEFGPSNBQBSUJDJQBUJWB 0;&&$USBUBUBNCÏNEBPSMBNBSÓUJNBEFmOJEBDPNP“a faixa contida na zona costeira, de largura variável, que compreende uma porção marítima e outra terrestre”, DVKPTMJNJUFTTFFODPOUSBNmYBEPTOPBSUJHPEP%FDSFUPO " HFTUÍP EB PSMB NBSÓUJNB TFSÈ FGFUJWBEB QPS NFJP EF VN QMBOP EF JOUFS WFOÎÍPFMBCPSBEPFFYFDVUBEPQFMPNVOJDÓQJPEFNPEPQBSUJDJQBUJWPDPNCBTFOP SFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTOBUVSBJTFOPTUJQPTEFVTPFPDVQBÎÍPFYJTUFOUFT FQSPKFUBEPTFNDPOGPSNJEBEFDPNPQMBOFKBNFOUPGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMFNVOJDJQBMEB ;$EFWFOEPDPOUFNQMBSBDBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPTPDJPBNCJFOUBMEBPSMBBDMBTTJmDBÎÍPDPN BOÈMJTFEPTBUSJCVUPTOBUVSBJTFBTUFOEÐODJBTEFTVBPDVQBÎÍPPVQSFTFSWBÎÍPCFN DPNPPFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEFEJSFUSJ[FTQBSBJOUFSWFOÎÍP 0TFTUVEPTFEJSFUSJ[FTDPODFSOFOUFTBP;&&$EFWFSÍPTFSDPNQBUJCJMJ[BEPT DPNPFORVBESBNFOUPFSFTQFDUJWBTFTUSBUÏHJBTEBHFTUÍPEBPSMBFBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTSFMBUJ WBTËHFTUÍPEBPSMBNBSÓUJNBUÐNBQMJDBÎÍPUBNCÏNQBSBBTJMIBTDPTUFJSBTFPDFÉOJDBT 5FOEPFNWJTUBBSFMFWÉODJBFBGSBHJMJEBEFBNCJFOUBMEB;$P%FDSFUPO DPOUFNQMB WÈSJBT OPSNBT EF DBSÈUFS HFSBM RVF HVBSEBN SFMBÎÍP EJSFUB DPNPMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMFRVFEFWFSÍPTFSPCTFSWBEBTQFMPTØSHÍPTFFOUJEBEFT JOUFHSBOUFTEP4*4/"."OPFYFSDÓDJPEFTVBTBÎÜFTEFDPNBOEPFDPOUSPMF "TTJNUPEPFRVBMRVFSFNQSFFOEJNFOUPMPDBMJ[BEPOB;$EFWFSÈTFSDPN QBUÓWFMDPNBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBEFTBOFBNFOUPFTJTUFNBWJÈSJPTFYJTUFOUFTEFWFOEPB TPMVÎÍPUÏDOJDBBEPUBEBQSFTFSWBSBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTBNCJFOUBJTFBRVBMJEBEFQBJTBHÓT UJDBOPTUFSNPTEPBSUJHPEPEFDSFUPFNRVFTUÍP /BIJQØUFTFEFJOFYJTUÐODJBPVEBGBMUBEFBDFTTJCJMJEBEFËSFEFQÞCMJDBEFDP MFUBEFMJYPFEFFTHPUPTBOJUÈSJPOBÈSFBEPFNQSFFOEJNFOUPPFNQSFFOEFEPSFTUBSÈ PCSJHBEPBBQSFTFOUBSVNBTPMVÎÍPBVUÙOPNBQBSBBOÈMJTFEPØSHÍPBNCJFOUBMRVF OFDFTTBSJBNFOUFTFKBDPNQBUÓWFMDPNBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTGÓTJDBTFBNCJFOUBJTEBÈSFB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 178 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen 6NJNQPSUBOUFEJTQPTJUJWPWPMUBEPËQSPUFÎÍPEBWFHFUBÎÍPOBUJWBEFUFSNJ OBRVFBÈSFBBTFSEFTNBUBEBQBSBJOTUBMBÎÍPBNQMJBÎÍPPVSFBMPDBÎÍPEFFNQSFFO EJNFOUPTPVBUJWJEBEFTOB;$RVFJNQMJDBSBTVBTVQSFTTÍPOPTUFSNPTMFHBMNFOUF BVUPSJ[BEPTEFWFSÈTFSDPNQFOTBEBNFEJBOUFBBWFSCBÎÍPEFOPNÓOJNPVNBÈSFB FRVJWBMFOUFOBNFTNB[POBBGFUBEBDPOGPSNF"SUEPDJUBEP%FDSFUP "ENJUFTFBDPNQFOTBÎÍPFN[POBEJWFSTBEBBGFUBEBQFMPFNQSFFOEJNFOUP NFEJBOUFQSÏWJBBQSPWBÎÍPEPØSHÍPBNCJFOUBMDPNQFUFOUFEFTEFRVFFTUBTFMPDBMJ[F OBNFTNBVOJEBEFHFPBNCJFOUBM"WFHFUBÎÍPOBUJWBFYJTUFOUFOBÈSFBBWFSCBEBBUÓ UVMPEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPQPEFSÈTFSNBOFKBEBNFEJBOUFQMBOPEFNBOFKPBQSPWBEPQFMP ØSHÍPBNCJFOUBMEFTEFRVFOÍPJNQMJRVFBMUFSBÎÍPEFTVBDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBFDPMØHJDBF EFTVBRVBMJEBEFQBJTBHÓTUJDB $BCFEFTUBDBSRVFB-FJOBPDVJEBSEBQSPUFÎÍPEP#JPNB .BUB"UMÉOUJDBDPNFOPSNFJODJEÐODJBOB;$FNTFV"SUJHVBMNFOUFJNQÜFB DPNQFOTBÎÍPEBTVQSFTTÍPEFTVBWFHFUBÎÍPOBUJWBQPSÈSFBFRVJWBMFOUFËÈSFBEFT NBUBEBDPNBTNFTNBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTFDPMØHJDBTOBNFTNBCBDJBIJESPHSÈmDBF TFNQSFRVFGPSWJÈWFMOBNFTNBNJDSPCBDJB /PTUFSNPTEP"SUEPSFGFSJEPEFDSFUPBTPCSBTFTFSWJÎPTEFJOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDPTPNFOUFQPEFSÍPTFSSFBMJ[BEPTPVJNQMBOUBEPTFNÈSFBEBPSMBNBSÓUJNB RVBOEPDPNQBUÓWFJTDPNP;&&PVPVUSPTJOTUSVNFOUPTTJNJMBSFTEFPSEFOBNFOUP EP UFSSJUØSJP &TUF EJTQPTJUJWP BQSFTFOUB VN HSBWF QSPCMFNB EF PSEFN UÏDOJDB FJT RVFGB[SFGFSÐODJBBPCSBTFTFSWJÎPTEFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTFNRVFIBKBVNBEFmOJÎÍP EFUBMJOUFSFTTFOÍPmDBOEPDMBSPBTTJNTFFTUFTFDPOGVOEFPVOÍPDPNBVUJMJEBEF QÞCMJDBPVPJOUFSFTTFTPDJBM 1BSBBTÈSFBTOÍPDPOUFNQMBEBTQPS1MBOPEF*OUFSWFOÎÍPPØSHÍPBNCJFOUBM SFRVJTJUBSÈFTUVEPTRVFQFSNJUBNBDBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPDMBTTJmDBÎÍPEBPSMBNBSÓUJNBQBSB PMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMEFFNQSFFOEJNFOUPTPVBUJWJEBEFT 5.2. Lei Estadual nº 10.019/98: o Plano Estadual de Gerenciamento Costeiro (PEGC/SP) /PÉNCJUPEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPB-FJOEFEFKVMIPEF EJTQÜFTPCSFP1MBOP &TUBEVBM EF (FSFODJBNFOUP $PTUFJSP 1&($ F EFmOF P ;&& DPNPVNJOTUSVNFOUPCÈTJDPEFQMBOFKBNFOUPRVFFTUBCFMFDFBQØTEJTDVTTÍPQÞCMJ DBEFTVBTSFDPNFOEBÎÜFTUÏDOJDBTJODMVTJWFFNÉNCJUPNVOJDJQBMBTOPSNBTEFVTP FPDVQBÎÍPEPTPMPFEFNBOFKPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFN[POBTFTQFDÓmDBTmYBEBTB QBSUJSEBTBOÈMJTFTEFTVBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTFDPMØHJDBTFTPDJPFDPOÙNJDBT ";$EP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPÏEJWJEJEBFNRVBUSPTFUPSFTQFMBMFJJ -JUPSBM /PSUFJJ #BJYBEB4BOUJTUBJJJ $PNQMFYP&TUVBSJOPo-BHVOBSEF*HVBQF$BOBOFJB FJW 7BMFEP3JCFJSBRVFTFSÍPEFMJNJUBEPTFDBSBDUFSJ[BEPTOPTSFTQFDUJWPT[POFB NFOUPTFJNQMBOUBEPTNFEJBOUFEFDSFUPEP(PWFSOBEPSEP&TUBEPRVFFORVBESBSÈ BTEJWFSTBT[POBTFTFVTVTPTBPTUFSNPTEBMFJ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 179 /PRVFDPODFSOFBP1&($BMFJEFUFSNJOBBTVBFMBCPSBÎÍPNFEJBOUFVNBBÎÍP DPOKVOUBEP&TUBEPEPTNVOJDÓQJPTFEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMPSHBOJ[BEB"P1PEFS&YFDVUJWP&T UBEVBMDPNQFUFBJOTUJUVJÎÍPEP(SVQPEF$PPSEFOBÎÍP&TUBEVBMQSFWJTUPOP1/($BQSP WBEPQFMB3FTPMVÎÍPOEB$*3.DPNJODVNCÐODJBEFFMBCPSBSP1&($3FGFSJEPHSV QPÏDPOTUJUVÓEPEFGPSNBQBSJUÈSJBQPSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEP&TUBEPEFSFQSFTFOUBOUFT EPTNVOJDÓQJPTFEFSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJMPSHBOJ[BEBFTDPMIJEPTFNJHVBM OÞNFSPFOUSFPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFDBEB(SVQP4FUPSJBMEF$PPSEFOBÎÍPDPSSFTQPOEFOUF BDBEBVNEPTTFUPSFTDPTUFJSPTQSFWJTUPTOP"SUEBMFJ"P(SVQP4FUPSJBMJHVBMNFOUF DPOTUJUVÓEPEFGPSNBQBSJUÈSJBQPSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEP&TUBEPEPTNVOJDÓQJPTFEBTPDJFEBEF DJWJMPSHBOJ[BEBDBCFBFMBCPSBÎÍPEP;&&FEPT1MBOPTEF"ÎÍPF(FTUÍPQBSBB;$ /PTUFSNPTEBMFJP;&&UFNQPSPCKFUJWPJEFOUJmDBSBTVOJEBEFTUFSSJUPSJBJT RVFQPSTVBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTGÓTJDBTCJPMØHJDBTFTPDJPFDPOÙNJDBTCFNDPNPQPSTVB EJOÉNJDBFDPOUSBTUFTJOUFSOPTEFWBNTFSPCKFUPEFEJTDJQMJOBFTQFDJBMDPNWJTUBTBP EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEFBÎÜFTDBQB[FTEFDPOEV[JSBPBQSPWFJUBNFOUPËNBOVUFOÎÍPPV ËSFDVQFSBÎÍPEFTVBRVBMJEBEFBNCJFOUBMFEPTFVQPUFODJBMQSPEVUJWP "P;&&DBCFBEFmOJÎÍPEBTOPSNBTFEBTNFUBTBNCJFOUBJTFTPDJPFDPOÙNJ DBTSVSBJTVSCBOBTFBRVÈUJDBTBTFSFNBMDBOÎBEBTQPSNFJPEFQSPHSBNBTEFHFTUÍP TPDJPFDPOÙNJDPBNCJFOUBJT0;&&EP&TUBEPEFWFHVBSEBSDPNQBUJCJMJEBEFNFUP EPMØHJDB DPN PT QSJODÓQJPT F DSJUÏSJPT BQSPWBEPT QFMB $PNJTTÍP $PPSEFOBEPSB EP ;&&EP5FSSJUØSJP/BDJPOBMJOTUJUVÓEBQFMP%FDSFUP%4/EFEFEF[FNCSPEF $BEBVNEPTRVBUSPTFUPSFTEB;$TFSÈPCKFUPEFFORVBESBNFOUPUFSSJUPSJBM PCTFSWBEBTDJODP [POBTEPUBEBTEFDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEJWFSTBTRVFQPTTJCJMJUBSÍP ";POB;ÏBRVFMBRVFNBOUÏNPTFDPTTJTUFNBTQSJNJUJWPTFNQMFOPFRVJMÓCSJPBNCJFOUBMDPNBFWFO UVBMPDPSSÐODJBEFBUJWJEBEFTIVNBOBTEFCBJYPTFGFJUPTJNQBDUBOUFTTFOEPOFMBBENJUJEBBQSFTFSWBÎÍPF BDPOTFSWBÎÍPEBWFHFUBÎÍPOBUJWBBQFTRVJTBDJFOUÓmDBBFEVDBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMPNBOFKPBVUPTTVTUFOUBEP PFDPUVSJTNPBQFTDBBSUFTBOBMFBPDVQBÎÍPIVNBOBEFTEFRVFOÍPQSFKVEJRVFNBNBOVUFOÎÍPEFTVBT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT";POB;QPSTVBWF[FNCPSBBQSFTFOUFBMUFSBÎÜFTOBPSHBOJ[BÎÍPGVODJPOBMEPTFDPT TJTUFNBTQSJNJUJWPTFODPOUSBTFDBQBDJUBEBQBSBNBOUFSFNFRVJMÓCSJPVNBDPNVOJEBEFEFPSHBOJTNPTFN HSBVTWBSJBEPTEFEJWFSTJEBEFNFTNPDPNBPDPSSÐODJBEFBUJWJEBEFTIVNBOBTJOUFSNJUFOUFTPVEFCBJYPT JNQBDUPT²BENJTTÓWFMOB[POBUFSSFTUSFBFYJTUÐODJBEFBTTFOUBNFOUPTIVNBOPTEJTQFSTPTFQPVDPQPQV MPTPTDPNQPVDBJOUFHSBÎÍPFOUSFTJ";BENJUFUPEPTPTVTPTDPNQBUÓWFJTDPNB;FBJOEBEFBDPSEP DPNPHSBVEFBMUFSBÎÍPEPTFDPTTJTUFNBTPNBOFKPTVTUFOUBEPBBRVJDVMUVSBFBNJOFSBÎÍPEFTEFRVF CBTFBEBFN1MBOP%JSFUPS3FHJPOBMEF.JOFSBÎÍPBTFSFTUBCFMFDJEPQFMPTØSHÍPTDPNQFUFOUFT";POBo ;BQSFTFOUBPTFDPTTJTUFNBTQSJNJUJWPTQBSDJBMNFOUFNPEJmDBEPTDPNEJmDVMEBEFEFSFHFOFSBÎÍPOBUVSBM QFMBFYQMPSBÎÍPTVQSFTTÍPPVTVCTUJUVJÎÍPEFBMHVNEFTFVTDPNQPOFOUFTFNSB[ÍPEBPDPSSÐODJBEFÈSFBT EFBTTFOUBNFOUPTIVNBOPTDPNNBJPSJOUFHSBÎÍPFOUSFTJ/B;QPEFSÍPTFSDPOGFSJEPTPTVTPTEB;F ;FEFQFOEFOEPEPHSBVEFNPEJmDBÎÍPEPTFDPTTJTUFNBTUBNCÏNBBHSPQFDVÈSJBBTJMWJDVMUVSBFBQFTDB JOEVTUSJBMOBTVOJEBEFTRVFBTQFSNJUBN2VBOUPË;POB;PTFDPTTJTUFNBTQSJNJUJWPTBQSFTFOUBNTF TJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFNPEJmDBEPTQFMBTVQSFTTÍPEFDPNQPOFOUFTEFTDBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPEPTTVCTUSBUPTUFSSFTUSFT FNBSJOIPTBMUFSBÎÍPEBTESFOBHFOTPVEBIJESPEJOÉNJDBCFNDPNPQFMBPDPSSÐODJBEFÈSFBTUFSSFTUSFT EFBTTFOUBNFOUPTSVSBJTPVQFSJVSCBOPTEFTDPOUÓOVPTJOUFSMJHBEPTOFDFTTJUBOEPEFJOUFSWFOÎÍPQBSBTVB SFHFOFSBÎÍPQBSDJBM/B;TÍPBTTFHVSBEPTPTVTPTEB;;F;NBJTPTBTTFOUBNFOUPTVSCBOPTEFT DPOUÓOVPTSFTUSJUPTËTVOJEBEFTRVFPTQFSNJUBNDPOGPSNFSFHVMBNFOUPEPT[POFBNFOUPTFTUBCFMFDJEPT QBSBPTTFUPSFTDPTUFJSPTQPSmNB;POB;ÏBRVFMBRVFBQSFTFOUBBNBJPSQBSUFEPTDPNQPOFOUFTEPT FDPTTJTUFNBTQSJNJUJWPTEFHSBEBEPTPVTVQSJNJEPTDPNBFMJNJOBÎÍPEBPSHBOJ[BÎÍPGVODJPOBMQBSBBRVBM TÍPQFSNJUJEPTPTVTPTEBT;;;F;CFNDPNPPBTTFOUBNFOUPVSCBOPBTBUJWJEBEFTJOEVTUSJBJT UVSÓTUJDBTOÈVUJDBTFBFSPSSPEPQPSUVÈSJBTEFBDPSEPDPNPFTUBCFMFDJEPFNMFHJTMBÎÍPNVOJDJQBM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 180 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen VNBEFRVBEPQMBOFKBNFOUPRVFQSPQJDJFVNEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPDPNQBUÓ WFMDPNBQSFTFSWBÎÍPBNCJFOUBM"DBEBVNBEBT[POBTDPSSFTQPOEFNVTPTDPOTJ EFSBEPTDPNFMBTDPNQBUÓWFJTTFOEPBENJUJEBBTVBEJWJTÍPFNTVC[POBTEFNBOFKP EFmOJEPDPOTUJUVJOEPVOJEBEFEFVTPWJTBOEPËPQFSBDJPOBMJ[BÎÍPEPDPOUSPMFEPT QMBOPTEFBÎÍPFHFTUÍPRVFTFSÍPJOTUJUVÓEPTQPSEFDSFUP7FKBTFRVFBFGFUJWJEBEF EPQMBOFKBNFOUPUFSSJUPSJBMQSFWJTUPOP;&&FODPOUSBTFDPOEJDJPOBEBËSFBMJNQMBO UBÎÍPEPTQMBOPTQSPKFUPTFBÎÜFTQFMP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPRVFEFGBUPQPTTBNEJSFDJPOBS BPDVQBÎÍPEBÈSFBEFNPEPTVTUFOUÈWFM "TBUJWJEBEFTEFTVCTJTUÐODJBTÍPBENJUJEBTFNUPEB;$JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EP[POFBNFOUPBUÏRVFQSPHSBNBTEFBEFRVBÎÍPUÏDOJDBFKVSÓEJDBTFKBNJNQMFNFO UBEPTFSFHVMBNFOUBEPT "MFJEFUFSNJOBRVFPFORVBESBNFOUPOPTEJGFSFOUFTUJQPTEF[POBTFKBGFJUP OÍPOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFDPOGPSNFBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTBUVBJTNBTSFTQFJUBOEPBEJOÉNJDB EFPDVQBÎÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPFBTNFUBTEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTPDJPFDPOÙNJDPFEFQSPUF ÎÍPBNCJFOUBMBTFSFNBMDBOÎBEBTBUSBWÏTEFQMFOPTEFBÎÍPFHFTUÍPJOUFHSBEPTDPN QBUJCJMJ[BEPTDPNPTQMBOPTEJSFUPSFTSFHJPOBJTFNVOJDJQBJTFOBBVTÐODJBEFTUFT DPNBTMFJTNVOJDJQBJTEFVTPFPDVQBÎÍPEPTPMP /PRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPBPMJDFODJBNFOUPP"SUEB-FJOFTUBCF MFDFRVFJODVNCJSÈBPTEFDSFUPTEF[POFBNFOUPEFmOJSBTBUJWJEBEFTRVFEFQFOEFSÍP EF MJDFODJBNFOUP BNCJFOUBM QSÏWJP TFN QSFKVÓ[P EBT EFNBJT MJDFOÎBT FYJHÓWFJT 0 MJDFODJBNFOUPFBmTDBMJ[BÎÍPTFSÍPSFBMJ[BEPTDPNCBTFOBTOPSNBTFOPTDSJUÏSJPTFT UBCFMFDJEPTOP;&&TFNQSFKVÓ[PEPEJTQPTUPOBTEFNBJTOPSNBTFTQFDÓmDBTGFEFSBJT FTUBEVBJT F NVOJDJQBJTBTTJNDPNPBTFYJHÐODJBT GFJUBT QFMPT ØSHÍPT DPNQFUFOUFT "VUJMJ[BÎÍPEFNBUFSJBMEFFNQSÏTUJNPQBSBBUFSSPTFSÈOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFPCKFUPEF MJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBM 1PSDBSBDUFSJ[BSTFDPNPQBUSJNÙOJPOBDJPOBMBTFSQSPUFHJEPQBSBBTHFSB ÎÜFTQSFTFOUFTFGVUVSBTBMFJWFEBOB;$BDPNFSDJBMJ[BÎÍPEFNBEFJSBCSVUBGPSBEB SFHJÍPBQFTDBEFBSSBTUPDPNBVYÓMJPEFQBSFMIBFBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFBHSPUØYJDPTPSHB OPDMPSBEPTOBBHSPQFDVÈSJB "UÏBHPTUPEFTPNFOUFPT;&&EPTFUPS-JUPSBM/PSUFFEPTFUPS#BJYB EB4BOUJTUBEB;$EP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPGPSBNJNQMBOUBEPTSFTQFDUJWBNFOUFQFMP %FDSFUPOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFFQFMP%FDSFUPOEFEF NBSÎPEF 6. POLÍTICA AGRÍCOLA – LEI Nº 8.171/91 E O ZEE "1PMÓUJDB"HSÓDPMBOP#SBTJMGPJJOTUJUVÓEBQFMB-FJOEFEFKBOFJSP EFRVFmYBPTGVOEBNFOUPTEFmOFBTDPNQFUÐODJBTJOTUJUVDJPOBJTQSFWÐPT SFDVSTPTFFTUBCFMFDFBTBÎÜFTFJOTUSVNFOUPTQBSBTVBJNQMBOUBÎÍPOPRVFEJ[SFT QFJUPËTBUJWJEBEFTBHSPQFDVÈSJBTBHSPJOEVTUSJBJTFEFQMBOFKBNFOUPEBTBUJWJEBEFT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 181 QFTRVFJSB F nPSFTUBM ² FOUFOEJEB DPNP BUJWJEBEF BHSÓDPMB B QSPEVÎÍP P QSPDFT TBNFOUPFBDPNFSDJBMJ[BÎÍPEPTQSPEVUPTTVCQSPEVUPTFEFSJWBEPTTFSWJÎPTFJO TVNPT BHSÓDPMBT QFDVÈSJPT QFTRVFJSPT F nPSFTUBJT RVF DPNQSFFOEF PT QSPDFTTPT GÓTJDPTRVÓNJDPTFCJPMØHJDPTFNRVFPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFOWPMWJEPTEFWFNTFSVUJ MJ[BEPTFHFSFODJBEPTTVCPSEJOBOEPTFËTOPSNBTFQSJODÓQJPTEFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP EFGPSNBRVFTFKBDVNQSJEBBGVOÎÍPTPDJBMFFDPOÙNJDBEBQSPQSJFEBEF $POTUBNDPNPPCKFUJWPTEB1PMÓUJDB"HSÓDPMBBQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUF FBHBSBOUJBEPTFVVTPSBDJPOBMDPNFTUÓNVMPËSFDVQFSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJT CFNDPNPBQSPNPÎÍPEBJEPOFJEBEFEPTJOTVNPTFTFSWJÎPTFNQSFHBEPTOBBHSJDVM UVSBDPOTPBOUFJODJTPT*7F9*7EP"SUEBMFJ"QSFTFSWBÎÍPEBTBÞEFFEPNFJP BNCJFOUFFTUÈQSFTFOUFUBNCÏNFOUSFPTEFWFSFTEBQFTRVJTBBHSÓDPMB"SU*7 " MFJ EB 1PMÓUJDB "HSÓDPMB QPTTVJ BJOEB VN DBQÓUVMP FTQFDÓmDP $BQÓUVMP 7*WPMUBEPËQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFFËDPOTFSWBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTRVF JNQÜFBTVBFGFUJWBÎÍPBP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPEFGPSNBJOUFHSBEBFNOÓWFMGFEFSBMFTUBEV BMFNVOJDJQBMKVOUBNFOUFDPNBTDPNVOJEBEFTDPNQFUJOEPBmTDBMJ[BÎÍPFPVTP SBDJPOBMEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTEPNFJPBNCJFOUFUBNCÏNBPTQSPQSJFUÈSJPTEFEJSFJUP EPTCFOFmDJÈSJPTEBSFGPSNBBHSÈSJBFEPTPDVQBOUFTUFNQPSÈSJPTEPTJNØWFJTSVSBJT 1BSBRVFBQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMTFKBFGFUJWBP"SUEB-FJDPOUFNQMBBT TFHVJOUFT BÎÜFT QBSB PT BHFOUFT BDJNB SFGFSJEPT J EJTDJQMJOBS F mTDBMJ[BS P VTP SBDJPOBMEPTPMPEBÈHVBEBGBVOBFEBnPSBJJ SFBMJ[BS[POFBNFOUPTBHSPFDPMØHJ DPTRVFQFSNJUBNFTUBCFMFDFSDSJUÏSJPTQBSBPEJTDJQMJOBNFOUPFPPSEFOBNFOUPEB PDVQBÎÍPFTQBDJBMQFMBTEJWFSTBTBUJWJEBEFTQSPEVUJWBTCFNDPNPQBSBBJOTUBMBÎÍP EF OPWBT IJESFMÏUSJDBT PCTFSWBOEPTF BT CBDJBT IJESPHSÈmDBT DPNP VOJEBEFT EF QMBOFKBNFOUPEPVTPEBDPOTFSWBÎÍPFEBSFDVQFSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTJJJ QSPNPWFS FPV FTUJNVMBS B SFDVQFSBÎÍP EBT ÈSFBT FN QSPDFTTP EF EFTFSUJmDBÎÍP JW EFTFOWPMWFS QSPHSBNBT EF FEVDBÎÍP BNCJFOUBM FN OÓWFM GPSNBM F JOGPSNBM EJSJHJEPT Ë QPQVMBÎÍP W GPNFOUBS B QSPEVÎÍP EF TFNFOUFT F NVEBT EF FTTÐO DJBTOBUJWBTFWJ DPPSEFOBSQSPHSBNBTEFFTUÓNVMPFJODFOUJWPËQSFTFSWBÎÍPEBT OBTDFOUFTEPTDVSTPTEÈHVBFEPNFJPBNCJFOUFCFNDPNPPBQSPWFJUBNFOUPEF EFKFUPTBOJNBJTQBSBDPOWFSTÍPFNGFSUJMJ[BOUFT %FBDPSEPDPNBSFGFSJEBMFJBQSFTUBÎÍPEFTFSWJÎPTFBBQMJDBÎÍPEFSFDVSTPT QÞCMJDPTFNBUJWJEBEFTBHSÓDPMBTEFWFNUFSQPSQSFNJTTBTCÈTJDBTPVTPUFDOJDBNFOUF BEFRVBEPPNBOFKPSBDJPOBMEPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFBQSFTFSWBÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUF &TUJQVMBPEFWFSEP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPFNUPEPPUFSSJUØSJPOBDJPOBMJEFOUJmDBS BTÈSFBTEFTFSUJmDBEBTDVKBFYQMPSBÎÍPTFFODPOUSBDPOEJDJPOBEBËBEPÎÍPEFBEF RVBEPQMBOPEFNBOFKPNFEJBOUFPFNQSFHPEFUFDOPMPHJBTDBQB[FTEFJOUFSSPNQFS PQSPDFTTPEFEFTFSUJmDBÎÍPFEFQSPNPWFSBTVBSFDVQFSBÎÍP. 0"SU"EB-FJEB1PMÓUJDB"HSÓDPMBJOUSPEV[JEPQFMB-FJO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 182 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen 0EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPBHSÓDPMBEPQBÓTBMJBEPËQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFF EPTSFDVSTPTOBUVSBJTFODPOUSBEFTUBRVFOB1PMÓUJDB"HSÓDPMBNFEJBOUFBJNQMFNFO UBÎÍPEFQSPHSBNBTQMVSJBOVBJTFQMBOPTPQFSBUJWPTBOVBJTFMBCPSBEPTQFMPTØSHÍPT DPNQFUFOUFTNBOUJEPTPVOÍPQFMP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPTPCBDPPSEFOBÎÍPEB6OJÍPFEPT EFNBJTFOUFTEBGFEFSBÎÍP +ÈP$BQÓUVMP7**EB-FJOUSBUBEBEFGFTBBHSPQFDVÈSJBDPOUFN QMBOEPFOUSFPTTFVTPCKFUJWPTBTBOJEBEFEBTQPQVMBÎÜFTWFHFUBJTBJEPOFJEBEF EPT JOTVNPT F EPT TFSWJÎPT VUJMJ[BEPT OB BHSPQFDVÈSJB BTTJN DPNP B JEFOUJEBEF F B TFHVSBOÎB IJHJÐOJDPTBOJUÈSJB F UFDOPMØHJDB EPT QSPEVUPT BHSPQFDVÈSJPT mOBJT EFTUJOBEPT BPT DPOTVNJEPSFT 1BSB UBOUP B MFJ JNQÜF BP 1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP P EFTFO WPMWJNFOUPFNDBSÈUFSQFSNBOFOUFEBTBUJWJEBEFTEFWJHJMÉODJBFEFGFTBTBOJUÈSJB WFHFUBMBJOTQFÎÍPFDMBTTJmDBÎÍPEFQSPEVUPTEFPSJHFNWFHFUBMTFVTEFSJWBEPT TVCQSPEVUPTFSFTÓEVPTEFWBMPSFDPOÙNJDPFBmTDBMJ[BÎÍPEPTJOTVNPTFEPTTFS WJÎPTVTBEPTOBTBUJWJEBEFTBHSPQFDVÈSJBT 5BJTBÎÜFTEFWJHJMÉODJBFEFGFTBTBOJUÈSJBEFWFNTFSFYFDVUBEBTQFMPTWÈ SJPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTEFGPSNBDPPSEFOBEBQPSNFJPEFVN4JTUFNB6OJmDBEPEF "UFOÎÍPË4BOJEBEF"HSPQFDVÈSJBBSUJDVMBEPDPNP4JTUFNBÁOJDPEF4BÞEFOP RVFGPSDBCÓWFMTFOEPPNVOJDÓQJPBÈSFBDPOTJEFSBEBDPNPVOJEBEFHFPHSÈmDB CÈTJDBOBPSHBOJ[BÎÍPFGVODJPOBNFOUPEPTTFSWJÎPTPmDJBJTEFTBOJEBEFBHSPQF DVÈSJB®JOTUÉODJBDFOUSBMFTVQFSJPSEPSFGFSJEPTJTUFNBDPNQFUFFOUSFPVUSBT BÎÜFTBmYBÎÍPEFOPSNBTSFGFSFOUFTBDBNQBOIBTEFDPOUSPMFFFSSBEJDBÎÍPEF QSBHBTFEPFOÎBTBBQSPWBÎÍPEPTNÏUPEPTEFEJBHOØTUJDPFEPTQSPEVUPTEFVTP WFUFSJOÈSJPFBHSPOÙNJDPBNBOVUFOÎÍPEPTJTUFNBEFJOGPSNBÎÜFTFQJEFNJPMØ HJDBTBBWBMJBÎÍPEBTBÎÜFTEFTFOWPMWJEBTOBTJOTUÉODJBTMPDBJTFJOUFSNFEJÈSJBT EP TJTUFNB VOJmDBEP EF BUFOÎÍP Ë TBOJEBEF BHSPQFDVÈSJB F B NBOVUFOÎÍP EP $ØEJHPEF%FGFTB"HSPQFDVÈSJB "JOTQFÎÍPJOEVTUSJBMFTBOJUÈSJBEFQSPEVUPTEFPSJHFNWFHFUBMFBOJNBMCFN DPNPBEPTJOTVNPTBHSPQFDVÈSJPTTFSÈHFSJEBEFNBOFJSBRVFPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTF BPSHBOJ[BÎÍPEBJOTQFÎÍPTFGBÎBQPSNÏUPEPTVOJWFSTBMJ[BEPTFBQMJDBEPTFRVJUBUJ WBNFOUFFNUPEPTPTFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPTJOTQFDJPOBEPTTFOEPBENJUJEBOBJOTQFÎÍPB BEPÎÍPEFNÏUPEPEFBOÈMJTFEFSJTDPTFQPOUPTDSÓUJDPTEFDPOUSPMF. 7FSJmDBTFBTTJNRVFBTBÎÜFTEFDPNBOEPFDPOUSPMFEPTFUPSBHSÓDPMBEF WFNTFSJNQMFNFOUBEBTOPÉNCJUPFFNDPOTPOÉODJBDPNBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTQSP HSBNBTFQSPKFUPTJOTFSJEPTOPQMBOFKBNFOUPEPTFUPS1BSBUBOUPPT[POFBNFOUPT BHSPFDPMØHJDPTEFRVFDVJEBP"SU***EB-FJODPOTUJUVFNJOTUSVNFOUP EPTNBJTSFMFWBOUFTBQPTTJCJMJUBSPEJTDJQMJOBNFOUPFPPSEFOBNFOUPEBPDVQBÎÍP FTQBDJBMQFMBTNBJTWBSJBEBTBUJWJEBEFTQSPEVUJWBT "SU"EB-FJO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 183 6.1. Zoneamento Agroambiental do setor sucroalcooleiro no Estado de São Paulo /P&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPBBUJWJEBEFDBOBWJFJSBPDVQBVNFTQBÎPEFFYUSFNB JNQPSUÉODJBQBSBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPDVKPDSFTDJNFOUPBDBSSFUBBOFDFTTJ EBEFEFVNQMBOFKBNFOUPFDPOUSPMFFTQFDÓmDPTQPSQBSUFEP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPEFNPEP RVFTFKBBTTFHVSBEBVNBFYQMPSBÎÍPBNCJFOUBMNFOUFTVTUFOUÈWFM 1BSBUBOUPDPNGVOEBNFOUPOBOFDFTTJEBEFEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEPTDSJUÏSJPT UÏDOJDPTQBSBBmYBÎÍPEFDPOEJDJPOBOUFTFFYJHÐODJBTEJGFSFODJBEBTOPQSPDFTTPEF MJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMGPJFEJUBEBB3FTPMVÎÍP$POKVOUB4."4""oEFEF TFUFNCSPEF QFMBT 4FDSFUBSJBT EP .FJP "NCJFOUF F EB "HSJDVMUVSB F "CBTUF DJNFOUPBMUFSBEBQPTUFSJPSNFOUFQFMB3FTPMVÎÍP4."4""oEFEFTFUFNCSP EFRVFJOTUJUVJP;POFBNFOUP"HSPBNCJFOUBMQBSBPTFUPSTVDSPBMDPPMFJSPOP &TUBEP F 4ÍP 1BVMP. %F BDPSEP DPN P [POFBNFOUP FN RVFTUÍP P &TUBEP EF 4ÍP 1BVMPGPJEJWJEJEPFNDJODP ÈSFBTMFWBOEPTFFNDPOUBBGSBHJMJEBEFBNCJFOUBMF BBQUJEÍPQBSBBQSPEVÎÍPw &N SB[ÍP EP [POFBNFOUP EB BUJWJEBEF DBOBWJFJSB OP &TUBEP GPJ FEJUBEB B 3FTPMVÎÍP4."OEFEFEF[FNCSPEFRVFFTUBCFMFDFBTEJSFUSJ[FTQBSB PMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMEFFNQSFFOEJNFOUPTEPTFUPSTVDSPBMDPPMFJSPTFHVOEPB RVBMPUJQPEF&TUVEP"NCJFOUBMBTFSBQSFTFOUBEPQBSBDPNQSPWBÎÍPEBWJBCJMJEBEF BNCJFOUBM EP FNQSFFOEJNFOUP F BT FYJHÐODJBT UÏDOJDBT SFTQFDUJWBT TFSÍP EFmOJEPT EFBDPSEPDPNBMPDBMJ[BÎÍPEBVOJEBEFJOEVTUSJBMOPi.BQB;POFBNFOUP"HSPBN CJFOUBMQBSBP4FUPS4VDSPBMDPPMFJSPEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPwDPOTUBOUFEPsite www. BNCJFOUFTQHPWCSFUBOPMWFSEFPCTFSWBEPBJOEBPEJTQPTUPOB3FTPMVÎÍP4." EFEFPVUVCSPEFRVFWFJPBTFSQPTUFSJPSNFOUFTVCTUJUVÓEBQFMB3FTPMVÎÍP 4."EFEFEF[FNCSPEF /PT UFSNPT EP NBQB BOFYP BP DJUBEP JOTUSVNFOUP RVF TF FODPOUSB EJTQPOÓWFM OP site IUUQXXX BNCJFOUFTQHPWCS[POFBNFOUPBHSPBNCJFOUBMDBOB i*o"EFRVBEBRVFDPSSFTQPOEFBPUFSSJUØSJPDPNBQUJEÍPFEBGPDMJNÈUJDBGBWPSÈWFMQBSBPEFTFOWPM WJNFOUP EB DVMUVSB EB DBOBEFBÎÞDBS F TFN SFTUSJÎÜFT BNCJFOUBJT FTQFDÓmDBT ** o "EFRVBEB DPN MJNJUBÎÜFTBNCJFOUBJTRVFDPSSFTQPOEFBPUFSSJUØSJPDPNBQUJEÍPFEBGPDMJNÈUJDBGBWPSÈWFMQBSBDVMUVSB EBDBOBEFBÎÞDBSFJODJEÐODJBEF«SFBTEF1SPUFÎÍP"NCJFOUBM"1" ÈSFBTEFNÏEJBQSJPSJEBEFQBSB JODSFNFOUPEBDPOFDUJWJEBEFDPOGPSNFJOEJDBÎÍPEP1SPKFUP#*05"'"1&41FBTCBDJBTIJESPHSÈmDBT DPOTJEFSBEBTDSÓUJDBT***o"EFRVBEBDPNSFTUSJÎÜFTBNCJFOUBJTRVFDPSSFTQPOEFBPUFSSJUØSJPDPN BQUJEÍPFEBGPDMJNÈUJDBGBWPSÈWFMQBSBBDVMUVSBEBDBOBEFBÎÞDBSFDPNJODJEÐODJBEF[POBTEFBNPS UFDJNFOUPEBT6OJEBEFTEF$POTFSWBÎÍPEF1SPUFÎÍP*OUFHSBM6$1*BTÈSFBTEFBMUBQSJPSJEBEFQBSB JODSFNFOUPEFDPOFDUJWJEBEFJOEJDBEBTQFMP1SPKFUP#*05"'"1&41FÈSFBTEFBMUBWVMOFSBCJMJEBEF EFÈHVBTTVCUFSSÉOFBTEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPDPOGPSNFQVCMJDBÎÍP*($&5&4#%"&&F*7 o*OBEFRVBEBRVFDPSSFTQPOEFËT6OJEBEFTEF$POTFSWBÎÍPEF1SPUFÎÍP*OUFHSBMo6$1*&TUBEVBJTF 'FEFSBJTBPTGSBHNFOUPTDMBTTJmDBEPTDPNPEFFYUSFNBJNQPSUÉODJBCJPMØHJDBQBSBDPOTFSWBÎÍPJO EJDBEPTQFMPQSPKFUP#*05"'"1&41QBSBBDSJBÎÍPEF6OJEBEFTEF$POTFSWBÎÍPEF1SPUFÎÍP*OUFHSBM o6$1*ËT;POBTEF7JEB4JMWFTUSFEBT«SFBTEF1SPUFÎÍP"NCJFOUBMo"1"TËTÈSFBTDPNSFTUSJÎÜFT FEBGPDMJNÈUJDBTQBSBDVMUVSBEBDBOBEFBÎÞDBSFËTÈSFBTDPNEFDMJWJEBEFTVQFSJPSBw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 184 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen 7. LEI Nº 12.651/2012: ZEE E A ALTERAÇÃO DO PERCENTUAL DE RESERVA LEGAL 0;&&DPNPSFMFWBOUFJOTUSVNFOUPEFQMBOFKBNFOUPWPMUBEPBPEFTFOWPM WJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFMFODPOUSBTFQSFWJTUPOB-FJOEFEFNBJPEF RVFDVJEBEBQSPUFÎÍPEBTnPSFTUBTFEFNBJTGPSNBTEFWFHFUBÎÍPOBUJWBEFNPEP RVFQPTTJCJMJUFBBMUFSBÎÍPEPTQFSDFOUVBJTEF3FTFSWB-FHBMBQMJDÈWFJTBEFUFSNJOBEBT SFHJÜFTEPQBÓT "TTJNP"SUEBMFJFTUBCFMFDFPQFSDFOUVBMNÓOJNPEF3FTFSWB-FHBMB TFSJOTUJUVÓEPFNDBEBJNØWFMSVSBMRVFDPOUVEPQPEFWJSBTFSBMUFSBEPQFMP1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP'FEFSBMOPTUFSNPTEPBSURVBOEPJOEJDBEPQFMP;&&/FTUBIJQØUFTF PQFSDFOUVBMEF3FTFSWB-FHBMEFJNØWFMSVSBMTJUVBEPFNÈSFBEFnPSFTUBMPDBMJ[BEB OB"NB[ÙOJB-FHBMQPEFSÈTFSSFEV[JEPEFQBSBFYDMVTJWBNFOUFQBSBmOT EFSFHVMBSJ[BÎÍPEPJNØWFMNFEJBOUFSFDPNQPTJÎÍPSFHFOFSBÎÍPPVDPNQFOTBÎÍPEB 3FTFSWB-FHBMEFJNØWFJTDPNÈSFBSVSBMDPOTPMJEBEB5BMSFHSBOÍPTFBQMJDBËTÈSFBT DPOTJEFSBEBTQSJPSJUÈSJBTQBSBDPOTFSWBÎÍPEBCJPEJWFSTJEBEFFEPTSFDVSTPTIÓESJDPT /PRVFDPODFSOFËBNQMJBÎÍPEB3FTFSWB-FHBMÏBENJUJEBQFMBMFJRVBOEP JOEJDBEPOP;&&PBVNFOUPEFBUÏEPTQFSDFOUVBJTQSFWJTUPTOP"SUQBSB DVNQSJNFOUPEBTNFUBTOBDJPOBJTEFQSPUFÎÍPEBCJPEJWFSTJEBEFPVEFSFEVÎÍPEF FNJTTÍPEFHBTFTEFFGFJUPFTUVGB1BSB1BVMP#FTTB"OUVOFTUBMBNQMJBÎÍPTFSJBJO DPOTUJUVDJPOBMVNBWF[RVFiBJOUFSWFOÎÍPOBQSPQSJFEBEFÏNBUÏSJBSFTFSWBEBËMFJw OÍPQPEFOEPTFSFGFUJWBEBQPSBUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPDBCFOEPOBIJQØUFTFEFTVB BQMJDBÎÍPBJOEFOJ[BÎÍPBPQSPQSJFUÈSJPSVSBM 8. ZONEAMENTO INDUSTRIAL "BUJWJEBEFJOEVTUSJBMËWJTUBEPTFVTJHOJmDBUJWPQPUFODJBMQPMVJEPSGPJVNB EBTQSJNFJSBTBTFSSFHSBEBEFGPSNBHMPCBMMFWBOEPTFFNDPOUBTFVTJNQBDUPTFN ÈSFBTFTQFDÓmDBT"TTJNP[POFBNFOUPEPTFUPSEBJOEÞTUSJBFNÈSFBTDSÓUJDBTEFQP MVJÎÍPGPJJOTUJUVÓEPQFMB-FJOEFEFKVMIPEFPVTFKBBOUFSJPSNFOUF ËJOTUJUVJÎÍPEBQSØQSJB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFOUFOPBOPEF "MFJFTUBCFMFDFRVFBJOTUBMBÎÍPEFJOEÞTUSJBTFNÈSFBTDSÓUJDBTEFQPMVJÎÍP OPTUFSOPTEPBSUEP%FDSFUPMFJOEFEFBHPTUPEFEFWFSÈPCF EFDFSËT[POBTEFmOJEBTFNFTRVFNBEF[POFBNFOUPVSCBOPBQSPWBEPQPSMFJRVF QPTTJCJMJUFBDPNQBUJCJMJ[BÎÍPEBTSFGFSJEBTBUJWJEBEFTDPNBQSPUFÎÍPEPNFJPBN CJFOUF5BJT[POBTTÍPDMBTTJmDBEBTFN[POBEFVTPFTUSJUBNFOUFJOEVTUSJBM[POBTEF $PNFOUÈSJPBPBSUEP$ØEJHP'MPSFTUBMOBPCSB/PWPDØEJHPnPSFTUBMDPNFOUÈSJPTË-FJO EFEFNBJPEFFË.FE1SPWEFEFNBJPEFDPPSEFOBÎÍP²EJT.JMBSÏ1BVMP "GGPOTP-FNF.BDIBEP4ÍP1BVMP35Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 185 VTPQSFEPNJOBOUFNFOUFJOEVTUSJBMF[POBTEFVTPEJWFSTJmDBEPRVFQPEFSÍPBJOEB TFS EJWJEJEBT FN TVCDBUFHPSJBT EFTEF RVF TFKBN PCTFSWBEBT BT QFDVMJBSJEBEFT EBT ÈSFBTDSÓUJDBTBRVFQFSUFOÎBNFBOBUVSF[BEBTJOEÞTUSJBTOFMBTJOTUBMBEBT /PTUFSNPTEBMFJJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBDBUFHPSJBBT[POBTEFVTPJOEVT USJBMTFSÍPDMBTTJmDBEBTFNOÍPTBUVSBEBTFNWJBEFTBUVSBÎÍPFTBUVSBEBTEFWFOEPP HSBVEFTBUVSBÎÍPTFSFTUBCFMFDJEPFNGVOÎÍPEBÈSFBEJTQPOÓWFMQBSBPVTPJOEVTUSJBM EBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBCFNDPNPEPTQBESÜFTFOPSNBTBNCJFOUBJTmYBEPTQFMP*OTUJUVUP #SBTJMFJSPEF.FJP"NCJFOUFF3FDVSTPT/BUVSBJT3FOPWÈWFJT*#"." BTTJNDPNP QFMPT&TUBEPTF.VOJDÓQJPTOPÉNCJUPEBTSFTQFDUJWBTDPNQFUÐODJBT ²DPOGFSJEBBPT&TUBEPTSFTTBMWBEBBDPNQFUÐODJBEB6OJÍPFVNBWF[PV WJEPTPTNVOJDÓQJPTJOUFSFTTBEPTBBUSJCVJÎÍPEFBQSPWBSQBESÜFTEFVTPFPDVQBÎÍP EPTPMPCFNDPNPEF[POBTEFSFTFSWBBNCJFOUBMOBTRVBJTQPSTVBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT DVMUVSBJTFDPMØHJDBTQBJTBHÓTUJDBTPVBJOEBQFMBOFDFTTJEBEFEFQSFTFSWBÎÍPEFNB OBODJBJTFQSFTFSWBÎÍPEFÈSFBTFTQFDJBJTWFEFBJNQMBOUBÎÍPEFJOEÞTUSJBT /PUPDBOUFBPMJDFODJBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMEFFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPTJOEVTUSJBJTFN ÈSFBTDSÓUJDBTEFQPMVJÎÍPDVKBDPNQFUÐODJBÏDPOGFSJEBBPT&TUBEPTPBSUEB-FJ O EFUFSNJOB RVF B TVB JOTUBMBÎÍP PQFSBÎÍP F BNQMJBÎÍP EFQFOEFSÈ EP BUFOEJNFOUPEFOPSNBTFQBESÜFTBNCJFOUBJTEFmOJEPTQFMP*#"."QFMPTØSHÍPT DPNQFUFOUFTEPT&TUBEPTFNVOJDÓQJPTOPUBEBNFOUFRVBOUPËTTFHVJOUFTDBSBDUFSÓT UJDBTEFQSPEVÎÍPJ FNJTTÍPEFHBTFTWBQPSFTSVÓEPTWJCSBÎÜFTFSBEJBÎÜFTJJ SJTDPTEFFYQMPTÍPJODÐOEJPTWB[BNFOUPTEBOPTPTFPVUSBTTJUVBÎÜFTEFFNFSHÐODJB JJJ WPMVNF F RVBMJEBEF EF JOTVNPT CÈTJDPT EF QFTTPBM F EF USÈGFHP HFSBEPT JW QBESÜFTEFVTPFPDVQBÎÍPEPTPMPW EJTQPOJCJMJEBEFOBTSFEFTEFFOFSHJBFMÏUSJDB ÈHVBFTHPUPDPNVOJDBÎÜFTFPVUSPTFWJ IPSÈSJPTEFBUJWJEBEF 1BVMP"GGPOTP-FNF.BDIBEPBmSNBRVF "EFmOJÎÍPEPTQBESÜFTEFFNJTTÍPQPSFYFNQMPNFSFDFTFSEFJYBEBBPT ØSHÍPTUÏDOJDPTNBTOÍPTFQPEFJNQFEJSRVFP-FHJTMBUJWPJOUFSWFOIB WBMJEBNFOUFOBmYBÎÍPEPTPCKFUJWPTEFRVBMJEBEFFEFmOJÎÍPEPTUJQPT EFFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPTJOEVTUSJBJTRVFQPEFSÍPTFSJNQMBOUBEPTFNDBEB VNB EBT [POBT JOEVTUSJBJT DPNP TF SFTFSWPV BPT HPWFSOPT FTUBEVBJT GB[FSBSU** $BCF EFTUBDBS RVF OP &TUBEP EF 4ÍP 1BVMP P HFSFODJBNFOUP F P DPOUSPMF EBTFNJTTÜFTBUNPTGÏSJDBTHBOIBNNBJPSFGFUJWJEBEFBQBSUJSEBFEJÎÍPEP%FDSFUP OBMUFSBEPQFMPT%FDSFUPTùOOFO "SUEB-FJ "SUEB-FJ %JSFJUP"NCJFOUBM#SBTJMFJSP4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 186 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen DPOIFDJEPTDPNPi%FDSFUPTEF#BDJBT"ÏSFBT4BUVSBEBTwRVFMFWBOEPFNDPOUBBT SFHJÜFT PV TVCSFHJÜFT FN WJB EF TBUVSBÎÍP DPOUFNQMBN EJTQPTJUJWPT EFTUJOBEPT Ë BEPÎÍPEFQSÈUJDBTQSFWFOUJWBTFDPSSFUJWBTQBSBRVFOÍPTFKBNVMUSBQBTTBEPTPTQB ESÜFTFTUBCFMFDJEPTEFRVBMJEBEFEPBS 9. ZONEAMENTO AMBIENTAL NO ESTATUTO DA CIDADE /BFYFDVÎÍPEB1PMÓUJDB6SCBOBQSFWJTUBQFMPTBSUJHPTFEB$POTUJUVJ ÎÍP'FEFSBMB-FJOFTUBCFMFDFOPSNBTEFPSEFNQÞCMJDBFJOUFSFTTFTPDJBM RVFSFHVMBNPVTPEBQSPQSJFEBEFVSCBOBFNQSPMEPCFNDPMFUJWPEBTFHVSBOÎBFEP CFNFTUBSEPTDJEBEÍPTCFNDPNPEPFRVJMÓCSJPBNCJFOUBM&TTBMFJFTUBCFMFDFEJSFUSJ[FT FJOTUSVNFOUPTQBSBBJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEB1PMÓUJDB6SCBOBPOEFTFJOTFSFP[POFBNFOUP BNCJFOUBMQSFWJTUPOPTFV"SU***DEBSFGFSJEBMFJRVFPCKFUJWBDPOUSPMBSBVUJMJ[BÎÍP EPTPMPFEFmOJSBTBUJWJEBEFTOFMFQFSNJUJEBTEFGPSNBRVFFOTFKFPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP JOUFHSBEPDPNBQSPUFÎÍPBNCJFOUBMPVTFKBPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPTVTUFOUÈWFM "TQSJODJQBJTEJSFUSJ[FTHFSBJTEP&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEFFTUÍPQSFWJTUBTOP"SU EB-FJOFOUSFBTRVBJTTFEFTUBDBNBHBSBOUJBEPEJSFJUPBDJEBEFT TVTUFOUÈWFJT FOUFOEJEB DPNP P EJSFJUP Ë UFSSB VSCBOB Ë NPSBEJB BP TBOFBNFOUP BNCJFOUBMËJOGSBFTUSVUVSBVSCBOBBPUSBOTQPSUFFBPTTFSWJÎPTQÞCMJDPTBPUSBCBMIP FBPMB[FSQBSBBTQSFTFOUFTFGVUVSBTHFSBÎÜFTPQMBOFKBNFOUPEPEFTFOWPMWJNFOUP EBTDJEBEFTEBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPFTQBDJBMEBQPQVMBÎÍPFEBTBUJWJEBEFTFDPOÙNJDBTEP NVOJDÓQJPFEPUFSSJUØSJPTPCTVBÈSFBEFJOnVÐODJBEFNPEPRVFFWJUFFDPSSJKBBT EJTUPSÎÜFT EP DSFTDJNFOUP VSCBOP F TFVT FGFJUPT OFHBUJWPT TPCSF P NFJP BNCJFOUF FBPSEFOBÎÍPFDPOUSPMFEPVTPEPTPMPEFGPSNBRVFFWJUFBVUJMJ[BÎÍPJOBEFRVB EBEPTJNØWFJTVSCBOPTBQSPYJNJEBEFEFVTPTJODPNQBUÓWFJTPVJODPOWFOJFOUFTP QBSDFMBNFOUPEPTPMPBFEJmDBÎÍPPVPVTPFYDFTTJWPPVJOBEFRVBEPFNSFMBÎÍPË JOGSBFTUSVUVSBVSCBOBBJOTUBMBÎÍPEFFNQSFFOEJNFOUPTPVBUJWJEBEFTRVFQPTTBN GVODJPOBSDPNPQPMPTHFSBEPSFTEFUSÈGFHPTFNBQSFWJTÍPEBJOGSBFTUSVUVSBDPSSFT QPOEFOUFBSFUFOÎÍPFTQFDVMBUJWBEFJNØWFMVSCBOPRVFSFTVMUFOBTVBTVCVUJMJ[BÎÍP PVOÍPVUJMJ[BÎÍPBEFUFSJPSBÎÍPEBTÈSFBTVSCBOJ[BEBTBQPMVJÎÍPFBEFHSBEBÎÍP BNCJFOUBM B FYQPTJÎÍP EB QPQVMBÎÍP B SJTDPT EF EFTBTUSFT "MÏN EFTTBT NFSFDFN TFSNFODJPOBEBTBKVTUBEJTUSJCVJÎÍPEPTCFOFGÓDJPTFÙOVTEFDPSSFOUFTEPQSPDFTTP EFVSCBOJ[BÎÍPBQSPUFÎÍPQSFTFSWBÎÍPFSFDVQFSBÎÍPEPNFJPBNCJFOUFOBUVSBMF DPOTUSVÓEPEPQBUSJNÙOJPDVMUVSBMIJTUØSJDPBSUÓTUJDPQBJTBHÓTUJDPFBSRVFPMØHJDP BEPÎÍPEFQBESÜFTEFQSPEVÎÍPFDPOTVNPEFCFOTFTFSWJÎPTFEFFYQBOTÍPVSCBOB DPNQBUÓWFJT DPN PT MJNJUFT EB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBEF BNCJFOUBM TPDJBM F FDPOÙNJDB EP NVOJDÓQJPFEPUFSSJUØSJPTPCTVBÈSFBEFJOnVÐODJBFBSFHVMBSJ[BÎÍPGVOEJÈSJBFVSCB OJ[BÎÍPEFÈSFBTPDVQBEBTQPSQPQVMBÎÍPEFCBJYBSFOEBNFEJBOUFPFTUBCFMFDJNFOUP EFOPSNBTFTQFDJBJTEFVSCBOJ[BÎÍPVTPFPDVQBÎÍPEPTPMPFFEJmDBÎÍPDPOTJEFSB EBTBTJUVBÎÍPTPDJPFDPOÙNJDBEBQPQVMBÎÍPFBTOPSNBTBNCJFOUBJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 187 $VNQSF PCTFSWBS RVF B $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM JNQÙT B PCSJHBUPSJFEBEF EF BQSPWBÎÍPEFQMBOPEJSFUPSPJOTUSVNFOUPCÈTJDPEBQPMÓUJDBEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFEF FYQBOTÍPVSCBOBBQFOBTQBSBBTDJEBEFTDPNNBJTEFIBCJUBOUFT"SU f 0&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEFBNQMJPVFTTBPCSJHBUPSJFEBEFQBSBBTDJEBEFTJOUFHSBOUFT EFSFHJÜFTNFUSPQPMJUBOBTFBHMPNFSBÎÜFTVSCBOBTPOEFP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPNVOJDJQBM QSFUFOEBVUJMJ[BSPTJOTUSVNFOUPTQSFWJTUPTOPfEP"SUEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'F EFSBMFmOBMNFOUFBTJOUFHSBOUFTEFÈSFBTEFFTQFDJBMJOUFSFTTFUVSÓTUJDP /FTTBNPMEVSBBJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEBTEJSFUSJ[FTQSFWJTUBTOP&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEF UFNTFSFMFWBEPQBSBEJ[FSPNÓOJNPCBTUBOUFQSPCMFNÈUJDBFJOFmDJFOUF"FYQFSJÐODJB EBTHSBOEFTNFUSØQPMFT4ÍP1BVMPF3JPEF+BOFJSP ÏBBOUÓUFTFEBTEJSFUSJ[FT"NPEJmDB ÎÍPEFTTFRVBESPEFNBOEBFOPSNFJOWFTUJNFOUPQBSBBSFDVQFSBÎÍPEFÈSFBTEFHSBEBEBT PFYFNQMPQSØYJNPÏBSFHJÍPDFOUSBMEF4ÍP1BVMP SBEJDBMNPEJmDBÎÍPEPTIÈCJUPT EFDPOTVNPDGPTFGFJUPTEBEFTPOFSBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBTPCSFPBVNFOUPEBGSPUBEFWFÓDV MPTOPTHSBOEFTDFOUSPT BSFHVMBSJ[BÎÍPGVOEJÈSJBFVSCBOJ[BÎÍPEFÈSFBTPDVQBEBTQPS QPQVMBÎÍPEFCBJYBSFOEBRVFTFSFWFMBBUSFMBEBËRVFTUÍPEBQSPUFÎÍPEBTQPQVMBÎÜFT FYQPTUBTBSJTDPTEFEFTBTUSFTDGEFTMJ[BNFOUPTJOVOEBÎÜFTFJODÐOEJPTFNGBWFMBT 5PNBOEPDPNPFYFNQMPBDJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMPDPOTUBUBNPTRVFFNCPSBB-FJO EFEFTFUFNCSPEFUFOIBJOTUJUVÓEPP1MBOP%JSFUPS&TUSBUÏHJDPFP4JTUFNB EF1MBOFKBNFOUPF(FTUÍPEP%FTFOWPMWJNFOUP6SCBOPEP.VOJDÓQJPEF4ÍP1BVMPFB-FJ OEFEFBHPTUPEFUFOIBFTUBCFMFDJEPOPSNBTDPNQMFNFOUBSFTBP1MBOP %JSFUPS&TUSBUÏHJDPJOTUJUVJOEPPT1MBOPT3FHJPOBJT&TUSBUÏHJDPTEBT4VCQSFGFJUVSBTEJTQPO EPUBNCÏNTPCSFPQBSDFMBNFOUPFEJTDJQMJOBOEPFPSEFOBOEPP6TPF0DVQBÎÍPEP4PMP EP.VOJDÓQJPEF4ÍP1BVMPJTTPQPSTJTØOÍPUSBOTGPSNPVBSFBMJEBEF ²WFSEBEFRVFPTJOTUSVNFOUPTQSFWJTUPTQFMPBSUJHPEP&TUBUVUPEB$J EBEF FOUSFPTRVBJTP[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMÏFYQSFTTBNFOUFQSFWJTUPOPJODJTP y FYJHJSOPTUFSNPTEBMFJGFEFSBMEPQSPQSJFUÈSJPEPTPMPVSCBOPOÍPFEJmDBEPTVCVUJMJ[BEPPV OÍPVUJMJ[BEPRVFQSPNPWBTFVBEFRVBEPBQSPWFJUBNFOUPTPCQFOBTVDFTTJWBNFOUFEF*QBSDFMB NFOUPPVFEJmDBÎÍPDPNQVMTØSJPT**JNQPTUPTPCSFBQSPQSJFEBEFQSFEJBMFUFSSJUPSJBMVSCBOBQSP HSFTTJWPOPUFNQP***EFTBQSPQSJBÎÍPDPNQBHBNFOUPNFEJBOUFUÓUVMPTEBEÓWJEBQÞCMJDBEFFNJTTÍP QSFWJBNFOUFBQSPWBEBQFMP4FOBEP'FEFSBMDPNQSB[PEFSFTHBUFEFBUÏEF[BOPTFNQBSDFMBTBOVBJT JHVBJTFTVDFTTJWBTBTTFHVSBEPTPWBMPSSFBMEBJOEFOJ[BÎÍPFPTKVSPTMFHBJTy w/PQMBOPJOGSBDPOT UJUVDJPOBMPTSFGFSJEPTJOTUJUVUPTFTUÍPSFHVMBEPTQFMP&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEF"SUTB "SU1BSBPTmOTEFTUBMFJTFSÍPVUJMJ[BEPTFOUSFPVUSPTJOTUSVNFOUPT*oQMBOPTOBDJPOBJTSFHJPOBJTF FTUBEVBJTEFPSEFOBÎÍPEPUFSSJUØSJPFEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPFTPDJBM**oQMBOFKBNFOUPEBTSFHJÜFT NFUSPQPMJUBOBTBHMPNFSBÎÜFTVSCBOBTFNJDSPSSFHJÜFTF***oQMBOFKBNFOUPNVOJDJQBMFNFTQFDJBMB QMBOP EJSFUPSC EJTDJQMJOBEPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPVTPFEBPDVQBÎÍPEPTPMPc) zoneamento ambiental; E QMBOP QMVSJBOVBMF EJSFUSJ[FTPSÎBNFOUÈSJBTFPSÎBNFOUPBOVBMG HFTUÍPPSÎBNFOUÈSJBQBSUJDJQBUJWBH QMBOPTQSP HSBNBTFQSPKFUPTTFUPSJBJTFI QMBOPTEFEFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPFTPDJBM*7oJOTUJUVUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTF mOBODFJSPTB JNQPTUPTPCSFBQSPQSJFEBEFQSFEJBMFUFSSJUPSJBMVSCBOBo*156C DPOUSJCVJÎÍPEFNFMIPSJBF D JODFOUJWPTFCFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJTFmOBODFJSPT7oJOTUJUVUPTKVSÓEJDPTFQPMÓUJDPTB EFTBQSPQSJBÎÍPC TFSWJEÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWBD MJNJUBÎÜFTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTE UPNCBNFOUPEFJNØWFJTPVEFNPCJMJÈSJPVSCBOPF JOTUJUVJÎÍP EFVOJEBEFTEFDPOTFSWBÎÍPG JOTUJUVJÎÍPEF[POBTFTQFDJBJTEFJOUFSFTTFTPDJBMH DPODFTTÍPEFEJSFJUPSFBMEF VTPI DPODFTTÍPEFVTPFTQFDJBMQBSBmOTEFNPSBEJBJ QBSDFMBNFOUPFEJmDBÎÍPPVVUJMJ[BÎÍPDPNQVMTØSJPT K VTVDBQJÍPFTQFDJBMEFJNØWFMVSCBOPM EJSFJUPEFTVQFSGÓDJFN EJSFJUPEFQSFFNQÎÍPO PVUPSHBPOFSPTB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 188 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen ***MFUSBiDwEFTTFBSUJHP CVTDBNDSJBSDPOEJÎÜFTQBSBBJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEFVNB QPMÓUJDB VSCBOB TBUJTGBUØSJB DSJBOEP DJEBEFT TVTUFOUÈWFJT P RVF OP FOUBOUP OÍP UFNTFNPTUSBEPTVmDJFOUF "SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFQFMPJOTVDFTTPQPSPCWJPOÍPQPEFTFSBUSJCVÓEBBP[P OFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMRVFTFNEÞWJEBTFDBSBDUFSJ[BDPNPVNBGFSSBNFOUBFTTFODJBMOB JNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEF1PMÓUJDBT1ÞCMJDBTNBTOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFEFQFOEFEFDPOKVHBÎÍPDPN PTEFNBJTJOTUSVNFOUPTQSFWJTUPTQFMP"SUQBSBRVFUFOIBNPTDJEBEFTTVTUFOUÈWFJT “Por cidades sustentáveis pode-se entender aquelas em que o desenvolvimento urbano ocorre com ordenação, sem caos e destruição, sem degradação, possibilitando uma vida urbana digna para todos.”25&TTFPCKFUJWPFTUÈMPOHFEFTFSBMDBOÎBEPFNDJEBEFTEPQPSUF EBTRVFDPNQÜFNBTSFHJÜFTNFUSPQPMJUBOBTEF4ÍP1BVMPF3JPEF+BOFJSP 5PEBWJBOÍPÏEFNBJTSFTTBMUBSRVFIÈJOTUSVNFOUPTQBSBCVTDBSFTTFPCKF UJWPTFOEPP[POFBNFOUPVNBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPDPODSFUBEPQMBOFKBNFOUPOÍPTFOEP QPTTÓWFMUSBOTGPSNBSBSFBMJEBEFQPSNFJPEPPSEFOBNFOUPEPVTPEPTSFDVSTPTOBUV SBJTTFNBOUFTQFOTBSRVFSFBMJEBEFTFQSFUFOEFTFKBSFTVMUBOUFEBTJOUFSWFOÎÜFTEP IPNFNOPNFJPBNCJFOUF 10. CONCLUSÃO 0[POFBNFOUPBNCJFOUBMJOTUSVNFOUPEB1PMÓUJDB/BDJPOBMEP.FJP"NCJFO UFDPOTJTUFFNQSPDFEJNFOUPEFEJWJTÍPEFEFUFSNJOBEPUFSSJUØSJPFNÈSFBTPOEFiTF BVUPSJ[BN EFUFSNJOBEBT BUJWJEBEFT PV TF JOUFSEJUB EF NPEP BCTPMVUP PV SFMBUJWP P FYFSDÓDJPEFPVUSBTwFNSB[ÍPEBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTBNCJFOUBJTTPDJPFDPOÙNJDBTEPMPDBM /FTTFEJBQBTÍPOÍPIÈDPNPEFJYBSEFSFDPOIFDFSRVFP;&&TFDBSBDUFSJ[B DPNPVNBGFSSBNFOUBFTTFODJBMOBFMBCPSBÎÍPFJNQMFNFOUBÎÍPEF1PMÓUJDBT1ÞCMJDBT OFDFTTBSJBNFOUFJNCSJDBEBTDPNEFNBJTJOTUSVNFOUPTEB1/."FOUSFPTRVBJTTF EFTUBDBPMJDFODJBNFOUPEFGPSNBRVFQFSNJUBPDPSSFUPPSEFOBNFOUPUFSSJUPSJBMCSB TJMFJSPDPNPCTFSWÉODJBEFBTQFDUPTEFPSEFNFDPOÙNJDBTPDJBMFBNCJFOUBM EPEJSFJUPEFDPOTUSVJSFEFBMUFSBÎÍPEFVTPP USBOTGFSÐODJBEPEJSFJUPEFDPOTUSVJSQ PQFSBÎÜFTVSCBOBT DPOTPSDJBEBTR SFHVMBSJ[BÎÍPGVOEJÈSJBS BTTJTUÐODJBUÏDOJDBFKVSÓEJDBHSBUVJUBQBSBBTDPNVOJEBEFTFHSVQPT TPDJBJTNFOPTGBWPSFDJEPTT SFGFSFOEPQPQVMBSFQMFCJTDJUPU EFNBSDBÎÍPVSCBOÓTUJDBQBSBmOTEFSFHVMBSJ[B ÎÍPGVOEJÈSJB*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF FV MFHJUJNBÎÍPEFQPTTF*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJO EF 7*oFTUVEPQSÏWJPEFJNQBDUPBNCJFOUBM&*" FFTUVEPQSÏWJPEFJNQBDUPEFWJ[JOIBOÎB&*7 f 0TJOTUSVNFOUPTNFODJPOBEPTOFTUFBSUJHPSFHFNTFQFMBMFHJTMBÎÍPRVFMIFTÏQSØQSJBPCTFSWBEPPEJTQPTUP OFTUB-FJf/PTDBTPTEFQSPHSBNBTFQSPKFUPTIBCJUBDJPOBJTEFJOUFSFTTFTPDJBMEFTFOWPMWJEPTQPSØSHÍPT PVFOUJEBEFTEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBDPNBUVBÎÍPFTQFDÓmDBOFTTBÈSFBBDPODFTTÍPEFEJSFJUPSFBMEFVTP EFJNØWFJTQÞCMJDPTQPEFSÈTFSDPOUSBUBEBDPMFUJWBNFOUFf0TJOTUSVNFOUPTQSFWJTUPTOFTUFBSUJHPRVF EFNBOEBNEJTQÐOEJPEFSFDVSTPTQPSQBSUFEPQPEFSQÞCMJDPNVOJDJQBMEFWFNTFSPCKFUPEFDPOUSPMFTPDJBM HBSBOUJEBBQBSUJDJQBÎÍPEFDPNVOJEBEFTNPWJNFOUPTFFOUJEBEFTEBTPDJFEBEFDJWJM .&%"6"30EFUF&TUBUVUPEB$JEBEF35Q ."$)"%01BVMP"GGPOTP-FNF%JSFJUPBNCJFOUBMCSBTJMFJSP4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 Zoneamento ecológico-econômico como instrumento essencial da política nacional 189 $PNPKÈPCTFSWBEPQPS)FSNBO#FOKBNJO i0#SBTJMBmSNBTFUFNIPKFVNEPTNBJTBWBOÎBEPTTJTUFNBTEFQSPUFÎÍP KVSÓEJDBEPNFJPBNCJFOUF1SJPSJUÈSJPQBSBPGVUVSPFQBSBPQSFTFOUF KÈ OÍPÏOPFTTFODJBMMFHJTMBS+ÈPm[FNPT0RVFTFFTQFSBBHPSBEPTØSHÍPT BNCJFOUBJT F EPT DJEBEÍPT PSHBOJ[BEPT PV OÍP Ï P DVNQSJNFOUP EBT FYJHÐODJBTMFHBJTRVFDPNGSFRVÐODJBOBEBNBJTTÍPEPRVFMFUSBNPSUBw BIBLIOGRAFIA "/56/&41BVMPEF#FTTB$PNFOUÈSJPBPBSUEP$ØEJHP'MPSFTUBMOBPCSB“Novo código florestal: comentários à Lei nº 12.651, de 25 de maio de 2012 e à MedProv 571, de 25 de maio de 2012”DPPSEFOBÎÍP²EJT.JMBSÏ1BVMP"GGPOTP-FNF.BDIBEP 4ÍP1BVMP35 "55"/"4*0+ÞOJPS.BSJP3PCFSUPF"55"/"4*0(BCSJFMB.VMMFS$BSJPCB“O Dever de Elaboração e Implementação do Zoneamento Ecológico-Econômico e a efetividade do Licenciamento Ambiental.”"SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMO nT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VM4FU #&/+".*/ "OUÙOJP )FSNBO “Introdução ao Direito Ambiental Brasileiro”. "SUJHP QVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VM 4FU %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBiDireito Administrativow4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT '"3*"45BMEFO“A Repartição de Competências para o Licenciamento Ambiental e a Autuação dos Municípios”. "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT &E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VM4FU '*(6&*3&%0(VJMIFSNF+PTÏ1VSWJO“Curso de Direito Ambiental”. 4ÍP1BVMP35 '*(6&*3&%0 -ÞDJB 7BMMF “Discriminação Constitucional das Competências Ambientais. Aspectos pontuais do regime jurídico das licenças ambientais.” "SUJHPQV CMJDBEP OB 3FWJTUB EF %JSFJUP "NCJFOUBM nT &E 3FWJTUB EPT 5SJCVOBJT +VM 4FU '*03*--0$FMTP"OUPOJP1BDIFDPi$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBM#SBTJMFJSPw4ÍP1BVMP 4BSBJWB (6&33"4ÏSHJP“A competência dos entes federados em matéria ambiental”. "SUJHP QVCMJDBEP OB 3FWJTUB EF %JSFJUP "NCJFOUBM nT &E 3FWJTUB EPT 5SJCVOBJT "CS+VO #&/+".*/"OUÙOJP)FSNBOi*OUSPEVÎÍPBP%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBM#SBTJMFJSPw. "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3F WJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VMTFUQÈH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 190 Sílvia Helena Nogueira Nascimento & Thaís Teizen (6*."3°&4+ÞOJPS+PÍP-PQFT“Direito urbanístico, direito de vizinhança e defesa do Meio Ambiente”. "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT &E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VMTFU ."$)"%01BVMP"GGPOTP-FNF“Direito ambiental brasileiro”4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT .*-"3²²EJT“Direito do ambiente: a gestão ambiental em foco: doutrina, jurisprudência, glossário.”4ÍP1BVMP35 .03"&43BJNVOEPEF+FTVT$PFMIPEF“Judicialização do licenciamento ambiental no Brasil: Excesso ou garantia de participação?” "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP "NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT"CS+VO 1&3&*3"3FHJOBMEPF8*/$,-&34JMWB5FSF[JOIBiInstrumentos de tutela administrativa do Meio Ambiente.w"SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT &E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VM4FU 1'&*''&33PCFSUP"VHVTUP$BTUFMMBOPT“A publiciade e o Direito de Acesso a informação no licenciamento ambiental.” "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBM nT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT0VU%F[ 13&45&47BOÐTDB#V[FMBUP“Resgatando a competência Constitucional concorrente na Constituição Federal: uma crítica à interpretação do STF no caso do amianto.” "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB 3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT"CS+VO 13&45&47BOÐTDB#V[FMBUP“A necessidade de compatibiização das licenças ambiental e urbanística no processo de municipalização do licenciamento ambiental.” "SUJHPQVCMJ DBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+VM4FU 3³(0 1BUSÓDJB EF "NPSJN F 1&3&*3" .ÈSDJB 3FHJOB EF 4PVTB “ A efetividade do Direito Ambiental brasileiro: instrumentos legais de proteção do meio ambiente.w "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCV OBJT+BO.BSÎP 4"/$)&;-VÓT&OSJRVF“Os papéis da avaliação de impacto ambiental”. "SUJHPQV CMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT&E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT 4*-7"'JMIP%FSMZ#BSSFUPF“A processualidade das licenças ambientais como garantia dos administrados”. "SUJHPQVCMJDBEPOB3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP"NCJFOUBMnT &E3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT+BO.BSÎP 4*-7"+PTÏ"GPOTPEBiDireito Ambiental Constitucional”4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT SITES CONSULTADOS IUUQNEGTFDSFMDPNCSENEPDVNFOUTTJEOFZQEG 4JEOFZ(VFSSB$PNQFUÐODJBBNCJFOUBMËMV[EB-FJ$PNQMFNFOUBSO IUUQXXXDBSUBGPSFOTFDPNCSDPOUFVEPBSUJHPTDPPQFSBDBPGFEFSBUJWBBNCJFOUBMJOP WBDPFTEBMFJDPNQMFNFOUBS 5IJBHP .BSSBSB $PPQFSBÎÍP GFEFSBUJWB BNCJFOUBMJOPWBÎÜFTEB-FJ$PNQMFNFOUBS $BSUB'PSFOTF IUUQXXXSFWJTUBEPVUSJOBUSGKVTCSBSUJHPTFEJDBPBOESF@HPEPZIUNM PVUo"OESÏ(PEPZZoneamento FDPMØHJDPFDPOÙNJDPFlicenciamento ambientalVNBBMJBOÎBOFDFTTÈSJB XXXJCBQPSHDCBQUFTFTNBSDFMPDBNBSHPT@UFTFEPD RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 165 a 190 MORATÓRIA JUDICIAL: INTERPRETAÇÃO DA INOVAÇÃO DO ARTIGO 745-A DO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL Judicial “Moratorium”: Interpretation of the new article 745-A of the Code of Civil Procedure Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga1 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP.PSBUØSJBEPBSU"EP$1$$SJBÎÍPEP*OTUJUVUP/B UVSF[BKVSÓEJDB%JSFJUPNBUFSJBM%JSFJUPQSPDFTTVBM4JTUFNÈUJDBEPBSU "EP$1$1SB[PQBSBPSFRVFSJNFOUPEPFYFDVUBEP0SFDPOIFDJNFOUPEP DSÏEJUPEFWJEPFPEFQØTJUPQSÏWJPEF)POPSÈSJPTF$VTUBT1BSDFMBNFOUP *OBEJNQMFNFOUP1POUPTDPOUSPWFSUJEPTEBNPSBUØSJBEPBSU"EP$1$ %JSFJUP4VCKFUJWPEPBVUPS 1SJODÓQJPEB.FOPS0OFSPTJEBEF91SJODÓQJP$POTUJUV DJPOBMEP$POUSBEJUØSJP1PTJÎÍPEPDSFEPSEJBOUFEB.PSBUØSJBJOTUJUVÓEBQFMB-FJO 'BDVMEBEFEP.BHJTUSBEP "QMJDBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPOBGBTFEFDVNQSJ NFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB%FGFTBEPFYFDVUBEPEJBOUFEB.PSBUØSJBEPBSU"EP$1$ 3FDPOIFDJNFOUPKVSÓEJDPEPQFEJEP*OEFGFSJNFOUPFPNBOFKPEPTFNCBSHPTË FYFDVÎÍP.PSBUØSJBOPOPWPQSPKFUPEP$1$4VHFTUÍPEFlege ferenda$POTJEF SBÎÜFTmOBJT3FGFSÐODJBT#JCMJPHSÈmDBT RESUMO 0QSFTFOUFFTUVEPUFNBmOBMJEBEFEFUSBÎBSDPOUPSOPTTPCSFBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEPOPWFM JOTUJUVUPEB.PSBUØSJBQSFWJTUPOP"SU"IJQØUFTFEFQBSDFMBNFOUPEPWBMPSBTFS FYFDVUBEPJOUSPEV[JEPOP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMQFMB-FJOJOTQJSBEB OB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMODPNWJTUBBEBSNBJTDFMFSJEBEFËQSFTUBÎÍPEB UVUFMBKVSJTEJDJPOBMFYFDVUJWB ABSTRACT 5IFQVSQPTFPGUIJTQSFTFOUTUVEZJTUPUBDLMFJNQPSUBOUBTQFDUTBCPVUBQQMJDBCJMJUZ PGUIFOFXJOTUJUVUFPGUIFi.PSBUPSJVNwBTTUBUFEJOUIFBSUJDMF"UZQFPGBO JOTUBMMNFOUPGUIFBNPVOUVOEFSFYFDVUJPOUIBUXBTJOUSPEVDFEJOUIF$PEFPG$JWJM 1SPDFEVSFVOEFSUIF-BXOJOTQJSFEJOUIF$POTUJUVUJPOBM"NFOENFOU OUPHJWJOHDFMFSJUZUPFYFDVUJPOKVSJTEJDUJPOBMQSPUFDUJPO Palavras-chaves &YFDVÎÍP FYUSBKVEJDJBM o .PSBUØSJB o 1BSDFMBNFOUP EP EÏCJUP o "QMJDBCJMJEBEF Keywords&YUSBKVEJDJBM&YFDVUJPOo.PSBUPSJVNo%FCU*OTUBMMNFOUo"QQMJDBCJMJUZ 1. INTRODUÇÃO $PNPBEWFOUPEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMORVFJOTUJUVJVBQSF NJTTBEBduração razoável do processoEFTFODBEFPVTFVNBTÏSJFEFSFGPSNBTOP$Ø EJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM WJTBOEP B EBS NBJT BHJMJEBEF F FGFUJWJEBEF OB QSFTUBÎÍP EB &TQFDJBMJTUBFN%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM$JWJMQFMB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP 1BVMP&TQFDJBMJTUBFN%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPQFMB"/"."(&4.(o"TTPDJBÎÍPEPT.BHJTUSBEPT&TUBEVBJT EP&TUBEPEF.JOBT(FSBJT5ÏDOJDP+VEJDJÈSJPOP5SJCVOBM3FHJPOBMEP5SBCBMIPo3FHJÍP 192 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga UVUFMBKVSJTEJDJPOBM/PUBEBNFOUFOPQSPDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPIPVWFBFEJÎÍPEB-FJO RVFUSBOTGPSNPVPQSPDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPEFUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMFNGBTFEF DVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBCFNDPNPPBEWFOUPEB-FJORVFEFOUSF PVUSPTJOTUSVNFOUPTJOUSPEV[JVP"SU"OP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMDSJBOEPP JOTUJUVUPEFOPNJOBEPOBEPVUSJOBEFNPSBUØSJBKVEJDJBM &TTB mHVSB KVSÓEJDB RVF Ï B BCPSEBHFN EP QSFTFOUF USBCBMIP QSFWÐ VNB FTQÏDJFEFQBSDFMBNFOUPFNRVFPFYFDVUBEPVNBWF[QSFFODIJEPTPTQSFTTVQPTUPT FYJHJEPTOPEJTQPTJUJWPMFHBMSFDPOIFDFPDSÏEJUPEFWJEPQVHOBOEPQFMPQBHBNFOUP QBSDFMBEPFNBUÏTFJTWF[FTBQØTEFQPTJUBSPNPOUBOUFEFUSJOUBQPSDFOUP EP WBMPSFYFRVFOEPBMÏNEFDVTUBTJOJDJBJTFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPT /PFOUBOUPQPSIBWFSPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPEÏCJUPDPNWFEBÎÍPFYQSFTTB EFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEFEFGFTBQPSQBSUFEPFYFDVUBEPTVBJODJEÐODJBÏCBTUBOUFDPOUSP WFSTBOBEPVUSJOB%FGBUPQPSTFUSBUBSEFJOTUJUVUPOPWPPRVBMJOEVCJUBWFMNFOUF USPVYFVNBSPVQBHFNQFDVMJBSËTFYFDVÎÜFTEFUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBJTJNQSFTDJOEÓWFM VNFTUVEPNBJTBQSPGVOEBEPTPCSFPUFNBEFMJOFBOEPTFVTDPOUPSOPTFBTTJNDPO USJCVJSQBSBBTVBDPSSFUBBQMJDBCJMJEBEF 2. MORATÓRIA DO ARTIGO 745-A DO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL 2.1. Criação do Instituto ²DFEJÎPRVFPTJTUFNBQSPDFTTVBMDJWJMCSBTJMFJSPWFNQBTTBOEPQPSNVEBO ÎBTTJHOJmDBUJWBTDPNPQSPQØTJUPEFWJBCJMJ[BSVNJOTUSVNFOUPDBQB[EFHBSBOUJS ËTQBSUFTBPCUFOÎÍPPVQSPUFÎÍPFGFUJWBEFTFVTEJSFJUPTDFSUPRVFPT1SJODÓQJPTEB *OTUSVNFOUBMJEBEF&GFUJWJEBEFF$FMFSJEBEFQSPDFTTVBMPTRVBJTTFNQSFOPSUFBSBN PMFHJTMBEPSBUVBMNFOUFHBOIBSBNVNSFMFWPNBJPSEFNPEPRVFDPNCBUBBNP SPTJEBEFQSPDFTTVBMFOPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPCVTRVFNBJTSBQJEBNFOUFBTBUJTGBÎÍP EPDSÏEJUPFYFRVFOEP /FTTBQSFNJTTBBTBMUFSBÎÜFTUSB[JEBTQFMB-FJOBPQSPDFTTPEF FYFDVÎÍPFNWJHPSEFTEFEFKBOFJSPEFQSFUFOEFSBNEBSNBJTBHJMJEBEFBP GFJUPFYFDVUJWPBPJOUSPEV[JSNFDBOJTNPTBMUFSOBUJWPTQBSBDPODSFUJ[BÎÍPEPEJSFJUP NBUFSJBMKÈBTTFHVSBEPFOUSFFMFTBDSJBÎÍPEBNPSBUØSJBQSFWJTUBOPBSU"EP $1$DPNBTFHVJOUFSFEBÎÍP "SU " /P QSB[P QBSB FNCBSHPT SFDPOIFDFOEP P DSÏEJUP EP FYFRVFOUF F DPNQSPWBOEP P EFQØTJUP EF USJOUB QPS DFOUP EP WBMPSFNFYFDVÎÍPJODMVTJWFDVTUBTFIPOPSÈSJPTEFBEWPHBEPQPEFSÈ PFYFDVUBEPSFRVFSFSTFKBBENJUJEPBQBHBSPSFTUBOUFFNBUÏTFJT QBSDFMBTNFOTBJTBDSFTDJEBTEFDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBFKVSPTEFVN QPSDFOUP BPNÐT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 193 fù4FOEPBQSPQPTUBEFGFSJEBQFMPKVJ[PFYFRVFOUFMFWBOUBSÈBRVBOUJB EFQPTJUBEBFTFSÍPTVTQFOTPTPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPTDBTPJOEFGFSJEBTFHVJS TFÍPPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPTNBOUJEPPEFQØTJUPù fù0OÍPQBHBNFOUPEFRVBMRVFSEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTJNQMJDBSÈEFQMFOP EJSFJUPPWFODJNFOUPEBTTVCTFRVFOUFTFPQSPTTFHVJNFOUPEPQSPDFTTP DPNPJNFEJBUPJOÓDJPEPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPTJNQPTUBBPFYFDVUBEPNVMUB EFEF[QPSDFOUP TPCSFPWBMPSEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTOÍPQBHBTFWFEBEB BPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPT 5SBUBTFEFJOPWBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMRVFBMÏNEFBDFMFSBSBQSFTUBÎÍPEBUVUFMB FYFDVUJWBPCKFUJWBJODFOUJWBSPEFWFEPSBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTVBPCSJHBÎÍPDPOGF SJOEPNBJTFGFUJWJEBEFOBCVTDBQFMBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPRVFFTUÈTFOEPFYFDVUBEP "SBLFO EF "TTJT BTTFWFSB RVF io Art. 745-A representa poderoso estímulo ao cumprimento voluntário e meio hábil para encerrar execução que, inexistisse o parcelamento, recortaria o patrimônio do executadow $PNDFSUF[BBIJQØUFTFMFHBMÏCBTUBOUFJOUFSFTTBOUFFJTRVFDPOTUJUVJBMUFSOBUJWB QSFWJTUBFNMFJQBSBWJBCJMJ[BSPQBHBNFOUPEPWBMPSRVFFTUÈTFOEPFYFDVUBEPFBPNFT NPUFNQPBNFOJ[BSBTJUVBÎÍPEPEFWFEPSEBOEPMIFPQPSUVOJEBEFEFTBMEBSTVBEÓWJEB EFGPSNBQBSDFMBEBTFNRVFIBKBEJMBQJEBÎÍPEFTFVQBUSJNÙOJPQFMPTBUPTEBQFOIPSB )VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSTBMJFOUBRVF BNFEJEBUFNPQSPQØTJUPEFGBDJMJUBSBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPBKVJ[BEP DPN WBOUBHFOT UBOUP QBSB P FYFDVUBEP DPNP QBSB P FYFRVFOUF 0 EFWFEPSTFCFOFmDJBDPNPQSB[PEFFTQFSBFDPNPBGBTUBNFOUPEPT SJTDPT F DVTUPT EB FYQSPQSJBÎÍP FYFDVUJWB F P DSFEPS QPS TVB WF[ SFDFCFVNBQBSDFMBEPDSÏEJUPEFTEFMPHPFmDBMJWSFEPTQFSDBMÎPTEPT FNCBSHPTEPFYFDVUBEP3 /FTTB FTUFJSB Ï GÈDJM QFSDFCFS RVF B JOUSPEVÎÍP EB NPSBUØSJB MFHBM SFQSF TFOUPVVNBWBOÎPBPQSPDFTTPKVEJDJBMCSBTJMFJSPBQSFTFOUBOEPTFDPNPJNQPSUBOUF JOTUSVNFOUPËTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPNBUFSJBMAté porque, conquanto deva ser efetivo, o processo não pode ser uma “arma de destruição”BPSFWÏTEFWFTFSNFDBOJTNPEFBMDBO DFBPSFTVMUBEPTPDJBMDFSUPRVFBPFODPSBKBSPEFWFEPSSFDBMDJUSBOUFBBEJNQMJSTVB PCSJHBÎÍPPJOTUJUVUPDPOUSJCVJQBSBBFGFUJWJEBEFEBQSFTUBÎÍPEBUVUFMBKVSJTEJDJPOBM 3 "44*4"SBLFOManual da ExecuçãoFESFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCV OBJTQ 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de direito processual civil: processo de execução e cumprimento da sentença, processo cautelar e tutela de urgência7PMFE3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTFQ 4*-7"3JOBMEP.PV[BMBTEF4PV[BFùA moratória do art. 745-A do CPC. Sua aplicação às demandas cognitivas condenatórias.ù+VT/BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPOKBO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 194 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga 2.2. Natureza jurídica "JOUSPEVÎÍPEPBSU"OP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMJOPWPVBPQSFWFS VNBBMUFSOBUJWBBPEFWFEPSEFQBSDFMBSTFVEÏCJUPOBTFYFDVÎÜFTEFUÓUVMPFYUSBKV EJDJBMPRVFTFHVSBNFOUFSFQFSDVUJVUBOUPOPDBNQPEFEJSFJUPNBUFSJBMRVBOUPOB GBTFQSPDFTTVBMEPDSÏEJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPBTFSFYJHJEP 3PESJHP.B[[FJSFTTBMUBRVF PEJTQPTJUJWPOÍPFTUÈBQFOBTOBFTGFSBEPEJSFJUPQSPDFTTVBMQPJTQPEFSÈ BMDBOÎBS B QSØQSJB SFMBÎÍP NBUFSJBM FOUSF BT QBSUFT OB NFEJEB FN RVF PFYFRVFOUFDPNPDSFEPSTFTVKFJUBSÈBPSFDFCJNFOUPQBSDFMBEPDBTP P EFWFEPS FORVBOUP FYFDVUBEP QSFFODIB UPEPT PT SFRVJTJUPT F TJHB B USJMIBEPcaputEP"SU"EP$1$<>1PSFTTBSB[ÍPQFOTBNPTRVF NVJUPFNCPSBBDBSHBQSPDFTTVBMTFKBQSFQPOEFSBOUFKÈRVFBPQÎÍPEP "SU " EP $1$ TPNFOUF TF EBSÈ FN BNCJFOUF KVEJDJBM USBUBTF EF EJTQPTJUJWPbifronteRVFQBSBTFSDPNQSFFOEJEPFNUPEPTPTTFVTFGFJUPT EFWFTFSFTUVEBEPUBOUPFNTVBGBTFQSPDFTTVBMRVBOUPNBUFSJBM %FTUBSUFWBMFBQFOBUFDFSBMHVOTDPNFOUÈSJPTTPCSFPBMDBODFEFTTFJOTUJUV UPWJTUPRVFTVBOBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBÏCBTUBOUFDPOUSPWFSTBOBEPVUSJOB 2.2.1. Direito material "NPSBUØSJBJOTUJUVÓEBQFMB-FJOFTUBCFMFDFVBQPTTJCJMJEBEF EFPFYFDVUBEPQBSDFMBSPNPOUBOUFDPOTVCTUBODJBEPOPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPFYUSBKVEJ DJBMDPOmHVSBOEPOBTMJÎÜFTEF-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUB8BHOFS+Siuma modalidade de extinção de obrigaçãowWJTUPRVFicaso seja deferido o pagamento parcelado do débito, ao final, cumprido na sua integralidade, estará o devedor liberado de sua obrigação, que será considerada extintaw $PNFGFJUPIÈKVSJTUBTRVFEFGFOEFNRVFBNPSBUØSJBJOTUJUVJVVNBFTQÏDJF EF QBHBNFOUP EJSFUP QVSP F TJNQMFT o NPEP BMJÈT EF FYUJOÎÍP EB PCSJHBÎÍP QPS .";;&*3PESJHP0QÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPFNQBHBSQBSDFMBEBNFOUFBEÓWJEBFYFDVUBEB*OReforma do CPC 2: nova sistemática processual civil/&7&4%BOJFM"NPSJN"TTVNQÎÍP<FUBM>4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB 3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUB$JODPRVFTUÜFTDPOUSPWFSUJEBTEBOPWBTJTUFNÈUJDBEB FYFDVÎÍPDJWJM*OAspectos Polêmicos da nova execução$PPSE$BTTJP4DBSQJOFMMB#VFOPF5FSFTB"SSV EB"MWJN7PM4ÍP1BVMP35 RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 195 FYDFMÐODJBoPDPSSFOEPDPOGPSNFFOTJOBNFOUPTEF0SMBOEP(PNFTiquando o devedor cumpre a obrigação, prestando a coisa, ou o fato, o crédito é diretamente satisfeitow /ÍPNFQBSFDFTFSFTTBBOBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBNBUFSJBMEBmHVSBQSFTDSJUBOP"SU "EP$1$FJTRVFNVJUPFNCPSBIBKBPQBHBNFOUPEBJOUFHSBMJEBEFEBPCSJ HBÎÍPTVBTBUJTGBÎÍPOÍPÏSFBMJ[BEBDPNPPSJHJOBSJBNFOUFQBDUVBEPFOUSFBTQBSUFT 1PSPVUSPMBEPFYJTUFNEPVUSJOBEPSFTFOUFOEFOEPUSBUBSTFEFOPWBÎÍPRVF TFHVOEP«MWBSP7JMBÎB"[FWFEPié um meio de execução obrigacional que importa a extinção da obrigação primitiva pelo nascimento de uma novaw /ÍP NF DPOWFODF RVF B NPSBUØSJB TF FODBJYF OFTTB NPEBMJEBEF VNB WF[ RVFBOPWBÎÍPQSFTTVQÜFBTVCTUJUVJÎÍPEBSFMBÎÍPPCSJHBDJPOBMQSJNJUJWBoRVFQPEF TFSTVCKFUJWBJTUPÏBMUFSBÎÍPEPDSFEPSEPEFWFEPSPVEFBNCPTPVBJOEBPCKFUJWB OBRVBMIÈNPEJmDBÎÍPEPPCKFUPEBQSFTUBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBoTJUVBÎÜFTFTTBTRVFOÍPTF DPBEVOBNDPNBmHVSBQSFWJTUBOP"SU"EP$1$FNRVFBTQBSUFTFPPCKFUP TÍPPTNFTNPTNVEBOEPTFBQFOBTBGPSNBEFQBHBNFOUP "TTJNTFOEPDPNQBSUJMIPBUFTFEFRVFPJOTUJUVUPDPOmHVSBIJQØUFTFEFUSBOTB ÎÍPRVF$BJP.ÈSJPEB4JMWB1FSFJSBDPODFJUVBDPNPTFOEPium determinado negócio jurídico, que se realiza por via de um acordo de vontades, e tem por objeto extinguir a obrigaçãow &TUBBNFVWFSÏBNPEBMJEBEFEFFYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPRVFNBJTTFFO RVBESBOBIJQØUFTFQSFWJTUBOP"SU"EP$1$QPTUPRVFOBNPSBUØSJBUFSFNPT DPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBTEFBNCBTBTQBSUFTQBSBRVFIBKBBFYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPP EFWFEPSSFDPOIFDFSÈPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUFBMÏNEFTFPCSJHBSBEFQPTJUBSVNWBMPS JOJDJBMEFEBEÓWJEBFPDSFEPSBDFJUBSÈRVFPSFTUBOUFTFKBQBHPEFGPSNBQBSDF MBEBNBTTFMJWSBOEPEPTUSBOTUPSOPTEPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWP 2.2.2. Direito processual /PQMBOPEP%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBMBDMBTTJmDBÎÍPEBOBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBEPJOTUJ UVUPFTUBCFMFDJEPOP"SU"EP$1$UBNCÏNÏCBTUBOUFDPOUSPWFSUJEB .JSOB$JBODJEFGFOEFDVJEBSTFEFJODJEFOUFOPGFJUPFYFDVUJWP /BWFSEBEFPOPWPBSU"DSJPVVNBNPEBMJEBEFEFJODJEFOUFEB FYFDVÎÍPEPUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBDPNBmOBMJEBEFEF HBSBOUJSBPFYFDVUBEPPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUP/ÍPTFUSBUBPOPWP (0.&40SMBOEPObrigações3FWBUVBMFBVNEFBDPSEPDPNP$ØEJHP$JWJMEFQPS&EWBMEP #SJUP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTFQ ";&7&%0«MWBSP7JMMBÎBTeoria Geral das ObrigaçõesFESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT 5SJCVOBJTQ 1&3&*3"$BJP.ÈSJPEB4JMWBInstituições de Direito Civil: teoria geral das obrigações.W3JPEF+BOFJSP &EJUPSB'PSFOTFQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 196 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga JOTUJUVUP B NFV TFOUJS EF NPSBUØSJB MFHBM VNB WF[ RVF B NPSBUØSJB QSFTTVQÜFBQFOBTPBMBSHBNFOUPEPQSB[PQBSBQBHBNFOUPTFNRVFP EÏCJUPTFKBBNPSUJ[BEPDPNPQBSDFMBNFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍP %FPVUSBTFOEB+PTÏ&EVBSEP$BSSFJSB"MWJNFOUFOEFRVFTFUSBUBEFVNB FTQÏDJFEF*OKVOÎÍPBTTFSUJWBDPNCBUJEBDPNWFFNÐODJBQPS#SVOP¶UBMP4PV[B1JOUP BPFYQMJDBSRVFio escopo da injunção é possibilitar a célere formação de título executivo, sendo normalmente proposta pelo credor, não se amoldando bem ao parcelamentowPRVF EFWFSBTUFNGVOEBNFOUPQPTUPRVFOBFYFDVÎÍPPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPKÈFTUÈGPSNBEP DPOUFOEPUPEPTPTSFRVJTJUPTQBSBBTVBFYJHJCJMJEBEFBPDPOUSÈSJPEPRVFPDPSSFOB BÎÍPNPOJUØSJBEJGFSFODJBOEPBJOEBOPGBUPEFPSFRVFSJNFOUPOBNPSBUØSJBPSJHJ OBSEPEFWFEPSEJGFSFOUFNFOUFUBNCÏNEBDJUBEBNPEBMJEBEFEBBÎÍPFTQFDJBM 1PSPVUSPMBEP.BSDFMP"CFMIB3PESJHVFTEFGFOEFBOBUVSF[Bsui generis13EP JOTUJUVUPDMBTTJmDBOEPPDPNPVNBGPSNBFTQFDJBMEFremição14EBFYFDVÎÍPWJTUP RVFUBMDPNPBSFHSBEP"SUEP$1$PQSFDFJUPQPTTVJEVBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT QSJNPSEJBJTRVBMTFKBPQSB[PFPNPEPFTQFDÓmDPQSBPTFVFYFSDÓDJPQPTJÎÍPFTUB RVFÏDSJUJDBEBQPSPVUSPTQSPDFTTVBMJTUBTTPCPBSHVNFOUPEFRVFPQBSDFMBNFOUP JOTUJUVÓEPQFMB-FJOQPTTVJQSFTTVQPTUPTQSØQSJPTDBQB[FTEFMIFEJGFSFO DJBSEBmHVSBEBSFNJÎÍPOPUBEBNFOUFQPSRVFOBNPSBUØSJBOÍPIÈBFYUJOÎÍPEB FYFDVÎÍPKÈRVFPGFJUPFYFDVUJWPmDBTVTQFOTPBUÏPQBHBNFOUPJOUFHSBMEBEÓWJEB 3FTQFJUBEBTBTPQJOJÜFTFNDPOUSÈSJPBDPSSFOUFNBKPSJUÈSJBÏOPTFOUJEPEF RVFP"SU"EP$1$JOTUJUVJVVNBFTQÏDJFEFNPSBUØSJBMFHBMQPTTJCJMJUBOEPBP FYFDVUBEPTBMEBSTVBEÓWJEBOVNQSB[PNÈYJNPEFBUÏTFJTNFTFT/FTTFTFOUJEPÏ PQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEF$BTTJP4DBSQJOFMB#VFOP+BOFUF3JDLFO-PQFTEF#BSSPT-VJ[ (VJMIFSNF.BSJOPOJF)VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+SFOUSFPVUSPTJMVTUSFTKVSJTUBT 1PS mN DVNQSF EFTUBDBS RVF P 45+ OP KVMHBNFOUP EP 3&41 3+KÈTFNBOJGFTUPVTPCSFPUFNBDMBTTJmDBOEPPDPNPUÏDOJDBEFDVNQSJNFOUP WPMVOUÈSJPEBPCSJHBÎÍP $*"/$*.JSOB<FUBM>Comentários à execução Civil – Título judicial e Extrajudicial4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB Q "-7*.+PTÏ&EVBSEP$BSSFJSBBQVE"3"6+0"MFYBOESF$PTUBA natureza jurídica do parcelamento do débito previsto pelo Art. 745-A do CPC. 1*/50#SVOP¶UBMP4PVTBArtigo 745-A do CPC: a natureza jurídica do parcelamento da dívida e outras polêmicas. 30%3*(6&4.BSDFMP"CFMIBManual de Direito Processual CivilFE4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB35Q .PBDZS"NBSBM4BOUPTFOTJOBRVFi3FNJÎÍPwTJHOJmDBSFTHBUFSFTTBMUBOEPRVFTFPJOUFSFTTBEPFGFUVB PQBHBNFOUPEPWBMPSFYFRVFOEPBFYFDVÎÍPÏFYUJOUBQPEFOEPPEFWFEPSSFTHBUBSPTCFOTRVFMIF GPSBNQFOIPSBEPTPVBSSFDBEBEPTInPrimeiras Linhas de Direito Processual Civil.WPM***FESFW FBUVBMQPS"SJDÐ.PBDZS"NBSBM4BOUPT4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ "SUù"OUFTEFBEKVEJDBEPTPVBMJFOBEPTPTCFOTQPEFPFYFDVUBEPBUPEPUFNQPSFNJSB FYFDVÎÍPQBHBOEPPVDPOTJHOBOEPBJNQPSUÉODJBBUVBMJ[BEBEBEÓWJEBNBJTKVSPTDVTUBTFIPOP SÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTù RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 197 3. SISTEMÁTICA DO ART. 745-A DO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL " 3FGPSNB EP QSPDFTTP EF FYFDVÎÍP EF UÓUVMP FYUSBKVEJDJBM PQFSBEB QFMP BEWFOUPEB-FJOJOUSPEV[JVP"SU"OP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM DSJBOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFPFYFDVUBEPSFDPOIFDFOEPPDSÏEJUPEFWJEPSFRVFSFSP QBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPFNBUÏTFJTWF[FTEFTEFRVFFGFUVFPEFQØTJUPEFEB EÓWJEBBMÏNEPQBHBNFOUPEBTDVTUBTFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTJODJEJOEPDPSSFÎÍP NPOFUÈSJBFKVSPTEFNPSBEFTPCSFBTQBSDFMBTNFOTBJT /FTTFEJBQBTÍPQPEFTFBmSNBSRVFBGBDVMEBEFQSPDFTTVBMJOTQJSBEBOPJOT UJUVUP EFOPNJOBEP favor debitoris. QSFWJV VNB FTQÏDJF EF NPSBUØSJB MFHBM BP DSJBS BMUFSOBUJWBQBSBEFWFEPSFGFUVBSPQBHBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPEFGPSNBQBSDFMBEBFTUJNV MBOEPPBPDVNQSJNFOUPWPMVOUÈSJPEBPCSJHBÎÍPDPOTVCTUBODJBEBOPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWP &OUSFUBOUPQBSBBQMJDBÎÍPEBOPSNBFNDPNFOUPÏOFDFTTÈSJPPQSFFODIJ NFOUPDPODPNJUBOUFEPTQSFTTVQPTUPTQSFWJTUPTOPDPNBOEPMFHBMSB[ÍPQFMBRVBMTF GB[JNQSFTDJOEÓWFMUFDFSBMHVOTDPNFOUÈSJPTBDFSDBEFTFVTSFRVJTJUPT 3.1. Prazo para o requerimento do executado 0BSUJHPFNBQSFÎPÏDMBSPBPQSFTDSFWFSRVFBQSFUFOTÍPEFPFYFDVUBEPQB HBSPEÏCJUPEFGPSNBQBSDFMBEBEFWFTFSGPSNVMBEBEFOUSPEPQSB[PQBSBPGFSFDJNFO UPEPTFNCBSHPTRVFBUFPSEPEJTQPTUPOP"SUcaputÏEFRVJO[F EJBT "TTJNTFOEPDJUBEPPEFWFEPSBCSFTFPQSB[PRVJO[FOBMQBSBPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBS HPTDBCFOEPBPFYFDVUBEPEFOUSPEFTTFQFSÓPEPFTDPMIFSFOUSFFNCBSHBSBFYFDVÎÍPPV SFRVFSFSPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPWJTUPRVFia opção escolhida, qualquer que seja, eliminará a outra faculdade processualw&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBTise se opõem os embargos não cabe mais o parcelamento; se se obtém o parcelamento, extingue-se a possibilidade de embargos à execuçãow. 4PCSFBOPWJEBEF4BSBI.FSÎPO7BSHBTBOPUBRVF 5PEBWF[RVFBMFHJTMBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMQSFWFSVNBPQÎÍPNFOPTHSBWPTBBPEFWFEPSFTUBNPTEJBOUFEFVN favor debitorisJOTUJUVUPFTTFRVFFTUÈJOUJNBNFOUFMJHBEPBPQSJODÓQJPEBNFOPSPOFSPTJEBEFEBFYFDVÎÍP TFNPMWJEBSDPOUVEPEBCVTDBQFMBFGFUJWJEBEFQSPDFTTVBM"QSPQØTJUP7JDFOUF(SFDP'JMIPTVHFSFRVF iJOTQJSBEPOFTTBJEFJBP$ØEJHPPGFSFDFEJWFSTBTBMUFSOBUJWBTEFFYFDVÎÍPEFWFOEPPKVJ[PQUBSQFMBEF NFOPSFODBSHPQBSBPEFWFEPSTFBTTFHVSBEBBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPDPNPUBOUBTWF[FTSFGFSJEP&OUSF FTTFTDBTPTFODPOUSBNTFQPSFYFNQMPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBTVCTUJUVJÎÍPEBQFOIPSBEBBEKVEJDBÎÍPEFCFOT QPSQBSUFEFQFTTPBTEBGBNÓMJBEPEFWFEPSQPSRVFPCFNQFSNBOFDFOPÉNCJUPGBNJMJBSFOUSFPVUSPT² QPTTÓWFMQPSÏNTVTUFOUBSRVFPDPODFJUPEFfavor debitoris TPNFOUFTFSFGFSFBPTDBTPTFNRVFPCFOFGÓDJP EFDPSSBEFNFSBMJCFSBMJEBEFFOÍPQPSBMUFSOBUJWBMFHBMwIn(3&$0'*-)07JDFOUFDireito processual civil brasileiroWPMFESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ "SUù0TFNCBSHPTTFSÍPPGFSFDJEPTOPQSB[PEFRVJO[F EJBTDPOUBEPTEBEBUBEBKVOUBEBBPT BVUPTEPNBOEBEPEFDJUBÎÍP3FEBÎÍPEBEBQFMB-FJOEF 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de direito processual civil: processo de execução e cumprimento da sentença, processo cautelar e tutela de urgência7PMQ 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUP-PDDJU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 198 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga 0 NBSDP EF BCFSUVSB EP QSB[P TFKB QBSB PGFSFDFS FNCBSHPT TFKB QBSB SFRVFSFS P QBSDFMBNFOUP EP WBMPS EB FYFDVÎÍP BP DPOUSÈSJP EB TJTUFNÈUJDBBOUFSJPSOÍPTFWJODVMBËSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFQFOIPSBNBTTJNBP ÐYJUPPCUJEPOBEJMJHÐODJBEFDJUBÎÍP1PSTVBWF[EJTQÜFPBSUEP $1$RVFBQFOIPSBEFCFOTTFSÈQSPWJEFODJBEBTFNQSFRVFPFYFDVUBEP OÍPFGFUVBSPQBHBNFOUPEPDSÏEJUPFYFRVFOEPEFOUSPEPQSB[PEF USÐT EJBTDPOUBEPTBQBSUJSEFTVBDJUBÎÍP %PSBDJPDÓOJPFYUSBJTFSUPUBMNFOUFQPTTÓWFMRVFPQBUSJNÙOJPEPEFWFEPS QPTTBTFSDPOTUSJUPBOUFTNFTNPRVFTFKBFYUFSOBEPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏ CJUPQPTUPRVFPQSB[PQBSBPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTÏNBJPSRVFPMBQTPmYBEPQBSB PQBHBNFOUPJOUFHSBMEBFYFDVÎÍPIBWFOEPQPSUBOUPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFRVFPFYF DVUBEPDBTPQPTTVBQBUSJNÙOJPUFOIBTFVTCFOTDPOTUSJUPTFNNPNFOUPBOUFSJPSË BQSFTFOUBÎÍPEBPQÎÍPDPOGFSJEBQFMP"SU"EP$1$. /FTTBIJQØUFTF3PESJHP.B[[FJEFGFOEFRVF <> P FYFDVUBEP QPEFSÈ BQSFTFOUBS NBOJGFTUBÎÍP QFMB QPTTJCJMJEBEF EF QBSDFMBNFOUPDPNBDPNQSPWBÎÍPEPEFQØTJUPNÓOJNPEFUSJOUBQPS DFOUP IJQØUFTF FN RVF IBWFSÈ B TVTQFOTÍP EB FYFDVÎÍP TFN DPOUVEP PQFSBSTFBVUPNBUJDBNFOUFPEFTGB[JNFOUPEBQFOIPSBSFBMJ[BEB"DPOUSJÎÍP TFSÈNBOUJEBBUÏPFYBNFEFBENJTTJCJMJEBEFEBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPBSU"f QPEFOEPFNDBTPEFNBOJGFTUPFYDFTTPTFSEJNJOVÓEBQFMPNBHJTUSBEP 1PSJTTPDPODMVJTFRVFPQFEJEPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPQBSBmOTEP"SU" EP$1$EFWFTFSGFJUPEFOUSPEPQSB[PQBSBPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPTPC QFOBEFQSFDMVTÍPEBGBDVMEBEFQSPDFTTVBMBOUFBBVTÐODJBEFVNEFTFVTSFRVJTJUPT WBMFEJ[FSBUFNQFTUJWJEBEFEFWFOEPTFSNBOUJEBFWFOUVBMQFOIPSBRVFUFOIBTJEP SFBMJ[BEBOPTBVUPTBUÏPFYBNFEPTQSFTTVQPTUPTEBNPSBUØSJBMFHBM 3.2. O reconhecimento do crédito devido e o depósito prévio de 30% 0"SU"EP$1$FTUBCFMFDFBGBDVMEBEFEFPEFWFEPSQBSDFMBSPEÏCJUP EFTEFRVFSFDPOIFÎBPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUFTFOEPFTUFVNEPTSFRVJTJUPTFTTFODJBJT QBSBPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPKVOUBNFOUFDPNPDPNQSPWBOUFEPEFQØTJUPQSÏWJP .