\\Academica-07\c\EVENTOS REALIZADOS _ PROVAS\2004_5

\\Academica-07\c\EVENTOS REALIZADOS _ PROVAS\2004_5

&GCEQTFQEQOQEQOCPFQCSWGECFCWOFQUKVGPUFG1 C 200UGTGHKTCOCTSWGPCfolha de respostasRCTCECFCKVGOQ
ECORQFGUKIPCFQEQOQEÎFKIQCECUQLWNIWGQKVGOCERTOQWQECORQFGUKIPCFQEQOQEÎFKIQEECUQLWNIWGQKVGO
ERRADO#CWUÄPEKCFGOCTECÁºQQWCOCTECÁºQFGCODQUQUECORQUPºQUGTºQCRGPCFCUQWUGLCPºQTGEGDGTºQRQPVWCÁºQ
PGICVKXC2CTCCUFGXKFCUOCTECÁÐGUWUGCHQNJCFGTCUEWPJQGRQUVGTKQTOGPVGCfolhaderespostasÕPKEQFQEWOGPVQX¶NKFQ
RCTCCEQTTGÁºQFCUWCRTQXC
GRUPO I: DIREITOS ADMINISTRATIVO, TRIBUTÁRIO E AMBIENTAL
'O TGNCÁºQ CQ NKEGPEKCOGPVQ CODKGPVCN G CQ GUVWFQ FG
KORCEVQCODKGPVCNLWNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGU
#UCVKXKFCFGURQVGPEKCNOGPVGECWUCFQTCUFGFGITCFCÁºQ
CODKGPVCNGUVºQUWLGKVCUCGUVWFQFGKORCEVQCODKGPVCN
Q SWCN FGXGT¶ UGT GZKIKFQ UQOGPVG PQ EWTUQ FQ
GORTGGPFKOGPVQCETKVÃTKQFCCWVQTKFCFGCFOKPKUVTCVKXC
ECUQ UGLC EQPUVCVCFQ TKUEQ TGCN FG FCPQU CQ OGKQ
CODKGPVG
1GUVWFQFGKORCEVQCODKGPVCNRQFGUGTUWDUVKVWÈFQRQT
RNCPQFGOCPGLQUWUVGPVCFQGOECUQFGTGHNQTGUVCOGPVQ
FG¶TGCUFGITCFCFCUGNQECNK\CFCUPQVGTTKVÎTKQFQ'UVCFQ
OGODTQVGPFQEQOQDCUGNGKGUVCFWCN
#EQPEGUUºQFGNKEGPÁCCODKGPVCNFGQRGTCÁºQPºQIGTC
FKTGKVQCFSWKTKFQCQGORTGGPFGFQTRQFGPFQUGTTGXKUVC
RGNCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQCKPFCSWGPQRTC\QFGUWCXCNKFCFG
ECUQUGLCEQPUVCVCFCCUWRGTXGPKÄPEKCFGITCXGKORCEVQ
CODKGPVCNPGICVKXQ
0QU VGTOQU FC TGIWNCOGPVCÁºQ HGFGTCN Q EWUVGKQ FQU
JQPQT¶TKQUFQURTQHKUUKQPCKUGPECTTGICFQUFCGNCDQTCÁºQ
FG GUVWFQ FG KORCEVQ CODKGPVCN EQPUVKVWK ÏPWU FQ
RTÎRTKQ GORTGGPFGFQT ECDGPFQ C GUVG VCODÃO C
GUEQNJCFQUVÃEPKEQUKPEWODKFQUFCCVKXKFCFG
0QEWTUQFQRTQEGFKOGPVQFGNKEGPEKCOGPVQCODKGPVCN
QTICPK\CÁÐGU PºQIQXGTPCOGPVCKU QW Q /KPKUVÃTKQ
2ÕDNKEQ RQFGTºQ UQNKEKVCT CQ ÎTIºQ CODKGPVCN C
TGCNK\CÁºQ FG CWFKÄPEKC RÕDNKEC RCTC FKUEWUUºQ FQU
KORCEVQU CODKGPVCKU C SWCN TGRTGUGPVC WOC GVCRC FQ
NKEGPEKCOGPVQ G SWG UGTXKT¶ FG DCUG RCTC CP¶NKUG FQ
ÎTIºQNKEGPEKCFQTFGXGPFQCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQCODKGPVCN
CECVCTCUEQPENWUÐGUFGUUCCWFKÄPEKCRÕDNKECPQSWGUG
TGHGTGCQFGHGTKOGPVQQWPºQFCNKEGPÁC
# %QPUVKVWKÁºQ DTCUKNGKTC FG CFQVQW Q OQFGNQ FG
HGFGTCNKUOQ EQQRGTCVKXQ GUVCDGNGEGPFQ C EQGZKUVÄPEKC FG
EQORGVÄPEKCU RTKXCVKXCU G FG EQORGVÄPEKCU EQOWPU
FKUVTKDWÈFCUGPVTGQUFKXGTUQUGPVGURQNÈVKEQU0QVQECPVG´
KORNGOGPVCÁºQFGRQNÈVKECURÕDNKECUC%QPUVKVWKÁºQHKZQWWO
TQNFGEQORGVÄPEKCUOCVGTKCKUUWDNKPJCPFQQQDLGVKXQIGTCN
FQRQFGTRÕDNKEQPCGZGEWÁºQFCUVCTGHCUGPWPEKCFCU%QO
DCUGGOVCKUEQPUKFGTCÁÐGULWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
%QORGVG´7PKºQCQUGUVCFQUCQ&KUVTKVQ(GFGTCNGCQU
OWPKEÈRKQU RTQOQXGT OGFKFCU FG RTQVGÁºQ FQ OGKQ
CODKGPVGECDGPFQCQUOWPKEÈRKQUGZGTEGTUGWRQFGTFG
RQNÈEKCCRGPCUGOTGNCÁºQCCVKXKFCFGUFGKORCEVQNQECN
&GCEQTFQEQOCNGIKUNCÁºQHGFGTCNEQORGVGCQ+$#/#
QNKEGPEKCOGPVQFGQDTCUQWCVKXKFCFGUEQOUKIPKHKECVKXQ
KORCEVQ FG ¸ODKVQ PCEKQPCN CQU ÎTIºQU CODKGPVCKU
GUVCFWCKU Q NKEGPEKCOGPVQ FG QDTCU G CVKXKFCFGU FG
¸ODKVQTGIKQPCNGCQUOWPKEÈRKQUQNKEGPEKCOGPVQFG
CVKXKFCFGU FG ¸ODKVQ NQECN G FCSWGNCU SWG NJGU HQTGO
FGNGICFCU OGFKCPVG EQPXÄPKQ QWXKFQU QU ÎTIºQU
CODKGPVCKUHGFGTCNGGUVCFWCN
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
%QPUKFGTCPFQCRTQVGÁºQFQRCVTKOÏPKQEWNVWTCNDTCUKNGKTQ
LWNIWGQURTÎZKOQUKVGPU
1RTQRTKGV¶TKQFGDGOVQODCFQGOTC\ºQFGUGWXCNQT
JKUVÎTKEQEWNVWTCNPCEKQPCNVGOQFGXGTFGEQPUGTX¶NQ
RQFGPFQ UGT FGNG GZKIKFC C TGCNK\CÁºQ FG QDTCU FG
EQPUGTXCÁºQ QW TGRCTCÁºQ ´U UWCU GZRGPUCU UCNXQ
JKRQUUWHKEKÄPEKCGEQPÏOKECFQRTQRTKGV¶TKQQWWTIÄPEKC
PCTGCNK\CÁºQFGUUCUQDTCUJKRÎVGUGUGOSWGC7PKºQ
RQFGT¶FGURGPFGTTGEWTUQURÕDNKEQUPCEQPUGTXCÁºQQW
PCTGRCTCÁºQFCSWGNGDGORTKXCFQ
5GORTGLWÈ\QFCCVWCÁºQFCEQOWPKFCFGC7PKºQPQ
GZGTEÈEKQFGUWCEQORGVÄPEKCCFOKPKUVTCVKXCFGXGCFQVCT
OGFKFCUFGRTQVGÁºQFQRCVTKOÏPKQEWNVWTCNDTCUKNGKTQ
PQSWCNVCODÃOUGKPENWGOCUHQTOCUFGGZRTGUUºQGCU
ETKCÁÐGUVGEPQNÎIKECUCFQVCPFQRCTCVCPVQOGFKFCUFG
VQODCOGPVQ FGUCRTQRTKCÁºQ KPXGPV¶TKQU QW QWVTCU
HQTOCUFGCECWVGNCOGPVQ
,WNIWG QU KVGPU UWDUGS×GPVGU TGNCVKXQU CQU RTKPEÈRKQU
TGIGFQTGUFCRTQVGÁºQLWTÈFKECFQOGKQCODKGPVG
#RTQOQÁºQFQOGKQCODKGPVGUCFKQGGEQNQIKECOGPVG
GSWKNKDTCFQCVWCEQOQHCVQTFGNKOKVCÁºQCQFKTGKVQFG
RTQRTKGFCFG TC\ºQ RGNC SWCN C GZKUVÄPEKC FG ¶TGC FG
RTGUGTXCÁºQ RGTOCPGPVG GO GURCÁQ RGTVGPEGPVG C
RCTVKEWNCT PºQ CECTTGVC FKTGKVQ C KPFGPK\CÁºQ UCNXQ
SWCPFQ KPXKCDKNK\CT VQVCNOGPVG Q CRTQXGKVCOGPVQ
GEQPÏOKEQFQDGO
1RTKPEÈRKQFQFGUGPXQNXKOGPVQUWUVGPV¶XGNRTGEQPK\C
WOGNQGPVTGCGEQPQOKCGCGEQNQIKCGUVCPFQTGHGTKFQ
GO FKXGTUCU FGENCTCÁÐGU KPVGTPCEKQPCKU OCU RQT PºQ
GUVCTRTGXKUVQGZRTGUUCOGPVGPC%QPUVKVWKÁºQDTCUKNGKTC
CVWC CRGPCU EQOQ CURKTCÁºQ UQEKCN G XGVQT KFGQNÎIKEQ
RCTCCCVKXKFCFGGEQPÏOKEC
1URTKPEÈRKQUFCRCTVKEKRCÁºQEQOWPKV¶TKCGFCGS×KFCFG
KPVGTIGTCEKQPCNVÄOUGFGEQPUVKVWEKQPCNWOCXG\SWGC
%QPUVKVWKÁºQ DTCUKNGKTC GUVCDGNGEG C HCEWNFCFG FG C
EQNGVKXKFCFGRTCVKECTCVQUEQOXKUVCU´RTQVGÁºQFQOGKQ
CODKGPVG G UWC RTGUGTXCÁºQ GO RTQN FCU RTGUGPVGU G
HWVWTCUIGTCÁÐGU
'O TGNCÁºQ ´U KPHTCÁÐGU CFOKPKUVTCVKXCU CODKGPVCKU G ´
CVKXKFCFGUCPEKQPCFQTCFQ'UVCFQLWNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGU
# NGIKUNCÁºQ DTCUKNGKTC CFQVC EQOQ TGITC IGTCN C
RTGUEKPFKDKNKFCFGFQGNGOGPVQFCEWNRCDKNKFCFGRCTCC
ECTCEVGTK\CÁºQ FC KPHTCÁºQ CFOKPKUVTCVKXC CODKGPVCN
FKURGPUCPFQCCRWTCÁºQFCXQPVCFGFQKPHTCVQT2CTCC
EQPHKIWTCÁºQFCKPHTCÁºQCFOKPKUVTCVKXCCODKGPVCNDCUVC
RQTVCPVQQEQORQTVCOGPVQVÈRKEQFQCFOKPKUVTCFQEQO
CXKQNCÁºQFCUPQTOCUFGRTQVGÁºQCQOGKQCODKGPVG
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–1–
'O ECUQ FG KPHTCÁºQ CFOKPKUVTCVKXC CODKGPVCN C
FGRGPFGTFCITCXKFCFGFQHCVQGFQUCPVGEGFGPVGUFQ
KPHTCVQT C CFOKPKUVTCÁºQ RQFGT¶ KORQT C UCPÁºQ FG
UWURGPUºQ FG QDTC NGUKXC CQ OGKQ CODKGPVG OCU PºQ
RQFGT¶FGVGTOKPCTUWCFGOQNKÁºQCSWCNFGRGPFGT¶FG
QTFGO LWFKEKCN C UGT UQNKEKVCFC RGNQ ÎTIºQ CODKGPVCN
EQORGVGPVG CRÎU Q GPEGTTCOGPVQ FQ RTQEGUUQ
CFOKPKUVTCVKXQ GO SWG HKSWG EQPUVCVCFC C QHGPUC ´U
PQTOCURTQVGVKXCUFQOGKQCODKGPVG
# NGIKUNCÁºQ RTGXÄ C CRTGGPUºQ FQU RTQFWVQU G
UWDRTQFWVQUFCHCWPCGHNQTCGOECUQFGEQPUVCVCÁºQFG
KPHTCÁºQRQTKPKEKCVKXCFCRTÎRTKCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQ#NGK
PºQCFOKVGEQPVWFQCCRTGGPUºQRGNCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQ
FQU GSWKRCOGPVQU QW XGÈEWNQU WVKNK\CFQU PC KPHTCÁºQ
CFOKPKUVTCVKXCCODKGPVCNUCNXQUGEQPUKUVKTGOGOQDLGVQU
EWLQ HCDTKEQ CNKGPCÁºQ WUQ RQTVG QW FGVGPÁºQ
EQPUVKVWCOHCVQKNÈEKVQ
7O EQOGTEKCPVG RQUUWKFQT FG ETÃFKVQ LWPVQ ´
4GEGKVC(GFGTCNRTQXGPKGPVGFGKORQUVQFGUWCEQORGVÄPEKC
HCEGFGENCTCÁºQFGKPEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFGRGNQ56(TGSWGTGW
CFOKPKUVTCVKXCOGPVGCEQORGPUCÁºQFQUXCNQTGUCRWTCFQU
EQOFÃDKVQRTÎRTKQGRGPFGPVGFGRCICOGPVQ&GEQTTKFQU
CPQUCCWVQTKFCFGCFOKPKUVTCVKXCCKPFCPºQVKPJCCPCNKUCFQ
QRGFKFQ
#TGURGKVQFCUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKECCRTGUGPVCFCCEKOCLWNIWG
QUKVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGU
%CUQQKORQUVQUGLCFQVKRQNCPÁCFQRQTJQOQNQICÁºQ
QOCPFCFQFGUGIWTCPÁCSWGRQUUCXKTCUGTKORGVTCFQ
RGNQEQOGTEKCPVGEQPVTCCQOKUUºQCFOKPKUVTCVKXCUGT¶
EQPJGEKFQCKPFCSWGQRGFKFQVKXGTRQTDCUGCEQTTGÁºQ
FQGPEQPVTQFGFÃDKVQUGETÃFKVQU
1EQPVTKDWKPVGFGXGT¶GHGVKXCTCEQORGPUCÁºQGOUGWU
NKXTQU HKUECKU NGXCPFQ VCKU HCVQU CQ EQPJGEKOGPVQ FQ
RQFGT LWFKEK¶TKQ RCTC SWG JQOQNQIWG Q NCPÁCOGPVQ
TGCNK\CFQ RGNC XKC OCPFCOGPVCN QDLGVKXCPFQ C
FGENCTCÁºQFGTGIWNCTKFCFGFCEQORGPUCÁºQ
6TCVCPFQUGFGKORQUVQUQDTGRTQFWVQUKPFWUVTKCNK\CFQU
+2+QEQOGTEKCPVGVGT¶FKTGKVQ´TGUVKVWKÁºQFQKPFÃDKVQ
ECUQEQORTQXGPºQVGTTGRCUUCFQQÏPWUVTKDWV¶TKQQW
GUVGLCFGXKFCOGPVGCWVQTK\CFQRGNQEQPVTKDWKPVGFGHCVQ
RQKUFQEQPVT¶TKQJCXGTKCGPTKSWGEKOGPVQUGOECWUCG
GPVTG GPTKSWGEGT C RCTVKEWNCT QW Q 'UVCFQ VGO GUUG
ÕNVKOQ C RTGXCNÄPEKC RTGUWOKPFQUG VGT Q 'UVCFQ
CRNKECFQQUTGEWTUQUCTTGECFCFQUGOUGTXKÁQURÕDNKEQU
0QTGHGTGPVGCEQORGVÄPEKCVTKDWV¶TKCVTCVCFQUGEQPXGPÁÐGU
KPVGTPCEKQPCKULWNIWGQURTÎZKOQUKVGPU
%QPUKFGTG SWG Q $TCUKN CUUKPQW EQPVTCVQ EQO Q %JKNG
RGNQSWCNPºQKPEKFKT¶VTKDWVQUPCKORQTVCÁºQFGUCNOºQ
G GO EQORGPUCÁºQ PºQ JCXGT¶ VTKDWVCÁºQ PC
GZRQTVCÁºQ FG RGUECFC COCTGNC 0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ VCN
EQPXGPÁºQCRGUCTFGTGIWNCTRTQEGFKOGPVQKPVGTPQSWG
GUVCDGNGEGWXKIÄPEKCGCRNKECÁºQPºQCDTCPIGVTKDWVQU
FGEQORGVÄPEKCGUVCFWCN
#UUKPCFC EQPXGPÁºQ KPVGTPCEKQPCN GPVTG RCÈUGU FC
#OÃTKECFQ5WNXKUCPFQ´FKOKPWKÁºQFCECTICVTKDWV¶TKC
UWCKPVGITCÁºQPQUKUVGOCPQTOCVKXQKPVGTPQFCTUG¶PQ
OQOGPVQ FG UWC CUUKPCVWTC RGNQ 'UVCFQ DTCUKNGKTQ
RQFGPFQ Q GZGSW¶VWT UGT GZKIKFQ RGTCPVG Q 5WRTGOQ
6TKDWPCN(GFGTCN
56(
1U VTCVCFQU KPVGTPCEKQPCKU RQFGO UGT FG PCVWTG\C
PQTOCVKXC ō VTCVCFQNGK ō QW EQPVTCVWCN ō VTCVCFQ
EQPVTCVQ ō UGPFQ Q RTKOGKTQ JKGTCTSWKECOGPVG
UWRGTKQTCQUGIWPFQ
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
C /CIPC %CTVC FG FG LWPJQ FG EQPUKIPCXC GO UGW CTVKIQ :++ SWG PGPJWO CWZÈNKQ QW
EQPVTKDWKÁºQ UG GUVCDGNGEGTKC UGO Q EQPUGPVKOGPVQ FQ
%QPUGNJQFQ4GKPQ(KTOCXCUGFGUUCHQTOCQ2TKPEÈRKQFG
%QPUGPVKOGPVQFQU6TKDWVQURGNQU5ÕFKVQUEQOQUKUVGOCFG
RTQVGÁºQFQEQPVTKDWKPVGFCÃRQECEQPVTCQURQUUÈXGKUCDWUQU
FC/QPCTSWKC
1PQHTG #NXGU $CVKUVC ,ÕPKQT O Poder de Polícia
Fiscal /CPFCOGPVQU R EQO CFCRVCÁÐGU