&3±0/7"3("44BSBI"GBDVMEBEFEFQBSDFMBNFOUPEPWBMPSEBFYFDVÎÍP"SU" SFRVJTJ UPTQSPDFEJNFOUPFBQMJDBCJMJEBEF*OExecução Extrajudicial: modificações da Lei 11.382/2006.$PPSE 4VTBOB)FOSJRVFTEBDPTUB4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB2VBSUJFS-BUJO .";;&*3PESJHP0QÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPFNQBHBSQBSDFMBEBNFOUFBEÓWJEBFYFDVUBEBQ .";;&*3PESJHP0QÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPFNQBHBSQBSDFMBEBNFOUFBEÓWJEBFYFDVUBEBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 199 EFOPNÓOJNPUSJOUBQPSDFOUP EPWBMPSEBEÓWJEBBMÏNEBTDVTUBTJOUFHSBJT FWFSCBIPOPSÈSJB "SFTQFJUP-VJ[(VJMIFSNF.BSJOPOJF%BOJFM.JUJEJFJSPFOTJOBNRVFBNP SBUØSJBQSFWJTUBOP"SU"EP$1$ <>WJTBFTUJNVMBSPFYFDVUBEPBSFDPOIFDFSPEJSFJUPDPOTVCTUBODJBEP OP UÓUVMP FYFDVUJWP FWJUBOEPTF FWFOUVBJT EJTDVTTÜFT B SFTQFJUP FN FYDFÎÍP EF QSÏFYFDVUJWJEBEF FNCBSHPT Ë FYFDVÎÍP PV FN BÎÍP BVUÙOPNBJNQVHOBUJWBEPUÓUVMP %FTUBSUFBPPQUBSQFMPQBSDFMBNFOUPPEFWFEPSSFDPOIFDFPDSÏEJUPFNGB WPSEPFYFRVFOUFKÈRVFPEFGFSJNFOUPEBNFEJEBJNQFEFBGVUVSBBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEF EFGFTBQPSQBSUFEPFYFDVUBEPDPOGPSNFEJTQPTJÎÍPFYQSFTTBEBMFJRVFÏUBYBUJWBBP WFEBSBPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPT 3FTTBMUFTFRVFOÍPCBTUBBQFOBTPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPDSÏEJUPFYFRVFOEP TFOEPJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMRVFPEFWFEPSOPNFTNPBUPEFSFRVFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFO UPBQSFTFOUFDPNQSPWBOUFEFEFQØTJUPEPNPOUBOUFDPSSFTQPOEFOUFBEPWBMPS EBEÓWJEBPRVBMEFWFTFSSFBMJ[BEPQSFWJBNFOUFQBHBOEPBJOEBBRVBOUJBSFGFSFOUF ËTEFTQFTBTQSPDFTTVBJTFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPT "QSPQØTJUP3PESJHP.B[[FJMFNCSBRVF 0EFQØTJUPTFTVCNFUFBPQSB[PQBSBBPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTEFWFOEP B EFNPOTUSBÎÍP EF TVB SFBMJ[BÎÍP TFS DPOUFNQPSÉOFB Ë BQSFTFOUBÎÍP EB NBOJGFTUBÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPNFTNPTFQPSRVFTUÜFTPQFSBDJPOBJTUJWFSTJEP FGFUVBEPBOUFTEBDPNVOJDBÎÍPFNKVÓ[P/ÍPTFBENJUJSÈDPOUVEPRVFB NBOJGFTUBÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPTFKBPGFSUBEBEFOUSPEPQSB[PNBTBFGFUJWBÎÍP PVNFTNPDPNQSPWBÎÍP EPEFQØTJUPTFPQFSFFNEBUBQPTUFSJPSFYDFUP OBTIJQØUFTFTEFKVTUPNPUJWPDPNPQPSFYFNQMPHSFWFHFSBMEPTCBODPT "MJÈTPcaputEP"SU"EP$1$OÍPEFJYBEÞWJEBTEFRVFPDPNQSPWBOUF EFEFQØTJUPEFWFBDPNQBOIBSPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPTVCUFOEFOEPTF RVFOÍPTFBENJUFPNFSPQSPUFTUPQFMPEFQØTJUPSB[ÍPQFMBRVBMOFTTBTIJQØUFTFTP QBSDFMBNFOUPOÍPEFWFTFSDPODFEJEPFJTRVFFTTFSFRVJTJUPFTTFODJBMQBSBDPODFTTÍP EBCFOFTTFMFHBMOPUJDJBBCPBGÏEPEFWFEPSRVFUFNPEFWFSEFEFNPOTUSBSBPTFV DSFEPSBJOUFOÎÍPEFTBMEBSBEÓWJEB /ÍPPCTUBOUFDPODPSEPDPN3FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSB.BSUJOTRVBOEPBmSNBRVF ."3*/0/*-VJ[(VJMIFSNF.*5*%*&*30%BOJFMCódigo de Processo Civil comentado artigo por artigo. 4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ .";;&*3PESJHP0QÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPFNQBHBSQBSDFMBEBNFOUFBEÓWJEBFYFDVUBEB<>Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 200 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga "QFTBSEFBMFJEFUFSNJOBSPEFQØTJUPEFEPWBMPSFNFYFDVÎÍPÏQPTTÓWFM BPFYFDVUBEPFGFUVÈMPBQFOBTTPCSFBRVBOUJBJODPOUSPWFSTBOPTDBTPTFN RVFDPOGPSNFKÈBQPOUBEPOPJUFNBOUFSJPSQSFUFOEFSBQSFTFOUBSFNCBSHPT FNSFMBÎÍPBPFYDFTTPKVOUBNFOUFDPNPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUP $VNQSFBOPUBSQPSmNRVFNVJUPFNCPSBPEJTQPTJUJWPGBMFFNEFQØTJUP EFEPWBMPSEBEÓWJEBOBEBJNQFEFRVFPEFWFEPSFGFUVFPQBHBNFOUPFNQFS DFOUVBMTVQFSJPSQBSBBNFOJ[BSPJNQBDUPEPTDPOTFDUÈSJPTMFHBJTOPTBMEPSFNBOFT DFOUFRVFTFSÈQBSDFMBEPEJBOUFEBQSFWJTÍPEBQBSUFmOBMEP"SU"caput$1$ RVFFTUBCFMFDFBJODJEÐODJBEFBPNÐTBUÓUVMPEFKVSPTNPSBUØSJPT 3.3. Honorários e Custas +VOUBNFOUFDPNPEFQØTJUPEFEPWBMPSEBEÓWJEBPEJTQPTJUJWPEFUFS NJOBRVFPFYFDVUBEPFGFUVFPQBHBNFOUPEBTDVTUBTQSPDFTTVBJTFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWP DBUÓDJPTQBSBPEFGFSJNFOUPEPCFOFGÓDJPMFHBM 1BSBRVFQPTTBDIFHBSBFTUFNPOUBOUF4BSBI.FSÎPO7BSHBTMFDJPOBRVF 0FYFDVUBEPEFWFSÈQSPDFEFSJOJDJBMNFOUFPDÈMDVMPEFBUVBMJ[BÎÍPEP WBMPSDPOTUBOUFEPUÓUVMPBUÏBEBUBFNRVFQSFUFOEFFGFUVBSPEFQØTJUP FFNTFHVJEBBEJDJPOBSBTEFTQFTBTQSPDFTTVBJTEFWJEBTBUÏFOUÍPFPT IPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTQSFWJBNFOUFBSCJUSBEPTQFMPKVJ[0SFTVMUBEP EFTTFTPNBUØSJPÏRVFEFWFSÈTFSVUJMJ[BEPDPNPCBTFEFDÈMDVMPQBSB RVF TF DIFHVF Ë FYQSFTTÍP NPOFUÈSJB DPSSFTQPOEFOUF BP QFSDFOUVBM QSFWJTUPOPDBQVUEPEJTQPTJUJWPFNDPNFOUPPVBPVUSPTVQFSJPS &OUSFUBOUPDBCFNFODJPOBSQPSPQPSUVOPVNBTJUVBÎÍPTVTDJUBEBQPS3P ESJHP.B[[FJOBIJQØUFTFEFOÍPUFSTJEPFGFUVBEPPQBHBNFOUPJOUFHSBMEPEFQØTJUP NÓOJNPNBTTVBGBMUBOÍPGPSTJHOJmDBUJWBDPNPQPSFYFNQMPEFOÍPUFSTJEPJODMV ÓEBTUPEBTBTEFTQFTBTQSPDFTTVBJTOBDPOUBFYFDVUØSJBGBMUBOEPMIFPSFDPMIJNFOUP EFBMHVNBEJMJHÐODJBQSPDFTTVBMKÈBOUFDJQBEBQFMPFYFRVFOUF/FTTFTDBTPTPQSP DFTTVBMJTUBEFGFOEFiser possível a complementação, devendo o julgador fixar prazo para o executado suplementar o depósito inicialw ."35*/43FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSBO parcelamento do Art. 745-A, do CPC, no cumprimento de sentença. In: &YFDVÎÍP$JWJMFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB$PPSE4FSHJP4IJNVSBF(JMCFSUP(PNFT#SVTI7PM 4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEP .&3±0/7"3("4 4BSBI A faculdade de parcelamento do valor da execução (art. 745-A): requisitos, procedimento e aplicabilidade... .";;&*3PESJHPOpção do executado em pagar parceladamente a dívida executada...Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 201 3FQVUPBTPMVÎÍPNVJUPBEFRVBEBKÈRVFOÍPUFSJBTFOUJEPOFHBSBCFOFTTFEP QBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPBPFYFDVUBEPFNSB[ÍPEFRVBOUJBNÓOJNBNVJUBTEBTWF[FT BUÏJSSJTØSJBQPSGBMUBEFDPNQVUPEFBMHVNBEJMJHÐODJBRVFMIFQBTTPVEFTQFSDFCJEP0 RVFOÍPTFBENJUFDPOUVEPÏPEFQØTJUPJOTVmDJFOUFQSPQPTJUBMEBRVBOUJBFYFRVFOEB DPNPQPSFYFNQMPPQBHBNFOUPUÍPTPNFOUFEFEPUPUBMEFWJEPTJUVBÎÍPFTTB RVFEFNPOTUSBBNÈGÏEPEFWFEPSFNOÍPDVNQSJSPQSFTDSJUPOPEJTQPTJUJWPMFHBM 3.4. Parcelamento "UFPSEPEJTQPTUPOP"SU"EP$1$PFYFDVUBEPBQØTTFSDJUBEPQPEFSÈ SFRVFSFSPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPTFVEÏCJUPRVFTFEBSÈFNQFUJÎÍPTJNQMFTGPSNVMBEBOP CPKPEPTBVUPTEBFYFDVÎÍPoBDPNQBOIBEPWBMFEJ[FSEPDPNQSPWBOUFEPEFQØTJUP JOJDJBMoEJTDSJNJOBOEPBGPSNBEFDPNPJSÈFGFUVBSPQBHBNFOUPEPWBMPSSFTUBOUF 4PCSFBRVFTUÍP3FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSB.BSUJOTBSHVNFOUBRVF $BCFSÈ BP EFWFEPS BQSFTFOUBS QSPQPTUB PCKFUJWB EF QBSDFMBNFOUP JODMVTJWFEBUBTEFWFODJNFOUPTEBTQBSDFMBT4PCSFFTTFÞMUJNPBTQFDUP QBSFDFOPT RVF B NFMIPS JOUFSQSFUBÎÍP EB OPSNB OÍP JNQFEF RVF P EFWFEPS QBHVF B EÓWJEB FN QBSDFMBT DPN WFODJNFOUPT FN JOUFSWBMPT EJGFSFOUFTEFVNNÐT &DPOUJOVBFYQMJDBOEPRVF 4VQPOIBNPT P DBTP EF VN EFWFEPS DPNFSDJBOUF RVF UFOIB nVYP EF DBJYBEJÈSJPFRVFJSBQBHBSBEÓWJEBFNQBSDFMBTDPNWFODJNFOUPT B DBEB RVJO[F EJBT $SFNPT RVF OBEB JNQFEF P EFGFSJNFOUP EFTTB QSPQPTUBQPJTBEÓWJEBBPmNFBPDBCPTFSÈRVJUBEBFNTFJTNFTFT mDBOEPSFTQFJUBEPPMJNJUFEBOPSNBFBUFOEJEPTFVPCKFUJWP 0SBOÍPNFQBSFDFEFUPEPBCTVSEPBBTTFSUJWBMBOÎBEBQFMPEPVUSJOBEPS QPSTFVTQSØQSJPTGVOEBNFOUPTBUÏQPSRVFOBBQMJDBÎÍPEBOPSNBBPDPODSFUPEF WFTFTFNQSFMFWBSFNDPOUBBmOBMJEBEFQBSBRVBMBNFTNBGPJJOTUJUVÓEBRVFPT FTUVEJPTPTEBIFSNFOÐVUJDBDIBNBNEFJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPUFMFPMØHJDBEFWFOEPPJOUÏS QSFUFQSFDJQVBNFOUFCVTDBSTFNQSFBWPOUBEFEBMFJEFNPEPBBUFOEFSBPTTFVT mOTFËTVBQPTJÎÍPEFOUSPEPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDP ."35*/43FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSBO parcelamento do art. 745-A, do CPC, no cumprimento de sentença... ."35*/43FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSBO parcelamento do art. 745-A, do CPC, no cumprimento de sentença... RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 202 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga 6MUSBQBTTBEBBRVFTUÍPVNBWF[EFGFSJEPPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPBFYF DVÎÍPTFTVTQFOEFSÈmDBOEPQSPJCJEBBQSÈUJDBEFRVBMRVFSBUPFYFDVUØSJPTFOEP MÓDJUPBPFYFRVFOUFDPOUVEPMFWBOUBSPWBMPSEFQPTJUBEPOPTBVUPT 4PCSFBTJTUFNÈUJDBWBMFBQFOBDPOGFSJSBTMJÎÜFTEF)VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPS &ORVBOUP WJHPSBS P QBSDFMBNFOUP mDBSÍP TVTQFOTPT PT BVUPT FYFDVUJWPT BSU " f 1PEF BDPOUFDFS RVF RVBOEP EP SFRVFSJNFOUP EP FYFDVUBEP KÈ FTUFKB DPOTVNBEB B QFOIPSB FTUB QPEFPDPSSFSUSÐTEJBTBQØTBDJUBÎÍPFPFYFDVUBEPUFNRVJO[FEJBT QBSBQMFJUFBSPQBSDFMBNFOUP &NUBMDJSDVOTUÉODJBBTVTQFOTÍPEPT BUPT FYFDVUJWPT OÍP JOWBMJEBSÈ B QFOIPSB F WJHPSBSÈ BQFOBT QBS BPT BVUPT FYQSPQSJBUØSJPT TVCTFRVFOUFT " TJUVBÎÍP BTTFNFMIBTF Ë EPT FNCBSHPTBSU"f /PFOUBOUPPEPVUSJOBEPSSFTTBMUBRVF /ÍPNFQBSFDFDPOUVEPRVFTFKBPCSJHBUØSJBBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEBQFOIPSB TF P QFEJEP EF QBSDFMBNFOUP GPS NBOJGFTUBEP BOUFT EB DPOTUSJÎÍP FYFDVUJWB²RVFOBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEP"SU"OÍPTFDPOEJDJPOB P CFOFGÓDJP EP QBSDFMBNFOUP Ë QFOIPSB OFN TF PSEFOB RVF FMB TF DVNQSBFNTFHVJEB/PDBTPEPTFNCBSHPTDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBP DPOUSÈSJPÏBQSØQSJBTVTQFOTÍPRVFmDBTVCPSEJOBEBËTFHVSBOÎBEP KVÓ[PBSU"f %PFYQPTUPJOGFSFTFRVFVNBWF[SFBMJ[BEBBDPOUSJÎÍPKVEJDJBMPQBSDF MBNFOUPOÍPUFNPDPOEÍPEFDBODFMBSBQFOIPSB.BTDBTPOÍPIBKBinão ficará o executado sujeito àquele ato executivo enquanto estiver prevalecendo o efeito suspensivo gerado pela moratória legalwBUÏQPSRVFPEJTQPTJUJWPEFUFSNJOBBTVTQFOTÍPEBQSÈUJDB EFRVBMRVFSBUPFYFDVUØSJPOÍPDPOEJDJPOBOEPBEFNBJTPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPË QSFTUBÎÍPEFRVBMRVFSDBVÎÍPPVËTFHVSBOÎBEPKVÓ[P .BTOBIJQØUFTFEPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPTFSJOEFGFSJEPPGFJUPFYFDVUJWP QSPTTFHVJSÈOPTTFVTVMUFSJPSFTUFSNPTNBOUJEPPEFQØTJUPFGFUVBEPQFMPFYFDVUBEP PRVBMBQSJODÓQJPOÍPQPEFSÈTFSMFWBOUBEPQFMPFYFRVFOUFQPTUPTVCFOUFOEFSRVF FTTFWBMPSJOUFHSBSÈBRVBOUJBOBFGFUJWBÎÍPEFFWFOUVBMQFOIPSB 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de direito processual civil: processo de execução e cumprimento da sentença, processo cautelar e tutela de urgênciaQ *EFNMPDDJU *EFNMPDDJU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 203 3.5. Inadimplemento "PPGFSFDFSQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPRVFBMVEFP"SU"EP$1$PFYF DVUBEPTFDPNQSPNFUFBTBMEBSPSFTUBOUFEBEÓWJEBEFGPSNBQBSDFMBEBBPJOWÏTEF UFSTFVQBUSJNÙOJPTVKFJUPËDPOTUSJÎÍPKVEJDJBM &OUSFUBOUPQBSBTFCFOFmDJBSEPJOTUJUVUPDSJBEPQFMB-FJOP EFWFEPSEFWFSÈSFTQFJUBSQPOUVBMNFOUFPQBHBNFOUPEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTDPOTPBOUFQSP QPTUBBQSFTFOUBEBFNKVÓ[PTFOEPRVFFWFOUVBMJOBEJNQMFNFOUPFOTFKBSÈPWFODJ NFOUPBOUFDJQBEPEFUPEBTBTEFNBJTQBSDFMBTDPNPSFJOÓDJPEPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPT "MÏNEJTTPPFYFDVUBEPmDBTVKFJUPBPQBHBNFOUPEFVNBNVMUBOBSB[ÍP EFEF[QPSDFOUP TPCSFPWBMPSEBTQBSDFMBTRVFOÍPBEJNQMJEBTTFOEPMIF WFEBEPDBCFMFNCSBSPQPSFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQPSQSPJCJÎÍPFYQSFTTBEPQBSÈ HSBGPTFHVOEP /FTTF TFOUJEP WFKB PT FOTJOBNFOUPT EF /FMTPO /FSZ +S F 3PTB .BSJB EF "OESBEF/FSZ 0EFWFEPSFYFDVUBEPEFWFFGFUVBSPTQBHBNFOUPTDPOGPSNFQSFWJTUPOB MFJFBVUPSJ[BEPQFMPKVJ[4PCSFWJOEPPJODVNQSJNFOUPEPQBHBNFOUP EFRVBMRVFSEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTUPEBTFMBTUPSOBSTFÍPFYJHÓWFJTQPSDBVTB EFTFVWFODJNFOUPBOUFDJQBEPBDSFTDFOEPTFËEÓWJEBBNVMUBEF EF[QPSDFOUP TPCSFPWBMPSUPUBMEBTRVFEFJYBSBNEFTFSQBHBT /ÍP IPOSBOEP PT QBHBNFOUPT EBT QBSDFMBT DPOGPSNF mYBEBT P FYFDVUBEP mDB JNQFEJEP EF PQPS FNCBSHPT EP EFWFEPS QPSRVF FTTB GBDVMEBEFKÈGPJBUJOHJEBQFMBQSFDMVTÍPMØHJDBQPSRVBOUPFMBQSBUJDPV BUP SFDPOIFDJNFOUP EB EÓWJEB DPN QSFTTVQPTJÎÍP EB BDFJUBÎÍP EB FYJTUÐODJB WBMJEBEF F FmDÈDJB EP UÓUVMP FYFDVUJWP JODPNQBUÓWFM DPN P FYFSDÓDJP EP EJSFJUP QPS NFJP EPT FNCBSHPT EJTDVTTÍP BDFSDB EB FYJTUÐODJBWBMJEBEFFFmDÈDJBEPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWP 33 /PFOUBOUP"OUÙOJP$BSMPT.BSDBUUPBEWFSUFRVF " WFEBÎÍP TVQSBNFODJPOBEB OÍP BUJOHF PT FNCBSHPT Ë BSSFNBUBÎÍP PV BEKVEJDBÎÍP VNB WF[ RVF FTUFT UFSÍP DPNP PCKFUJWP BSHVJS B OVMJEBEF EB FYFDVÎÍP PV DBVTBT FYUJOUJWBT EB PCSJHBÎÍP EFTEF RVF TVQFSWFOJFOUFTËQFOIPSB 33 /&3:+3/FMTPO/&3:3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEFCódigo de Processo Civil Comentado e Legislação Extravagante.FESFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTFEQ ."3$"50"OUÙOJP$BSMPTCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoFESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB "UMBTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 204 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga "TTJNÏRVFIBWFOEPPEFTDVNQSJNFOUPOPQBHBNFOUPEFRVBMRVFSVNB EBTQBSDFMBTPDPSSFSÈPWFODJNFOUPBOUFDJQBEPEBTEFNBJTDPNJODJEÐODJBEFNVMUB EFTPCSFPWBMPSGBMUBOUFCFNDPNPPSFTUBCFMFDJNFOUPEPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWP TFOEPEFGFTPBPFYFDVUBEPPQPSFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPDPNFYDFÎÍPEBTIJQØUFTFT QSFWJTUBTOPBSUEP$1$FNCBSHPTËBSSFNBUBÎÍPFËBEKVEJDBÎÍP 4. PONTOS CONTROVERTIDOS DA MORATÓRIA DO ART. 745-A DO CPC &NWJHPSEFTEFKBOFJSPEFP"SU"EP$1$JOUSPEV[JEPQFMB-FJ OQPTTVJWÈSJPTQPOUPTPCTDVSPTTFOEPRVFTUÍPEFEJWFSHÐODJBFOUSF PTEPVUSJOBEPSFTFOBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBEFOPTTPT5SJCVOBJT *TUPQPSRVFBSFEBÎÍPEPEJTQPTJUJWPOÍPEFJYPVDMBSPTFTVBBQMJDBCJMJEBEF TFSJBEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEPEFWFEPSPVTFDPOTUJUVJSJBQPEFSEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPEPNBHJT USBEPBRVFNQPEFSJBJOEFGFSJSPQFEJEPNFTNPTFQSFFODIJEPTPTSFRVJTJUPTQSF WJTUPT OP BSUJHP F NBJT TF TFSJB OFDFTTÈSJP QSÏWJB DPODPSEÉODJB EP DSFEPS NBJPS JOUFSFTTBEPOFTTBSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBSB[ÍPQFMBRVBMTFGB[OFDFTTÈSJPVNFTUVEPNBJT BQSPGVOEBEPTPCSFPUFNB 4.1. Direito Subjetivo do autor? 0"SU"EP$1$USPVYFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFPFYFDVUBEPSFDPOIFDFOEPP DSÏEJUPEFWJEPFGFUVBSPEFQØTJUPEFEPWBMPSFNFYFDVÎÍPFSFRVFSFSPQBSDFMB NFOUPEPTBMEPSFNBOFTDFOUF&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBTQSFFODIJEPTPTSFRVJTJUPTFYJHJEPT OPEJTQPTJUJWPMFHBMPEFWFEPSQPEFGPSNVMBSSFRVFSJNFOUPBPKVÓ[PJOGPSNBOEPB QSFUFOTÍPEFQBHBSBRVBOUJBFYFDVUBEBEFGPSNBQBSDFMBEB 1FMB MFJUVSB OÍP IÈ EÞWJEBT EF RVF P EJTQPTJUJWP QSFWÐ VNB GBDVMEBEF BP EFWFEPSia quem cabe decidir sobre a conveniência de exercitá-la ou não, pois tal decisão põe em cheque a possibilidade de oferecer embargosw. "SFTQFJUP3PESJHP.B[[FJBEWPHBRVFio art. 745-A do CPC criou para o executado uma opção que pode ou não ser exercida (direito potestativo), por meio de ato volitivow *OEP NBJT BMÏN "MVJTJP *VOFT .POUJ 3VHHFSJ 3Ï BDSFEJUB RVF io legislador criou verdadeiro direito subjetivo do devedor ao pagamento parcelado, cujo exercício independe da anuência do credor.w1BSBPEFGFOTPSQÞCMJDPPBSU"EP$1$JOTUJUVJV ialém de uma faculdade processual, um verdadeiro direito subjetivo e material ao devedor *EFNMPDDJU .";;&*3PESJHPOpção do executado em pagar parceladamente a dívida executada...Q 3²"MVÓTJP*VOFT.POUJ3VHHFSJO Acesso à justiça do devedor de boa-fé: a atuação da Defensoria Pública na efetivação do direito ao pagamento parcelado. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 205 inadimplente de saldar seu débito de forma parceladawJTTPiem contemplação aos novos princípios da boa-fé objetiva e da função social que passaram a reger as relações privadasw 4FHVJOEPFTTBMJOIBEFSBDJPDÓOJP/FMTPO/FSZ+SF3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEF /FSZFOUFOEFNRVFia norma estabelece o direito subjetivo de o executado pagar parceladamente a dívida, desde que reconheça e preencha os requisitos legais estabelecidos na norma comentadaw &OUSFUBOUPPTQSPDFTTVBMJTUBTSFTTBMUBNRVFQBSBBBQMJDBÎÍPEBOPSNBiem virtude do contraditório (CF 5º, LV), o juiz poderá mandar ouvir o exequente que, contudo, não poderá opor-se ao parcelamento caso o executado preencha os pressupostos legais para seu deferimentow 3FTQFJUBEBT BT PQJOJÜFT FN DPOUSÈSJP BT RVBJT EFGFOEFN B UFTF EF RVF B NPSBUØSJBQSFWJTUBOPBSU"EP$1$JOTUJUVJVVNEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPBPFYFDVUBEP FOUFOEPRVFUBMQSFSSPHBUJWBDPOTUJUVJUÍPTPNFOUFNFSBGBDVMEBEFEPEFWFEPSQPS RVBOUPJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMBOVÐODJBEPDSFEPSQBSBRVFIBKBPEFGFSJNFOUPEPCFOFGÓDJP ²FTTBBQPTJÎÍPBEPUBEBQPS"SBLFOEF"TTJT 0 BSU " BVUPSJ[B P FYFDVUBEP B QBSDFMBS P QBHBNFOUP EB EÓWJEB FN BUÏ TFJT NFTFT &TTB SFHSB JOPWBOEP B MFJ NBUFSJBM o FN QBSUJDVMBS P BSU EP$$TFHVOEPPRVBMFNCPSBEJWJTÓWFMBQSFTUBÎÍPiOÍPQPEFP DSFEPSTFSPCSJHBEPBSFDFCFSOFNPEFWFEPSBQBHBSQPSQBSUFTTFBTTJN OÍPTFBKVTUPVwoDPOGFSJVJOFRVÓWPDPEJSFJUPBPFYFDVUBEPDesse modo, exercido no prazo e observados os respectivos pressupostos, o pedido do executado subordina o órgão judiciário e o exequente.HSJGPOPTTP *TUPQPSRVFBPBmSNBSRVFBNPSBUØSJBTFSJBEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEPEFWFEPSTJHOJ mDBSJBEJ[FSRVFBPDSFEPSOÍPÏEBEPSFDVTBSPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPDBTPQSFTFOUFT PTSFRVJTJUPTMFHBJTFOUFOEJNFOUPFTTFRVFOÍPQPEFQSFWBMFDFSQPTUPRVFFNDPOGSPOUP DPNPQSJODÓQJPEPDPOUSBEJUØSJPHBSBOUJBQSFWJTUBOP"SUJODJTP-9EB$BSUB.BHOB 4.2. Princípio da Menor Onerosidade X Princípio Constitucional do Contraditório "DFSDBEPQPTUVMBEPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM#BSCPTB.PSFJSBFOTJOBRVFisobre o pedido formulado pelo autor, com a demanda, naturalmente deve abrir-se ao réu oportunidade de pronunciar-se: princípio do contraditório (audiatur et altera pars)w 3²"MVÓTJP*VOFT.POUJ3VHHFSJ*CJEFN /&3:+3/FMTPO/&3:3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEFCódigo de Processo Civil Comentado e Legislação Extravagante...Q /&3:+3/FMTPO/&3:3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEF-PDDJU "44*4"SBLFOManual da ExecuçãoFEQ .03&*3"+PTÏ$BSMPT#BSCPTBO Novo Processo Civil Brasileiro: exposição sistemática do procedimento. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 206 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga "QMJDBOEPTFUFNTFRVFBSFHSBÏBEFRVFVNBWF[GPSNVMBEBVNBQSF UFOTÍPFNKVÓ[PIÈEFTFSOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFPVWJEBBQBSUFDPOUSÈSJBBOUFTEPQSP OVODJBNFOUP EP ØSHÍP KVMHBEPS TPCSF P SFRVFSJNFOUP GFJUP QFMP QFUJDJPOBOUF ² P RVF 1BVMP )FOSJRVF EPT 4BOUPT -VDPO DIBNB EF bilateralidade do processo RVF TF EFTFOWPMWFDPNPDPOUSBEJÎÍPSFDÓQSPDB. ²DMBSPRVFUPEBSFHSBDPNQPSUBFYDFÎÍPDFSUPRVFOPQSPDFTTPEFFYFDV ÎÍPIÈEJTQPTJUJWPTRVFNJUJHBNPQSJODÓQJPEPDPOUSBEJUØSJPQBSBRVFIBKBVNBFGF UJWJEBEFOBQSFTUBÎÍPEBUVUFMBFYFDVUJWBNBTBNBJPSJBFNCFOFGÓDJPEPDSFEPSRVF EFUÏNBQSFSSPHBUJWBEFKÈMIFUFSTJEPBTTFHVSBEPPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPRVFTFFYFDVUB /ÍP PCTUBOUF P FYFDVUBEP UBNCÏN EJTQÜF EF QPTUVMBEPT RVF WJTBN BTTF HVSBSVNBFYFDVÎÍPFRVJEJTUBOUFQBSBPTMJUJHBOUFTFOUSFFMFTPQSJODÓQJPEBNFOPS POFSPTJEBEFOÍPNFOPTJNQPSUBOUF3FTVNJEBNFOUFBSFHSBEP"SUEP$1$ DPOTVCTUBODJBBJEFJBEFRVFBùFYFDVÎÍPEFWFTFSSFBMJ[BEBEFNBOFJSBNFOPTHSBWPTB QPTTÓWFMùQBSBùPùEFWFEPSFWJUBOEPTF “a prática de atos executivos desnecessariamente onerosos ao executadow &OUSFUBOUPFTTFQSJODÓQJPDPNPRVBMRVFSPVUSPEFWFTFSBQMJDBEPDPNSF TFSWBTOÍPQPEFOEPTFSJOUFSQSFUBEPEFGPSNBBCTPMVUBKÈRVFOÍPTFQPEFPMWJEBS RVFBUFPSEPEJTQPTUPOP"SUEP$1$BFYFDVÎÍPTFEFTFOWPMWFTFNQSFOP JOUFSFTTFEPDSFEPS "TTJNÏRVFIBWFOEPVNDPOnJUPEFWBMPSFT-VJ[3PESJHVFT8BNCJFS'MÈ WJP3FOBUP$PSSFJBEF"MNFJEBF&EVBSEP5BMBNJOJBOVODJBNRVFBTPMVÎÍPFOWPMWFSÈ QSÏWJPKVÓ[PEFWBMPS1BSBFTTFTSFOPNBEPTKVSJTUBT %JBOUFEFTJUVBÎÍPQBSBBRVBMTFQPOIBNEPJTQSJODÓQJPTJHVBMNFOUF SFMFWBOUFToDPNPÏPDBTPoDBCFSÈCBMBODFBSPTGBUPSFTDPODSFUBNFOUF FOWPMWJEPTBRVFMFRVFQSFWBMFDFSIBWFSÈEFTBDSJmDBSPPVUSPBQFOBTOB NFEJEBFTUSJUBNFOUFOFDFTTÈSJBQBSBBDPOTFDVÎÍPEBTTVBTmOBMJEBEFT QSJODÓQJPEBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEF . /FTTB FTUFJSB P NBHJTUSBEP EFWF DPOEV[JS P QSPDFTTP QSPDVSBOEP CVTDBS VNB TPMVÎÍP RVF DPSSFTQPOEB DPN NBJPS mEFMJEBEF QPTTÓWFM B DPODSFUJ[BÎÍP EP EJSFJUPNBUFSJBM1BSBUBOUPEFWFUFSBTFOTJCJMJEBEFEFFGFUJWBSBNFEJEBRVFSFQVUB NBJTBEFRVBEBBPDBTPDPODSFUPTFNEFTDVJEBSEPJOUFSFTTFEPDSFEPSNBTRVFFN &ESFWFBUVBM3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTFQ -6$0/1BVMP)FOSJRVFEPT4BOUPTEmbargos à execução4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ "(".( "SUùùù3FTTBMWBEPPDBTPEFJOTPMWÐODJBEPEFWFEPSFNRVFUFNMVHBSPDPODVSTPVOJWFSTBM"SU *** SFBMJ[BTFBFYFDVÎÍPOPJOUFSFTTFEPDSFEPSRVFBERVJSFQFMBQFOIPSBPEJSFJUPEFQSFGF SÐODJBTPCSFPTCFOTQFOIPSBEPT 8".#*&3-VJ[3PESJHVFT<FUBM>Curso Avançado de Processo Civil: processo de execução7PMFE SFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 207 DPOUSBQBSUJEBOÍPJNQPSUFOBJOTPMWÐODJBEPEFWFEPSDBTPIBKBPVUSPNFJPNFOPT HSBWPTPQBSBTFPCUFSBTBUJTGBÎÍPEBUVUFMBFYFDVUJWB²PRVFPTWÈSJPTEPVUSJOBEP SFTDIBNBNEFexecução equilibrada. 4.3. Posição do credor diante da Moratória instituída pela Lei nº 11.382/06 6MUSBQBTTBEBTFTTBTRVFTUÜFTQSFMJNJOBSFTBDPOUSPWÏSTJBBJOEBQFSTJTUFTP CSFBPCSJHBUPSJFEBEFPVOÍPEFTFPVWJSPDSFEPSQBSBRVFPDPSSBPEFGFSJNFOUPEP QBSDFMBNFOUP JOTUJUVÓEP QFMB -FJ O IBKB WJTUB RVF DPNP BOPUBEP P QSJODÓQJPEPDPOUSBEJUØSJPEFWFTFSDPOKVHBEPDPNPVUSPTQPTUVMBEPTRVFHBSBOUBN PSFTQFJUPËEJHOJEBEFEPEFWFEPS 7BMFOEPTFEFTTFFRVJMÓCSJP&SOBOF'JEÏMJTEPT4BOUPTBTTFWFSBRVF %B NFTNB GPSNB TF P SFRVFSJNFOUP TF BDPNQBOIBS EF EFQØTJUP EF EBFYFDVÎÍPDVTUBTFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTKÈmYBEPTFNPV TFmYBSFNDPNQSPQPTUBEFQBHBNFOUPFNBUÏTFJTQBSDFMBTNFOTBJT BDSFTDJEBTEFDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBFKVSPTPKVJ[EFWFSÈPVWJSPFYFRVFOUF NBT TVB EJTDPSEÉODJB OÍP JNQPSUBSÈ FN OFDFTTÈSJP JOEFGFSJNFOUP KÈ RVFBMFJDPODFEFBPKVMHBEPSBEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFEFEFGFSJSPVOÍPB QSPQPTUBFNWFSEBEFJSBDPODPSEBUBDJWJM /ÍPPCTUBOUFBEWFSUFRVF " EJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEF EP KVJ[ OP FOUBOUP OÍP MIF BUSJCVJ B GBDVMEBEF BCTPMVUB EF EFGFSJS PV JOEFGFSJS P CFOFGÓDJP 1BSB P EFGFSJNFOUP PV JOEFGFSJNFOUP EFWF MFWBS FN DPOUB BT DJSDVOTUÉODJBT FTQFDÓmDBT EP DBTPJODMVTJWFBDBQBDJEBEFFDPOÙNJDBEPFYFDVUBEPFOBUVSBMNFOUF QPEFSÈEFUFSNJOBSBUÏHBSBOUJBTQBSBPQBHBNFOUPSFTUBOUFFNEFDJTÍP EFWJEBNFOUFGVOEBNFOUBEBDPOUSBBRVBMDBCFSÈBHSBWP "MVJTJP*VOFT.POUJ3VHHFSJ3ÏQPSTFVUVSOPQPTTVJQPOUPEFWJTUBNBJT SBEJDBMBPTVTUFOUBSRVFPBSU"EP$1$DPNQPSUBFYDFÎÍPBPDVNQSJNFOUPEB PCSJHBÎÍPPSJHJOBMNFOUFDPOWFODJPOBEB4FHVOEPPEPVUSJOBEPS $BTTJP4DBSQJOFMMB#VFOP-VJ[3PESJHVFT8BNCJFS'MÈWJP3FOBUP$PSSFJBEF"MNFJEB&EVBSEP5BMB NJOJFOUSFPVUSPT 4"/504&SOBOF'JEÏMJTEPTManual de Direito Processual Civil. Execução e Processo CautelarFE 4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ *EFNMPD$JU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 208 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga *TTPTJHOJmDBRVFPQSJODÓQJPEPpacta sunt servandaRVFQSF[BWBQFMB JOUBOHJCJMJEBEFEBWPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTSFTUBFOGSBRVFDJEPFnFYJCJMJ[BEP FN DPOUFNQMBÎÍP BP CPN EFTGFDIP EP QSPDFTTP PCSJHBDJPOBM P BEJNQMFNFOUPEFOUSPEFVNDPOUFYUPDPNQMFYPEFEJSFJUPTFEFWFSFT JNQPTUPTËTQBSUFTRVFDPNQPSUBSÍPDPNQBSDFSJBFDPPQFSBÎÍP 1PSTVBWF[3PESJHP.B[[FJBDSFEJUBRVFDPNPPBEWFOUPEPBSU"EP $1$IPVWFNJUJHBÎÍPEPBSUEP$ØEJHP$JWJM 0 EJTQPTJUJWP OÍP FTUÈ BQFOBT OB FTGFSB EP EJSFJUP QSPDFTTVBM QPJT BMDBOÎBSÈBQSØQSJBSFMBÎÍPNBUFSJBMFOUSFBTQBSUFTOBNFEJEBFNRVF PFYFRVFOUFDPNPDSFEPSTFTVKFJUBSÈBPSFDFCJNFOUPQBSDFMBEPDBTP P EFWFEPS FORVBOUP FYFDVUBEP QSFFODIB UPEPT PT SFRVJTJUPT F TJHB BUSJMIBEPDBQVUEP"SU"EP$1$)ÈQPJTFNDFSUBNFEJEB BMDBODF F NJUJHBÎÍP BP EJTQPTUP OPT BSUT F EP $ØEJHP $JWJMJMVNJOBEPTQFMPTQSJODÓQJPTEBFYBUJEÍPFEBJOEJWJTJCJMJEBEFEP QBHBNFOUP. &NRVFQFTFBWFFNÐODJBEFTTFTEPVUSJOBEPSFTBNBJPSJBEPTKVSJTUBTFO UFOEFRVFPDPOUSBEJUØSJPEFWFTFSPCTFSWBEPSFQVUBOEPJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMBPJUJWBF DPODPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSQBSBPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPBRVFBMVEF P"SU"EP$1$ /FTTB USJMIB &SOBOF 'JEÏMJT EPT 4BOUPT BmSNB RVF io pagamento feito diretamente ao credor só terá força de força de extinguir a execução, se com ele concordar o exequentew "BTTFSUJWBEFGFOEJEBQFMPEPVUSJOBEPSUFNSB[ÍPEFTFSFJTRVFTFBTTJN OÍPGPTTFiteria sido instituída uma hipótese de moratória imposta ao credor que já pode estar esperando por meses ou anos a satisfação de seu crédito reconhecido e incontestávelw. &TTBÏBQPTJÎÍPEF7JDFOUF(SFDP'JMIP /ÍPÏQPTTÓWFMQPSUBOUPBENJUJSRVFPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUP OÍP FTUFKB TVCNFUJEP B BMHVNBT DPOEJÎÜFT FOUSF BT RVBJT FTUÈ 3²"MVÓTJP*VOFT.POUJ3VHHFSJAcesso à justiça do devedor de boa-fé: a atuação da Defensoria Pública na efetivação do direito ao pagamento parcelado... "SU"JOEBRVFBPCSJHBÎÍPUFOIBQPSPCKFUPQSFTUBÎÍPEJWJTÓWFMOÍPQPEFPDSFEPSTFSPCSJHBEP BSFDFCFSOFNPEFWFEPSBQBHBSQPSQBSUFTTFBTTJNOÍPTFBKVTUPV "SU"TEÓWJEBTFNEJOIFJSPEFWFSÍPTFSQBHBTOPWFODJNFOUPFNNPFEBDPSSFOUFFQFMPWBMPS OPNJOBMTBMWPPEJTQPTUPOPTBSUJHPTTVCTFRàFOUFT .";;&*3PESJHPOpção do executado em pagar parceladamente a dívida executada...Q 4"/504&SOBOF'JEÏMJTEPTManual de Direito Processual Civil. Execução e Processo Cautelar... Q (3&$0'*-)07JDFOUFDireito Processual Civil Brasileiro.FE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 209 QSJNPSEJBMNFOUF B NBOVUFOÎÍP EP BTTFHVSBNFOUP EB FYFDVÎÍP F B DPODPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSRVFQPEFQBSBUBMFTUBCFMFDFSDPOEJÎÜFTDPNP QPS FYFNQMP P SFGPSÎP EBT HBSBOUJBT TF IPVWF B EÞWJEB RVBOUP BP DVNQSJNFOUPEPQSPQPTUP /PFOUBOUPBKVTUJmDBUJWBOPTÏEBEBQPS-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUB8BHOFS +SBPFOVNFSBSDPNNVJUBQSPQSJFEBEFPTBSHVNFOUPTRVFGVOEBNFOUBNBOFDFTTJ EBEFEFDPODPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSQBSBPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUP %F JOÓDJP P KVSJTUB JOWPDB B OBUVSF[B KVSÓEJDB EFTTB GBDVMEBEF QSPDFTTVBM SFTTBMUBOEPRVFiseja qual for a modalidade de adimplemento que mais se assemelhe às disposições constantes no Art. 745-A do CPC, será sempre necessária a prévia manifestação e aceitação do credor para a formalização do negócio jurídicow 5SPDBOEP FN NJÞEPT FMF EFGFOEF RVF TF FOUFOEFSNPT RVF P EJTQPTJUJWP FNDPNFOUPTFUSBUBEFIJQØUFTFEFQBHBNFOUPEJSFUPEBÓBMFHJTMBÎÍPDJWJMÏCBT UBOUF DMBSB BP QSFTDSFWFS RVF P QBHBNFOUP EFWF TFS FGFUVBEP OB GPSNB BWFOÎBEB MFNCSBOEPRVFUPEBFRVBMRVFSBMUFSBÎÍPFYJHFQSÏWJBBVUPSJ[BÎÍPEPDSFEPSNBTTF BENJUJSDVJEBSTFEFIJQØUFTFEFOPWBÎÍPUBNCÏNBQSÏWJBBOVÐODJBEPDSFEPSQBSBB SFBMJ[BÎÍPEFOPWPOFHØDJPKVSÓEJDPTFSJBJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMFOUSFUBOUPTFFTUJWÏTTFNPT EJBOUFEBmHVSBEBUSBOTBÎÍPEPNFTNPNPEPBBOUFSJPSBDFJUBÎÍPEPDSFEPSTFSJB OFDFTTÈSJBQBSBRVFIBKBDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBTFOUSFBTQBSUFTBVUPSJ[BEBTQFMP"SU EP$ØEJHP$JWJM &BSSFNBUBBmSNBOEPRVF 'PSÎPTPSFDPOIFDFSFOUÍPRVFTFKBRVBMGPSBFTQÏDJFEFNPEBMJEBEF EFFYUJOÎÍPEFPCSJHBÎÍPFNRVFPBSU"EP$1$TFJODMVBIÈRVF TFUFSFNNFOUFRVFBTmHVSBKVSÓEJDBTUSBUBEBTOPDBNQPEP%JSFJUP $JWJMFYJHFNBQSÏWJBBDFJUBÎÍPEPDSFEPSQBSBRVFPOFHØDJPFYUJOUJWP TFBQFSGFJÎPF "JOEBPEPVUSJOBEPSSFTTBMUBRVFQPSTFUSBUBSEFNBUÏSJBRVFWFSTBTPCSF EJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTEJTQPOÓWFJTOÍPQPEFSJBP&TUBEPQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEPKVJ[iintervir na esfera de diretos do credor, retirando-lhe a prerrogativa de exigir seu crédito de imediato de forma integral, sob pena de flagrante ofensa ao direito de propriedade, constitucionalmente asseguradow *EFNMPDDJU 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUBSou obrigado a receber parceladamente o meu crédito em execução... 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUBSou obrigado a receber parceladamente o meu crédito em execução... *EFN*CJEFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 210 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga 1PSmNPBVUPSBMFHBRVFiem época em todos estimulam a composição amigável, visualizando que acordos são as melhores, mais rápidas e menos custosas formas de se colocar fim a um litígiowBENJUJSBQPTJUJWBÎÍPEFVNEJSFJUPEPEFWFEPSEFQBHBSTFV EÏCJUPQBSDFMBEBNFOUFTFNBDPODPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSÏBUPRVFTFPQÜFËUFOEÐODJB BUVBM QFMB CVTDB EF NFJPT BMUFSOBUJWPT EF TPMVÎÍP EPT DPOnJUPT BEWFSUJOEP BJOEB QFSTQJDB[NFOUFQBSBPGBUPEFRVFiquem em sã consciência vai querer honrar as suas obrigações na data do vencimento se for sabedor de que tem, no judiciário, a prerrogativa de pagar em seis parcelas o seu débitow &OFNQPEFSJBTFSEJGFSFOUFFJTRVFPQSØQSJPDPODFJUPEFMoratóriaQSFT TVQÜFBFYJTUÐODJBEFVNBUPWPMJUJWPEPDSFEPSDFSUPEFRVFNVJUPFNCPSBPJOTUJUV UPWJBCJMJ[FPQBHBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPEFNBOFJSBNFOPTPOFSPTBBPEFWFEPSBFYFDVÎÍP TFNQSFTFEFTFOWPMWFOPJOUFSFTTFEPDSFEPS "EFNBJTBOPSNBEP"SU"EP$1$ÏCFNDMBSBBPGBMBSFNQSPQPTUB WJEFf PRVFQSFTTVQÜFOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFVNBBDFJUBÎÍPEBPVUSBQBSUFSB[ÍP QFMBRVBMQPSNBJTFTTFNPUJWPPNBHJTUSBEPEFWFTFNQSFPVWJSPFYFRVFOUFRVF EFWFSÈBOVJSQBSBRVFIBKBPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPKÈRVFPDSFEPSOÍPFTUÈ PCSJHBEPBSFDFCFSTFVDSÏEJUPQPSQBSUFTTFBTTJNOÍPDPOWFODJPOPVPVDPOTFOUJV /PFOUBOUPDVNQSFEFTUBDBSQPSPQPSUVOPPQPOEFSBEPFOUFOEJNFOUPEF .JSOB$JBODJ %F PSEJOÈSJP QSFTVNJV B novel MFHJTMBÎÍP RVF TFSJB NBJT WBOUBKPTP BP DSFEPS SFDFCFS FN QBSDFMBT EP RVF BHVBSEBS P EFNPSBEP USÉNJUF EB FYFDVÎÍP "RVJ QBTTBNPT B DPOTJEFSBS RVF CBTFBEPT OB MFJUVSB DPOTUJUVDJPOBMEPQSPDFTTPFGFUJWJEBEFYNFOPSPOFSPTJEBEF IÈRVF TFSQSFTFSWBEPPequilíbrio da execuçãoEFTPSUFRVFDPOTVMUBEPPDSFEPS poderá afastar o pedido de parcelamento apenas e tão somente se apresentar pleito fundamentado.HSJGPOPTTP .BTQPSmNB1SPDVSBEPSBFTUBEVBMSFDPOIFDFRVFitratando-se de direito patrimonial, caberá exclusivamente ao credor dele dispor, da maneira que entender mais conveniente, nos limites da leiw *EFN*CJEFN .PSBUØSJB TFHVOEP EJDJPOÈSJP EB -ÓOHVB 1PSUVHVFTB TJHOJmDB QSPSSPHBÎÍP EF QSB[P RVF P DSFEPS DPODFEFBPEFWFEPSQBSBQBHBNFOUPEFVNBEÓWJEBIn%JDJPOÈSJP.FMIPSBNFOUPTQ $*"/$*.JSOB<FUBM>Comentários à execução Civil – Título judicial e ExtrajudicialQ $*"/$*.JSOB*CJEFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 211 4.4. Faculdade do Magistrado? /PPCTUBOUFPVUSBRVFTUÍPTVSHFQBSBBDPSSFUBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEPJOTUJUVUP TFQPEFSJBPØSHÍPKVMHBEPSNFTNPQSFTFOUFTUPEPTPTSFRVJTJUPTMFHBJTFEJBOUFEF VNBSFTQPTUBQPTJUJWBEPDSFEPSJOEFGFSJSBCFOFTTFEBNPSBUØSJBBPFYFDVUBEP $PTUB.BDIBEPBPBOBMJTBSPOPWFMJOTUJUVUPQSFTDSFWFRVF 1SPTTFHVJOEPOBEJTDJQMJOBEBNPSBUØSJBJOTUJUVÓEPQPSFTTFOPWPBSU " P QSFTFOUF EJTQPTJUJWP QSFWÐ JOJDJBMNFOUF B QPTTJCJMJEBEF EF EFGFSJNFOUP QFMP KVJ[ EB iQSPQPTUBw QSPQPTUB EF QBSDFMBNFOUP F BT EVBT DPOTFRVÐODJBT QSPDFTTVBJT EFTTF BUP EFGFSJUØSJP RVBJT TFKBN P MFWBOUBNFOUP EB JNQPSUÉODJB EFQPTJUBEB QPS QBSUF EP FYFRVFOUF F TVTQFOTÍP EB QSÈUJDB EF BUPT FYFDVUJWPT F mOBMNFOUF QSFWÐ B QPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJOEFGFSJNFOUPDVKPFGFJUPOBUVSBMÏPQSPTTFHVJNFOUP EBFYFDVÎÍPNBOUJEPPEFQØTJUPEJ[PUFYUP &DPODMVJBmSNBOEPRVF 7ÈSJBTPCTFSWBÎÜFTTFUPSOBNOFDFTTÈSJBT"QSJNFJSBFNBJTSFMFWBOUF DPODFSOFBPGBUPEFRVFFTUFfGBMBFYQSFTTBNFOUFEFiQSPQPTUBwP RVFOPTMFWBBQFOTBSRVFVNBDFSUBNBSHFNEFEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFÏ DPOGFSJEBBPKVJ[QBSBBWBMJBSBDPOWFOJÐODJBEPQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUP PRVFQÜFËTDMBSBTUBNCÏNBJEFJBEFRVFPEFGFSJNFOUPEBQSPQPTUB OÍPÏBVUPNÈUJDB &NQPTJÎÍPDPOUSÈSJB-VJ[(VJMIFSNF.BSJOPOJF%BOJFM.JUJEJFSPBDSFEJUBN RVFiatendidos todos os pressupostos, tem o juiz o dever de deferir o parcelamento. Nesse contexto, tem o executado direito ao parcelamento do valor em execuçãowBUÏQPSRVFBOPSNB JNQÜFQBSBPPGFSFDJNFOUPEBQSPQPTUBPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPDSÏEJUPFYFRVFOEP 1PSUBMSB[ÍPP"OUÙOJP$BSMPT.BSDBUUPÏDBUFHØSJDPFNBTTFWFSBSRVFio parcelamento na forma estabelecida no caput do Art. 745-A constitui um direito do executado e o juiz não pode recusá-lowSFTTBMUBOEPBJOEBRVFBQSPQPTUBFNNFMIPSFTDPO EJÎÜFTQBSBPFYFRVFOUFEBNFTNBNBOFJSBEFWFTFSBDFJUPQFMPKVJ[KÈRVFPJOUVJUP ."$)"%0"OUÙOJP$MÈVEJPEB$PTUBCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoFESFWFBUVBM#BSVFSJ &EJUPSB.BOPMFQ ."$)"%0"OUÙOJP$MÈVEJPEB$PTUBCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoFESFWFBUVBM#BSVFSJ &EJUPSB.BOPMFQ ."3*/0/*-VJ[(VJMIFSNF.*5*%*&*30%BOJFMCódigo de Processo Civil comentado artigo por artigo...Q ."3$"50"OUÙOJP$BSMPTCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 212 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga EBMFJÏKVTUBNFOUFBCSFWJBSBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPEPDSFEPSSB[ÍPQFMBRVBMFOUFOEF RVFDVJEPVPMFHJTMBEPSEFFTUBCFMFDFSSFRVJTJUPTNÓOJNPTQBSBPTFVEFGFSJNFOUP "TTJNTFOEPDPODPSEPDPN"MVJTJP*VOFT.POUJ3VHHFSJ3ÏBPBTTJOBMBSRVF iao juiz, por sua vez, somente lhe cabe averiguar se presentes estão os requisitos ao exercício dessa faculdade, não podendo indeferi-la injustificadamentew $PNFGFJUPOÍPÏEBEPBPNBHJTUSBEPEFTEFRVFQSFTFOUFTPTSFRVJTJUPTMFHBJT FIBWFOEPBDPODPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSJOEFGFSJSBQSFUFOTÍPEPEFWFEPSOÍPDPOmHV SBOEPOBIJQØUFTFQPEFSEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPEPØSHÍPQSPMBUPSKÈRVFVNEPTSFRVJTJUPT FTTFODJBJTQBSBPSFRVFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPÏPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBEÓWJEBPRVF JNQMJDBBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEFRVBMRVFSUJQPEFEFGFTBQFMPFYFDVUBEP 1PSJTTPOÍPTFSJBMFHÓUJNPQSFWFSVNBBMUFSOBUJWBBPEFWFEPSRVFJNQPS UBSJBFNSFOÞODJBBPTFVEJSFJUPEFEFGFTBNBTRVFQVEFTTFBPMJWSFBMWJUSFEPKVJ[ JOEFGFSJSBQSFUFOTÍPOÍPEFJYBOEPDPOUVEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPSÏVTFSFUSBUBSDPO TJEFSBOEPRVFKÈIPVWFPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBEÓWJEBTPCQFOBEFPGFOTBBPQSJODÓQJP EBBNQMBEFGFTBRVFÏVNQPTUVMBEPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFEFWFQSFWBMFDFSTPCSFBOPSNB JOGSBFTUBUVÓEBOP"SU"EP$1$4PNFOUFOFTTFTFOUJEPÏRVFTFQPEFEJ[FSRVF BNPSBUØSJBÏVNEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEPFYFDVUBEP )VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSUBNCÏNBEPUBPNFTNPSBDJPDÓOJPBPQSFTDSFWFS RVFinão se afigura, in casu, um poder discricionário do juiz diante do pedido de parcelamento. Presentes os requisitos legais, é direito do executado obtê-low $PSSPCPSBOEPFTTFFOUFOEJNFOUP4BSBI.FSÎPO7BSHBTSFHJTUSBRVF "ÞOJDBNBSHFNEFEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFEFJYBEBQFMPMFHJTMBEPSGPJBJOTUJUVÓEB OPDBQVUEPEJTQPTJUJWPRVFDPOGFSFBPFYFDVUBEPQPEFSFTQBSBFTDPMIFSTF QSFUFOEFFGFUVBSPQBHBNFOUPEFNBOFJSBQBSDFMBEBFWPMVOUÈSJBBJOEBRVF OÍPUPUBMNFOUFFTQPOUÉOFBPVTFQSFGFSFSFTJTUJSËFYFDVÎÍPQPSNFJPEBT PVUSBTBMUFSOBUJWBTQSPDFEJNFOUBJTRVFFTUJWFSFNBPTFVBMDBODF "MJÈTPQSØQSJPEJTQPTJUJWPFNDPNFOUPOPTFVQBSÈHSBGPQSJNFJSPQSFTDSF WFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBNPSBUØSJBTFSPVOÍPEFGFSJEB&TFÏBTTJNPNBJTMØHJDPÏRVF FTUBEFDJTÍPSFDBJBTPCSFPDSFEPSRVFÏPNBJPSJOUFSFTTBEPOBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSÏEJUP EFTPSUFRVFBFYFDVÎÍPTFEBSÈOBGPSNBQPSFMFFTDPMIJEB"TTJNÏRVFPVWJEPP FYFRVFOUFoRVFEFWFSÈSFQJUPDPODPSEBSDPNBQSFUFOTÍPoPKVJ[GBSÈPFYBNFEPT 3²"MVÓTJP*VOFT.POUJ3VHHFSJO Acesso à justiça do devedor de boa-fé: a atuação da Defensoria Pública na efetivação do direito ao pagamento parcelado... 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de direito processual civil: processo de execução e cumprimento da sentença, processo cautelar e tutela de urgência..7PMQ .&3±0/7"3("4 4BSBI A faculdade de parcelamento do valor da execução (art. 745-A): requisitos, procedimento e aplicabilidade... RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 213 SFRVJTJUPTQSFTDSJUPTOPEJTQPTJUJWPFTFQSFTFOUFTUFNPEFWFSEFEFGFSJSPQBSDFMB NFOUPmDBOEPBFYFDVÎÍPEFTEFFOUÍPTVTQFOTB 1PSmNDVNQSFSFTTBMUBSRVFPØSHÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMiexercendo seu poder geral de cautela, pode exigir alguma garantia, em razão da peculiar situação do executado71w 1PEFBEFNBJTEFGFSJSPCFOFGÓDJPTFDPOTUBUBSBUJUVEFBCVTJWBEPFYFRVFOUF/FTTF TFOUJEPDPOmSBQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEP45+ 130$&440 $*7*- 3&$6340 &41&$*"- $6.13*.&/50 %& 4&/5&/±"1"3$&-".&/50%07"-03&9&26&/%0"1-*$"±°0 %0"35"%0$1$1044*#*-*%"%&13*/$¶1*0%"&'&5*7*%"%& 130$&446"- "35 3 %0 $1$ "1-*$"±°0 46#4*%*«3*" )*1»5&4& %& 1"(".&/50 &410/5¬/&0 %0 %²#*50 /°0 */$*%³/$*" %" .6-5" 13&7*45" /0 "35 + f %0 $1$ )0/03«3*04 "%70$"5¶$*04 %" 0#3*("±°0 7&*$6-"%" /" 4&/5&/±"13*/$¶1*0%"/0/3&'03."5*0*/1&+647*0-"±°0 %04"354&%0$1$/°0$0/'*(63"%" <> 3. Não obstante, o parcelamento da dívida não é direito potestativo do devedor, cabendo ao credor impugná-lo, desde que apresente motivo justo e de forma fundamentada, sendo certo que o juiz poderá deferir o parcelamento se verificar atitude abusiva do exequente, uma vez que tal proposta é-lhe bastante vantajosa<> 3&TQ 3+ 3FM .JOJTUSP -6*4 '&-*1& 4"-0.°0 26"35" 563."KVMHBEPFN%+F HSJGPOPTTP 4.5. Aplicação do instituto na fase de cumprimento de sentença &NCPSBBGBDVMEBEFUSB[JEBOP"SU"EP$1$BQSJODÓQJPSFTUSJOKBBBQMJ DBCJMJEBEFEPJOTUJUVUPËFYFDVÎÍPEFUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPFYUSBKVEJDJBMNVJUPTFEJTDVUFTPCSF TVBJODJEÐODJBUBNCÏNOBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBFNSB[ÍPEBOPSNBQSFTDSJUB OP"SU3EP$1$RVFQFSNJUFBBQMJDBÎÍPTVCTJEJÈSJBOBRVFMBGBTFEBTSFHSBTQSF WJTUBTQBSBFYFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMOBRVJMPRVFOÍPGPSJODPNQBUÓWFM )VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSÏDBUFHØSJDPFNOÍPBENJUJSBBQMJDBÎÍPEBNP SBUØSJBKVEJDJBMOBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBKVTUJmDBOEPRVF %*%*&3+3'SFEJF<FUBM>É possível que o “favor legal” previsto no Art. 745-A (parcelamento do valor executado) seja invocado na etapa de cumprimento de sentença?#JCMJPUFDB%JHJUBM3FWJTUB#SBTJMFJSBEF%JSFJUP 1SPDFTTVBMo3#%1SP#FMP)PSJ[POUFBOPOKBONBS%JSFUPBPQPOUP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 214 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga <> OÍP UFSJB TFOUJEP CFOFmDJBS P EFWFEPS DPOEFOBOEP QPS TFOUFOÎB KVEJDJBM DPN OPWP QSB[P EF FTQFSB RVBOEP KÈ TF WBMFV EF UPEBT BT QPTTJCJMJEBEFT EF EJTDVTTÍP SFDVSTPT F EFMPOHBT EP QSPDFTTP EF DPOIFDJNFOUP4FSJBVNOPWPFQFTBEPÙOVTQBSBPDSFEPSRVFUFWFEF QFSDPSSFSBMPOHBFQFOPTBWJBDSVDJTEPQSPDFTTPDPOEFOBUØSJPUFSBJOEB RVFTVQPSUBSNBJTTFJTNFTFTQBSBUPNBSBTNFEJEBTKVEJDJBJTFYFDVUJWBT DPOUSBPEFWFEPSSFOJUFOUF0RVFKVTUJmDBBNPSBUØSJBEP"SU"Ï BTVBBQMJDBÎÍPOPJOÓDJPEPQSPDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPFYUSBKVEJDJBM 3FCBUFOEPFTTFBSHVNFOUP$BTTJP4DBSQJOFMMB#VFOPTBMJFOUBRVF B RVFTUÍP GPJ QPTUB QBSB P MFHJTMBEPS RVF FOUFOEFV TFS PQPSUVOP DPODFEFSBNPSBUØSJBQBSBPFYFDVUBEPDSJBOEPQBSBFMFVNBWFSEBEFJSB BMUFSOBUJWBQBSBTPMWJNFOUPEBEÓWJEB1BSBUBOUPFODBSSFHPVTFEFDSJBS DPOEJÎÜFTQBSBRVFBNFEJEBTFKBJOUFSFTTBOUFUBNCÏNQBSBPDSFEPS² FTTBBSB[ÍPQFMPRVBMPEJTQPTJUJWPQSFWÐBJODJEÐODJBEFKVSPTEFBP NÐTTFNQSFKVÓ[PEBDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBBMÏNEBNVMUBDPNQFOTBUØSJB FNDBTPEFOÍPQBHBNFOUPEFBMHVNBQBSDFMB"SU"DBQVUFf 5SBUBTFEFEJTQPTJUJWPQPSUBOUPRVFBPMIPTWJTUPTCVTDBDPODJMJBSPT JOUFSFTTFTDPOUSBQPTUPTEPFYFRVFOUFFEPFYFDVUBEP & DPODMVJ BmSNBOEP RVF ino prazo que o executado tem para apresentar a ‘impugnação’ de que tratam os Arts. 475-L e 475-M do Código de Processo Civil, ele poderá optar pela formulação do pedido do Art. 745-Aw .BOJGFTUBOEPTFQPTJUJWBNFOUF&EVBSEP+PTFEB'POTFDB$PTUBBOPUBRVF <> OÍP IÈ QMBVTJCJMJEBEF FN MJNJUBSTF JOTUJUVUP EP QBSDFMBNFOUP DPNQVMTØSJP B VN iHVFUP FTUBORVFw BDPSSFOUBOEP P TFV ÉNCJUP EF JODJEÐODJBËQBMBWSBiFNCBSHPTw"OPSNBEPBSUJHP"OÍPQPEF TJNQMFTNFOUFFYBVSJSTFOBMFUSBGSJBEPTFVUFYUPUPEBOPSNBÏGFOÙ NFOPtransproposicionalOÍPproposicional"MÏNEPNBJTOÍPWJTMVN CSPSB[ÍPQBSBPQBSDFMBNFOUPDPNQVMTØSJPTFSBENJUJEPOVNBNP EBMJEBEFFYFDVUØSJBFOÍPTFSOBPVUSBBFYFDVÎÍPMBTUSFBEBFNUÓUVMP FYUSBKVEJDJBMOÍPUFNRVBMRVFSRVJERVFKVTUJmRVFBEJGFSFODJBÎÍPP 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de direito processual civil: processo de execução e cumprimento da sentença, processo cautelar e tutela de urgência..7PMQ #6&/0$BTTJP4DBSQJOFMMB<FUBM>É possível que o “favor legal” previsto no art. 745-A (parcelamento do valor executado) seja invocado na etapa de cumprimento de sentença? #6&/0$BTTJP4DBSQJOFMMB<FUBM>É possível que o “favor legal” previsto no art. 745-A (parcelamento do valor executado) seja invocado na etapa de cumprimento de sentença?... RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 215 TFVEFWFEPSOÍPÏNBJTNFSFDFEPSEFGBWPSFTEPRVFPEFWFEPSOVN DVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB 3JOBMEP.PV[BMBTEF4PV[BF4JMWBPCTFSWBRVFPOPWFMJOTUJUVUPipouco se importou em dilatar a aplicação do instituto às demandas judiciais cognitivasw&OUSFUBOUP JOEPNBJTBMÏNPBVUPSEFGFOEFTVBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFJODMVTJWFOBTBÎÜFTEFDPCSBOÎB BJOEBOÍPKVMHBEBTFOUFOEFOEPRVF TFOEP B EFNBOEB EF OBUVSF[B DPHOJUJWB BDBTP P QSFUFOTP EFWFEPS SFDPOIFÎBPBMFHBEPDSÏEJUPOÍPIÈSB[ÍPQBSBOÍPMIFTFSDPODFEJEB BNPSBUØSJBEP"SU"EP$1$.PSNFOUFTFGPSDPOTJEFSBEPRVF TFOEPFMBBQMJDÈWFMËFYFDVÎÍPEFUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPFYUSBKVEJDJBMPOEF PDSÏEJUPÏMÓRVJEPDFSUPFFYJHÓWFM RVBMBSB[ÍPEFOÍPTFSBDSÏEJUP BJOEBOÍPDPOTUJUVÓEP &TFÏBTTJNNVJUPFNCPSBBEPVUSJOBKVTUJmRVFRVFOÍPGB[TFOUJEPDPODF EFSBPFYFDVUBEPPCFOFGÓDJPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPFJTRVFOBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEF TFOUFOÎBBEÓWJEBKÈGPJEFDMBSBEBQFMPØSHÍPKVEJDJBMBPDPOUSÈSJPEPRVFPDPSSFOP QSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPFNRVFFYFDVUBEPEFWFQSJNFJSPSFDPOIFDFSPWBMPSEFWJEPOÍP TFBOUFWÐRVBMRVFSFNQFDJMIPQBSBOÍPBQMJDBÎÍPEBOPSNBQSFTDSJUBOP"SU" EP$1$UBNCÏNËGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB 1SJNFJSP QPSRVF TF USBUB EF GBDVMEBEF EP EFWFEPS RVF QPEFSÈ PQUBS TF EFTFKBSFRVFSFSPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPWBMPSEFWJEPPVTFTVKFJUBSBPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPT FNBJTPDSFEPSDPNPKÈEFNPOTUSBEPUBNCÏNUFNQSFSSPHBUJWBEFBDFJUBSPVOÍP BQSPQPTUBPGFSFDJEBQFMPFYFDVUBEPDBCFOEPMIFEFDJEJSTPCSFBDPOWFOJÐODJBEF SFDFCFSTFVDSÏEJUPFNBUÏTFJTNFTFTPVQSPTTFHVJSOBUVSBMNFOUFOBGBTFEFDVN QSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB 4FHVOEPQPSRVFBOPWJEBEFBHSPTTPNPEPUSB[WBOUBHFOTQBSBBNCBTBT QBSUFTQPTUPRVFBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBEBNFTNBNBOFJSBRVFPGFJUP FYFDVUJWPDPMIFSÈios frutos de um desenvolvimento mais célere e menos imperativo, cuja conclusão posse ser alcançada sem que se tenha que levar a cabo qualquer ato constritivo ou expropriatório78w "EFNBJT3FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSB.BSUJOTSFTTBMUBRVF $045"&EVBSEP+PTÏEB'POTFDB<FUBM>Ibidem. 4*-7"3JOBMEP.PV[BMBTEF4PV[BFùA moratória do art. 745-A do CPC. Sua aplicação às demandas cognitivas condenatórias... ù *EFNMPDDJU .&3±0/7"3("4 4BSBI A faculdade de parcelamento do valor da execução (art. 745-A): requisitos, procedimento e aplicabilidade... RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 216 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga <> OFTTF DBTP P FYFRVFOUF FTUBSÈ OVNB QPTJÎÍP NBJT WBOUBKPTB FN SFMBÎÍP BP RVF PDPSSF OB FYFDVÎÍP EF UÓUVMP FYUSBKVEJDJBM QPJT P SFRVFSJNFOUP EF QBSDFMBNFOUP OP DVNQSJNFOUP EF TFOUFOÎB QSFTTVQÜFBFYJTUÐODJBEFQFOIPSB"TTJNDBTPPQBSDFMBNFOUPOÍPTFKB DVNQSJEP JOJDJBTF MPHP FN TFHVJEB B FYQSPQSJBÎÍP TFN FNCBSHP Ï DMBSPEBJODJEÐODJBEBNVMUBEFTPCSFPEÏCJUPFNBCFSUPQSFWJTUB OPfEP"SU" &OFNFYJTUFPCTUÈDVMPRVBOUPBPTEFNBJTQSFTTVQPTUPTQSFWJTUPTOBSFHSBEP "SU"EP$1$QPTUPRVFBQSPQPTUBEFQBSDFMBNFOUPQPEFQFSGFJUBNFOUFTFS QMFJUFBEBOPQSB[PQBSBPGFSFDJNFOUPEBJNQVHOBÎÍPEFRVFUSBUBPfEP"SU+ EP$1$JTUPÏOPTRVJO[FEJBTTFHVJOUFTËTVBJOUJNBÎÍPTPCSFBQFOIPSBFBWBMJBÎÍP FPEFQØTJUPEFEPWBMPSEFWJEPFGFUVBEPOPNFTNPBUPQSPDFTTVBM 1PSTVBWF[BKVSJTQSVEÐODJB80UBNCÏNOÍPÏVOÉOJNFTPCSFBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEP JOTUJUVUPEBNPSBUØSJBOBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB/ÍPPCTUBOUFSFQVUPJOFYJT ."35*/43FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSBO parcelamento do Art. 745-A, do CPC, no cumprimento de sentença... /PUBEBNFOUFOP5+41BRVFTUÍPÏCBTUBOUFEJWJEJEB iA moratória legal ou parcelamento do débito em até seis vezes, com depósito de trinta por cento, instituído pela Lei nº 11.383/2006, em vigor desde 7 de janeiro de 2007 e que acresceu o Art. 745-A e parágrafos ao Código de Processo Civil, diz respeito apenas à execução do título extrajudicial, não ao cumprimento de sentença.w "HSBWPEF*OTUSVNFOUPO3FMBUPS$FMTP1JNFOUBM$ÉNBSBEF%J SFJUP1SJWBEPK iEXECUÇÃO POR TÍTULO JUDICIAL. Pretensão da agravante de beneficiar-se com o parcelamento do débito previsto no Art. 745-A, do CPC. Admissibilidade. Hipótese em que o bem penhorado e posto a leilão supera em 35 vezes o valor da dívida. Proposta de parcelamento como medida razoável e adequada - Recurso providow"HSBWPEF*OTUSVNFOUPO3FMBUPS+#'SBODPEF(PEPJ $ÉNBSBEF%JSFJUP1SJWBEPK 04VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBOPFOUBOUPBENJUFBJODJEÐODJBEP"SU"EP$1$OBGBTFEFDVN QSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB 130$&440$*7*-3&$6340&41&$*"-$6.13*.&/50%&4&/5&/±"1"3$&-".&/50%0 7"-03 &9&26&/%0 "1-*$"±°0 %0 "35 " %0 $1$ 1044*#*-*%"%& 13*/$¶1*0 %" &'&5*7*%"%&130$&446"-"353%0$1$"1-*$"±°046#4*%*«3*")*1»5&4&%&1" (".&/50&410/5¬/&0%0%²#*50/°0*/$*%³/$*"%".6-5"13&7*45"/0"35+ f%0$1$)0/03«3*04"%70$"5¶$*04%&4$"#*.&/50"/5&0$6.13*.&/50&4 10/5¬/&0%"0#3*("±°07&*$6-"%"/"4&/5&/±"13*/$¶1*0%"/0/3&'03."5*0 */1&+647*0-"±°0%04"354&%0$1$/°0$0/'*(63"%" "WJPMBÎÍPBPT"SUTFEP$1$OÍPGPJDPOmHVSBEBVNBWF[RVFP5SJCVOBMEFPSJHFN FNCPSBTVDJOUBNFOUFQSPOVODJPVTFEFGPSNBDMBSBFTVmDJFOUFTPCSFBRVFTUÍPQPTUBOPTBVUPTTFO EPDFSUPRVFPNBHJTUSBEPOÍPFTUÈJNQFMJEPBSFCBUFSVNBVNPTBSHVNFOUPTUSB[JEPTQFMBQBSUFTF PTGVOEBNFOUPTVUJMJ[BEPTGPSBNTVmDJFOUFTQBSBFNCBTBSBEFDJTÍP "FGFUJWJEBEFEPQSPDFTTPDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPEFUVUFMBEFEJSFJUPTÏPQSJODJQBMEFTJEFSBUPEBTSFGPSNBT QSPDFTTVBJTFOHFOESBEBTQFMBT-FJTOFO0"SU3EP$1$FYQSFTTB NFOUFQSFWÐBBQMJDBÎÍPTVCTJEJÈSJBEBTOPSNBTRVFSFHFNPQSPDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPEFUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBM OBRVJMPRVFOÍPDPOUSBSJBSPSFHSBNFOUPEPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBTFOEPDFSUBBJOFYJTUÐODJBEF ØCJDF SFMBUJWP Ë OBUVSF[B EP UÓUVMP KVEJDJBM RVF JNQPTTJCJMJUF B BQMJDBÎÍP EB OPSNB FN DPNFOUP OFN NFTNPJODPNQBUJCJMJEBEFMFHBM1PSUBOUPPQBSDFMBNFOUPEBEÓWJEBQPEFTFSSFRVFSJEPUBNCÏNOBGBTF EFDVNQSJNFOUPEBTFOUFOÎBEFOUSPEPQSB[PEFEJBTQSFWJTUPOP"SU+DBQVUEP$1$ /ÍPPCTUBOUFPQBSDFMBNFOUPEBEÓWJEBOÍPÏEJSFJUPQPUFTUBUJWPEPEFWFEPSDBCFOEPBPDSFEPS JNQVHOÈMPEFTEFRVFBQSFTFOUFNPUJWPKVTUPFEFGPSNBGVOEBNFOUBEBTFOEPDFSUPRVFPKVJ[QP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 217 UJSNPUJWPTQBSBTFBEPUBSQPTJÎÍPUÍPSFTUSJUJWBTFBBDFJUBÎÍPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPOPmOBM SFDBJTPCSFPDSFEPSRVFÏPNBJPSJOUFSFTTBEPFNTBUJTGB[FSNBJTSBQJEBNFOUFPTFV DSÏEJUPFTQFDJBMNFOUFQPSRVFIÈQFSNJTTJWPMFHBMRVFSFNFUFBQMJDBÎÍPTVCTJEJÈSJBEBT EJTQPTJÎÜFTRVFSFHFNPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPËGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB "MÏNEJTTPBQMJDBSPNFDBOJTNPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPUBNCÏNËFTTB GBTFÏQSFTUJHJBSP1SJODÓQJPEB&GFUJWJEBEFEBKVSJTEJÎÍPEFNPEPBPCUFSVNSFTVM UBEPDPODSFUPNBJTDÏMFSFBPDSFEPSRVFÏBTBUJTGBÎÍPEFTFVDSÏEJUPPQÎÍPRVFTFSÈ QPSFMFNFTNPFTDPMIJEB&TTFÏPFOUFOEJNFOUPEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB 5. DEFESA DO EXECUTADO DIANTE DA MORATÓRIA DO ART. 745-A DO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL 7JVTFRVFBOPSNBFTUBUVÓEBOPBSU"EP$1$QSFWÐVNBFTQÏDJFEF QBSDFMBNFOUPEPWBMPSFYFRVFOEPEFTEFRVFPEFWFEPSPQUFQPSFTTBWJBEFQBHB NFOUPFBUFOEBPTSFRVJTJUPTQSFWJTUPTOPEJTQPTJUJWPFOUSFFMFTPSFDPOIFDJNFOUP EPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUFDPOGPSNFEJTQPTJÎÍPFYQSFTTBEBMFJ &OUSFUBOUPQPSOÍPTFUSBUBSEFEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEPEFWFEPSKÈRVFTFVEF GFSJNFOUPQSFTTVQÜFBBOVÐODJBEPDSFEPSOFDFTTÈSJPUSBÎBSPTDPOUPSOPTEPTFVJO EFGFSJNFOUPFJTRVFBQSJODÓQJPBOPSNBWFEBBBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTTFOEP RVFOVNBMFJUVSBNBJTEFTBUFOUBBDBCBSJBUPMIFOEPPEJSFJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEPDPO USBEJUØSJPFBNQMBEFGFTBEPFYFDVUBEPRVFOÍPÏPPCKFUJWPEBMFJ EFSÈEFGFSJSPQBSDFMBNFOUPTFWFSJmDBSBUJUVEFBCVTJWBEPFYFRVFOUFVNBWF[RVFUBMQSPQPTUBÏMIF CBTUBOUFWBOUBKPTBBQBSUJSEPNPNFOUPFNRVFQPEFSÈMFWBOUBSJNFEJBUBNFOUFPEFQØTJUPSFMBUJWPBPT EPWBMPSFYFRVFOEPFBJOEBFNDBTPEFJOBEJNQMFNFOUPFYFDVUBSBEJGFSFOÎBIBKBWJTUBRVFBT QBSDFMBTTVCTFRVFOUFTTÍPBVUPNBUJDBNFOUFBOUFDJQBEBTFÏJOFYJTUFOUFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJNQVHOBÎÍP QFMPEFWFEPSOPTUFSNPTEPTffFEP"SU" $BSBDUFSJ[BEPPQBSDFMBNFOUPDPNPUÏDOJDBEFDVNQSJNFOUPFTQPOUÉOFPEBPCSJHBÎÍPmYBEBOBTFO UFOÎBFGSVUPEPFYFSDÓDJPEFGBDVMEBEFMFHBMEFTDBCFBJODJEÐODJBEBNVMUBDBMDBEBOPJOBEJNQMFNFOUP "SU+EP$1$ TFOEPDFSUPRVFPJOEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPQFMPKVJ[SFOEFFOTFKPËJODJEÐODJBEB QFOBMJEBEFVNBWF[DPOmHVSBEPPJOBEJNQMFNFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍPBJOEBRVFPQFEJEPUFOIBTJEPJOTUSV ÓEPDPNPDPNQSPWBOUFEPEFQØTJUPEFWFOEPQSPTTFHVJSBFYFDVÎÍPQFMPWBMPSSFNBOFTDFOUF /PDBTPTPCFYBNFBEFTQFJUPEBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEFSFDVTBEPSFDPSSFOUFn P+VÓ[PEFGFSJVPQF EJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPBOUFBTVBUFNQFTUJWJEBEFFBFGFUVBÎÍPEPEFQØTJUPEFJODMVTJWFDPOTJHOBOEP PBEJNQMFNFOUPUPUBMEBEÓWJEBn SFTTPBOEPJOFRVÓWPDPPEFTDBCJNFOUPEBNVMUBQMFJUFBEB "$PSUF&TQFDJBMQPSPDBTJÍPEPKVMHBNFOUPEP3&TQ4$TFEJNFOUPVPFOUFOEJNFOUPEFRVF OBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBIBWFOEPPBEJNQMFNFOUPFTQPOUÉOFPEPEFWFEPSOPQSB[PmYBEPOP "SU+EP$1$OÍPTÍPEFWJEPTIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTVNBWF[EFTOFDFTTÈSJBBQSÈUJDBEFRVBJTRVFSBUPT UFOEFOUFTËTBUJTGBÎÍPGPSÎBEBEPKVMHBEP/PDBTPDPODSFUPQPSÏNDPORVBOUPUFOIBTFDBSBDUFSJ[BEPPDVN QSJNFOUPFTQPOUÉOFPEBEÓWJEBPUSJCVOBMDPOEFOPVBSFDPSSJEBBPQBHBNFOUPEFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTP RVFFNGBDFEFSFDVSTPFYDMVTJWPEPFYFRVFOUFOÍPQPEFTFSTFSBGBTUBEPTPCQFOBEFSFGPSNBUJPJOQFKVT 3FDVSTPFTQFDJBMOÍPQSPWJEP 3&TQ3+3FM.JOJTUSP-6*4'&-*1&4"-0.°026"35"563."KVMHBEPFN %+F RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 218 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga 5.1. Reconhecimento jurídico do pedido O caputEP"SU"EP$1$FTUBCFMFDFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFPEFWFEPSOP QSB[PQBSBFNCBSHPTQBSDFMBSPEÏCJUPEFTEFRVFSFDPOIFÎBPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUF FRVFOPTFOTJOBNFOUPTEF"OUÙOJP$BSMPT.BSDBUUPiequivale a um reconhecimento jurídico do pedido e impede a futura apresentação de defesa por parte do executado, a não ser que haja alguma circunstância superveniente a tal reconhecimentow &EVBSEP "SSVEB "MWJN FYQMJDB RVF P SFDPOIFDJNFOUP KVSÓEJDP EP QFEJEP OÍPTJHOJmDBRVFio réu tenha aceitado a versão dos fatos tais como narrados pelo autor, mas a aceitação das consequências jurídicas que pretende, a parte contrária, extrair desses mesmos fatosw $PNFGFJUPUPEPTPTEPVUSJOBEPSFTTÍPVOÉOJNFTFNBmSNBSRVFBFTDPMIB QFMPQBSDFMBNFOUPUFNPDPOEÍPEFJNQFEJSBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTRVFTUÍPFTTB BCPSEBEBDPNNVJUBQSPQSJFEBEFQPS+BOFUF3JDLFO-PQFTEF#BSSPT "P PQUBS QFMP QBSDFMBNFOUP P FYFDVUBEP OÍP QPEFSÈ PQPS FNCBSHPT Ë FYFDVÎÍP VNB WF[ RVF TF DPOmHVSB BUP JODPNQBUÓWFM DPN P SFDPOIFDJNFOUPKVSÓEJDPEPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUFPDPSSFOEPBmHVSB EBQSFDMVTÍPMØHJDB"QSFTFOUFWFEBÎÍPFTUÈFYQSFTTBOBQBSUFmOBMEP fEP"SU"FUFNSFMBÎÍPDPNPQSJODÓQJPivinere contra factum propriumwRVFUSBUBEBQSPJCJÎÍPOPQSPDFTTPDJWJMEFDPNQPSUBNFOUP DPOUSBEJUØSJPCFNDPNPEBCPBGÏPCKFUJWBFDPOmBOÎB ²DMBSPRVFBWFEBÎÍPEFJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTOÍPBUJOHFNBUÏSJBEF PSEFN QÞCMJDB UBM DPNP EFGFOEF 4BSBI .FSÎPO7BSHBT RVF BmSNB TFS itotalmente razoável que venha se insurgir, por exemplo, contra penhora que tenha recaído sobre bem impenhorável ou que, de qualquer maneira, exceda às balizas do princípio do menor sacrifício possívelw .BTIBWFOEPPJOEFGFSJNFOUPEPCFOFGÓDJPQSFWJTUPOP"SU"EP$1$ PRVFBDPOUFDFDPNPEJSFJUPEPEFWFEPSRVFSFDPOIFDFVPDSFEJUPEPFYFRVFOUF RVFOBTMJÎÜFTEPTEPVUSJOBEPSFTFRVJWBMFSJBBVNSFDPOIFDJNFOUPKVSÓEJDPEPQF EJEPDPNBQSPJCJÎÍPEFPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPT ."3$"50"OUÙOJP$BSMPTCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoQ "-7*.&EVBSEP"SSVEBDireito Processual CivilFESFGPSNBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3F WJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQ #"3304+BOFUF3JDLFO-PQFTEFDa possibilidade de aplicação do Art. 745-A do CPC na Ação Monitória. $MVCKVT#SBTÓMJB%'GFW .&3±0/7"3("4 4BSBI A faculdade de parcelamento do valor da execução (art. 745-A): requisitos, procedimento e aplicabilidade... RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 219 5.2. Indeferimento e o manejo dos embargos à execução -BOÎBEBBJOEBHBÎÍPDVNQSFMFNCSBSEFJOÓDJPRVFPEJTQPTJUJWPGBMBFNQSP QPTUBPRVFQSFTTVQÜFVNBBDFJUBÎÍPEBQBSUFDPOUSÈSJB"JOEBPUFYUPMFHBMGB[SFGFSÐODJB BPEFGFSJNFOUPFJOEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPQSFWFOEPDBNJOIPTEJWFSTPTQBSBDBEBTJUVB ÎÍPSB[ÍPQFMBRVBMPVUSBDPODMVTÍPOÍPTFQPEFDIFHBSBOÍPTFSBEFRVFEFQFOEFOEP EPQSPWJNFOUPKVSJTEJDJPOBMBSFQFSDVTTÍPEPJOTUJUVUPOPTJTUFNBKVSÓEJDPTFSÈEJGFSFOUF 0DPSSFRVFFNOÍPSBSBTWF[FTNFTNPSFDPOIFDFOEPPWBMPSEFWJEPPEFWF EPSQPEFOÍPDPODPSEBSDPNPNPOUBOUFRVFFTUÈTFOEPFYFDVUBEPEJTDPSEBOEPTPCSF PWBMPSEPTBDFTTØSJPTEBEÓWJEBPVNFTNPPUFSNPJOJDJBMEFBMHVNEPTDPOTFDUÈSJPT MFHBJT FUD NBT NFTNP BTTJN PQUB QFMP QBSDFMBNFOUP QPS KVMHBS TFS P NPEP NBJT TVBWFEFTBMEBSBEÓWJEBBMÏNEFFWJUBSFWFOUVBMDPOTUSJÎÍPOBTVBFTGFSBQBUSJNPOJBM /ÍPPCTUBOUFBBDFJUBÎÍPEBQSPQPTUBGPSNVMBEBQFMPEFWFEPSEFWFQBTTBS QFMPDSJWPEPDSFEPSRVFUFNBQSFSSPHBUJWBEFDPODPSEBSPVOÍPDPNPQBSDFMBNFO UPPGFSFDJEPQFMPFYFDVUBEP)BWFOEPBOVÐODJBPQFEJEPTFSÈEFGFSJEPQFMPNBHJT USBEPPRVBMEFUFSNJOBSÈBTVTQFOTÍPEPGFJUPFYFDVUJWPBUÏPQBHBNFOUPEPWBMPS SFNBOFTDFOUFOPQSB[PEPQBSDFMBNFOUP .BTTFBPDPOUSÈSJPIPVWFSBEJTDPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSIJQØUFTFFNRVFP QFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPTFSÈJOEFGFSJEPPRVFBDPOUFDFSÈDPNPEFWFEPSRVFSFDP OIFDFVBEÓWJEBNBTOÍPMIFGPJEFGFSJEPTFVQFEJEPEFQBSDFMBNFOUP "OUFWFOEP VNB TJUVBÎÍP DPNP FTTB -VJ[ (VJMIFSNF EB $PTUB 8BHOFS +S TVTUFOUBRVF <>DBTPIBKBPJOEFGFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPQBSBRVFPEFWFEPSOÍP mRVFFNVNBTJUVBÎÍPBCTPMVUBNFOUFEFTQSJWJMFHJBEBKÈRVFIPVWFSB MFHJUJNBNFOUFBQPTUBEPOBDPODFTTÍPEPCFOFGÓDJP BMHVNBTQPTUVSBT EFWFN TFS FOUFOEJEBT DPNP EFDPSSFOUFT EP GBUP BJOEB RVF OÍP IBKB QSFWJTÍPMFHBMFYQSFTTBOFTTFTFOUJEP /FTTFEJBQBTÍPUFOEPTJEPGFJUPBQSPQPTUBFSFTUBOEPBNFTNBJOEFGFSJEBQFMP ØSHÍPKVMHBEPSOBEBNBJTKVTUPRVFIBKBBEFTDPOTJEFSBÎÍPEPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBEÓ WJEBGBDVMUBOEPBPFYFDVUBEPFWFOUVBMNFOUFEJTDVUJSWBMPSFTRVFQPEFSJBUFSTJEPTV QFSBEPDBTPIPVWFTTFVNBSFTPMVÎÍPDPOTFOTVBMDPNPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUP "TTJNTFOEPEJTDPSEPEF3PESJHP.B[[FJRVBOEPBmSNBRVFPSFDPOIFDJ NFOUPEPDSÏEJUPQSPEV[FGFJUPEFTEFPNPNFOUPFNRVFDSBWBEPOPTBVUPTKÈRVF SFnFUJSJBVNBPQÎÍPMJWSFEPFYFDVUBEPFYFSDJEBOPÉNCJUPEFTVBEJTQPOJCJMJEBEF. 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUBSou obrigado a receber parceladamente o meu crédito em execução... .";;&*3PESJHPOpção do executado em pagar parceladamente a dívida executada...Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 220 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga /BWFSEBEFIBWFOEPSFRVFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUPPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEP EÏCJUPTØTFSJBFmDB[DPNBBOVÐODJBEPDSFEPSFPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPIJQØUFTF FNRVFPEFWFEPSmDBSJBJNQFEJEPEFPGFSFDFSDPOKVOUBNFOUFRVBMRVFSPVUSPNFJP EFEFGFTB$POUVEPOÍPUFOEPPDSFEPSDPODPSEBEPDPNBQSPQPTUBPQSB[PQBSB FNCBSHBSEFWFTFSEFWPMWJEPBPFYFDVUBEPRVFQPEFSÈFYFSDJUBSTFVEJSFJUPEFEFGFTB DPNPQSFTDSFWFPNBOEBNFOUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM /FTTFTFOUJEPÏPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEF-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUB8BHOFS " QBSUJS EBT QSFNJTTBT BDJNB TVTUFOUBNPT RVF P SFDPOIFDJNFOUP EP EÏCJUP Ï QSPWJEÐODJB BUSFMBEB Ë DPODFTTÍP EP QBSDFMBNFOUP PV TFKB UFNPT EF BENJUJS RVF P EFWFEPS TPNFOUF BDFJUBSJB QBHBS P RVF MIF Ï BQSFTFOUBEP TFN FOTFKBS RVBMRVFS EJTDVTTÍP DBTP MIF TFKB EFGFSJEP P QBSDFMBNFOUP <> "P DPOUSÈSJP TF QPS RVBMRVFS SB[ÍP P SFGFSJEP CFOFGÓDJP MIF GPS OFHBEP DPNP QPS FYFNQMP RVBOEP P DSFEPS OÍP BDFJUBS SFDFCFS TFV DSÏEJUP FN QBSDFMBT UFNTF DPNP TFN FGFJUP P SFDPOIFDJNFOUPEBEÓWJEBQPTTJCJMJUBOEPTFBTTJNBPEFWFEPSTFTFSWJS EF RVBMRVFS FTUSBUÏHJB QSPDFTTVBM DPNP BQSFTFOUBÎÍP EF FNCBSHPT KÈ RVF OÍP UFSÈ B TFV GBWPS B BVUPSJ[BÎÍP QBSB RVJUBÎÍP QBSDFMBEB EP NPOUBOUFFYJHJEPQFMPFYFRVFOUF %FTUBSUFQPEFTFEJ[FSRVFPPGFSFDJNFOUPEBQSPQPTUBEFQBSDFMBNFOUPUFN iforça para interromper o prazo para a propositura de embargos, sendo restituído em sua integralidade ao interessado caso reste indeferido o benefíciow 6NFOUFOEJNFOUPBPDPOUSÈSJPJNQPSUBSJBFNDFSDFBNFOUPEFEFGFTBEPEF WFEPSBMÏNEFTFSNBJTWBOUBKPTPBPDSFEPSKÈRVFUFOEPPFYFDVUBEPSFDPOIFDJEPB EÓWJEBCBTUBSJBOÍPDPODPSEBSDPNPQBSDFMBNFOUPQBSBRVFPKVJ[JOEFmSBPQFEJEP EBNPSBUØSJBNVJUPFNCPSBDPMIFOEPPTGSVUPTEPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPQFEJEPoRVFS TFKBBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPFYFDVUBEPPGFSFDFSEFGFTBDPOUSBBQSFUFOTÍPFYFDVUJWBoP RVFOÍPTFQPEFQFSNJUJSBUÏQPSRVFOÍPÏFTTFPJOUVJUPEBOPSNB %FTTBGPSNBBRVFTUÍPQSJNPSEJBMmDBSÈOBTNÍPTEPDSFEPSNBJPSJOUFSFT TBEPBRVFNDPNQFUJSÈEFDJEJSBDFJUBSBNPSBUØSJBFSFDFCFSTFVDSÏEJUPQBSDFMBEP PVFOUÍPSFKFJUBSBQSPQPTUBFQSPTTFHVJSOBFYFDVÎÍPDPNUPEPTPTNFJPTEFEFGFTBT QPTTÓWFJTBPFYFDVUBEP0RVFOÍPTFQPEFBENJUJSÏPVJNQPSVNBBOVÐODJBPCSJHB UØSJBBPDSFEPSPVUPMIFSPEJSFJUPEFEFGFTBEPEFWFEPSBPSFDPOIFDFSBEÓWJEBNBT mDBOEPBPBMWJUSFEPDSFEPSPVKVJ[ PEFGFSJNFOUPEBQSPQPTUBDVKPJOEFGFSJNFOUP MIFTFSJBNBJTWBOUBKPTP 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUB*CJEFN *EFN*CJEFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 221 6. MORATÓRIA NO NOVO PROJETO DO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL "JOEBFNGBTFEFFMBCPSBÎÍPP1SPKFUPEF-FJORVFDVJEBEB 3FGPSNBEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMEBNFTNBGPSNBRVFPBOUFSJPSDPOUFNQMPV PJOTUJUVUPEBNPSBUØSJBKVEJDJBMBHPSBQSFWJTUPOP-JWSP***RVFUSBUBEP1SPDFTTPEF &YFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPFYUSBKVEJDJBM 1PVRVÓTTJNBTGPSBNBTBMUFSBÎÜFTPQFSBEBTOPEJTQPTJUJWPBTRVBJTTFDPO DFOUSBNNBJTOBSFEBÎÍPEPRVFOBTVBFTTÐODJBDPOGPSNFEFTUBRVFBCBJYPQBTTBO EPBNPSBUØSJBMFHBMTFSSFHJEBQFMP"SUDPNPTFHVJOUFUFPS "SU/PQSB[PQBSBFNCBSHPTSFDPOIFDFOEPPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUF FDPNQSPWBOEPPEFQØTJUPEFUSJOUBQPSDFOUPEPWBMPSFNFYFDVÎÍP JODMVTJWFDVTUBTFIPOPSÈSJPTEFBEWPHBEPPFYFDVUBEPQPEFSÈSFRVFSFS TFKBBENJUJEPBQBHBSPSFTUBOUFFNBUÏTFJTQBSDFMBTNFOTBJTBDSFTDJEBT EFDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBFKVSPTEFVNQPSDFOUPBPNÐT f4FOEPBQSPQPTUBEFGFSJEBQFMPKVJ[PFYFRVFOUFMFWBOUBSÈBRVBOUJB EFQPTJUBEBFTFSÍPTVTQFOTPTPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPTDBTPsejaJOEFGFSJEB TFHVJSTFÍPPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPTNBOUJEPPEFQØTJUP f 0 OÍP QBHBNFOUP EF RVBMRVFS EBT prestações acarretará cumulativamente I -PWFODJNFOUPEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTTVCTFRVFOUFTFPQSPTTFHVJNFOUPEP QSPDFTTPDPNPJNFEJBUPJOÓDJPEPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPT II - a imposiçãoBPFYFDVUBEPEFNVMUBEFEF[QPSDFOUPTPCSFPWBMPS EBTQSFTUBÎÜFTOÍPQBHBT § 3º A opção pelo parcelamento de que trata este artigo importa renúncia ao direito de oporFNCBSHPTHSJGPOPTTP 6NB QFOB P MFHJTMBEPS OÍP UFS EBEP BUFOÎÍP FTQFDJBM BP JOTUJUVUP UFOUBO EPTBOBSWÈSJBTRVFTUÜFTDPOUSPWFSUJEBTRVFJNQFSBNOBEPVUSJOBFKVSJTQSVEÐODJB MJNJUBOEPTFBSFQFUJSPDPOUFÞEPEBOPSNBBOUFSJPSTFNTFQSFPDVQBSFNDPOTUBS FYQSFTTBNFOUFBEFT OFDFTTJEBEFEBDPODPSEÉODJBEPDSFEPSTFQPEFSJBPNBHJTUSB EPJOEFGFSJSPQMFJUPFYFSDFOEPTFVQPEFSHFSBMEFDBVUFMBPVTFDPOmHVSBSJBEJSFJUP TVCKFUJWPEPEFWFEPSOFNTFRVFSQSFWFOEPPPGFSFDJNFOUPEFRVBMRVFSDBVÎÍPEF NPEPBEFNPOTUSBSBCPBGÏPCKFUJWBEPFYFDVUBEPFNDVNQSJSQPSJOUFJSPPQBSDF MBNFOUPRVFQSPQÙTFNBJTTFBOPSNBUBNCÏNUFSJBBMDBODFËGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUP EFTFOUFOÎBFJTRVFEBNFTNBGPSNBRVFP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMWJHFOUFIÈ SFGFSÐODJBHFOÏSJDBTPCSFBBQMJDBÎÍPTVCTJEJÈSJBEBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTRVFSFHFNP-JWSP*** UBNCÏNBP-JWSP*F**FWJDFWFSTB QPSÏNDPNBSFTTBMWBino que couberwUSBEV[JEB OPBSUEP/PWP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM "TTJN TFOEP DPODPSEP DPN -VJ[ (VJMIFSNF EB $PTUB 8BHOFS +VOJPS BP PGFSFDFSPVUSBSFEBÎÍPBPEJTQPTJUJWP$POmSB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 222 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga 6.1. SUGESTÃO DE LEGE FERENDA 0DJUBEPBVUPSivisando compatibilizar os eventuais benefícios que a concessão do parcelamento poderá trazer a um processo executivo com o sagrado direito do credor de não se obrigado a receber em partes aquilo que ajustou por inteirowTVHFSFEFlege ferenda BTFHVJOUFSFEBÎÍP "SU " o 0 QSB[P EPT FNCBSHPT TFSÈ JOUFSSPNQJEP DBTP P FYFDVUBEP OPT USÐT QSJNFJSPT EJBT SFRVFJSB TFKB BENJUJEP B QBHBS QBSDFMBEBNFOUF P WBMPS JOUFHSBM EP EÏCJUP BQPOUBEP OB JOJDJBM FN BUÏ TFJT QBSDFMBT NFOTBJT BDSFTDJEBT EF DPSSFÎÍP NPOFUÈSJB F KVSPT EF VN QPS DFOUP BP NÐT TFOEP B QSJNFJSB QBSDFMB OP JNQPSUFEFUSJOUBQPSDFOUP EPWBMPSFYFDVUBEPBDSFTDJEBEB JOUFHSBMJEBEFEPSFFNCPMTPEBTDVTUBTFEPTIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPT mYBEPTQFMPKVÓ[P fo$PODFEJEPPQSB[PEFDJODPEJBTQBSBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEPDSFEPS IBWFOEP B TVB FYQSFTTB DPODPSEÉODJB DPN B QSPQPTUB PV BJOEB OB IJQØUFTF EF TFV TJMÐODJP P QBSDFMBNFOUP TFSÈ EFGFSJEP F P FYFDVUBEP EFWFSÈ FGFUVBS P EFQØTJUP EB QSJNFJSB QBSDFMB OP QSB[P EF IPSBT WJOUF F RVBUSP TPC QFOB EF SFWPHBÎÍP EP CFOFGÓDJP BVUPSJ[BEP P FYFRVFOUFBQSPDFEFSPMFWBOUBNFOUPJNFEJBUPEBRVBOUJBEFQPTJUBEB TVTQFOEFOEPTFPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPT fo0OÍPQBHBNFOUPEFRVBMRVFSEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTJNQMJDBSÈEFQMFOP EJSFJUPPWFODJNFOUPEBTTVCTFRVFOUFTFPQSPTTFHVJNFOUPEPQSPDFTTP DPNPJNFEJBUPJOÓDJPEPTBUPTFYFDVUJWPTJNQPTUBBPFYFDVUBEPNVMUB EFEF[QPSDFOUP TPCSFPWBMPSEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTOÍPQBHBTFWFEBEB BPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPT f o 4F OP QSB[P EF DJODP EJBT RVF MIF GPSB DPODFEJEP P DSFEPS NBOJGFTUBSTVBSFDVTBFNSFDFCFSFNQBSDFMBTTFVDSÏEJUPTFSÈPQFEJEP EF QBSDFMBNFOUP JOEFGFSJEP F B FYFDVÎÍP QSPTTFHVJSÈ OPSNBMNFOUF SFTUJUVJOEPTFBPEFWFEPSBJOUFHSBMJEBEFEPQSB[PQBSBBBQSFTFOUBÎÍP EFFNCBSHPT fo/ÍPTFBQMJDBPEJTQPTUPOPDBQVUEFTUFBSUJHPQBSBBTIJQØUFTFT EFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUBSou obrigado a receber parceladamente o meu crédito em execução... 