%QPUKFGTCPFQQVGZVQCEKOCGEQOTGHGTÄPEKC´%QPUVKVWKÁºQ
DTCUKNGKTCFGGCUICTCPVKCUCUUGIWTCFCUCQEQPVTKDWKPVG
LWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
1RTKPEÈRKQFCCPVGTKQTKFCFGVTKDWV¶TKCPºQUGEQPHWPFG
EQOQFCCPWCNKFCFGUGPFQGUVGÕNVKOQTGLGKVCFQRGNQ
CVWCNQTFGPCOGPVQEQPUVKVWEKQPCNL¶SWGCNGKSWGETKC
VTKDWVQURQFGUGTCPVGTKQTCQQTÁCOGPVQ
1RTKPEÈRKQFCCPVGTKQTKFCFGVTKDWV¶TKCÃEN¶WUWNCRÃVTGC
EQPUVKVWEKQPCNPQSWGUGTGHGTG´OCLQTCÁºQFGVTKDWVQU
PºQ RQFGPFQ UGT GZEGREKQPCFC RQT GOGPFC
EQPUVKVWEKQPCN UGPFQ EGTVQ SWG VCN PºQ UG CRNKEC CQ
KORQUVQUQDTGQRGTCÁÐGUHKPCPEGKTCU
+1(
œNÈEKVQ´7PKºQHCEGCEQORGVÄPEKCVTKDWV¶TKCTGUKFWCN
ETKCTEQPVTKDWKÁºQKPEKFGPVGUQDTGQFÈ\KOQFQUHKÃKUFCU
KPUVKVWKÁÐGU TGNKIKQUCU SWCPFQ QU XCNQTGU CTTGECFCFQU
GZEGFGTCOQUWHKEKGPVGRCTCCOCPWVGPÁºQFCGPVKFCFG
TGNKIKQUCGQGZEGFGPVGGUVKXGTUGPFQGPXKCFQCHKNKCFCU
PQGZVGTKQT
#EGTEC FC TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG VTKDWV¶TKC LWNIWG QU UGIWKPVGU
KVGPU
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
# 7PKºQ (GFGTCN EQPEGFGW KUGPÁºQ FG +2+ ´
KPFWUVTKCNK\CÁºQ G VTCPUHQTOCÁºQ FG HGTVKNK\CPVGU
FGUVKPCFQU ´ WVKNK\CÁºQ PC NCXQWTC FG RTQFWVQU
VTCPUIÄPKEQU7OCOCPKRWNCFQTCFGTGOÃFKQUFGUEQDTKW
C RQUUKDKNKFCFG FG WVKNK\CÁºQ FG HGTVKNK\CPVG RCTC WUQ
VGTCRÄWVKEQ 'UUC OCPKRWNCFQTC RCUUQW C CFSWKTKT
HGTVKNK\CPVG FG WOC KPFÕUVTKC G CRÎU VTCPUHQTO¶NQ
XGPFKC Q RTQFWVQ TGUWNVCPVG KUGPVQ OCU GO HCEG FG
CVWCÁºQHKUECNEQDTCPFQQ+2+FGXKFQXGKQCGPEGTTCTCU
UWCUCVKXKFCFGU
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQQHKUEQRQFGT¶EQDTCTQ+2+FCKPFÕUVTKC
SWGHCDTKECXCQHGTVKNK\CPVGRQTVGTXGPFKFQQRTQFWVQ
SWGHQKWVKNK\CFQRCTCHKPUPºQKPEGPVKXCFQU
6GPFQ C 5% $TCUOÎXGKU 5# KPEQTRQTCFQ C GORTGUC
/ÎXGKU$TCUKNGKTQU.VFCFGXGFQTCFGKORQUVQUTGNCVKXQU
CTGPFCGHGVKXCOGPVGCWHGTKFCGPºQNCPÁCFCPQUNKXTQU
HKUECKU EQPUGS×GPVGOGPVG PºQ EQPUVKVWÈFQ Q ETÃFKVQ
VTKDWV¶TKQRCUUCT¶CUGTTGURQPU¶XGNRGNQRCICOGPVQFQ
VTKDWVQFCKPEQTRQTCFC
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
,QºQ(GTPCPFGUCFSWKTKWFGUGWRCVTÈEKQ/CPQGN2GTGKTC
SWG PGEGUUKVCXC TGITGUUCT EQO C HCOÈNKC CQ RCÈU FG
QTKIGOQHWPFQFGEQOÃTEKQFC5%/CPQGNG%KC.VFC
EQPVKPWCPFQPCGZRNQTCÁºQFCCVKXKFCFGCPVGTKQTEQOC
FGPQOKPCÁºQ ,QºQ G %KC .VFC &C CNKGPCÁºQ EQPUVQW
GZRTGUUCOGPVG C GZENWUºQ FC TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG RQT
SWCNSWGTFÈXKFCCPVGTKQTFQCFSWKTGPVG#ECWVGNCPFQUG
,QºQNGXQWQEQPVTCVQCTGIKUVTQPCLWPVCEQOGTEKCNGPQU
HKUEQUGUVCFWCNGHGFGTCN2CUUCFQUFQKUCPQUFQUTGIKUVTQU
C(C\GPFC2ÕDNKEC(GFGTCNCWVWQWCPQXCUQEKGFCFGRQT
FÃDKVQUFCGORTGUC/CPQGNG%KC.VFC
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQCUQEKGFCFGUWEGUUQTCTGURQPFGT¶RGNQU
FÃDKVQUVTKDWV¶TKQU
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–2–
,WNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
# 7PKºQ RQFGT¶ KPUVKVWKT GORTÃUVKOQ EQORWNUÎTKQ
UGORTGRQTNGKEQORNGOGPVCTXKPEWNCPFQQUTGEWTUQU´U
FGURGUCUSWGHWPFCOGPVCTCOUWCKPUVKVWKÁºQUGPFQSWG
C TGUVKVWKÁºQ FGXGT¶ UGT PGEGUUCTKCOGPVG GO OQGFC
SWCPFQGUVCHQTQQDLGVQFQGORTÃUVKOQ
œUWDUVKVWVCVTKDWV¶TKCCHQPVGRCICFQTCTGURQPU¶XGNRQT
NGK RGNC TGVGPÁºQ FG KORQUVQ FG TGPFC FG UGWU
HWPEKQP¶TKQUGECUQPºQRTQOQXCCTGVGPÁºQTGURQPFGT¶
RGNQ VTKDWVQ FGXKFQ RQFGPFQ GZGTEGT Q FKTGKVQ FG
TGITGUUQ
5GPFQQRTQFWVQ KPFWUVTKCNK\CFQFGUVKPCFQCQGZVGTKQT
KOWPGFG+2+RQFGT¶CUQEKGFCFGEQOGTEKCNGZRQTVCFQTC
ETGFKVCTUGFGVCNVTKDWVQCVÈVWNQFGETÃFKVQRTÄOKQCHKO
FGCHCUVCTQUGHGKVQUFCEWOWNCVKXKFCFGFQ%1(+05SWG
QPGTQWQUKPUWOQUCFSWKTKFQU
#U CIÄPEKCU TGIWNCFQTCU UºQ CWVCTSWKCU UQD TGIKOG
GURGEKCN SWG Ã ECTCEVGTK\CFQ RGNC KPFGRGPFÄPEKC
CFOKPKUVTCVKXCRGNCCWVQPQOKCHKPCPEGKTCGRGNQRQFGT
PQTOCVKXQCVTKDWÈFQUCGUUCUCIÄPEKCU
# SWCNKHKECÁºQ FG WOC CWVCTSWKC EQOQ CIÄPEKC
GZGEWVKXCQSWGNJGCUUGIWTCCWOGPVQFQUXCNQTGUFG
EQPVTCVCÁºQ FG QDTCU G UGTXKÁQU FG GPIGPJCTKC EQO
FKURGPUC FG NKEKVCÁºQ FGRGPFG FG GNC VGT WO RNCPQ
GUVTCVÃIKEQ FG TGGUVTWVWTCÁºQ G FG FGUGPXQNXKOGPVQ
KPUVKVWEKQPCN GO CPFCOGPVQ QW CNVGTPCVKXCOGPVG FC
EGNGDTCÁºQ FG EQPVTCVQ FG IGUVºQ EQO Q TGURGEVKXQ
OKPKUVÃTKQUWRGTXKUQT
7OC RGUUQC LWTÈFKEC FG FKTGKVQ RTKXCFQ UGO HKPU
NWETCVKXQU SWG VGO EQOQ QDLGVQ UQEKCN C RTQOQÁºQ FC
EWNVWTC FGHGUC G EQPUGTXCÁºQ FQ RCVTKOÏPKQ JKUVÎTKEQ G
CTVÈUVKEQTGSWGTGWCQ/KPKUVÃTKQFC,WUVKÁCUWCSWCNKHKECÁºQ
EQOQ QTICPK\CÁºQ FC UQEKGFCFG EKXKN FG KPVGTGUUG RÕDNKEQ
15%+2#PCNKUCFQQTGSWGTKOGPVQSWGHQKKPUVTWÈFQEQOQU
FQEWOGPVQU GZKIKFQU G EQPUVCVCFQ Q CVGPFKOGPVQ FQU
TGSWKUKVQU NGICKU HQK EQPEGFKFC C GUUC RGUUQC LWTÈFKEC C
SWCNKHKECÁºQTGSWGTKFC
#7PKºQFGUCRTQRTKQWKOÎXGNEQOCHKPCNKFCFGFG
KPVGTNKICT FWCU TQFQXKCU HGFGTCKU 2QTÃO GO TC\ºQ FG
EQPVKPIGPEKCOGPVQFGFGURGUCUCUQDTCUFGKPVGTNKICÁºQPºQ
HQTCOTGCNK\CFCU6GPFQJCXKFQPQCPQUGIWKPVGGNGKÁÐGU
RCTC RTGUKFGPVG FC 4GRÕDNKEC Q PQXQ IQXGTPQ GNGKVQ PºQ
FGOQPUVTQW KPVGTGUUG PC QDTC G EQO XKUVCU C RTQOQXGT Q
FGUGPXQNXKOGPVQ FC TGIKºQ CECDQW RQT CNKGPCT Q VGTTGPQ
FGUCRTQRTKCFQSWGHQKCFSWKTKFQRQTWOCGORTGUCRTKXCFC
SWG PGNG KPUVCNQW WOC WPKFCFG FG RTQFWÁºQ 0GUUG OGKQ
VGORQ CDCNCFQ EQO C FGUCRTQRTKCÁºQ Q RTQRTKGV¶TKQ FQ
VGTTGPQXGKQCHCNGEGTGQUUGWUJGTFGKTQUKPEQPHQTOCFQUEQO
CWVKNK\CÁºQFQDGORQTWOCGORTGUCRTKXCFCKPITGUUCTCO
EQOCÁºQTGSWGTGPFQCFGUEQPUVKVWKÁºQFCFGUCRTQRTKCÁºQG
CTGVTQEGUUºQFQDGO
%QO DCUG PC UKVWCÁºQ JKRQVÃVKEC CEKOC LWNIWG QU KVGPU C
UGIWKT
%QOTGNCÁºQ´UKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKECCRTGUGPVCFCCEKOCLWNIWG
QUKVGPUCUGIWKT
&GUFGSWGCVGPFKFCUCUGZKIÄPEKCUNGICKUCEQPEGUUºQC
WOCRGUUQCLWTÈFKECFGFKTGKVQRTKXCFQFCSWCNKHKECÁºQFG
15%+2ÃCVQSWGUGKPUGTGFGPVTQFQRQFGTFKUETKEKQP¶TKQ
FCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQRÕDNKECSWGCXCNKCT¶CQRQTVWPKFCFGG
CEQPXGPKÄPEKCRCTCCUWCRT¶VKEC
#XKPEWNCÁºQGPVTGQRQFGTRÕDNKEQGWOC15%+2ÃHGKVC
RQT OGKQ FG VGTOQ FG RCTEGTKC QU DGPU KOÎXGKU
CFSWKTKFQU RQT GNC EQO TGEWTUQU RTQXGPKGPVGU FC
EGNGDTCÁºQ FQ VGTOQ FG RCTEGTKC UºQ ITCXCFQU EQO
EN¶WUWNCFGKPCNKGPCDKNKFCFG
'O HCEG FC VTGFGUVKPCÁºQ à RQUUÈXGN C TGVTQEGUUºQ FQ
DGO CQU JGTFGKTQU WOC XG\ SWG UGIWPFQ Q
GPVGPFKOGPVQFQ5WRTGOQ6TKDWPCN(GFGTCN
56(GFQ
5WRGTKQT 6TKDWPCN FG ,WUVKÁC 56, C TGVTQEGUUºQ VGO
PCVWTG\CFGFKTGKVQTGCN
0CUKVWCÁºQEQPUKFGTCFCRQTKPENWKTGPVTGQUGWQDLGVQ
UQEKCNCRTQOQÁºQFCEWNVWTCCTGHGTKFCRGUUQCLWTÈFKEC
FGUFGSWGEWORTKFQUQUFGOCKUTGSWKUKVQUGZKIKFQUGO
NGKVCODÃORQFGTKCUGTSWCNKHKECFCEQOQQTICPK\CÁºQ
UQEKCN0GUUGECUQCRCTEGTKCGPVTGGNCGQRQFGTRÕDNKEQ
UGTKCHGKVCRQTOGKQFGWOEQPVTCVQFGIGUVºQSWGPCUWC
GNCDQTCÁºQ GPVTG QWVTQU RTGEGKVQU FGXG QDUGTXCT QU
RTKPEÈRKQUFCKORGUUQCNKFCFGGGEQPQOKEKFCFG
%CUQ C FGUCRTQRTKCÁºQ FQ KOÎXGN VKXGUUG QEQTTKFQ GO
TC\ºQ FQ EWNVKXQ KNGICN FG RNCPVCU RUKEQVTÎRKECU PºQ
JCXGTKCCPGEGUUKFCFGFGCVQFGENCTCVÎTKQFGWVKNKFCFG
RÕDNKEC PGEGUUKFCFG RÕDNKEC QW KPVGTGUUG UQEKCN
RQFGPFQCFGUVKPCÁºQFQKOÎXGNFGUCRTQRTKCFQRCTCHKPU
FG EQPUVTWÁºQ FG KPVGTNKICÁºQ GPVTG FWCU TQFQXKCU
HGFGTCKUUGTFGHKPKFCPQ¸ODKVQFCCÁºQLWFKEKCNRTÎRTKC
%QO TGNCÁºQ ´ CFOKPKUVTCÁºQ KPFKTGVC G ´U CIÄPEKCU
TGIWNCFQTCUGGZGEWVKXCULWNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGU
0ºQJ¶TGUVTKÁºQNGICNRCTCSWGGORTGUCRÕDNKECEQPVTCVG
EQO UWC UWDUKFK¶TKC EQO FKURGPUC FG NKEKVCÁºQ
RTGUVCÁºQFGUGTXKÁQUQWCSWKUKÁºQFGDGPU
'ODQTCC%QPUVKVWKÁºQ(GFGTCNCFQVGCNKXTGEQPEQTTÄPEKC
EQOQ WO FQU RTKPEÈRKQU FC QTFGO GEQPÏOKEC Ã
RQUUÈXGN XKUCPFQ C RTQVGÁºQ FQ OGKQ CODKGPVG
GUVCDGNGEGT VTCVCOGPVQ FKHGTGPEKCFQ GPVTG GORTGUCU
EQPHQTOGQKORCEVQCODKGPVCNFQURTQFWVQUGFGUGWU
RTQEGUUQUFGGNCDQTCÁºQ
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
# TGURGKVQ FG TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG EKXKN FQ 'UVCFQ UGTXKFQTGU
RÕDNKEQUGRTQEGUUQFKUEKRNKPCTLWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
'OQDTCRÕDNKECEQPVTCVCFCRQTGORTGKVCFCINQDCNEQO
GORTGUCRTKXCFCFGUCRCTGEGCTGURQPUCDKNKFCFGQDLGVKXC
FCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQRÕDNKEC1UFCPQUECWUCFQUCVGTEGKTQU
GO TC\ºQ FC QDTC GO UK UºQ FG TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG
GZENWUKXCFCGORTGUCEQPVTCVCFC
1UGTXKFQTRÕDNKEQSWG´FCVCFCRWDNKECÁºQFC'OGPFC
%QPUVKVWEKQPCN
'%PL¶VKXGUUGKORNGOGPVCFQ
CUEQPFKÁÐGURCTCCUWCCRQUGPVCFQTKCXQNWPV¶TKCEQO
DCUG PC NGIKUNCÁºQ XKIGPVG G SWG XGPJC C QRVCT RQT
RGTOCPGEGT GO CVKXKFCFG HC\ LWU C CDQPQ FG
RGTOCPÄPEKCGSWKXCNGPVGCQXCNQTFCUWCEQPVTKDWKÁºQ
RTGXKFGPEK¶TKC CVÃ EQORNGVCT CU GZKIÄPEKCU RCTC
CRQUGPVCFQTKC EQORWNUÎTKC FGUFG SWG EQPVG EQO PQ
OÈPKOQXKPVGGEKPEQCPQUFGEQPVTKDWKÁºQUGOWNJGT
QWVTKPVCCPQUFGEQPVTKDWKÁºQUGJQOGO
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–3–
1UGTXKFQTFC7PKºQFQUGUVCFQUFQ&KUVTKVQ(GFGTCNQW
FQUOWPKEÈRKQUKPENWÈFCUUWCUCWVCTSWKCUGHWPFCÁÐGU
SWGVGPJCKPITGUUCFQPQUGTXKÁQRÕDNKEQCVÃCFCVCFG
RWDNKECÁºQFC'%PRQFGT¶CRQUGPVCTUGEQO
RTQXGPVQUKPVGITCKUSWGEQTTGURQPFGTºQ´VQVCNKFCFGFC
TGOWPGTCÁºQFQUGTXKFQTPQECTIQGHGVKXQGOSWGUGFGT
CCRQUGPVCFQTKCPCHQTOCFCNGK
#EGTEC FG NKEKVCÁÐGU TGIKUVTQ FG RTGÁQU G EQPVTCVQU
CFOKPKUVTCVKXQULWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
0QECUQFGUWRTGUUºQFGQDTCUUGQEQPVTCVCFQL¶JQWXGT
CFSWKTKFQQUOCVGTKCKUGQURQUVQUPQNQECNFGVTCDCNJQ
FGXGT¶CCFOKPKUVTCÁºQVºQUQOGPVGKPFGPK\CTQUEWUVQU
FGCSWKUKÁºQCVWCNK\CFQUTGIWNCTOGPVGEQORTQXCFQU
PºQUGPFQECDÈXGNQWVTQVKRQFGKPFGPK\CÁºQ
#NKEKVCÁºQRCTCTGIKUVTQFGRTGÁQUSWGÃRTGEGFKFCFG