8"(/&3+6/*03-VJ[(VJMIFSNFEB$PTUBSou obrigado a receber parceladamente o meu crédito em execução... RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 223 "NFVWFSBSFEBÎÍPEPBSUJHPMBOÎBEBQFMPEPVUSJOBEPSDPOTFHVFSFTPMWFS B NBJPSJB EBT DPOUSPWÏSTJBT RVF HJSBN FN UPSOP EB BQMJDBCJMJEBEF EP JOTUJUVUP BP NFTNPUFNQPFNRVFDPNQBUJCJMJ[BBCFOFTTFDPODFEJEBBPEFWFEPSBPJOUFSFTTFEP DSFEPSTFNRVFIBKBEFUSJNFOUPEPEJSFJUPEFVNTPCSFPPVUSP &OUSFUBOUPPVTPEJTDPSEBSEPKVSJTUBBQFOBTOVNBTQFDUPBJOBQMJDBCJMJEBEF EBNPSBUØSJBOBGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBQPTUPRVFPNFVFOUFOEJNFOUP ÏOPTFOUJEPEFTFSQFSGFJUBNFOUFQPTTÓWFMQPTUVMBSPSFRVFSJNFOUPEPQBSDFMBNFOUP EFOUSP EP QSB[P EF JNQVHOBÎÍP DPOGPSNF KÈ FYQPTUP BOUFSJPSNFOUF FJT RVF UBM DPNPEFGFOEFPBVUPSDPSSPCPSBEPQFMBQSFWJTÍPFYQSFTTBEFTUBSFEBÎÍPPEFGFSJ NFOUPEPCFOFGÓDJPÏDPOEJDJPOBEBËBOVÐODJBEPDSFEPSOÍPIBWFOEPTFOUJEPFN OÍPBQMJDBSPJOTUJUVUPUBNCÏNËGBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBTFBTTJNPFYF RVFOUFEFTFKBS 7. CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS 0BEWFOUPEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOQSPNPWFVVNBSFGPSNVMB ÎÍPOP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMJOTUJUVJOEPFOUSFPVUSPTNFDBOJTNPTEFDFMFSJEBEF P"SU"DSJBOEPBmHVSBEBmoratória judicial&TUFJOTUJUVUPWJTBEBSFGFUJWJEBEF ËQSFTUBÎÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMBPQSFWFSVNBFTQÏDJFEFQBSDFMBNFOUPEPWBMPSFYFRVFO EPJODFOUJWBOEPPFYFDVUBEPBQBHBSPTFVEÏCJUPTFNRVFIBKBNBJPSFTEJTDVTTÍP TPCSF P UÓUVMP FYFDVUJWP FYUSBKVEJDJBM BOUF B WFEBÎÍP FYQSFTTB EF JOUFSQPTJÎÍP EF FNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP 1BSBRVFIBKBEFGFSJNFOUPEPCFOFGÓDJPQFSGFJUBNFOUFDBCÓWFMJODMVTJWFFN GBTFEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBPEFWFEPSEFWFQSFFODIFSPTSFRVJTJUPTQSFWJTUPT OPUFYUPEBMFJGPSNVMBSQSPQPTUBEPQBSDFMBNFOUPOPQSB[PEFRVJO[FEJBTSFDP OIFDFOEPPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRVFOUFFQSPDFEFSBPEFQØTJUPEPNPOUBOUFJOJDJBMEF EPUPUBMEBEÓWJEBBMÏNEBTDVTUBTFIPOPSÈSJPTBEWPDBUÓDJPTTFOEPRVFFWFOUVBM JOBEJNQMFNFOUPFOTFKBPWFODJNFOUPBOUFDJQBEPEBTEFNBJTQBSDFMBTBMÏNEFNVMUB QFMPEFTDVNQSJNFOUP 7FSJmDBTFFOUSFUBOUPRVFBNPSBUØSJBOÍPDPOTUJUVJEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEP FYFDVUBEP QPTUP TFS JNQSFTDJOEÓWFM BOVÐODJB EP DSFEPS OÍP QPEFOEP P NBHJT USBEP DPOUVEP JOEFGFSJS B QSFUFOTÍP VNB WF[ TBUJTGFJUPT UPEPT PT QSFTTVQPTUPT QSFWJTUPTOPBSUJHP/PFOUBOUPDBTBIBKBPJOEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPÏQPTTÓWFMP NBOFKPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQFMPEFWFEPSTPCQFOBEFPGFOTBBPQPTUVMBEP DPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBBNQMBEFGFTBIJQØUFTFFNRVFTFSÈSFTUJUVÓEPPQSB[PQBSBJOUFS QPTJÎÍPEFEFGFTB 1PSmNP1SPKFUPEF-FJORVFDVJEBEB3FGPSNBEP$ØEJHPEF 1SPDFTTP$JWJMOÍPEFVBUFOÎÍPFTQFDJBMBPJOTUJUVUPMJNJUBOEPTFBSFQFUJSBFTTÐODJB EP"SU"DPNQPVRVÓTTJNBTBMUFSBÎÜFTOBTVBSFEBÎÍPBTRVBJTDPOUVEPOÍP UÐNPDPOEÍPEFTBOBSUPEBTBTDPOUSPWÏSTJBTRVFHJSBNTPCSFTVBBQMJDBCJMJEBEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 224 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS "-7*.&EVBSEP"SSVEBDireito Processual CivilFESFGPSNBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP &EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTFE "3"Á+0"MFYBOESF$PTUB%F"OBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBEPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPEÏCJUPQSFWJTUP QFMPBSUJHP"EP$1$*OÂmbito Jurídico3JP(SBOEF<*OUFSOFU> %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXBNCJUPKVSJEJDPDPNCSTJUFJOEFYQIQ O@MJOLSFWJTUB@BSUJ HPT@MFJUVSBBSUJHP@JE"DFTTPFN "3.&-*/%POBMEP#0/*$*0.BSDFMP+PTÏ.BHBMIÍFT$*"/$*.JSOB26"35*&3* 3JUB$PNFOUÈSJPTË&YFDVÎÍP$JWJMUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMFFYUSBKVEJDJBMBSUJHPQPSBSUJHP 4ÍP 1BVMP4BSBJWB "44*4"SBLFOManual da ExecuçãoFESFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUB EPT5SJCVOBJTFE ";&7&%0«MWBSP7JMMBÎBTeoria Geral das ObrigaçõesFESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP&EJ UPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT #"3304+BOFUF3JDLFO-PQFTEFDa possibilidade de aplicação do art. 745-A do CPC na Ação Monitória. $MVCKVT #SBTJMJB%' GFW %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXDMVCKVT DPNCS DPOUFOU"DFTTPFNOPW %*%*&3 +3 'SFEJF #6&/0 $BTTJP 4DBSQJOFMMB $045" &EVBSEP +PTÏ GB 'POTFDB "#&-)".BSDFMPÉ possível que o “favor legal” previsto no art. 745-A (parcelamento do valor executado) seja invocado na etapa de cumprimento de sentença?#JCMJPUFDB%JHJUBM3F WJTUB#SBTJMFJSBEF%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBMo3#%1SP#FMP)PSJ[POUFBOPOKBONBS %JSFUPBPQPOUP%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUPSBGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE$PO UFVEP4IPXBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFN '"-$°0"NÓMDBSùEF"SBÞKPA natureza jurídica do parcelamento do débito%JTQPOÓWFMFN IUUQBCEQDPSHCSBCEQD"SUJHPTBTQ PSEFNBSUJHP"DFTTPFN (0.&40SMBOEPObrigações3FWBUVBMFBVNEFBDPSEPDPNP$ØEJHP$JWJMEF QPS&EWBMEP#SJUP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF (06-"35 )BSPMEP 4BODIPUFOF Aplicação Subsidiária do art. 745-A no cumprimento de sentença.%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXBCEQDPSHCSBCEQD"SUJHPTBTQ PSEFNBSUJHP (3&$0 '*-)0 7JDFOUF Direito Processual Civil Brasileiro FE 4ÍP 1BVMP 4BSBJWB -01&4+PÍP#BUJTUBTutela Antecipada no processo civil brasileiroFESFWBUVBMFBNQM 4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT -6$0/1BVMP)FOSJRVFEPT4BOUPTEmbargos à execução4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB ."$)"%0"OUÙOJP$MÈVEJPEB$PTUBCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoFESFWF BUVBM#BSVFSJ&EJUPSB.BOPMF ."3$"50"OUÙOJP$BSMPTCódigo de Processo Civil InterpretadoFESFWFBUVBM4ÍP 1BVMP&EJUPSB"UMBT ."3*/0/* -VJ[ (VJMIFSNF .*5*%*&*30 %BOJFM Código de Processo Civil comentado artigo por artigo.4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 Moratória Judicial: interpretação da inovação do artigo 745-A do Código de Processo Civil 225 ."35*/43FOBUP$BTUSP5FJYFJSB0QBSDFMBNFOUPEPBSU"EP$1$OPDVNQSJ NFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB*OExecução Civil e cumprimento de sentença$PPSE4FSHJP4IJNVSBF (JMCFSUP(PNFT#SVTI7PM4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEP .";;&*3PESJHP0QÎÍPEPFYFDVUBEPFNQBHBSQBSDFMBEBNFOUFBEÓWJEBFYFDVUBEB*O Reforma do CPC 2: nova sistemática processual civil/&7&4%BOJFM"NPSJN"TTVNQÎÍP<FU BM>4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT .&3±0/7"3("44BSBI"GBDVMEBEFEFQBSDFMBNFOUPEPWBMPSEBFYFDVÎÍPBSU" SFRVJTJUPTQSPDFEJNFOUPFBQMJDBCJMJEBEF*OExecução Extrajudicial: modificações da Lei nº 11.382/2006.$PPSE4VTBOB)FOSJRVFTEBDPTUB4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB2VBSUJFS-BUJO .03&*3"+PTÏ$BSMPT#BSCPTBO Novo Processo Civil Brasileiro: exposição sistemática do procedimento.&ESFWFBUVBM3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF /&3:+3/FMTPO/&3:3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEFCódigo de Processo Civil Comentado e Legislação Extravagante.FESFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT FE 1&3&*3"$BJP.ÈSJPEB4JMWBInstituições de Direito Civil: teoria geral das obrigações.W 3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB'PSFOTF 1*/50#SVOP¶UBMP4PVTBArtigo 745-A do CPC: a natureza jurídica do parcelamento da dívida e outras polêmicas+VT/BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPOTFU%JTQPOÓWFM FNIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSFWJTUBUFYUP"DFTTPFN 3² "MVÓTJP *VOFT .POUJ 3VHHFSJ O Acesso à justiça do devedor de boa-fé: a atuação da Defensoria Pública na efetivação do direito ao pagamento parcelado. IUUQXXX EFGFOTPSJBTQHPWCSEQFTQSFQPTJUPSJPEPDVNFOUPTDDTBJ0"$&440 "+645*$"%0%&7&%03%�"'$EPD "DFTTP FN 30%3*(6&4.BSDFMP"CFMIBManual de Execução CivilFE3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF 6OJWFSTJUÈSJB 4*-7"3JOBMEP.PV[BMBTEF4PV[BFùA moratória do Art. 745-A do CPC. Sua aplicação às demandas cognitivas condenatórias.ù+VT/BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPOKBO %JTQPOÓWFMFNùIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSFWJTUBUFYUP"DFTTPFNù 4"/504&SOBOF'JEÏMJTEPTManual de Direito Processual Civil. Execução e Processo Cautela. FE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB 4"/504.PBDZS"NBSBMPrimeiras Linhas de Direito Processual CivilWPMFESFWF BUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB @@@@@@@Primeiras Linhas de Direito Processual CivilWPMFESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP 4BSBJWB 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de direito processual civil: processo de execução e cumprimento da sentença, processo cautelar e tutela de urgência7PMFE3JPEF+BOFJSP 'PSFOTF 8"(/&3 +6/*03 -VJ[ (VJMIFSNF EB $PTUB $JODP RVFTUÜFT DPOUSPWFSUJEBT EB OPWB TJTUFNÈUJDBEBFYFDVÎÍPDJWJM*OAspectos Polêmicos da nova execução$PPSE$BTTJP4DBS QJOFMMB#VFOPF5FSFTB"SSVEB"MWJN7PM4ÍP1BVMP35 RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 226 Cristiane Aquino Gonzaga @@@@@@@@ Sou obrigado a receber parceladamente o meu crédito em execução 3FWJTUB EF 1SPDFTTP3F1SPBOPGFW 8".#*&3-VJ[3PESJHVFT"-.&*%"'MÈWJP3FOBUP$PSSFJBEF5"-".*/*&EVBSEP Curso Avançado de Processo Civil: processo de execução7PMFESFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP 1BVMP3FWJTUBEPTUSJCVOBJT @@@@@@@5"-".*/*&EVBSEPCurso Avançado de Processo Civil: execução7PMFE SFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP3FWJTUBEPTUSJCVOBJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 191 a 226 EXECUÇÃO CONTRA A FAZENDA PÚBLICA POR OBRIGAÇÕES PECUNIÁRIAS DECORRENTES DE TÍTULOS JUDICIAIS: REFLEXÕES SOBRE O PROCEDIMENTO ATÉ A EXPEDIÇÃO DA ORDEM DE PAGAMENTO EXECUTION AGAINST PUBLIC TREASURY FOR CASH OBLIGATIONS ARISING OF COURT ORDERED PAYMENTS: Reflections by the expedition of the payment order Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz1 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP0FNCBUFEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTDPNPTJOUFSFTTFTQSJWBEPTFN SFMBÎÍPBPTEÏCJUPTGB[FOEÈSJPT"TSFHSBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT SFMBUJWBTËFYQFEJÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTFEBTSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSQBSBPTUÓ UVMPTKVEJDJBJT%PNPEFMPBUVBMEBFYFDVÎÍPOPDØEJHPEFQSPDFTTPDJWJM1FSNB OÐODJBEPQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB0QPMÐNJDP DPODFJUPEFFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB"QMJDBÎÍPEFSFHSBTEPDVNQSJ NFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB%FmOJUJWJEBEFFQSPWJTJPSJFEBEFEBFYFDVÎÍP3FMBÎÍP EF QSPWJTJPSJFEBEF DPN B QPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPNBUFSJBMFDPNB FYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTP%BQFOEÐODJBEFSFDVSTPFNSFMBÎÍPBPGSBDJPOBNFOUPEF QSFDBUØSJPT%BFYJHÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPQBSBBFYQFEJÎÍP EPQSFDBUØSJPFEBSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS0JOÓDJPEBFYFDVÎÍP0 FGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPFEPSFDVSTPEFBQFMBÎÍP0USÉOTJUP FNKVMHBEPOPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP%BTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEPQSPKFUPEPOPWP$1$ $POTJEFSBÎÜFTmOBJT3FGFSÐODJBT#JCMJPHSÈmDBT RESUMO 0QSFTFOUFUSBCBMIPFTUVEBBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQPSPCSJHBÎÜFT QFDVOJÈSJBTEFDPSSFOUFTEFUÓUVMPTKVEJDJBJTDPNÐOGBTFOPiter QSPDFEJNFOUBMRVF DVMNJOBDPNBFYQFEJÎÍPEBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPBP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP1BSUJVTFEP FYBNF EB OBUVSF[B KVSÓEJDB EB FYFDVÎÍP DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB FN DPOGSPOUP DPN PT QSJODÓQJPT F DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT EB FYFDVÎÍP DJWJM F BT SFHSBT EP DVNQSJNFO UP EF TFOUFOÎB BQMJDÈWFJT Ë FYFDVÎÍP DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB " EFUFSNJOBÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EP USÉOTJUP FN KVMHBEP SFMBUJWB BPT QBHBNFOUPT EPT QSFDBUØSJPT F EBTSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSGPJDPOTJEFSBEBTPCPFOGPRVFEPTDPODFJUPTEF AQSPWJTPSJFEBEFFAEFmOJUJWJEBEFEPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWP1SFUFOEFVTFEFNPOTUSBSRVF ÏQSFDJTPBNPMEBSPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTQSPDFTTVBJTËTEFUFSNJOBÎÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT SFMBUJWBTBPTQSFDBUØSJPTFSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSMFWBOEPTFFNDPOUBBOB UVSF[BEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTFNFTQFDJBMOPRVFDPODFSOFËFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB ABSTRACT This paper studies the performance against the public treasury, for pecuniary obligations arising from judicial titles, with emphasis on iter procedural that culminates with the issuance of a payment order to the Government. This started from the examination of the legal nature of execution against the National Treasury in confrontation with the principles and characteristics of civil enforcement and compliance with the rules applicable to the enforcement of a judgment against the Revenue. The constitutional determination of res judicata on payments of judicial requests and requisitions was considered of little value 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP&TQFDJBMJTUBFN%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM$JWJMQFMB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB 1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEP4ÍP1BVMP 228 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz from the standpoint of the concepts of ‘temporariness’ and ‘finality’ of Enforcement. It was intended to demonstrate that the procedures must conform to the procedural constitutional provisions relating to judicial requests and requests of small value, taking into account the nature of public interests, especially with regard to provisional execution, Palavras-chaves'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPQSFDBUØSJP Keywords: Public Treasury, provisional execution, res judicata, Court - ordered payment 1. INTRODUÇÃO " PQÎÍP QFMB BCPSEBHFN EP UFNB SFGFSFOUF Ë FYFDVÎÍP DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBQPSPCSJHBÎÜFTQFDVOJÈSJBTEFDPSSFVEBDPOTUBUBÎÍPEBPDPSSÐODJBEFEJWFS HÐODJBTEPVUSJOÈSJBTFKVSJTQSVEFODJBJTBSFTQFJUPEBGPSNBFEPNPNFOUPEFFYQF EJÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTMFWBOEPTFFNDPOUBBBEPÎÍPEFQSFNJTTBTEJGFSFOUFTRVBOUP ËQPTTJCJMJEBEFPVOÍPEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBFRVBOUPË BQMJDBÎÍP EP QSFDFJUP MFHBM SFMBUJWP BP FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP EPT FNCBSHPT Ë FYFDVÎÍP %FDPSSFVEBOFDFTTJEBEFEFmYBÎÍPEBTCBMJ[BTQBSBDPNQSFFOTÍPEPTDÉOPOFTDPOT UJUVDJPOBJTQBSBBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTFEBTSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSFN WJTUBEBTSFHSBTQSPDFTTVBJTSFMBUJWBTËTPCSJHBÎÜFTEFQBHBS &NUFNQPTPOEFPQFOTBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPFTUÈWPMUBEPQBSBBPCUFOÎÍPEFNF EJEBTUFOEFOUFTBNBJPSFGFUJWJEBEFEPQSPDFTTPCVTDBTFVNBSFnFYÍPEFTTFQSPQØ TJUPFNWJTUBEPiterQSPDFEJNFOUBMUSBÎBEPQBSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBFTQFDJmDBNFOUF OPRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPË&YFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUB 0PCKFUJWPÏRVFTFKBBQSFDJBEPPUFNBSFGFSFOUFBPNPNFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍP EBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPBP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPQBTTBOEPTFQFMBWJTÍPEPVUSJOÈSJBTPCSFB TJTUFNÈUJDBEPTQSFDBUØSJPTFQFSDPSSFOEPTFPTDBNJOIPTQSPDFTTVBJTDPNJOEJDBÎÍP EBTEJWFSHÐODJBTEFJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPTPCSFPTDPODFJUPTVUJMJ[BEPTOPUBEBNFOUFBRVFMFT SFMBDJPOBEPTËQSPWJTPSJFEBEFFËTVTQFOTÍPEBFYFDVÎÍP "SB[ÍPEBNBOVUFOÎÍPEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBUSBWÏTEF QSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPGPJWJTUBTFNRVFTFPMWJEBTTFEBUFOEÐODJBFYQSFTTBOPQSPKFUP EPOPWP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMEFQBTTBHFNQBSBPNPEFMPTJODSÏUJDP 2. O EMBATE DOS INTERESSES PÚBLICOS COM OS INTERESSES PRIVADOS EM RELAÇÃO AOS DÉBITOS FAZENDÁRIOS %FTEFÏQPDBTQBTTBEBTUFNTFRVFPQBSUJDVMBSRVFEFNBOEBFNBÎÜFTFYF DVUJWBTFNGBDFEB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBÏUBOUPFNSB[ÍPEFUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMDPNP KVEJDJBMVNDSFEPSEFTQSFTUJHJBEPKÈRVFFNCPSBUFOIBFTTBEFWFEPSBQFMPNFOPT FNUFTFNBJPSFTDPOEJÎÜFTEFBEJNQMJSTVBTPCSJHBÎÜFTPGB[DPNSFUBSEPRVFNVJ UBTWF[FTOFNDIFHBBBMDBOÎBSPCFOFmDJÈSJPEJSFUPNBTTPNFOUFTFVTIFSEFJSPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 229 4VSHFNEJTDVTTÜFTOFTTFÉNCJUPDPNPBMJÈTFNUPEPTPTEFNBJTPOEFmHVSF DPNPQBSUFB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTPCSFBFYJTUÐODJBEFQSJWJMÏHJPTPOEFEFWFSJBNFYJTUJS TPNFOUFQSFSSPHBUJWBT &NHFSBMBTDSÓUJDBTNBJTTFWFSBTQSPWÐNEFQSPDFTTVBMJTUBTRVFTFPMWJEBN RVFVNBDPOEFOBÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBÏOBWFSEBEFVNBDPOEFOBÎÍPJN QPTUBDPOUSBUPEBBTPDJFEBEFOBNFEJEBFNRVFPFSÈSJPÏDPNQPTUPQPSSFDVSTPT QÞCMJDPTBSSFDBEBEPTEJSFUBPVJOEJSFUBNFOUFEPTDJEBEÍPT/FTTFTFOUJEPTÍPEF .BSDFMP"CFMIBBTTFHVJOUFTQPOEFSBÎÜFT #BTUB VNB SÈQJEB QBTTBEB EPMIPT TPCSF P $1$ QBSB TF WFS RVF OPT RVBUSPDBOUPTEP$ØEJHPPMFHJTMBEPSTFGBSUPVEFDSJBSQSFSSPHBUJWBTQBSB B'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBoFRVBTFOFOIVNMJNJUFoRVFNVJUBTWF[FTUPSOBN TF WFSEBEFJSPT QSJWJMÏHJPT DPN JOFHÈWFM DPMPSJEP BCTPMVUJTUB F DIFJSP JODPOGVOEÓWFM EF JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF $SÓUJDBT Ë QBSUF B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBUFNBTFVGBWPSEFOUSFJOÞNFSBTQSFSSPHBUJWBTBWBOUBHFNEF FYFDVUBSFEFTFSFYFDVUBEBOBTPCSJHBÎÜFTEFQBHBSRVBOUJBQPSVN SFHJNFKVSÓEJDPQSPDFTTVBMCBTUBOUFFTQFDJBM 4PCPFOGPRVFEPTBENJOJTUSBUJWJTUBTQFSNBOFDFÓOUFHSPPFOUFOEJNFOUPEF RVFPTQSJODÓQJPTEBTVQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPFEBJOEJTQPOJ CJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPKVTUJmDBNBEJTUJOÎÍPEFUSBUBNFO UP/PEJ[FSEF$FMTP"OUPOJP#BOEFJSBEF.FMP PTJTUFNBEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP#SBTJMFJSPTFDPOTUSØJTPCSFPTQSJODÓQJPT EBTVQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPFEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEF EPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP5BJTQSJODÓQJPTCVTDBNPGFSFDFS VNB SFTQPTUB UFØSJDB Ë UFOTÍP RVF TF DPOmHVSB FOUSF iQSFSSPHBUJWBT EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEJSFJUPTEPTBENJOJTUSBEPTw3 /ÍPPCTUBOUFBJOEBRVFOÍPTFQFSDBPGPDPTPCSFPTJOUFSFTTFTRVFKVTUJm DBNUSBUBNFOUPEJGFSFODJBEPDPNQFUFBPJOUÏSQSFUFEPEJSFJUPVNBBOÈMJTFDVJEBEPTB BmNEFFWJUBSBBDFJUBÎÍPEFNFEJEBTQPMÓUJDBTRVFWFOIBNBFYUSBQPMBSBSB[ÍPRVF KVTUJmDBBDPODFTTÍPEFQSFSSPHBUJWBT .VJUBT NFEJEBT WÐN TFOEP UPNBEBT BP MPOHP EP UFNQP OP RVF DPODFSOF BPTQBHBNFOUPTEPTEÏCJUPTGB[FOEÈSJPT"FYFNQMPFNVNQBTTBEPSFMBUJWBNFOUF SFDFOUFGPJJOTUJUVÓEPPTJTUFNBEJGFSFODJBEPQBSBSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSRVF 3 "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJBQ .&-0$FMTP"OUPJP#BOEFJSBBQVE/6/&4"MMBO5JUPOFMMJ"TQSFSSPHBUJWBTEB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBFP 1SPKFUPEF-FJO/PWP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM +VT/BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPO KBO%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSSFWJTUBUFYUP"DFTTPFNBHP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 230 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz CFOFmDJPVPTDSFEPSFTEFQFRVFOPTEÏCJUPT1PSPVUSPMBEPUBNCÏNGPJFTUBCFMFDJEB BNPSBUØSJBOPQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPT 0TJTUFNBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMWJHFOUFSFDFCFDSÓUJDBTGFSSFOIBTOPRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPBP SFHJNFEPTQSFDBUØSJPT/PEJ[FSEF-FPOBSEP(SFDPUBMSFHJNFDPOTUJUVJiVNBJOBDFJUÈWFM JNVOJEBEFEP&TUBEPBPDVNQSJNFOUPEBTDPOEFOBÎÜFTRVFBKVTUJÎBMIFJNQÜFw "EFTQFJUPEFTTBQPTJÎÍPRVFFYQSFTTBOBWFSEBEFNFOPTQSF[PËTSB[ÜFT RVF KVTUJmDBN USBUBNFOUP EJGFSFODJBEP QBSB B "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP P GBUP Ï RVF OÍP TF QPEFPMWJEBSRVFPQSØQSJPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPUBNCÏNGPSOFDFNFJPTQBSBiOFV USBMJ[BSwBMHVNBTQSFSSPHBUJWBTBFTUBBUSJCVÓEBT $PN FGFJUP TF QPS VN MBEP P PSEFOBNFOUP KVSÓEJDP QSPQJDJB VN USBUB NFOUP BP &TUBEP RVF QFMP NFOPT FN VN QSJNFJSP NPNFOUP QBSFDF DPOTUJUVJS QSJWJMÏHJPQPSPVUSPMBEPUBNCÏNDPOTBHSBQSJODÓQJPTNBJTTFWFSPTDPNPQPS FYFNQMPBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFDJWJMPCKFUJWBUSBUBEBOPQBSÈHSBGPEPBSUJHPEB $POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDB 5BMBOUBHPOJTNPÏFYQSFTTPFNWJTUBEPTJTUFNBEFQSFDBUØSJPTNFJPEFTUJ UVÓEPEFnFYJCJMJEBEF FNSFMBÎÍPËTUVUFMBTEFVSHÐODJBOÍPTØOBGBTFEFDPOIFDJNFOUP DPNPOBGBTFEFFYFDVÎÍPOBNFEJEBFNRVFFTUBTQSPQJDJBNBPTQBSUJDVMBSFTBTBUJTGBÎÍP EFTFVTJOUFSFTTFTVMUSBQBTTBOEPBTCBSSFJSBTFSJHJEBTQBSBPTQBHBNFOUPTQFMP1P EFS1ÞCMJDP²PRVFTFWÐQPSFYFNQMPRVBOEPP&TUBEPÏDPNQFMJEPQPSEFDJTÍP KVEJDJBMBBSDBSDPNPTDVTUPTEFVNBFTDPMBFTQFDJBMJ[BEBQBSBEFUFSNJOBEPTFOGFS NPTOPJOÓDJPEPQSPDFTTPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPRVBOEPFMFÏDPNQFMJEPBQBHBSVN NFEJDBNFOUPEJTQPOÓWFMFNPVUSPQBÓTFOÍPSFHJTUSBEPQFSBOUFPTØSHÍPTEFTBÞEF MPDBJT/BWFSEBEFBJNQPTJÎÍPEFVNBPCSJHBÎÍPEFGB[FSDVKPQSPDFEJNFOUPQBSBB 'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBMJÈTÏPNFTNPQBSBPQBSUJDVMBSBDBCBTFOEPPNFJPQBSBFODVSUBS PDBNJOIPQBSBSFDFCJNFOUPEFWBOUBHFOTRVFOÍPEFJYBNEFTFSQFDVOJÈSJBT %FQFOEFOEPEPTJOUFSFTTFTFOWPMWJEPTSFTUBNVMUSBQBTTBEPTNVJUPTNFDB OJTNPTMFHÓUJNPTEFDPOUSPMFEPTHBTUPTQÞCMJDPTDPNPPEPTQSFDBUØSJPT FNCFOF GÓDJPEFQPVDPTDJEBEÍPTTFNQSFFNWJTUBEBQSPQBMBEBFGFUJWJEBEF "PDPOUSÈSJPEPRVFQPEFQBSFDFSÏEFEJGÓDJMDPNQBUJCJMJ[BÎÍPPTNFDBOJT NPTQBSBHBSBOUJBEPTJOUFSFTTFTEBTPDJFEBEFDPNPVNUPEPDPNSFMBÎÍPËRVFMFTRVF HBSBOUFNPTEJSFJUPTJOEJWJEVBJT %FPVUSBQBSUFNBTTFHVJOEPBJOEBBQSFNJTTBEFRVFPSFHJNFEFQSFDBUØ SJPTQFSNBOFDFOFDFTTÈSJPDPNPHBSBOUJBEBCPBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJ DPTOÍPTFQPEFGFDIBSPTPMIPTËTNBOPCSBTRVFUÐNTJEPVUJMJ[BEBTQBSBBQPTUFS HBÎÍPEPTSFTQFDUJWPTQBHBNFOUPT /FTTBTFBSBEFNBJTSFDFOUFTJHOJmDBUJWPFDSJUJDBEPGPJB&NFOEB$POT UJUVDJPOBMOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFRVFJODMVTJWFWFNTFOEPDIBNBEBEF (3&$0-FPOBSEPO Processo de ExecuçãoWPM**3JPEF+BOFJSP3FOPWBSQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 231 i&NFOEBEP$BMPUFwFFTUÈTFOEPDPNCBUJEBBUSBWÏTEBT"%*TF BJOEBQFOEFOUFTEFKVMHBNFOUP "&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOBMUFSPVPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM FBDSFTDFOUPVPBSUJHPBP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBTJOTUJ UVJOEPSFHJNFFTQFDJBMEFQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPTQFMPT&TUBEPT%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMF NVOJDÓQJPTBNQMJBOEPBJOEBNBJTPTQSB[PTQBSBQBHBNFOUPTEPTQSFDBUØSJPT 0BSUJHPEP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBTUSBUPVEBGPS NBDPNPEFWFNTFSGFJUPTBUÏBFEJÎÍPEB-FJDPNQMFNFOUBSQSFWJTUBOPQBSEP BSUEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMPTQBHBNFOUPTEFWJEPTQFMB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBRVBOEP &TUBEPTNVOJDÓQJPTFP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFTUFKBNFNNPSBOBRVJUBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPT 'JDPVBTTJNEFmOJEBVNBEVQMJDJEBEFEFSFHJNFTEFQBHBNFOUPVNSFHJNF PSEJOÈSJPEFTUJOBEPËTFOUJEBEFTEFWFEPSBTRVFFTUÍPDPNTFVTQBHBNFOUPTSFHVMBSJ[B EPTFVNSFHJNFFTQFDJBMQBSBËTFOUJEBEFTEFWFEPSBTRVFFTUÍPFNNPSB/PSFHJNF FTQFDJBMQPEFNBTEFWFEPSBTPQUBSQPSVNQSB[PEFRVJO[FBOPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPQPEF IBWFSBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFMFJMÜFTSFWFSTPTFNRVFUFSÈQSJPSJEBEFEFQBHBNFOUPPDSFEPS RVFPGFSFDFSVNNBJPSEFTÈHJPFNSFMBÎÍPBPWBMPSRVFUFNQBSBSFDFCFS0VUSPQPOUP BGBWPSEBTEFWFEPSBTSFTJEFOBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPRVBOUPËBUVBMJ[BÎÍPEFWBMPSFTRVFEF WFNBHPSBTFCBTFBSOPÓOEJDFPmDJBMEFSFNVOFSBÎÍPCÈTJDBEBDBEFSOFUBEFQPVQBOÎB %FTFSFHJTUSBSRVFPBSHVNFOUPGVOEBNFOUBMMBOÎBEPQBSBEBSMFHJUJNJEBEFË FTTBNPSBUØSJBFTUBUBMSFQPVTBOBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFQBHBNFOUPEFDSÏEJUPTFNSB[ÍP EBBVTÐODJBEFEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFPSÎBNFOUÈSJB /FTTFFOGPRVFÏTFNQSFMFNCSBEPPQSJODÓQJPEBSFTFSWBEPQPTTÓWFMTPCSF PRVBM8BOUVJM-VJ[$ÉOEJEP)PM[PCUFNQFSB " FYQSFTTÍP reserva do possível JEFOUJmDB B MJNJUBÎÍP EPT SFDVSTPT QÞCMJDPTEJTQPOÓWFJTGSFOUFËTHJHBOUFTDBTFDSFTDFOUFTOFDFTTJEBEFTRVF EFWFN TFS TVQSJEBT QFMPT FOUFT QÞCMJDPT USBUBOEPTF EF MJNJUF GÈUJDP JOUSBOTQPOÓWFM RVF PCTUB B QFMB DPODSFUJ[BÎÍP EF UPEBT BT EJSFUSJ[FT QSFTUBDJPOBJTUSB[JEBTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPPRVFTFEÈQSJODJQBMNFOUFFN QBÓTFTQPCSFTDPNPP#SBTJM "TCBSSFJSBTQBSBBJOUFHSBMBQMJDBÎÍPEFTTFQSJODÓQJPFTUÍPJOTFSJEBTOPÉNCJUP EPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJT04VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMBUSBWÏTEP.JOJTUSP(JMNBS .FOEFTMBOÎPVNÍPEPTDPODFJUPTFTUBCFMFDJEPTQPS)PMNFTF4VOTUFJOQBSBUSBUBSEB SFTFSWBEPQPTTÓWFMOBTFHVJOUFGPSNB 3FTTBMUPOFTTBQFSTQFDUJWBBTDPOUSJCVJÎÜFTEF4UFQIFO)PMNFTF$BTT4VOT UFJOQBSBPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFRVFUPEBTBTEJNFOTÜFTEPTEJSFJUPTGVOEB )0-;8BOUVJM-VJ[$ÉOEJEP5FTFEFEJTTFSUBÎÍP%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXGEDCS"SRVJWPT.FTUSB EP%JTTFSUBDPFT*OUFHSB8BOUVJM-VJ[$BOEJEP)PM[QEG"DFTTPFNKVM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 232 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz NFOUBJTUÐNDVTUPTQÞCMJDPTEBOEPTJHOJmDBUJWPSFMFWPBPUFNBEBiSFTFSWB EPQPTTÓWFMwFTQFDJBMNFOUFBPFWJEFODJBSBiFTDBTTF[EPTSFDVSTPTwFBOFDFT TJEBEFEFTFGB[FSFNFTDPMIBTBMPDBUJWBTDPODMVJOEPBQBSUJSEBQFSTQFDUJWB EBTmOBOÎBTQÞCMJDBTRVFilevar a sério os direitos significa levar a sério a escassez” (HOLMES, Stephen; SUNSTEIN, Cass The Cost of Rights: Why Liberty Depends on Taxes. W.W. Norton & Company: Nova Iorque, 1999). /ÍP CBTUBTTFN UBJT EJmDVMEBEFT EFDPSSFOUFT EB JOTVmDJÐODJB EF SFDVSTPT DPOTUJUVFNBJOEBPCTUÈDVMPTËTBUJTGBÎÍPEPTDSÏEJUPTKVOUPBP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPGBMIBT OBMFHJTMBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMOPUBEBNFOUFOBDPODFJUVBÎÍPEBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB 2VFSTFDPODFCBPTJTUFNBEFQSFDBUØSJPTDPNPCFOFGÓDJPPVDPNPQSFSSPHB UJWBQBSBSFTHVBSEPEPTJOUFSFTTFTEBTPDJFEBEFPGBUPÏRVFBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFT EPTQBSUJDVMBSFTBPSFDFCJNFOUPEFWBMPSFTQFDVOJÈSJPTUBNCÏNFTCBSSBFNEJWFSHÐO DJBTEFJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEBTOPSNBTQSPDFTTVBJTWJHFOUFT 3. AS REGRAS CONSTITUCIONAIS E INFRACONSTITUCIONAIS RELATIVAS À EXPEDIÇÃO DOS PRECATÓRIOS E DAS REQUISIÇÕES DE PEQUENO VALOR PARA OS TÍTULOS JUDICIAIS " &NFOEB $POTUJUVDJPOBM O USPVYF JOPWBÎÜFT OB TJTUFNÈUJDB EPT QSFDBUØSJPTQFSNJUJOEPBQPTUFSHBÎÍPEPTQBHBNFOUPTEPTQSFDBUØSJPTiGBWPSFDFO EPwP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP ²DFSUPRVFBFYJHÐODJBEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBTTFOUFOÎBTQBSBBFYQFEJÎÍP EBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPQSFDBUØSJPTFSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPS QFSNBOFDFVUBM DPNPJNQPTUBQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMODPNBBMUFSBÎÍPEPBSUJHP $PNFGFJUPPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMRVFUFWFTFVQBSÈHSBGPQSJ NFJSPJOTFSJEPQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEFEFTFUFNCSPEFJN QÙTBOFDFTTJEBEFEFUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBTTFOUFOÎBT"&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO QBTTPVQBSBPQBSÈHSBGPEPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDBBT NFTNBTEFUFSNJOBÎÜFTiJOWFSCJTw 1BS²PCSJHBUØSJBBJODMVTÍPOPPSÎBNFOUPEBTFOUJEBEFTEFEJSFJUP QÞCMJDBEFWFSCBOFDFTTÈSJBBPQBHBNFOUPEFTFVTEÏCJUPTPSJVOEPTEF TFOUFOÎBT USBOTJUBEBT FN KVMHBEP DPOTUBOUFT EF QSFDBUØSJPT KVEJDJBJT BQSFTFOUBEPTBUÏEFKVMIPEFGB[FOEPTFPQBHBNFOUPBUÏPmOBMEP FYFSDÓDJPTFHVJOUFRVBOEPUFSÍPTFVTWBMPSFTBUVBMJ[BEPTNPOFUBSJBNFOUF 45'"H3FH/B4VTQFOTÍPEF-JNJOBS1FSOBNCVDPKVMH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 233 0DPSSFRVFEFTTBTJOHFMBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPQBSBPCTFSWÉODJBEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVM HBEP FNBOBN TÏSJBT DPOUSPWÏSTJBT RVF BDBCBN QPS EJmDVMUBS BJOEB NBJT P QSPDF EJNFOUP RVF DPOEV[ BP SFDFCJNFOUP QFMP QBSUJDVMBS EBT JNQPSUÉODJBT RVF MIF TÍP EFWJEBTQFMP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP $VNQSFTJUVBSPUFNBFNWJTUBEBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTSFMBUJWBT ËFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBMFNCSBOEPRVFPTDPNBOEPTTPCSFPBTTVOUP QFSNBOFDFNOPTBSUJHPTBUPEPTEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTPDJWJM "-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFFYUJOHVJVPQSPDFTTPBVUÙ OPNPEFFYFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMQFSNJUJOEPPNFSPDVNQSJNFOUPEB TFOUFOÎBNBTOÍPFNSFMBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTFOEPNBOUJEBFNSFMBÎÍPBFTUBB FYFDVÎÍPBVUÙOPNBUBMDPNPFTUBCFMFDJEBQFMPTEJTQPTJUJWPTBDJNBSFGFSJEPT 7BMFMFNCSBSRVFPQSB[PQBSBBPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTGPJFNEFDPSSÐODJB EPEJTQPTUPOB.FEJEB1SPWJTØSJBOEFEJMBUBEPEFEJBT QBSBEJBTSFTUBOEPNPEJmDBEBBTTJNBSFEBÎÍPEPQSJNJUJWPBSUJHPEP&TUB UVUP1SPDFTTVBM 0TQSJODJQBJTQPOUPTEPQSPDFEJNFOUPQSFWJTUPOPTBSUJHPTFEP$ØEJHP EF1SPDFTTP$JWJMTÍPPTTFHVJOUFTB B'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBÏDJUBEBQBSBPQPSFNCBSHPTF OÍPQBSBQBHBSDPNPPDPSSFQFMPTNPMEFTEPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMC PQSB[PEFPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTÏEFEJBTFBTNBUÏSJBTOFMFQBTTÓWFJTEFBCPSEBHFN DPOTUBNEPBSUJHPD PQSPDFEJNFOUPTFDPNQMFUBDPNBFYQFEJÎÍPEFPSEFNEF QBHBNFOUPQFMPKVJ[FYQSFTTBBUSBWÏTEFSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPSPVQSFDBUØSJP 4. DO MODELO ATUAL DA EXECUÇÃO NO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL. PERMANÊNCIA DO PROCESSO AUTÔNOMO DA EXECUÇÃO CONTRA A FAZENDA PÚBLICA "USBWÏTEB-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFRVFBQSFTFOUPVPT BSUJHPT*B3IPVWFBFMJNJOBÎÍPEPQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPDPNBEFOPNJOBEB GBTFEFcumprimento de sentença. $PORVBOUPB-FJOUFOIBFYUJOHVJEPPQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEBFYFDV ÎÍPOÍPTFQPEFBGBTUBSBJEFJBEFRVFBFYFDVÎÍPTFFTUBCFMFDFNFTNPEFTUJUVÓEBEFBV UPOPNJB&NPVUSBTQBMBWSBTÏQPTTÓWFMFYFDVÎÍPTFNQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEFFYFDVÎÍP /PEJ[FSEF'SFEEJF%JEJFS+ÞOJPS-FPOBSEP+PTÏ$BSOFJSPEB$VOIB1BVMB 4BSOP#SBHBF3BGBFM0MJWFJSBihá execução sem processo autônomo de execução, mas não há execução sem processow1BSBFMFT“toda a execução realiza-se em um processo de execução, procedimento em contraditório, seja em um processo instaurado com esse objetivo, seja como fase de um processo sincréticow %*%*&3+Á/*03'SFEJFF$6/)"-FPOBSEP+PTÏ$BSOFJSPF#3"("1BVMB4BSOPF0-*7&*3" 3BGBFMCurso de Direito Processual Civil. Execução. 7PMVNF4BMWBEPS&EJUPSB1PEJWNQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 234 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz $PNPFTDMBSFDF.BSDFMP"CFMIB B BUJWJEBEF KVSJTEJDJPOBM FYFDVUJWB OP $1$ QPEF TFS EFTFOIBEB EB TFHVJOUFGPSNB &YFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMGB[TFNFEJBOUFPVTPEP QSPDFTTP EF FYFDVÎÍP BVUÙOPNP OPT UFSNPT EP -JWSP ** EP $1$ BQMJDBOEP TFNQSF RVF OFDFTTÈSJP F EF PGÓDJP QFMP KVJ[ BT SFHSBT UÏDOJDBTFYFDVUJWBTQSFWJTUBTOP-JWSP*BSUT*FTFHT &YFDVÎÍP GVOEBEB FN UÓUVMP KVEJDJBM DBTP TF USBUB EF UVUFMB EBT PCSJHBÎÜFT EF GB[FS PV OÍP GB[FS F EF FOUSFHB EF DPJTB B SFHSB Ï B FYFDVÎÍP ex officio, TFN OFDFTTJEBEF EF QSPDFTTP EF FYFDVÎÍP BVUÙOPNPFQPSUBOUPTFNPUSBEJDJPOBMJOUFSWBMPEFVNQSPDFTTP QBSB P PVUSP TFHVJOEP SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF PT BSUT F " EP $1$ 4F TF USBUBS EF UVUFMB EF QSFTUBÎÍP EF QBHBS RVBOUJB FOUÍP B SFHSB Ï UBNCÏN B EB FYFDVÎÍP OP NFTNP QSPDFTTP QSPDFTTP TJODSÏUJDP TØRVFOFTTFDBTPFMBOÍPÏJOJDJBEBEFPGÓDJPDPOGPSNF PSJFOUBÎÍPEPTBSUT*FTFHTEP$1$ 1SPTTFHVFP.FTUSF 0 EFTFOIP BOUFSJPSNFOUF GPSNVMBEP NFSFDF BMHVN SFQBSP RVBOEP B UVUFMBKVSJTEJDJPOBMFYFDVUJWBSFDBJTPCSFVNBTJUVBÎÍPEFFNFSHÐODJB /FTTBTIJQØUFTFTTFKBPUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMPVKVEJDJBMFRVBOUPBFTUF TFKB FMF QSPWJTØSJP MJNJOBS PV BOUFDJQBÎÍP EF UVUFMB PV EFmOJUJWP TFOUFOÎB RVF DPOUFNQMB VNB TJUVBÎÍP EF VSHÐODJB B SFHSB TFSÈ B BEPÎÍP EP QSPDFEJNFOUP FYFDVUJWP TFN B OFDFTTJEBEF EF QSPDFTTP BVUÙOPNPEFFYFDVÎÍPTFHVJOEPOFTTFQBSUJDVMBSBTSFHSBTEPTBSUT QBSÈHSBGPQBSÈHSBGPF"QBSÈHSBGPEFBDPSEP DPNBOBUVSF[BEBQSFTUBÎÍPBTFSFYFDVUBEB -FNCSFTFRVFBQBSUJSEBHFOFSBMJ[BÎÍPEBUVUFMBBOUFDJQBEBDPOGPSNFBS UJHPT F QBSÈHSBGP EP $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM P MFHJTMBEPS QFSNJUJV EFOUSPEPQSPDFEJNFOUPQBESÍPBQSÈUJDBEFBUPTFYFDVUJWPTSFTVMUBOEPUBMNFEJEB EBFWPMVÎÍPBSFTQFJUPEPTmOTEPQSPDFTTPPVTFKBBCVTDBDBEBWF[NBJTBDFOUVBEB EBFGFUJWJEBEFEPQSPDFTTP "JEFJBEFRVFBEJWJTÍPEPTQSPDFTTPTEFWFSJBTFEBSQFMBQSFEPNJOÉODJBEB GVOÎÍPOÍPQFMBFYDMVTJWJEBEFGPJDSFTDFOEP "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 235 "NVEBOÎBOBUVUFMBKVSJTEJDJPOBMEBTPCSJHBÎÜFTEFGB[FSFOÍPGB[FSJOJDJB EBQFMPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHPEF%FGFTBEP$POTVNJEPSEFQPJTHFOFSBMJ[BEBOPBSUJHP EP&TUBUVUP1SPDFTTVBMBMUFSPVTJHOJmDBUJWBNFOUFPTJTUFNBEBUVUFMBFYFDVUJWB KÈRVFEJTQFOTPVQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEFFYFDVÎÍP&TTFNFTNPTJTUFNBGPJFTUFOEJEP QPTUFSJPSNFOUFËTPCSJHBÎÜFTEFEBSDPJTBEJTUJOUBEFEJOIFJSPOPTUFSNPTEPTBSUJHPT "FEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM $PNBEJTQFOTBEFVNQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEFFYFDVÎÍPQBSBFTTBTIJQØUFTFT TVSHJSBNEVBTWBOUBHFOTDPOTJEFSÈWFJTEJNJOVJÎÍPEPUFNQPOFDFTTÈSJPËQSFTUBÎÍP KVSJTEJDJPOBMEFTOFDFTTJEBEFEFDJUBÎÍP SPNQJNFOUPDPNPEPHNBTFHVOEPBRVBM BBUJWJEBEFFYFDVUJWBFTUBSJBEJTTPDJBEBEBDPHOJUJWB 5PEPTFTTFTNPUJWPTOPFOUBOUPOÍPGPSBNDBQB[FTEFTVQFSBSBTQFDVMJB SJEBEFTBUJOFOUFTBBMHVNBTFTQÏDJFTEFTFOUFOÎBTEFNPEPBGBTUBSEFMBTPQSPDFEJ NFOUPBOUFSJPSNFOUFWJHFOUF $PNFGFJUPPQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEFFYFDVÎÍPEFTFOUFOÎBQFSNBOFDFVQBSB BTIJQØUFTFTEFTFOUFOÎBQFOBMDPOEFOBUØSJBUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPEFTFOUFOÎBBSCJ USBMEFTFOUFOÎBFTUSBOHFJSBIPNPMPHBEBQFMP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBEPBDØS EÍPRVFKVMHBQSPDFEFOUFSFWJTÍPDSJNJOBMFBJOEBFNDBTPEFTFOUFOÎBQSPGFSJEB DPOUSBPQPEFSQÞCMJDP $PNPKÈTFEFTUBDPVQBSBFTTBÞMUJNBIJQØUFTFIÈOFDFTTJEBEFEFBKVJ[B NFOUPEFVNBOPWBBÎÍPBQØTBGPSNBÎÍPEPUÓUVMPEFDPSSFOUFEBTPMVÎÍPBEPUBEB OPQSPDFTTPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP 5. O POLÊMICO CONCEITO DE EXECUÇÃO CONTRA A FAZENDA PÚBLICA $POTJEFSBOEP RVF P PCKFUJWP EB FYFDVÎÍP Ï QSPQJDJBS BP DSFEPS B NFTNB QSFTUBÎÍPRVFSFDFCFSJBDPNPDVNQSJNFOUPWPMVOUÈSJPEBPCSJHBÎÍPEFTFRVFTUJP OBSTFFNSFMBÎÍPËFYFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBUBMQSPQØTJUP TFWÐBUJOHJEP&NBJTTFQFSDPSSJEPÏQBSBBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEÏCJUPPDBNJOIPEFVNB FYFDVÎÍPQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUB "SFTQPTUBQBSBBNCBTBTRVFTUÜFTÏOFHBUJWB /P RVF DPODFSOF BP DVNQSJNFOUP EBT UVUFMBT EF PCSJHBÎÍP EF GB[FS OÍP GB[FSFFOUSFHBSDPJTBFNSFMBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBPSFHJNFÏPNFTNPRVFTFBQMJDB BPT QBSUJDVMBSFT $PNP EJ[ .BSDFMP "CFMIB inas execuções por desapossamento (art. 461-A) e por transformação (art. 461), a fazenda submete-se ao regime normal do Código de Processo Civil como se fosse um cidadão comumw )ÈFOUÍPSFHJNFEJGFSFODJBEPQBSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTPNFOUFOPRVFDPO DFSOFËTPCSJHBÎÜFTEFQBHBSRVBOUJBDFSUB "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJBQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 236 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz 0DPSSFRVFNFTNPBOUFTEBTBMUFSBÎÜFTQSPDFTTVBJTRVFUSPVYFSBNPEFOPNJ OBEPprocesso sincréticoBFYFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTFNQSF DPOUPVDPNDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTRVFBEJTUBODJBWBNEPQSPDFEJNFOUPOPSNBMQBSBPQSPQØTJUP EBFYFDVÎÍPDPNPTFJOEJDBSÈBEJBOUFMFNCSBOEPTFBHPSBTØQBSBFYFNQMJmDBSPGBUP EFRVFBDJUBÎÍPOÍPTFEBWBQBSBQBHBNFOUPFNIPSBTPVEJBTDGBSU$1$ DPNBSFEBÎÍPEBEBQFMB-FJO NBTQBSBPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTFNEJBT &KVTUBNFOUFQPSRVFBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTFNQSFDPNQPS UPVDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTQSØQSJBTÏRVFTFmSNBSBNDPOUSPWÏSTJBTTPCSFTVBOBUVSF[B &N PVUSBT QBMBWSBT DPORVBOUP P BSUJHP EP $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM BmSNFRVFBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTFUSBUBEFNPEBMJEBEFEFFYFDVÎÍP QPSRVBOUJBDFSUBWÈSJBTQFDVMJBSJEBEFTFYJTUFNRVFBBGBTUBNEPQSØQSJPDPODFJUPEF FYFDVÎÍPQSJODJQBMNFOUFQFMBBVTÐODJBEFDPOTUSJÎÍPQBUSJNPOJBM "TQFDUPRVFCFNEFmOFBFYFDVÎÍPDJWJMSFTJEFOBSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BÎÍPEPEF WFEPSBUSBWÏTEFTFVQBUSJNÙOJP%JWFSTBNFOUFEPRVFPDPSSJBOBBOUJHVJEBEFPOEFB QSØQSJBQFTTPBGÓTJDBSFTQPOEJBQFMBEÓWJEBOBFSBNPEFSOBBFYFDVÎÍPTPNFOUFJODJEF TPCSFPTCFOT²PDIBNBEPQSJODÓQJPEBQBUSJNPOJBMJEBEFUSBUBEPOPBSUJHPEP $ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMiWFSCJTw "SUo0EFWFEPSSFTQPOEFQBSBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTVBTPCSJHBÎÜFT DPN UPEPT PT TFVT CFOT QSFTFOUFT F GVUVSPT TBMWP BT SFTUSJÎÜFT FTUBCFMFDJEBTFNMFJ 5BMQSJODÓQJPOÍPJODJEFFNSFMBÎÍPËTFYFDVÎÜFTDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB VNB WF[ RVF OÍP Ï QPTTÓWFM B SFTQPOTBCJMJ[BÎÍP SFDBJS TPCSF TFVT CFOT QÞCMJDPT TFOEPRVFTJNQMFTNFOUFTFFYQFEFVNQSFDBUØSJPPVSFRVJTJÎÍP 1FMPNFTNPNPUJWPP1SJODÓQJPEB1SJNB[JBEBUVUFMBFTQFDÓmDBPVQSJODÓQJP EPSFTVMUBEPDPOTVCTUBODJBEPFNSFMBÎÍPËFYFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBOBQPTTJCJ MJEBEFEFQBHBNFOUPBPDSFEPSDPNBBEKVEJDBÎÍPEPCFNQFOIPSBEP"SU" $1$ OÍPUFNBQMJDBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB "JOBQMJDBÎÍPEFTTFTEPJTQSJODÓQJPTË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBÏPUSBÎPEJGFSFODJB EPSCÈTJDPFNSFMBÎÍPËFYFDVÎÍPDJWJMQBSBPTQBSUJDVMBSFT "EJTUJOÎÍPEFUSBUBNFOUPQBSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOBFYFDVÎÍPUFNTVCTUSBUP OBT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT EPT CFOT QÞCMJDPT JOBMJFOBCJMJEBEF JNQSFTDSJUJCJMJEBEF F JNQF OIPSBCJMJEBEF RVFUPSOBNJOWJÈWFMBBQMJDBÎÍPEBTSFHSBTQSPDFTTVBJTUSBEJDJPOBJT QBSBBFYFDVÎÍPEPTEFWFEPSFTTPMWFOUFTEFPCSJHBÎÜFTQPSRVBOUJBDFSUB -VJT)FOSJRVF#BSCBOUF'SBO[ÏMFNCSBRVF B *OFYJTUF B GBTF QSFQBSBUØSJB EF QFOIPSB F EB BWBMJBÎÍP QPJT P CFN QÞCMJDP Ï JOBMJFOÈWFM $$ BSUT F F DPOTFRVFOUFNFOUF JNQFOIPSÈWFM$1$BSUTF* "QSPQØTJUPNFTNPBFYDFÎÍP QSFWJTUBOP"SUEP$$OÍPBVUPSJ[BBQFOIPSBEPCFNQÞCMJDP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 237 EBFTQÏDJFEPNJOJDBMQPJTDPOEJDJPOBBBMJFOBÎÍPEFTUFËFYJTUÐODJB EFBVUPSJ[BÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWB C BGBTFFYQSPQSJBUØSJBÏUPUBMNFOUFEJWFSTBQPJTFNSFHSBPQBHBNFOUP ÏGFJUPQFMPEFNPSBEPSJUPEPQSFDBUØSJP$'BSU OÍPIBWFOEP BEKVEJDBÎÍPBMJFOBÎÍPPVVTVGSVUP$1$BSU )ÈBEFNBJTBOFDFTTJEBEFEFDPNQBUJCJMJ[BÎÍPEPQSPDFEJNFOUPDPNBQSF WJTÍPPSÎBNFOUÈSJBEJUBEBQFMP"SUf$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM0PSÎBNFOUP GVODJPOBDPNPVNBBVUPSJ[BÎÍPQBSBBFGFUJWBÎÍPEBEFTQFTBPVTFKBTFNQSFWJTÍP PSÎBNFOUÈSJBOÍPIÈQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFEFTQFTB 0 TJTUFNB QBSB QBHBNFOUP EPT EÏCJUPT GB[FOEÈSJPT BUSBWÏT EF QSFDBUØSJP MFWB FOUÍP FN DPOUB B OBUVSF[B EPT CFOT QÞCMJDPT BMJBEB Ë RVFTUÍP EB QSFWJTÍP PSÎBNFOUÈSJB " NBSDBS BJOEB B FYFDVÎÍP DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB IÈ B QFDVMJBSJEBEF EFOÍPQPEFSPDPSSFSPBEJNQMFNFOUPFTQPOUÉOFPTPCQFOBEFQSFUFSJÎÍPEBPSEFN OBUVSBMEFQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTPRVFÏWFEBEPQFMPTQSJODÓQJPTEBNPSBMJEB EFEBJHVBMEBEFFEBJNQFTTPBMJEBEF"SUTF,caput$' "TTJNTFOEPQBSBB MFHJUJNBÎÍPEPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBCBTUBUFSPDSFEPSVN UÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPKVEJDJBMPVFYUSBKVEJDJBMDPNBJOEJDBÎÍPEPWBMPSEBPCSJHBÎÍPMÓ RVJEBDFSUBFFYJHÓWFMEJTQFOTBOEPTFBTTJNPPVUSPSFRVJTJUPOFDFTTÈSJPBQFOBTBP QBSUJDVMBSPJOBEJNQMFNFOUP /FTTBPSEFNEFJEFJBTTFOEPTVCTUSBUPEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB FEPSFHJNFEFQSFDBUØSJPTBJOUBOHJCJMJEBEFEPTCFOTQÞCMJDPTIÈRVFNFOUFOEBRVF OÍPTFUSBUBEFVNBWFSEBEFJSBFYFDVÎÍPPVDBUBMPHBTFDPNPVNBFYFDVÎÍPJNQSØQSJB $PNFGFJUPOPEJ[FSEF)VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSQBSBBFTQÏDJF“há tão somente uma execução imprópria”. 4PCSFPUFNB*CSBIJN+PTÏEBT.FSDÐTMFNCSBBTMJÎÜFTEF$ÉOEJEP3BOHFM %JOBNBSDP '3"/;²-VJT)FOSJRVF#BSCBOUFoBSUJHPJOUJUVMBEPi5VUFMBEF6SHÐODJBOB&YFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FO EB1ÞCMJDBwJOi&YFDVÎÍPDJWJMFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBw$PPSEFOBÎÍP4ÏSHJP4IJNVSBF(JMCFSUP (PNFT#SVTDIJWPM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.ÏUPEPQBH Celso Ribeiro Bastos FOTJOB RVF “A regra geral fundamental é que a realização de despesa depende de previsão na lei orçamentária. O artigo 167 da Constituição proíbe, taxativamente, a realização de despesas ou a assunção de obrigações diretas que excedam os créditos orçamentários ou adicionais (inc. II), assim como o início de programas ou projetos não incluídos na lei orçamentária anual (inc. I). Daí resulta o princípio da legalidade: nenhuma despesa pode ser levada a efeito sem lei que a autorize e que determine o seu montante máximo. Note-se que a autorização para que se efetive a despesa não significa o dever de o administrador levá-la a efeito. Pode perfeitamente considerar não oportuna a sua realização. O controle dos limites máximos permanece, contudo, firmemente enfeixado nas mãos do Legislativo. Basta que se considerem os seguintes dispositivos constitucionais, que vedam: ‘a abertura de crédito suplementar ou especial sem prévia autorização do legislativo e sem indicação dos recursos correspondentes.’(Art. 167, V).i$VSTPEF%JSFJUP'JOBODFJSPFEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPw4ÍP1BV MP&EJUPSB4BSBJWBFEJÎÍPQHF 5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPS)VNCFSUP$VSTPEF%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM$JWJMQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 238 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz ù0NFTUSF%JOBNBSDPOPTFVDMÈTTJDPFTUVEPTPCSFBFYFDVÎÍPBQPOUB RVFFYJTUFNEFUFSNJOBEPTMJNJUFTBPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPFOUSFPTRVBJT TF TJUVB P QSPDFTTP FYFDVUJWP DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB MJNJUBÎÜFT EFDPSSFOUFTEFQSJODÓQJPTQPMÓUJDPT%BEPPDBSÈUFSTJTUFNÈUJDPEFTVB PCSBBQØTBmSNBSBOBUVSF[BEPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPDPNPTVCTUJUVUJWP EP DVNQSJNFOUP WPMVOUÈSJP EB PCSJHBÎÍP mYBEB OP QSPDFTTP EF DPOIFDJNFOUPQFMPDPOEFOBEPMFDJPOBDPNBHVEF[BPNFTUSF “o certo é que verdadeira execução não é aquela que se volta contra a Fazenda Pública, pois não há invasão imperativa do patrimônio do Estado pelo juiz (ou seja, pelo próprio Estado). É o devedor mesmo quem paga (voluntariamente), estimulado pelo ofício requisitório da autoridade judiciária. HSJGPEPBVUPS -VJ[(VJMIFSNF.BSJOPOJF%BOJFM.JUJEJFSPOPTDPNFOUÈSJPTBPBSUJHP EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMBmSNBNUSBUBSTFEFVNBFYFDVÎÍPNBTDPNDBSÈUFS FTQFDJBMBTTJNEFmOJEP "FTQFDJBMJEBEFSFTJEFFNRVFB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBQSFTFOUBVNBGPSNB QBSUJDVMBSQBSBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFVTEÏCJUPTQFDVOJÈSJPTBSU $3'# OB NFEJEB FN RVF PT CFOT QÞCMJDPT QPSRVF TF FODPOUSBN WJODVMBEPTFNQSJODÓQJPBVNBmOBMJEBEFQÞCMJDBTÍPJOBMJFOÈWFJTBSU $$ OÍPTFOEPQBTTÓWFJTEFQFOIPSBBSU$1$ "FYFDVÎÍPQSFTTVQÜFBUJWJEBEFTBODJPOBUØSJBEPFTUBEPFNTVCTUJUVJÎÍPB WPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTJOWBEJOEPPQBUSJNÙOJPEPEFWFEPSQBSBEFMÈSFUJSBSPOFDFTTÈ SJPQBSBBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSFEPS/PDBTPEFTFSQBSUFEFWFEPSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍP IÈFTTBBUJWJEBEFTVCTUJUVUJWBQSÈUJDBEFBUPTEFTVCSPHBÎÍP mDBOEPQPSUBOUPB TFOUFOÎBDPOEFOBUØSJBEFTUJUVÓEBEFGPSÎBFYFDVUJWB 4FOÍPIPVWFSFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPPVIBWFOEPGPSFNFTUFTKVMHBEPTJN QSPDFEFOUFTSFRVJTJUBTFPQBHBNFOUPFNMVHBSEFTFQSPDFEFSBQFOIPSBEFCFOT 5BMSFRVJTJÎÍPTFHVFVNBMJOIBRVFDIFHBFNDBTPEFEFTSFTQFJUPEFPSEFNFTUSJUBEP QSFDBUØSJPBPTFRàFTUSPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBSFTQFDUJWBJNQPSUÉODJB /ÍPIÈOBFYFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBRVBOUPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBWJPMÐODJB QBUSJNPOJBMDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBEFTUBNPEBMJEBEFEFFYFDVÎÍPFNSFMBÎÍPBPTQBSUJDVMBSFT BRVBMTFJOJDJBDPNBQFOIPSBFUFSNJOBDPNBFYQSPQSJBÎÍPFNIBTUBQÞCMJDB 30$)"*CSBJN+PTÏEBT.FSDÐT&YFDVÎÍPEFEÏCJUPTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB"SUf ¡VSHÐODJBEFVNBNFEJEBQSPWJTØSJBFTVBQPTTJCJMJEBEFBSUEB$' +VT/BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPO BCS%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQKVTVPMDPNCSEPVUSJOBUFYUPBTQ JE"DFTTPFNOPW ."3*/0/* -VJ[ (VJMIFSNF F .*5*%*&30 %BOJFM Código de Processo Civil Comentado. 4ÍP 1BVMP&EJUPSB35QBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 239 /PQSPDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍPFYJUFFYJTUFBQPTTJ CJMJEBEFEFBQMJDBÎÍPEFRVBMRVFSTBOÎÍP3FTTBMUBNTFBTQBMBWSBTEF8BOUVJM-VJ[ $ÉOEJEP)PM[ $PNP FYQÜF -&0/"3%0 (3&$0 BT TBOÎÜFT QSFWJTUBT QFMP EFTDVNQSJ NFOUPBPQSFDBUØSJPSFRVJTJUØSJPKVEJDJBMUBJTDPNPDSJNFEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFJO UFSWFOÎÍPGFEFSBMOP&TUBEPNFNCSPFEFTUFOPNVOJDÓQJPTÍPTBOÎÜFTRVFFYJHFN JOTUBVSBÎÍPEFPVUSPQSPDFTTPFRVFGPHFNËDPNQFUÐODJBEPKVÓ[PEBFYFDVÎÍP %FOUSP EP QSPDFTTP EF FYFDVÎÍP QPS RVBOUJB DFSUB DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB QPSUBOUP OÍP FYJTUF QPTTJCJMJEBEF KVSÓEJDB QBSB BQMJDBÎÍP EF RVBMRVFS TBOÎÍP P RVF MIF SFUJSB B OBUVSF[B QSØQSJB EF QSPDFTTP FYFDVUJWPFNTFVTFOUJEPFTUSJUPMFWBOEPDPNPWJTUPEPVUSJOBEPSFTB DIBNÈMBEFFYFDVÎÍPJNQSØQSJB /FTTF RVBESP CBTJDBNFOUF QPSRVF OÍP IÈ QSÈUJDB EF BUPT EF TVCSPHBÎÍP QPSRVFOÍPJODJEFNBMHVOTQSJODÓQJPTEBFYFDVÎÍPDJWJMDPNPPTEBQBUSJNPOJBMJEB EFFEPSFTVMUBEP QPSRVFOÍPTÍPQBTTÓWFJTEFBQMJDBÎÍPRVBJTRVFSTBOÎÜFTÏRVF BFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍPÏNFTNPWFSEBEFJSBFYFDVÎÍPDPNPEJ[ $ÉOEJEP3BOHFM%JOBNBSDPUFYUPBDJNBSFQSPEV[JEP /ÍPPCTUBOUFDPOTBHSBEBRVFFTUÈBEFOPNJOBÎÍPiFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBwJODMVTJWFQFMBMFHJTMBÎÍPOÍPTFKVTUJmDBBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFOPNFODMBUVSBEJWFSTB 6. APLICAÇÃO DE REGRAS DO CUMPRIMENTO DE SENTENÇA $PORVBOUP B FYFDVÎÍP FN SFMBÎÍP Ë 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB DPOUJOVF B TFS GFJUB NFEJBOUFQSPDFTTPBVUÙOPNPEFFYFDVÎÍPBMHVNBTSFHSBTBUJOFOUFTBPDVNQSJNFOUP EFTFOUFOÎBTÍPBFMBBQMJDÈWFJT ²DFSUPRVFGPSBNSFWPHBEPTPTBSUJHPTEP-JWSP**EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP $JWJMPTRVBJTUSBUBWBNEPQSPDFTTPEFMJRVJEBÎÍPRVBOEPDPODFCJEPFTUFEFNBOFJSB BVUÙOPNB"MJRVJEBÎÍPEFTFOUFOÎBQBTTPVBTFSSFHVMBEBQFMPTBSUJHPT"B )EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTPDJWJM 5BJTEJTQPTJUJWPTFOUSFUBOUPUÐNBQMJDBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB)BWFSÈBQF OBT B JOUJNBÎÍP EP QSPDVSBEPS RVF BUVB OPT BVUPT OÍP NBJT B DJUBÎÍP QBSB RVF SFTQPOEBËMJRVJEBÎÍP )0-; 8BOUVJM -VJ[ $ÉOEJEP o &YFDVÎÍP QPS RVBOUJB DFSUB DPOUSB 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB 5FTF EF EJT TFSUBÎÍP *OIUUQXXXGEDCS"SRVJWPT.FTUSBEP%JTTFSUBDPFT*OUFHSB8BOUVJM-VJ[$BOEJEP)PM[QEG "DFTTPFNKVM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 240 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz +ÈPBSUJHP+OÍPUFNBQMJDBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQPJTOÍPQPEFOEP FMBEFTSFTQFJUBSBPSEFNEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTJODPODFCÓWFMTFKBPCSJHBEB KÈOPJOÓDJPEPQSPDFTTPFYFDVUJWPTFSDJUBEBQBSBQBHBNFOUPJNFEJBUPTPCQFOBEF NVMUBPVRVBMRVFSPVUSBTBOÎÍPDPNPKÈBENJUJVP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB. &TQFDJmDBNFOUFP"SU*fBQSFTFOUBPDPODFJUPEFAFYFDVÎÍPQSP WJTØSJBUBNCÏNTFBQMJDBË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB 7. DEFINITIVIDADE E PROVISORIEDADE DA EXECUÇÃO 7.1. Relação da provisoriedade com a possibilidade de satisfação do direito material e com a existência de recurso 0BSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMRVFUFWFTFVQBSÈHSBGPQSJNFJSPJOTFSJ EPQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEFEFTFUFNCSPEFJNQÙTBOFDFTTJEB EFEFUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBTTFOUFOÎBT"&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOQBTTPV QBSBPfEPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDBBTNFTNBTEFUFSNJOBÎÜFT 4FQBSBBMHVOTDPNPTFWFSÈBEJBOUFmDPVDMBSPRVFOÍPNBJTTFSJBDBCÓWFM FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB QBSB PVUSPT P QSPQØTJUP EB SFGFSJ EBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOÍPFYQSFTTPVBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFTTF NPEP EF FYFDVÎÍP NBT BQFOBT DPOEJDJPOPV B FYQFEJÎÍP EP PGÓDJP SFRVJTJUØSJP Ë FYJTUÐODJBEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP /FTTFRVBESPFNCPSBNVJUPKÈTFUFOIBEJTDVUJEPBSFTQFJUPEBEFmOJUJWJ EBEFFQSPWJTPSJFEBEFEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBJNQSFTDJOEJCJMJEBEF EPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPFNGBDFEFTTFTDPODFJUPTQBSBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPPVEB SFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPSUSBUBEBFYQSFTTBNFOUFOPEJQMPNBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBJOEB FYQSFTTBDPOUSPWÏSTJBT %FTFQPOEFSBSRVFBQFTBSEFOÍPTFSFNTVmDJFOUFTPTDPODFJUPTEFQSPWJ TPSJFEBEFFEFmOJUJWJEBEFEBFYFDVÎÍPQBSBTFBGFSJSPNPNFOUPFBTDPOEJÎÜFTEB FYQFEJÎÍP EP PGÓDJP RVF SFRVJTJUB RVBOUJB EP 1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP QPS FMFT OÍP TF QPEF EFJYBSEFQBTTBS &NCPSBBMHVOTBVUPSFTUFOUFNQSFDJTBSPTDPOUPSOPTEBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB PGBUPÏRVFOÍPSFTVMUBEBMFJUVSBEBMFJDMBSF[BOPDPODFJUP 4FHVOEP.BSDFMP"CFMIB BFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBDPSSFTQPOEFBPJOTUJUVUPKVSÓEJDPQSPDFTTVBMFN RVF TF QFSNJUF RVF TFOUFOÎBT PV BDØSEÍPT BJOEB OÍP USBOTJUBEPT FN KVMHBEPQPTTBNQSPEV[JSBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPFYFRàFOEPSFDPOIFDJEB 45+3&TQ3+3FM.JO.BVSP$BNQCFMM.BSRVFToKVMH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 241 B QPTTJCJMJEBEF EF EFTGB[FS P RVF GPJ FYFDVUBEP DBTP TFKB QSPWJEP P SFDVSTPEPEFWFEPS "TTJUVBÎÜFTRVFFOTFKBNFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBTÍPJOEJDBEBTQPS"SBLFNEF "TTJTOPTTFHVJOUFTUFSNPT ²SFMBUJWBNFOUFGÈDJMDBUBMPHBSBTTJUVBÎÜFTFNRVFBUPTEFDJTØSJPTBVUP SJ[BNBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBB BEFRVBMRVFSEFDJTÍPJOUFSMPDVUØSJBDVKB DBSHBTFKBDPOEFOBUØSJBFYFDVUJWBPVNBOEBNFOUBMBSUQBS UF QSJODJQBMNFOUF B BOUFDJQBÎÍP MJNJOBS EB UVUFMB BSUT F Q SFTTBMWBGFJUBBTVTQFOTÍPEFTVBFmDÈDJBBSU C BEF RVBMRVFSBDØSEÍPVOÉOJNFFOÍPFNCBSHBEPQPJTPTSFDVSTPTFTQFDJBM FFYUSBPSEJOÈSJPDBSFDFNEFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBSUQ D BEF TFOUFOÎBBUBDBEBQPSBQFMBÎÍPRVFPKVJ[EFHSBVNFEJBOUFEFDJTÍP OÍPSFDFCFVFEFTUFBUPBHSBWPVPBQFMBOUFE BEFTFOUFOÎBBHSFEJEB QPSBQFMBÎÍPEFTUJUVÓEBEFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBSU*B7** ²EFTF BTTJOBMBSRVFPBSU7**OÍPFMJNJOBBFmDÈDJBEBEFDJTÍPBOUFDJQB UØSJBOBQFOEÐODJBEBBQFMBÎÍPDPOUSBBTFOUFOÎBQSPGFSJEBOPQSPDFTTP EPRVBMFMBTFPSJHJOPV .BT IÈ WÈSJBT PVUSBT IJQØUFTFT RVF BENJUFN B FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB BMÏN EFTTBTSFHVMBEBTQFMP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMDPOUFNQMBEBTFNMFJTFYUSBWBHBOUFT DPNPQPSFYFNQMPOB-FJEP.BOEBEPEF4FHVSBOÎB"SU-FJO OP )BCFBT%BUB"SU-FJO OB"ÎÍP$JWJM1ÞCMJDB"SU-FJO 'SFEJF %JEJFS +ÞOJPS F PVUSPT MFNCSBN P USBUBNFOUP EBEP BOUFSJPSNFO UFËFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBQFMP&TUBUVUP1SPDFTTVBMBSUJHPSFWPHBEPQFMB-FJO EFEFEF[FNCSPEF PRVBMUSB[JBBJEFJBEFRVFFTUBNPEBMJEBEFEF FYFDVÎÍPTFEJTUJOHVJBEBFYFDVÎÍPEFmOJUJWBQPSOÍPQSPQJDJBSBPFYFRVFOUFDIFHBS ËGBTFmOBMJTUPÏBPSFTVMUBEPNBUFSJBMQSFUFOEJEPEBÓTFOEPDIBNBEBJODMVTJWFEF FYFDVÎÍPJODPNQMFUB 0USBUBNFOUPEBNBUÏSJBFTUÈBUVBMNFOUFTJUVBEPOP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM OPBSUJHPQBSBPTUÓUVMPTFYUSBKVEJDJBJTFOPTBSUJHPT*fF0QBSBPT UÓUVMPTKVEJDJBJT&TUBCFMFDFNSFGFSJEPTQSFDFJUPT "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJB QBH "44*4"SBLFNManual da ExecuçãoFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT QBH %JEJFS+S-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEB$VOIB1BVMB4BSOP#SBHBF3BGBFM0MJWFJSB$VSTPEF%JSFJUP1SPDFT TVBM$JWJM&YFDVÎÍPWPM&EJUPSB1PEWVNQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 242 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz "SUo²EFmOJUJWBBFYFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBM Ï QSPWJTØSJB FORVBOUP QFOEFOUF BQFMBÎÍP EB TFOUFOÎB EF JNQSPDF EÐODJB EPT FNCBSHPT EP FYFDVUBEP RVBOEP SFDFCJEPT DPN FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWPBSU "SUo*<> f²EFmOJUJWBBFYFDVÎÍPEFTFOUFOÎBUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPFQSPWJ TØSJBRVBOEPTFUSBUBSEFTFOUFOÎBJNQVHOBEBNFEJBOUFSFDVSTPBPRVBM OÍPGPJBUSJCVÓEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP "SU0"FYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBEBTFOUFOÎBGBSTFÈOPRVFDPVCFS EPNFTNPNPEPRVFBEFmOJUJWBPCTFSWBEBTBTTFHVJOUFTOPSNBT*O DMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF *oDPSSFQPSJOJDJBUJWBDPOUBFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFEPFYFRàFOUFRVFTF PCSJHBTFBTFOUFOÎBGPSSFGPSNBEBBSFQBSBSPTEBOPTRVFPFYFDVUBEP IBKBTPGSJEP*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF **omDBTFNFGFJUPTPCSFWJOEPBDØSEÍPRVFNPEJmRVFPVBOVMFBTFO UFOÎBPCKFUPEBFYFDVÎÍPSFTUJUVJOEPTFBTQBSUFTBPFTUBEPBOUFSJPSF MJRVJEBEPT FWFOUVBJT QSFKVÓ[PT OPT NFTNPT BVUPT QPS BSCJUSBNFOUP *ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF ***oPMFWBOUBNFOUPEFEFQØTJUPFNEJOIFJSPFBQSÈUJDBEFBUPTRVF JNQPSUFNBMJFOBÎÍPEFQSPQSJFEBEFPVEPTRVBJTQPTTBSFTVMUBSHSBWF EBOPBPFYFDVUBEPEFQFOEFNEFDBVÎÍPTVmDJFOUFFJEÙOFBBSCJUSBEB EFQMBOPQFMPKVJ[FQSFTUBEBOPTQSØQSJPTBVUPT*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJO EF fP/PDBTPEPJODJTP**EPDBQVUEFTUFBSUJHPTFBTFOUFOÎBQSPWJTØSJB GPSNPEJmDBEBPVBOVMBEBBQFOBTFNQBSUFTPNFOUFOFTUBmDBSÈTFN FGFJUPBFYFDVÎÍP*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF fP"DBVÎÍPBRVFTFSFGFSFPJODJTP***EPDBQVUEFTUFBSUJHPQPEFSÈ TFSEJTQFOTBEB*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF *oRVBOEPOPTDBTPTEFDSÏEJUPEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUBSPVEFDPSSFOUF EFBUPJMÓDJUPBUÏPMJNJUFEFTFTTFOUBWF[FTPWBMPSEPTBMÈSJPNÓOJNP PFYFRàFOUFEFNPOTUSBSTJUVBÎÍPEFOFDFTTJEBEF*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJO EF ** o OPT DBTPT EF FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB FN RVF QFOEB BHSBWP EF JOT USVNFOUPKVOUPBP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMPVBP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBM EF+VTUJÎBBSU TBMWPRVBOEPEBEJTQFOTBQPTTBNBOJGFTUBNFOUF SFTVMUBSSJTDPEFHSBWFEBOPEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍP*ODMVÓEP QFMB-FJOEF fP"PSFRVFSFSBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBPFYFRàFOUFJOTUSVJSÈBQFUJÎÍP DPNDØQJBTBVUFOUJDBEBTEBTTFHVJOUFTQFÎBTEPQSPDFTTPQPEFOEPP BEWPHBEPWBMFSTFEPEJTQPTUPOBQBSUFmOBMEPBSUfP*ODMVÓEP QFMB-FJOEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 243 *oTFOUFOÎBPVBDØSEÍPFYFRàFOEP*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF **oDFSUJEÍPEFJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEPSFDVSTPOÍPEPUBEPEFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJ WP*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF ***oQSPDVSBÎÜFTPVUPSHBEBTQFMBTQBSUFT*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJO EF *7oEFDJTÍPEFIBCJMJUBÎÍPTFGPSPDBTP*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJO EF 7oGBDVMUBUJWBNFOUFPVUSBTQFÎBTQSPDFTTVBJTRVFPFYFRàFOUFDPOTJ EFSFOFDFTTÈSJBT*ODMVÓEPQFMB-FJOEF /BBOÈMJTFEBEJTUJOÎÍPFOUSFFYFDVÎÍPEFmOJUJWBFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB'SF EJF%JEJFS+VOÓPSFDPBVUPSFTQSPTTFHVFNEJ[FOEP B EJGFSFOÎB TVCTUBODJBM FOUSF FTTBT EVBT FTQÏDJFT EF FYFDVÎÍP DPNP TFWÐOÍPNBJTSFTJEFOBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFDIFHBSTFPVOÍPËGBTFmOBM EPQSPDFEJNFOUPFYFDVUJWPDPNBFOUSFHBEPPCKFUPEBQSFTUBÎÍPBP DSFEPS$PNPBEWFOUPEB-FJ'FEFSBMORVFSFGPSNPV PBSUJHPEP$1$IPKFSFWPHBEPWJOEPBTFSTVCTUJUVÓEPQFMPBUVBM BSUJHP 0 B EJTUJOÎÍP FOUSF FTTBT FTQÏDJFT EF FYFDVÎÍP QBTTPV B OÍPNBJTTFSGFJUBDPNCBTFOFTUFDSJUÏSJP$PNPBHPSBÏQPTTÓWFMRVF NFTNPFNFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBTFBUJOKBBGBTFmOBMEPQSPDFEJNFOUP FYFDVUJWPBJOEBRVFTPCDPOEJÎÜFTVNUBOUPEJGFSFOUFTOÍPÏQPTTÓWFM NBJTEJTUJOHVJMBTDPNCBTFOJTTPBNCBTQPEFNTFSDPNQMFUBTQPJT 0DSJUÏSJPBHPSBÏBestabilidadeEPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPFNRVFTFGVOEBB FYFDVÎÍPTFTFUSBUBSEFEFDJTÍPBDPCFSUBEBQFMBDPJTBKVMHBEBNBUFSJBM BFYFDVÎÍPÏdefinitiva;TFTFUSBUBSEFEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMBJOEBQBTTÓWFMEF BMUFSBÎÍPSFGPSNBPVJOWBMJEBÎÍP FNSB[ÍPEBQFOEÐODJBEFSFDVSTP DPOUSBFMBJOUFSQPTUPBRVFOÍPUFOIBTJEPBUSJCVÓEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP BFYFDVÎÍPÏprovisória. &NP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBFNBDØSEÍPSFMBUBEPQFMB.JOJTUSB &MJBOB$BMNPOFTUBCFMFDFVRVFBTSFHSBTSFMBUJWBTÈFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBEFWFNTFS SFMBUJWJ[BEBTRVBOEPFNFYBNFMFWBOUBNFOUPEFWBMPSFTJODPOUSPWFSTPT $MJUP'PSOBDJBSJ+ÞOJPSDSJUJDBPFOUFOEJNFOUPBEPUBEPOPSFGFSJEPBSFTUP UFDFOEPBTTFHVJOUFTDPOTJEFSBÎÜFT %*%*&3+Á/*03'SFEJFF$6/)"-FPOBSEP+PTÏ$BSOFJSPF#3"("1BVMB4BSOPF0-*7&*3"3BGBFM Curso de Direito Processual Civil. Execução. 7PMVNF4BMWBEPS&EJUPSB1PEJWNQBH 45+3&TQ3+3FM.JOJTUSB&MJBOB$BMNPOKVMHFN '03/"$*"3*+3$MJUP"MÏNEB&YFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB&EJUPSB.BHJTUFS1PSUP"MFHSF%JTQPOÓWFMFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 244 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz 0GBUPEFFYJTUJSSFDVSTPQFOEFOUFEFKVMHBNFOUPFTVKFJUPBQFOBTBPFGFJUP EFWPMVUJWP OÍP Ï TVmDJFOUF QBSB USBOTGPSNBS FN FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB UVEPRVBOUPOBRVFMFQSPDFTTPTFEJTDVUF)ÈRVFTFQSFTFSWBSTPNFOUF B NBUÏSJB PCKFUP EP SFDVSTP 2VBOUP OÍP GPJ JNQVHOBEP USBOTJUB FN KVMHBEP F EFTTB GPSNB BVUPSJ[B FYFDVÎÍP EFmOJUJWB RVF TF GB[ TFN MJNJUBÎÜFTPVDPOEJÎÜFTEFRVBMRVFSPSEFNEÈTFDPNUPEBGPSÎB/ÍP Ï OFDFTTÈSJP SFMBUJWJ[BSTF P DPODFJUP EF FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB QBSB TF DPODMVJSRVFBQFOEÐODJBSFDVSTBMQPTTJCJMJUBBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBNBT DPOTJEFSBOEPTFEFNPEPJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMPÉNCJUPEPSFDVSTP %F GBUP OÍP Ï QSFDJTP B SFMBUJWJ[BÎÍP EP DPODFJUP EF FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB QBSBTFBUSJCVJSWBMPSFTRVFOÍPFTUÍPTFOEPEJTDVUJEPTQPJTFTUFTKVTUBNFOUFQPS OÍPTPGSFSFNBUBRVFKÈDPOTUJUVÓSBNQBSUFQBTTÓWFMEFFYFDVÎÍPEFmOJUJWB"MJÈTUBM QPOEFSBÎÍPKÈGPJGFJUBQFMP.JOJTUSP-VJ['VY. 4PCSFFTTBRVFTUÍP-VJ[(VJMIFSNF.BSJOPOJF4ÏSHJP$SV["SFOIBSUBQSF TFOUBNBTFHVJOUFDPODMVTÍP /ÍP Ï QPTTÓWFM DPOGVOEJS B FYFDVÎÍP EF EFDJTÍP QSPWJTØSJB DPN B FYFDVÎÍPEFQBSDFMBEPDSÏEJUPFYFRàFOEPRVFOÍPGPJJNQVHOBEBPV DPOUSPWFSUJEB OPT FNCBSHPT Ë FYFDVÎÍP BQSFTFOUBEPT QFMB 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB5SBUBTFEFIJQØUFTFFNRVFPTFNCBSHPTEFJYBNEFDPOUSPWFSUFS QBSUFEPDSÏEJUPFYJHJEPOBFYFDVÎÍP 0SB TF P QSPDFTTP EFWF DPOUJOVBS OÍP PCTUBOUF B FWJEÐODJB EF QBSDFMBEPEJSFJUPBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFYFDVÎÍPJNFEJBUBFWJUBOEPB QPTUFSHBÎÍPEBTBUJTGBÎÍPEFTTFEJSFJUPFTUBSJBFNUPUBMEFTBDPSEPDPN PTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTËUVUFMBKVSJTEJDJPOBMFGFUJWBBSU9997EB $' FËEVSBÎÍPSB[PÈWFMEPQSPDFTTP"SU-997***EB$' "TTJN B FYFDVÎÍP EF QBSDFMB EP DSÏEJUP OÍP DPOUSPWFSUJEP OBEB NBJT Ï EP RVFBFYJHÐODJBJNQPTUBQFMPTEJSFJUPTGVOEBNFOUBJTQSPDFTTVBJTTPCSF BFTUSVUVSBUÏDOJDBEPQSPDFTTPFBTVBDPNQSFFOTÍPQFMPKVJ[ $MJUP'PSOBDJBSJUFNBWJTÍPEBQSPWJTPSJFEBEFTPCPFOGPRVFEPFGFJUPEP SFDVSTPJOUFSQPTUPNBTDPNDSÓUJDBTËMFHJTMBÎÍPOPUBEBNFOUFQPSOÍPUFSFMBGBMBEP QSPQSJBNFOUF EFTTF FGFJUP NBT OP DBTP EP BSUJHP EPT FGFJUPT EPT FNCBSHPT FNCPSBKÈGB[FOEPNFOÎÍPËFYJTUÐODJBEFBQFMBÎÍP"mSNBTPCSFPUFNB iXXXFEJUPSBNBHJTUFSDPNEPVUSJOBMFSQIQ JE%BUBEFBDFTTP 45+3&TQ.(3FM.JOJTUSP-VJ['VYKVM ."3*/0/* -VJ[ (VJMIFSNF F .*5*%*&30 %BOJFM Código de Processo Civil Comentado. 