CORNC RGUSWKUC FG OGTECFQ RQFGT¶ UGT TGCNK\CFC PC
OQFCNKFCFG FG EQPEQTTÄPEKC QW FG RTGIºQ FQ VKRQ
OGPQTRTGÁQUGPFQRQUUÈXGNGOECT¶VGTGZEGREKQPCN
CFQVCTUGPCOQFCNKFCFGFGEQPEQTTÄPEKCQVKRQVÃEPKEC
GRTGÁQ
5GIWPFQ Q EQPUQNKFCFQ GPVGPFKOGPVQ FQ 6TKDWPCN FG
%QPVCUFC7PKºQ
6%7PºQÃRQUUÈXGNCTGRCEVWCÁºQFG
EWUVQU FG OºQFGQDTC GO EQPVTCVQU FG UGTXKÁQU
VGTEGKTK\CFQU CPVGU FG FGEQTTKFQ WO CPQ FC FCVC FC
CUUKPCVWTCFQEQPVTCVQ
4GEWTUQU CFOKPKUVTCVKXQU KPVGTRQUVQU EQPVTC CVQU FG
JCDKNKVCÁºQ QW KPCDKNKVCÁºQ FG NKEKVCPVG VÄO GHGKVQ
UWURGPUKXQ#CWVQTKFCFGEQORGVGPVGOQVKXCFCOGPVG
GRQTTC\ÐGUFGKPVGTGUUG RÕDNKEQRQFGCVTKDWKTGHGKVQ
UWURGPUKXQ CQ TGEWTUQ EQPVTC Q CVQ FG TGUEKUºQ FG
EQPVTCVQ CFQVCFQ WPKNCVGTCNOGPVG RGNC CFOKPKUVTCÁºQ
GO TC\ºQ FG NGPVKFºQ PC GZGEWÁºQ FQ EQPVTCVQ SWG
EQORTQXG C KORQUUKDKNKFCFG FG UGW EWORTKOGPVQ PQ
RTC\QGUVKRWNCFQ
# TGURGKVQ FG RQFGT TGIWNCOGPVCT DGPU RÕDNKEQU TGIKOG
LWTÈFKEQFQUTGEWTUQUOKPGTCKUGVGTTCUFGXQNWVCULWNIWGQU
KVGPUCUGIWKT
1 RQFGT TGIWNCOGPVCT CVTKDWÈFQ CQ EJGHG FQ 2QFGT
'ZGEWVKXQ RQT FGEQTTGT FG GZRTGUUC RTGXKUºQ
EQPUVKVWEKQPCNÃFGPCVWTG\CQTKIKP¶TKCQWRTKO¶TKC
#EQPEGUUºQFGFKTGKVQTGCNFGWUQFGDGORÕDNKEQÃRQT
HQTÁCFGNGKKPVTCPUHGTÈXGNRQTCVQinter vivos
'UVºQUWLGKVCUCUGTXKFÐGUFGUQNQGUWDUQNQRCTCHKPUFG
RGUSWKUC QW NCXTC FG TGEWTUQU OKPGTCKU PºQ UÎ C
RTQRTKGFCFG QPFG UG NQECNK\C C LC\KFC EQOQ CU
NKOÈVTQHGU
6GTTCU FGXQNWVCU UºQ VQFCU CSWGNCU RGTVGPEGPVGU CQ
FQOÈPKQRÕDNKEQFGSWCNSWGTFCUGPVKFCFGUGUVCVCKUPºQ
WVKNK\CFCU RGNQ RQFGT RÕDNKEQ PGO FGUVKPCFCU C HKPU
CFOKPKUVTCVKXQUGURGEÈHKEQU
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
GRUPO II: DIREITOS CONSTITUCIONAL
E PROCESSUAL CIVIL
1 FGRWVCFQ 4QDGTVQ ,GHHGTUQP GO GPVTGXKUVC CQ
LQTPCN Folha de S. Paulo KPFKEQW JCXGT KPFÈEKQU FG
UWRGTHCVWTCOGPVQ GO EQPVTCVQU EGNGDTCFQU PQ ¸ODKVQ FC
'ORTGUC $TCUKNGKTC FG %QTTGKQU G 6GNÃITCHQU '%6 EQO
GORTGUCURTKXCFCUGFGPWPEKQWWOGUSWGOCFGRCICOGPVQU
CRCTNCOGPVCTGUHGKVQRGNQ2CTVKFQFQU6TCDCNJCFQTGUEQOC
HKPCNKFCFGFGICTCPVKTCRQKQPCDCUGCNKCFCRCTCCRTQXCÁºQ
FGRTQRQUKÁÐGUFGKPVGTGUUGFQIQXGTPQ
2TGUUKQPCFQRGNCETKUGRQNÈVKECSWGUGKPUVCNQWCRCTVKT
FCU FGPÕPEKCU HGKVCU RGNQ FGRWVCFQ 4QDGTVQ ,GHHGTUQP Q
RTGUKFGPVG.WK\+P¶EKQ.WNCFC5KNXCCPWPEKQWPQFKCFG
LWPJQFGCCFQÁºQFGWOCUÃTKGFGOGFKFCUFGUVKPCFCU
C EQODCVGT C EQTTWRÁºQ 'PVTG GNCU GUVºQ C RTQRQUVC FG
ETKOKPCNK\CT Q GPTKSWGEKOGPVQ KNÈEKVQ G C ETKCÁºQ FG
EQPVTQNCFQTKCU RCTC KPXGUVKICT ICUVQU G FGURGUCU PQU
OKPKUVÃTKQU
#KPFC EQOQ EQPUGS×ÄPEKC FCU FGPÕPEKCU
CRTGUGPVCFCUHQTCOKPUVCNCFCUWOCEQOKUUºQFGUKPFKE¸PEKC
PC %¸OCTC FQU &GRWVCFQU G WOC EQOKUUºQ RCTNCOGPVCT
OKUVC FG KPSWÃTKVQ PQ %QPITGUUQ 0CEKQPCN G JQWXG WO
CVTCUQPCCRTQXCÁºQFCNGKFGFKTGVTK\GUQTÁCOGPV¶TKCUSWG
VGXGCUWCXQVCÁºQCFKCFCRCTCCRTKOGKTCUGOCPCFGCIQUVQ
%QOTGHGTÄPEKCCQVGZVQCEKOCLWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
5WRQPFQSWGHQUUGRTQVQEQNCFQPC5GETGVCTKC)GTCNFC
/GUCFC%¸OCTCFQU&GRWVCFQUPQFKCFGLWPJQWO
RTQLGVQ FG NGK FG CWVQTKC FQ RTGUKFGPVG FC 4GRÕDNKEC
VKRKHKECPFQ Q GPTKSWGEKOGPVQ KNÈEKVQ EQOQ ETKOG G
JQWXGUUGPCOGPUCIGOSWGGPECOKPJQWQRTQLGVQFG
NGK WO RGFKFQ FG WTIÄPEKC EQPUVKVWEKQPCN RCTC GUUC
RTQRQUKÁºQ C RCTVKT FG FG UGVGODTQ UGTKCO
UQDTGUVCFCUVQFCUCUFGOCKUFGNKDGTCÁÐGUNGIKUNCVKXCUFC
%¸OCTCFQU&GRWVCFQUECUQCVÃGUUCFCVCPºQVKXGUUG
UKFQEQPENWÈFCCXQVCÁºQFGUUGRTQLGVQFGNGK
%CUQCEQOKUUºQFGUKPFKE¸PEKCEQPUKFGTGPGEGUU¶TKQGNC
RQFGT¶GPECOKPJCTWORGFKFQGUETKVQFGKPHQTOCÁÐGUCQ
OKPKUVTQFG'UVCFQFCU%QOWPKECÁÐGURCTCGUENCTGEGT
FGVCNJGUFCPQOGCÁºQFGFKTKIGPVGUFC'%6KORQTVCPFQ
GOETKOGFGTGURQPUCDKNKFCFGFQOKPKUVTQCTGEWUCQWQ
PºQCVGPFKOGPVQPQRTC\QFGVTKPVCFKCUDGOEQOQC
RTGUVCÁºQFGKPHQTOCÁÐGUHCNUCU
5GCQHKPCNFQUVTCDCNJQUFCEQOKUUºQFGUKPFKE¸PEKCHQT
EQORTQXCFC C TGCNK\CÁºQ FG RCICOGPVQU RCTC
RCTNCOGPVCTGUEQOXKUVCUCICTCPVKTCRQKQCQIQXGTPQPCU
XQVCÁÐGU QU FGRWVCFQU SWG HQTGO CRQPVCFQU EQOQ
DGPGHKEK¶TKQUFQGUSWGOCFGRCICOGPVQRQFGTºQUQHTGT
RTQEGUUQFGRGTFCFGOCPFCVQECDGPFQCFGEKUºQUQDTG
C RGTFC ´ %¸OCTC FQU &GRWVCFQU RQT XQVQ UGETGVQ G
OCKQTKCCDUQNWVCCUUGIWTCFCCQURCTNCOGPVCTGUCCORNC
FGHGUC
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–4–
5GCETKCÁºQFGEQPVTQNCFQTKCURCTCKPXGUVKICTQUICUVQU
FQU OKPKUVÃTKQU HQUUG HGKVC RQT OGFKFC RTQXKUÎTKC G Q
%QPITGUUQ0CEKQPCNCRTQXCUUGQUGWVGZVQQTKIKPCNUGO
CNVGTCÁºQGUUCOGFKFCRTQXKUÎTKCUGTKCEQPXGTVKFCGONGK
FKURGPUCFCCUCPÁºQRTGUKFGPEKCNUGPFQCVTKDWKÁºQFQ
%QPITGUUQ0CEKQPCNUWCRTQOWNICÁºQGRWDNKECÁºQ
1 6%7 VGO CVTKDWKÁºQ EQPUVKVWEKQPCN RCTC CRTGEKCT QU
EQPVTCVQUCFOKPKUVTCVKXQUKPFKECFQUPCFGPÕPEKCEQOQ
KNGICKURQFGPFQCUUKPCTRTC\QRCTCSWGC'%6CFQVGCU
RTQXKFÄPEKCU PGEGUU¶TKCU RCTC C EQTTGÁºQ FQU XÈEKQU
CRQPVCFQU G PQ ECUQ FG PºQ CVGPFKOGPVQ FC UWC
FGVGTOKPCÁºQ UWUVCT C GZGEWÁºQ FQ EQPVTCVQ
EQOWPKECPFQCFGEKUºQ´%¸OCTCFQU&GRWVCFQUGCQ
5GPCFQ(GFGTCN
#EGTECFQEQPVTQNGFGEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFGGFCTGEGRÁºQFG
PQTOCUKPHTCEQPUVKVWEKQPCKULWNIWGQUKVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGU
156(CNVGTCPFQCLWTKURTWFÄPEKCFQOKPCPVGRCUUQWC
CFOKVKTCNGIKVKOCÁºQCVKXCRCTCCRTQRQUKVWTCFGCÁºQ
FKTGVCFGKPEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFGFCGPVKFCFGFGENCUUGFG
¸ODKVQ PCEKQPCN HQTOCFC RQT RGUUQCU LWTÈFKECU
EQPJGEKFCEQOQőCUUQEKCÁºQFGCUUQEKCÁÐGUŒ
#RCTVKTFC'%PSWGKPUVKVWKWCTGHQTOCFQ2QFGT
,WFKEK¶TKQCUFGEKUÐGUFGOÃTKVQRTQHGTKFCURGNQ56(PCU
CÁÐGU FKTGVCU FG KPEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFG RCUUCTCO C VGT
GHGKVQ XKPEWNCPVG #PVGU FC GOGPFC C QTFGO LWTÈFKEC
GPVºQ XKIGPVG DGO CUUKO C LWTKURTWFÄPEKC CRGPCU
EQPHGTKCO VCN GHGKVQ ´U FGEKUÐGU RTQHGTKFCU PCU CÁÐGU
FGENCTCVÎTKCUFGEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFG
1 IQXGTPCFQT FG GUVCFQ PºQ VGO NGIKVKOKFCFG RCTC
RTQRQTCÁºQFGENCTCVÎTKCFGEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFGRGTCPVG
Q 56( CKPFC SWCPFQ C NGK HGFGTCN EWLC XCNKFCFG UG
RTGVGPFGCHKTOCFCVGPJCTGRGTEWUUºQPQUGWGUVCFQ
1 56( L¶ UG RTQPWPEKQW FGHKPKVKXCOGPVG C TGURGKVQ FC
XCNKFCFG FC .GK PPQRQPVQSWGTGIWNCPFQC
CÁºQ FG FGUEWORTKOGPVQ FG RTGEGKVQ HWPFCOGPVCN
RGTOKVGCPCNKUCTEQPVTQXÃTUKCEQPUVKVWEKQPCNUQDTGNGKQW
CVQPQTOCVKXQHGFGTCNGUVCFWCNQWOWPKEKRCNGFKVCFQU
CPVGU FC %QPUVKVWKÁºQ GO QTFGO C TGRCTCT NGUºQ C
RTGEGKVQHWPFCOGPVCN
,WNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGUSWCPVQCQTGIKOGFQURTGECVÎTKQU
1UFÃDKVQUFGPCVWTG\CCNKOGPVÈEKCEQOQXGPEKOGPVQU
UCN¶TKQUGRGPUÐGUFKURGPUCORTGECVÎTKQU
*CXGPFQSWGDTCFCQTFGOETQPQNÎIKECFGRTGEGFÄPEKC
FQ RCICOGPVQ FQU RTGECVÎTKQU XGPEKFQU NGIKVKOCUG Q
UGS×GUVTQFCSWCPVKCPGEGUU¶TKC´UCVKUHCÁºQFQFÃDKVQ
RGNQRTGUKFGPVGFQVTKDWPCNFQSWCNGOCPQWCFGEKUºQ
GZGS×GPFC
#RGUCT FG CU GORTGUCU RÕDNKECU GUVCTGO UWDOGVKFCU C
TGIKOGRTÎRTKQFCUGORTGUCURTKXCFCUKPENWUKXGSWCPVQ
´RGPJQTCFGUGWU DGPUPQRTQEGUUQGZGEWVKXQQ56(
TGEQPJGEGGOECUQUGZEGREKQPCKUGOSWGCGORTGUC
TGCNK\CUGTXKÁQRÕDNKEQGUVCVCNQRTKXKNÃIKQFGVGTUGWU
FÃDKVQURCIQURQTOGKQFGRTGECVÎTKQU
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
# '% P CRGTHGKÁQQW Q UKUVGOC FG ICTCPVKCU FQU
FKTGKVQUHWPFCOGPVCKUVGPFQGOXKUVCCGZKIÄPEKCUQEKCNFG
SWGVGPJCOGHGVKXKFCFGGQUEQORTQOKUUQUCUUWOKFQURGNQ
$TCUKNPCQTFGOLWTÈFKECKPVGTPCEKQPCN%QOTGNCÁºQCGUUG
CUUWPVQLWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUGIWGO
1U VTCVCFQU KPVGTPCEKQPCKU UQDTG FKTGKVQU JWOCPQU
RQFGO EQPUVKVWKTUG GO RCT¸OGVTQ EQPUVKVWEKQPCN FG
XCNKFCFGFGPQTOCUNGICKUOCUFGXGOUGTUWDOGVKFQUC
KFÄPVKEQRTQEGUUQNGIKUNCVKXQFGXQVCÁºQGCRTQXCÁºQFCU
GOGPFCUEQPUVKVWEKQPCKU
*CXGPFQ XKQNCÁºQ ITCXG FG FKTGKVQU JWOCPQU EWLQ
RTQEGUUQQWKPSWÃTKVQLWFKEKCNEQOVTCOKVCÁºQPCLWUVKÁC
GUVCFWCNUGOQUVTGOQTQUQQWKPGHKEKGPVGQTGURGEVKXQ
RTQEWTCFQTIGTCNFGLWUVKÁCRQFGT¶RTQRQTRGTCPVGQ56,
KPEKFGPVGFGFGUNQECOGPVQFGEQORGVÄPEKCRCTCCLWUVKÁC
HGFGTCN
#TGHQTOCFQ2QFGT,WFKEK¶TKQICTCPVKWCVQFQUQFKTGKVQ
UWDLGVKXQ ´ TC\Q¶XGN FWTCÁºQ FQ RTQEGUUQ EQOQ
RTQLGÁºQ FQ FGXKFQ RTQEGUUQ NGICN 6TCVCUG FG PQTOC
EWLCCRNKECÁºQPºQÃKOGFKCVCTGUVCPFQEQPFKEKQPCFC´
TGIWNCÁºQ GURGEÈHKEC SWG FKUEKRNKPCT¶ Q SWG UG RQFG
GPVGPFGTRQTTC\Q¶XGN
,WNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGUCEGTECFCVGQTKCFC%QPUVKVWKÁºQG
FQEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKUOQDTCUKNGKTQ
%QPHQTOGCUUGPVCFQRGNQ56(JCXGPFQEQPHTQPVQGPVTG
PQTOCU EQPUVKVWEKQPCKU QTKIKP¶TKCU C UQNWÁºQ FQ ECUQ
EQPETGVQPºQRQFGUGTGPEQPVTCFCPQ¸ODKVQFQEQPVTQNG
FGEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFGOCURQFGUGTFCFCRQTETKVÃTKQU
JGTOGPÄWVKEQUKPENWUKXGRGNCRQPFGTCÁºQFGXCNQTGU
1SWGOCKUEQPVTKDWKWRCTCCCRTQZKOCÁºQFQUVGZVQU
FCU%QPUVKVWKÁÐGUFGGHQKCEQKPEKFÄPEKCFQU
HCVQTGURQNÈVKEQUSWGKPURKTCTCOCGNCDQTCÁºQFCU%CTVCU
QTKGPVCFCUPQUFQKUOQOGPVQURQTWOCTGCÁºQEQPVTC
QUGZCIGTQUFQRTGUKFGPEKCNKUOQFC4GRÕDNKEC8GNJCQW
EQPVTC CU VGPFÄPEKCU FKVCVQTKCKU SWG OQFGNCTCO C
%QPUVKVWKÁºQFG
#EQPUVKVWKÁºQFKTKIGPVGÃCSWGNCSWGCNÃOFGNGIKVKOCT
GNKOKVCTQRQFGTGUVCVCNGOHCEGFCUQEKGFCFGFGHKPG
OGVCU RCTC Q HWVWTQ OGFKCPVG C KPUVKVWKÁºQ FG PQTOCU
RTQITCO¶VKECUGZKIKPFQVQFCXKCXKPEWNCÁºQFQURQFGTGU
RÕDNKEQU´UWCTGCNK\CÁºQ
#%QPUVKVWKÁºQFGKPCWIWTQWQUKUVGOCFGEQPVTQNG
FGEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCFGCDUVTCVQFGPQTOCURQTSWCPVQCU
EQPUVKVWKÁÐGUCPVGTKQTGUCRGPCURTGXKCOQEQPVTQNGFKHWUQ
TGCNK\CFQincidenter tantum.
,WNIWG QU KVGPU UGIWKPVGU SWG XGTUCO CEGTEC FC TGHQTOC
EQPUVKVWEKQPCNFQ2QFGT,WFKEK¶TKQRTQOQXKFCRGNC'%P
2CTC ICTCPVKC FC EGNGTKFCFG FC CVKXKFCFG LWTKUFKEKQPCN
RTGXKWUG SWG C FKUVTKDWKÁºQ FG RTQEGUUQU FGXG UGT
KOGFKCVCGOVQFQUQUITCWUFGLWTKUFKÁºQ(QTCOXGFCFCU
CU HÃTKCU EQNGVKXCU VCPVQ PQU LWÈ\QU FG RTKOGKTQ ITCW
SWCPVQPQUVTKDWPCKUFGUGIWPFQITCWPQTOCSWGGZENWK
Q56,GQ56(
6QFCU CU CÁÐGU FGEQTTGPVGU FG CEKFGPVGU FQ VTCDCNJQ
CPVGU FC EQORGVÄPEKC FC LWUVKÁC EQOWO FQU GUVCFQU
RCUUCTCORCTCCEQORGVÄPEKCFCLWUVKÁCFQVTCDCNJQ
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–5–
1EWORTKOGPVQFCUOGFKFCUUQNKEKVCFCURQTCWVQTKFCFGU
LWFKEK¶TKCUGUVTCPIGKTCURQTOGKQFGECTVCTQICVÎTKCÃFG
EQORGVÄPEKCFQ56,GPºQOCKUFQ56(
#FOKVKFCCJKRÎVGUGFGFGVGTOKPCFQVTKDWPCNFGLWUVKÁC
LWNICT X¶NKFC NGK GUVCFWCN EQPVGUVCFC GO HCEG FG NGK
HGFGTCN VGOUG WO EQPHNKVQ UKVWCFQ PQ ¸ODKVQ FQ
EQPVTQNG FG NGICNKFCFG ECDGPFQ WPKECOGPVG CQ 56, Q
LWNICOGPVQHKPCNFGOÃTKVQ
#TGHQTOCFQ2QFGT,WFKEK¶TKQVQTPQWGZRTGUUQSWGQU
CIGPVGU RQNÈVKEQU PºQ RQFGO UGT UWLGKVQU RCUUKXQU FC
CÁºQ FG KORTQDKFCFG CFOKPKUVTCVKXC RQKU TGURQPFGO
CRGPCU RQT ETKOGU EQOWPU G FG TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG
TGUVCPFQCUUKORCEKHKECFCCRQNÄOKECKPUVCWTCFCUQDTG
QCUUWPVQ
2QFG Q GZGS×GPVG TGSWGTGT C GZGEWÁºQ RTQXKUÎTKC FG
VÈVWNQLWFKEKCNQWGZVTCLWFKEKCNFGUFGSWGRTGUVGECWÁºQ
KFÏPGCTGCNQWHKFGLWUUÎTKCRCTCCECWVGNCOGPVQKPVGITCN
FQTKUEQFGRTGLWÈ\QRCTCQGZGEWVCFQ
%CDÈXGN C EQPFGPCÁºQ GO JQPQT¶TKQU CFXQECVÈEKQU PC
GZGEWÁºQ HWPFCFC GO VÈVWNQ LWFKEKCN QW GZVTCLWFKEKCN
GODCTICFCQWPºQOGUOQSWCPFQUGVTCVCFGGZGEWÁºQ
EQPVTC C HC\GPFC RÕDNKEC RQT UGT C GZGEWÁºQ CÁºQ
CWVÏPQOCKORÐGUGCHKZCÁºQFGPQXQUJQPQT¶TKQUGO
UGFGFGGZGEWÁºQCKPFCSWGPºQGODCTICFC
0CGZGEWÁºQHKUECNQRTC\QFGVTKPVCFKCURCTCQRQUKÁºQ
FQUGODCTIQUFQFGXGFQTEQPVCUGFCKPVKOCÁºQRGUUQCN
FQ TGRTGUGPVCPVG NGICN FC FGXGFQTC EQO GZRTGUUC
CFXGTVÄPEKCSWCPVQCQRTC\QGPºQFCLWPVCFCCQCWVQU
FQTGURGEVKXQOCPFCFQ
#EGTEC FQ OCPFCFQ FG UGIWTCPÁC KPFKXKFWCN G EQNGVKXQ
LWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUGIWGO
0QOCPFCFQFGUGIWTCPÁCCRGUUQCLWTÈFKECFGFKTGKVQ
RÕDNKEQSWGKPVGITCCTGNCÁºQRTQEGUUWCNPCEQPFKÁºQFG
NKVKUEQPUQTVGPGEGUU¶TKQVGONGIKVKOKFCFGRCTCTGEQTTGTFC
UGPVGPÁCSWGNJGHQKFGUHCXQT¶XGNQWSWGEQPVGPJCXÈEKQ
FGPWNKFCFGKPUCP¶XGN
%QPUKFGTCUG CWVQTKFCFG EQCVQTC G RQTVCPVQ CRVC C
QEWRCT Q RÎNQ RCUUKXQ FQ OCPFCFQ FG UGIWTCPÁC C
RGUUQC SWG TGEQOGPFC QW GNCDQTC PQTOCU RCTC C
GZGEWÁºQQWKPGZGEWÁºQFQCVQKORWIPCFQ
'ZCTCFC UGPVGPÁC FGPGICPFQ C UGIWTCPÁC TGUVC UGO
QDLGVQ Q CITCXQ FG KPUVTWOGPVQ KPVGTRQUVQ EQPVTC Q
KPFGHGTKOGPVQFCNKOKPCTTGSWGTKFCPQUCWVQU&COGUOC
HQTOC C UWRGTXGPKÄPEKC FG UGPVGPÁC EQPEGUUKXC FC
UGIWTCPÁCTCVKHKECPFQNKOKPCTCPVGTKQTOGPVGEQPEGFKFC
VQTPCRTGLWFKECFQUQUTGEWTUQUKPVGTRQUVQUGOHCEGFGUUC
FGEKUºQKPVGTNQEWVÎTKC
%QORGVG ´ LWUVKÁC HGFGTCN LWNICT ECWUCU EQPVTC CVQ FG
FKTKIGPVG FG GUVCDGNGEKOGPVQ FG GPUKPQ UWRGTKQT
RGTVGPEGPVGCQUKUVGOCFGGPUKPQFQUGUVCFQURQTSWGGNG
GZGTEGPCJKRÎVGUGCVKXKFCFGFGNGICFCFQRQFGTHGFGTCN
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
3WCPFQQOCPFCFQFGUGIWTCPÁCVGORQTQDLGVQCVWVGNC
FGFKTGKVQNÈSWKFQGEGTVQSWGRQUUWKGZRTGUUºQHKPCPEGKTC
KOGFKCVC G SWCPVKHKE¶XGN FGXG Q XCNQT FCFQ ´ ECWUC
TGHNGVKTQGZCVQRTQXGKVQGEQPÏOKEQRGTUGIWKFQ
# TGURGKVQ FQU OGKQU FG KORWIPCÁºQ FQU RTQXKOGPVQU
LWTKUFKEKQPCKULWNIWGQUUGIWKPVGUKVGPU
0CU UGPVGPÁCU RTQHGTKFCU GO FGUHCXQT FC (C\GPFC
2ÕDNKECUGPFQJKRÎVGUGFGTGGZCOGPGEGUU¶TKQQLWK\
CQRTQHGTKTUGPVGPÁCFGXGFGVGTOKPCTSWGPºQJCXGPFQ
TGEWTUQXQNWPV¶TKQUGLCCDGTVCXKUVC´URCTVGURCTCSWG
CRTGUGPVGOUWCUTC\ÐGURCTCOCPWVGPÁºQQWTGHQTOCFC
UGPVGPÁCRGNQVTKDWPCN
1TGEWTUQFGCRGNCÁºQFGXQNXGCQVTKDWPCNVQFCCOCVÃTKC
GHGVKXCOGPVGKORWIPCFC#UUKOQRGFKFQFQTGEQTTGPVG
NKOKVCCCVWCÁºQFQVTKDWPCNOCUQOGUOQPºQUGCRNKEC
´ HWPFCOGPVCÁºQ RQFGPFQ Q VTKDWPCN CQ LWNICT C
CRGNCÁºQ GZCOKPCT VQFCU CU SWGUVÐGU UWUEKVCFCU G
FKUEWVKFCU PQ RTQEGUUQ CKPFC SWG C UGPVGPÁC PºQ CU
VGPJCFGEKFKFQRQTKPVGKTQ
2QFGTºQ CU RCTVGU PCU TC\ÐGU QW EQPVTCTC\ÐGU FG
CRGNCÁºQCNGICTSWGUVºQFGHCVQPºQUWUEKVCFCPCCÁºQ
CKPFC SWG VCN CNGICÁºQ CNVGTG C ECWUC FG RGFKT QW Q
RGFKFQFGUFGSWGUGLCRTQXCFQSWGFGKZCTCOFGHC\ÄNQ
CPVGURQTOQVKXQFGHQTÁCOCKQTGUGLCOICTCPVKFQUQ
EQPVTCFKVÎTKQGCCORNCFGHGUC
5ºQECDÈXGKUGODCTIQUKPHTKPIGPVGUEQPVTCFGEKUºQPºQ
WP¸PKOGRTQHGTKFCGOCITCXQFGKPUVTWOGPVQSWCPFQ
PGUUG HQT FGEKFKFC OCVÃTKC FG OÃTKVQ G FGETGVCFC C
GZVKPÁºQFQRTQEGUUQ
#TGVGPÁºQFGTGEWTUQGURGEKCNKPVGTRQUVQEQPVTCCEÎTFºQ
RTQHGTKFQPQCITCXQFGKPUVTWOGPVQFGFW\KFQGOHCEG
FG FGEKUºQ KPVGTNQEWVÎTKC FG RTKOGKTQ ITCW KORÐG CQ
TGEQTTGPVG TGKVGT¶NQ PQ RTC\Q RCTC C KPVGTRQUKÁºQ FQ
TGEWTUQEQPVTCCFGEKUºQHKPCNQWRCTCCUEQPVTCTC\ÐGU
1U GODCTIQU FG FGENCTCÁºQ PºQ FGXGO TGXGUVKTUG FG
ECT¶VGTKPHTKPIGPVG0QGPVCPVQGZEGREKQPCNOGPVGGO
ECUQUFGGTTQOCVGTKCNGXKFGPVGQWFGOCPKHGUVCPWNKFCFG
FQ CEÎTFºQ RQFG Q CEÎTFºQ FG GODCTIQU RTQEGFGT C
EQTTGÁºQFQLWNICFQCPVGTKQT
#UHWPÁÐGUFQ%QPUGNJQFC,WUVKÁC(GFGTCNTGNCEKQPCFCU
´ UWRGTXKUºQ CFOKPKUVTCVKXC G QTÁCOGPV¶TKC FC LWUVKÁC
HGFGTCNFGRTKOGKTQGUGIWPFQITCWUHQTCOOCPVKFCURGNC
TGHQTOC ,WPVQ CQ 56, HWPEKQPCT¶ VCODÃO C GUEQNC
PCEKQPCNFGHQTOCÁºQGCRGTHGKÁQCOGPVQFGOCIKUVTCFQU
#TGURGKVQFQRTQEGUUQFGGZGEWÁºQLWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
#TGURGKVQFCCÁºQEKXKNRÕDNKECLWNIWGQUKVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGU
#EQPEGUUºQFGOGFKFCUFGWTIÄPEKCGUV¶EQPFKEKQPCFC
CTGSWKUKVQURTÎRTKQUFCTGNGX¸PEKCFQFKTGKVQGFQTKUEQ
FGFCPQRTGXKUVQUHWPFCOGPVCNOGPVGGONGKGZVGPUKXQU
CQUECUQUFGEQPEGUUºQFGOGFKFCNKOKPCTGOUGFGFG
CÁºQEKXKNRÕDNKEC
# GZGEWÁºQ FG UGPVGPÁC IGPÃTKEC FG RTQEGFÄPEKC
RTQHGTKFC GO CÁºQ EQNGVKXC lato sensu FGOCPFC
EQIPKÁºQ GZCWTKGPVG G EQPVTCFKVÎTKQ CORNQ UQDTG C
KPFKXKFWCNK\CÁºQ G NKSWKFCÁºQ FQ XCNQT FGXKFQ DGO
EQOQ Q LWÈ\Q UQDTG C VKVWNCTKFCFG FQ GZGS×GPVG GO
TGNCÁºQCQFKTGKVQOCVGTKCNTGEQPJGEKFQPCCÁºQEQNGVKXC
1/KPKUVÃTKQ2ÕDNKEQÃRCTVGNGIÈVKOCRCTCCLWK\CTCÁºQ
EKXKN RÕDNKEC XKUCPFQ ´ FGXQNWÁºQ FG XCNQTGU RCIQU
KPFGXKFCOGPVG GO EQPVTCVQU FG CSWKUKÁºQ FC ECUC
RTÎRTKC FKUEKRNKPCFQU RGNQ UKUVGOC HKPCPEGKTQ
JCDKVCEKQPCNHKTOCFQUEQORGUUQCUJKRQUUWHKEKGPVGU
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–6–
GRUPO III: DIREITOS PENAL E
PROCESSUAL PENAL
,WNIWGQUUGIWKPVGUKVGPU
#CÁºQFGOCPWVGPÁºQFGRQUUGFGKOÎXGNSWCPFQGUUG
UG CEJCT UKVWCFQ GO OCKU FG WO GUVCFQ QW EQOCTEC
EQPVÈIWQU UGT¶ EQORGVGPVG Q HQTQ EQTTGURQPFGPVG CQ
NQECNGOSWGUGGPEQPVTCCOCKQTGZVGPUºQFQDGO0Q
GPVCPVQ RQT UG VTCVCT FG EQORGVÄPEKC VGTTKVQTKCN GUVC
RQFG UGT OQFKHKECFC RQT CEQTFQ V¶EKVQ QW GZRTGUUQ
GPVTGCURCTVGU
5GGOFGVGTOKPCFQRTQEGUUQQÏPWUFCRTQXC FQHCVQ
EQWDGT CQ CWVQT UQOGPVG GNG VGO NGIKVKOKFCFG RCTC
TGSWGTGTCRTQFWÁºQFGVCNRTQXC
1U RTGUUWRQUVQU FG EQPUVKVWKÁºQ G FGUGPXQNXKOGPVQ
X¶NKFQUGTGIWNCTGUFQRTQEGUUQFGXGOUGTGZCOKPCFQU
UQD Q RQPVQ FG XKUVC GUVTKVCOGPVG RTQEGUUWCN
EQORTGGPFGPFQQUUGIWKPVGUCURGEVQUCEQORGVÄPEKCFQ
LWK\CECRCEKFCFGEKXKNFCURCTVGUUWCTGRTGUGPVCÁºQRQT
CFXQICFQCQDUGTX¸PEKCFCHQTOCRTQEGUUWCNCFGSWCFC
´RTGVGPUºQCGZKUVÄPEKCPQUCWVQUFQKPUVTWOGPVQFG
OCPFCVQCKPGZKUVÄPEKCFGNKVKURGPFÄPEKCEQKUCLWNICFC
EQORTQOKUUQ QW KPÃREKC FC KPKEKCN G CKPFC C
KPGZKUVÄPEKC FG SWCKUSWGT PWNKFCFGU RTGXKUVCU PC
NGIKUNCÁºQRTQEGUUWCN
#TGURGKVQFQULWK\CFQUGURGEKCKUHGFGTCKULWNIWGQURTÎZKOQU
KVGPU
0QLWK\CFQGURGEKCNHGFGTCNEÈXGNRQFGOHKIWTCTEQOQ
RCTVGUTÃUC7PKºQCWVCTSWKCUHWPFCÁÐGUUQEKGFCFGUFG
GEQPQOKCOKUVCGCUGORTGUCURÕDNKECUHGFGTCKU
#EQORGVÄPEKCFQULWK\CFQUGURGEKCKUHGFGTCKUÃCDUQNWVC
PCUNQECNKFCFGUSWGL¶VKXGTGOLWK\CFQUKPUVCNCFQUGCU
UGPVGPÁCU RTQHGTKFCU GO FGUHCXQT FQU NGIKVKOCFQU
RCUUKXQUGUVºQUWLGKVCUCQTGGZCOGPGEGUU¶TKQ
#EGTECFCUVWVGNCUFGWTIÄPEKCPQRTQEGUUQEKXKNLWNIWGQU
KVGPUCUGIWKT
5ºQTGSWKUKVQURCTCCQDVGPÁºQFCVWVGNCECWVGNCTCRTQXC
KPGSWÈXQECCEGTVG\CSWCPVQCQFKTGKVQCUGTTGCNK\CFQG
Q HWPFCFQ TGEGKQ FG FCPQ KTTGRCT¶XGN QW FG FKHÈEKN
TGRCTCÁºQ
%CUQCRCTVGHQTOWNGRGFKFQFGCPVGEKRCÁºQFGVWVGNCG
UGLCEQPUVCVCFCPCVWTG\CECWVGNCTPQRGFKFQHQTOWNCFQ
FGUFGSWGRTGUGPVGUQUTGSWKUKVQUGUUGPEKCKUCQRGFKFQ
QLWK\FGXGT¶RTQOQXGTCEQPXGTUºQFGWORGFKFQGO
QWVTQ
#Q GZCOKPCT RGFKFQ FG CPVGEKRCÁºQ FG VWVGNC PQ
RTQEGFKOGPVQQTFKP¶TKQQLWK\RQFGEQPEGFGTOGFKFC
ECWVGNCTRCTCCUUGIWTCTCWVKNKFCFGFQRTQEGUUQCQKPXÃU
FGCPVGEKRCTQUGHGKVQUFCFGEKUºQFGOÃTKVQ
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
#EGTEC FCU PQTOCU FG EQPXGPÁÐGU G VTCVCFQU FG FKTGKVQ
KPVGTPCEKQPCN TGNCVKXQU CQ RTQEGUUQ RGPCN FQ KPSWÃTKVQ
RQNKEKCNGFCCÁºQRGPCNLWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUWEGFGO
%QPUQCPVG QTKGPVCÁºQ FQ 56( Q 2CEVQ FG 5ºQ ,QUà FC
%QUVC4KECHQKTGEGREKQPCFQRGNQQTFGPCOGPVQLWTÈFKEQ
DTCUKNGKTQ EQOQ PQTOC KPHTCEQPUVKVWEKQPCN IGTCN ō lex
generalis&GUVCTVGPºQVGOHQTÁCRCTCFGTTQICTPQTOC
KPHTCEQPUVKVWEKQPCNGURGEKCNEQOQCTGRTGUGPVCFCRGNC
.GKP
.GKFQU %TKOGU*GFKQPFQUō lex
specialis
&GCEQTFQEQOQGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ56(CFGEKUºQSWG
FGVGTOKPC Q CTSWKXCOGPVQ FQ KPSWÃTKVQ RQNKEKCN C
RGFKFQ FQ /KPKUVÃTKQ 2ÕDNKEQ SWCPFQ Q HCVQ PGNG
CRWTCFQPºQEQPUVKVWKTETKOG
CVÈRKEQRTQFW\OCKUSWG
RTGENWUºQ EQKUC LWNICFC OCVGTKCN KORGFKPFQ WNVGTKQT
KPUVCWTCÁºQFGRTQEGUUQSWGVGPJCRQTQDLGVQQOGUOQ
GRKUÎFKQ CKPFC SWG C FGPÕPEKC UG DCUGKG GO PQXQU
GNGOGPVQUFGRTQXC
'O CÁºQ RGPCN RQT ETKOG FG FKHCOCÁºQ G ECNÕPKC
EQPUQCPVGGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ56(QSWGTGNCPVGPºQRQFG