4ÍP 1BVMP&EJUPSB35QBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 245 BFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBRVFTFEFTFOIBWBUÍPDMBSBNFOUFOPUFYUPPSJHJ OÈSJPEP$1$WJHFOUFGPJTFOEPBPMPOHPEFTTFTBOPTUPEPTSFNPOUBEB DPNEFGFJUPTTBMJÐODJBTCVSBDPTFPOEVMBÎÜFTBQPOUPEFDSJBSRVFT UÜFTRVFBOUFTOÍPTFDPMPDBWBN <> PBSUJHPmDPVDBQFOHBQPJTOÍPNBJTEJTDJQMJOBBFYFDVÎÍPEFUÓ UVMPKVEJDJBMIPKFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB/FMFDPOTUBTPNFOUFRVF BFYFDVÎÍPEFUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMÏEFmOJUJWBNBTTFSJBQSPWJTØSJBiFO RVBOUPQFOEFOUFBQFMBÎÍPEBTFOUFOÎBEFJNQSPDFEÐODJBEPTFNCBSHPT EPFYFDVUBEPRVBOEPSFDFCJEPTDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPw"UFOUFTFRVF a lei, nesse passo, não cogita do efeito em que o recurso tenha sido recebido, mas sim do efeito em que os embargos do executado, nessa altura, já tidos como improcedentes, foram recepcionados. Faz supor, mas escrito não está, que, tendo os embargos sido recebidos com efeito suspensivo, também a apelação o seria, o que colide com a previsão do art. 520, V,RVFQSFWÐDPNPSFHSBPFGFJUPTØEFWPMVUJWP EPSFDVSTPDPOUSBBTFOUFOÎBEFJNQSPDFEÐODJBEPTFNCBSHPT &TTBRVFTUÍPËQBSUFPDFSUPÏRVFcom isso se cria uma terceira sorte de regime, pois tal disciplina contrapõe-se ao princípio de que o efeito suspensivo é óbice para a realização do título, enquanto não decidido o recurso. No caso, todavia, o efeito suspensivo não é impedimento à execução, que pode prosseguir, porém sob o signo da provisoriedade. Relativamente aos títulos judiciais, a questão foi trazida para o p. 1º, do art. 475-I, nos mesmos termos anteriores: as sentenças transitadas em julgado ensejam execução definitiva e as impugnadas sem recurso no efeito suspensivo, só execução provisória. A clareza dispersa-se com adornos "TTJN o efeito suspensivo concedido à impugnação (ex-embargos), que não é recurso, autoriza o prosseguimento da execução, que se faria provisória, sujeita à prestação de caução (par. 1º, do art. 475-M): que suspensão é esta? De outro lado, se o recurso pendente de julgamento for agravo de instrumento contra a negativa de seguimento ao especial e/ou extraordinário, a execução provisória pode ensejar levantamento de dinheiro sem prestação de caução (art. 475-)- par. 2º, II wHSJGPTOPTTPT 5BNCÏN FN DSÓUJDB TFWFSB BP SFGFSJEP BSUJHP QPS FOUFOEFS BCTVSEB B DPOWFSTÍPEFVNBFYFDVÎÍPEFmOJUJWBFNQSPWJTØSJBsecundum eventus litisEJ[.BS DFMP"CFMIB *EFNJCJEFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 246 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz $PNPTFWÐBOPWBSFEBÎÍPEPBSURVFMIFGPJBUSJCVÓEBQFMB-FJO MFWBËJODPSSFUBDPODMVTÍPEFRVFVNBFYFDVÎÍPQPEFJOJDJBSEFmOJUJWBNBT EFQFOEFOEPEFDJSDVOTUÉODJBTEBMJEFUPSOBSTFQSPWJTØSJBFBMHVNUFNQP EFQPJTWPMUBSBTFSEFmOJUJWBUBMDPNPTFPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPQBEFDFTTFEF VN BUSJCVUP NJNÏUJDP 5FOUBOEP EFDJGSBS P RVF RVJT EJ[FS P EJTQPTJUJWP RVFTFSFGFSFBQFOBTËTFYFDVÎÜFTGVOEBEBTFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMQSFUFOEF EJ[FSRVFBFYFDVÎÍPÏEFmOJUJWBTBMWPTFGPSFNJOUFSQPTUPTFNCBSHPTEP FYFDVUBEPFBFMFTGPSBUSJCVÓEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP&BJOEBRVFUBJTFNCBSHPT TFKBNKVMHBEPTJNQSPDFEFOUFTBNFSBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFBQFMBÎÍPNBOUFSJBP FTUBEPEFQSPWJTPSJFEBEFEBFYFDVÎÍP6NBCTVSEP 1SJNFJSP QPSRVF P FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP FWFOUVBMNFOUF BUSJCVÓEP BPT FNCBSHPTOÍPEFTOBUVSBBOBUVSF[BEFmOJUJWBEBFYFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFN UÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMTFOÍPBQFOBTQPSRVFPCTUBDVMJ[BBNBSDIBFYFDVUJWB "TTJNPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPDPODFEJEPOPTFNCBSHPTOÍPBMUFSBBOBUVSF[B EPUÓUVMPFOFNNFTNPEBFYFDVÎÍPOFTUFMBTUSFBEB%FPVUSBCBOEB EJTTFBJOEBPMFHJTMBEPSRVFFTTFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPDPODFEJEPQFMPKVJ[ EF QSJNFJSP HSBV UFN P QPEFS VMUSB BUJWP NBOUFOEPTF P FTUBEP EF JOFmDÈDJB EB FYFDVÎÍP BJOEB RVF PT FNCBSHPT TFKBN JNQSPDFEFOUFT F DPOUSB FMFT P FYFDVUBEP NBOFKF B BQFMBÎÍP RVF FN HFSBM OFTTFT DBTPTOÍPUFNPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP"SU7 0NBJTBCTVSEPEFTTB SFHSBÏRVFEÈBPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPSFWPHBEPQFMBJNQSPDFEÐODJBEPT FNCBSHPTOPKVMHBNFOUPEBJNQSPDFEÐODJBFFNVNKVÓ[PFYBVSJFOUF VNFGFJUPBMÏNVMUSBBUJWP +È"SBLFOEF"TTJTGBMBFNFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBsecundum eventus litis EPBS UJHPverbis "FYFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMBSU JOJDJBEFmOJUJWB NFOUFBSUQSJNFJSBQBSUFOBSFEBÎÍPEB-FJ QPSÏN PQPTUPTFNCBSHPTBPTRVBJTPØSHÍPKVEJDJÈSJPBUSJCVJVFGFJUPTVTQFOTJ WPBUFPSEPBSU"QOPUPEPPVFNQBSUFFFORVBOUPTFNF MIBOUFBUPOÍPGPSNPEJmDBEPBSU"QOPUPEPPVFNQBSUF BQFOEÐODJBEBBQFMBÎÍPDPOUSBBTFOUFOÎBEFJNQSPDFEÐODJBBVUPSJ[B PTFHVJNFOUPEBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTPSJBNFOUFBSUTFHVOEBQBSUF OPRVFUBOHFBPDBQÓUVMPPCKFUPEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP&TUBÏSFMFWBOUF NVEBOÎBQSPNPWJEBQFMB-FJQPSRVFB-FJ OÍPBMUFSBSBTVCTUBODJBMNFOUFPSFHJNFEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBFTUBCF MFDJEPQFMBMFJ "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJBQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 247 %PDPOKVOUPEFTTBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTTFFYUSBJBOPÎÍPEFRVFBFYFDVÎÍP EJUBiQSPWJTØSJBwPDPSSFOBQFOEÐODJBEFSFDVSTPSFQVUBEPMFHBMNFO UF JEÙOFP B NPEJmDBS BOVMBS PV EFTGB[FS P UÓUVMP FYFDVUJWP 4F OP EJSFJUP CSBTJMFJSP P DBSÈUFS QSPWJTØSJP EP QSPDFEJNFOUP in executivis mDBTTFSFTUSJUPBPUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMQPEFSTFJBBmSNBSRVFÏQSPWJTØSJBB FYFDVÎÍPCBTFBEBFNUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMRVFOÍPTFSFWFTUFEBBVUPSJEBEF EBDPJTBKVMHBEB %P BSU * Q DD BSU EFSJWBN EVBT DPOTFRVÐODJBT JNFEJBUBTQSJNFJSBUPEBFYFDVÎÍPCBTFBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMJOJDJBEFm OJUJWBQPSRVFTØBERVJSFBDPOEJÎÍPEFQSPWJTØSJBsecundum eventus litisBEF NBJTBQFOBTBMHVNBTFYFDVÎÜFTEFUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMRVBOEPBJOEBQBTTÓWFMP UÓUVMPEFSFGPSNBNFEJBOUFSFDVSTPJOJDJBNFQSPTTFHVFNQSPWJTPSJBNFOUF /PFYBNFEPTUÓUVMPTFYUSBKVEJDJBJTÏEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBBDØS EÍPRVFBMVEFËPDPSSÐODJBEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBEFQFOEFOEPEBPQPTJÎÍPEPTFN CBSHPTFBPNFTNPUFNQPJOEJDBBNVEBOÎBEFQPTJDJPOBNFOUPFNTFOUJEPEJWFSTP DPNPTFDPOTUBUB PBSUEP$1$OBQBSUFFNRVFEJTQÜFTFSEFmOJUJWBBFYFDVÎÍP RVBOEPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMEFWFTFSJOUFSQSFUBEBDPNPT MJNJUFTQPTUPTQFMPfEPBSUEP$1$DPOGPSNFB-FJO BPBmSNBSTFSFNTFNQSFSFDFCJEPTDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPPTFNCBSHPT JOUFSQPTUPTQFMPEFWFEPSFYFDVUBEP 4VSHFDPNPDPOTUSVÎÍPJOUFSQSFUBUJWBMØHJDBBDPODMVTÍPEFRVFBFYF DVÎÍPTFSÈEFmOJUJWBUÍPTPNFOUFRVBOEPOÍPGPSFNJOUFSQPTUPTFN CBSHPTEPEFWFEPSPVFTUFTUFOIBNTJEPKVMHBEPTEFmOJUJWBNFOUFRVFS RVBOUPBPNÏSJUPRVFSQPSWJBEFSFKFJÎÍPMJNJOBS1FOEFOUFBQFMBÎÍP DPOUSBBTFOUFOÎBRVFKVMHBJNQSPDFEFOUFTPVQBSDJBMNFOUFQSPDFEFO UFTFNCBSHPTEPEFWFEPSBFYFDVÎÍPOÍPÏEFmOJUJWBNBTQSPWJTØSJB OÍPQPEFOEPDIFHBSQPSUBOUPBBUPTRVFJNQPSUFNBMJFOBÎÍP"BMJF OBÎÍPEFCFOTQFOIPSBEPTBOUFTEPKVMHBNFOUPEBBQFMBÎÍPQSPQPTUB QPEFSÈBDBSSFUBSEBOPEFEJGÓDJMSFQBSBÎÍPVNBWF[RVFDBTPQSPWJEPP SFDVSTPOÍPQPEFSÈPCUFSEFWPMUBPTCFOTBMJFOBEPTUFOEPFNWJTUBPT EJSFJUPTBTTFHVSBEPTBPBERVJSFOUFEFCPBGÏ&TUFFOUFOEJNFOUPQSFEP NJOPVEFNPEPVOÉOJNFOB5VSNB3&TQO34"H3&TQO 413&TQO413&TQO343&TQO "44*4"SBLFNManual da ExecuçãoFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT QBH 45+&%DMOP"H3HOP3&TQ.(3FM.JOJTUSP+PTÏ%FMHBEP%0+VMH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 248 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz 34F3&TQO41 )PVWFQPSÏNNPEJmDBÎÍPEFFOUFOEJNFO UPEBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBEP45+DPOGPSNFKVMHBEPTEBF5VSNBT BTBCFS"H3&TQ34"("3+3&TQ343&TQ 413&TQ413&TQ3+F3&TQ34 &NVNEFTTFTKVMHBEPTDPNQPTJDJPOBNFOUPFNTFOUJEPPQPTUPEJ[B.JOJTUSB &MJBOB$BMNPO que “o acórdão impugnado bem enfrentou a questão central da controvérsia, ao rechaçar a tese de que é provisória a execução sujeita a recurso recebido só no efeito devolutivo”. %FOUSPEPRVBESPBQSFTFOUBEPQPEFTFEJ[FSRVFFYJTUFNEVBTIJQØUFTFTEF FYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBBRVFMBBOUFSJPSNFOUFFYJTUFOUFFOWPMWFOEPUÓUVMPQSPWJTØSJPFY TFOUFOÎBFYFDVUBEBQFOEFOEPBOÈMJTFEFBHSBWPEFJOTUSVNFOUPJOUFSQPTUPDPOUSBOFHB UJWBEFTFHVJNFOUPEFSFDVSTPFYDFQDJPOBM FOPDBTPEFUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPEFmOJUJWPFY FYFDVÎÍPEFUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMOBIJQØUFTFQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEP$1$ $PORVBOUPBJOEBNVJUPTFEJTDVUBTPCSFBNBUÏSJBEFDPSSFEBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍP EBTOPSNBTQSPDFTTVBJTWJHFOUFTPFOUFOEJNFOUPOPRVBMBQSPWJTPSJFEBEFÏEJUBEB QFMBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTPTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP&TUFBTQFDUPBTTVNFNBJPSSFMFWÉO DJBRVBOEPTFUFNBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBEFUÓUVMPEFmOJUJWPQPSFYFNQMPBFYJTUÐO DJBEFVNBFYFDVÎÍPDPNDPNUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPOBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPFRVF TFQSPDFTTBQSPWJTPSJBNFOUFFNSB[ÍPEBBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEFJNQVHOBÎÍPPVFNCBSHPT FEFSFDVSTPBFMFTSFGFSFOUFTTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP &YUSBJTFEFTTBTDPOTJEFSBÎÜFTBPTFGBMBSFNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFYFDVÎÍPQSP WJTØSJBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBRVFÏQSFDJTPUFSQSFTFOUFPRVFEFmOFFTTFDBSÈUFS QPSRVFPSBDJPDÓOJPRVFMJNJUBBDPNQSFFOTÍPEFVNBFYFDVÎÍPDPNPEFmOJUJWBBP GBUPEFBJOEBFTUBSQFOEFOUFEFBQSFDJBÎÍPSFDVSTPTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOBBÎÍPEF DPOIFDJNFOUPOÍPSFTPMWFBRVFTUÍP²QSFDJTPRVFTFTJUVFBQSPWJTPSJFEBEFUBNCÏN FNWJTUBEBFYJTUÐODJBEFEFGFTBEPFYFDVUBEPFEPSFDVSTPJOUFSQPTUPOFTTBTFEF²P RVFEFDPSSFEBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEBTSFHSBTWJHFOUFT"SUT*FBNCPTEP$1$ 7.2. Da pendência de recurso em relação ao fracionamento de precatórios 4FBQSPWJTPSJFEBEFOÍPTFEFmOFTFNBRVFTUÍPEBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTPTFN FGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPUBNCÏNÏDFSUPRVFFMBOÍPQPEFTFSWJTUBTPCPFOGPRVFÞOJDP EBFYJTUÐODJBEPBQFMP#FNEFNPOTUSBUBMGBUPBRVFTUÍPRVFUFNTJEPTVTDJUBEBOP +VEJDJÈSJPQBVMJTUBRVBOUPËQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFQBHBNFOUPEFSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOP WBMPSFYUSBÓEBTBQBSUJSEPEFTNFNCSBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPTKÈFYQFEJEPT "TFBENJUJSSBDJPDÓOJPDPOUSÈSJPUFSÓBNPTRVFTFQFOEFEFBQSFDJBÎÍPSF DVSTPTVQFSJPSRVBOUPËQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFEFTNFNCSBNFOUPoSFDVSTPFTUFTFNFGFJUP 45+3FTQ413FM.JOJTUSB&MJBOB$BMNPOKVMH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 249 TVTQFOTJWP o BJOEB RVF KÈ FYJTUB EFDJTÍP DPN USÉOTJUP FN KVMHBEP OB BÎÍP EF DP OIFDJNFOUPFBUÏNFTNPDFSUF[BRVBOUPBPTWBMPSFTEBDPOEFOBÎÍPPGBUPEFIBWFS VNQSPWJNFOUPKVEJDJBMJOUFSJOBMPVTFKBBJOEBOÍPTFEJNFOUBEPUBNCÏNSFOEFSJB FOTFKPBPFOUFOEJNFOUPEFVNBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBKVTUJmDBOEPTFEBÓPOÍPMFWBO UBNFOUPEFJNQPSUÉODJBKÈQBHBFNSB[ÍPEFQSFDBUØSJP5BMOÍPPDPSSFFP+VEJDJÈSJP MPDBMKÈUFNTFNBOJGFTUBEPOFTTFTFOUJEP $PNPÏJODPOUSPWFSTPBEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMRVFEFUFSNJOPVBFYQFEJÎÍP EP 0GÓDJP 3FRVJTJUØSJP EF 1FRVFOP 7BMPS GPJ PCKFUP EF SFDVSTP BP RVBM OP FOUBOUP OÍP GPJ DPOGFSJEP FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP & UBM TJUVBÎÍP OÍPTVCUSBJEPUÓUVMPKVEJDJBMTVBDFSUF[BFFYJHJCJMJEBEFUBOUPRVFEP SFDVSTPOÍPQPEFSÈSFTVMUBSBJNQSPDFEÐODJBEBBÎÍP 05SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBWFNSBUJmDBOEPBQPTJÎÍPBDJNBSFnFUJEBBGBTUBOEPB BMFHBÎÍPEFJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFMFWBOUBNFOUPTFNQSFFODIJNFOUPEPTSFRVJTJUPTEP BSUJHPo0EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMQPSFOUFOEFSRVFOÍPIÈRVFTFGBMBSOB IJQØUFTFEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBVNBWF[RVFBQFOEÐODJBEPFYBNFEPGSBDJPOBNFO UPEPQSFDBUØSJPOÍPBGBTUBBEFmOJUJWJEBEFEPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWP. "MJÈTJOUFSFTTBOUFOPUBSOFTTFBTQFDUPRVFTFPQSPDFEJNFOUPEFQBHBNFOUP FTUÈJODPSSFUPFBTTJNWJFSBTFSSFDPOIFDJEPQPSGPSÎBEPSFDVSTPTVQFSJPSJOUFSQPTUPB TPMVÎÍPOÍPQPEFSÈTFSEFSFQBSBÎÍPJOEFOJ[BUØSJBVNBWF[RVFBPCSJHBÎÍPFYJTUFFP TFVWBMPSUBNCÏNÏJODPOUSPWFSTP&NEFDPSSÐODJBBDBCBTFOEPJOØDVPBRVFMFSFDVSTP FYDFQDJPOBMKÈRVFUBNCÏNOÍPGB[TFOUJEPQFOTBSOPSFUPSOPEPEJOIFJSPTPNFOUFQBSB QPTUFSHBSPQBHBNFOUPTPCBGPSNBEFQSFDBUØSJPFOÍPEFSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS VNBWF[RVFBRVBOUJBKÈTBJVEPTDPGSFTQÞCMJDPTFÏNFTNPEFWJEBËRVFMFTDSFEPSFT 3BDJPDÓOJPEJWFSTPBUFOUBSJBDPOUSBBFGFUJWJEBEFUÍPBMNFKBEBQFMPTJTUFNBQSPDFTTVBM 8. DA EXIGÊNCIA CONSTITUCIONAL DO TRÂNSITO EM JULGADO PARA A EXPEDIÇÃO DO PRECATÓRIO E DA REQUISIÇÃO DE PEQUENO VALOR 8.1. O início da execução 0 TJTUFNB QSPDFTTVBM QFSNJUF B DPODFQÎÍP EB FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB DPNP BRVFMB QBTTÓWFM EF TBUJTGB[FS P EJSFJUP NBUFSJBM EB QBSUF TVKFJUBOEPB OP FOUBOUP B DPOTFRàÐODJBT FN DBTP EF EFDJTÍP KVEJDJBM FN TFOUJEP EJWFSTP EB SFTQBMEBEB P 4FUPSEF&YFDVÎÜFTDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBù"VUPT 1SPDFEJNFOUP0SEJOÈSJPo)JSPTIJ4IJSBTTVFPVUSPToEFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBQFMB+VÓ[B"MFYBOESB'VDIT EF"SBÞKPFNEFEF[FNCSPEFQVCMJDBEBOP%0&EF 5+41"HSBWPEF*OTUSVNFOUPO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 250 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz WFJDVMBEPQFMPUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPBPNFTNPUFNQPFNRVFQPTTJCJMJUBTJUVBSBQSPWJTP SJFEBEFFNGVOÎÍPEBNFSBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTPTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP &NSFMBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBÏQSFDJTPRVFFTTFUFNBTFKBTJUVBEPËMV[EP EJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPfEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM &NSFMBÎÍPBPNPNFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPBEPVUSJOBBQSFTFOUB FOUFOEJNFOUPT EJWFSHFOUFT NFTNP FN TF USBUBOEP EF VNB FYFDVÎÍP RVF KÈ DPOUB DPNUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP%JTDVUFTFOFTTFÉNCJUPB TF GPSBNPQPTUPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPC TFFTUFTGPSBNSFDFCJEPTOPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP FD TFPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPDPOUBNDPNUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP " EFUFSNJOBÎÍP EP f EP BSUJHP EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM RVBOUP Ë FYJHÐODJBEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBTFOUFOÎBQBSBBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPFOTFKB EVQMJDJEBEFEFFOUFOEJNFOUPT "QSJNFJSBDPSSFOUFDPODMVJQFMBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJOÓDJPEBFYFDVÎÍPNFT NPFTUBOEPBJOEBQFOEFOUFEFBQSFDJBÎÍPSFDVSTPTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOBBÎÍPEF DPOIFDJNFOUPGBMBOEPFNFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBBJOEBRVFFTUBOÍPDVMNJOFDPNB FYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPFEBSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS/FTTFUFNB-FPOBSEP $BSOFJSPEB$VOIB'SFEJF%JEJFS+ÞOJPS1BVMB4BSOP#SBHBF3BGBFM0MJWFJSBBTTJN TFFYQSFTTBN 0UFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFYJHFPQSÏWJPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPQBSBBFYQFEJÎÍP EPQSFDBUØSJPPVEBSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS/ÍPTFFYJHFPQSÏWJP USÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPQBSBRVFTFUFOIBJOÓDJPBFYFDVÎÍP-PHPPRVFTF QPEFQFSNJUJSDPNPBKVJ[BNFOUPEFVNBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBEJBOUFEF VNSFDVSTPEFTQSPWJEPEFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPÏPQSPDFTTBNFOUPJNFEJBUP EBFYFDVÎÍPQSPDFEFOEPTFËDJUBÎÍPEB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQBSBPGFSFDJNFO UPEFFNCBSHPTPTRVBJTTFSÍPQSPDFTTBEPTFKVMHBEPTEBÓTFTFHVJOEPB JOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFFWFOUVBMSFDVSTPEFBQFMBÎÍP&ODFSSBEPUPEPPQSPDFTTB NFOUPEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBEFWFSÈFOUÍPBHVBSEBSTFP EFTGFDIPEPQSPDFTTPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP"QBSUJSEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP QPEFSTFÈFYQFEJSPQSFDBUØSJPPVBSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS <> 4JHOJmDB FOUÍP RVF Ï QPTTÓWFM B FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB FN GBDF EB 'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBQFOBTQBSBQSPDFTTBNFOUPEBEFNBOEBFYFDVUJWB "FYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPPVEBSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPSÏRVFmDB DPOEJDJPOBEBBPQSÏWJPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBTFOUFOÎBQSPGFSJEBOP QSPDFTTPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP/FTTBIJQØUFTFBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBTFSWF BQFOBTQBSBBEJBOUBSPQSPDFTTBNFOUPEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBFMJNJOBOEPVNBFUBQBGVUVSB %*%*&3+Á/*03'SFEJFF$6/)"-FPOBSEP+PTÏ$BSOFJSPF#3"("1BVMB4BSOPF0-*7&*3"3BGBFM Curso de Direito Processual Civil. Execução. 7PMVNF4BMWBEPS&EJUPSB1PEJWNQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 251 /FTTFTFOUJEPKÈTFEFDJEJV '";&/%" 1Á#-*$" &9&$6±°0 1307*4»3*" 0#3*("±°0 %& 1"("31044*#*-*%"%&-*.*5&4 "FYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBDPOUSBBGB[FOEBEFWFHVBSEBSDPOTPOÉODJBDPN BTSFHSBTQFSUJOFOUFTËNBUÏSJBSFTQFJUBOEPPTQSJODÓQJPTEBJNQFOIP SBCJMJEBEF EPT CFOT QÞCMJDPT F OÍP QPEFOEP BMDBOÎBS P NPNFOUP EB FYQFEJÎÍP EF QSFDBUØSJP *TTP QPSRVF B JODMVTÍP EP QSFDBUØSJP OB PS EFNDSPOPMØHJDBFQPTUFSJPSNFOUFFNPSÎBNFOUPBOUFTRVFTFFGFUJWFP USÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBEFNBOEBJNQFEJSÈRVFPWBMPSSFRVJTJUBEPTFKB VUJMJ[BEPQBSBBTmOBMJEBEFTFTTFODJBJTEP&TUBEP"EFNBJTBQFSNJTTÍP QBSBFYQFEJSQSFDBUØSJPFNTFEFEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBÏEJTGBSÎBEB NFOUFVNNFJPEFCVSMBSBPSEFNEFQSFGFSÐODJBGBWPSFDFOEPBRVFMFT RVFUÐNFYQFDUBUJWBEFEJSFJUPFNEFUSJNFOUPEPTRVFKÈPCUJWFSBNVN UÓUVMPEFmOJUJWP33 &NHSVQPEFUSBCBMIPGPSNBEPQPSKVÓ[FTGFEFSBJTRVFQBSUJDJQBSBNEPQSP HSBNBEFQFTRVJTBi&YFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBoSB[ÜFTQPMÓUJDBTEPEFTDVN QSJNFOUPËTPSEFOTKVEJDJBJTwEFTFOWPMWJEPQFMP%FQBSUBNFOUPEF%JSFJUP1SJWBEPEB 6OJWFSTJEBEF'FEFSBM'MVNJOFOTF6'' FNQBSDFSJBDPNP$FOUSPEF&TUVEPTEP +VEJDJÈSJP$&+ EP$POTFMIPEB+VTUJÎB'FEFSBMP3FMBUPSEBQSPQPTUBSFGFSFOUFBP UFNBi&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOP+VJ['SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEB%BOUBTBQSFTFO UPVFOUFOEJNFOUPOPNFTNPTFOUJEPBmSNBOEPRVF“a execução provisória contra a Fazenda Pública pode ser promovida; a exigência do trânsito em julgado da sentença só é necessária para a expedição do precatório”. 34 6NBTFHVOEBDPSSFOUFQBSUFEPQSFTTVQPTUPEFRVFPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVJTTJNFTUBCFMFDFSBGPSNBEFFYFDVÎÍPDBCÓWFMDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBFOÍP BQFOBTmYBSPNPNFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPSFRVJTJUØSJP /FTTFTFOUJEP"SBLFNEF"TTJTKÈTFQSPOVODJPVBPFYBNJOBSPBSUJHP EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM OB SFEBÎÍP BOUFSJPS Ë &NFOEB O FN DPUFKP DPN P BSUJHP/EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMverbis 5PEBFYFDVÎÍPCBTFBSTFÈFNUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPKVEJDJBMPVFYUSBKVEJDJBM &N SFMBÎÍP BP UÓUVMP IÈCJM QBSB SFBMJ[BS DSÏEJUPT QFDVOJÈSJPT QFSBOUF B 'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBIÈUSÐTNFOÎÜFTËTFOUFOÎBBSU/* OPQBS" OPBSUEB$'&NQSJNFJSPMVHBSPcaputBMVEFBiTFOUFOÎBKV 33 535"(3"70%&1&5*±°0"11*+VMHBNFOUP %"/5"4'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEBExecução contra a Fazenda Pública- Regime de PrecatórioFEJÎÍP 4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.ÏUPEP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 252 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz EJDJÈSJBwBEFNBJTPQ"EFmOJOEPBTPCSJHBÎÜFTBMJNFOUBSFTBMVEFB iTFOUFOÎBUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPwmOBMNFOUFPQBHPSBSFMBUJWBNFOUF ËEÓWJEBEFQFRVFOPWBMPSFYJHFiTFOUFOÎBKVEJDJBMUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEP &TTFTUFYUPTDPOWFSHFOUFTOPTFOUJEPJOTJOVBNRVFBFYFDVÎÍPQSFWJTUB OP "SU EP $1$ TPNFOUF JOJDJBSÈ DPN CBTF FN UÓUVMP KVEJDJBM EFmOJUJWP"SU/* SFMFWBOEPTFOBUVSBMNFOUFPFNQSFHPQPVDP UÏDOJDPEBQBMBWSBiTFOUFOÎBwOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEB%BOUBTEJ[RVF)VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSmMJBTF UBNCÏNBFTTBDPSSFOUFDPNPTFWÐ "FTTFSFTQFJUP)6.#&3505)&0%030+Á/*03FOUFOEFIBWFSTJEP FMJNJOBEBEFOPTTPPSEFOBNFOUPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB DPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQPSBmSNBSRVFBNPEJmDBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM FTUBNQBEBOPBSUQBSÈHSBGPBUVBMQBSÈHSBGP EB$' QBTTPVBFYJHJSRVFPQSFDBUØSJPFTUFKBMBTUSFBEPFNiTFOUFOÎBUSBOTJUBEB FNKVMHBEP&NTVBTQBMBWSBTPRVFJOUFOUPVPDPOTUJUVJOUFGPJBCPMJS P FOUFOEJNFOUP BUÏ FOUÍP BDPMIJEP QFMB KVSJTQSVEÐODJB EF RVF B FYFDVÎÍPEFTFOUFOÎBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQPEFSJBTFSJOTUBVSBEB BOUFTEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPTFPSFDVSTPQFOEFOUFOÍPUJWFTTFFGFJUP TVTQFOTJWPw *TTP BHPSB o BmSNB QFSFNQUØSJP o QPTJUJWBNFOUF OÍP Ï NBJTBENJUJEPQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍPw %FTFSFTTBMWBSRVFPQSØQSJP)VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSGB[OPFOUBOUPB TFHVJOUFPCTFSWBÎÍP 04VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBUPEBWJBUFNJOUFSQSFUBEPBWFEBÎÍPDPOT UJUVDJPOBMEFNBOFJSBNBJTCSBOEBPVTFKBB&$OOÍPUFSJBFMJNJOBEP UPUBMNFOUFBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBBRVBMQPEFSJBTFSQSPDFTTBEBBUÏBGBTFEF FNCBSHPTimDBOEPTVTQFOTBEBÓFNEJBOUFBUÏPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEP UÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPTFPTFNCBSHPTOÍPGPSFNPQPTUPTPVGPSFNSFKFJUBEPT 5BMFOUFOEJNFOUPWFJPFYQPTUPDPNNFOÎÍPBPEFDJEJEPQFMP4VQFSJPS5SJ CVOBMEF+VTUJÎBOB.$SFM.JO5FPSJ"MCJOP;BWBTLJPOEFTFEFTUBDPVRVF "44*4"SBLFNManual da ExecuçãoFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT QBH %"/5"4'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEBExecução contra a Fazenda Pública- Regime de PrecatórioFEJÎÍP 4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.ÏUPEPQÈH 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de Direito Processual Civil7PMVNF**FEJÎÍP3JPEF+B OFJSP&EJUPSB'PSFOTFQÈH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 253 iOÍPGPJJOUFJSBNFOUFFYUJOUBBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBwDPNB&NFOEB$POTUJUVJDJPOBMO QPEFOEPTFSQSPDFTTBEBBFYFDVÎÍPBUÏBGBTFEFFNCBSHPTw /FTTFDPOUFYUPEFTFUFSQSFTFOUFRVFQPSWF[FTBTEJWFSHFOUFTQPTJÎÜFTB SFTQFJUPEPJOÓDJPEBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTFFMFQPEFPVEFWFTFEBS BOUFTEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPPVTFEFWFBHVBSEBSOFDFT TBSJBNFOUFBTPMVÎÍPEFmOJUJWBOPQSPDFTTPDPHOJUJWP QBSUFNEFNFOÎÍPTJOHFMBB iFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBwRVBOEPFTUBQPSTFSWJTUBTPCWÈSJBTJOUFSQSFUBÎÜFTOÍPDPO EV[BVNBDPODMVTÍPJOFRVÓWPDB 0GBUPÏRVFPQSJNFJSPDPODFJUPNFODJPOBEPOPTFOUJEPEFRVFÏQPTTÓWFM DIFHBSNFEJBOUFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBËTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPNBUFSJBMEBQBSUFPCUJ EPFNWJTUBEFVNBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPJTPMBEBEPBSUJHP0EP$1$ OÍPÏBQMJDÈWFM Ë 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB EBEB B WFEBÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EF FYQFEJÎÍP EPT QSFDBUØSJPT F SFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSBOUFTEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP &NSFMBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBFYQSFTTÍPiFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBwTPNFOUFÏ BENJUJEBFNEFDPSSÐODJBEFVNBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEPTBSUJHPTF*EP&TUBUVUP 1SPDFTTVBMRVFBMVEFNËTFUBQBTEBFYFDVÎÍPQFSNJUJEBTFORVBOUPQFOEFOUFSFDVSTP TFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBENJUJOEPTFRVFPiUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPwEJ[SFTQFJUPTPNFOUF ËFYQFEJÎÍPEBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUP %FRVBMRVFSGPSNBRVFSTFNFODJPOFPVOÍPBFYQSFTTÍPiFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØ SJBwEFTFDPODMVJSRVFBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPRVFNFMIPSTFDPBEVOBDPNBTEFUFSNJOBÎÜFT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJTÏOPTFOUJEPEFRVFPQSØQSJPJOÓDJPEBFYFDVÎÍPFTUÈDPOEJDJPOBEP BPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP 8.2. O efeito suspensivo dos embargos à execução e do recurso de apelação "EJTDVTTÍPTPCSFTFSQSPWJTØSJBPVEFmOJUJWBVNBFYFDVÎÍPUBNCÏNTFFN CBSBMIBDPNPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP /FTTFBTQFDUPNFSFDFNEFTUBRVFBTDPOTJEFSBÎÜFTEF.BSDFMP"CFMIB 5FNBRVFGSFRVFOUBDPNBTTJEVJEBEFPTOPTTPTUSJCVOBJTÏBDPOGVTÍP RVFTFGB[FOUSFPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPEBPQPTJÎÍPPGFSFDJEBQFMPFYFDVUB EPFBEFmOJUJWJEBEFQSPWJTPSJFEBEFEBUVUFMBFYFDVUJWB "OUFTEFNBJTOBEBEFWFTFEJ[FSRVFBRVBMJmDBÎÍPEBFYFDVÎÍPFNiQSP WJTØSJBwPViEFmOJUJWBwEFDPSSFOBWFSEBEFEPUÓUVMPRVFBGVOEBNFOUB 2VBOEPBFYFDVÎÍPÏMBTUSFBEBFNUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWPQSPWJTØSJPEFOPNJOB TFFOUÍPQSPWJTØSJBBFYFDVÎÍP2VBOEPÏMBTUSFBEBFNUÓUVMPFYFDVUJWP EFmOJUJWPEFOPNJOBTFEFmOJUJWBBFYFDVÎÍP$MBSPRVFRVBOEPTFUSBUB EBQSJNFJSBIJQØUFTFIÈDFSUPTSJHPSFTFFYJHÐODJBTFNSFMBÎÍPËPCUFOÎÍP EBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPFYFRàFOEPNBTFNBNCPTPTDBTPTGVOEBEBFN UÓUVMPQSPWJTØSJPPVEFmOJUJWP BFYFDVÎÍPQPEFSÈDIFHBSBPTFVmOBM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 254 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz 1PSPVUSPMBEPEJ[TFTFSQSPWJTØSJPPUÓUVMPRVBOEPBJOEBFTUÈFNGPS NBÎÍP F EFmOJUJWP RVBOEP KÈ FTUÈ GPSNBEP 4ÍP UÓUVMPT EFmOJUJWPT P QSPWJNFOUPKVEJDJBMUSBOTJUBEPFNKVMHBEPFUPEPTPTUÓUVMPTFYUSBKVEJ DJBJT1PSJTTPRVBOEPTFSWFNEFCBTFBVNBFYFDVÎÍPFMBTFSÈEFm OJUJWB%FPVUSBCBOEBTÍPQSPWJTØSJPTUPEPTPTQSPWJNFOUPTKVEJDJBJT JOUFSJOBJT PV TFKB RVF BJOEB OÍP FTUÍP TFEJNFOUBEPT F RVF QPEFN TFSTVCTUJUVÓEPTQPSVNQSPWJNFOUPEFmOJUJWP1PSUBOUPFTUFTFOTFKBN VNBFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB 0CTFSWFTFRVFPGBUPEFTFSFNPQPTUPTSFNÏEJPTPVNFEJEBTKVEJDJBJT BVNUÓUVMPEFmOJUJWPPVBVNBFYFDVÎÍPGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPEFmOJUJWP QPSUBOUPFYFDVÎÍPEFmOJUJWBOÍPTFMIFTSFUJSBEPUÓUVMPFEBFYFDV ÎÍP P DBSÈUFS EF EFmOJUJWJEBEF QPSRVF SFQJUBTF TÍP UÓUVMPT RVF KÈ GPSBNGPSNBEPT &TUBCFMFDFPfEPBSUJHP"EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM "SUo"0TFNCBSHPTEPFYFDVUBEPOÍPUFSÍPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP 1BSÈHSBGPo0KVJ[QPEFSÈBSFRVFSJNFOUPEPFNCBSHBOUFBUSJCVJS FGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBPTFNCBSHPTRVBOEPTFOEPSFMFWBOUFTTFVTGVOEB NFOUPTPQSPTTFHVJNFOUPEBFYFDVÎÍPNBOJGFTUBNFOUFQPTTBDBVTBSBP FYFDVUBEPHSBWFEBOPEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍPFEFTEFRVFBFYF DVÎÍPKÈFTUFKBHBSBOUJEBQPSQFOIPSBEFQØTJUPPVDBVÎÍPTVmDJFOUFTw "-FJOEFEFEF[FNCSPEFBPJOUSPEV[JSFTTFEJTQPTJUJWP BMUFSPVBTJTUFNÈUJDBDPOTVCTUBODJBEBOBDPODFTTÍPEFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBVUPNÈUJDP BPTFNCBSHPTDPOEJDJPOBOEPBBUSJCVJÎÍPBPQSFFODIJNFOUPEPTSFRVJTJUPTHFOÏSJDPT EBTDBVUFMBSFTfumus boni iuris F periculum in mora ËHBSBOUJBEPKVÓ[PFBPSFRVFSJ NFOUPEPFYFDVUBEP /FMTPO/FSZ+SF3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEF/FSZBDSFTDFOUBNBJOEBBFTTFT SFRVJTJUPTBUFNQFTUJWJEBEFEPTFNCBSHPT 5BMBMUFSBÎÍPOBTJTUFNÈUJDBEBDPODFTTÍPEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBPTFNCBSHPT ËFYFDVÎÍPoEFex lege B ope judicisoJNQMJDPVBUSBOTGFSÐODJBEPTÙOVTEBEFNPSBEP QSPDFTTP0TSJTDPTEBNPSPTJEBEFEPQSPDFTTPRVFFSBNEPFYFRàFOUFNFEJBOUFB TJNQMFTPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQBTTBSBNBTFSEPFYFDVUBEP $PNNVJUBQSPQSJFEBEFFYQMJDB.BSDFMP"CFMIBRVF "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJB QBH /&3:+Á/*03/FMTPOF/&3:3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEFCódigo de Processo Civil comentado e legislação extravaganteFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJTQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 255 VN EPT NPUJWPT QFMPT RVBJT IPVWF VNB JSSFTJHOBÎÍP DPOUSB P FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP ex lege EPT FNCBSHPT GPJ P GBUP EF RVF FSB BCTPMVUBNFO UFQBSBEPYBMRVFVNBUVUFMBBOUFDJQBEBUJWFTTFVNBFYFDVÎÍPJNFEJB UBNFTNPFNVNKVÓ[PEFQSPCBCJMJEBEFFRVFBTFOUFOÎBEFNÏSJUP USBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPDPNDPJTBKVMHBEBNBUFSJBMFDPHOJÎÍPNBJTRVF FYBVSJFOUFBJOEBUJWFTTFEFTFTVCNFUFSBPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPEPTFN CBSHPTEPFYFDVUBEP&SBJOFYQMJDÈWFM )ÈOPFOUBOUPRVFNFOUFOEBRVFPfEPBSUJHPEP&TUBUVUP1SPDFT TVBMOÍPTFBQMJDBË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBPRVFDPOEV[ËDPODMVTÍPQFMBNBOVUFOÎÍPEP TJTUFNBBOUFSJPSDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBVUPNÈUJDPBPTFNCBSHPT5BMFOUFOEJNFOUP WFNMBTUSFBEPOPGBUPEFRVFB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍPTFTVKFJUBBDPOTUSJÎÍPKVEJDJBMOB FYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBTJQSPQPTUB &TTBÏBQPTJÎÍPEF-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEB$VOIBBPDPODMVJSQFMBJOBQMJ DBÎÍPEPSFGFSJEPQSFDFJUPËFYFDVÎÍPQSPQPTUBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQPSRVFFTUB OÍPQSFDJTBHBSBOUJSPKVÓ[PFPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOFMFUSBUBEPFTUÈDPOEJDJPOBEPË QSÏWJBQFOIPSBEFQØTJUPPVDBVÎÍP"EFNBJTBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPPVEBSFRVJ TJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPSEFQFOEFSJBEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEBTFOUFOÎBEPTFNCBSHPT ËFYFDVÎÍP4PNFOUFRVBOEPOÍPIPVWFTTFNBJTEÞWJEBTTPCSFPWBMPSFYFDVUBEPÏ RVFTFSJBQPTTÓWFMBFYQFEJÎÍPEBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPFYQSFTTBBUSBWÏTEPQSFDBUØSJP PVEBSFRVJTJÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS &NDPOTPOÉODJBDPNUBMQPTJDJPOBNFOUPFTUÈ'SFEEJF%JEJFS+ÞOJPSDPNBT TFHVJOUFTQPOEFSBÎÜFT 0QBSÈHSBGPEP"SU"EP$1$OÍPTFBQMJDBËFYFDVÎÍPQSPQPTUB DPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBQFMPTTFHVJOUFTNPUJWPTB PFGFJUPTVTQFOTJ WPEFQFOEFEFQFOIPSBEFQØTJUPPVDBVÎÍP"'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍPTF TVKFJUBBQFOIPSBEFQØTJUPOFNDBVÎÍPOÍPQSFDJTBOEPHBSBOUJSPKVÓ[P QBSBPQPSTFVTFNCBSHPTFC BFYQFEJÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPPSFRVJTJÎÍP EF QFRVFOP WBMPS EFQFOEF EP prévio trânsito em julgado $' "SU QBSÈHSBGPF EFTPSUFRVFTPNFOUFQPEFTFSEFUFSNJOBEPP QBHBNFOUPTFOÍPIPVWFSNBJTEJTDVTTÍPRVBOUPBPWBMPSFYFDVUBEP &OUFOEJNFOUP IÈ OP FOUBOUP FN TFOUJEP DPOUSÈSJP QBSUJOEP EP QSFTTV QPTUPEFRVFBFYJHÐODJBEBHBSBOUJBEPKVÓ[PBQSFTFOUBEBQFMPfEPBSUJHP "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFSTJUÈSJB QBH $6/)"-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPA Fazenda Pública em JuízoFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDBQBH %*%*&3+Á/*03'SFEJFF$6/)"-FPOBSEP+PTÏ$BSOFJSPF#3"("1BVMB4BSOPF0-*7&*3"3BGBFM Curso de Direito Processual Civil. Execução. 7PMVNF4BMWBEPS&EJUPSB1PEJWNQBH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 256 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTPOÍPKVTUJmDBPBGBTUBNFOUPEPDPNBOEPEFTTFQSFDFJUPFN SFMBÎÍPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB /FTTFFOGPRVFKÈTFEFDJEJV BT JOPWBÎÜFT MFHJTMBUJWBT JOTFSJEBT OP $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM RVF GBDJMJUBNBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPEPFYFRàFOUFEFWFNTFSVUJMJ[BEBTOP QSPDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEBTPCQFOBEFBFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSB B'B[FOEBTFUPSOBSNFOPTFmDB[RVFBTFYFDVÎÜFTDPNVOT 0GBUPEFFTUBSTJMFOUFPEJTQPTJUJWPTPCSFB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBUBNCÏNUFN TJEPJOWPDBEPQBSBBBQMJDBÎÍPEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSB FTUBPQPTUB 4PCFTTFQFOTBSOPTDPNFOUÈSJPTBPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM EF5IFPUÙOJP/FHSÍPF+PTÏ3PCFSUP'(PVWFBSFTUPVDPOTJHOBEP /ÍP PCTUBOUF B FYFDVÎÍP DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB PCFEFÎB B SFHSBT FTQFDJBJT FMBT OBEB EJTQÜFN BDFSDB EB FmDÈDJB TVTQFOTJWB EPT SFTQFDUJWPTFNCBSHPT-PHPQBSBFTTFBTTVOUPWBMFNBTOPSNBTHFSBJT DPNBSFEBÎÍPEBEBQFMB-FJO"TTJNFNCBSHPTEB'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBTPNFOUFTFSÍPBQUPTBTVTQFOEFSBFYFDVÎÍPTFQSFFODIJEPTOP RVFDPVCFSPTSFRVJTJUPTQSFWJTUPTOP"SU"Q 05SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBEF4ÍP1BVMPUBNCÏNKÈFOUFOEFVBQMJDÈWFMPQSFDFJUP FNFYBNFOBTBÎÜFTEFFNCBSHPTPQPTUPTQFMB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBTPCBNFTNBQSFNJTTB EFRVFOÍPNBJTIÈPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBVUPNÈUJDPEFWFOEPUBNCÏNPFOUFQÞCMJDP QSPWBSPQSFFODIJNFOUPEPTSFRVJTJUPTEPHSBWFEBOPEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍPPV TFKBPTSFRVJTJUPTHFOÏSJDPTEBTDBVUFMBSFTFNCPSBOÍPFTUFKBDPNQFMJEPBBQSFTFOUBS BTHBSBOUJBTJOEJDBEBTOFTTFEJTQPTJUJWPQFOIPSBEFQØTJUPPVDBVÎÍP /FTTFTFOUJEP /PUPDBOUFËBMFHBÎÍPEFOÍPTFSBQMJDÈWFMPBSUfEP$1$OBT FYFDVÎÜFTDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBJOGVOEBEBBUFTF&NCPSBBFYFDV ÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBPCFEFÎBBSFHSBTFTQFDJBJTÏFMBSFHJEBQF MBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEPDØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM"TTJNJOFYJTUJOEPQSFWJTÍP FYQSFTTBBDFSDBEPTFGFJUPTEPSFDFCJNFOUPEPTFNCBSHPTÈFYFDVÎÍP BUSJCVÓBTFBFMFTPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBQMJDBOEPTFEFJNFEJBUPPBOUJHP BSUJHPQBSÈHSBGPEP$1$ 45+3&TQ343FM.JO)VNCFSUP.BSUJOT%+EF /&(3°05IFPUÙOJPF(067&"+PTÏ3PCFSUP'Código de Processo Civil e legislação processual em vigorFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB4BSBJWBQÈH RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 257 5PEBWJBDPNBSFWPHBÎÍPEPSFGFSJEPEJTQPTJUJWPMFHBMQFMB-FJO EFEFEF[FNCSPEFÏOFDFTTÈSJPBWFSJHVBSTFPTFNCBSHPTEB 'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBJOEBTVTQFOEFNBFYFDVÎÍP 0OPWPBSUJHP"iDBQVUwEP$1$EJTQÜFFYQSFTTBNFOUFRVFiPT FNCBSHPTEPFYFDVUBEPOÍPUFSÍPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPwHSJGFJ 0SBDPNBSFWPHBÎÍPEPQBSÈHSBGPEP"SUEP$1$FBJOUSP EVÎÍP EP BSU " EP NFTNP EJQMPNB MFHBM SFTUB FWJEFOUF RVF B DPODFTTÍP BVUPNÈUJDB EP FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP BPT FNCBSHPT Ë FYFDVÎÍP OÍPNBJTFODPOUSBBNQBSPOBMFHJTMBÎÍPFNWJHPS ²DFSUPRVFPQBSÈHSBGPEPSFGFSJEPEJTQPTJUJWPMFHBMQSFWÐBDPODFT TÍPEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBPTFNCBSHPT 5PEBWJBÏOFDFTTÈSJPOÍPTØPSFRVFSJNFOUPEPFNCBSHBOUFDPNPUBN CÏNBFYQPTJÎÍPEFGVOEBNFOUPTSFMFWBOUFTOPTFOUJEPEFRVFPQSPTTF HVJNFOUPEBFYFDVÎÍPQPTTBDBVTBSBPFYFDVUBEPHSBWFEBOPEFEJGÓDJM PVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍP <> &OÍPBQSPWFJUBËBHSBWBOUFBBMFHBÎÍPEFRVFOÍPDBCFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJ TØSJBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB /PDBTPEPTBVUPTOÍPTFUSBUBEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBNBTEFFYFDVÎÍP EFTFOUFOÎBUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPQPSRVBOUPEPBDØSEÍPFODBSUBEPB nTOÍPDPOTUBUFOIBIBWJEPJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFRVBMRVFSSFDVSTP /P4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBIÈQPTJDJPOBNFOUPOPNFTNPTFOUJEPDPNP TFDPOTUBUB &9&$6±°0 $0/53" " '";&/%" 1Á#-*$" "(3"70 3&(*.&/ 5"- $0/53" %&41"$)0 */*$*"- 26& */%&'&3*6 " $0/$&4 4°0%&&'&*504641&/4*70"04&.#"3(04®&9&$6±°0-&* /"1-*$"#*-*%"%&&'&*504641&/4*70/&$&4 4*%"%& %& $0.1307"±°0 %04 3&26*4*504 13&7*4504 /0 "35"f%0%*1-0."130$&446"-7"-03&4*.16( /"%04 */7*"#*-*%"%& %& 1"(".&/50 *.&%*"50 /&$&44* %"%& %& 53¬/4*50 &. +6-("%0 %04 &.#"3(04 "64³/$*" %&%"/0%&%*'¶$*-06*/$&35"3&1"3"±°0 "-FJOBPSFWPHBSPfEP"SUEP$ØEJHPEF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM FMJNJOPV B BVUPNÈUJDB DPODFTTÍP EF FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP ËFYFDVÎÍPQFMBPQPTJÎÍPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP%FBDPSEPDPNB 5+41"*3FM%FT3FJOBMEP.JMV[[JKVMH 45+"H3HOPT&NC&YF.4%'o3FM.JOJTUSB-BVSJUB7B[oKVM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 258 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz OPWBEJTDJQMJOBFTUBCFMFDJEBQFMBOPWFMMFHJTMBÎÍPRVFJOUSPEV[JVPBSU "OP%JQMPNB1SPDFTTVBMBDPODFTTÍPEFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBPTFN CBSHPTEPEFWFEPSEFQFOEFSÈEFQSPWJNFOUPKVEJDJBMBSFRVFSJNFOUP EPFNCBSHBOUFRVBOEPEFNPOTUSBEPRVFPQSPTTFHVJNFOUPEBFYFDV ÎÍPQPTTBBDBSSFUBSBPFYFDVUBEPEBOPEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍP "TEJTQPTJÎÜFTHFSBJTTPCSFFYDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPTÍPBQMJDÈWFJTBPQSP DFEJNFOUPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBUFPSEB KVSJTQSVEÐODJBEFTUB$PSUFDPSSPCPSBEBQFMBEPVUSJOBTPCSFPUFNB "PQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQFMB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍPDPOmHVSB BQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFEBOPEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍPDBQB[EFFOTFKBSB TVTQFOTÍPEBFYFDVÎÍPOBNFEJEBFNRVFQPSJNQPTJÎÍPMFHBMDPOUJEBOB -FJEF%JSFUSJ[FT0SÎBNFOUÈSJBTPTWBMPSFTJNQVHOBEPTTPNFOUFQPEFSÍP TFSQBHPTBQØTPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEPTSFGFSJEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP "HSBWPSFHJNFOUBMEFTQSPWJEP #FNEFTFWFSOPFOUBOUPFNSFMBÎÍPBFTUFÞMUJNPKVMHBEPEJWFSTBNFOUFEP RVFGB[QBSFDFSBFNFOUBUSBOTDSJUBOÍPFTUÈBMJDFSÎBEPPFOUFOEJNFOUPOBEFTOFDFT TJEBEFEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP0SBDJPDÓOJPFYQPTUPMFWPV FNDPOUBTPNFOUFBQBSUFJODPOUSPWFSTBEPEÏCJUPQBSBUSBUBSEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP DPNPTFDPOTUBUB i0SBPQSØQSJP*/44OPTUFSNPTEBTÞNVMBO"(6SFDPOIFDFRVF i²DBCÓWFMBFYQFEJÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPSFGFSFOUFBparcela incontroversa FN TFEF EF FYFDVÎÍP BKVJ[BEB FN GBDF EB 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBw & OP UPDBOUF Ë parcela impugnada pelos embargos à execução Ï DFSUP RVFTPNFOUFBQØTPKVMHBNFOUPEPTSFGFSJEPTFNCBSHPTTFSÈEFmOJEP P quantum debeatur, UPSOBOEP FYJHÓWFM P DSÏEJUP EFWJEP QFMB 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBHSJGPEPBVUPS /ÍPTFPMWJEBUFSTJEPPPCKFUJWPEBFYUJOÎÍPEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBVUPNÈUJDP EPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPGPJBGBTUBSBEFNPSBEBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPQBSBPDSFEPS RVFKÈTFWJVDPNQFMJEPBBHVBSEBSUPEPPUSÉNJUFEBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUP5BMQSP QØTJUPFTUÈMBOÎBEPFNUPEBBBUVBMEJOÉNJDBEFFGFUJWJEBEFEPEJSFJUP -VJ[(VJMIFSNF.BSJOPOJF4ÏSHJP$SV["SFOIBSUBOBMJTBOEPDBTPDPNQBSUF JODPOUSPWFSTB EP WBMPS QSPQVHOBEP OB FYFDVÎÍP USBUBN EP FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP EPT FNCBSHPTEBTFHVJOUFGPSNB "UVBMNFOUFOÍPIÈNBJTEÞWJEBRVFPDSÏEJUPOÍPFNCBSHBEPQPEFTFS JNFEJBUBNFOUFFYFDVUBEPFRVFBFYFDVÎÍPOFTUFDBTPÏEFEFDJTÍP EFmOJUJWBFOÍPEFEFDJTÍPQSPWJTØSJB"OPWJEBEFEB-FJO FTUÈ FN SFMBÎÍP Ë QPTTJCJMJEBEF EF FYFDVÎÍP EP DSÏEJUP FNCBSHBEP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 259 &TUF DSÏEJUP QPEFSÈ TFS JOUFHSBMNFOUF FYFDVUBEP RVBOEP OÍP GPS BUSJCVÓEPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBPTFNCBSHPTFBMÏNEJTUPFYFDVUBEPFN QBSUFRVBOEPPKVJ[BUSJCVJSFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBPTFNCBSHPTBQFOBTFN SFMBÎÍPBQBSUFEPPCKFUPEBFYFDVÎÍP"QFOBTOFTUFÞMUJNPDBTPÏRVF FYJTUJSÈiFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBwEFQBSDFMBEFDSÏEJUP 2VBOEP PT FNCBSHPT Ë FYFDVÎÍP GPSFN BDPMIJEPT P SFDVSTP EF BQFMBÎÍP TFSÈSFDFCJEPOPEVQMPFGFJUP&NTFUSBUBOEPEFSFKFJÎÍPMJNJOBSEPTFNCBSHPTPV KVMHBNFOUPEFJNQSPDFEÐODJBEPTNFTNPTPFGFJUPEPSFDVSTPFTUBSÈTVKFJUPËSFHSB EP"SU"EP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM 7BMFMFNCSBSRVFPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQPEFNTFSSFKFJUBEPTMJNJOBSNFOUF RVBOEPGPSFNJOUFNQFTUJWPTRVBOEPGPSFNNBOJGFTUBNFOUFQSPUFMBUØSJPTRVBOEP WFSTBSFNTPCSFNBUÏSJBOÍPQSFWJTUBOPSPMEPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJM FRVBOEPGPSJOFQUBBJOJDJBM 5BOUPOPDBTPEFSFKFJÎÍPMJNJOBSRVBOUPOPDBTPKVMHBNFOUPEFJNQSPDF EÐODJBBBQFMBÎÍPOPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPTFHVOEPBSFHSBEPJODJTP7EP &TUBUVUP1SPDFTTVBMOÍPUFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP/PFOUBOUPBOFDFTTJEBEFEFDPNQB UJCJMJ[BÎÍPEPTJTUFNBQSPDFTTVBMDPNBTJTUFNÈUJDBEPTQSFDBUØSJPTDPOEV[ËTPMVÎÍP EJWFSTBOFTTFBTQFDUP /FTTFTFOUJEPDPODMVJ-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEB$VOIB QBSUJOEP EPQSFTTVQPTUPEFRVFBFYFDVÎÍPOÍPQPEFDIFHBSËFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPSFRVJ TJUØSJPBOUFTEFFTUBCFMFDJEPTEFmOJUJWBNFOUFPTSFTQFDUJWPTWBMPSFTRVF“a apelação contra a sentença que rejeita os embargos à execução contra a Fazenda Pública, mercê das referidas exigências constitucionais, há de ser recebida no duplo efeito”. /BWFSEBEFPSFGFSJEPBSUJHPJODJTP7OÍPUFSJBNBJTBQMJDBÎÍPQBSB RVBMRVFS IJQØUFTF KÈ RVF QBSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB P JNQFEJNFOUP EFDPSSFSJB EP UFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFQBSBPTQBSUJDVMBSFTEFDPSSFSJBEPGBUPEFOÍPNBJTFYJTUJS EFGFTBNFEJBOUFBÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTNBTTPNFOUFBUSBWÏTEFJNQVHOBÎÍPDVNQSJ NFOUPEFTFOUFOÎB 8.3. O trânsito em julgado nos embargos à execução $ÈTTJP4DBSQJOFMMB#VFOPBTTFWFSBRVFPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPFYJHJEPQBSBB FYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPOÍPÏBRVFMFRVFTFDPOmHVSBDPNBTPMVÎÍPEPQSPDFTTPEF DPOIFDJNFOUP“mas em relação à sentença que rejeita os embargos opostos pela Fazenda Pública”. ."3*/0/*-VJ[(VJMIFSNFF.*5*%*&30%BOJFMProcesso de ExecuçãoFEJÎÍP&EJUPSB35QÈH #VFOPBQVE$VOIB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 260 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz /FDFTTÈSJPNFTNPQBSBBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPÏPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP EFBNCBTBTBÎÜFTEPQSPDFTTPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPFEBFYFDVÎÍP $VNQSFBUFOUBS OFTTFFOGPRVFRVFNFTNPQBSBBRVFMFTRVFBENJUFNBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJOÓDJPEB FYFDVÎÍPOBQFOEÐODJBEFSFDVSTPTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPW JUFNSFUSP OFDFTTÈSJPTFGB[PUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEPTFNCBSHPTQBSBPTmOTEF FYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJP3BDJPDÓOJPEJWFSTPGBSJBQPSJNQMJDBSOPRVF.BSDFMP"CFMIB EFOPNJOBiQSFDBUØSJPQSPWJTØSJPwPRVFÏJOBDFJUÈWFMQSJODJQBMNFOUFRVBOEPTFUFN QSFTFOUFTFSPCSJHBUØSJBBJODMVTÍPEPTDSÏEJUPTOBEPUBÎÍPPSÎBNFOUÈSJB 0DPOEJDJPOBNFOUPGFJUPQFMBPSEFNDPOTUJUVDJPOBM"SU EBFYQFEJ ÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPFEBTSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSBPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPEFWF TFSDPNQBUJCJMJ[BEPDPNBTOPSNBTQSPDFTTVBJTPVNFMIPSBTSFHSBTQSPDFTTVBJT EFWFNTFSBNPMEBEBTËTEFUFSNJOBÎÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTBUJOFOUFTBPTQBHBNFOUPT EPTEÏCJUPTGB[FOEÈSJPT ²DFSUPRVFPMFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVJOUFQSFUFOEFVJNQFEJSBJOTFSÎÍPEPWB MPSEFVNUÓUVMPGSÈHJMOBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPEFDSÏEJUPTWBMFEJ[FSQBTTÓWFMEF EFTDPOTUJUVJÎÍP"FYJHÐODJBEBEFmOJUJWJEBEFEFDPSSFEPQSJODÓQJPPSÎBNFOUÈSJP TFHVOEPPRVBMPQPEFSQÞCMJDPOÍPEFWFTFSJOTUBEPBPEFTFNCPMTPEFRVBOUJBT RVFOFNNFTNPUFNVNUÓUVMPEFmOJUJWPDPNPMBTUSP5BNCÏNÏDFSUPOÍPKVT UJmDBSTFPQMFJUPQPSRVBOUJBTRVFBJOEBOÍPSFTUBSBNEFmOJEBTQSJODJQBMNFOUF QPSRVF B JOTFSÎÍP EF VNB PSEFN DSPOPMØHJDB EF QBHBNFOUP OÍP FTUBSJB TFOEP UPUBMNFOUFSFTQFJUBEBTFQVEFTTFVNEPTDSFEPSFTTFBOUFDJQBSFNQFEJSWBMPSFT BJOEBQBTTÓWFJTEFBMUFSBÎÍP 9. DAS DISPOSIÇÕES DO PROJETO DO NOVO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL 0 QSPKFUP EP $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM BUVBMNFOUF FN USÉNJUF TPC P O USBUBEBNBUÏSJBBRVJBQSFDJBEBOPTBSUJHPTF %0$6.13*.&/50%&0#3*("±°0%&1"("326"/5*"$&35"1&-"'";&/%"1Á#-*$" Art. 519. 5SBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPBTFOUFOÎBRVFJNQVTFSË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBPEFWFSEFQBHBSRVBOUJB DFSUBPVTFGPSPDBTPBEFDJTÍPRVFKVMHBSBMJRVJEBÎÍPPFYFRVFOUFBQSFTFOUBSÈEFNPOTUSBUJWPEJT DSJNJOBEPFBUVBMJ[BEPEPDSÏEJUPDPOUFOEP *oPOPNFDPNQMFUPPOÞNFSPEPDBEBTUSPEFQFTTPBTGÓTJDBTPVEPDBEBTUSPOBDJPOBMEFQFTTPBT KVSÓEJDBTEPFYFRVFOUF **oPÓOEJDFEFDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBBEPUBEP ***oBUBYBEPTKVSPTEFNPSBBQMJDBEB *7oPUFSNPJOJDJBMFPUFSNPmOBMEPTKVSPTFEBDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBVUJMJ[BEPT 7oFTQFDJmDBÎÍPEPTFWFOUVBJTEFTDPOUPTPCSJHBUØSJPTSFBMJ[BEPT f )BWFOEP QMVSBMJEBEF EF FYFRVFOUFT DBEB VN EFWFSÈ BQSFTFOUBS P TFV QSØQSJP EFNPOTUSBUJWP BQMJDBOEPTFËIJQØUFTFTFGPSPDBTPPEJTQPTUPOPTffFEPBSU f"NVMUBQSFWJTUBOPfEPBSUOÍPTFBQMJDBË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 261 %FUFSNJOBÎÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTRVBOUPBPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPFBSFRVJTJÎÍP EFQFRVFOPWBMPSQBTTBSBNBDPNQPSBMFHJTMBÎÍPJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 0 OPWP $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM FTUBCFMFDF OP BSUJHP FYQSFTTBNFOUF B OFDFTTJEBEF EF TF BQPOUBS EF JNFEJBUP B EJGFSFOÎB EP BMFHBEP DPNP FYDFTTP EF FYFDVÎÍP BTQFDUP FTTF RVF OP QBTTBEP HFSPV NVJUP EJTDVTTÍP QPJT NVJUBT WF[FT QSJODJQBMNFOUFRVBOEPTFEJTDVUJBDSJUÏSJPEFBUVBMJ[BÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBÓOEJDFTDPSSFUJ WPT EFJYBWBB'B[FOEBEFJOEJDBSPTWBMPSFTRVFKVMHBWBEFWJEPTQPTUFSHBOEPPNP NFOUPEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEBNFNØSJBEFDÈMDVMPTPCBMFHBÎÍPEFRVFQPSTFUSBUBSEF EJOIFJSPQÞCMJDPKVTUJmDBWBTFBFMBCPSBÎÍPEBDPOUBEFMJRVJEBÎÍPQFMB$POUBEPSJB +VEJDJBM0CTFSWBTFRVFFTTFNFTNPEJTQPTJUJWPUBNCÏNFTUBCFMFDFRVFB'B[FOEB TFSÈintimada, QPSUBOUPOÍPNBJTDJUBEBFQBSBimpugnarBFYFDVÎÍPOÍPNBJTPQPS FNCBSHPTBQPOUBOEPBTTJNQBSBBBEPÎÍPEPNPEFMPTJODSÏUJDP0QSFDFJUPTJMFODJB RVBOUPBPFGFJUPRVFTFSÈSFDFCJEBBJNQVHOBÎÍP NBTQFSNJUFBDPODMVTÍPFNWJTUB EPEJTQPTUPOPTFVfRVFOBQBSUFJNQVHOBEBOÍPTFSÈQPTTÓWFMPQSPTTFHVJNFOUP EBTNFEJEBTQBSBBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPBUÏTFVKVMHBNFOUP %FTFOPUBSRVFBQSØQSJBMPDBMJ[BÎÍPUPQPHSÈmDBEBNBUÏSJBOP5ÓUVMP** EFOPNJOBEPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBoKÈJOEV[ËEFSSVCBEBEBBVUPOPNJBEPQSP DFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPQBSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB /PÉNCJUPEBEFGFTBBTFSBQSFTFOUBEBOPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQFSNBOFDF PFMFODPSFTUSJUJWPEFNBUÏSJBTEPBSUJHPEPEJQMPNBMFHBMWJHFOUF Art. 520. " 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB TFSÈ JOUJNBEB QBSB RVFSFOEP OP QSB[P EF USJOUB EJBT F OPT QSØQSJPT BVUPTJNQVHOBSBFYFDVÎÍPDBCFOEPOFMBBSHVJS *oGBMUBPVOVMJEBEFEBDJUBÎÍPTFPQSPDFTTPDPSSFVËSFWFMJB **oJMFHJUJNJEBEFEFQBSUF ***oBJOFYJHJCJMJEBEFEPUÓUVMP *7oPFYDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍP 7oDVNVMBÎÍPJOEFWJEBEFFYFDVÎÜFT 7*oJODPNQFUÐODJBEPKVÓ[PEBFYFDVÎÍPCFNDPNPTVTQFJÎÍPPVJNQFEJNFOUPEPKVJ[ 7**oRVBMRVFSDBVTBJNQFEJUJWBNPEJmDBUJWBPVFYUJOUJWBEBPCSJHBÎÍPDPNPQBHBNFOUPOPWBÎÍP DPNQFOTBÎÍPUSBOTBÎÍPPVQSFTDSJÎÍPEFTEFRVFTVQFSWFOJFOUFTËTFOUFOÎB f2VBOEPTFBMFHBSRVFPFYFRVFOUFFNFYDFTTPEFFYFDVÎÍPQMFJUFJBRVBOUJBTVQFSJPSËSFTVMUBOUF EPUÓUVMPDVNQSJSÈËFYFDVUBEBEFDMBSBSEFJNFEJBUPPWBMPSRVFFOUFOEFDPSSFUPTPCQFOBEFOÍP DPOIFDJNFOUPEBBSHVJÎÍP f/ÍPJNQVHOBEBBFYFDVÎÍPPVSFKFJUBEBTBTBSHVJÎÜFTEBFYFDVUBEB *oFYQFEJSTFÈQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEPQSFTJEFOUFEPUSJCVOBMDPNQFUFOUFQSFDBUØSJPFNGBWPSEPFYF RVFOUFPCTFSWBOEPTFPEJTQPTUPOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDB **oQPSPSEFNEPKVJ[EJSJHJEBËBVUPSJEBEFDJUBEBQBSBBDBVTBPQBHBNFOUPEFPCSJHBÎÍPEFQFRVFOP WBMPSTFSÈSFBMJ[BEPOPQSB[PEFTFTTFOUBEJBTDPOUBEPTEBFOUSFHBEBSFRVJTJÎÍPNFEJBOUFEFQØTJUPOB BHÐODJBNBJTQSØYJNBEFCBODPPmDJBM f 5SBUBOEPTF EF JNQVHOBÎÍP QBSDJBM B QBSUF OÍP RVFTUJPOBEB QFMB FYFDVUBEB TFSÈ EFTEF MPHP PCKFUPEFDVNQSJNFOUP f1BSBFGFJUPEPEJTQPTUPOPJODJTP***EPcaput EFTUFBSUJHPDPOTJEFSBTFUBNCÏNJOFYJHÓWFMPUÓUVMP KVEJDJBMGVOEBEPFNMFJPVBUPOPSNBUJWPEFDMBSBEPTJODPOTUJUVDJPOBJTQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM PVGVOEBEPFNBQMJDBÎÍPPVJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEBMFJPVBUPOPSNBUJWPUJEBTQFMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM DPNPJODPNQBUÓWFJTDPNB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDBFNDPOUSPMFDPODFOUSBEPEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF PVRVBOEPBOPSNBUJWFSTVBFYFDVÎÍPTVTQFOTBQFMP4FOBEP'FEFSBMw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 262 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz "EFDJTÍPTPCSFBJNQVHOBÎÍPTFSÈEFTBmBEBNFEJBOUFSFDVSTPEFBHSBWP MFNCSBOEPTFRVFIPKFPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPDPNPDPOTUJUVFNBÎÍPBVUÙOPNB EFDJEJEBNFEJBOUFTFOUFOÎBTVKFJUBNTFBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFBQFMBÎÍP 5SBUPVBJOEBPOPWP$1$EFSFHVMBSBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDBGVOEBEBFNUÓUVMPFYUSBKVEJDJBMFMFWBOEPBstatusEFMFJPFOUFOEJNFOUPDSJTUBMJ[BEP OB4ÞNVMBOEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBBUSBWÏTEBOPSNBEPBSUJHP0QSP DFEJNFOUPQBSBPTUÓUVMPTFYUSBKVEJDJBJTÏPEFPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍP /BEBSFTUPVFTUBCFMFDJEPOP1SPKFUPRVBOUPËTNFEJEBTBTFSFNBEPUBEBT FNDBTPEFGBMUBEFQBHBNFOUPEBTSFRVJTJÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSDBCFOEPBBQMJ DBÎÍP BOBMØHJDB EP BSUJHP EB -FJ EPT +VJ[BEPT DPOUSB B 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB RVF FTUBCFMFDFRVF“desatendida a requisição judicial, o juiz, imediatamente, determinará o sequestro do numerário suficiente ao cumprimento da decisão, dispensada a audiência da Fazenda Pública.” 10. CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS "TDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEPTCFOTQÞCMJDPToJOBMJFOBCJMJEBEFJNQSFTDSJUJCJ MJEBEFFJNQFOIPSBCJMJEBEFoUPSOBNJNQPTTÓWFMBBQMJDBÎÍPEBTSFHSBTQSPDFTTVBJT USBEJDJPOBJTQBSBBFYFDVÎÍPEPTEFWFEPSFTTPMWFOUFTEFPCSJHBÎÜFTQPSRVBOUJBDFSUB /ÍPIÈOBFYFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBRVBOUPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEF BEJNQMFNFOUPWPMVOUÈSJPFBWJPMÐODJBQBUSJNPOJBMRVFDBSBDUFSJ[BFTTBNPEBMJEBEF EFFYFDVÎÍPBRVBMQBSBPTQBSUJDVMBSFTJOJDJBTFDPNBQFOIPSBFUFSNJOBDPNB FYQSPQSJBÎÍPFNIBTUBQÞCMJDB $PNPBFYFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBUFNQFDV MJBSJEBEFTEFDPSSFOUFTEBOBUVSF[BEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTOÍPGPJBEPUBEPPNPEFMP TJODSÏUJDPDPOTVCTUBODJBEPOBFYFDVÎÍPDPNPFUBQBTFHVJOUFËDPOEFOBÎÍPOPRVF QFTFBMHVNBTEBTEFUFSNJOBÎÜFTSFGFSFOUFTBPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBQPTTBNMIF TFSWJSFYOPSNBEP"SUO*$1$ "FYFDVÎÍPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBUFNQFDVMJBSJEBEFTQSØQSJBTEJTTP DJBEBTEPDPODFJUPUSBEJDJPOBMEFFYFDVÎÍPMFNCSBOEPTFRVFUBMDPODFQÎÍPFTUÈJOFYPSB WFMNFOUFSFMBDJPOBEPËWJPMÐODJBSFBMJ[BEBQFMP&TUBEPOPQBUSJNÙOJPEFVNEFWFEPS/P DBTPEB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBDPNPOÍPIÈBUJWJEBEFTVCTUJUVUJWBQSÈUJDBEFBUPTEFTVCSPHB ÎÍP OÍPIÈDBCJNFOUPOBBmSNBÎÍPEFUFSBTFOUFOÎBDPOEFOBUØSJBUFOIBGPSÎBFYFDVUJWB "$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMBQBSUJSEB&NFOEBOFTUBCFMFDFV QBSB B FYQFEJÎÍP EPT QSFDBUØSJPT B OFDFTTJEBEF EF isentenças transitadas em julgadowQSPQJDJBOEPDPNUBMSFEBÎÍPQPTJÎÜFTEPVUSJOÈSJBTFKVSJTQSVEFODJBJTEJWFSTBT %PVUSJOBFKVSJTQSVEÐODJBVUJMJ[BNPTDPODFJUPTEFEFmOJUJWJEBEFFQSPWJTPSJFEBEFEB FYFDVÎÍPQBSBTJUVBSPNPNFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍPEBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPFNWJTUBEB SFGFSJEBFYJHÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 Execução contra a Fazenda Pública por obrigações pecuniárias decorrentes de títulos judiciais 263 &YJTUFNEPJTUJQPTEFFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBDPODFCJEBFTUBFNWJTUBEB FYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTPQFOEFOUFEFBQSFDJBÎÍPo(i)BRVFSFTVMUBEBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTP TFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPF(ii) BRVFEFDPSSFEFQSPWJEÐODJBTJO UFSJOBJTOPDVSTPEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPFEBQSØQSJBPQPTJÎÍPEFTUFToPTDPODFJUPT DPOGVOEFNTFOPNPNFOUPEBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEBFYJHÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEPUSÉOTJUPFN KVMHBEPQBSBmOTEFFYQFEJÎÍPEBPSEFNEFQBHBNFOUPBPQPEFSQÞCMJDP " QPTJÎÍP EPVUSJOÈSJB RVF BENJUF GBMBS FN FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB QBSB B'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBOÍPQBSUFEBQSFNJTTBEFTFSBQSPWJTPSJFEBEFVNQSPDFEJNFOUP RVFTFDPNQMFUBDPNBTBUJTGBÎÍPEPDSFEPSTVKFJUBOEPPBEFUFSNJOBEBTDPOTFRV ÐODJBTFNDBTPEFQSPOVODJBNFOUPKVEJDJBMEJWFSTPNBTBEPUBFOUFOEJNFOUPEFRVF BQSPWJTPSJFEBEFFTUÈSFMBDJPOBEBËBEPÎÍPEFQSPWJEÐODJBTOPÉNCJUPEBFYFDVÎÍP UPEBWJBJNQFEJEBTFNSB[ÍPEBJOFYJTUÐODJBEFTPMVÎÍPEFmOJUJWBOBBÎÍPEFDPOIF DJNFOUPEBPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPPVEBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFBQFMBÎÍPOFTTB TFEFEFQSPQJDJBSBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEPEJSFJUPNBUFSJBMEBQBSUF 1BSB BMHVOT QPEFTF GBMBS FN FYFDVÎÍP QSPWJTØSJB OB QFOEÐODJB EF SFDVSTPTFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOBBÎÍPEFDPOIFDJNFOUPBQFOBTQBSBBEJBOUBSPQSP DFTTBNFOUPEBFYFDVÎÍP+ÈQBSBPVUSPTBVUPSFTBSFEBÎÍPEPBSUJHPEPEJQMPNB DPOTUJUVDJPOBMUFSJBQSPJCJEPBJOTUBVSBÎÍPEBFYFDVÎÍPBOUFTEPUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEP 04VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBVUJMJ[BBFYQSFTTÍPiFYFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJBwDPOUSBB'B [FOEB1ÞCMJDBNBTSFMBUJWJ[BPSFTQFDUJWPDPODFJUPMFWBOEPFNDPOUBOBNBJPSJBEBT WF[FTBFYJTUÐODJBEFQBSUFJODPOUSPWFSTBEPEÏCJUP 0FGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPex legisEPTFNCBSHPTËFYFDVÎÍPQBTTPVBTFSope judicisNBTOÍPQBSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBRVBMFTUÈTVCNFUJEBBEJUBNFTDPOTUJUV DJPOBJTRVFFYDFQDJPOBNBTSFHSBTQSPDFTTVBJT)ÈOPFOUBOUPQPTJÎÍPFNTFOUJEP DPOUSÈSJPFOUFOEFOEPRVFQBSBPCUFSUBMFGFJUPB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBUBNCÏNEFWFTF TVKFJUBSBEFNPOTUSBÎÍPEPQSFFODIJNFOUPEPTSFRVJTJUPTEPBSUJHP"fEP $ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMSFRVJTJUPTHFOÏSJDPTEBTDBVUFMBSFTHBSBOUJBEPKVÓ[PFSF RVFSJNFOUPEPFYFDVUBEP &NTFEFKVSJTQSVEFODJBMUBNCÏNIÈBEPÎÍPEFTTBMJOIB EFFOUFOEJNFOUPTFSWJOEPEFFYFNQMPDBTPTEP+VEJDJÈSJP1BVMJTUB 0QSPKFUPEP/PWP$ØEJHPEF1SPDFTTP$JWJMGF[BMUFSBÎÜFTEFNPEP B TVCUSBJS EB 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB P QSPDFTTP BVUÙOPNP EF FYFDVÎÍP FTUFOEFOEPMIF PVUSBTSFHSBTEPDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBBMHVNBTSFHSBTEPNPEFMPTJODSÏUJDPKÈB BMDBOÎBNBUVBMNFOUF REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS "#&-)".BSDFMPManual de Execução CivilFEJÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF6OJWFS TJUÈSJB "44*4"SBLFNManual da ExecuçãoFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT 5SJCVOBJT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 264 Regina Maria Rodrigues da Silva Jacovaz #"4504$FMTP3JCFJSPCurso de Direito Financeiro e de Direito Tributário.FEJÎÍP4ÍP 1BVMP&EJUPSB4BSBJWB $6/)"-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPA Fazenda Pública em JuízoFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDB %"/5"4'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEBExecução contra a Fazenda Pública - Regime de PrecatórioFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.ÏUPEP %*%*&3+Á/*03'SFEJFF$6/)"-FPOBSEP+PTÏ$BSOFJSPF#3"("1BVMB4BSOPF 0-*7&*3"3BGBFMCurso de Direito Processual Civil. Execução. 7PMVNF4BMWBEPS&EJUPSB 1PEJWN %*/"."3$0 5BTTVT o Da Execução contra a Fazenda Pública – Aspectos gerais de uma execução ainda controvertida. XXXBCEQDPSHCSBCEQDBSUJHPTBVUPSBTQ JE "DFTTP FNNBJP '03/"$*"3*+Á/*03$MJUP"MÏNEB&YFDVÎÍPQSPWJTØSJB&EJUPSB.BHJTUFS1PSUP"MF HSF%JTQPOÓWFMFNiXXXFEJUPSBNBHJTUFSDPNEPVUSJOBMFSQIQ JE%BUBEFBDFTTP '3"/;²-VJT)FOSJRVF#BSCBOUFoBSUJHPJOUJUVMBEPi5VUFMBEF6SHÐODJBOB&YFDVÎÍPDPO USBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBwJOi&YFDVÎÍPDJWJMFDVNQSJNFOUPEFTFOUFOÎBw$PPSEFOBÎÍP4ÏSHJP 4IJNVSBF(JMCFSUP(PNFT#SVTDIJWPM4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.ÏUPEP (3&$0-FPOBSEPoO Processo de ExecuçãoWPM**3JPEF+BOFJSP3FOPWBS )0-;8BOUVJM-VJ[$ÉOEJEPo&YFDVÎÍPQPSRVBOUJBDFSUBDPOUSB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB5FTF EFEJTTFSUBÎÍP*OIUUQXXXGEDCS"SRVJWPT.FTUSBEP%JTTFSUBDPFT*OUFHSB8BOUVJM-VJ [$BOEJEP)PM[QEG "DFTTPFNKVMIP ."3*/0/*-VJ[(VJMIFSNFF.*5*%*&30%BOJFMCódigo de Processo Civil Comentado. 4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB35 @@@@@@@@@@@@@Processo de ExecuçãoFEJÎÍP&EJUPSB35 .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito AdministrativoFE4ÍP1BVMP .BMIFJSPT /&(3°05IFPUÙOJPF(067&"+PTÏ3PCFSUP'Código de Processo Civil e legislação processual em vigorFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB4BSBJWB /&3:+Á/*03/FMTPOF/&3:3PTB.BSJBEF"OESBEFCódigo de Processo Civil comentado e legislação extravaganteFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB3FWJTUBEPT5SJCVOBJT 30$)"*CSBJN+PTÏEBT.FSDÐTExecução de débitos de pequeno valor contra a Fazenda Pública"SUf¡VSHÐODJBEFVNBNFEJEBQSPWJTØSJBFTVBQPTTJCJMJEBEF"SU EB$' +VT/BWJHBOEJ5FSFTJOBBOPOBCS%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQKVTVPM DPNCSEPVUSJOBUFYUPBTQ JE"DFTTPFNOPW 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPCurso de Direito Processual Civil7PMVNF**FEJÎÍP 3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB'PSFOTF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 227 a 264 MANDADO DE SEGURANÇA E SILÊNCIO ADMINISTRATIVO Writ of Mandamus and the administrative silence Marina de Lima Lopes1 SUMÁRIO .BOEBEP EF 4FHVSBOÎB o CSFWF IJTUØSJDP )JQØUFTFT EF DBCJNFOUP 4JMÐODJP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP .BOEBEP EF 4FHVSBOÎB FN GBDF EP 4JMÐODJP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP 1SJNFJSBIJQØUFTFQSFWJTÍPMFHBMEFQSB[PQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPFEBTDPOTFRVÐODJBT EBPNJTTÍP4FHVOEBIJQØUFTFQSFWJTÍPMFHBMEFQSB[PQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPTFN JNQPTJÎÍPEFDPOTFRVÐODJBTQBSBBPNJTTÍP5FSDFJSBIJQØUFTFBVTÐODJBEFQSFWJTÍP MFHBMEFQSB[PQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPFEBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTEBPNJTTÍP"VTÐODJBEF SFTQPTUBBSFRVFSJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP'BMUBEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFEFWFSMFHBM $PODMVTÍP3FGFSÐODJBT#JCMJPHSÈmDBT RESUMO 0FTUVEPBOBMJTBBTIJQØUFTFTEFBENJTTÍPEBBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBO ÎBDPOUSBBUPTPNJTTPTEP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP"CPSEBPTDBTPTDPNQSFWJTÍPMFHBMEFQSB[PQBSB BQSÈUJDBEPBUPDPNBVTÐODJBEFQSB[PmYBEPQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPBBVTÐODJBEFSFTQPTUB BPSFRVFSJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPFQPSmNBGBMUBEFDVNQSJNFOUPEFEFWFSMFHBM ABSTRACT 5IF QSFTFOU TUVEZ BOBMZ[FT UIF BQQMJBODF GPS .BOEBNVT BOE JUT IZQPUIFTJT BT B DPOTUJUVUJPOBM XSJU BHBJOTU UIF 1VCMJD 1PXFS PNJTTJPO "EESFTTJOH DBTFT GPS BO BCTFODFPOBMFHBMUFSNGPSBTUBUFBDUJPOPSGPSBQVCMJDSFTQPOTFUPUIFBENJOJTUSBUJWF SFRVFTUTPSmOBMMZUPUIFQVCMJDBENJOJTUSBUJPOUPDPNQMJBODFXJUIBMFHBMEVUZ Palavras-chaves1SPDFTTP$POTUJUVDJPOBM.BOEBEPEF4FHVSBOÎB4JMÐODJP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP)JQØUFTFT1SB[P%FDBEFODJBM Keyword1SPDFTT$POTUJUVUJPOBM8SJUPG.BOEBNVT1VCMJD1PXFSPNJTTJPO-FHBMEVUZ 1. MANDADO DE SEGURANÇA – BREVE HISTÓRICO 0NBOEBEPTFHVSBOÎBDPNPJOTUSVNFOUPQSPDFTTVBMDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFQSPUF ÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPOUSBMFTÜFTBEJSFJUPTTVCKFUJWPTQÞCMJDPTGPJDPOTBHSBEPJOJDJBMNFOUFOB $POTUJUVJÎÍPEFTPCJOnVÐODJBEPTwrits EPEJSFJUPBNFSJDBOPBQØTBSFTUSJÎÍP EP habeas corpus ËT IJQØUFTFT EF PGFOTB BP EJSFJUP EF MPDPNPÎÍP GFJUB QFMB &NFOEB $POTUJUVDJPOBMEF "$BSUBEFFNTFVBSUQSFWJBPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPNP SFNÏEJPQBSBBEFGFTBEFiEJSFJUPDFSUPFJODPOUFTUÈWFMwOPTTFHVJOUFTUFSNPT %BSTFÈ NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎB QBSB EFGFTB EF EJSFJUP DFSUP F JODPOUFTUÈWFM BNFBÎBEP PV WJPMBEP QPS BUP NBOJGFTUBNFOUF JODPOTUJUVDJPOBM PV JMFHBM EF RVBMRVFS BVUPSJEBEF 0 QSPDFTTP TFSÈ 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEP&TQFDJBMJTUBFN%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM$JWJMF%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPQFMB&TDPMB4VQF SJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB(FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP&41(& .&/%&4(JMNBS'FSSFJSBet al. Curso de Direito Constitucional. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB Q 266 Marina de Lima Lopes P NFTNP EP IBCFBT DPSQVT EFWFOEP TFS TFNQSF PVWJEB B QFTTPB EF EJSFJUPQÞCMJDPJOUFSFTTBEB0NBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBOÍPQSFKVEJDBBT BÎÜFTQFUJUØSJBTDPNQFUFOUFT "QSFWJTÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMNBOUFWFTFFNRVBTFUPEPTPTUFYUPTQPTUFSJPSFTDPOT UBOEPEFNPEPTFNFMIBOUFEP"SUfEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFEP"SUf EB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFFEP"SUfEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO¡ $POTUJUVJÎÍPEPT&TUBEPT6OJEPTEP#SBTJMEF "SU<>f1BSBQSPUFHFSEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPOÍPBNQBSBEP QPSIBCFBTDPSQVTDPODFEFSTFÈNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBTFKBRVBMGPS BBVUPSJEBEFSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFS $POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDB'FEFSBUJWBEP#SBTJMEF "SU<>f$PODFEFSTFÈNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBQBSBQSPUFHFS EJSFJUPJOEJWJEVBMMJRVJEPFDFSUPOÍPBNQBSBEPQPSIBCFBTDPSQVTTFKB RVBMGPSBBVUPSJEBEFSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFS &NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEFEFPVUVCSPEF "SU<>ùf$PODFEFSTFÈNBOEBUPEFTFHVSBOÎBQBSBQSPUFHFS EJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPOÍPBNQBSBEPQPSIBCFBTDPSQVTTFKBRVBMGÙSB BVUPSJEBEFSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFS &YDFÎÍP TF EFV OB $BSUB EF RVF BQFOBT QSFWJV P habeas corpus. /P FOUBOUPDPOGPSNFSFTTBMUB"OESÏ3BNPT5BWBSFT3BQFTBSEBGBMUBEFBTTFOUPDPOTUJUV DJPOBMPJOTUJUVUPQFSNBOFDFVEJTDJQMJOBEPËÏQPDBOPÉNCJUPJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM <>P%FDSFUPMFJEFEFOPWFNCSPEFSFBmSNPVBNFEJEB QSBUJDBNFOUF OPT UFSNPT EP RVF EJTQVOIB B BOUJHB -FJ O FNCPSBQFSEFOEPPBTTFOUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFBTHBSBOUJBTRVFMIFFSBN JOFSFOUFTQPSGPSÎBEFTTBJOTFSÎÍPOPSNBUJWBNÈYJNB 0 $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFTTP $JWJM OBDJPOBM EF BDPMIFV P JOTUJUVUP DPOTJEFSBOEPPVNQSPDFTTPFTQFDJBMFEJTDJQMJOBOEPPOPBSU "UVBMNFOUF P NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎB FTUÈ QSFWJTUP OP "SU ¡ -9*9 EP $BQÓUVMP * o %PT %JSFJUPT F %FWFSFT *OEJWJEVBJT F $PMFUJWPT EP 5ÓUVMP ** o %PT %JSFJUPTF(BSBOUJBT'VOEBNFOUBJTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFRVFEJTQÜF FYQSFTTBNFOUFRVF 3 5"7"3&4"OESÏ3BNPTManual do Novo Mandado de Segurança: Lei 12.016/2009.3JPEF+BOFJSP'P SFOTFQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 267 -9*9 o DPODFEFSTFÈ NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎB QBSB QSPUFHFS EJSFJUP MÓRVJEPFDFSUPOÍPBNQBSBEPQPSiIBCFBTDPSQVTwPViIBCFBTEBUBw RVBOEPPSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFSGPSBVUPSJEBEF QÞCMJDB PV BHFOUF EF QFTTPB KVSÓEJDB OP FYFSDÓDJP EF BUSJCVJÎÜFT EP 1PEFS1ÞCMJDP 5SBUBTFEFHBSBOUJBJOTUSVNFOUBMRVFWJTBBTTFHVSBSBFGFUJWJEBEFEPTEJSFJUPT GVOEBNFOUBJTDMBTTJmDBEBEPVUSJOBSJBNFOUFDPNPcláusula pétreaFQSPUFHJEBQFMP"SU f¡EB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEB3FQÞCMJDBOÍPQPEFOEPQPSUBOUPTFSTVQSJNJEBPVUFS TFVFTQFDUSPEFQSPUFÎÍPBMUFSBEPPVBMJKBEPQPSNFJPEF&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBM. "EFNBJTPBTTFOUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFTUFJOTUSVNFOUPQSPDFTTVBMUBNCÏNJN QFEF VNB JOUFSQSFUBÎÍP SFTUSJUJWB EF TFV DBCJNFOUP F WFEB B JNQPTJÎÍP EF OPWPT DPOEJDJPOBNFOUPTQPSMFJSFHVMBNFOUBEPSB *NQPSUBOUFOPUBSRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍP$JEBEÍJOPWPVBPFYQSFTTBNFOUFQSF WFSBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJNQFUSBÎÍPEFNBOEBOEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPMFUJWPFNTFV"SU ¡-99RVFQPEFTFSQSPQPTUPQPSQBSUJEPQPMÓUJDPDPNSFQSFTFOUBÎÍPOP$POHSFT TP/BDJPOBMPVQPSPSHBOJ[BÎÍPTJOEJDBMFOUJEBEFEFDMBTTFPVBTTPDJBÎÍPMFHBMNFOUF DPOTUJUVÓEBFFNGVODJPOBNFOUPIÈQFMPNFOPTVNBOPFNEFGFTBEPTJOUFSFTTFTEF TFVTNFNCSPTPVBTTPDJBEPT /PÉNCJUPJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBFTUÈIPKFEJTDJQMJOB EPQFMB-FJO¡RVFOPSNBUJ[PVDPNQMFUBNFOUFPJOTUJUVUPSFWPHBOEP FYQSFTTBNFOUFBMFHJTMBÎÍPBOUFSJPSTFNDPOUVEPJNQMFNFOUBSHSBOEFTBMUFSBÎÜFT WJTUPRVFTFMJNJUPVBSFQFUJSPTBOUJHPTEJTQPTJUJWPTBDSFTDFOUBOEPFOUFOEJNFOUPTKÈ DPOTBHSBEPTOBEPVUSJOBFKVSJTQSVEÐODJBQÈUSJB i"SU<>f/ÍPTFSÈPCKFUPEFEFMJCFSBÎÍPBQSPQPTUBEFFNFOEBUFOEFOUFBBCPMJS oBGPSNBGFEFSBUJWBEF&TUBEP II oPWPUPEJSFUPTFDSFUPVOJWFSTBMFQFSJØEJDP III oBTFQBSBÎÍPEPT1PEFSFT IV oPTEJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBTJOEJWJEVBJTw i"HBSBOUJBEFQFSNBOÐODJBFNRVFDPOTJTUFBDMÈVTVMB QÏUSFB FN TVNB JNVOJ[B P TFOUJEP EFTTBT DBUFHPSJBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTQSPUFHJEBTDPOUSBBMUFSBÎÜFTRVFBMJHFJSFNPTFVOÞDMFPCÈTJDPPVEFMJNJUFN BQSPUFÎÍPRVFGPSOFDFN/FTTFTFOUJEPTFEFWFDPNQSFFOEFSPBSUf¡EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM DPNPQSPJCJÎÍPËEFMJCFSBÎÍPEFQSPQPTUBUFOEFOUFBBCPMJSJTUPÏBNJUJHBSBSFEV[JSPTJHOJmDBEPF BFmDÈDJBEBGPSNBGFEFSBUJWBEP&TUBEPEPWPUPEJSFUPTFDSFUPVOJWFSTBMFQFSJØEJDPBTFQBSBÎÍPEF 1PEFSFTFPTEJSFJUPTFHBSBOUJBTJOEJWJEVBJTw.&/%&4(JMNBS'FSSFJSBet al. Curso de Direito Constitucional. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQoHSJGPEPBVUPS "SU¡<>i-99oPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPMFUJWPQPEFTFSJNQFUSBEPQPS B QBSUJEPQPMÓUJDPDPNSFQSFTFOUBÎÍPOP$POHSFTTP/BDJPOBM C PSHBOJ[BÎÍPTJOEJDBMFOUJEBEFEFDMBTTFPVBTTPDJBÎÍPMFHBMNFOUFDPOTUJUVÓEBFFNGVODJPOBNFOUPIÈ QFMPNFOPTVNBOPFNEFGFTBEPTJOUFSFTTFTEFTFVTNFNCSPTPVBTTPDJBEPTw 'PSBNFYQSFTTBNFOUFSFWPHBEPTQFMP"SUEB-FJO¡B-FJO¡B-FJO¡ B-FJO¡FB-FJO¡BMÏNEP"SU¡EB-FJO¡EP "SU¡EB-FJO¡EP"SUEB-FJO¡FEP"SU¡EB-FJO¡ù I RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 268 Marina de Lima Lopes &TUFOPWPEJQMPNBMFHBMGPJFMBCPSBEPQPSVNB$PNJTTÍPEF+VSJTUBTDPN QPTUBFNQPS$BJP5ÈDJUP"SOPMEP8BME.FOF[FT%JSFJUPFOUSFPVUSPTOP NFBEPTQFMB"EWPDBDJB(FSBMEB6OJÍPDPNPQSPQØTJUPEFDPOTPMJEBSBTSFHSBTFYJT UFOUFTFNVNBÞOJDBMFJDPNQBUJCJMJ[BSPVTPEFTUFSFNÏEJPBPNPEFMPQSPDFTTVBM QSFWJTUPOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFFËKVSJTQSVEÐODJBDPOTPMJEBEBCFNDPNP EJTDJQMJOBSPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPMFUJWPRVFBJOEBOÍPUJOIBSFHÐODJBQSØQSJB "TVBBQSPWBÎÍPDPOTUBWBDPNPNFUBEP**1BDUP3FQVCMJDBOPEF&TUBEPmSNBEP QFMPT1SFTJEFOUFTEB3FQÞCMJDBEP4FOBEP'FEFSBMFEB$ÉNBSBEPT%FQVUBEPTFEP 4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMFNEFBCSJMEFQPSVNTJTUFNBEF+VTUJÎBNBJT BDFTTÓWFMÈHJMFFGFUJWP. 2. HIPÓTESES DE CABIMENTO %FBDPSEPDPNBMFHJTMBÎÍPEFSFHÐODJB-FJO¡TFSÈDPODFEJ EBBTFHVSBOÎBQBSBQSPUFÎÍPEFEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPOÍPBNQBSÈWFMQPShabeas corpus PV habeas data RVBOEP TFV UJUVMBS FTUJWFS TPGSFOEP PV OB JNJOÐODJB EF TPGSFSWJPMBÎÍPFNSB[ÍPEFJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTP EF QPEFS QSBUJDBEP QPS BUP PV PNJTTÍPEF"VUPSJEBEF "SU¡$PODFEFSTFÈNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBQBSBQSPUFHFSEJSFJUP MÓRVJEP F DFSUP OÍP BNQBSBEP QPS IBCFBT DPSQVT PV IBCFBT EBUB TFNQSF RVF JMFHBMNFOUF PV DPN BCVTP EF QPEFS RVBMRVFS QFTTPB GÓTJDBPVKVSÓEJDBTPGSFSWJPMBÎÍPPVIPVWFSKVTUPSFDFJPEFTPGSÐMB QPSQBSUFEFBVUPSJEBEFTFKBEFRVFDBUFHPSJBGPSFTFKBNRVBJTGP SFNBTGVOÎÜFTRVFFYFSÎBù "MFJQPSUBOUPSFQFUJVPDPODFJUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMDPOUJEPOP"SU-9*9 BQFOBT FYQMJDJUBOEP B KÈ DPOTBHSBEB QPTTJCJMJEBEF EF DBCJNFOUP EP mandamus EF GPSNBQSFWFOUJWB "TTJNPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBQPEFSÈTFSJNQFUSBEPUBOUPSFQSFTTJWBDPNP QSFWFOUJWBNFOUFFNGBDFEFBUPPVGBUPDPNJTTJWPPVPNJTTJWPEFBVUPSJEBEFJMFHBM PVBCVTJWPEFTEFRVFOÍPTFKBFYDMVTJWBNFOUFWJPMBEPSEBMJCFSEBEFEFMPDPNPÎÍPF EBUVUFMBEFEBEPTQFTTPBJToDBSÈUFSSFTJEVBMEBBÎÍPNBOEBNFOUBM 0NBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBSFQSFTTJWPÏBRVFMFJNQFUSBEPDPOUSBBUPWJHFOUFF FmDB[RVFQSPEV[BUVBMWJPMBÎÍPBEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPEPBVUPS+ÈPEFOPNJOBEP ("+"3%0/* 'FSOBOEP EB 'POTFDB et al. Comentários à Nova Lei do Mandado de Segurança: Lei nº 12.016, de 7 de agosto de 2009. 4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEPQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 269 NBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBQSFWFOUJWPWJTBBSFTHVBSEBSEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPRVFFTUÈ TFOEPBNFBÎBEPQPSBUPGVUVSPFJNJOFOUFPVBJOEBQPSBUPBUVBMNBTTFNFmDÈDJB 5PEBWJBOÍPÏRVBMRVFSBNFBÎBRVFFOTFKBUBMQSPUFÎÍPBBNFBÎBQSFDJTBTFS SFBMPCKFUJWBFBUVBMDPOTPBOUFBEWFSUF+PTÏEPT4BOUPT$BSWBMIP'JMIP "EWJSUBTFBQFOBTRVBOUPËUVUFMBQSFWFOUJWBRVFOÍPÏRVBMRVFSBNFBÎB RVF IBCJMJUB P JOUFSFTTBEP Ë QSPQPTJUVSB EB BÎÍP BUÏ QPSRVF FYJTUFN QPTUVSBT RVF TØ SFQSFTFOUBN BNFBÎB B FTQÓSJUPT GSÈHFJT %FTTF NPEP B BNFBÎBSFDMBNBB SFBMJEBEFQBSBRVFPJOUFSFTTBEPEFNPOTUSFTFÏFGFUJWB BQSÈUJDBJNJOFOUFEPBUPPVEFTFVTFGFJUPTC PCKFUJWJEBEFJOEJDBOEP TFRVFBBNFBÎBEFWFTFSTÏSJBFOÍPGVOEBEBFNNFSBTTVQPTJÎÜFTFD BUVBMJEBEFTJHOJmDBOEPRVFBBNFBÎBÏJNJOFOUFFEFWFFTUBSQSFTFOUFBP NPNFOUPEBBÎÍPOÍPTFSWJOEPQPJTBNFBÎBTQSFUÏSJUBTFKÈVMUSBQBTTBEBT "UFOUFTFRVFPDBSÈUFSSFTJEVBMEFTUBBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFNSFMBÎÍPBPhabeas corpus FBPhabeas data,EFWFTFSBOBMJTBEPDPNPEFWJEPDSJUÏSJPQPJTTFBEFGFTB EBMJCFSEBEFEFMPDPNPÎÍPFEFEBEPTQFTTPBJTGPSBQFOBTVNNFJPPVDPOEJÎÍPQBSB SFTHVBSEBSPVUSPEJSFJUPPCKFUPQSJODJQBMEBTFHVSBOÎBTFSÈDBCÓWFMPmandamus FN EFUSJNFOUPEPTPVUSPTSFNÏEJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT. 5BNCÏNTFSÈDBCÓWFMBJNQFUSBÎÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBOPTDBTPTEFQVOJÎÜFTEJTDJ QMJOBSFTNJMJUBSFTRVFOÍPTFTVKFJUBNBJNQVHOBÎÍPWJBhabeas corpus, QPSFYQSFTTB WFEBÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM"SUfEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM "JOEBEFOUSPEBBOÈMJTFEPDBCJNFOUPDVNQSFJOEJDBSRVFBNFOÎÍPGFJUB QFMBMFJBPBCVTPEFQPEFSBPMBEPEBJMFHBMJEBEFDPNPIJQØUFTFTEFJNQFUSBÎÍPEB TFHVSBOÎBÏDSJUJDBEBQPSQBSUFEBEPVUSJOB*TUPQPSRVFOÍPIÈDPOEVUBBCVTJWBRVF OÍPTFKBJMFHBMQPSUBOUP <>BNFMIPSJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPIÈEFTFSBRVFMBTFHVOEPBRVBMPNBOEBEPEFTF HVSBOÎBWJTBBBUBDBSBJMFHBMJEBEFTFKBFMBQSBUJDBEBPVOÍPDPNBCVTPEFQP EFS"mOBMJMFHBMJEBEFÏHÐOFSPEPRVBMPBCVTPEFQPEFSDPOTUJUVJFTQÏDJF 1SFUFOEFVTFBQFOBTEBSÐOGBTFËOFDFTTJEBEFEFDPOUFSDPOEVUBTBCVTJWBT $"37"-)0'*-)0+PTÏEPT4BOUPTManual de Direito Administrativo. FE3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB -VNFO+VSJTQ i"SU"T'PSÎBT"SNBEBTDPOTUJUVÓEBTQFMB.BSJOIBQFMP&YÏSDJUPFQFMB"FSPOÈVUJDBTÍPJOT UJUVJÎÜFTOBDJPOBJTQFSNBOFOUFTFSFHVMBSFTPSHBOJ[BEBTDPNCBTFOBIJFSBSRVJBFOBEJTDJQMJOBTPC B BVUPSJEBEF TVQSFNB EP 1SFTJEFOUF EB 3FQÞCMJDB F EFTUJOBNTF Ë EFGFTB EB 1ÈUSJB Ë HBSBOUJB EPT QPEFSFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFQPSJOJDJBUJWBEFRVBMRVFSEFTUFTEBMFJFEBPSEFN <> f/ÍPDBCFSÈIBCFBTDPSQVTFNSFMBÎÍPBQVOJÎÜFTEJTDJQMJOBSFTNJMJUBSFTw 0BCVTPEFQPEFSGPJJODMVÓEPDPNPDBVTBBKVTUJmDBSBJNQFUSBÎÍPBQFOBTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEF WJTUPRVFB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFSFTUSJOHJBPSFNÏEJPËiJMFHBMJEBEFNBOJGFTUBw $"37"-)0'*-)0+PTÏEPT4BOUPTManual de Direito Administrativo. FE3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB -VNFO+VSJTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 270 Marina de Lima Lopes "EFNBJTBJMFHBMJEBEFBMVEJEBEFWFTFSFOUFOEJEBEBNBOFJSBNBJTBNQMB QPTTÓWFMQBSBUBNCÏNBCSBOHFSBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFFBWJPMBÎÍPËMFJFNTFOUJEP GPSNBM"MÏNEJTTPDPOGPSNFEFTUBDB.JDIFM5FNFSFTUÈSFMBDJPOBEBDPNPSFHSBB BUPWJODVMBEPQPJTPBCVTPEFQPEFSSFGFSFTFEFNPEPHFSBMBBUPTEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPT 3FMFWBOUFBJOEBEFTUBDBSRVFPSFNÏEJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFNBOÈMJTFOÍPGPJ QSFWJTUPQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍPQBSBEFGFTBEFUPEBFRVBMRVFSMFTÍPBEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUP NBTTPNFOUFQBSBDPNCBUFSBCVTPPVJMJDJUVEFQSBUJDBEBFNMJOIBTHFSBJTQFMP&TUBEP /FTTFTFOUJEPOÍPQPEFTFSJNQFUSBEPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBFNGBDFEP QBSUJDVMBSBFYDFÎÍPTFEÈRVBOEPFTUFFYFSDFSGVOÎÍPQÞCMJDBQPJTOÍPCBTUBPBUP FNTJQBSBBQSPQPTJUVSBEFTUBBÎÍPFTQFDJBMTFOEPOFDFTTÈSJPBJOEBRVFUFOIBTJEP QSBUJDBEPQFMP1PEFS1ÞCMJDPPVQPSRVFNMIFGBÎBBTWF[FT"SU¡ff¡F¡EB -FJO¡ &OUSFUBOUPB-FJO¡FTUBCFMFDFFNTFVBSU¡BMHVNBTIJQØUF TFTFNRVFOÍPTFJNQPSÈBTFHVSBOÎB "SU¡ù/ÍPTFDPODFEFSÈNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBRVBOEPTFUSBUBSù *oEFBUPEPRVBMDBJCBSFDVSTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFDBVÎÍPù **oEFEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMEBRVBMDBJCBSFDVSTPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPù ***oEFEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPù<> a) Primeira Hipótese:JOUFSFTTBOUFSFTTBMUBSBSFTQFJUPEBQSJNFJSBIJQØUFTF "SU¡* RVFBPQÎÍPQFMBWJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBBOUFTEBKVEJDJBMDBCFFYDMVTJWBNFO UFBPJOUFSFTTBEPWJTUPRVFGBDVMUBUJWBFNSB[ÍPEPQSJODÓQJPEBJOBGBTUBCJMJEBEFEB KVSJTEJÎÍP"SU¡9997EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM "TTJNBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPTPNFOUFTFSÈ JNQFEJUJWBEBTFHVSBOÎBDBTPPJNQFUSBOUFUFOIBPQUBEPJOJDJBMNFOUFQPSBRVFMBWJBFUBN CÏNTFQPSØCWJPUSBUBSTFEFBUPDPNJTTJWPEB"VUPSJEBEF*TUPQPSRVFOFTTFTDBTPTOÍP FTUBSÈDPOmHVSBEPPJOUFSFTTFEFBHJSQPJTPBUPBUÏFOUÍPOÍPUFSÈQSPEV[JEPFGFJUPT "ENJUFTFOPFOUBOUPRVFPJOUFSFTTBEPSFOVODJFFYQSFTTBNFOUFBPEJSFJUP EFSFDPSSFSFJNQFUSFEJSFUBNFOUFBTFHVSBOÎBPVPGBÎBEFQPJTEFUSBOTDPSSJEPin albis PQSB[PSFDVSTBM 0CTFSWBTF QPS PQPSUVOP RVF B -FJ O RVF SFHVMB P QSP DFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPOPÉNCJUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB'FEFSBMQSFWÐBQPT TJCJMJEBEF EF TFS BUSJCVÓEP FYDFQDJPOBM FGFJUP TVTQFOTJWP BP SFDVSTP EF PGÓDJP 5&.&3.JDIFMBQVE 5"7"3&4"OESÏ3BNPTManual do Novo Mandado de Segurança: Lei 12.016/2009.3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTFQ /FTUFQPOUPNFSFDFEFTUBRVFPFOVODJBEPEB4ÞNVMBEP&4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMi"FYJT UÐODJBEFSFDVSTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPOÍPJNQFEFPVTPEPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB DPOUSBPNJTTÍPEBBVUPSJEBEFw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 271 QFMB"VUPSJEBEF"ENJOJTUSBUJWBSFTQPOTÈWFMPVNFEJBOUFQSPWPDBÎÍPEFTEFRVF IBKBSFDFJPEFQSFKVÓ[PEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍPEFDPSSFOUFEFTVBFYFDVÎÍP o"SUQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDP/FTUBIJQØUFTFWFSJmDBSTFÈPDBCJNFOUPEPmandamus FPQSB[PQBSBTVBJNQFUSBÎÍPBQBSUJSEBEFDJTÍPRVFSFDFCFSPSFDVSTP DPODFEFOEPMIFPTSFHVMBSFTFGFJUPT b) A segunda hipótese, QSFWJTUB OP "SU ** BDJNB USBOTDSJUP QSFWÐ B JNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBJNQFUSBÎÍPQBSBJNQVHOBSEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMEBRVBMDBJCBSFDVSTP DPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPQPJTPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBOÍPQPEFTFSVUJMJ[BEPDPNP TJNQMFTTVDFEÉOFPSFDVSTBM/BEBPCTUBOUFDPOWÏNEFTUBDBSBSFTTBMWBGFJUBQFMBQSP GFTTPSB.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMB%J1JFUSP $POUVEPBDFJUBTFBJOEBNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBQBSBJNQSJNJSFGFJUP TVTQFOTJWPËEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMTFPJNQFUSBOUFUJWFSJOEFGFSJEPPQFEJEP EFFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPBRVFTFSFGFSFPBSUJHPEP$1$QPSPVUSBT QBMBWSBTUFOEPTJEPJOUFSQPTUPPBHSBWPEFJOTUSVNFOUPDPNQFEJEPEF TFVSFDFCJNFOUPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPTFJOEFGFSJEPFTTFQFEJEPBÓTJN ÏDBCÓWFMPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPOUSBPEFTQBDIPEFJOEFGFSJNFOUP PCKFUJWBOEPPFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPEFOFHBEP 5BNCÏNUFNBEPVUSJOBFBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBEPT5SJCVOBJT4VQFSJPSFTBENJUJ EPBJNQFUSBÎÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBJOEFQFOEFOUFEBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFDVSTPDPNFGFJUPTVT QFOTJWPOBTIJQØUFTFTEFEFDJTÍPUFSBUPMØHJDBFRVBOEPPmandamus GPSEFUFSDFJSP RVFEFWFSJBUFSTJEPQBSUFOBBÎÍPMJUJTDPOTØSDJPOFDFTTÈSJPoFOÍPPGPJQBSBFWJUBS RVFTPGSBPTFGFJUPTEBEFDJTÍP /PUFTFFOUSFUBOUPRVFEJGFSFOUFNFOUFEBIJQØUFTFBOUFSJPSoSFDVSTPBE NJOJTUSBUJWPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWPoTFPJOUFSFTTBEPEFJYBSUSBOTDPSSFSFNCSBODPP QSB[PQBSBJOUFSQPTJÎÍPEFSFDVSTPKVEJDJBMOÍPMIFTFSÈQFSNJUJEBTVCTJEJBSJBNFOUF JNQFUSBSBTFHVSBOÎBDPNPTVDFEÉOFPSFDVSTBMWJTUPRVFBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFVUJ MJ[BÎÍPEFTUBWJBEFDPSSFEBTJNQMFTQSFWJTÍPMFHBMEFSFDVSTPKVEJDJBMFOÍPEFTFV FGFUJWPFYFSDÓDJPDPNPOBTFBSBBENJOJTUSBUJWB c) A terceira hipótese "SU¡*** SFUSBUBFOUFOEJNFOUPRVFKÈFTUBWBDPO TPMJEBEPOB4ÞNVMBEP&4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBM“OÍPDBCFNBOEBEPEF TFHVSBOÎBDPOUSBEFDJTÍPKVEJDJBMDPNUSÉOTJUPFNKVMHBEPw i"SU4BMWPEJTQPTJÎÍPMFHBMFNDPOUSÈSJPPSFDVSTPOÍPUFNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP 1BSÈHSBGP ÞOJDP)BWFOEPKVTUPSFDFJPEFQSFKVÓ[PEFEJGÓDJMPVJODFSUBSFQBSBÎÍPEFDPSSFOUFEBFYF DVÎÍPBBVUPSJEBEFSFDPSSJEBPVBJNFEJBUBNFOUFTVQFSJPSQPEFSÈEFPGÓDJPPVBQFEJEPEBSFGFJUP TVTQFOTJWPBPSFDVSTPw %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMB. Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP"UMBTQ ("+"3%0/* 'FSOBOEP EB 'POTFDB et al. Comentários à Nova Lei do Mandado de Segurança: Lei nº 12.016, de 7 de agosto de 2009. 4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEPQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 272 Marina de Lima Lopes +VTUJmDBTFBWFEBÎÍPFNSB[ÍPEPQSJODÓQJPEBFTUBCJMJEBEFTFHVSBOÎBEBT SFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDBT5PEBWJBUBNCÏNOFTTFDBTPFYDFQDJPOBTFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFJN QFUSBÎÍPQPSUFSDFJSPRVFOÍPGPJQBSUFOBSFMBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBM. 0QPSUVOP EFTUBDBS RVF P QSPKFUP EF MFJ RVF SFEVOEPV OP UFYUP EB BUVBM OPSNBRVFSFHFPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPOUJOIBVNQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDPOFTUFBSU TVQSBUSBOTDSJUPRVFGPJWFUBEPFQSFWJBRVF "SU <> 1BSÈHSBGP ÞOJDP 0 NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎB QPEFSÈ TFS JNQFUSBEPJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFSFDVSTPIJFSÈSRVJDPDPOUSBPNJTTÜFT EBBVUPSJEBEFOPQSB[PEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBTBQØTTVBOPUJmDBÎÍP KVEJDJBMPVFYUSBKVEJDJBMù "SB[ÍPEPWFUPGPJSFUJSBSBOFDFTTJEBEFEFOPUJmDBÎÍPQSÏWJBDPNPDPO EJÎÍP QBSB VUJMJ[BÎÍP EFTUB BÎÍP NBOEBNFOUBM OPT DBTPT EF PNJTTÍP F DPN JTTP FWJUBSEÞWJEBTRVFQPEFSJBNTVSHJSBSFTQFJUPEPJOÓDJPEBDPOUBHFNEPQSB[PQBSB JNQFUSBÎÍP5BJTRVFTUJPOBNFOUPTQPEFSJBNEFSJWBSTFHVOEPDPOTUPVEBNPUJWBÎÍP EPWFUPEBBVTÐODJBEFUFNQPSB[PÈWFMQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPPVEBJODPNQFUÐODJBEB "VUPSJEBEFOPUJmDBEB *OTUBTBMJFOUBSRVFUBNCÏNSFTUBSÈQSFKVEJDBEBBJNQFUSBÎÍPDBTPBTJUVBÎÍP NFTNPDPNBDPODFTTÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBOÍPQPTTBTFSSFQPTUBBPstatus quo ante. *TUP QPSRVFFNTFUSBUBOEPEFBÎÍPFTQFDJBMEFSJUPNBJTDÏMFSFOÍPTFKVTUJmDBEFNBOEÈ MBQBSBSFQBSBSVNBTJUVBÎÍPKÈEFWBTTBEBPVTFKBRVBOEPOÍPTFSJBNBJTQPTTÓWFM SFTHVBSEBSPEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPJOWPDBEP "JOEBRVFQPTTBTFSJOWPDBEBBMHVNBVSHÐODJBQBSBmOTEFSFQBSBÎÍP OFDFTTJEBEF mOBODFJSB EP JOUFSFTTBEP USBUBTF BRVJ EF TJUVBÎÍP EJWFSTBEBRVFMBQBSBBRVBMGPJDPHJUBEBBDFMFSJEBEFEPNBOEBEPEF TFHVSBOÎBRVFÏBRVFMBSFGFSFOUFBPEJSFJUPiQSJODJQBMwFOÍPËTPMVÎÍP FNQFSEBTFEBOPT %B NFTNB GPSNB OÍP TF BENJUF NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎB DPOUSB MFJ PV BUP OPSNBUJWPFNUFTFDPOGPSNFFOUFOEJNFOUPKÈBTTFOUBEPOP&OVODJBEPEB4ÞNVMB OEP&4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMQPJTiFORVBOUPSFHSBTHFSBJTFBCTUSBUBTOÍP BUJOHFNPTEJSFJUPTJOEJWJEVBJTFQFSNBOFDFNJOBUBDÈWFJTQPSBÎÜFTPSEJOÈSJBTPV NFTNPQPSNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBw $"37"-)0'*-)0+PTÏEPT4BOUPTManual de Direito Administrativo. FE3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB -VNFO+VSJTQ 5"7"3&4"OESÏ3BNPTManual do Novo Mandado de Segurança: Lei nº 12.016/2009.3JPEF+BOFJSP 'PSFOTFQOPUBEFSPEBQÏ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 273 ²DBCÓWFMQPSÏNBJNQFUSBÎÍPDPOUSBOPSNBEFFGFJUPTDPODSFUPTPVBVUP FYFDVUØSJBTiQPSRVFKÈUSB[FNFNTJPTSFTVMUBEPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTPCKFUJWBEPT/ÍP TÍPBUPTOPSNBUJWPTHFSBJTNBTTJNEFMJCFSBÎÜFTJOEJWJEVBMJ[BEBTSFWFTUJOEPBGPSNB BOÙNBMBEFMFJPVEFDSFUPw /FTTFTDBTPTBTBVUPSJEBEFTDPBUPSBTTFSÍPP-FHJTMBUJWP FP$IFGFEP&YFDVUJWPRVFTBODJPOPVBMFJBUPDPNQMFYP 5BNCÏNÏQPTTÓWFMBJNQFUSBÎÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBOPTDBTPTEFWJPMBÎÍPEPQSP DFTTP MFHJTMBUJWP JODMVTJWF P DPOTUJUVDJPOBM 5SBUBTF EF VUJMJ[BÎÍP EJGFSFODJBEB EP mandamus, BUSBWÏTEBRVBMOÍPTFFTUBSJBBTTFHVSBOEPEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPEPQBS MBNFOUBSNBTTJNSFTPMWFOEPQFDVMJBSDPOnJUPEFBUSJCVJÎÜFTPVEFØSHÍPTFSFTHVBS EBOEPBSFHVMBSJEBEFKVSÓEJDPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEPQSPDFTTPQPMÓUJDPEFEFMJCFSBÎÍPF BQSPWBÎÍPEFMFJTFFNFOEBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT. 5PEBWJBPTBUPTinterna corporis22, RVFTÍPBRVFMFTRVFSFHVMBNJOUFSOBNFOUF EFUFSNJOBEP1PEFSPVØSHÍPFPTBUPTQPMÓUJDPTRVFUÐNQSFWJTÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMF QPEFN TFS QSPGFSJEPT OP ÉNCJUP EF EJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEF EP BENJOJTUSBEPS UBNCÏN OÍPTÍPQBTTÓWFJTEFJNQVHOBÎÍPWJBmandamus, EFTEFRVFSFHVMBSNFOUFFEJUBEPT *TUPQPSRVFP+VEJDJÈSJPOÍPQPEFTVCTUJUVJSOFTTFTDBTPTBWPOUBEFEP&YFDVUJWPPV EFPVUSPTØSHÍPTFTPNFOUFQPEFSÈGB[FSPDPOUSPMFEFMFHBMJEBEF%FTUBSUFQPSFYFN QMPOÍPQPEFTFSJNQFUSBEPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBDPOUSBWFUPEFMFJBUPQPMÓUJDP EPDIFGFEP&YFDVUJWP "-FJO¡FNTFVBSUUBNCÏNFTUBCFMFDFQSB[PQBSBJNQFUSB ÎÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBi0EJSFJUPEFSFRVFSFSNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBFYUJOHVJSTFÈEFDPSSJ EPTDFOUPFWJOUF EJBTDPOUBEPTEBDJÐODJBQFMPJOUFSFTTBEPEPBUPJNQVHOBEPwù "EJTDVTTÍPBSFTQFJUPEBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBQSFWJTÍPEFUBMMJNJUBÎÍPUFN QPSBMQPSMFJJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMKÈGPJUSBWBEBOBÏHJEFEBMFHJTMBÎÍPBOUFSJPSFTFEJ NFOUBEBOPTFOUJEPEFRVFFTUBOÍPDPOmHVSBRVBMRVFSPGFOTBB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM "PSJFOUBÎÍPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMTFNQSFDBNJOIPVOPTFO UJEP EF SFDPOIFDFS B DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF EB OPSNB RVF mYBWB B QSF DMVTÍP QSPDFTTVBM QBSB JNQFUSBÎÍP EP NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎB TPC P GVOEBNFOUPEFRVFTFDVJEBEFQSPWJEÐODJBDPOTFOUÉOFBDPNBTJOHV MBSJEBEFFFTQFDJBMJEBEFEBHBSBOUJB0QFSmMEFHBSBOUJBJOTUJUVDJPOBM EPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBOÍPQBSFDFFYDMVJSBBEPÎÍPEFGØSNVMBEF .&*3&--&4)FMZ-PQFTet al. Direito Administrativo Brasileiro. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT -UEBQ .&/%&4(JMNBS'FSSFJSBet al. Curso de Direito Constitucional. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ i4ÍPBUPTFTQFDÓmDPTQSPEV[JEPTOPÉNCJUPEBDPNQFUÐODJBSFTFSWBEBBEFUFSNJOBEPTØSHÍPTEP&TUB EPFEFDPSSFNEFWBMPSBÎÍPEFDPOWFOJÐODJBFPQPSUVOJEBEFNBSDBEBQFMBEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEF"TTJN TÍPJOJEÙOFPTQBSBPGFOEFSEJSFJUPTJOEJWJEVBJTPVUSBOTJOEJWJEVBJT²PDBTPEBTOPSNBTEFSFHJNFOUPT EF5SJCVOBJTF$BTBT-FHJTMBUJWBTw$"37"-)0'*-)0+PTÏEPT4BOUPTManual de Direito Administrativo. FE3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB-VNFO+VSJTQ &OVODJBEPEB4ÞNVMBEP&4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMi²DPOTUJUVDJPOBMMFJRVFmYBPQSB[PEF EFDBEÐODJBQBSBBJNQFUSBÎÍPEFNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 274 Marina de Lima Lopes QSFDMVTÍPFTQFDJBMNFOUFTFFMBOÍPEJmDVMUBPVJNQPTTJCJMJUBPFYFSDÓ DJPEPEJSFJUP 5SBUBTF EF QSB[P EFDBEFODJBM RVF OÍP BENJUF QPSUBOUP TVTQFOTÍP PV JOUFSSVQÎÍP "DPOUBHFNEPQSB[PJOJDJBTFEBDJÐODJBEPBUPMFTJWPQFMPJOUFSFTTBEPRVFS TFKBQFMBTVBOPUJmDBÎÍPQVCMJDBÎÍPRVFSBJOEBRVBOEPEFDJEJEPPÞMUJNPSFDVSTP BENJOJTUSBUJWPJOUFSQPTUPDPNFGFJUPTVTQFOTJWP /PTDBTPTEFPNJTTÍPDPOGPSNFTFSÈNFMIPSFYQPTUPBTFHVJSJOJDJBSTFÈ QFMPEFDVSTPEPQSB[P SFHVMBSNFOUF QSFWJTUP QBSB B BUVBÎÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWB PV OB GBMUBEFTUFEFTEFRVFUSBOTQPTUPQSB[PSB[PÈWFMQBSBUBOUP 3. SILÊNCIO ADMINISTRATIVO 0FTUVEPEPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPFNCPSBTFKBFTDBTTPOBEPVUSJOBCSBTJMFJ SBQFMBTTVBTSFQFSDVTTÜFTUFNDVSJBMJNQPSUÉODJBQSÈUJDBQBSBBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPFQBSB PTBENJOJTUSBEPTFTQFDJBMNFOUFOBTIJQØUFTFTFOTFKBEPSBTEFNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB /P FOUBOUP OÍP TF USBUB EF UFNB OPWP QPJT .BSDFMP 4DJPSJMMJ SFGFSFTF B BSUJHPQVCMJDBEPKÈFNJOUJUVMBEPi"5FPSJBEP4JMÐODJP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPwEF BVUPSJBEF5IFNÓTUPDMFT#SBOEÍP$BWBMDBOUJBEWFSUJOEPRVFOÍPQPEFSJBNTFSVUJ MJ[BEBTOPÉNCJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPBTTPMVÎÜFTEBEBTBPTJMÐODJPOBFTGFSBQSJWBEB *TTPQPSRVFBTGPSNBTEFNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEBWPOUBEFFTUBUBMTÍPNBJTDPN QMFYBTEFQFOEFNNVJUBTWF[FTEPDPODVSTPEFEJWFSTBTBVUPSJEBEFT EFGPSNBMJEBEFTCVSPDSÈUJDBTJOEJTQFOTÈWFJTËEFUFSNJOBÎÍPEBWPOUB EFEP&TUBEPQPSNFJPEFVNPVNBJTØSHÍPTDPNQFUFOUFT 0BVUPSJEFOUJmDBWBËÏQPDBEVBT IJQØUFTFTEFTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPB QSJNFJSBDPOTJTUJSJBOBJOÏSDJBEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOBEFGFTBEFTFVTEJSFJUPTFEBDPMFUJ WJEBEFFBTFHVOEBOBBVTÐODJBEFEFDJTÍPEFQFEJEPBENJOJTUSBUJWP"DPOTFRVÐODJB OPQSJNFJSPDBTPQBSB$BWBMDBOUJTFSJBJOUFSQSFUBSPTJMÐODJPDPNPDPOTFOUJNFOUP UÈDJUPFOPTFHVOEPDPNPSFDVTBUÈDJUB .&/%&4(JMNBS'FSSFJSBet al. Curso de Direito Constitucional. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB Q 4$*03*--*.BSDFMPSilêncio e Administração Pública. *O3FWJTUB&MFUSÙOJDB+VTUJUJBo"3FWJTUBEP.J OJTUÏSJP1ÞCMJDPEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXKVTUJUJBDPNCSBSUJHPTY QEG"DFTTPFNOPWQ $"7"-$"/5*5IFNÓTUPDMFT#SBOEÍPA Teoria do Silêncio Administrativo*ORevista Forense, março de 1939QBQVE 4$*03*--*PQDJUQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 275 "OPUBBJOEBRVFPTJMÐODJPOPDBTPEFSFDVSTPEFEFDJTÜFTBENJOJTUSBUJWBT JNQMJDBSJBBDPOmSNBÎÍPJNQMÓDJUBEFTUBTFOBIJQØUFTFEFJOÏSDJBOPGPSOFDJNFOUP EFDFSUJEÜFTDPOGFSJSJBBPBENJOJTUSBEPPEJSFJUPEFFYJHJMBKVEJDJBMNFOUF$POUVEP KÈBEWFSUJBPBVUPSËÏQPDBRVFTFSJBEFTFKÈWFMBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEPBTTVOUPQFMP %JSFJUP1PTJUJWPQBSBVNUSBUBNFOUPHFSBMFJHVBMJUÈSJPEBTRVFTUÜFT 0UFNBOÍPFWPMVJNVJUPFTQFDJBMNFOUFFNSB[ÍPEBBVTÐODJBEBKÈSFDMBNB EBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPHFSBMEPTFGFJUPTEPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWP5PEBWJBBEPVUSJOB FNHSBOEFQBSUFJOTVSHJVTFDPOUSBPTDIBNBEPTFGFJUPTUÈDJUPTSFTVMUBOUFTEPTJMÐO DJP JNPUJWBEP EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP F BP NFTNP UFNQP GPSBN QSPNVMHBEBT BMHVNBT MFJTFTQBSTBTRVFRVBMJmDBSBNBPNJTTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBOFTTFTDBTPTJEFOUJmDBOEPP NPNFOUPEBDBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPEBJOBÎÍPFBUSJCVJOEPDFSUPTFGFJUPTMFHBJTBFTUB /BWFSEBEFQBSBBOBMJTBSPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPÏQSFDJTPFNDPOUSBQBS UJEBUFSFNGPDPPEFWFSEFSFTQPTUBEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPRVFTFHVOEP"OESÏ4BEEZ TFSJB EFDPSSFOUF EP QSFWJTUP OP "SU EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM FN FTQFDJBM EPT DPNBOEPTEFSJWBEPTEPTQSJODÓQJPTEBMFHBMJEBEFEBQVCMJDJEBEFFEBNPSBMJEBEF BENJOJTUSBUJWB 3FTVMUBSJBUBNCÏNEPQSJODÓQJPEBNPUJWBÎÍPEPTBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTJN QMÓDJUPOBTHBSBOUJBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTEPEJSFJUPBPSFDFCJNFOUPEFJOGPSNBÎÜFTEPTØS HÍPTQÞCMJDPT"SU999*** EPEJSFJUPEFQFUJÎÍP"SU999*7a Fb , EP EJSFJUP BPBNQMPBDFTTPBP+VEJDJÈSJP"SU9997 FEPEJSFJUPBPDPOUSBEJUØSJPBNQMBEF GFTBFSB[PÈWFMEVSBÎÍPEPTQSPDFTTPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFKVEJDJBJT"SU-7F-997** 5BMSFTQPTUBUFOEPFNWJTUBPQSJODÓQJPEBMFHBMJEBEFEBQVCMJDJEBEFFN TVBWFSUFOUFEBUSBOTQBSÐODJB FEBNPUJWBÎÍPFYJHFRVFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP FYQSFTTF QPS FTDSJUP OVN QSB[P SB[PÈWFM EF NBOFJSB FMPRVFOUF P “porquê”EFTFVTBUPT'B[TFOFDFTTÈSJBQPSUBOUPBTSB[ÜFTEFUPEPTTFVT DPNQPSUBNFOUPT OÍP CBTUBOEP RVF FYJTUB VN NPUJWP QBSB B BUVBÎÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWBTFOEPOFDFTTÈSJBTVBFOVODJBÎÍPPVTFKBTVBNPUJWBÎÍP DBTP DPOUSÈSJP FTUBSÈ JNQMJDBOEP VN DFSDFBNFOUP EF EFGFTB EP BENJOJTUSBEP GFSJOEP EJSFJUPT RVF MIF TÍP GVOEBNFOUBJT BMÏN EF UPSOBS JNQPTTÓWFMPDPOUSPMFEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP"MÏNEPNBJTBJOBGBTUBCJMJEBEF EB QSFTUBÎÍP KVSJTEJDJPOBM DPOmSNB B JNQPTTJCJMJEBEF EF TF BENJUJS P TJMÐODJPDPNPVNDPNQPSUBNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPTVTUFOUÈWFMVNBWF[RVF QPTTVJSJB FTTB VNB BVTÐODJB EF NPUJWBÎÍP B RVBM BDBSSFUBSJB VN ØCJDF Ë BQSFDJBÎÍPKVEJDJBM 4"%%:"OESÏEfeitos Jurídicos do Silêncio Positivo no Direito Administrativo Brasileiro. *O3FWJTUB&MF USÙOJDBEF%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPo3&%&4BMWBEPS*OTUJUVUP#SBTJMFJSPEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPO¡PVUVCSP OPWFNCSPEF[FNCSP %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXEJSFJUPEPFTUBEPDPNSFWJTUB3&%&06 56#30"/%3&4"%%:QEG"DFTTPFNOPWQ 4"%%:PQDJUQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 276 Marina de Lima Lopes 5PEBWJBUBJTEJTQPTJUJWPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTBPNFTNPQBTTPFNRVFBTTFHV SBN P EJSFJUP BP BENJOJTUSBEP EF PCUFS VNB SFTQPTUB EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP UBNCÏN JNQÜFNBFMBBPCFEJÐODJBBPEFWJEPQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPOTJTUFOUFOPSFTQFJUP ËTFUBQBTJOEJTQFOTÈWFJTQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPTTFVTBUPT ""ENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFNQSFEFWFQBVUBSTVBBUVBÎÍPOPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDP WJHFOUFoQSJODÓQJPEBMFHBMJEBEFoUBOUPQBSBRVFTFKBQSPGFSJEBVNBEFDJTÍPDPNP QBSBTFKBGPSOFDJEBVNBSFTQPTUBBSFRVFSJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP /FTUFDFOÈSJPTPNFOUFFTUBSÈDBSBDUFSJ[BEPPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPPVTJ MÐODJPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPRVBOEPWFSJmDBEBBJOBÎÍPEFTUBRVFSTFKBQFMBBVTÐODJBEF FGFUJWBSFTQPTUBËQSPWPDBÎÍPEPBENJOJTUSBEPRVFSTFKBQFMBGBMUBEFDVNQSJNFOUP EPEFWFSEFPGÓDJPEFTEFRVFVMUSBQBTTBEPPQSB[PSFHVMBNFOUBSQBSBUBOUP /BTQBMBWSBTEF$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF.FMMP 4FB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOÍPTFQSPOVODJBRVBOEPEFWFGB[ÐMPTFKBQPSRVF GPJ QSPWPDBEB QPS BENJOJTUSBEP RVF QPTUVMB JOUFSFTTF QSØQSJP TFKB QPSRVFVNØSHÍPUFNEFQSPOVODJBSTFQBSBmOTEFDPOUSPMFEFBUPEF PVUSPØSHÍPFTUÈTFQFSBOUFPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWP %FTUBDBTFBJOEBRVFFTUBPNJTTÍPDPOGPSNFKÈBEJBOUBEPQPEFSÈTFSBJOEBRVB MJmDBEBQFMBQSØQSJBMFJ RVBOEP MIF GPS BUSJCVÓEP VN FGFJUP PV TFKB RVBOEP P TJMÐODJP JNQMJDBSFGFUJWBSFTQPTUBEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPQPTJUJWBPVOFHBUJWBQPSFYQSFTTBEJTQPTJÎÍP MFHBMRVFEFOFHBoiTJMÐODJPOFHBUJWPwoPVDPODFEFoiTJMÐODJPQPTJUJWPwoPSFRVFSJEPTF EFDPSSJEPEFUFSNJOBEPQSB[PQBSBBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFQSPOVODJBSFFTUBQFSNBOFDFSJOFSUF /FTTFDBTPQBSBBEPVUSJOBQPSUVHVFTBUFSÓBNPTBQSÈUJDBEFVNBUPBE NJOJTUSBUJWPUÈDJUP$POUVEPBEWFSUF$FMTP"OUÙOJPRVFOBWFSEBEFBOBUVSF[B KVSÓEJDBEPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPOÍPÏEFBUPKVSÓEJDPUBNQPVDPEFBUPBENJOJT USBUJWPNBTTJNEFGBUPKVSÓEJDPQPJTRVFNTFBCTUFWFOBEBEFDMBSPVQPSUBOUP .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJ UPSFT-UEBQ “&NBMHVOTDBTPTBMFJBUSJCVJEBEPFGFJUPBPTJMÐODJP&TUBCFMFDFRVFEFDPSSJEPin albisPQSB[POFMB QSFWJTUPQBSBQSPOVODJBNFOUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPDPOTJEFSBTFEFGFSJEBPVJOEFGFSJEBRVFÏNBJTDP NVN BQSFUFOTÍPEPBENJOJTUSBEPPVFOUÍPRVFPBUPTPCDPOUSPMFFTUÈDPOmSNBEPPVJOmSNBEP /P %JSFJUPQPSUVHVÐTBNCBTBTIJQØUFTFTTÍPEFOPNJOBEBTABUPTUÈDJUPT<>w .&--0PQDJUQ $POUVEPBRVFTUÍPOÍPÏQBDÓmDBDPOGPSNFBEWFSUF#POJGÈDJPi$POTJEFSBNPTJMÐODJPVNGBUPBENJOJT USBUJWP$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF.FMMPPQDJU 5FNÓTUPDMFT#SBOEÍP$BWBMDBOUJ*O3FWJTUB'PSFOTF "16%3FWJTUBEB'BDVMEBEFEF%JSFJUPEF4ÍP1BVMPWPM999*7GBTD**Q 3FOBUP "MFTTJ<>"OESÏ(POÎBMWFT1FSFJSB&SSPF*MFHBMJEBEFOP"UP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP4ÍP1BVMP«UJDB &EVBSEP(BSDJBEF&OUFSSÓB$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP4ÍP1BVMP35 F"HVTUÓO(PSEJMMPPQ DJU FOUSFPVUSPT$POTJEFSBNOPBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP"MCFSUP9BWJFSBQVE"OUÙOJP$BSMPT$JOUSB&YUJOÎÍP EP"UP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP 4ÏSHJP'FSSB[*O$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"ENJOJTUSBUJWP*OTUSVNFOUPTEF%FGFTBEPT"E NJOJTUSBEPT4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB +PTÏ8JMTPO'FSSFJSB4PCSJOIP*O4JMÐODJP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPF-JDFOÎB EF$POTUSVÎÍP353FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPO "USJCVFNOPPDBSÈUFSEFBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPOEJ DJPOBOEPËFYQSFTTBQSFWJTÍPMFHBMPVËmYBÎÍPEFQSB[PQBSBTVBFNBOBÎÍPSFTQFDUJWBNFOUF/FZEF'BMDP 1JSFT$PSSÐBFN04JMÐODJPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP353FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPO F3ÏHJT'FSOBOEFTEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 277 OFOIVNBUPQSBUJDPVBJOEBRVFBMFJUFOIBJNQPTUPVNBDPOTFRàÐODJBBFTUFTJMÐO DJP“imputação legal” "MJÈTTFGPSBQPTTÓWFMFNUBJTDBTPTDPOTJEFSBSPTJMÐODJPDPNPBUPF KÈ TF WJV RVF OÍP QPEF TÐMP BMÏN EF TF UFS RVF BENJUJS B FYJTUÐODJB EF VN BUP TFN GPSNBMJ[BÎÍP o QJPS BJOEB TFN GPSNB TFRVFS P RVF Ï MPHJDBNFOUF JNQPTTÓWFM o USBUBSTFJB EF VN BUP JMÓDJUP $PN FGFJUP B GPSNBMJ[BÎÍPÏEFSFHSBVNBHBSBOUJBRVFSQBSBB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPRVFS QBSBPBENJOJTUSBEPQPJTDVNQSFBGVOÎÍPEFDPOGFSJSTFHVSBOÎBFDFSUF[B KVSÓEJDBTBTRVBJTEFTUBSUFmDBSJBNTVQSJNJEBT"MÏNEJTUPPQTFVEPBUP JODPSSFSJBOPWÓDJPEFGBMUBEFNPUJWBÎÍP'SVTUSBSJBVNBGPSNBMJ[BÎÍPRVF ÏVNBHBSBOUJBEPBENJOJTUSBEPFVNEJSFJUPEFTDFOEFOUFEPQSJODÓQJPEF RVFUPEPPQPEFSFNBOBEPQPWPPRVBMCFNQPSJTUPUFNPEJSFJUPEF TBCFSBTSB[ÜFTQFMBTRVBJTB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFEFDJEFQFSBOUFEBEPDBTP /PFOUBOUPVNBWF[DPOmHVSBEPFTUFGBUPPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPSFTUB BJOEBËBOÈMJTFEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTVBJNQVHOBÎÍPWJBBÎÍPNBOEBNFOUBM 4. MANDADO DE SEGURANÇA EM FACE DO SILÊNCIO ADMINISTRATIVO 0NBOEBEPTFHVSBOÎBDPOTPBOUFKÈFYQPTUPÏVNJOTUSVNFOUPQSPDFTTVBM DPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFQSPUFÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPOUSBMFTÜFTBEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPQÞCMJDPEFTEF RVF FTTF EJSFJUP TFKB RVBMJmDBEP DPNP MÓRVJEP F DFSUP F OÍP FTUFKB QSPUFHJEP QPS habeas corpus PVhabeas data FRVFPSFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFS EFDPSSFOUFEFBUPDPNJTTJWPPVPNJTTJWPTFKBBVUPSJEBEFQÞCMJDBPVBHFOUFEFQFTTPB KVSÓEJDBOPFYFSDÓDJPEFBUSJCVJÎÜFTEP1PEFS1ÞCMJDP 5PEBWJBBDPOmHVSBÎÍPEBIJQØUFTFRVFQPEFTFSBHBTBMIBEBQPSUBMSFNÏ EJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOPTDBTPTEFMFTÜFTPSJVOEBTEFPNJTTÍPEBBVUPSJEBEFUJEBQPS DPBUPSBÏCBTUBOUFUPSNFOUPTBTPCSFUVEPFNSB[ÍPEBEJmDVMEBEFFNEJTUJOHVJSP 0MJWFJSB"UP"ENJOJTUSBUJWPFE4ÍP1BVMP35 -ÞDJB7BMF'JHVFJSFEP%JTDJQMJOB6SCBOÓTUJDBEB 1SPQSJFEBEF4ÍP1BVMP SFGFSJOEPTFËMJDFOÎBQBSBDPOTUSVJSBENJUFPTJMÐODJPDPNPBUPBENJOJT USBUJWPEFEFGFSJNFOUPTPCDPOEJÎÍPSFTPMVUØSJB&OUÍPEPTJMÐODJPUFNTFQPSEFGFSJEBBDPOUJOVJEBEFEBT PCSBTNFEJBOUFDPNVOJDBÎÍPBmNEFTFDPOTUJUVJSBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPFNNPSBNBSDBOEPTFPQSB[PQBSB QSFDMVTÍP)FMZ-PQFT.FJSFMMFT%JSFJUPEF$POTUSVJS TVTUFOUBTFSPTJMÐODJPVNBDPOEVUBPNJTTJWB EB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPw #0/*'«$*0"SUVS$PSUF[Direito de Petição: garantia constitucional.4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEP QOPUBBQVE 4"%%:"OESÏEfeitos Jurídicos do Silêncio Positivo no Direito Administrativo Brasileiro. 3FWJTUB&MFUSÙOJDBEF%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPo3&%&4BMWBEPS*OTUJUVUP#SBTJMFJSPEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPO¡ PVUVCSPOPWFNCSPEF[FNCSP %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXEJSFJUPEPFTUBEPDPNSFWJTUB3&%& 0656#30"/%3&4"%%:QEG"DFTTPFNOPWQ .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJ UPSFT-UEBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 278 Marina de Lima Lopes RVFDBSBDUFSJ[BSJBBSFBMPNJTTÍPUBNCÏNEFOPNJOBEBEFTJMÐODJPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP EFOUSPEPQSPDFEJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPRVFEFWFTFSPCTFSWBEPQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUP %FTUBSUFWJTBOEPBNFMIPSBOBMJTBSBNBUÏSJBQPEFNPTJEFOUJmDBSFTFQBSBS USÐT IJQØUFTFTEJTUJOUBTEFTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPUFOEPFNWJTUBTFVTFGFJUPTF SFQFSDVTTÜFTMFHBJT "QSJNFJSBPDPSSFRVBOEPBMFJQSFWÐVNQSB[PQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPBENJ OJTUSBUJWPKÈJNQPOEPBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTBPTFVEFTDVNQSJNFOUP"TFHVOEBIJQØUFTF FTUBSÈDPOmHVSBEBRVBOEPBMFJFNCPSBFTUBCFMFÎBVNQSB[PQBSBBBÎÍPBENJOJT USBUJWBOÍPQSFWÐTBOÎÜFT PV DPOTFRVÐODJBT FYQMÓDJUBT BP TFV EFTDVNQSJNFOUP & QPSmNUFNPTBUFSDFJSBIJQØUFTFRVBOEPOÍPIÈQSFWJTÍPFTQFDÓmDBEFQSB[PQBSBB QSÈUJDBEPBUPOFNEPTFGFJUPTRVFTFSÍPBUSJCVÓEPTBPNJTTÍP *OTUBSFTTBMUBSRVFFNUPEBTFTTBTIJQØUFTFTPNBOFKPEBTFHVSBOÎBTFSÈFN UFTFQPTTÓWFMEFOUSPEPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBMEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBT1PSJTTPP FYBUPNPNFOUPFNRVFOBTDFBPNJTTÍPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPFNCPSBOÍPTFKBEFTJN QMFTJEFOUJmDBÎÍPoDPNPPDPSSFOBIJQØUFTFEFBUPDPNJTTJWPoUFNDSVDJBMJNQPS UÉODJBQBSBmOTEFJNQFUSBÎÍPQPJTÏBQBSUJSEBTVBDBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPRVFUFNJOÓDJPP DÙNQVUPEFTUFQSB[PEFDBEFODJBM %FTUBSUFQBTTBSFNPTBBOÈMJTFEFDBEBVNBEBTIJQØUFTFTBDJNBFMFODBEBT WJTBOEPFYBUBNFOUFJEFOUJmDBSFTUFFYBUPNPNFOUPFNRVFTVSHFBPNJTTÍPBENJ OJTUSBUJWBQBSBRVFQPTTBTFSBWBMJBEPTFOPDBTPDPODSFUPFTUFTJMÐODJPBJOEBTFSÈ QBTTÓWFMEFJNQVHOBÎÍPQFMPmandamus PVTFPJOUFSFTTBEPUFSÈRVFTFWBMFSEBTWJBT PSEJOÈSJBTQBSBBQSPUFÎÍPEFTFVEJSFJUPQPSRVFQSFDMVTBBWJBFTQFDJBM 4.1. Primeira hipótese: previsão legal de prazo para a prática do ato e das consequências da omissão /FTUFQSJNFJSPDBTPIÈVNBMJNJUBÎÍPUFNQPSBMQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPDPN FYQMJDJUBÎÍPEBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTEBJOBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBQPSFYFNQMPEFGFSJNFOUP PVJOEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEP "-FJEF1BSDFMBNFOUPEF4PMP6SCBOP-FJORVFQSFWÐFNTFV "SUfFRVFVNBWF[USBOTDPSSJEPPQSB[PQSFWJTUPTFNBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEP 1PEFS1ÞCMJDPPQSPKFUPEFQBSDFMBNFOUPBQSFTFOUBEPTFSÈDPOTJEFSBEPSFKFJUBEPFBT PCSBTSFDVTBEBTQPEFTFSJOEJDBEBDPNPFYFNQMPEFTUBIJQØUFTF "SU"MFJNVOJDJQBMEFmOJSÈPTQSB[PTQBSBRVFVNQSPKFUPEFQBS DFMBNFOUPBQSFTFOUBEPTFKBBQSPWBEPPVSFKFJUBEPFQBSBRVFBTPCSBT FYFDVUBEBTTFKBNBDFJUBTPVSFDVTBEBT f5SBOTDPSSJEPTPTQSB[PTTFNBNBOJGFTUBÎÍPEPQPEFSQÞCMJDPP QSPKFUPTFSÈDPOTJEFSBEPSFKFJUBEPPVBTPCSBTSFDVTBEBTBTTFHVSBEBB JOEFOJ[BÎÍPQPSFWFOUVBJTEBOPTEFSJWBEPTEBPNJTTÍP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 279 f/PTNVOJDÓQJPTDVKBMFHJTMBÎÍPGPSPNJTTBPTQSB[PTTFSÍPEFOP WFOUBEJBTQBSBBBQSPWBÎÍPPVSFKFJÎÍPFEFTFTTFOUBEJBTQBSBBBDFJUB ÎÍPPVSFDVTBGVOEBNFOUBEBEBTPCSBTEFVSCBOJ[BÎÍP "DBSBDUFSJ[BÎÍPEBPNJTTÍPQBSBmOTEFNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBOFTUFDBTP ÏNBJTTJNQMFT%VSBOUFPQSB[PQSFWJTUPFNMFJQBSBFYFDVÎÍPEPBUPOÍPQPEFSÈ TFSJNQVUBEBË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPRVBMRVFSJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFSEFDPSSFOUFEF TVBJOBÎÍPQPJTMIFÏMÓDJUPVTVGSVJSUPEPFTUFQFSÓPEPQBSBSFHVMBSNFOUFQSBUJDÈMP 'JOEPFTUFDBTPB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFPNJUBBJOÏSDJBJNQPSUBSÈOBDPOTFRàÐO DJBMFHBMJNQPTUBPRVFEBNFTNBGPSNBOÍPJNQMJDBSÈFNQSJODÓQJPOBQSÈUJDBEF RVBMRVFSJMFHBMJEBEFPVBCVTPEFQPEFSRVFQVEFTTFTFSJNQVHOBEBWJBmandamus QPJTBQSØQSJBMFJJOUFSQSFUBFTUBJOBÎÍPJNQPOEPBFMBEFUFSNJOBEBSFQFSDVTTÍPKVSÓ EJDB5PEBWJBQPEFSÈTFSBQVSBEBFWFOUVBMSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFEBTBVUPSJEBEFTPNJTTBT BEFQFOEFSEPDBTPDPODSFUP 1PSUBOUPOFTUBQSJNFJSBIJQØUFTFTPNFOUFBQØTPUÏSNJOPEPQSB[PEJTQPTUP FNMFJQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPÏRVFTFJOJDJBBDPOUBHFNEPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBMEF DFOUPFWJOUF EJBTQBSBBJNQFUSBÎÍPEPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB $POUVEPFOUFOEFNPTRVFUBMJNQFUSBÎÍPOÍPQPEFSÈUFSQPSGVOEBNFO UPBTJNQMFTPNJTTÍPNBTTJNEFWFSÈTFSWJSQBSBJNQVHOBSPTFGFJUPTDPODSFUPT EBEPTQFMBMFJBPTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPQPSFYFNQMPEFGFSJNFOUPPVJOEFGFSJ NFOUPEPQFEJEP 5PEBWJBDBTPBMFJDPODFEBVNFGFJUPQPTJUJWPBPTJMÐODJPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPo DPNPUFNPTOPFYFNQMPEPEFGFSJNFOUPEPQFEJEPoGBMUBSÈBPCFOFmDJBEPJOUFSFTTF EFBHJSQBSBQSPQPSFWFOUVBMBÎÍPJNQVHOBOEPPTFGFJUPTEFTUBPNJTTÍPBOUFTEFTF WFSBNFBÎBEPQPSBMHVNRVFTUJPOBNFOUPEBTVBQPTJÎÍPKVSÓEJDBQPJTOÍPQPEFSF RVFSFSRVFP+VEJDJÈSJPDPODFEBBRVJMPRVFBMFJKÈMIFDPODFEFV 4.2. Segunda hipótese: previsão legal de prazo para a prática do ato, sem imposição de consequências para a omissão +È OFTUB TFHVOEB IJQØUFTF FN RVF FNCPSB IBKB VNB MJNJUBÎÍP RVBOUP BP NPNFOUPQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPBMFJOÍPQSFWÐFYQSFTTBNFOUFPTFGFJUPTEBPNJTTÍP TPNFOUFQPEFSÈTFSVUJMJ[BEBBWJBNBOEBNFOUBMEFQPJTEFFYBVSJEPPUFNQPDPODF EJEPËBENJOJTUSBÎÍP*TUPPDPSSFQPSFYFNQMPOB-FJORVFEJTQÜF TPCSFBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBGFEFSBMFmYBQSB[PFNTFV"SUQBSBRVFBBE NJOJTUSBÎÍPQSPmSBEFDJTÍPTFNJNQVUBSUPEBWJBOFOIVNBDPOTFRVÐODJBËJOBÎÍP "SU ù ² PCSJHBUØSJP RVF TFKB QSPGFSJEB EFDJTÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWB OP QSB[PNÈYJNPEFUSF[FOUPTFTFTTFOUB EJBTBDPOUBSEPQSPUPDPMP EFQFUJÎÜFTEFGFTBTPVSFDVSTPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTEPDPOUSJCVJOUF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 280 Marina de Lima Lopes %FTTBGPSNBPQSB[PEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBTQBSBBJNQFUSBÎÍPUFSÈJOÓDJP DPNPmNEPQSB[PMFHBMNFOUFQSFWJTUPQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP /FTTFDBTPPmandamusEFWFSÈJNQVHOBSPTJMÐODJPFNTJWJTUPRVFBQSØ QSJBPNJTTÍPFTUBSJBDBVTBOEPMFTÍPBEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUP0JNQFUSBOUFEFNBO EBSÈBPKVÓ[PRVFEFUFSNJOFËBVUPSJEBEFJNQFUSBEBBQSPOÞODJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBFN QSB[PSB[PÈWFMQPJTOÍPÏQPTTÓWFMRVFP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPQSBUJRVFEJSFUBNFOUFPBUP PNJUJEP &OUSFUBOUPOÍPTFPMWJEBBFYJTUÐODJBEFQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEPVUSJOÈSJPOPTFO UJEPEFRVFOFTTFTDBTPTPJNQFUSBOUFQPEFSJBUBNCÏNEFNBOEBSBP+VÓ[PRVFGPTTF TVQSJEBBJOBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBRVBOEPTFUSBUBTTFEFBUPEFDPOUFÞEPWJODVMBEP SFTFSWBOEPËTIJQØUFTFTEFBUPEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPBNFSBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPKVEJDJBMEFQSP OVODJBNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP33. $POUVEPDPNPEFWJEPSFTQFJUPBPTEFGFOTPSFTEFTUBUFTFOÍPTFSJBQPTTÓWFM BP+VEJDJÈSJPTVCTUJUVJSBWPOUBEFEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPNFTNPRVFTFKBFTUBWJODVMBEB DPOGPSNFBEWFSUF+PTÏEPT4BOUPT$BSWBMIP'JMIP $BTPOÍPUFOIBÐYJUPOBWJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBQBSBPCUFSNBOJGFTUBÎÍPDP NJTTJWB EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP OÍP SFTUBSÈ QBSB P JOUFSFTTBEP PVUSB BMUFS OBUJWBTFOÍPSFDPSSFSBWJBKVEJDJBM%JGFSFOUFNFOUFEPRVFTVDFEFOB IJQØUFTFFNRVFBMFJJOEJDBRVFBPNJTTÍPTJHOJmDBEFOFHBÎÍPIJQØ UFTFFNRVFTFQSFUFOEFEFTDPOTUJUVJSSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBPJOUFSFTTBEP EFEV[JSÈQFEJEPEFOBUVSF[BmandamentalPVQBSBBMHVOTDPOEFOBUØ SJBQBSBDVNQSJNFOUPEFPCSJHBÎÍPEFGB[FS PRVBMTFGPSBDPMIJEPOB TFOUFOÎBJNQMJDBSÈBFYQFEJÎÍPEFPSEFNKVEJDJBMËBVUPSJEBEFBENJ OJTUSBUJWBQBSBRVFDVNQSBTFVQPEFSEFWFSEFBHJSFGPSNBMJ[FNBOJ GFTUBÎÍPWPMJUJWBFYQSFTTBTPCQFOBEFEFTPCFEJÐODJBBPSEFNKVEJDJBM )ÈKVSJTUBTOPFOUBOUPRVFTVTUFOUBNRVFTFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFTUBWB WJODVMBEBBPDPOUFÞEPEPBUPOÍPQSBUJDBEPBUPWJODVMBEP FUFOEPP JOUFSFTTBEPEJSFJUPBPRVFQPTUVMBSBQPEFSJBPKVJ[TVQSJSBBVTÐODJBEF NBOJGFTUBÎÍP 0VTBNPT EJTTFOUJS EFTTF FOUFOEJNFOUP QPSRVBOUP OÍP QPEFPØSHÍPKVSJTEJDJPOBMTVCTUJUVJSBWPOUBEFEPØSHÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWP QPEF JTUP TJN PCSJHÈMB B FNJUJMB TF B MFJ P JNQVTFS BSDBOEP P BENJOJTUSBEPSDPNBTDPOTFRàÐODJBTEFFWFOUVBMEFTDVNQSJNFOUP *OUFSFTTBOUFOFTTFQPOUPNFODJPOBSBEJTQPTJÎÍPDPOUJEBOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP EP&TUBEPEP3JP(SBOEFEP/PSUFRVFQSFWÐVNBFTQÏDJFEFiJOUFSQFMBÎÍPKVEJDJBMw 33 .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJ UPSFT-UEBQ $"37"-)0'*-)0+PTÏEPT4BOUPTManual de Direito Administrativo. FE3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB -VNFO+VSJTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 281 RVBOEPBJOGPSNBÎÍPSFRVFSJEBOÍPGPSQSFTUBEBQFMPTØSHÍPTQÞCMJDPTFTUBEVBJTOP QSB[PEFEF[ EJBTEFTEFRVFOÍPTFKBIJQØUFTFEFhabeas data: "SU¡2VFNOÍPSFDFCFSOPQSB[PEFEF[ EJBTJOGPSNBÎÜFTEFTFV JOUFSFTTFQBSUJDVMBSPVEFJOUFSFTTFDPMFUJWPPVHFSBMSFRVFSJEBTBØSHÍPT QÞCMJDPTFTUBEVBJTQPEFOÍPTFOEPIJQØUFTFEFhabeas dataFYJHJMBTKV EJDJBMNFOUFEFWFOEPP+VJ[DPNQFUFOUFPVWJEPRVFNBTEFWBQSFTUBSOP QSB[PEFWJOUFFRVBUSP IPSBTEFDJEJSFNDJODP EJBTJOUJNBOEPP SFTQPOTÈWFMQFMBSFDVTBPVPNJTTÍPBGPSOFDFSBTJOGPSNBÎÜFTSFRVFSJEBT TPCQFOBEFEFTPCFEJÐODJBTBMWPBIJQØUFTFEFTJHJMPJNQSFTDJOEÓWFMËTF HVSBOÎBEBTPDJFEBEFPVEP&TUBEP 4.3. Terceira hipótese: ausência de previsão legal de prazo para a prática do ato e das consequências da omissão 1PSmNUFNPTBÞMUJNBIJQØUFTFRVFPDPSSFRVBOEPB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOÍP FTUÈTVKFJUBBQSB[PFTQFDÓmDPQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPFUBNCÏNOÍPIÈFNQSJODÓQJP DPOTFRVÐODJBKVSÓEJDBEFTUBJOBÎÍP 5PEBWJBOFTUFDBTPTFSÈQSFDJTPEJTUJOHVJSTFBJOBÎÍPJNQVUBEBTFSFGFSFË BVTÐODJBEFSFTQPTUBBSFRVFSJNFOUPEFBENJOJTUSBEPPVËGBMUBEFDVNQSJNFOUPEP EFWFSEFPGÓDJP &NBNCPTPTDBTPTQPSÏNPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBUBNCÏNJNQVHOBSÈ BQSØQSJBPNJTTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBHFSBEPSBEFMFTÍPBEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPSFRVF SFOEPTFKVEJDJBMNFOUFBQSPOÞODJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBQPJTDPNPKÈTBMJFOUBEPP1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJPOÍPQPEFTVCTUJUVJSBWPOUBEFEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFEFUFSNJOBSEJSFUBNFOUF BQSÈUJDBEPBUPBJOEBRVFTFUSBUFEFBUVBÎÍPWJODVMBEB 4.3.1. Ausência de resposta a requerimento administrativo $BTPTFUSBUFEFPNJTTÍPFNSFMBÎÍPBQFEJEPBENJOJTUSBUJWPGPSNVMBEPQPS JOUFSFTTBEPEFWFSÈTFSBQMJDBEBBSFHSBQSFWJTUBFNMFJQBSBSFHVMBSPTQSPDFEJNFOUPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPTEFNPEPHFSBMRVFOFTUFTDBTPTQPTTVJDBSÈUFSTVCTJEJÈSJP *TUPQPSRVFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFTUÈTFNQSFBETUSJUBBPQSJODÓQJPEBMFHBMJ EBEFoBSUcaputEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMoQPSRVBOUPTØMIFÏFYJHÓWFMRVF GBÎBPRVFÏQSFWJTUPFNMFJFBTTJNTFOÍPIPVWFTTFQSB[PSFHVMBNFOUBOEPP NPNFOUP EF TVB BÎÍP FN EFUFSNJOBEB IJQØUFTF QPEFSJB TF BSHVNFOUBS RVF P UFNQPEFUBMSFTQPTUBFTUBSJBEFOUSPEPÉNCJUPEFTVBEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFoDPO WFOJÐODJB F PQPSUVOJEBEF BENJOJTUSBUJWB o F QPSUBOUP OFOIVNB PNJTTÍP MIF QPEFSJBTFSJNQVUBEB RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 282 Marina de Lima Lopes 5PEBWJBOÍPTFPMWJEBEPEFWFSEFEFDJEJSRVFUFNB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFEP QSJODÓQJP EB FmDJÐODJB RVF UBNCÏN SFHF TVB BUVBÎÍP F JNQÜF B DÏMFSF SFTPMVÎÍP EPT QSPDFEJNFOUPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT %FTTB GPSNB OFTUBT IJQØUFTFT EFWFSÍP JODJEJS BTSFHSBTHFSBJTEFQSPDFEJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPEFPCTFSWÉODJBPCSJHBUØSJBQFMB"E NJOJTUSBÎÍPRVFEJTDJQMJOBNHFOFSJDBNFOUFPEJSFJUPEFSFTQPTUBEPTBENJOJTUSBEPT /FTTFDPOUFYUPUFNPTB-FJ'FEFSBMO¡RVFSFHVMBPQSPDFTTP BENJOJTUSBUJWP OP ÉNCJUP EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB 'FEFSBM F QSFWÐ FN TFVT BSUT FPQSB[PEFBUÏUSJOUB EJBTBQØTBDPODMVTÍPEBJOTUSVÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWB QBSBRVFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEFDJEB5BMOPSNBFOUSFUBOUPOÍPDPOGFSFOFOIVNFGFJUP BPTJMÐODJPTFVMUSBQBTTBEPFTTFQFSÓPEP "SU""ENJOJTUSBÎÍPUFNPEFWFSEFFYQMJDJUBNFOUFFNJUJSEFDJTÍP OPTQSPDFTTPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFTPCSFTPMJDJUBÎÜFTPVSFDMBNBÎÜFTFN NBUÏSJBEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJB "SU$PODMVÓEBBJOTUSVÎÍPEFQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPB"ENJOJT USBÎÍPUFNPQSB[PEFBUÏUSJOUBEJBTQBSBEFDJEJSTBMWPQSPSSPHBÎÍPQPS JHVBMQFSÓPEPFYQSFTTBNFOUFNPUJWBEB 3FTTBMUBTF QPS PQPSUVOP P DBSÈUFS OBDJPOBM F TVCTJEJÈSJP EB SFGFSJEB MFJ GFEFSBMRVFFTUBCFMFDFVOPSNBTCÈTJDBTQBSBPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFN HFSBM EBOEP BQMJDBÎÍP BPT QSJODÓQJPT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJT RVF HBSBOUFN PT EJSFJUPT EP DJEBEÍPQFSBOUFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPDPOTPBOUFMFDJPOB.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBEF1JFUSP RVFOPFOUBOUPBEWFSUF /PUFTF RVF B -FJ OÍP FTUBCFMFDFV QSPDFEJNFOUP FTQFDÓmDP B TFS BEPUBEP QFMPTØSHÍPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPT&MBFTUBCFMFDFVOPSNBTCÈTJDBTTPCSFQSPDFTTPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPTFNHFSBM0PCKFUJWPEB-FJOÍPGPJBQFOBTFTUBCFMFDFSOPS NBTTPCSFQSPDFTTPTFGPTTFPDBTPB-FJQPEFSJBTFSDPOTJEFSBEBEFÉNCJUP GFEFSBMBQFOBT0DPSSFRVFFMBOÍPTFMJNJUPVBJTTP&MBGPJBMÏN0TFVQSJO DJQBMPCKFUJWPGPJPEFEBSBQMJDBÎÍPBQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTQFSUJOFOUFT BPTEJSFJUPTEPDJEBEÍPQFSBOUFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB0SBRVBOEPTFGBMB FNQSJODÓQJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFFNEJSFJUPTEPDJEBEÍPFOUSBTFOBFTGFSBEF UFNBTEFJOUFSFTTFOBDJPOBMFQPSUBOUPEFDPNQFUÐODJBEB6OJÍP<> *TTPOÍPJNQFEFRVF&TUBEPTF.VOJDÓQJPTUBNCÏNMFHJTMFNTPCSFBNBUÏ SJBEFQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNWJTUBTËBQMJDBÎÍPEPTNFTNPTQSJODÓ QJPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT$PNSFMBÎÍPËTMFJTFTUBEVBJTFNVOJDJQBJTWBMJEBNFO UFQSPNVMHBEBTB-FJ'FEFSBMUFSÈBQMJDBÎÍPTVCTJEJÈSJBEBNFTNBGPSNB RVFPDPSSFDPNSFMBÎÍPËTMFJTGFEFSBJTTPCSFQSPDFEJNFOUPTFTQFDÓmDPT. %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMB. A Lei de Processo Administrativo: sua ideia matriz e âmbito de aplicação. RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 283 /P &TUBEP EF 4ÍP 1BVMP P QSPDFEJNFOUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP FTUÈ EJTDJQMJOBEP QFMB-FJ&TUBEVBMO¡RVFQSFWÐFNTFV"SUPQSB[PNÈYJNPEF DFOUPFWJOUF EJBTQBSBBEFDJTÍPEFSFRVFSJNFOUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTmOEPFTUFEFWF SÈTFSDPOTJEFSBEPSFKFJUBEPPQFEJEPiTJMÐODJPOFHBUJWPw "SUJHP0QSB[PNÈYJNPQBSBEFDJTÍPEFSFRVFSJNFOUPTEFRVBMRVFS FTQÏDJFBQSFTFOUBEPTË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFSÈEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBT TFPVUSPOÍPGPSMFHBMNFOUFFTUBCFMFDJEP f6MUSBQBTTBEPPQSB[PTFNEFDJTÍPPJOUFSFTTBEPQPEFSÈDPOTJEFSBS SFKFJUBEPPSFRVFSJNFOUPOBFTGFSBBENJOJTUSBUJWBTBMWPQSFWJTÍPMFHBM PVSFHVMBNFOUBSFNDPOUSÈSJP f 2VBOEP B DPNQMFYJEBEF EB RVFTUÍP FOWPMWJEB OÍP QFSNJUJS P BUFOEJNFOUP EP QSB[P QSFWJTUP OFTUF BSUJHP B BVUPSJEBEF DJFOUJmDBSÈ P JOUFSFTTBEP EBT QSPWJEÐODJBT BUÏ FOUÍP UPNBEBT TFN QSFKVÓ[P EP EJTQPTUPOPQBSÈHSBGPBOUFSJPS fo0EJTQPTUPOPfEFTUFBSUJHPOÍPEFTPOFSBBBVUPSJEBEFEP EFWFSEFBQSFDJBSPSFRVFSJNFOUP 1PSUBOUPOPDBTPEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPPQSB[PQBSBBQSPMBÎÍPEFEFDJTÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWBTFSÈFNSFHSBEFOPNÈYJNPEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBTJOEFQFO EFOUFNFOUFEBDPODMVTÍPPVOÍPEBJOTUSVÎÍPTBMWPQSFWJTÍPFTQFDJBM"-FJ/BDJPOBM O¡oTPNFOUFUFSÈBQMJDBÎÍPTVCTJEJÈSJBFNSFMBÎÍPË-FJ&TUBEVBMo-FJ &TUBEVBMO¡ %FTUBDBTFRVFPQSB[PEFUSJOUB EJBTQSFWJTUPOP"SUEB$POTUJ UVJÎÍPEFTUF&TUBEPTPNFOUFTFBQMJDBBPGPSOFDJNFOUPEFJOGPSNBÎÜFTPVDFSUJEÜFT OÍPBCSBOHFOEPQPSUBOUPBIJQØUFTFBDJNBNFODJPOBEBRVFQPEFUFSQSB[PEJWFSTP UBNCÏNQPSFYQSFTTBQSFWJTÍPEP$POTUJUVJOUF&TUBEVBM"SU %FTTBGPSNBUFNPTRVFOFTUFÞMUJNPDBTPEFPNJTTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBFN SFMBÎÍPBSFRVFSJNFOUPTGPSNVMBEPTQFMPBENJOJTUSBEPTPNFOUFFTUBSÈJEFOUJm DBEBBJOBÎÍPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFEFQPJTEFmOEPPQSB[PQSFWJTUPFNMFJRVF SFHVMB PT QSPDFEJNFOUPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT EF NPEP HFSBM OÍP IPVWFS OFOIVNB SFTQPTUBBENJOJTUSBUJWB *O/0)"3"*SFOF1BUSÓDJB.03"&4'*-)0.BSDP"OUPOJP1SBYFEFTEFPSHBOJ[BEPSFT Processo Administrativo: temas polêmicos da Lei n° 9.784/99. 4ÍP1BVMP"UMBTQ i"SUJHPo"BENJOJTUSBÎÍPÏPCSJHBEBBGPSOFDFSBRVBMRVFSDJEBEÍPQBSBBEFGFTBEFTFVTEJSFJUPT FFTDMBSFDJNFOUPTEFTJUVBÎÜFTEFTFVJOUFSFTTFQFTTPBMOPQSB[PNÈYJNPEFEF[EJBTÞUFJTDFSUJEÍP EFBUPTDPOUSBUPTEFDJTÜFTPVQBSFDFSFTTPCQFOBEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFEBBVUPSJEBEFPVTFSWJEPSRVF OFHBSPVSFUBSEBSBTVBFYQFEJÎÍP/PNFTNPQSB[PEFWFSÈBUFOEFSËTSFRVJTJÎÜFTKVEJDJBJTTFPVUSP OÍPGPSmYBEPQFMBBVUPSJEBEFKVEJDJÈSJBw i"SUJHPo"MFJEFWFSÈmYBSQSB[PTQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPTBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTFFTUBCFMFDFSSFDVSTPT BEFRVBEPTËTVBSFWJTÍPJOEJDBOEPTFVTFGFJUPTFGPSNBEFQSPDFTTBNFOUPw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 284 Marina de Lima Lopes $BSBDUFSJ[BEB EFTTF NPEP B JOBÎÍP JOJDJBTF B QBSUJS EFMB P DÙNQVUP EP QSB[PEFDFOUPFWJOUF QBSBJNQFUSBÎÍPTPCQFOBEFVNBWF[FYBVSJEPOÍP NBJTQPEFSTFSVUJMJ[BEBBWJBNBOEBNFOUBMSFTUBOEPBPTBENJOJTUSBEPTBQFOBTBT WJBTPSEJOÈSJBT 4.3.2. Falta de cumprimento de dever legal $POTJEFSBOEPBJOEBFTUBUFSDFJSBIJQØUFTFJUFN DBTPTFUSBUFEFPNJTTÍP SFMBDJPOBEBBEFWFSEFDPSSFOUFEFMFJoFOÍPEFBVTÐODJBEFSFTQPTUBBSFRVFSJNFOUP BENJOJTUSBUJWPoRVBOEPOÍPIPVWFSQSB[PFYQSFTTBNFOUFQSFWJTUPQBSBBBUVBÎÍP EB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPDPNPSFHSBFTUBEFWFSÈTFSUJEBQPSPNJTTBBQBSUJSEBWJHÐODJBEB QSØQSJBOPSNBRVFEFWFSJBUFSTJEPPCTFSWBEBFOÍPGPJPVEFTEFRVBOEPPJNQF USBOUFm[FTTFKVTBPCFOFGÓDJPOFMBQSFWJTUPRVFOÍPMIFGPJDPODFEJEP 0SBDPNPKÈTBMJFOUBEPBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPFTUÈBETUSJUBBPQSJODÓQJPEBMFHBMJ EBEFQPSUBOUPFOUSBOEPFNWJHPSVNBMFJRVFDPNJOFBQSÈUJDBEFEFUFSNJOBEPBUP BENJOJTUSBUJWPFVNBWF[DBSBDUFSJ[BEBBIJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJBTVBPCTFSWÉODJBÏPCSJ HBUØSJBFJNFEJBUBSFWFTUJOEPTFEFJMFHBMJEBEFBJOKVTUJmDBEBJOBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWB "TTJNDBSBDUFSJ[BEBBPNJTTÍPUFSÈJOÓDJPPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBMQBSBVUJMJ[B ÎÍPEBWJBNBOEBNFOUBM ²DPOWFOJFOUFOPFOUBOUPEFTUBDBSQFMBTTVBTQFDVMJBSFTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTBT IJQØUFTFTEFPNJTTÍPEJBOUFEFMFHJTMBÎÜFTRVFJNQÜFNËBENJOJTUSBÎÍPQSFTUBÎÜFT EF OBUVSF[B DPOUJOVBEB PV EF USBUP TVDFTTJWP SFMBUJWBT BPT BENJOJTUSBEPT PV BPT QSØQSJPTTFSWJEPSFT*TTPPDPSSFQPSFYFNQMPFNSFMBÎÍPËTMFJTRVFQSFWÐFNPQBHB NFOUPNFOTBMEFEFUFSNJOBEBHSBUJmDBÎÍPBPTGVODJPOÈSJPTQÞCMJDPT "KVSJTQSVEÐODJBSFNBOTPTBEFOPTTPTUSJCVOBJTTFSFWFMBOPTFOUJEPEFRVF OFTTFTDBTPTQPSIBWFSBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPMFHBMEFQBHBNFOUPQFSJØEJDPEFUBJTQSFT UBÎÜFTPEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍPJNQPTUBTFSJBDPOTUBUBEPFNDBEBVNEPT QFSÓPEPTSFOPWBOEPTFUBNCÏNQFSJPEJDBNFOUFPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBM /FTTFTFOUJEPUSB[FNPTBDPMBÎÍPPTKVMHBEPTBTFHVJSUSBOTDSJUPT ."/%"%0%&4&(63"/±"3&$634003%*/«3*04&37*%03&4 %0 .*/*45²3*0 1Á#-*$0 %0 &45"%0 %& 30/%¼/*" 7"/5" (&.1&440"-3&"+645&3&-"±°0%&53"5046$&44*70%& CADÊNCIA. INOCORRÊNCIA. 4FSWJEPSFT QÞCMJDPT CVTDBN OB JNQFUSBÎÍP UVUFMB KVSJTEJDJPOBM FN GBDFEFPNJTTÍPEBBVUPSJEBEFJNQFUSBEBRVFTFOFHBBSFBKVTUBSWBOUB HFNQFTTPBMOBNFTNBQSPQPSÎÍPEPBVNFOUPDPODFEJEPQPSMFJFTUBEVBM BPWFODJNFOUPCÈTJDP5SBUBOEPTFEFJNQFUSBÎÍPDPOUSBPNJTTÍPBENJ OJTUSBUJWBEFFGFJUPTDPOUJOVBEPTOÍPFTUÈDPOmHVSBEBBEFDBEÐODJB 3FDVSTPPSEJOÈSJPQSPWJEP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 285 4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB3.4303FDVSTP0SEJOÈSJP FN.BOEBEPEF4FHVSBOÎB3FMBUPS.JOJTUSP5FPSJ "MCJOP;BWBTDLJ»SHÍP+VMHBEPS51SJNFJSB5VSNB%BUBEP+VMHB NFOUP "%.*/*453"5*70 130$&446"- $*7*- "(3"70 3&(*.&/5"- 3&$6340&41&$*"-"$»3%°03&$033*%00.*44°0*/&9*4 5³/$*"4&37*%031Á#-*$07"/5"(&.1&440"-"500.*44* VO DA ADMINISTRAÇÃO. DECADÊNCIA. INOCORRÊNCIA. <>"KVSJTQSVEÐODJBEFTUBDPSUFmSNPVFOUFOEJNFOUPOPTFOUJEP EFRVFUSBUBOEPTFEFNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBOPRVBMTFJNQVHOBBMF HBEBPNJTTÍPEBBVUPSJEBEFDPBUPSBFNQBHBSQBSDFMBSFNVOFSBUØSJB PQSB[PEFEFDBEÐODJBQBSBBJNQFUSBÎÍPEPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB SFOPWBTFNÐTBNÐT "HSBWPSFHJNFOUBMBRVFTFOFHBQSPWJNFOUP 4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBo"H3HOP3&TQ.4o"HSBWP 3FHJNFOUBMOP3FDVSTP&TQFDJBMoo3FMBUPS.JOJTUSP 0H'FSOBOEFTo»SHÍP+VMHBEPS5o4FYUB5VSNBo%BUBEP+VMHBNFO UP 1PSPVUSPMBEPUBNCÏNOÍPTFPMWJEBRVFFNEFUFSNJOBEBTIJQØUFTFTBBÎÍP JNQPTUBQFMBMFJQSFDFEFOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFEBBEPÎÍPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTNFEJEBTBENJ OJTUSBUJWBTQBSBBTVBQSÈUJDB /PFYFNQMPIJQPUÏUJDPEFVNBMFJRVFEFUFSNJOBTTFBQBSUJSEFTVBWJHÐO DJB RVF UPEBT BT SFQBSUJÎÜFT QÞCMJDBT EJTQVTFTTFN EF BS SFGSJHFSBEP QBSB NBJPS DPOGPSUP EPT BENJOJTUSBEPT UBM BUVBÎÍP QBSB TFS JNQMFNFOUBEB EFQFOEFSJB EF SFHVMBSQSPDFEJNFOUPMJDJUBUØSJPQSÏWJPEFOUSFPVUSPTBUPTOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFBOUFDF EFOUFTBTVBQSÈUJDB /FTUFTDBTPTQPSOÍPUSBUBSTFEFBUPJTPMBEPB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEFWFSJBEBS JOÓDJPBPTWÈSJPTQSPDFEJNFOUPTRVFPQSFDFEFNFNiQSB[PSB[PÈWFMw6MUSBQBTTBEP FTUFFTUBSJBDBSBDUFSJ[BEBBPNJTTÍPEBOEPFOTFKPEBNFTNBGPSNBËEFDBEÐODJB EBWJBFTQFDJBM *TUP QPSRVF OÍP Ï BENJTTÓWFM B VUJMJ[BÎÍP EF VNB BÎÍP FNFSHFODJBM DPNP ÏPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBQBSBJNQVHOBSVNBTJUVBÎÍPRVFUFOIBTFQSPMPOHBEP OPUFNQPFNNVJUPTDBTPTQPSBOPTFBOPTTFNRVBMRVFSDPOUFTUBÎÍP0VTPEFTUF FYDFQDJPOBMSFNÏEJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFWFTFSSFTFSWBEPQFMBTVBQSØQSJBOBUVSF[BB TJUVBÎÜFTQSFNFOUFT $PNJTTPEFTUBDBTFOPWBNFOUFRVFOÍPTFFTUÈJNQPTTJCJMJUBOEPPBDFTTP BP+VEJDJÈSJPQPJTBJNQPTJÎÍPEFQSB[PEFDBEFODJBMQBSBJNQFUSBÎÍPOÍPBUJOHFP EJSFJUPTVCTUBOUJWPRVFBGVOEBNFOUBFQPEFSÈTFSEFGFOEJEPQFMBTWJBTPSEJOÈSJBT "QFOBTIBWFSÈBEFDBEÐODJBEPEJSFJUPËVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFTUFSFNÏEJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMQFMP EFDVSTPEFQSB[PTVQFSJPSBDFOUPFWJOUF EJBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 286 Marina de Lima Lopes /P DBTP EP mandado de segurança IÈ VN EJSFJUP TVCKFUJWP QÞCMJDP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EF EFGFTB EPT EJSFJUPT MÓRVJEPT F DFSUPT GFSJEPT PV BNFBÎBEPTVUJMJ[BOEPTFBWJBEPmandamus, FÏEFTTFEJSFJUPRVFEFDBJ PJOUFSFTTBEPRVFOÍPBVUJMJ[BOPTDFOUPFWJOUFEJBTOÍPEPEJSFJUP TVCTUBOUJWPRVFGVOEBNFOUBBJNQFUSBÎÍPPRVBMQPEFFWFOUVBMNFOUF TFSEFGFOEJEPQPSPVUSPTNFJPTQSPDFTTVBJT "TTJNQPEFNPTJOEJDBSRVFTFSJBDPNPSFHSBQSB[PiSB[PÈWFMwTFBHVBSEBS BBUVBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBQPSDFOUPFWJOUF EJBTQPSBOBMPHJBBPQSØQSJPQSB[P QSFWJTUPQBSBJNQFUSBÎÍPEBTFHVSBOÎB&YDFÎÍPMPHJDBNFOUFEFWFIBWFSOBTIJQØ UFTFTNBJTVSHFOUFTFNRVFPJOUFSFTTFQFSFDFSJBFNNFOPSQSB[PPVOBTIJQØUFTFT RVFEFQFOEFTTFNEFBUPTBOUFSJPSFTDPNQMFYPTRVFEFNBOEBSJBNEFGPSNBTFNQSF KVTUJmDBEBNBJPSUFNQPQBSBTFVDVNQSJNFOUP "VUJMJ[BÎÍPQPSBOBMPHJBEPQSB[PQSFWJTUPQBSBBJNQFUSBÎÍPEPNBOEBEP EFTFHVSBOÎBFTUÈBNQBSBEBNBJTVNBWF[OBQSØQSJBOBUVSF[BEPSFNÏEJPDPOT UJUVDJPOBMRVFWJTBSFTHVBSEBSPGFOTBTQSFNFOUFTBEJSFJUPFOÍPBTJUVBÎÜFTRVFTF QSPMPOHBSBNOPUFNQP %FTUFNPEPPJOUFSFTTBEPEFWFSJBBHVBSEBSPQSB[PEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBT QBSBBBUVBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBTFOEPRVFVMUSBQBTTBEPFTUFFTUBSJBDBSBDUFSJ[BEBBPNJTTÍP PRVFEBSJBFOTFKPBPJOÓDJPEPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBMUBNCÏNEFDFOUPFWJOUF EJBTQBSB TVBJNQVHOBÎÍPWJBmandamus. 'JOEPTFTUFTEV[FOUPTFRVBSFOUB EJBTTPNFOUFSFTUB SJBBPJOUFSFTTBEPPVTPEBTWJBTPSEJOÈSJBTQBSBBEFGFTBEFTFVQSFUFOTPEJSFJUP *OUFSFTTBOUFOFTUFQPOUPDPOTJHOBSPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEF7JDFOUF(SFDP'J MIPRVFEFGFOEFRVFOBTIJQØUFTFTFNRVFOÍPIÈOPSNBMFHBMSFHVMBEPSBQBSBDB SBDUFSJ[BSBPNJTTÍPFBDPOTFRàFOUFWJPMBÎÍPBEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPEFBMHVÏNOÍP IBWFSJBBMUFSOBUJWBTFOÍPQSPWPDBSBNPSBBENJOJTUSBUJWBJOUFSQFMBOEPQPSFTDSJUP QPSNFJPEFQFUJÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBPVOPUJmDBÎÍPKVEJDJBMPVFYUSBKVEJDJBMQBSBRVF BBVUPSJEBEFTFNBOJGFTUFFNQSB[PFTUBCFMFDJEPQFMPQSFKVEJDBEP. 5BMWF[TFKBFTTBBQPTUVSBNBJTTFHVSBBPBENJOJTUSBEPQBSBHBSBOUJSPVTPEB WJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM$VNQSFQPSÏNTBMJFOUBSRVFQPSUSBUBSTFEFQSB[PEFDBEFODJBM UBMJOUFSQFMBÎÍPOÍPUFSJBPDPOEÍPEFJOUFSSPNQÐMPPVTVTQFOEÐMP "3"Á+0&ENJS/FUUPEFCurso de direito administrativo. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB &TUFFSBPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEF$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF.FMMPBUÏFEJÎÍPEFTFV$VSTPEF%JSFJUP"E NJOJTUSBUJWPDPOUVEPBMUFSPVTFVFOUFOEJNFOUPOBTFEJÎÜFTQPTUFSJPSFTDPOTJHOBOEPRVFiPOEFGBMUBSMFJ EJTDJQMJOBOEPBNBUÏSJBIBWFSTFÈEFFOUFOEFSDPNPQSB[PSB[PÈWFMQPSBOBMPHJBBPEJTQPTUPOBMFJGFEFSBM EFQSPDFTTPPNFTNPQSB[POFMBFTUBCFMFDJEPw .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT-UEB, Q . 5PEBWJBSFTTBMWBEPOPTTPSFTQFJUP QFMPNFTUSFOÍPBDPNQBOIBNPTBBMUFSBÎÍPEFTFVQPTJDJPOBNFOUPQPJTFOUFOEFNPTRVFPQSB[PDPOUJEP OBMFJGFEFSBMEFQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPTPNFOUFTFBQMJDBËTIJQØUFTFTEFJOBÎÍPGSFOUFBQFEJEPTBENJOJT USBUJWPTFOÍPRVBOEPIPVWFSPNJTTÍPSFMBUJWBBEFWFSEFPGÓDJPQPSTFUSBUBSEFIJQØUFTFEJTUJOUB (3&$0'*-)07JDFOUFO novo mandado de segurança: comentários à Lei n. 12.016, de 7 de agosto de 2009. 4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 287 "OPUBTFOPFOUBOUPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPEJWFSHFOUFEF.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBEF 1JFUSPRVFEFGFOEFRVFOFTTBUFSDFJSBIJQØUFTFEFTJMÐODJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPEFNPEP HFSBMoWJTUPRVFBQSPGFTTPSBOÍPGB[FTTBEJTUJOÎÍPFOUSFPTDBTPTEFBVTÐODJBEFSFT QPTUBBSFRVFSJNFOUPEFBENJOJTUSBEPFEFGBMUBEFDVNQSJNFOUPEPEFWFSEFPGÓDJP oOÍPTFDPHJUBSJBFNEFDBEÐODJBQBSBPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB“por inexistência de um termo a quo; enquanto persistir a omissão, é cabível o mandado”41. &TUFUBNCÏNÏPFOUFOEJNFOUPEF)VNCFSUP5IFPEPSP+ÞOJPSRVFMFDJPOB RVFRVBOEPPBUPJMFHBMPVBCVTJWPÏQSBUJDBEPEFGPSNBPNJTTJWBOÍPIÈUFSNPJOJDJBM QBSBBCFSUVSBEPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBMFNDPNFOUP 0QPSUVOPQPSmNDPOTJHOBSRVFOP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPBEJTDVTTÍPBDJNBTF UPSOBFNQSJODÓQJPEFTQJDJFOEBQPJTBKÈNFODJPOBEB-FJORVFSFHVMB PQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPOPÉNCJUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB&TUBEVBMFTUBCFMFDFFN TFVBSUQSB[PQBSBBQSÈUJDBEFBUPTRVFOÍPTFKBNEFSJWBEPTEFQSPDFTTPTBENJOJT USBUJWPTNBTRVFEFDPSSBNEJSFUBNFOUFEBBQMJDBÎÍPEBMFJPVEFEFDJTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWB "SUJHPo4FSÈEFTFTTFOUB EJBTTFPVUSBOÍPGPSBEFUFSNJOBÎÍP MFHBMPQSB[PNÈYJNPQBSBBQSÈUJDBEFBUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTJTPMBEPT RVFOÍPFYJKBNQSPDFEJNFOUPQBSBTVBQSPMBÎÍPPVQBSBBBEPÎÍPQFMB BVUPSJEBEFQÞCMJDBEFPVUSBTQSPWJEÐODJBTOFDFTTÈSJBTËBQMJDBÎÍPEFMFJ PVEFDJTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWB 1BSÈHSBGPÞOJDPo0QSB[PnVJSÈBQBSUJSEPNPNFOUPFNRVFËWJTUB EBTDJSDVOTUÉODJBTUPSOBSTFMPHJDBNFOUFQPTTÓWFMBQSPEVÎÍPEPBUPPV BBEPÎÍPEBNFEJEBQFSNJUJEBQSPSSPHBÎÍPRVBOEPDBCÓWFMNFEJBOUF QSPQPTUBKVTUJmDBEB .FSFDFUSBOTDSJÎÍPPDPNFOUÈSJPEPQSPGFTTPS&ENJS/FUUPEF"SBÞKPBSFT QFJUPEBOPSNBFNEFTUBRVF 7FSJmDBTFRVFOP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPVMUSBQBTTBEPTPTTFTTFOUBEJBT QBSBPTBUPTRVFOÍPUFOIBNiPVUSBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPMFHBMwDPOUBEPTEB PQFSBDJPOBMJEBEFNFODJPOBEBOPQBSÈHSBGPÞOJDPQPEFSÈDBSBDUFSJ[BS TF B EFDJTÍP JNQMÓDJUB EF SFKFJÎÍP DPJCJOEP B DFOUFOÈSJB QSÈUJDB EP iFOHBWFUBNFOUPEFQSPDFTTPTwFQPTTJCJMJUBOEPPNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB 'JDBPFYFNQMPQBSBPVUSBT"ENJOJTUSBÎÜFT %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMB. Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP"UMBTQ 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPO mandado de segurança segundo a Lei nº 12.016, de 07 de agosto de 2009. 3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTFQ "3"Á+0&ENJS/FUUPEFCurso de direito administrativo. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB, Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 288 Marina de Lima Lopes 1PSUBOUPFTUBSÈDPOmHVSBEBBPNJTTÍPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1BVMJTUBQBTTÓWFM EFJNQVHOBÎÍPWJBmandamus,RVBOEPVMUSBQBTTBEPPQSB[PQSFWJTUPEFTFTTFOUB EJBTTFNBQSÈUJDBEPBUPRVFEFDPSSBEJSFUBNFOUFEFMFJPVEFDJTÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBF EFTEFRVFQSFFODIJEPTPTSFRVJTJUPTMFHBJTQBSBTVBQSPMBÎÍP 5. CONCLUSÃO %JBOUF EF UPEP P FYQPTUP DPODMVÓNPT RVF OBT IJQØUFTFT EF NBOEBEP EF TFHVSBOÎBDPOUSBPNJTTÍPUFNFTQFDJBMJNQPSUÉODJBBJEFOUJmDBÎÍPEPTJMÐODJPBENJ OJTUSBUJWPRVFEFDPSSFEBJOBÎÍPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPDBSBDUFSJ[BEBUBOUPQFMBBVTÐODJB EFFGFUJWBSFTQPTUBËQSPWPDBÎÍPEPBENJOJTUSBEPRVBOUPQFMBGBMUBEFDVNQSJNFOUP EPEFWFSEFPGÓDJP "TTJNDBTPBMFJQSFWFKBVNQSB[PQBSBBQSÈUJDBEPBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPKÈ JNQPOEPBTDPOTFRVÐODJBTEPTFVEFTDVNQSJNFOUPTPNFOUFEFQPJTEFmOEPFTUFÏ RVFQPEFSÈTFDPHJUBSEBJNQFUSBÎÍPRVFEFWFSÈJNQVHOBSPTFGFJUPTDPODSFUPTEBEPT QFMBMFJBPTJMÐODJPFOÍPQSPQSJBNFOUFBPNJTTÍP$BTPBMFJFNCPSBFTUBCFMFÎBVN QSB[P QBSB B BÎÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWB OÍP QSFWFKB TBOÎÜFT PV DPOTFRàÐODJBT FYQMÓDJUBT EPTFVEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEFQPJTEFFYBVSJEPPUFNQPDPODFEJEPË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP QPEFSÈTFSVUJMJ[BEBBWJBNBOEBNFOUBMQBSBJNQVHOBSBQSØQSJBPNJTTÍPFFYJHJSB QSPOÞODJBBENJOJTUSBUJWB 1PS mN TF OÍP IPVWFS QSFWJTÍP FTQFDÓmDB EF QSB[P QBSB B QSÈUJDB EP BUP OFNEPTFGFJUPTRVFTFSÍPBUSJCVÓEPTBPNJTTÍPFTFFMBFTUJWFSSFMBDJPOBEBBQFEJEP BENJOJTUSBUJWPTPNFOUFFTUBSÈDBSBDUFSJ[BEBBJOBÎÍPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFUFSÈJOÓDJPP QSB[PEFDBEFODJBMTFEFQPJTEFmOEPPQSB[PQSFWJTUPFNMFJRVFSFHVMBPTQSPDFEJ NFOUPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTEFNPEPHFSBMOÍPIPVWFSRVBMRVFSSFTQPTUBBENJOJTUSBUJWB .BTTFBIJQØUFTFBDJNBEJTTFSSFTQFJUPËPNJTTÍPSFMBUJWBBEFWFSEFDPSSFOUF EFMFJB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPDPNPSFHSBEFWFSÈTFSUJEBQPSPNJTTBBQBSUJSEBWJHÐODJB EBQSØQSJBOPSNBRVFEFWFSJBUFSTJEPPCTFSWBEBFOÍPGPJPVEFTEFRVBOEPPJNQF USBOUFm[FTTFKVTBPCFOFGÓDJPOFMBQSFWJTUPRVFOÍPMIFGPSBDPODFEJEP "EWFSUFTFUPEBWJBRVFOPTDBTPTEFPNJTTÍPEJBOUFEFMFHJTMBÎÍPRVFJN QPOIBË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPQSFTUBÎÜFTEFOBUVSF[BDPOUJOVBEBPVEFUSBUPTVDFTTJWPQPS IBWFSBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPMFHBMEFQBHBNFOUPQFSJØEJDPEFUBJTQSFTUBÎÜFTPEFTDVNQSJ NFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍPJNQPTUBTFSÈDPOTUBUBEPFNDBEBVNEPTQFSÓPEPTSFOPWBOEPTF UBNCÏNQFSJPEJDBNFOUFPQSB[PEFDBEFODJBM 1PSmNDBTPTFUSBUFEFMFJRVFJNQPOIBVNBBÎÍPRVFQSFDFEBOFDFTTB SJBNFOUFEBBEPÎÍPEFEFUFSNJOBEBTNFEJEBTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTQBSBBTVBQSÈUJDB FTUBT EFWFSÍP TFS BEPUBEBT QFMB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP FN iQSB[P SB[PÈWFMw TPC QFOB EF FOTFKBSBJNQVHOBÎÍPKVEJDJBMEBPNJTTÍPWJBNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎB²DPOTJEF SBEP SB[PÈWFM TF BHVBSEBS B BUVBÎÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWB QPS DFOUP F WJOUF EJBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 Mandado de segurança e silêncio administrativo 289 QPSBOBMPHJBBPQSØQSJPQSB[PQSFWJTUPQBSBJNQFUSBÎÍPEBTFHVSBOÎBWJTUPRVFUBM SFNÏEJPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMWJTBSFTHVBSEBSPGFOTBTQSFNFOUFTBEJSFJUPFOÍPTJUVBÎÜFT RVFTFQSPMPOHBNOPUFNQP 6. REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS "-7*. + & $BSSFJSB Comentários à nova lei do mandado de segurança – Lei 12.016/09. $VSJUJCB+VSVÈ&EJUPSB "3"Á+0&ENJS/FUUPEFCurso de direito administrativo. FESFWFBUVBM4ÍP1BVMP 4BSBJWB #0/"7*%&41BVMPCurso de Direito Constitucional. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT -UEB #6&/0$BTTJP4DBSQJOFMMBO Poder Público em juízo.FESFWBUVBMFBNQM4ÍP1BVMP 4BSBJWB $"37"-)0 '*-)0 +PTÏ EPT 4BOUPT Manual de Direito Administrativo. FE 3JP EF +BOFJSP&EJUPSB-VNFO+VSJT $6/)"-FPOBSEP$BSOFJSPEBA Fazenda Pública em juízo. FE4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDB %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMB. Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT ("+"3%0/*'FSOBOEPEB'POTFDBet al. Comentários à Nova Lei do Mandado de Segurança: Lei 12.016, de 7 de agosto de 2009. 4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEP (3&$0'*-)07JDFOUFO novo mandado de segurança: comentários à Lei n. 12.016, de 7 de agosto de 2009. 4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB -*."3VZ$JSOFPrincípios de Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT -UEB ."35*/4+6/*038BMMBDF1BJWBO mandado de segurança e o Direito Administrativo. *O3FWJTUB &MFUSÙOJDB +VTUJUJB o " 3FWJTUB EP .JOJTUÏSJP 1ÞCMJDP EF 4ÍP 1BVMP 4ÍP 1BVMP%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXKVTUJUJBDPNCSBSUJHPTDQEG"DFTTPFN OPW .&*3&--&4)FMZ-PQFTet al. Direito Administrativo Brasileiro. FE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJ SPT&EJUPSFT-UEB .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo. FE4ÍP1BVMP .BMIFJSPT&EJUPSFT-UEB .&/%&4 (JMNBS 'FSSFJSB et al. Curso de Direito Constitucional. FE SFW F BUVBM 4ÍP 1BVMP4BSBJWB .03"&4"MFYBOESFEFDireito Constitucional. FE4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT /0)"3"*SFOF1BUSÓDJB.03"&4'*-)0.BSDP"OUPOJP1SBYFEFTEFPSHBOJ[BEPSFT Processo Administrativo: temas polêmicos da Lei n° 9.784/99. 4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT '69-VJ[Mandado de Segurança. 3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF 5"7"3&4"OESÏ3BNPTManual do Novo Mandado de Segurança: Lei 12.016/2009.3JPEF +BOFJSP'PSFOTF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 290 Marina de Lima Lopes 5)&0%030+Á/*03)VNCFSUPO mandado de segurança segundo a Lei nº 12.016, de 07 de agosto de 2009. 3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF 4"%%:"OESÏEfeitos Jurídicos do Silêncio Positivo no Direito Administrativo Brasileiro. *O 3FWJTUB&MFUSÙOJDBEF%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPo3&%&4BMWBEPS*OTUJUVUP#SBTJMFJSPEF%JSFJUP 1ÞCMJDPO¡PVUVCSPOPWFNCSPEF[FNCSP%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXEJSFJUP EPFTUBEPDPNSFWJTUB3&%&0656#30"/%3&4"%%:QEG "DFTTP FN OPW 4$*03*--*.BSDFMPSilêncio e Administração Pública. *O3FWJTUB&MFUSÙOJDB+VTUJUJBo"3F WJTUBEP.JOJTUÏSJP1ÞCMJDPEF4ÍP1BVMP4ÍP1BVMP%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXKVTUJUJB DPNCSBSUJHPTYQEG"DFTTPFNOPW RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 265 a 290 A COMPENSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA E O REGIME CONSTITUCIONAL DE PRECATÓRIOS INSTITUÍDO PELA EMENDA CONSTITUCIONAL Nº 62/2009 The Tax Offset and the Court-ordered payments regime under the constitutional framework imposed by the 62º Amendment Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti1 SUMÁRIO 0JOTUJUVUPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍP"DPNQFOTBÎÍPOP%JSFJUP$JWJM"DPNQFOTB ÎÍPFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJB3FHJNFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEPTQSFDBUØSJPT%JTDJQMJOBBUVBM $POTUJUVJÎÍPEF"&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO0"SUEB$' DPNBOPWBSFEBÎÍPEBEBQFMB&$O0BSUJHPEP"%$5DSJBEPQFMB&$ O"DPNQFOTBÎÍPEFDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPDPNEÏCJUPDPOTVCTUBODJBEPFNQSF DBUØSJPOB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO4ÓOUFTFDPODMVTJWB3FGFSÐODJBT RESUMO &TUFBSUJHPUFNQPSPCKFUJWPBOBMJTBSEJTDVUJSFBPmOBMDPODMVJSQFMBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEF EFTFQSPDFEFSËDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTDPNDSÏEJUPTEFDPSSFOUFTEFQSF DBUØSJPTFNGBDFEPOPWPSFHJNFJOTUJUVÓEPQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO FEJUBEBFNEFOPWFNCSPEFËNÓOHVBEBMFJEPFOUFGFEFSBUJWPDPNQFUFOUF QSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBM ABSTRACT 5IF PCKFDUJWF PG UIJT QBQFS JT BOBMZ[F UIF BQQMJDBCJMJUZ PG UIF OFX DPOTUJUVUJPOBM GSBNFXPSL JNQPTFE CZ UIF "NFOENFOU QSFDMVEJOH UIF VTF PG $PVSUPSEFSFE QBZNFOUTUPTPMWFUBYEFCJUTQSFWJPVTMZQSFEJDUPO3VMF–#SB[JMJBO/BUJPOBM5BY $PEF Palavras-chaves: $PNQFOTBÎÍP1SFDBUØSJPT&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO /FDFTTJEBEFEFMFJ"SU$5/ Keyword: UBYPGGTFU–$PVSUPSEFSFEQBZNFOUT–$POTUJUVUJPOBM"NFOENFOU– .BOEBUPSZMBX–3VMF#SB[JMJBO/BUJPOBM5BY$PEF 1. O INSTITUTO DA COMPENSAÇÃO 1.1. A compensação no Direito Civil /PTNPMEFTEPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHP$JWJM#SBTJMFJSP“se duas pessoas forem ao mesmo tempo credor e devedor uma da outra, as duas obrigações extinguem-se, até onde se compensarem”. 5SBUBTFEFNFJPFTQFDJBMEFFYUJOÎÍPEFPCSJHBÎÜFTBUÏPOEFTFFRVJWBMFSFN ²VNBWBSJBÎÍPEFQBHBNFOUP²GPSNBEFQBHBNFOUPJOEJSFUPFOUSFQFTTPBTRVFTÍP 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP.FTUSFFN%JSFJUPEP&TUBEPQFMB1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØ MJDBEF4ÍP1BVMPo16$41&TQFDJBMJTUBFN%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPQFMB&TDPMB4VQFSJPSEB1SPDVSBEPSJB (FSBMEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP 292 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti BPNFTNPUFNQPEFWFEPSBTFDSFEPSBTVNBEBPVUSB3FTPMWFSTFÈBPCSJHBÎÍPBUÏ BDPODPSSÐODJBEPTWBMPSFTEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTEFWJEBT 4ÍPUSÐTBTFTQÏDJFTEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPBENJUJEBTFNOPTTP%JSFJUPBTBCFS B DPNQFOTBÎÍPMFHBMÏBBEPUBEBQFMP$ØEJHP$JWJM#SBTJMFJSP&MBBUVBQPSGPSÎB EFMFJWBMFEJ[FSTFVTFGFJUPTPQFSBNEFQMFOPEJSFJUPJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EFDPOWFOÎÍPFOUSFBTQBSUFTBHJOEPNFTNPRVFVNBEFMBTTFPQPOIB "TTJNOPNPNFOUPFNRVFTFDPOTUJUVÓSFNDSÏEJUPTSFDÓQSPDPTFOUSFEVBT QFTTPBTBDPNQFOTBÎÍPSFBMJ[BTFBVUPNBUJDBNFOUF C DPNQFOTBÎÍPDPOWFODJPOBMPVDPNQFOTBÎÍPWPMVOUÈSJBSFTVMUBEF BDPSEPEFWPOUBEFFOUSFBTQBSUFT5FNBQFDVMJBSJEBEFEFQPEFSFN BTNFTNBTUSBOTJHJSRVBOEPBBVTÐODJBEFBMHVNEPTQSFTTVQPTUPT EBDPNQFOTBÎÍPMFHBMJNQFEJSBFYUJOÎÍPEPTEÏCJUPTQPSFTTBWJBF D DPNQFOTBÎÍP KVEJDJBM EFUFSNJOBEB QPS BUP EFDJTØSJP EP KVJ[ %F QFOEFEFBMFHBÎÍPEBTQBSUFTFTFGPSBMFHBEBQFMPSÏVUFNOBUVSF[B SFDPOWFODJPOBM &OUSFFMBTBNBJTJNQPSUBOUFFBBEPUBEBQFMP$ØEJHP$JWJMQÈUSJPÏBDPN QFOTBÎÍPMFHBM %F DPOGPSNJEBEF DPN P PSEFOBNFOUP KVSÓEJDP CSBTJMFJSP FODPOUSBTF TV CPSEJOBEBBEFUFSNJOBEPTQSFTTVQPTUPTEFBENJTTJCJMJEBEFUBJTBSFDJQSPDJEBEFEBT PCSJHBÎÜFTBMJRVJEF[EBTEÓWJEBTBFYJHJCJMJEBEFBUVBMEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTFBGVOHJCJMJ EBEFEPTEÏCJUPT 1PSSFDJQSPDJEBEFEBTPCSJHBÎÜFTFOUFOEFTFRVFTPNFOUFTFQPEFGBMBSFN DPNQFOTBÎÍPRVBOEPIÈPCSJHBÎÜFTFDSÏEJUPTSFDÓQSPDPTFOUSFBTNFTNBTQBSUFT %J[TFMÓRVJEBBEÓWJEBRVBOEPBPCSJHBÎÍPGPSDFSUBRVBOUPËTVBFYJTUÐODJB FEFUFSNJOBEBRVBOUPBPTFVNPOUBOUF4FHVOEP4JMWJP3PESJHVFT“seria inconcebível ocorrer compensação de pleno direito, automaticamente, sem que houvesse a certeza quanto ao montante de uma das dívidas”.3 3FMBUJWBNFOUFËFYJHJCJMJEBEFBUVBMEBTQSFTUBÎÜFTOÍPQPEFTFSDPNQFOTBEPVN EÏCJUPWFODJEPDPNPVUSPBWFODFS%FGBUPTFPEFWFEPSBJOEBEJTQÜFEFQSB[PQBSBFGFUVBS QBHBNFOUPEFTVBEÓWJEBOÍPQPEFTFSDPNQFMJEPBOUFDJQBEBNFOUFËDPNQFOTBÎÍP 1PSmNOBDPNQFOTBÎÍPMFHBMFYJHFTFRVFBTEÓWJEBTTFKBNEFDPJTBTGVO HÓWFJTFOUSFTJJTUPÏEBNFTNBOBUVSF[B%JOIFJSPDPNQFOTBTFDPNEJOIFJSPQPS FYFNQMP"MFJOÍPBENJUFRVFTFDPNQFOTFEJOIFJSPDPNPVUSPPCKFUPQPJTOJOHVÏN ÏPCSJHBEPBSFDFCFSQSFTUBÎÍPEJWFSTBEPQBDUVBEP 3 %*/*;.BSJB)FMFOBCurso de Direito Civil BrasileiroWPMFE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ/PNFTNP TFOUJEP30%3*(6&44JMWJPDireito Civil: Parte Geral das ObrigaçõesFE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ 30%3*(6&44JMWJPDireito Civil: Parte Geral das ObrigaçõesFE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ ("(-*"/01BCMP4UPM[F1".1-0/"'*-)03PEPMGPNovo Curso de Direito CivilObrigaçõesFE 4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 293 )JQØUFTFTIÈFNRVFÏJOBENJTTÓWFMBDPNQFOTBÎÍPQBSBBFYUJOÎÍPEBTPCSJHB ÎÜFT5BMQPEFPDPSSFSRVFSQPSJNQPTJÎÍPMFHBMUBMRVBMQSFWJTUPOPBSUJHPEP$Ø EJHP$JWJMRVFSQFMBWPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTOPTUFSNPTEPBSUJHPEPNFTNPFTUBUVUP 1.2 A compensação em matéria tributária &NNBUÏSJBmTDBMBDPNQFOTBÎÍPQPTTVJDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEJTUJOUBTEBQSFWJTUB OP$ØEJHP$JWJM &TUÈSFHVMBEBOPBSUJHPJODJTP**EP$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBMDPNP NPEBMJEBEFEFFYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB&YTVSHFRVBOEPPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEB PCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBÏBPNFTNPUFNQPDSFEPSEPFSÈSJP ®WJTUBEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJDPTFTFOEPPUSJCVUPex legeP &TUBEPTØQPEFSFBMJ[BSBDPNQFOTBÎÍPMFHBM&ORVBOUPPTQBSUJDVMBSFTUÐNMJWSFEJTQPTJ ÎÍPEFTFVTCFOTFEJSFJUPTUBMOÍPPDPSSFDPNP&TUBEPBETUSJUPRVFFTUÈBPQSJODÓQJPEB FTUSJUBMFHBMJEBEFTØQPEFOEPBHJSOPTFTUSFJUPTMJNJUFTRVFMIFQFSNJUFBNPMEVSBMFHBM 0$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBMRVFWFJDVMBOPSNBTHFSBJTEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈ SJPFCVTDBGVOEBNFOUPEFWBMJEBEFOPBSUJHP***EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMFTUB CFMFDFFNTFVBSUJHPRVFQBSBBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPIÈOFDFTTJEBEFEF BVUPSJ[BÎÍPQPSMFJFTQFDÓmDBEPTFOUFTQÞCMJDPTEPUBEPTEFDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJB -VDJBOP"NBSPEJTDPSSFOEPTPCSFPJOTUJUVUPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBÏQSFDJTP no direito tributário, não obstante sua inegável utilidade, tem aplicação restrita aos casos em que a lei expressamente a preveja, nos termos do Art. 170 do Código Tributário Nacional.(...)A compensação, quando couber, é modo alternativo de satisfação do débito tributário. O sujeito passivo da obrigação tributária tem, pois, a faculdade legal de extingui-la por compensação, nos termos do que for previsto pela lei. Por outro lado, embora o Código diga que a lei pode atribuir à autoridade administrativa competência para autorizar a compensação, é claro que o legislador pode também, na própria lei, já permitir a compensação, independentemente de qualquer ato da autoridade &TUBCFMFDFNDJUBEPTQSFDFJUPTEP$ØEJHP$JWJMiArt. 373. A diferença de causa nas dívidas não impede a compensação, exceto: I - se provier de esbulho, furto ou roubo; II - se uma se originar de comodato, depósito ou alimentos; III - se uma for de coisa não suscetível de penhora. Art. 375. Não haverá compensação quando as partes, por mútuo acordo, a excluírem, ou no caso de renúncia prévia de uma delas” %JTQÜFFGFUJWBNFOUFDJUBEPEJTQPTJUJWP“Art. 170 – A lei pode nas condições e sob as garantias que estipular, ou cuja estipulação em cada caso atribuir à autoridade administrativa, autorizar a compensação de créditos tributários com créditos líquidos e certos, vencidos ou vincendos, do sujeito passivo contra a Fazenda Pública. Parágrafo único – Sendo vincendo o crédito do sujeito passivo, a lei determinará, para os efeitos deste artigo, a apuração do seu montante, não podendo, porém, cominar redução maior que a correspondente ao juro de 1% (um por cento) ao mês pelo tempo a decorrer entre a data da compensação e a do vencimento.” RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 294 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti administrativa. Mas não pode, quando conferir à autoridade competência para ‘autorizar’ a compensação, outorgar-lhe poderes discricionários. Ensina Pontes de Miranda que, na compensação, não existe BSCJUSJVN por isso, onde couber a compensação, sua alegação produz efeitos JQTPKVSF "DPNQFOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBBTTFNFMIBTFËQSFWJTUBOP$ØEJHP$JWJM.BTOP%JSFJUP 5SJCVUÈSJPUFNBQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFEFTFSBQMJDBEBUBNCÏNFNSFMBÎÍPBDSÏEJUPTWJODFOEPT -PHPFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBBDPNQFOTBÎÍPQPSTFTVCNFUFSBPSFHJNFKV SÓEJDPEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPUFNNBUJ[FTEJGFSFOUFTEBRVFMBPQFSBEBOPUPDBOUFËTPCSJ HBÎÜFTQSJWBEBTTVCNFUJEBTBPSFHJNFKVSÓEJDPEFEJSFJUPQSJWBEP%BÓTFVDBSÈUFS QFDVMJBSOPDBNQPEP%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJP 5BJTPCTFSWBÎÜFTTÍPJNQPSUBOUFTOBNFEJEBFNRVFQBSUFTJHOJmDBUJWBEB EPVUSJOB TVTUFOUB B OPTTP WFS FN GSBODB WJPMBÎÍP BPT QSJODÓQJPT EB JOEJTQPOJCJMJ EBEFEPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJDPTFEBFTUSJUBMFHBMJEBEFKÈNFODJPOBEPTRVFPJOTUJUVUP EBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFUSJCVUPTGPJDPOUFNQMBEPOB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMDPOGFSJOEP JNQMJDJUBNFOUFBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEBSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJBPEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPEF SFBMJ[ÈMBDPNQSFDBUØSJPTOÍPQBHPTQFMP&TUBEP,TFOEPEFTOFDFTTÈSJBBMFJBVUPSJ[B EPSBQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEP$5/ ²FOUSFPVUSPTPQFOTBNFOUPEF-FBOESP1BVMTFOQBSBRVFN OÍPIÈOFOIVNBDMÈVTVMBHFSBMEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 7JBEFSFHSBoFQPSGPSÎBEBOPSNBHFSBMEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPBSU EP$5/ BDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFQFOEFEFMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSB1PEFTFFYUSBJS EJSFUBNFOUFEP5FYUP$POTUJUVDJPOBMJTUPTJNBTVCNJTTÍPEP&TUBEP ËKVSJTEJÎÍPFTVBPCSJHBÎÍPEFFGFUJWBNFOUFDVNQSJSBTDPOEFOBÎÜFT SFTUJUVJOEPWBMPSFTJOEFWJEBNFOUFSFDFCJEPTPRVFTFGB[QFMPTJTUFNB EF QSFDBUØSJP "TTJN OB IJQØUFTF FN RVF B SFTUJUVJÎÍP EF JOEÏCJUP USJCVUÈSJPOÍPÏFGFUJWBFNGBDFEPOÍPQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPTDPNP PDPSSFDPNWÈSJPT&TUBEPTF.VOJDÓQJPT BCSFTFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFQBSB RVFTFKBCVTDBEPEJSFUBNFOUFOP5FYUP$POTUJUVDJPOBMPGVOEBNFOUP QBSB B DPNQFOTBÎÍP EF NPEP B JNQFEJS RVF IBKB VNB SVQUVSB EPT QJMBSFT EP &TUBEP EF %JSFJUP 0T GVOEBNFOUPT TFSÍP KVTUBNFOUF P BDFTTP Ë KVSJTEJÎÍP F P QSJODÓQJP EP &TUBEP EF %JSFJUP &GFUJWBNFOUF OÍPFGFUVBEPPQBHBNFOUPUFNP+VEJDJÈSJPEFFODPOUSBSPVUSPNPEP EFEBSDVNQSJNFOUPËTTVBTEFDJTÜFTTBUJTGB[FOEPPDSFEPS"HBSBOUJB EFBDFTTPËKVSJTEJÎÍPUFNEFTFSFGFUJWBNFTNPDPOUSBP&TUBEP "."30-VDJBOPDireito Tributário Brasileiro, 15ª ed., 4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ in %JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJP$POTUJUVJÎÍPF$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJPËMV[EBEPVUSJOBFEBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBFE 1PSUP"MFHSF-JWSBSJBEP"EWPHBEP&EJUPSB&4."'&Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 295 )VHPEF#SJUP.BDIBEPÏBEFQUPEFTTBDPSSFOUFEFQFOTBNFOUP4FHVOEPPKVSJTUB P EJSFJUP EP DPOUSJCVJOUF Ë DPNQFOTBÎÍP UFN JOFHÈWFM GVOEBNFOUP OB $POTUJUVJÎÍP *TUP RVFS EJ[FS RVF OFOIVNB OPSNB JOGFSJPS QPEF WBMJEBNFOUFOFHBSFTTFEJSFJUPTFKBEJSFUBNFOUFTFKBQPSWJBPCMÓRVB UPSOBOEP JNQSBUJDÈWFM P TFV FYFSDÓDJP "TTJN B RVFTUÍP EF TBCFS TF P EJSFJUP Ë DPNQFOTBÎÍP UFN PV OÍP GVOEBNFOUP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM Ï FN PVUSBT QBMBWSBT B RVFTUÍP EF TBCFS TF WBMFN BT OPSNBT KVSÓEJDBT JOGFSJPSFTRVFEFBMHVNNPEPJOWJBCJMJ[BNBDPNQFOTBÎÍP 0 EJSFJUP EF DPNQFOTBS Ï EFDPSSÐODJB OBUVSBM EB HBSBOUJB EPT EJSFJUPT EF DSÏEJUPRVFDPOTVCTUBODJBNQBSDFMBTEPEJSFJUPEFQSPQSJFEBEFDPNCJOBEB DPNPVUSPTQSFDFJUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT4FSJBBCTVSEPQSFUFOEFSRVFBMHVÏN TFOEPDSFEPSFUBNCÏNEFWFEPSEBNFTNBQFTTPBQVEFTTFFYJHJSEBRVFMBP QBHBNFOUPEFTFVDSÏEJUPTFNRVFFTUJWFTTFUBNCÏNPCSJHBEPBQBHBSPTFV EÏCJUP"DPNQFOTBÎÍPÏOBWFSEBEFVNFGFJUPJOFYPSÈWFMEBTPCSJHBÎÜFT KVSÓEJDBTFEFTTFDPOUFYUPOÍPTFQPEFFYDMVJSB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB 5PEBWJBFNTFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJPSJWBMJ[B&VEJNBS"MWFT'FSSFJSB QBSB RVF P DPOUSJCVJOUF QPTTB QSFUFOEFS B DPNQFOTBÎÍP EP DSÏEJUP USJCVUÈSJP EF RVF Ï EFWFEPS OÍP CBTUB RVF QPTTVB VN DSÏEJUP DPOUSB B'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB²OFDFTTÈSJPUBNCÏNRVFFYJTUBVNBMFJRVFBDPMIBB IJQØUFTFQSFUFOEJEB.BJTBJOEBEFWFPNFTNPPCTFSWBSUPEBTBTFYJHÐODJBT QSFWJTUBTOFTTBNFTNBMFJTPCQFOBEFBCFNEPQSJODÓQJPEBMFHBMJEBEFFEB JOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPOÍPTFSQPTTÓWFMPFODPOUSPEFDPOUBT /ÍP QPEF QSPTQFSBS P BSHVNFOUP EF RVF FYJTUFN QSJODÓQJPT DPOTUJUVDJPOBJT JNQPTJUPSFT EF QFS TJ EB DPNQFOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB DPOGFSJOEP BP DPOUSJCVJOUF VN WFSEBEFJSP EJSFJUP JOEJWJEVBM IBVSJEP EJSFUBNFOUF EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP " QBSUJS EFMF QPEFSTFJB EFDMBSBS B EFTOFDFTTJEBEF EP MFHJTMBEPS JOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM OÍP TPNFOUF QBSB BJOEJTQFOTÈWFMBVUPSJ[BÎÍPDPNPQBSBmYBSBTDPOEJÎÜFTFHBSBOUJBT EBPQFSBÎÍPPRVFDFSUBNFOUFQSFKVEJDBSJBBTFHVSBOÎBKVSÓEJDBFB JOEJTQFOTÈWFMQSPUFÎÍPBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPw ²BJOEBPFOUFOEJNFOUPFTQPTBEPQPS%JWB.BMFSCJ in Curso de Direito TributárioFE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ in 6N&TUVEPTPCSFB$PNQFOTBÎÍP5SJCVUÈSJB%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPF'JOBODFJSP"QMJDBEPDPPSE'FS OBOEP'BDVSZ4DBGG 4ÍP1BVMP2VBSUJFS-BUJOQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 296 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti DPNPOPSNBHFSBMB-FJOOÍPDSJBQPSTJEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWP Ë DPNQFOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB &TUF Ï P GSVUP FYDMVTJWP EB MFJ EB QFTTPB QPMÓUJDBDPNQFUFOUFRVFDPOUFSÈBQSFWJTÍPEBTDPOEJÎÜFTFHBSBOUJBT TPC BT RVBJT BT EÓWJEBT SFDÓQSPDBT TFSÍP DPNQFOTBEBT 4ÍP BTTJN SFRVJTJUPT EB DPNQFOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB B B FYJTUÐODJB EF DSÏEJUP EP 'JTDPC BFYJTUÐODJBEFEÏCJUPEP'JTDPD BUPRVFSEP'JTDPRVFSEP QBSUJDVMBSRVFSFBMJ[FFTTFFODPOUSPEFSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDBTFE MFJEB QFTTPBQPMÓUJDBDPNQFUFOUFRVFBVUPSJ[F "OUFTEFUFDFSNPTDPNFOUÈSJPTBSFTQFJUPEFTUBDFMFVNBBOBMJTFNPTPTJTUF NBEPTQSFDBUØSJPTCFNDPNPBTOPSNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTBFMFBQMJDÈWFJT 2. REGIME CONSTITUCIONAL DOS PRECATÓRIOS &OTJOB'FSOBOEP'BDVSZ4DBGGRVFQSFDBUØSJPÏ“uma ordem de pagar quantia certa decorrente de decisão judicial transitada em julgado contra a Fazenda Pública.”12 4FHVOEP%F1MÈDJEPF4JMWB Ï B DBSUB EF TFOUFOÎB SFNFUJEB QFMP KVJ[ EB DBVTB BP 1SFTJEFOUF EP 5SJCVOBM QBSB RVF FTUF SFRVJTJUF BP 1PEFS 1ÞCMJDP NFEJBOUF QSFWJTÍP OBMFJPSÎBNFOUÈSJBBOVBMPQBHBNFOUPEFRVBOUJBDFSUBQBSBTBUJTGB[FS PCSJHBÎÍP EFDPSSFOUF EF DPOEFOBÎÍP EBT QFTTPBT QPMÓUJDBT TVBT BVUBSRVJBTFGVOEBÎÜFT "JOEBOBTQBMBWSBTEF"OUPOJP'MÈWJPEF0MJWFJSB Ï BUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP EF DPNVOJDBÎÍP QPTTVJOEP NBJT FTQFDJmDBNFOUF B DBSBDUFSÓTUJDB EF BUP EF DPNVOJDBÎÍP JOUFSOB QPS JOUFSNÏEJPEPRVBMP&TUBEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPDPNVOJDBTFDPN&TUBEP 1PEFS &YFDVUJWP EBOEPMIF OPUÓDJB EB DPOEFOBÎÍP B mN EF RVF BP FMBCPSBS PSÎBNFOUPQSPHSBNB QBSB P QSØYJNP FYFSDÓDJP P WBMPS DPSSFTQPOEFOUFUFOIBTJEPJODMVÓEPOBQSFWJTÍPPSÎBNFOUÈSJB in A cláusula pétrea da legalidade tributária e o instituto da compensação, 3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPO 4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ 4$"'''FSOBOEP'BDVSZGrandes Questões Atuais de Direito TributáriooWPMVNF7BMEJSEF0MJWFJSB 3PDIBDPPSE 4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDBQ %&1-«$*%0&4*-7"Vocabulário Jurídico, FE3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTFQ 0-*7&*3""OUPOJP'MÈWJPEF Precatórios: Aspectos Administrativos, Constitucionais, Financeiros e Processuais, FE#FMP)PSJ[POUF'PSVNQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 297 5SBUBTFEFBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPQSBUJDBEPOPÉNCJUPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPQPTUP OÍPIBWFSDBSHBEFDJTØSJB5BMOBUVSF[BGPJJODMVTJWFEFmOJUJWBNFOUFSFDPOIFDJEBQFMP 4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMDPOTPBOUF4ÞNVMB“os atos do presidente do tribunal que disponham sobre o processamento e pagamento de precatório não têm caráter jurisdicional”. ²DSJBÎÍPFYDMVTJWBNFOUFCSBTJMFJSBTFNTJNJMBSFNOFOIVNBPVUSBQBSUFEP NVOEP/PEJSFJUPDPNQBSBEPBNBUÏSJBOÍPÏPCKFUPEFEJTDJQMJOBFNOÓWFMDPOT UJUVDJPOBMFOÍPNFSFDFUSBUBNFOUPEJGFSFODJBEPEBRVFMFSFTFSWBEPQBSBPQBHBNFOUP EBTEÓWJEBTEPTQBSUJDVMBSFT 0SJHJOBSJBNFOUF UBM JOTUJUVUP EJBOUF EB JNQFOIPSBCJMJEBEF F JOBMJFOBCJMJ EBEFEPTCFOTQÞCMJDPTWJTBWBBJOTUSVNFOUBMJ[BSBDPCSBOÎBEFEÏCJUPTEP1PEFS 1ÞCMJDPSFTHVBSEBOEPPTEJSFJUPTEFTFVTDSFEPSFTFBTTFHVSBOEPJHVBMEBEFFOUSFFMFT BPFTUBCFMFDFSBPCTFSWÉODJBEFVNBPSEFNDSPOPMØHJDBOBTVBRVJUBÎÍP %FBDPSEPDPNPTFTDØMJPTEF$FMTP3JCFJSP#BTUPTF*WFT(BOESBEB4JMWB.BSUJOT ÏEFOPUBSTFRVFTFPTCFOTQÞCMJDPTGPTTFNQFOIPSÈWFJTDPNPTÍPPT CFOTEPTQBSUJDVMBSFTOÍPIBWFSJBOFDFTTJEBEFEFQSFDBUØSJP&TUFTØGPJDSJBEP FN WJSUVEF EB JNQFOIPSBCJMJEBEF EFTTFT CFOT " QSPQØTJUP P QSFDBUØSJP UFN TVB PSJHFN OP EJSFJUP QSPDFTTVBM DJWJM NBJT QSFDJTBNFOUF OB QSÈUJDB GPSFOTF"PRVFQBSFDFTVBGPSNBNBJTSVEJNFOUBSOBTDFVEBJNBHJOBÎÍP EFVNKVJ[EJBOUFEFVNQSPCMFNBTVSHJEPOBFYFDVÎÍPEBTFOUFOÎBDPOUSB VNB$ÉNBSB.VOJDJQBMFNRVFVNQBSUJDVMBSQMFJUFBWBPQBHBNFOUPEF DFSUBRVBOUJB"JNQFOIPSBCJMJEBEFEPTCFOTQÞCMJDPTOÍPQPEFSJBJTFOUBSB 'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBEFQBHBSPTFVEÏCJUP0FOHFOIPTPNBHJTUSBEPSFTPMWFVB RVFTUÍPFYQFEJOEPQSFDBUØSJBEFWÐOJBDPNPRVFEFUFSNJOPVBQFOIPSBEP QSØQSJPEJOIFJSPEBUFTPVSBSJBEB$ÉNBSB4VSHJBBTTJNBGPSNBQSJNJUJWB EFSFRVJTJÎÍPRVFTFSJBNBJTUBSEFFODBNQBEBQFMPQSFDBUØSJP 0QSFDBUØSJPBTTJNEFJUBTVBTPSJHFOTOBQSÈUJDBGPSFOTF OBÈSFBQSPDFT TVBMDJWJM0%JSFJUP1SPDFTTVBM$JWJMWFJPMFHBMJ[ÈMPBUSBWÏTEP%FDSFUPOEF BSU QBSUF RVJOUB SFQSFTFOUBOEP OBT QBMBWSBT EF 8MBEJNJS 4PV[B $BSWBMIPTPMVÎÍPËMVUBEFWÈSJPTTÏDVMPTWJTBOEPBEFSSVCBSBJSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFEP &TUBEPQBSBDPNQFMJMPBQBHBSTFVTEÏCJUPTTFNRVFJTTPWJFTTFBEJNJOVJSBTPCF SBOJBFTUBUBMNBTBQFOBTTVCNFUFSP&TUBEPËTSFHSBTEBPSEFNKVSÓEJDB $G%"/5"4'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEBExecução Contra a Fazenda Pública: Regime de Precatório, FE 4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEPQ +645&/'*-)0.BSÎBMEstado Democrático de Direito e Responsabilidade Civil do Estado: a questão dos precatórios#JCMJPUFDB%JHJUBM3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPEB&DPOPNJBo3%1&#FMP)PSJ[POUFBOPOKVM #"4504$FMTP3JCFJSPF."35*/4*WFT(BOESBEB4JMWBComentários à Constituição do Brasil, 4º vol, tomo III,FE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ. $"37"-)0 8MBEJNJS 4PV[B Iniciação ao estudo do precatório 4FQBSBUB EB 3FWJTUB EF *OGPSNBÎÍP -FHJTMBUJWBEP4FOBEP'FEFSBM#SBTÓMJBBOPOPVUEF[Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 298 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti %BMFHJTMBÎÍPQSPDFTTVBMTØGPJBTTVNJSGPSPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTDPNBQSPNVM HBÎÍPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFBSU 8MBEJNJSEF4PV[B$BSWBMIPSFQSPEV[BTSB[ÜFTDJUBEBTQPS$BTUSP/VOFT QFMBTRVBJTUBMNBUÏSJBGPJJOTFSJEBOPQMBOPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM ²VNBNFEJEBNPSBMJ[BEPSBEJTTFFVSFGFSJOEPNFBPBOUFQSPKFUPEP *UBNBSBUZEFPOEFQBTTPVB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEFWJTBOEPDPNCBTFFNBO UFDFEFOUFTDPOIFDJEPTDPJCJSBBEWPDBDJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBRVFTFEFTFOWPMWJB OPBOUJHP$POHSFTTPQBSBPCUFOÎÍPEFDSÏEJUPTEFTUJOBEPTBPDVNQSJNFOUP EFTFOUFOÎBTKVEJDJÈSJBT/ÍPSBSPEFQVUBEPTMFWBSBNPTFVEFTFNCBSBÎPBP QPOUPEFPCTUSVÓSFNPDSÏEJUPTPMJDJUBEPFOUSBOEPOPFYBNFEBTTFOUFOÎBT QSÈUJDBWJDJPTBEFRVFEÈOPUÓDJBP4S$"3-04."9*.*-*"/0OPTFHVJOUF DPNFOUÈSJPA&TUFP$POHSFTTP QSPWPDBEPQPSQSPQPTUBEFVNEPTTFVT NFNCSPTPVQPSNFOTBHFNEP&YFDVUJWPBWPUBSWFSCBQBSBPDVNQSJNFO UPEFTFOUFOÎBFYBNJOBWBPTGVOEBNFOUPTEFTUBFTFMIFOÍPBHSBEBWBN OFHBWBPSÏEJUPTPMJDJUBEP"TTJNTFTPCSFQVOIBVNKVMHBNFOUPQPMÓUJDPBP +VEJDJÈSJPFSBVNQPEFSFYBVTUPSBEPOPFYFSDÓDJPEFTVBTGVOÎÜFT 'JHVSPV UBNCÏN OB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM EF NBT BTTJN DPNP B EF BQFOBTBQMJDBWBTFPSFHJNFEFQSFDBUØSJPTË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB'FEFSBMJOPWBO EPBQFOBTOBQSFWJTÍPEBOFDFTTJEBEFEFJOTFSJSOPPSÎBNFOUPRVBOUJBTVmDJFOUFQBSBB TBUJTGBÎÍPEPTEÏCJUPTEB'B[FOEB/BDJPOBM$PNB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFBSU UBMSFHJNFGPJFTUFOEJEPËT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBT&TUBEVBJTF.VOJDJQBJT&BQBSUJS EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFUBMTJTUFNBGPJBQFSGFJÎPBEPUPSOBOEPPCSJHBUØSJBB JODMVTÍPOPPSÎBNFOUPEBTFOUJEBEFTEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPEFWFSCBOFDFTTÈSJBBPQB HBNFOUPEFTFVTEÏCJUPTDPOTUBOUFTEFQSFDBUØSJPTKVEJDJÈSJPTRVBOEPFTUFTUJWFTTFN TJEPBQSFTFOUBEPTBUÏQSJNFJSPEFKVMIP"SUf "&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO OÍPUSPVYFOFOIVNBNPEJmDBÎÍPEFGVOEPBPSFHJNFEPTQSFDBUØSJPT 4PCBÏHJEFEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFPSFHJNFEFQSFDBUØSJPTTPGSFV QSPGVOEBTNPEJmDBÎÜFTQPSGPSÎBEBOPUØSJBJODBQBDJEBEFEF&TUBEPTFNVOJDÓQJPT EFTBMEBSTVBTEÓWJEBTBEWJOEBTEFEFDJTÜFTKVEJDJBJTUSBOTJUBEBTFNKVMHBEPDPNP WFSFNPTOPUØQJDPTFHVJOUF 3. DISCIPLINA ATUAL. CONSTITUIÇÃO DE 1988 0MFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVJOUFPSJHJOÈSJPQSFWJVPSFHJNFEPTQSFDBUØSJPTOPBSUJHP &NTFVUFYUPPSJHJOBMEJTQVOIB $"37"-)08MBEJNJS4PV[B Iniciação ao estudo do precatórioDPNSFNJTTÍPBPCSBEF$BTUSP/VOFTDJUQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 299 ®FYDFÎÍPEPTDSÏEJUPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJBPTQBHBNFOUPTEFWJEPT QFMB'B[FOEB'FEFSBM&TUBEVBMPV.VOJDJQBMFNWJSUVEFEFTFOUFOÎB KVEJDJÈSJBGBSTFÍPFYDMVTJWBNFOUFOBPSEFNEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEPTQSF DBUØSJPTFËDPOUBEPTDSÏEJUPTSFTQFDUJWPTQSPJCJEBBEFTJHOBÎÍPEFDB TPTPVEFQFTTPBTOBTEPUBÎÜFTPSÎBNFOUÈSJBTFOPTDSÏEJUPTBEJDJPOBJT BCFSUPTQBSBFTUFmN 5PEBWJB EJBOUF EBT EJmDVMEBEFT mOBODFJSBT KÈ FOUÍP FYJTUFOUFT FYDFQDJP OPV UBM TJTUFNÈUJDB QPS FMF QSØQSJP JOUSPEV[JEB F QSFWJV NPSBUØSJB OB MJRVJEBÎÍP EPTEÏCJUPTEBT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBTJOUSPEV[JOEPPBSUJHPOP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT $POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBT 5BM EJTQPTJUJWP FTUBCFMFDFV QBSDFMBNFOUP EPT EÏCJUPT GSVUP EF QSFDBUØSJPT QFOEFOUFTOBEBUBEBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEB$'FNPJUPQSFTUBÎÜFTBOVBJTSFTTBMWBEPT PTDSÏEJUPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUBS /FTUBPQPSUVOJEBEFOBEBQSFWJVBDFSDBEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPEF UBJTEÏCJUPTDPNDSÏEJUPTPQPOÓWFJTBPTFVDSFEPS "TTJNFTUBCFMFDFPDJUBEPQSFDFJUP "SU3FTTBMWBEPTPTDSÏEJUPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUBSPWBMPSEPTQSF DBUØSJPTKVEJDJBJTQFOEFOUFTEFQBHBNFOUPOBEBUBEBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEB $POTUJUVJÎÍPJODMVÓEPPSFNBOFTDFOUFEFKVSPTFDPSSFÎÍPNPOFUÈSJB QPEFSÈ TFS QBHP FN NPFEB DPSSFOUF DPN BUVBMJ[BÎÍP FN QSFTUBÎÜFT BOVBJTJHVBJTFTVDFTTJWBTOPQSB[PNÈYJNPEFPJUPBOPTBQBSUJSEF EFKVMIPEFQPSEFDJTÍPFEJUBEBQFMP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPBUÏDFOUPF PJUFOUBEJBTEBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP "MWPEBBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFO%'QPTUPFYDFQDJPOBS WÈSJPTQSJODÓQJPTOVDMFBSFTEFEV[JEPTOBQBSUFQFSNBOFOUFOPUBEBNFOUFPQSJODÓ QJPEBJTPOPNJBPEPEJSFJUPBERVJSJEPFPEBKVTUBJOEFOJ[BÎÍPFOUSFPVUSPTUBM EJTQPTJUJWP SFTUPV NBOUJEP VNB WF[ RVF P 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM DPOTPMJEPV FOUFOEJNFOUPTFHVOEPPRVBMFNCPSBBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTUSBOTJUØSJBTFQFSNBOFOUFTGPT TFNBOUBHÙOJDBTP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBTDPOUJOIBNFSB FYDFÎÍPBPTQSJODÓQJPTDJUBEPTFYDFÎÍPFTUBDSJBEBQFMPQSØQSJPQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUF PSJHJOÈSJP"TTJNTFOEPOÍPUJOIBFMFKVSJTEJÎÍPQBSBmTDBMJ[BSUBMQPEFSSB[ÍPQFMB RVBMBBÎÍPOÍPGPJDPOIFDJEBQPSJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFKVSÓEJDBEPQFEJEP &NEFTFUFNCSPEFGPJQSPNVMHBEBB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO RVFDSJPVBPJOUSPEV[JSPBSUJHPOP"%$5OPWPTJTUFNBQBSBMFMBNFOUF ËTJTUFNÈUJDBBOUFSJPSRVFQSFWJVFNGBDFEPDSFTDJNFOUPJNPEFSBEPEBTEÓWJEBT EFDJTÍPQVCMJDBEBOP%+FN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 300 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti EFDPSSFOUFT EF QSFDBUØSJPT OPWP QBSDFMBNFOUP BPT QSFDBUØSJPT QFOEFOUFT OB EBUB EBTVBQSPNVMHBÎÍPFBPTRVFEFDPSSFSFNEFBÎÜFTJOJDJBJTBKVJ[BEBTBUÏEFEF [FNCSPEFFNQSFTUBÎÜFTBOVBJTOPQSB[PNÈYJNPEFEF[BOPTQFSNJUJEBB DFTTÍPEPTDSÏEJUPT3FTTBMWPVEFUBMTJTUFNBPTDSÏEJUPTEFmOJEPTDPNPEFQFRVFOP WBMPSPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJBPTEFRVFUSBUBPBSUJHPEP"%$5FPTRVFKÈ UJWFSFNPTSFTQFDUJWPTSFDVSTPTMJCFSBEPTPVEFQPTJUBEPTFNKVÓ[P 1SFWJVBJOEBFNTFVQBSÈHSBGPPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEPQBHBNFOUPEFUSJ CVUPTEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBDBTPTVBTQSFTUBÎÜFTBOVBJTOÍPUJWFTTFNTJEPMJRVJEBEBT BUÏPmOBMEPFYFSDÓDJPBRVFTFSFGFSJTTFN /PTUFSNPTEPEJTQPTJUJWPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMUSBOTJUØSJPGPJBCFSUBBPTDSFEPSFT EBT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBTBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFNDBTPEFOÍPQBHBNFOUPEBTQBSDFMBT BOVBJTVUJMJ[BSFNTFVTDSÏEJUPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPEFEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTSFTTBMWBEPT EFTUFTJTUFNBPTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTPTEÏCJUPTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSFPTQSFDBUØSJPT QBSDFMBEPTQFMPBSUEP"%$5 &TUFÏPTJHOJmDBEPEPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPBDJNBNFODJPOBEP0DSFEPSEP &TUBEPUJUVMBSEFVNQSFDBUØSJPFNDBTPEFBUSBTPPVOÍPQBHBNFOUPEPWBMPS EB QBSDFMB QPS QBSUF EB FOUJEBEF EFWFEPSB OP QSB[P mYBEP OP EJTQPTJUJWP mDB MJCFSBEPEPQBHBNFOUPEFTFVEÏCJUPDPNPFOUFGFEFSBUJWPEFRVFÏDSFEPSBUÏ PMJNJUFEFTFVDSÏEJUP 1PSGPSÎBEFUBMEJTQPTJUJWPQBTTPVTFBJOUFSQSFUBSUBMQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPDPNP TJOÙOJNPEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFSFBMJ[BSBDPNQFOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB i"SU3FTTBMWBEPTPTDSÏEJUPTEFmOJEPTFNMFJDPNPEFQFRVFOPWBMPSPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJBPT EFRVFUSBUBPBSUEFTUF"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBTFTVBTDPNQMFNFOUBÎÜFTF PTRVFKÈUJWFSFNPTSFTQFDUJWPTSFDVSTPTMJCFSBEPTPVEFQPTJUBEPTFNKVÓ[PPTQSFDBUØSJPTQFOEFOUFTOB EBUBEFQSPNVMHBÎÍPEFTUB&NFOEBFPTRVFEFDPSSBNEFBÎÜFTJOJDJBJTBKVJ[BEBTBUÏEFEF[FNCSPEF TFSÍPMJRVJEBEPTQFMPTFVWBMPSSFBMFNNPFEBDPSSFOUFBDSFTDJEPEFKVSPTMFHBJTFNQSFTUBÎÜFT BOVBJTJHVBJTFTVDFTTJWBTOPQSB[PNÈYJNPEFEF[BOPTQFSNJUJEBBDFTTÍPEPTDSÏEJUPT f"TQSFTUBÎÜFTBOVBJTBRVFTFSFGFSFPcaputEFTUFBSUJHPUFSÍPTFOÍPMJRVJEBEBTBUÏPmOBMEP FYFSDÓDJPBRVFTFSFGFSFNQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEPQBHBNFOUPEFUSJCVUPTEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBw "OUFT EF UBM &$ O OÍP IBWJB QSFWJTÍP RVF QFSNJUJTTF GPTTFN DPNQFOTBEPT WBMPSFT DPO TVCTUBODJBEPTFNQSFDBUØSJPTKVEJDJBJTQSØQSJPTPVEFUFSDFJSPTDPNEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPT045'IBWJB mSNBEPFOUFOEJNFOUPTFHVOEPPRVBMUBMQSPDFEJNFOUPJNQMJDBWBBGSPOUBËPSEFNEFQSFDFEÐODJB EPTQSFDBUØSJPTBUFPSEPEJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPcaputEB$''PJPRVFSFTUPVDPOTJHOBEPOB"%* OQSPQPTUBFNGBDFEB-FJOEP&TUBEPEP&TQÓSJUP4BOUPSFM.JO.BSDP"VSÏMJP K&TUBRVFTUÍPOÍPÏBRVJPCKFUPEFBOÈMJTFNBTBOPTTPWFSOÍPTFFODPOUSBTVQFSBEB )ÈBJOEBRVFTUJPOBNFOUPTTPCSFRVBMPNPNFOUPFNRVFTFQPEFBQSFTFOUBSPQSFDBUØSJPWFODJEPF OÍPQBHPQBSBBDPNQFOTBÎÍPTFBRVBMRVFSUFNQPFNWJSUVEFEBNPSBEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBPVTF OPFYBUPNPNFOUPFNRVFQPEFSJBTFSQBHPPCFEFDFOEPTFËPSEFNQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEB$'" EPVUSJOBEPNJOBOUFFOUFOEFRVFBQØTBFEJÎÍPEB&$OFNFTNPDPNPBEWFOUPEB&$O EFTDBCFBFYJHÐODJBEFJNQPSQBHBNFOUPOBPSEFNDSPOPMØHJDBEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPT QBSB mOT EF DPNQFOTBÎÍP ² FOUSF PVUSPT P QFOTBNFOUP EF %"/5"4 'SBODJTDP 8JMEP -BSDFSEB Execução contra a Fazenda Pública: Regime de PrecatóriosFE4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEPQ&N TFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJP0-*7&*3""OUPOJP'MÈWJPEFPrecatórios: Aspectos Administrativos, Constitucionais, Financeiros e Processuais,FE#FMP)PSJ[POUF'ØSVNQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 301 5BMFNFOEBGPJPCKFUPEFWÈSJBTBÎÜFTKVEJDJBJT"MWPEFEVBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBT EFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFBKVJ[BEBTQFMP$POTFMIP'FEFSBMEB0SEFNEPT"EWPHBEPT EP#SBTJMFQFMB$POGFEFSBÎÍP/BDJPOBMEB*OEÞTUSJBFNFNKVMHBNFOUP DPOKVOUPEBTNFEJEBTDBVUFMBSFTQSPQPTUBTOBT"%*TFPCUFWFBQØTEF[ BOPTEFUSBNJUBÎÍPFNWPUPQBSBEJHNÈUJDPEFEFTFNQBUFEP.JOJTUSP$FMTPEF.FMMP BTVTQFOTÍPQFMP1MFOÈSJPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMEBFYQSFTTÍPDPOTUBOUFEP DBQVUEPDJUBEPBSUJHPEP"%$5oios precatórios pendentes na data da promulgação desta emenda”BUÏKVMHBNFOUPmOBMEBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBT &OUFOEFVP.JOJTUSP$FMTPEF.FMMPOBNFTNBEJSFÎÍPEP.JOJTUSP/ÏSJEB 4JMWFJSBSFMBUPSPSJHJOÈSJPEBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBTRVFKÈIBWJBJODMVTJWFQSPGFSJEPWPUP RVFEFGFSJBBNFEJEBMJNJOBSFNRVFP$POHSFTTP/BDJPOBMBPJNQPS P QBSDFMBNFOUP BPT QSFDBUØSJPT QFOEFOUFT EF MJRVJEBÎÍP OB EBUB EF QVCMJDBÎÍP EB FNFOEB UFSJB JODPSSJEP FN EJWFSTBT WJPMBÎÜFT Ë $POTUJUVJÎÍP " QSPDSBTUJOBÎÍP OP UFNQPEPQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTKVEJDJÈSJPTQFOEFOUFTOBEBUBEBQSPNVMHBÎÍP EB&$ODPNPTSFTQFDUJWPTWBMPSFTQBSDFMBEPTFNBUÏBOPTDVMNJOBSJB QPSQSJWBSEFFmDÈDJBJNFEJBUBBEFDJTÍPBNQBSBEBQFMBBVUPSJEBEFEBDPJTBKVMHBEB PRVFWVMOFSBSJBPQPTUVMBEPEBTFQBSBÎÍPEFQPEFSFTCFNDPNPBGFUBSJBVNWBMPS FTTFODJBMBP&TUBEP%FNPDSÈUJDPEF%JSFJUPBTFHVSBOÎBKVSÓEJDB .BTBJOEBIÈNVJUBEJTDVTTÍPHJSBOEPFNUPSOPEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFDPO GFSJSQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPBPTQSFDBUØSJPTWFODJEPT5FNTJEPPCKFUPEFRVFTUJPOBNFOUPB OFDFTTJEBEFEFMFJWFJDVMBEPSBEFBVUPSJ[BÎÍPQBSBBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBUFPSEPEJTQPTUP OPBSUJHPEP$5/PVTFBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBHPSBFSJHJEBBTUBUVTDPOTUJUVDJPOBM TFHVOEPBMHVOTÏBVUPBQMJDÈWFM 5BNCÏNSFMBUJWBNFOUFBPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTWFO DJEPT5ÐNQSFWBMFDJEPEFDJTÜFTFNTFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJPEJBOUFEBMJUFSBMJEBEFEPUFYUP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM ²RVFDPNBSFJUFSBEBJOBEJNQMÐODJBEBT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBTFDPNPPcaput EPBSUJHPJOUSPEV[JEPQFMB&$OQFSNJUJVBDFTTÍPEFDSÏEJUPTPTDSF EPSFTPSJHJOBJTUJUVMBSFTEFEJSFJUPTEFDPSSFOUFTEFQSFDBUØSJPTWFODJEPTJODMVTJWFF QSJODJQBMNFOUFEFQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTFYDFQDJPOBEPTEPQBSDFMBNFOUPBMJBVUP SJ[BEPQBTTBSBNBBMJFOBSTFVTEJSFJUPTDSFEJUØSJPTDPNEFTDPOUP0TBERVJSFOUFT EFWFEPSFTEFUSJCVUPTQBTTBSBNBBERVJSJMPTQBSBmOTEFDPNQFOTBÎÍP "TVTQFOTÍPEBNFODJPOBEBFYQSFTTÍPQPSDFSUPJSÈJOnVFODJBSPSFTVMUBEPEPKVMHBNFOUPEBT"%*T QSPQPTUBTDPOUSBB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOQPJTBNFTNBQBEFDFEPTNFTNPTWÓDJPTEFJO DPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFOBNFEJEBFNRVFBMDBOÎPVTJUVBÎÜFTQFOEFOUFTDPOTPBOUFPBSUJHPEP"%$5 QPSFMBJOUSPEV[JEPDPNPWFSFNPT $PNPPTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTOÍPTFTVKFJUBNBPQBSDFMBNFOUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOPTUFSNPTEPBSUf EP"%$5JOBQMJDÈWFMBFMFTPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEPQBHBNFOUPEFUSJCVUPTJODMVTJWFOPUPDBOUFËDPNQFOTBÎÍP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 302 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti &BT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBTJOWPDBOEPPBSUJHPEP$5/QBTTBSBNBJOEF GFSJSUBMQMFJUPEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFTFVTEÏCJUPTDPNDSÏEJUPTBERVJSJEPTBUSBWÏTEF DFTTÍP²PDBTPEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP 0GBUPÏRVFPT5SJCVOBJTUÐNSFDPOIFDJEPBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPVTPEFQSF DBUØSJPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPTEFUSJCVUPTTPCPGVOEBNFOUPEFOUSFPVUSPTEBOFDFTTJ EBEFEFMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSBQBSBBBMNFKBEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBQFTBSEFFYJTUJSFNEFDJTÜFT FNTFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJPCFNDPNPEFSFTQFJUÈWFJTPQJOJÜFTOBEPVUSJOBQVHOBOEPQFMB BQMJDBÎÍPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBQBSUJSEPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM %FRVBMRVFSGPSNBQFOEFEFKVMHBNFOUPP3&.(OPRVBMKÈIPV WFQSPOVODJBNFOUPSFDPOIFDFOEPBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMFNRVFTFEJTDV UFKVTUBNFOUFFTUBTRVFTUÜFTBTBCFSBFYUFOTÍPEPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEFQBHBNFOUP EFUSJCVUPEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBBPTQSFDBUØSJPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJBFBBVUPBQMJ DBCJMJEBEFEPfEP"SUEP"%$5 "OBMJTFNPTBQBSUJSEFBHPSBBOPWBTJTUFNÈUJDBEFQSFDBUØSJPTJNQMBOUBEB QFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO 4. A EMENDA CONSTITUCIONAL Nº 62/09 'PJ FEJUBEB FN QBTTBEP SFDFOUF B KÈ NFODJPOBEB &NFOEB $POTUJUVDJPOBM ORVFDSJPVUFSDFJSBTJTUFNÈUJDBEFQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPT%FVOPWBSF EBÎÍPBPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMFBDSFTDFOUPVPBSUJHPBP"UPEBT %JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBT. 5SPVYFJNQPSUBOUFTJOPWBÎÜFTRVFFYQPSFNPTFNCSFWFTMJOIBT 4.1. O Art. 100 da CF, com a nova redação dada pela EC nº 62/09 1SJNFJSPOPBSUJHPSFBmSNBTFBSFHSBHFSBMEFQBHBNFOUPQFMBPSEFN DSPOPMØHJDBEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPT %FmOFPRVFFOUFOEFQPSEÏCJUPEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUBSDPNPTFOEPBRVFMFEF DPSSFOUFEFTBMÈSJPTWFODJNFOUPTQSPWFOUPTQFOTÜFTFTVBTDPNQMFNFOUBÎÜFTCFOFGÓDJPT QSFWJEFODJÈSJPTFJOEFOJ[BÎÜFTQPSNPSUFPVQPSJOWBMJEF[GVOEBEBTFNSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF DJWJMFNWJSUVEFEFTFOUFOÎBKVEJDJBMUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEP%JTQÜFUBNCÏNRVFUBJTEÏCJUPT TFSÍPQBHPTDPNQSFGFSÐODJBTPCSFUPEPTPTEFNBJTDPNFYDFÎÍPEPTSFGFSJEPTOPf26. %FTEFBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFGPSBNDPODFEJEBTUSÐTNPSBUØSJBTËT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBT BEP"SUEP"%$5BEP"SUEP"%$5FBHPSBBEPBSUEP"%$5RVFTFSÈFYQMJDJUBEPFNTFHVJEB #BTJDBNFOUFPTQSFDBUØSJPTOÍPBMJNFOUBSFTTÍPUPEPTPTEFNBJTRVFOÍPTFFODPOUSBNEFmOJEPTDPNP BMJNFOUBSFTOPEJTQPTJUJWP4ÍPGPSNBEPTQPSDPOEFOBÎÜFTSFTVMUBOUFTEFEFTBQSPQSJBÎÜFTSFTDJTÜFT DPOUSBUVBJTFJOEFOJ[BÎÜFTEFDVOIPQBUSJNPOJBM RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 303 &TUFfDSJBVNBQSFGFSÐODJBTPCSFBQSFGFSÐODJBSFMBUJWBBPTEÏCJUPTEFOB UVSF[BBMJNFOUBSOBNFEJEBFNRVFQSFTUJHJBBTQFTTPBTDPNBOPTPVNBJTFPT QPSUBEPSFTEFEPFOÎBHSBWFBTRVBJTUFSÍPQSJPSJEBEFTPCSFUPEPTPTPVUSPTEÏCJUPT NBTBUÏPWBMPSFRVJWBMFOUFBPUSJQMPmYBEPFNMFJDPNPPCSJHBÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS 0fEFJYBEFGPSBEBTJTUFNÈUJDBEPTQSFDBUØSJPTPQBHBNFOUPEBTPCSJHB ÎÜFTEFmOJEBTFNMFJDPNPEFQFRVFOPWBMPS. 0 f FTUBCFMFDF RVF QBSB PT mOT EP f QPEFSÍP TFS mYBEPT QPS MFJT QSØQSJBTWBMPSFTEJTUJOUPTËTFOUJEBEFTEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPNBTFTUBCFMFDFVVNWBMPS NÓOJNPRVFÏJHVBMBPWBMPSEPNBJPSCFOFGÓDJPEPSFHJNFEFQSFWJEÐODJBTPDJBM &TUBCFMFDFBPCSJHBUØSJBJODMVTÍPOPPSÎBNFOUPEBTFOUJEBEFTEFEJSFJUPQÞ CMJDPEBWFSCBOFDFTTÈSJBBPQBHBNFOUPEFTFVTEÏCJUPTFPfQSFWÐRVFBTEPUBÎÜFT PSÎBNFOUÈSJBTFPTDSÏEJUPTBCFSUPTTFSÍPDPOTJHOBEPTBP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPDBCFOEP BP 1SFTJEFOUF EP 5SJCVOBM RVF QSPGFSJV B EFDJTÍP FYFRàFOEB EFUFSNJOBS TFV QBHB NFOUP JOUFHSBM 1SFWÐ UBNCÏN P TFRVFTUSP EB RVBOUJB SFTQFDUJWB B SFRVFSJNFOUP EPDSFEPSTFIPVWFSQSFUFSJNFOUPEPTFVEJSFJUPEFQSFGFSÐODJBPVFNDBTPEFOÍP BMPDBÎÍPPSÎBNFOUÈSJBEPWBMPSOFDFTTÈSJPËTBUJTGBÎÍPEPTFVEÏCJUP &TUBCFMFDFBJOEBDSJNFEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFBP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMDPN QFUFOUFRVFSFUBSEBSPVUFOUBSGSVTUSBSBMJRVJEBÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPT &NTÓOUFTFBTTJNTFQSPDFTTBBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJP)BWFOEPTFOUFOÎB USBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPRVFDPOEFOFB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBBQBHBSEFUFSNJOBEBRVBOUJB JOJDJBTF P QSPDFTTP EF FYFDVÎÍP RVF EJGFSF EB FYFDVÎÍP SFMBUJWB BPT QBSUJDVMBSFT &YUSBÓEBT DØQJBT EBT QFÎBT QSPDFTTVBJT QFSUJOFOUFT Ë TVB JOTUSVÎÍP P NBHJTUSBEP JODVNCJEPEBFYFDVÎÍPEBTFOUFOÎBPmDJB BP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMBPRVBMFTUÈ WJODVMBEPTPMJDJUBOEPQSPWJEÐODJBTOPTFOUJEPOÍPEBSFRVJTJÎÍPEBJNQPSUÉODJBOF DFTTÈSJBËTBUJTGBÎÍPEPEÏCJUPNBTTJNEFTVBQSFWJTÍPPSÎBNFOUÈSJB01SFTJEFOUF EP 5SJCVOBM FOUÍP EF QPTTF EB TPMJDJUBÎÍP EP KVJ[ FODBNJOIB Ë 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB DPNQFUFOUFVNPGÓDJPEJUPSFRVJTJUØSJPQBSBRVFTFGBÎBBJODMVTÍPOPPSÎBNFOUPEB /PÉNCJUPEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPBPSEFNDSPOPMØHJDBDSJBEBFNGVOÎÍPEPTQPSUBEPSFTEFEPFOÎBHSBWF FTUÈTFOEPPSHBOJ[BEBEFBDPSEPDPNPBSUJHPJODJTP9*7EB-FJOOPTUFSNPTEB0SEFNEF 4FSWJÎPOFYQFEJEBQBSBPSJFOUBSFQBESPOJ[BSPTTFSWJÎPTJOUFSOPTEP%&13&OPRVFBGFUBBP DVNQSJNFOUPEBTSFHSBTFQSJODÓQJPTUSB[JEPTDPNB&$OEP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBCBOEFJSBOUF /P&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPOPTUFSNPTEB-FJOFTUFWBMPSÏEF6GFTQT0QBHB NFOUPÏGFJUPBUSBWÏTEF3FRVJTJÎÍP%JSFUBEF1BHBNFOUPEF0CSJHBÎÍPEF1FRVFOP7BMPSDVKPQBHB NFOUPPDPSSFFNBUÏOPWFOUB EJBTEBEBUBEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍPËFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSB "&$OFYDMVJVEPSFHJNFEFFYQFEJÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPTPTQBHBNFOUPTRVFBMFJEFmOJTTFDPNPEF QFRVFOPWBMPS1PTUFSJPSNFOUFB&$OBDSFTDFOUPVP"SUBP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT 5SBOTJUØSJBTBRVBMJOEJDPVUBJTNPOUBOUFTBUÏRVFTFEFTTFBQVCMJDBÎÍPEBTMFJTEPTSFTQFDUJWPTFOUFTEB 'FEFSBÎÍPEFmOJEPSBTEBTPCSJHBÎÜFTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSTBMÈSJPTNÓOJNPTQBSBBT'B[FOEBTEPT&TUBEPT F%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFTBMÈSJPTNÓOJNPTQBSBB'B[FOEBEPT.VOJDÓQJPT 0fEPBSUJHPEP"%$5 JOUSPEV[JEPQFMB&$OSFWPHPVPTPCSFEJUPBSUJHPSFHVMBOEPFMFQSØQSJPBNBUÏSJBFTUBCFMFDFOEP RVFTFBMFJSFGFSJEBOPfEPBSUJHPOÍPFTUJWFTTFQVCMJDBEBFNBUÏDFOUPFPJUFOUBEJBTEBQVCMJDBÎÍP EFTUBFNFOEBPTWBMPSFTQBSBPTFOUFTGFEFSBUJWPTPNJTTPTOFTUBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPTFSJBNEFTBMÈSJPT NÓOJNPTQBSB&TUBEPTF%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFTBMÈSJPTNÓOJNPTQBSBPTNVOJDÓQJPT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 304 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti JNQPSUÉODJBEFTUJOBEBBTBMEBSPEÏCJUP"PCSJHBÎÍPEFQBHBSQSPWÏNEFTFOUFOÎB DPOEFOBUØSJBUSBOTJUBEBFNKVMHBEPDPOUSBB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB 1PJT CFN PT QBHBNFOUPT TÍP GFJUPT BUFOEFOEPTF Ë PSEFN DSPOPMØHJDB EB BQSFTFOUBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTFËDPOUBEPTDSÏEJUPTSFTQFDUJWPT&TUBPSEFNOBWFS EBEFTÍPEVBTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTFOÍPBMJNFOUBSFT ÏBEBTEBUBTFNRVFPT PGÓDJPTSFRVJTJUØSJPTEÍPFOUSBEBOBSFQBSUJÎÍPGB[FOEÈSJBDPNQFUFOUFFQBSBRVFIBKB PQBHBNFOUPBUÏPmOBMEPFYFSDÓDJPTFHVJOUFÏPCSJHBUØSJPRVFPTQSFDBUØSJPTTFKBN BQSFTFOUBEPTBUÏEFKVMIP %FTUBGPSNBIÈUFNQPTVmDJFOUFQBSBPDSÏEJUPSFRVJTJUBEPTFSJODMVÓEPOPQSPKFUP EFMFJPSÎBNFOUÈSJBBOVBMDVKBBQSFTFOUBÎÍPBP1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWPEFWFSÈPDPSSFSBUÏRVBUSP NFTFTBOUFTEPFODFSSBNFOUPEPFYFSDÓDJPmOBODFJSPPVTFKBBUÏEFKVMIPBUFPSEP EJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPfJODJTP***EP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBT 0TQBHBNFOUPTTÍPSFBMJ[BEPTËDPOUBEPTDSÏEJUPTSFTQFDUJWPTQPSRVFOÍP QPEFIBWFSOBMFJPSÎBNFOUÈSJBQSFWJTÍPEFEFTQFTBTTFNBDPSSFTQPOEFOUFSFDFJUB $BCFBP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMRVFQSPGFSJVBEFDJTÍPFYFRVFOEBEFUFSNJOBSP QBHBNFOUPJOUFHSBM0TQBHBNFOUPTTFSÍPBTTJNQPSFMFMJCFSBEPT1PSJTTPÏRVFÏQSF WJTUBBTVBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFRVBOEPUBMEJTQPTJUJWPOÍPÏQPSFMFDVNQSJEPDPSSFUBNFOUF 7FEBBJOEBPEJTQPTJUJWPBFYQFEJÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPTDPNQMFNFOUBSFTPV TVQMFNFOUBSFTEFWBMPSQBHPCFNDPNPPGSBDJPOBNFOUPSFQBSUJÎÍPPVRVFCSBEP WBMPSEBFYFDVÎÍP &TUBWFEBÎÍPSFTJEFOPGBUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTDPOTVCTUBODJBSFNWBMPSFTMÓRVJ EPTFDFSUPT4FVDVNQSJNFOUPTJHOJmDBQBHBNFOUPEPEÏCJUP%BÓSFTVMUBBPNFOPT FNUFTFOÍPQPEFSIBWFSSFTUPBTFSDPNQMFNFOUBEPPVTVQMFNFOUBEP*TUPFNDBTP EFQBHBNFOUPEPWBMPSJOUFHSBM4FFYJTUJSPVUSPEÏCJUPFNGBDFEPNFTNPDSFEPSUFSÈ RVFTFSPCKFUPEFPVUSPQSFDBUØSJPTVKFJUPBPTNFTNPTUSÉNJUFTQFMPTRVBJTTFTVCNF UFPOPWPQBHBNFOUP"UÏQPSRVFTFIPVWFTTFDPNQMFNFOUBÎÍPPVTVQMFNFOUBÎÍP JNQPSUBSJBFNRVFCSBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMEBPSEFNDSPOPMØHJDBEFQBHBNFOUP %B NFTNB GPSNB P GSBDJPOBNFOUP 4F UBM GPTTF QPTTÓWFM UPEPT PT DSÏEJUPT FYJTUFOUFTDPOUSBBT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBTBPNFOPTFNQBSUFTFFORVBESBSJBNOPDPO DFJUPEFPCSJHBÎÍPEFQFRVFOPWBMPSJODJEJOEPPEJTQPTUPOPfEPBSUJHP "ÞOJDBFYDFÎÍPQSFWJTUBFTUÈDPOTVCTUBODJBEBOPfEFTUFEJTQPTJUJWPRVF QFSNJUFPGSBDJPOBNFOUPSFMBUJWBNFOUFBEÏCJUPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJBEFQFTTPB NBJPSEFBOPTEFJEBEFPVQPSUBEPSBEFEPFOÎBHSBWF $SJBBmHVSBEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBVUPNÈUJDBQSÏWJBFDPNQVMTØSJBBGBWPSEBT 'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBT/FTUFTFOUJEPTFPDSFEPSEFQSFDBUØSJPTUJWFSEÏCJUPMÓRVJEPF DFSUP JOTDSJUP PV OÍP FN EÓWJEB BUJWB FN GBWPS EB 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB EFWFEPSB P 1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMUFOEPEJTUPDJÐODJBEFWFSÈBCBUFSEFTFVWBMPSBJNQPSUÉODJB DPSSFTQPOEFOUFBPEÏCJUPEPDSFEPSËUÓUVMPEFDPNQFOTBÎÍP1BSBUBOUPP5SJCVOBM OÍPNBJTiTFHVOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPEFQØTJUPwDPNPEJTQVOIBPBOUJHPfEPBSU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 305 SFTQFDUJWP TPMJDJUBSÈ Ë 'B[FOEB 1ÞCMJDB EFWFEPSB JOGPSNBÎÍP TPCSF PT EÏCJUPT RVF QSFFODIBNUBJTDPOEJÎÜFTQBSBRVFPGBÎBFNEJBTTPCQFOBEFQFSEBEPEJSFJUP BPBCBUJNFOUP 5SÐTPCTFSWBÎÜFTNFSFDFNSFGFSÐODJBFNSFMBÎÍPBPEJTQPTJUJWP"QSJNFJSBÏ RVFPEJTQPTJUJWPÏBVUPBQMJDÈWFMQPSFYQSFTTBEJTQPTJÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM"TFHVOEB ÏRVFQFSNJUFBDPNQFOTBÎÍPOÍPTØDPNSFMBÎÍPBEÏCJUPTWFODJEPTNBTBQBSDFMBT WJODFOEBTUBNCÏNSFTTBMWBEBTBRVFMBTDVKBFYFDVÎÍPFTUFKBTVTQFOTBFNWJSUVEFEF DPOUFTUBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBPVKVEJDJBM&BUFSDFJSBÏRVFUBNCÏNQPSFYQSFTTBEJT QPTJÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMÏRVFBDPNQFOTBÎÍPTPNFOUFQPEFSÈPDPSSFSFNSFMBÎÍPBP DSFEPSPSJHJOBMEB'B[FOEBFYDMVJOEPTFEBÓPDSFEPSDFTTJPOÈSJP &NRVFQFTFTFSBENJUJEBBDFTTÍPEFDSÏEJUPTOPTUFSNPTEPTffFEP BSUJHPTFPDSFEPSPSJHJOBMDFEFSTFVDSÏEJUPBUFSDFJSPOÍPIBWFSÈBCBUJNFOUPEF UBMWBMPSBUÓUVMPEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPBJOEBRVFFTUFUFSDFJSPPDFTTJPOÈSJPUFOIBEÓWJEB MÓRVJEBFDFSUBFNGBDFEB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDB "DFTTÍPÏQFSNJUJEBJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBDPODPSEÉODJBEB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJ DBEFWFEPSBDFTTÍPFTUBRVFQSPEV[JSÈFGFJUPTBQFOBTBQØTDPNVOJDBÎÍPBPUSJCVOBM EFPSJHFNFËFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSB "JOEB P EJTQPTJUJWP QPTTJCJMJUB BP DSFEPS EF BDPSEP DPN MFJ FEJUBEB QFMB FOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBBFOUSFHBEFDSÏEJUPTFNQSFDBUØSJPTQBSBBDPNQSBEFJNØWFJT QÞCMJDPTEPSFTQFDUJWPFOUF &TUBCFMFDFRVFBBUVBMJ[BÎÍPEFWBMPSFTBQØTBFYQFEJÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTBUÏ PFGFUJWPQBHBNFOUPTFSÈGFJUBQFMPÓOEJDFPmDJBMEFSFNVOFSBÎÍPCÈTJDBEBDBEFSOFUB EFQPVQBOÎBFQBSBmOTEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFNPSBJODJEFNKVSPTTJNQMFTOPNFTNP QFSDFOUVBM EF KVSPT JODJEFOUFT TPCSF B DBEFSOFUB EF QPVQBOÎB FYDMVÓEPT PT KVSPT DPNQFOTBUØSJPT 5BMTJTUFNÈUJDBGPJBMUFSBEBFNSFMBÎÍPBPSFHJNFBOUFSJPSRVFEJTQVOIBRVFPT EÏCJUPTEFWFSJBNTFSQBHPTBUÏPmOBMEPFYFSDÓDJPNPNFOUPFNRVFUFSJBTFVTWBMPSFT BUVBMJ[BEPTNPOFUBSJBNFOUFTFNJOEJDBSDPOUVEPQBSÉNFUSPTQBSBUBMBUVBMJ[BÎÍP 1PSmNBUSJCVJB6OJÍPBQSFSSPHBUJWBEFOBGPSNBEBMFJBTTVNJSFSFmOBODJBS EJSFUBNFOUFEÏCJUPTPSJVOEPTEFQSFDBUØSJPTEPT&TUBEPT%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFNVOJDÓQJPT 4.2. O artigo 97 do ADCT, criado pela EC nº 62/09 3FMBUJWBNFOUFËQBSUFUSBOTJUØSJBPBSUJHPBDSFTDFOUPVPBSUJHPBP"UP EBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBT &OUFOEFNPTRVFPTEJSFJUPTEPDFEFOUFQBTTBNBPDFTTJPOÈSJPNBTOÍPÏUSBOTNJUJEPPEJSFJUPEFFN SFMBÎÍPË'B[FOEBBCBUFSEPDSÏEJUPDFEJEPFWFOUVBMEÓWJEBEPDFTTJPOÈSJPBUÓUVMPEFDPNQFOTBÎÍP DPNPTFSÈPQPSUVOBNFOUFBCPSEBEP "SU“Até que seja editada a lei complementar de que trata o § 15 do art. 100 da Constituição Federal, os Estados, o RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 306 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti 0EJTQPTJUJWPJOTUJUVJSFHJNFFTQFDJBMQBSBQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPTQBSBPT &TUBEPT%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMF.VOJDÓQJPTFNNPSBOBRVJUBÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTWFODJEPT OBEBUBEBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEBFNFOEBFOPTTFHVJOUFTBUÏFEJÎÍPEFMFJDPNQMFNFOUBS RVFUSBUBSÈEPNFTNPBTTVOUP &TUBMFJDPNQMFNFOUBSFTUÈQSFWJTUBOPfEPBSUJHP-PHPUBMUSBOTJUP SJFEBEFJSÈWJHPSBSBUÏBQSPNVMHBÎÍPEFTUBMFJ33 1BTTÓWFMEFDSÓUJDBUBMEJTQPTJUJWPUSBOTJUØSJPQPJTQBSBEPYBMNFOUFEFDFSUB GPSNBQFSQFUVBVNBTJUVBÎÍP0VQPSRVFWBJQFSEVSBSBUÏBFEJÎÍPEBMFJDPNQMF NFOUBSRVFUBMWF[OVODBWFOIBBTFSDSJBEBPVQPSRVFWBJQFSEVSBSQPSQFMPNFOPT BOPTOPTUFSNPTEPfEPBSUJHP 1PJTCFN5BMSFHJNFFTQFDJBMOPSNBUJ[BEVBTQPTTJCJMJEBEFTEFQBHBNFOUP QBSBBTFOUJEBEFTDPNFTUPRVFEFQSFDBUØSJPTBTVBFTDPMIB "QSJNFJSBPQÎÍPÏPEFQØTJUPNFOTBMFNDPOUBFTQFDJBMBCFSUBQBSBUBMmN EFBDPSEPDPNQFSDFOUVBJTmYBEPTFOUSFFEBSFDFJUBDPSSFOUFMÓRVJEBTFPFT UPRVFEFQSFDBUØSJPTGPSTVQFSJPSBEBSFDFJUBDPSSFOUFMÓRVJEB7JHPSBSÈBUÏRVFP WBMPSEPTQSFDBUØSJPTEFJYFEFTFSTVQFSJPSBPWBMPSEPTSFDVSTPTWJODVMBEPTRVBOEP QBTTBSÈBJODJEJSPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM 4FSWJNPOPTEPFYFNQMPEF'MBWJP$EF5PMFEP+SQBSBFMVDJEBSFTUBPQÎÍP #BTFBOEPTF FN FYFNQMP PUJNJTUB DFSUP .VOJDÓQJP RVF B UÓUVMP EF QSFDBUØSJPTEFWF3NJMIÍPFEJTQÜFEFVNBSFDFJUBDPSSFOUFMÓRVJEBEF 3NJMIÜFTUBM$PNVOBQSFDJTBSÈEFQPTJUBSOBDPOUBFTQFDJBMUPEP NÐTBRVBOUJBEF3PVTFKB3OPBOPUPEP EB3$- /FTTBUSJMIBFDBTPOÍPDPNQBSFÎBNOPWPTQSFDBUØSJPT 33 Distrito Federal e os Municípios que, na data de publicação desta Emenda Constitucional, estejam em mora na quitação de precatórios vencidos, relativos à sua Administração direta e indireta, inclusive os emitidos durante o período de vigência do regime especial instituído por este artigo, farão esses pagamentos de acordo com as normas a seguir estabelecidas, sendo inaplicável o disposto no art. 100 desta Constituição Federal, exceto em seus §§ 2º, 3º, 9º, 10,11,12,13 e 14, e, sem prejuízo dos acordos de juízos conciliatórios já formalizados na data de promulgação desta Emenda Constitucional.” "SUf “Sem prejuízo do disposto neste artigo, lei complementar a esta Constituição Federal poderá estabelecer regime especial para pagamento de crédito de precatórios de Estados, Distrito Federal e Municípios, dispondo sobre vinculações à receita corrente líquida e forma e prazo de liquidação.” "SUf“O regime especial de pagamento de precatório previsto no inciso I do § 1º vigorará enquanto o valor dos precatórios devidos for superior ao valor dos recursos vinculados, nos termos do § 2º, ambos deste artigo, ou pelo prazo fixo de até quinze anos, no caso da opção prevista no inciso II, do § 1º.” &TUBÏUBNCÏNBPQJOJÍPEF4*-7"+PTÏ"GPOTPEB in Comentário Contextual à ConstituiçãoFE .BMIFJSPT4ÍP1BVMPQ &TUBGPJBPQÎÍPGFJUBQFMP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPDPOGPSNFP%FDSFUPEF0T SFTUBOUFTOPTUFSNPTEPf**EPBSUEP"%$5EFTUJOPVBPQBHBNFOUPBWJTUBEFQSFDBUØSJPTOÍP RVJUBEPTFNPSEFNÞOJDBFDSFTDFOUFEFWBMPSQPSQSFDBUØSJPQBSBPFYFSDÓDJPEFDPOTPBOUFP %FDSFUPOFQBSBPFYFSDÓDJPEFDPOGPSNFP%FDSFUPOEF1BSB PFYFSDÓDJPEFP%FDSFUPEFEFTUJOPVBPQBHBNFOUPQPSNFJPEFMFJMÍP FBPQBHBNFOUPFNPSEFNÞOJDBFDSFTDFOUFEPWBMPSQPSQSFDBUØSJP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 307 BSFTQFDUJWB'B[FOEBFNDJODPBOPTUFSÈMJRVJEBEPTVBEÓWJEBKVEJDJBM OJTTPDPOTJEFSBOEPRVFBBUVBMJ[BÎÍPNPOFUÈSJBEPTQSFDBUØSJPTTFEÐ FNOÓWFMTFNFMIBOUFËFWPMVÎÍPBOVBMEBSFDFJUBDPSSFOUFMÓRVJEB "HPSBTPCVNBØUJDBQFTTJNJTUBQPEFTFUFSPVUSP.VOJDÓQJPRVFEFWF 3NJMIÜFTEFQSFDBUØSJPTFBSSFDBEB3NJMIÜFT&NUBMIJQØUFTF UBMMPDBMJEBEFQSFDJTBSÈEFQPTJUBSOBDPOUBFTQFDJBM3QPS BOP 3 QPS NÐT MFWBOEP OBEB NFOPT RVF BOPT QBSB TBMEBSTFVQBTTJWPKVEJDJBMFBJOEBBTTJNDBTPOÍPTPCSFWJFTTFNPVUSBT SFRVJTJÎÜFTKVEJDJBJTOPQFSÓPEPEFBKVTUF "TTJNFTTBPSBDPNFOUBEBQSJNFJSBBMUFSOBUJWBIÈEFTFSFYFSDJEBQPS &TUBEPT F .VOJDÓQJPT RVF NVJUP EFWBN FN GBDF EP UBNBOIP EF TVB SFDFJUBDPSSFOUFMÓRVJEB "TFHVOEBPQÎÍPÏPQBSDFMBNFOUPEPFTUPRVFEFQSFDBUØSJPTFNBUÏBOPT DPSSJHJEPFSFNVOFSBEPQFMPÓOEJDFEBTDBEFSOFUBTEFQPVQBOÎBQBHBOEPBWPT EFTFVTBMEPBOVBMNFOUF"PmOBMEFTUFMPOHPQSB[PBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBPQUBOUF QPSFTUFSFHJNFWPMUBSÈBPCTFSWBSPNFTNPBSUJHPEB$BSUB.BHOB ²PNFTNP'MBWJP$EF5PMFEP+SRVFNFYFNQMJmDB %JUPEFPVUSBNBOFJSBPFOUFGFEFSBEPOPBOPQBHBVNRVJO[FBWPT EPTUÓUVMPKVEJDJBJTWFODJEPTOPBOPMJRVJEBVNDBUPS[FBWPT EPTBMEPBUVBMDPSSJHJEPQFMPÓOEJDFEBDBEFSOFUBEFQPVQBOÎB OPBOPMJRVJEBVNUSF[FTBWPT EPBUVBMJ[BEPWBMPSFNBCFSUP FBTTJNQPSEJBOUF 0SB FN DPNFOUP FTTB TFHVOEB IJQØUFTF IÈ EF TFS FYFSDJEB QFMPT HPWFSOPTDVKPTPCSFPFTUPRVFEFWFEPSSFWFMFQFSDFOUVBMJOGFSJPS BPEBTPCSFEJUBUBCFMBBQPTUBOBBMUFSOBUJWBBOUFSJPSBEBWJODVMBÎÍPË SFDFJUBMÓRVJEB &N VN DBTP MJNÓUSPGF EB PQÎÍP EPT BOPT UFSTFJB UBMWF[ VN .VOJDÓQJPEFUFOUPSEFVNÞOJDPQSFDBUØSJPEPRVBMKÈTFUFOIBNQBHP PJUP QBSDFMBTEPGSBDJPOBNFOUPEFDFOBMEB&NFOEBOTFOEP RVFFNUBMDFOÈSJPBTEVBTQBSDFMBTSFTUBOUFTQPEFSJBNTFSRVJUBEBTFN NBJTBOPTFNØCWJPQSFKVÓ[PQBSBPDSFEPS 50-&%0+3'MBWJP$EFO regime especial dos precatórios à luz da Emenda Constitucional nº 62.#J CMJPUFDB%JHJUBM'ØSVNEF$POUSBUBÎÍPF(FTUÍP1ÞCMJDB'$(1#FMP)PSJ[POUFBOPOKBO %JTQPOÓWFMIUUQXXXFEJUPSBGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE$POUFVEP4IPXBTQY JE$POUFVEP ÁMUJ NPBDFTTPFNKBOFJSP 50-&%0+3'MBWJP$EFPQDJU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 308 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti %FmOFSFDFJUBDPSSFOUFMÓRVJEBDPNPTFOEPBTPNBEBTSFDFJUBTUSJCVUÈSJBT QBUSJNPOJBJTJOEVTUSJBJTBHSPQFDVÈSJBTEFDPOUSJCVJÎÜFTFEFTFSWJÎPTUSBOTGFSÐO DJBTDPSSFOUFTFPVUSBTSFDFJUBTDPSSFOUFTJODMVJOEPBDPNQFOTBÎÍPmOBODFJSBQFMB FYQMPSBÎÍPEFSFDVSTPTNJOFSBJTOPQFSÓPEPFOUSFPNÐTEFSFGFSÐODJBFPTNFTFT BOUFSJPSFTFYDMVÓEBTBTEVQMJDJEBEFTFBTUSBOTGFSÐODJBTPCSJHBUØSJBTEPfEPBSUJHP EP"%$5 "TDPOUBTTFSÍPBENJOJTUSBEBTQFMPT5SJCVOBJTSFTQFDUJWPTFOÍPQPEFSÍPSF UPSOBSQBSB&TUBEPT%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMF.VOJDÓQJPT $JORVFOUB QPS DFOUP EPT SFDVSTPT EFQPTJUBEPT FN BNCBT BT DPOUBT TFSÍP VUJMJ[BEPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPTEFQSFDBUØSJPTFNPSEFNDSPOPMØHJDBEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍP SFTQFJUBEBTBTQSFGFSÐODJBTEPTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTHFSBJTfEP"SU$' QBSBPTSFRVJTJUØSJPTEPNFTNPBOPFBTEPTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTFTQFDJBJTf EP"SU$' QBSBPTSFRVJTJUØSJPTEFUPEPTPTBOPT 0CTFSWFTF RVF PT QSFDBUØSJPT BMJNFOUBSFT RVF QFMB &$ O FSBN FYDMVÓEPT EB NPSBUØSJB EF BOPT BHPSB OÍP NBJT P TÍP " ÞOJDB SFTTBMWB Ï RVF EFWFSÍPTFSQBHPTQSJPSJUBSJBNFOUFFSFMBUJWBNFOUFBPTNBJPSFTEFBOPTOBEBUB EBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPFPTQPSUBEPSFTEFEPFOÎBTHSBWFTPTNFTNPTSFDFCFSÍP JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFTUBPSEFNPWBMPSDPSSFTQPOEFOUFBPUSJQMPEPWBMPSmYBEP QBSB BT PCSJHBÎÜFT EF QFRVFOP WBMPS RVBOEP FOUÍP JOHSFTTBSÍP DPNP PT EFNBJT QFMPTBMEPSFNBOFTDFOUFDPNQSFGFSÐODJBTOPFOUBOUPOBPSEFNEFBQSFTFOUBÎÍP EPTQSFDBUØSJPTOPTUFSNPTEPfEPBSUJHPPSBBOBMJTBEP 2VBOEPOÍPTFQVEFSFTUBCFMFDFSBQSFDFEÐODJBDSPOPMØHJDBFOUSFEPJTQSF DBUØSJPTTFSÈQBHPQSJNFJSPPEFNFOPSWBMPS 0TDJORVFOUBQPSDFOUPSFTUBOUFTEFQFOEFOEPEBPQÎÍPRVFm[FSFN&TUBEPT %JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFNVOJDÓQJPTPCFEFDFSÈËTFHVJOUFGPSNBRVFQPEFSÈTFSBQMJDBEB JTPMBEBPVTJNVMUBOFBNFOUF0VTFSÍPEFTUJOBEPTBPQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTQPS NFJPEFMFJMÍPFPVTFSÍPEFTUJOBEPTBQBHBNFOUPËWJTUBEFQSFDBUØSJPTOÍPRVJUBEPT DPNPTQSJNFJSPTPVOÍPRVJUBEPTQFMPMFJMÍPSFBMJ[BEP%FWFSÍPTFSQBHPTFN PSEFNÞOJDBFDSFTDFOUFEFWBMPSQPSQSFDBUØSJPFPVEFTUJOBEPTBQBHBNFOUPQPS BDPSEPEJSFUPDPNPTDSFEPSFTOBGPSNBFTUBCFMFDJEBFNMFJEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSB 0fEP"SUEP"%$5EJTDJQMJOBPMFJMÍP$POGPSNFPTJODJTPT*B*9P MFJMÍPTFEBSÈQPSNFJPEFTJTUFNBFMFUSÙOJDPFTFSÈBENJOJTUSBEPQPSFOUJEBEFBVUPSJ [BEBQFMB$PNJTTÍPEF7BMPSFT.PCJMJÈSJPTPVQFMP#BODP$FOUSBMEP#SBTJM &TUBSÍPIBCJMJUBEPTBQBSUJDJQBSEPMFJMÍPPTDSFEPSFTQFMPWBMPSJOUFJSPEP QSFDBUØSJPPVQBSDFMBQPSFMFTJOEJDBEBEFTEFRVFOÍPIBKBQFOEÐODJBEFSFDVSTPPV JNQVHOBÎÍPEFRVBMRVFSOBUVSF[B0TDSFEPSFTRVFTFFODPOUSBSFNOFTUBDPOEJÎÍP DPOTJEFSBSBNTFIBCJMJUBEPTBVUPNBUJDBNFOUF "TTJNWFSJmDBTFRVFOÍPIÈOFDFTTJEBEFEFIBCJMJUBÎÍPFTQFDÓmDBTFBQUPBTFS MFJMPBEPPDSÏEJUPBOÍPTFSRVFPDSFEPSQSFUFOEBGB[FSJOEJDBÎÍPFTQFDÓmDBEFQBSDFMB )BWFSÈPGFSUBQÞCMJDBFPMFJMÍPTFSFQFUJSÈUBOUBTWF[FTRVBOUPOFDFTTÈSJPBUÏ RVFTFFTHPUFPWBMPSEJTQPOÓWFMBDPNQFUJÎÍPTFWFSJmDBQPSNFJPEBNPEBMJEBEFEF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 309 EFTÈHJPBTTPDJBEBBPNBJPSWPMVNFPGFSUBEPDPNNBJPSEFTÈHJPPVOÍP PCTFSWBEP BmOBMPNBJPSQFSDFOUVBMEFEFTÈHJPTFOEPMÓDJUPJNQPSWBMPSNÈYJNPQPSDSFEPS PVQPSPVUSPDSJUÏSJPUVEPDPOGPSNFPFEJUBMEFDBEBMFJMÍP "RVJUBÎÍPUPEBWJBTFNQSFEFQFOEFSÈEFIPNPMPHBÎÍPQFMP5SJCVOBMRVF FYQFEJVPQSFDBUØSJP %FUPEPNPEPTFSÈQFSNJUJEBQPSJOJDJBUJWBEP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPBDPNQFO TBÎÍPDPNEÏCJUPTMÓRVJEPTFDFSUPTJOTDSJUPTPVOÍPFNEÓWJEBBUJWBDPOTUJUVÓEPT DPOUSBPEFWFEPSPSJHJOÈSJPBUÏBEBUBEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPTBMWPPTEFFYJHJ CJMJEBEFTVTQFOTBPVRVFKÈUFOIBNTJEPPCKFUPEFBCBUJNFOUPBOUFSJPS 0fFTUBCFMFDFRVFOPDBTPEFOÍPMJCFSBÎÍPUFNQFTUJWBEPTSFDVSTPTIB WFSÈTFRVFTUSPEBRVBOUJBEFWJEBOBTDPOUBTEBTFOUJEBEFTEFWFEPSBTPSEFOBEPQFMP 1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMMPDBM "&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMODSJBEVBTNPEBMJEBEFTEFTFRVFTUSP "QSJNFJSBQSFWJTUBOPfEPBSUJHPQBSBPDBTPEPQSFUFSJNFOUPEP EJSFJUPEFQSFDFEÐODJBEPDSFEPSDPOTPBOUFKÈNFODJPOBEP "TFHVOEBNPEBMJEBEFÏBQSFWJTUBOBIJQØUFTFPSBFNFTUVEP5SBUBTFEFTBO ÎÍPQFMBOÍPMJCFSBÎÍPUFNQFTUJWBNFOTBMEPTSFDVSTPTEFTUJOBEPTËTDPOUBTFTQFDJBJT BDJNBOPUJDJBEBTfEP"SU "TTJN, PTFRVFTUSP TFSFBMJ[BSÈTFOÍPMJCFSBEPTUFN QFTUJWBNFOUFPTSFDVSTPTBUSFMBEPTËNPSBUØSJBBOVBMPVNFOTBMOPTUFSNPT EPJODJTP**EPfFfEP"SU 5BNCÏNTFSFBMJ[BSÈTFOÍPMJCFSBEPTPT QSFWJTUPTOPfEP"SUQBSBQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTQPSPSEFNDSPOPMØHJDB "MUFSOBUJWBNFOUFQPSPSEFNEP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMSFRVFSJEPDPOTUJ UVJSTFÈFNGBWPSEPTDSFEPSFTEFQSFDBUØSJPTEJSFJUPMÓRVJEPFDFSUPBVUPBQMJDÈWFM FJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPËDPNQFOTBÎÍPBVUPNÈUJDBDPNEÏCJUPTMÓ RVJEPTMBOÎBEPTQFMBTFOUJEBEFTEFWFEPSBTDPOUSBBRVFMFTFIBWFOEPTBMEPFNGBWPS EPDSFEPSPWBMPSUFSÈBVUPNBUJDBNFOUFQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEPQBHBNFOUPEFUSJCVUPT EF&TUBEPT%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMFNVOJDÓQJPTEFWFEPSFTBUÏPOEFTFDPNQFOTBSFN 0DIFGFEP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBmDBUBNCÏNTVKFJUPBTBOÎÜFT QSFWJTUBTOBMFHJTMBÎÍPTPCSFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFmTDBMFJNQSPCJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWB5BN CÏNBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBFORVBOUPQFSEVSBSBPNJTTÍPOÍPQPEFSÈDPOUSBJSFNQSÏTUJ NPFYUFSOPPVJOUFSOPmDBSÈJNQFEJEBEFSFDFCFSUSBOTGFSÐODJBTWPMVOUÈSJBT5BNCÏN B6OJÍPSFUFSÈPTSFQBTTFTSFMBUJWPTBP'VOEPEF1BSUJDJQBÎÍPEPT&TUBEPTFEP%JTUSJUP 'FEFSBMFBP'VOEPEF1BSUJDJQBÎÍPEPT.VOJDÓQJPTFPTEFQPTJUBSÈOBTDPOUBTFTQFDJBJT .VJUP FNCPSB OÍP QSFWJTUP OB FNFOEB EFWF BVUPSJ[BS P TFRVFTUSP B OÍP MJCFSBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTBPWFODFEPSEPMFJMÍP 0TQSFDBUØSJPTQBSDFMBEPTOBGPSNBEPBSUJHPPVEPBSUJHPBNCPTEP"%$5 FBJOEBQFOEFOUFTEFQBHBNFOUPJOHSFTTBSÍPOPSFHJNFFTQFDJBMDPNPWBMPSBUVBMJ[BEPEBT QBSDFMBTOÍPQBHBTPVTBMEPTEFBDPSEPKVEJDJBJTFFYUSBKVEJDJBJTSFMBUJWBTBDBEBQSFDBUØSJP 1PSmNPEJTQPTJUJWPDPOWBMJEBBTDFTTÜFTEFQSFDBUØSJPTFBTDPNQFOTBÎÜFT DPNUSJCVUPTFGFUVBEPTBOUFTEFTVBQSPNVMHBÎÍP &NSFTVNPTÍPFTUBTBTTVBTEJTQPTJÎÜFT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 310 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti 5. A COMPENSAÇÃO DE CRÉDITO TRIBUTÁRIO COM DÉBITO CONSUBSTANCIADO EM PRECATÓRIO NA EMENDA CONSTITUCIONAL Nº 62/09 &NRVFQFTFNBTPQJOJÜFTFNTFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJPPGBUPÏRVFTPCBÏHJEF EB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOKÈFTUBWBFNWJBEFTFTFEJNFOUBSBKVSJTQSV EÐODJBBUJOFOUFËFYJHÐODJBEFMFJQBSBSFHVMBSBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPTDPN EÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPT &NGPJKVMHBEBBBQFMBÎÍPDÓWFMO $ÉNBSBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB3FMBUPS/PHVFJSB%JFGFOUIBMFSDVKB FNFOUBPSBSFQSPEV[JNPT ."/%"%0%&4&(63"/±"53*#65«3*0 $0.1&/4"±°0 1SFDBUØSJPT EF OBUVSF[B BMJNFOUÓDJB*NQPTTJCJMJEBEF EF DPNQFOTBÎÍP DPN DSÏEJUP USJCVUÈSJP /ÍP QSFFODIJNFOUP EBT FYJHÐODJBT JOUSPEV[JEBT QFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO /FDFTTJEBEFBEFNBJTEFMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSBEB DPNQFOTBÎÍP1SFDFEFOUFT EP$PMFOEP4VQFSJPS 5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎB &YFHFTF EP BSUJHP f EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM BSU EP "UP EBT %JTQPTJÎÜFT $POTUJUVDJPOBJT 5SBOTJUØSJBT F EP BSUJHP EP $ØEJHP 5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBM3FDVSTPEFTQSPWJEP 0FOUFOEJNFOUPFTQPTBEPQFMP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBEF4ÍP1BVMPOÍPEJGFSF EPQPTJDJPOBNFOUPFYUFSJPSJ[BEPQFMP$PMFOEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBRVFm YPVQPSTVBTEVBT5VSNBTPBEFRVBEPUSBUBNFOUPGSBORVFBEPËNBUÏSJB "1SJNFJSB5VSNBQPSPDBTJÍPEPKVMHBNFOUPEP3FDVSTPFN.BOEBEPEF 4FHVSBOÎB O 30 %+ FYQSFTTPV QPS VOBOJNJEBEF QPS TFV 3FMBUPSP.JOJTUSP'3"/$*4$0'"-$°0BOFDFTTJEBEFEBFEJÎÍPEFMFJQFMPFOUF GFEFSBEPQBSBBSFHVMBÎÍPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFDSÏEJUPTDPNEÏCJUPTGB[FOEÈSJPTDPO TVCTUBODJBEPTFNQSFDBUØSJPT"FNFOUBÏFMVDJEBUJWBOFTUFTFOUJEP 53*#65«3*0."/%"%0%&4&(63"/±"$0.1&/4"±°0 &/53& 13&$"5»3*04 "%26*3*%04 %& 5&3$&*304 & %²#*504 53*#65«3*04%"$0/53*#6*/5&"35*(0f%0"50%"4 %*4104*±¿&4$0/45*56$*0/"*453"/4*5»3*"4&4'&3"%&10 .VJUBTPVUSBTEFDJTÜFTQPEFSJBNTFSNFODJPOBEBTOPNFTNPTFOUJEPFOUSFBTRVBJTMFNCSBNPTBHSB WP EF JOTUSVNFOUP O $ÉNBSB EF %JSFJUP 1ÞCMJDP 3FM 1BVMP %JNBT .BTDBSFUUJKVMHBEBFNBQFMBÎÍPDÓWFM$ÉNBSBEF%JSFJUP 1ÞCMJDP3FM$BTUJMIP#BSCPTBKVMHBEBFNBQFMBÎÍPDÓWFMO $ÉNBSBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDP3FM%FT.PBDJS1FSFTKVMHBEBFNBQFMBÎÍPDÓWFMO $ÉNBSBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDP3FM'SBOLMJO/PHVFJSBKVMHBEBFNFUD RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 311 %&33&4&37"%"®"%.*/*453"±°01Á#-*$""-&("±°0%&*-& ("-*%"%&"'"45"%"%*-"±°0130#"5»3*"*.1044*#*-*%"%& *o.BOEBEPEF4FHVSBOÎBJNQFUSBEPCVTDBOEPBDPNQFOTBÎÍPFOUSF QSFDBUØSJPKVEJDJBMBERVJSJEPEFUFSDFJSPFEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTEBFNQSF TBJNQFUSBOUF **o0BSUJHPEP$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBMBPUSBUBSEPJOTUJUVUP EBDPNQFOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBJNQÜFPFOUFOEJNFOUPEFRVFTPNFOUFB MFJQPEFBUSJCVJSËBVUPSJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWBPQPEFSEFEFGFSJSPVOÍP B SFGFSJEB DPNQFOTBÎÍP FOUSF DSÏEJUPT MÓRVJEPT F DFSUPT DPN EÏCJUPT WFODJEPTPVWJODFOEPT ***o /FTTF RVBESP WFSJmDBTF B BCTPMVUB JNQPTTJCJMJEBEF EF P 1PEFS +VEJDJÈSJP JOWBEJS B FTGFSB SFTFSWBEB Ë "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB F QPS DPOTFHVJOUFEFUFSNJOBSBDPNQFOTBÎÍPQSFUFOEJEBQFMB3FDPSSFOUF *7o"P1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPDPNQFUFUÍPTPNFOUFPCTFSWBSPTDBTPTFN RVFQMBTNBEBBJMFHBMJEBEFEPBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPGSFOUFËPSEFNKVSÓ EJDBWJHFOUFFOÍPPDPOUSÈSJPDPNPEFTFKBB3FDPSSFOUFBPQMFJUFBSP EFGFSJNFOUPEFVNBPQFSBÎÍPRVFBQSØQSJBMFJDPOEJDJPOPVBPBMWFESJP EB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDB1SFDFEFOUFT3.4O303FM.JO -"63*5"7";%+EFF3.4O303FM.JO.