CPVGU FQ TGEGDKOGPVQ FC SWGKZCETKOG FGUKUVKT
WPKNCVGTCNOGPVGGTGSWGTGTQCTSWKXCOGPVQFCTGHGTKFC
CÁºQKPFGRGPFGPVGOGPVGFCTGCNK\CÁºQFGCWFKÄPEKCFG
EQPEKNKCÁºQ
4GNCVKXCOGPVG´EQORGVÄPEKCPQRTQEGUUQRGPCNLWNIWGQU
RTÎZKOQUKVGPU
%QORGVG´LWUVKÁCHGFGTCNFGCEQTFQEQOGPVGPFKOGPVQ
FQ56(RTQEGUUCTGLWNICTETKOGUFGCDWUQFGCWVQTKFCFG
GFGNGUÐGUEQTRQTCKURTCVKECFQURQTRQNKEKCKUOKNKVCTGU
EQPVTCUKNXÈEQNCPQKPVGTKQTFGTGUGTXCKPFÈIGPC
0CUCÁÐGURGPCKUQTKIKP¶TKCUEQORGVGCQ56(RTQEGUUCT
GLWNICTQUVKVWNCTGU FGECTIQUFGPCVWTG\CGURGEKCNFC
GUVTWVWTC QTI¸PKEC FC 2TGUKFÄPEKC FC 4GRÕDNKEC SWG
RQUUWGORQTNGKRTGTTQICVKXCUICTCPVKCUXCPVCIGPUG
FKTGKVQUGSWKXCNGPVGUCQUVKVWNCTGUFQUOKPKUVÃTKQU
%QORGVGCQVTKDWPCNTGIKQPCNHGFGTCN
64(RTQEGUUCTG
LWNICT GZRTGHGKVQ OWPKEKRCN RGNC RT¶VKEC FWTCPVG UWC
IGUVºQCFOKPKUVTCVKXCFGETKOGFGRGEWNCVQGPXQNXGPFQ
TGEWTUQUFQ5KUVGOC­PKEQFG5CÕFG1UEQTÃWUCPVGC
GZKUVÄPEKCFGTGNCÁºQFGEQPGZºQGEQPVKPÄPEKCFQUHCVQU
UºQVCODÃORTQEGUUCFQUGLWNICFQURGNQ64(
3WCPVQ ´U OGFKFCU CUUGEWTCVÎTKCU G CQ KPEKFGPVG FG
KPUCPKFCFGOGPVCNLWNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGU
#XKCKORWIPCVKXCFQUGODCTIQUÃECDÈXGNPQECUQFGQ
UGS×GUVTQTGECKTUQDTGDGPUKOÎXGKUCFSWKTKFQUEQOQU
RTQXGPVQU FC KPHTCÁºQ OGFKFC EQPUVTKVKXC RTGXKUVC PQ
%ÎFKIQ FG 2TQEGUUQ 2GPCN %22 /QUVTCUG ECDÈXGN Q
QHGTGEKOGPVQFQUGODCTIQUEQPVTCQUGS×GUVTQRTÃXKQō
CTV FQ %22 ō SWG VGO PCVWTG\C FG ICTCPVKC ´
JKRQVGECNGICNGSWGCVKPIGSWCKUSWGTDGPUKOÎXGKUFQ
TÃWRCTCCUUGIWTCTRQUVGTKQTGURGEKCNK\CÁºQGKPUETKÁºQ
FGUUGUDGPU
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–7–
1 GZCOG FG KPUCPKFCFG OGPVCN SWG QDLGVKXC ´
FGOQPUVTCÁºQFCJKIKFG\RUÈSWKECFQTÃWPQOQOGPVQ
FCRT¶VKECFCKPHTCÁºQRGPCNFGXGUGTFGHGTKFQRGNQLWK\
UGORTGSWGJQWXGTTGSWGTKOGPVQFCFGHGUCUQDRGPCFG
EGTEGCOGPVQFGFGHGUCGEQPUVTCPIKOGPVQKNGICN
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
1/KPKUVÃTKQ2ÕDNKEQTGSWGTGWCOGFKFCCUUGEWTCVÎTKCFG
GURGEKCNK\CÁºQGKPUETKÁºQFGJKRQVGECNGICNUQDTGDGPU
KOÎXGKUFGRTQRTKGFCFGFGTÃWFGPWPEKCFQRGNCRT¶VKEC
FG ETKOG FG CRTQRTKCÁºQ KPFÃDKVC RTGXKFGPEK¶TKC DGO
EQOQFGUWCUEQVCUUQEKCKUPCGORTGUC#/'PI.VFC
PCSWCNGTCUÎEKQIGTGPVGCHKOFGICTCPVKTQUGHGKVQUFG
GXGPVWCNGHWVWTCEQPFGPCÁºQ
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQCOGFKFCPºQUGT¶ECDÈXGNEQOTGNCÁºQ
´GORTGUCRCTCPºQXKQNCTQRTKPEÈRKQFCRGUUQCNKFCFG
EQOCVTKDWKÁºQFGTGURQPUCDKNKFCFGRGPCNCVGTEGKTQUFC
TGNCÁºQLWTÈFKEC
%QO TGNCÁºQ ´ CRNKECÁºQ FC .GK P PC LWUVKÁC
HGFGTCN´UUGPVGPÁCURGPCKUG´HKZCÁºQFCRGPCLWNIWGQU
KVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGU
œECDÈXGNCUWURGPUºQEQPFKEKQPCNFQRTQEGUUQPQECUQ
FG FGUENCUUKHKECÁºQ QRGTCFC GO UGFG FG UGPVGPÁC
EQPFGPCVÎTKC FQ ETKOG ECRKVWNCFQ PC XGUVKDWNCT
CEWUCVÎTKCRGNQRTQEWTCFQTFC4GRÕDNKEC0GUUGECUQQ
LWK\ FGXG QWXKT RTGXKCOGPVG Q ÎTIºQ FQ /KPKUVÃTKQ
2ÕDNKEQCEGTECFQsursisRTQEGUUWCN
156(VGOGPVGPFKOGPVQSWCPVQ´KORQUUKDKNKFCFGFGC
EQPFGPCÁºQ ETKOKPCN CPVGTKQT SWG PºQ ECTCEVGTK\C
TGKPEKFÄPEKCGOHCEGFQFGEWTUQFQRTC\QFGOCKUFG
CPQU GPVTG C FCVC FC GZVKPÁºQ FC RGPC G C KPHTCÁºQ
RQUVGTKQTUGTEQPUKFGTCFCCVÈVWNQFGOCWUCPVGEGFGPVGU
SWCPFQ FC CP¶NKUG FCU EKTEWPUV¸PEKCU LWFKEKCKU PC
FQUKOGVTKCFCRGPC
0C HKZCÁºQ FC RGPC C CVGPWCPVG FC OGPQTKFCFG
RTGRQPFGTCUQDTGSWCNSWGTQWVTCEKTEWPUV¸PEKCKPENWUKXG
UQDTGCTGKPEKFÄPEKCRQTUWCXG\OCKUITCXQUCSWGCU
EQPUGS×ÄPEKCUFQETKOGGCUCITCXCPVGUIGPÃTKECU
# TGURGKVQ FC RTKUºQ GO HNCITCPVG FC RTKUºQ GURGEKCN G FC
NKDGTFCFGRTQXKUÎTKCLWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUWEGFGO
&G CEQTFQ EQO C QTKGPVCÁºQ FQ 56, Q FKTGKVQ FQ
CFXQICFQ QW FG SWCNSWGT QWVTQ RTGUQ GURGEKCN FGXG
EKTEWPUETGXGTUG ´ ICTCPVKC FG TGEQNJKOGPVQ GO NQECN
FKUVKPVQFCRTKUºQEQOWO0ºQJCXGPFQGUVCDGNGEKOGPVQ
GURGEÈHKEQRQFGT¶QRTGUQUGTTGEQNJKFQCEGNCFKUVKPVCFC
RTKUºQ EQOWO QDUGTXCFCU CU EQPFKÁÐGU OÈPKOCU FG
UCNWDTKFCFGGFKIPKFCFGFCRGUUQCJWOCPC
œECDÈXGNCFGETGVCÁºQFGRTKUºQRTGXGPVKXCRCTCHKPUFG
RGFKFQ FG GZVTCFKÁºQ DGO EQOQ C EQPEGUUºQ FG
NKDGTFCFG RTQXKUÎTKC EQO HKCPÁC RTGGPEJKFQU QU
TGSWKUKVQUNGICKURTGXKUVQUPQ%22
3WCPVQ C JQOQNQICÁºQ FG UGPVGPÁC GUVTCPIGKTC ECTVCU
TQICVÎTKCU G TGEWTUQU PQ RTQEGUUQ RGPCN LWNIWG QU KVGPU C
UGIWKT
#JQOQNQICÁºQFGUGPVGPÁCUGUVTCPIGKTCUGCEQPEGUUºQ
FG GZGSW¶VWT ´U ECTVCU TQICVÎTKCU Ã FG EQORGVÄPEKC
QTKIKP¶TKCFQ56,CDTCPIGPFQVQFQUQURGFKFQUCKPFCGO
EWTUQFGRTQEGUUCOGPVQPQ56(
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
'OHCEGFQURTKPEÈRKQUFCCORNCFGHGUCGRTGUWPÁºQFG
KPQEÄPEKC FG CEQTFQ EQO Q 56( C TGECRVWTC FQ TÃW
HQTCIKFQ CPVGU FQ LWNICOGPVQ FC CRGNCÁºQ KPVGTRQUVC
CHCUVCCFGETGVCÁºQFCFGUGTÁºQFQTGEWTUQ
0QTGEWTUQGOUGPVKFQGUVTKVQQPºQQHGTGEKOGPVQFCU
TC\ÐGUTGEWTUCKUFGCEQTFQEQOQGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ56(
PºQQDUVCCUWDKFCFCKTTGUKIPCÁºQCQLWÈ\Qad quem
4GNCVKXCOGPVGCQhabeas corpusCQOCPFCFQFGUGIWTCPÁC
GO OCVÃTKC RGPCN ´ SWGDTC FG UKIKNQ DCPE¶TKQ G C
KPVGTEGRVCÁÐGUFGEQOWPKECÁÐGULWNIWGQURTÎZKOQUKVGPU
%QPUQCPVG GPVGPFKOGPVQ FQ 56( Q habeas corpus Ã
KPUVTWOGPVQKFÏPGQGOVGUGRCTCKORWIPCTCXCNKFCFG
FG FGEKUºQ LWFKEKCN SWG FGETGVC C SWGDTC FQ UKIKNQ
DCPE¶TKQEQPUKFGTCPFQSWGFGVCNRTQEGFKOGPVQRQFG
CFXKTOGFKFCTGUVTKVKXC´NKDGTFCFGFGNQEQOQÁºQ
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
7O KPFKXÈFWQ HQK RTGUQ GO HNCITCPVG RGNC RT¶VKEC FQ
ETKOGFGVT¶HKEQKNÈEKVQFGGPVQTRGEGPVGUVGPFQQLWK\GO
HCEG FG RGFKFQ FG FGHGPUQT EQPUVKVWÈFQ EQPEGFKFQ C
NKDGTFCFGRTQXKUÎTKCRQTGPVGPFGTCWUGPVGUQUTGSWKUKVQU
FC RTKUºQ RTGXGPVKXC +PEQPHQTOCFQ Q ÎTIºQ FQ
/KPKUVÃTKQ2ÕDNKEQKPVGTRÏUTGEWTUQGOUGPVKFQGUVTKVQ
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQFGCEQTFQEQOCQTKGPVCÁºQ FQ56,Ã
ECDÈXGN OCPFCFQ FG UGIWTCPÁC RCTC CVTKDWKT GHGKVQ
UWURGPUKXQCQTGEWTUQGOUGPVKFQGUVTKVQ
0ºQÃRQUUÈXGNFGCEQTFQEQOQ56(CRTQTTQICÁºQFQ
RTC\Q FG CWVQTK\CÁºQ LWFKEKCN RCTC C KPVGTEGRVCÁºQ
VGNGHÏPKECSWCPFQUWEGUUKXCOGUOQVTCVCPFQUGFGHCVQ
EQORNGZQSWGGZKLCKPXGUVKICÁºQFKHGTGPEKCFCGEQPVÈPWC
%CFC WO FQU KVGPU UGIWKPVGU CRTGUGPVC WOC UKVWCÁºQ
JKRQVÃVKECTGNCVKXCCRTKPEÈRKQUFGOCVÃTKCRGPCNVKRKEKFCFGG
KOWPKFCFG RCTNCOGPVCT UGIWKFC FG WOC CUUGTVKXC C UGT
LWNICFC
#CWVQTKFCFGRQNKEKCNKPUVCWTQWKPSWÃTKVQRQNKEKCNEQPVTC
/CPQGN RGNC RT¶VKEC FQ ETKOG FG FGUECOKPJQ RQT VGT
KPITGUUCFQ PQ VGTTKVÎTKQ PCEKQPCN EQO OGTECFQTKC
GUVTCPIGKTCKNWFKPFQQRCICOGPVQFQTGURGEVKXQKORQUVQ
FGXKFQ CXCNKCFQ GO 4 0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ FG
CEQTFQ EQO Q GPVGPFKOGPVQ FQ 56, PºQ Ã ECDÈXGN C
CRNKECÁºQFQRTKPEÈRKQFCKPUKIPKHKE¸PEKCQWDCICVGNC
7OFGRWVCFQHGFGTCNFKXWNIQWRQTOGKQFQKPHQTOCVKXQ
GNGVTÏPKEQUGOCPCNIGTCFQGOUGWICDKPGVGNQECNK\CFQ
PC %¸OCTC FQU &GRWVCFQU Q EQPVGÕFQ FG WOC ECTVC
CPÏPKOC CRÎETKHC SWG PQVKEKCXC HCNUCOGPVG HCVQU
QHGPUKXQU´JQPTCFGWORTGHGKVQOWPKEKRCNEQPUKUVGPVGU
PCRT¶VKECFGCVQUFGEQTTWRÁºQRCUUKXC0GUUCUKVWCÁºQ
QFGRWVCFQHGFGTCNRTCVKEQWETKOGFGKORTGPUC
ECNÕPKC
RQT PºQ GUVCT UWC EQPFWVC CDTKICFC RGNC KOWPKFCFG
OCVGTKCN
4GNCVKXCOGPVG CQU ETKOGU EQOKUUKXQU G QOKUUKXQU CQ
EQPEWTUQCRCTGPVGFGPQTOCUGCQEQPEWTUQFGETKOGULWNIWG
QUKVGPUSWGUGUGIWGO
#CRTQRTKCÁºQKPFÃDKVCRTGXKFGPEK¶TKCÃETKOGQOKUUKXQ
RTÎRTKQQWRWTQSWGUGCRGTHGKÁQCKPFGRGPFGPVGOGPVG
FQHCVQFGQCIGPVGōGORTGICFQTōXKTCUGDGPGHKEKCT
EQOQUXCNQTGUFGUEQPVCFQUFGUGWUGORTGICFQUGPºQ
TGRCUUCFQU´RTGXKFÄPEKCUQEKCN
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–8–
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
.GQPCTFQ GZRQTVQW KNGICNOGPVG DGPU KNWFKPFQ Q
TGEQNJKOGPVQFQKORQUVQFGXKFQGHC\GPFQWUQFGHCNUC
FQEWOGPVCÁºQ
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ UGIWPFQ Q 56( .GQPCTFQ TGURQPFG
UQOGPVG RGNQ ETKOG FG FGUECOKPJQ GO HCEG FC
EQPUWPÁºQ
5GCHCNUKFCFGQWQWUQFGFQEWOGPVQHCNUQÃQOGKQ
GORTGICFQRCTCCRT¶VKECFQGUVGNKQPCVQFGCEQTFQEQO
QGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ56(QCIGPVGTGURQPFGUQOGPVGRGNQ
ETKOG FG GUVGNKQPCVQ EQO C CDUQTÁºQ FQU ETKOGU FG
HCNUKFCFGQWFGWUQFGFQEWOGPVQHCNUQ
#TGURGKVQFGCITCXCPVGUGCVGPWCPVGUNKXTCOGPVQEQPFKEKQPCN
G UWURGPUºQ EQPFKEKQPCN FC RGPC LWNIWG QU KVGPU
UWDUGS×GPVGU
0CCRNKECÁºQFCRGPCPQEQPEWTUQGPVTGEKTEWPUV¸PEKCU
CVGPWCPVGU G CITCXCPVGU C EQPHKUUºQ GURQPV¸PGC
RTGXCNGEGUQDTGCTGKPEKFÄPEKC
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
4GPCVQ RTKO¶TKQ G UGO CPVGEGFGPVGU ETKOKPCKU HQK
EQPFGPCFQ´RGPCRTKXCVKXCFGNKDGTFCFGFGCPQUFG
TGENWUºQ C UGT EWORTKFC GO TGIKOG KPKEKCNOGPVG
HGEJCFQRGNCRT¶VKECFQETKOGFGVT¶HKEQKPVGTPCEKQPCNFG
UWDUV¸PEKCUGPVQTRGEGPVGU
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ CRGUCT FC HKZCÁºQ FQ TGIKOG RTKUKQPCN
KPKEKCNOGPVG HGEJCFQ 4GPCVQ UQOGPVG RTGGPEJGT¶ Q
TGSWKUKVQ QDLGVKXQVGORQTCN FQ NKXTCOGPVQ EQPFKEKQPCN
CRÎUQEWORTKOGPVQFGCPQUFCRGPC
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
7O KPFKXÈFWQ HQK EQPFGPCFQ ´ RGPC RTKXCVKXC FG
NKDGTFCFG FG CPQU FG TGENWUºQ GO TGIKOG
KPVGITCNOGPVGHGEJCFQRGNCRT¶VKECFQETKOGFGVT¶HKEQ
KNÈEKVQFGGPVQTRGEGPVGU
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ EQPHQTOG GPVGPFKOGPVQ FQ 56(
RTGGPEJKFQUQUTGSWKUKVQUNGICKUÃECDÈXGNCEQPEGUUºQFC
UWURGPUºQEQPFKEKQPCNFCRGPC
0Q SWG VCPIG CQU TGIKOGU RTKUKQPCKU G CQ EQPEWTUQ FG
RGUUQCULWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
0C UGPVGPÁC RGPCN EQPFGPCVÎTKC Q LWK\ CRÎU CRNKECT
C RGPC RTKXCVKXC FG NKDGTFCFG CQ TÃW RGNC RT¶VKEC FQ
ETKOG FG NCVTQEÈPKQ HKZQW Q TGIKOG HGEJCFQ HC\GPFQ