*- 50/-6*;1&3&*3"%+EF 7**o3FDVSTPFNNBOEBEPEFTFHVSBOÎBJNQSPWJEP /FTUBMJOIBBNFTNB5VSNBEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBQSPDMBNPV BJNQFSJPTBOFDFTTJEBEFEFMFJQBSBSFHVMBSBDPNQFOTBÎÍPOPTNPMEFTBTTJOBMBEPT DPNPBUFTUBPWPUPQSPGFSJEPQFMPJMVTUSF3FMBUPS.JOJTUSP+04²%&-("%0OPBDØS EÍPQSPGFSJEPOP3FDVSTP&TQFDJBMO34%+RVFBQØTGB[FS SFNJTTÍPBPFOUFOEJNFOUPQSPGFSJEPQFMP.JOJTUSP'SBODJTDP'BMDÍPOP3.4 BDJNBDJUBEPBTTJNTFQSPOVODJPV -PHPOÍPFTUÈBVUPSJ[BEBFNMFJOFNÏDPNQBUÓWFMDPNPSFHJNF QSØQSJPQSFWJTUPOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFDSÏEJUPTDPOTUBOUFT EF QSFDBUØSJPT DPN EÏCJUPT USJCVUÈSJPT WFODJEPT "QMJDBS QVSB F TJNQMFTNFOUF P SFHJNF EF DPNQFOTBÎÍP QSFWJTUB OP EJSFJUP QSJWBEP QBSBBTSFMBÎÜFTEFEJSFJUPUSJCVUÈSJPBCSJSJBQFSJHPTBWJBQBSBGSBVEBS PNPEPEFQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTQSFWJTUPTOB$POTUJUVJÎÍPDPN EFTWJSUVBNFOUPEPTWBMPSFTKVSÓEJDPTRVFDPNFMFTFCVTDPVQSFTFSWBS *TTPmDBNBJTFWJEFOUFFNDBTPTEFDFTTÍPEFDSÏEJUPFNRVFPQSFDBUØSJP JNQVMTJPOBEPQFMBGBDJMJEBEFEFDJSDVMBÎÍPEFTVBUJUVMBSJEBEFKVSÓEJDB HBOIBVNQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPTFNFMIBOUFBPEBNPFEBFmDÈDJBFTTBRVFB $POTUJUVJÎÍPSFTFSWPVBDBTPTFYDFQDJPOBJT"%$5BSUf RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 312 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti .BJT SFDFOUFNFOUF OP KVMHBNFOUP EP 3FDVSTP &TQFDJBM O 13 %+FB.JOJTUSB&-*"/"$"-.0/FNSFGPSÎPËUFTFBRVJEFGFOEJEB BDSFTDFOUPVSFTQFJUÈWFMFOUFOEJNFOUPËNBUÏSJB " DPNQFOTBÎÍP Ï JOTUJUVUP EF %JSFJUP RVF WJTB FYUJOHVJS PCSJHBÎÜFT SFDÓQSPDBT0TDSÏEJUPTEFWFNTFSMÓRVJEPTFDFSUPT0SFHJNFKVSÓEJDP EB DPNQFOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB UFN TVB GPOUF OPSNBUJWB OB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBMFOPBSUEP$5/RVFEJ[DPNQFUJSËMFJEPFOUFGFEFSBEP PSFHSBNFOUPEPJOTUJUVUPEFOUSPEFTVBTIPTUFT "DPNQFOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBEFQSFDBUØSJPKVEJDJBMNFTNPRVBOEPGVOEBEB OPBSUfEP"%$5OÍPQSFTDJOEFEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPQFMPFOUF QPMÓUJDP B RVFN DPNQFUJSÈ EJTQPS TPCSF B FmDÈDJB EB DPNQFOTBÎÍP FGFUVBEBQFMPDPOUSJCVJOUFOPÉNCJUPEPTUSJCVUPTTVKFJUPTËSFWJTÍPEP BDFSUBNFOUPQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP /PÉNCJUPGFEFSBMBDPNQFOTBÎÍPFYUJOHVFPDSÏEJUPTPCDPOEJÎÍPEBVMUFSJPS IPNPMPHBÎÍPQFMBBVUPSJEBEFMBOÎBEPSBDGBSUfEB-FJO QPSÏN P NFTNP OÍP PDPSSF OFDFTTBSJBNFOUF OP ÉNCJUP EPT &TUBEPT F .VOJDÓQJPTRVFEJBOUFEBOBUVSF[BTVQMFUJWBFHFSBMEBOPSNBEPBSUEP $5/QPEFNEJTQPSDPNPKVMHBSFNQPMJUJDBNFOUFDPOWFOJFOUF &UBMFSBEFSJHPS0BSUJHPEP$5/DPOEJDJPOBBDPNQFOTBÎÍPËFYJTUÐODJB EFMFJ4FB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBTØQPEFBHJSOPTMJNJUFTRVFMIFBVUPSJ[BBMFJBPDPO USÈSJPEPTQBSUJDVMBSFTRVFQPEFNMJWSFNFOUFBHJSEFTEFRVFOÍPIBKBMFJRVFMIFTSFTUSJO KBFTUFDBNQPEFBUVBÎÍPTØQPEFQSPDFEFSËFYUJOÎÍPEFVNBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBBUSB WÏTEPJOTUJUVUPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFTEFRVFQPTTVBQFSNJTTJWPMFHBMQBSBUBMEFTJEFSBUP /ÍPPCTUBOUFPBDJNBBMFHBEPDPOGPSNFKÈUJWFNPTPQPSUVOJEBEFEFNFO DJPOBSMJOIBTBDJNBQFOEFEFKVMHBNFOUPP3FDVSTP&YUSBPSEJOÈSJP.(BP RVBMP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMQPSNBJPSJBQFMB3FMBUPSB.JOJTUSB$ÈSNFO-ÞDJB SFDPOIFDFVDPOGPSNFQVCMJDBÎÍPOP%JÈSJPEF+VTUJÎBEBUBEBEFBFYJT UÐODJBEFSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMEBRVFTUÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMOPTTFHVJOUFTUFSNPT 03FDPSSFOUFQMFJUFJBPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFQSFUFOTPEJSFJUPMÓ RVJEPFDFSUPËDPNQFOTBÎÍPFOUSFQSFDBUØSJPTBERVJSJEPTEFUFSDFJSPTF 7ÈSJBTPVUSBTEFDJTÜFTQPEFSJBNTFSDJUBEBTOPNFTNPTFOUJEP&OUSFPVUSBTEFTUBDBNPT3.43 3FM .JO.JMUPO-VJ[1FSFJSB1SJNFJSB5VSNB%+30.4303FM.JO-BVSJUB7B[4FHVOEB5VS NBK3FTQ343FM.JO'SBODJTDP'BMDÍP1SJNFJSB5VSNBK3FTQ 343FM.JO&MJBOB$BMNPO4FHVOEB5VSNB%+F"H3HOP3.4O133FM.JO-VJ['VY 1SJNFJSB5VSNB%+FP3FTQO343FM.JO.BVSP$BNQCFMM.BSRVFT4FHVOEB5VSNB %+FP"H3HOP3.4O133FM.JO)VNCFSUP.BSUJOT4FHVOEB5VSNB%+F FP"H3HOP3FTQO343FM.JO)VNCFSUP.BSUJOT4FHVOEB5VSNB%+F"H3HOP "HSBWPFN3FTQ343FM.JO#FOFEJUP(POÎBMWFT1SJNFJSB5VSNB%+F RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 313 PTEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTRVFUJUVMBSJ[BKVOUPË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBEP&TUBEP EF.JOBT(FSBJTOPTUFSNPTEPBSUfEP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT $POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBT 0.JOJTUSP'SBODJTDP'BMDÍPEP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBOFHPV QSPWJNFOUPBPSFDVSTPPSEJOÈSJPBPGVOEBNFOUPEFRVFOÍPTFGBMBSFN BVUPBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEPBSUEP"%$5EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMQPJT FNCPSB UFOIB TJEP BVUPSJ[BEB B VUJMJ[BÎÍP EPT QSFDBUØSJPT QBSB DPN QFOTBÎÍPEFEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTTVBFGFUJWBÎÍPEFWFSÈBUFOEFSËTSFHSBT QSØQSJBTEF DBEBFOUF QÞCMJDPOB GPSNB EPBSU EP $5/ TPCSF USBOTDSJUPoBTRVBJTSFHJTUSFTFEFQBTTBHFNGPSBNSFDPOIFDJEBTDPNP UFOTPsic)TJEPSFDFQDJPOBEBTQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍPn 0.JOJTUSP5FPSJ"MCJOP;BWBTDLJBDSFTDFOUPVBJOEBPGVOEBNFOUPEF RVFOBFTQÏDJF“(...), o precatório que se pretende ‘compensar’ representa créditos de natureza alimentar. Ora, se tais créditos estão expressamente excluídos do referido parcelamento conforme acentua o caput do art. 78, não é possível atribuir-lhes o efeito liberatório de pagamento das dívidas tributárias (fl. 239). 4ÍPEVBTQPSUBOUPBTRVFTUÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTQPTUBTËBQSFDJBÎÍP EFTUF 4VQSFNP 5SJCVOBM 'FEFSBM B QSJNFJSB SFMBUJWB Ë BQMJDBCJMJEBEF JNFEJBUB EP EJTQPTJUJWP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVF QFSNJUF DPNQFOTBÎÍP EF QSFDBUØSJP DPN EÏCJUPT USJCVUÈSJPT BSU f EP "UP EBT %JTQP TJÎÜFT $POTUJUVDJPOBJT 5SBOTJUØSJBT o "%$5 B TFHVOEB DVKP FYBNF EFQFOEFSÈEBDPODMVTÍPBRVFTFDIFHBSOBQSJNFJSBFTUÈFNTBCFSTF QSFDBUØSJPT EFDPSSFOUFT EF DSÏEJUPT EF OBUVSF[B BMJNFOUBS QPEFN TFS DPNQFOTBEPTDPNEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPT &TTFTEPJTUFNBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTUÐNSFMFWÉODJBFDPOÙNJDBFKVSÓEJDB BMÏNEFBMDBOÎBSFNVNBRVBOUJEBEFTJHOJmDBUJWBEFDSFEPSFTUJUVMBSFT EFQSFDBUØSJPT 1FMPFYQPTUPmanifesto-me pela existência de repercussão geral EBTRVFTUÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFTVCNFUPBRVFTUÍPËBQSFDJBÎÍPEPTFNJ OFOUFT1BSFTEFTUF4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM "UVBMNFOUFPO[F&TUBEPTNBJTP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMQPTTVFNMFJEJTDJQMJOBEPSB EBDPNQFOTBÎÍP4ÍPFMFT3JPEF+BOFJSP.BUP(SPTTP.BUP(SPTTPEP4VM$FBSÈ .BSBOIÍP3PSBJNB4BOUB$BUBSJOB"MBHPBT3JP(SBOEFEP/PSUF"NB[POBTF1BSÈ. /P&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPOÍPIÈMFJQSFWFOEPDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFDSÏEJUPTFEÏ CJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPT)ÈTJNRVBUSPQSPKFUPTEFMFJUSBNJUBOEPOB"TTFNCMÏJB-FHJTMBUJWB $POTPBOUF3FWJTUB&MFUSÙOJDB$POTVMUPS+VSÓEJDPBDFTTBEBBUSBWÏTEPTJUFXXXDPOKVSDPNCS BHPPO[FFTUBEPTDPOTUBNMFJTBVUPSJ[BNDPNQFOTBÎÍPÁMUJNPBDFTTPFN RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 314 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti OFTUFTFOUJEP%BÓQPSRVFËNÓOHVBEFMFJOÍPSFDPOIFDFBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFEÏCJ UPTTFVTDPNDSÏEJUPTEFDPSSFOUFTEFQSFDBUØSJPT &FNOPTTBPQJOJÍPB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOOÍPBMUFSPVFTUFRVBESP /ÍPÏOPTTPPCKFUJWPOPQSFTFOUFUSBCBMIPEJTDPSSFSBDFSDBEBTJODPOTUJUVDJP OBMJEBEFTEPSFHJNFRVFTFJNQMBOUPVDPNPBEWFOUPEFTUBFNFOEB4ÍPFMBTFWJEFOUFT BOPTTPWFS1BJSBNTPCSFFMBBPNFOPTRVBUSPBÎÜFTEJSFUBTEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF QSPQPTUBTQFMB0SEFNEPT"EWPHBEPTEP#SBTJMo0"# QFMB"TTPDJBÎÍP/BDJPOBMEPT .BHJTUSBEPTEB+VTUJÎBEP5SBCBMIP"/"."53" QFMB"TTPDJBÎÍP/BDJPOBMEPT.B HJTUSBEPT&TUBEVBJT"/"."(&4 FQFMB$POGFEFSBÎÍP/BDJPOBMEB*OEÞTUSJB$/* /BFTUFJSBEPRVFKÈSFTUPVBTTFOUBEPOPWPUPEFEFTFNQBUFQSPGFSJEPQFMP .JOJTUSP $FMTP EF .FMMP RVBOEP EP KVMHBNFOUP EBT NFEJEBT DBVUFMBSFT OBT "%*T FDPOTPBOUFKÈFYQVTFNPTBPNFOPTOBQBSUFFNRVFBMDBOÎBPTQSFDB UØSJPTBFMBBOUFSJPSFTUVEPTJOBMJ[BQBSBPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEFTVBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJ EBEFOBNFEJEBFNRVFUBMFNFOEBBPWJPMBSPEJSFJUPBERVJSJEPFBDPJTBKVMHBEB QSJODÓQJPT FTUFT JOTDVMQJEPT OP BSUJHP 9997* EB $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM BUJOHJV DMÈVTVMBQÏUSFBJOUBOHÓWFMQFMPQPEFSDPOTUJUVJOUFEFSJWBEPDPOmHVSBOEPJOEVCJUB WFMNFOUFBCVTPEPQPEFSEFMFHJTMBSQPSQBSUFEP$POHSFTTP/BDJPOBM 1SPKFUPTEF-FJOTBOFYBEPTFNBP1SPKFUPEF-FJO 3FTQFDUJWBNFOUF"%*TF "QSPQØTJUPFNP.JOJTUSP"ZSFT#SJUUPFOUÍP3FMBUPSEBTNFODJPOBEBT"%*T FSFVOJEBTQBSBKVMHBNFOUPDPOKVOUPQSPGFSJVWPUPQFMBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBFNFOEB QFMBFYJTUÐODJBEFWÓDJPGPSNBMOBNFEJEBFNRVFP$POHSFTTP/BDJPOBMOÍPPCTFSWPVPJOUFSTUÓDJP EFDJODPEJBTÞUFJTOBTWPUBÎÜFTFNQSJNFJSPFTFHVOEPUVSOPTUBMRVBMQSFWÐPBSUJHPEP3FHJ NFOUP*OUFSOPEP4FOBEP'FEFSBM.BOJGFTUPVTFUBNCÏNQFMBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEPQBSÈHSBGP EPBSUJHPEB$'RVFEFUFSNJOBPQBHBNFOUPQSFGFSFODJBMEFQSFDBUØSJPEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJB FTQFDJmDBNFOUFOBEBUBEFTVBFYQFEJÎÍPBQFTTPBTDPNBOPTPVNBJTQPJTOPTFVKVÓ[PVNB QFTTPBEFBOPTRVFBDBCPVEFUFSTFVQSFDBUØSJPFYQFEJEPSFDFCFSÈQBSUFEFTFVDSÏEJUPBOUFTEF VNBQFTTPBEFBOPTRVFFTQFSBQFMPQBHBNFOUPEFTFVQSFDBUØSJPIÈNBJTEFEVBTEÏDBEBTFQFMB JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEPTQBSÈHSBGPTFEPNFTNPEJTQPTJUJWPOBNFEJEBFNRVFDSJBNNBJT VNBQSFSSPHBUJWBQSPDFTTVBMBP&TUBEPBPDIBODFMBSVNBDPNQFOTBÎÍPPCSJHBUØSJBEPDSÏEJUPBTFSJOT DSJUPFNQSFDBUØSJPDPNEÏCJUPTQFSBOUFB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBFQPSGFSJSPTQSJODÓQJPTEBTFQBSBÎÍPEPT 1PEFSFTFEBJTPOPNJB7PUPVEFTGBWPSBWFMNFOUFBPQBSÈHSBGPEPBSUJHPEB$'FBPBSUJHP EP"%$5QPSDPOUSBSJBSFNBBVUPSJEBEFEBTEFDJTÜFTKVEJDJBJTFBGSPOUBSFNPQSJODÓQJPEBTFQBSBÎÍP EF1PEFSFTBTHBSBOUJBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTEFMJWSFBDFTTPBP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPFBSB[PÈWFMEVSBÎÍPEP QSPDFTTP2VBOUPBPBSUJHPEP"%$5FOUFOEFVBJOEBRVFBOPSNBQSFWÐPQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØ SJPTFNPSEFNÞOJDBFDSFTDFOUFEFWBMPSGBWPSFDFOEPEFTBSSB[PBEBNFOUFPTDSFEPSFTNBJTSFDFOUFT FNEFUSJNFOUPEFRVFNKÈFTQFSBIÈNBJTUFNQPOBmMB"MÏNEJTTPPBSUJHPUPSOBTVCKFUJWPPDSJUÏSJP EFFTDPMIBQBSBPQBHBNFOUPFQSFKVEJDBBBVUPOPNJBEB+VTUJÎB5SBCBMIJTUBBPDPOGFSJSBQFOBTBPT 5SJCVOBJTEF+VTUJÎBBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEBDPOUBFTQFDJBMEFEFQØTJUPEPTWBMPSFTQBSBRVJUBSBEÓWJEB1PS mNWPUPVQFMBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFEBFYQSFTTÍPiÓOEJDFPmDJBMEFSFNVOFSBÎÍPCÈTJDBEBDBEFSOFUB EFQPVQBOÎBwDPOTUBOUFEPQBSÈHSBGPEPBSUJHPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPEPJODJTP**EPQBSÈHSBGPF EPQBSÈHSBGPBNCPTEPBSUJHPEP"%$5QPSEFTFRVJMJCSBSBFRVBÎÍPFDPOÙNJDPmOBODFJSBFOUSF EFWFEPSFDSFEPSFNEFTGBWPSEFTUFÞMUJNP /P&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPP»SHÍP&TQFDJBMEP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBQPSPDBTJÍPEPKVMHBNFOUPEP.BO EBEPEF4FHVSBOÎBFNJNQFUSBEPQFMB.VOJDJQBMJEBEFEF 4ÍP1BVMPFNGBDFEP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBRVFEFGFSJVQFEJEPEFJOUFSWFOÎÍPKVMHPV incidenter tantum JODPOTUJUVDJPOBJT PT BSUJHP F EB &$ O QPS GFSJS FOUSF PVUSPT PT QSJODÓQJPTEBNPSBMJEBEFEBSB[PBCJMJEBEFFEBQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEF&TUFNFTNP»SHÍPOPKVMHBNFOUP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 315 5PEBWJBOÍPTFQPEFBENJUJSRVFTPCPQÈMJPEBJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFQFS QFUSFNTFPVUSBTJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFT&TDMBSFDFNPT "&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOUSPVYFFGFUJWBNFOUFBMHVNBTBMUFSBÎÜFT SFMBUJWBNFOUFËDPNQFOTBÎÍPEJ[FOEPFYQSFTTBNFOUFRVBJTBTTJUVBÎÜFT FNRVFB QFSNJUFJODMVTJWFËNÓOHVBEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPNBTOBTIJQØUFTFTBMJDPOTJHOBEBT "DSJUÏSJPFFNGBWPSEPFOUFQÞCMJDPEFWFEPSFNEPJTNPNFOUPTEJTUJOUPT 0QSJNFJSPEFMFTDPNPGBDVMEBEFEPFOUFEFWFEPSFJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEF SFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPFDPOUSBPDSFEPSPSJHJOBMOPNPNFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJP OPTUFSNPTEPEJTQPTUPOPTffFEPBSUJHPEB$' &PTFHVOEPOBIJQØUFTFEFPQÎÍPEPFOUFQÞCMJDPQFMBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFMFJMÜFT OPUPDBOUFBEPTSFDVSTPTRVFTFSÍPVUJMJ[BEPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPT PQÎÍPFTUBQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPfJODJTP*FfJODJTP**EP"%$5 "GBWPSEPDSFEPSIÈBQFOBTVNBIJQØUFTFEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPDPODFEJEBFY QSFTTBNFOUF F JOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EF SFHVMBNFOUBÎÍP NBT OÍP QPS TVB FTDPMIB F TJNQPSPSEFNEP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMRVFPQUBSÈPVQPSTFRàFTUSPFNDPOUBEP FOUFEFWFEPSEBRVBOUJBOFDFTTÈSJBPVQFMBDPNQFOTBÎÍP/PDBTPEFOÍPMJCFSBÎÍP UFNQFTUJWBEFSFDVSTPTQSFWJTUBOP"SUfJODJTP**EP"%$5 0CTFSWFNPTRVFPMFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVJOUFEFSJWBEPRVBOEPPRVJTDPOGFSJV EJSFJUPËDPNQFOTBÎÍPUBOUPQBSBBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBRVBOUPQBSBPDSFEPSTVCMJ OIFTFJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPFGSJTFTFDPOUSBPDSFEPSPSJHJOBM EP.4OFNJNQFUSBEPQFMP*OTUJUVUP1BVMJTUB"EWFOUJTUBEF &EVDBÎÍPF"TTJTUÐODJB4PDJBMFNGBDFEP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBRVFFYUJOHVJVQFEJEPEF TFRVFTUSPËWJTUBEBTOPWBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTEB&$OFYUFSOPVQPTJDJPOBNFOUPTFHVOEPPRVBMB DJUBEBFNFOEBWJPMBBUPKVSÓEJDPQFSGFJUPOÍPQPEFOEPUFSFGFJUPSFUSPBUJWP i"SUy f /PNPNFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEFMFTEFWFSÈ TFSBCBUJEPBUÓUVMPEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPWBMPSDPSSFTQPOEFOUFBPTEÏCJUPTMÓRVJEPTFDFSUPTJOTDSJUPTPV OÍPOBEÓWJEBBUJWBFDPOTUJUVÓEPTDPOUSBPDSFEPSPSJHJOBMQFMB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBEFWFEPSBJODMVÓEBT QBSDFMBTWJODFOEBTEFQBSDFMBNFOUPTSFTTBMWBEPTBRVFMFTDVKBFYFDVÎÍPFTUFKBTVTQFOTBFNWJSUVEFEF DPOUFTUBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBPVKVEJDJBM f "OUFTEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTP5SJCVOBMTPMJDJUBSÈË'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBEFWFEPSBQBSBSFT QPTUBFNBUÏUSJOUB EJBTTPCQFOBEFQFSEBEPEJSFJUPEFBCBUJNFOUPJOGPSNBÎÍPTPCSFPTEÏCJUPT RVFQSFFODIBNBTDPOEJÎÜFTFTUBCFMFDJEBTOPfQBSBPTmOTOFMFQSFWJTUPTw i"SUy f "BQMJDBÎÍPEPTSFDVSTPTSFTUBOUFTEFQFOEFSÈEFPQÎÍPBTFSFYFSDJEBQPS&TUBEPT%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM F.VOJDÓQJPTEFWFEPSFTQPSBUPEP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPPCFEFDFOEPËTFHVJOUFGPSNBRVFQPEFSÈTFS BQMJDBEBJTPMBEBNFOUFPVTJNVMUBOFBNFOUF I oEFTUJOBEPTBPQBHBNFOUPEPTQSFDBUØSJPTQPSNFJPEPMFJMÍP f 0TMFJMÜFTEFRVFUSBUBPJODJTP*EPfEFTUFBSUJHP **oBENJUJSÍPBIBCJMJUBÎÍPEFQSFDBUØSJPTPVQBSDFMBEFDBEBQSFDBUØSJPJOEJDBEBQFMPTFVEFUFOUPSFNSF MBÎÍPBPTRVBJTOÍPFTUFKBQFOEFOUFOPÉNCJUPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPSFDVSTPPVJNQVHOBÎÍPEFRVBMRVFSOB UVSF[BQFSNJUJEBQPSJOJDJBUJWBEP1PEFS&YFDVUJWPBDPNQFOTBÎÍPDPNEÏCJUPTMÓRVJEPTFDFSUPTJOTDSJUPT PVOÍPFNEÓWJEBBUJWBFDPOTUJUVÓEPTDPOUSBEFWFEPSPSJHJOÈSJPQFMB'B[FOEB1ÞCMJDBEFWFEPSBBUÏBEBUB EBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPSFTTBMWBEPTBRVFMFTDVKBFYJHJCJMJEBEFFTUFKBTVTQFOTBOPTUFSNPTEBMFHJTMBÎÍP PVRVFKÈUFOIBNTJEPPCKFUPEFBCBUJNFOUPOPTUFSNPTEPfEPBSUEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMw RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 316 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti &YQSFTTBNFOUFDPOTJHOPVRVFFNUBJTIJQØUFTFTBDPNQFOTBÎÍPÏBVUPBQMJDÈWFMP RVFOPTMFWBËDPODMVTÍPEFRVFFNPVUSBTFOUFOEFVRVFOPFYFSDÓDJPEBDPNQF UÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBBUSJCVÓEBQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMBPTFOUFTQPMÓUJDPTBFMFTDBCF QPSMFJFNGBDFEPQSJODÓQJPEBFTUSJUBMFHBMJEBEFFEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPTSFDVSTPT QÞCMJDPTSFHVMBSBTIJQØUFTFTFNRVFÏDBCÓWFMBDPNQFOTBÎÍP &UBMÏEFSJHPS0BSUJHP*EB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMQSFWÐRVFDPNQFUFË 6OJÍPBPT&TUBEPTFBP%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMMFHJTMBSDPODPSSFOUFNFOUFTPCSFEJSFJUPUSJ CVUÈSJP%JTQÙTFNTFVQBSÈHSBGPQSJNFJSPRVFOPÉNCJUPEBMFHJTMBÎÍPDPODPSSFOUF BDPNQFUÐODJBEB6OJÍPMJNJUBSTFÈBFTUBCFMFDFSOPSNBTHFSBJT 0BSUJHPJODJTP***MFUSBiCwEPUFYUPNBHOPEJTQÜFRVFDBCFËMFJDPN QMFNFOUBSFTUBCFMFDFSOPSNBTHFSBJTTPCSFPCSJHBÎÍPMBOÎBNFOUPDSÏEJUPQSFTDSJÎÍP FEFDBEÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJPT 0JOTUJUVUPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPNPEBMJEBEFEFFYUJOÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP FTUÈQPSEJTQPTJÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMTPCSFTFSWBEFMFJDPNQMFNFOUBSOPRVFDPODFSOF ËFEJÎÍPEFOPSNBTHFSBJT 0BSUJHPEP$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBMRVFBUFOEFBUBMRVBMJmDBUJWP BTTFWFSBRVFDPNQFUFËMFJPSEJOÈSJBEFDBEBFOUFGFEFSBUJWPBTVBBVUPSJ[BÎÍP "$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMÏRVFNEJUBQPSUBOUPPRVFQPEFDBEBQFTTPBQPMÓUJDB SFBMJ[BSFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBEFNBSDBOEPPTSFTQFDUJWPTÉNCJUPTEFBUVBÎÍPOPJOUVJUP EFFWJUBSDPOnJUPTFOUSFBTQFTTPBTQPMÓUJDBTJODMVTJWFOPRVFTFSFGFSFËDPNQFOTBÎÍP &UBMTFEÈFNSFTQFJUPBPQSJODÓQJPGFEFSBUJWPDPSPMÈSJPEP&TUBEP%FNP DSÈUJDPEF%JSFJUPFNGVOÎÍPEPRVBMBTDPNQFUÐODJBTPVUPSHBEBTQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBMBPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTOÍPQPEFNTFSWJPMBEBT %FGBUPOÍPDBCFË$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEFTDFSBNJOVEÐODJBT&OÍPÏPBSUJHP EP$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBMRVFDPODFEFPEJSFJUPËDPNQFOTBÎÍPFTJNBMFJPSEJ OÈSJBBMJQSFWJTUBRVFWJFSBEJTQPSTPCSFBNBUÏSJB "EFNBJTOFNPBSUJHPFQBSÈHSBGPTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMOFNUBN QPVDPPBSUJHPEP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SJCVUÈSJBTBGBTUPVBDPN QFUÐODJBEPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTQBSBEJTDJQMJOBSBNBUÏSJB 1VHOBSQFMBBVUPBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBQBSUJSEPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJP OBMÏWJPMBSPQSJODÓQJPGFEFSBUJWPWJPMBOEPPSÓHJEPSFHJNFEFSFQBSUJÎÍPEBTDPNQF UÐODJBTUSJCVUÈSJBTEFmOJEPQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBM %JTDPSEBNPTQPSUBOUPEFHSBOEFQBSUFEBEPVUSJOBRVFQSFTUJHJBFTUFQP TJDJPOBNFOUPRVFEFDPSSFBDSFEJUBNPTEBHSBOEFJOTBUJTGBÎÍPQFMPOPUØSJPEFTDBTP EPTFOUFTQÞCMJDPTFNTBMEBSTVBTEÓWJEBT "MHVOTEFGPSNBNBJTSBEJDBMDPNPÏFYQSFTTÍP"MFYBOESF.BDFEP4PB SFTEFGFOEFNBJODJEÐODJBEJSFUBFJNFEJBUBEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBPDBTPDPODSFUP4ÍP TVBTQBMBWSBT DPN BSSJNP OB JOEJTQFOTÈWFM JOUFSQSFUBÎÍP MØHJDPTJTUÐNJDB EPT QSFDFJUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTEÞWJEBTOFNSFDFJPEFWFNPTUFSFNBENJUJSRVF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 317 PEJSFJUPËDPNQFOTBÎÍPSFTTBSDJNFOUP EPRVFGPJQBHPJOEFWJEBNFOUF BP&SÈSJPBUÓUVMPEFUSJCVUPÏDPOTFDUÈSJPMØHJDPOBUVSBMEFVNBTÏSJF EFSFHSBTQSJODJQJPMØHJDBTFODBSUBEBTFNOPTTB/PSNB'VOEBNFOUBM 0VUSPTBVUPSFTEFGFOEFNOBEFNBOFJSBNBJTUFNQFSBEBEPTRVBJTEFTUBDB NPT'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEB%BOUBTRVFPCUFNQFSB 1FOTP RVF Ï QSFGFSÓWFM RVF TF UFOIB MFJ RVF EJTDJQMJOF B DPNQFOTBÎÍP $POTJEFSPQPSÏNRVFËNÓOHVBEBFYJTUÐODJBEFTTBMFJOÍPTFQPEFSÈ QSPJCJSBDFTTÍPEFDSÏEJUPoQPSRVFQSFWJTUBOPQSØQSJPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM OFN NVJUP NFOPT B VUJMJ[BÎÍP QPS FWFOUVBM FNQSFTB DFTTJPOÈSJB EP DSÏEJUP EP QSFDBUØSJP UFOEP FN WJTUB RVF JTTP JNQPSUBSJB FN DSJBS PCTUÈDVMPËFGFUJWJEBEFEBEJTDJQMJOBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJOEFWJEBNFOUF 4ØBMFJQPSUBOUPQPEFSÈSFHVMBSDPNPTFQSPDFEFSÈBDPNQFOTBÎÍPRVBJT USJCVUPTQPEFSÍPTFSDPNQFOTBEPTTFJOTDSJUPTPVOÍPFNEÓWJEBBUJWBRVBMBBVUP SJEBEFDPNQFUFOUFQBSBQSPDFEFSBDPNQFOTBÎÍPFNRVBMNPNFOUPTFDPOmHVSBB NPSBEPFOUFQPMÓUJDPEFWFEPSRVFFOTFKBBDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFOUSFPVUSBTRVFTUÜFT 3FMBUJWBNFOUF Ë DFTTÍP EF DSÏEJUPT EFDPSSFOUFT EF QSFDBUØSJPT B UFSDFJSPT IPVWFQSFWJTÍPFYQSFTTBOPfEPBSUJHPEB$'&P"SUEB&$O DPOWBMJEPV BT DFTTÜFT EF QSFDBUØSJPT FGFUVBEBT BOUFT EB QSPNVMHBÎÍP EB SFGFSJEB FNFOEBJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEBDPODPSEÉODJBEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSB /BWFSEBEFUBJTEJTQPTJUJWPTOÍPUSB[FNRVBMRVFSJOPWBÎÍPWJTUPRVFBDFT TÍPTFNQSFGPJQFSNJUJEBFOÍPTFDPOGVOEFDPNBDPNQFOTBÎÍP4ÍPEPJTJOTUJUV UPTDPNQFSmTEJGFSFOUFTDBEBRVBMDPNTVBTQSØQSJBTSFHSBTOÍPIBWFOEPQPSRVF DPNPRVFSFNBMHVOTBVUPSFTGPSÎBSJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPOPTFOUJEPEFJNCSJDÈMPT 1PS mN NBJT VNB PCTFSWBÎÍP TF GB[ OFDFTTÈSJB FN SFGPSÎP EB OPTTB BSHVNFOUBÎÍP $PNPKVMHBNFOUPEBTDBVUFMBSFTOBT"%*TFRVFTVTQFOEFSBN BFmDÈDJBEPBSUJHPEB&$OSFMBUJWBNFOUFBPTQSFDBUØSJPTQFOEFOUFTOB EBUBEFTVBQSPNVMHBÎÍPQFMPNFOPTFNSFMBÎÍPBFTUFTQSFDBUØSJPTTFQFSTJTUJSB EFDJTÍPQSPGFSJEBOBTDBVUFMBSFTOÍPNBJTTFTVCNFUFNBPQBSDFMBNFOUPEFEF[BOPT 4FOEPBTTJNOÍPIÈRVFTFDPHJUBSEFEFTDVNQSJNFOUPEFQBSDFMBTBOVBJTQBSBmOT EFDPOGFSJSQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPBPTQSFDBUØSJPTQFSEFOEPBTTFOUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMPJOT UJUVUPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPDPNPEFDPSSÐODJBEJSFUBFJNFEJBUBEPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 5"7"3&4"MFYBOESF.BDFEPCompensação do Indébito Tributário4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDBQ %"/5"4'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEBExecução Contra a Fazenda Pública: Regime de Precatório, FE4ÍP 1BVMP.ÏUPEPQ ²JODMVTJWFPQFOTBNFOUPEF)"3"%",JZPTIJPrecatórios. Suspensão do art. 78 do ADCT. Consequências$POUFÞEP+VSÓEJDP#SBTÓMJB%'EF[%JTQPOÓWFMFN)551XXXDPOUFVEPKVSJEJDP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 318 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti 4ÍPFTUBTBTSB[ÜFTRVFOPTMFWBNBDPODMVJSOPNFTNPTFOUJEPFNRVFTF JODMJOBBKVSJTQSVEÐODJBQÈUSJBEFOFDFTTJEBEFEFFEJÎÍPEFMFJRVFBVUPSJ[BBDPN QFOTBÎÍPBJOEBNBJTBHPSBTPCBÏHJEFEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO 6. SÍNTESE CONCLUSIVA "TJTUFNÈUJDBEFQBHBNFOUPQPSQSFDBUØSJPTGPJQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEB $POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEF/PNFTNPEJQMPNBPBSUJHPEP"%$5QFSNJUJV PQBSDFMBNFOUPFNPJUPBOPTEPTEÏCJUPTGSVUPTEFQSFDBUØSJPTQFOEFOUFTOBEBUBEB TVBQSPNVMHBÎÍPSFTTBMWBOEPPTDSÏEJUPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUBS/BEBFTUBCFMFDFV OBPQPSUVOJEBEFBDFSDBEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPEFUBJTEÏCJUPTDPNDSÏEJ UPTPQPOÓWFJTBPTFVDSFEPS 5BMEJTQPTJUJWPUSBOTJUØSJPGPJBMWPEFBÎÍPEJSFUBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEF UFOEPP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMFOUFOEJEPRVFFNCPSBBTEJTQPTJÎÜFTUSBOTJUØSJBT FQFSNBOFOUFTGPTTFNBOUBHÙOJDBTP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØ SJBTDPOUJOIBNFSBFYDFÎÍPDSJBEBQFMP1PEFS$POTUJUVJOUF0SJHJOÈSJPBPTQSJODÓQJPT EBJTPOPNJBEPEJSFJUPBERVJSJEPFEBKVTUBJOEFOJ[BÎÍPEFOUSFPVUSPTSB[ÍPQFMB RVBMNFODJPOBEBBÎÍPOÍPGPJDPOIFDJEB $PN P BEWFOUP EB &$ O JOTUJUVJVTF OPWB NPSBUØSJB 3FTUPV QFSNJUJEPBPTFOUFTQÞCMJDPTOPWPQBSDFMBNFOUPEFEÏCJUPTBHPSBFNEF[QSFTUBÎÜFT BOVBJTFTVDFTTJWBT"CSJVTFFNDPOUSBQBSUJEBBPTDSFEPSFTEBT'B[FOEBT1ÞCMJDBT BQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFFNDBTPEFOÍPQBHBNFOUPEFTUBTQBSDFMBTVUJMJ[BSFNTFVTDSÏEJ UPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPEFEÏCJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTSFTTBMWBEPTEFTUFTJTUFNBPTQSFDBUØSJPT BMJNFOUBSFTPTEÏCJUPTEFQFRVFOPWBMPSFPTQSFDBUØSJPTQBSDFMBEPTQFMP"SUEP "%$5"QBSUJSEBÓQBTTPVTFBJOUFSQSFUBSFRVJWPDBNFOUFRVFPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJP OFMBQSFWJTUPFSBTJOÙOJNPEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFSFBMJ[BSDPNQFOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB 1FMPWPUPEFEFTFNQBUFEP.JOJTUSP$FMTPEF.FMMPRVFEFGFSJVBDBVUFMBS OBT"%*TFP1MFOÈSJPEP4VQSFNP5SJCVOBM'FEFSBMTVTQFOEFVBFYQSFTTÍP DPOTUBOUFEPDBQVUEPBSUJHPEP"%$5DSJBEPQFMBBMVEJEB&NFOEBoios precatórios pendentes na data da promulgação desta emenda”BUÏKVMHBNFOUPmOBMEBTBÎÜFTEJSFUBT &NRVFQFTFIBWFSBJOEBNVJUBEJTDVTTÍPHJSBOEPFNUPSOPEBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFTFDPO GFSJSQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPBPTQSFDBUØSJPTBMJNFOUBSFTWFODJEPTUÐNQSFWBMFDJEPEFDJTÜFT FNTFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJPEJBOUFEBMJUFSBMJEBEFEPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM 5BNCÏN UFN TJEP PCKFUP EF RVFTUJPOBNFOUP B OFDFTTJEBEF EF MFJ WFJDVMB EPSB EF BVUPSJ[BÎÍP QBSB B DPNQFOTBÎÍP B UFPS EP EJTQPTUP OP BSUJHP EP $5/ DPNCS DPMVOBTDPMVOJTUBWFSÁMUJNPBDFTTPFNKBO "QSPQØTJUPP4VQFSJPS5SJCVOBMEF+VTUJÎBOP3.4O133FM.JOJTUSP#FOFEJUP(POÎBMWFT 1SJNFJSB5VSNB%+FFTQPTPVFOUFOEJNFOUPTFHVOEPPRVBMPBSUJHPfEP"%$5 FTUBSJBSFWPHBEPQFMB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 A compensação tributária e o regime constitucional 319 0T5SJCVOBJTUÐNSFDPOIFDJEPBQFTBSEFEFDJTÜFTFNTFOUJEPDPOUSÈSJPCFNDPNPEF SFTQFJUÈWFJTPQJOJÜFTOBEPVUSJOBQVHOBOEPQFMBBQMJDBÎÍPEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBQBSUJSEP UFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFEPVTPEFQSFDBUØSJPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPTEFUSJCV UPTTPCPGVOEBNFOUPEFOUSFPVUSPTEBOFDFTTJEBEFEFMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSBQBSBBBMNFKBEB DPNQFOTBÎÍP %FRVBMRVFSGPSNBQFOEFEFKVMHBNFOUPP3&.(OPRVBMKÈIPVWF QSPOVODJBNFOUPSFDPOIFDFOEPBFYJTUÐODJBEFSFQFSDVTTÍPHFSBMFNRVFTFEJTDVUFKVTUB NFOUFBFYUFOTÍPEPQPEFSMJCFSBUØSJPEFQBHBNFOUPEFUSJCVUPEBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBBPT QSFDBUØSJPTEFOBUVSF[BBMJNFOUÓDJBFBBVUPBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEPfEP"SUEP"%$5 &NOPTTBPQJOJÍPB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOOÍPBMUFSPVFTUF FTUBEPEFDPJTBT&NRVFQFTFFTUBSFJWBEBEFEJWFSTBTJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFTDPOTP BOUFKÈSFDPOIFDJEPJODMVTJWFQFMPFOUÍP3FMBUPSEBT"%*TF P.JOJTUSP"ZSFT#SJUUPOÍPÏQPSFTUBSB[ÍPRVFTFQPEFBENJUJSQFSQFUSFNTFPVUSBT JODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFT "&$OUSPVYFBMUFSBÎÜFTSFMBUJWBNFOUFËDPNQFOTBÎÍPEJ[FOEP FYQSFTTBNFOUFRVBJTBTTJUVBÎÜFTFNRVFBQFSNJUFJODMVTJWFËNÓOHVBEFSFHVMB NFOUBÎÍPNBTOBTIJQØUFTFTBMJDPOTJHOBEBT"DSJUÏSJPFFNGBWPSEPFOUFQÞCMJDP EFWFEPS FN EPJT NPNFOUPT EJTUJOUPT 0 QSJNFJSP EFMFT DPNP GBDVMEBEF EP FOUF EFWFEPSFJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPFDPOUSBPDSFEPSPSJHJOBMOPNP NFOUPEBFYQFEJÎÍPEPQSFDBUØSJPffFEPBSUJHPEB$' &PTFHVOEP OBIJQØUFTFEFPQÎÍPEPFOUFQÞCMJDPQFMBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEFMFJMÜFTOPUPDBOUFB EPTSFDVSTPTRVFTFSÍPVUJMJ[BEPTQBSBQBHBNFOUPEFQSFDBUØSJPT PQÎÍPFTUBQSFWJTUB OPBSUJHPfJODJTP*FfJODJTP**EP"%$5"GBWPSEPDSFEPSFNBQFOBT VNBIJQØUFTFEFDPNQFOTBÎÍPDPODFEJEBFYQSFTTBNFOUFFJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUFEF SFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPNBTOÍPQPSTVBFTDPMIBFTJNQPSPSEFNEP1SFTJEFOUFEP5SJCVOBM OPDBTPEFOÍPMJCFSBÎÍPUFNQFTUJWBEFSFDVSTPT"SUfJODJTP**EP"%$5 0MFHJTMBEPSDPOTUJUVJOUFEFSJWBEPRVBOEPPRVJTDPOGFSJVEJSFJUPËDPNQFOTB ÎÍPUBOUPQBSBBFOUJEBEFEFWFEPSBRVBOUPQBSBPDSFEPSTVCMJOIFTFJOEFQFOEFOUFNFOUF EFSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPFGSJTFTFDPOUSBPDSFEPSPSJHJOBMPRVFOPTMFWBËDPODMVTÍPEFRVF FNPVUSBTIJQØUFTFTBPTFOUFTQPMÓUJDPTDBCFNQPSMFJFNGBDFEPTQSJODÓQJPTGFEFSBUJWPEB FTUSJUBMFHBMJEBEFFEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJDPTSFHVMBSBTIJQØUFTFTFNRVF ÏDBCÓWFMBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBUFPSEPEJTQPTUPOPBSUJHPEP$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBM "EFNBJTOFNPBSUJHPFQBSÈHSBGPTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMOFN UBNQPVDPPBSUJHPEP"UPEBT%JTQPTJÎÜFT$POTUJUVDJPOBJT5SBOTJUØSJBTBGBTUPVB DPNQFUÐODJBEPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTQBSBEJTDJQMJOBSBNBUÏSJB 1VHOBSQFMBBVUPBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBQBSUJSEPUFYUPDPOT UJUVDJPOBMÏWJPMBSPQSJODÓQJPGFEFSBUJWPWJPMBOEPPSÓHJEPSFHJNFEFSFQBSUJÎÍPEBT DPNQFUÐODJBTUSJCVUÈSJBTEFmOJEPQFMB$BSUB.BHOB %BÓDPODMVJSNPTOPNFTNPTFOUJEPFNRVFTFJODMJOBBKVSJTQSVEÐODJB QÈUSJBEFOFDFTTJEBEFEFFEJÎÍPEFMFJRVFBVUPSJ[FBDPNQFOTBÎÍPBJOEBNBJTBHPSB TPCBÏHJEFEB&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMO RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 320 Cláudia Bocardi Allegretti REFERÊNCIAS "."30-VDJBOPDireito Tributário Brasileiro, 15ª ed., 4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB #"4504$FMTP3JCFJSPF."35*/4*WFT(BOESBEB4JMWBComentários à Constituição do Brasil, WPMUPNP***FE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB #3"4*-&NFOEB$POTUJUVDJPOBMOEFEFOPWFNCSPEF%JÈSJP0mDJBMEB3F QÞCMJDB'FEFSBUJWBEP#SBTJM#SBTÓMJB%'EFOPWFNCSPEF%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQ XXXQMBOBMUPHPWCSÁMUJNPBDFTTPFN $"37"-)08MBEJNJSEF4PV[B Iniciação ao estudo do precatório4FQBSBUBEB3FWJTUBEF *OGPSNBÎÍP-FHJTMBUJWBEP4FOBEP'FEFSBM#SBTÓMJBBOPOPVUEF[ %"/5"4'SBODJTDP8JMEP-BDFSEBExecução Contra a Fazenda Pública: Regime de Precatório, FE4ÍP1BVMP.ÏUPEP %&1-«$*%0&4*-7"Vocabulário Jurídico, FE3JPEF+BOFJSP'PSFOTF %*/*;.BSJB)FMFOBCurso de Direito Civil BrasileiroWPMFE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB '&33&*3"&VEJNBS"MWFT Um Estudo sobre a Compensação Tributária. Direito Tributário e Financeiro Aplicado'FSOBOEP'BDVSZ4DBGGDPPSE 4ÍP1BVMP2VBSUJFS-BUJO ("(-*"/0 1BCMP 4UPM[F 1".1-0/" '*-)0 3PEPMGP Novo Curso de Direito Civil ObrigaçõesFE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB )"3"%",JZPTIJPrecatórios. Suspensão do Art. 78 do ADCT. Consequências$POUFÞ EP+VSÓEJDP#SBTÓMJB%'EF[%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXDPOUFVEPKVSJEJDP DPNCS DPMVOBTDPMVOJTUBWFSÁMUJNPBDFTTPFNKBO +645&/'*-)0.BSÎBMEstado Democrático de Direito e Responsabilidade Civil do Estado: a questão dos precatórios#JCMJPUFDB%JHJUBM3FWJTUBEF%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPEB&DPOPNJBo3%1& #FMP)PSJ[POUFBOPOKVM ."$)"%0)VHPEF#SJUPCurso de Direito TributárioFE4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT ."-&3#*%JWB A cláusula pétrea da legalidade tributária e o instituto da compensação, 3F WJTUBEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPO4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT ."9*.*-*"/0$BSMPT Hermenêutica e Aplicação do DireitoFE3JPEF+BOFJSP'P SFOTF 0-*7&*3""OUPOJP'MÈWJP Precatórios: Aspectos Administrativos, Constitucionais, Financeiros e Processuais, FE#FMP)PSJ[POUF'PSVN 1"6-4&/-FBOESPDireito Tributário: Constituição e Código Tributário à luz da Doutrina e da JurisprudênciaFE1PSUP"MFHSF-JWSBSJBEP"EWPHBEP&EJUPSB&4."'& 3&7*45" &-&53¼/*$" $0/46-503 +63¶%*$0 BDFTTBEB BUSBWÏT EP TJUF XXXDPOKVSDPN CSBHPPO[FFTUBEPTDPOTUBNMFJTBVUPSJ[BNDPNQFOTBÎÍPÁMUJNPBDFTTPFN 30%3*(6&44JMWJPDireito Civil: Parte Geral das ObrigaçõesFE4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB 4$"'''FSOBOEP'BDVSZGrandes Questões Atuais de Direito Tributário – 13º volume7BMEJS EF0MJWFJSB3PDIBDPPSE 4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDB 4*-7"+PTÏ"GPOTPComentário Contextual à Constituição,FE.BMIFJSPT4ÍP1BVMP 5"7"3&4"MFYBOESF.BDFEPCompensação do Indébito Tributário4ÍP1BVMP%JBMÏUJDB 50-&%0+3'MBWJP$EFO regime especial dos precatórios à luz da Emenda Constitucional nº 62.#JCMJPUFDB%JHJUBM'ØSVNEF$POUSBUBÎÍPF(FTUÍP1ÞCMJDB'$(1#FMP)PSJ[POUF BOP O KBO %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXFEJUPSBGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE$PO UFVEP4IPXBTQY JE$POUFVEPÁMUJNPBDFTTPFNKBOFJSP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 291 a 320 TRANSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA NO BRASIL: POSSIBILIDADES E LIMITES TRANSACTION TAX INSTITUTE IN BRAZIL: possibilities and limits Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos1 SUMÁRIO *OUSPEVÎÍP 5SBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB OP #SBTJM PSJHFN F GVOEBNFOUP DPOTUJUV DJPOBM'VOEBNFOUPEFWBMJEBEF5SBOTBÎÍP5SJCVUÈSJBF3FHJNFEF%JSFJUP 1ÞCMJDP4VQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP*OEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFQFMB"ENJ OJTUSBÎÍPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP*OEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPFUSBOTB ÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB5SBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFDPOUPSOPUSBÎBEPQFMBOPSNBHFSBMEPBSUJHP EP$5/5SBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFGBDVMEBEFEPFOUFQPMÓUJDP5SBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBFMFJQFSNJTTJWB4VKFJUPTEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB5SBOTBÎÍPUSJCV UÈSJBFmOBMJEBEFUFSNJOBUJWBEFMJUÓHJP-JUÓHJPKVEJDJBMFMJUÓHJPBENJOJTUSBUJWP -JUÓHJPFNPNFOUPEFTVBJOTUBMBÎÍP"MDBODFEPMJUÓHJPOBUSBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB5SBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBT$PODFTTÜFTNÞ UVBT$PODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBTFDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP5SBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBF DPOEJÎÜFTFTUBCFMFDJEBTOBMFJQFSNJTTJWB%JTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWB 5SBOTBÎÍPFFGFJUPEFFYUJOÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP5SBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBF DPOWÐOJPQBSBP*$.45SBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOPEJSFJUPDPNQBSBEP.PEFMPT FTUSBOHFJSPT$PODMVTÍP3FGFSÐODJBT RESUMO 0 FTUVEP BQSFTFOUB OB QSJNFJSB QBSUF VN QBOPSBNB HFSBM EP JOTUJUVUP EB USBO TBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB OP #SBTJM F BOBMJTB TVB BmOJEBEF DPN P QSJODÓQJP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EB JOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEF EP JOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDP DPN EFTUBRVF B BOÈMJTF EB MFHJTMBÎÍP JOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM "SU EP $5/ B RVBM BTTFHVSB B DBEB FOUF USJCVUBOUF B PQÎÍPQPMÓUJDBQFMBUSBOTBÎÍPNFEJBOUFPFYFSDÓDJPEBTVBDPNQFUÐODJBMFHJTMBUJWB BGBTUBEBBBVUPOPNJBEFWPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTQSØQSJBEBTSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDBTEFEJSFJUP QSJWBEP/BTFHVOEBQBSUFFOGSFOUBRVFTUÜFTQPMÐNJDBTDPNPBQBSFOUFQBSBEPYP FOUSFBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFEJTQPTJÎÍPEPDSÏ EJUPUSJCVUÈSJPOBUSBOTBÎÍPFBDSJUJDBEBEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFRVFFOWPMWFBBUVBÎÍP EBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPOBDFMFCSBÎÍPEPTBDPSEPTTFNRVFDPNJTTPTJHOJmRVFMFTÍP BPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP&YQMPSBPTMJNJUFTEBFYJHÐODJBEFDPOWÐOJPQBSBBUSBOTBÎÍP RVFFOWPMWBP*$.4"QSFTFOUBBMHVOTNPEFMPTQJODFMBEPTEPEJSFJUPDPNQBSBEP FBTSFTUSJÎÜFTEPTJTUFNBCSBTJMFJSPQBSBJNQMBOUÈMPT$PODMVJQFMPDBCJNFOUPEB USBOTBÎÍPOBTFBSBUSJCVUÈSJBEFOUSPEPTMJNJUFTMFHÓUJNPTFNRVFGPJDPODFCJEB QFMPPSEFOBNFOUPCSBTJMFJSP ABSTRACT 5IJTUXPQBSUTTUVEZQSFTFOUTPOUIFmSTUQBSUBOPWFSWJFXPG5SBOTBDUJPO5BY *OTUJUVUF JO #SB[JM BOE BOBMZ[FT UIFJS BGmOJUZ XJUI UIF DPOTUJUVUJPOBM QSJODJQMF PG VOBWBJMBCJMJUZ PG QVCMJD JOUFSFTU VOEFS DPOTUJUVUJPOBM MFHJTMBUJPO BSU $5/ XIJDI FOTVSFT FBDI HPWFSONFOUBM FOUJUZ UP VTF BO 5SJCVUBSZ 1PMJDZ BOE USBOTBDUJPO JOTUJUVUF VQPO UIF FYFSDJTF PG JUT MFHJTMBUJWF QPXFST BXBZ UIF BVUPOPNZPGUIFQBSUJFTPXOMFHBMSFMBUJPOTPGQSJWBUFMBX*OUIFTFDPOEQBSU GBDJOHDPOUSPWFSTJBMJTTVFTXJUIUIFBQQBSFOUQBSBEPYCFUXFFOUIFVOBWBJMBCJMJUZ 1SPDVSBEPSBEP&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP1ØT(SBEVBÎÍPlatu sensuFN%JSFJUPEP5SBCBMIPQFMB6OJWFSTJEBEF EF4ÍP1BVMPo641 1ØT(SBEVBÎÍPlatu sensuFN%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPQFMB&41(& 322 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos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alavras-chavesUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBoJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPoOPSNBHFSBMoDBCJNFOUP oMJNJUFT Keywords5SBOTBDUJPOUBYQVCMJDJOUFSFTUHFOFSBMSVMFOPQMBDFoMJNJUT 1. INTRODUÇÃO 0FYBNFEPJOTUJUVUPEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBÏVNDPOWJUFËSFnFYÍPQPJT UPDBDPODFJUPTPTNBJTWBSJBEPTDPNPPQSJODÓQJPGFEFSBUJWPFBBVUPOPNJBEBTQFT TPBT QPMÓUJDBT B SFMBÎÍP KVSÓEJDB USJCVUÈSJB F TFVT QFSTPOBHFOT P SFHJNF EF EJSFJUP QÞCMJDPFTVBSFMBÎÍPVNCJMJDBMDPNPEJSFJUPUSJCVUÈSJPBOPÎÍPEFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP QSJNÈSJPFTFDVOEÈSJPBOFDFTTJEBEFEFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFQBVUBSBRVBMRVFSNP NFOUPFQPSRVBMRVFSNFJPOBmFMQSPTTFDVÎÍPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP -JNJUBNPTOPTTPFTUVEPBPFYBNFEPDBCJNFOUPEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOP EJSFJUPCSBTJMFJSPTFVGVOEBNFOUPEFWBMJEBEFTFVEFTFOIPOPSNBUJWPTVBTDBSBD UFSÓTUJDBTFMJNJUFTBOBMJTBOEPPBQBSFOUFQBSBEPYPFOUSFPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJ MJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFEJTQPTJÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPOB USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB "OBMJTBNPTBBVTÐODJBEFBVUPOPNJBEPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTFEP%JTUSJUP'F EFSBMQBSBJOTUJUVJSUSJCVUBÎÍPFYDFQUJWBFNSFMBÎÍPBP*$.4FPSFnFYPEBFYJHÐODJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EF EFMJCFSBÎÍP QSÏWJB EF UPEPT PT FOUFT OB USBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB $' "SUf9**H 5BNCÏNCVTDBNPTJOWFTUJHBSDPNPBUSBOTBÎÍPWFNTFOEPUSBUBEBOP%JSFJUP $PNQBSBEPOPUBEBNFOUFFNPSEFOBNFOUPTEFJOTQJSBÎÍPDPOUJOFOUBMDPNPOPTTP POEFPSFHJNFEPBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPJNQPSUBEPEPTTJTUFNBTBOHMPTBYÜFTTFNTFGB[FS BDPNQBOIBSEPTNFDBOJTNPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTMBSHBNFOUFVUJMJ[B EPTQPSBRVFMFTTJTUFNBTWFNTVGPDBOEPP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPDPNPOBUVSBMBVNFOUP EBTMJEFTUSJCVUÈSJBT /ÍPJOWFTUJHBNPTOFOIVNBMFJQFSNJTTJWBFTQFDÓmDB"DBTVÓTUJDBBEFNBJT ÏMJNJUBEBQPJTPQSØQSJPQSFDPODFJUPFNUPSOPEPJOTUJUVUPGSVUPEFBOÈMJTFTTV QFSmDJBJTFDSÓUJDBTBQSFTTBEBTBGBTUPVPMFHJTMBEPSEBFYQMPSBÎÍPEFTTBGFSSBNFOUB QPUFODJBMNFOUFSJDBFNTPMVÎÜFTQBSBDPOnJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPT "P mOBM BQSFTFOUBNPT OPTTBT DPODMVTÜFT DPOWFODJEPT EB WJBCJMJEBEF EB USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOPEJSFJUPCSBTJMFJSPQPSÏNDJFOUFTEFRVFFTTFÏTØPJOÓDJPEF VNFTUVEPRVFNFSFDFTFSBQSPGVOEBEP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 323 2. TRANSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA NO BRASIL: ORIGEM E FUNDAMENTO CONSTITUCIONAL $PNPMFDJPOB1POUFTEF.JSBOEBOPTFV5SBUBEPEF%JSFJUP1SJWBEPUSBOTB ÎÍPÏVN OFHØDJPKVSÓEJDPCJMBUFSBMFNRVFEVBTPVNBJTQFTTPBTBDPSEBNFN DPODFTTÜFT SFDÓQSPDBT DPN P QSPQØTJUP EF QÙS UFSNP Ë DPOUSPWÏSTJB TPCSF EFUFSNJOBEB PV EFUFSNJOBEBT SFMBÎÜFT KVSÓEJDBT TFV DPOUFÞEP FYUFOTÍPWBMJEBEFPVFmDÈDJB 5SBUBTF EF JOTUJUVUP VOJWFSTBM PSJHJOÈSJP EP EJSFJUP QSJWBEP SFDPOIFDJEP QFMPTWÈSJPTPSEFOBNFOUPTKVSÓEJDPTFNRVFBWPOUBEFEBTQBSUFTBPMBEPEBSFDJ QSPDJEBEFEBTDPODFTTÜFTÏFMFNFOUPFTTFODJBMËTVBGPSNBÎÍPTFNQSFDPNWJTUBTË FYUJOÎÍPPVQSFWFOÎÍPEFSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDBTEVWJEPTBTPVMJUJHJPTBT /P %JSFJUP $JWJM CSBTJMFJSP B USBOTBÎÍP QPTTVJ OBUVSF[B KVSÓEJDB DPO USBUVBMQPSRVBOUPJODMVÓEBOPDBQÓUVMPRVFSFHVMBPTWÈSJPTUJQPTEFDPOUSBUP FSFTUSJUBBPTEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTOPTUFSNPTEPTBSUJHPTFEPOPWP $ØEJHP$JWJM 3 4ÍPQPSUBOUPFMFNFOUPTFTTFODJBJTEBUSBOTBÎÍPOPEJSFJUPQSJWBEPCSBTJMFJ SP BDPSEPFOUSFBTQBSUFT FYJTUÐODJBEFSFMBÎÜFTDPOUSPWFSUJEBTFBJOUFOÎÍPEF MIFTQÙSUFSNP SFDVSTPBDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBTQBSBBMDBOÎBSUBMFTDPQPMJNJUBEB BPTEJSFJUPTEJTQPOÓWFJTQBUSJNPOJBJT *OTQJSBEBOBUSBOTBÎÍPEP%JSFJUP$JWJMBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBBEBQUPVPJOT UJUVUPBPSFHJNFEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPQSØQSJPEBTSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJBTBGBTUBOEP BBVUPOPNJBEBWPOUBEFFTTÐODJBEPEJSFJUPQSJWBEP 0MFHJTMBEPSUSJCVUÈSJPFTUÈQMFOBNFOUFBVUPSJ[BEPBSFHVMBSEFGPSNBEJGF SFODJBEBJOTUJUVUPTEJTDJQMJOBEPTFNPVUSBTÈSFBTEP%JSFJUPOPTUFSNPTEPRVFEJT QÜFPTBSUJHPTFEP$5/5SBUBTFEBautonomia de qualificaçãoEPMFHJTMBEPS USJCVUÈSJPFNBUSJCVJSRVBMJmDBÎÜFTEJTUJOUBTBJOTUJUVUPTSFHVMBEPTFNPVUSPTSBNPT desde que veiculadas em lei e nos limites do ordenamento. )FMFOP5BWFJSB5ÙSSFTSFDPOIFDFBMFHJUJNJEBEFEBautonomia de qualificação EPMFHJTMBEPSUSJCVUÈSJPFBEWFSUFRVFBQFOBTBMFJOÍPPJOUÏSQSFUFQPTTVJFTTFQPEFS 3 .*3"/%"1POUFTEF5SBUBEPEF%JSFJUP1SJWBEP7PMVNFQ4ÍP1BVMP35BQVE'*(6&*3& %01BVMP)FOSJRVFA transação tributária como expressão dos direitos do cidadão.3FDJGF#BHBÎPQ "EJTDJQMJOBEBUSBOTBÎÍPOPBOUJHP$ØEJHP$JWJMÏTJNJMBSËBUVBMJODMVTJWFFNSFMBÎÍPËMJNJUBÎÍPEB USBOTBÎÍPBPTEJSFJUPTQBUSJNPOJBJTBSU $G30%3*(6&44ÓMWJP&ODJDMPQÏEJB4BSBJWBEP%JSFJUP7PMVNFQ4ÍP1BVMP&E4BSBJWB BQVE$"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias. 4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 324 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos &NSFTVNPOÍPTFQPEFEFJYBSEFSFDPOIFDFSBPMFHJTMBEPSUSJCVUÈSJP BVUPOPNJBEFRVBMJmDBÎÍPOPTMJNJUFTEPRVBOUPPPSEFOBNFOUPBVUP SJ[F<>"TQSPQSJFEBEFTEFVNNFTNPGBUPEBWJEBQPEFNTFSDPMIJ EBTTFHVOEPPTEJWFSTPTJOUFSFTTFT<>%FWFSBTOBEBJNQFEFRVFBMFJ NBTOVODBPJOUÏSQSFUFFNBUPTEFBQMJDBÎÍPQPTTBEBSRVBMJmDBÎÜFT NBJTBNQMBTPVNBJTSFTUSJUBTBDPODFJUPTJOTUJUVUPTFGPSNBTKÈSFHVMB EPTFNPVUSPTSBNPTEPEJSFJUP /FTTFDPOUFYUPPOPTTPPSEFOBNFOUPUSJCVUÈSJPqualificouPJOTUJUVUPEBUSBO TBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOPTTFHVJOUFTUFSNPTB GPSNBEFFYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB $5/"SU*** C BDPSEPFOUSFTVKFJUPTBUJWPFQBTTJWPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB QBSBQÙSmNBMJUÓHJPOÍPQBSBQSFWFOJMP NFEJBOUFDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBT$5/ "SU FD FYJHFMFJRVFBBVUPSJ[FEPFOUFUSJCVUBOUF OPTMJNJUFTFDPOEJÎÜFT RVFFTUBCFMFÎB$5/"SU $PNBTNVUBÎÜFTTPGSJEBTBUSBOTBÎÍPOPÉNCJUPUSJCVUÈSJPQBSUJDVMBSJ[PV TF/ÍPPCTUBOUFIBWFS BDPSEP FOUSF BT QBSUFT OÍP IÈ BVUPOPNJB EF WPOUBEF )È disposiçãoOPTUFSNPTDPOEJÎÜFTFMJNJUFTQSFWJTUPTFNMFJ 2.1. Fundamento de validade /P&TUBEP%FNPDSÈUJDPEF%JSFJUPUPEBOPSNBUFNGVOEBNFOUPFPSJHFN OPTDPNBOEPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT PV TFKB B OPSNBEF RVBMRVFS IJFSBSRVJB CVTDB TFV GVOEBNFOUPÞMUJNPEFWBMJEBEFOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM /ÍPQPEFSJBTFSEJGFSFOUFDPNBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB O poder jurídicoEFFYJHJSUSJCVUPEPDJEBEÍPUSBOTmHVSBTFFNcompetência tributáriaRVFTVSHFEPHSBOEFFTPCFSBOPBKVTUFEBTPDJFEBEFCSBTJMFJSBFNUPSOPEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP EB3FQÞCMJDBRVFDPOGFSFBPTFOUFTQPMÓUJDPTQPSNFJPEFMFJFQBSBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEPTmOTQPS FMBTPDJFEBEFFTUBUVÓEPTBGBDVMEBEFEFJOTUJUVJSQSFTUBÎÜFTQFDVOJÈSJBTDPNQVMTØSJBT ² BTTFOUF B DPNQSFFOTÍP EF RVF B DPNQFUÐODJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBM USJCVUÈSJB QBSBDSJBSUSJCVUPTUBNCÏNJNQPSUBFNDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBQBSBexoneraçãoUPUBM PVQBSDJBMEPTNFTNPTUSJCVUPT"PCTFSWBÎÍPEF3PRVF"OUPOJP$BSSB[[BTJOUFUJ[B CFNFTTFFOUFOEJNFOUP 0RVFRVFSFNPTTJHOJmDBSÏRVFRVFNQPEFUSJCVUBSQPEFEPNFTNP NPEPBVNFOUBSPUSJCVUPNJOPSÈMPQBSDFMBSTFVQBHBNFOUPJTFOUÈ 5¼33&4)FMFOPDireito Tributário e Direito Privado: autonomia privada, simulação, elisão tributária.4ÍP 1BVMP35Q $G$"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPTCurso de direito tributário4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 325 MP OP UPEP PV FN QBSUF SFNJMP BOJTUJBS BT JOGSBÎÜFT mTDBJT PV BUÏ OÍPUSJCVUBSPCTFSWBEBTTFNQSFÏDMBSPBTEJSFUSJ[FTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJT 5VEPWBJEFQFOEFSEFVNBEFDJTÍPQPMÓUJDBBTFSUPNBEBQFMBQSØQSJB FOUJEBEFUSJCVUBOUF 0UFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBCSJHBJOÞNFSPTFYFNQMPTEFFYPOFSBÎÍP7* f***"SUf**"SUf9"SUf TFOEPVNEPTNBJT JMVTUSBUJWPTP"SUf "SU f $' 2VBMRVFS TVCTÓEJP PV JTFOÎÍP SFEVÎÍP EF CBTF EF DÈMDVMPDPODFTTÍPEFDSÏEJUPQSFTVNJEPBOJTUJBPVSFNJTTÍPSFMBUJWPTB JNQPTUPTUBYBTPVDPOUSJCVJÎÜFTTØQPEFSÈTFSDPODFEJEPNFEJBOUFMFJ FTQFDÓmDBGFEFSBMFTUBEVBMPVNVOJDJQBMRVFSFHVMFFYDMVTJWBNFOUFBT NBUÏSJBTBDJNBFOVNFSBEBTPVPDPSSFTQPOEFOUFUSJCVUPPVDPOUSJCVJÎÍP TFNQSFKVÓ[PEPEJTQPTUPOP"SUf9**HHSJGPOPTTP " USBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB BJOEB RVF OÍP mHVSF FYQSFTTBNFOUF EP EJTQPTJUJWP SFUSPDJUBEPQPSQPEFSJNQMJDBSBMHVNBGPSNBEFFYPOFSBÎÍPFODPOUSBTFVGVOEB NFOUPEFWBMJEBEFOBDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBEBQFTTPBQPMÓUJDBQBSBDSJBSFDPOTF RVFOUFNFOUFQBSBEJTQPSEPTUSJCVUPTNFEJBOUFMFJFTQFDÓmDBEPFOUFUSJCVUBOUFF OPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUP"SUfEB$' 3. TRANSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA E REGIME DE DIREITO PÚBLICO 0BQBSFOUFQBSBEPYPFOUSFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFUSBOTJHJSFPQSJODÓQJPEBJO EJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPNFSFDFTFSFOGSFOUBEPQBSBRVFTFKBNBGBTUBEBT EÞWJEBTTPCSFBMFHJUJNJEBEFEPJOTUJUVUPOBTFBSBUSJCVUÈSJB 0 %JSFJUP 1ÞCMJDP TF PDVQB EPT JOUFSFTTFT EB TPDJFEBEF DPNP VN UPEP JOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP DVKPBUFOEJNFOUPÏVNEFWFSKVSÓEJDPJOFTDVTÈWFM²P&TUBEP RVFNKVSJEJDBNFOUFFODBSOBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP"BVUPOPNJBEBWPOUBEFEBFT TÐODJBEPEJSFJUPQSJWBEPÏBGBTUBEBFTVCTUJUVÓEBQFMBJEFJBEFGVOÎÍPEFEFWFS EFBUFOEJNFOUPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP"GVOÎÍPQÞCMJDBOP&TUBEP%FNPDSÈUJDP EF%JSFJUPÏQPSUBOUPBBUJWJEBEFFYFSDJEBOPDVNQSJNFOUPEPEFWFSEFBMDBO ÎBSPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPNFEJBOUFPVTPEPTQPEFSFTJOTUSVNFOUBJTDPOGFSJEPTQFMB PSEFNQÞCMJDB $"33";;"3PRVF"OUPOJPCurso de Direito Constitucional Tributário4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFCurso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQF RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 326 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos 0SFHJNFEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPTFRVBMJmDBFEFMJNJUBFNGVOÎÍPEBDPOTBHSBÎÍP EFEPJTQSJODÓQJPT TVQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPF JOEJT QPOJCJMJEBEFQFMBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPT 3.1. Supremacia do interesse público "TVQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPQSPDMBNBBTVQFSJPSJEBEF EPJOUFSFTTFEBDPMFUJWJEBEFQFMPQPTUVMBEPEBTVBQSFWBMÐODJBDPNPDPOEJÎÍPEF TPCSFWJWÐODJBFBTTFHVSBNFOUPEBDPMFUJWJEBEFFEPQSØQSJPQBSUJDVMBS %FTUFQSJODÓQJPEFDPSSFB BQPTJÎÍPQSJWJMFHJBEBEPØSHÍPOBTSFMBÎÜFTDPN PTQBSUJDVMBSFTQSJWJMÏHJPTBUSJCVÓEPTQFMBPSEFNKVSÓEJDB FC BQPTJÎÍPEFTVQSF NBDJBEPØSHÍPOBTSFMBÎÜFTDPNPTQBSUJDVMBSFTQPTJÎÍPEFBVUPSJEBEF "T QSFSSPHBUJWBT EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP MJNJUBNTF FN SB[ÍP EB GVOÎÍP QÞCMJDB FYFSDJEBQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP"QFOBTBmOBMJEBEFEFBUJOHJNFOUPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP MFHJUJNBUBJTQSFSSPHBUJWBTEFUBMTPSUFRVFTÍPDPODFCJEBTQFMBNFMIPSEPVUSJOBDPNP EFWFSFTQPEFSFTEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFYQSFTTÍPRVFFOGBUJ[BBTVCPSEJOBÎÍPEPQPEFSBP EFWFSEFBUFOEJNFOUPBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP4FVNBOFKPQPSUBOUPTPNFOUFQPEFTFS DPOTJEFSBEPMFHÓUJNPRVBOEPWJTFBPBMDBODFEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTOVODBBPTJOUFSFT TFTPVDPOWFOJÐODJBTEPBQBSFMIPFTUBUBMFBJOEBNFOPTEPTBHFOUFTHPWFSOBNFOUBJT 3.2. Indisponibilidade, pela administração, do interesse público /B"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPPTCFOTFJOUFSFTTFTOÍPTFBDIBNFOUSFHVFTËMJWSFEJTQP TJÎÍPEBWPOUBEFEPBENJOJTUSBEPS""ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOÍPUJUVMBSJ[BJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJ DPT0UJUVMBSÏP&TUBEPRVFNBOJGFTUBBTVBWPOUBEFQFMBPSEFNMFHBMOPTMJNJUFT EPPSEFOBNFOUP ²BTTFOUFPFOUFOEJNFOUPEFRVFRVBMRVFSBUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPRVFTFEFTFO DPOUSFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTFSÈOFDFTTBSJBNFOUFJOWÈMJEPSB[ÍPEBJNQPSUÉODJBEF BMDBOÎBSTFBOPÎÍPKVSÓEJDBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP 0JOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPÏBEJNFOTÍPQÞCMJDBEPTJOUFSFTTFTJOEJWJEVBJTEPJO UFSFTTFEFDBEBJOEJWÓEVPFORVBOUPQBSUÓDJQFEBTPDJFEBEFOJTUPTFBCSJHBOEPPEF QØTJUP JOUFSUFNQPSBM EFTUFT NFTNPT JOUFSFTTFT DPOTJEFSBEPT FN TVB DPOUJOVJEBEF IJTUØSJDBUFOEPFNWJTUBBATVDFTTJWJEBEFEBTHFSBÎÜFTEFTFVTOBDJPOBJT $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF*CJEFNQ $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF*CJEFNQ $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF*CJEFNQ $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFCurso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 327 "DPODSFUBJOEJWJEVBÎÍPEPTEJWFSTPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTdepende de sua qualificação como interesse público pelo próprio ordenamento positivo2VFNQSPNPWFFTTB RVBMJmDBÎÍPÏB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFBQBSUJSEFMBP&TUBEPQSJNFJSBNFOUFQFMPTØSHÍPT MFHJTMBUJWPTFEFQPJTQFMPTØSHÍPTBENJOJTUSBUJWPTOPTDBTPTFMJNJUFTEFEJTDSJDJPOB SJFEBEFRVFBMFJMIFTUFOIBDPOGFSJEP "QFTBSEFUPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTFSJOUFSFTTFEP&TUBEPOFNUPEPJOUFSFTTF EP&TUBEPÏQÞCMJDP 0Tinteresses públicos primáriosTÍPPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUPT 4ÍPPTJOUFSFTTFTEBDPMFUJWJEBEFDPNPVNUPEPBTTJNRVBMJmDBEPTQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP FBQBSUJSEFMBP&TUBEPQFMBTVBGVOÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWBFBENJOJTUSBUJWBOPTMJNJUFTEBMFJ 0Tinteresses secundáriosTÍPBRVFMFTRVFP&TUBEPQPEFUFSQFMPGBUPEFTFS TVKFJUP EF EJSFJUPT DPNP RVBMRVFS PVUSB QFTTPB /ÍP TÍP JOUFSFTTFT QÞCMJDPT NBT JOUFSFTTFTJOEJWJEVBJTEP&TUBEPTJNJMBSFTBPTJOUFSFTTFTEPTQBSUJDVMBSFTNBTOÍP JHVBJTQPJTP&TUBEPDPODFCJEPQBSBBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPNFOUFQP EFSÈEFGFOEFSTFVTQSØQSJPTJOUFSFTTFTQSJWBEPTTFDPJODJEFOUFTDPNBSFBMJ[BÎÍPEP JOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQSJNÈSJP 0TJOUFSFTTFTTFDVOEÈSJPTiOÍPSFTQPOEFNËSB[ÍPÞMUJNBEFFYJTUJSQSØQSJB EBTQFTTPBTHPWFSOBNFOUBJTFNHFSBMw4ÍPQPSÏNFOÍPNFOPTJNQPSUBOUFinstrumentaisBPBMDBODFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPOBNFEJEBFNRVFBOPSNBEPOEFEFnVFN BTTJNPTRVBMJmDB 3.3. Indisponibilidade do interesse público e transação tributária %FDPSSFEPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPRVFPBENJ OJTUSBEPSOÍPUFNQPEFSEFEJTQPTJÎÍPEFTTFJOUFSFTTFDBCFOEPBQFOBTHFSJMPOPT UFSNPTFTUSJUPTEBMFJ2VFNUFNPQPEFSEFEJTQPSEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPÏP&TUBEP TFVUJUVMBSRVBOEPFYFSDFGVOÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWBTFHVOEPPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUP /FTTFTFOUJEPPNFTUSF)FMZ-PQFT.FJSFMMFT 0QSJODÓQJPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPFTUÈJOUJNBNFOUFMJHBEPBPEBmOBMJEB EF"QSJNB[JBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPÏJOFSFOUFËBUVBÎÍP FTUBUBMFEPNJOBBOBNFEJEBFNRVFBFYJTUÐODJBEP&TUBEPKVTUJmDBTF QFMBCVTDBEPJOUFSFTTFHFSBM $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFCurso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFCurso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFAtos Administrativos e Direitos dos Administrados4ÍP1BVMP&E 35QBQVE.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BV MP.BMIFJSPTQ $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFCurso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 328 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos %FMFEFDPSSFPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTFHVO EPPRVBMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBOÍPQPEFEJTQPSEFTTFJOUFSFTTFHFSBM OFNSFOVODJBSBQPEFSFTRVFBMFJMIFEFVQBSBUBMUVUFMBNFTNPQPSRVFFMB OÍPÏUJUVMBSEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPDVKPUJUVMBSÏP&TUBEPRVFQPSJTTPNF EJBOUFMFJQPEFSÈBVUPSJ[BBEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFPVBSFOÞODJBHSJGPOPTTP 0EFTEPCSBNFOUPEPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPFN SFMBÎÍPËUSJCVUBÎÍPÏBOFDFTTJEBEFBCTPMVUBEFMFJQBSBRVFPBENJOJTUSBEPSUSJCVUÈ SJPQPTTBSFNJUJSUSBOTJHJSDPNQFOTBSPVEJTQPSEFCFOTEP&TUBEP²PRVFFOUFOEF 1BVMPEF#BSSPT$BSWBMIP 0TJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTTÍPJOBQSPQSJÈWFJT0UJUVMBSEPØSHÍPBENJOJT USBUJWPJODVNCJEPEFSFQSFTFOUÈMPTOÍPUFNQPEFSEFEJTQPTJÎÍPIB WFOEPEFHFSJMPTOBNBJTFTUSFJUBDPOGPSNJEBEFEPRVFQSFDFJUVBBMFJ "EJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTFTUÈQFSNBOFOUFNFOUFSFUJEB OP ÉNCJUP EP &TUBEP RVF B NBOJQVMB EF NPEP TPCFSBOP FYFSDJUBO EPBTVBGVOÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWB$PSPMÈSJPEFTTFQSJODÓQJPOPUFSSFOPEPT USJCVUPT Ï B QSFNÐODJB BCTPMVUB EF MFJ FN UPEB B DJSDVOTUÉODJB FN RVF P BENJOJTUSBEPS USJCVUÈSJP DBCF SFNJUJS EÏCJUPT USBOTJHJS FGFUVBS DPNQFOTBÎÜFTPVMJEBSEFBMHVNNPEPDPNBUJUVMBSJEBEFEFCFOTPV JOUFSFTTFTEP&SÈSJPHSJGPOPTTP 1BSB3FHJOB)FMFOB$PTUBPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFTFJNQÜFBPMFHJT MBEPSFBPBENJOJTUSBEPSQSJODJQBMNFOUFOPUSBUPEFJOTUJUVUPTRVFJNQMJRVFNNBOFKP EPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPDPNPJTFOÎÍPDPNQFOTBÎÍPUSBOTBÎÍPSFNJTTÍPFBOJTUJB 0TBVUPSFTDJUBEPTSFDPOIFDFNDPNBDFSUPOBFYJHÐODJBEFMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSB QBSBBUSBOTBÎÍPBBmSNBÎÍPEPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP OÍPFODPOUSBOEPØCJDFËBQMJDBÎÍPEPJOTUJUVUPËTFBSBUSJCVUÈSJB 0QSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPTCFOTQÞCMJDPTJNQÜFTFKBOFDFTTÈSJB QSFWJTÍPOPSNBUJWBQBSBRVFBBVUPSJEBEFDPNQFUFOUFQPTTBFOUSBSOP SFHJNFEFDPODFTTÜFTNÞUVBTRVFÏEBFTTÐODJBEBUSBOTBÎÍP &OUSFUBOUPBPCKFÎÍPRVFGFSJSJBPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEP JOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP OÍPOPTQBSFDFWÈMJEBVNBWF[RVFBUSBOTBÎÍPOFTTF .&*3&--&4)FMZ-PQFTDireito Administrativo Brasileiro4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPTCurso de Direito Tributário4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ $G$045"3FHJOB)FMFOBCurso de Direito Tributário: Constituição e Código Tributário Nacional4ÍP 1BVMP4BSBJWBQ $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT. Curso de direito tributário.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 329 DPOUFYUPTPNFOUFQPEFSÈTFSFGFUVBEBPCTFSWBEPTPTQBSÉNFUSPTmYBEPT OB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFOBMFJFNDPOTPOÉODJBDPNPBMVEJEPQSJODÓQJP "VUÐOUJDP JOTUSVNFOUP EF QSBUJDBCJMJEBEF USJCVUÈSJB QPS WF[FT B USBOTBÎÍP SFWFMBSTFÈ NBJT WBOUBKPTB BP JOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDP EP RVF P QSPMPOHBNFOUPPVFUFSOJ[BÎÍPEPDPOnJUP 3FTTBMUFTFBJOEBBOBUVSF[BJOTUSVNFOUBMEBUSJCVUBÎÍP.VJUPTEPVUSJOBEP SFTTVTUFOUBNRVFPUSJCVUPJOUFHSBBDBUFHPSJBEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPT TFDVOEÈSJPT PVJOTUSVNFOUBJT EP&TUBEPPTRVBJTQPEFNTFSEJTQPTUPTTFNQSFQPSJOUFSNÏEJP EFMFJOPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUPOBQFSTFDVÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTQSJNÈSJPT JOEJTQPOÓWFJT 4. TRANSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA E CONTORNO TRAÇADO PELA NORMA GERAL DO ARTIGO 171 DO CTN 0"SU***CEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEJTDJQMJOBRVFDPNQFUFËMFJDPN QMFNFOUBSFTUBCFMFDFS/03."4(&3"*4FNNBUÏSJBEFMFHJTMBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFTQF DJBMNFOUFTPCSFPCSJHBÎÍPMBOÎBNFOUPDSÏEJUPQSFTDSJÎÍPFEFDBEÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJPT 0$ØEJHP5SJCVUÈSJP/BDJPOBM-FJOEF SFDFQDJPOBEP DPNPMFJDPNQMFNFOUBSÏVNEPTQSJODJQBJTJOTUSVNFOUPTOPSNBUJWPTRVFWFJDVMBN /03."4(&3"*4FNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBOPUBEBNFOUFFNSFMBÎÍPBPOBTDJNFOUPFË FYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB 0"SU***EP$5/FOVNFSBBUSBOTBÎÍPDPNPVNBEBTGPSNBTEFFY UJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB0"SUEP$5/EÈPNPMEFFNRVFBUSBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBTFSÈQFSNJUJEBFWBMJEBEBQFMPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPCSBTJMFJSP /ÍP IÈ EÞWJEB QPSUBOUP EF RVF PT BSUJHPT F EP $5/ WFJDVMBN /03."4(&3"*4RVFPCSJHBNBUPEPTPTFOUFTQPMÓUJDPTJNQPOEPMJNJUFTBPFYFS DÓDJPEBTVBDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJB %JTQÜFNPTBSUJHPTFNDPNFOUP $5/"SUJHPo"MFJQPEFGBDVMUBSOBTDPOEJÎÜFTRVFFTUBCFMFÎB BPT TVKFJUPT BUJWP F QBTTJWP EB PCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB DFMFCSBS USBOTBÎÍP RVFNFEJBOUFDPODFTTÜFTNÞUVBTJNQPSUFFNEFUFSNJOBÎÍPEFMJUÓHJP FDPOTFRVFOUFFYUJOÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP $045"3FHJOB)FMFOBCurso de Direito Tributário: Constituição e Código Tributário Nacional4ÍP1BVMP 4BSBJWBQ 0UFNBTFSÈBCPSEBEPOP$BQÓUVMP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 330 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos 1BSÈHSBGPÞOJDP"MFJJOEJDBSÈBBVUPSJEBEFDPNQFUFOUFQBSBBVUPSJ[BS BUSBOTBÎÍPFNDBEBDBTP $5/"SUJHP&YUJOHVFNPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP ***oBUSBOTBÎÍP "QBSUJSEBMFJUVSBEBOPSNBHFSBMDVNQSFFYBNJOBSPTFMFNFOUPTFTTFODJBJT EBUSBOTBÎÍPOPÉNCJUPEP%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPCSBTJMFJSPEPTRVBJTOÍPQPEFTFBGBTUBS PMFHJTMBEPSPSEJOÈSJP 4.1. Transação tributária e faculdade do ente político "OPSNBHFSBMEP"SUEP$5/DPOGFSFVNBfaculdadeiBMFJpodew BP FOUFUSJCVUBOUFQBSBQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEFMFJBVUPSJ[BSBDFMFCSBÎÍPEFUSBOTBÎÍPQFMPT TVKFJUPTBUJWPFQBTTJWPEFPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOBTDPOEJÎÜFTFMJNJUFTRVFFTUBCFMFÎB "OPSNBHFSBMBCSJVFTQBÎPQBSBBPQÎÍPQPMÓUJDBoQSÏWJBFOFDFTTÈSJBoBPFYFS DÓDJPEBDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBEFiEJTQPSwEPUSJCVUPQFMPJOTUJUVUPEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB %FOUSPEP&TUBEP%FNPDSÈUJDPEF%JSFJUPBGVOÎÍPQPMÓUJDBUSBEV[TFFNiniciativasFNopções de governoFNescolhasRVFJSÍPJOnVJSFJOnVFODJBSUPEBBTPDJFEBEF 0 FOUF QPMÓUJDP QPSUBOUP QPS EJTQPTJÎÍP FYQSFTTB EB OPSNB HFSBM OÍP Ï PCSJHBEPBJOTUJUVJSBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQPEFOEPOPFOUBOUPBRVBMRVFSUFNQP EFQFOEFOUF TFNQSF EF VNB PQÎÍP QPMÓUJDB TVB BVUPSJ[BS B USBOTBÎÍP NFEJBOUF P exercícioEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJBMFHJTMBUJWB 1PSDPOTFRVÐODJBBUSBOTBÎÍPGBDVMUBEBOPBSUEP$5/QPSTJTØOÍP HFSBBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPËDFMFCSBÎÍPEFBDPSEP %FPVUSPUVSOPDBTPPFOUFQPMÓUJDPopteQPSBVUPSJ[BSBUSBOTBÎÍPWFJDVMBO EPMFJQFSNJTTJWBPBDPSEPTFSÈUBNCÏNVNBGBDVMEBEFDPOGFSJEBBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWP iBMFJQPEFfacultar BPTTVKFJUPTBUJWPFpassivow BRVFNDPNQFUFWPMVOUBSJBNFOUF BEFSJSFDPNQSPWBSPQSFFODIJNFOUPEBTDPOEJÎÜFTQSÏFTUBCFMFDJEBT"PBENJOJTUSB EPSUSJCVUÈSJPOFTUFDBTPDVNQSJSÈBOBMJTBSPFGFUJWPQSFFODIJNFOUPEBTDPOEJÎÜFT FYJHJEBTOBMFJQFSNJTTJWBFDBTPQSFFODIJEBTDFMFCSBSBUSBOTBÎÍP 4.2. Transação tributária e lei permissiva "OPSNBHFSBMEP"SUEP$5/FYJHFiMFJwQBSBRVFPFOUFQPMÓUJDPBVUPSJ[F BUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFYJHÐODJBSFGPSÎBEBQFMBOPSNBHFSBMEP"SU7*EP$5/ $G%*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBDireito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP"UMBTQ $5/BSU4PNFOUFBMFJQPEFFTUBCFMFDFS RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 331 /ÍPÏEFNBJTSFQJTBSRVFTPNFOUFPFOUFQPMÓUJDPDPNQFUFOUFQBSBJOTUJUVJSP USJCVUPÏPDPNQFUFOUFQBSBEJTQPSEFMFJODMVTJWFQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB " SFQBSUJÎÍP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EF DPNQFUÐODJBT OPUBEBNFOUF B DPNQFUÐODJB USJCVUÈSJB Ï EB FTTÐODJB EP QBDUP GFEFSBUJWP F EB BVUPOPNJB NVOJDJQBM F EJTUSJUBM DPOTBHSBEPTDPNPQSJODÓQJPTJOUBOHÓWFJTBPDPOTUJUVJOUFEFSJWBEP 2VFNUFNDPNQFUÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM QBSBUSJCVUBSPVTFKBDSJBSVOJMBUF SBMNFOUFEFUFSNJOBEPUSJCVUPOBEJTDJQMJOBFOPTMJNJUFTUSBÎBEPTOBQSØQSJB$POT UJUVJÎÍP UFN DPNQFUÐODJB QSJWBUJWB QBSB EP NFTNP NPEP BVNFOUBS P USJCVUP NJOPSÈMPJTFOUÈMPOPUPEPPVFNQBSUFPVOÍPUSJCVUBS5VEPWBJEFQFOEFSNBJT VNBWF[EFVNBEFDJTÍPQPMÓUJDBEPFOUFUSJCVUBOUF /ÍPCBTUBRVFPFOUFQPMÓUJDPDPNQFUFOUFQBSBDSJBSPUSJCVUPBVUPSJ[FBUSBO TBÎÍPQPSNFJPEFMFJBMFJEFWFTFSespecífica. 1PSFYJHÐODJBEP"SUfEB$'OBTIJQØUFTFTFNRVFIBKBDPODFTTÍP EFJODFOUJWPTFCFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJTRVFJNQMJRVFNBMHVNUJQPEFFYPOFSBÎÍPFOUSFFMFT TVCTÓEJPTJTFOÎÜFTSFEVÎÜFTEFCBTFEFDÈMDVMPDPODFTTÜFTEFDSÏEJUPQSFTVNJEP BOJTUJBTFSFNJTTÜFTTVBPVUPSHBEFWFSÈTFSGFJUBQPSMFJespecífica. "P FYJHJS lei específica P EJTQPTJUJWP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM WJTB B JNQFEJS RVF CF OFGÓDJPTPVJODFOUJWPTmTDBJTEFRVBMRVFSPSEFNTFKBNDPODFEJEPTOPCPKPEFMFJT UPUBMNFOUFFTUSBOIBTËNBUÏSJBDPNPGPSNBEFPDVMUBSGBWPSFDJNFOUPTFQSJWJMÏHJPT DPOUSÈSJPTBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP $PNPPOÞDMFPEBTDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBTQPEFSÈFOWPMWFSJODFOUJWPTPVCF OFGÓDJPTmTDBJTRVFJNQMJRVFNBMHVNUJQPEFFYPOFSBÎÍPBFYJHÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM EFMFJFTQFDÓmDBÏUBNCÏNBQMJDÈWFMËUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB 1PSPVUSPMBEPFNSFMBÎÍPBPTEFTUJOBUÈSJPTEBOPSNBBMFJEFUSBOTBÎÍPQPEFSÈ TFSHFSBMPVTFKBEJSJHJEBBUPEPTPTTVKFJUPTQBTTJWPTin abstratoRVFQSFFODIBNBTDPOEJ ÎÜFTOFMBFTUBCFMFDJEBTFQPEFSÈTFSFTQFDÓmDBOPTFOUJEPEFTFSEJSJHJEBBEFUFSNJOBEP DPOUSJCVJOUFFPVËEFUFSNJOBEBTJUVBÎÍPTFNQSFDPNWJTUBTBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP 4.3. Sujeitos da transação tributária 0 BSU EP $5/ FTUBCFMFDF RVF BQFOBT PT TVKFJUPT BUJWP F QBTTJWP EB PCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB QPEFN DFMFCSBS USBOTBÎÍP FYDMVÓEP QPSUBOUP RVBMRVFS PVUSP VI oBTIJQØUFTFTEFFYDMVTÍPTVTQFOTÍPFFYUJOÎÍPEFDSÏEJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTPVEFEJTQFOTBPVSFEVÎÍPEF QFOBMJEBEFT /PPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPCSBTJMFJSPBcompetência tributáriaÏVNUFNBFYDMVTJWBNFOUFDPOTUJUVDJPOBM FTHPUBEPQFMPDPOTUJUVJOUF&OUSFBTTVBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTFODPOUSBTFBQSJWBUJWJEBEFPVTFKBDBEBFOUF QPMÓUJDPQPTTVJGBJYBTUSJCVUÈSJBTQSJWBUJWBTRVFFYDMVFNBVUPNBUJDBNFOUFBDPNQFUÐODJBEPTEFNBJT FOUFTQPMÓUJDPT$G$"33";;"3PRVF"OUPOJPCurso de Direito Constitucional Tributário4ÍP1BVMP 35QF $G$"33";;"3PRVF"OUPOJPCurso de Direito Constitucional Tributário4ÍP1BVMP35Q RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 332 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos JOUFSFTTBEPRVFOÍPQPTTBmHVSBSFNVNBEFTTBTQPTJÎÜFT/JTTPHVBSEBQBSBMFMP DPNPEJSFJUPQSJWBEPRVFSFTUSJOHFBUSBOTBÎÍPBPDSFEPSFBPEFWFEPSEBPCSJHBÎÍP $$"SU 4ÍPFMFNFOUPTEFmOJEPSFTEBFTUSVUVSBCÈTJDBEFRVBMRVFSSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDB PTVKFJUPBUJWPUJUVMBSEPEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEFRVFNTFQPEFFYJHJS EFUFSNJOBEBQSFTUBÎÍPFPPCKFUPDFOUSPEFDPOWFSHÐODJBEPEJSFJUPFEPEFWFS /BTSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDBTUSJCVUÈSJBTTÍPFODPOUSBEPTEPJTUJQPTEFSFMBÎÍPKV SÓEJDBBTQBUSJNPOJBJTPCSJHBÎÍP QSFWJTUBTOBSFHSBNBUSJ[EFJODJEÐODJBFBTRVF GB[FNJSSPNQFSNFSPTEFWFSFTBENJOJTUSBUJWPT "SFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBUSJCVUÈSJBFTUÈQSFTDSJUBOPDPOTFRVFOUFOPSNBUJWPEBSF HSBNBUSJ[EFJODJEÐODJBKVOUBNFOUFDPNTFVTTVKFJUPTFTFVPCKFUPFEFDPSSFEP BDPOUFDJNFOUPin concretoEPGBUPEFTDSJUPIJQPUFUJDBNFOUFOPBOUFDFEFOUFEBOPSNB 0 TVKFJUP BUJWP EB SFMBÎÍP KVSÓEJDB USJCVUÈSJB Ï B QFTTPB UJUVMBS EP EJSFJUP TVCKFUJWPEFFYJHJSBQSFTUBÎÍPQFDVOJÈSJBOPTOFYPTPCSJHBDJPOBJTFOÍPQFDVOJÈSJB PVJOTVTDFQUÓWFMEFBWBMJBÎÍPFDPOÙNJDBOBTSFMBÎÜFTRVFWFJDVMBNNFSPTEFWFSFT JOTUSVNFOUBJTPVGPSNBJT 0"SUEP$5/SFTUSJOHFJOEFWJEBNFOUFBmHVSBEPTVKFJUPBUJWPËQFTTPB KVSÓEJDBEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPUJUVMBSEBDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBQBSBDSJBSPUSJCVUP0 EJTQPTJUJWPÏJODPNQMFUPEJBOUFEPTNBOEBNFOUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTRVFBVUPSJ[BNËT QFTTPBTQPMÓUJDBTUJUVMBSFTEBDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBJOEFMFHÈWFM BUSBOTGFSÐODJBEB DBQBDJEBEFBUJWBEFMFHÈWFM BFOUFTQÞCMJDPTPVQSJWBEPTRVFQBTTBNBmHVSBSDPNP TVKFJUPBUJWPEPWÓODVMPPCSJHBDJPOBMUFOEPPEJSFJUPEFFYJHJSFBSSFDBEBSBQSFTUBÎÍP EFWJEBQFMPTVKFJUPQBTTJWP0DPODFJUPEFTVKFJUPBUJWPQPSUBOUPEFWFJSBMÏNEP EJTQPTJUJWPEP$5/BCSBÎBOEPPDPMPSJEPRVFMIFFNQSFTUBPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM &N TVNB TFSÈ TVKFJUP BUJWP EB PCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB F QPS DPOTFRVÐODJB EBUSBOTBÎÍPBQFTTPBQPMÓUJDBEPUBEBEBDPNQFUÐODJBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMUSJCVUÈSJBQBSB DSJBS P USJCVUP P EJSFJUP EF FYJHJS OFTUF DBTP Ï DPOTFRVÐODJB ØCWJB EP EJSFJUP EF JOTUJUVJS PVBRVFNTFHVOEPBTSFHSBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTFEFTJHOBEPOBSFHSBNBUSJ[ EFJODJEÐODJBGPSUSBOTGFSJEPPEJSFJUPEFBSSFDBEBSFmTDBMJ[BSPVTFKBEFFYFSDFSB DBQBDJEBEFUSJCVUÈSJBBUJWB $G$"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT. Curso de direito tributário.