GZRTGUUC OGPÁºQ ´ .GK FQU %TKOGU *GFKQPFQU ō
.GKP
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ FG CEQTFQ EQO C QTKGPVCÁºQ FQ 56(
GO HCEG FC QOKUUºQ FQ CFXÃTDKQ integralmente HKEQW
CUUGIWTCFQQFKTGKVQ´RTQITGUUºQFQTGIKOGRTKUKQPCN
VTCPUKVCFC GO LWNICFQ RCTC Q /KPKUVÃTKQ 2ÕDNKEQ C
UGPVGPÁC
0Q JQOKEÈFKQ FQ VKRQ OGTEGP¶TKQ C SWCNKHKECFQTC
TGNCVKXC CQ EQOGVKOGPVQ FQ ETKOG OGFKCPVG RCIC QW
RTQOGUUCFGTGEQORGPUCEQPUQCPVGGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ
56,EQOWPKECUGEQOQUEQCWVQTGUQWRCTVÈEKRGURQT
VTCVCTUGFGEQPFKÁºQFGECT¶VGTPºQRGUUQCN
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
3WCPVQ CQU ETKOGU FG NCXCIGO FG FKPJGKTQ EQPVTC Q
RCVTKOÏPKQ FG TCEKUOQ G EQPVTC C CFOKPKUVTCÁºQ RÕDNKEC
LWNIWGQURTÎZKOQUKVGPU
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
2CTCQEWNVCTCQTKIGOKNGICNSWGPºQRQFGTKCLWUVKHKECT
WO UGTXKFQT RÕDNKEQ GHGVWQW FGRÎUKVQU FG EJGSWGU FG
VGTEGKTQU TGEGDKFQU EQOQ RTQFWVQ FG EQPEWUUºQ GO
EQPVCUEQTTGPVGU FG RGUUQCU LWTÈFKECU EQPUVKVWÈFCU RCTC
GUUGOKUVGTPCUSWCKUHKIWTCXCEQOQUÎEKQLWPVCOGPVG
EQOUWCGURQUCVGPFQNKXTGCEGUUQCQUPWOGT¶TKQURCTC
RQUVGTKQTGUKPXGUVKOGPVQU
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ Q UGTXKFQT RÕDNKEQ RTCVKEQW GO VGUG
ETKOGFGNCXCIGOFGFKPJGKTQ
#RÎUQTGEGDKOGPVQFCFGPÕPEKCQRCICOGPVQKPVGITCN
FQU FÃDKVQU QTKWPFQU FC HCNVC FG TGEQNJKOGPVQ FG
EQPVTKDWKÁºQ´RTGXKFÄPEKCUQEKCNFGUEQPVCFCFQUUCN¶TKQU
FQU GORTGICFQU FG CEQTFQ EQO Q 56, G 56( PºQ
GZVKPIWG C RWPKDKNKFCFG FQ ETKOG FG CRTQRTKCÁºQ
KPFÃDKVCRTGXKFGPEK¶TKC
%QPUQCPVG GPVGPFKOGPVQ FQ 56( EQPUVKVWK ETKOG FG
TCEKUOQ GUETGXGT NKXTQ HC\GPFQ CRQNQIKC FG KFÃKCU
RTGEQPEGKVWQUCUGFKUETKOKPCVÎTKCUEQPVTCCEQOWPKFCFG
LWFCKECPQUGPVKFQFGSWGQULWFGWUUGTKCOTCÁCKPHGTKQT
PGHCUVCGKPHGEVCECTCEVGTÈUVKECUUWHKEKGPVGURCTCLWUVKHKECT
CUGITGICÁºQGQGZVGTOÈPKQ
1ETKOGFGEQTTWRÁºQRCUUKXCEQPUQCPVGGPVGPFKOGPVQ
FQ 56( RCTC C UWC EQPHKIWTCÁºQ TGENCOC SWG Q
HWPEKQP¶TKQ RÕDNKEQ VGPJC UQNKEKVCFQ QW TGEGDKFQ
XCPVCIGOKPFGXKFCQWCEGKVQUWCRTQOGUUCGOTC\ºQFG
CVQGURGEÈHKEQFGUWCHWPÁºQQWECTIQQWUGLCCVQFG
QHÈEKQōQOKUUKXQQWEQOKUUKXQ
%CFC KVGO UGIWKPVG CRTGUGPVC WOC UKVWCÁºQ JKRQVÃVKEC
TGHGTGPVG CQU ETKOGU FG VÎZKEQU EQPVTC Q RCVTKOÏPKQ C HÃ
RÕDNKECGQOGKQCODKGPVGUGIWKFCFGWOCCUUGTVKXCCUGT
LWNICFC
7OKPFKXÈFWQCFSWKTKWPC$QNÈXKCGVTCPURQTVQWGOWOC
CGTQPCXG RCTVKEWNCT RCTC Q $TCUKN MI FG RCUVC FG
EQECÈPC SWG RQUVGTKQTOGPVG UGTKC TGHKPCFC GO WO
NCDQTCVÎTKQ PQ OWPKEÈRKQ FG 4GEKHG Ō 2' RCTC UGT
EQOGTEKCNK\CFC PQ VGTTKVÎTKQ PCEKQPCN #Q CVGTTKUUCT C
CGTQPCXG GO WOC RKUVC FG RQWUQ FG WOC HC\GPFC FQ
TGHGTKFQOWPKEÈRKQQKPFKXÈFWQHQKRTGUQRQTRQNKEKCKU
OKNKVCTGU0GUUCUKVWCÁºQQKPFKXÈFWQRTCVKEQWQETKOG
FG VT¶HKEQ KPVGTPCEKQPCN FG GPVQTRGEGPVGU EWLC RGPC
RTKXCVKXCFGNKDGTFCFGUGT¶OCLQTCFCFGWOVGTÁQCFQKU
VGTÁQU
7OUGTXKFQTRÕDNKEQFGWOCCWVCTSWKCRTGXKFGPEK¶TKC
TGURQPU¶XGN RGNC CWVGPVKECÁºQ FG FQEWOGPVQU
CRTGUGPVCFQU RCTC HKPU FG DGPGHÈEKQU EGTVKHKEQW EQOQ
TGRTQFWÁÐGU HKÃKU EÎRKCU FG FQEWOGPVQU CRTGUGPVCFQU
RQT WO RCTVKEWNCT GO TGSWGTKOGPVQ RCTC HKPU FG
QDVGPÁºQ FG CRQUGPVCFQTKC SWG RQUVGTKQTOGPVG HKEQW
EQORTQXCFQ UGTGO HCNUKHKECFQU 0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ Q
UGTXKFQT RÕDNKEQ RTCVKEQW GO VGUG Q ETKOG FG
GUVGNKQPCVQSWCNKHKECFQRQTVGTQETKOGUKFQRTCVKECFQGO
FGVTKOGPVQFGGPVKFCFGFGFKTGKVQRÕDNKEQGCUUKUVÄPEKC
UQEKCN
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
–9–
7O ÎTIºQ FQ /KPKUVÃTKQ 2ÕDNKEQ QHGTGEGW FGPÕPEKC
EQPVTCWOCRGUUQCLWTÈFKECFGFKTGKVQRTKXCFQGFQKUFG
UGWUCFOKPKUVTCFQTGURQTETKOGEQPVTCQOGKQCODKGPVG
RQTECWUCTGORQNWKÁºQGONGKVQFGWOTKQKPVGTGUVCFWCN
RQTOGKQFGNCPÁCOGPVQFGTGUÈFWQUVCKUEQOQITCZCU
ÎNGQ NQFQ CTGKC G RTQFWVQU SWÈOKEQU TGUWNVCPVGU FC
CVKXKFCFGFQGUVCDGNGEKOGPVQEQOGTEKCN0GUUCUKVWCÁºQ
FGCEQTFQEQOGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ56,CRGUUQCLWTÈFKEC
PºQRQFGUGTUWLGKVQRCUUKXQFGETKOGCODKGPVCN
#EGTEC FQU ETKOGU EQPVTC C CFOKPKUVTCÁºQ RÕDNKEC CU
VGNGEQOWPKECÁÐGUGCHCWPCLWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
'OWOCTGENCOCÁºQVTCDCNJKUVCQCFXQICFQFCGORTGUC
TGENCOCFCKPUVKIQWGQTKGPVQWWOCVGUVGOWPJCCRTGUVCT
FGRQKOGPVQKPXGTÈFKEQGOCWFKÄPEKCPGICPFQQXÈPEWNQ
GORTGICVÈEKQSWGQGORTGICFQTGENCOCPVGCNGICXCVGT
GZKUVKFQ RCTC HC\GT LWU C FKTGKVQU VTCDCNJKUVCU ō CXKUQ
RTÃXKQUCN¶TKQGHÃTKCU
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQEQPUQCPVGGPVGPFKOGPVQFQ56(G56,Q
CFXQICFQRTCVKEQWGOVGUGQETKOGFGHCNUQVGUVGOWPJQ
GOEQPEWTUQFGCIGPVGU
%QPHKIWTCGOVGUGETKOGEQPVTCCUVGNGEQOWPKECÁÐGUC
KPUVCNCÁºQQWWVKNK\CÁºQFGT¶FKQEQOWPKV¶TKCCKPFCSWG
FG DCKZC RQVÄPEKC G UGO HKPU NWETCVKXQU UGO C FGXKFC
CWVQTK\CÁºQFQRQFGTRÕDNKEQ
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
7O KPFKXÈFWQ FWTCPVG Q RGTÈQFQ FG TGRTQFWÁºQ FQ
ECOCTºQDTCPEQ
ÃRQECFGFGHGUQRGUEQWRGNQUKUVGOC
FG RCTGNJCU MI FQ ETWUV¶EGQ UGPFQ HNCITCFQ RQT
HKUECKUFQ+$#/#SWCPFQCVTCECXCUWCGODCTECÁºQ
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ Q KPFKXÈFWQ RTCVKEQW GO VGUG ETKOG
EQPVTCCHCWPC
GRUPO IV: DIREITOS CIVIL E COMERCIAL
#EGTEC FC VGQTKC IGTCN FQU EQPVTCVQU G FQU EQPVTCVQU GO
GURÃEKGLWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKT
# DQCHÃ QDLGVKXC Ã WO RTKPEÈRKQ SWG VGO HQTÁC RCTC
XCNKFCT PGIÎEKQU LWTÈFKEQU 'NC HWPEKQPC EQOQ TGITC
KORNÈEKVC GO VQFQ PGIÎEKQ LWTÈFKEQ DKNCVGTCN
PQVCFCOGPVGPQEQPVTCVQFGUGIWTQEQPVTCVQGOSWG
RGNCU UWCU ECTCEVGTÈUVKECU C OCPKHGUVCÁºQ FC XQPVCFG
TGRTGUGPVC Q GNGOGPVQ PWENGCT RCTC C UWC HQTOCÁºQ
XCNKFCFGGGHKE¶EKC
%QPUKFGTGSWGHQKHKTOCFQWOEQPVTCVQFGGORTÃUVKOQ
PQ SWCN HQK KPENWÈFC EN¶WUWNC GUVCDGNGEGPFQ SWG ECUQ
PºQQEQTTCQRCICOGPVQFCFÈXKFCPQXGPEKOGPVQGGO
FKPJGKTQQKOÎXGNSWGHQKVTCPUHGTKFQOGFKCPVGGUETKVWTC
RÕDNKEC PC FCVC FQ GORTÃUVKOQ UG EQPUQNKFC PC
RTQRTKGFCFG FC RGUUQC FQ ETGFQT 0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ C
VTCPUHGTÄPEKC FC RTQRTKGFCFG FQ KOÎXGN RCTC Q ETGFQT
ECTCEVGTK\CUGEQOQFCÁºQGORCICOGPVQ
0C EQORTC G XGPFC FG KOÎXGKU PC OQFCNKFCFG ad
mensuram RQTGZVGPUºQ QEQORTCFQTPºQVGOFKTGKVQ
CEQORNGOGPVCÁºQFC¶TGCQWCTGFWÁºQFQRTGÁQCQ
EQPVT¶TKQ FQ SWG QEQTTG PC OQFCNKFCFG FG EQORTC G
XGPFCad corpus EQKUCEGTVC
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
,QºQXGPFGWC,QUÃWOKOÎXGNFGRTQRTKGFCFGFGVGTEGKTQ
RQT OGKQ FG GUETKVWTC RÕDNKEC SWG HQK NGXCFC CQ
EQORGVGPVG ECTVÎTKQ FG TGIKUVTQ KOQDKNK¶TKQ RQTÃO
WVKNK\CPFQUGFGHCNUCRTQEWTCÁºQ
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQCRÎUCGHGVKXCÁºQFCXGPFCGCRQUUGFQ
EQORTCFQTFGDQCHÃRQFGQXGTFCFGKTQRTQRTKGV¶TKQRQT
OGKQFGCÁºQRTÎRTKCQDVGTCFGETGVCÁºQFCKPXCNKFCFG
FQVÈVWNQGQECPEGNCOGPVQFQTGURGEVKXQTGIKUVTQ
0Q EQPVTCVQ GUVKOCVÎTKQ C TGUVKVWKÁºQ FC EQKUC
EQPUKIPCFCÃQRÁºQNKXTGFQEQPUKIPCV¶TKQFGUFGSWGQ
HCÁC FGPVTQ FQ RTC\Q FGVGTOKPCFQ RCTC C XGPFC C
VGTEGKTQU PºQ RQFGPFQ Q EQPUKIPCPVG KORGFKNC QW
NKOKV¶NCRQKUXKQNCTKCCPCVWTG\CFQPGIÎEKQ
%QOTGNCÁºQCQUFKTGKVQUFCUQDTKICÁÐGUGUGWUGHGKVQULWNIWG
QUKVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGU
# EN¶WUWNC RGPCN EQORGPUCVÎTKC GUVKRWNCFC RCTC C
JKRÎVGUG FG FGUEWORTKOGPVQ VQVCN FC QDTKICÁºQ RQFG
UQHTGTTGFWÁºQLWFKEKCNPCJKRÎVGUGFGFGUEWORTKOGPVQ
RCTEKCN FC CXGPÁC œ XGFCFQ CQ LWK\ FGHGTKT Q RGFKFQ
WPKNCVGTCN FG WOC FCU RCTVGU FG TGFWÁºQ FQ XCNQT
NKXTGOGPVG RCEVWCFQ RGNCU RCTVGU UQD C CNGICÁºQ FG
RGPCNKFCFGOCPKHGUVCOGPVGGZEGUUKXC
1 FGXGFQT DGPGHKEKCFQ RGNC TGOKUUºQ PQ ECUQ FG
TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG UQNKF¶TKC RCUUKXC HKEC GZQPGTCFQ GO
TGNCÁºQ CQ VQVCN FQ FÃDKVQ RCTC EQO Q ETGFQT
EQPVKPWCPFQ QU FGOCKU EQQDTKICFQU KPUQNXGPVGU
TGURQPU¶XGKURGNQTGUVCPVGFCFÈXKFC
0ºQ J¶ PGEGUUKFCFG FG SWG C QDTKICÁºQ RCTC UGT
UQNKF¶TKCDCUGKGUGGOWOCOGUOCECWUCQWHWPFCOGPVQ
LWTÈFKEQ#UUKOSWCPFQGOTC\ºQFGWOOGUOQFCPQ
WOUWLGKVQCRTGUGPVCUGTGURQPU¶XGNRGTCPVGQNGUCFQRQT
CVQ KNÈEKVQ QWVTQ RGNQ TKUEQ SWG NJG Ã KORWV¶XGN G WO
VGTEGKTQ RGNC KPHTCÁºQ FG WO FGXGT EQPVTCVWCN FG
FKNKIÄPEKCCQDTKICÁºQÃUQNKF¶TKC
#EGTECFQUTGIKUVTQURÕDNKEQULWNIWGQURTÎZKOQUKVGPU
# HWUºQ FG OCVTÈEWNCU F¶ JQOQIGPGKFCFG LWTÈFKEC C
KOÎXGKU HKUKECOGPVG EQPVÈIWQU G SWG PºQ QDUVCPVG
EQPUVKVWÈTGO WO VQFQ JCTOÏPKEQ CRCTGEGO RCTC Q
FKTGKVQ EQOQ GPVKFCFGU CRCTVCFCU 1 GZGTEÈEKQ FGUUG
FKTGKVQFGEQTTGFCRTQRTKGFCFGRQKUVQFCUCUOCVTÈEWNCU
C WPKHKECT FGXGO GUVCT TGIKUVTCFCU UQD Q OGUOQ
RTQRTKGV¶TKQ
&ÕXKFCTGIKUVT¶TKCÃQLWÈ\QGOKVKFQRGNQTGIKUVTCFQTPQ
GZGTEÈEKQFGUWCUHWPÁÐGUQDUVCPFQCWOCRTGVGPUºQFG
TGIKUVTQ 1 RTQEGFKOGPVQ FG FÕXKFC VGO PCVWTG\C
CFOKPKUVTCVKXC RQKU PºQ J¶ EQPVTCFKVÎTKQ GPVTG RCTVGU
KPVGTGUUCFCU CRGPCU FKUUGPUQ GPVTG Q TGSWGTGPVG G Q
UGTXGPVW¶TKQ
%QOTGHGTÄPEKC´RQUUGGCQFKTGKVQFGUWRGTHÈEKGLWNIWGQU
UGIWKPVGUKVGPU
0C XKIÄPEKC FQ RTC\Q FG EQPVTCVQ FG EQPEGUUºQ FG
UWRGTHÈEKGRQFGQUWRGTHKEK¶TKQVTCPUHGTKTUGWFKTGKVQTGCN
RQTCVQinter vivosUGPFQXGFCFCSWCNSWGTGURÃEKGFG
RCICOGPVQ CQ RTQRTKGV¶TKQ #UUKO Ã PWNC C EN¶WUWNC
KPUGTKFC PQ EQPVTCVQ FG EQPEGUUºQ FQ FKTGKVQ FG
UWRGTHÈEKG SWG KORQPJC CQ RTQRTKGV¶TKQ EQPEGFGPVG Q
ÏPWUFGKPFGPK\CTSWCKUSWGTEQPUVTWÁÐGUQWRNCPVCÁÐGU
SWGQUWRGTHKEK¶TKQXKGTCKPEQTRQTCTCQUQNQ
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
– 10 –
%QPUKFGTGSWGWOCRGUUQCQEWRGJ¶OCKUFGFG\CPQU
WOC¶TGCFGFQOÈPKQRÕDNKEQNQECNQPFGHQKEQPUVTWÈFC
WOC RGSWGPC DCTTCEC FG CNXGPCTKC FGUVKPCFC ´
GZRNQTCÁºQFCCVKXKFCFGEQOGTEKCNFGXGPFCUFGDGDKFCU