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ 3FHJOB)FMFOB$PTUBDPODFJUVBIJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJBPVSFHSBNBUSJ[EFJODJEÐODJBFEFTUBDBPTTFVT FMFNFOUPTDPOTUJUVUJWPTi&OUFOEFTFQPSIJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBBEFTDSJÎÍPMFHJTMBUJWBEFVN GBUPRVFVNBWF[BDPOUFDJEPFOTFKBPOBTDJNFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB<>5SBUBTFQPSUBOUPEFVNB TJUVBÎÍPGÈUJDBBQPOUBEBOBMFJDPNPBQUBBEFnBHSBSPTVSHJNFOUPEBPCSJHBÎÍPEFQBHBSPUSJCVUP<> "IJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBEFTEPCSBTFFNBOUFDFEFOUFFDPOTFRVFOUF/PBOUFDFEFOUFEFTDSFWF PGBUPBQPOUBOEPBTDPPSEFOBEBTEFFTQBÎPFUFNQPEFTVBPDPSSÐODJB/PDPOTFRVFOUFQSFTDSFWFVNB SFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBEFMBEFDPSSFOUFJOEJDBOEPTFVTTVKFJUPTCFNDPNPTFVPCKFUP1BSBFGFJUPTEJEÈUJDPTB IJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJBQPEFTFSDJOEJEBFNDJODPBTQFDUPTPVDSJUÏSJPTOPBOUFDFEFOUFmHVSBNPTBTQFD UPTNBUFSJBMFTQBDJBMFUFNQPSBMOPDPOTFRVFOUFPTDSJUÏSJPTQFTTPBMFRVBOUJUBUJWP<>wCurso de Direto Tributário – Constituição e Código Tributário Nacional.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ $G$"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT. Curso de direito tributário.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 333 "TTJNDPNPPTVKFJUPBUJWPPTFMFNFOUPTQBSBEFUFSNJOBÎÍPEPTVKFJUPQBT TJWPFTUÍPmYBEPTOBSFHSBNBUSJ[EFJODJEÐODJB 0 TVKFJUP QBTTJWP EFWF FTUBS JOWFTUJEP EF capacidade tributária passiva PV TFKBQPTTVJSBQUJEÍPQBSBmHVSBSOPQPMPQBTTJWPEBSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBUSJCVUÈSJBJOBV HVSBEBDPNBPDPSSÐODJBOPNVOEPGÓTJDPEPGBUPEFTDSJUPOBIJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJB HFSBOEPPEFWFSKVSÓEJDPEFQBHBNFOUPEBQSFTUBÎÍP 5BMBQUJEÍPQSFTTVQÜFTFKBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEPUBEPEFQFSTPOBMJEBEFKVSÓEJ DBOPTUFSNPTFNRVFÏEFmOJEBQFMBMFJDJWJMTPCQFOBEBPCSJHBÎÍPTFUPSOBSJOFYJ HÓWFMiFNGVOÎÍPEBJOBQMJDBCJMJEBEFEFDBEFJBTEFEJTQPTJUJWPTEFEJSFJUPQSPDFTTVBM RVFEÍPTJHOJmDBEPFDPBUJWJEBEFËTBTQJSBÎÜFTGB[FOEÈSJBTw %JTUJOUBÏBcapacidade para praticar o fato jurídico tributárioOPRVBM P MFHJT MBEPSEFOUSPEPTMJNJUFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTÏMJWSFQBSBFMFHFSRVBMRVFSGBUPMÓDJUPEB WJEBFFMFWÈMPBPQBUBNBSEFIJQØUFTFEFJODJEÐODJBDVKBSFBMJ[BÎÍPOPNVOEPGÓTJDP FOTFKBSÈPOBTDJNFOUPEBSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBUSJCVUÈSJBindependentemente da capacidade jurídica de quem o pratique ou dele participe (CTN, Art. 126). 4FNQSFRVFPMFHJTMBEPS QSFUFOEFSJOTDSFWFSOBIJQØUFTFOPSNBUJWBfato praticado por sujeito sem personalidade jurídica EFWFSÈ DVJEBS QBSB JOEJDBS OP DSJUÏSJP QFTTPBM EP DPOTFRVFOUF OPSNBUJWP iQFTTPB GÓTJDB PV KVSÓEJDB FTDPMIJEB OP RVBESP EBRVFMBT QSFWJTUBT F BENJUJEBT OP TFHNFOUPEBTSFHSBTEFEJSFJUPQSJWBEPQBSBPmNEFSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BSPFOUFRVFQSP NPWFVPFWFOUPw33EPUBEBQPSUBOUPEFDBQBDJEBEFUSJCVUÈSJBQBTTJWBTPCQFOBEF DSJBSVNBPCSJHBÎÍPJOFYJHÓWFM $PODMVJOEPOBTFBSBEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQPEFSÈmHVSBSDPNPUSBOTBUPS KVOUBNFOUFDPNPTVKFJUPBUJWPPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBJOEJDBEPOP DSJUÏSJPQFTTPBMEPDPOTFRVFOUFOPSNBUJWPDPNPEFWFEPSEBQSFTUBÎÍPFQPSDPOTF RVÐODJBQPTTVJEPSEFQFSTPOBMJEBEFKVSÓEJDB 4.4. Transação tributária e finalidade terminativa de litígio "OPSNBHFSBMEPBSUEP$5/QSFWÐRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBEFWFSÈ QÙSmNBPMJUÓHJPiA lei pode facultar, nas condições que estabeleça, [...] celebrar transação que, mediante concessões mútuas, importe em determinação do litígio e consequente extinção do crédito tributáriow 33 .BJTQSFDJTBNFOUFOPDSJUÏSJPQFTTPBMEPDPOTFRVFOUFEBSFHSBNBUSJ[EFJODJEÐODJB $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT. Curso de direito tributário.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ 0 "SU EP $5/ VUJMJ[B B FYQSFTTÍP DBQBDJEBEF USJCVUÈSJB FN EPJT TFOUJEPT DBQBDJEBEF QBSB B QSÈUJDBEPGBUPKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJPRVFQSFTDJOEFEFQFSTPOBMJEBEFKVSÓEJDBFDBQBDJEBEFQBSBmHVSBS OPQPMPQBTTJWPEBSFMBÎÍPKVSÓEJDBUSJCVUÈSJBRVFTFJOTUBVSBBQBSUJSEBQSÈUJDBEPGBUPFQBSBBRVBMB QFTTPBEFWFSÈQPTTVJSQFSTPOBMJEBEFKVSÓEJDBOPTUFSNPTEPEJSFJUPDJWJM $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT. Curso de direito tributário.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 334 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos ²DPOTFOTPPFOUFOEJNFOUPEFRVFPMFHJTMBEPSEP$5/DPNFUFVFSSPNBUFSJBM BPMBOÎBSNÍPEBSFEBÎÍPiEFUFSNJOBÎÍPEFMJUÓHJPwFNMVHBSEFiUFSNJOBÎÍPEFMJUÓHJPw 0FRVÓWPDPOBSFEBÎÍPOÍPNBDVMBPTFOUJEPEBOPSNBHFSBMRVFÏDMBSPBUSBOTBÎÍP RVBOEPDFMFCSBEBOBTFBSBUSJCVUÈSJBUFSÈTFNQSFDBSÈUFSSFTPMVUØSJPEFMJUÓHJP "RVJFTUÈVNBEJGFSFOÎBGVOEBNFOUBMFOUSFBUSBOTBÎÍPEPEJSFJUPQSJWBEP FBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOBUSBOTBÎÍPDJWJMPDPOTFOTPWJTBUBOUPBprevenirDPNPB terminarMJUÓHJPTOBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBBQFOBTterminarMJUÓHJPT 4.4.1. Litígio judicial e litígio administrativo "CPBEPVUSJOBDPOTJEFSBDBCÓWFMBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBRVFFOWPMWBMJUÓHJP UBOUPOPÉNCJUPKVEJDJBMRVBOUPOPÉNCJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWP1BSB1BVMPEF#BSSPT$BS WBMIPPFOUFOEJNFOUPNBJTBNQMPOÍPEFTOBUVSBPJOTUJUVUPOFNWBJDPOUSBBSB DJPOBMJEBEFEPTJTUFNBFSFTTBMUBPGBUPEPMFHJTMBEPSEP$5/OÍPUFSQSJNBEPQFMP SJHPSOPTUFSNPTUÏDOJDPT "PDPOUSÈSJPEPRVFTVDFEFOPEJSFJUPDJWJMFNRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUBOUPQSFWJ OFDPNPUFSNJOBPMJUÓHJPOPTRVBESBOUFTEPEJSFJUPUSJCVUÈSJPTØTFBENJUF BUSBOTBÎÍPUFSNJOBUJWB)ÈEFFYJTUJSMJUÓHJPQBSBRVFBTQBSUFTDPNQPOEP TFVTNÞUVPTJOUFSFTTFTUSBOTJKBN"HPSBEJWFSHFNPTBVUPSFTBQSPQØTJUP EBTQSPQPSÎÜFTTFNÉOUJDBTEPWPDÈCVMPMJUÓHJP2VFSFNBMHVOTRVFTFUSBUF EFDPOnJUPEFJOUFSFTTFTEFEV[JEPKVEJDJBMNFOUFBPQBTTPRVFPVUSPTFO UFOEFNBBDFQÎÍPBQPOUPEFBCSBOHFSBTDPOUSPWÏSTJBTNFSBNFOUFBENJ OJTUSBUJWBT&NUFTFDPODPSEBNPTDPNBTFHVOEBBMUFSOBUJWB0MFHJTMBEPS EP$ØEJHPOÍPQSJNPVQFMBSJHPSPTBPCTFSWÉODJBEBTFYQSFTTÜFTUÏDOJDBT FOÍPWFNPTQPSRVFPFOUFOEJNFOUPNBJTMBSHPWJSJBFNEFUSJNFOUPEP JOTUJUVUPPVEBSBDJPOBMJEBEFEPTJTUFNBHSJGPOPTTP /PNFTNPTFOUJEP)VHPEF#SJUP.BDIBEP <>QBSBRVFTFKBQPTTÓWFMBUSBOTBÎÍPOP%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPJNQÜF TFUFOIBTJEPJOTUBVSBEPPMJUÓHJPNBTOÍPIÈEFTFFYJHJSRVFFTUFTF DBSBDUFSJ[FQFMBQSPQPTJUVSBEBBÎÍPKVEJDJBM $ØEJHP$JWJM"SU²MÓDJUPBPTJOUFSFTTBEPTQSFWFOJSFNPVUFSNJOBSFNPMJUÓHJPNFEJBOUFDPODFT TÜFTNÞUVBT $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT. Curso de direito tributário.4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ ."$)"%0)VHPEF#SJUP"5SBOTBÎÍPOP%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJP*O3FWJTUB%JBMÏUJDBEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJP 7PMVNFEF[FNCSPQ4ÍP1BVMP&E%JBMÏUJDBBQVE'*(6&*3&%01BVMP)FOSJRVFA transação tributária como expressão dos direitos do cidadão3FDJGF&EJÎÜFT#BHBÎPQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 335 4.4.2. Litígio e momento de sua instalação $POTJEFSBOEPTF B MJNJUBÎÍP JNQPTUB QFMB OPSNB HFSBM EB mOBMJEBEF EB USBOTBÎÍP ËT IJQØUFTFT EF UFSNJOBÎÍP EF MJUÓHJP RVBM P NPNFOUP FN RVF P MJUÓHJP QPEFTFSDPOTJEFSBEPJOTUBMBEPFOTFKBOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB )VHPEF#SJUP.BDIBEPDPOTJEFSBOFDFTTÈSJPRVFTFUFOIBFTUBCFMFDJEPVNB QFOEÐODJBDPNBBCFSUVSBEFVNQSPDFEJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPQBTTÓWFMEFKVMHBNFO UPQPSØSHÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNQFUFOUFQBSBRVFTFDPOTJEFSFFYJTUFOUFVNlitígio administrativoBVUPSJ[BEPSEFUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB&OUFOEFRVFFTTFNPNFOUPOVN BVUPEFJOGSBÎÍPTFKBPEBSFTQFDUJWBJNQVHOBÎÍPQFMPTVKFJUPQBTTJWP #BTUB RVF UFOIB TJEP JNQVHOBEP QFMP TVKFJUP QBTTJWP EB PCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBVNBVUPEFJOGSBÎÍPDPOUSBPNFTNPMBWSBEP²OFDFTTÈSJP RVFTFUFOIBFTUBCFMFDJEPVNBQFOEÐODJBEBOEPMVHBSËJOTUBVSBÎÍP EF VN QSPDFEJNFOUP BENJOJTUSBUJWP B TFS KVMHBEP QFMP ØSHÍP BENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNQFUFOUF 4FHVJOEPFTTBMJOIBEFFOUFOEJNFOUPGPJFEJUBEBBOPWBMFJQBVMJTUBRVFSF HVMBPQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPUSJCVUÈSJPEFDPSSFOUFEFMBOÎBNFOUPEFPGÓDJP-FJO 0TFVBSUJHPFTUBCFMFDFRVFPiQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPwUFNPSJHFN OBFGFUJWBBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEBEFGFTBQFMPBVUVBEP4PNFOUFBQBSUJSEFTTFNPNFOUP RVBOEPDBSBDUFSJ[BEPOBGPSNBEBMFJFTUBEVBMPMJUÓHJPJOTUBVSBTFPDPOUFODJP TPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNUPEBTBTHBSBOUJBTQSPDFTTVBJTBENJOJTUSBUJWBTBFMFBUJOFOUFT QBTTÓWFMEFBQSFDJBÎÍPQFMPØSHÍPKVMHBEPS O litígio judicialQPSTVBWF[TFHVJOEPPNFTNPSBDJPDÓOJPFTUBSJBJOTUBMBEP DPNBPQPTJÎÍPEFFNCBSHPTBPEFWFEPSOBFYFDVÎÍPmTDBMDPNPQSPDFTTBNFOUP EFFYDFÎÍPEFQSÏFYFDVUJWJEBEFPVDPNPBKVJ[BNFOUPEFBÎÍPBVUÙOPNBWJTBOEPË BMUFSBÎÍPPVBEFTDPOTUJUVJÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍP $MFETPO.PSFJSB(BMJOBSJDPOTJEFSBRVFBFYJTUÐODJBEFlitígio latenteBOUFSJPS ËJNQVHOBÎÍPEPMBOÎBNFOUPna iminência de ser posto à apreciação de uma instância administrativa ou judicialBUFOEFSJBËFYJHÐODJBEBOPSNBHFSBM%FGFOEFPBVUPSRVF TFPMJUÓHJPQVEFSTFSDPOIFDJEPOÍPIÈQPSRVFOFHBSMIFBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFSFTPMV ÎÍPQFMBUSBOTBÎÍP$JUBPFYFNQMPEPBHFOUFmTDBMRVFBOUFTEFRVBMRVFSBVUVBÎÍP ."$)"%0)VHPEF#SJUP"5SBOTBÎÍPOP%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJP*O3FWJTUB%JBMÏUJDBEF%JSFJUP5SJ CVUÈSJP7PMVNFEF[FNCSPQ4ÍP1BVMP&E%JBMÏUJDBBQVE'*(6&*3&%01BVMP )FOSJRVFA transação tributária como expressão dos direitos do cidadão3FDJGF&EJÎÜFT#BHBÎP Q "SUo0QSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWPUSJCVUÈSJPSFHVMBEPQPSFTUBMFJUFNQPSPSJHFNBBQSFTFOUBÎÍPEF EFGFTBFNGBDFEFBVUPEFJOGSBÎÍPMBWSBEPQPS"HFOUF'JTDBMEF3FOEBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 336 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos OPUJmDBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPBBEFRVBSTFBBMHVNBDPOEVUBRVFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFOUFO EFDPSSFUBPGFSFDFOEPMIFBMHVNBWBOUBHFNQSFWJTUBFNMFJ 0FYFNQMPUSB[JEPQFMPBVUPSNVJUPPQPSUVOPÏBOBMJTBEPFNQBSBMFMPDPNBT QSÈUJDBTEFBKVTUBNFOUPEFDPOEVUBFOUSF1PEFS1ÞCMJDPFBENJOJTUSBEPTBNQMBNFOUF BEPUBEBTOBFTGFSBEPEJSFJUPBNCJFOUBMFEPEJSFJUPFDPOÙNJDPEBOEPJOEÓDJPTEBTVB BEFRVBÎÍPQFSBOUFPPSEFOBNFOUP /ÍPFODPOUSBNPTPCTUÈDVMPTQBSBRVFUBJTTJUVBÎÜFTQSÏWJBTËJOTUBVSBÎÍP EPDPOUFODJPTPUSJCVUÈSJPQSPQSJBNFOUFEJUPTFKBNDPOTJEFSBEBTMJUJHJPTBTQBSBPmN EFDFMFCSBSUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBEFTEFRVFDPOUFNQMBEBTOBMFJQFSNJTTJWB 4.4.3. Alcance do litígio na transação tributária 0 MJUÓHJP QSFTTVQÜF EÞWJEB PV JODFSUF[B F DBSBDUFSJ[BTF QFMB DPOUSPWÏSTJB PVQSFUFOTÍPSFTJTUJEB"USBOTBÎÍPMPHJDBNFOUFDPNPTFEFTUJOBBQÙSmNBMJUÓHJP QSFTTVQÜF EÞWJEB F JODFSUF[B TPCSF EJSFJUPT PV TJUVBÎÜFT /ÍP IBWFOEP EÞWJEB PV JODFSUF[B QBTTÓWFM EF DPODFTTÜFT NÞUVBT FTUBSTFJB EJBOUF EF SFNJTTÍP PV BOJTUJB OÍPEFUSBOTBÎÍP 0TFTUVEJPTPTEPUFNBTVTUFOUBNRVFBEÞWJEBPVJODFSUF[BQBTTÓWFMEFUSBO TBÎÍPÏBRVFMBSFTJEFOUFOBTquestões de fato não suficientemente provadasBGBTUBOEPB QPTTJCJMJEBEFEFUSBOTBÎÍPFNSFMBÎÍPËTRVFTUÜFTEFEJSFJUPVNBWF[RVFBPCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBEFDPSSFEFMFJFOÍPQPEFQFMPDPOTFOTPTFSBMUFSBEB 1BSB )FMFOP 5BWFJSB 5ÙSSFT B USBOTBÎÍP FTUBSJB MJNJUBEB BPT DBTPT FN RVF TF SFDPOIFDF FGFUJWB JODFSUF[B HFSBEPSB EF MJUÓHJP OPT RVBJT B "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP QPS TJ QSØ QSJBOÍPQPEFBMDBOÎBSTBUJTGBUPSJBNFOUFVNSFTVMUBEPNBJTDPNQBUÓWFMDPNPQSJODÓQJP JORVJTJUØSJPFEBWFSEBEFNBUFSJBMQSJODÓQJPTPSJFOUBEPSFTEPQSPDFTTPBENJOJTUSBUJWP USJCVUÈSJP"USBOTBÎÍPQPSUBOUPTFSJBBQMJDÈWFMPOEFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOÍPUFNDFSUF[BEB PDPSSÐODJBEPGBUPKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJPPVOBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEPTGBUPTKVSÓEJDPTFTQFDJBMNFO UFOPTDBTPTTVKFJUPTBSFHJNFEFQSFTVOÎÜFTRVBOEPIPVWFSEJmDVMEBEFEFEFNBSDBÎÍP EFDPODFJUPTGÈUJDPTFRVBOEPOÍPIPVWFSQSPWBTPVGPSFNFTUBTJOTVmDJFOUFT $G("-*/"3*$MFETPO.PSFJSBA aplicabilidade da transação no direito tributário brasileiro%JTQPOÓ WFM FN IUUQXXXBQFUPSHCSBSUJHPTWFSBTQ BSU@JEBVUPS0NBS5BOVTEF"SBV KP.BMVG"DFTTPFNTFU $G3*#"4"OUPOJP4PV[B3*#"4-JEJB.BSJB-PQFT3PESJHVFT"SCJUSBHFNDPNPNFJPBMUFSOBUJWP OBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas7PMVNFBOP KBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G5¼33&4)FMFOP5BWFJSB5SBOTBÎÍPBSCJUSBHFNFDPODJMJBÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPNPNFEJEBTBMUFSOBUJWBT QBSBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPFOUSFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPF$POUSJCVJOUFToTJNQMJmDBÎÍPFFmDJÐODJBBENJOJT USBUJWB*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributárioo3'%57PMVNFBOPNBSÎPQ #FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJOU$POUFV EPBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFNOPW $G5¼33&4)FMFOP5BWFJSB5SBOTBÎÍPBSCJUSBHFNFDPODJMJBÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPNPNFEJEBTBMUFSOBUJWBT RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 337 0DBUFESÈUJDPFTQBOIPM+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSP-BQBU[BHSBOEFEFGFOTPSEBUSBO TBÎÍPFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBSFTTBMUBRVFPJOTUJUVUPÏSFTUSJUPËTTJUVBÎÜFTEFJODFSUF[B OÍPDBCFOEPTPCSFGBUPTEFTDPCFSUPTFDPNQSPWBEPTQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP $MFETPO.PSFJSB(BMJOBSJPCTFSWBRVFOÍPIÈUSBOTBÎÍPTPCSFGBUPTPVTP CSFEJSFJUPTNBTBQFOBTGVOEBEBFNdúvidaEFGBUPPVdúvidaEFEJSFJUP"mSNBDPN BDFSUPRVFBEÞWJEBBDFSDBEBMFHBMJEBEFEBinterpretação EP'JTDPWFJDVMBEBQPSBUP JOGSBMFHBMTFSJBQBTTÓWFMEFUSBOTBÎÍPOPUBEBNFOUFTFKÈDPOUBSDPNEFDJTÜFTEFTGB WPSÈWFJTEP+VEJDJÈSJP /B NFTNB MJOIB 3VCFOT .JSBOEB EF $BSWBMIP DPOTJEFSB RVF PT BDPSEPT USBOTBDJPOBJTQPEFNTFSTVCTUJUVUJWPTPVJOUFHSBUJWPTEFVNBEFDJTÍPPVSFTPMVÎÍPEB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍPQBSBUPSOBSNBJTDMBSPPTFVTFOUJEP 3VCFOT.JSBOEB$BSWBMIPWBJBMÏN$POTJEFSBRVFBdúvidaEFRVFTFSFWFTUF PMJUÓHJPQPEFSFTVMUBSOÍPTPNFOUFEPSFTVMUBEPJODFSUPEBMJEFUSJCVUÈSJBNBTUBN CÏNEBpossibilidade material de realização do crédito em função da inexistência de bens do devedor."JODFSUF[BFNSFMBÎÍPËSFBMJ[BÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPQPSGBMUBEFCFOT TFSJBTVmDJFOUFOBWJTÍPEPBVUPSQBSBEBSFOTFKPËUSBOTBÎÍPOPTNPMEFTFDPOEJ ÎÜFTEFmOJEPTFNMFJ %F OPTTBQBSUFFOUFOEFNPTOBEBJNQFEJS RVF P MFHJTMBEPS JOGSBDPOTUJ UVDJPOBMBPEJTDJQMJOBSBUSBOTBÎÍPFNTFVÉNCJUPEFDPNQFUÐODJBDSJFDSJUÏSJPT NBJTBNQMPTQBSBFTUBCFMFDFSDPNWJTUBTËUSBOTBÎÍPTFVNBRVFTUÍPÏMJUJHJPTB $VJEBTFOFTTFBTQFDUPEPQPEFSRVBMJmDBEPSEPMFHJTMBEPSUSJCVUÈSJPRVFFN QSFTUBDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTQSØQSJBTBJOTUJUVUPTSFHVMBEPTFNPVUSPTSBNPTEPEJSFJUP " MFHJUJNJEBEF EFTTB RVBMJmDBÎÍP EFQFOEFSÈ EP DPOKVOUP EF DPOEJÎÜFT F DPO DFTTÜFT SFDÓQSPDBT FTUBCFMFDJEBT OB MFJ BVUPSJ[BEPSB F EBT TJUVBÎÜFT RVF WJTBSÈ BUJOHJSDPNQPOEPVNUPEPIBSNÙOJDPRVFSFnJUBBJOUFMJHÐODJBEBMFJFTFVGPDP OPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP QBSBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPFOUSFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPF$POUSJCVJOUFToTJNQMJmDBÎÍPFFmDJÐODJBBENJOJT USBUJWB*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributárioo3'%57PMVNFBOPNBSÎPQ #FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJOU$POUFV EPBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFNOPW $G-"1"5;"+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSP4PMVDJØODPOWFODJPOBMEFDPOnJUPTFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJB*O3FWJTUB "SHFOUJOBEF%FSFDIP5SJCVUBSJP7PMVNFQ#VFOPT"JSFT6OJWFSTJEBE"VTUSBM'BDVMEBEFEF %FSFDIPBQVE3*#"4"OUPOJP4PV[B3*#"4-JEJB.BSJB-PQFT3PESJHVFT"SCJUSBHFNDPNP NFJP BMUFSOBUJWP OB TPMVÎÍP EF DPOUSPWÏSTJBT USJCVUÈSJBT *O Revista tributária e de finanças públicas. 7PMVNFBOPKBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G("-*/"3*$MFETPO.PSFJSBA aplicabilidade da transação no direito tributário brasileiro%JTQPOÓ WFM FN IUUQXXXBQFUPSHCSBSUJHPTWFSBTQ BSU@JEBVUPS0NBS5BOVTEF"SBV KP.BMVG"DFTTPFNTFU $G$"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSBQ $G$"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias.4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 338 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos 4.5. Transação tributária e concessões recíprocas 0MFRVFEFQPTTJCJMJEBEFTFEFJNQPTTJCJMJEBEFTTFBCSFRVBOEPPUFNB ÏPRVFQPEFTFSPCKFUPEFDPODFTTÍPOBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB%FVUJMJ[BÎÍPBJOEBUÓNJ EBOP#SBTJMQPVDPTFUFNQBSBPFTUVEPEBDBTVÓTUJDBFTFVDPOGSPOUPDPNBMHVNBT EBTMJNJUBÎÜFTJNQPTUBTQFMBEPVUSJOBEFTPSUFRVFBUFTUFTVBMFHJUJNJEBEF "TQPTTJCJMJEBEFTFPTMJNJUFTBRVJQSPQPTUPTGSVUPTEFOPTTBQFTRVJTBGVO DJPOBNNFOPTDPNPCBSSFJSBTFNBJTDPNPJOEJDBUJWPTEPTQPOUPTOPTRVBJTPMFHJT MBEPSEFWFSÈTFEFUFSOPNPNFOUPEFUSBÎBSPTDPOUPSOPTEBBVUPSJ[BÎÍPUSBOTBDJPOBM &NOPTTPTFOUJSBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBNFTNPTPCPTMJNJUFTEBOPSNBHFSBM UFNHSBOEFBNQMJUVEF4VBMFHJUJNJEBEFEFQFOEFSÈEBTDPOEJÎÜFTMJNJUFTFHSBEVB ÎÜFTRVFBMFJQFSNJTTJWBFTUBCFMFDFSGPSNBOEPVNUPEPIBSNÙOJDPRVFFWJEFODJF PVOÍPPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPFNBUFOEJNFOUP 4.5.1. Concessões mútuas "OPSNBHFSBMEPBSUJHPEP$5/FTUBCFMFDFRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB FOWPMWFSÈ DPODFTTÜFT NÞUVBT SFQJTBOEP OFTTF QPOUP B EJTDJQMJOB EP JOTUJUVUP OP ÉNCJUPEPEJSFJUPQSJWBEP$$"SU 4ÍPEBFTTÐODJBEBUSBOTBÎÍPBTDPODFTTÜFTEFMBEPBMBEP/ÍPTFDVJEBSÈ EFUSBOTBÎÍPTFTPNFOUFVNBQBSUFDPODFEFS$BTPJTTPPDPSSBFTUBSFNPTEJBOUFEF PVUSPTJOTUJUVUPTSFNJTTÍPEBÎÍPFNQBHBNFOUPEPBÎÍPPVNFSBEFTJTUÐODJB 5PEBWJBBUÏQPSRVFPTJOUFSFTTFTFNDPOnJUPOÍPFTUÍPOBNFTNBNFEJEB BTDPODFTTÜFTOÍPUFSÍPEFTFSJHVBJTPVFRVJWBMFOUFT 4.5.2. Concessões recíprocas e crédito tributário 2VFTUÍPUPSNFOUPTBÏBRVFEJ[SFTQFJUPËQPTTJCJMJEBEFEBUSBOTBÎÍPFO WPMWFS P QSØQSJP DSÏEJUP USJCVUÈSJP QPSRVBOUP BGFUBEP QFMB JOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEF EP JOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP %FDPSSFEPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPBDPNQSFFO TÍPEFRVFPBENJOJTUSBEPSOÍPÏUJUVMBSOFNUFNQPEFSEFEJTQPTJÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFT QÞCMJDPTDBCFOEPBQFOBTHFSJMPTOPTUFSNPTFTUSJUPTEBMFJ4PNFOUFP&TUBEPTFV UJUVMBS RVBOEP FYFSDF GVOÎÍP MFHJTMBUJWB UFN P QPEFS EF EJTQPS EFTTFT JOUFSFTTFT 1BSB3JDBSEP-PCP5PSSFTi3FOÞODJBBPMJUÓHJPmTDBMTFNBDPSSFTQFDUJWBDPODFTTÍPÏNFSBEFTJTUÐODJB FOÍPUSBOTBÎÍPwCurso de Direito Financeiro e Tributário.3JPEF+BOFJSP3FOPWBSQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 339 TFHVOEPPTMJNJUFTEB$POTUJUVJÎÍPFTFNQSFDPNWJTUBTNBJTVNBWF[BPQSØQSJP JOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPSB[ÍPEFFYJTUJSEP&TUBEP 0EFTEPCSBNFOUPEFTTFQSJODÓQJPFNSFMBÎÍPËUSJCVUBÎÍPÏBOFDFTTJEBEF BCTPMVUBEFMFJQBSBRVFP&TUBEPBVUPSJ[FRVBMRVFSGPSNBEFFYPOFSBÎÍP "TQFDUPDPNQMFNFOUBSFJNQPSUBOUFRVFNFSFDFTFSEFTUBDBEPÏBOPÎÍP EFRVFPUSJCVUPFORVBESBTFOBDBUFHPSJBEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTTFDVOEÈSJPTEP &TUBEP PT RVBJT QPS OÍP TFSFN B SB[ÍP ÞMUJNB EF FYJTUJS EP &TUBEP SFWFMBNTF JOTUSVNFOUBJT Ë TBUJTGBÎÍP EPT JOUFSFTTFT QÞCMJDPT QSJNÈSJPT BTTJN RVBMJmDBEPT QFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP&NGVOÎÍPEBTVBOBUVSF[BJOTUSVNFOUBMPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPT TFDVOEÈSJPTQPEFNTFSEJTQPTUPTTFNQSFQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEFMFJFOPTMJNJUFTEPPS EFOBNFOUPRVBOEPFTTBEJTQPTJÎÍPTFSFWFMFFTTFODJBMBPBUJOHJNFOUPEPJOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDPQSJNÈSJP DPMJNBEP 4FMNB-FNFTSFDPOIFDJEBBVUPSJEBEFFNBSCJUSBHFNFBVUPSBEFFYDFMFOUF PCSBTPCSFBBSCJUSBHFNOB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBBTTFWFSBRVFPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJ DPTTFDVOEÈSJPTDPNDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTQBUSJNPOJBJTQPSTVBOBUVSF[BJOTUSVNFOUBMEF TBUJTGBÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFTQSJNÈSJPTTÍPQBTTÓWFJTEFEJTQPTJÎÍP 1PEFNPTDMBTTJmDBSPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTFNiQSJNÈSJPTwFiTFDVOEÈSJPTw JOTUSVNFOUBJTPVEFSJWBEPT 0TJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTQSJNÈSJPTTÍPJOEJT QPOÓWFJTFQPSTVBWF[PTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTEFSJWBEPTUÐNOBUVSF[BJOT USVNFOUBMFFYJTUFNQBSBPQFSBDJPOBMJ[BSBRVFMFTDPNDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTQB USJNPOJBJTFQPSJTTPTÍPEJTQPOÓWFJTFTVTDFUÓWFJTEFBQSFDJBÎÍPBSCJUSBM 3VCFOT.JSBOEBEF$BSWBMIPDPOTJEFSBRVFPDSÏEJUPEFPSJHFNUSJCVUÈSJB QPSQFSUFODFSBPQBUSJNÙOJPEP&TUBEPQPEFTFSEJTQPOJCJMJ[BEPOBEBJNQFEJOEP RVFTFKBPCKFUPEFUSBOTBÎÍPBOÍPTFSBBVTÐODJBEFMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSB )VHPEF#SJUP.BDIBEPFOUFOEFRVFPUSJCVUPDPNPPTCFOTQÞCMJDPTFN HFSBMÏQBUSJNÙOJPEP&TUBEP*OEJTQPOÓWFMOPEJBBEJBEBBUJWJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWB QPSÏNEJTQPOÓWFMBP&TUBEPTFVUJUVMBSQFMBWJBMFHJTMBUJWBTFNQSFQBSBBQSPUFÎÍP FSFBMJ[BÎÍPEBmOBMJEBEFQÞCMJDB *NQPSUBOUFSFTTBMUBSRVFOÍPIÈOPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPOFOIVNBQSPJCJÎÍP ËUSBOTBÎÍPFNSFMBÎÍPBPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP&NMVHBSEFQSPJCJÎÍPIÈQSFWJTÍPOB 0UFNBÏBCPSEBEPOPDBQÓUVMP -&.&44FMNBArbitragem na Administração Pública – fundamentos jurídicos e eficiência econômica.4ÍP 1BVMP2VBSUJFS-BUJOQ $G$"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias.4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSBQ $G."$)"%0)VHPEF#SJUP5SBOTBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNOPÉNCJUPUSJCVUÈSJP*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributário – RFDT7PMVNFBOPKVMIPQ#FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJOU$POUFVEPBTQY JE$POUFVEP "DFTTPFNOPW RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 340 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos OPSNBHFSBMEP"SUEP$5/EFRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBTFSÈDBVTBFYUJOUJWB UPUBMPVQBSDJBMEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP /FTTFTFOUJEP8BMUFS1BMEFT7BMÏSJPOPTJEPTEFDPNNBFTUSJBKÈEFT UBDBWBBJNQSPQSJFEBEFEBTDSÓUJDBTËUSBOTBÎÍPRVFFOWPMWFTTFPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP "MHVOTBVUPSFTSFMVUBNFNBENJUJSBBQMJDBÎÍPEBUSBOTBÎÍPBPTDSÏEJUPT USJCVUÈSJPTEFmOJUJWBNFOUFDPOTUJUVÓEPTJTUPÏMÓRVJEPTFDFSUPTQPSFO UFOEFSFNRVFP'JTDPOÍPUFNEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFTPCSFBSFDFJUBUSJCVUÈSJB QBSBFGFUVBSDPODFTTÜFTSFTQFJUPBFMB0DFSUPQPSÏNÏRVFBMFHJTMBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBFYQSFTTBNFOUFOÍPTØBDPMIFBUSBOTBÎÍPDPNPEFGPSNBJOF RVÓWPDBQFSNJUFTFGBÎBNFOUSFPTTVKFJUPTBUJWPFQBTTJWPDPODFTTÜFT SFDÓQSPDBTDPNQPTJÎÍPEFJOUFSFTTFTQBSBFODFSSBNFOUPEFMJUÓHJPFDPO TFRVFOUFFYUJOÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPmTDBM&QPSRVFOBSFBMJEBEFOÍPFYJTUF EJTQPOJCJMJEBEF EB SFDFJUB USJCVUÈSJB QPS QBSUF EB BVUPSJEBEF BSSFDBEB EPSBBUSBOTBÎÍPTPNFOUFÏWÈMJEBTFSFBMJ[BEBOBTDPOEJÎÜFTFTPCBT HBSBOUJBTRVFGPSFNFTUJQVMBEBTFTQFDJmDBNFOUFFNUFYUPEFMFJ 4.6. Transação tributária e condições estabelecidas na lei permissiva "OPSNBHFSBMEP"SUEP$5/EJTDJQMJOBRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPTFSÈGFJUBOBT iDPOEJÎÜFTwRVFBMFJQFSNJTTJWBFTUBCFMFDFS $PNPFYBNJOBEPFYTVSHFEPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞ CMJDPBOPÎÍPEFRVFPOEFIPVWFSEJTQPTJÎÍPEFWFSÈIBWFSBVUPSJ[BÎÍPMFHBMFTQFDÓmDB MJNJUBOEPFCBMJ[BOEPFTTBEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFQPJTBQFOBTP&TUBEPÏDPNQFUFOUFQBSB EJTQPSOPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUPFOPTUFSNPTEBMFJFYQFEJEBOÍPPBENJOJTUSBEPS "TDPOEJÎÜFTFMJNJUFTQBSBBUSBOTBÎÍPQPSUBOUPBMÏNEFDPNQBUÓWFJTDPN BOPSNBHFSBMEFWFSÍPTFSmYBEBTFNMFJFTQFDÓmDB/BBVTÐODJBEFTTBNBUFSJBMJEBEF BMFJQFSNJTTJWBTFSÈJODPOTUJUVDJPOBM 4.6.1. Discricionariedade administrativa " EJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEF FOWPMWJEB OB USBOTBÎÍP BMWP EF DSÓUJDBT BQSFTTBEBT DPOTUJUVJTFVNEPTQJMBSFTEFSFTJTUÐODJBËUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOP#SBTJM1PSUFNPS B VNB BUVBÎÍP BSCJUSÈSJB EB "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP PV TFKB VN BHJS DPN GBWPSFDJNFOUPT 7"-²3*08BMUFS1BMEFT1SPHSBNBEF%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJP1PSUP"MFHSF&E4VMJOBQBQVE $"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSBQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 341 EJTDSJNJOBÎÍPFUFOEFODJPOJTNPTOFHBTFPQSØQSJPJOTUJUVUPEBUSBOTBÎÍPFUPEBB OPSNBUJWJEBEFEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDP0UFNPSDPNPTFSÈWJTUPOÍPTFKVTUJmDB 0MFHJTMBEPSJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBPEFmOJSBTDPOEJÎÜFTFNRVFBUSBOTBÎÍP QPEFSÈPDPSSFSQPEFSÈPVOÍPBCSJSNBSHFOTEJTDSJDJPOÈSJBTËBENJOJTUSBÎÍP "BCFSUVSBEFNBSHFOTEJTDSJDJPOÈSJBTQSFTTVQÜFBmYBÎÍPEFCBMJ[BNFOUPT QFMBMFJQFSNJTTJWBQBSBBUVBÎÍPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPOPDBTPDPODSFUPQPSRVBOUPIÈ PSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPMFHJTMBEPSEFRVFOÍPQPEFEJTDJQMJOBSUPEBTBTTJUVBÎÜFTOFN QSFWFSUPEBTBTOVBOÎBTQBSBBUJOHJSEFGPSNBNBJTQMFOBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPmOBMÓT UJDPEBOPSNB 0BHJSWJODVMBEPFPBHJSEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPTÍPDPOTUSVÎÜFTMBQJEBSFTEP%JSFJUP "ENJOJTUSBUJWPGSVUPEBFWPMVÎÍPEB4PDJFEBEF%FNPDSÈUJDBFEP&TUBEPEF%JSFJUP QBSB BGBTUBS B BSCJUSBSJFEBEFEPQPEFSFNBOUFS B "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB OB QPTUVSB QSPTTFDVUPSBEPTJOUFSFTTFTEBDPMFUJWJEBEF "BUVBÎÍPEBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPEFWFTFQBVUBSOBiCPBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPwOBFm DÈDJBQBSBCVTDBSTFNQSFFNRVBMRVFSTJUVBÎÍPBEFDJTÍPPVPQÎÍPRVFNFMIPS BUFOEBBPJOUFSFTTFDPNVN 0EFWFSEFCPBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPQSJODÓQJPRVFSFHFUPEBBBUJWJEBEFEB"E NJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB seja no agir vinculado, seja no agir discricionário JNQMJDB dever jurídicoEFCVTDBFPQÎÍPQFMBEFDJTÍPPVBÎÍPRVFNFMIPSBUFOEBËmWFMBPJOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDPWJTBEPOBMFJ "EJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFOÍPÏQPSUBOUPVNQPEFSBSCJUSÈSJPDPOGFSJEPË"ENJ OJTUSBÎÍP1ÞCMJDBNBTVNEFWFSQPEFSRVFEFWFTFSFYFSDJEPFTUSJUBNFOUFQSFTPBP EFTJEFSBUPNBJPSEFBUFOEFSEBNFMIPSNBOFJSBQPTTÓWFMBPCFNDPNVN %F PVUSB TPSUF TFNQSF IBWFSÈ VN quantum EF BQSFDJBÎÍP QFTTPBM OP BUP BENJOJTUSBUJWPQPSQBSUFEPBHFOUFEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPTFOEPJNQPTTÓWFMSFUJSBSB 0 QSJODÓQJP EB FmDJÐODJB PV FmDÈDJB BENJOJTUSBUJWB FSJHJEP Ë DBUFHPSJB EF QSJODÓQJP FYQSFTTP QFMB &$OÏVNBGBDFUBEPQSJODÓQJPNBJPSEBiCPBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPwBNQMBNFOUFFTUVEBEPQFMP EJSFJUPJUBMJBOP²PiEFWFSKVSÓEJDPwEBBUJWJEBEFBENJOJTUSBUJWBTFSEFTFOWPMWJEBiEPNPEPNBJTDPO HSVFOUFNBJTPQPSUVOPFNBJTBEFRVBEPBPTmOTBTFSFNBMDBOÎBEPTHSBÎBTËFTDPMIBEPTNFJPTFEB PDBTJÍPEFVUJMJ[ÈMPTDPODFCÓWFJTDPNPPTNBJTJEÙOFPTQBSBUBOUPw$PNPCFNSFTTBMUB$FMTP"OUÙOJP #BOEFJSBEF.FMMPPQSJODÓQJPEBFmDJÐODJBTPNFOUFQPEFTFSDPODFCJEPOPÉNBHPEPQSJODÓQJPEB MFHBMJEBEFQSJODÓQJPNBJPSRVFSFHFP%JSFJUP1ÞCMJDPQPJTiKBNBJTVNBTVQPTUBCVTDBEFFmDJÐODJB KVTUJmDBSJBQPTUFSHBÎÍPEBRVFMFRVFÏPQSJODÓQJPBENJOJTUSBUJWPQPSFYDFMÐODJBwDG.&--0$FMTP "OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFCurso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPTQ $G.&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFDiscricionariedade e controle jurisdicional.4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT Q $G#"5*45"+30OPGSF"MWFT5SBOTBÎÍPOP%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFFJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP *ORevista Dialética de Direito Tributário.7PMVNFQ4ÍP1BVMP&E%JBMÏUJDB $G5¼33&4)FMFOP5BWFJSB5SBOTBÎÍPBSCJUSBHFNFDPODJMJBÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPNPNFEJEBTBMUFSOBUJWBT QBSBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPFOUSFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPF$POUSJCVJOUFToTJNQMJmDBÎÍPFFmDJÐODJBBENJOJT USBUJWB*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributárioo3'%57PMVNFBOPNBSÎPQ #FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJOU$POUFV EPBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFNOPW RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 342 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos BQSFDJBÎÍPTVCKFUJWBEPDPNQPSUBNFOUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPBJOEBRVFFNBUVBÎÍPWJO DVMBEB1BVMPEF#BSSPT$BSWBMIPDPNBNBFTUSJBRVFMIFÏQFDVMJBSBTTJNPCTFSWB <>OÍPDSFJPQPTTBFYJTUJSDPNQPSUBNFOUPEB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEFTUJUVÓEP EFBQSFDJBÎÍPTVCKFUJWBQ <>BWJODVMBÎÍPRVFTFQSFEJDBEJ[SFTQFJUPBPQSPDFEJNFOUPFOÍPBPBUP 0DBSÈUFSWJODVMBEPPVEJTDSJDJPOÈSJPNPSBOBBUJWJEBEFQSPDFEJNFOUBM OÍPOPTFVQSPEVUPPBUPEFMBOÎBNFOUP"DBTPOPTEFQBSÈTTFNPTDPN EPJT EPDVNFOUPT BUFTUBUØSJPT EF BUPT KVSÓEJDPT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT TFOEP VN QSPWFOJFOUF EF BUJWJEBEF WJODVMBEB F PVUSP PSJVOEP EF BUJWJEBEF EJTDSJDJPOÈSJB OFOIVN USBÎP FTQFDÓmDP SFNBOFTDFSJB QBSB EFOVODJBS B WJODVMBÎÍPPVEJTDSJÎÍPDPNRVFPFYQFEJFOUFGPJSFBMJ[BEPBOÍPTFSÏ DMBSPRVFDPOIFÎBNPTBTSFHSBTRVFQSFTJEJSBNTVBDFMFCSBÎÍPQ " MFJ EFWFSÈ FTUBCFMFDFS PT MJNJUFT FN RVF B BENJOJTUSBÎÍP QPTTB DFMFCSBS USBOTBÎÜFTOPTDPOnJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPTEFmOJOEPQSPDFEJNFOUPTFQBSÉNFUSPTRVFHB SBOUBNBJNQBSDJBMJEBEFBNPSBMJEBEFFBFmDJÐODJBJOFYJTUJOEPRVBMRVFSØCJDFË BCFSUVSBEFNBSHFOTEJTDSJDJPOÈSJBT 4.7. Transação e efeito de extinção do crédito tributário "OPSNBHFSBMEPBSUJHPEP$5/FTUBCFMFDFRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPEFWFSÈQÙS mNBMJUÓHJPFFYUJOHVJSPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPiJNQPSUFFNEFUFSNJOBÎÍPEPMJUÓHJPF FYUJOÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPw "EVQMBmOBMJEBEFEBOPSNBQFSNJTTJWBÏSFMBUJWB"USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBTF EFTUJOBEFGBUPBQPSmNBMJUÓHJPQPSÏNOFNTFNQSFUFSÈDPNPDPOTFRVÐODJBB FYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB /FNPGBUPEFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBDPNQPSPSPMEFDBVTBTFYUJOUJWBTEB PCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB EB OPSNB HFSBM EP "SU EP $5/ BMUFSB B TVB DPOEJÎÍP EF NFSPJOTUSVNFOUPWJBCJMJ[BEPSEBFYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPRVFQPEFSÈPVOÍPPDPSSFS EFQFOEFOUFTFNQSFEPBEJNQMFNFOUPEPRVFGPSQBDUVBEP $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPT$VSTPEFEJSFJUPUSJCVUÈSJPFEJÎÍP4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWBQ FBQVE5¼33&4)FMFOP5BWFJSB5SBOTBÎÍPBSCJUSBHFNFDPODJMJBÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPNPNFEJEBT BMUFSOBUJWBTQBSBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPFOUSFBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPFDPOUSJCVJOUFToTJNQMJmDBÎÍPFFmDJÐODJB BENJOJTUSBUJWB*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributárioo3'%57PMVNFBOPNBSÎP Q#FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJO U$POUFVEPBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFNOPW $G3*#"4"OUPOJP4PV[B3*#"4-JEJB.BSJB-PQFT3PESJHVFT"SCJUSBHFNDPNPNFJPBMUFSOBUJWP OBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas7PMVNFBOP KBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 343 3VCFOT.JSBOEBEF$BSWBMIPDPOTJEFSBRVFBDPSSFUBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEPBSU EP$5/EFWFDPOEV[JSËDPODMVTÍPEFRVFBOPSNBQFSNJTTJWBQPTTBQSFWFSaté BFYUJOÎÍPEPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPTFNDPOUVEPDPOTUJUVJSTFDPOTFRVÐODJBOFDFTTÈSJB EBUFSNJOBÎÍPEPMJUÓHJP "USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFYUJOHVJSÈBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOBRVJMPFNRVFB'B [FOEBDPODFEFVBCSJVNÍP)VHPEF#SJUP.BDIBEPDPOTJEFSBRVFFTUBQPTTJCJMJEBEF KÈKVTUJmDBBJODMVTÍPEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOPSPMEFDBVTBTFYUJOUJWBTEBPCSJHBÎÍP EP"SUEP$5/ "DSFTDFOUFTF RVF BDBTP B MFJ QFSNJTTJWB EB USBOTBÎÍP OÍP FTUBCFMFÎB PT NFJPTBENJTTÓWFJTEFmOBMJ[BÎÍPEPMJUÓHJPJOEJDBOEPBQFOBTPTMJNJUFTEBEJTQPOJCJ MJEBEFQPEFSÍPTFSVUJMJ[BEPTPTJOTUSVNFOUPTJOEJDBEPTOBOPSNBHFSBMEFFYUJOÎÍP EPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPPVTFKBPSPMEP"SUEP$5/ 5. TRANSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA E CONVÊNIO PARA O ICMS &NNBUÏSJBEFDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBTPNFOUFBQFTTPBQPMÓUJDBRVFDSJPVP USJCVUPQPEFSÈDPODFEFSTVCTÓEJPPVJTFOÎÍPSFEVÎÍPEBCBTFEFDÈMDVMPDPODFTTÍP EFDSÏEJUPQSFTVNJEPBOJTUJBPVSFNJTTÍPQPSNFJPEFMFJFTQFDÓmDBFTUBEVBMGFEF SBMPVNVOJDJQBM$'"SUf "SFHSBHFSBMQPSUBOUPÏBBVUPOPNJBEPFOUFQPMÓUJDPQBSBDPODFEFSRVBJT RVFSFYPOFSBÎÜFTTPCSFPUSJCVUPEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJBNFEJBOUFPNFTNPJOTUSVNFO UPOPSNBUJWP &NSFMBÎÍPBP*$.4PTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTOÍPQPTTVFNBVUPOPNJBQBSBJOT UJUVJSUSJCVUBÎÍPFYDFQUJWBQPSMJNJUBÎÍPJNQPTUBQFMPQSØQSJPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM OPTFV"SUf9**gEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMRVFFYJHFQBSBDPODFTTÍPPV SFWPHBÎÍPEFJTFOÎÜFTJODFOUJWPTFCFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJT préviaEFMJCFSBÎÍPEPT&TUBEPT F%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMOPTUFSNPTFNRVFEJTDJQMJOBSBMFJDPNQMFNFOUBS "-FJ$PNQMFNFOUBSOSFDFQDJPOBEBQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMEF FTUBCFMFDFRVFBGPSNBEFEFMJCFSBÎÍPJOUFSFTUBEVBMQBSBBDPODFTTÍPFSFWPHB ÎÍPEFJTFOÎÜFTJODFOUJWPTFCFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJTEP*$.4ÏPconvênio "SU FYJHJO EPTFEFDJTÍPVOÉOJNFQBSBBBQSPWBÎÍPEFDPODFTTÍPEFCFOFGÓDJPT"SUf $G$"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias. 4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSBQ $G."$)"%0)VHPEF#SJUP5SBOTBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNOPÉNCJUPUSJCVUÈSJP*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributário – RFDT7PMVNFBOPKVMIPQ#FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJOU$POUFVEPBTQY JE$POUFVEP "DFTTPFNOPW $G"3"6+0/BEKBTransação Tributária: possibilidade de consenso na obrigação imposta.1PSUP"MFHSF /VSJB'BCSJTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 344 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos 0"SUEB-$OEJTQÜFRVFPTDPOWÐOJPTEFmOJSÍPBTcondições geraisFNRVFPTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTQPEFSÍPDPODFEFSBOJTUJBSFNJTTÍPFtransaçãoCFN DPNPQBSDFMBNFOUPTFBNQMJBÎÍPEFQSB[PQBSBSFDPMIJNFOUPEPUSJCVUP /ÍPPCTUBOUFGVOEBNFOUBJTQBSBBDPODFTTÍPEFJTFOÎÜFTFPVUSPTJODFOUJWPT mTDBJTPTDPOWÐOJPTOBEBDPODFEFNBQFOBTQFSNJUFNRVFDBEBFOUFWFOIBBGB[ÐMP 6NBRVFTUÍPRVFTFBQSFTFOUBÏTFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBEFGBUPOÍPFTDB QBSJBËFYJHÐODJBEFDPOWÐOJPQSFWJTUBFYQSFTTBNFOUFOPBSUEB-$OKÈ RVFPUFSNPiUSBOTBÎÍPwOÍPGPJJODMVÓEPOBSFEBÎÍPEP"SUf9**gEB$' RVFQSFWÐBEFMJCFSBÎÍPQSÏWJBEPT&TUBEPTF%'BQFOBTQBSBiJTFOÎÜFTJODFOUJWPTF CFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJTw4FSJBBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBVNBFTQÏDJFEPHÐOFSPiJODFOUJWPPV CFOFGÓDJP mTDBMw B KVTUJmDBS B FYJHÐODJB EF DPOWÐOJP QBSB FTUBCFMFDFS BT DPOEJÎÜFT HFSBJTFNRVFQPTTBTFSDFMFCSBEB 1BEFDFSJBEFJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEFBFYJHÐODJBEF DPOWÐOJPQBSBBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQSFWJTUBOPBSUJHPEB-$O $PNPBNQMBNFOUFUSBUBEPOPQSFTFOUFFTUVEPPSPMEFDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSP DBTBDPSEBEBTOVNBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQPEFSÈFOWPMWFSSFNJTTÍPQBSDJBMBOJTUJBEF NVMUBFKVSPTQBSDFMBNFOUPEJGFSFODJBEPEJGFSJNFOUPFOUSFUBOUPTPVUSPTPVTFKB UPEPTPVNVJUPTEPTJODFOUJWPTFPVCFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJTFNNBUÏSJBEF*$.4QBSBPT RVBJT B $POTUJUVJÎÍP 'FEFSBM SFTFSWPV P NBOUP EB QSÏWJB EFMJCFSBÎÍP DPMFUJWB OÍP IBWFOEPDPNPFTDBQBSQPSUBOUPEBEJTDJQMJOBEPDPOWÐOJP 0CTFSWFTFDPOUVEPRVFPDPOWÐOJPQSFWJTUPOP"SUEB-$O OÍPÏGFDIBEPFJNQPTJUJWPUBMDPNPBRVFMFQSFWJTUPQBSBBTJTFOÎÜFTUSJCVUÈSJBTOP "SU0DPOWÐOJPRVFWFSTBSTPCSFUSBOTBÎÍPBOJTUJBSFNJTTÍPNPSBUØSJBQBSDF MBNFOUPFBNQMJBÎÍPEPQSB[PEFSFDPMIJNFOUPDPOGPSNFMFUSBFYQSFTTBEPcaput EFWFSÈBQFOBTFTUBCFMFDFSBTiDPOEJÎÜFTHFSBJTwFNRVFPTFOUFTiVOJMBUFSBMNFOUFw QPEFSÍP DPODFEFS UBJT JODFOUJWPTCFOFGÓDJPT ² P RVF B EPVUSJOB DPTUVNB EFTJHOBS convênio autorizativo62PVTFKBFTUBCFMFDFVNBGBDVMEBEFBPFOUFGFEFSBEPRVFQPEF SÈVOJMBUFSBMNFOUFDPODFEFSNFEJBOUFMFJPTJODFOUJWPTFCFOFGÓDJPTOFMFQSFWJTUPT FNiDPOEJÎÜFTHFSBJTw )ÈCPBNBSHFNQBSBEJTDJQMJOBJOEJWJEVBMEBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQFMPFOUF GFEFSBEPTFNQSFQPSMFJPSEJOÈSJBEFTEFRVFPCWJBNFOUFPCTFSWBEPTPTMJNJUFTEBT iDPOEJÎÜFTHFSBJTwUSBÎBEBTQFMPDPOWÐOJP &OUFOEFNPTBJOEBRVFDBTPBUSBOTBÎÍPOÍPFOWPMWBBDPODFTTÍPEFCFOF GÓDJPTPVJODFOUJWPTRVFOÍPPTKÈBVUPSJ[BEPTFNPVUSPTDPOWÐOJPTBJOEBFNWJHPS DPSSFTQPOEFOEPBBDPSEPFNUPSOPEFRVFTUÜFTDPOUSPWFSUJEBTEFGBUPPVEFEJSFJUP RVFSFEV[BNPVFYUJOHBNPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPOÍPIBWFSÈBOFDFTTJEBEFEFDPOWÐOJP FYJHJOEPTFEFRVBMRVFSGPSNBMFJPSEJOÈSJBQFSNJTTJWB $G+03(&5ÈSTJT/BNFUBMB4BSMPManual do ICMS – Direito Tributário Material, Processual e Direito Penal Tributário3JPEF+BOFJSP&E-VNFO+VSJTQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 345 6. TRANSAÇÃO TRIBUTÁRIA NO DIREITO COMPARADO 1BSBPDBUFESÈUJDPEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF#BSDFMPOB+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSB-BQBU[B OPRVFQFSUJOFËUSBOTBÎÍPFËTGPSNBTBMUFSOBUJWBTEFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTUSJCVUÈSJPT PTEPJTPSEFOBNFOUPTKVSÓEJDPTPDJEFOUBJTPBOHMPTBYÍPFPDPOUJOFOUBMOÍP QPEFNEFJYBSEFTFSBOBMJTBEPTFNDPOKVOUPFNGVOÎÍPEBGPSUFJOnVÐODJBRVFP TJTUFNBBOHMPTBYÍPFYFSDFVTPCSFPDPOUJOFOUBMOBTÞMUJNBTEÏDBEBT /PTJTUFNBKVSÓEJDPBOHMPTBYÍPWJHPSBPSFHJNFEPBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPPOEFP DPOUSJCVJOUFJEFOUJmDBRVBMJmDBFEFDMBSBPTGBUPTSFMFWBOUFTEBPCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB CFNDPNPRVBOUJmDBPWBMPSEPUSJCVUPEFWJEPFSFBMJ[BPTFVQBHBNFOUPTFNJOUFS NFEJBÎÍPEBmTDBMJ[BÎÍP/PTJTUFNBDPOUJOFOUBMPDPOUSJCVJOUFBQFOBTEFDMBSBPT GBUPTSFMFWBOUFTQBSBPQBHBNFOUPEFUSJCVUPTÏPmTDPRVFNRVBMJmDBFTTFTGBUPTF RVBOUJmDBPUSJCVUPEFWJEPBUVBOEPQPSUBOUPOBDBEFJBRVFBOUFDFEFPQBHBNFOUP EPUSJCVUP "NBJPSQPUFODJBMJEBEFEFDPOnJUPTOPSFHJNFEFBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPÏBDPNQB OIBEBOPTTJTUFNBTBOHMPTBYÜFTEFBNQMBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEFTJTUFNBTFYUSBKVEJDJBJTEF TPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTCBTFBEPTFNQBDUPTFOUSFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFPDPOUSJCVJOUFRVF JNQFEFNRVFBBMUBMJUJHJPTJEBEFHFSBEBQFMPTJTUFNBDIFHVFBP+VEJDJÈSJPSFUBSEBOEP BDPCSBOÎBEPUSJCVUP 0TPSEFOBNFOUPTKVSÓEJDPTDPOUJOFOUBJTBQBSUJSEBFYQFSJÐODJBCFNTVDF EJEBEPT&TUBEPT6OJEPTJNQPSUBSBNPNPEFMPEPBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPNFOPTPOFSP TPQBSBB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFNBJTFmDJFOUFQBSBBBSSFDBEBÎÍPQPSÏNSFTJTUJSBNFN BDPMIFSFNTFVTPSEFOBNFOUPTPTNFDBOJTNPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPT "DPOTFRVÐODJBEFTTBJNQPSUBÎÍPQFMBNFUBEFGPJPBVNFOUPWFSUJHJOPTPEBTMJEFT USJCVUÈSJBTDPNPTVGPDBNFOUPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJPQPJTUPEBBMJUJHJPTJEBEFOBUVSBM NFOUFHFSBEBQFMPSFHJNFEPBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPTFSFTPMWFFNEFNBOEBKVEJDJBMTFN QPTTJCJMJEBEFEFOFHPDJBÎÍP 0FYBNFEPEJSFJUPDPNQBSBEPTFSWFDPNPJEFOUJmDBEPSEPTQSPCMFNBTFN HSBOEFQBSUFDPNVOTFOGSFOUBEPTQFMPTPSEFOBNFOUPTRVFJNQMBOUBSBNPSFHJNFEP BVUPMBOÎBNFOUPTFNTFGB[FSBDPNQBOIBSEPTNFJPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFTPMVÎÍPEFDPO nJUPTFTVBUFOUBUJWBEFDPSSFÎÍPEFSPUB "USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBOPGPSNBUPRVFWFNTFOEPBEPUBEPQPSBMHVOTPS EFOBNFOUPTFTUSBOHFJSPTNFTNPPTNBJTFYJUPTPTBFYFNQMPEB*UÈMJBOÍPQPEF TFS TJNQMFTNFOUF USBOTQMBOUBEP QBSB P PSEFOBNFOUP CSBTJMFJSP QPS IBWFS TÏSJBT 0BVUPMBOÎBNFOUPSFnFUFVNBNBJPSMJUJHJPTJEBEFEFWJEPËFYUFOTBSFHVMBNFOUBÎÍPEPSFHJNFUSJCV UÈSJPJNQPTUPBPDPOUSJCVJOUFNJOVDJPTPQSPMJYPDBTVÓTUJDPFPCTDVSPDPNVUJMJ[BÎÍPFYBHFSBEBEF UFSNPTBNCÓHVPTFJNQSFDJTPTEFDPODFJUPTJOEFUFSNJOBEPTQSFTVOÎÜFTFmDÎÜFTRVFNVEBNBSFB MJEBEFFMJNJUBNPTNFJPTEFQSPWBEBOEPNBSHFNBJOUFSQSFUBÎÜFTEJWFSTBTFDPOEVUBTFMJTJWBTOFN TFNQSFBDFJUBTQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP$G-"1"5;"+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSPDireito tributário – teoria geral do tributo5SBEVUPS3PCFSUP#BSCPTB"MWFT#BSVFSJ.BOPMFQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 346 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos MJNJUBÎÜFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTVNBWF[RVFOPTTPTJTUFNBUSJCVUÈSJPTFDBSBDUFSJ[BQPS VNB BNQMB EJTDJQMJOB EF ÉNCJUP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM UPSOBOEPP SÓHJEP F SFTJTUFOUF B FYQFSJÐODJBTNBJTPVTBEBT$POUVEPBSJHJEF[EPTJTUFNBUSJCVUÈSJPCSBTJMFJSPGBWP SFDFVNBNBJPSSFnFYÍPFNUPSOPEFUFNBTDPOUSPWFSUJEPTFFYJHFVNBBÎÍPNBJT NBEVSBEPMFHJTMBEPS 6.1. Modelos estrangeiros " "MFNBOIB MFHÓUJNB SFQSFTFOUBOUF EP TJTUFNB DPOUJOFOUBM EF EFDMBSBÎÍP F MJRVJEBÎÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWBvisando a eficácia da gestão, ao desafogo dos tribunais e a melhorias nas relações entre a administração e os contribuintes FTUBCFMFDFV P BDPSEP FN TFVTJTUFNBQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEBDIBNBEBFOUSFWJTUBmOBMEJTDJQMJOBEBOP"SUEB 0SEFOBÎÍP5SJCVUÈSJBBMFNÍDPNPTPMVÎÍPBMUFSOBUJWBËSFTPMVÎÍPKVEJDJBMEPTMJUÓHJPT /B'SBOÎBÏDBEBWF[NBJPSBVUJMJ[BÎÍPEPBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPOBHFTUÍPUSJ CVUÈSJB FTUBOEP P TJTUFNB DPOUJOFOUBM SFTUSJUP BP *31' *NQPTUP EF 3FOEB 1FTTPB 'ÓTJDB "USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFRVJWBMFËDJWJMFSFTVMUBFNDPOUSBUPFOUSFB"ENJOJT USBÎÍPFPDPOUSJCVJOUF²BQMJDBEBOBSFEVÎÍPEBTTBOÎÜFTQFDVOJÈSJBT .BJTEFEBTTBOÎÜFTBQMJDBEBTTFSFTPMWFNQFMBUSBOTBÎÍPFWJUBOEPTF PSFDVSTPKVEJDJBM "*UÈMJBGPJNBJTMPOHFOBJNQMBOUBÎÍPHFOFSBMJ[BEBEPTJTUFNBEFBVUPMBO ÎBNFOUP "QFTBS EBT QSJNFJSBT FYQFSJÐODJBT DPN NÏUPEPT BMUFSOBUJWPT EF TPMVÎÍP EFDPOnJUPTEBUBSFNEFBQFOBTFNBTNPEJmDBÎÜFTNBJTJNQPSUBOUFT GPSBN FGFUJWBNFOUF JNQMBOUBEBT NPUJWBEBT QFMPT FMFWBEPT ÓOEJDFT EF MJUJHJPTJEBEF USJCVUÈSJB1SFWJTUPOP%FDSFUP-FHJTMBUJWPOEFPaccertamento con adesioneQPTTVJBNQMPÉNCJUPEFBQMJDBÎÍPUFOEPDPNPGVOEBNFOUPBJOTUJUVDJP OBMJ[BÎÍPEPEJÈMPHPFOUSFBTQBSUFT -"1"5;"+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSPDireito tributário – teoria geral do tributo5SBEVUPS3PCFSUP#BSCPTB"MWFT #BSVFSJ.BOPMFQ $G-"1"5;"+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSPDireito tributário – teoria geral do tributo5SBEVUPS3PCFSUP#BSCPTB "MWFT#BSVFSJ.BOPMFQ $G3*#"4"OUPOJP4PV[B3*#"4-JEJB.BSJB-PQFT3PESJHVFT"SCJUSBHFNDPNPNFJPBMUFSOBUJWP OBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas7PMVNFBOP KBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G.03"*4$BSMPT:VSJ"SBVKPEF5SBOTBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBBFYQFSJÐODJBFT USBOHFJSBFTVBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFBPEJSFJUPCSBTJMFJSP*ORevista Tributária e de Finanças Públicas7PMVNF BOPNBSÎPBCSJMQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G3*#"4"OUPOJP4PV[B3*#"4-JEJB.BSJB-PQFT3PESJHVFT"SCJUSBHFNDPNPNFJPBMUFSOBUJWP OBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas7PMVNFBOP KBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G(0%0:"SOBMEP4BNQBJPEF.PSBFTTransação tributária – introdução à justiça fiscal consensual. #FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVNQ RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 347 O accertamento con adesione, negoziato PV accertamento concordato DPOTUJUVJTF QPSUBOUPOVNBDPSEPFOUSFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPFPDPOUSJCVJOUFBQBSUJSEFVNQSPDFEJNFO UPDPOUSBEJUØSJPRVFDVMNJOBFNDPNQSPNJTTPTPCSFPTBTQFDUPTDPOUSPWFSUJEPTEBFTUJ NBUJWBEPJNQPTUPQPEFOEPSFTVMUBSFNSFEVÎÍPPVNPEJmDBÎÍPEBQSFUFOTÍPFTUBUBM "OUFT EP JOÓDJP EP DPOUSBEJUØSJP QPEFSÈ PDPSSFS B aquiescenza BQFOBT QBSB SFEVÎÍPEBTTBOÎÜFT/PÉNCJUPKVEJDJBMFYJTUFBconciliazione giudizialeDPNFYUJOÎÍP EPMJUÓHJPQFMPDPOTFOTPFFYUJOÎÍPEPQSPDFTTPKVEJDJBM 0 TVDFTTP BMDBOÎBEP QFMB *UÈMJB OB SFEVÎÍP EBT MJEFT USJCVUÈSJBT JOTQJSPV B &TQBOIBQBÓTEB&VSPQBRVFNBJTBDPMIFVPTJTUFNBEBBVUPMJRVJEBÎÍPFRVFNBJT SFTJTUJVBPTNFDBOJTNPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPTBJOUSPEV[JSBJOEB RVFUJNJEBNFOUFNPEJmDBÎÜFTFNTFVTJTUFNBKVSÓEJDP&NTVSHJVBmHVSBEB acta com acuerdoQSFWJTUBOPBSUEB-FZ(FOFSBM5SJCVUBSJBOJUJEBNFOUFJOTQJSBEB OPJOTUJUVUPJUBMJBOP 7. CONCLUSÃO *OTQJSBEBOBUSBOTBÎÍPEP%JSFJUP$JWJMBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBBEBQUPVP JOTUJUVUPBPSFHJNFEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPQSØQSJPEBTSFMBÎÜFTKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJBTBGBT UBOEPBBVUPOPNJBEBWPOUBEF$PNBTRVBMJmDBÎÜFTTPGSJEBTBQBSUJSEBTVBEJTDJQMJOB QFMPSFHJNFKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJPBUSBOTBÎÍPQBSUJDVMBSJ[PVTF/ÍPPCTUBOUFIBWFSBDPS EPFOUSFBTQBSUFTOÍPIÈBVUPOPNJBEFWPOUBEF /P&TUBEP%FNPDSÈUJDPEF%JSFJUPBOPSNBEFRVBMRVFSIJFSBSRVJBCVTDB TFVGVOEBNFOUPÞMUJNPEFWBMJEBEFOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBM"USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFO DPOUSBTFVGVOEBNFOUPEFWBMJEBEFOBDPNQFUÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJBEBQFTTPBQPMÓUJDBQBSB DSJBSFDPOTFRVFOUFNFOUFQBSBEJTQPSEPTUSJCVUPTNFEJBOUFMFJFTQFDÓmDBEPFOUF USJCVUBOUFOPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUP"SUfEB$' 0%JSFJUP5SJCVUÈSJPFTUÈTVKFJUPBPSFHJNFKVSÓEJDPEFEJSFJUPQÞCMJDPRVF TFRVBMJmDBFEFMJNJUBFNGVOÎÍPEFEPJTQSJODÓQJPTB TVQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞ CMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPC JOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFQFMB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJ DP"TVQSFNBDJBEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPTPCSFPQSJWBEPQSPDMBNBBTVQFSJPSJEBEFEP $G 3*#"4 "OUPOJP 4PV[B 3*#"4 -JEJB .BSJB -PQFT 3PESJHVFT "SCJUSBHFN DPNP NFJP BMUFSOBUJWP OBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas7PMVNFBOP KBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G 3*#"4 "OUPOJP 4PV[B 3*#"4 -JEJB .BSJB -PQFT 3PESJHVFT "SCJUSBHFN DPNP NFJP BMUFSOBUJWP OBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas7PMVNFBOP KBOFJSPGFWFSFJSPQ4ÍP1BVMP35 $G-"1"5;"+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSPDireito tributário – teoria geral do tributo5SBEVÎÍP3PCFSUP#BSCPTB "MWFT#BSVFSJ.BOPMFQ $G.03"*4$BSMPT:VSJ"SBVKPEF5SBOTBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBBFYQFSJÐODJBFTUSBO HFJSBFTVBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFBPEJSFJUPCSBTJMFJSP*ORevista Tributária e de Finanças Públicas7PMVNFBOP NBSÎPBCSJMQ4ÍP1BVMP35 RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 348 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos JOUFSFTTFEBDPMFUJWJEBEFDPNPDPOEJÎÍPEFTPCSFWJWÐODJBFBTTFHVSBNFOUPEBDPMFUJ WJEBEFFEPQSØQSJPQBSUJDVMBS0QSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP JNQMJDBPGBUPEFRVFOBBENJOJTUSBÎÍPPTCFOTFJOUFSFTTFTOÍPTFBDIBNFOUSFHVFTË MJWSFEJTQPTJÎÍPEBWPOUBEFEPBENJOJTUSBEPS""ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOÍPUJUVMBSJ[BJOUFSFT TFTQÞCMJDPT0UJUVMBSÏP&TUBEPRVFNBOJGFTUBBTVBWPOUBEFQFMBPSEFNMFHBMOPT MJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUP0EFTEPCSBNFOUPEFTTFTQSJODÓQJPTFNSFMBÎÍPËUSJCVUBÎÍP FËUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBÏBOFDFTTJEBEFBCTPMVUBEFMFJQBSBRVFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPQPTTB SFNJUJSUSBOTJHJSDPNQFOTBSPVEJTQPSEFCFOTPVJOUFSFTTFTFNOPNFEP&TUBEP TFNQSFDPNWJTUBTBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP "$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMBUSJCVJËMFJDPNQMFNFOUBSBDPNQFUÐODJBQBSBFT UBCFMFDFS/03."4(&3"*4FNNBUÏSJBEFMFHJTMBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFTQFDJBMNFOUFTPCSF PCSJHBÎÍPMBOÎBNFOUPDSÏEJUPQSFTDSJÎÍPFEFDBEÐODJBUSJCVUÈSJPT"SU***b EB$' 0"SUEP$5/OPSNBMHFSBMEÈPNPMEFFNRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB TFSÈQFSNJUJEBFWBMJEBEBQFMPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPCSBTJMFJSPTFNQSFEFQFOEFOUF EFMFJQFSNJTTJWBFTQFDÓmDBEPFOUFUSJCVUBOUF "SFQBSUJÎÍPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMEFDPNQFUÐODJBTOPUBEBNFOUFBDPNQFUÐODJB USJCVUÈSJB Ï EB FTTÐODJB EP QBDUP GFEFSBUJWP F EB BVUPOPNJB NVOJDJQBM F EJTUSJUBM DPOTBHSBEPTDPNPQSJODÓQJPTJOUBOHÓWFJTBPDPOTUJUVJOUFEFSJWBEP-PHPsomente a pessoa política competente para instituir o tributo é competente para dispor deleJODMVTJWF QPSJOUFSNÏEJPEFUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB "OPSNBHFSBMEP"SUEP$5/DPOGFSFVNBfaculdadeBPFOUFQPMÓ UJDPRVFQPEFSÈPVOÍPBVUPSJ[BSBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBFNTVBFTGFSBEFDPNQF UÐODJBNFEJBOUFPFYFSDÓDJPEFTVBDPNQFUÐODJBMFHJTMBUJWB5SBUBTFEFVNBPQÎÍP QPMÓUJDBBTFSFYFSDJEBBRVBMRVFSUFNQP1PSDPOTFRVÐODJBBUSBOTBÎÍPGBDVMUBEB OP"SUEP$5/QPSTJTØOÍPHFSBBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPEJSFJUPTVCKFUJWPËDFMF CSBÎÍPEFBDPSEP "MFJQFSNJTTJWBQPSFYJHÐODJBEP"SUfEB$'EFWFTFSespecífica OPTFOUJEPEFRVFEFWBveicular exclusivamente matéria relativa à transação tributária. &NSFMBÎÍPBPTEFTUJOBUÈSJPTEBOPSNBBMFJQFSNJTTJWBQPEFTFSHFSBMPVTFKBEJSJ HJEBBUPEPTPTTVKFJUPTQBTTJWPTin abstratoRVFQSFFODIBNBTDPOEJÎÜFTOFMBFTUBCF MFDJEBTPVTFSFTQFDÓmDBOPTFOUJEPEFTFSEJSJHJEBBEFUFSNJOBEPDPOUSJCVJOUFFPV ËEFUFSNJOBEBTJUVBÎÍPTFNQSFDPNWJTUBTBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP %JTQÜFPBSUEP$5/RVFBQFOBTPTsujeitos ativoFpassivoEBPCSJHB ÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQPEFNDFMFCSBSUSBOTBÎÍPFYDMVÓEPQPSUBOUPRVBMRVFSPVUSPJOUFSFT TBEPRVFOÍPQPTTBmHVSBSFNVNBEFTTBTQPTJÎÜFT4FSÈsujeito ativoEBPCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBFQPSDPOTFRVÐODJBEBUSBOTBÎÍPBQFTTPBQPMÓUJDBEPUBEBEBDPNQFUÐODJB DPOTUJUVDJPOBMUSJCVUÈSJBQBSBDSJBSPUSJCVUPPEJSFJUPEFFYJHJSOFTUFDBTPÏDPOTF RVÐODJBØCWJBEPEJSFJUPEFJOTUJUVJS PVBRVFNTFHVOEPBTSFHSBTDPOTUJUVDJPOBJTF EFTJHOBEPOBSFHSBNBUSJ[EFJODJEÐODJBGPSUSBOTGFSJEPPEJSFJUPEFBSSFDBEBSFmTDB MJ[BSPVTFKBEFFYFSDFSBDBQBDJEBEFUSJCVUÈSJBBUJWB4FSÈsujeito passivoEBPCSJHBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJBFUSBOTBUPSBQFTTPBEPUBEBEFQFSTPOBMJEBEFKVSÓEJDBJOEJDBEBOPDSJUÏSJP RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 349 QFTTPBMEPDPOTFRVFOUFOPSNBUJWPDPNPEFWFEPSEBQSFTUBÎÍPQFDVOJÈSJBOPTOFYPT PCSJHBDJPOBJTFOÍPQFDVOJÈSJBPVJOTVTDFQUÓWFMEFBWBMJBÎÍPFDPOÙNJDBOBTSFMBÎÜFT RVFWFJDVMBNNFSPTEFWFSFTJOTUSVNFOUBJTPVGPSNBJT "OPSNBHFSBMEPBSUEP$5/QSFWÐRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBTFSÈ BQFOBTterminativaEFMJUÓHJPBGBTUBOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFQSFWFOÎÍPEPMJUÓHJP5BOUP PMJUÓHJPKVEJDJBMRVBOUPPBENJOJTUSBUJWPTÍPQBTTÓWFJTEFUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBQPJT DPNPCFNEFTUBDBBCPBEPVUSJOBPFOUFOEJNFOUPNBJTBNQMPOÍPEFTOBUVSBPJOT UJUVUPOFNWBJDPOUSBBSBDJPOBMJEBEFEPTJTUFNB $POTJEFSBTFPlitígio instaladoOPÉNCJUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPDPNBBCFSUVSB EFVNQSPDFEJNFOUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPQBTTÓWFMEFKVMHBNFOUPQPSØSHÍPBENJOJTUSBUJWP DPNQFUFOUFDPNBJNQVHOBÎÍPPGFSFDJEBQFMPTVKFJUPQBTTJWP"FYJTUÐODJBEFlitígio latente QSÏWJP BP BUP EF JNQVHOBÎÍP BP MBOÎBNFOUP OB JNJOÐODJB EF TFS QPTUP Ë BQSFDJBÎÍPEFVNBJOTUÉODJBBENJOJTUSBUJWBPVKVEJDJBMQPEFSÈBUFOEFSËFYJHÐODJBEB OPSNBHFSBMEFTEFRVFQSFWJTUPOBMFJQFSNJTTJWBDPNPOPFYFNQMPFNRVFPBHFOUF mTDBMEFSFOEBTBOUFTEFRVBMRVFSBVUVBÎÍPOPUJmDBPTVKFJUPQBTTJWPBBEFRVBSTF B BMHVNB DPOEVUB RVF B "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP FOUFOEF DPSSFUB PGFSFDFOEPMIF WBOUBHFN QSFWJTUBFNMFJ 04FTUVEJPTPTEPUFNBDPODPSEBNRVFBEÞWJEBPVJODFSUF[BQBTTÓWFM EFUSBOTBÎÍPÏBRVFMBSFTJEFOUFOBTquestões de fato não suficientemente provadasBGBT UBOEPBQPTTJCJMJEBEFEFUSBOTBÎÍPFNSFMBÎÍPËTRVFTUÜFTEFEJSFJUPVNBWF[RVFB PCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBEFDPSSFEFMFJFOÍPQPEFQFMPDPOTFOTPTFSBMUFSBEB"USBO TBÎÍPQPSUBOUPTFSJBBQMJDÈWFMPOEFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOÍPUFNDFSUF[BEBPDPSSÐODJB EPGBUPKVSÓEJDPUSJCVUÈSJPPVOBJOUFSQSFUBÎÍPEPTGBUPTKVSÓEJDPTFTQFDJBMNFOUFOPT DBTPTTVKFJUPTBSFHJNFEFQSFTVOÎÜFTRVBOEPIPVWFSEJmDVMEBEFEFEFNBSDBÎÍPEF DPODFJUPTGÈUJDPTFRVBOEPOÍPIPVWFSQSPWBTPVGPSFNFTUBTJOTVmDJFOUFT&OUFOEF NPTOBEBJNQFEJSRVFPMFHJTMBEPSJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBPEJTDJQMJOBSBUSBOTBÎÍPFN TFVÉNCJUPEFDPNQFUÐODJBDSJFDSJUÏSJPTNBJTBNQMPTQBSBFTUBCFMFDFSDPNWJTUBTË USBOTBÎÍPTFVNBRVFTUÍPÏMJUJHJPTB"MFHJUJNJEBEFEFTTBRVBMJmDBÎÍPEFQFOEFSÈEP DPOKVOUPEFDPOEJÎÜFTFDPODFTTÜFTSFDÓQSPDBTFTUBCFMFDJEBTOBMFJBVUPSJ[BEPSBFEBT TJUVBÎÜFTRVFWJTBSÈBBUJOHJSDPNQPOEPVNUPEPIBSNÙOJDPRVFSFnJUBBJOUFMJHÐODJB EBMFJFTFVGPDPOPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDP "OPSNBHFSBMEPBSUJHPEP$5/FTUBCFMFDFRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈ SJBFOWPMWFSÈconcessões mútuas/ÍPTFUSBUBSÈEFUSBOTBÎÍPDBTPTPNFOUFVNBQBSUF DPODFEFSFTJNSFNJTTÍPEBÎÍPFNQBHBNFOUPEPBÎÍPPVNFSBEFTJTUÐODJB /ÍPIÈOPPSEFOBNFOUPKVSÓEJDPOFOIVNBQSPJCJÎÍPËUSBOTBÎÍPFNSFMB ÎÍPBPcrédito tributário&NMVHBSEFQSPJCJÎÍPIÈQSFWJTÍPOBOPSNBHFSBMEPBSU &YFNQMPGPSOFDJEPQPS$MFETPO.PSFJSB(BMJOBSJOPTFVA aplicabilidade da transação no direito tributário brasileiro%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXBQFUPSHCSBSUJHPTWFSBTQ BSU@JEBVUPS0NBS 5BOVTEF"SBVKP.BMVG"DFTTPFNTFU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 350 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos EP$5/EFRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBTFSÈDBVTBFYUJOUJWBUPUBMPVQBSDJBMEPDSÏEJUP USJCVUÈSJP"TQFDUPDPNQMFNFOUBSFJNQPSUBOUFRVFNFSFDFTFSEFTUBDBEPÏBOPÎÍPEF RVFPUSJCVUPTFFORVBESBOBDBUFHPSJBEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTTFDVOEÈSJPTEP&TUBEP PTRVBJTQPSOÍPTFSFNBSB[ÍPÞMUJNBEFFYJTUJSEP&TUBEPSFWFMBNTFJOTUSVNFOUBJTË TBUJTGBÎÍPEPTJOUFSFTTFTQÞCMJDPTQSJNÈSJPTBTTJNRVBMJmDBEPTQFMB$POTUJUVJÎÍP&N GVOÎÍP EB TVB OBUVSF[B JOTUSVNFOUBM PT JOUFSFTTFT QÞCMJDPT TFDVOEÈSJPT QPEFN TFS EJTQPTUPTTFNQSFQPSJOUFSNÏEJPEFMFJFOPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUPRVBOEPFTTB EJTQPTJÎÍPTFSFWFMFFTTFODJBMBPBUJOHJNFOUPEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPQSJNÈSJP DPMJNBEP "Tcondições e limitesQBSBBUSBOTBÎÍPBMÏNEFDPNQBUÓWFJTDPNBOPS NBHFSBMEFWFNTFSmYBEPTFNMFJFTQFDÓmDB/BBVTÐODJBEFTTBNBUFSJBMJEBEFBMFJ QFSNJTTJWBTFSÈJODPOTUJUVDJPOBM%FDPSSFNBJTVNBWF[EPQSJODÓQJPEBJOEJTQPOJ CJMJEBEFEPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPBOPÎÍPEFRVFPOEFIPVWFSEJTQPTJÎÍPEFWFSÈIBWFS BVUPSJ[BÎÍPMFHBMFTQFDÓmDBMJNJUBOEPFCBMJ[BOEPFTTBEJTQPOJCJMJEBEFQPJTBQFOBT P&TUBEPÏDPNQFUFOUFQBSBEJTQPSOPTMJNJUFTEPPSEFOBNFOUPFOPTUFSNPTEBMFJ FYQFEJEBOÍPPBENJOJTUSBEPS 0MFHJTMBEPSJOGSBDPOTUJUVDJPOBMBPEFmOJSBTDPOEJÎÜFTQBSBBUSBOTBÎÍP QPEFSÈPVOÍPBCSJSmargens discricionáriasË"ENJOJTUSBÎÍP"BCFSUVSBEFNBSHFOT EJTDSJDJPOÈSJBTQSFTTVQÜFBmYBÎÍPEFCBMJ[BNFOUPTQFMBMFJQFSNJTTJWBQBSBBUVBÎÍP EB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPOPDBTPDPODSFUPQPSRVBOUPIÈPSFDPOIFDJNFOUPEPMFHJTMBEPSEF RVFOÍPQPEFEJTDJQMJOBSUPEBTBTTJUVBÎÜFTOFNQSFWFSUPEBTBTOVBOÎBTQBSBBUJOHJS EFGPSNBNBJTQMFOBPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPmOBMÓTUJDPEBOPSNB"EJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEF OÍP Ï QPSUBOUP VN QPEFS BSCJUSÈSJP DPOGFSJEP Ë "ENJOJTUSBÎÍP 1ÞCMJDB NBT VN EFWFSQPEFSRVFEFWFTFSFYFSDJEPFTUSJUBNFOUFQSFTPBPEFTJEFSBUPNBJPSEFBUFOEFS EBNFMIPSNBOFJSBQPTTÓWFMBPCFNDPNVN "OPSNBHFSBMEPBSUJHPEP$5/FTUBCFMFDFRVFBUSBOTBÎÍPEFWFSÈ QÙSmNBMJUÓHJPFFYUJOHVJSPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJP"USBOTBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJBTFEFTUJOBEF GBUPBQÙSmNBMJUÓHJPQPSÏNnem sempre terá como consequência a extinção da obrigação tributária.5SBUBTFEFJOTUSVNFOUPviabilizador EBFYUJOÎÍPEBPCSJHBÎÍPRVF QPEFSÈPVOÍPPDPSSFSEFQFOEFOUFTFNQSFEPBEJNQMFNFOUPEPRVFGPSQBDUVBEP TFOEPJSSFMFWBOUFQPSUBOUPPGBUPEBUSBOTBÎÍPDPNQPSPSPMEFDBVTBTFYUJOUJWBTEB PCSJHBÎÍPUSJCVUÈSJB"SUEP$5/ &NSFMBÎÍPBP*$.4PTFOUFTGFEFSBEPTOÍPQPTTVFNBVUPOPNJBQBSB JOTUJUVJSUSJCVUBÎÍPFYDFQUJWBQPSMJNJUBÎÍPJNQPTUBQFMPQSØQSJPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJP OBMOPTFV"SUf9**HEB$POTUJUVJÎÍP'FEFSBMRVFFYJHFQBSBDPODFTTÍP PVSFWPHBÎÍPEFJTFOÎÜFTJODFOUJWPTFCFOFGÓDJPTmTDBJT préviaEFMJCFSBÎÍPEPT&T UBEPTF%JTUSJUP'FEFSBMOPTUFSNPTFNRVFEJTDJQMJOBSBMFJDPNQMFNFOUBS0"SU EB-$OEJTQÜFRVFPTconvêniosEFmOJSÍPBTcondições geraisFNRVFPT FOUFTGFEFSBEPTQPEFSÍPDPODFEFSBOJTUJBSFNJTTÍPFtransaçãoCFNDPNPQBSDFMB NFOUPTFBNQMJBÎÍPEFQSB[PQBSBSFDPMIJNFOUPEPUSJCVUP &OUFOEFNPT RVF DBTP B USBOTBÎÍP OÍP FOWPMWB B DPODFTTÍP EF CFOFGÓ DJPTPVJODFOUJWPTRVFOÍPPTKÈBVUPSJ[BEPTFNPVUSPTDPOWÐOJPTBJOEBFNWJHPS RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 Transação tributária no Brasil: possibilidades e limites 351 DPSSFTQPOEFOEPBBDPSEPFNUPSOPEFRVFTUÜFTDPOUSPWFSUJEBTEFGBUPPVEFEJSFJUP RVFSFEV[BNPVFYUJOHBNPDSÏEJUPUSJCVUÈSJPOÍPIBWFSÈBOFDFTTJEBEFEFDPOWÐOJP FYJHJOEPTFEFRVBMRVFSGPSNBMFJQFSNJTTJWBEPFOUFUSJCVUBOUF 0FYBNFEPEJSFJUPDPNQBSBEPBRVFOPTQSPQVTFNPTOPQSFTFOUFFTUVEP TFSWFDPNPJEFOUJmDBEPSEPTQSPCMFNBTFNHSBOEFQBSUFDPNVOTFOGSFOUBEPTQPSPSEF OBNFOUPTRVFDPNPPCSBTJMFJSPJNQMBOUBSBNPSFHJNFEPBVUPMBOÎBNFOUPPSJHJOÈSJPEPT TJTUFNBTBOHMPTBYÜFTTFNTFGB[FSBDPNQBOIBSEPTJOTUSVNFOUPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEFTPMVÎÍP EFDPOnJUPTRVFMIFTTÍPQSØQSJPTSFTVMUBOEPFNBVNFOUPWFSUJHJOPTPEBMJUJHJPTJEBEFF TVGPDBNFOUPEP1PEFS+VEJDJÈSJP.FSBJNQPSUBÎÍPEFNPEFMPTFTUSBOHFJSPTEFTPMVÎÍPEF DPOnJUPTBJOEBRVFFYJUPTPTFTCBSSBNFNTÏSJBTMJNJUBÎÜFTEPOPTTPTJTUFNBUSJCVUÈSJPRVF EFJUBSBÓ[FTOPUFYUPDPOTUJUVDJPOBMUPSOBOEPPSÓHJEPFSFTJTUFOUFBNVEBOÎBTNBJTPVTB EBT"SJHJEF[EPTJTUFNBUSJCVUÈSJPCSBTJMFJSPQPSTVBWF[GBWPSFDFVNBNBJPSSFnFYÍPFN UPSOPEFUFNBTDPOUSPWFSUJEPTFFYJHFVNBBÎÍPNBJTNBEVSBEPMFHJTMBEPS "T QPTTJCJMJEBEFT F PT MJNJUFT BQSFTFOUBEPT OP QSFTFOUF FTUVEP QBSB B USBOTBÎÍP USJCVUÈSJB OP #SBTJM GVODJPOBN NFOPT DPNP CBSSFJSBT F NBJT DPNP JOEJ DBUJWPTEPTQPOUPTOPTRVBJTPMFHJTMBEPSEFWFSÈTFEFUFSOPNPNFOUPEFUSBÎBSPT DPOUPSOPT EB BVUPSJ[BÎÍP USBOTBDJPOBM 4VB MFHJUJNJEBEF EFQFOEFSÈ EBT DPOEJÎÜFT MJNJUFTFHSBEVBÎÜFTRVFBMFJQFSNJTTJWBFTUBCFMFDFSGPSNBOEPVNUPEPIBSNÙOJDP RVFFWJEFODJFPJOUFSFTTFQÞCMJDPFNBUFOEJNFOUP REFERÊNCIAS "3"6+0/BEKBTransação Tributária: possibilidade de consenso na obrigação imposta.1PSUP "MFHSF/VSJB'BCSJT #"5*45"+30OPGSF"MWFT5SBOTBÎÍPOPEJSFJUPUSJCVUÈSJPEJTDSJDJPOBSJFEBEFFJOUFSFTTF QÞCMJDP*ORevista Dialética de Direito Tributário.7PMVNF4ÍP1BVMP&E%JBMÏUJDB $"33";;"3PRVF"OUPOJPCurso de Direito Constitucional Tributário4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJ SPT $"33";;"3PRVF"OUPOJPICMS.4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT $"37"-)01BVMPEF#BSSPTCurso de Direito Tributário4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB $"37"-)03VCFOT.JSBOEBTransação tributária, arbitragem e outras formas convencionadas de solução de lides tributárias. 4ÍP1BVMP+VBSF[EF0MJWFJSB $045"3FHJOB)FMFOBCurso de Direito Tributário: Constituição e Código Tributário Nacional4ÍP1BVMP4BSBJWB %*1*&530.BSJB4ZMWJB;BOFMMBDireito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP"UMBT '*(6&*3&%01BVMP)FOSJRVFA transação tributária como expressão dos direitos do cidadão3FDJGF&EJÎÜFT#BHBÎP ("-*/"3* $MFETPO .PSFJSB A aplicabilidade da transação no direito tributário brasileiro. %JTQPOÓWFM FN IUUQXXXBQFUPSHCSBSUJHPTWFSBTQ BSU@JEBVUPS0NBS 5BOVTEF"SBVKP.BMVG"DFTTPFNTFU RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 352 Lucilia Aparecida dos Santos (0%0:"SOBMEP4BNQBJPEF.PSBFT045+FBOBUVSF[BKVSÓEJDBEBEFDJTÍPIPNPMP HBUØSJBEFUSBOTBÎÍPmTDBM*ORevista de Processo RePro. 7PMVNFBOPPVUVCSP 4ÍP1BVMP35 (0%0:"SOBMEP4BNQBJPEF.PSBFTTransação tributária – introdução à justiça fiscal consensual. #FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN )037"5)&TUFWÍPLançamento tributário e “autolaçamentow4ÍP1BVMP2VBSUJFS-BUJO +03(&5ÈSTJT/BNFUBMB4BSMPManual do ICMS – Direito Tributário Material, Processual e Direito Penal Tributário3JPEF+BOFJSP&E-VNFO+VSJT -"1"5;"+PTÏ+VBO'FSSFJSPDireito tributário – teoria geral do tributo5SBEVÎÍP3PCFSUP #BSCPTB"MWFT#BSVFSJ.BOPMF -&.&4 4FMNB Arbitragem na Administração Pública – fundamentos jurídicos e eficiência econômica.4ÍP1BVMP2VBSUJFS-BUJO ."$)"%0)VHPEF#SJUP5SBOTBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNOPÉNCJUPUSJCVUÈSJP*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributário – RFDT7PMVNFBOPKVMIP#FMP)PSJ [POUF&E'ØSVN%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJECJE1SJOU$PO UFVEPBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFNOPW .&*3&--&4)FMZ-PQFTDireito Administrativo Brasileiro4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEF. Curso de Direito Administrativo4ÍP1BVMP.BMIFJSPT .&--0$FMTP"OUÙOJP#BOEFJSBEFDiscricionariedade e controle jurisdicional. 4ÍP1BVMP .BMIFJSPT .03"*4$BSMPT:VSJ"SBVKPEF5SBOTBÎÍPFBSCJUSBHFNFNNBUÏSJBUSJCVUÈSJBBFYQFSJÐO DJBFTUSBOHFJSBFTVBBQMJDBCJMJEBEFBPEJSFJUPCSBTJMFJSP*ORevista Tributária e de Finanças Públicas7PMVNFBOPNBSÎPBCSJM4ÍP1BVMP35 3*#"4"OUPOJP4PV[B3*#"4-JEJB.BSJB-PQFT3PESJHVFT"SCJUSBHFNDPNPNFJPBMUFS OBUJWPOBTPMVÎÍPEFDPOUSPWÏSTJBTUSJCVUÈSJBT*ORevista tributária e de finanças públicas. 7PMVNFBOPKBOFJSPGFWFSFJSP4ÍP1BVMP35 5¼33&4)FMFOP5BWFJSB5SBOTBÎÍPBSCJUSBHFNFDPODJMJBÎÍPKVEJDJBMDPNPNFEJEBTBMUFSOBUJWBT QBSBSFTPMVÎÍPEFDPOnJUPFOUSFB"ENJOJTUSBÎÍPF$POUSJCVJOUFToTJNQMJmDBÎÍPFFmDJÐODJB BENJOJTUSBUJWB*OBiblioteca Digital Revista Fórum de Direito Tributárioo3'%57PMVNFBOP NBSÎP#FMP)PSJ[POUF&E'ØSVN%JTQPOÓWFMFNIUUQXXXFEJUGPSVNDPNCSCJE CJE1SJOU$POUFVEPBTQY JE$POUFVEP"DFTTPFNOPW 5¼33&4)FMFOPDireito Tributário e Direito Privado: autonomia privada, simulação, elisão tributária.4ÍP1BVMP35 5033&43JDBSEP-PCPCurso de Direito Financeiro e Tributário.3JPEF+BOFJSP3FOPWBS RESPGE - SP São Paulo v. 3 n. 1 jan./dez. 2012 p. 321 a 352 ESCOLA SUPERIOR DA PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO DE SÃO PAULO ESPGE ESCOLA SUPERIOR DA PROCURADORIA GERAL DO ESTADO DE SÃO PAULO ISSN 2179-8532 9 772179 853008 ESPGE