G UCNICFQU # TGHGTKFC RGUUQC CFSWKTKW Q FKTGKVQ FG
GZRNQTCÁºQFQEQOÃTEKQFGVGTEGKTCRGUUQCSWG´ÃRQEC
FGVKPJCVGTOQFGQEWRCÁºQGCNXCT¶FGHWPEKQPCOGPVQ
FQEQOÃTEKQ0GUUCUKVWCÁºQUGCCFOKPKUVTCÁºQRÕDNKEC
FGUGLCTTGCXGTCRQUUGFQKOÎXGNFGXGHC\ÄNQRQTOGKQ
FG CÁºQ TGKXKPFKECVÎTKC G Q QEWRCPVG VGT¶ FKTGKVQ ´
KPFGPK\CÁºQ RGNCU DGPHGKVQTKCU PGEGUU¶TKCU G ÕVGKU
TGCNK\CFCUEQOFKTGKVQ´TGVGPÁºQRQTUGTRQUUWKFQTFG
DQCHÃ
#TGURGKVQFCFGHGUCGFCRTQVGÁºQFQEQPUWOKFQTLWNIWGQU
KVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGU
2CTCECTCEVGTK\CÁºQFGRWDNKEKFCFGGPICPQUCDCUVCSWG
C KPHQTOCÁºQ RWDNKEKV¶TKC RQT UGT HCNUC KPVGKTC QW
RCTEKCNOGPVGQWRQTQOKVKTFCFQUKORQTVCPVGUNGXGQ
EQPUWOKFQTCQGTTQ0GUUCUKVWCÁºQPºQUGGZKIGEWNRC
QW FQNQ FQ CPWPEKCPVG RTQÈDGUG CRGPCU Q TGUWNVCFQ
SWGCRWDNKEKFCFGKPFW\CQEQPUWOKFQTCHQTOCTHCNUC
PQÁºQFCTGCNKFCFG
7OCKPUVKVWKÁºQHKPCPEGKTCRQFGGPEGTTCTEQPVCEQTTGPVG
OGFKCPVGPQVKHKECÁºQCQEQTTGPVKUVCPQUVGTOQURTGXKUVQU
PQ EQPVTCVQ PºQ UG ECTCEVGTK\CPFQ PQ ECUQ TGEWUC ´
RTGUVCÁºQ FG UGTXKÁQ RT¶VKEC XGFCFC RGNQ %ÎFKIQ FG
&GHGUCFQ%QPUWOKFQT
'UVCPFQ KPFKXKFWCNK\CFC C TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG FQ
HQTPGEGFQTRGNCEQNQECÁºQ FGWORTQFWVQPQEKTEWKVQ
EQOGTEKCNJ¶GZENWUºQCDUQNWVCFCTGURQPUCDKNKFCFGFQ
EQOGTEKCPVGRGUUQCQWGORTGUCSWGXGPFGWQWHG\C
GPVTGICFQRTQFWVQCQEQPUWOKFQT
#EGTEC FC VGQTKC FC GORTGUC G FC VGQTKC IGTCN FQ FKTGKVQ
UQEKGV¶TKQLWNIWGQUKVGPUUGIWKPVGU
'OEQPHQTOKFCFGEQOCVGQTKCFQURGTHKUFCGORTGUC
RGNQ RGTHKN QDLGVKXQ C GORTGUC UG EQPHWPFG EQO C
RTÎRTKCCVKXKFCFGGORTGUCTKCN
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
#PVÏPKCCTVGUºCPVGQCWOGPVQPCFGOCPFCRQTUGWU
RTQFWVQU G FKCPVG FC RTGVGPUºQ FG CWOGPVCT UWC
RTQFWÁºQ FGEKFKW EQPUVKVWKT UQEKGFCFG GO EQPVC FG
RCTVKEKRCÁºQEQO/CPQGNRCTCSWGGUUGHKPCPEKCUUGUWC
CVKXKFCFG GORTGUCTKCN (KEQW CEQTFCFQ SWG QU FQKU
FKXKFKTKCOQNWETQFCUXGPFCU
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQCKPUETKÁºQGOTGIKUVTQEQORGVGPVGFQ
CVQEQPUVKVWVKXQFCUQEKGFCFGGPVTGQUFQKUSWGRQFGUGT
GUETKVQQWXGTDCNPºQEQPHGTGRGTUQPCNKFCFGLWTÈFKEC´
TGHGTKFCUQEKGFCFG
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
7O ITWRQ FG RGUUQCU TGUQNXGW EQPUVKVWKT UQEKGFCFG
EQQRGTCVKXC EWLQ QDLGVQ EQPUKUVKC PC RTGUVCÁºQ FG
UGTXKÁQUFGRTQEGUUCOGPVQFGFCFQU
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQQCVQEQPUVKVWVKXQFCTGHGTKFCUQEKGFCFG
FGXGEQPVGTEN¶WUWNCUSWGKPFKSWGOPGEGUUCTKCOGPVGQ
ECRKVCNUQEKCNSWGFGXGUGTHKZQGGZRTGUUQGOOQGFC
EQTTGPVG DGO EQOQ C RCTVKEKRCÁºQ FG ECFC UÎEKQ PQU
NWETQUGPCURGTFCU
%QPUKFGTG SWG Q 2QFGT 'ZGEWVKXQ HGFGTCN FGHKTC
OGFKCPVG FGETGVQ TGSWGTKOGPVQ HGKVQ RQT UQEKGFCFG
FGRGPFGPVGFGCWVQTK\CÁºQ0GUUCUKVWCÁºQQTGHGTKFQ
FGETGVQFGXGUGTRWDNKECFQPCKORTGPUCQHKEKCNFC7PKºQ
PQRTC\QFGFKCUEQPVCFQUFCFCVCFGUWCGZRGFKÁºQ
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
3WCPVQCQFKTGKVQEQOGTEKCNOQFGTPQLWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUG
UGIWGO
0CUUQEKGFCFGUCPÏPKOCUCCUUGODNÃKCIGTCNÃKPUVCNCFC
GO UGIWPFC EQPXQECÁºQ EQO SWCNSWGT PÕOGTQ FG
CEKQPKUVCUEQOFKTGKVQCXQVQ
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
0QCEGTXQRCVTKOQPKCNFGFGVGTOKPCFCRGUUQCLWTÈFKEC
J¶ FQKU KOÎXGKU 1 RTKOGKTQ Ã UGFG FC UQEKGFCFG
GORTGU¶TKC GPSWCPVQ Q UGIWPFQ NQECNK\CFQ GO QWVTC
WPKFCFGFCHGFGTCÁºQGPEQPVTCUGCNWICFQ1UXCNQTGU
TGEGDKFQUCVÈVWNQFGCNWIWÃKUFGUUGUGIWPFQKOÎXGNUºQ
CRNKECFQU PQ CVKXQ RCVTKOQPKCN FC TGHGTKFC UQEKGFCFG
GORTGU¶TKC
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ Q KOÎXGN CNWICFQ PºQ HC\ RCTVG FQ
GUVCDGNGEKOGPVQ GORTGUCTKCN FC OGPEKQPCFC RGUUQC
LWTÈFKEC
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
0QEWTUQFGEQPVTCVQFGCNKGPCÁºQHKFWEK¶TKCGOICTCPVKC
QFGXGFQTHKFWEKCPVGVQTPQWUGKPCFKORNGPVGGGOTC\ºQ
FKUUQQETGFQTCLWK\QWCÁºQFGDWUECGCRTGGPUºQFQ
DGOCNKGPCFQ2QUVGTKQTOGPVGQFGXGFQTRTQRÏUCÁºQFG
EQPUKIPCÁºQGORCICOGPVQGFGRQUKVQWQXCNQTFGXKFQ
GOLWÈ\Q
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQ QFGRÎUKVQNGXCFQCGHGKVQPCCÁºQFG
EQPUKIPCÁºQGORCICOGPVQEQPUVKVWKÎDKEG´EQPEGUUºQ
FG OGFKFC NKOKPCT PQU CWVQU FC CÁºQ FG DWUEC G
CRTGGPUºQCPVGTKQTOGPVGCLWK\CFC
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
,QºQ HKTOQW EQPVTCVQ FG ECTVºQ FG ETÃFKVQ EQO
FGVGTOKPCFC KPUVKVWKÁºQ HKPCPEGKTC G CQ GHGVWCT Q
RCICOGPVQ FG CNIWOCU HCVWTCU QDUGTXQW SWG C
CFOKPKUVTCFQTCFQTGHGTKFQECTVºQEQDTCXCLWTQUCWOC
VCZCUWRGTKQTCQNKOKVGHKZCFQRGNCNGKFGWUWTC
0GUUCUKVWCÁºQUG,QºQCLWK\CTCÁºQEQPVTCCOGPEKQPCFC
KPUVKVWKÁºQHKPCPEGKTCFGXGVGTCUUGIWTCFCCTGRGVKÁºQFQ
SWGJQWXGTRCIQCOCKU
,WNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUGIWGOSWCPVQ´FKUEKRNKPCLWTÈFKECFC
EQPEQTTÄPEKCGORTGUCTKCN
%QPUKFGTGCUGIWKPVGUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKEC
&WCU CWVQGUEQNCU SWG FQOKPCO OGPQU FG FQ
OGTECFQTGNGXCPVGGEWLCUUGFGUNQECNK\COUGPCOGUOC
CXGPKFCFGEKFKTCOHKZCTGOEQOWOCEQTFQRTGÁQUG
EQPFKÁÐGURCTCCRTGUVCÁºQFGUGWUUGTXKÁQU
0GUUC UKVWCÁºQ EQO DCUG PC FKUEKRNKPC LWTÈFKEC FC
EQPEQTTÄPEKC GORTGUCTKCN Ã EQTTGVQ EQPENWKT SWG PºQ
JQWXGKPHTCÁºQ´QTFGOGEQPÏOKEC
#RGUUQCLWTÈFKECSWGKPEKFKTGORT¶VKECFGKPHTCÁºQFC
QTFGOGEQPÏOKECRQFGT¶UGUWLGKVCT´RGPCFGOWNVCFG
CVÃFQXCNQTFQHCVWTCOGPVQDTWVQPQUGWÕNVKOQ
GZGTEÈEKQ
%QOTGNCÁºQCQUEQPVTCVQUDCPE¶TKQUCQUKUVGOCHKPCPEGKTQ
PCEKQPCNGCQUVÈVWNQUFGETÃFKVQGHKPCPEKCOGPVQKPFWUVTKCN
LWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUWEGFGO
%QPUKFGTG SWG PQ FKC FGVGTOKPCFQ
EQTTGPVKUVC VGPJC HKTOCFQ EQPVTCVQ FG OÕVWQ DCPE¶TKQ
EQOQDCPEQFGSWGÃENKGPVG1EQTTGSWGQOQPVCPVG
QDLGVQ FQ EQPVTCVQ CRGPCU GUVCT¶ FKURQPÈXGN RCTC Q
OWVW¶TKQPQFKC0GUUCUKVWCÁºQQEQPVTCVQ
FGOÕVWQDCPE¶TKQUQOGPVGGUVCT¶RGTHGKVQPQOQOGPVQ
FCGHGVKXCGPVTGICFQFKPJGKTQCQOWVW¶TKQFGXKFQCUWC
PCVWTG\CFGEQPVTCVQTGCN
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
– 11 –
# 7PKºQ G C %CKZC 'EQPÏOKEC (GFGTCN FGXGO HKIWTCT
EQOQNKVKUEQPUQTVGURCUUKXCUPCUCÁÐGUGOSWGUGFKUEWVG
QTGCLWUVGFGRTGUVCÁºQFGHKPCPEKCOGPVQFGCSWKUKÁºQFG
ECUC RTÎRTKC TGIKFQ RGNQ 5KUVGOC (KPCPEGKTQ FG
*CDKVCÁºQ
%QPUKFGTGSWGFGVGTOKPCFCUQEKGFCFGGORTGU¶TKCVGPJC
ITCXCFQEQOJKRQVGECRQTEÃFWNCFGETÃFKVQKPFWUVTKCN
WOFGUGWUDGPUGSWGRQUVGTKQTOGPVGVGPJCCFXKPFQ
GZGEWÁºQ HKUECN OQVKXCFC RGNQ PºQ TGEQNJKOGPVQ FG
EQPVTKDWKÁÐGU UQEKCKU CFOKPKUVTCFCU RGNQ +PUVKVWVQ
0CEKQPCNFQ5GIWTQ5QEKCN
+0550GUUCUKVWCÁºQQDGO
ITCXCFQ EQO C EÃFWNC FG ETÃFKVQ KPFWUVTKCN PºQ UGT¶
RCUUÈXGNFGRGPJQTCPQEWTUQFCCÁºQFGGZGEWÁºQHKUECN
OQXKFCRGNQ+055
#EGTECFCTGEWRGTCÁºQLWFKEKCNGZVTCLWFKEKCNGFCHCNÄPEKCFQ
GORTGU¶TKQ G FC UQEKGFCFG GORTGU¶TKC LWNIWG QU KVGPU
UGIWKPVGU
0QRGFKFQFGTGEWRGTCÁºQLWFKEKCNCRGVKÁºQKPKEKCNFGXG
3WCPFQ HQT KPXK¶XGN C RTQFWÁºQ FC RTQXC FQ VGQT G
XKIÄPEKCFGNGKGUVTCPIGKTCQLWK\DTCUKNGKTQCRNKECT¶Q
FKTGKVQ PCEKQPCN RCTC SWG Q NKVÈIKQ PºQ HKSWG UGO
UQNWÁºQ
0CCRNKECÁºQFGNGKGUVTCPIGKTCQLWK\DTCUKNGKTQFGXGT¶
KPVGTRTGV¶NCFGCEQTFQEQOCLWTKURTWFÄPEKCHKTOCFCPQU
VTKDWPCKU R¶VTKQU G EQO Q GPVGPFKOGPVQ FC FQWVTKPC
DTCUKNGKTC
%QO HWPFCOGPVQ PC CVWCN LWTKURTWFÄPEKC FQU VTKDWPCKU
R¶VTKQU LWNIWG QU KVGPU UGIWKPVGU CEGTEC FC KOWPKFCFG FQ
'UVCFQGUVTCPIGKTQGOHCEGFCLWTKUFKÁºQDTCUKNGKTC
1'UVCFQGUVTCPIGKTQGUV¶UWLGKVQ´LWTKUFKÁºQDTCUKNGKTC
SWCPFQRTCVKECCVQjure gestionesEQOQRQTGZGORNQ
CCSWKUKÁºQFGDGPUOÎXGKUGKOÎXGKU
'O ECWUCU TGNCVKXCU ´ TGURQPUCDKNKFCFG EKXKN Q 'UVCFQ
UGT KPUVTWÈFC EQO CU FGOQPUVTCÁÐGU EQPV¶DGKU FQ
GORTGU¶TKQ QW FC UQEKGFCFG GORTGU¶TKC TGNCVKXCU CQU
EKPEQÕNVKOQUGZGTEÈEKQUUQEKCKU
GUVTCPIGKTQIQ\CFGKOWPKFCFGFGLWTKUFKÁºQFGXGPFQC
RCTVGNGUCFCFKUEWVKTUWCRTGVGPUºQKPFGPK\CVÎTKCRGTCPVG
QUVTKDWPCKUFQRCÈUHCNVQUQ
1 /KPKUVÃTKQ 2ÕDNKEQ Ã RCTVG NGIÈVKOC RCTC KPVGTRQT
1 'UVCFQ GUVTCPIGKTQ GUV¶ KUGPVQ FQ RCICOGPVQ FQ
TGEWTUQFGCITCXQEQPVTCFGEKUºQSWGEQPEGFGTRGFKFQ
FGTGEWRGTCÁºQLWFKEKCN
GRUPO V: DIREITOS INTERNACIONAL E
PREVIDENCIÁRIO
#ITCPFGEQPSWKUVCFQFKTGKVQKPVGTPCEKQPCNRTKXCFQ
à C CRNKECÁºQ FQ FKTGKVQ GUVTCPIGKTQ UGORTG SWG C TGNCÁºQ
LWTÈFKECVKXGTOCKQTEQPGZºQEQOQWVTQUKUVGOCLWTÈFKEQFQ
SWG EQO Q FQ HQTQ 7O OGUVTG FC FKUEKRNKPC SWG
GZRGTKOGPVQWGOUWCRTÎRTKCXKFCCFKUETKOKPCÁºQTCEKCNG
TGNKIKQUCCRGTUGIWKÁºQGCDGUVKCNETWGNFCFGSWGUGCDCVGW
UQDTG C 'WTQRC GO RNGPQ UÃEWNQ :: G SWG EQPUGIWKW
TGHWIKCTUG GO PQUUQ EQPVKPGPVG QPFG PC (CEWNFCFG FG
&KTGKVQ FC 7PKXGTUKFCFG FG $WGPQU #KTGU ETKQW GUEQNC G
FGKZQW KPÕOGTQU FKUEÈRWNQU KPVKVWNQW WOC FG UWCU QDTCU
Derecho Internacional Privado, Derecho de la Tolerância
#EQORTGGPUºQFGSWGGOFGVGTOKPCFCUEKTEWPUV¸PEKCUHC\UG
OKUVGTCRNKECTNGKGOCPCFCFGQWVTCUQDGTCPKCRQTSWGCUUKO
UGRQFGT¶HC\GTOGNJQTLWUVKÁCGQTGEQPJGEKOGPVQFGSWG
GOPCFCQHGPFGOQUPQUUCUQDGTCPKCPQUUQUKUVGOCLWTÈFKEQ
RGNC CRNKECÁºQ FG PQTOC NGICN FG QWVTQ UKUVGOC GUUC
VQNGT¸PEKCGUUCNCTIWG\CFGXKUºQLWTÈFKECFQUQDLGVKXQUFC
NGKōGOUGPVKFQNCVQōTGHNGVGOCITCPFG\CFGUUCFKUEKRNKPC
CKORQTV¸PEKCFGUWCOGPUCIGOHKNQUÎHKEC
KORQUVQ RTGFKCN G VGTTKVQTKCN WTDCPQ +267 KPEKFGPVG
UQDTGQKOÎXGNSWGCDTKICOKUUºQEQPUWNCTPQ$TCUKN
1'UVCFQGUVTCPIGKTQGUV¶KUGPVQFQRCICOGPVQFGVCZCU
TGHGTGPVGU C UGTXKÁQU GURGEÈHKEQU RTGUVCFQU RGNQ RQFGT
RÕDNKEQNQECN
0CGZGEWÁºQHQTÁCFCFGUGPVGPÁCEQPFGPCVÎTKCEQPVTC
'UVCFQGUVTCPIGKTQECUQGUVGPºQRQUUWCDGPUGUVTCPJQU
´UWCTGRTGUGPVCÁºQFKRNQO¶VKECPQUNKOKVGUFCLWTKUFKÁºQ
DTCUKNGKTC FGXG UGT GZRGFKFC ECTVC TQICVÎTKC
CEQORCPJCFCFGIGUVÐGUFKRNQO¶VKECURCTCUGRTQEGFGT
´EQDTCPÁCFQETÃFKVQ
,WNIWGQUKVGPUUWDUGS×GPVGUEQOTGHGTÄPEKC´UKOWPKFCFGU
GCQURTKXKNÃIKQUFQUFKRNQOCVCUGEÏPUWNGUPQ$TCUKN
2QT IQ\CT FG CORNC KOWPKFCFG FG LWTKUFKÁºQ EKXKN Q
CIGPVGFKRNQO¶VKEQPºQRQFGHKIWTCTEQOQTGEQPXKPFQ
PQUCWVQUFGWOCCÁºQEÈXGN
#Q EQOGVGT WO ETKOG RWPKFQ OCKU DTCPFCOGPVG PQ
6GPFQQVGZVQCEKOCEQOQTGHGTÄPEKCKPKEKCNLWNIWGQUKVGPU
UGIWKPVGUCTGURGKVQFCCRNKECÁºQFGNGKGUVTCPIGKTCPQ$TCUKN
$TCUKN SWG PQ UGW 'UVCFQ FG QTKIGO WO CIGPVG
FKRNQO¶VKEQRQFGTGPWPEKCT´KOWPKFCFGFGLWTKUFKÁºQ
RGPCN RCTC SWG UGLC RTQEGUUCFQ G LWNICFQ RGTCPVG QU
VTKDWPCKU DTCUKNGKTQU FGUFG SWG GUUC TGPÕPEKC UGLC
GZRTGUUCOGPVG EQOWPKECFC RGNQ RTÎRTKQ CIGPVG
FKRNQO¶VKEQCQ'UVCFQCETGFKVCFQ
1 LWK\ DTCUKNGKTQ RQFG FKCPVG FG WO ECUQ EQPETGVQ
'ODQTC WO EÏPUWN EQOGVC ETKOG EQOWO CQ HQTPGEGT
,CEQD&QNKPIGTDireito internacional privado: parte geralCGF4KQFG
,CPGKTQ5ºQ 2CWNQ 4GPQXCT R EQO CFCRVCÁÐGU
CRNKECTFGQHÈEKQCNGKGUVTCPIGKTC
%CDG´RCTVGSWGKPXQECTNGKGUVTCPIGKTCVTC\GTCQUCWVQU
RTQXCFQUGWVGQTGFGUWCXKIÄPEKC
#QCRNKECTCNGKGUVTCPIGKTCQLWK\DTCUKNGKTQVGT¶GOXKUVC
QSWGGUVCFKURÐGUGOEQPUKFGTCTSWCNSWGTTGOKUUºQRQT
GNCHGKVCCQWVTCNGKGUVTCPIGKTC
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
KPHQTOCÁÐGUHCNUCU´LWUVKÁCDTCUKNGKTCRCTCHCXQTGEGTWO
EQORCVTKQVCUGWFGXGUGTNJGEQPEGFKFQhabeas corpus
RCTCVTCPECOGPVQFGCÁºQRGPCNEQPVTCUKOQXKFCRGNQ
/KPKUVÃTKQ 2ÕDNKEQ (GFGTCN WOC XG\ SWG UGPFQ
HWPEKQP¶TKQEQPUWNCTIQ\CFGKOWPKFCFGFGLWTKUFKÁºQ
RGPCNPQ'UVCFQTGEGRVQT
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
– 12 –
# EQPEGUUºQ FG CRQUGPVCFQTKC RQT KFCFG G FG
Competência, deslocamento,
justiça federal, crime hediondo
CRQUGPVCFQTKC RQT VGORQ FG UGTXKÁQ DGO EQOQ C FG
# UGÁºQ KPFGHGTKW Q RGFKFQ PQ KPEKFGPVG FG
FGUNQECOGPVQ FG EQORGVÄPEKC RCTC C LWUVKÁC HGFGTCN FQ
RTQEGUUQGLWNICOGPVQFQETKOGFGCUUCUUKPCVQFCTGNKIKQUC
KTOº&QTQVJ[5VCPIQEQTTKFQGO#PCRWŌ2#RQTEQPUKFGTCT
FGUECDÈXGN C CXQECVÎTKC CPVG C GSWKXQECFC RTGUWPÁºQ
XKPEWNCFCOQTOGPVGRGNCOÈFKCRQTJCXGTRQTRCTVGFQU
ÎTIºQUKPUVKVWEKQPCKUFGUGIWTCPÁCGFQLWFKEK¶TKQFQGUVCFQ
FQ2CT¶QOKUUºQQWKPÃTEKCPCEQPFWÁºQFCUKPXGUVKICÁÐGU
FQ ETKOG G UWC GHGVKXC RWPKÁºQ RGNC ITCXG XKQNCÁºQ FQU
FKTGKVQU JWOCPQU GO RTGLWÈ\Q CQ RTKPEÈRKQ FC CWVQPQOKC
HGFGTCVKXC
'%P+&%2#4GN/KP#TPCNFQ
'UVGXGU.KOCLWNICFQGO
Informativo de jurisprudência do Superior Tribunal de Justiça
2GTÈQFQ FG C EQO CFCRVCÁÐGU
#RCTVKTFQVGZVQCEKOCLWNIWGQUKVGPUCUGIWKTTGHGTGPVGUCQ
KPEKFGPVG FG FGUNQECOGPVQ FG EQORGVÄPEKC +&% RCTC C
LWUVKÁCHGFGTCNPCUJKRÎVGUGUFGITCXGXKQNCÁºQFQUFKTGKVQU
JWOCPQU
%QORGVGCQRTQEWTCFQTIGTCNFC4GRÕDNKEC´XÈVKOCQW
CQUUGWUHCOKNKCTGUUWUEKVCTRGTCPVGQ56,GOSWCNSWGT
HCUGFQKPSWÃTKVQQWRTQEGUUQ+&%RCTCCLWUVKÁCHGFGTCN
EQO C HKPCNKFCFG FG CUUGIWTCT Q EWORTKOGPVQ FG
QDTKICÁÐGU FGEQTTGPVGU FG VTCVCFQU KPVGTPCEKQPCKU FG
FKTGKVQUJWOCPQUFQUSWCKUQ$TCUKNUGLCRCTVG
7O ECUQ FG ITCXG XKQNCÁºQ FQU FKTGKVQU JWOCPQU
RTGXKUVQUGOVTCVCFQUKPVGTPCEKQPCKUGOSWGQ$TCUKNUGLC
RCTVGGODQTCQEQTTKFQPQ¸ODKVQFGWOGUVCFQOGODTQ
FC HGFGTCÁºQ à ECRC\ FG GPUGLCT PQ EGP¶TKQ
KPVGTPCEKQPCNCTGURQPUCDKNKFCFGFQ'UVCFQDTCUKNGKTQFG
OQFQSWGQFGUNQECOGPVQFGEQORGVÄPEKCRCTCCÎTDKVC
HGFGTCN GO ECUQU EQOQ GUUG F¶ C QRQTVWPKFCFG PQ
RNCPQKPVGTPQRCTCQÎTIºQFC,WUVKÁCFC7PKºQGZCOKPCT
GFGEKFKTCSWGUVºQCPVGUFGCTECTEQOQRGUCFQÏPWU
FGUUCXKQNCÁºQ
#.GKPSWGGUVCDGNGEGQURNCPQUFGDGPGHÈEKQU
FCRTGXKFÄPEKCUQEKCNFGHKPKWPQUGWCTVQRGTÈQFQFG
ECTÄPEKC EQOQ UGPFQ Q PÕOGTQ OÈPKOQ FG EQPVTKDWKÁÐGU
OGPUCKUKPFKURGPU¶XGKURCTCSWGQDGPGHKEK¶TKQHCÁCLWUCQ
DGPGHÈEKQEQPUKFGTCFCUCRCTVKTFQVTCPUEWTUQFQRTKOGKTQFKC
FQU OGUGU FG UWCU EQORGVÄPEKCU #EGTEC FQU RGTÈQFQU FG
ECTÄPEKC FQU DGPGHÈEKQU RTGXKFGPEK¶TKQU LWNIWG QU KVGPU
UWDUGS×GPVGU
CRQUGPVCFQTKC GURGEKCN FGRGPFGO FQ RGTÈQFQ FG
ECTÄPEKCFGEQPVTKDWKÁÐGUOGPUCKU
#EQPEGUUºQFGCWZÈNKQTGENWUºQKPFGRGPFGFGECTÄPEKC
,CKTQGORTGICFQFCGORTGUC%GTXGLCTKC$GO)GNCFC
5# RTGUVC UGTXKÁQU FG PCVWTG\C WTDCPC GO ECT¶VGT PºQ
GXGPVWCNUQDUWDQTFKPCÁºQGOGFKCPVGTGOWPGTCÁºQGGUV¶
KPUETKVQPQ4GIKOG)GTCNFC2TGXKFÄPEKC5QEKCNGUVCDGNGEKFQ
RGNC.GKP#TGNCÁºQFGGORTGIQVGXGKPÈEKQGO
LCPGKTQFGGÃQUGWRTKOGKTQGORTGIQ,CKTQÃECUCFQ
EQO /CTKC UGTXKFQTC RÕDNKEC QEWRCPVG FG ECTIQ GO
EQOKUUºQFC7PKºQUGOXÈPEWNQGHGVKXQ1ECUCNVGOFQKU
HKNJQUOGPQTGU0¶FKCEQOCPQUFGKFCFGG$TWPQEQO
CPQFGKFCFG
%QODCUGPGUUCUKVWCÁºQJKRQVÃVKECGPQSWGFKURÐGC.GK
PLWNIWGQUUGIWKPVGUKVGPU
#RTGXKFÄPEKCUQEKCNEQPUKFGTC,CKTQG/CTKCUGIWTCFQU
QDTKICVÎTKQUEQOQGORTGICFQU
0CJKRÎVGUGFCOQTVGFG,CKTQQUFGRGPFGPVGU/CTKC
0¶FKCG$TWPQFGXGOTGEGDGTFCRTGXKFÄPEKCUQEKCNC
RGPUºQ RQT OQTVG G FGXG EQPVKPWCT C TGEGDGT Q
UCN¶TKQHCOÈNKCCSWGHC\KCLWUQde cujus
#RGPUºQRQTOQTVGRCICRCTCQHKNJQÃGZVKPVCUGQHKNJQ
HQT GOCPEKRCFQ QW SWCPFQ GNG EQORNGVCT CPQU FG
KFCFGUCNXQUGHQTKPX¶NKFQ
%CUQ ,CKTQ UQHTC WO CVQ FG CITGUUºQ RQT RCTVG FG WO
EQORCPJGKTQ FG VTCDCNJQ PQ NQECN G JQT¶TKQ FG
GZRGFKGPVGCRQPVQFGECWUCTTGFWÁºQVGORQT¶TKCFCUWC
ECRCEKFCFGRCTCQVTCDCNJQCRTGXKFÄPEKCUQEKCNFGXGT¶
ENCUUKHKECTGUUGCVQEQOQCEKFGPVGFGVTCDCNJQ
# EGTXGLCTKC FGXGT¶ EQOWPKECT SWCNSWGT CEKFGPVG FG
VTCDCNJQ UQHTKFQ RGNQU UGWU GORTGICFQU ´ RTGXKFÄPEKC
#EQPEGUUºQFGCWZÈNKQFQGPÁCGFGCRQUGPVCFQTKCRQT
UQEKCNCVÃQRTKOGKTQFKCÕVKNFQOÄUUGIWKPVGGGOECUQ
KPXCNKFG\ FGRGPFG FQ RGTÈQFQ FG ECTÄPEKC FG EQPVTKDWKÁÐGUOGPUCKU
FG OQTVG CVÃ FKCU CRÎU C QEQTTÄPEKC FQ HCVQ ´
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
CWVQTKFCFGEQORGVGPVGUQDRGPCFGOWNVC
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
– 13 –
# .GK P SWG FKURÐG UQDTG C QTICPK\CÁºQ FC
UGIWTKFCFG UQEKCN G KPUVKVWK UGW RNCPQ FG EWUVGKQ PQ UGW
CTVFGHKPGSWGCUGIWTKFCFGUQEKCNFGXGUGTHKPCPEKCFCRQT
VQFCCUQEKGFCFGFGHQTOCFKTGVCGKPFKTGVCPQUVGTOQUFC
%QPUVKVWKÁºQ (GFGTCN G FGUUC NGK OGFKCPVG TGEWTUQU
RTQXGPKGPVGUFC7PKºQFQUGUVCFQUFQ&KUVTKVQ(GFGTCNFQU
OWPKEÈRKQU G FG EQPVTKDWKÁÐGU UQEKCKU #EGTEC FCU
EQPVTKDWKÁÐGU UQEKCKU RCTC C UGIWTKFCFG UQEKCN LWNIWG QU
RTÎZKOQUKVGPU
#TGURGKVQFQUDGPGHÈEKQUFQ4GIKOG)GTCNFC2TGXKFÄPEKC
5QEKCNLWNIWGQUKVGPUSWGUGUGIWGO
2TGEGFGPGEGUUCTKCOGPVG´CRQUGPVCFQTKCRQTKPXCNKFG\
QDGPGHÈEKQFQCWZÈNKQFQGPÁCSWGUGT¶EQPEGFKFQCQ
UGIWTCFQ EQPUKFGTCFQ KPECRC\ G KPUWUEGVÈXGN FG
TGCDKNKVCÁºQRCTCQGZGTEÈEKQFGCVKXKFCFGSWGNJGICTCPVC
CUWDUKUVÄPEKC
1XCNQTFQDGPGHÈEKQFCCRQUGPVCFQTKCRQTKPXCNKFG\FG
KPFKXKFWCN G HCEWNVCVKXQ Ã FG UQDTG Q TGURGEVKXQ
UCN¶TKQFGEQPVTKDWKÁºQ
UGIWTCFQ SWG PGEGUUKVCT FC CUUKUVÄPEKC RGTOCPGPVG FG
QWVTC RGUUQC FGXG UGT CETGUEKFQ FG UGPFQ GUUG
CETÃUEKOQFGXKFQOGUOQGOUKVWCÁÐGUGOSWGQXCNQT
FCCRQUGPVCFQTKCCVKPLCQNKOKVGO¶ZKOQNGICN
#EQPVTKDWKÁºQFQGORTGICFQTFQOÃUVKEQÃFGFQ
#CRQUGPVCFQTKCRQTKFCFG Ã FGXKFCCQUGIWTCFQSWG
# CNÈSWQVC FG EQPVTKDWKÁºQ FQ UGIWTCFQ EQPVTKDWKPVG
UCN¶TKQFGEQPVTKDWKÁºQFQGORTGICFQFQOÃUVKEQCUGW
UGTXKÁQ
#UFK¶TKCUTGEGDKFCURGNQUGIWTCFQGORTGICFQFWTCPVGQ
OÄU KPFGRGPFGPVGOGPVG FG UGW XCNQT KPVGITCO Q
UCN¶TKQFGEQPVTKDWKÁºQ
7P$%'52'Ō64(m4GIKºQ
Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.a Região
EWORTKFC C ECTÄPEKC GZKIKFC RGNC .GK P EQORNGVCTCPQUFGKFCFGUGJQOGOGUGOWNJGT
0Q ECUQ FG VTCDCNJCFQTGU TWTCKU GUUCU KFCFGU UºQ
TGFW\KFCURCTCGCPQUTGURGEVKXCOGPVG
#QGORTGICFQFQOÃUVKEQPºQÃFGXKFQQUCN¶TKQHCOÈNKC
%#&'401(4'81
œRGTOKVKFCCTGRTQFWÁºQCRGPCURCTCHKPUFKF¶VKEQUFGUFGSWGEKVCFCCHQPVG
– 14 –
U N I V E R S I D A D E D E B R A S Í L I A (UnB)
CENTRO DE SELEÇÃO E DE PROMOÇÃO DE EVENTOS (CESPE)
TRIBUNAL REGIONAL FEDERAL DA 5.ª REGIÃO
Concurso Público – Cargo: Juiz Federal Substituto da 5.ª Região
GABARITOS OFICIAIS PRELIMINARES DA PROVA OBJETIVA – Aplicação: 24/7/2005
O Centro de Seleção e de Promoção de Eventos (CESPE) da Universidade de Brasília (UnB) divulga os gabaritos oficiais
preliminares das provas objetivas aplicadas no dia 24 de julho de 2005. Para recorrer contra esses gabaritos, o candidato disporá dos
dias 27 e 28/7/2005, no horário das 9 horas do primeiro dia às 18 horas do último dia (horários de Brasília). Para tal fim, o candidato
deverá utilizar os modelos de formulários disponíveis no Sistema Eletrônico de Interposição de Recurso, na Internet, no endereço
eletrônico http://www.cespe.unb.br/concursos/trfjuiz2005, e seguir as instruções ali contidas. Não serão objeto de conhecimento
recursos em desacordo com o estabelecido nos editais pertinentes e nas instruções mencionadas .
AGENDA
8/8/2005 – Resultado final da prova objetiva e convocação para as provas subjetivas: http://www.cespe.unb.br/
concursos/trfjuiz2005 e Diário da Justiça da União.
CADERNO FREVO
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
E E C C E C E C C C E E C E E E E C E E E C C E E
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
C C C C C E C C E C C E C E E C C E C E C E E C C
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
E E C C E C E E E E C C C E E C C C E C E C E E C
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
E E C E E C E C E C E C C E C C C E E C E E E C C
101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125
C C E C E C E E E C E C C E C E C C E E E E C E E
126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150
E C C E E C E C C C E E C C C C E E C C E E C C C
151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175
E E C C E E C E C C C E E C E C E E E C C C C C E
176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200
C E C E C E E E E C C E C C E E C E C C E E C E C